Go back

Fiscal Policy Special

1h 20m 57s

Fiscal Policy Special

Fiscal policy, the use of government spending and taxation to influence the economy, is central to economic management in the UK. Traditionally announced in the spring budget, recent political changes have led to fiscal events without independent oversight from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), raising concerns about transparency and accountability. In the UK, income tax and National Insurance are the primary revenue sources, with a notable shift toward more regressive taxation over the past two decades, contributing to growing inequality. Public spending is heavily concentrated in social protection—particularly pensions—followed by health and education, with schools currently facing severe financial pressure from rising staff pay demands. A budget deficit arises when government spending exceeds tax revenue, and such deficits accumulate over time to form the national debt, which now stands at around 106% of GDP, rising sharply since 2008 due to the financial crisis and pandemic-related measures. While deficits are often seen as a sign of fiscal mismanagement, economists argue that automatic stabilizers—like benefits and progressive taxation—help stabilize the economy during downturns. Discretionary fiscal policy, such as tax cuts or spending increases, can be used to stimulate demand during recessions, though its effectiveness is debated. Theories like Ricardian equivalence suggest households save in anticipation of future tax burdens, potentially weakening the impact of fiscal expansion, whereas Keynesian multiplier theory supports significant short-term effects, especially during downturns when the multiplier can reach 2–3. Nonetheless, concerns about crowding out—where government borrowing reduces private investment—remain, and the policy response to crises has varied, with the UK adopting austerity after 2008 in contrast to more expansionary approaches in other economies. Overall, fiscal policy remains a complex, politically charged, and economically significant tool in managing national economic cycles.

Transcription

13929 Words, 75328 Characters

English
Hello and welcome to Economics in 10 with Pete and Gav. Today we're looking at fiscal policy, another economics in 10 special to kind of coincide or to go think with a monthly policy special that we've only recently done. So hopefully these two can work together in tandem to give you a better knowledge about our economic situation today. So we're discussing things in the October of 2022 in UK which is an interesting time to say the least for fiscal policy but hopefully the things we'll talk about tonight will be timeless. Yes, as all our podcasts are. Okay, so first question Pete, what is fiscal policy? Fiscal policy very simply is the use of taxation and government spending to achieve government aims. In the UK at least the plans for fiscal policy are normally laid out in an annual statement called the budget and there's a bit of razzmatazz about that. The chancellor appears outside number 11 Downing Street with a red box. There's other sort of little traditions associated with the budget like apparently they can choose what they want to drink and what do you drink to live in your sort of budget. Oh, I go whiskey. Would you? Yeah, I think a traditionalist one is not traditional. Is it? You find out later on. Oh, okay. Well, there we are. So the timing of the budget in the financial year has been moved around a bit. It used to be in the spring and then in the autumn they'd allow sort of what's called the autumn statement. But it's been I can't remember where we're at in a moment. There's been so many budgets recently. In part because when you get a new government in the UK or a new administration, you often get an emergency budget and we've had loads of bloody new governments recently. So we've had various budgets or fiscal events. Yes. So Gavin, what is the difference between a budget and a fiscal event? Is it to do with the fact that one doesn't get overviewed by the OBR? Yes, I think so. So in the UK recently, I was going to say recently demise then. He's not dead, but are recently sacked Chancellor of the Extractor Quasi Quartengue. He held a fiscal event and the reason for that, rather than when our, oh god, she is the last prime minister isn't here, it just came to power. Rather than hold a budget, which would mean that there had to be some sort of external oversight by the office of a budget responsibility, it was called a fiscal event. Yeah. In large part, independent commentators would say to avoid that kind of oversight. Or very odd. Now normally though, it was done in March, wasn't it because it was just before the change of the tax year, wasn't it? Yeah. So that was kind of a traditional one. I think Philip Harmon changed it, didn't he? Yeah, he bought it in and then bought this. But then what was interesting is, do you remember when Gordon Brown used to have the green budget and it was around this time? It was like, no, there was the green budget and there was this brilliant ease to send out these great documents because it was like basically a consultation paper, green paper, and then he'd do the budget after supposedly this kind of consultation. That's really what's going to happen. And I know I used to, like with my classes, get us to, we used to write because they wanted feedback. So we used to write to Gordon Brown and say, you know, and then he'd then obviously deliver it. Now the best thing about the budget piece is what, if you're a school teacher, playing budget pingo. Yeah, yeah. So you know, many, many, many times the pie got students in a classroom, we were watching it, we all got to have bingo sheets and it was always brilliant with Osborne because it'd have all these kind of like sayings, you know, let's fix the roof while the sun shines and, you know, this kind of para countries. You know, you used to have these fantastic slogans. But last, kind of gone these days. Well, there's been so much change, doesn't it? Yeah, it's some stability. But anyway, by the way, I should mention, because I'm not sure we're going to mention it again, but the office for budget responsibility was brought in in 2010 by the coalition government. And in some respects, it does mirror the sort of new labour announcement in 