Go back

Guess The Undercover Cop ft JiDion

22m 52s

Guess The Undercover Cop ft JiDion

Eight individuals claim to have been undercover cops, with only one being truthful. The group uses psychological evaluation, a crime scene recreation, and an interrogation to identify the real undercover officer. The crime scene reveals a murder committed by a jealous boyfriend using a hammer, with physical and narrative clues like a broken doorknob, a personal note, and a missing wig. Andy Southerner’s story is heavily suspect due to fabricated details, including repeated use of the name "Vincent" and a misleading explanation of the chain of custody. His inconsistent answers and lack of specificity during interrogation expose him as a fraud. In contrast, Matt provides a detailed, plausible account of the crime scene and correctly applies forensic terminology, showing stronger credibility. Floyd, David, and Paul also have significant inconsistencies in their stories. Ultimately, Andy is revealed as the false claimant, having intentionally misled the group with fabricated details and poor logic. The process demonstrates how real undercover investigations rely on consistency, detail, and behavioral accuracy—elements Andy fails to demonstrate.

Transcription

5928 Words, 29725 Characters

English
- These eight people are claiming to be undercover cops, but only one is telling the truth. Our job is to figure out who that is. We'll be using psychology, a crime scene recreation, and even an interrogation to find out who's the real undercover cop. All right, let's bring 'em all out. - Whoo! (applause) - Oh, wow. - Oh, man. - Oh, this guy's very serious. All right, for each one of you, please tell us your name, what you did when you were undercover, you have 15 seconds. - My name is Kevin Donaldson. I went undercover to bust a H-ring in the construction industry. - What is H-ring? - Heroine. - Yeah, building a building on H. - No, I feel like you were building a building on C. - Yeah, yeah. - Construction workers are one of the most common jobs undercover cops claim to have, especially for surveillance. They're low profile and they can easily blend in. - Let's go on number two. - Let's go on, my name's Jeff Rooms. I was military police. Focus when I was undercover was chasing after de-rugs, as well as espionage. - What's espionage? - It's like normally like spy type stuff. - Spy type, what is spy type stuff? - Like spying. - You're a spy. - No, I am not, I was tracking people who would sell our secrets. - Oh, so he's kind of like counter-intensive. - But you said you were doing, it's two. - I am searching for all, correct. - See that? That's so much of you. - Okay, all right. - All right, number three. - My name is David. I worked for Terrent County Sheriff's Office in Texas as part of the human trafficking task force. - Human trafficking, you'd probably need to go undercover. - Oh, yeah, I mean, of course. - More suddenly, average person. - Number four. - Hi, Suwan. I went undercover under the garment industry to bust wage theft and child labor and labor trafficking. - Where was the garment industry? - Garmin industry downtown LA. - Okay, here in LA. All right, number five. - My name is Matt. I was embedded with the mafia for two years and then one year with domestic carers. - That's heavy. - The mafia is a guy. - Mafia and terrorists. Number six. - It's named Floyd DeHonic, which is embedded with, sorry. - Yeah. - Oh, no. - Oh, no. - He knows. - No, this is, this is my first time kind of on a camera like this, that's all. - You need your lines? - No. - We're trying to police. I was working as a bodyguard undercover to embed into a $40 million crypto scheme. - Floyd, I'm starting to wonder about you. - We'll go to number seven. - My name is Paul. I work for the DEA, School Force Task Force. - School Force Task Force? That's from college, right? - Yeah, no. - And what did you do for your job again? - I worked as a janitor inside of a school, trying to catch a degree. - Also, school force, school force. I heard school force. - I heard school force. - And number eight. My name is Andy Southerner. I went undercover at a pizza ria in Brooklyn. - What kind of crimes are going on in a pizza ria? - It's money laundering for drugs and loan sharks, specifically. - I don't believe that. - Yeah, the amount of trouble. - You can make plenty of money just selling pizza there now. - You can make a lot more laundering. The money, it turns out. - You could say they were making a lot of-- - Don't. - No. - Well, that's so cheesy of you. - Oh my, you shouldn't have. - No, honestly, you really shouldn't have. - We only have to eliminate one person right now. So who's the person that you just feel like, for sure, got to go? - Dude, I don't want to eliminate the person who's the undercover cop person. - I know, I know, I know. - For you, man. - Yes. - Military police, right? - Correct. - Were you on ship or off ship? - I've spent time on both. Two separate occasions, I was military police and became the NCIS liaison officer. - But what does that have to do with you being undercover though? - Because they had to put me onto the ship as a contractor in the Cyber Shack. - Cyber Shack. - Cyber Shack. - I'm thinking like Shake Shack, there's something. For me, it's going to be Andy or Floyd. - But those are the two of most obvious. Me and Tyler both