Go back

Her Dad Opened Her Garage… All That Was Left Was One Earring | Kim Antonakas

1h 54m 22s

Her Dad Opened Her Garage… All That Was Left Was One Earring | Kim Antonakas

In March 1995, 19-year-old Kimberly "Kim" Antonakis disappeared after a night out with a friend in Brooklyn. Her father, Tommy, discovered her missing and searched for her, eventually finding her body in a burned-out house in Queens, where she was tied, starved, and set on fire. Despite extensive investigations, no one was ever arrested. Key evidence included a call from her phone near the JFK airport, a missing car, and phone records showing falsified alibis by her friend Josh, who had lied about being asleep and later visited her apartment. Investigators also found Kim’s earring and personal items, confirming her identity. A psychic’s reading suggested she was held against her will, with the letter "J" recurring in names of suspects, including Josh, Julio, and Flatic. However, no definitive proof tied any individual to the crime. The case raised suspicions about possible connections to organized crime or personal vendettas, especially due to Josh’s criminal history and links to underage activity. While Tommy remained devastated and committed to justice, the investigation ultimately concluded without a conviction. The case remains one of New York’s most haunting unsolved disappearances, marked by a lack of physical evidence and persistent contradictions in the suspects’ stories.

Transcription

20029 Words, 107089 Characters

English
It's Wednesday, March 1st of 1995, around three in the afternoon. A father named Tommy gets a phone call at his office on Long Island. It's his daughter's boss. They're calling from a furniture store in Brooklyn. His twin-year-old daughter, Kim, was supposed to be at work at noon, and she never showed up. Her boss paged her hours ago, and he said, "Kim, never call back." This isn't like her. She's the friend that's always there, the loyal one. Tommy drives to his daughter's apartment, and no one is there. And no one has seen her since she went out the night before. By 8.30 at night, Tommy is standing in Kim's garage. He turns on the light, her car is gone, her purse is gone, and so is her phone and her keys. All that's left on the floor is one gold earring. It would be three more days before anyone knew where Kim was. [Music] Hi, everyone. Welcome back to my channel. And if you have never been here before, I am Kimberlaya. It's nice to finally meet you. I can't believe Halloween's over. Thanksgiving is coming. I'm trying to redecorate this back half. I also want to try to take a trip home to see my family in Florida. But I know it comes with a cost, especially when you put it on your credit card. And if you are carrying a balance on your credit cards right now, that debt is literally costing you more money every single day that you wait to deal with it. And this is something that I think a lot of people need to hear because you could be working your butt off, making payments every single month, doing everything you think you're supposed to be doing. And somehow you still feel like you're getting nowhere. I have been there. That's because making minimum payments can keep you stuck paying interest for years. So if this sounds familiar, I want to at least let you see what your options are with our sponsor, PDSDET. PDSDET helps people who are struggling with things like credit cards, personal loans, collections, and medical bills. They help find a customized solution for your situation. They actually use AI and data to go beyond just looking at the numbers and help personalize potential saving solutions specifically for you. And instead of juggling a bunch of different payments every month, the goal is to get you down to one lower monthly payment. And I want you to look at this number because it's going to crazy. PDSDET has helped viewers save an average of $16,647. This is the exact method that I use to help me get out of debt. But what that number also shows is that people are deciding they're going to do something about it instead of just continuing to throw money at balances every month, hoping they will eventually disappear. So depending on your situation, PDSDET may help you be able to reduce up to half of what you owe on qualifying credit cards, personal loans, or your medical bills. And finding out what options you have takes about 30 seconds. And it's completely free to check. And there's no minimum credit score required. According to PDSDET, your potential savings can start from the day you complete that 30-second assessment. So there really isn't a reason to keep putting off finding out whether they can help you. PDSDET is also a top-rated company in the industry, with thousands of five-star reviews, and an A+ rating on the better business bureau. So if debt has been hanging over your head or you're making payments every month and wondering why the balance never seems to move, just see what your options are. Get your free 30-second personalized assessment today at pdsdET.com/kimber. That's pdsdET.com/kimber. Thank you so much to PDSDET for sponsoring this video. Now, I'm going to bring you back to that garage where Kim's father, Tommy, is standing under the light that he just turned on, holding and earring in his hand. He knows it's his daughter's earring. What he doesn't know is when did it fall off? Was she wearing it the night before? Or has it been lying on the floor for weeks? Was it a clue? Or just another thing a young woman hadn't noticed that she had lost? Tommy had already gone to the 69th precinct that afternoon to report his daughter missing, but she's an adult. Adults are allowed to go quiet for a day, but Tommy knows his daughter. They talk every single day, so he picks up the phone and calls the detective. And within the hour, that detective is standing in that garage with him. Now, before we talk about everything that happened to Kim, I, of course, want you to know who she is. Kimberly Antonakis was born on November 15th of 1974 in Brooklyn, New York. Now, everyone called her Kim, so I will be doing so as well. She was the only child of Tommy and Marlene Antonakis with Greek and Italian roots. And when Kim was just a year old, her parents sadly divorced. Now, this could make for a pretty rocky childhood, but Kim grew up knowing without a doubt that both of her parents loved her no matter whether they stayed together or not. Tommy and Marlene didn't work as a couple, but they agreed on one thing. Their daughter would never go without. Kim lived with her mom after her dad moved out, but she and Tommy talked every single day. And on the weekends, she actually stayed with him. They had their rituals. Chinese take out on Friday nights, pancakes on Saturday mornings, and then the two of them would settle in for cartoons. Kim's favorite was Tweety and Sylvester. She was a daddy's girl through and through. And Tommy never hid that. Kim was the center of his entire world. Now, part of what let Tommy give his daughter so much was everything that he had built. He ran a computer business on Long Island called Vista Systems with Fortune 500 companies as its clients. He had a real estate investment firm, and he was a partner with his brother Joseph in a fire insurance firm in Queens. Tommy was a self-made millionaire, and he worked hard to get there. He wanted to share what he learned with his daughter, his only child. But he also wanted her to see the work that went with it, so that she knew what it took to get there. When her mother later remarried and moved to Florida, Kim decided to stay in New York with her dad on Staten Island. Kim made Tommy promise that he would not get remarried. That's a pretty big promise, but even though he dated, he kept that promise. And when it came to celebrating Kim, Tommy went all out. For her first communion, he threw her party at Tavern on the Queen. This is an iconic restaurant by Central Park. And for her 16th birthday, they went to Tavern on the Queen again, and father and daughter would take vacations, cruises together. They would go to Texas, California, the Bahamas, and once Tommy surprised her with a trip to Hollywood to visit Alyssa Milano, a family friend. On the set of who's the boss. Now, if you were a kid grown up in the '80s, you would know how cool that is. It says, "Cools Against." Kim graduated from South Shore High School in 1992, and later she enrolled at the college of Staten Island. Tommy even bought her a car, so she could drive instead of taking public transit. Because New York in the early '90s was actually a pretty dangerous place, and he was a worried father. He even got her a cell phone and a pager. But it wasn't just so that they could keep in touch. It was so she could handguise her pager number instead of her phone number until she knew she could trust them. And if you're wondering why, well, I think a lot of girls are age or boy crazy, but it was actually a little bit of the other way around. A lot of guys were interested in Kim. And giving someone your pager number is safer because they don't get access to you right away. You actually have to call them back if they paid you. Now, you probably know what a pager is, but if you're a little younger, they're small, little electronic devices that actually clipped your pocket, or you can put them in your purse, and someone would call your pager number. And either the number they're calling from would come across your screen, so you could call them back, or they could leave a code with it, like one, four, three, four, I love you, or nine, one, one, four, emergency, so that you would call them back fast. Kim was growing into a level-headed, independent, and ambitious young woman. She loved to read, but she wouldn't be spending like her entire night with her nose in a book. She also loved going out, dancing, hanging out with her friends, including her best friend Tara and her friend April. They had known each other since childhood. Kim was known to be the life of the party. She was popular, smart, and really funny. But what really drew people to her was that she never acted like she was a girl from a really wealthy dad. She knew that not everyone had what she had, and she was grateful for it. If anything, she was very generous to a fault. She was done earth, she trusted people, and she always put her family first, and she had a really good heart. She and Tommy still talked on the phone, at least once a day as she got older, and every week they had dinner at their place, which was the arco-diner in Brooklyn. And on the weekends, they would go visit Kim's grandmother Betty, who Kim actually called Nanny. The two of them were very close. Kim loved to dance. Remember, she looked to go out. She was life of the party. And in the '90s, New York dance clubs were pretty amazing, and they were everything back then. Kim would be on the dance floor at salsa clubs with her close friend Liz Pace. She loved rap music. She would play it really loud. And one of her favorites was the notorious B.I.G. Biggie. She had a little bit of a rebellious side as well. She had two tattoos, if that's her values, I don't know, but she had a nude man and a woman in her twine with one another and an infinity symbol on her lower back and a scorpion on her right hip for her star sign. She wore her hair long, it was stark and curly and she also had these beautiful brown eyes but she would like to switch up her look and wear blue contact lenses. She was kind of still figuring out her own style and who she was and she was just having a lot of fun doing it. That's what a lot of people her age at 19 or 20 are doing as well. Kim had a dad who adored her, friends who loved her and her whole life in front of her. And she was about to take a very big step on her own. By the fall of 1993, Kim was craving independence. She loved her dad and she knew she could never fully repay him for everything he had done for her. But here she was at 19, ready to spread her wings. And a lot of her friends lived in Canarsie, which is in Brooklyn, including April and her friend Liz. Kim wanted to be closer to her friends and she also wanted to be closer to where her social life was. The fear of missing out was really real for her and Kim was a social butterfly. So she let her dad know she wanted to move out. Now Tommy had always known that this day would come, but it didn't make it any easier. She was his only child, his baby girl and she was leaving. And the house was about to get a lot quieter without her last feeling it. But he had a real reason to worry because even though crime had been trending down from where it was a few years earlier, Crockocaine was still driving violence and theft and poverty across the city. But Tommy also knew his daughter. She was responsible and she was very determined. So he said yes on two conditions. He had to approve the apartment to make sure that it was relatively safe. And Kim had to get a job to help pay her rent. Brooklyn in the early 90s was not the Brooklyn of today, of course not. It was grittier, a lot more affordable home to around 2.3 million people. And after the Brooklyn Navy yard closed in the 1960s and manufacturing left the city, factory set empty. And the local economy took a really big hit for decades. Now Canarsie is in the borough's southeast corner and it was its own little world. It was quiet, working to middle-class neighborhood, full of small family businesses and semi-detached homes. People there worked in civil service, transit, healthcare and the school system. A lot of the residents were older but young families lived there as well. And most of the young people had grown up right there. It was not a college neighborhood and it wasn't known for its nightlife like a lot of New York was at that time and it was considered safe. For Kim, it was a chance to make her own way. She was excited. In December of 1993, Kim moved into a ground floor to bedroom apartment at 1437 East 87 Street. It was part of a three-story building. The second bedroom would come in handy when her mom came to visit or any of her friends wanted to stay. And then taught me rented her a two-car garage right across the street so that she would not have to park her car on the street and risk it getting stolen or broken into. And he also got her some company, a cute little pit bull puppy that she named Sugar so that she would not have to live alone. To help pay the rent, Kim got a part-time bookkeeping job at a furniture store called Amelia Interiors. And before long, a kitten named Spike joined her household. Kim absolutely loved living on her own. Things were really working out for her. And by early 1995, Kim had been in her apartment for a little over a year. And it was good. Sugar and Spike kept her company. Her best friend's April and Liz were just a few blocks away. And Tommy took comfort in the fact that he knew her landlord, not Sanders. He lived right upstairs. And Kim and not got along really well. He found her kind and polite. And she took really good care of his place. She was, by every account, a great tenant to have. And let's talk about romance. When it came to guys in her life, there wasn't one special one. She was dating. She was still trying to figure out the type of person she wanted to be in her life long-term. She was young. She had college to finish and a career to build. And she was not in a rush to get serious. In the meantime, she was really enjoying going out with different guys. And Kim definitely had a type. She was drawn to the stereotypical bad boy image. There weren't always the kind of guys her dad would have approved of her pick for her. But like most fathers, Tommy just one of the best for his daughter. And I think mentioning some of these guys is going to be important. Her very first boyfriend was the guy named Michael, her friend April's brother. Now they had broken up, but they stayed on good terms, which when your ex is your best friend's brother is probably a good thing. Now in the spring of 1974, Kim met a guy named Sean Hayes at a club in Manhattan. And things moved pretty fast. By that July, he actually moved into our apartment with her. Sean didn't have an address of his own before that. He had mostly been staying around the Alphabet City area of Manhattan. But the romance, unfortunately, didn't last. Because Kim found out that Sean was seeing another woman. And two months after he moved in, she broke up with him. But according to Sean, he told friends that him and Kim were on good terms still. And then there was a guy she was really interested in named Valatic. They had met at a New Year's Eve party at the tunnel nightclub. But by Valentine's Day of 1995, she was actually dating a guy named Albert DeSoto. She also briefly dated a 23 year old guy named Julio Negron. Now, none of these turned into anything serious. And she stayed friends with all of her exes. She just hadn't met the one guy she was ready to settle down with. And so, this was Kim's world, a dad who loved her, a tight circle of good friends. And a few exes she was still in touch with. And then in February of 1995, Kim's apartment got a little more crowded. Her friend April, April's boyfriend Joshua Torres, and their three-year-old son needed a place to stay while the floors were being redone in their own apartment. And Kim had that spare bedroom, so Kim, being who she was, offered it to them to stay in. So, they moved in. April worked as a paralegal. Josh was actually a stay-at-home dad at the time looking after their son while April was at work. And for a few weeks, Kim's place was full of people. Her best friend was right down the hall, and there was a little boy running around and two pets, and they were just trying to figure out who all these new people were in the house. On the morning of Tuesday, February 28th of 1995, Kim trove to college like she would any other day. She had a morning class, and then around midday, she started her shift at Amelia and