Go back

Good Culture: How Jesse Merrill Made Cottage Cheese Cool

from How I Built This with Guy Raz ·

1h 21m 5s

Good Culture: How Jesse Merrill Made Cottage Cheese Cool

Jesse Merrill founded Good Culture in 2015 after personal health challenges—his diagnosis of ulcerative colitis and his wife’s pregnancy—prompted a deep interest in clean, nutrient-dense foods. He saw an opportunity in cottage cheese, a long-neglected food with high protein and low sugar, but lacking innovation and modern appeal. Drawing from his years of experience in experiential marketing, he reimagined the product with simple, clean-label ingredients, a creamy texture, and fruit-on-bottom single-serve cups. Early traction came through strategic sampling and in-store education at Whole Foods and Sprouts, where consumers were initially confused by the product’s unfamiliarity. The team faced intense pressure to meet high weekly sales targets in these stores, requiring constant shelf monitoring and rapid clearance to avoid spoilage. Despite the challenges, the brand gained momentum, expanding nationally by 2016 and growing to $70 million in sales by 2021. Its success stemmed from a strong alignment with modern consumer trends: clean label, high protein, gut health, and mission-driven branding. A viral moment in 2023, when a health influencer created a creamy ice cream using cottage cheese, dramatically boosted visibility and sales, proving that the product could appeal to a new generation of health-conscious consumers. Good Culture’s story reflects how personal health experiences, combined with innovative marketing and deep product refinement, can transform a forgotten food into a cultural sensation.