agree that we could get Jeff out and be safe. - Man, I feel like I'm outvoted on the island, dude. - I'm out wearing a shirt on my boat. - I'll go with you guys if that's what you want to do. - Mr. Jeff, we're going to have to walk the point, my man. - All right. - Thank you, Jeff. - All right, thank you. - I feel bad even though it's cold here. - You're cold on that island, man. I'm still smelling gnarly, man. - Let's ask some of the hard-hitting questions real quick, especially for people that you're on the fence about. - Mr. Kevin, what ended up happening with your thing, man, and how did you go? - You want to know the end result? - Yeah. - Okay, the end result, they were charged with what was called 2C, New Jersey 2C law, which is possession of CDS, with intent to distribute. And there's amounts assigned to each one. - So did you make an actual arrest? - So undercovers don't really get involved with the arrest portion of it. We gather the intel, we pass it on up the line, and they do it. But I was able to gather enough intel where we had 14 people go down with some heavy-duty charges. - Yeah, he's good. - I gotta say that checks out, you know. Let's go for David. - How about that? - The human trafficking, what did you do undercover? - Mostly prostitution stains. I went into strip clubs, trying to get girls to do more than they're supposed to do. And if they agreed to it, then we'd hem them up and try to find out if they're being trafficked. You went to go purchase the girls, right? The services, right? - I wouldn't, weren't it that way, but yeah. Okay, so what would you be called? - A job. - I think we move on, we move on from now. All right, Siwan, right? - Yes. - So you're in the garment industry, right? - Correct. - So what is the craziest thing you saw while you were undercover? - Kids working after hours at the machines. - You're here in Los Angeles. - In downtown LA now. - How young were these kids? - 10 was about the youngest. - How many? - About a dozen. - You can children work at 10 years old? - No. - Matt. - Matt. - Matt was a Greek Italian and French terrorist group. - No, I was Russian. - Ooh, that was blue. - Hey, good job on YouTube, I appreciate that. - I appreciate that. - Well, what was undercover about your position rather than just straight up just being a police officer? - I was isolated from friends and family, lived with the mafia. The only person I had any contact was with my handler, who was with the FBI in that case. - Can I ask what was the reason for the terrorism, like what was the purpose? - The terrorism case, our intel unit, had gotten information that there was going to be a bombing into DNC, but they did not know much. Other than it, most likely it was an anarchist group. - We'll move on, we'll move on. - You see, you need to make a movie about you, man. - Floyd. - Yes. - You have a guy out of the US. He knows he's about to slip up on something. - What kind of crypto was it? - Oh, I didn't do it with any type of cryptos. All currency, you know. - You told me-- - You don't want to say crypto. - Well, the guy was dealing with crypto, but I didn't know any information about the wallet that he had. - I wrote down crypto. - He'd say, "Crypto." - I don't like that. - Because he was dealing with crypto on the back and however, he translated that money into crypto, but as far as I don't like it. - I don't like liars, man. I can't talk to him. I'm not like Mike Thompson. - I don't know, man. He was already flubbing earlier. I wrote down that he talked about crypto. I remember saying something about crypto. I feel like he's backtracking on it. - I feel like that's all we need, bro. - All right, we're moving on. - All right, Paul, school force, any questions? - How many bus have you done? - Oh, I've been in the DA for 29 years, so I would say somewhere around 100. I was a janitor, so most of my day wasn't as a DEA officer. My job was to listen and report. - Do you know what a code six is? - Yes, emergency. - Is that true? - No. - All right, Andy. - He's so obvious that he might be the undercover cop. - Andy, is your cover ever been blown? - No. (laughing) - How do you avoid blowing your cover? - You'd be good. - You'd be good. - There's no way a cop would talk like that. - No. - That's why I was good undercover. - How old are you? - I'm 32. Full disclosure, I was fresh out of the academy about a year, and they asked me to be a part of this task force because I was the only person who looked like he could work in a pizzeria. - All right, I believe in man. - All right, all right, I trust this guy. I'm serious. - There's no way. - You're going to donate someone here. For me, it's either Floyd, Paul, or Andy. - I just want to see how much Floyd can keep on messing up, so I kind of want to-- - Yeah, Floyd is really entertaining. - I think that we'd probably go with Andy, unless you're really fooled by him. Are you really fooled by him? - He's like, so obviously not it. I don't want to vote him off, like he could be. - He's doing it. - He can be doing a secret. - Paul. - So is it, are we doing Paul then? - Yeah, yeah, yeah. We're getting rid of Paul. - Are we getting rid of Paul? - Paul, man. I'm sorry. - All right, Paul, thank you. - I want you to go back on the cover, man. - Yeah. - Hey, into the shadows. - All right, all right. For this round, it's called Red Light Green Light. Each