Former DOJ Official Tears Apart Trump Admin’s Threat to Congress (w/ Elliot Williams)
24m 54s
The White House, through a letter from Will Sharf, has threatened to pursue criminal charges against Congress for its oversight actions, but this claim is legally unfounded. The speech or debate clause protects members of Congress from prosecution for performing their constitutional duties, including investigations into the executive branch. No criminal statute supports prosecuting lawmakers for issuing subpoenas or conducting oversight, and courts consistently uphold the legitimacy of such actions when tied to a valid legislative purpose. Former Deputy Assistant Attorney General Elliott Williams emphasizes that the administration’s rhetoric is an empty threat, especially given past failures by Republican officials to comply with congressional requests. He notes that while investigations can be costly and disruptive, they remain within Congress’s constitutional authority. The incoming House Oversight Chair, Robert Garcia, defends Congress’s role as a co-equal branch with inherent oversight powers, asserting that accountability is a constitutional duty, not political pettiness. However, Garcia’s framing of investigations as "petty" could legally undermine the legitimacy of the actions by providing grounds for the executive to challenge them in court. Ultimately, the threat reflects an effort by the administration to intimidate Congress, but legal precedent and constitutional principles firmly protect congressional oversight as a vital check on executive power. This dynamic suggests a potential for increased legal and political conflict over the next two years, especially as the new Democratic majority takes office.
Hey, everyone, I'm Catherine Randpell, economics editor here at The Bullwork, and today we are talking about this very ominous threat from the White House, suggesting that they are going to potentially pursue criminal charges against Congress for basically doing their jobs. I am joined today by the perfect guest to talk with about all of this Elliott Williams, who is a CNN legal analyst. But more to the point for our topic today, he was the former deputy assistant AG under the Obama administration, where he oversaw legislative affairs. So Elliott, thanks so much for joining me today. Thanks for having me here. This is good. Okay, so let's just get into what actually happened here. So the White House council, Will Sharf, who by the way, I know from school, we can get into all of that later. I know, I know. I know if you really want to do this. Was there, well, not even going to ask, not even going to ask, but I want the tea. I want the tea. I mean, he's exactly today as he was, then, more or less. Will Sharf penned this letter saying that Congress can only investigate matters for a legislative purpose and that the fact that they are overstepping their responsibilities might be verging into criminal behavior from the letter. The White House is, quote, "monitoring the abusive and capricious threats that are now proliferating from democratic legislators who seek to abuse the legislative process to intimidate and to interfere with the lawful functioning of government." So before we get into the response from the incoming House chair over the oversight committee currently ranking member Robert Garcia, I want to hear from you, Elliott, about just like your general takeaways from this letter. He's absolutely right. About one thing and one thing only, the idea of the legitimate legislative purpose. That's actually long-standing Supreme Court precedent, Catherine, this idea that whenever Congress proceeds with an oversight request, it has to have what's called a, quote, "legitimate legislative purpose." He's parroting legal language there and that's perfectly fine. And quite frankly, courts have a very broad notion of what constitutes legitimate legislative purpose. So you're going to be hearing that word or that phrase again and again and again over the next two years, right? It's just because that's just, you're going to be seeing a lot of congressional oversight. Where he's completely out to lunch is this idea of criminal enforcement against members of Congress for investigating an administration for a host of reasons, right? Number one, you have right out of the Constitution, it's something called the speech or debate clause. You've probably heard that term before. And it just affects virtually everything members of Congress do from criminal prosecution when they do it. So you're not going to prosecute a member of Congress for whether it's issuing a subpoena or whatever else. That's nonsense. You can vote them out of office. You can say you don't like them. You can make nasty campaign commercials about them, but you're not going to prosecute them for that. Number one, number two, I know from being a former federal prosecutor, Catherine, there's a lot of crimes in America. There's a lot of criminal offenses in America. There's a website literally called crime a day that tells you all the wacky things you can be prosecuted for in the United States. So I get it. There's a lot of things you can be prosecuted for. What would you be prosecuting members of Congress for here? Tell us what the crime is and no one in the administration could say, including Will Sharf can say credibly, you know, 18 U.S.C., whatever, whatever is the crime, because it just doesn't exist. There's no crime for issuing a subpoena against someone wrongly, at least in the way he's talking about