Terriers. That night, her phone rang. It was her friend Liz, asking if she wanted to go out dancing in Manhattan. It wasn't the middle of the week, but Kim was in the mood to see what was happening at the nightclubs. So she said yes. She said she would drive over to Liz's house just a few blocks away. They would get ready to gather. And 9.30 that night, Kim headed over in her white 1994 Honda Accord. And they did what so many of us have done on a night out. They picked out outfits together, they did their hair and nails, they gossiped, and it really took out resuming. That's kind of the fun of going out sometimes, just the getting ready process. Now Kim went with the classic 90s look, brown Timberland boots, black jeans, and a blue and white stripe long sleeve shirt with a brown vest of red. She wore her hair down. It was long dark shadow, blue contact lenses in. And when it came to her jewelry, gold earrings shaped like little shells, a large gold crucifix with red stones on a chain, a gold bangle, a big purple ring, and to finish off the look, a brown designer purse over her shoulder. The two of them jumped into Kim's Honda and they drove into Manhattan to a club in Tribeca called Sounds of Brazil. They got there around 1.30 in the morning on Wednesday March 1st. And that night, a traveling party called the Soul Kitchen was playing, moving from club to club around the city. Kim and Liz had a great night just getting lost in the music. Now, they only had a couple drinks because they were just there to dance and Kim was driving. After a couple hours, they decided to call it a night. Kim had school and work the same day within the next few hours because it was in the middle of the night at this point. So she needed to get just a little bit of sleep. So at 3.50 in the morning, Kim dropped Liz off at her place. And then she pulled away and headed home just a few blocks away with Biggie's latest album "Ready to Die" blasting from her car's stereo as she drove off. Almost 12 hours after Kim dropped Liz off at 3 o'clock on that afternoon of March 1st, Tommy's phone rang at his office. It was Amelia Interiors. Tommy was actually dating the office manager there at the time, Kim's boss, who I'm going to be calling Gabrielle. She told him that Kim did not show up for her midday shift. And then she told him something else. Earlier that day, she had gotten a call from April, saying that Kim never came home after her night out with Liz. Gabrielle said she paged Kim at 12.30 and there was no response. Now, she did not call Tommy at that time. because she didn't really want to get Kim in trouble just because she might be running late. Well now, with Tommy knowing that Kim was kind of nowhere to be found, he gets in his car and drives over to Kim's apartment. On the way, he's paging his daughter. And there's nothing. Now, when he got there, there's April and Josh and they're worried. Josh told Tommy that once they realized that Kim did not come home, they actually got a hold of her address book and they started calling everyone in it. He said that they reached most of them and no one had seen her heard from her. But there was one person that they could not reach. The guy that they said Kim had recently been seeing. I mentioned him once before. His name is Aflatic Rabinovich. But Josh said everyone actually knew him by a different name. Psycho. Josh and April told Tommy what they knew about this guy. He was said to have ties to the Russian mob and he was unpredictable. But Kim wasn't dating him anymore. They said that she was scared of him when she broke it off with him and he had been stalking her. Tommy had never met this guy before and now no one could find his daughter or her car. At five o'clock that evening, Tommy walks into the police department and reports Kim missing. But as I said in the beginning, we're dealing with an adult. She's allowed to go wherever she wants, whenever she wants without telling anyone and police can't automatically assume that anything criminal has taken place. But Tommy was adamant. This was not his daughter. She didn't just disappear. She and her dad talked every single day and detected Philip Tricola took him very seriously. He could see how worried Tommy was. So he started working on this case. One of the first people he talked to was a last person who had been with Kim. Her friend lives. She walked him through the whole night step by step and described exactly what Kim was wearing down to her jewelry. The night had been on eventful as said and nothing strange happened. Kim had dropped her off. She remembered the music blaring and Liz had not seen or heard from her since. Back at her apartment, Kim's friends are still calling people and a couple hours later, Tommy realized something. There is a spare key to Kim's garage still inside the apartment. What if she's inside? What if she's hurt or worse and locked in her own garage? Around 830, Tommy took that key, crossed the street and opened the garage door. It was dark inside, so he turned on the light and he noticed the garage was empty. No car, no purse, no phone, and no keys. But there on the floor was something small and cold and Tommy bent down and picked it up. It was an earring. It had to be Kim's, but at that time he did not know if she was wearing it the night before or if it had been there for who knows how long. Tommy called the detective who came over started knocking on doors up and down the block and no one had seen or heard anything strange in the early morning hours. When they showed the earring to Liz, she confirmed it. Kim had been wearing those earrings that night and Liz told the detective about flattic too, the one that everyone called psycho. She said he even had Kim's name tattooed on his leg. Tommy could not just sit around and wait so he gets back into his car. He's driving up and down the street looking for his daughter and he's not alone because April's boyfriend Josh, the one that had been living there, who was 21, offered to ride along. Tommy had never even met Josh before, but Kim had opened her home to his family and Josh came to look at Kim like a sister and as they drove around the neighborhood, Tommy was actually really grateful that Josh was there. They were trying to come up with ideas about where to even look and meanwhile the police had put out a below for Kim's car and they noticed that there had been no activity on her bank account and her cards had up and touched either. But Detective Trichola did learn one strange thing. In the early hours of March 1st, Kim's cell phone had pinged near the JFK airport Hilton and she had no reason to be anywhere near that hotel at that hour or any reason to be there at all. Out of all the possibilities, the detective's gut said this could probably be a car jacking. Now kidnapping also crossed his mind but they thought kidnapping for what because nobody had called demanding money or anything like that but then again somebody could have taken her to harm her. He also talked to April and Josh and they told him they had both been asleep the night Kim went up and they were so worried and they did not know what to do but at least they had a theory. Josh said that maybe Kim's car was sold to one of those shop shops in Brooklyn. This had been going on around this time period and they would take a car, chop it all up and it's much harder to figure out you know where it came from whose car was and they would sell all the parts. It was reasonable enough to look into it. So Josh went out to start searching for any clues to where her car may be and he brought along his friend 23 year old Julio Negron and now I've mentioned Julio before. This was one of the guys that Kim had briefly dated and they were still in contact and still friends. Julio was as worried as everyone else. As for Tommy, he didn't care what part of the city the search was taking place. He just wanted his daughter to be found and at this point he did assume that she was probably taken by someone very dangerous. People from a world that they knew nothing about and that had Tommy driving through really rough neighborhoods at night. Places where drug dealing was going on where people were living on the street and that's when he decided to do something a little bit different let's just say. He started walking up to talk to people but what he would do is he would take out a $50 bill and he would tear it in half and he would hand one half to a stranger with the promise help me find my daughter and I will give you the other half and I thought that was an interesting way to go about it. Why not just offer them 25 bucks and say I'll give you the other 25 but I get it because half of the actual bill wouldn't be worth anything so it made it a better incentive. Now Kim's mom Marlene flew up from Florida and she was desperate for any news about her daughter and she was so desperate that she actually reached out to a psychic named Ellie Crystal. Marlene and Kim's friend Tara set up this reading and they actually tape recorded it. Ellie said that she felt Kim was still alive and that she was being held somewhere against her will by men and it was cold and she was getting weak. She did not have shoes on and she had not eaten and some time and if she wasn't found she would die. Now the psychic also said something very interesting about a letter that kept coming up the letter J and that Kim had already tried to escape but they caught her and she was being held like a prisoner. She said she started getting the feeling that Kim was tied up and I know not everyone's going to be on board with this type of thing I get it but we've never been in the circumstance before so I think when you're that desperate you will try anything to get answers. Marlene was so emotional she was crying during the entire reading. She goes back to Kim's apartment and Marlene actually plays the recording for all of Kim's friends that were there. April, Josh, Julio and let me be clear about something. The letter J. It's true. Josh and Julio both start with the letter J but it's also a very common letter for a first name but coincidentally the two of them decide they've heard enough. They want to get out there and they want to get searching. They're just standing there waiting for something to happen so they leave. Now meanwhile, Detective Tricola and his partner Detective Jimmy Tarrini finally track down psycho of Latic. Now he's 23 years old and he is known to be violent. He has a criminal record and at that moment he was facing charges involving a 12-year-old, a 12-year-old girl. Not first Latic told Detective that he didn't even know Kim which was a lie and then he said they never really dated. Also a lie. He claimed that he'd met her one night at a New Year's Eve party at the tunnel nightclub but that was it. They dug a little deeper and he did admit okay well wait we did go on a trip to Florida together but Kim stayed with her mom and they never hung out as a couple. And that's when the detective's noticed a tattoo on his neck that said together forever and if it sounds romantic it's not. It was the name of a violent gang based in Brooklyn. They dealt in drugs and money laundering and a lot of other terrible things but they would present themselves as a group of aspiring rappers. Not a good sign. And Latic did not have an alibi for the night that Kim disappeared. He also showed them the Kim tattoo on his leg but he said it had nothing to do with her. It was for a friend fighting addiction. He said that the letters stood for a kick at Mike. Is it a coincidence? Maybe but why abbreviate that? Something kind of seems off with the sky but something also told Detective Tracola this wasn't too they were looking for. He was shady. There's no question about it but he just didn't seem like someone who would kidnap a woman and then holds her hostage somewhere. I don't know how we could tell that but I know detectives do have instinct. Now a couple days went by. No Kim? no car. And then around two o'clock in the morning on March 4th, in the Queen's neighborhood of Woodhaven, a man named John Cuniff, another J name. Remember the psychic as we go along? He was about to head to bed. And that is when he started to smell smoke. At first, John thought it could be his own house on fire. And then he realized the smell was coming from outside. So we stepped out. He walked down 86 Avenue, and a light snow was actually falling at the time. And the whole street was deserted. The smell of smoke got stronger. And he was just about to turn back when he saw it. Smoke coming out of the windows of a two story house nearby at 78-08-86 Avenue. John hurried back and called 911. He knew that house. That house had been empty for years. So at least he thought nobody would be inside needing rescue. Fire Lieutenant Fred Reich arrived with two crews with him. And the front door was unlocked. Lieutenant Reich walked around the outside of the house first, looking for what firefighters call this seat of the fire. This is the place where it started. Down at ground level, through a seller window, he could see a bright orange glow. The fire was in the basement. Firefighters broke open the storm seller door from the outside, and ran a hose down to put out the fire at the source. The flames went out quickly, but the smoke was so thick that no one could see anything down there. Inside the house Lieutenant Reich made his way to the basement stairs, and climbed up to the door that led to the first floor. It would not open. He pushed as hard as he could and finally squeezed through a gap into the kitchen, and on the other side, he saw why. Someone had actually pushed a refrigerator up against the basement door. And now with doors open and windows broken, the smoke began to clear. Crews had gotten in there in time to stop the fire before it spread to the rest of the house. But the smell of gasoline was overwhelming. Now this basement had been packed with old furniture and household things stacked every which way. Lieutenant Reich could tell this was non-electrical fire, and his first thought was that somebody torched this place for insurance money. And then through the haze and the water dripping from the ceiling, he saw what was lying on the basement floor. It was a person. They were lying on their side, but in a seated position, as though they had been sitting in a chair that had collapsed underneath them, and their hands were behind their back. Lieutenant Reich called in fire marshals and detectives. This was no longer just an arson. It was most likely a homicide. The responding NYPD officer was Jose Moral. Now I'm going to stop mentioning all the names that start with letter J, but just to prove my point, as you can see, it's very common. Jose couldn't even tell whether the victim was a man or a woman. At 3.14 a.m., the victim was pronounced dead. Detective Louis Pia and Tom Shedlin of the 102nd precinct arrived at the scene. These were veteran investigators, and even they were shaken by what was inside. They had hoped the person had already been dead before this fire was set. Most of the victim's clothing was burned away, but from the jeans and what remained of the shirt, they presumed it was a woman. She did not have shoes on. A pair of boots were about six feet from her body, along with a burned piece of clothing that looked like it might be a vest. When Detective Pia picked up the vest, a watch fell out of the pocket that band had been burned away. And a long strand of black hair near the body suggested that maybe she was a Caucasian or Hispanic female, but whoever she was, it was clear that she had been bound to a chair with her arms tied behind her back. And there was something shoved into her mouth that looked like a cloth, and some kind of towel had been placed over her head before the fire was lit. On her body were two tattoos that had not been destroyed, a scorpion on her right hip, and what looked like an infinity symbol on her lower back. I think you know that they had just found Kim's body. Queen's assistant district attorney Julian Wise was one of the first people to arrive after the discovery was called in. He was just as stunned as everybody else. The fire marshal was reading the scene from more of a fire science perspective. The fire had started on the victims' upper body. Her wrists, which were bound with duct tape, were untouched by the flames. And the pattern of the gasoline showed that she was the target, not the house. Only about 10 percent of the basement was actually damaged. The gasoline had been poured over her head before she was set on fire. So this was not an accident. She had not done this to herself either. Someone wanted her dead, and they wanted to leave nothing behind. There was no sign of her sentry, and whoever brought her there had to have known this house existed. We'll get to that. But it was just the feeling they had from everything they had gathered so far. Detectives then went across this entire neighborhood, knocking on doors. The man who had first noticed the fire, John, had told the detectives that the house had been empty for years. Remember, he thought it was totally abandoned, no one living there. But he said it belonged to an older woman named Ruth McCook, who moved out about four years earlier for health reasons. She didn't want to sell the house, so she kept the water on and the electricity as well. And the house was pretty well kept. Her son Wayne came by every week to pick up their mail. Now around 7 a.m., police spoke with a neighbor that I'm calling Gina, and her backyard backed up onto this property. She said she hadn't seen anyone coming or going, but for the past several days, her dog had been barking like crazy any time it went outside, which was not like him. And she did not know why. She also said that she noticed the flickering light one night in one of the side windows, but she didn't think much of it at the time. Later that morning, detective Shavelin called the missing person's unit to see