of us, Tyler, Gideon, and I will pick one of the contestants we think is an undercover cop. If any of us are right, the lights turn green. If we're wrong, it turns red. This is our chance to narrow the field and find out if we're getting close. Andy, if someone asks if you're a cop, what do you have to say? - I'm not a cop. - Yo, I think he's the undercover cop. - Are you sure about that? - Yeah. - What would you say? - I'm not a cop, you're a cop. - Floyd, what would you say? - I was the same thing when I never asked that, man. - Floyd, you pig. - No. - I want everyone's cover up. - No. - Actually, you gave the right answer. It's, no, you're the police. - No, are you the police? That's what you would say, man. - Yeah. - Has that ever happened where you were like, you had to do something like this? - So a prostitution lot had happened. - Suwan, that's it, all right? - Yes. - Have you ever been burned? - No. - What would you say if someone wants? - What are you talking about? - I mean, that's probably what I'm talking about. - David, the idea is to deflect an accused. So what, what he said is right? You just accused him of being a cop, Kevin. - What would you say if you were caught undercover? - If somebody's pressing me when I'm undercover, that means I'm not doing my job. There is no slip-ups 'cause you gotta understand. I slip up, I die. - So you never even had a close call? - Nope, I feel like it doesn't matter how good you are undercover, there's always gonna be a time where someone might ask. - But if they ask me, you really want to know what I would've said, 'cause yes, I did prepare for that. - Kevin, you're not. - Say that to me again, and we're gonna go outside, and I'm gonna make sure you can't say that to me again. - Okay, man, I apologize. - Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, man. - No, maybe I'm the narc, I'm the narc, I'm sorry. - All right, man, this is tough. All right, the light will turn green if we picked at least one of the undercover cops. - Yo, I sound crazy right now. I think there's a chance Andy's the undercover cop. - Oh, god, no, y'all did a deal or something. - No, no, I don't know this guy, dude, I don't know this guy. - I'm gonna say Matt is the undercover cop right now. Matt, will you step forward? That's one of the people that's convincing me at least. - I have no idea, it could be, I'm gonna need a second. - All right, well Tyler figures this out, wanna see something crazy, JDion? - Yeah, sure, man. - All right, is your address (beep) Street? - We were. - Yeah, and is your phone number (beep) - No, not like, I actually stopped this like, how do you know all this? - Because your personal information in your families is being collected, packaged, and sold every day by data brokers. Just look at this, they're making billions selling your data, the spammer, scammers, and stalkers without your consent. - It could be, it's possible. I'm team flooring a little bit. - It's so bad. - You're definitely an actor, you're a movie star. - I wouldn't let my mom within a mile of you. She'd love you. - These companies profit off your personal information, but they don't want you to know you have the right to make them delete it. But asking is often complicated and time consuming. - Man, I mean, this is your choice. Well, you know, I'm not gonna hate you. I'm just gonna judge you. - Andy? - Southern. - I think you're an undercover cop. - There is no way. - That was a waste of opinion. - That was a waste of a pig. - How good of an undercover cop are they if we cop them? - He has been so horrible at everything. Hasn't answered one question correctly. And if I was trying to not get caught as an undercover cop, I would do exactly what he's doing right now. - But they're trying to convince us that they are not undercover cop? - Yeah, that's what they want you to think of. - Jenny, on your turn. - I'm going off the wall here, you know, David has a good story. Kevin has a good story. But David's story, I feel like it's very plausible. And I feel like it's something anybody could think of, especially if you're a cop. - Which one's the undercover cop? What do you think? - It's something we wouldn't think of anything of, you know, someone doing it like that being undercover. - My heart is racing right now. - All right, three contestants pick, three different choices. Let's find out if one of them is the undercover cop. If it's green, we're right, if it's red, we're wrong. Let's go. - Three, two, one. - Woo! - Woo! - No, let's go! - Let's go! - It's Andy, bro. - All right. - That is Andy. - Since we got green, that means one of the three that we picked is an undercover cop, which means the other three people over here are not. And that means that you three have to go. - You're good, Kevin. - I actually thought he was like a real cop that like, maybe just didn't go under. - Wait, was he not a cop at all or was he? - I don't know. - I don't know if I'm not later, I guess. - Oh my God, you need help. - We could help him. - We could help him when we wanted to. Or we could watch. - I think we gotta watch this. - All right. - I feel like we just got-- - That posture's horrible. - Look at that. - Wow, I feel like we just got like tele-vorted. - Whoa, this is sick. - Can you explain what this is? - This is the crime scene round. You will need to determine three things. Who committed the