Go back

Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County Girls 

1h 29m 13s

Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County Girls 

The podcast *Deadly Nightmares* explores real-life cases of stalking and disappearance, focusing on the tragic vanishing of Robyn Murphy, a 17-year-old from Carmel, New York, in 1995. Robyn disappeared after being last seen with Howard Gombert, a laundromat attendant. Gombert had a documented history of sexual assault and was linked to the earlier disappearance of 12-year-old Josette Wright, whose body was found in the woods. Prosecutors found Robyn’s DNA in Gombert’s clothing, and he admitted to being the last person to see her. Despite claiming innocence, his connections to both cases and prior criminal behavior strongly suggest guilt. Anthony DePippo, convicted of Josette’s murder, was later exonerated due to flawed evidence, with new testimony and witnesses pointing to Gombert as the true suspect. However, no formal charges or arrests have been made in Robyn’s case, and the investigation remains unresolved. Her family, particularly her mother Judy, continues to seek answers through psychics, investigators, and public appeals, highlighting the enduring trauma and unanswered questions of unresolved disappearances. The case underscores how systemic failures, lack of evidence, and institutional denial can prolong the suffering of victims’ families.

Transcription

12214 Words, 67096 Characters

English
This show is sponsored by Deadly Nightmares, a podcast from i-D. Picture yourself alone in the middle of nowhere and somebody's following you. On Deadly Nightmares, a podcast from i-D, you can hear real stories from ordinary people who were stalked by predators. On each episode, survivors describe the moment they sensed something was wrong and how they managed to escape. Then investigators and family members speak to the details of each case, sharing exactly what happened. These terrifying stories are the stuff of nightmares, and they're all completely real. Listen to Deadly Nightmares wherever you get your podcasts. The longer I searched, the more focused I was. And I became fixated on finding her. Today could be the day. And it kept me going, kept me coming back here. Deadly Nightmares Since 2014, I have dived the Tilly Foster mine 419 times. The mine was used as a dumping ground. Whatever was thrown in there was never seen again. It's 500 feet deep. It's dark. It's cold. It's very, very claustrophobic. So it's dangerous. But I'll never stop searching until I find her. Deadly Nightmares They call me the voice of Putnam County. I worked for the Putnam County Courier. Carmel is a close-knit community. It's an hour and 15 minutes from New York City by train. But yet you have the rural character here in Putnam County. So back in the 1940s, letters sent to residents of Carmel were addressed to Mr. and Mrs. John Smith, Carmel, New York. Because everybody knew everybody back then. No address was needed, no zip codes, just the town. The Putnam County Courier was a weekly newspaper. We reported on everything, everything and anything. From Mrs. O'Leary's 100th birthday, to the local town board meeting, and crime. I remember like it was yesterday, the Robyn Murphy disappearance. Robyn Murphy was a kid with big ambitions in a small town. She wanted to be a writer. She wanted to be a singer. She was a born. born punk rocker. Robyn loved the Ramones. She loved cranking out their music, especially "I Wanna Be Sedated." This is someone who would stand at a bus stop and cut off jean shorts, fishnet tights, Doc Martens in the winter. From the jump, she had her own style, and we kept hearing how distinctive, how memorable. from the jump, she had her own style, and we kept hearing how distinctive, how sweet she was. Robyn's my younger sister. She was cool. You know, she was real fun. We were very close. She was smart, she liked to write. Her and her friends and her boyfriend had a little band going. She was special. When Robyn was around me, she acted like a younger sibling. She seemed to make it her life mission to make me either laugh or at least smile. When Robyn was in ninth grade, we moved from Arizona to Carmel. Robyn found her tribe in the alternative kids group. Back in the '90s, she was what you call goth. You know, she had the trench coat, the boots, but sweetest, sweetest girl. Robyn dropped out of Carmel High at 16. She was way too smart for that school. She got a full-time job as a cashier at the ShopRite. She was saving money to get out of town and move to a big city. Robyn worked at a shopping center. She did, ShopRite. And there were other businesses in that. That's correct. There's strip mall. Four doors down was the laundromat that Howard Gombert was an attendant at. He was quite a bit older. He was an acquaintance. He was a friend. Robyn befriended Gombert's sometime girlfriend. They were both cashiers at ShopRite. The laundromat was the hang spot at that strip mall. And then at the head of the strip mall was the Burger King, where Robyn's boyfriend, Matt Esposito, worked night shifts. I worked at Burger King back in 1995 with Matt. Matt really seemed to love Robyn, seemed to light up when she came in. They were cute. Matt and Robyn dressed alike and, you know, were into that whole goth look. They both wore matching padlock necklaces. And they called each other Sid and Nancy after Punk Rock's most infamous couple. We'd see her every day at Burger King. She'd usually doodle in her notepad. Eat something. But she would hang out there until Matt had his break, and then they'd hang out together. Robyn and Matt were always happy when they were together. They never had anything that would seem like there was trouble between them. On April 9, 1995, Robyn got out of work. She went into the Burger King. Matt had a later shift, supposed to start about 4:00 in the afternoon. He hadn't shown up. She went home. And she had gotten a call from Howard Gombert asking if she would come meet him at the laundromat. And she drove the five minutes it took to get to the ShopRite. She was parked right next to the Burger King. Howard saw her. They talked in the car for maybe 10 minutes. And then he said around 7:15 or so, he saw her walk toward the Burger King, and he went back to work. He had plans to meet up with her boyfriend, Matt, at the Burger King at 6:00 PM, but she's a no-show. Out the window of the Burger King, her boyfriend could see her car parked out there. When my shift was wrapping up, Matthew came into the Burger King. He said, "Kevin, have you seen Robyn?" I said, "No. Why?" And then Matt said, "Because her car's in the parking lot." Robyn never went home on a bus. She left on April 9th. So her parents did notice that she was gone, but they thought maybe she was out with friends. And then when her mother's car is seen still parked in the same parking spot that she had left it the night before, they started to get worried. No one reported her missing until her best friend notified the Carmel PD that Robyn had been missing for 18 hours. I got the call. I was at work. And they said, "My sister never came home." And I got a gut feeling something was wrong. Even though everyone was telling me like, "Ah, you know, she's a kid. She'll come back." I don't know. I thought something was off. When Robyn disappeared, you know, us workers had talked about the fact, "Well, hey, remember that other young girl?" So as it turns out, Robyn Murphy wasn't the only girl that went missing. No, not at all. Not at all. I'm Paul Solitaroff, senior writer at Rolling Stone magazine and host and executive producer of the Devil's Quarry 2 podcast. Now, practically every kid in Carmel bitched about being bored, but Robyn actually did something about it. She got a full-time job at ShopRite and made plans to get as far from Putnam as she could. She'd been fast-tracked for raise and better hours. She's been a good friend. And then Monday rolled around, and Robyn never showed for work. I heard on the police scanner that they were looking for a young lady, a young girl. I went down there that night, and there were numerous police officers scouring the area. It was like a circus between the helicopters, the detectives interviewing the employees. The investigators started talking to everyone in Robyn's orbit, and that includes Howard Gombert. He worked at the laundromat. She worked several doors down at the ShopRite. He said that he did talk to her, and he did admit that he was the last one to see her. Matt Esposito, Robyn's boyfriend, he was like a punk rock star. rocker-type kid, troubled. I really didn't have any bad feelings about him at the time, just a little anger issues. The cops went to Robin's house and got permission to search her room. There were posters on her walls of the band she loved, nothing bloody or black metal, just a standard mix of pissed-off punk and goth. Then there was the packet of letters they found. One of them was from her boyfriend, Matt, who might have signed his postscript in blood. They were reading her journals and her writings, and some of them at the time, you know, you're 17 years old at dark. Investigators began interviewing some of Robin's friends, who said that in the past she had harmed herself, but more recently she seemed happier. Police thought that perhaps maybe she had left Putnam County on her own. Running away just didn't even cross our minds. Something happened to her. We all knew it. In the weeks before her disappearance, Robin had the distinct feeling she was being tailed. A guy in a dark sedan was following her. She would see it sometimes near where she lived, and she also saw it in the parking lot where she worked. She couldn't pin it down, but she told her friends, someone has an eye on me. One of Robin's best friends, James, said that Robin tried to call him around 7.15 on