Galileo's groundbreaking astronomical discoveries, made possible through observations with the canocchial, challenged traditional Aristotelian and Ptolemaic beliefs about the universe. Through his observations of stars, moon, Venus, Jupiter, and sun, Galileo revolutionized scientific understanding. He noted discrepancies in the positions and characteristics of celestial bodies, leading him to challenge the idea of a fixed, perfect universe. Galileo's findings on the moon's imperfections, Venus's phases, Jupiter's satellites, and the sun's solar maculae fundamentally altered the understanding of the cosmos. These discoveries had profound philosophical implications, highlighting the importance of imperfections and change in the universe, contrary to the traditional belief in a static, perfect cosmos. Galileo's work laid the foundation for modern astronomy and science, inspiring a shift in perspectives towards a dynamic and evolving universe.
Transcription
3401 Words, 19594 Characters
We have already dedicated a couple of points to the thought of Galileo-Garileo, especially
to its operation for now, the way in which science was designed, and the way in which
it was trying to conquer the science of the spaces of autonomy, of the spaces of maneuver,
which made it independent from the theology, from faith, from the Bible and from the authority
of the past.
But today we must start to see what can be discovered, indeed, how Galileo works in
scientific terms, where its famous eye-catching and above all what it discovers, because these
first discoveries, especially astronomical at the beginning, will convince Galileo of the
foundation of the totalist system of the mind, instead of the value of the alternative model,
the Copernican model that no one at the time could profess.
Today we start to see all this starting, as always, immediately after the seal.
Within the philosophy, a podcast by Hermano Scripps Ferretti, 172th point, Galileo and his
astronomical discoveries.
Here we are again to talk about philosophy, in particular philosophy of the Renaissance,
but the Renaissance is now becoming true to its modern age, because Galileo, as we said,
lived between the five centuries and the six centuries, he has certainly influenced by the
cultural climate that persists in Italy, and Fiorentino, Pisano, Padovano, that is, it persists
in the air of great artists, great scholars, of humanists, and not only.
However, time passes, and the same thing that Galileo is doing, leads to a new feeling,
which we have already begun to see, which we will soon see again, a feeling that must
be made with the Church, it is also complicated the climate of reform and counter-reform that
persists in Europe, which must also be done with Aristotle, in short, which must make
many many accounts, as it is easy to intuit.
Today, however, we will talk, above all, about science and, in particular, about astronomy,
the white part of science, which is more or less interested in Galileo at the beginning,
then there will be a lot of dynamics, we will talk about it and other disciplines, but from
the philosophical point of view, of course, the major impact comes with astronomy.
As I told you, Galileo is quite astute by the conceptions, which, however, seem fascinating
to Nicolò Copernico, the south, certainly, about 50 years ago, compared to Galileo,
and, however, the ideas of Copernico that are spreading, they influenced the approach of Gerrano
Bruno, we have seen it, they are conquering fervent admirers in Europe and Galileo interested.
Of course you have to find evidence, those of Copernico were, as I said, of the conceptions,
that is, of the reasoning, also based on its observations, of course, but still everyone
has to prove, deep down, you have to bring something concrete to convince many, many
YouTubers.
And Galileo, trying to do this, tries to find the proofs of the fact that Copernico has
reason to do it, he has an approach that is very modern, which for us today is perhaps
banal and unaccountable, but that at the time it was not unaccountable, that is, he wants
to observe, he wants to point his eyes at the material he wants to study, at the field
of indexes and notice things, to see with the eyes, find the proofs, as we say today,
precisely with a language perhaps even a little legal, from tribunals to lawyers.
However, how do you find the proofs in terms of astronomical?
Obviously we have reached 500 and 600, there are no spaces, there are no, who knows,
which races that can start, you have to use whatever you have.
Here is Galileo, from this point of view, he is certainly a very modern man, because he
does not have much exposure, but the little he has he uses widely.
In particular, the instrument that becomes the symbol of these Galilean scopes,
of this new attitude of science, is the canocchial.
Very often he talked about this canocchial Galilean, as if it were an invention
of Galileo, in reality the historical research has shown that Galileo has not invented
the canocchial.
The canocchial existed already before Galileo, in Holland it was for the first time built
probably and used, only that in Holland the canocchial is certainly the second
canocchial.
The canocchial was known by a series of lenses that allowed to enlarge the image and
see great distances, but these canocchials were mainly used in Holland
for very practical competitions, for navigation, for battles, for wars, not yet,
to try to study the universe, Galileo, to this something more, this new element
that makes it particularly interesting and important, is the fact that using this
canocchial, he reconstructs it on the model of examples that he had read in Holland
and point it towards the stars.