here. Just to use the word, he used harassment. Well, yeah, I mean, sure, harassment exists, but you can only be criminally prosecuted for harassment if you're intentionally trying to bother, demean, attack, delay, distress, you know, whatever. So whatever, it's just not, it's an empty threat. I understand nobody likes congressional oversight. They didn't like it when I was there, whether it was Democrats or Republicans getting subpoenas or even oversight requests, but it's part of what makes our government our government. And it's actually a good thing. Okay, so a couple questions here. So the speech or debate speech and debate speech or debate or fun trivia question is actually the speech or debate clause. People get that wrong all the time. Okay, so the speech or debate clause. This was the thing that people were citing when they were demanding that like lawmakers read into the congressional record stuff about the Epstein files before materials became public and things like that, right? It was like they have some kind of immunity from, okay. Yeah, and it's and again, and it's treated very broadly. Like it was for instance, when I believe it was when Lamarika McIver in New Jersey was prosecuted at the or at least arrested at the ice center, one of the things she said was that this is featured debate protected conduct. I as a member of Congress, even though not speaking on the floor of the House of Representatives, I'm engaged in work as a member of Congress. You can't prosecute me for that. So you see that a lot. So has this been challenged before? The ability of lawmakers to engage in oversight or to do other things that they say falls under the speech or debate clause. Sure. Every oversight action with respect to administration, regard gets some pushback. Now, typically that's through what's called the accommodations process. That is where the administration just just pushes back and says, well, we either we think your request is overbroad. We think it's not good. We think it might even be abusive. And so we're either not going to respond to it or here are the ways in which we can respond to it. And in a healthy functioning government, I'll leave it up to you as to whether we have one right now, but in a healthy functioning government, they'd go back and forth over that very question. And it's not uncommon for likely, you know, you introduced me as a legislative affairs. Our office of justice would sit down with someone in the, whether it's the White House, pardon me, not the White House, you know, in Congress and say, okay, well, these are the documents that you've requested. Some of them are protected. Some of them are turning client privilege. We're not going to come in for a hearing, but maybe if we sat down for a meeting with the deputy attorney general or with, you know, such and such, US attorney and just talked it through, that might satisfy your request. And that's not uncommon at all. They don't like it, but they're accommodating each other. It's, they are one branch of government is respecting that it's got work to do. And another one is respecting that it's got stuff to do too. And there is a middle ground off in a normal functioning government. And is that generally how it's been working under this administration? Do you know? Well, they haven't gotten a ton of very pointed, this administration meaning since 2025 when the second Trump, they haven't gotten a lot of critical, much of a critical eye from Congress to begin with. Like, they've just had a friendly Congress. And that's normal. Again, it's the president's own party. The difference is there have been significant questions that the public certainly had and a wide swath of Republicans around the country certainly had about actions taken by the administration, but they just haven't faced that kind of criticism or, you know, critical oversight from Congress. So it will be a big change come January, whatever it is January 3rd of next year when Democrats come in. And I just think this administration isn't quite used to it. I will say one more thing, Catherine, which is that under the last Trump administration, they weren't exactly tripping over themselves to cooperate with Congress either. A great example is Wilbur Ross, who was Secretary of Commerce literally didn't show up to a hearing for the Appropriations Committee. Just didn't show up. Just saying, I'm sorry, I got stuff to do. I mean, I don't I don't want to speculate, but he had better things to do than his constitutional duty. Sorry. Yeah. Maybe he fell asleep. He was known for falling asleep. He was a tired man. And quite literally, did fall asleep quite a bit. Maybe he's napping. Who knows? And as a napper myself, I can respect that. I am tired often. I look, you know, however, were I asked by Congress to testify, I think napping is not a great excuse for it. You would set an alarm at least. Yes. Literally, I would set two alarms. I would actually set the alarm and a timer so that if I got one wrong, it would still chime a few minutes after. So look, you and I are right here on this, Catherine, I get it. This message is brought to you by Temple Meals. The past few weeks have been pretty damn busy. I feel like my whole calendar has been swallowed up by meetings in Mania not to mention all the elections and the election coverage. It's only going to get more intense though as we head to the end of the year and I just don't have time to do much meal prep. Thankfully, Tempo's kept me fed while everything else piles up. Every meal is perfectly