the night she disappeared. Robin left an answering machine message. James recounted for us what the message said. She didn't sound well put together. She sounded like she was in desperate need to talk to somebody. It sounded hurried, fearful. James, are you awake? I need to talk to you. James, are you there? That was the last time I heard her voice. At dusk on April 13th, four days after she goes missing, Robin's coworkers and friends organize a civilian search of the woods behind the shop right. Quite a lot of people showed up and did like a march around. The whole property of ShopRite. Behind the shopping center, there was a wooded path. It was an undeveloped area. It was overgrown. On that night in 95, those kids still nursed hopes that Robin was up there somewhere. Maybe she'd fallen and hurt herself, or lay bound and gagged in a culvert. Either way, they weren't coming down, so they cased each inch of that hill. We did a grid search, and we were in a line. They make a crucial discovery. They find her pay stub. They find her work schedule. They also find letters that were addressed to her. And they immediately call the Carmel PD, who shows up. And more items were found by the dumpsters. They found her wallet and an ID. It was good to find something, but that was like a stab in the chest, because now it's getting real. Our friend group had no idea how to park. They had to process Robin's disappearance. Those of us that knew Robin were all destroyed. Every single one of us. I was working as a go-between between the family and the police, as well as researching and organizing searches. The Murphys suffered at the loss of their daughter. I'm afraid to hope, because it set myself up for so much hurt that she's still out there. As a mother now, I couldn't imagine not knowing where my child is. I couldn't imagine not having answers. When I would see Robin's mother in Chapre, you can see the devastation in her eyes, in her face. And I, myself, could never even imagine what this woman was going through. I went down to talk to the police, and I looked over on the wall, the missing persons. I seen Josette Wright's poster. And it immediately stuck out to me. I said, "This is connected." "This is connected somehow." And for some, what had been this missing persons file is now elevated to the crime of the century. Ralph Jones has always had an appetite for danger. He's a former Naval officer who specialized in underwater explosives. After retirement, the Texas cowboy decamped to the suburbs of New York, where he became a private eye. I excelled in surveillance and catching people doing things. At what point do you hear the name Robin Murphy? I had a town councilman come to me and hand me a box about Robin. He knew what I did for a living. He goes, "There's a girl that went missing. Would you be interested in looking at the box?" I said, "Hell yeah." That's when you started untangling this web. That's right. But then I was also so busy doing my own thing. And then the name Robin Murphy came back to Ralph years later when he was investigating a different case. Robin Murphy disappeared on April 9th, 1995. But she was not the first Putnam school girl to go missing. Just six months prior, another girl had gone missing in broad daylight. Her name was Josette Ray. So I'm here with my extraordinary reporter, Kathleen. We're here because we are retracing the steps that I took when I wrote the role. The Rolling Stones story called "The Devil You Know" that launched this massive reinvestigation. So here we are, the former Wright household. Back in 1994, Josette was 12. She lived here with her older sister and their mother. Josette loved it. She loved everybody. She didn't see the bad in people. She was a waif-like little girl, petite. Loved Mickey Mouse. She loved all the Disney characters. She really wanted to go to Disney World, but she didn't make it. Josette had a real zest for life. She liked to be around everyone. She really didn't want to be alone, ever. She'd go out that front door as fast as she walked in it after school and head down Seminary Hill Road. But she was never alone. She loved to go to the girls' group home, St. Cabrini, where girls her age and up to 18 essentially adopted her as a baby sister. So this is the group home you lived in. Yes. And this is where you met Josette. Yes, I met Josette here. You would hang out on that porch right over there. Yes, yup, the stone porch. What would you talk about? We would talk about boys, of course. We would talk about teachers, you know, that we don't like, and just regular little kid stuff. And then listen to her stereo. October 3, 1994. It was the last day Josette was seen in Carmel. At 3:45, she went walking down the hill. That night, when she didn't come home for dinner, her mom Susan called around to Josette's friends, knocked on the doors of their houses. But none of them had seen her that day. I went with my boyfriend to find her. Nobody knew where she was. And in the morning, I went to the police. They did searches and stuff, but nothing ever came of it. It's like she fell off the face of the earth. That's right. Your mind, every time you drive down the street, you're looking at everybody. Just trying to scan for this kid that isn't there, you know. It was horrible, horrible. I always think they're a runaway. I'm like, there's no way she's a runaway. Six months after Josette goes missing, Robin Murphy, like Josette, vanishes into thin air. What had been rumor and gossip now suddenly was a full-scale public panic. I was born in that town. I grew up in that town. And to think that this was happening, we never heard of anything like this. Josette had gone missing first week of October 1994. Now it's 13 months later, and I can't believe it. I can't believe it. I can't believe it. 13 months later, a couple of hunters are setting up their tree stand in-- the deep woods off of Fields Lane, just outside Carmel. One of those hunters noticed a patch of dirt that looked arranged, walked over to it, lifted up a branch, and with it came a huge chunk of ground cover. Police in Putnam County think the year-old disappearance of a young girl from Carmel is a case of homicide after all. The scattered remains of 13-year-old Josette Wright may have been found by a deer hunter. And we have the story tonight from Tim Flight. The condition of the body was pretty bad. There was nothing but bones left and clothing. Her panties were in her mouth. She had her training bra wrapped around her head. Josette was discovered face down with her hands bound behind her. The cops found. an 8-inch Sears Roebuck hunting knife and a couple of her articles of clothing that were scattered 20, 30 yards away. We were at the dinner table when two detectives from the sheriff's department walked up into our front door. And they came in and proceeded to tell us that they found Josette. And everything just. went really wrong after that. My grandmother was screaming at the top of her lungs. I had to calm everybody down. They went nuts. Josette's cause of death was never established. It was impossible after 13 months whether her throat had been cut, whether she'd been strangled. For Josette's mother, the last year has been an agonizing one. Who would do such a thing? They've made no effort to. to find my. my child in the past year. Now they've got to find a killer. When Josette's remains were found, it confirmed the town's worst fears. That there was a killer in their midst. This show is supported by Chime. Can we talk about how this is the most expensive time of year? The flights, the groceries, the seasonal peppermint lattes. But with 5% cash back with a Chime card, it can also be the most rewarding time of year. Chime is a breath of fresh air compared to all the traditional banks out there. Each month, you can choose your monthly selected category where you'll receive 5% cash back. Choose from categories like gas, groceries, restaurants, travel, or rides. Then, whatever category you choose helps you save. Choose groceries and you can really splurge when you shop for that dinner where you're hosting your in-laws. Or choose travel and take advantage of a little extra luxury by upgrading your seat. Whatever category you choose, it'll help you enjoy the holidays with a little bit more money in your pocket. That's why. Chime is America's number one choice for banking. Head to Chime.com slash 20, spelled out T-W-E-N-T-Y. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. That's Chime.com slash 20. Chime. Feels like progress. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card provided by Chime's bank partners. Qualifying direct deposits required. Terms and limits apply. See Chime.com slash disclosures for details. This show is sponsored by Mint Mobile. Remember being a kid and anytime you would ask for something, your parents would always say, wait until the holidays. Well, with Mint Mobile's holiday deal, there's no waiting. Right now, all their plans are just $15 a month. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with big wireless and made it right, with premium wireless for just $15 a month. All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. It's quick and easy to sign up online and you can bring your own phone and number. So what are you waiting for? To get your new wireless plan for $15 a month, go to MintMobile.com slash 20, spelled out T-W-E-N-T-Y. That's MintMobile.com slash 20. Cut your wireless bill to $15 a month at MintMobile.com slash 20. Upfront payment of $45 for 3-month, $90 for 6-month, $180 for 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. Capable device required. Availability, speed, and coverage varies. See MintMobile.com. Support comes from WISE, the smart way to manage the currencies you need around the globe. Are you fed up with losing out? The hidden fees when you send money abroad with your everyday bank? Choose the smart way. WISE. You can count on the exchange rate you'd usually find on Google. No unwelcome surprises. Plus ditch that where's my money feeling. Most transfers arrive in under 20 seconds. Join millions saving billions on hidden fees. Be smart. Get WISE. Download the WISE app now. T's and C's apply. So, we're on our way to Fields Lane where on November 25th, 1995, two hunters stumbled upon the skeletonized remains of Joseph Wright. So, the infamous Fields Lane, or as we called it, the dumping ground. This was completely uninhabited. And those woods are impassable. There's a certain level of fear in a case like what happened where two young ladies both disappeared. Robin was last seen at this Lake Carmel shopping center. Investigators say they have no leads in the case. Were the cases connected, it certainly could have looked that way. For 13 months, Josette's whereabouts remained a mystery. We're doing extensive interviews of relatives and friends. Law enforcement certainly mobilized their efforts, but they put some heat on local kids that were the usual suspects. My name is Anthony Tipipo. I was born in Carmel, New York. I grew up there. I mean, high school. High school has ups and downs. I never went to class. I repeated the ninth grade three times. Anthony Tipipo at the time was 19, and his best friend, Andy Krivak, were in the parlance of the local cop community. They were the ogres. They were the kids who were slinging weed after school and really stood out. I met Anthony Tipipo. I met Anthony in 1992. He was just a big, fun, lovable guy. And then Andy came in the picture a few months later. Andy was my first boyfriend, so I loved him. You became a tight circle of friends? Yes. St. Cabrini's group home was a hangout for us. We'd go out and hang out on the porch. Andy and Anthony both acknowledged having seen Josette hanging around St. Cabrini. I was friendly enough to say hello to Josette. There wasn't a lot of communication. Friends told police they had seen Andy Krivak and Anthony Tipipo hanging out with Josette. Police were familiar with them. They had records. They had been arrested previously on drug charges. I see money in drug dealing, but also you get the attention of law enforcement. Three days after Josette's remains were discovered in that horrific scene, Anthony, Andy, and a buddy of his were coming back from a rave, and they were pulled over by Putnam County Sheriff deputies, and they find PCP inside. They arrested me, charged me with felony possession, with intent to sell. So Anthony and Andy got the idea that the cops were desperate for leads, and the cops went at them as if. They either did the murder or knew who did. I remember them getting meaner. The good cop, bad cop thing was the real thing. I gave them nothing and they hated it. I did not kill Josette Wright. I swear to God, I had nothing to do with that. Unbeknownst to Anthony and Andy, the cops had started talking to their friends. Investigators came in. They came in and spoke to you. They showed me a hunting knife. They asked me if I had ever seen Andy and Anthony with this knife, and I said, "No." When the investigators left that day, what was the feeling you had in your heart? I kept telling my mom, "Something's not right." The cops then went after kids they got high with, kids they went to raves with, kids they drank beer in someone's basement on a Tuesday afternoon with. Denise Rose was in the crew of kids that Andrew and Anthony hung out with, and she was Anthony's sometimes paramour. - Denise Rose, who was facing her own unrelated criminal charges, told investigators that she had information about Josette's murder. - Denise goes on to tell police that a group that includes Anthony and Josette Wright were riding in the back of Andy's van and they decided to go out and party on the night that police Police say Josette Wright disappeared, and she claims that they started playing spin the bottle and things got out of hand. What happens next, according to Denise Rose, is that Andy Krivak plants an unwanted kiss on 12-year-old Josette Wright. Josette Wright resists, tries to push him off, at which point Andy throws Josette onto the floor of. the van. And they took turns sexually assaulting Josette and then killing her in the process and then taking her out of the van and disposing of her body there in the woods. On July 1st, 1996, I was already in the custody of the Putnam County Sheriff's Department for violation of probation. It was. It was a day that changed my life forever. Unbeknownst to Anthony, earlier that morning, sheriff's investigators arrested Andy Krivak, brought him in for an epic five, six-hour grilling. Later in a lawsuit, Krivak claimed that that interrogation turned violent at one point, that there was force used against him, something police deny. Tell me about Andy's confession. They wrote it for him. He signed it. A deadly secret in the open tonight. I saw a gamut of reporters. Police in Putnam County say witnesses have talked, and now two men are charged with the 1994 killing of 12-year-old Josette Wright. They're like, how do you feel now you're being charged with the murder of Josette Wright? I'm like, holy s***. Let's see who we could find. Two charged with murder of girl 12 years old, Josette Wright. Remember taking that picture at their arraignment? There's Andrew Krivak being taken to a police car and Anthony DiPippo being escorted out of the jail by Investigator Quick. Amazing. The years have gone by so fast. There was intense anticipation, a palpable energy as this trial was about to get underway, because so many people had been waiting so long to get justice for Josette. It takes about a year for the two boys to come to trial separately. Before his trial, Andy Krivak. Andy Krivak recanted that confession, maintained his innocence, said he didn't do it. Nevertheless, he was convicted based on that confession and the testimony of those who placed him at the scene. The charges against 21-year-old Anthony DePippo are first-degree rape and second-degree murder. We get the trial. It was in an old colonial courthouse, and it was like something straight out of A Time to Kill. The atmosphere of the trial. was that DePippo was guilty before it began. The community was outraged over the whole situation. People were out for blood. In his opening statement, Assistant District Attorney James Rooney told jurors. DePippo and Krivak drove out to the desolate road with Wright, two other men, and a woman identified as Denise Rose. And Rooney said the case may have remained unsolved if Rose hadn't broken the wall of silence late last year. What sort of case did the prosecution put on? Denise Rose was the star witness. In broad stroke, they had Denise Rose. Cameras weren't present for Denise's testimony, but she would later recount in a videotaped deposition what happened in the final moments of Josette's life. While she was struggling, he tied. she kept swinging. He took her hands and tied them like this. Who raped Josette Wright first? Was it Anthony or. It was Andy Krivak first, then Anthony said, Yo, save some s*** for me. Man, come on, man, hurry up with that s***. They saw the Wright family at the trials. They remembered Denise Rose's testimony. It was graphic. I think they really suffered a lot through the testimony. The way that they killed her, you don't get over that. She really fought for her life, and it's just incredibly sad to know that she tried to live and she wasn't able to. At the time that Ms. Wright was taken out of the van, you didn't know one way or another whether she was alive and breathing. She was dead. DePippo's lawyer, Robert Leder, warned jurors not to trust the testimony of Denise Rose. That's because Rose only talked to police after she'd been arrested on an unrelated charge. Denise Rose and the other witnesses to the horrors of what occurred, you might think, are not your pillars of the community. Denise Rose is never going to be mistaken for Mother Teresa. They're in court because they were there. One of the defense's primary arguments centered around Krivak's van, where the alleged crime occurred. That van, what shape was it in when the police investigated it? They confiscated it from what I remember for Krivak Sr.'s property and towed it down to the sheriff's department, and that's where it sat. Let me describe the state of the van. That van was basically an ashtray on wheels. It had filthy shag carpets, Miller High Life bottles, cigarette butts. That van was searched back then for DNA. They didn't find anything. They did not find one molecule of Josette. Putnam County Sheriff's Investigator John Reese testified how he found what is believed to be Josette Wright's jewelry. The van owned by DePippo's co-defendant, Andrew Krivak. In the map pocket of the Krivak van. Was there any physical evidence tying DePippo and Krivak to the crime scene near Josette's body? None. Nothing. Nothing? Nothing. Not one damn thing. I had a shot. I wasn't thinking about it. Losing. The outcome? What happens? Guilty. Guilty. You know, now you've got to go to prison for murdering and raping a 12-year-old. Nobody wants to be in prison under those conditions. Susan Wright, Josette's mother, told us the verdict moves her closer to closure in her daughter's death. She's dead. If there was something worse than prison we could do, that would be fine. But that's all we can do is put them away and they can't hurt anybody else. Any other children. I thought justice was served. Susan Wright, when I was found guilty, I turned around to her and I said, Susan, I'm sorry you think I killed your daughter. I won't stop until you see that I'm innocent. You thought the boys were innocent. I knew when a real killer had to be out there. It was heartbreaking. But I knew that there was something else that could be done. The