if anyone had been reported missing recently who matched the description of this woman. That's when he was put through to detective Tracola in Brooklyn. At that moment, detective Tracola was actually questioning Vladik again, and Tommy was there too, waiting to hear what Vladik knew about the disappearance of his daughter. One detective Pia described the woman in the basement, and now she had two tattoos. Detective Tracola said he felt sick. Together, they told Tommy that the woman found deceased in that fire in Queens was most likely his daughter, and they needed her dental records to prove it. Tommy was inconsolable, and detective Pia made him a promise. Every single person in Kim's life would be scrutinized until whoever did this was caught. And then Tommy had to tell Kim's mom Marlene. But in that moment, he just could not bring himself to tell her the truth. So he lied. He told her that Kim had died in a car accident while trying to get away from kidnappers. I am sure that it was a very hard decision to lie to Marlene, but in desperate situations, it's truly hard to know what to do. On March 6th, dental records did confirm that the body and the basement belonged to Kim. The autopsy had been done the day before on March 5th by forensic pathologist Dr. Carrie Ryber. It had been determined that Kim had not been sexually assaulted. Her mouth and her eyes had been covered with gray duct tape. She was still wearing her blue contact lenses, and there was nothing in her stomach, which meant that she had not eaten for quite some time. And it raised a question that no one could answer yet. Had whoever had taken her tried to starve her, at this point, that was only speculation. There were more. Under one of her fingernails on her left hand were four small metal teeth from a zipper, possibly from a jacket. And then there was one finding that everyone tried it after they knew. Kim had been alive when the gasoline was poured over her, and the fire was lit. The skin on her hands had blistered. And this was the first time I ever heard this, but blistering happens when the body is still alive and sends blood rushing to an injury. It's called a vital reaction. Her airway was blockied as well, meaning that she had breathed in smoke and heat. Dr. Ryber couldn't say whether Kim was conscious, but the cause of her death was severe burns to her body, which I found to be so heartbreaking because it shows the callousness and evilness of this crime for her to be alive when it happened. At five thirty that evening on March 4th, April, Josh and Liz were asked to come down to the police station. And they were told by detectives that Kim was dead. It was overwhelming, but at the same time, and unfortunately, they needed their help. They needed to question them before they forgot, I mean, those little details in the very first beginning of an investigation like this are so important. So after things settled a bit, questions started, who would have hated Kim enough to want to kill her and to go even further? Who would want her to suffer like that? Were there unhappy ex-boyfriends? That was pretty much the top of their list. Let's go through everyone she dated. And Vladik was already there at the police station. April told investigators that Kim had also briefly dated Hulio, Josh's friend. Remember him? We don't know much about him, but they wanted snow with April and John. knew where Julio was the night Kim disappeared and they said we have no idea. They said they had both been asleep at home all night with their son. And Josh said he did notice that Kim had not come home, but that he didn't realize she was actually missing or that anything was wrong until around 1 p.m. that day. But as soon as he did, he craved Roger's book, started going on the list reaching out to everyone except Vladik, both April and Josh were scared of him. And they believed if anyone, he could possibly be responsible for what happened to Kim. And for the night of the fire, Josh said that he and Julio had been out driving looking for Kim at the time and they got home around 1 a.m. Then detectives talked to Julio himself. He said that even though him and Kim were not dating anymore, they still hung out sometimes and they were on good terms. The night Kim disappeared, he said that he was at his sister's place and she backed up that story and also backed up Josh's story about the night of the fire. The two of them were out searching until about 1 o'clock in the morning. Julio also told detectives something else. He thought that Tommy might have links to the mafia, so we're talking about Kim's father. But if the mob had taken Kim, why hadn't anyone demanded a ransom and Tommy had gone straight to the police the minute his daughter was missing. Detectives didn't think that that was the way someone was something to hide from the mob would behave, but still this was very early on. They had to keep an open mind. Kim's white Honda was still missing. So there was a chance that the theory of the shop shop was still something to look into. Flattick, meanwhile, was denying any involvement to anyone who would listen, including reporters. He said he had nothing to hide. So the detectives tried something. They put Flattick in a car and they drove him by that house in Woodhaven where Kim had been found. If he was involved, they thought maybe seeing the house would make him talk, but it didn't. Flattick actually seemed genuinely concerned and confused about why they were bringing him there. He lived in Rain Beach. He had no idea why he was in Woodhaven. As the days went by, he was looking less and less like the prime suspect, but he still could not be rolled out. But detectives also had to look hard at everyone else as well. Kim's murder was all over the news, especially in New York tabloids. At first, the story is just reported an unidentified body found after a fire. But soon, Kim's name and face were on front pages and every story ended with a police hotline number. If anyone knew anything, they should speak up. The community was actually in shock. New Yorkers knew their city was violent. They had shootings, stabbings, and car jacking. That was just part of their life at this point. But this was different. It was vicious and cruel. And it seemed to be for no reason at all. And Kim was so young. She had so much of her life to live. It seemed senseless. They wanted answers, especially since no one had been arrested. On March 8th, Kim's family and friends gathered for her funeral at our Lady Star of Sea Church on Staten Island, dozens of flower arrangements surrounded her closed white casket and photos of a smiling Kim were everywhere. Reverend Jeff Conway's hold the mourners. There is no rhyme or reason she had to leave this world at such a young age, but not everyone there was actually a mourner. Detectives were in that church. And so were undercover officers because they were wondering, could whoever killed Kim be sitting in those pews? Instead of kneeling to pray, the undercover officers quietly videotaped about 200 people who came to say goodbye. And among them were Tara, April Liz, Josh, and Julio. They always are going to work from the people who knew her and were closest to her out. Kim was finally laid to rest, a Moravian cemetery in Staten Island in the family mausoleum alongside her grandfather William. And from then on, Tommy visited her every single day. And he brought fresh flowers every week. He would not rest until he found out whoever did this to his little girl. And that same day, the day of Kim's funeral, there was actually a real break in her case in Malvern, Long Island, a couple named Dennis and Joanne Scully had a friend over to their house on Tucker Lane. Their friend looked across the street and recognized a car that he saw on the news. The white Honda Accord, the police were looking for. Now the Scully's had noticed that car parked there for about a week and they were kind of surprised the police had not already towed it away. Detectives came there to seize the car. It was Kim's Honda. But Malvern was about 15 miles from where she lives, so why would her car be all the way over there? When forensics processed this Honda, they found a purple hairbrush on the passenger seat and a folder on the dashboard. And the outside of the car looked like it had been wiped clean on the back seat was an empty spray bottle of cleaner suspicious. It looked like it. Now detectives knocked on doors in Laverne as well, but no one noticed anything. As Detective Pia walked the neighborhood, he started looking over fences into the bushes into yards and in one yard, he spotted something on the ground, a roll of gray duct tape just lying there. He actually had it bad and brought back to the police station in case it was connected. The fact that the car was in one piece actually mattered because remember they were thinking car jacking chop shop. The car would most likely have been in pieces if that were the case. The car left parked on a quiet street, pointed to more of their other theory kidnapping, but there was so little to prove that kidnapping was the motive here. Inside the car, investigators found one fingerprint on the front passenger side. They found hair as well, long dark hairs that look like Kim's, but also some light brown and reddish brown hairs as well. And in the trunk was Kim's other gold shell earring. They also found a baseball cap, a white electrical cord and a wool blanket cigarette butts were taken from the ash tray for testing. Detectives also knew that whoever did this had to have some connection to that house in Queens, so they're trying to put it all together. This street, the house Kim was found in and where she was taken because remember her other earring was in her garage. The public started to ask a terrifying question was there a serial killer out there because the day after Kim was taken a 23 year old woman named Mary Ann Moroney was shot in the face and sat on fire in an apartment in Manhattan. The day after Kim's funeral, the burned body of another young woman was found in a suitcase near a school in Brooklyn. Also looking at whether Kim's case had anything to do with a woman in stacey pennant who had been missing since February 9th, but in the end, nothing linked them to Kim, but it didn't make anyone feel safer. And through all of it, her father did everything he could. He stood on the sidewalk outside of that house on 86 Avenue for hours handing out flyers and hoping for a break in her case. He also offered a $10,000 reward. He was carrying an enormous amount of guilt. Why had he let Kim move out? That's very painful for a father, for a parent, because you want to feel like you were protecting your child. But as painful as it was, Tommy knew police had to look at him as well. Detectives eliminated him almost immediately, but they did look at his business dealings. Had he made enemies in his business life or his personal life, but Tommy's record came out clean. Detectives had to consider the possibility of organized crime. His insurance business in Howard Beach was actually near the Bergen Hunt and Fish Club, which at the time was the headquarters of the mob boss John Gotti. And Tommy was a partner with his brother in that fire insurance firm, and we're talking about a house that was burned down. It can look a lot like an arson for insurance job. So had Tommy cross someone. That was a question. Had someone gone after his daughter to get a hint. Tommy had been cooperative from the very beginning. He denied any connection to John Gotti or any mob family at all. And he couldn't think of any business dealings that would have made him or his daughter a target. And by then, the FBI was actually helping the NYPD, especially with this possible mafia angle, but there was no evidence that the mob was involved or that Tommy had any mob ties at all. Burning someone alive as terrible as that is was not how the mob usually dealt with its enemies anyway. And detectives knew that if the mafia had a problem with Tommy, they would have gone after Tommy, not his daughter. But there was one more reason police couldn't let the mob theory go completely and that was Julio. Julio was so paranoid that the mob was after him. He was convinced Tommy was involved and actually made the police look at Julio even more. Did he know more than he was saying now there was no sign anyone from the mob was watching Julio, but Tommy agreed with detectives to let Julio go on believing he was being watched because if someone involved in Kim's murder was scared enough, maybe they would crack. Meanwhile, the detectives kept working through the list of men that Kim had dated, they checked out Albert DeSoto, who she had gone out with around Valentine's Day, they looked at her first boyfriend. Michael, which was April's brother, the woman who was living with her, her best friend. And they talked to Sean Hayes, the ex who had moved in with Kim the summer before. Sean was open about the fact that he was a major dealer in the area, but he was adamant he had nothing to do with what happened to Kim. He also said something interesting. Kim and April were best friends and Kim had obviously opened up her home to April's family. But according to Sean, Kim did not like April's boyfriend, Josh. She made an exception to let them live there because of course he was dating her best friend, but she was not a fan. No one else had said that. But it was enough to keep Josh on the detective's list as well, but what did the forensic show? Sadly in this case, very little. There were no fingerprints, DNA or hairs that pointed to a particular suspect. I guess who the only usable fingerprint the police found in Kim's car belonged to. Julio. And that seems like a lead, but it was actually on a notebook that was lying on the floor in the back seat. They used to belong to him, and he had been in that car plenty of times when they were dating and they were still friends. So to detectives, it really didn't prove anything. Fingerprints can stay on an object for a very long time, but of course they took note of it. Also took those four zipper teeth from underneath Kim's fingernail to an expert in the garment district. He identified them as coming from a cheap painted zipper made in Asia. The kind that's usually sewn into jackets, and that's where that lead actually ended. So what were they working with right now? There were no witnesses of a kidnapping, and all they knew was that the fire looked like it was set to destroy evidence and to kill Kim. And part of the problem was that her case didn't really fit into the usual boxes, because if it was a kidnapping for, let's say, money, why was there no ransom demand? It didn't look like a mob hit. And if it were a revenge killing or a crime of passion by, let's say, an ex, that would be extreme. So they kept working the list they had. And investigators eliminated Ruth McCook's sons, Wayne and Gary, who lived with their mother, because it made no sense for them to burn down their childhood home. Whoever set this fire wasn't just trying to burn down a house. They were trying to destroy what was inside evidence of Kim. So detectives circled back to Kim's friends and associates, because you worked from the inside out and then back to the inside. And Julio was acting really nervous. And the reason why was because no one had been arrested yet. He was still convinced the mob was after him, and they found out he had a record for substance charges and attempted car theft. And Josh had a record too, a more disturbing one. In early 1990, he pleaded guilty to recruiting little boys, some as young as eight, for let's just call it an illegal scheme in Manhattan, where he paid the boys $20 each to do things with men. And the men paid Josh $200 for every boy he brought in. He only got five years probation. No jail time. And in 1991, he was arrested on charges that he was doing things with an underage girl. And he held her against her will. He pleaded guilty and got 60 days in jail. And in November of 1992, he got 18 months in jail and three years probation for carrying a gun, because he was already a felon. It's a pretty nasty record, even so both Josh and Julio had alibis. But for one of those alibis, they were each other for the night of the fire. They said they were out looking for Kim by that point. But detectives had to keep in mind that having a criminal record does not mean that you killed someone. So they did something that in 1995, took a lot of patience. They requested the phone records of everyone they interviewed. And back then, those records took a lot longer than they do today. And going through them meant a lot of hours of tedious work because they were not digital. They came in a big stack of papers. And when Kim's landline records came in, they told an interesting story between the late hours of February 28th and the early hours of March 1st, which was when she went missing, 65 calls had been made from Kim's apartment. From the landline phone, 3 times at night, at 10.41pm, 11.50pm, and 12.10am, someone at Kim's apartment had paged Josh. But wait, Josh and April had always said they were both home asleep in bed. So why would anyone at that apartment need to page Josh? They were also calls to numbers registered to at least five different women. And there was more. From the afternoon of March 1st around 4pm, Josh had told Tommy that he spent all day calling Kim's friends. But the record showed he hadn't called any of those numbers until 5pm. He said he tried calling Vladik that afternoon. Vladik's number wasn't dialed until 9.30 that night. So Josh was lying. Why? And then there was the night of the fire. Josh and Julio had been each other's alibis. They said they got back to Kim's apartment around 1am on March 4th after searching for her. But at 2.48am, a call was made from Kim's apartment to a number belonging to Josh's aunt. And Tara, who had been waiting at the apartment that night with Liz, was adamant. The men didn't get