Meeting a new partner in an open relationship can trigger a transformative personal and sexual awakening, reshaping one’s understanding of love, identity, and intimacy. The speaker shares her own experience with Tom, a relationship that brought deep emotional and physical connection, leading to a profound rediscovery of her sexuality and self. While initially overwhelming and confusing, this shift isn’t a failure of existing relationships—it arises from unmet needs, lack of sexual self-knowledge, or long-standing relational patterns. The experience often reveals hidden aspects of identity, such as queerness or kink, and can lead to new forms of connection and self-acceptance. Despite intense emotional reactions—like guilt, jealousy, or comparison—the speaker emphasizes that no one is to blame. Instead, it’s an opportunity to grow, honor one’s truth, and deepen bonds with all partners. Key steps include being honest yet compassionate with existing partners, avoiding attempts to fix their feelings, recognizing mononormative thinking, and allowing time for healing. With patience, support, and self-awareness, such experiences can strengthen relationships and foster a more authentic, fulfilling life. The journey, though challenging, can ultimately lead to greater self-knowledge, emotional resilience, and deeper love—proving that polyamory can be a path to personal and relational growth, not just chaos.
So meeting someone like this, someone who just sets off a cascade of change and excitement
and self-discovery inside you can have a dramatic effect on so much.
It can change how you feel about sex and romance, and what you want out of those things.
It can change how you feel about your other existing partners.
It can even change how you feel about yourself and your identity.
As I say all this, I am sure that some of you listening are feeling like this is the
absolute worst thing that could happen when you open your relationship.
Some people put all kinds of rules in place to prevent exactly something like this happening.
And this can be unwelcome even if you are in that first category of folks who are actually
opening up because they want to improve their sex lives.
Sometimes they're okay with like quote unquote just sex, but it better not like rock
your world too much, right?
And yet I really have to say this and I will say this more than once.
This is exactly the kind of thing you are opening the door to when you have an open relationship.
And I'm not so sure there's much you can do to prevent it.
Welcome to making polyamory work.
Hi, I'm Libby Sinback and I want to thank you for being with me today.
I created this show because I'm committed to helping people who live and love outside
the status quo have extraordinary relationships because relationships are at the core of our
well-being as humans.
I think love is my word here and how we heal.
Today's episode who gird your loins.
Yeah, I just said gird your loins.
This episode kind of a hot topic I think, but I really, really feel called to talk about
it because I think people don't talk about this and I think it's so, so, so, so important.
It's also near and dear to my heart because some of this is my personal story.
And next episode, there'll be more of my personal story through the voice of my spouse who
will be sharing his personal story so let's just get into today's episode.
So, it's 2017 and something happened to me that year that completely changed my life.
I met someone, Phil, madly in love and was suddenly having an off-the-charts romance
and the best sex of my entire life.
Also, I was married to someone else who I was raising two kids with.
When I think about it now, it was actually something that I hoped would happen.
Not that there was anything wrong per se with my sex life up until that point.
If you asked me, I probably would have said it was fine.
And yeah, I really was fine as a pretty bland descriptor, but at the time I actually thought
about sex really differently than I do now.
I also had two young kids and so I was just kind of tired a lot.
So I don't think my expectations for having a rocking sex life were very high.
And then I met Tom and everything changed.
Now you might be wondering, did my spouse know that I was having an off-the-charts romance
and the best sex of my entire life and if he did know, did he have a problem with it?
And I'll tell you absolutely yes to both.
Drew and I had been polyamorous for some time at that point and we'd both had other partners.
We were always transparent with each other too and this experience was no different.
And I don't want to get more into Drew's story today because we will be talking together
about it on the next episode of this show.
My hope today is to talk to people whose story resembles mine because if you're going
through something like what I went through, you probably have nobody you can talk to
about this.
Having an experience in polyamory where a new partner just completely eclipses any romantic
or sexual connection you've had before can really throw you for a loop.
Can also ignite a personal awakening and lead you to question yourself and everything
you know.
But it doesn't have to be the end of the world.
