Hayden Panettiere’s Mom SLAMS Boyfriend for Daughter’s Death: Report
21m 23s
Hayden Panatier died in August 2023 from a toxic overdose involving fentanyl and multiple prescription drugs, officially ruled an accidental overdose by both the coroner and Greenville Police. No arrests have been made, and law enforcement found no evidence of foul play, though the DEA is investigating the origin of the fentanyl. Her mother publicly accused Brian Hickerson, Panatier’s then-boyfriend, of responsibility, citing an abusive relationship, a large supply of prescription drugs bearing his name, and a history of domestic violence. Hickerson previously pleaded no contest to domestic violence charges in 2021, and both he and his brother remain uncharged. While the mother claims the relationship re-established control over her daughter, who had been estranged for months, legal experts note that the accusations are vague and lack direct evidence of drug supply. Proving fentanyl as the sole cause of death is medically complex due to the presence of other substances and individual physiological differences. A defamation claim could arise if specific allegations of drug supply are made, but current statements are general. Federal investigations continue, but challenges remain in identifying the drug’s source and proving criminal liability. Experts warn that drug trafficking operations often rely on low-level dealers who are prosecuted while higher-level distributors evade arrest, highlighting systemic issues in combating the opioid crisis.
The on-again, off-again boyfriend of late actress, Hayden Panatier is back in the spotlight after her mom publicly blames him for the death of her daughter in an exclusive interview that aired on National Television. No arrests have been made and it was ruled an accidental overdose. So what would it take for police to reopen the investigation into Hayden Panatier's death? We're on the case presented by Lawncrime. I'm Chris Stewart. It's been just over three months since the late actress Hayden Panatier lost her life and a lot of information has come to light since. It was out one 51 in the afternoon on August 16th when Zach Hickerson, the brother of Panatier's then boyfriend, Brian, called 911 to report the actress unresponsive in her and Brian Hickerson's Greenville South Carolina Airbnb. If you breathing out of it, no. Okay, we need to start CPR. By 232 that day, Panatier was pronounced dead and the first people interviewed in the investigation were the Hickerson brothers. And here's what Brian reportedly told police this is taken from the Greenville Police Department incident report. Peradapted, they arrived at Greenville, Sparnberg Airport last night from Los Angeles. Peradapted, he woke up this morning around 10-10-30 and the deceitant was awake in the bathroom putting on her makeup. Peradapted, they ate cereal together and afterwards he fell back asleep. Peradapted, he was woken up this afternoon by his brother, redacted, knocking on the door. Peradapted, he got up and let redacted in. Peradapted the deceitant and he had slept on the sofa bed in the living room the night before. Peradapted, they had planned to stay at this Airbnb and his brother was to join them today from Nashville. Peradapted, redacted, he went to wake the deceitant so they could go to lunch. Peradapted, he found the deceitant sitting criss-cross applesauce, their words in the court documents, face down and unresponsive on the sofa bed. Redacted stated that it is not uncommon for the deceitant to fall asleep in that position. Peradapted, the deceitant was purple in color and he administered a nasal narcan. Peradapted, the deceitant remained unresponsive so he administered another narcan without any changes. Peradapted, he told redacted to call 911 and they started CPR. Peradapted, they continued compressions and rescue breaths until emergency medical services arrived on scene. As police continue their investigation, the final coroner's report is released in September saying that Hayden Panatier died from "toxic effects of fentanyl" as well as several other medications. The coroner officially ruled Panatier's death in accidental overdose and it was a month later, on October 28th, that the Greenville Police Department announced their own conclusions. That based on the coroner's report and the department's own investigation, they were also ruling Panatier's death in accidental overdose. No arrests have been made in the case as far as the death investigation is concerned, but the DEA has also investigated the potential source of the drugs involved in Panatier's death, although it's unclear whether that federal investigation remains active. While law enforcement found no evidence of foul play, Vogel shared her own personal view of the case through an exclusive interview with Inside Edition on Monday. So I will add, her accusations have not been substantiated by investigators. When asked if she believed Brian Hickerson was responsible for her daughter's death, she told Inside Edition's Eva Pilgrim, quote, "absolutely. There's no doubt in my mind." I think that he knows that. I think that his brother Zach also feels responsible and quote, "Vogel also told the publication that Brian appeared to threaten her." Saying, quote, "I did get some harassing emails from Brian, which I certainly did not respond to, and then, of course, I blocked him." He was just threatening any statements that I had made that he could come after me. He could take action, something