back at 1am. They got back almost two hours later, so around 3 o'clock in the morning. So someone at that apartment was calling Josh's aunt. Why? Were they looking for him? So their alibis were starting to crack. Kim's cell phone record showed one more thing. At 5.52am on March 1st, a 41 second call had been made from her phone to the phone company's customer service number. That was the call that pinged off of the tower near the JFK airport, Hilton. That march detective Pia also got an anonymous call. And the man on that line was really nervous. He said, police should be looking at three people who were responsible for Kim's kidnapping and her murder. And he actually gave names, Josh, Julio, and a guy named Joey. And I can't help but think, they all start with a letter J, like the psychic said. Now, the call said that this man overheard them talking on a street corner in Queens. And it was about money, but here's a thing. All couldn't be traced. And the detective had no idea who this call it was. And how do you just like overhear this on a street corner, sound shady and weird. But the phone records already exposed Josh's lies. So detectives knew they were going to have to take a good hard look at everyone's alibis again. And it wasn't lost on them from the very beginning that Josh had been steering everyone towards athletic. Was it to take the pressure off himself? Let me confirm something else. It was Josh, not the police, who had first mentioned flattic as a possible suspect. They were now convinced that Josh was involved somehow. They just didn't know how to prove it. And they didn't know how deeply. And they were starting to think there was more than one person responsible. And Tommy was told all of this and Tommy couldn't believe it. He's like, no, not Josh, because it didn't make sense. Josh was there for him at his lowest point, they were driving all over the city, all hours of the night searching chop shops for Kim's car. Sure. Josh did point to flattic, but it was kind of because he had a reputation. So he gave a reason to point on him. But still, Tommy promised Detective Shavelin. He would keep up his relationship with Josh while the investigation went on. So they wouldn't tip him off that he looks suspicious. On March 17th, Josh came in to me with detectives. They just told them we're re-interviewing everyone. It's totally routine. We're just making sure we didn't miss anything. And Josh didn't even seem faced. He talked about how much he respected Kim, how protective he was, and how he looked out for her when it came to the guy she dated. And then he wrote out his alibi for the night that Kim disappeared. And taking April to work, doing housework, there was actually around 10 hours of his day that he could not account for. He said he was home the whole night of February 28th and went to sleep around 10/30 that night watching TV with his girlfriend, April. When it came to the calls, he said he did not call anyone the night. And there was a call that came in around 1/30 in the morning and it went to the answer machine. So who was making all those calls? Then the detectives showed him crime scene photos of Kim. And Josh didn't even react. The detectives told him that they didn't think of a lot of kid anything to do with this. And to his surprise, Josh actually agreed. And then he offered a theory. He said that he thought there was possibly three guys involved, which would have taken at least two cars. He said they probably grabbed Kim when she pulled up to her garage after dropping off Liz. They drove her car out to Long Island and dumped it, then went to the house in Queens. And he mentioned casually that Tommy was loaded, meaning rich, as in there was a reason to go after his daughter, but he added something. think that these men wanted to kill him, that it wasn't the plan, that it was all about money, but the plan must have fallen apart, and then they had to destroy any evidence. So think about hearing this, everything he's saying, so many details, and he added that the police would probably never find them, because none of them would crack and give each other up. I don't know if you noticed this, but Detective Pia noticed that this version, this theory lined up with that anonymous color, three guys. Josh also insisted that Tommy really did have ties to the mob. The detectives didn't push back at all, but they did note that Julio had told them pretty much the same thing, that it's something to do with Tommy. And then they asked about his pager. Josh said he had not let anyone borrow his pager, not even April, so Detective Pia asked the obvious question. If Josh was asleep at home that night, why would someone page him from Kim's apartment three times? And that's when Josh remembered. He's like, I had to go run out and get milk that night for my son, but he couldn't explain why he had been paged three times from the house. But he insisted, I'm not involved in anything that happened to Kim, but then he said something very strange. He said, if he had been involved, he would have fed her and let her go. And that's when it raised a red flag. Both detectives were like, wait a minute, because remember the question from the autopsy, whether someone had kept food from Kim because her stomach was empty? That had never been made public. So how would Josh know that Kim had eaten? Detectives didn't say anything, they didn't challenge him at all, not yet. Detective Pia kept pressing Josh on the calls from Kim's apartment, and Josh still had no answer. But he was furious at the suggestion that he knew more than he was saying. He said, he didn't care if they told April about the calls to other women. Yes, it looked odd, but he swore he didn't make those calls. So who were these people? And why call them at that hour? Unfortunately, at this point, even as suspicious as Josh looked, they had to let him go. If he did know something, he refused to tell them, but he was physically rattled. And they knew wherever Josh had gone the night, Kim disappeared, he must have slipped out while April was asleep, or someone else had his major. Over the next few days, Detective spoke with April again, and she went through her movements on the key dates, and then they showed her the phone records. And April was livid. She was so mad that Josh, because she knew it wasn't her, had been calling other women, including his most recent ex-girlfriend. With everything put together, his lies, the suspicion, and now women, she ended the relationship and kicked him out. They were now back living by the way in their own place, because remember, they were only temporary living with Kim while their floors are being fixed. Next, Detective sat down with Julio, and they showed him the same photos. He gave the very same alibi as before. He said again, Tommy had mob connections, and he talked about how much he cared about Kim. And then Detective Pia mentioned that some guy named Joey was supposedly in on a kidnapping plan. Julio maintained he had no idea who this Joey was, and had no idea who did this to Kim. He would not budge, even though police made it clear that whoever talked to them first was going to get a much better deal than anyone else. And then came the polygraphs. Josh agreed to take one, and afterward the detective thanked him and told him he was free to go. He later bragged to his friends that the trick to passing was to smoke a lot of weed first, which he said he did right before the test. No one even told him the results. However, April passed and so did her brother Michael. Julio refused to take one all together. Now something happened that was a real setback. On May 15th, Detective Pia and Detective Shedlin were in a car accident in the line of duty. It was not related to Kim's case. Detective Pia was okay, but Detective Shedlin was not so lucky, and he was not clear to return to the line of duty. So Detective Rick Turelli was assigned to the case as Pia's new partner. So we have a new person on the case that has to go through everything they already went through. So it was kind of like they were starting from scratch. But the next month, it looked like they were finally going to get a break. A man named Sean Wright out was arrested in Brooklyn for robbery while on probation. He was facing life in prison, and he had a scrapbook, full of newspaper clippings about Kim's case, and in custody he started talking. He said he knew who killed her, five men, all members of the gang together forever. The same gang whose name was tattooed on Flattick's neck. Their names were Michael Garrett, Paul Rivera, Saul Khalil, Dave Watts, and Lewis Wright out. Flattick wasn't one of the men named. Sean said he wasn't a member himself, but that Dave was the driver. And he claimed that his girlfriend had heard the man bragging about the murder back in April. And when police talked to his girlfriend, she told him the same story. Detectives along with ADA-wise brought Dave in. He filled two polygraphs. But he identified the house in Queens when they drove by. He claimed Paul was the mastermind of the whole thing. And after all this, Paul was actually arrested for the murder. But he denied everything. He even passed a polygraph, and so did Saul, Michael, and Garrett. And Michael finally blew everything up. But then detectives found out that Paul couldn't have been responsible. He was sitting in jail in New Jersey when Kim was found. So it was such a waste of time and resources. Why would you say you were involved? Why would you go through all of this to what bragged about a crime you didn't even commit? And in the end, Sean admitted in tears that he made the whole thing up. He thought if he handed police the killers in a high profile unsolved murder, it would keep him from going to prison for life. This was just another dead end in the case in a huge waste of police time. As some were arrived, so did the rise in violent crime. And that usually comes with warmer months. And Queens homicide detectives found themselves with another murder. At 1am on June 23rd, a 26-year-old man was arriving home with his girlfriend and their young son. He got out of his car and he was shot once in the head execution style with a nine-millimeter semi-automatic pistol and he died instantly. His name was Jose Negron. But most people knew him as Joey. Joey had a record for drug offenses and was on probation when he was killed. Right after the shooting his girlfriend, Angela, saw a man running towards a dark colored Honda which sped off. She screamed for help and when police interviewed her, Angela said she had no idea who would want Joey dead. When they asked who his friends were though, she named two. Joshua Torres and a guy named Nicholas LaBretty who went by the street name Little J. And she said Joey was scared of Josh. Josh. As in the same Josh, connected to Kim through April. So two people connected to Josh were now dead within four months. Is it a coincidence? Police also noted that Joey was one of the three names that anonymous caller had given detectives. He said Joey, Josh and Julio were involved in Kim's kidnapping and murder. So was this the same Joey? It seemed like too much of a coincidence not to be. Detectives also pulled Nick's records. He was only 19 and at the time Kim had been killed, he was out on just a $1,000 bail. On charges of burglary, criminal possession of a weapon robbery and assault. Five months before Kim was taken, Nick and two other men had terrorized a woman in her four-year-old son. Nick shoved a 45 automatic into a wound's mouth and poached her little boy in the face with a gun. He was said to be the ring leader and he was facing 25 years in prison. But his lawyer argued he had no criminal record and that his mother was involved in community activism and local politics. He got a letter of support from a Brooklyn congressman. So his bail was somehow allowed to be cut from $25,000 to $1,000 and he got out. But even with all this information for three months, everything installed. No movement on Kim's case and no movement on Joey's case. Then on September 3rd, two friends walked into the police station to report a robbery and attack in Queens. One of them was a man named Miguel Castillo. The other was a 25-year-old woman that police nicknamed Blondie to protect her identity. Blondie said a man had beaten her really badly and threatened her with a gun and stolen her motorcycle. And guess what she said, his name was Joshua Torres. That name rang a bell for the detective Johnny Wilde. Detective Wilde had responded to Joey's murder back in June. Blondie told him she and Josh had started to recently date after his breakup with April and that he moved in with her in her four children in early August. Later that month, she said she was going to throw him out and that's when he threatened to kill her. He told her he had killed two people already. According to Blondie, Josh told her that back in late February, him and his friends had kidnapped a young woman, held her in a vacant house, tried to get ransom money from her wealthy father and when it all fell apart, he set her on fire. He also told Blondie he killed his friend Joey because Joey had secretly made it. a recording of the men talking about Kim's kidnapping. Josh told Blondie he had no remorse, and he would kill her if she told anyone. Blondie said she didn't wanna believe it, but when she asked some friends whether it really happened, they showed her newspaper articles. She also told Detective Wild that Josh had given himself a nickname, KQ, for King Quality. Sounds like a real winner. But Detective Wild was stunned, given the world that Joey moved in, he assumed Joey's murder was actually a drug deal gone bad. But now it looked like something totally different. Shutting down a witness to Kim's murder. So he talked to Miguel, who backed everything that Blondie said. Miguel said that in mid-July, Josh told him he had killed Joey. The way Josh told it to him, everything was Joey's fault, because Joey had not given Kim food or took care of her after the kidnapping. Josh believes that Joey was ready to turn them in. He knew Joey had this secret recording, so Joey had to die. Now, if you're asking a lot of questions, you aren't the only one. My job was on the floor. So many people, so many different stories. Miguel said that Josh, another man, had threatened to kill him as well. That's when he decided to go to the police. Detective Wild contacts the detectives on Kim's case, and he laid it all out. Two people separately naming Josh for both murders. Miguel and Blondie, they'd given written statements. This was the lead the investigators had been waiting for. Josh was pretty bold for opening up his mouth as much as he did. At this point, what they decided to do is track down Joey's girlfriend, Angela. She was staying at her mom's house in Woodhaven, which they quickly realized was right near the house where Kim was killed. They didn't think this was a coincidence. Blondie's story brought him right back to an anonymous caller from six months earlier. Josh, Julio, and a guy named Joey. All J names, by the way. Kim's case was coming into focus as a kidnapping gone horribly wrong. Angela told them. In the spring of 1995, Joey started carrying a loaded 380 automatic everywhere he went. He was on edge. He was worried that Josh was going to kill him. And he did have a secret tape recording. It was something incriminating. And he called it his insurance. One night in June, he finally gave that tape to his sister and asked her to give it to the police if anything bad ever happened to him. Angela said she hadn't seen who shot Joey. And she didn't personally have a copy of the tape. But police were able to get some items from the home. Joey's address book, which had Nick's information in it, a pair of handcuffs, and a micro cassette recorder. This new evidence was sent back to Detective Pia. And this made them go back to the phone records in the night that Kim disappeared. Remember those calls that had been made from Kim's apartment that night and the next morning? Well, one of them was to Angela's number and to Nick's girlfriend's number. Remember that they were all women who were called? Well, detectives had assumed Josh was calling these women because they were the names the phones were registered to. But now they realize Josh was really calling Joey and Nick through their girlfriend's numbers. And now here's the issue. There was no security footage from the gas station. So now investigators have three names. Josh, Julio, and this new one Nick. And between these three men, at least one of them would crack. The question was who? And finding Josh wasn't easy. He knew at this point that police were looking for him so he was lying low. So detectives turned to the woman named Blondie. Josh had been so desperate to get his hands on her motorcycle. So detectives had Blondie set up a meeting in public, telling Josh she was going to give him the registration. At 5 p.m. on September 6, Blondie shows up at a McDonald's on Hendrick Street in Atlantic Avenue. Josh fell for it. He pulls up driving April's car. And what he didn't know was that officers were waiting. Before he had time to even think, police, including Detective Pia, surrounded the car with her gun's drawn. They dragged Josh out and arrested him for the murder of Kimberly Antonakis. They took him to the police station. Where Detective Sheplin was waiting. He still wasn't back on full duty after the accident, but he was clear to come in just for this since he had been the lead on this case from the beginning. He wanted to see it through. At the same time, Nick was also being put in handcuffs. Angela helped that arrest happen. She agreed to help the police. She calls Nick. She says she needs help collecting a debt and Nick fell for it. When he walked outside, detectives grabbed him and brought him into the police station. Now they had both men in separate rooms at the same time. They were telling Josh that