truth is going to come out. I don't know. This is basically an homage to my childhood hero. Hulk Hogan. Over the years, wrestling has given me great inspiration, fighting my case. Sometimes it takes a while for the good guy to win and that makes people root for you. Freedom has been taken away from Anthony DePippo. He's to serve 25 years to life. It's a crime DePippo vows he never committed. As men convicted of murder, both Anthony and Andrew were sent to maximum security prison. Is this where they housed the worst of the worst prisoners? Some of them. I wouldn't want to be there. Generally tried to stay out of trouble. Guards would tell other inmates what you're in for. They just assume you're guilty or guilty. I was wrongfully imprisoned for 16 years. It's very easy to lose hope when you're wrongfully convicted and it seems like there's no way out of it. One of the main ways that Anthony kept his hope alive was to learn his case file backwards and forwards. A couple guys that really cared took me into a law library and just started teaching me. It didn't start out easy. I was uneducated. I could hardly write. We filed the appeal, we lost it. We filed another, we lost that. He reads and re-reads his case file, which is, you know, hundreds of pages long. and He keeps you safe. seeing one name appear over and over in different witness statements. It was Howard Gombert. Who was the same Howard Gombert who had last seen Robin Murphy. So as Anthony is in prison and reading all these statements that witnesses made to the detectives, he realizes that Howard Gombert at one point in the investigation was on police's radar. When the cops interviewed Josette's sisters, one of them, Chloe, described Gombert as a rapist to cops. Howard Gombert has been in legal trouble since he was a kid. He started with burglary and then he moves up to sexual assault. The night Josette's remains were discovered, two Putnam investigators showed up on Susan Wright's doorstep to tell her the horrible news. The first words out of Josette Wright's mother's mouth were, "Howard Gombert killed my daughter." Gombert has denied any rape allegations or that he killed Josette. It was enough to kind of crack down on her. It was enough to kind of crack the door. I needed more. Anthony had one great stroke of good fortune. His mother met this very successful businessman and he had the money to help Anthony. He spent quite a bit of money on me to go and do what I did. What did they want you to do? They wanted me to reinvestigate Leeds. As a part of Anthony De Pippo's appeal strategy, his team finds a handful of women who each alleged in court filings to have been sexually assaulted by Howard Gombert. You think you were Howard's first victim? Yes, I do. At the time he was 16, I was 12. Can you tell us what Howard did to you? I'm a kid, so basically I'd never done anything, obviously, before I was a child. He would tie my hands behind my back. I was outside like in a tent. It was sickening as I think about it now. You didn't tell anyone? No, I didn't. And how long did this go on? I'd have to say very close to three years. When you first told your mother, what happened to them? My mother said that she was going to call the police and she did and I was asking her not to. I said it was consensual. I sided with him. You were protecting him. I was protecting myself. Looking back now, was it rape? Absolutely was rape, 100%. Gombert is arrested for sexual assault, which he denies. That charge is later dropped. While Anthony DePippo's team points at Howard Gombert as an alternative suspect, more information comes to light to help DePippo's legal cause. Howard Gombert, unbeknownst to Anthony, had been represented by Anthony's trial lawyer for sex crimes, leveled by, in one case, a 13-year-old girl, in another case, a 19-year-old girl. Gombert pled not guilty in the two cases. The charges were ultimately dropped. My lawyer had a duty to tell me he previously represented Gombert. He didn't do that. The New York appellate court found overwhelmingly he had cause for a new trial. Anthony is sent to the Putnam County Sheriff's Office while awaiting the start of his new trial. While there, he's sent to the police office. He's approached by another inmate. That inmate says, "My name is Joe Santoro. I know Howard Gombert. I was just in jail with him in Connecticut. Have I got something to tell you?" As fate would have it, DePippo and Santoro cross paths in Putnam County lockup. In an affidavit, Joseph Santoro says that Howard Gombert spoke about Josette Wright. I talked to Joe about what he heard in prison that day. He went into, how, you know, Josette. How, you know, yeah, he was with her. He was, you know, he had slept with her. And I'm like, "What?" And I'm like, "Yeah, but," you know, he's like, "Yeah, they got these two other suckers for it, though, so, heh, they'll never get me." ♪♪ Joe Santoro ran back to his cell and wrote recollections of his conversation. This guy handed me those dolls, and I was given them. I was given a gift. Howard Gombert tells "2020" he never made those statements to Joe Santoro. In that affidavit, Joe Santoro alleges Howard Gombert also mentions someone else. And when he brought up Robert Murphy, I'm like, "Oh, she just went missing." And then he tells me, "Uh, they'll never find the body." Ryan Reynolds here for "Mint Mobile" with a story about deception. Beautiful little tin. You open it, expecting delicious butter cookies. Instead, 40 years of loose buttons. Mint wouldn't do that to you. What you see is what you get. All plans, even unlimited, are $15 a month, unlike this blue box of lies. Give it a try at mintmobile.com/switch. Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent to taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms. Some personality quirks are really funny. Like, I talk to my left foot more than ever. More than I talk to my right. You know what's not funny and not a personality quirk? OCD. Although the term OCD is widely recognized, it's misunderstood by most people. It doesn't mean being tidy or clean. It's having obsessive fears, thoughts, and urges. You question your character. You question your safety. That's OCD. Breaking the OCD cycle takes effective treatment. Go to nocd.com to learn more. - If your holiday shopping list is getting longer by the minute, you need to go to Dee Dee's Discounts. Find gifts for your whole family, cute outfits for all those holiday parties, and even some festive decor for your home all in one trip. And the best part, you can stay on a budget because Dee Dee's prices are unbelievable. So you can get everything you need and then some. Don't sleep on Dee Dee's. Visit a store near you today. - The following section contains descriptions of sexual assault, which may be disturbing to some. - Marker. - Can I touch your camera? - Yeah, please. - It's where you need it. - Okay. - Can you tell us when to start? - Yeah, you're gonna put it on her. - Okay. In here, in this little pile is you at Christmas time with one of your gowns that you would knit. - This is where you would never take off. - My Swan Lake costume, I wore it on top of a velvet dress because I was like, no, this one's prettier. I was so mad you wanted me to wear velvet when I wanted to wear a Swan Lake costume. - And then that's just us hugging. - Yeah, my big smile, my big cheese. - Yeah. And then, I think this is both of our favorites. This is at the horses. - I would never have wanted. I would never have wanted to be this way, nor did I ever want to be involved with someone that would hurt me. - After those two young girls, Robin and Josette, go missing, Howard Gombert, the then 30-something-year-old laundromat attendant, relocates to Connecticut, where his father lives. - Robert Gombert moves in with a nurse named Jane. - Howard was the maintenance man on the property that I lived in. We just started up a casual friendship. He had other girlfriends, but I had fun with him, but he didn't do anything harmful to me until we got closer. He just was very controlling, and he would say things that no one else would hear. And I told him I was pregnant, and he got very angry. The abuse didn't stop, even after I had Dana. And then, with the stuff with Sarah, I had no idea. - Tell me about the first time you met Howard Gombert. - So I was probably like six or seven when we had first met, and he was dating my mom's best friend. - Sarah has been a very special angel to me. Sarah was my best friend's only daughter, and she used to come and spend time with me during her breaks. And I asked Howard if he would take her swimming. - It was just like, "Oh, okay, well, I can't go with you, "so have fun." I guess Jane didn't think anything of it, you know? But we went, first, we had gone shopping. He bought me a two-piece leopard print bathing suit for a little seven-year-old girl. That was weird. And now as an adult thinking back on it, I'm like, oh my gosh, that was horrible. And when we had gotten to where we were going to go swimming, he pulled off on like a side road. And we got out and we started taking a trail. And it was almost. In the woods? Yes. And the spot that he took you to, can you describe it? So after walking through the dirt path and going off, it was just a cutout of trees. Like I didn't see tree stumps. It was just a perfectly round area where it was like almost like ritualistic sort of, I guess. Because it was too perfect. It didn't make sense. Right in a circle. Mm-hmm. And as uncomfortable as it can be. Can you tell me what he did? To you? He actually sodomized me. And then he actually took pictures with a camera that like the instant cameras. And he took his nasty white tank top off and he shoved it in my mouth. And I just stayed quiet because I didn't know what else to do. I thought that was what I was supposed to do. Afterwards. I remember