1997, I think, about the independence of the Bank of England, because it's a way of sort of stating, we are serious about the economy. And we're not just going to publish our own sort of forecast of what impact we think the budget will have. We've got an independent body who will do that for us. So you can see why when, oh, well, perhaps you can see why when Quartan sort of said, oh, no, we're going to call it a fiscal event. And there won't be OBR oversight. A lot of people start getting a bit jittery, thinking, well, why not? Why wouldn't you have this independent oversight, unless you felt that that independent oversight would reveal that your numbers didn't add up? But I read the other day as well that the OBR can only go with what is kind of the assumptions put forward by the government. So the government actually come up with unrealistic assumptions. And yet the OBR still just have to run with it. That's basically their mandate. So it's kind of quite interesting, isn't it? What I was going to say, though, before I assume we're going to move on, but you said government spending a taxation there. Yeah. So a nice way of remembering it is G&T, isn't it? Yeah, G&T. A classic kind of approach, fiscal policy, G&T. That actually my wife, who is also an economist teacher, small world, she, her students at the end of the summer term, because occasionally, if any of our students are listening to this, do bury in this mind, this is a long-standing tradition, students don't buy their teachers, I'll call it beverages. Yeah. And her students quite witterly bought some gin and some tonic and labeled them government-spanning taxation. Perfect. So when it comes to fiscal policy, what are the big revenue raises? So it has to be said, this differs from country to country, but I'm going to talk about the UK and perhaps we can also mention a couple of other countries as well. But in the UK, the biggest contributors to public finances are unsurprisingly, or maybe isn't unsurprisingly, income tax. So in 2021-22, that was anticipated to raise about 198 billion, right, according to Treasury's own figures, national insurance, which a good chunk of which is really income tax account. That's 147 billion. And then the third biggest is VAT value added tax, which is a sales tax, if you like, on the majority of purchases one might make. So there are other sort of contributors, Xi's duty, so that petrol duty, alcohol duty, cigarette duty, corporation tax, so tax on firm profits is relatively small. Only 40 billion, I'm not saying that's insignificant, but relatively small. So that's the UK. It's any of that surprised you? Not really. Can I just say that we should point out, probably, I hope you don't mind explaining this, Pete, the difference between, when we think about taxation, the difference between progressive and regressive. Yeah, I thought we were going to come on to that later. I don't think so. Okay. I haven't got that down as later, but I mean, because the thing is, I think it's kind of important to kind of maybe appreciate that probably over the last 20 odd years, we've definitely moved from a more progressive to more regressive. So I don't mind mentioning that. So progressive tax is a bit like, always explain a bit like Robin Hood, taking from the rich to give to the pool. And regressive, if you like, is the opposite of that. So something like income tax, which has sort of higher taxes for higher income brackets. So in the UK, in a set, in effect, for income tax, there's three main sort of tax thresholds. So you get a certain amount of income tax free, about £30,000. Then between, I think it's approximately £13,000 and maybe about £45,000, something like that. It's £20,000. And above that is £40,000 and then there's a high income threshold of £150,000. And any income above that, you pay £45,000. It's all on the margin, isn't it? It's all on the margin. It's worth saying that because it's like, you do get the odd sort of person sort of talking head. Remember someone getting really irate on question time, this is a political show in the UK. I pay this much on my earnings and it's not true. I mean, if you do pay, if you are earning enough, if you're fortunate enough to earn enough to pay the sort of high, high tax rate, £45,000. It's only on the earnings of £50,000. I remember Alan Sugar saying he wants about basically having half his income taxed. But I would assume actually at the real top end, it probably is quite true, isn't that I suppose? Yeah, it may well be. Anyway, we've got a regressive tax, is a tax which falls disproportionally on the poor. An example of that would be cigarette duties, poor more likely to smoke and it will form quite a large part of their income. But VAT is regressive as well. So as you rightly pointed out, there's probably been shifted in the UK away from sort of more progressive measures towards more regressive measures. And that's reflected in the fact that linking back to our last episode, you know, the genie coefficient for the UK, the sort of measure of inequality, the UK has become more unequal in our sort of 20 to 30 years. I did look at just one of the other economies to look at sort of sources of income. That does vary from country to country. I was looking at the Chinese economy, which is probably slightly more opaque, but there was some sort of Bloomberg data about this based on the Ministry of Finance data. And actually for the funding sources for Chinese sort of budgetary spending, only 47% of it is from taxation. And so all the sources include sort of government funds, special sort of non-tax fees, you know, it seems more complex. And I suppose for some countries as well, they will have a sovereign well fund. That's a well-liked normal way. That's a sort of significant contribution from that sort of sovereign well fund. And I was actually looking as well, really good infographic in which it shows the sort of proportions of taxation raised in various countries from different sources. So if you look at America, for example, individual taxes, accounts for about 42% of American sort of budgetary spending, consumption taxes or sales taxes you like is about 18%. And the UK that does differ, you know, income tax or individual taxes, only like 32, 32, 33%. Does that surprise you? Yeah, it probably does. But yeah, it varies more than I thought actually, you