Nick was in the other room, telling them that Josh was the mastermind and the one who killed Kim. Josh was kind of left. He was so arrogant. So they left him alone in that interview room just to stew. And then Detective Pia went to work on Nick. At first, Nick denied knowing anything. The strategy was to make Nick feel like they didn't even need him because they already knew everything they needed to know, but that didn't work. So the detectives told him something that wasn't true. And they're allowed to lie in interrogations. So they said Josh, right in him out and the detectives then softened their approach. They told Nick that they didn't think Nick was the ringleader, which could help him make a deal with them. And Nick started talking and he laid out a horrifying story. He said it was all Josh's idea. The Josh was staying with Kim at the time and he came up with a plan to kidnap her for money. They would take her to that vacant house in Woodhaven, hold her there until her father paid. And on February 28th, Josh called to let them know Kim was going out for the night. Nick and Joey drove over to Kim's block, parked on the street and waited for her for hours. Just before 4am, Kim turned the corner. Her music was blaring. She pulled into the driveway, got out to open the garage door and that's when Nick and Joey, both wearing gloves, pounced on her. Joey grabbed her from behind, put duct tape around her eyes and mouth and forced her into the trunk of her own car. Nick drove Kim's Honda while Joey followed in his car. They drove to the house in Woodhaven and Joey carried Kim into that house, unlocking it with a key that they had. They took her down to the basement, tied her to a chair, handcuffed her to a metal pole that ran from the floor to the ceiling. They took her jewelry off and they left her there. Then they drove both of the cars to Melbourne Long Island and left Kim's Honda on that street where it was later found. Nick tried to get into Kim's cell phone, but he couldn't. And they paged Josh with a code word, letting him know it was done. So think about that 552 call from Kim's cell phone, the one to customer service, the one that pinged near that hotel. Kim was taken just before 4am and by around 6, Nick said he was in the car with her phone trying to get into it. It lines up, "Nobody ever said for certain what the call was, but it's hard to imagine who else would have been holding Kim's phone at that hour." Nick told detectives that Josh had called Kim's dad Tommy and played a tape demanding money in exchange for Kim's safety. But they said Tommy never responded and they didn't know why. Meanwhile, Kim was in that basement and the dead of winter with no heat. And Nick said one of the guys wanted to bring her blanket after three days of nothing from Tommy. Nick, Josh and Joey went back to that house and Nick said that Kim looked unconscious. And he told the others he thought that she was dead. They planned to try to move her body, but he said they couldn't because she was actually stuck to the pole. And instead of calling for help, since she was actually alive, they turned to fire. It's sick. Nick said Josh poured the gasoline. Nick also said that Josh later grabbed about beating the polygraph. Remember that because he said he smoked weed. And when it came to Joey's murder, Nick said Josh told him that's what happens to snitches. And no point in his entire interview, did Nick express any remorse. He had never even met Kim. He couldn't even remember her last name. And in all of it, he didn't mention Julio either. And meanwhile in the other room, Josh still refused to believe that Nick was even at the PlayStation. Detectives showed Josh Nick through a one-way mirror, talking with the assistant district attorney. And Josh just kept denying everything. So finally, the detectives told Josh they had more. They had a camera at that gas station where he was filling up the gasoline. They had his fingerprints in the house where Kim was found. But neither of those things were actually the truth. But it worked. Josh flirted out that he had only bought the gas can, not the gas itself. And that's when he wanted to make a deal. He said it was all Julio that orchestrated the entire thing with Joey and Nick's support. Josh said he was just along for the ride. He was too scared to back out. He said he didn't even know where Kim was being held. And then he never even stepped foot in that house. But before the interview could go any further, They got a call that April had hired a lawyer. for Josh. Now, I don't know how Kim's former best friend, who supposedly ended things with this man, was now supporting him. I don't know, maybe he fooled her too. But Josh was no longer talking, however, he had already written down his movements for the night Kim disappeared, but he hadn't signed anything, and nothing had been recorded. On September 7th, Josh and Nick were both charged with murder, kidnapping, arson, and robbery in Kim's death. Josh was also charged with murder and criminal possession of a weapon in Joey's death, and both were held without bail. New York had actually just brought back the death penalty on September 1st of 1995, but the state hadn't had a working death penalty since 1984, and it didn't apply here, because Kim was killed before the new law took effect. So that was off the table. But when Tommy got the call, the two men had been arrested for his daughter's murder, he actually thought a little bit of relief, but he knew nothing was going to bring her back. And he didn't even know who Nick was, but Josh, Josh was supposed to be Kim's friend, so how could he have done this? Tommy described his daughter this way, he said, "It was her goodness that was her weakness," end quote. And at a press conference that followed, Queen's district attorney, Richard Brown, called Kim's murder, one of the most brutal and savage homicides that has ever occurred in this country. And Blondie, for her, the arrests did not bring her relief at all. They brought her fear. She had snitched on Josh, so her and her four children and Miguel were actually all moved into witness protection and sent to a hotel. While all this is happening, detectives were still looking for Joey's secret tape, and eventually his uncle Lewis came forward and handed it over. But he really wasn't the smoking gun they were hoping it was. Parts of it were not even clear. Joey had array sections of it as well, and if anything, the defense could have used it. And then the prosecution's case took another hit, because Blondie was actually caught smuggling drugs into Florida after a trip to Ecuador, so she had caught some federal charges. She tried to make up a story that she'd been forced to do it, and somebody was holding her children hostage, but that was a lie. And it just added perjury charges. How would a jury trust a convicted criminal and a perjure? She was supposed to be one of their biggest witnesses, but at least they still had Miguel, but he had a criminal record as well. Without someone else, Josh might walk, and that someone was Julio. But after the murders, Julio had left for Puerto Rico. In February, 1996, he was back in the States, though. And he, actually reached out to detectives, and he sat down with them. At first, Julio said he had not taken part in the kidnapping, and didn't know anything about Kim's death until after she was killed. And then Detective Pia told him his voice was on Joey's tape recording, discussing the kidnapping with Josh and Nick. So Julio changed his story. He admitted he knew about the kidnapping, but only after the fact. He said Josh called him at 10/30 the morning of March 1st to tell him, Joey and Nick had taken Kim. And once they got the money from Tommy, they would let her go. Julio had admitted to some involvement, so he couldn't just walk out of the police station. And he was in danger if Josh found out that he was cooperating. So what they did was they sent him to Suffolk County jail on Long Island to wait for trial. He was actually booked under a different name, Junior Cortez. And he turned down a plea agreement for two to six years. Detectives saw something in Julio that they could actually make work for their case, though. He opened up to them about losing people close to him, including his mother and his son. And he had actually dated Kim. So they felt like there was a little glimmer of remorse in there. In jail, Julio had a lot of time to think. And he called the detectives often. He was scared. He was scared of Josh and Nick that if they got out of jail, they would come after him and kill him because look what happened to Joey. When Julio first got back from Puerto Rico, he visited Nick and Jill. And he was grateful that Nick hadn't given him up yet. But Nick wanted something in return. He wanted Blondie and Miguel killed before they could testify. Of course, Julio refused. Julio knew police didn't have enough to charge him with murder, though. So we decided he was going to do the right thing and tell them everything you know. So here is his version. It started, he said in late January of 1995, when he and Josh drove past a car dealership, Josh pointed to an infinity Q 45. It was being sold for $45,000 and he said it was his dream car. And then he sat there and proceeded to tell Julio how he planned to get the money. He said we're going to take him. We're going to hold her hostage and make her father pay a ransom. Now at the time, Julio said he did not really think that Josh was going to do this. He thought it was all talk. But on February 27th, Julio said he, Josh, Joey and Nick were together. And that was when the plan actually went into motion. Joey knew about the empty house in Woodhaven. Angela's mom lived right around the corner. Joey had broken in the house, taken a spare key from a hook next to the front door. And that night, Josh drove Joey and Nick passed Kim's garage. He explained how she always had her music blasting when she drove home. And he explained the way she usually parked her car when she went to unlock the garage. They would wait for her to get out and they would attack her. They didn't have to wait long. Julio filled in the details about the night Kim was taken. Things Nick had left out in his version. He said Nick and Joey were armed with a handgun and a roll of duct tape. Joey held his hand over Kim's mouth so she couldn't scream. Well, Nick taped her eyes and mouth and they bound her hands and legs. In Julio's version, Nick turned the music up as he drove so no one could hear Kim as she kicked the inside of the trunk. In the basement, Joey pulled off Kim's boots so she couldn't stomp for help. And then they stuffed medical gauze into her mouth underneath the tape so she couldn't talk or scream. After they left the car, Julio said Joey threw the roll of duct tape into someone's yard. Remember the duct tape roll that was found? Then Nick went through Kim's purse, kept her cell phone in her wallet and tossed the purse in a shopping bag with a new pair of jeans into the belt parkway. Then Joey called Josh from a pay phone with a message. The party's over. That was a code that it was done. Julio told detectives about the ransom call as well. He said, Josh had pre-recorded a message on a micro cassette with his voice altered so that it sounded kind of like a chipmunk. That afternoon on March 1st, he called Tommy from a pay phone. When you heard a man's voice say hi, Josh immediately put the receiver up to the cassette player and hit the play button. The message said, hugged your daughter lately, 75,000, your money or your daughter. I gotta say it's pretty vague if you ask me especially in a chipmunk voice, but either way, whether it would have sounded like a real threat or not, when the tape ended, Josh listened. Thinking Tommy would at least say something, but there was just silence. Nobody was there. He was confused and he was agitated so we called back and the same thing happened. He never spoke to Tommy. At this point, Julio told the detectives that he was worried because it was winter and Kim would be freezing and hungry. So he was the one that offered to go feed her himself or at least to bring her a blanket. But he said he didn't call the police because he was afraid of Josh and Joey. A couple days later, he said the man met to figure out what to do. Nick was annoyed. He had done his part and Josh hadn't come through with his. Joey was supposed to be taking care of Kim while they waited to hear from Tommy. And he told Julio he was feeding her and keeping her warm, but he wasn't. These guys are so heartless. And that's me talking. Josh was getting more and more on edge and so was Julio. They both been at Kim's apartment when her mom Marley and played that psychic reading. Remember that? And that one detail scared them, the letter J. Josh, Julio and Joey all started with J. And Nick went by little J. So Julio and Josh agreed they need to let Kim go. They actually arranged to meet Nick and Joey at Dunkin Donuts on Woodhaven Boulevard at 1 a.m. on March 4th to release Kim. On the way, Josh stopped at a friend's house and borrowed some clothes, which he put on top of his own clothes. He told Julio that after they let Kim go, he would throw the outer clothes away so there would be no evidence that he'd been in the basement. Nick and Joey agreed to let Kim go as well. But Joey was the one that wasn't happy. He and Nick had done their part and Josh had blown everything. Joey was worried that they have let themselves open to kidnapping charges if Kim went to the cops. Joey drove the group to 79th Street and Parked. They walked around the corner to the house on the 86th Avenue and they went in. Using flashlights, they made their way down to the basement, careful that they didn't draw any attention from outside. Kim was still in the chair. But the problem was she was no longer moving. Her head was tilted back and she didn't seem to be breathing. Julio said that Josh actually kicked her in the shins. and Nick used a knife to cut the duct tape away from her face but he accidentally cut her cheek, Kim didn't make a sound or move and they said they couldn't find a pulse. She was cold and she seemed rigid. It had been freezing for days and to them it looked like she had died from the cold but they were wrong. Kim was still alive and that's just devastating. Josh was angry. He thought if Joey had just done his part and fed her and kept her warm, this wouldn't have happened. Julio said he was upset that his friend had lied to him. Said he was taking care of her. At first, Josh was like we have to take her somewhere and then he changed his mind. Letting someone go was one thing but getting rid of a body was another and he told them we have to get rid of every piece of evidence tied to this kidnapping. So that's why Julio said they set the house on fire with Kim still inside. They drove to the gas station and Josh filled the gas can. Back at the house according to Julio, he and Joey stayed upstairs in the kitchen while Nick and Josh went down to the basement with the gas can. Nick took off Kim's handcuffs. Josh pulled off some of the duct tape which he said he wanted to keep as a souvenir which is just disgusting. Then he bent down, closed to Kim's head and said I'm sorry it has to end this way but life sucks. Shit happens. And he kissed her on the forehead. Then he poured gasoline over her head and her upper body and he said it ran through her dark hair and splashed all over the floor. He then took a match, lit it and threw it on her. Josh and Nick ran up the stairs as the fire started. And up there, Joey and Julio pushed the refrigerator against the basement door to keep the fire burning as long as possible. They all ran out and jumped in the car and Joey sped off. As they drove, Julio said that Joey snapped the house key in two and threw out the window. Nick threw the handcuffs into a storm drain and Josh threw the gas cans in a trash can. Back at Dunkin Donuts, they split up. Josh smelled like gas. So he and Julio went back to the friends place where he borrowed the clothes and he stripped them off, splashed water on his boots to wash off the gasoline. And then Josh actually drove back to Kim's apartment where she was letting him stay. He arrived at 2.45 AM. April was still awake. Tara and Liz were there as well. They were waiting to hear if they knew where their friend was. So they were right. They did get back around 3 o'clock in the morning. As far as these girls knew, the guys had been out searching for Kim. To think they were actually burning her alive is too much to imagine. Julio also told detectives that a few days after the news broke that Kim's car had been found, Joey was driving through Brooklyn with Nick and through Kim's car keys out the window to get rid of more evidence. Julio's account was exactly what investigators needed. Yes, he implicated himself, but by his account, he was less involved than Josh and Nick. Josh and Nick actually blamed each other. But those statements could not be used against each other at trial. And I wondered why it's because every defendant has a right to cross examine a witness against them. And you can't cross examine a videotape of their interview. And neither man could be forced to testify against the other. But Julio could testify against both of them. So he became their hopeful start witness. There's one more piece of this puzzle. When detectives told Tommy about the ransom calls, he was stunned. If you were thinking why this whole time, like why sitting Kim's dad responds to these messages, he never heard any ransom demand. Investigators came to believe that both times Josh called. He started playing his recording without waiting for the beep after Tommy's greeting. Tommy's answer machine never caught a word of that message. Josh's ransom demand had gone nowhere. And he didn't even realize it. He was just playing that demand in the thin air. But Tommy said he did remember two messages on his