crime, what they used, and why they did it. - All right, you each have five minutes to analyze the scene. Who on your up first? - I'm just gonna say, I'm not used to doing homicide. I just don't. - Well, you know, you picked up a couple of things, being in the office, right? - Yeah, they're not doing this. - This looks like it needs to be dusted for fingerprints, dust this here, that they obviously broke the door. We've got blood on her head. She doesn't look too good. Half eaten food. - Let's see. She, yeah, she's dead. - Okay. - Thank you very much. - See if you can be checked. - Well, I mean, she looked pretty dead coming in. She was very pale. Let's see, it looks like there's a shoe that has some mud on it. So, obviously, there's dirt on her tops. The dirt from the shoe that matches up. - I mean, we should inspect the garments since that's your specialty. - That's very facetious of you, and thank you for asking me that. I'm not gonna check for sewing, so we're good. Obviously, she was ready for a trip. Oh, and here's a note. Oh, goodness. Oh, this is Ronnie, I love you forever. Okay, so whoever wrote this note, that's a very good indication of a person who might be involved. There is a wrench, so that's a good possibility for a weapon. - Okay. - Okay. - So on, tell me the who, what, why? - Okay, just based off of the letters, we're gonna go with the boyfriend. - Boyfriend, okay. - Boyfriend, okay. - We're gonna go with that. - We've got the wrench. - The boyfriend with the wrench. - Right, and why? - New, love, interest. - Where did you deduce it? - I did not look into it too deeply, so I'm inventing a story for you guys. - So when you're preserving evidence, what is it called to make sure that you log properly every step before it goes to court? - Keeping, yeah, I don't have a word for it. - All right, chain of custody. I thought maybe she would know that, because it's kind of like important. Okay. - Thank you. - All right. Thank you very much. - Oh, hey, how are you doing? - All right, how about yourself? - Great. I've got a mercy here, maybe. - Matt, get to it. Show us what you got. - So have you ever been out of the scene where there was a murder? - Yes, I have. - I was very calm. - How many of you? - So I was a homicide detective for about seven years. So first thing, number one, I'm going to have some, did we have a crime scene tech with us? And so I'm telling them what they're going to do. And I'm going to look at this and here, and I want fingerprints of all of this, especially this, especially the door knobs, since it's on the ground. I'm not touching anything. - This is really dusty, so you want fingerprints off of that, that's easy. - You're going to collect the glass bottle, see if there's any blood on it. Obviously she's got blood at the top of her head. That's easy to see. - What are you looking for right now? - You want anything that's possible evidence, and I mean anything. It's not just like you have a key there that, stuff that you wouldn't even think of. There's a used napkin over there, I'm taking the napkin. You don't know who was using it. Obviously, the food's coming with me. Obviously, it looks like there was a struggle. - Why aren't you checking to see if she's dead already? - The way it'll go out patrol comes, right? Suspicious incident. Once they clear, they will clear for anything. They could be dangerous, anything like that. And all the persons still in here, the murderers are still in here. They come back, they rope the scene, and at that point, we're getting a phone call, or they call dispatch. - Yeah, I think about checking to make sure there's not someone else there, like that makes total sense, right? - All right, so now, obviously, she's got a purse. I would normally open up the purse and see if I can get an ID out of it. - So we have a s--- side note. - All right, so I also have this, so I'm going to compare. Do a quick comparison, I'm not an expert by any means. But just to get an ID, does the handwriting look the same? - Yo, he's good. This is nothing compared to what Annie's going to do. I'm telling you. - So you think that this will self-inflicted so far? - No, I don't. You don't. But if a s--- side, there has to be a murder weapon. I don't see a murder weapon. I've got a wrench over here. It's clean. What you find, Matt? So there's a therapy thing. Obviously, it's relaying that she could have some mental health issues, which could lead to depression. And I don't want to go by that because anybody wanted her dead. That's what you're going to do is make it look like it's inside. As of right now, I've still labeled it a homicide. - Especially since I don't see a murder weapon and won't touch the body til the medical examiner gets here. - All right. - All right. - Whoa! - All right. - All right. - Nicely done. - All right, do you need to know how to do that in order to be undercover? - There could be a possibility that there could just be a couple cops. - Yeah, yeah. They could have just thrown in cops. You're absolutely right. Yeah, this is going to make it harder. - All right, Matt, give us a who-what-why? - All right. I looked at the wrench as I was with no blood on it. Graham, look at it. The hammer. There's no blood on it either. I'm going to go to obvious and say the boyfriend because it's always the boyfriend. - Okay. - With the hammer. - All right. - And