like that. I knew that wasn't going to happen." Panatier's mom has been very vocal since her daughter's death, specifically regarding her relationship with Brian Hickerson, and how it reportedly impacted their relationship as mother and daughter. She told Pilgrim, quote, "I had done everything to try and clean up her life in the end, and I thought we were making amazing progress." It was going very well, and then sadly, she allowed Brian to reel her back in. Hayden had clearly let Brian somehow take over many aspects of her life. I found an enormous bag of prescription drugs. All had Brian Hickerson's name on it, all of them. Now, I do want to add that Vogel said that she and her daughter had not spoken in roughly a year before her death with their last contact coming through text messages sometime afterward. Panatier has also described their mother-daughter relationship as estranged, both through interviews and her 2026 memoir, "This is me, a reckoning," including the toll she says Vogel's role as her childhood manager took on their family relationship. However, Vogel said that she was invited to Panatier's celebration of life, but did not attend. She told Inside Edition, quote, "I knew that some of the people there wanted to believe that I'm the horrible mother because Hayden was angry and made statements. I just didn't want to rock the boat either. It was probably for the best." As of now, Hickerson has not been charged in connection with Hayden Panatier's death and authorities have reported no evidence of foul play, but putting Panatier's relationship with her mother aside, she herself has openly discussed her struggles with postpartum depression, addiction issues, and domestic violence. Her began dating in 2018 and two years later, Inside Edition reports, that Panatier filed a protection order against Hickerson, writing that he snaps generally when alcohol is involved, pulls her hair, swings her around, and hits her, spits in her face, and has dumped water on her in bed and has thrown objects at her face. The following year, in April, 2021, Hickerson pleaded no contest to two felony counts of corporal injury to a spouse or intimate partner in California. He was sentenced to 45 days in jail, four years of formal probation, 52 domestic violence classes, and a five-year protection order which, under its original terms, would have expired in April, 2026, four months before Panatier's death. Also, in April, 2021, Brian pleaded no contest to charges of domestic battery and intimidating a witness in a separate Wyoming incident where he allegedly threw Panatier around the bedroom and punched her in the face with a closed fist. Afterwards, he allegedly threatened to expose embarrassing information about her if she did not drop the charges. He received suspended jail sentences on the Wyoming charges under an agreement coordinated with his California plea deal. Hickerson's attorney Sloan Ellis issued a formal statement on his behalf just days after Panatier's death saying, quote, "Haden's death remains under investigation and it is important to allow that investigation to proceed. As has been publicly reported, police confirmed there were no signs of foul play. Out of respect for Haden's loved ones and the ongoing investigation, there will be no further comment at this time. I will add, Brian did briefly address a photographer back in September when they asked how he felt about Haden's death responding with, how do you think I'm doing?" So, we'll have to wait and see if Brian decides to address the public further about the situation, but again, as of now, neither Brian nor Zach Hickerson have been charged in connection to the case. Joining me now to talk more about this, criminal defense attorney Shonda Radia, always great to have you on law and crime. What do you make of what Haden Panatier's mom is saying about her boyfriend? Chris, I think what Leslie is saying about the mom, I think she's kind of stretching it, right? If you look at the facts, the coroner said it was an accident, law enforcement said it's an accident, they closed the file, they announced that they are not looking into the boyfriend, there was really no evidence that he was responsible for the death. And if you go a step further, I mean, like when Haden died, she was very open about her addiction use as she was suffering with mental health issues. So, when they found her body in the Tox College report, she had several substances in her system, several prescription pills, she did that fentanyl, no one knows what caused the death, right? So in these type of cases, for the boyfriend to be responsible, it would have to be shown that he supplied a certain drug and bad drug was the one that caused the death and right now from what we've seen and what evidence we have from the coroner and law enforcement, nothing to that point to Brian. Well, and, you know, for people who have covered this story and know of Haden Panityer, I mean, for as successful as she was as an actress from a very young age, I mean, I remember her and remember the Titans, like, you know, she had a troubled life in a lot of ways and she had a tough relationship with her mom, I don't believe they spoke for, you know, months, you know, at least since, you know, maybe October of 2025. And so her mom's been out of her life for a period of time or mom didn't go to the funeral, you know, to go on a national television show and to, in some ways, accuse someone of being responsible for someone's death when you look at.