portioned for lunch or dinner and it's ready in just two minutes. So instead of scrambling to figure out what to eat, selling for that sad desk lunch or grabbing something on the go, I have a real meal ready in no time. They have more than 20 recipes to choose from every week all made with nutrient rich ingredients. So there's plenty of variety and you never get bored. And whatever your health goals are, there's something for you. Tempo offers protein pack meals with more than 30 grams of protein, fiber rich, calorie conscious, gut support, and GLP1 smart options. For a limited time, Tempo is offering our listeners 60 percent off that 60. Your first box, go to Tempo Meals.com/Bullwerktakes. That's Tempo Meals.com/Bullwerktakes for 60 percent off your first order. Tempo Meals.com/Bullwerktakes Rules and Restrictions may apply. But point being, what we're asking to show up to a hearing and I know he didn't fall asleep because he said I'm not going to show up to this hearing and that happened quite a bit in the first Trump administration when Democrats were in control. They just did not comply with oversight requests, including up to not showing up for hearing. So
I mean, I think that's actually versions of this have happened already in this, in the second term, because like I know Russell Vogue, who's the OMB director, they were having like chase him down to get him to show up before the House Budget Committee. I think he eventually did, but Republicans were mad that he wasn't coming. So it's, and again, Republicans were in control. >> Yeah, absolutely. And I also think just the hostility that they've exhibited during hearings is noteworthy. It is, it's certainly a president who has an eye for the spectacle, enjoys the splashy. You know, you hear a lot about the audience of one, and when they come in and testify, they are speaking to Donald Trump as much as they're speaking to the committee that's interviewing them. But you've seen certainly from RFK Jr., from Pete Heggsepp, my goodness. Really, I would almost say, belligerent performances in these congressional hearings. And that is just an extension of what I think we could anticipate when the new Democratic Congress comes in. You know, if you remember, Pam Bondy showed up with talking points and almost like, what do you want to call it? Like, like, op-o research on the Democrats who are investigating her. So again, it's going to be quite a ride over these next couple of years. >> I want to zoom in on that word, harassment, that you mentioned. Maybe this is a dumb question, but doesn't Congress harass people all the time? I mean, maybe they don't use that word. But I feel like they have certainly used their subpoena power to make life very difficult for a lot of people. Like, I remember back in the day, there's this economist at MIT who designed the individual mandate. This is like a real throwback, you know, individual mandate in the original, yeah. In the original ACA, Obamacare, and they just like kept hauling him before Congress and making him answer questions and stuff like that. And he clearly saw that as harassment. I think he had huge legal bills that he had to deal with simply because they thought he was like a healthcare nerd who had said some stuff that they didn't like and designed this part of this major legislation and they made life really difficult for him. And he's not the only one who has been through this experience. He just happens to have been somebody who I interviewed about it a long time ago. But like it doesn't seem as if it's new territory for legislators to make life really unpleasant for the people that they are overseeing or investigating. And so I don't even understand like I'm not saying the Democrats are going to do this. But even if they were, what law breaking is an issue here? Well, yeah. No, that's a great question. Number one, no one, and whether it's criminal or congressional, no one likes being on the business end of investigations, right? It's just not a fun place to be, no matter, no matter how much you, like all this lofty government shit that I'm talking about here, like, yeah, no one really wants to receive a subpoena or even a request from Congress. So I get that. And it's always going to feel like harassment in some way. Still, courts have really been deferential to Congress. If Congress can demonstrate that there is any sort of back of that term, legitimate legislative purpose to what they're doing. And if they can say this is tied to work that is important to us as a branch of government, they're probably going to get away with it now. If a subpoena is seen to be a fishing expedition, if it's, you know, I want every single financial record Donald Trump has ever had, if it's, I want every conversation he's had with Donald Trump Jr. I mean, those are the kinds of things that are just going to be overbroad and not tied to a specific investigation that Congress is working on. But if it's at all close, courts are going to, you know, tie goes to the Congress and if you just look at the kinds of things that might come up, like, so just take Nvidia and any investigation into Jensen Wong and maybe ties to the administration or conversations that might have been had. That's squarely within Congress's purview. Even if it might be embarrassing, either for a major corporation or ultimately the Secretary of State or the President of the United States, the Secretary of Defense, but it's still within Congress's purview to oversee the Department of Commerce, to oversee the Department