climbing up on the rocks and looking out and across from where we were was the beach of Squants Pond. So I could see all of the families and the kids. And I remember being in the water after jumping off and like, I remember staring at them and thinking like, I wish I was having fun. And I wish I could just swim over there and I don't want to leave the water. That was, uh, it's hard to think about. And what, what did Howard tell you would happen if you said anything about this? I was under the impression when it had happened, because he told me, he said, if you say anything, you know, you're not, you're going to die. You're not going to see your family again. If you scream, if you tell anybody. And, um, I did not say anything. And it actually happened again. He had chased me up the stairs, like trying to play when everybody was around. And he, he grabbed my foot and tried to put a little butterfly hair clips in the nineties that all the little girls loved. I hate them. And I, I took my hand and I smacked him as hard as I could in his back because I was in front of everybody, you know, and everyone got so angry with me. And they were like, why did you hit him? He was. He was trying to play. They had no idea. But no one knew. So things escalate and Gombert held Jane in a three day siege of sexual violence. I don't know exactly how it all started, but I know he wanted sex and I didn't want sex. Howard sodomized me those three days. He tortured me. Dana was really sick and I was really worried about her. And I said, I need to bring her to the doctor. He wouldn't let me bring her to the doctor. All I kept thinking about was, oh, my God, I have a baby to protect, too. There was no doubt in my mind that I was going to press charges. The second Gombert left the house that morning, Jane instantly drove herself to the hospital. They immediately rushed her baby into ICU. And called the New Milford police who took Jane's statement. Howard Gombert pleaded guilty to the sexual assault of Jane and then he sent to prison. So he was in prison before I told anyone. I mean, maybe my little self felt safe enough knowing that, oh, well, he's going away. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know what it was, but I confided in my best friend. And that day. How did you even have the language to say? I didn't, actually. I had told her that he used his hot dog. Not even a, not even an adult term. And she knew what it meant. She was older. She was a few years older than me and she understood. And she went home and she told my mom. Her father is the one that called me to tell me. And he said, first of all, before I say anything, it's not your fault. Well, of course, I felt like it was my fault. I introduced that man to that family. With Howard now in prison, police decide to do a search of Jane's home. Did police have any idea the kind of Pandora's box that they were about to uncover? To find out, they're going to have to look for it one day. But it's not the only thing that's going to be out there. They're going to have to look for it one day. It was in my closet, always. I couldn't move at first. I just looked down at it. And I was like, oh, my God. I zippered it back up, and I couldn't look at it again. During the search of Jane's cottage, During the search of Jane's cottage, they found hidden away a tan suitcase. they found hidden away a tan suitcase. And inside the suitcase, there were underwear in Ziploc bags that were labeled. Mine was on top, so I could tell you what it said. My name, a date, my particular nightgown was that I had been looking for. The cops found troves of jewelry of ladies' handbags and purses. of ladies' handbags and purses. At Howard Gombert's father's house, At Howard Gombert's father's house, they found troves and troves of Polaroids. they found troves and troves of Polaroids. And then the police discover this Manila folder, And then the police discover this Manila folder, and in that folder are newspaper articles and in that folder are newspaper articles all connected to Robin Murphy's disappearance. all connected to Robin Murphy's disappearance. So Carmel, New York police, So Carmel, New York police, who are still trying to solve the disappearance of Robin Murphy, that 17-year-old who was last seen with Howard Gombert, suddenly learn of Gombert's crimes out in Connecticut, sexually assaulting the mother of his child sexually assaulting the mother of his child and 7-year-old Sarah. He's now serving 30 consecutive years for those crimes. The cops submitted the underwear for DNA testing. One of those pairs came back conclusive for Robin Murphy's DNA. I found out that they found my sister's underwear. Yeah, that totally caught me off guard. It was sickening. And he admitted to being the last person to see my sister. So obviously, she was with him. As far as I can tell. And that's when police publicly identify Howard Gombert as a suspect in Robin Murphy's disappearance. From this shopping center in Carmel, nearly six years ago, Robin Murphy, 17 years old at the time, disappeared. Little evidence found until now. We have recovered a piece of evidence that we feel has the potential to be a significant break in this case. Perhaps leading them to the whereabouts of Robin Murphy. Reporting from Carmel, Tim Fleischer, ABC7 Eyewitness News. Over the years, Gombert has offered varying, conflicting explanations for the items that police seized. Including that they were acquired from a thrift store. As for the underwear with Robin's DNA. When confronted with the evidence, Howard completely denied those underwear. Or that he had gotten them from Robin. So in their application for the search warrant, Carmel Police maintained that searching Howard Gombert's home could yield some evidence to tie him to the Robin Murphy disappearance. Well, they knew each other, and Gombert wanted Robin to go talk to his girlfriend because him and her, again, were on the outs. They spent a lot of time together. So the day Robin disappeared, Howard, who doesn't normally come to the drive-thru, had pulled through the drive-thru, and he had said to my co-worker, where is that bitch Robin? And he goes, well, she stood me up. and we come to find out from the detectives that howard admitted to seeing her robin's id was found behind the shop right and the laundromat gomber worked at robin's driver's license was found with howard gombert's thumbprint on it howard said that robin had shown him her license a week before and that's why he had handled it. - And a week after she disappears, Robin, what happened with Howard Gombert? - Well, he winds up in the hospital. - With Howard, he tried to take his own life. He took a bunch of pills, according to him, and he fell on his face and ended up in the hospital. - Gombert tells a local newspaper reporter that he was just distraught over a custody battle with his ex-girlfriend, and then he claims once police started asking him all about Robin, it was, quote, "the final push." - The day after he tried to end his life, Gombert had visitors at the hospital. Carmel detectives had questions about Robin Murphy. They found Gombert more or less lucid by then and willing to speak on the record. He told them that he'd seen Robin just before she vanished, saying they talked for 10 minutes in his car. Gombert goes on to say he doesn't know what happened to her after that conversation. - And years later, he writes to investigators saying he had nothing to do with Robin Murphy's disappearance. - When I asked Howard, especially about Robin Murphy, and that he was the last person to see her, and why did you even think about committing suicide if you had nothing to do with it? He goes, I was tired of everybody always putting the questions towards me. when there was no evidence. And I said, "Are you sure you didn't -- Nope, that has nothing to do with me." -For reasons that shall ever, forever remain unknown to me, the Carmel PD did not immediately arrest Gombert with an enormous amount of circumstantial evidence. -Carmel police declined to comment on the investigation. -To be clear, Howard Gombert nor anyone else was ever arrested, charged, or convicted for the disappearance of Robin Murphy. Now, in a stunning development, Howard Gombert is called to testify in another case, the murder of Josette Wright. Howard Gombert came in wearing his orange jumpsuit, shackled and handcuffed, walked up to the bench, was sworn in you can imagine the tension in the courtroom as anthony to people was finally waiting for howard gombert to take the stand and testify but instead gombert pleads the fifth and says nothing i'm like i promise i'm gonna get you when an intruder approaches a home they expect a camera what they don't expect stop this is simply - Without the cameras, live US-based agents help deter intruders in under 30 seconds. Don't just record a break-in, stop it from ever happening. Plan starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com/spotify. - 30 seconds response time requires monitoring plan with outdoor protection starting at $49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com/licenses for alarm license information. ♪ We're all here, it's family ♪ ♪ Presents for the wild ♪ ♪ As you run and run ♪ ♪ As you run and run ♪ ♪ As you run and run ♪ - This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month. A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song, like "All I Want". Right, okay, we can't afford that. You know what, forget the music budget. We're gonna stick with whatever's in the public domain. - Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months, or $180 for a 12-month plan. - Upfront payment of $45 for three months, or $180 for a 12-month plan. Required $15 per month equivalent, taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only, greater than 50 gigabytes, may slow when network is