Transcription

13949 Words, 74052 Characters

English
When you launch into a Whole Foods, you're on full reclamation, right, for like six months. So like anything that doesn't sell, you have to buy back. You had to sell eight to ten tubs of this per store per week, which doesn't sound like a lot, but it's a lot. It is. It was very hard. It was incredibly stressful for me. I was monitoring as many stores as I could. I would drive into stores and I would look at the codes and I would see that there was only a few days left and the shelf was still stocked. And in a panic, I would call our brand ambassador and tell them they have to immediately get a SWAT team in here and they need to clear the shelf so that it doesn't spoil out. And that's what we did. We were hitting all the highest volume stores and just clearing shelves, clearing shelves, clearing shelves. Welcome to How I Built This, a show about innovators, entrepreneurs, idealists, and the stories behind the movements they built. I'm Guy Raz, and on the show today, how Jesse Merrill traded film sets for grocery store aisles, made cottage cheese cool again, and built good culture into a brand worth a reported half a billion dollars. Our presenting sponsor today. is Anthropik, the team behind Claude. Every founder on this show started with a hard question, not the marketing plan, the 2 a.m. kind. Is this idea any good? Am I the one to build it? Should I quit my job? Anthropik got built the same way. A public benefit corporation founded on one hard question. How do we make sure AI goes well for people? So they asked over 100,000 people their hopes. And their fears. And are publishing what they find. Even the uncomfortable parts. Me? I've got my own hard question about AI. Here it is. If everyone has access to something that can help them write the business plan, build the prototype, analyze the market, maybe even come up with the idea. What separates the people who actually build something from everyone else? I don't have a clean answer yet. So I've been sitting with it with Claude. There's hope in hard questions. Ask yours at claude.ai/hibt. Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. Amex Corporate connects cards, expenses and payments to streamline the way you work. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/amexcorporate. Terms apply. If you read this article, you will be able to learn more about how to use Amex Corporate and how to use it. If you read this article, you will be able to learn more about how to use Amex Corporate and how to use Amex Corporate and how to use it. If you work on a small business, you know that having a clear picture of your finances is invaluable. Xero, spelled with an X, is a simple but powerful platform built for small business owners that makes managing business finances easier from day one. Accounting, payments, payroll and analytics are available in one connected platform. Reports, visual dashboards, forecasts and AI insights help owners better understand cash flow and make smarter decisions. Join the 5 million customers worldwide using Xero. Learn more at Xero.com. That's X-E-R-O dot com. When most people think of cottage cheese, they're not thinking of something they want to run to the fridge and eat right away. It's the stuff you remember your mom eating in the 80s or 90s. It's definitely not the first food you might think about going viral. But in 2023, that is exactly what happened. The world is not ready for this healthy food. It's the ice cream hack that has 60 grams of protein and loaded with probiotics. I don't know why no one's done this yet, but you can literally make the creamiest ice cream by blending good cottage cheese with raw honey or whatever sweetener you like. This is a video of health influencer Lainey Kate making peanut butter cheesecake ice cream with cottage cheese. And after she posted that video, the brand she was using, Good Culture, saw sales skyrocket. Though it might sound like just a lucky break, this wasn't a complete accident. Because the founder of Good Culture, Jesse Merrill, had spent years thinking up creative ways to market food and drinks. He'd helped build brands like Honest Tea and Activate. And he learned how to get people excited about products they might otherwise overlook. But the idea for Good Culture came from something a lot more personal. Around the time Jesse's wife was pregnant and eating a lot of cottage cheese, he was diagnosed with ulcerative colitis, a health scare that got him thinking differently about the food he was putting into his body. And as he started paying closer attention to ingredients, Jesse noticed something about cottage cheese. It was packed with protein. But a lot of the options on grocery store shelves were loaded with additives. And the brands that were selling it? Well, most of them looked pretty much the same as they had in the 60s or 70s. And Jesse began to wonder, what if he could take this old-fashioned food, make it with really simple ingredients, and turn it into something people actually got excited about eating? Well, that's the idea that became Good Culture. And by 2025, it was doing $200 million in sales. As for Jesse, he didn't set out to become an entrepreneur. When he was young, he dreamed of being a filmmaker. And after college, he got a job as an office assistant for the famous director Jonathan Demme. It wasn't glamorous, right? I was getting coffee. I was running errands. I was looking through scripts and taking notes. But it was really cool. It was just to be around that environment. And I did that for a period of time. I then started to get the itch to do more. I really wanted to be on a set. I wanted to be part of a production versus being in the office. And so I started to communicate my interest in looking for other opportunities. And Jonathan and team were fantastic about it. And they actually opened up a door for me to go to LA and work for Spike Jones, who was the executive producer. And he was the producer on MTV's Jackass with Johnny Knoxville and team. And so at the time, nobody knew what Jackass was. And he's like, hey, my friend Spike needs an office PA and, you know, it'll get you out to LA. And I had expressed an interest in wanting to move to LA because I was kind of, you know, looking for a change. And so that took me out to LA. And I went out there and worked for Spike on Jackass. And it was very exciting. You know, Johnny Knoxville and team would come. You know, running into the studio after they had done some stunt and cops were chasing them. It was like this really fun, you know, kind of chaotic environment. But again, for me, it was, it was, I was still an office PA and it wasn't glamorous. And I was continuing to do, you know, a lot of the same stuff in terms of running errands and getting lunches for people, coffee for people, etc. And while I was in that mode, I needed more money. I was looking for ways to make more cash. And I was talking to a bunch of friends who were in the industry. And several of them pointed to event marketing or experiential marketing firms or agencies that would hire folks to, you know, come on as brand ambassadors. I had some friends that introduced me to an agency and they were hiring brand ambassadors. And I started just taking on contract positions where I'd be hired, you know, I would be hired to pass out samples for various products. And this is like, this is like you would go like, let's say it was like a vodka brand. You'd go to a bar. With like 20 attractive young people, men and women, and you'd have them go up to the bar and make sure that they were loudly ordering, you know, Tito's or whatever. I mean, that's just one example of like that kind of marketing, right? Like, and, and then you might have people giving samples or something like that in addition to it. Yeah, that's right. I, my, for one of my first sampling jobs is working for KY. The lubricant. The lubricant brand. Yes. So I, so this is. So this was in, this was in San Diego and I was actually on the streets in San Diego passing out samples of KY. Like along the beat, like the boardwalk. That's right. That's right. And so that was like one of my first jobs. I'm like, all right, this is, this is fun. Just packets of relatively easy. Yes. Yeah. Just packets and you're passing them out and, you know, you're getting capturing content and, you know, everyone thought it was, you know, fun. Oh, you're filming this stuff too. Yeah. I mean, I, I personally wasn't. I wasn't filming it, but you had camera crews and people were capturing social media. It was pretty social media, but people were still capturing content and they would, you know, build out a reel and they would use that for their, for their client. Right. And, and so I was out there, you know, slinging KY for, for a bit. But, you know, worked my way up. So initially it was very transactional. It was like, all right, I'm still trying to like find my next film, but in parallel, you know, passing out KY and I'm making more money doing that. And I am that I'm making as a PA. And, and this is, and, and I mean, just to, just to like, for this perspective, I mean, I'll go, I think recently I was on, I was walking along the beach from Venice to Santa Monica and somebody was young group people handing out a gum brand. Right. And, and so they are paid a lot to do that. You, I mean, now I would say, you know, you're a brand ambassador is typically, typically getting paid between 20 and $30 an hour to pass out samples. Wow. Yeah. Right. So, I mean, probably steady work then, right. Then film work. Yeah. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. It may be more. lucrative in the short term yes i was making you know close to nothing as a pa you know you were getting free lunch and that was like the biggest biggest perk um and so you know so i did that with ky then i got hired to do a job for amstel light which is similar to what you were describing where i actually went out to arizona and i was hired to oversee a tour or a campaign where we were introducing amstel light to the college market in tempe and i had a team of people under me and we would go into bars with the tab and we'd buy people amstel light and we had a little photo booth station because this was before iphones and before social media like you said and we would take you know polaroid photos of people drinking an amstel light in a college bar and then you would give them the photo i have not had an amstel light in probably probably since i was in my early 20s right uh that's interesting so i guess i'm i'm i want to jump ahead just on this because i think this is what would lead you to meeting another famous person who's a musician named moby correct yes so i was working on these promotional sampling campaigns i started to like them a lot like initially it was transactional passing out samples make money done as i started to lean in more learn more about cpg learn more about building a connection an emotional connection with consumers i really started to enjoy it and i and i and i appreciated the creativity that went into building a brand in a way that was going to resonate with folks right so that that started to resonate with me more and so i started to put more heart into it and that's when i started to get bigger jobs within the space and i went from being a sampler to being a manager um i started going on the road and i was hired to do a job with nokia um in new york city and this was soon after the amstel light campaign when i was living in tempe and that brought me back to new york and i worked this this campaign for a few months and i met someone that uh worked on the job with me who had a connection to moby and she knew that this job was ending soon and she knew that i'd be looking for the next one and she said hey what would you think about working for moby i know him and he's launching a better for you lightly sweetened tea a bottle ready to drink tea called teeny or tea new york he has a lower east side vegan cafe where he sells the tea today but he thinks he wants to start selling it outside of the cafe and he's looking for somebody that has an experiential marketing background and i really think you guys would like each other and i said that sounds really interesting happy to talk to him so she connects me to moby we have a conversation we hit it off he's looking for alternative marketing and he was and and he was looking for somebody like you to do what to help spread the word across metro new york um and do it in a way that was disruptive and lifestyle driven he wanted to create a lifestyle destination brand he didn't want to market this brand in a conventional way um you know he wanted to get alternative distribution you know how do we sell this product in high-end uh like luxury apparel you know uh businesses things like that kind of innovative back in that time and and this what did it say like moby's tea or did you just know that moby was behind it no it it was teeny and on the back of the bottle there was romance copy written by moby so you know once you started consuming the brand and you read the back of the bottle you you knew it was moby but front of pack um didn't shout his name this is like the height of his fame right yeah he was working on um the album hotel if you remember that that album so he was working on the album hotel so yeah he was he was super relevant he was he was really um popular and had a lot of uh momentum behind him and and that must have been kind of an an interest i mean interesting and probably exciting opportunity for you because i imagine you were the marketing team you were the marketing guy for the whole brand yeah i was so this was a crash course in brand building for me right like really fell in love with it because there were so many creative elements i have a creative background i went to school for photography fine art major and i started to see a lot of uh parallels between storytelling from a filmmaking standpoint and storytelling from a brand standpoint and i was like look there's there's they're they are analogous right like on one hand if you tell a really great story um and you present that story in a way that resonates with a wide audience you'll have a hit movie on the brand side of your brand you'll have a hit movie on the brand side if you're telling a really great story and that delivers and that um you know emotionally connects with a wide audience you should hopefully have a hit brand and i i just i loved the build i loved having the opportunity to work on positioning work on brand work on marketing and so i kind of like threw myself into it and i learned