Ryan Hickerson, generally speaking, like how does a defamation case look? If he looks at this and says, hey, I didn't have anything to do with this and you're going on national TV, trying to tie me to something like this. - I mean, honestly, this could be a potential defamation case, but the thing is in these defamation suits, can you prove it, right? You have to prove it and then you have to prove damages. Like, what are his damages? What loss did he incur because of these statements? And I think she's saying he is responsible. She left it kind of vague. So what does that mean? I mean, he potentially could have been responsible in some way. She didn't say he supplied the fentanyl, she took and she died. If that were the words she said, then definitely that is a defamation suit. But because she's saying he's responsible, that's kind of vague. And if you look at responsibility, back in 2021, he did plead no contest to felony counts of abusing a girlfriend or spouse at the house when law enforcement came, the mother said that there was a big bag of prescription pills, the brine's name on it. Those, and she also mentioned that they had an abusive relationship, she had mental health issues because of their relationship. If you couple all those factors, I mean, there is evidence potentially that he was potentially responsible. He could have been responsible for her drug use or mental health issues that caused her to spiral. But I think so far what she said, I believe she still is okay. But if she crosses that line, crosses that line and gets into more specific words saying he bought fentanyl, he gave it to her, he told her to take it, then she's crossing in that line where a defamation suit could be a realistic possibility. Because in a lot of ways with how vague she kept it, because you could look at it and say, "Hey, I interpret this." Someone in the audience could interpret her accusing him of something criminal. On the other hand, she could argue that she was speaking to the totality of the circumstances as far as what the relationship was. The fact that she left it as vague as she did, even though the headlines for Brian or things, I'm sure if he logs on to the internet, he's not thrilled with seeing the fact that it is so vague, that is something that potentially could protect her. If he said, "Hey, I'm gonna sue you over this." - Yeah, I think he has enough to file a lawsuit. You don't need much to file a lawsuit, you just need some evidence. So he has enough for that, but whether he could win in court, I think she left it vague enough that how defamation suit works is, you have to prove what you said is true. So she'd have, her defense would be to prove that he is responsible in some way. And I believe some of the things we talked about their abusive relationship, the them doing drugs together, whether it be prescription drugs or recreational drugs, the issues they had could have led to the death. It could have had some responsibility. So I think in terms of that, if she had to defend herself in a defamation suit, I think she would be okay. It would be difficult for Brian to get liability and damages. But again, she's right at that line. If she crosses it a little bit more, I think she might be in trouble. - From the criminal side of things, with where an investigation may stand at this point, the DEA says that they're looking into trying to figure out how hate and pain it's here got the drugs that led to her death. They say this was an accidental overdose, but she has drugs, including fentanyl, which we know is at the center of so many overdose cases across the country. What does the process typically look like for the authorities to actually track down where she may have gotten these drugs? - I mean, the DEA has a lot of resources. When you get into federal cases, they have a lot of resources and they're gonna do everything they can to find out. I think the fentanyl is gonna be the main issue because in South Carolina, it is a felony after 30 years in prison. If you supply fentanyl to someone in that leads to a death, that is after 30 years. So again, when we look into Brian, if he had any part in getting that fentanyl supplied and it doesn't have to just be, he's the one that actually supplied it. If he was part of the process of getting it, if providing it to her, that could be potential criminal charges. But so far, we have heard nothing of that sort. Right now, it's been ruled by law enforcement as an accident, corner said it is an accident. But I know because fentanyl isn't involved, those cases take priority. And I do believe there's gonna be an investigation. And they're gonna go through every step, right? And they're gonna go through that fentanyl. They're gonna analyze it. They're gonna try to see where the locations in South Carolina, who are the dealers, and they're gonna do their full investigation to really find out who was the main supplier that led to this death, right? - Yeah, and I think of some of the laws in these states related to fentanyl and what the punishments can be. I know you're based in Texas. I used to in a past life, I worked in local news in South Florida where, I mean, the opioid crisis is a problem everywhere. But when I was there, it was a huge issue in Florida past some serious laws where if you were found to be dealing fentanyl, you could ultimately be charged with something like the equivalent of murder. When you look at cases like this, and I'm