Graham Platner and the Rise of the ‘Dirtbag’ Democrat
43m 1s
Graham Plattner’s emergence as a Democratic Senate candidate in Maine reflects a growing trend within the party to embrace younger, "authentic" figures who appear relatable and morally outspoken. His appeal lies in his youth, anti-war stance, and perceived connection to average voters, especially amid fatigue toward older politicians. However, a series of scandals—including a Nazi-themed tattoo and past sexting—have sparked intense ethical scrutiny, with critics arguing that such behavior undermines the standards expected of a U.S. Senator. The discussion highlights a broader tension in modern politics: whether personal flaws can be seen as politically advantageous in times of polarization. Meanwhile, Republicans are showing internal shifts, with members voting to demand Trump withdraw from Iran and reacting against his slush fund, signaling a breakdown in his political dominance. On a deeper level, the Democratic Party faces a crisis of identity—lacking a unifying, principled vision that can unite diverse constituencies. While some see personal failings as a way to appeal to voters, others warn that this risks normalizing morally questionable leadership. The conversation underscores the urgent need for Democrats to develop a clear, shared value-based platform—such as equality and liberty—that can transcend ideological divides and offer a compelling, coherent alternative to the current political climate.
You know, I have an electric car and a charging station at home that's connected to my solar
panels.
The charging station is connected to your solar panels?
Yeah.
I don't really pay for fuel anymore.
You are ready for the zombie apocalypse.
They're knifing each other at the gas pump.
Jamel will be like, later.
I'm Michelle Cottle.
I cover national politics for New York Times Opinion.
And this week, I'm here with the usual suspects.
My fabulous colleagues and columnists, David French and Jamel Bowie.
Guys, how's it going?
Hey, Michelle.
Hello, hello.
Hello, hello.
All right.
This week, I want us to talk about Graham Plattner, the headline-grabbing Democratic
Senate candidate at the center of Tuesday's main primary elections.
What does his rise say about where Dems are placing their bets on the future leadership
of the party?
And bigger picture, what is the role of morality and authenticity in politics today?
But first, I want to talk about the Republicans in Congress, which is one of, I know, everybody's
favorite topics on the show.
They're starting to show a wee bit of spine.
This past week, the House voted for a resolution demanding that Trump withdraw forces from
Iran.
To make this possible, four Republicans had to cross the aisle and join with Democrats.
Now, two weeks ago, after Trump announced his $1.8 billion political slush fund, there
was also serious pushback from his own party.
Why are we seeing this pulse now, and what do you think it means going forward?
David?
Yeah, it's a great question.
I would say there's a couple of things happening.
One is, I think it's actually true that, believe it or not, Trump is getting even more brazen.
So, when you're talking about the slush fund.
For example, we had a good time talking about that as, is this one of the most monarchical
things that he's done?
You know, he's subverted Congress.
He's subverted the judiciary.
It was a remarkable power grab, just a breathtaking act of corruption.
And so, I do think there is a difference in degree in some of what Trump has been doing.
Also, launching a war without preparing the American people, without going to Congress.
I mean, you're going to chip away.
And then also, I think there's a difference in degree in some of what Trump has been doing.
Also, I actually think this internal purge that Trump has been mounting is backfiring
on him, at least in the short term.
So, you know, he's gotten rid of Senator Cassidy.
He's gotten rid of Cornyn.
He's gone down to the state legislative level and intervened to endorse primary candidates
at the state level.
And I'm not sure that it's actually doing what he wants it to do, because he's obviously
seriously alienated the Republicans in the state.
So, I think there's a difference in degree in some of what Trump has been doing.
How are you feeling about it?
I see all of this as very much downstream, the fact that the president's, I wouldn't
say in a polling collapse, but it's clearly very unpopular and trending downward.
The most recent New York Times Sienna poll had him at 37 percent, and the disapproval
numbers are all in the high 50s and the low 60s.
And those are just those are just terrible numbers.
And I think Republican congresspeople are approaching this situation where, you know,
primary season is just about over and they'll have to deal with the general electorate.
And it'll be it is a general election, not even will be.
It is a general electorate that is quite unhappy with the state of things across all the big
issues that that Trump was elected to to deal with, mainly inflation and the cost of living.
And so I just think this is Republican lawmakers beginning to recognize that, like, yeah, they
have to actually run in elections and Trump is not going to be on the ballot.
Well, this does remind me.