know, Japan is probably social insurance, which I presume is their equivalent of national insurance, is about 40% of income. And individual taxes is is relatively small. Yeah, do you know what? I think it's I made an overview later on, come to it. There's some really good infographics, which I'll come to later on. So we've explained progressive and regressive, we should say that the proportionals as well, that's another way of there was a few years ago people talking about flat taxes. And that's the idea that everyone gets the same tax on all their income. There was a case for that in that if you if you've got a country where lots of individuals operating in the informal economy, what used to be called black markets, you could argue that to have a simple tax code might draw more people back into the formal economy. And if you went for a it might be better to have a low flat rate of tax, if that means more people are prepared to operate legally, you'll get more tax that way than if you have basically squeezed a few people who do pay taxes. You know what I think you're talking about there? What about talking about trust andomics? No, honestly, I think that's the like the long term for me. I mean, you think about quasi and trust, we kind of bought up in the incubator of the IAA and that those kind of think tanks. And they, a few years back, they did a massive push on flat taxes. They're having a basically a 20% flat tax. I think they were basically arguing as well, you raised the threshold up a little bit more, but then you have a flat tax. There's 20% and that was it. And you could see it with the collapsing of the 45% rate to 40%. I mean, it's not a big leap to say, right, let's collapse it all again, or you know, or have 25% for everyone at every level. So it's a kind of an interesting one to think about really there. But yeah, the proportional tax action, thank you very much. So we know the bigger revenue raises. Okay, what do most countries spend their money on? Well, in the UK, far and away, the largest area of public sector spending is social protection. It's interesting within that, so social protection will include sort of all benefits, including sort of pensions. And I remember I always do this as an exercise at the start of the year, whereby I sort of kid's like, oh, look at this massive sum of money. The government spends on social protection. What proportion of it do you think is unemployment benefit? And they're always like eight percent, six percent. And actually, it's about 2%. It's tiny, you know, compared with the sort of huge sums of money, which has an age in population, we spend on pensions. No, that's always one of the fascinating things, isn't it? Because it's like, well, we're going to cut benefits, and then you go, right, okay, well, how are you going to do that to save lots of money? You can't do quite targeting unemployment. No, you can't. The only way you should really save money is to actually have repensions, and then never going to do it if there you'll call vote. Yeah, and actually, the conservative, conservative party in the UK has committed off for quite a relatively long period now to something called the triple lock, which means that pensions will always rise in line with, I think it's average earnings inflation or real pay, so whichever is highest. So basically, without being too cynical, I think the reason for that is simply that the elderly tend to vote, and probably disproportionately the vote, their vote can serve it. But if you look at the others, the second largest area of public spending in the UK health at 230 billion, probably a lot of that is looking after the elderly as well. So in a sense, if we are in sort of a budgetary squeeze and happen for some time now, it's partly due to a sort of lack of willingness to address the sort of demographic change in the UK. The fact that when pensions were brought in, or you know, sort of a universal sort of pension was brought in, people just didn't live that long. And it's an enormous success story that people now live to a much greater age in the UK. But that hasn't really, I mean, there's been some sort of changes to reflect that like an increase in the retirement age. But it's only recently people have been sort of having to sort of made to contribute to their own pensions, or, you know, so it's a big problem. We're doing the third biggest one is education. Yeah, yeah, paying our wages. Yeah, money whilst paying, obviously. And what's quite interesting about that, I mean, that was in the news today. There were some headteach basically saying that 90% of schools would be bust. Well, there's a couple of reasons for that. One is the energy prices, which schools are having a face, which are huge. But secondly, the government is very likely to agree to hire pay increases for teachers. Dan's schools will have budgeted for, but they're going to be told to make those pay increases out of current funders, which is incredible, because probably about 80% of a secondary school certainly's budget is salaries. Yeah. So if you add on sort of five, ten, you know, anything above five percent, and that's a huge sum of money, but there's no additional funding coming from central government. So something will have to give there. So it'll be interesting to see how that plays out as the year goes on. Another one I always find fascinating when I do this, I do this kind of wagon wheel in the car, I'll show how the people do as well, you know, like guest at top five. And no one obviously ever gets that debt interest. Yeah. Basically the fourth highest one isn't it, obviously. Was it fifth highest? It is high. I mean, it's 45 billion. So I think that would be yeah. I think it is. I'm sure. And next is like defense, I think. Defense is about 60 billion. Oh, is it? Okay. So it's a fifth fifth highest. But it's a bit less than transport. Yeah. Oh, is it? No, normally. Oh, okay. Well, I'm only looking at the 20, 21, 22 figures. Okay. So that's 51 billion for trying to know. Normally it's definitely five billion. Top five. It's a debt interest. And it's, but what it does, it kind of highlights sort of like the opportunity cost of borrowing money, because you're then thinking, look, this is how much we have to pay back. And of course, that's been worse than by the recent debacle. Yeah. Because I think the sort of fiscal