sure it would be since the DA's investigating a potentially federal case, she lived in Los Angeles, she was out in Airbnb in South Carolina. What are some of the challenges? Like say they find the person, okay, this person gave fentanyl to Hayden Panatier. What are some of the challenges in prosecuting these cases that authorities can run into? - I think in prosecuting at the biggest difficulty they have is a lot of times, if there's fentanyl and anything else in their system that's illegal, that shouldn't be in their system, you have to prove that the fentanyl was the cause of that. That is what caused this individual to die. And Chris, I'm glad you mentioned. Like I'm in Texas, I have a case is coming up in a few weeks. I know you guys are gonna be covering it. I have a young 18-year-old girl. She's charged with murder. Like the charge of the indictment is murder. All she did was, she was with a group of people, some drugs were bought and someone took some drugs. She was involved. She's alleging that she was involved in buying them and someone died. And so the charge was with murder. So that's where it is at this point. But again, the difficulty is, was the fentanyl the cause of death or something else? And the act is pinpoint and make it that fentanyl, that cause of death. That's the same thing in Hayden's case. That's the same thing in my case coming up. - And when you look at like a toxicology report, like in Hayden-Panetier's case, like you have fentanyl, but you have a list of several other drugs that were in her system. Like how clear is the information? And I know you've been a prosecutor as well as you've seen both sides of it. Like how clear can it be that, you know, fentanyl, which absolutely can be deadly? How do you prove that fentanyl was what killed Hayden-Panetier? - I can say there's no expert that the state brings can say with 100% certainty that the fentanyl or this drug or whatever drug was the sole cause of death. They can give an opinion that in their experience, based on seeing different things, based off, you know, certain chemical reactions, this could have been the cause, but no one can say with absolute certainty. So these cases are hard in that respect that the state not only has to prove that it was supplied, that they took it, but they have to prove that that was the actual cause of death because then diamonds gonna say fentanyl. And if there's several substances like there was in Hayden's system, I mean, how do you know exactly what caused the death? And really, you don't know 'cause you don't know how, if you think several drugs, how they interact, they interact in different ways. Everyone's body's different. So these cases are difficult, they're difficult to prove. - And in Brian Hickerson's situation as well as his brother, Zach, they have not been accused of wrongdoing, they have not been charged with anything. But at what point does in these situations where if Hayden has these drugs, and they're not, it's not like she had a prescription, you know, for these drugs, she's struggled with addiction. As far as awareness that she had the drugs or she was getting the drugs, like is there any criminal culpability there that someone was aware that she had fentanyl on her? If that was the case, and I'm not saying it is related to Brian or Zach. - If someone knew that she had her on her, I don't think just knowledge of someone having drugs is enough, it has to be more so that you were involved in the process of her acquiring those drugs. If there's evidence of that, yeah, then there is a criminal liability, but just having knowledge of someone having those drugs, you know, I think that falls under the line of personal responsibility. That's why our criminal justice system doesn't penalize someone just for knowing because at a certain point, people have their own, well, it's not even personal responsibility, people have their own privacy, right? And I think that's kind of protecting those privacy rights. - And I just, I also just think of, you know, in some of these cases, when you look at these laws, maybe it's Texas, maybe it's South Carolina, Florida, wherever it may be, where like they're these very serious charges, and you're, you know, trying to take people off the streets who are dealing very lethal, lethal drugs, yet at the same time, you know, I always wonder when you have someone who might be a low-level dealer. You know, they're just kind of the tip of the sword of the entire organization, just generally speaking, not talking about your case, you have coming up, and maybe not even really talking about Haydn's case. But let's just say they find this dealer, and it's this individual she gave her the drugs. It's like, what does that do to getting to like, the crux of the issue? And I know this might be even like a political question to an extent because we see, you know, you're in Texas drugs coming across the border all the time. And I just always wonder in these cases, yes, it's good to get someone who's a drug dealer off of the streets at the same time. It's like, okay, this is just one person, and they'll be replaced by somebody else. - You know, I just had a fentanyl trafficking jury trial maybe last month, and my client was a low-level dealer. The high-level people that were the ones running the operation, they weren't arrested, they weren't prosecuted, and I see it happens so much,