so much working for teeny because we were there were only a few of us so though i was hired to run marketing i was very quickly doing sales i was doing i was working with the ops team on supply chain manufacturing procurement you know i was working with the finance team we were all you know coming together to help you know move this brand forward as as a group so i i learned a lot about building a cpg brand i was out there in the streets of manhattan hustling slinging cases knocking on doors you know trying to convince bodegas to give a shelf space while i was working with the ops team on supply chain thinking through effective forms of in-store point-of-sale communication how can we create a better shelf cling a better shelf dangler is going to tell a story to drive trial it's interesting because it sounds like this was sort of a a fun little side project for moby but um it was like it was like an it was like a massive education for you it was yes yeah yes i learned a tremendous amount there in a very short period of time and forgive me i don't remember this brand at all but i how did it do yeah so we did well in new york metro and by design we kept it small right moby was personally financing this business and he had desire to you know spread the word and scale within new york um but i don't think he had a lot of ambition to take it you know much wider than that and we did a really good job of building this brand up and down the street um going after shelf space and bodegas and other high-end uh retailers and it was it was sticking it was resonating it was a great tasting product was but he wasn't did he make money off of it um yeah i think he did i don't know exactly where he landed but i i think he did okay um in a in a short period of time right so we never we didn't build a massive brand it was a you know a a brand that had a cult following in new york city grew healthily in the year plus that i was there um then he sold it and i'm sure he did okay huh yeah so all right so so that happens that he he moves on and you i guess yes on the strength of that get recruited to join another tea brand another startup brand yeah that's right so when we were building teeny another brand on shelf that we were going after was honesty um honesty at the time was a small you know sub 10 million dollar brand i think they were like six or seven million dollars at the time again this is two thousand six and they're trying to find their footing in manhattan at the same time as you know teeny um is out there trying to find their footing and it was you know we were we were competing with each other in a big way we were we were fighting for the same shelf space and when teeny was sold i got a phone call from the head of sales um at at honesty and he's like hey i heard teeny sold we love what you're doing for teeny in metro new york we would love for you to consider doing that for us here at honesty and i said okay you know i need to i need to think about it make sure it's what i want to do and they're like hey we want you to meet the founder the co-founder um and ceo seth goldman and they you know the the team honesty you know asked me to please get onto an amtrak and go out to bethesda to meet with him and so i decided to do it and i met with seth and very quickly um you know became convinced that seth goldman was the real deal the genuine article and from a mission-led standpoint he led with heart um he cared so much about building a thoughtful um responsibly sourced brand that was going to be you know kind of values led and so that really resonated with me not to mention seth is a you know just such a dynamic charismatic person with a magnetic personality so he did an amazing job of you know telling me his story and walking me through his vision um and it was just so authentic and you know i really believed in seth first and foremost so tell me what so you you get hired to do marketing for them and to basically run marketing for them so no so when i first got hired they wanted me to do what i was doing for teeny for honesty in new york metro campaigns or or distribution the the objective was how do we make honesty more accessible across the new york metro market because they were performing really well um in natural accounts doing really well with whole foods and other um other natural stores he was based in the mid-atlantic in bethesda so he that's right so he was that was his area but he didn't have a whole lot of distribution in new york city yeah he was building it um and i wanted to make it more accessible i wanted to find a way to get this brand to resonate with younger consumer segments i didn't have a big budget i hired an intern to help me out i hired my younger sister to help me um on the design side because i wanted to develop my own point of sale materials i felt modernized that kind of elevated tone of voice i wanted to be um you know as relevant as possible to to younger consumers and so that's what we did in in new york metro and you started to pick up real distribution you felt you felt the growth um you saw the the uptick in velocity um and you really felt like you have some good momentum um in the new york metro market tell me what tell me like specifically you know what you're doing in the new york metro market like an example of of a way a campaign that you launched with honesty because i i should mention in 2008 coca-cola makes an investment in honesty which was transformational because then you get then i and i remember this all of a sudden honesty starts showing up in 7-eleven because coca-cola can make that happen right right but how are you generating interest and like were you giving it away were you doing an like what kind of event would you do for honesty yeah it was heavy event sampling heavy grassroots marketing and uh we were focused on art galleries on art we have marathons marathons music events interesting okay yeah we again we wanted to show up as a lifestyle brand um you know we wanted to play where younger consumers were um you know we're playing and we looked for these destination events yeah yeah so all right so you um and and eventually you're going to be in the new york metro market and you're going to be in the new york metro market eventually i mean you know again the story with honesty which is a it's an amazing story and i i think somewhat of a tragic story because coca-cola eventually exercised its right to buy out the whole company in in 2011 and kept it going for a while until it um killed the brand i think in 2022 yeah yeah yeah right so i so i moved to bethesda to take on the director of marketing role we that became a huge success story yeah the t the t business can you know grew very quickly um and over the four and a half to five year period that i was there um we took the brand to roughly i think 75 80 million revenue something like that um and then the company sold in 2011 to coke all right so that ends and you then move on to a new opportunity which is another beverage brand i get called activate and i don't again i don't remember this beverage brand but tell me tell me the story behind how that happened yeah so when honest when the press release went out that honesty was selling to coca-cola i receive a phone call from a guy named anders eisner who is the son of michael eisner the ex-ceo at disney um i had met anders at a trade show like two or three years before that and gave him my card he talked to me at that point about this new concept that he was working on called activate drinks he wanted to go after the enhanced water market vitamin water i just sold for 4.2 billion dollars to coke and enhanced water was all the rage and he felt that he had this technology that was going to really position himself to compete effectively uh versus versus vitamin water and so that was you know that was his concept he gave me or i gave him my card he held on to it honesty sells he sees the the and he's like hey listen i have i'm i'm getting you know i have activate up and running now um i really want to start scaling it my dad is the chairman of the board i just raised money from tata group out of india and so we have a lot of great really smart people around us and we want to go go strong on this and this is 2011 this is 2011 yep exactly so so anders he's trying to build a new drink and it's a yeah it's an enhanced water drink so his point of difference was he had a proprietary twist cap technology that held vitamins separately in a cap oh so you would twist the cap and the vitamins would release yes that would cut a membrane and it was liquid vitamins powder powder oh wow and you would shake it yeah the powder would would drop into the water you'd shake the bottle and then you would twist the cap again to drink it okay so this is totally different than like vitamin water yes i mean i can't imagine the it would be cheap to to make that because there's a lot of components that go i mean just a bottle alone is expensive yeah it was an expensive cap um it was complex i think that was that was a challenge for us we had to put a lot of dollars behind educating folks on how to open the cap effectively yeah you gotta twist it one way vitamins drop you gotta shake it then you gotta twist the cap the other way it's a lot of friction there you know like we wanted to lean in on the benefit but you had to talk more about how to how to open the cap how do you remember how how much you know revenue the brand made at its height it was roughly a five million dollar company so it's small yeah it was small yeah yeah had a lot of buzz i think it raised like 15 or 12 million more than 12 million dollars yeah um and i guess listen an interesting idea but you know you know this working in the space sometimes things just don't work they don't they don't click and it doesn't matter how good the marketing is if the product just doesn't if there's no product market fit it doesn't work and i guess by or late 2013 the biggest one of the biggest investors tata decides to stop investing further in this brand which is not a good sign it suggests that they've lost faith in its ethic if it's it's you know it's uh potential right well look i mean they were looking for rocket ship growth right they wanted this thing to go from zero to zero and they were looking for zero to a hundred quickly and it was more incremental and i think they decided not to follow on in the next round and at that point in time um the eisner family had an opportunity to sell the company and they decided to sell at that point so that was sold it to a canadian company called unique beverages that's right yeah i think had we um gone slower uh you know brought on less people you know had stronger fundamentals stretched every dollar those things i think you probably could have optimized and found real rhythm and i think you could have made it work over time but we ran out of time and they decided to sell the company and that's fine and um and and when that happened you know anders and i came together and started to talk about what we wanted to do next okay so you already i mean he was interested in working with you on something new at that point and i mean i imagine you were too because there's access to capital and and and you probably liked each other we we loved working with each other we built a strong friendship he knew that i wanted to build my own company i was very vocal with him about that i was like look i'm happy to help you build activate but once this is over um i i want to go off and do my own thing that's that is my focus i want to build a mission-led company i have several different ideas i don't know exactly what the idea is yet but i have a few different categories that i'm i want to i want to make sure we do that yeah i just want to pause for a second i mean you were you had been diagnosed with ulcerative colitis which is i don't think that uncommon it's it's an inflammatory bowel disease right correct yep yeah so i was diagnosed with ulcerative colitis as an as an autoimmune condition where your body unnecessarily attacks itself and what are the symptoms what happens cramping weight loss your body start stops absorbing nutrition because you're that when did that happen when are you diagnosed so this was in 2015 so so so i started working on i started working on good culture in 2014 in terms of the concept yeah um because activate was sold in 2014 right and then in june of 2014 i started actively working on the good culture concept and in early 2015 as we were kind of getting up and i started working on the good culture concept and in early 2015 as we were kind of getting up and like as an adult right i guess maybe that is how most people are diagnosed and uh and i'm imagining and i shouldn't imagine but i'm assuming your doctor said hey there's a medication you know you can take yeah so i had horrific symptoms i was dropping weight um i think i had lost 20 pounds um i had it just came on like that all of a sudden oh yeah i thought it was food poisoning because it was so sudden i became very scared after a few weeks of this happening so i didn't go to a doctor right away i thought i could push through push through push through yeah i then started losing a lot of weight and that really made me nervous so i went to a gi gi said hey i don't like i don't like the symptoms i want you to immediately get a colonoscopy and i was like oh yeah which is not what i wanted to hear right you're thinking of what you think of cancer that was yes that was that was on that was on the list right and that's and that's what he was trying to solve for right he's like hey we need to make sure it's not that like let's rule that out. So now I'm terrified. And I'm now, of course, I'm doing all my own research on Google. This is pre-AI. So I'm like researching on Google, and it points to the C word over and over and over again. Thank God you didn't have CHET-GPT. That would scare you even more. Yes, 100%. So I'm now in a panic. I immediately schedule a colonoscopy. I want to know what's going on. And you're a young guy. I mean, you're in your late 30s. Yeah, right. So yeah, not not ideal. And I'm just, you know, getting up and running with good culture. So I have like all this stuff going on. I'm manufacturing, I'm getting ready for a trade show, like, I'm in the thick of it. And suddenly I have brain fog, and I have no energy and everything hurts, and I can't function well. So was not ideal. And so I went to get I went to get the colonoscopy. I stayed awake for the colonoscopy. I don't like getting sedated. I try to avoid drugs as much as I can. I got sedated. I highly recommend it is a wonderful, wonderful 