When I talked to Thomas Massey, who was one of the four Republicans who sided with Democrats
this week on the war vote, when I talked to him back in January about all this, he predicted
that once the midterm primary elections were passed, that more of his Republican colleagues
would feel comfortable stepping forward and showing a little life.
And in part, it was just a question of timing.
In addition to being wildly unpopular.
The president is a lame duck.
People are starting to realize in Congress that they may have ambitions to continue on
beyond this guy who clearly cares nothing for the party and has no intention of doing
anything other than his pet projects.
It also does help that, you know, if you're talking about the members that he has targeted
specifically, Tom Tillis, who's already, you know, was already on his way out because of
clashes with Trump, has been pretty harsh.
He's been very harsh about Trump's attempt to stick Bill Pulte in as the director of national
intelligence, wildly unqualified.
And also, you know, they're starting to see a little bit of the limits of Trump's political
power.
His candidate for governor went down in Iowa this week.
And of course, I should clarify, we're taping on Thursday.
So by Saturday, it may have all gone sideways again.
But for now, at least, it looks like, oh, my God, you know, alert the media.
The Republican Congress is at least breathing.
And with that, let's just forget about Republicans altogether and go on to the chaos of Democrats
in Maine.
So Graham Platner, we've talked about Graham Platner a little bit, what his pros and cons
are.
David, I know you have very strong feelings on this.
But first, I want Jamel to kind of walk us through how we wound up here.
I mean.
Jamel, you want to unpack his rise and his appeal in the Democratic political world of
late?
So last year, prior to last year, as this Maine Senate race was approaching, the DSCC,
the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, was trying to recruit incumbent Governor Janet
Mills to be the kind of party endorsed nominee for the seats.
Mills.
You know, incumbent governor, one statewide, seems, you know, basically well matched for
Susan Collins, the incumbent Republican senator, except for the fact that Mills is in her late
70s.
And so there's this very there's strong uneasiness with the attempt to get Mills in just because
the public seems to be have grown quite tired of elderly politicians, to put it.
You're being you're trying to be so gentle about this whole thing.
You're trying to avoid those old ageist.
You're trying to avoid the complaints for the listenership, I'm sure.
Yes.
Continue.
But it is the case that especially in the wake of Biden, there's a lot more reticence
about older candidates.
Last year, there was another effort to find a different alternative, sort of a candidate
who might embody some of the economic populism and whatnot that has gained a lot of currency
in Democratic politics.
And my understanding is that Plattner is a recruit amongst, you know, a group of Democratic
consultants and the like who were looking for someone who would who would have that
kind of aesthetic, but also seem to have the at least political talent to be able to carry
a Senate race.
He is an oyster farmer and has this, you know, this.
Not quite blue collar background.
He comes from a relatively privileged background, but he's driven the Marines, serving the army.
And this was the guy that they found to try to, you know, as I would describe it, maybe
like pilot an approach, sort of like use this as an attempt to see if a different kind of
approach to candidate recruitment might be successful.
And last summer, Plattner did sort of take off among.
Democratic primary voters in Maine, in part because I think he's just young.
He'll be the youngest person in the race, in part because he speaks to a lot of the
frustrations.
I think a lot of voters feel he's in this funny way, very reminiscent of like a median
voter.
He kind of like he looks like sounds like just sort of like a guy and he just happens
to be running for the Senate.
And he was.
I'm very vocally opposed to the Israeli war in Gaza.
He condemned it as a genocide early on.
And that is a really important issue for Democratic primary voters.
But the thing about kind of recruiting just a guy to run is that you don't necessarily
know everything about his background.
And so there's been kind of a steady stream of revelations, scandals that range from,
from
Being, I would say, quite serious, which is the question of his tattoo to things that are not great, but I think for a lot of voters, not no longer disqualifying.
So the most recent one that I saw is his sort of texting with other women, not his wife, which 10 years ago, 15 years ago, candidacy destroying scandal.
Would you say texting? Because as I understand it, it was sexting.
Point still stands. A decade ago, candidacy destroying scandal. These days, I think.
With Trump in the White House and the Family Values Party having gone all in with, you know, Kaddish men.
Okay. Okay. So what? There's also this question of, you know, he's still polling quite well against Susan Collins and there's a real, you know, desperation to beat Susan Collins.
So I think.
There's two points I want to make here. The first is that there's probably more to drop about Plattner.
There's earlier in the year or late last year, there was stuff about his internet conduct, things he posted on Reddit in particular.
And this is the second point, which is that it is precisely because his whole political persona is just kind of a guy.
Okay.
There's an extent to which unless.