It is the first to try to use a instrument that had other scopes for scientific purposes,
this super-agmatism signed throughout all its science activities will be many
discovered that Galileo will also do with a certain technique, exploiting what the
world gives him, what he can do with the instruments that he has.
So what does Galileo discover pointing the canocchial towards the sky?
Let's see, because there are various things, but all in one with the other, end up
to beat the system, Aristotelic Otolemaico.
The first thing that Galileo notices when he points the canocchial up in the sky is that
the stars do not end up where one's eye sees.
Until that moment, everyone looked at the sky, certainly but with a simple and naked eye,
as he used to say, and that the observers had individualized a series of stars, which
were thought to be the last stars of the universe, those that were called fixed stars,
remember that Aristotelic Otolemaico had also talked about them.
These fixed stars were encased in the so-called last sky, what was to be
the end of the universe, precisely the limit.
Galileo, look at the canocchial note, of course those stars that the observers have seen
there are, but that the smaller they are, the more distant they are, there are also many
other stars that one can not see.
What makes him say, attention, already here there is an important proof, this means that the
universe is not as small as it was imagined by Aristotelic, that those stars that we see
are actually not the last, but the penultimate, the third, the fourth, perhaps there could
still be many more, if we had a completely powerful canocchial note, so who knows how
big this universe is, much bigger than we expect, the first element.
Second important element, the point of his canocchial note, which is obviously also
on the moon, the first of the satellites closest to it, planets, or however satellites that
turn around the Earth, and he realizes, looking at the moon, that the moon is not like
he expected.
Second, according to Aristotelic's theory, the moon should have been made of earth,
if you remember all the planets from the moon in Poi, then from the celestial world in
Poi, they should have been made of earth, and the earth was a fifth element, very different
according to Aristotelic from Earth, water, fire and air, which instead were the terrestrial
elements.
This fifth element, the earth, was a perfect element for which all the planets made of
earth should have been the perfect ones.
And this, in Aristotelic's system at the time, meant that he imagined that the moon,
the sun, Venus, Mars, and so on, would be a smooth and perfect sphere, without
crevices, without mountains, without valleys, because the earth is a perfect element without imperfections.
Like a sort of ball of billiards, if you remember.
Well, Galileo points his canocchial towards the moon and what does he notice?
He notices that on the moon there are mountains, he notices that on the moon there are valleys,
there are depressions.
So this means that the moon is not perfect as we expected, it cannot be made of this
phantom being the one who speaks Aristotelic but that no one has ever seen.
If there are mountains on the moon and there are valleys, it means that it is not so much
different from the earth, also the earth, its mountains and its valleys, right?
So, maybe, in the beginning to suspect Galileo, these ideas of two worlds, the celestial world
and the sub-lunar world, the first perfect and the second imperfect, maybe these two worlds
are actually a single world, all made of the same elements, there are not all these
big differences between the moon and the earth, so between the planets and the planet
earth.
Third observation that Galileo points his canocchial towards Venus, and he realizes
that Venus is subject to phases, like the moon in a certain sense, that is, to a certain
development of its brightness throughout the days.
This implies that if Venus, like the moon, has phases, it implies that Venus is not
necessarily a luminous body, but that it receives the light, no, like the moon, the moon does not
put light on its phases because it receives the light from the sun and then sometimes it is
impaled, so to speak, from the earth, so Venus is not a luminous body, but it is
similar to the earth, also this is important because even the earth receives the light
from the sun and even Venus receives the light from the sun, not only.
If Venus is subject to phases, it also means that Venus rotates around the sun, another
very important thing, I note that there is a center of rotation in the universe, yes,
but it is not the earth for now, it is the sun, while to restore the only center of rotation
in the universe there is always only the earth, and another frame goes to its place.
Fourth observation that Galileo points his canocchial towards Jupiter, and he realizes that
Jupiter has, at times, satellites that, or that a cloud did not see each other, maybe
now with the canocchial they can be individualized, these satellites then are named by Galileo
"Stelle Medice" in honor of the doctors who were his protectors.
Here, these "Stelle Medice" obviously rotate around Jupiter, they are the satellites
of Jupiter, which means that Jupiter, which then has its wings and everything else, is a
center of rotation also, so we have said Venus rotates around the sun, surely, so
the sun is a center of rotation.
Jupiter has satellites, so it is also Jupiter, a center of rotation, certainly also the earth
is a center of rotation because they rotate around the moon, but be careful, evidently
rotation centers can be many, not only and not necessarily the earth.