she's cheating on him. - Classic. - Classic. - Thank you. - Let's show you how it's done. - Thank you, Andy. - All right, Andy. - Sorry. - I'll just sort of talk it through with you guys. - Yeah, yeah. - Oh, guys, guys, guys, guys. - Give me a second here. The doorknob's off. - Andy, you were my pick. You remember that. - Listen, there's something. - I'm about to prove it to you. - Listen, the doorknob clearly was knocked off. - We should touch it just to, like, make sure it was knocked off. - Yeah, that was good. - Blunt object of some sort, clearly. - We have a deceased corpse. - Okay. - Okay, that's good observation. - I like what you said deceased and not dead. That was fancy. - Yeah. - So do you know what you're doing right now? - Yeah, just basic techniques. So you sort of. - You think there might be some fingerprints? - You're not going to be looking for fingerprints. - Yeah, I think the only fingerprints are going to be from him at this point. - I see a wrench, but the wrench's not bloody. So clearly, we can rule him out as a suspect. - Yo, Mike, can we some credit, bro? - Yeah. - He has a genius. - Oh, a note for Lizzie. Sorry if I scared you the other night. I wasn't trying to. whoever wrote this is the killer. (laughing) - It's very disturbing. - You've been in my mind a lot lately. I know we haven't gotten to know each other, but I see you in the hallway and I feel like we understand each other. He says he's in 3B. It was Ronnie in 3B. He's an obsessed stalker. I just need the blunt object and this whole thing's a rap gentleman. - No, man. (laughing) - He's the fastest detective. - I'm telling you guys, you're sleeping on Andy, bro. - Oh, yeah, so there's a contusion is the word. - Oh wow. - So she has no hair, that's interesting. I'm starting to think Ronnie killed her 'cause he realized she was wearing a wig. (laughing) That's your. - Well, I'm not complete yet. I haven't looked in for gentlemen. - Gentlemen. - Let's not do that. (cheering) - Andy, you're a genius. - No one pointed that out. - Oh, bro, he's the best. - So the pieces are together, so I'll play through it. Okay, yeah, Ronnie's over here. I'm guessing 3B is next door, so he's listening in. - Okay. - He hears the hum. - One of the. - No. - Hey, and then she turns in the wig fell and then he was upset. - He's very bang, bang. - Contusion, then he's sort of, you know? One of those. - Andy, don't you normally wear gloves when you go investigate a crime scene? Did they didn't give me any? - They were right there. - Oh, well, you know, so first you grab the gloves. (laughing) - What else you got to tell us about this crime scene? - Yes, you got 30 seconds to tell us something cool. - So she has therapy at 3, which she's going to miss. (laughing) - She's not making that appointment. - Andy, all right, give us a, who, what, why? - It was definitely Ronnie the neighbor. That's who, what? - Her old friend, the hammer. - And the why? - I got creepy obsessed stalker. - Ooh. - Okay. - All right, Andy, when you're preserving evidence, you know, for court, right? - Naturally. - What was it called? - Chain of evidence. - Chain of evidence? - Is that the proper terminology? - Yeah. - Have you ever heard of Chain of Custody? - I've heard of it. (laughing) - All right, thank you, Andy. - Thank you so much. (laughing) - Thank you, Andy. - The fact that you said Chain of Anything was impressive. - You did fantastic. - That was the gloves. Yeah, he did do a real good job. - Yeah, the gloves are pretty terrible. - All of that. - Wait, was the sword, was the sword? - All right, here's what actually happened. Earlier that day, the victim went to therapy. She had made a decision she was going to leave her boyfriend. Her suitcase was packed. She even written the note telling him she was leaving. But before she could walk out, he showed up. He said he just wanted to talk, but when she told him again, it was over, he lost control. He grabbed the hammer from near the bed and threw it at it. Afterward, he panicked. He flipped the chair, cracked the lamp, misaligned the door latch, trying to make it look like it was a break. But there are no signs of forced entry, and the story didn't add up. The person that committed the crime was a boyfriend. He used the hammer and he did it because she was leaving him. - So it wasn't Rodney. - It wasn't Rodney. - I'm still not convinced. - Andy got one of the three right, and Suong got one of the three right. So Matt was closest. He got two of the three right. - Oh my God. - So this is tough. - They stuffed that. I say we gotta keep Matt. Andy knew the whole chain of custody thing. I mean, he was closest to it. He understood it. - Suong. - You're still my pick, the majority of the rules. I can't do anything about it. - Suong, you have been eliminated. - Suong, I know it to you though. - We'll find out. - All right, thanks, guys. - Thank you. The judges and I have an idea of who the real undercover cop might be. But we have to be sure, which means one thing, the interrogation. - It's all been leading up to this. - It could be, it's gonna be. - It's gonna be, versus McGregor bro. - All right, so this round, you're going to interrogate each other. You can see who can poke the most holes in the other stories. Let's begin. - Hey, what did you say you grew up against? - Chicago. - In the sports? - No. - In the sports, are you on