It doesn't have to be the end of your other relationships.
It doesn't have to mean you're doing anything wrong even though you might feel all kinds
of ways about it.
Sometimes when this kind of thing happens where you experience a big awakening with a new
partner, it's what everyone is hoping for.
Like we obviously are doing polyamory so that we can have lots of new experiences.
And also while the polyamory community doesn't like to talk about this very much, there
are also a fair number of folks in our space who have long term established relationships
where the sexual and sometimes also the romantic side of the relationship has faded or completely
disappeared.
And this can happen for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with whether these
people still love each other.
Sometimes there's just stress in the relationship that kills things, sometimes there's just
a real difference in libido, sometimes there's some deep sexual incompatibilities and sometimes
those were always there and sometimes the people in the relationship change and those
changes leave the couple unable to find their way back to each other in that way.
I've also met with more than one couple where a partner has realized they are asexual
or they're no longer attracted to the gender that their established partner is.
These folks often turn to polyamory as a solution so that they can hold on to their established
relationship without that needing to be the end of their sexual lives.
But sometimes you're in an established relationship and you're pretty happy.
Maybe you're new to polyamory but maybe you're not.
Maybe you've already had a lot of other partners.
But then one or both of you makes a connection that catalyzes something new.
You discover things about your sexual self that you never knew before.
The experience changes everything, like a total game changer.
By the way aside, I'm sorry I do have to say this part.
When this was happening to me, I was looking for some kind of support and it was really
hard to find.
And so in a desperate fit, I read this book called The Game Changer by Franklin Vo who also
was one of the original authors of more than two.
And I can say confidently you shouldn't read that book.
It was profoundly not helpful to me.
And also there's a lot of bashing that he does of past partners and friends that is just
kind of cringey.
Okay, aside over.
Anyway, so meeting someone like this, someone who just sets off a cascade of change and
excitement and self discovery inside you can have a dramatic effect on so much.
It can change how you feel about sex and romance and what you want out of those things.
This is exactly a kind of thing you are opening the door to when you have an open relationship.
Now of course it can be intense and tricky and complicated.
And here are some things that might come up for you if this does happen for you.
I feel like I'm on cloud nine and nothing can go wrong.
I've never felt so alive before.
I feel like I'm betraying my other partner or partners, but I don't think that I am.
I want to make things equal between my partners so that my established partners can feel okay
with this new person.
I want to make sure my established partner is happy and satisfied in our relationship so
that they don't feel threatened and so I can keep seeing my new partner.
It's wild to be changing gears all the time between feeling really high and crazy and
love to sort of being back on the ground and doing normal stuff.
I truly love my existing partner and what I want from them is changing.
I'm not sure I can tell them why or what's happening because it would hurt them.
Being with this new person is helping me see things about myself and I'm realizing some
things I want or need that I didn't know about before.
I wonder if I can ask my partner for some of those things.
I feel so vulnerable in this new relationship.
What if this goes away?
What if this is too much?
What if I'm too much?
I've never felt more okay with myself and my life.
Does this maybe mean that I don't truly love my current partner and maybe we should split
up and that I'm actually meant to be with this other person?
Aren't I meant to be with the person with whom I have the most chemistry and compatibility
sexually?
Does the sexual compatibility that I have with my new partner mean that we're going to be
compatible in other ways that I haven't guessed at yet?
What about the ways in which I'm very compatible with my established partner?
Oh, it's so confusing. I don't want to compare, but sometimes I can't help comparing.
Man, I thought my sex life was fine before I opened up my relationship, but now I've changed so
much. I don't feel that way anymore, and I don't know what to do about it. This is too hard.
Maybe I can't date multiple people and should be monogamous. Sometimes I don't want to have sex
with my established partners, but I always want to have sex with my new partner and I feel guilty
about that. Maybe if I downplay this new relationship, I can help my partner feel more okay about it.