event has led to a seemingly semi-permanent increase at the rate at which the government can borrow money. Yeah. So even a couple of years ago, the government in the UK was able to borrow money at a really low rate of interest at about 2%. And I'm probably jumping out there slightly. But that's that's that's risen quite significantly. That's about four and a half percent. Something like that. I mean, does change on a fairly daily basis. But that was one of the big criticisms. And I think of like altcoins austerity that at a time when he was kind of really hauling back, that was like the best time to kind of borrow to invest. Although you could argue the reason why the interest rate remained low was because the financial markets in effect, like, the prudence. Yeah. Yeah. So I mean, there's two ways of looking at that. It's a fair point. It's a fair point to make. I mean, just again, to look at other countries in America, social security is still, it's not this similar actually. Social security is 19% of discretionary and mandatory sort of spending in the United States. I've got Medicaid is really high. Yeah. It's the second highest 15% well health. Yeah. Oh, no, I've got the different thing where I've got. Oh, no, sorry. Yeah. You've got health men and Medicaid is the percent. And then health is And then but the big one big difference for America is always their national defense spending, which is always utterly yeah There's some sort of fairly it depends. I've seen on some sort of sources that When you're looking at the proportions of spending sometimes they make this the distinction between discussionary and Mandatory. Oh, okay, and so if you looked just that discretionary spending like almost Defense spending is about like 57% but it's slightly misleading because actually when you look at the federal budget overall Including sort of Mandatory and discretionary defenses. It's still it's a huge sum of money But it's it's not quite as big of a portion of the overall federal budget I suppose the American sort of tax system is is complicated because so much of it is devolved to the states Yeah, the individual states will have a lot more power to both raise taxes and you know very how they spend money Yeah, which is there isn't really a power level in UK. Yeah, we've got a very centralized government Yeah, because I looked up the French one. I was trying to work out what they do and it seemed a lot of it was regional kind of Yeah, I mean, I think we're unusually sort of centralized. I mean again in Germany I think there's a lot of power devolved to the different regions on Lender as they're called Interested. Yeah, right. Are we are we done there? Yeah, let's move on excellent Okay, what do we mean by budget deficit budget surplus and a balanced budget? Okay, so budget deficit is about The plans or the spending by government in one year So if government spending is greater than taxation In sort of one financial year Then that would be a budget deficit If on the other hand taxation was greater than government spending in that financial year Then you would say the government was running a surplus. All right. It does extremely rarely A balanced budget would be where government spending gets equal to taxation And for some, you know, some would sort of make the analogy and I think we did mention this before we went on air um Between the household budget and then and the the government budget and you're like, oh, you should always stop balance your books I think we're I think in California um, I think when Schwarzenegger was governor there was sort of this Um, I did that a balanced budget amendment was was going to be signed into law maybe I'm making it all um, but I think some of those sort of comparisons between household budgets and and governments are false You know, I don't think you can quite extend that um and also probably households if you like running to um Deficit you might borrow a bit more money at some points than all the points you would pay that back So the idea that a government budget should always balance. I'm not even sure that is true of household budgets You know, you might borrow money to buy a car and pay it back over time. Yeah. So in a sense. Why shouldn't governments do that? But I don't I don't want to sort of get into that too much, but yeah, um I think as well um We sometimes call uh when government spending is great in taxation We call that an expansionary budget. Yes, and the idea there is that will ultimately increase demand in the economy what we call an economic aggregate demand right because government spending is quite significant proportion of overall demand in the economy probably about sort of 20 between 20 and 25% in the UK um And then a contractionary budget Would be where taxation was greater than government spending. So that in effect would be removing sort of funds from the We call in economics a circular flow of income And that would have the effect of contracting aggregate demand and you might do that for example If you're in a period of high inflation, you might want to increase taxes to stop that demand pull inflation Sort of rising too rapidly, right um And another bit of lingo with respect to that uh, did you want me to talk about discretionary Versus automatic stabilizers. Yeah, go on in yeah, because I think that's a good thing to know is an ultimate stabilizer Yeah, so Let's imagine you've got the Economic cycle and generally economies are cyclical. It's not they're not sort of cyclical in some smooth way like every 10 years We boom yeah every 10 years we're going to recession, but they do tend to rise and fall um, and so Governments in the past certainly have and even today have I've used either fiscal or probably more commonly these days monetary policy to try and sort of Ameliorate the sort of the the more extreme aspects of that cycle. Yeah, so the economy is booming too rapidly and this concerns about inflation Then you would aim for some form of contractionary policy And the economy is going into recession or is already sort of going sort of on a downward turn You would then sort of aim to be expansionary in either your sort of monetary or fiscal policy Now a discretionary fiscal policy would be where the government actually changes Either government spending or taxation Uh, like the rate. So for example If you're in a