These scandals or these revelations, whatever you want to call them, tip into actual illegality or something, you know, extremely unethical.
I'm actually pretty confident in whether all of them, because they are, they are the kind of scandal that reinforces the political persona.
You know what I mean?
David, I wanted you to jump in here because I know you have some fairly harsh views about some of Plattner's.
Some of Plattner's behavior or history. You want to, you want to get a little bit into that?
Yeah. You know, the guy is waving red flags everywhere. It's like he's waving flags, abort, abort, no, don't do this.
Because it's not just that he has a number of scandals, the nature of them and the way that he's responded to them raises the possibility that this is just not, let's just be.
That he's not the kind of person you would want in the United States Senate, to put it mildly.
So, you know, here you have a guy who's had an SS tattoo.
So it's not just Nazi, it's sort of super Nazi involving a unit that one of its jobs was guarding concentration camps.
This is the insignia of, of the unit.
And you're not lying that he didn't know.
No, the guy's a history buff.
The story has been, he's gone through a tough time.
He didn't know exactly what he was doing.
He's come out of the tough time.
He's better now.
And then we get the sexting scandal.
Well, the sexting scandal takes place after he's married, relatively recently.
He had a profile on a very, an app that's known, I think called Kick, that is known to be extremely, it's a home.
Let's just say it's not the home of the best people in America, Michelle.
And he has this sort of, you know, profile.
He's not wearing clothes.
He's just wearing a towel and he's taking the mirror picture.
And guess what he's doing?
He's just conveniently covering up in the mirror selfie.
You've got it, the Nazi tattoo.
And so, you know, you're, you just, you look at this stuff and I, and I know, and I hear the word authenticity.
Well, he's authentic.
Well, okay.
I, let me say, I get, here's what I get about the authenticity point.
We've all seen people who are like, you know, political bot 9,000.
That just sort of walk out there and they deliver talking points and they've got the right gestures.
And everyone's just sick of that, just sick of it.
But authenticity by itself isn't a virtue.
You can go into prison and there's a lot of authenticity in prison.
You could be authentically horrible.
So I want, I would prize of virtues over authenticity.
And you're going to walk into this.
And as Jamel said.
You cannot open social media without the rumor mill of just you wait, just you wait.
There is more to come.
And I'm getting this feeling that a lot of Democrats are walking pretty far out on a limb that is going to just get chopped right out from under them as more comes out about this guy.
Yeah, I know they're really nervous.
So the question I've always had is if this is what we know, what do we not know?
Because it's, you know, it's not.
Like this stuff tends to hit all at once.
And I mean, maybe I'm wrong, but that campaign doesn't seem the kind to go ahead and drop everything early so that you can get it over with.
They're going to let it drip, drip, drip.
But I do think that this whole authenticity thing and let me just say the whole authenticity thing aside from Platner has always driven me crazy because what it is clear is it's not that people want somebody who's authentic.
They want somebody who's kind of charming and folksy.
They want somebody who's kind of funny or whatever.
If you're authentically awkward, they have no use for you if you are authentically anything except a what you can fake if you're a professional, then they are.
So I just I have no, no kind of sympathy for that to the degree that it allows you to embrace complete jackasses or horrible people.
Not that I'm saying he is.
I'm just saying that that whole excuse drives me nuts.
And I get your point about robots.
And things like that.
But voters don't want authentic.
They want authentically charming and folksy and looks regular guy.
They want someone who can perform a certain kind of.
I'm going to sound like an academic here.
Perform like a certain kind of legible authenticity, right?
Something that authentic capital A refers to a set of traits that are politically advantageous.
And if you can perform them well.
Then you get labeled authentic, right?
So as per your point, Michelle, like if you are authentically kind of a patrician, that is like say Mitt Romney, authentic patrician.
That's sort of a hard thing to get past that reads to voters as being sort of like awkward and robotic.
Even if it's not, even if it's just, he's just a guy being who he is.
And that's why you see candidates doing all kinds of often very silly things.
You know, at, at state fairs at all kinds of places to try to perform the meat on stick this parade.
Yeah.
This particular kind of, of, of authenticity.
And I wanted to say real quick that setting aside the questions of authenticity and ethical behavior from Mr.
Plattner.
I do think that if I were, if I were a Democrat.
A Democratic party insider.
The thing that would make me worry is the fact that they haven't released this stuff early on.
Like the time to the time to drop all of these scandals was last summer.
Just get it over with.
Just get it all out there.
So how do we feel more broadly about the fact that his team reportedly knew about this?