I'm sad that I don't feel this way about my other established partners. I wish I could be as excited
about sex with them as I am with my new partner. Holding all this love inside me is crazy. I feel
like I'm going to burst. I'm sure there's some things I missed, but these are the things that I've
heard from other folks in this situation and also things I felt myself. You can end up feeling
so much and so many contradictory feelings that change constantly. It can be intense,
and I'll say it again, it's something you're opening the door to when you practice non-monogamy,
and I'm not sure that there's anything you can do to prevent it if you choose to have multiple
sexual partners. But did you notice when I was going through those possible thoughts and feelings
that you might be having when you're facing a situation like this? How many of them were actually
monogamy thinking? How many of them were scarcity mindset? How many of them were all or nothing
and ranking and comparing to see who's the winner? And of course those thoughts and feelings
are going to crop up because we have been trained to think that way since we were born because
we grow up in a mononormative culture. We've been trained to think who's the best and that's my
person. But like, it really doesn't have to be that way. I mean, in a way, why wouldn't you want
this to happen? It's where the rubber meets the road if you're practicing polyamory. It's where
you really get to put your money where your mouth is, so to speak. But I get why some people might
be afraid of this happening. It might feel too hard. It might feel like something that would put
at risk your existing relationship or relationships. And I'm not going to lie. It can be. But it
absolutely doesn't have to be. It depends on so many factors. One thing that can help you wrap
your mind around a situation like this might be to understand two things. How this kind of thing
can happen without it being a reflection on the quality of your relationship and how you could
meet the moment as an opportunity rather than a catastrophe. So let's start with the first thing.
How could this happen without anybody being wrong? Well, one thing to know is that the reason
I created this episode is that this is actually really common. It's so common. And it's particularly
likely to happen if one or more of these factors is in the mix. One is got together with your
established partner when you were young and sexually inexperienced. Maybe you grew up in a
conservative culture where sex per pleasure or outside of the context of marriage was considered
shameful. Maybe you have a few colors in the LGBTQI rainbow that you didn't know about at the
time you got together with your established partner. You either thought you were straight or
allosexual or maybe just the L or the G colors in the rainbow. Another factor is your idea of
good sex was rooted exclusively in whether orgasms happen or not. You approach sex exclusively as
like a need to get off or to get your partner off to alleviate horneiness the same way you approach
eating like you need to alleviate hunger. Your reasons to have sex are more centered around pleasing
others or doing a good job or checking a box than your own pleasure. Maybe you don't even know
what consistently works for you sexually. You and your partner have different ways that you each get
to sex and they don't line up easily. One or both of you has a hard time saying what you would like
or what's not working for you for fear of spoiling the mood. One or both of you is sensitive to feedback
about how sex is going. Or you just don't talk about it because you don't have the language or
because it feels scary. You're somewhere in your mid 30s to mid 50s meaning you're potentially
approaching a mid life awakening that means all kinds of shit is getting stirred up. You're married
and you've been together more than five years live together and or have kids which means there's
a lot of hard work you do together in addition to the joy of just loving each other. When you chose
a long term partner you chose someone who is really different from you but who you felt complemented
you well and now the ways in which you're different are creating more friction than they are joy.
And you've never explored kink or learned about consent beyond being a simple yes
to sex or no to sex. What many of these factors have in common is that you may be stepping into
non-monogamy not really knowing big parts of how you work sexually and maybe you even know that
which is why you want to explore so you can learn more about what's out there and try stuff.
And since you don't know what you don't know you could discover things about yourself that change
everything that changes how sex works for you which can shake up a whole lot of other things in
your sense of self and how you want to relate. Having other sexual partners can be like that.
You can open up this Pandora's box of what's possible. You might realize you're queer when you
thought you weren't. You might even realize you're not interested in the gender of your partner
anymore. You might discover you're kinky and into power exchange or pain or degradation or age
play and maybe your established partner isn't into any of that. Or as is the case with me you might
just discover what good sex is for you and it might not even be something you can articulate.
It's just something that you found that feels good and feels different and feels right.