And I think the people at the top, they find ways to -- they're smarter about it. They find ways to prevent themselves from being arrested, being caught. They have plenty more resources. And I think what's happening, you know, and the reason it's called the crisis is because they get people that are low level, the people that have addictions that have mental health issues. They're the ones running things. They're the ones that, when things go wrong, they get arrested. They get prosecuted. The people at the top just replace them and then the cycle keeps going. That's why it is a true crisis, as you mentioned. But you're right. I think it's more of a political thing. I think to really stop that, it needs to be -- you need to start from the top and stop the people at the top to really get everything to get fixed. Yeah. And, you know, we don't really talk politics on the show, but I think when you look at this issue, you see some of these, you know, some of these cases where, you know, certainly the search is on. You want to find how she was able to get the fentanyl, and hopefully that'll save someone else's life. But then it's kind of the big picture of 40,000 foot view, you know, sadly, we see these cases where maybe it's Hayden Panettier or someone you've never heard of who lose their lives this way. And how can we prevent it going forward? Sean Duretia. Always great to have you on Longcrime. Thanks for taking the time to do this. Thank you, Chris. That will do it for on the case, presented by Longcrime. I'm Chris Stewart. See you next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Hayden Panatier died from a toxic overdose of fentanyl and other medications, officially ruled an accidental overdose by both coroner and Greenville Police.
No arrests have been made, and law enforcement found no evidence of foul play, though the DEA is investigating the source of the fentanyl.
Panatier's mother publicly accused Brian Hickerson, her then-boyfriend, of being responsible, citing an abusive relationship and a large bag of prescription drugs with his name on them.
Brian Hickerson previously pleaded no contest to domestic violence charges in 2021, and both he and his brother Zach remain uncharged in connection with the death.
The mother claimed the relationship with Brian re-established emotional control over her daughter, who had been estranged from her for months prior.
Experts note that proving fentanyl as the sole cause of death is difficult due to the presence of multiple substances and individual differences in drug metabolism.
A defamation claim could arise if the mother makes specific allegations of supplying fentanyl, but current statements are vague and lack direct evidence.
Federal and state investigations into drug trafficking are ongoing, but prosecutions face challenges in identifying the true source and proving direct culpability.
Summary:
Hayden Panatier died in August 2023 from a toxic overdose involving fentanyl and multiple prescription drugs, officially ruled an accidental overdose by both the coroner and Greenville Police. No arrests have been made, and law enforcement found no evidence of foul play, though the DEA is investigating the origin of the fentanyl. Her mother publicly accused Brian Hickerson, Panatier’s then-boyfriend, of responsibility, citing an abusive relationship, a large supply of prescription drugs bearing his name, and a history of domestic violence.
Hickerson previously pleaded no contest to domestic violence charges in 2021, and both he and his brother remain uncharged. While the mother claims the relationship re-established control over her daughter, who had been estranged for months, legal experts note that the accusations are vague and lack direct evidence of drug supply. Proving fentanyl as the sole cause of death is medically complex due to the presence of other substances and individual physiological differences.
A defamation claim could arise if specific allegations of drug supply are made, but current statements are general. Federal investigations continue, but challenges remain in identifying the drug’s source and proving criminal liability. Experts warn that drug trafficking operations often rely on low-level dealers who are prosecuted while higher-level distributors evade arrest, highlighting systemic issues in combating the opioid crisis.
FAQs
The coroner ruled that Hayden Panatier died from toxic effects of fentanyl, along with several other medications, and the death was officially classified as an accidental overdose.
No arrests have been made in the death investigation, and law enforcement has concluded there was no evidence of foul play.
Yes, in 2021, Brian Hickerson pleaded no contest to two felony counts of corporal injury to a spouse or intimate partner in California, and was also involved in a separate Wyoming incident where he was charged with domestic battery and intimidating a witness.
The DEA investigated the origin of the drugs, particularly fentanyl, that were found in Panatier's system, though no active federal charges have been reported as of now.
Yes, Brian could potentially file a defamation lawsuit, but it would depend on whether the accusations were specific—such as supplying fentanyl—rather than vague claims of responsibility.
The legal system relies on toxicology reports and expert opinions, but no one can prove with absolute certainty that fentanyl was the sole cause, especially when multiple substances were found in the body.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.