The sexting history, at least months ago, chose to keep pushing forward.
Is that concerning?
Or do you, as you've noted with the morality question, Trump has basically blown that up.
When we talk about leadership and character, that's almost laughable these days.
When I would like be talking to people, for instance, one of David's favorite candidates, Ken Paxton, the Republican Senate candidate now in Texas.
When I would mention his long string of personal, I don't, how do we even, how do we even put this gently?
Degeneracy?
He, you would get laughs.
I mean, people would be like, oh, that doesn't matter anymore.
Like, like, look at Trump.
Yeah.
So have we reached, have we reached the point where that sort of thing just doesn't factor in?
And is it even, I mean, you know, honestly, is it even fair to compare Platner to somebody like Paxton or Trump?
You know, I, I, I, I don't think it's fair.
I don't think it's fair.
And I say that because so far what we've learned about Platner is that like, for lack of a better term, he's kind of a dirtbag.
He's just kind of like, kind of a dirtbaggy kind of guy.
You mean that in the nicest way possible?
I mean, in the nicest way possible.
That's, that's, that's versus Trump who, you know, wasn't, isn't just like a kind of a reprehensible person.
But like actively engaged in like harming other people in his private life.
Right.
And I'd say the same for Paxton, not just sort of like a slimy guy, but a guy who, who, who sort of modus operandi as a human being is to try to dominate the people around him in really ugly ways.
And so I think Platner is more on the Fetterman continuum than he is on the Trump continuum, which is just sort of like kind of dirtbaggy.
Okay.
So I want to drill down.
Just a little bit more.
As you guys probably know, our colleague Ross Douthat recently wrote about the subjective view of morality and politics these days.
He was comparing Plattner or contrasting him with someone like the Democrats' Senate pick in Texas, James Tallarico. Seminarian, very kind of straight-laced. As Ross sees it, sometimes voters view the, quote, sinner as more reassuring because they think that his vices are doubling as the promise that he won't be too fanatical or self-righteous.
So in politics, have sins and shortcomings to some degree become a political asset in some cases?
You know, I kind of had the opposite instinct that actually that the vice that you're seeing in politicians is an appeal precisely because it demonstrates that they are fanatical.
That, in other words, they are not restrained by the norms and the rules.
And in a moment of extreme negative polarization, at a time when there is an enormous amount of raw hatred, the presence of this vice says and broadcasts to partisan voters, I have no walls.
I have no rules.
And you can see this sort of mirrored in the talk around Plattner because you keep hearing, I want a fighter.
I want a fighter.
And I think if Tallarico loses, and let's be clear, I mean, the odds are against him.
Yeah.
I think there's a lot of sort of this burst of optimism.
But the reminder is that Texas is the Lucy with the football for Democrats, and it has been for some time.
He's got an enormous sort of structural deficit to overcome, not to say that he can't do it, but it's a tough race.
But I guarantee you if he loses, if he loses, one of the knocks against him will be, well, he wasn't a fighter.
Well, what do they mean by that?
I guarantee you that Tallarico will campaign his heart out.
That his staff will exert themselves to the limit of their endurance to try to win this race.
But he will not be a fighter because he's not cruel.
He's not belligerent.
He is leading and leaning into the race in a way that is trying to emphasize sort of, even if you disagree with me, I'm going to treat you with decency.
And that is not fighting right now.
That's not fighting.
And that's why I think that the Plattner situation is dangerous.
Obviously, he's not Donald Trump.
No one is.
He is the gateway drug to Trumpism.
Because if he wins, let's put it this way, if he wins and Tallarico loses, the cry across the land in that Democratic consultant class will be, find me more Plattners.
We need more Plattners.
These are the guys who know how to win.
And where have I heard this before?
Where have I heard this before?
And so.
I do think that we're at this really interesting moment where, in my question, and I do think we're in this thermostatic reaction against Trump.
Yeah.
But it's not clear to me yet the exact nature of it.
Is the thermostatic reaction against Trump and for decency?
Or is the thermostatic reaction against Trump and to pummel and to pummel the other side?
And I think that that's going to be.
I don't know how we're going to.
And I think that this who wins, who loses, who overperforms, who underperforms in the midterms is going to be an indicator of all of this.
The extent to which how Plattner and Tallarico in particular do this year, I do think is going to shape how Democratic consultants go about doing the recruitment, thinking about the candidates they want to try to find.
And I know my frustration about any kind of conclusion drawn.