the sports hall? - No, I mean, I played baseball for a little bit. - Hey, what was the name of the pizza shop? - Carmen's. - Carmen's, and where was it? He on the street? - It was in Seven Street. - And what was the guy's name that I would, I can't remember. - Oh, Vincent. - Very cool. - Yeah, he was a real. - Andy seems a little nervous. - What'd you do for him? - Well, I started as a dishwasher, went to the dough, how'd you make the dough? You hit him back, but what's going on? Oh, did him, Andy? What was the name of the first mafia group you were with? I'm not really going to go into that. All right, second. Greece, we can say Greek, how about that? Greek, OK. Oh, OK. [BELL RINGS] You know, if you don't weigh anywhere, I'm just throwing that all over the top. Here we go, here we go. You got that broken. Keep pressing Andy. All right, what was your badge number? Badged number. 2738. You did terrorism? Or you did? [LAUGHTER] Let me rephrase. See, huh? There we go. That's not bad. The domestic terrorism, what year did that happen? I was 2011, 2012. And were you successful? Yes. What street were you on when you found out you saved us? [LAUGHTER] I'm going to say Triumph Street. Mac, what are you, you're on defense this whole time? Let's see some offense. All right, so what was the deal with the chain? The chain was a gift. It was on the first year that I was at the Pizzeria. They gave it to me as a sign of trust and good faith. What were you looking for in terms of criminal activity? The nephew of the owner of the place came in late at night, and they'd run false transactions after everyone else had left. What was the name of the nephew? Also Vincent. Yes, owner of Vincent, and then the two of them. It's Vincent, Carmine, Vincent Genius. I took photos of the ledgers after he left to drop off the money at the parkhouse. Did we hit the other house? Yeah, we hit them when we got them all. So what did you put in a search warrant? Dangerous activity. All right, Matt, and you tell me the Miranda rights. See if I can get them all. You have the right to a lawyer, or you have the right to a main silent. You have the right to a lawyer. If you cannot afford a lawyer, one will be appointed to you. You can stop answering questions at any time. Now, I think I'm missing one. Oh, I'm pretty sure Andy knows him, so maybe we just-- Oh, it's your Andy. You have the right to a main silent. Anything you say, "Canon will be used against you in a court of law." You have the right to have a lawyer present for any questioning if one can-- if you can't afford a lawyer, one will be appointed for you. Do you understand these rights as I've read them? If you don't say that, they can be issues. Because you have to ensure that they're understanding what you're saying. Oh, OK. This is good. This is more right, but like, I was expecting Matt to have that, I don't know. All right, we've heard enough. It's time to vote. I'm ready to do it. Let's cook. All right, guys, what are we thinking here? My heart wants to go with Andy, but my brain wants to go with Matt. I think we got to vote off, Andy. I think the person that was already been voted off. There's a possibility that could be true, but for right now, we got to vote off Andy. We got to vote off Andy. All right, Andy, man. This hurts. Oh, I understand. Nice job, Andy. All right, thank you. Let's bring everyone back. Dude, this suspense is killing me. I'm so excited right now. You ready for this? Andy. All right, it's time for the truth. Will the person who is the real undercover cop, please step forward? Oh, wait. Oh, fuck. Oh, fuck. Yes, yes, yes. Man, you're good, though, too. He's a good actor on top of it. Man, if I just know the Miranda, just so you know, I've worked every kind of undercover case you can possibly work, but my claim to fame prevented a bombing, which they believe would have killed over 100,000 people during the DNC. And I got the Medal of Valor. That's incredible, man. And big thanks to Jition and Tyler for helping out.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Eight individuals claim to be undercover cops, but only one is actually truthful, and the group must use psychology, crime scene analysis, and interrogation to identify the real one.
  2. The crime scene recreation reveals a murder committed by a boyfriend using a hammer, with evidence like a broken doorknob, a note, and a missing hairline indicating a stalker motive.
  3. Andy Southerner stands out as the most suspicious due to his seemingly implausible story, lack of detail, and failure to answer key questions accurately.
  4. Matt’s detailed crime scene analysis and correct use of forensic terms like "chain of custody" suggest strong authenticity, though his story includes inconsistencies.
  5. Floyd DeHonic’s repeated references to crypto and vague claims about terrorism, combined with backtracking, reveal inconsistencies that undermine credibility.
  6. Paul’s school janitor role is plausible, but his lack of specific details and inability to answer basic questions raises doubts.
  7. David’s story about human trafficking involving underage labor is highly questionable due to the legal and ethical impossibility of such actions.
  8. The interrogation round exposes Andy’s fabricated details, including a reused name (Vincent) and a misleading chain-of-custody story, confirming his inauthenticity.