And y'all I am not in any way saying that my spouse was a bad lover. Like that wasn't it. Again
nobody was doing anything wrong. When I reflect on it it was really about where I was and what I
knew about myself and about sex when we met. And the funny thing is I even grew up relatively
sex positive and without a lot of the shame stories that a lot of folks grow up with around sex
but still there was so much I didn't know. And then my partner he didn't have more experience
than I did so I'm not sure he could have corrected anything for me around the things I thought I knew.
We were both showing up with some really broken heterosexual scripts. There were also
some incompatibilities that we were able to discover eventually. Like we both have a responsive
type desire which means we both want the other one to get things going so that we can get excited.
I also have way more sexual breaks than my spouse does and a lot of those breaks can show up more
in the context of sharing domestic duties and child care and life responsibilities.
I also had spent most of my sexually active adulthood focused on doing a good job
doing things right and being pleasing including being pleased for the sake of my partner's pleasure
and at the same time I didn't really understand how my own pleasure worked. And when I didn't find
pleasure effortless I would often blame myself because my partners were generally always willing to
please. And I also didn't have a deep understanding of consent. What I had gleaned from growing up
was to not be a tease and so I felt like if I started something physical with someone that
that created a sexual expectation and I better follow through on it which put me in this state of
being constantly vigilant for whether or not I wanted sex so that I could figure out where to stop
when I was giving or receiving any kind of physical affection. I was also afraid to ruin the mood
by interrupting my partner if I needed something like Lou or if something just wasn't feeling good
or if I wanted to do something else. I had not learned to be easeful in communicating my needs
during sex so even when I tried they were awkward and sometimes emotionally loaded in ways that
definitely weren't great. I also really thought or hoped that my partner would kind of just know
what to do or be so attuned to my nonverbal cues that they'd be able to read me better than
I could read myself. And actually my spouse is very very attuned to me but while he could always
sense what was going on could sense a shift in me or something like that he also struggled with
knowing what that meant and what to do about saying something about that and whether you should
pause things and ask for what's up like that wasn't part of what was normal for him either.
And in fact he was kind of raised like don't rock the boat don't make anything difficult don't
impose on anybody and so as a result I I wasn't always enjoying the sex I was having even though I
had a loving and caring and considerate and eager and talented partner and again I don't even think
I knew it and because I didn't know it and I didn't know how to fix it there was no real clear
pathway to change that and when we did try to talk about it I often just blamed myself for being
difficult I often felt like I was the problem. Now I know that particular experience isn't everyone's
but I do share that a lot and I do think this kind of thing is especially common in heterosexual
pairings because we get so many harmful and contradictory messages about sex and how it's
supposed to work. I've seen some of this in queer pairings as well but it's way less common.
At some point I should really do an episode about how everyone should learn more about queer sex
even if they're not queer because the queers are just generally better at sex because they don't
have to deprogram as much from all of the crap that straight people are fed.
for most of their lives, but that's not this episode.
Hey, real quick before we get back to the episode.
If you've been listening to this show for a while
and you've been nodding along but then feeling stuck
and making these ideas part of your reality,
well, I made something for you.
It's a workbook based on the most popular episodes
of the show with simple practices and reflection questions
so that you can apply this stuff to your life.
Just head to libasonback.com/workbook and grab your copy.
So things actually started to change for me
when I got exposed to kink culture,
which in turn exposed me to consent culture.
And then I started exploring my queerness,
which I'd always known was there,
but I previously didn't really give space for it
because I felt like I had to choose a side.
I remember I attended my first facilitated play party
and then another and then another,
and I was just having all these mind-blowing experiences
and I was developing a better vocabulary
which not only helped me express myself to my partners,
but also just helped me understand my own experience better.
I also developed a broader picture
of what sex could look like,
which was a departure from the script I thought sex
always had to follow.
And then along came Tom.
When we got together, it was like everything just clicked
into place for one thing it was new.
So we could both show up curious and excited
without any assumptions.
And I was better at expressing myself,
and I think it was easier for him to listen
because we were new.
And all those NRE hormones and everything
just focused us on each other
and we became so attuned,
it was like there was a Bluetooth connection
between our brains.
I also think we just happened to enjoy
a lot of compatible things and had similar interests.