20 minutes of my life. No, no, I'm like, I need to be in control. So I'm like, I don't care if I'm uncomfortable. I want to see what's going on. And if they find something that is scary, I want to tell you when you wake up time. I'll tell you when you wake up. Yeah, I was like, I don't want to wait. I don't want to wait till I wake up. I want to know now. All right, you do you. I'm going to sleep. Put me out. Yeah, so I stayed awake. And they're showing me everything on the monitor. And almost immediately, they see ulcerative colitis, which was a relief, right? They're like, hey, just so you know, you see, you see these white patches here. That's colitis. It's called ulcerative colitis. It's an autoimmune condition. You have unnecessary inflammation in your body. Your body is attacking food as if it's a pathogen. No one know what no one knows why this happens. It's unfortunate. But at the end of the day, it's chronic. So you're going to have to live on steroids for life, or something to help manage your inflammation. And that was, of course, not what I wanted to hear. Like I said, I don't like drugs. I wouldn't even get sedated for the colonoscopy. So the last thing I wanted to do was start living on steroids or something similar. And I pushed back in a pretty big way. And I just challenged the doctor. I was like, well, hold on a minute. Shouldn't there be some correlation between what I eat and inflammation in my gut? And the response was, well, there's not that's true. You know, we can't speak to that. What we do know is that this medication works. And this is a chronic condition. So you're going to have to get on the on this for life. And that's how you're going to manage your symptoms and have a relatively normal life from this point forward. And did you take medication for some time? I took medication for about three days while I was in immense pain. Didn't like the medication at all. I felt lightheaded. I felt sick. It just like turned my stomach. So I really didn't like it and got off of it pretty quickly. And in parallel, I was meeting with functional doctors to help me think through alternatives. And a functional doctor that I met with was very confident that I could I could beat this through food. And he talked to me about a diet called the autoimmune paleo diet, where you eliminate um, nuts, seeds, caffeine, alcohol, grain, right, like anything that can create inflammation, you pull it all out. And you primarily nuts, I didn't know about nuts. That's yeah, because it's so high in fat and protein. Yeah, I mean, look, nuts are healthy. But when you have UC, it's harder to digest, and it can set off a flare. And so I had to remove anything like that. And so I pulled all those foods out of my diet. I lived primarily, primarily on grass fed meats, organic meats. And I wasn't a huge meat eater before this, by the way. And I started eating tons of meat. And within a week, maybe maybe a week and a half of eating like that, all those horrific symptoms started to go away, I started to feel higher levels of energy, more mental clarity, more strength, bloating went away. I mean, I just felt like a new person very, very quickly. After changing my diet. If you run a small business, you know that having a clear picture of your finances is invaluable. Zero spelled with an X is a simple but powerful platform built for small business owners that makes managing business finances easier from day one. That's X-E-R-O.com. But the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed sponsored jobs. Get a $75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. It's officially the holiday season and Abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar. It's the busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites I don't have time to plan every look but Abercrombie's always got me covered. Their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key plans and on a nice night out I'm reaching for their classic trousers. Fill your closet with the pieces you'll need all season long. Have a very Abercrombie holiday. Shop in the app, online and in stores. So here's a question for you. Have you taken any medication since then or do you manage this entirely through food now? I manage it entirely through food. That said, I do have a medication that my GI gives me. In the event I have a flare, they're like, look, if you have a flare and you can't get control of it, you just have it. Take these meds. They're there for you. But I try really hard to never take them. I almost. So that's amazing. So you basically have managed to do this with little or no medication and it works for you, which is great. 100%. Yes. It's interesting that this happens to you because this is not actually the catalyst for going into cottage cheese. It's your wife eating cottage cheese while she's pregnant. And so you're seeing her eat cottage cheese while you're while she's pregnant with your third kid. And we know cottage cheese packs a punch. It's got a lot of protein. It's for if you're pregnant, you want that good fat. But it's a weird like 2014, like it's a weird product. I remember my mom eating cottage cheese in the 80s, you know, it was like cottage cheese. And and and then it became like a trend for a while, cottage cheese and pineapple. And but I would never even if I saw my wife eating cottage cheese, I wouldn't think, ah, cottage cheese. That's it. Because you were thinking bone broth. And I'm like, yeah, bone broth. Yeah. But you're you're looking at cottage cheese. How does her eating cottage cheese get your the gears in your head start start spinning about cottage cheese? Right. I mean, so it was the nutritional facts table was compelling, right? Like I said, it was there was more protein and less sugar in a cup of cottage cheese than Greek yogurt. So that was like number one. I'm like, okay, this is interesting. This is potentially an overlooked superfood that's no one's going to no one's talking about. And it's just not being presented in the right way. Then I look at the category data. And I find that cottage cheese was actually bigger than yogurt in the 70s, and then fell off to due to a lack of innovation. Okay, cottage cheese. So you thought, okay, the existing brands are what they're watery, or they're not, I don't know, soupy, slimy, because they're loaded with additives. It was, let's change the flavor taste file of this. Use different ingredients, simple ingredients. Yep. And repackage this in a new way. Correct. Okay, so when you go to Anders with this idea, he's like, genius. I love it. Yeah, he loved it. Really? Okay. Yeah, he actually was eating cottage cheese at the time. But but also didn't really like it. He was eating it for, you know, functional purposes. And he saw to disrupt it. But you're right, like conventional wisdom would have told us to run from this opportunity. Like, yeah, lining category. Yeah, audience is aging out, primarily private label driven, not relevant, you know, to, to today's consumer. Why we loved it was we looked at the megatrends at the time. We were like, and still today, but we're like, okay, what are the megatrends that are resonating in a big, big way right now? Okay, well, high protein resonating low sugars, right? Yes, the macro story resonating, gut health resonating, clean label resonating. mission-led, resonating, founder-led, resonating. Okay, well, guess what? We check all these boxes. And I remember when we were doing an earlier round of fundraising, one of the groups that invested presented it to their investment committee in that way and didn't even mention the words cottage cheese. They said, hey, we're thinking about investing in this really exciting company. It's a high-protein, clean-label, low-sugar, nutrient-dense real food. And they go, oh, wow, that sounds really interesting. What is it? And they go, it's something called cottage cheese. And they were like, oh, like mind-blown, right? So that was how we thought about it. We were like, we can reframe this and in a way that will resonate because it's already checking all the megatrend boxes. It's just not being presented in the right way. So you now have a lot of experience under your belt in marketing and in the beverage space. First of all, where do you start? Like, you know, you want to make a different recipe of cottage cheese. I guess you could probably make it in a home kitchen, but what did you start to experiment and play around with? Yeah, so I did make kitchen samples. I would go to the market. I would buy a lot of the competition and I started to actually create my own version of cottage cheese. I would squeeze several different, private label, different national brands. I was just like exploring to see what was out there. And I would, you know, squeeze the curd and try to make it drier. Because my whole thing is I wanted to make it thicker and creamier. I wanted it to be more homogeneous. I wanted it to eat more like a yogurt, right? Because in all the research that we did, the folks that didn't like cottage cheese didn't like it because of some kind of textural barrier. But how do you come up with a recipe? I mean, you mentioned that you're buying off-the-shelf cottage cheese and squeezing out the water. So I guess you're putting it like cheese. Just to see if you get a texture right. That's right. But when it comes to you actually making it or making a prototype, did you have to find like a co-manufacturer that was willing to experiment with you? Correct. So it started with kitchen sample, got to a texture that felt okay, experimented with different flavors. I had strawberry acai chia, blueberry acai chia. I had kalamata olive. I had sunflower. I had sun-dried tomato. I was playing with all these different things and I was putting it on the bottom and I was putting them in little glass jars. So I got to a place that felt really good in my kitchen. In parallel to doing that, of course, yes, I'm looking for manufacturing. Who can actually bring this to life for me? And I found a small co-packer in Wisconsin that was willing to work with me. Okay. So now we did an episode a while back about a baby formula brand and that's really hard to find somebody to make that for you, especially because it's so highly regulated. Um, was it pretty easy to find a manufacturer that would be willing to do this for you to kind of play around with ideas and make cottage cheese for you? Yeah, it was hard because I was calling it. I was calling a lot of, I mean, number one, not a lot of folks still making cottage cheese because the category is in decline. A lot of cottage cheese manufacturers had pivoted to yogurt. So not a lot of players out there. And the folks that were out there were looking for volume, right? They wanted big brands. That could bring a lot of volume to the table. They didn't want to bring in a startup. Um, and so I was knocking on doors, trying to present my vision. And typically folks would say, Hey, interesting, like what you're trying to do, but until you can like satisfy our MOQs, doesn't, doesn't really make sense. So like come back when you're bigger. And also the other thing I should say is we were launching as an organic only product and we were launching as a clean label product. So a lot of folks, so didn't love that. A lot of folks either didn't have organic capability, um, or they didn't have the ability to make clean label. And I was also launching single serve cups with fruit on the bottom. And a lot of folks didn't have single serve fillers. I could do fruit on the bottom. So it was really hard to find someone that had the capabilities that I needed to make good culture the way I wanted to make it. And when you say clean label, I just, I'm just going to say this. I've said a million times a show. I have slight issues with that term because it's not, it's not like US, it's not like USDA organic. It's, it's a, it's more of a marketing term. I understand what it means, right? But when you talk about it, you mean, uh, ingredient, no, no xanthan gum, no, no guar gum, no calcium phosphate. Like you just wanted milk, cream, salt, and cultures. That's right. That's, that's well said. And they wouldn't, they, why would they not be interested in making it that way? It's harder to do it. It's more expensive. It's harder to control. Um, it's less efficient. They're afraid that they're going to lose money and money in the facility. So yeah, it's just a harder thing to do. Cause they're not adding starches. So when you, when you can add a chemical preservative, that makes life a lot easier. When you can add a bunch of gums in there to help stabilize, that makes life a lot easier. Okay. So you are calling around and how did you find somebody who's like, okay, we'll give you a shot. Yeah. So it was a very sophisticated process where I pounded Google for, for weeks and ultimately found someone that could make organic, had single serve capability, could do fruit on the bottom and was open to collaborating with me on the R and D to find a way to make a good clean label product. So what do you, did you go out there and like spend some time having them like go through the process of making different versions of this? Yeah, we did. I worked closely with our R and D team and, um, there was, there was a lot of testing. We did several trials and we just kept dialing it and optimizing it. Um, and a lot of the runs didn't work. Initially it was all lab samples, like trying to get to a great place with lab samples. Once we got to good lab samples, then we actually started running it through the equipment. Once you start running it through the equipment, it gets much harder. So like, you know, this is, I was, I didn't know what I didn't know. And at the time we had hit perfect gold standard lab samples and I thought we were all, you know, we were there. And then we had to do our, our first run in advance of introducing the brand at Expo West in March of 2015. And we started running that batch through their equipment and it was soupy. It was everything that I didn't want. And there was a huge panic moment and we had to like quickly resolve it. Okay. Before we get to the Expo West, which is the biggest natural foods, uh, um, convention in Anaheim. Um, I want to ask about the, the business side, right? Because you are starting a business with Anders who you like and is a friend of yours. Yeah. Um, but, um, he's coming with the funding. I mean, he comes from a very prominent family and there's money behind it. And so how did, I mean, this is a little bit of a, a complex question to ask and it's not always, you know, but I think it's instructive and interesting