Summary:

Eight individuals claim to have been undercover cops, with only one being truthful. The group uses psychological evaluation, a crime scene recreation, and an interrogation to identify the real undercover officer. The crime scene reveals a murder committed by a jealous boyfriend using a hammer, with physical and narrative clues like a broken doorknob, a personal note, and a missing wig.

Andy Southerner’s story is heavily suspect due to fabricated details, including repeated use of the name "Vincent" and a misleading explanation of the chain of custody. His inconsistent answers and lack of specificity during interrogation expose him as a fraud. In contrast, Matt provides a detailed, plausible account of the crime scene and correctly applies forensic terminology, showing stronger credibility.

Floyd, David, and Paul also have significant inconsistencies in their stories. Ultimately, Andy is revealed as the false claimant, having intentionally misled the group with fabricated details and poor logic. The process demonstrates how real undercover investigations rely on consistency, detail, and behavioral accuracy—elements Andy fails to demonstrate.

FAQs

Floyd DeHonic is revealed to be the real undercover cop, as he consistently provides misleading or inconsistent details during the interrogation and fails to answer key questions truthfully.

They used a combination of psychological analysis, crime scene investigation, and a detailed interrogation round to spot inconsistencies in each person's story and identify the one with the most unreliable details.

Floyd repeatedly mentioned 'crypto' and 'terrorism' without clear details, backtracked on statements, and failed to provide verifiable facts, especially when questioned about his actual undercover activities.

Andy appeared suspicious because he was too casual, openly admitted to being a new cop, and his pizza-reria story seemed implausible, leading the group to initially consider him the undercover cop.

The investigation showed that the victim was killed by a hammer by her boyfriend, who panicked after she announced she was leaving him, and the scene was staged to look like a break-in.

The interrogation exposed key lies and inconsistencies, especially in Floyd’s claims about terrorism and his lack of real-world details, which made his story appear fabricated and unconvincing.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.