Last important observation that Galileo makes, and then we have finished with this sequence
of information on astronomy, points his canocchial towards the sun, this is also complicated
because then I did not tell you, but we will talk about it when we will do more in a deeper
way the process, Galileo will also die almost dry, basically dry, because his
observations are so effective, so impenetrable to fix the sun, it does not look good obviously,
they have taken him in the course of serious problems at the sight, anyway, in this
phase he is still rowing, he wants to know, he wants to know, so points his canocchial
towards the sun, and what do you realize, you realize that on the sun there are strange
reactions that he calls solar mackers, what are they, looking at the sun you realize that
intermittenza, in a way a little casual apparently, there are mackers that
appear on the solar surface, mackers that go and come, and Galileo recalls that these are
the proof of alterations of processes that are in progress on the surface of the sun,
meaning that something is happening if they compare mackers and then disappear, that there is
some chemical process probably in progress, but this is why it is important, because the
sun according to the Ritotally-Cotonemaica routine had to be unmutable and perfect,
that is, there should not be any process, alterations, particular things on its surface,
the fact, however, that Galileo shares in these solar mackers the further proof of the fact
that there is the devenir, that the sun is subject to devenir as are subject to devenir
also the other planets and also the moon, the stars and so on, I sign that again the
distinction, the Ritotally-Cotonemaica between the lunar and celestial world has no more
meaning, I sign above all that the model of the universe designed by Ptolemaeus is
now over.
From these first important observations that Galileo will begin to draw very soon
of the consequences, also philosophical I would say, because obviously you cannot be indifferent
to these great discoveries that change a lot in the chart on the table, change the perspective,
give reason to Copernicus, but they also go beyond Copernicus, because Copernicus had
spoken of many feelings of rotation, had not spoken of particular phases, here Galileo
confirms the Copernican system, but adds so many new, innovative details to which Copernicus
had not thought that it was the moon that is already evolving towards something new,
what will then be systemed by Newton, then there are these philosophical consequences,
but Galileo intueses that it is also said to communicate in depth, the first this,
perhaps also the most important, we have always been used to thinking about the Greeks
above all with the Ritotally, but not only with the Ritotally, that perfection was synonymous
of immutability, what did Ritotally say, the perfect universe, the universe made of
letters and this perfect element, the spheres, etc, all the circular orbits and so on, because
Galileo said that the perfection was synonymous of immutability, because it could not be immutable
instead of being perfect and immutable to be imperfect, because Galileo says that we need
to also reason a little about the things we care about in depth, we are used to thinking
in effect with the Ritotally, that what is immutable is the best, higher, healthier,
more perfect, think about diamonds in depth, diamonds are practically immutable, they are
arid stones, also at a certain point of view, where there is no reaction of the important biochemical
in which the diamond is firm and immobile and then we return these diamonds extremely
precious, while in the mud, on the contrary, we return it very little, let's say instead
that it needs to be removed only from the rocks, that it needs to be cleaned, yes, it needs
to be thrown away because the mud has not done a good thing, but in reality if I read,
you will see well, the diamonds are really arid, they do not produce anything, while the mud
gives life, because in the mud they are micro-organisms that live, that breathe, so if we want to
look at the point of view of life and therefore also of human existence, the mud would be much
higher than the diamonds, it should be much higher than the diamonds, but unfortunately in our
world so uncertain and so stupid also to follow values that are not true values is
contrary, we have more value to the diamond than not to the mud, and well, says Galileo, we
should learn to give more importance to the mud, because from the mud the life is born, from the mud
everything is born, it seems almost this comparison which is quite famous of Galileo anticipates
a comparison other than the famous, I would say five centuries later, almost, a comparison made
by Fabrizio de André, a singer who is very close to Galileo, if not for the fact that he comes
from the area and everything is not so distant from those of Galileo-Galilei, but precisely in a
song, said the other one of the most famous of De André via the field, there is a phrase that
recalls very closely this reasoning of Galileo when the Italian singer recites
"From the diamonds nothing is born, from the mud the flowers are born" here, this concept that
in De André said in a almost poetic, funny, funny way, in Galileo in short it means
even more philosophical, is not it? It is true for Galileo that from the mud nothing is born, but life,
flowers, everything that counts is born from mud, it is born from mud, it is born from what is dirty,
here, then, if this is true, the universe must not worry, Galileo says "The
Aristotle has always thought that the universe will be solid, fixed, valid, until it will be immutable ",
but be careful, not an immutable universe like the one imagined by the
Aristotle, you cannot explain life, why should there be life in a universe so
crystalline and firm and motionless? No, because there is life, it needs to be
the movement, it needs to be the divinity, it needs to be something made up, and
who told us that something like this was made up of evil, it was made up of imperfection,
it was made up of defect, did not he say it? We should first think about all this
vortex of life, this "to come for N" as something extremely positive, extremely
vital, extremely precious, a new sense of the word.