From electoral performance is that this year, it's clear, as David was suggesting, that the the most important factor is just how unpopular Trump is.
And so it's almost I wouldn't say the candidates are immaterial.
You can have candidates like fit their states, fit their districts.
But I'm not sure how many lessons you can draw.
But people are going to want to draw the lessons in part because I think Plattner in particular.
And this is a point I meant to get to earlier is not just a candidate, but I think like he's like a position in like an intrademocratic party.
It's a factional battle, right?
It stands with how you view the kinds of people that Democrats tend to recruit to run for office.
Should they be, you know, polished with the right credentials, you know, in that sort of thing?
Or should there be a bit of a looser and more open approach to candidate recruitment?
So there are all these things sort of tied up in Plattner that I think don't actually have that much to do with Graham Plattner and have much more to do with.
These factional battles that are happening, right, have a lot to do with the particular constellation of consultants who are behind Plattner and who are looking for perhaps like a greater say in the direction of Democratic Party strategy.
And so that's that's I mean, to me, that's one of the interesting things about this entire dynamic about, you know, observing the arguments about Plattner online is that everything feels like a proxy fight and not so much dealing with like the particular candidate in the particular race in a particular.
Circumstance.
Yeah, that makes me kind of mental with the overlearning of lessons.
So like when Janet Mills suspended her campaign was everybody was like, oh, my God, this proves that, you know, Chuck Schumer was hideous in his, you know, recruiting and whatever.
I'm sorry. Janet Mills was is 78 years old.
She would have been the oldest freshman senator ever.
That enough was a problem for her beyond whatever kind of issues.
But if you look at who else Schumer has recruited, you've got.
Mary Peltola in Alaska and Sheridan, Ohio, and Roy Cooper, North Carolina, and Josh Turk just won in Iowa, which was a race that was basically internally heavily about whether or not you supported Chuck Schumer.
So I just not that Chuck is the greatest thing since sliced cheese.
Nobody's going to go there.
And in my position is that it may be time for him to publicly come up with a succession plan.
But just the overlearning.
From one race makes me mental on these things.
So just, you know, Maine is not the only show in town with this primary season.
We're seeing this whole range of options for new leadership in the party.
Jamel, give us your basic take on how the party should be trying to expand its tent.
I mean, you can break it down any way you like.
But like, you know, are we talking about more moderates?
Are we talking to how much should we be paying attention to anti establishment?
Disruptors, that sort of thing.
I mean, when you look at the landscape of candidates this cycle, I'm not sure you can draw an actual through line between any of them.
Right.
So or even since since Trump got into office.
So obviously last year you had, you know, Abigail Spanberger, a centrist Democrat, Cheryl in New Jersey, who is kind of just like a center left.
Democrat Zoran Mamdani identifies with the Democratic Socialists.
When you look at Telerico, he seems to be sort of like a standard Texas liberal in terms of his views.
We're not looking at a situation right where it's like, oh, look, the moderates are doing so much better than the than the progressives or the progressives doing so much better than the moderates.
A lot of it, again, as I said earlier, shaped by the overall national environment.
Trump is very conservative.
He's very unpopular.
And if you seem like a basically capable, reasonable person, voters are going to give you a hearing right now.
My sense of when you're thinking about how to stitch together a large political coalition, majority coalition, you have to have something that like your party believes in.
And it has to be broad enough that it can include a lot of people in specific enough that it's distinctive.
So I think the classic example.
American political history is the Republican Party in the 1850s, which was anti-slavery.
That's what it was.
There was no particular litmus test centered around this.
I think this is kind of the next point.
To be anti-slavery in the 1850s could mean that you were an abolitionist.
It could mean that you were a free soiler, meaning that you just didn't want slavery to expand, but otherwise didn't really care where it was.
It could mean that you didn't even care about that all that much.
And you didn't like black people that much.
You just didn't like the fact that you were a free soiler.
You didn't like the fact that all of the Southern slaveholders controlled the government, right?
It meant a lot of different things.
And the hat trick of that iteration of the Republican Party is that they were basically sort of like, yeah, sure.
Okay.
Whatever it wants to mean to you, it can mean to you.
But as long as we can agree on this one thing, that we're against slavery, we can figure out the details later.
And I kind of think something like that is important.
I think Democrats, and I'll say they struggle with this now.
They've always struggled with this by virtue of the fact that the Democratic Party has always been, from its very inception, this kind of stitched together brokerage party of lots of different groups.
But I think we're in an age where a political party that will succeed and that can bring people over, that can expand the tent, as language goes, is one that can kind of voice some kind of broad principle.