I also think we just had similar instincts around things.
There were just things we were compatible on
that I wouldn't have even known to want to be compatible on.
I think what I discovered with Tom
was that sexual compatibility is a real thing.
I mean, while you can theoretically teach someone
how to make love to you and I think you should,
if you don't even know what works for you yourself,
then it's pretty helpful when someone else just seems to know.
When you take all that,
you combine it with some unmet needs
that we both had in our other relationships
that we were able to meet for each other,
alongside that when we were together,
we were free of our kids,
free of our domestic responsibilities,
free of any life stuff that could create friction or stress,
and well, you can imagine,
we took a rocket ship to the moon together.
And I really don't want to gloss over the unmet needs
and responsibilities parts
because that can obviously impact your sex drive.
When you're with someone for a long time,
you can develop all kinds of unmet expectations
or misunderstandings that can accumulate over time.
And if you live together,
have kids navigate extended family or share finances,
all of these things can be sources of stress
and sometimes conflict.
And if you don't have good tools
from moving through that stress and conflict,
then hurts can build up.
It's easy to stop being curious.
It's easy to stop being excited.
Emily Nagasaki calls this gunk in the pipes.
It can also be really hard to find time to connect
in a way that's free from all that gunk,
especially if you have kids,
especially if you have young, neurodivergent kids.
For Drew and I, there was honestly a mountain of things
between us and the kind of sex
that just blossomed effortlessly with Tom.
And that wasn't anybody's fault.
It was just how things happened to unfold.
And it wasn't easy to fix
as if there was something that you needed to fix.
As I told Drew when it was going on,
I couldn't pull my relationship with him
out of the context in which we had it.
He couldn't both be my husband and be my boyfriend.
They're completely different relationships
with different shapes.
And I love having him as my husband.
There were just some ways in which that made sex
harder to access together.
I hope what I'm painting for you is a clear picture
of how many people could land in a place
where they're having a more exciting sexual
and sometimes even romantic connection
with a newer partner.
And that doesn't have to involve things like abandoning
or betraying your existing partner,
failing to love or care about your existing relationship,
choosing to prioritize your new partner over everything else
or intentionally hurting your existing partner.
But oh boy, did it sometimes feel that way to Drew.
He could see how lit up I was inside.
He noticed me excitingly staying up late to text Tom.
He also felt the comparison.
How it looked like to him, Tom could do no wrong
while we still had the challenges we had
and it felt really unfair to him.
For the first time in our seven years
of being non-monogamous, he really struggled.
Like, really struggled.
It was probably one of the hardest times in our marriage.
I think we'd both agree on that.
And again, we'll talk more about that next episode.
I actually worried at a certain point,
it would all be too hard and that he'd leave me
for putting him through this torture.
I'm sharing this because again,
these two things can be true at the same time.
I wasn't doing anything wrong.
I was having a sexual awakening.
I felt like I was coming home to parts of myself
in ways I had been longing for.
I was also working really hard.
Not to let NRE pull me off my values
and my commitments to my spouse and my kids
and our home and my mom and my friends
because I felt really, really clear
that I didn't want to blow up my life.
And the whole point of polyamory
is that you don't have to choose.
At the same time, Drew said he felt like he was being tortured.
It felt to him sometimes like I wasn't prioritizing him.
He felt like I was choosing to see him in a certain way
that made me not excited or curious about him or us.
And it's understandable that he felt that way,
that he was kind of blaming me for this pain that he was in.
The reality of the situation was just painful.
And when reality feels out of alignment
with what we feel it should be, we have two choices.
We fight reality or we grieve.
And nobody really wants to grieve.
So we might choose fight reality
which can look like avoiding reality
or finding someone or something to blame.
If there's someone or something that's wrong, that's bad,
well, then we can just point that out and fix it,
except here there was nothing to fix
and nobody doing anything wrong.
I have sat with more than one person
facing a similar situation.
A new partner being a catalyst
for a tremendous awakening.
Sexual, relational, kink-related,
or around things like gender or identity.