of Defense, to oversee national security. And so absolutely, they will be able to issue subpoenas on that and get away with it. And one more thing, Catherine, and one more thing I would add, you know, and we, it's also not just all about subpoenas. We use that term a lot that that this is about avoiding getting subpoena. And it's, it's not, most thing, most, most back and forths with Congress and the administration don't reach that subpoena point. It's often just a conversation and can you come in and provide this information to us? Can you come in and sit for a hearing? Can you talk to our investigators? And most of the time in a healthy functioning government, most of the time, they will work something out eventually. Let's talk a little bit about Garcia's response. Again, Robert Garcia is the incoming House Oversight Chair once Democrats retake control of the House. So his response was, quote, it appears Donald Trump has something to hide. Let's be clear. Congress's authority comes from Article One of the Constitution, which is what you were saying, Elliot, not from the permission of the White House. Congress has wide latitude to conduct investigations and oversight and authority inherent in the power to legislate, unquote. My question is, if the White House is trying to investigate Congress for investigating the White House, can Congress investigate the White House for investigating Congress for investigating the White House? So meta, I love it. That's deep. I mean, they can. I mean, this is where courts, I mean, we've got this three-ring government from schoolhouse rock. That's where courts come in and would, in all likelihood, bless what Congress is doing. Again, assuming it's not, it's not a fishing expedition or an overbroad request, right? Again, I understand there's a political energy and clamoring for accountability and investigate it, and I get it. But you just can't send a subpoena to the White House for every document in their possession because no court would bless that. Now, if it's a question of, this is a legitimate subpoena or document request, and they just don't want to respond to it, then yes, that is where the court comes in and can order the administration to comply with it. It'll take a while, but it can happen. I guess what I mean is, is the very fact that the White House Council, Will Scharfe, is threatening Congress itself a cause for investigation. >> Absolutely. >> I assume that lawmakers, democratic lawmakers, once they return to power are going to be investigating all of the other retaliatory actions that this administration has taken against James Comey, just as, for instance, Jerome Powell and others, would this in itself justify its own investigation? I think it's oversight of the Justice Department, actually, because the entity that would be investigating Congress would be the DOJ, because the ones who are seeking, who would gather information as to whether somebody is criminally liable for something. Absolutely, Congress, in its oversight capacity with respect to the Attorney General, could investigate investigators who are investigating the ones doing the investigating, right? Which would be bizarre. Now, the one thing Congress can do where they probably, the biggest hammer, and this is what makes them not even, I would say, a co-equal branch of government, but the first among equals. It is the most powerful branch of government, not the presidency, right? They can just suspend the funding for the Justice Department. If, in fact, they're finding that there's funny business with how the White House of the Justice Department wants to approach Congress's ability to carry out its constitutional duty to oversee the executive branch, right? So, yeah, it is one of the deepest wildest investigations ever, but you're going to see investigations in the investigators investigating the investigating, and here we are. 2026, man. Or 2027. No, it's a lot of tongue twisters. Yeah, although suspending their funding, presumably, they would have to pass that with a veto proof majority, which may or may not be possible, but maybe the Republicans are going to be annoyed enough. I, who knows? Yeah, hard to say how the next, how the next time we'll work out, the way, if the way for it to, there's an easy way in a hard way, and the easy way is just come in and negotiate with Congress. And if you don't like the request, figure out one that you can get behind. But Will Sharfner, who is a very smart lawyer, and I know you know him from back in the day, Will Sharf knows what the Supreme Court said in 2020 about Donald Trump's own records. And this, you will hear the word the Maysars case. That's the Supreme Court case from 2021. I believe about how the president's records are handled, and that was Trump's account, right? Maysars? Yeah. Exactly. And it laid out exactly how records ought to be handled, and this idea of the quote legitimate legislative purposes right out of the Supreme Court, echoing decades of cases on this. He knows that, so, and he also knows that the likelihood of successfully prosecuting a member of Congress for the host of reasons you and I were talking about earlier is just ain't going to happen. I'm sorry. Well, I imagine they could still do some things, they being the White House and the DOJ. They could still do some things to make life pretty unpleasant for lawmakers. There's a few. Yeah. Yeah. There's a few things. Number one, investigations are costly, part of the investigations, when, when, when I'm the judge about this.