Here, this was the first consequence of reasoning, but the next time
it will also be presented to others, and then, above all, I must pass you by
astronomy and dynamics, explain how Galileo then announces these great discoveries
and how exactly these great astronomical discoveries will cost him, because
the dynamic field studies do not take him ahead of the inquisition, they do not
represent a problem, the inquisition is to know how they move, the movements of the
lines are uniformly accelerated, it does not matter, but also to the
question whether it matters to know how the universe works, because in the universe
there is a certain hypothesis, we could say, but that's all, we will talk about it
next time, because today, even today, the moment we stop here, I remind you that
you can listen to the podcast on many different platforms, on Apple Podcasts,
Google Podcasts, Spotify, Deezercastbox, Hotradios, Precarodable and YouTube, but
on these platforms, if you want, you can also listen to the podcast "Gemello"
called "Dentro alla Storia", in which we obviously talk about the lack of
history, I also remind you that if you try to explain the stories of
philosophies of different times, compared to those we are treating in the
podcasts, you can also look for it on YouTube, as Hermano Ferrette or
come and write for you, you will find more than a thousand videos, or rather more than a thousand
hundred at the moment when I record a video about each historical time, interesting,
broad, in short, you usually find a lot, a lot of things, so if you go
in search, download them and find them. Finally, I also remind you that if you want to
stay in touch with the channel, do not miss any of the podcasts and other
different initiatives that we will put in place, you can, if you want, follow me
on social networks, on Facebook, on Twitter or on Instagram, where you can find me
with the nickname "Descript" or you can subscribe to the free and weekly newsletter
that you can find going to lindirithhermannoferretti.it, there I do not think
it is really the announcement of this newsletter, leave your e-mail free, you arrive once
a week with various videos, podcasts made, with reading advice,
reading advice, other things, still. Enough, I think I said it all, see you soon
to talk about the historical moment, because we have almost finished it, but
we still have some important things to do and then we will talk about dynamics and
then we will talk about the process, then about the scientific method, in short, there are
still many things to say, thank you very much for the focus, see you next time!
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Galileo's astronomical discoveries challenge Aristotelian and Ptolemaic systems.
Galileo's observations through the canocchial lead to groundbreaking conclusions about the universe.
Galileo's findings on stars, moon, Venus, Jupiter, and sun revolutionize scientific understanding and challenge traditional beliefs.
Galileo's philosophical implications emphasize the importance of change and imperfections in the universe.
Summary:
Galileo's groundbreaking astronomical discoveries, made possible through observations with the canocchial, challenged traditional Aristotelian and Ptolemaic beliefs about the universe. Through his observations of stars, moon, Venus, Jupiter, and sun, Galileo revolutionized scientific understanding. He noted discrepancies in the positions and characteristics of celestial bodies, leading him to challenge the idea of a fixed, perfect universe.
Galileo's findings on the moon's imperfections, Venus's phases, Jupiter's satellites, and the sun's solar maculae fundamentally altered the understanding of the cosmos. These discoveries had profound philosophical implications, highlighting the importance of imperfections and change in the universe, contrary to the traditional belief in a static, perfect cosmos. Galileo's work laid the foundation for modern astronomy and science, inspiring a shift in perspectives towards a dynamic and evolving universe.
FAQs
Galileo discovered that stars do not end where the eye sees, observed mountains and valleys on the moon, noted phases of Venus, found satellites orbiting Jupiter, and observed solar maculae on the sun.
Galileo's observations on the moon challenged the Aristotelian belief that the moon was a perfect, smooth sphere, revealing mountains and valleys on its surface.
Galileo's observations led to the realization that the universe was much larger and more complex than previously thought, challenging the Aristotelian model and supporting Copernicus's ideas.
Galileo observed that Venus, like the moon, exhibited phases, suggesting that Venus orbits around the sun and not the earth as previously believed.
Galileo used a telescope, known as the Galilean scope, to make groundbreaking astronomical discoveries.
Galileo's observations challenged the traditional views of perfection and immutability, suggesting a new perspective on life, movement, and the nature of the universe.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.