recession, let's say the basic rate of taxation was 20% And you thought while we're in a recession, we need to boost consumption If you cut the marginal rate to sort of 19 or 18% that would be a discretionary fiscal policy expansionary And expansionary discretionary fiscal policy. Okay, and similarly if you went into a boom you could think well Let's move that 20p up to 22p. Yeah, you know try to sort of Uh pull out some of the spending which may be causing inflation in the economy Automatic stabilizers is just an effect of having in place two things Firstly, um, a benefit system. So let's say you do go into a recession If automatically people have an entitlement of benefits It will mean that the worst of a recession may be less than somewhat in that people's incomes don't drop to zero They drop down to whatever the benefit level is and that means some consumption still takes place And it means the uh, you know, the economy doesn't bottom out as much as it might if you didn't have that benefit system in place And similarly most countries have a progressive taxation system And so let's say you've got these different thresholds at which you pay higher rates of tax So let's say you're a relatively low income earner you're earning sort of 12 grand a year But that moves up to 15,000 well, you would then go into You'd go above the personal allowance and into the area where you uh, pay some tax So that in effect would siphon off a little bit of income or people might move into the 40p sort of rate By sort of earning earning extra salaries, but then their tax the little bit more So some of those that extra income which might arise during a boom is siphoned off as people head upwards Into higher tax thresholds. Yeah, and that's a stabilizing effect on the economy and perhaps Lessons the more severe impacts of uh that could occur in an inflationary sort of boom and that and those things Going back to say a debt a deficit situation Where you're in a bust and then yeah, obviously the automatic stabilizers kick in yeah. Yeah, it's a something like we're paying out more benefits Normally as a government or economists probably wouldn't really worry about that deficit They kind of call it a cyclical deficit. Yeah, they would yeah, and they say right. There's no you know as long as we know that that's part of the business Cygur is fine. Yeah, what a lot of economists get worried about when they talk about budget deficit is what is known as a structural Yeah, and basically you're absolutely right. I've sort of drawing a recession. It would be expected that You know the government's finances would worse for one you'd be paying out more in sort of unemployment benefit And for two in a recession people's incomes tend to fall and therefore income tax receipts will fall people will probably spend less money So any you know VAT receipts Excise duties all these things would fall so your tax revenues would fall and your spending would rise could be paying more in benefits So that is likely to happen What many economists would like to see is that join the boom phase yeah almost that that um The funds which you might have lost or you know the deficit you might have run up Join that recessionary period are offset by sort of extra income accruing to the government join a boom phase But it very rarely happens. No, that was the only thing about Osborne's fixed in the roof when the sun shone, wasn't it? Yeah, so you basically patch up your your your finances when it's boom time And in many respect brown had that dint he had this kind of golden sonnacle or something that he had two golden rules and one was that The government should really only borrow To invest. Yeah and secondly that Well, absolutely that you shouldn't run structural deficits. Yeah, because it's over the cycle over the cycle Yeah, things should even out and Yeah, that didn't happen. Yeah, but to be fair to Gordon Because he had those two surplus years at the beginning didn't he he was kind of quite close and then the and then obviously the financial crash Arundin Because these are his argument was is that literally when that happened He was going to then start kind of putting it back So they would have even there across the time, but possibly obviously it didn't really happen Okay, well, that's quite a lot there. Yeah I hope everyone's getting these kind of terms. I know sometimes it could be quite difficult. And that's why John Langchester's book's really good called Whoops. Yeah, because he talks about the kind of hidden language of economics. And I think some of this stuff tonight is exactly what we're talking about. Contrary to their expansionery and automatic stabilizers. - There's a lot on there. - And as I said, to be honest, most of it is not that difficult. - No, you know, but yeah, I suppose the fact that. - What I mean is the actual concepts once they're explained in simple terms. And not that challenging. It's just that there is a lot of jargon. - Yeah, yeah, that's true. Okay, how does the budget deficit slash surplus link to the national debt? - Oh, it's kind of a classic question. - Gets a level students a lot done. - Yes. And you've probably noted that when I talked about budget earlier, I said in one year, in one year. So basically the government in one year could run a budget deficit. So that's how it's government spending was planned to be greater than taxation. Well, obviously there's a shortfall there. So the government will have to borrow the money. And the way the government borrows money is typically by the issuance of government bonds, which in the UK. - It ain't guilt. - It ain't guilt. - I've read about it the other day. I can't remember. - They've got a little gold edge to that. - That's right. - That's a certificate, you get. And every time the government borrows money, that adds to the existing debts of the government called the national debt. Now some of that debt may be from like 50, 60 years ago in some cases, but it's not yet fully been paid off. So every time in one year we run a deficit, then that adds to the overall national debt. So just to summarize, deficit, a budget deficit is a difference between taxation spending in one year. And the national debt is an accumulation of all those deficits, plus any unpaid interest, and minus any efforts to pay off the debt, which the government could do on occasion