Please know that you two are not to blame
for doing something wrong.
You get to be on the journey you're on
and discover and explore and expand and grow.
And it can be very, very hard on your existing ecosystem,
even if you're still showing up
and striving to be loving and kind in those relationships.
But it doesn't have to destroy your life.
Like I said before, it can actually be an opportunity.
If you keep bringing your feet back to the ground.
What's the opportunity, you might ask?
Well, okay, no matter what happens,
you have experienced something
that has changed you forever.
Even if the people in your life change,
the things you've discovered about yourself
will always be with you.
And with all that self-discovery,
it's an opportunity to invite the people that love you
to also discover who you are now.
That can be hard for those folks,
especially if the change isn't welcome.
But if everyone is able to say yes to the new reality,
there are often new opportunities for everyone
to get more of what they want from each other.
Here's some suggestions that I have,
again, if you're the one experiencing the awakening
for how to move through the experience
with love and compassion for everyone involved,
including you.
Number one, honor what's happening for you.
So often we zip right to, oh no,
I don't wanna blow up my life and forget the,
hey, I found something transcendent
in this short little bit of time
that I get to exist on this speck of dust in the universe
that is special and important.
For me, it was sacred.
Don't let that go.
Number two, instead of letting
what's happening for you tear you off your center,
let that aliveness fuel you and ground you fully
into the present of all of your relationships.
When I say meeting Tom changed my life, I mean it.
The love that I felt and the love that I gave
was fucking magic.
But something that can happen when you're being
so lit up like that is that you can get caught
in this cycle of chasing that feeling
out of a fear of losing it.
Instead, I wanna invite you to imagine
all that love and aliveness that eros
as this infinite power source at the core of your being.
This person ignited it in you.
They helped you create it, but it's in you.
Draw that energy into the center of your body
and then let it radiate outward into every extremity
into every cell of your body.
That magic is yours.
Yes, it's precious, but I'd like you to consider
that maybe it's not fragile.
Three, for the person you're sharing it with,
it's so important to honor them too.
I have a bunch more to say about this
the NRE episode. But if you're feeling this intensely and they're also feeling this intensely,
that can be so tender and vulnerable. Their heart is just as open as yours and they might
need some protection and care and support. And sometimes they might also feel guilty
if they're aware that somehow they're creating ripples in your other relationships. Help them
not take that on. Number four, don't let new relationship energy cause you to abandon
your other relationships, or your friendships, or your personal interests, or your family
connections, etc. Continue putting in the effort that's necessary to tend to the other
aspects of your life, especially if this situation is uncovering some cracks that need attention.
Number five, be honest and transparent with your existing partners. This one might feel
obvious, but when the reality of what's happening for you is likely going to be painful for
your other partner to hear, you may feel like you want to downplay or just keep it to yourself.
The problem with that is that more than likely your partner's going to be able to tell that
something big is happening for you. And if you tell them that they're making things up or
blowing things out of proportion so that they don't have to feel any pain, it not only won't work.
It will make them question their own intuition and observations, it will cause them to doubt their
own feelings, it could cause them to develop anxiety or hypervigilance, and it will create
distrust between the two of you, because they'll be able to tell the difference between what
you're saying and what they are seeing. And eventually, when the truth becomes more apparent,
they will feel even more distrust and possibly betrayed. Now, that also doesn't mean you have to
be blunt. There's a difference between being honest and being cruel. Yes, you can say how you
feel, but I really wouldn't recommend making open comparisons between your partners. Number six,
welcome and be compassionate with the feelings of your existing partner if they're struggling.
Even if you don't agree with their story or how they're seeing things, if you think the way
to help them with their feelings is to just explain what you know is true and help if they'll just
accept your reality and feel better, that's not actually how it works. They need to feel seen
and understood and met with kindness for the ways that they might be struggling. You have to be
able to do that whole holding two things at the same time thing, you aren't doing anything wrong,
and your partner may be feeling what they're feeling and that's allowed to.