busy. See terms. - All right, ready? Yeah, there we go, good job! What a good boy! - What gives you peace these days? - Oddly enough, being out in the woods. My boyfriend and I spend a lot of time camping. - Howard Goss. or changed who you were as a little girl? Absolutely. But I didn't let that make me a worse person. I struggled a lot growing up, but realized if I do just keep doing the things and falling in the same patterns, then he's winning. And he can't, I will not let him win. I was at one point a victim. At one point, I am not. I am Sarah. That's who I am. I'm a woman who loves animals. I look forward to having a farm with my boyfriend and us having a family and getting married and doing all the things that I thought I wasn't going to be able to at one point in my life. Anthony DePippo has spent almost 20 years in prison for the murder and rape of 12-year-old Josette Ride. In 2016, he is released pending a retrial. You've spent 20 years behind bars. What does it feel like now to be out in the sun? Wow. It feels good. It feels great. But the thing is, I don't let my mind focus too much off my case. I'm just considering the case and trying to work hard to vindicate myself. When Putnam County gave him a new trial, it was like the whole rug was just ripped out underneath you. Helpless feeling. Hopeless feeling. Anthony's trial should be a movie. Anthony had some of the finest legal counsel I've ever seen. Anthony's stepfather went out and hired the best criminal attorney in New York City. A guy named Mark Baker. Baker then brought aboard Mark Agnifilo. He was P. Diddy's lawyer. Like in the first trial, the prosecution's star witness was Denise Rose. And similarly, in the first trial, she recounted what, she says she saw in that van. She saw DePippo rape Joseph Wright and that she was killed during the attack. A claim she repeats on tape during a video deposition. Anthony DePippo's a murderer. He's a murderer. You're defending a murderer who killed a 12-year-old girl in 1994. Hello, people. Wake up. I'm the truth. I'm the only one that saw it. Goodbye. Denise Rose claimed that the reason she never came forward after witnessing the rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl was that she lived in fear of her life from Anthony DePippo for a year and a half. I believe it's still today that he's going to kill me. If he ever sees me, I'm going to be, he's going to kill me. And when Agnifilo did his cross-examination of Denise Rose, he started with not the facts of the case, but the facts of Denise Rose's romance. With Anthony DePippo, that she'd slept with Anthony, that she thought he was funny after she witnessed him murder and rape Josette Gray. You don't like me calling you a liar, do you? No, I'm not a f***ing liar. Don't leave. Shove your testimony. Don't leave. Shove it up your ass. You want to take a break? Shove it up your ass, all of you. In an extraordinary step, the court allows for Sarah to testify about her assault at the hands of Howard Gombern. Believing the jury should hear her account because she was attacked in a very similar fashion to that of Josette. Why did you agree to testify? Because I saw I could help. And there were similarities between what happened to you and what happened to Josette? Yes. I believe that they had found her bound and with something in her mouth, and that was really what connected our cases together and the fact that it had happened in the woods. And the fact that people who shouldn't have been in prison, that was heartbreaking. As I was telling this story, I looked out into the jury and it was hard, but I was kind of trying to keep it together. And then you look out in the courtroom and you see someone else crying? She didn't need to know the details. She didn't need to know that those truly horrible things are real. I disassociated when they were testifying. It's hard to absorb. You know, I could not imagine what they've been through. The defense bring in prison informant Joe Santoro. And when he's on the stand, he gets the chance to tell the jury about the conversations he says he had with Howard Gombert when they were serving time together back in 2011. And I never said that he said blatantly that, I killed this one, I killed that one. Because he never did. But you're in jail talk insinuating. that those are your bodies. Santoro testifies that Gombert mentions two bodies, Josette and one belonging to the longtime missing teen, Robin Murphy. And when he brought up Robin Murphy, I'm like, oh, she just went missing. And then he tells me they'll never find the body. In an email to 2020, Howard Gombert says he never discussed Josette or Robin with Joe Santoro. The prosecution questioned Santoro's credibility by showing his extensive rap sheet. In court, defense attorneys argue that Gombert is the actual culprit. The prosecution argues that while Gombert is a horrible person for what he did to Sarah, he did not kill Josette Wright. And that the jury should believe Denise and not Joe Santoro. They send me back, they bring me back out for the final time. And judges like, all rise, jury, have you reached the verdict? How do you find the defendant? Not guilty. Yeah, I did it. When Anthony DePippo was found not guilty, we were just shocked. We didn't do anything. We sat there in shock. I ran out of there. I left. Goodbye. Here, Anthony DePippo is a free man, but his friend Andy Krivak is still sitting behind bars fighting for justice and begging for a new trial. All these years later, the Robin Murphy case is still an open case for the Carmel Police Department and even the Sheriff's Department. The not knowing is a nightmare because you can never close that wound. You can't grieve totally. You can't bury it. It's just always that question mark. Judy Murphy, Robin's mother, is desperate for answers. She spoke to a long list of psychics and mediums and paranormal investigators. All investigators hoping to get a lead. Driving with police back here, I remember coming down this way and I saw the little light again and I said to them, keep going. I tell them that she's in there. Robin Murphy's family had hoped a $5,000 reward might bring answers. Murphy's unsolved case, has garnered intense local interest over the years. Judith Murphy would like nothing better than to see her daughter Robin come home, but there does not seem to be much hope. Back when she disappeared, that was a very bad time for my parents. As a brother, it was life-altering, but my mother took it pretty hard. Do you have any hope that Robin still alive? Just don't feel it. Just waiting for somebody to finally, you know, press for conscience. Tell me something. It's been too long. My father, it tore him up too. I just hope that if anybody's out there, that they can slide it in your heart to say something and come forward. We were desperate for anything. I mean, I was out looking in the woods with my mother for evidence and just, it is very frustrating. Quite early on, Robin's mother, Judy, began casting around for TV psychics, for women who had appeared on Sally, Jesse, Raphael. So, when all else fails, we have brought world-renowned psychic, Dorothy Allison, to the show today. How many cases have you solved? I've done over 5,000. When Dorothy Allison gave us this list of clues, I'd say it was fascinating. It was like a puzzle, you know. And now it's time to solve the puzzle. I rode around with her. We just basically drove her around spots we might have thought would be of interest. And her indicator that it was of interest is if she'd said, "I like this place." It never really led us to any more information. As always happens in these disappeared girl cases, psychics come first. They read a headline and they call to offer their services. Twenty different psychics, or folks claiming to have paranormal vision, called the Carmel Police Department. There's been so many different, you know, psychics and other people who try to help and come up and search the area and all this. But every time, you know, nothing definite. It's apparent Carmel Police Department is taking these leads from psychics and mediums very seriously. And one day, the detectives go out with a medium named Philip Quinn. I was sitting on a party about 45 minutes from here and this young female came walking up toward me and she had this long, dark hair. She looked very simple and average, but very physically real. And she said, "My name is Robin." But the interesting part was when she pointed behind her, there was a lake behind me. That's not what I saw. I saw an entirely different body of water. And as she was walking up, she said, "I'm there." And boom, she was gone. Driving with police back here and periodically, I would see this little light. And I remember coming down this way and, I saw the little light again. And I said to them, "Keep going." So, we get out here and this is where I see this light jumping, going down here. The police had stopped. And I said to them, "This is the location that we need to go." I'm thinking I'm going to look down here and see a big hole. I'm not realizing it. There's water in here. There were numerous divings, state police divers, all kinds of investigators. And when something is in the mine, it's there forever. Every year, multiple times a year, veteran volunteer dive crews go down into those pitch black waters to look for any trace of Robin Murphy. We started diving here and I heard almost right away the story of Robin Murphy. And then the more I looked into it, the more I was intrigued and tried to find her. We can go far beyond what the police can do. They can do generally around a hundred feet. And they're just not equipped like we are. If you forget any one of these little pieces, you aren't going in. I'm serious. You're not going in. You're not going in. You're not going in. You're not going in. I'm serious. I'm serious. It's like you're being born for the first time. I usually attach a GoPro right on that. So all the healthy cam footage. That's what I wear. The first diving here we were just exploring. We were just exploring. It's like finding a needle in a needle stack because the landscape is not flat. It's conical and it's jagged. There is a tremendous amount of garbage been thrown in there. The mine was in like the 1920s, 1930s, 1940s used as a dumping ground. So there are many antique cars down there. It's been a grueling search and we search out a quadrant until we know that she's not there. Then we move on to the next one. For years they found nothing. But then one of the volunteer divers made a discovery. They found a Doc Martin boot. The mother described the boot had a tear in the leather and this boot had a tear in the leather. And the mother said she finally cleared out Robin's room, the only footwear missing for those boots. That definitely gave us a renewed sense of hope. At least something is happening. If I can liberate her and allow her to be properly protected, that would be great. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. Were you ever in this building? This is my second and third trial. Second and third trial was this building. Yeah. Nice. And Andy's trial. And Andy's trial. Wow. Had a lot of panic attacks here. I'll bet you did. While I was recording my podcast, Anthony returned to Carmel with me. Nearly a decade after his acquittal, this town still had a hold on him. I have to tell you, I'm feeling it. Oh, I can hear you're feeling it, guy. He was sweating through his shirt. with something like cold terror. That town is so haunted for him. And so I did my perp walk right there. All the news cameras are down now. What do you say now? Oh, no, we didn't. I spent a lot of time here, a lot of time. After I was acquitted they brought me back down, process, and I came out that door and I was a free man. What were you feeling when you came out those doors a free man? Just joy, you know. But then when, you know, the PTSD kicks in and you start to realize what actually happened, what they took from you. Anthony DePippo is now a free man. Andy Krivak is still in prison until he gets the word that he had been praying for. The judge overturns his conviction and orders another trial. It's in October of 2020, still during the COVID pandemic, that Andy Krivak is released on bail. We were there covering it. The anticipation was almost too much for family members. who have waited 24 years for this. -Yeah! -Whoo! -We saw when he came out, hugs, cheers. There was certainly relief, but also the realization that there was likely gonna be a retrial. -They were actually convicted. -Yes. -The first step towards proving my innocence, clearing my name. -The last time he was home, Bill Clinton was president. And, um, I love you, man. -I love you, too. -Yeah! -Ultimately, he was acquitted at trial. -Yeah. -I appreciate the jury seeing the truth and coming back with a not guilty verdict. It's been far too long. -To see him walk out the door, to be a part of that day, it -- it was full circle. -I wanted justice for her, and I didn't get it. -We had justice, and it was taken away from us. -I didn't get it. -It was taken away. -I don't -- I always believed Anthony and Andy were the killers. Always. -Anthony DePippo sues Putnam County. They settle for $12 million, and the county admits no wrongdoing. -And then another settlement -- $20 million for Andy Krivak. Once again, the county admits no wrongdoing. -What happened to 17-year-old Robin Murphy has been a mystery. Last week, these decayed skeletal remains were found on Ice Pond Road, not far from where Wright's body was discovered. -The feeling around the community was, "It's Robin Murphy." -And I'm like, "Wow, this is it. This is it." They found her. It was like a flood of emotions, like, "Wow, this is gonna be it, and I'm planning the funeral." -I was really hopeful that it was Robin. -State and Carmel police have confirmed that DNA samples collected from human remains does not match the profile of missing Putnam residents. -We were able to find out what happened to 17-year-old Robin Murphy, who died in a car accident. -It was a combination of relief, 'cause she might still be alive, and it was also a combination of sadness, 'cause we still have no idea what happened with her. -You get the hope, and then it knocks you down. Nope, nope. It's an emotional roller coaster that I don't wish on anybody. -Robin and Josette, do you think one day we'll find out what happened to her? -I don't want to believe that. I have to have hope, because if it's not for hope, then what are we gonna believe in? -In the search for answers, there's one voice we haven't heard from yet. -Listen, dude, anything you want to know, right now. -Now, Howard Gombert is speaking out. -This is a scrapbook that my best friend had started, and we've been friends for 23 years, almost 24 years now. This one was the first time we had done each other's hair, and they came out pretty rough. They were bright red, fire engine red. My mothers were not happy. I get to look back on this and remember that, even in hard times when I was younger, that I had my best friend. -He's told parts of me that, "I still hate him for it, but I'm also proud of who I am. I can't let him win." -I have spoken twice with Howard Gombert, both times by phone. They were not civil conversations. -Right. How did I -- Wait. How did -- How did I kill your dad? It's something I didn't even know. I met once. -I'm sorry. You met her once? I've got five witnesses who said you met her repeatedly. -No, I met her once, then I know about it. -You have one minute left. -Listen, dude, anything you want to know, write down. -I asked Howard point-blank where Robin's body was. -Really, dude? -Really, dude. -Look, look. -Nah, nah. -Gombert has repeatedly denied any involvement in Josette's murder or Robin's disappearance. -There is news. -And cause for grave public concern. Next month, Howard Gombert is walking out of those prison gates. ♪♪ -I turned off the notifications because I don't want that quiet fear in the back of my head saying, "He's out. He's among other people." -Breathing the same air. -Exactly. -You describe him as a monster, as the anti-Christ. -Now that person might get out of prison soon. -I have fear, but I'm afraid for some other women. That's what scares me. -In messages to "2020," Gombert says his accusers are lying about him. He vows to confront them in court. -The Putnam Sheriff's Office, in combination with the Carmel PD and the state police, have appointed a task force. -To reinvestigate these two cold cases. -In a statement to "2020," the task force stresses how seriously it's taking these cases, knowing how long Josette and Robin's families have been waiting for answers. -How do you want Josette to be remembered? -For her smile and her friendliness. She was very friendly. She had a good heart. Good kid. -I want Josette to be remembered as a sweetheart, never hurt anybody. It's inconceivable that someone would take this beautiful girl and destroy her. -Her story was just completely just stopped. And it's not fair. -And I think it's important that people become aware that Robin has never been found over 30 years. -We want somebody who knows any information, so that they can help Robin's family and find her. Because Robin's out there somewhere. -If she is gone, she's not going to be at rest until, you know, we either find her or they make some arrests. -I think there will always be a hole in our lives with Robin missing. Think about her every day. I would like people to remember her as smart, funny, ambitious, willing to be a journalist. Loving. Good sister to me and her siblings. Good daughter. It was a robbed opportunity of a living. ♪♪ -We should point out that Robin Murphy's brother tells us that his family has never given up hope that they will actually someday learn what happened to Robin, but adds that their communication with law enforcement over the decades has been limited. -There is even more insight, David, into the disappearance of Robin Murphy on the newest installment of the "Bone Valley" podcast, "The Devil's Quarry II." That's our program for tonight. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Deborah Roberts. -And I'm David Muir from all of us here at "2020" and ABC News. Good night. -If your holiday shopping list is getting longer by the minute, you need to go to Dee Dee's Discounts. Find gifts for your whole family, cute outfits for all those holiday parties, and even some festive decor. There's even a store for your home, all in one trip. Visit a store near you today.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The podcast *Deadly Nightmares* features real stories of people stalked or abducted, with survivors and investigators sharing detailed accounts.
  2. Robyn Murphy, a 17-year-old from Carmel, New York, disappeared in 1995 after being last seen with Howard Gombert, a laundromat attendant.
  3. Six months earlier, 12-year-old Josette Wright went missing, and her body was later found in the woods, leading to suspicions of a local killer.
  4. Howard Gombert, linked to both disappearances, had a history of sexual assault and admitted to seeing Robyn Murphy the night she vanished.
  5. DNA from Robyn’s underwear was found in Gombert’s possession, connecting him directly to her disappearance.
  6. Gombert claimed he had nothing to do with either case, but his statements and prior criminal behavior raise serious suspicion.
  7. Anthony DePippo, convicted for Josette’s murder, was later exonerated on appeal, with new evidence pointing to Gombert as a likely suspect.
  8. The Robin Murphy case remains unsolved, with no arrest or conviction, and her family continues to seek answers through investigations and appeals to truth.