for people listening, which is you are not coming to the table with tons of money, I'm assuming. Maybe you had a little bit from some of the sales, but not tons. So how do you make it? So it's not another situation where you're just working for another, somebody else, somebody else's money. Yeah. Well, I mean, it's how we structured it, right? Anders approached me and said, Hey, I really want to build something with you. I want to invest in you. If you have a good idea, let me know what that is. And if I like it, I'm happy to put in, you know, the capital to get it off the ground. And, you know, as part of that structure, you'll be a co-founder. I'll be a co-founder. You'll be the CEO and I'll be chairman of the board, but I'll be a bit more passive. You'll be the day-to-day guy. And that worked for both of us. Okay. And the name, Good Culture. Yeah. Good Culture, double entendre, right? Good, good. Like honest tea. Yeah. Right. Right. So good in that the products taste really, really good, but also good in terms of, you know, how we source our ingredients, how we work with our farmers, how we work across, you know, all of our, all of our stakeholders. So, you know, we want to ensure that we're, we're always doing good for people, planet animals, right? So that's a big, a big part of the story. And then culture obviously also speaks to what's inside of the product, right? We use live and active cultures. So this is a cultured fermented food to speak to that. But we also want to ensure that we're always driving a healthy, a culture for our, our employees and for our partners. So building a culture that we're proud of across all stakeholders is also incredibly important. Okay. So you get to this convention, March, 2015, you've got a booth at Expo West. And from what I understand, there was a lot of interest in, in a different kind of or new, new kind of approach to cottage cheese. Correct. Yeah. So number one, going into this show, Anders and I both said, look, if, if we get a lot of interest, amazing, let's keep going. If we present at the show and customers just don't care about cottage cheese because it's a declining category and maybe they just, they're not looking for a new innovation within cottage. You know, that was, if that was the reality or that was the outcome of that event, then we would have pivoted. And so that's really how we looked at Expo West. But we knew we needed to introduce it there. We needed to get information. in front of retailers and get real feedback. we introduced the brand March, 2015, and yes, a lot of interest. And we had whole foods approach us. Um, sprouts approached us several different larger retailers, um, in the conventional space approached us. We had club mass, you name it. Like so many folks were coming up to the, to the booth and asking us about what we were doing and validating our thesis, right? They were, Hey, this is amazing. It's about time that somebody is doing something exciting in cottage cheese. Okay. So you have, um, good, you get some track of good traction. You walk out of that with whole, with national distribution at whole foods and sprouts, 55 stores only for whole foods. Okay. And all stores for sprouts. So one re one region of whole foods. Okay. Now what's the game plan? I mean, you, you have this background in gorilla, not gorilla marketing, but marketing. Maybe some gorilla marketing, you know, the, the vitamin water, you know, and, and the don't kill the vitamins and stuff that you did, um, with honesty, what are you going to do from a marketing perspective to get people? I'm assuming you're going to sample the hell out of this stuff in, in every whole foods you can get into, but, uh, how are you going to build a bigger story? Like where are you going to go? What platforms are you going to use? What's the story you're going to tell? So number one, we, we needed to ensure that we were hitting velocity thresholds to survive and keep our shelf space at both whole foods and sprouts. Um, you know, is that, is that, is that a pretty high threshold or was it, did it seem fairly doable? It felt high at the time. Um, you know, I mean, when, cause when we first launched our velocities were not great, right. We were in a category where, you know, the shoppers had their blinders on, they were buying the same thing they had been buying for decades. They weren't necessarily, looking for innovation at the time. They were actually confused by who we were and why we were there because we were the only brand in single serve fruit on the bottom cups that looked like yogurt cups. And we received a lot of feedback from customers saying, Hey, I, I, I bought that and I thought it was yogurt. And then I opened it and it was cottage cheese, or we would be in the store and someone would walk right by our set and buy something else. And we would ask them, why didn't like, why didn't you buy that one? And the response was, Oh, I had no idea that was cottage. I thought it was, was yogurt. So that was a barrier initially that we had to overcome. And ultimately that led to bringing in larger sizes that led to making the, making cottage cheese more prominent on the front of the pack. We actually, we added an illustration of a bowl of cottage cheese, which we didn't have in the first packaging iteration. There was no visual at all. It was, you know, cottage cheese was very small and it was more flavor forward. Um, so we had to make some tweaks and optimize to ensure that that confusion barrier, uh, was no longer there. But sampling was a huge focus. We, we absolutely needed folks in the store, uh, in, in the stores to drive word of mouth, to drive trial, uh, to ensure that people were picking it up and, and trying it and eating it on site. Because we knew that when folks tried good culture, they would like it. It was a wildly different experience than anything else that they were eating in the cottage. She said our tagline at the time was, cottage cheese, but better. And we needed to explain what we meant by that. And so the high protein story, low sugar story, plus the texture story was a big one. Uh, clean label was a big one. Live and active cultures was a big, and all of those things resonated, but you needed to tell that story in, in, you know, at, in, in the store in order to get people to stop and pay attention. But most people walking past, I'm assuming a significant, maybe most people walking past your sampling thing are not eating cottage cheese at all. Right. Yeah. Which again is why we had to rely so heavily on in-store samplings because we were able to stop people in the aisle that were maybe shopping the yogurt set and educate them on who good culture is and why we're better and why they should try it. And then we started hearing from folks that were buying it. Like the number one piece of feedback that we would receive from folks that started buying it regularly was I don't like cottage cheese, but I love good culture. So they were elevating the brand above the category. And that, that worked. Yeah. I mean, like early on that really worked because you built a pretty loyal cult following and enough of a base to drive, you know, velocities across the storage where we were sold. And that was enough to hit those velocity targets to help maintain our shelf space. Okay. But still probably still comparatively small, right? At that time. Oh yes. Yes. We were still a very small brand. I think the velocity targets at the time were like, we have to get to eight to 10 units per store per week if you want to keep your shelf space. And when you launch into a Whole Foods, you're on full reclamation, right? For like six months. You're effectively selling on consignment. So it's really, really stressful. And because we're clean label, we only had a 45 day shelf life. By the time it hits the store, you're probably at like 30 days. And so now you got roughly 30 days to sell through. And if it doesn't sell through, you're eating that, you know, right. Cause the preservative is just the salt, right? Or right. So it's, you know, it was, you had to ensure that we had folks in store driving sales, driving velocities very directly. That's not sustainable over time or at scale, but it is sustainable when you're in 55 stores. Right. And that's why we launched in that way by design. We knew like we didn't want to go too wide, too fast, or else we likely wouldn't have survived. But you had to sell eight to 10 tubs of this per store per week. Which doesn't sound like a lot, but it's a lot. It is. Cause it's not eight. It's not like a hundred percent of the people walking into Whole Foods even see it. Maybe only seven to 10% even pass by that the cottage cheese section in the cooler. And then you need a percentage of them to buy. So it's not actually as easy as it sounds to sell eight to 10 tubs a week. Oh no, it was very hard. That was, it was incredibly stressful for me. I was, I was monitoring as many stores as I could. We were hitting all the, you know, highest volume stores and just clearing shelves, clearing shelves, clearing shelves to help, you know, build that velocity story. And obviously get more folks into the brand and hopefully drive loyalty and repeat. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Hiring now? When you shop Kroger delivery, you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door. Our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right. Carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing you fresh quality groceries is what we do best. And right now, enjoy $20 off your first online order of $75 or more. Restrictions apply. See site for details. Kroger, fresh for everyone. It's the busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites, I don't have time to plan every look. But Abercrombie's always got me covered. Their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low key plans. And on a nice night out, I'm reaching for their classic trousers. Do you remember after your first sort of full year, which would have been 2016? What your overall sales were? 2016, we did about 2 million revenue. Okay, so that's great. I mean, that's a pretty good year. Yeah. And you're I think that year you get national or you expand nationwide with Whole Foods. We did. Yeah. So we launched into the 55 stores that we talked about in August of 2015. And by January 2016, we get an authorization to go national with Whole Foods, which was amazing. Okay, so let's get to so you guys are growing. And before we get to the hyper growth, like in the viral moment, what worked? Like because by 2021, you're doing $70 million in sales. That's a good year. That's a really good year. You know, you started in 2015. Middle of that year. 2016 is 2 million by 2021. 70 million in sales. Now, a lot of that has to do with the fact that you are in Kroger and now you know, and Walmart by that point. But was it just that it was just the more stores or was there a campaign or? A marketing strategy that you felt really did actually work. So we were seeding. influencers. We were building our presence on social media. We were getting a lot more PR. And so we were doing a lot of great work in terms of building more awareness, driving the brand story, couponing tactics. We were pushing people into various retailers through different shopper marketing levers. And so between the lower funnel, middle funnel efforts, and with the air coverage, that we were getting through social and PR, it felt like that was really starting to come together and work together holistically to create more momentum. And how were you using influencers? Just give me an example. Is it just clear? You find an influencer and say, hey, here's some protein, cottage cheese, go for it. Yeah. I mean, we were selective in terms of the micro and macro influencers that we would work with. We typically look to work with people that were that were authentically consuming good culture. We would identify those folks and we would then reach out to them and we would give them VIP kits or, you know, in some cases we would pay them, but it was mostly organic and mostly just through VIP kits. And these folks would create recipes for us. They would, you know, talk about the brand relative to their daily routine. They would share it with their audience. And then we had the ability to, you know, whitelist their content and help, you know, promote and drive their message to our audience as well. So we really leaned in pretty hard on building a thoughtful, you know, base of strong influencers that were serving as the mouthpiece for the brand. So that was really helpful. And like I said, we were also getting a lot of PR just based on our distribution growth on, you know, the disruption category, the fact that, you know, cottage cheese was now starting to show some growth because of the macro trends that were occurring. So like all of those things came together and you were just getting much more chatter, much more visibility. Okay. Let's talk about something that I experienced and maybe people listening. I think it was about two years ago. I remember going into Whole Foods and it's lasted actually for a while. And I still occasionally see it. And it was like, a hurricane was about to come and everybody just bought all the cottage cheese, like buying the toilet paper at Target before the pandemic. I remember that. I went to Target before the pandemic and it was like, there's no toilet paper. And you're like, why toilet paper? All of a sudden, I noticed cottage cheese gone. Now I'm not on, so I mean, I am on social media, but I don't, I don't use it. I just post, I don't consume it. I just make what I make and I leave it aside. So I'm like, what is going on? And one of my kids is like, oh yeah, there's a whole cottage cheese thing going on on TikTok and whatever. And I was like, oh, that's why I could not find cottage cheese. What, what was, what did you, when did you first learn about this thing going on? Yeah. So again, we had been seeding influencers for years. We were kind of like a building to this moment, if you will. You know, they say virality is the right message. You know, meeting the right moment. And that's what happened here, right? So we were working with influencers and one of our influencers found, you know, figured out a way to make a high protein ice cream using good culture. And she launched that video. The world is not ready for this healthy ice cream hack that has 60 grams of protein and loaded with probiotics. Is this Laney Cooks? Yeah. I don't know why no one's done this yet, but you can literally make the creamiest ice cream by blending good cottage cheese with raw