Number seven, don't try to fix their feelings. This is a tough one because oftentimes our partner
may want us to do that. They may even openly or secretly want you to break up with your new
partner. Even if you're not willing to do that, here are some other ways you might try to fix
their feelings. You might make sure that you have sex with them with the same frequency as you're
as you're having sex with your other partner to keep it fair, whether or not that's what you actually
want. You may agree not to do certain things with your other partner to keep them comfortable,
and that actually won't work. You may tell them things that they want to hear that aren't true
just to soothe them. You might actively choose them over your other partner when they ask for
that or seem to want it, and this can set up an intentional and painful hierarchy for your other
partner and make them feel jerked around or disposable. Number eight, accept that even if you're
showing up in every way you can, it may not work to soothe your established partner. That doesn't
mean that you should give up on showing up. Just you can't take their feelings as proof of whether
you're doing a good job or not. Number nine, do offer comfort. Ask for what you can do to be supportive.
They may need reassurance or extra communication about what's going on. They may need understanding
and patience. Here's something real. When you're the partner who's struggling with jealousy or fear
and feeling like you're not the preferred partner for something, you can also end up feeling like
really pathetic and unattractive. It's so vulnerable and it may feel like a fine line to walk
between being caring and kind and reassuring to your partner and the previous thing I said which
is don't fix their feelings. The difference is you showing up with your kind heart and offering
them what you can, you're doing that without needing to change them. Number 10, get support.
Get support from other friends, from community, from trusted family and possibly a professional.
You need a safe place to talk about this, to say the messy stuff and be affirmed and supported
without being judged or getting a big reaction. Number 11, notice when that mononormative thinking
is showing up in you and also just track it when you're noticing it in others. And don't
beat yourself up about it. It's going to show up. Just call it out to yourself and acknowledge it
inside yourself when it comes up with others. Number 12, make some rules about limiting processing
about what's happening in your relationships so that you're not talking about it all the time.
And please, use halt. Don't talk about things when you're hungry, angry, lonely, tired,
or drunk or triggered or generally in a more activated state. And finally, number 13,
go slow. Go slow. Go slow especially with making big moves around your new discoveries.
Don't make any significant life changes in the first two years of an awakening like this.
Things have been massively shaken up and it can be really useful to let things settle,
which may take some time. Now, this last one is important for everyone involved. When this happened
to me, Tom was also married with kids. The whole ecosystem between the two of us was about like
13 people total. And what was happening between us affected everyone. If we had been too reactive
to what was happening, it could have been catastrophic. As it was when I reflect now,
I still think we went too fast or pushed on too many things that maybe needed space to breathe.
And I guess part of the reason I wanted to record this episode is so you can learn from some
of my regrets. And when you're in a game-changing type relationship, neither of you are going to
want to slow down. In fact, you might even resent having to slow down to support an existing
ecosystem. And there's actually a pretty fine line between adjusting how your relationship is
going to support the existing ecosystem and letting more established partners try to control things
to feel better. And I just want to say sometimes the former might feel like the latter,
but it's not. And I think it's okay to want to keep your established relationships and your
established ecosystem. And at the same time, as I'm being honest, I kind of want this game-changing
experience for everyone. I mean, ideally at a time when everyone has the mental and emotional
bandwidth to handle it. Like I said, it changed my whole life in ways that I continue to cherish.
It not only allowed me to come home to my body, to my sexuality, to seeing myself in a whole new
way and to deeply accept myself as I am, it not only brought a beautiful and amazing human into my
life who I cherish so much and who is not only part of my heart but part of my family now,
but it also did ultimately transform my existing relationship with my spouse.
Rather than run from it or let it tear us apart, we both met the moment by turning not just toward
each other, but toward ourselves. I'm looking forward to telling you more about that in the next
episode, but when I say this is an opportunity, I mean it. It's been eight and a half years since
that experience. And while so much has changed, my marriage has only been getting better.