coming after you criminally, it's costly and time consuming. And just by filing that lawsuit, or part of those charges or opening investigations or searching someone's office, is itself time-consuming costly, a pain in the ass for the people who are there. Like, I get it, right? So that can happen. And also litigation over these things will take time. Like, it imagine the Justice Department. So imagine Congress issues, a document request or something to the White House. And they don't want to comply with it. And they just decide not to. Congress can bring them to court and get their subpoena or whatever it is enforced. Well, that's a lawsuit in itself. And that's going to take time. Now, they only have two years to do this. And a lot of that could be eaten up by litigation. And the administration knows that full well. And I think they are, they almost heard Robert Garcia's statement to lawyer up as a, a bike, okay, great. That means we have to go to court. That means we can slow all this down. So I think they know that too and are welcoming the opportunity to bring all this stuff to court, even if they're going to lose, which they will. The last thing I wanted to ask you about, I don't if you saw this, but Robert Garcia was at CricutCon last weekend. And he talked about the responsibilities and agenda before him and the Democrats and he talked about accountability, but he also framed it as pettiness. Just because you're a Kimberley Goldfoil or your Cristinaum or your Pambondi and you're no longer in office, that doesn't mean that we're still not interested in accountability for all of your crimes and grift. We're not going to, we're not going to forget like, you know, like we can't forget about these folks that are causing harm like you know, I think it's like, I mean, maybe it's maybe it's because I'm like, I'm gay, but like, you know, like, like pettiness is a thing. Like I am, I am a mad, you know, like I think like, this is the moment in history where all the young people like are you in their families in their classrooms, like they have to know that what's happening right now is wrong. And to just move on does it disservice to the future of our country? >> He said something to the effect of, you know, pettiness is a thing. And of course, we're going to go after things that this administration did or their friends did, even if it's several years old. I was kind of with him on all of the accountability and investigation stuff until he framed it as pettiness, which I do think undermines the importance of what the incoming Democratic majority will be doing. They want to, my view is they need to be framing what they're doing as upholding rule of law and not contributing to further undermining a rule of law. But be that as it may, is that language, whether it was a joke or not, that Garcia used is that something that could be used against Garcia and the Democrats if this goes to court? >> You must be a journalist, or at least a smart thinker, because that's exactly the right question. It's not, it doesn't just undermine what they're doing, but it's actually legally actionable. It's think about, and the example I would use, let's look at Donald Trump, in his own criminal prosecutions of whether it's Jim Comey or Latisha James or whatever else. It's his own statements that undermine them by saying, I am going after these people because I mad at them. And, you know, getting back to the word of the day, if like if this were Sesame Street, the word of the day is legitimate legislative purpose. Getting back to this idea of a legitimate legislative purpose, if they want, if the Democrats want to claim that they had a purpose that was grounded in law for doing all of this. Oh, but our chairman was out there talking about, no, we're actually just being kind of petty, or at least as part of why we're doing this. It does give strength to the president's legal arguments, or any legal arguments challenging whatever actions they took. So, yes, I understand that politics is kind of petty quite often. And I understand that people are vindictive in the actions they take. But when you put that on the record, you are creating a roadmap for a court to get in the way of the very action you're trying to take. And so, you know, that is a caution. I would think that his staff probably spoke to him about afterward. Okay. Well, hopefully he will frame it in more August terms next time around. Thanks, Elliot. So much for your insights today. And thanks, everyone, for watching and listening. Please, if you liked this, I think you will love the rest of our content. Go to the bullwork.com where you can listen to bullwork takes. My podcast receipts, you can find those on the bullwork.com, YouTube, Apple podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. Like, subscribe, and we'll see you next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The White House has threatened to pursue criminal charges against Congress for conducting oversight, but this is legally baseless under the Constitution and Supreme Court precedent.