That, again, that's big enough.
That can. That can include a lot of people.
People can make of it what they want, but still specific enough that it's identifiable, right?
That like, if you believe that. this, then this is the party that you ought to support. Versus how I think Democrats often go
when it comes to trying to appeal to people, which is to say, hey, listen, I'm totally inoffensive.
You know, I don't trigger anything you dislike, so you should vote for me.
Oh, don't use that word.
You know, what am I, just coming from looking at it from the outside, I'm struck by something
our colleague Ezra Klein said in a podcast not long ago, where I think it was something along
the lines of, it's easier to imagine the end of the republic than a Democrat winning a Senate seat
in Arkansas. Which is, you know, one of those, as they say, tough but fair assessments. And the
question is, when I hear things like, what does the Democratic Party need to do to win? One of my
first questions is, where? Where? So if you're talking about in Arkansas, where the Democratic
Party has been in retreat for a very long time, where is the Democratic Party going to win?
You have Republican supermajorities, you have extreme difficulty breaking through.
Well, if I'm the Democrats, there's going to be a degree of, say, moderation or ideological
malleability that's going to be necessary that would be political suicide if you're running in
a Brooklyn congressional district. And there's just going to have to be a comfort with that
stitched together coalition. And I think that's going to be a very, very important thing.
And I think, actually, one of the problems that emerged for the Democrats is they were starting
to move away from that very stitched together coalition towards a much more narrow ideological
litmus test. And just as Jamel was saying, the one thing, the one test, if you wanted to be a
Republican in, you know, 1860, was you had to have some, at least some degree of discomfort with
slavery. The test in 2024 was far less virtuous. It was, can you put on the red hat? Are you pro
vaccine, anti-vaccine? Doesn't matter. Pro-Ukraine, anti-Ukraine? Doesn't matter. Pro-life, pro-choice?
Doesn't matter. Can you put on the red hat? And anyone who could put on the red hat was welcome
into this constituency. The Democrats could use a bit more of that, I'd have to say. This ability
to say,
hey, you know, I disagree with you on X or Y or Z. Welcome to the party, my friend,
because you agree with me on A, B, C, D, and E.
Oh, yeah, they don't, they don't really do that. So I think it's exactly the opposite situation of
what Jamel was talking about with the Civil War era Republicans. It is, the Democratic Party
isn't great for like big shared values that they talk about, but they got a ton of litmus tests.
And if you mess up those, you're in a heap of trouble. So by the time the next presidential
election rolls around, they are going to need to have a better message about who they are and
what they stand for, which, okay, Jamel, we're going to, we're going to bring this back again
to the, to the kind of future vision and leadership. You recently wrote about what a
Democratic response to Project 2025 would look like, you know, and by that, the Heritage
Foundation's conservative blueprint for a second Trump administration. So you are exploring the
future of not just how to rebuild American democracy, but the importance of choosing
leadership that can do that. So who are the leaders that you think would be good to help
execute a so-called Project 2029 vision of what America could be?
I honestly do not have an answer to this. Like, I really don't.
Really? That's, that's depressing, actually. That's sort of sad, right?
You know, part of what I, what I was writing was relating to what I just said,
a little earlier, was that I think the thing that, that Project 2025 was truly successful at
was actually sort of like communicating a broad vision of what they want the country to be.
And I think Democrats have a lot of policies they hope to, you know, pass, but I don't think they
have a broad vision of what they want the country to be, what, what they think the Constitution is.
Not sort of what they think it allows them to do, but like, what values they think it instantiates.
I'll say that I want to go to something David said a little earlier, and something you said too,
Michelle. Like, I, I am also anti-litmus test. I just don't think it's very politically useful.
When I think of, you know, the importance of principle, it very much is actually not
about a litmus test. Because people understand principles in all kinds of different ways.
But I, I do think that it is important to be able to articulate kind of just a set
of principles and values, and not kind of vague ones about, oh, you know, we all want
security and that kind of thing. But, but it's something that, that is substantive, right? That,
you know, if I, if I think about my own values, right? Like I am an egalitarian,
and I believe very deeply in the promise of like a multiracial democracy, where all
people are welcome in this country to participate in self-governance. That's what I believe in.
And are there Democrats who talk like that, right? Who can say, this is what I believe in.
This is what I want the country to be. And if you also want the country to be like this,
you should vote for me.
How are we going to fit that on a hat, Jamel?