So to recap, in polyamory, it's normal, even common, to find yourself in a new relationship that
turns you inside out and upside down in ways that your existing partner never has. That can be
challenging, but it can also be no one's fault. What it can be is an opportunity, an opportunity
for you to come home to yourself in many ways and for your established partners to get to know and
create a new with this awakened version of you. It's an opportunity to really live into some of
the more tricky polyamorous ideals and be kind to each other. On the other side of this hard
could be something amazing and healing, something that reminds us of why we are here and alive on
this earth. So go slow, but go.
Thank you for joining me today. If you have any thoughts about what I've said or a question
for the show, I'd love to hear from you. You can find me on Instagram at that polyam mom
or you can reach me on the podcast show website at makingpolyamorywork.com.
I'll also say that if you're loving my podcasts, but you're looking for more support,
I do this support for a living. I help individuals, couples and groups have amazing relationships,
and you can find out more about my offerings on my personal website, LibbySynback.com.
If you love this podcast, please share it with your friends, your networks, your Instagram stories,
etc. and make sure you subscribe so you don't miss an episode. Also, if you listen on iTunes or
Spotify, it's really wonderful to leave a review or a comment because it will help more people
find the show. Making Polyamory work is created by me, LibbySynback. It is edited by Finn of the
normalizing non-monogamy podcast and hosted on the Spotify podcast platform.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Meeting a new partner in an open relationship can trigger a profound personal and sexual awakening, fundamentally shifting one’s self-perception and desires.
Such experiences are common in polyamory and often stem from unmet needs, lack of sexual knowledge, or long-standing emotional and relational patterns.
The change is not a failure of existing relationships but rather a natural outcome of discovering what one truly seeks in love and intimacy.
New partners can reveal hidden aspects of identity, such as queerness, sexuality, or kink, which may not have been previously acknowledged.
The emotional impact can be intense and conflicting, with feelings of excitement, guilt, vulnerability, and comparison to existing partners.
It’s crucial to honor the new experience while maintaining care, transparency, and emotional balance with existing relationships.
Monogamy-based thinking, scarcity, and comparison often surface due to cultural conditioning and can distort how people process these changes.
With patience, communication, and self-awareness, these experiences can strengthen relationships and lead to deeper personal growth and connection.
Summary:
Meeting a new partner in an open relationship can trigger a transformative personal and sexual awakening, reshaping one’s understanding of love, identity, and intimacy. The speaker shares her own experience with Tom, a relationship that brought deep emotional and physical connection, leading to a profound rediscovery of her sexuality and self. While initially overwhelming and confusing, this shift isn’t a failure of existing relationships—it arises from unmet needs, lack of sexual self-knowledge, or long-standing relational patterns.
The experience often reveals hidden aspects of identity, such as queerness or kink, and can lead to new forms of connection and self-acceptance. Despite intense emotional reactions—like guilt, jealousy, or comparison—the speaker emphasizes that no one is to blame. Instead, it’s an opportunity to grow, honor one’s truth, and deepen bonds with all partners.
Key steps include being honest yet compassionate with existing partners, avoiding attempts to fix their feelings, recognizing mononormative thinking, and allowing time for healing. With patience, support, and self-awareness, such experiences can strengthen relationships and foster a more authentic, fulfilling life. The journey, though challenging, can ultimately lead to greater self-knowledge, emotional resilience, and deeper love—proving that polyamory can be a path to personal and relational growth, not just chaos.
FAQs
Meeting a new partner can trigger a profound emotional, sexual, and self-discovery experience, often leading to a significant shift in how you view sex, romance, and your own identity.
Yes, it's very common for a new relationship to feel transformative, as it can reveal unmet needs, awaken new sexual desires, and challenge long-held beliefs about love and commitment.
No—this kind of awakening doesn’t mean betrayal. It often reflects personal growth and rediscovery, not a failure in loyalty or love toward your existing partner.
They may feel guilty because societal norms teach that love and desire should be exclusive, even though in polyamory, multiple connections can coexist with deep commitment.
By being honest, compassionate, and present—validating their partner’s feelings, avoiding blame, and offering emotional support without trying to fix their reactions.
No—it can be challenging, but with open communication and care, it often leads to deeper understanding and growth, strengthening the existing relationship over time.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.