The speech or debate clause grants members of Congress immunity from prosecution for their legislative actions, including oversight investigations.
No existing U.S. criminal law criminalizes routine congressional investigations, subpoenas, or oversight requests, making the White House’s claims unfounded and speculative.
The idea of "harassment" used by the White House lacks legal standing unless it involves intentional, malicious, and harmful behavior beyond legitimate oversight.
Congress has broad constitutional authority to investigate the executive branch, and such actions are protected under Article I, not subject to executive retaliation.
Past administrations, including Trump’s, have routinely failed to comply with congressional requests, highlighting a pattern of accountability gaps.
Incoming House Oversight Chair Robert Garcia responded with a constitutional defense of Congress’s oversight powers, framing the issue as one of accountability, not petty politics.
Language describing investigations as "petty" could weaken legal arguments and provide a legal basis for the executive to challenge congressional actions in court.
Summary:
The White House, through a letter from Will Sharf, has threatened to pursue criminal charges against Congress for its oversight actions, but this claim is legally unfounded. The speech or debate clause protects members of Congress from prosecution for performing their constitutional duties, including investigations into the executive branch. No criminal statute supports prosecuting lawmakers for issuing subpoenas or conducting oversight, and courts consistently uphold the legitimacy of such actions when tied to a valid legislative purpose.
Former Deputy Assistant Attorney General Elliott Williams emphasizes that the administration’s rhetoric is an empty threat, especially given past failures by Republican officials to comply with congressional requests. He notes that while investigations can be costly and disruptive, they remain within Congress’s constitutional authority. The incoming House Oversight Chair, Robert Garcia, defends Congress’s role as a co-equal branch with inherent oversight powers, asserting that accountability is a constitutional duty, not political pettiness.
However, Garcia’s framing of investigations as "petty" could legally undermine the legitimacy of the actions by providing grounds for the executive to challenge them in court. Ultimately, the threat reflects an effort by the administration to intimidate Congress, but legal precedent and constitutional principles firmly protect congressional oversight as a vital check on executive power. This dynamic suggests a potential for increased legal and political conflict over the next two years, especially as the new Democratic majority takes office.
FAQs
The 'legitimate legislative purpose' is a long-standing Supreme Court precedent requiring that congressional investigations must be tied to a valid legislative goal. It ensures oversight is not arbitrary or abusive and is grounded in the branch's constitutional duty to check executive power.
No, the White House cannot criminally prosecute members of Congress for performing their legislative duties. The Constitution’s speech or debate clause protects such activities from criminal prosecution, and no law exists that would justify such actions.
The speech or debate clause protects members of Congress from being prosecuted for their legislative actions, including issuing subpoenas or making inquiries. It ensures that lawmakers can conduct oversight without fear of criminal liability.
No, it is not a legitimate legal argument. Legal experts, including former federal prosecutors, say there is no crime for issuing a subpoena or conducting oversight, and such threats are considered empty and politically motivated.
Congress can bring the matter to court, where a judge can order the administration to comply. This process, while time-consuming, is a constitutional check and can result in enforcement of legitimate oversight requests.
While investigations may feel like harassment, criminal harassment charges require intentional actions like distress or intimidation. No such charges are valid under current law for routine oversight activities.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.