answering machine the day after Kim disappeared. But they were nothing but static. And that's even more heartbreaking. Detectives wanted to understand this. And so did I. So they listened to Tommy's outgoing message. It started with Tommy saying hi, followed by a pause before the rest of the greeting kicked in. And that's when it clipped to them. Both times a Josh called. He heard the high and he actually thought Tommy had picked up the phone. So he took his ear off the phone, put the receiver up to the tape, hit play, and his recording played right over Tommy's greeting before the machine even started recording. It was too short of a message. So by the time the beep played, he was actually just leaving static. Josh's ransom demand never made it onto that answering machine. Tommy never knew it existed. And Josh never realized he was talking to a machine, which is tragic. On November 1st, in 1996, 23 year old Joshua Torres went on trial in the state Supreme Court in Queens. The prosecutor told the jury exactly who he believed Josh was, the mastermind. Josh had sent Joey and Nick to do his dirty work, all so that he could have his dream car that he was too lazy to work for. And while Kim sat tied up in that basement, freezing hungry and near death, Josh was pretending to help her father search for her. When Tommy never answered and Josh thought Kim had died, it was Josh who came up with a plan to set fire to that house and Josh who carried it out. Now Josh's defense lawyer Martin Chandler didn't even give an opening statement. He simply told the jury that once they heard all the evidence, they would find his client not guilty. The prosecution walked the jury through everything. The guy who saw the blaze and called it in. The fire marshal describing what he found inside that house. How the blaze had been burning for at least 30 or 40 minutes before it was put out. The medical examiner that explained how Kim was alive when the fire was set. Photos from the scene were shown to the jury and Wayne McCook testified that he noticed the spare key to his mother's house was missing and he told the jury he picked up the mail at the house on March 3rd and didn't see or hear anything to suggest anyone was inside. A March 3rd Kim was in that basement. Liz and Tara testified as well and so did Tommy who told the jury how much he leaned on Josh to help him find his daughter. And he said that at Kim's funeral, he noticed that Josh never cried, but that Julio did. And that meant something to him. Detective Shavelin testified the back in March of 1995. Josh had given detectives a detail that only the killer could have known. The Kim had eaten for days and then came the moment the defense didn't even see coming. On cross examination, Detective Shavelin agreed that Josh had taken a polygraph, the one that he bragged about passing. When he told the courtroom, Josh had actually failed it. He looked stunned. Nobody ever told him otherwise, so he assumed he passed it because they let him go. He had been bragging about it to anyone who would listen to him. The defense demanded a mistrial at this point, but the judge denied it. With the detectives done, it looked like the prosecution was about to rest, but there was one more witness. One the defense didn't even know about Julio Negron himself. Now normally the prosecution has to give the defense its witness list before the trial, but the court had granted the request to keep Julio a secret. Why? Because of the danger to his life, if Josh and Nick found out that he was testifying. No wonder the defense thought this was going to be a slam dunk. Now back in February of 1996, Julio had been charged with criminal facilitation and he pleaded guilty in exchange for his testimony. When he walked into that courtroom, Josh was stunned and furious. Julio told the jury the whole story that I told you. He testified about driving past that car dealership with Josh and him seeing that infinity and dreaming of owning it and how he laid out his plan to get the money. Kidnap him and make her father pay. He told the jury that after Nick and Joey taped him to that chair in that poll, they told her that her dad owed them money. Then they took her pager, her jewelry, and they left her there. And then he got to March 4th and Julio testified that he and Joey waited in the car while Josh and Nick went into the house. Now that's not quite what he told detectives. Back then, he said he and Joey were upstairs in the kitchen, remember? But as Julio described Josh and Nick going inside, Josh couldn't hold it in. He jumped up in the courtroom and shouted, "You were there, too." But think about what Josh just did. In trying to call Julio a liar, he placed himself at the scene of the murder in front of the jury. The prosecution didn't even have to do anything. If he even had a chance for a reasonable doubt, he just blew it. But Julio continued. He testified that Josh told him he poured gas on Kim, kissed her on the floor. Orhead and said shit happens in life sucks before lighting her on fire. Julio also testified about Joey's murder. That Josh had told him, he smoked him. Julio told the jury because he made a tape about everything that happened. Julio admitted he was afraid of Josh, which is why he ran. He went to Puerto Rico and you only came back after Josh was arrested. But on cross-examination, the defense went hard after Julio. He had lied to police at first when they asked if he knew what happened. The defense painted him as someone who was in on the whole plot and hoping for a cut of that money, which is why he never told on anyone. But Julio's testimony held up. There were also people the prosecution chose not to call. Miguel never took the stand and neither did Detective Pia. The defense only called two witnesses, a man named Peter Rodriguez and his girlfriend. They testified that on the night that Joey was killed, they were with Josh playing video games. So that was if that was his alibi, video games. In closing, the defense argued there wasn't a DNA, there were no independent witnesses. All the prosecution really had was Josh's statement to detectives and Julio's word, a man who was part of the group that had lied to the police. The prosecution didn't hold back. They called Josh an evil and stupid man who left too many holes and too many people alive. And after nine hours of deliberation, late on the night of November 14th of 1996, the jury came back. Josh was found guilty on six of the seven charges, every charge related to Kim. However, he was acquitted on Joey's murder. And he showed no remorse as a verdict was read. This was just hours before what would have been Kim's 22nd birthday. And outside the courthouse, her father said, this is a very sweet birthday. It is the only gift I can give her for a birthday. And what a gift it is. Hours later, he went to Kim's grave to tell her and he left one of her favorite dolls there. And he made her a promise. Every year on her birthday, he would remind her that the man who killed her was still behind bars. He said on year one and on year 20 and for as long as I live. That same day, someone Kim never met showed up at the cemetery. Miguel Castillo, he found Tommy at that grave and he told them that he was the one who turned Josh in. And his mom was sick. Tommy's $10,000 reward was sitting in a bank account and he wanted to give it to Miguel. He only had $300 on him at the time, but he gave him all of it. And when Miguel's mother died not so long afterward, Tommy gave him $500 towards her funeral expenses. Miguel never received any more of the reward and it's not clear why. I had just wondered since it was true that him and Blondie did provide the information that led to not only arrests, but conviction. Before Josh was sent in saying, Tommy made his feelings very clear. Even though the death penalty wasn't on the table, he said he wouldn't have won it anyway. The death penalty was too good for him, he said. Let him rot in jail for 50 years. I hope every day of it is a nightmare. On December 10th, 1996, Josh stood before a judge for sentencing. The state asked for the maximum. The prosecutor told the court that Josh had treated Kim as nothing more than a commodity. To be taken from her home offered for sale to her family. And for the first time publicly, he laid out Josh's history of selling those bullways for indecent acts. He said, Joshua Torres is evil. And he called Joshua a coward who ended his crime in fire because his fear of getting caught was too great. Now, Josh was lured and asked for any particular sentence. He maintained his clients innocence. And then Josh wrote a statement in front of about 20 of Kim's family and friends. He said he didn't kill Kim. He claimed he was being sentenced for something that Joey did, the same Joey whose murder he had just been acquitted of. He said, I give my condolences to the family for losing such a precious jewel in such a hideous way. The judge made no secret of how he felt. He said this case cried out for the death penalty and that hearing this testimony almost brought him to tears. What horrified him the most was that Kim was alive. What can be more inhumane, he said? And appraved than an act of burning someone alive. And in that courtroom, Kim's mother heard the truth for the first time. She had been too distraught to attend the trial and told me a told her from the beginning that Kim died in a car crash when she was found dead. Now as a judge described what really happened, she broke down. Josh was sentenced to 25 years to life for murder and 25 years of life for kidnapping. And eight and a half to 25 years for arson, all to run consecutively. Marlene was so distraught that she had to be helped out of that courtroom. She was weeping the entire time. Not everyone in that family felt the way Tommy did about the death penalty. Outside the courthouse, Kim's cousin Lorraine screamed, where is justice? Kimberly is not going to have a life. Her life is over. Kim's aunt Francine said about Josh that he was an animal and he didn't deserve to speak. Tommy was quieter. He called Josh nothing but a liar and a low life. And neither he nor Marlene gave a victim impact statement. She was too devastated. And Tommy said he couldn't find enough words in the dictionary to describe what he thought of Josh. He's not worth my words, he said. In October of 1997, 21-year-old Nick Lombardi went on trial in the same courthouse. He had been offered a plea deal of 15 years but he turned it down. The prosecutors on Kim's case were back this time again. And they told the jury that Nick signed right up for the kidnapping, which proved he never thought of Kim as a human being at all. He never thought about the people who loved her. To Nick, she was just something to be traded for cash. Nick's lawyer argued that Nick wasn't even there the night Kim was killed. He said Nick was at a party. And that all investigators did was pressure him into confessing. Then the prosecution actually played the confession. On videotape, the jury watched Nick admit to going with Josh to the gas station and placed him in the house in Woodhaven when the gas line was poured. And when she was lit on fire, Tommy had to take the stand again and relive the entire thing. He told the jury he would have paid any ransom to get his daughter back. They called in a telephone expert from Belodlanek to testify that in the afternoon of February 28th, hours before Kim was taken, a call was made from Nick's girlfriend's house to Kim's apartment. Nick didn't even know him, but Josh was living there. And Nick was in on the plan from the start. This time Detective Pia did take the stand. And in the middle of his testimony about Nick's confession, Nick's mother jumped her feet and shouted, I can't believe it, not my son. The jury also heard about the day of Nick's arrest. As September 6th, he went to see a woman who suspected new about Kim's murder and threatened her. He said, if anything looks wrong, I will kill you. And her eight-year-old son blurted out. I know what you did. I know everything. Nick told her he would be back. And thankfully, he never got the chance because he was arrested that night. Nick never testified. And the defense didn't call a single witness. And after more than eight hours of deliberations on October 16th of 1997, Nick was found guilty on all counts, murder, kidnapping, and arson. He didn't react, but his mother burst into tears. Tommy said, thank God, it's all over. The devil is gone. We can close this chapter. And the next day, he went to Kim's grave just like he did after Josh's verdict and Halloween was coming. So he brought decorations, a ceramic pumpkin, a vase, and a little scarecrow. And as he set them up, he told his daughter, we did it, baby. We got rid of that garbage. The devil is gone, baby. The devil is gone. On November 13th of 1997, Nick stood before a judge for sentencing the same judge that sentenced Josh. The prosecution asked for the maximum again. And the judge called Nick one of those soulless individuals, someone who'd been given break after break by the system and he should never be free again. Like Josh, Nick read a statement maintaining his innocence. He just said, I wish to say that the crime was terrible and I'm so sorry it happened, but I am innocent. Isn't it interesting that they all seem to say the same thing? I just think they're heartless cowards. The judge called burning Kim alive the most depraved and inhumane thing. And he gave Nick the same sentence as Josh. In the hallway, after court, Tommy yelled at Nick to go to hell and to live in hell. Detective Pia told reporters justice was done. And he hoped it would bring a sense of closure to the family. Nick didn't get to serve as much of a sentence because in July of 1999, he died in prison of an HIV related illness. He was 23. Julio was sentenced to two to six years for his role. And if he did serve his full term, He would have been released around 2002 today. He would be in his mid fifties and his whereabouts are currently unknown But all I have to say is who cares who cares what happens to any of these people any of these monsters This is one of those cases where everyone involved pretty much blamed one another and prosecutors were clear the Josh was the ringleader But the only people still alive which really note everything that happened over those three days are Josh and Julio They both said they believe Kim was already dead when they said that fire But the autopsy said that she was alive and even by their own account Josh had already shown Unimaginable cruelty taking her from her own home leaving her bound in the cold in the dark and spending those days at her father's side Pretending to search for her. He didn't see Kim as a person as someone that had shown him kindness that he didn't even deserve He saw dollar signs Tommy was given a copy of Nick's video tape confession and in the years after Kim's death he said he watched it constantly several times today In the immediate aftermath he was too devastated to keep working He actually shut down his businesses in November of 1998. He went back to work and Kim was on his mind Every minute of the day, but he tried to focus on the good times that they shared and let that carry him forward He said he had a huge amount of guilt for the rest of his life Sadly, he died in 2005 at just 60 years old Like any parent he would have done anything to be there for his child when she needed him the most He did everything right. He called the police within hours. He searched the city day and night He trusted the people around him. He simply didn't know where she was And there was nothing Tommy could have done differently to save her It's hard not to think about the times the system let these men walk free Josh had pleaded guilty to what he did with those young boys and he walked away with probation Nick held a gun to a woman in the rent her four-year-old son with it and his bail went from 25,000 to 1,000 Both men were free in February of 1995. If they hadn't been This wouldn't have happened. I think it's easy for people to imagine that an only child with a wealthy father grows up to be spoiled and entitled But Kim didn't she knew that not everyone had what she did and she was very grateful She wanted other people to feel good as well and to pay her father's kindness forward when her best friend's family needed a place to stay She opened her own door without a second thought But for all the good in the world There are people who see others purely as means to an end and when you're young and kind That kindness can draw the wrong people maybe with time and Kim would have learned who not to trust who to keep it a distance But maybe not it was in her nature to believe the best in people That's not a flaw and she shouldn't be blamed for it kindness is never the mistake You cannot see someone's criminal record from your spare room But we can trust our gut when something feels off Take notice of that. Remember Kim said she didn't like Josh that there must have been a reason But she was loyal to her friend April and Kim store was open because that's who she was What she deserved was a place where she felt safe. Now, there are not that many unanswered questions in this case But there are a lot of what ifs What if Tommy's machine would have recorded that message what if someone would have come forward sooner? There's so many what ifs that haunted Tommy until the day he died Some things we may never know and Josh by his own account Maintained that he never killed Kim, but I think she deserves to be remembered for more than how she died She was a girl who loved to dance Who loved blasting music when she was driving who loved Chinese take out with her dad on Friday nights and pancakes on Saturday mornings Who opened her door to a friend who needed a place to stay and she should be alive Today, I want to thank you so very much for being here and hearing Kim story. I will see you in my very next one. Bye