by running a budget surplus. Now, do you want me to give you a brief part of your history of the national debt? - Yeah, you don't think that's right. - Can I just say, you can go on before you do that on this site called the national debt clock, and it's quite frightening what you see, just to see this numbers ticking long. And UK national debt grows at a rate of 5,170 pounds per second. Okay, debt per citizen is 44,106 debt per tax per 75,832. - Yeah, and all of that-- - That's all quite scary, doesn't it? - Yeah, it does all sound quite scary, but again, I think it's partly from that mistaken desire, and I think it's all of it dates back to that too, and then that too would sort of talk about the government as if it was like a household. And I get it to a degree, you don't want to go crazy, and there is a role for sort of prudence, but the government is qualitatively different than a household in terms of how it borrows, and I'm sure there's some people who disagree with me there. But anyway, just to go back to the history of the national debt, when in history was the national debt at its all-time peak, and when I say it's all-time peak, we tend to compare the national debt to the size of GDP. So when we say, and again, I think some people misunderstand this, but they might say, oh, the national debt is 80% of GDP. It's not that 80% of the value of GDP has been used in that year to pay off. It's just comparing, it's like we've got one number here, GDP, which we might vaguely understand, and then national debt is another number, and people like to sort of compare the two of you like, so there's some kind of benchmark. So at the moment, I think the national debt in the UK is about 106% of GDP, something like that, but it has been much higher. To be fair though, nearly invariably that's joined sort of war time period. - War time period, yeah. - So the Napoleonic war and the sort of period just after led to the national debt rise into about over 250% of GDP. And then subsequent peaks were around World War I, where it rose to about 170% of GDP, and then World War II again closing on sort of 250% of GDP. So then after World War II, it tends to sort of decline fairly steadily until we get down into sort of the 30% of GDP. And it's only with the financial crisis in 2008, and the huge sums of money sort of spent on bank bailouts that we then tend to rise very rapidly to what, and really, we've stayed up about that figure now. Somewhere between sort of 90, I'm 110% of GDP, and we've also had the sort of coronavirus pandemic, which was a huge, you know, the furlough scheme was very, very expensive. And so the national debt as a proportion of GDP has risen fairly very rapidly, in fact, in the last 15 years. But still well below, one could argue, some of the previous peaks, albeit those aren't sort of joining wars, which if you think about the impact of a war, one, you've got to spend loads of money on the war effort, but lots of things, you know, normal activity will be suspended, you know, tracing, be suspended, you know, and so on. - On a side note, though, Pete, can I just say, and this is just a bit of historical thing. You know, those numbers have in the past sort of mattered. So for example, if the UK wanted to join the Eurozone, they put in some rules, didn't they? It was like, oh, every country had to be 60% GDP. - I thought so, it was 4% - GDP, right, I think. - But whatever it was. - There were 3% for the actual. That was a card. - Yeah, it was at the fiscal stability frame. - Yeah, so there was this kind of thing. And so if you had over 60% GDP ratio or whatever, maybe 40% or something, you know. And then 3% yearly, you wouldn't have been able to join. So it's kind of, they're trying to get this convergence criteria, wasn't it? - Yeah. - To try and get everyone in sync. - And then what was funny about it is that they basically all cheated, anyway, didn't they? They're something that's what I've actually came up with. - I think firstly, I think the Germans, particularly, were quite sniffy about the fact that some of the sort of Mediterranean countries, like Portugal and Spain, were breaking this, but then I think they broke it. - Yeah, it's everything. - It's everything. France broke it, and then we'd better keep quiet. - Yeah, yeah. - But the reason for that ultimately, though, was that so, and this will become more relevant later on, fiscal policy didn't undermine monetary policy. Because in a sense, if you're committing to a common sort of monetary framework, which, you know, the eurozone countries now do entirely, but even the pre-curse of the ERM, you can't really, 'cause in a sense, once you go into the eurozone, you're committing to a common currency, but also a common interest rate, you have to become an interest rate, and you can't really have a situation, 'cause you're setting, if you're setting an interest rate, the whole of the euro zone, that's a huge sort of range of sort of territory, but also countries, perhaps, at different stages in their economic cycle. - You need fiscal discipline. - Yeah, but if you don't have fiscal discipline, you know, the idea is, you then might unleash inflation in one country, the sort of central euro zone interest rate may need to rise, even though that might be to the detriment of other countries who have been more disciplined in their fiscal policy. So you can sort of see the logic of it. - Yeah. - And who in the world has the highest debt to GDP ratio? - Well, I'm gonna guess Japan. - It is Japan. Do you know what it is? - No. - Well, according to these figures, 257%. - Wow. - And I think, do you know why that's so high? - 'Cause I assume they've just tried to spend, and spend, and spend to try and get out of their depression. - Yeah, I think while they're that sort of lost decade, where they sort of were in a sort of deflationary spiral. - Yeah. - And I think there was huge sums of common spending aimed at sort of getting the, it's amazing, isn't it? - It's amazing, isn't it? - Yeah, so what's the lowest? I mean, the lowest? - Well, there's some on the periphery. I mean, there's, it's interesting though, 'cause there's a different range of countries on those sort of peripheries. Quite so again, it's a really good infographic that we must share. But they're almost there for different reasons. Some of those are sort of