honey or whatever sweetener you'd like. Frozen cottage cheese, honey, chocolate chips, and peanut butter. Right? Right. Swirl that together, throw it back in the container, into the freezer for a few hours, and you literally have the creamiest protein cheesecake ice cream that actually is good for you. It gets a ton of momentum. Everyone's talking about it. Other influencers start replicating it, trying to one-up it. Consumers start paying attention and now they're wanting to run to the store to buy good culture, to figure out how they can make their version of ice cream wild. And the other amazing thing about this, if you remember, like our thesis from day one was we want to bring in younger Gen X and millennials into the category to help drive growth. Overnight, Gen Z jumps in because, you know, I have Gen Z kids. My kids did not care at all about cottage cheese. And this viral moment happens. It happens on TikTok. Gen Z is, of course, living on TikTok. And so they're now discovering good culture through an aspirational influencer. And it's inherently cool. Like you didn't have to re-educate. Like with millennials and younger Gen X, you had to like help them understand why cottage cheese can be cool, why it can be better, like all these things. With Gen Z, it was inherently a cool food that they discovered on TikTok through an aspirational influencer. That was it. So this TikTok thing goes, and you know that this is happening. All of a sudden, not just good culture, all cottage cheese is just flying off the shelves. You cannot find it for a period of time. It was like news stories about this. Yeah. So that video hits. We hear about it. We're excited. We think it's going to be a fleeting moment. And then it just starts to snowball. And it goes from ice cream to flat breads, to bagels, to smoothies, to eggs, to various pasta dishes, etc. It just keeps snowballing. And influencers are creating more recipes. And Gen Zers are creating more recipes. Millennials are creating more recipes. And it just keeps going. And it really put a lot of visibility on the category. And you started to see velocities soar. There was a finite amount of cottage cheese capacity in the space because there wasn't a lot happening in cottage cheese before that happens. And suddenly, everyone's scrambling to get more capacity because we need to support this exponential growth that is occurring. And it became a really tight capacity situation really for the category, for our business initially. And then all boats were rising. And it became really tight. And so now several folks that play in cottage cheese are building more manufacturing to ensure we can actually capture the growth. I mean, it's kind of amazing. I think by the end of 2025, you guys are the top 200 million in revenue. How much of that do you. I mean, a big part of that has to be attributed to that, just this viral story, right? Yeah. And I think that was a big driver of it, for sure. Like I said, we brought Gen Z in. I tell the story that I went from being the lame cottage cheese dad to being the cool cottage cheese dad overnight. You're like, dude, you're not cool yet. No, but I mean, and I'm going to say this is an uncool dad. But it's interesting because you were well-placed for that moment. It's like at some point, something is going to happen in a category. And if you are well-placed and you had the branding, you had the work that you'd done for four or five years already, that when it happened, that moment happened, you were well-placed. Other cottage cheese brands were too. They benefit. They must have benefited from this too. But you guys were clearly, you were in the video. So that was. Super helpful. Oh, yeah. We were in the video and we were in a disproportionate amount of the content that followed. So wait, you're saying that what was a $1 billion category in 2014 and declining and continues to decline is now a $2 billion category in the US? 2.4. That's crazy. And if you look at per capita consumption, that's also an interesting story because back in the 70s, like I said, when cottage cheese was bigger than yogurt, per capita consumption was roughly five pounds. When good culture launched, it was like, I don't know, one, one and a half or something, one, four, one, five. And now it's back up to about two, four, two, five. So we're about halfway to where it was in the 70s. So as you think about like size of prize, like we feel like this category should at minimum get back to where it was in the 70s and maybe even go beyond that. That's wild. So, I mean, I have to assume that Knudsen's also doing better and the other Breakstone, like they're selling more cottage cheese too. Yeah. I think it's safe to say, everybody is selling more cottage cheese. Yeah. I mean, even though you want more market share, I'm sure that they're psyched that good culture came out. Yeah. I would imagine so. We created a lot of momentum for the category, brought a lot of new users in, really put it on the map through social, and now the category is benefiting. Okay. Does it mean that there are more competitors now in the space? I think there's absolutely risk of that happening. For the first, you know, eight years that I was building a culture, no one cared about what I was doing. Everybody ignored what I was doing. Everyone dismissed cottage cheese as a category that was never going to go anywhere. Everyone, you know, kind of patted me on the head and said, oh, that's cute that you're doing your cottage cheese thing, but what's your next idea? Because this one isn't a good one. And, you know, that obviously shifted pretty dramatically. And now everyone wants to try to find a way to get into cottage cheese. So sure, there's a lot of competitive action. Now, here's where we're sort of at today. I think, you know, as I say, by the end of 2025, you're firing on all cylinders, 200 million in revenue, which sounds amazing, right, and exciting. But actually, it also sounds like, based on what I'm reading through the lines, it was masking some potential challenges and maybe catastrophic challenges that started to get you worried. In terms of supply chain? Yeah. Yeah. And your capacity to, like, continue, because if you grow too fast, and we've had examples of this, it can actually tank the business if the balance isn't right. Right. So, look, I think we're hyper aware of the opportunity from a demand standpoint, and we know what we need to build from a supply chain standpoint to meet that demand. And we have several irons in the fire right now. We just ramped a new dedicated facility. We're ramping another dedicated facility at the end of this year. We just brought in a great new COO that has a great background in helping to scale durable supply chains. And so we feel like we're in a pretty good place to really lean in and start playing offense. But certainly, there were growing pains between viral moment and today. In terms of getting there. Because, like I said, all boats were rising, and there wasn't a lot of capacity out there. And it became harder to get the capacity that we needed to truly meet demand. And like I said, we're currently servicing less than 50% of demand. We did north of $200 million in revenue last year. We'll do much more than that this year. And, again, that does not come close to reflecting demand. That reflects capacity. So I guess what I'm curious about is, from what I understand, you run into a situation where there's tons of demand. You don't have the ability to fulfill that demand. And in order to do it, you would have to bring in a lot more capital, which you could do. Because I'm assuming lots of people wanted to give you money. But that's a different – that's a challenge. It's a challenge in and of itself. And from what I gather, you decide in 2025 that probably the best route is to look for mergers or acquisition offers or some kind of structure where you don't have to constantly raise more money. But maybe you bring in an investor or partner who buys a chunk of the business. Is that fair? Yeah, that's right. Yeah, and we partnered with Elkatterton in 2025. Before you tell Elkatterton, but you decided to do this because – You felt like these are your two options, either just constantly raise more and more capital or find a partner who can really just – we can focus on the things we want to focus on and let them bring in some cash. Yeah, I mean, look, we didn't feel like we needed to raise more. We were a highly profitable company, so we weren't raising in order to support what we were needing to do from a supply standpoint. We had opportunities to raise debt. And other things that didn't require raising outside capital, raising through private equity or really raising any private equity. So that was not a huge concern. We really wanted to bring on a partner that brought sophistication, experience, rigor, folks that have scaled businesses from our size to something bigger, that have gone through similar challenges, that had proven themselves. So that was like the bigger driver of partnering with Elk Hatterton. All right. So they take a majority stake. And so this closes in 2026. And now what does it mean? I mean, they're the majority shareholder now. Yes. The majority owner. And you are the CEO of Good Culture. So I imagine it means you don't have to worry about where the money comes from, because that's not your primary job anymore. You can focus on brand, you can focus on product innovation. Is that right? Yeah, I think I'm focused on, on all of it. I'm still maniacally focused on unit economics, good fundamentals, EBITDA, like ensuring we have a healthy, you know, enduring business. But of course, yes, I'm also now leaning in on brand, on innovation, on supply chain. I mean, I'm working across all functions in the business, but certainly having a partner like Al Catterton does allow me to have more time to focus on the commercial aspects of the business. So, I mean, what's your long-term game plan here? I mean, you are the CEO, and of course, because they run the company or the only company, they could one day say, I want a new CEO. Of course, you know that going in. But what do you think? I mean, do you do you imagine, you know, staying on for a couple of years and then starting something else? Or how do you see your the next five to 10 years playing out? Yeah, look, right now, I'm just focused on getting this thing to to the next level. I believe there's a ton of headspace, a ton of opportunity ahead. And I want to turn good culture into a billion plus dollar, you know, business into a household name. And I am confident that we can get there. So I'm going to partner with Al Catterton and do everything that I can to get us to the top of that mountain. And beyond that, who knows what happens or where I go. But today, that is 100% where I'm focused. When you think about the journey you took and you look back on it, I mean, how much do you think has to do with good luck and good fortune and how much do you think has to do with the hard work and the methodical strategic planning that made this successful? I will always say it's a little bit of both. But in my case, I think it was more about grit and hard work and perseverance because it was not easy for several years. This was never a rocket ship brand until we had that viral moment. And so it was just grinding, grinding, grinding. There were several nights where I would lie awake wondering whether or not this thing would survive. Loss of existential concerns along the way. Look, we had, we had, if you just look at the business, strong business, like strong double digit year over year growth year after year after year. But it, I never felt like I was in a sustainable place where I could just like, you know, take a breath and feel comfortable. And, you know, like I said earlier, in terms of the viral moment, virality is the right message meeting the right moment. And we just kept, you know, leaning in, leaning in, leaning in reps, reps, reps, reps, reps, until we kind of hit that perfect moment where things started to really align. And we kept turning the flywheel. And then you felt that you felt those tailwinds, you felt that sustained growth. And so I don't ever take a deep breath. I don't ever feel comfortable even today. Because I know there's just so much more work to be done. so again big a big believer in work ethic and grit and fighting to win versus you know fighting to not lose that's that's that's how i'm wired that's my dna um so i feel like that's a much bigger part of it than just being in the right place at the right time jesse thank you thank you thanks for having me that's jesse merrill co-founder and ceo of good culture by the way jesse isn't the only one in this family who's had big time success his son brecken had a huge role in the hit tv show yellowstone and is bringing that role to the new show marshalls and thanks so much for listening to the show this week please make sure to tap the follow button on your podcast app so you never miss a new episode of the show. And you can now watch How I Built This on YouTube. This conversation is on our brand new YouTube channel. Just search How I Built This on YouTube and subscribe. We'll also put a link to our new YouTube channel in the episode description. Our show is produced by podcast Point Man. I'm Guy Raz, and you've been listening to How I Built This. of your finances is invaluable. Accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics are available in one connected platform. Reports, visual dashboards, forecasts, and AI insights help owners better understand cash flow and make smarter decisions. CRO.com. it's officially the holiday season and abercrombie's new collection has outfits for everything on your calendar it's the busiest time of year and between shopping and party invites i don't have time to plan every look but abercrombie's always got me covered their sweaters are the perfect easy layer for low-key plans and on a nice night out i'm reaching for their classic trousers fill your closet with the pieces you'll need all season long have a very abercrombie holiday shop in the app online and in stores when you shop kroger delivery you can expect the savings you love and fresh groceries delivered right to your door our refrigerated trucks keep your items fresh while our associates are committed to getting every detail right carefully selecting and packing your order with care because bringing you fresh quality groceries is what we do best and right now enjoy twenty dollars off your first online order of seventy or more restrictions apply see site for details kroger fresh for everyone