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Kimberly "Kim" Antonakis, a close, socially active daughter of Tommy, vanished on March 1, 1995, after a night out with a friend, leaving no trace of her car, phone, or belongings.
  2. Her father, Tommy, discovered only a gold earring in her garage, which confirmed her presence the night before, but raised questions about whether she had been missing for days or had been taken.
  3. Investigators found a burned body in a Queens basement with Kim’s tattoos, clothing, and personal items, confirming her death and showing signs of torture and deliberate arson.
  4. A key clue was a call from Kim’s phone near the JFK airport, and a suspicious alibi for her friend Josh, who had falsified his whereabouts and phone records.
  5. Phone records revealed multiple paged calls to Josh and others at Kim’s apartment, contradicting his claims of being asleep, indicating possible involvement.
  6. The case raised suspicions about ex-boyfriends, including Julio Negron and Sean Hayes, but no direct evidence tied them to the crime.
  7. A psychic’s reading predicted Kim was held hostage and starved, with the letter "J" appearing repeatedly, leading to scrutiny of individuals with that initial.
  8. Ultimately, the investigation found no definitive criminal link, but evidence pointed to Josh’s false alibis and possible complicity, with the case remaining unresolved.

Summary:

In March 1995, 19-year-old Kimberly "Kim" Antonakis disappeared after a night out with a friend in Brooklyn. Her father, Tommy, discovered her missing and searched for her, eventually finding her body in a burned-out house in Queens, where she was tied, starved, and set on fire. Despite extensive investigations, no one was ever arrested.