We can disagree, we can disagree about all kinds of issues,
right? This isn't about issues. We can disagree about the proper role of, you know,
the level of taxation. We can disagree about even tough ones like abortion. But what do you want the
country to be? And it's fully stipulated, what do I know? I've never run an election.
No, no, no. But I'm saying, like, I'm serious about the hat thing. You've got to
figure out a way. This is your mission. You've got to figure out a way to boil that down,
so that it can be sold on the campaign trail. Because you know, politics is no place for nuance,
but if you can come up, if you can come up with a way to take your vision and come up with a bumper
sticker, you probably, you probably can rule the world.
A hat, a bumper sticker, a pin.
You know, one of the challenges on that is,
that you've got a kind of bifurcated electorate, because you've got a lot of people in the
electorate who are really focused very much on the kitchen table issues. You know, I want lower
prices. I want no crime. You've got a whole other part of the electorate that, it's not that they're
not focused on that, but they recognize that we are in an extraordinary time, just an extraordinary
time, where what is being fought over isn't just what's the best policy for reducing the price of
eggs, but what's being fought over is the nature of the American experiment itself. And so if I was
thinking of, you know, what is a political party I would be drawn to, I would be drawn to one that
is the party of the American creed. That is, you know, that all men are created equal. We're endowed
by a creator with inalienable rights. Among them are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
I want to be on that party. And the reason why I double down on it is because that is,
on the right in particular, is a very light,
live argument. Is this a creedal nation, or is this a nation that is rooted in a different,
in your identity? You know, your racial identity, your religious identity. And so that is a very
much of a big battle on the right. And it's about liberalism, small-L liberalism itself.
But I don't, you know, I'm not naive. I know that putting something like that out is like,
millions of people would be like, "What?" Your challenge then, again, is still you have
to tie that to how it will make life better for the people who don't have time to think about
big picture issues and are trying to put eggs on the table. So again, if you can figure that one
out, I will come, I will come run both your campaigns. I mean, Shamel Bouy, David French, 2028.
Okay. We're going to end with that and move on to everyone's favorite recommendations.
All right. Got anything to get us into summer mood, David?
Oh, so we're going to, this is going to be published on Saturday. So we're still
going to be in the middle of my recommendation is if you are not an NBA basketball fan,
if you've not watched the finals, you need to be watching the finals. Okay. So two things are
happening at once. Number one, you have the emergence of potentially a generational talent,
perhaps could be not just the greatest basketball player of all time, but one of the most unique
athletes of all time in Victor Wimbledon.
Yeah. I mean, I think that's a great point. I think that's a great point. Just an incredibly compelling figure on and off the court. And then on the other side, you have
the New York Knicks who are on just this incredible run that hasn't been seen for a long time. And by
some measures in basketball ever, but here's what's so fun about it. I'm enjoying the Knicks
because I'm enjoying Knicks fans. They're losing their minds. It's hilarious. I mean, just the level
of hysteria is just so fun to watch in this moment. Like we're just, it's like, you feel like
life kind of beats you down. Just being around a group of people who are in the middle of just this
most exquisite joy is so much fun. So tune in.
I'm all about the joy. Jamel?
I don't have any sports recommendations, but it's
basically, it's summer movie season, summer blockbuster season. And I have a little ritual
where the one thing that I do watch every summer is the entire Mission Impossible series.
Oh, dear God.
Oh.
It's what's eight movies at this point.
Oh, sheesh.
Yes. And they're all, they're all, they're all terrific. So I would highly recommend
picking up a film in the Mission Impossible series and giving it a spin. And if there's
any one of these, you should watch on like a big TV with a nice sound system. This Mission
Impossible Fallout, that movie is incredible. It's, it's in the theater. It's sort of like a
theater shaking film. It came out when my wife was pregnant with her first child. And we went
like a couple of days before my wife gave birth. And we were kind of almost hoping that the movie
would like cause something, jostle something. It didn't, but it was a great time. So that's
my recommendation. Okay. I probably have the stamina for two of these, but other than that,
that sounds like a very big commitment, but I will take your recs and, and, and watch and
watch a couple of these. So I want to go and I'm in a musical direction and invite people to
check out Stephen Wilson, Jr. It's kind of country,
indie rock with a kind of big dollop of grunge in it, which I know sounds weird, but it's fabulous.
And the best way I know to describe his voice is he just sounds, it's haunted. And that really
kind of fits with my mood a lot of the times these days. So Stephen Wilson, Jr., check it out.
And with that, I want to sneak in before we go, I need to sneak in an extra in-house wreck of
sorts.