European countries like Luxembourg and Sweden, who you can imagine, you know, manage their sort of finances very well in the quite wealthy countries. But then you also get countries like Chad. And they're indebtedness is probably 'cause they're just not able to borrow on international markets. So there's people, there's sort of, people are on this periphery probably for different reasons. - Yeah. - I suppose, you know, again, I mean, there's obviously concerns about the UK's debt, but Italy has a much higher sort of debt to GDP ratio. Spain's is higher. Canada's is higher, which surprised me. France is is higher, you know. So it's, in a sense, it sort of reiterates, though, or reinforces what we were saying earlier about how, you know, Cretanus, the sort of recent fiscal event was because in a sense, the government has been able to portray itself as being sort of disciplined with its finances. And I think that reputation to a certain extent has now gone, 'cause even with the reversal of a lot of the policies which are outlined. in that fiscal measure, the interest rate which people are prepared to land to the UK government has not yet, to mean I suppose you could argue it's early days, but it's not yet gone down to sort of previous levels, it's just a matter of time. - Well, I think that reputation for sort of fiscal prudence is quite hard one though. - Yeah. - Yeah, so there we are, do you know what the US is? - No, 133% GDP. - Oh, there you go. - But again, you could argue in some respects, so what? - I think that's what Keynes would argue, as long as you can pay it back. - Exactly. - Or who cares, you know? - You can pay your debts. - As long as you can keep up your bets. And it's a bit like, you know, if you borrow money, and everyone, if you can extend the household analogy here, loads of households borrow money, they borrow huge sums of money relic to their income in the UK, particularly, to buy a house. And everyone thinks what it's fine, so you can keep up with the debt repayments. - Exactly. - Clickers, you know? - Exactly. - So you could almost make, you know, as long as people are prepared to buy your debt, as it were, you know, then, you know, does it matter? - Exactly. I think that's a fair point. Right. Is that at the end for that one? - Yeah. - Okay. Now it's halfway through, Pete. - Yeah. - I think it's time for a quiz. - Oh. - Looking forward to it. - Are you ready? - I'm ready. - Okay, this is the red box quiz. - Okay. - So as you've quite rightly pointed out every year, the Chance of the Exchequer will hold up a red box to signify the new budget for the UK economy. - Yeah. - So here we go. Quiz all about this. (upbeat music) Question one. The red box of William Gladstone was made for his first budget in 1853, was used by many subsequent Chancements. Who's the last Chancellor to use it? Was it Gordon Brown? George Osborne, Alistair Darling, or Philip Hammond? - Oh, you know, I was hoping you would say something much earlier, and I am going to say Gordon Brown. - Oh. - Oh. - That goes George Osborne. - I think in 2010 or 2011. - That box was nice. - That's a good idea. - And he retired it. Gordon Brown had his own one made. I think Philip Hammond did as well, actually. - I sound a bit of a cheek-wash. - Something like that. But George, no, look, 'cause then he came back. He was just there. But you got that wrong. - No. - He did, he did. Who famously opened up his red box in 1868? The discover it left his speech at home. Was it William Gladstone, George Redhunt, or Benjamin Disraeli? - I don't think this radio is Chancellor. I am going to say, Gladstone. - Oh. - Well, you're just George Redhunt. 'Cause yeah, this is obvious, isn't it? - George Redhunt. - Yeah, that was his name. - Oh, really? - No, exactly. That's why I assume, 'cause I would never have known him either. So it was him. - Okay. - I don't know how far. - But you know what though? It's interesting you said that about Disraeli, 'cause I looked at him. - He was Chancellor. - He was. - I don't think he was Disraeli. Disraeli was. - Yeah, that's the thing. 'Cause when I looked up, I was saying, Lucy's George Redhunt dude, so I then list up. I looked up the list of Chancellors. And there was George Redhunt nestled him between Glaston and Disraeli. Do you know what, I don't know that. I thought Disraeli, why aren't you getting into it? - Why aren't you getting into it? - The custom of using a red box, supposedly came from Queen Elizabeth I, representative. Francis Throck Morton, presenting the Spanish ambassador Bernardino de Mondoza, a red box in the late 16th century. But what was inside the box? - What was it? - Black pudding, carrots, steak and kidney pies. - Do you know what, black pudding is light in space. It's got much more to you. - What are the options again? - Black pudding, carrots, or steak and kidney pies. - I'll say black pudding. - It is black pudding, yes. - Yes, it made me laugh when I found that out. So, I thought, I really like black pudding. - I love black pudding. - What is the summer residence of the UK Chancellors? - Is it chabin? - Oh, I've got it in it. - No problem. - Is it checkers, chabin or thorny wood? - Look, it's chabin, thorny wood. - Who is it? - It's chabin in the forest aqua tree. - Yeah. - I knew that. - I think it's in forest aqua, chabin. - It's definitely not. - Thorny wood. - Traditionally, this is why I got you to. - No one goes out these days 'cause no one's there long enough to be chancellors. It's not really in the news. - I've got a lot of fat thorny wood, isn't it? It's not a hollywood. - The chancellors. - It is, it is. - It's a reintervalent. - Nice name. - This is why I got a pen and pencil for you, Pete. - Okay, yeah. - This is very rare, everyone. - Come on, Pat, come on. - Pete, you might have to take notes for this one. - Come on. - Now, you said about how the chance of tradition has been able to drink whatever they wanted for the dispatch box. - Yes. - Can you match the former chancellors in the drink? - All right. - Come on. - All right, so who are the chancellors? - Kenneth Clark. - Yeah. - Jeffrey Howe. - Yeah. - John Major. - William Gladstone. - Yeah. - Nigel Lawson. - Oh God, I don't know. - And George Osborne. - Yeah. - Yeah. - All right, come on. - John Drinks. - Give me the drink. - Gin and Sonic. - Spritzer. - Hey, don't slow down. - Yeah, Gin and Sonic. - Yeah. - Oh. - Brandy and Walter. - Oh. - Whiskey. Sherry and a beaten egg. - And Walter. - Here you go again. - Gin and Sonic, Spritzer. Brandy and Walter. Whiskey, Sherry and a beaten egg. - And Walter. - You're gonna start with an easy one. Do you think there is an easy one there? - Wow. - I think there's an easy one there. - Right. - Uh, cook one. Sorry, you have to read them one more time. - Which one? - Gin and Sonic, Spritzer, Brandy and Walter. Walter. - Oh, it's cool. - Sorry. - I hope listeners are trying to work this out. - All right, can I clap? Brandy? - Here we go. - Well, hold your hand. Oh, no, you got it. 