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Jesse Merrill founded Good Culture after being inspired by his wife’s pregnancy and his own diagnosis of ulcerative colitis, which led him to rethink food ingredients and gut health.
  2. He observed that cottage cheese was nutritionally strong—high in protein, low in sugar—but poorly marketed and overlooked, with most brands relying on outdated, additive-heavy formulations.
  3. Drawing on his experience in experiential marketing, he focused on clean-label, simple-ingredient, and innovative packaging to reposition cottage cheese as a healthy, modern food.
  4. Early success came through strategic sampling, in-store education, and targeting Whole Foods and Sprouts, where strong consumer interest validated the product’s potential.
  5. To meet velocity targets, the team executed intense in-store operations, often clearing shelves within days to avoid spoilage due to the product’s short 45-day shelf life.
  6. The brand grew rapidly from $2 million in 2016 to $70 million by 2021, driven by a strong alignment with macro-trends like clean label, high protein, and gut health.
  7. Good Culture’s dual meaning—“good taste” and “good culture” for people, planet, and employees—resonated with consumers and built a loyal, mission-driven community.
  8. A viral moment in 2023, sparked by a health influencer making peanut butter cheesecake ice cream with cottage cheese, demonstrated the product’s newfound appeal to younger, health-conscious audiences.

Summary:

Jesse Merrill founded Good Culture in 2015 after personal health challenges—his diagnosis of ulcerative colitis and his wife’s pregnancy—prompted a deep interest in clean, nutrient-dense foods. He saw an opportunity in cottage cheese, a long-neglected food with high protein and low sugar, but lacking innovation and modern appeal. Drawing from his years of experience in experiential marketing, he reimagined the product with simple, clean-label ingredients, a creamy texture, and fruit-on-bottom single-serve cups.

Early traction came through strategic sampling and in-store education at Whole Foods and Sprouts, where consumers were initially confused by the product’s unfamiliarity. The team faced intense pressure to meet high weekly sales targets in these stores, requiring constant shelf monitoring and rapid clearance to avoid spoilage. Despite the challenges, the brand gained momentum, expanding nationally by 2016 and growing to $70 million in sales by 2021.

Its success stemmed from a strong alignment with modern consumer trends: clean label, high protein, gut health, and mission-driven branding. A viral moment in 2023, when a health influencer created a creamy ice cream using cottage cheese, dramatically boosted visibility and sales, proving that the product could appeal to a new generation of health-conscious consumers. Good Culture’s story reflects how personal health experiences, combined with innovative marketing and deep product refinement, can transform a forgotten food into a cultural sensation.

FAQs

Jesse was inspired by his wife's pregnancy and her consumption of cottage cheese, which sparked his interest in the product's nutritional value. He also discovered that most cottage cheese on the market was loaded with additives and lacked innovation, leading him to envision a healthier, cleaner, and more appealing version.

He started by testing various off-the-shelf cottage cheese brands in his kitchen, squeezing out water to create a thicker, creamier texture. He experimented with flavors like strawberry, blueberry, and sun-dried tomato, and eventually partnered with a small Wisconsin co-packer willing to work on clean-label, single-serve, fruit-on-bottom packaging.

Many cottage cheese manufacturers had pivoted to yogurt production and were focused on volume, not startups. Additionally, Good Culture required organic, clean-label, and single-serve capabilities—features that were rare and costly to produce, making it hard to find a manufacturer willing to collaborate.

Jesse focused on in-store sampling, especially at Whole Foods and Sprouts, to drive trial and word-of-mouth. He educated shoppers on the product's benefits—high protein, low sugar, clean label, and live cultures—and used visual packaging changes, like adding a bowl illustration, to clarify that it was cottage cheese, not yogurt.

Good Culture had to sell eight to ten tubs per store per week to maintain shelf space. This was extremely difficult because only a small percentage of shoppers pass by the dairy section, and converting them into buyers required intensive in-store sampling and direct sales efforts.

The product had a 45-day shelf life, with only about 30 days remaining by the time it reached stores. This meant Jesse had to urgently drive sales, often calling brand ambassadors to send SWAT teams to clear shelves before spoilage occurred.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.