And by that, I want to urge everyone out there to check out Popcast, which is the New York Times'
now weekly pop culture video podcast and chat show. So the hosts are John Caramonica and Joe
Coscarelli, and they are our culture, you know, culture critic and culture reporters. And on
Thursdays, they, you can watch or just listen to them as they sit down and chat with like the
hottest musicians, actors, internet celebrities, cultural influencers. You know, you can get
everybody from A$AP Rocky to Anne Hathaway. I think they have a recent episode out where they sit down
with Olivia Rodrigo ahead of her new album coming out. Check it out, newyorktimes.com
slash popcast. Or you can go to youtube.com slash popcast. I highly recommend. It's great fun.
And with that,
we're going to land this plane. Guys, thank you. As always, we've solved the world's problems.
And I hope the rest of your week is fantastic. Let's do it again.
Yep. Problem solved.
All solved. We're done.
That's what we do here. We solve the problems.
We're here to offer answers and slogans for hats.
We're here to solve the problems.
We're here to solve the problems.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Graham Plattner’s rise as a Democratic Senate candidate in Maine reflects a broader shift in party recruitment strategies, favoring young, relatable, and visibly authentic figures over traditional, experienced candidates.
Plattner’s appeal stems from his perceived median voter alignment, youthful image, and strong stance against the Gaza war, resonating with Democratic primary voters amid fatigue toward older politicians.
A series of scandals—including a Nazi-themed tattoo and past sexting—have raised serious ethical concerns, with critics arguing that his behavior undermines the integrity of Senate leadership.
The Democratic Party is grappling with how to balance authenticity and morality, with some viewing personal failings as a political asset in polarized times, while others warn such traits signal a dangerous erosion of standards.
The Republican party is showing signs of internal cohesion, with members voting to demand Trump’s withdrawal from Iran and distancing from his political slush fund, signaling a backlash against his leadership and unpopularity.
Critics argue that the Democratic party lacks a clear, unifying vision or shared values, relying instead on litmus tests that alienate voters and fail to build a broad coalition.
There is growing concern that Plattner's success could signal a shift toward more disruptive, morally ambiguous candidates as a strategy to win elections, potentially normalizing a “Trump-style” political aesthetic.
The broader political discourse highlights the need for Democrats to articulate a strong, principled identity—centered on shared values like equality and liberty—able to unite diverse voters without compromising on core beliefs.
Summary:
Graham Plattner’s emergence as a Democratic Senate candidate in Maine reflects a growing trend within the party to embrace younger, "authentic" figures who appear relatable and morally outspoken. His appeal lies in his youth, anti-war stance, and perceived connection to average voters, especially amid fatigue toward older politicians. S.
Senator. The discussion highlights a broader tension in modern politics: whether personal flaws can be seen as politically advantageous in times of polarization. Meanwhile, Republicans are showing internal shifts, with members voting to demand Trump withdraw from Iran and reacting against his slush fund, signaling a breakdown in his political dominance.
On a deeper level, the Democratic Party faces a crisis of identity—lacking a unifying, principled vision that can unite diverse constituencies. While some see personal failings as a way to appeal to voters, others warn that this risks normalizing morally questionable leadership. The conversation underscores the urgent need for Democrats to develop a clear, shared value-based platform—such as equality and liberty—that can transcend ideological divides and offer a compelling, coherent alternative to the current political climate.
FAQs
Plattner's emergence reflects a shift toward recruiting younger, non-traditional candidates who seem authentic and relatable, especially in response to voter fatigue with older politicians. This approach signals a move away from conventional, polished candidates toward more populist, 'regular guy' personas.
While the scandals raise serious ethical concerns, they are not necessarily disqualifying as long as they don't involve illegal acts. However, they do highlight tensions between authenticity and integrity in political candidacy.
Democrats are concerned because his history—including a Nazi-themed tattoo and past sexting—raises questions about his character and judgment, especially in a role requiring high moral standards and public trust.
Authenticity alone isn't a virtue; voters often seek 'authentically charming' or 'folksy' personas, not raw authenticity. True authenticity can be present in harmful or unkind behavior, making it a flawed political ideal.
The party is increasingly open to disruptive, non-traditional candidates who appeal to younger voters, suggesting a shift from ideological purity to more relatable, emotionally resonant political personas.
Personal scandals can become political assets if they demonstrate a candidate's defiance of norms, but they also risk undermining trust. Their impact depends on severity and context, with voters often weighing emotional appeal against ethical concerns.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.