Summary:

The podcast *Deadly Nightmares* explores real-life cases of stalking and disappearance, focusing on the tragic vanishing of Robyn Murphy, a 17-year-old from Carmel, New York, in 1995. Robyn disappeared after being last seen with Howard Gombert, a laundromat attendant. Gombert had a documented history of sexual assault and was linked to the earlier disappearance of 12-year-old Josette Wright, whose body was found in the woods.

Prosecutors found Robyn’s DNA in Gombert’s clothing, and he admitted to being the last person to see her. Despite claiming innocence, his connections to both cases and prior criminal behavior strongly suggest guilt. Anthony DePippo, convicted of Josette’s murder, was later exonerated due to flawed evidence, with new testimony and witnesses pointing to Gombert as the true suspect.

However, no formal charges or arrests have been made in Robyn’s case, and the investigation remains unresolved. Her family, particularly her mother Judy, continues to seek answers through psychics, investigators, and public appeals, highlighting the enduring trauma and unanswered questions of unresolved disappearances. The case underscores how systemic failures, lack of evidence, and institutional denial can prolong the suffering of victims’ families.

FAQs

Deadly Nightmares is a podcast from i-D that features real stories of people who were stalked or abducted by predators. Survivors describe the moments they sensed danger and how they escaped, followed by investigators and family members sharing details of the cases.

Robyn Murphy was a 17-year-old from Carmel, New York, who disappeared on April 9, 1995. She was last seen with Howard Gombert, a laundromat attendant, and her disappearance sparked a major investigation. No body was found, and the case remains unsolved.

Both Robyn Murphy and Josette Wright disappeared in the same town, Carmel, with similar circumstances. Josette was found in 1995, and later evidence linked Howard Gombert, who had seen Robyn, to both cases. The two disappearances raised suspicions of a pattern of abuse and possible criminal activity.

Howard Gombert was the last person seen with Robyn Murphy before she vanished. He admitted to seeing her and handling her driver’s license. Later, police found Robin’s underwear in his home with her DNA, linking him to the case. He denied involvement but was not charged or convicted for her disappearance.

Yes, investigators found Robin’s wallet, ID, work schedule, and pay stubs near the ShopRite parking lot. Later, her DNA was found in a pair of underwear discovered in Howard Gombert’s home, which became key evidence in the case.

Robyn reported feeling pursued by a dark sedan, which she saw near her home and at her workplace. She told friends she believed someone had an eye on her, and this concern preceded her disappearance.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.