Key evidence included a call from her phone near the JFK airport, a missing car, and phone records showing falsified alibis by her friend Josh, who had lied about being asleep and later visited her apartment. Investigators also found Kim’s earring and personal items, confirming her identity. A psychic’s reading suggested she was held against her will, with the letter "J" recurring in names of suspects, including Josh, Julio, and Flatic.

However, no definitive proof tied any individual to the crime. The case raised suspicions about possible connections to organized crime or personal vendettas, especially due to Josh’s criminal history and links to underage activity. While Tommy remained devastated and committed to justice, the investigation ultimately concluded without a conviction.

The case remains one of New York’s most haunting unsolved disappearances, marked by a lack of physical evidence and persistent contradictions in the suspects’ stories.

FAQs

Kimberly Antonakis, her father Tommy's daughter, disappeared after a night out with her friend Liz. Her car was later found missing, and she was discovered dead in a house in Queens after a fire, with signs of torture and being bound to a chair.

At her garage, only one gold earring was found on the floor. In her car, investigators discovered a purple hairbrush, a folder, a spray bottle of cleaner, and her other gold earring in the trunk. A fingerprint and hair samples were also found.

A man named Flatic Rabinovich, known as 'Psycho,' was linked to Kim through claims he had a tattoo with her name and had dated her. He denied involvement and had ties to a violent gang, but no direct evidence connected him to her murder.

The fire was deliberately set with gasoline poured over the victim before burning, the gasoline was targeted at her body, and the fire was contained to a small area, indicating it was a calculated act to destroy evidence and kill her.

Several suspects, including Josh, Julio, and Flatic, have names starting with 'J.' A psychic reading also mentioned the letter 'J,' leading investigators to focus on these individuals, raising suspicion despite lack of direct evidence.

Phone records showed Josh was called multiple times at night during the disappearance, and he had false alibis. He was also called by Kim's apartment at 2:48 a.m. on March 4th, contradicting his claim of returning home at 1 a.m., suggesting he was not where he said he was.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.