'Cause you'll end up working it out through. - I don't think I'll get any of them, right? Well, I'll try it. Okay, can I clap? Oh, it's like a jazz man, isn't it? - I thought you'd get can't clap. I thought you'd only get two, basically. - All right, can I clap, Brandy? - I think it's-- - Brandy and Walter. - Yeah. - All right. - How? Spritzer. - All right. - Major, Walter. - Glad that the Sherry and Walter-- - Yeah, Sherry and the beaten egg. - Lawson, Jane, Tony. Osborne. Oh, I don't know, I don't know what I've got left. I don't know what yet. - Whiskey, I don't know. - You've got one right. (laughs) - Is that the class tomorrow? - Yeah. - Well, I'll do the same. - Well, I thought you'd get kind of thought. - I'd say he was always drinking whiskey. - He always drinks whiskey. - Thank you John. - No, I know whiskey, whiskey. - Jeffrey Howard was a gin and tonic man. - Yeah. - John Major was Brandy and Walter. - I don't know if I'm not doing it. - Glad Stone was Sherry and the beaten egg. Lawson. Nigel Lawson was the Spritzer. And George Osborne was Walter. - Oh, that's what I wrote. - What did you say? - I don't know. - Yeah, well I can't. - I can have two. - I can give you two, yeah. - Because the thing about it is-- - I've got confused. - Over the last, I think the last four chances they were going to hold up. And so Osborne's like the beginning of it. The beginning of the end. - It's actually a dish, isn't it? - You know, you want them stagging in, aren't you, with a bit of alcohol. So basically, you could get 10 points there, Pete. - And I got it. - And you got four. - I'm having them. - Come on. - Really? - Right? - No, you got black pudding. - Oh yeah. - Yeah, you missed out on Donnie Road, George Osborne, and you got two in that quiz. - Yeah. - All right. - So I read that, I'm free and tall. - Yeah. - I'm sure our listeners will. - I'm sure we will. - I'm sure we'll like seed my dessert. - Or get a score. (upbeat music) - Okay, let's get back into the questions. Why does the UK, and are she in most other countries, historically have a deficit? And what's that got to do with James Buchanan and his public choice theory? - Well, it's obviously not everyone on the deficit, country wise, but I suppose there's, in some respects, it's a very simple answer. It's very difficult to raise taxes, 'cause no one likes them. - Yeah. - It's politically unpopular. And it's also very difficult to reign in spending. And that's where the sort of Buchanan might come in. If you remember from our Buchanan episode, the idea of public choice theory, that in a sense, politicians are just like anyone else. If you place them in a particular situation, they'll try and maximize their welfare. And welfare in that sense might be having a big department, having a department which spends lots of money, a country resident. All the big self interest for them is to get reelected. Yeah. Yeah. And so they will be very, very low to rain and spending even if it might be the right thing to do in the sort of national interest and so on. By the way, here's a question for you. Since 1955, so that's 67 years, in how many years has the government run a budget surplus? I'm going to go seven. Have you looked before? No. But I just know this information because I know you've got, you've got, you've got the kind of brown, because what's always interesting about it as well is that Labour have had more surpluses and the Conservatives. I think so, maybe four. Okay, so let's go brown. The right two of those years. So 6970. Sorry, no, there's a surplus in 5556. That will be the Conservatives. Then 6970, that will be Wilson's Labour. So that's 21. And then 8788, I think that's Lawson. That's 22. And then there's two years, 99, there's two, no, maybe three years of soup surplus actually. So there are more from Labour. In some respects, there's sort of a Labour reputation probably not larger deficits. Look at throughout the 80s, I suppose the rate of increase was declining. But certainly throughout the that two years, the government was running. But what was interesting about the Labour brown is, the reason why they've got that surplus is because they agreed to stick to the Conservatives spending pants to prove their fiscal kind of in discipline. So I mean, it's sort of a little kind of cheat. I mean, fair rate them for doing it. But I mean, it is interesting that they did it having committed to the Conservatives. It's like a kind of a, I think kind of like a Conservative kind of catch, isn't it? Yeah, I'm not sure, but I believe as well that one of the reasons why the Conservatives deficits weren't even higher in the 1980s was because of the privatisation programme because obviously those are one-off. That's a one-off income. You can't sell the family silver twice. Yeah, that's what that was like. But then that would have allowed them to either not run services, but their deficits would have been even higher without the income from those sorts. Right, and set up all those houses as well. Yeah, yeah. So, but there you go. Yeah, anyways, so we always said, well, not always, a lot of people have deficits and you can put it down to Buchanan's public joystery, who wants to reign in spending and increase taxes when you want to get elected. Yeah, no one. How effective is fiscal policy and what can Ricardo and Phillips teach us about this? Okay, so in some respects, if you want to say how effective is fiscal policy, you need to sort of say, well, what is its objective? Right. If its objective is to sort of perhaps sort of pump prime the economy, sort of reflate the economy as it were, then Ricardo, if you come across the concept of Ricardian equivalent, I think we mentioned it briefly, didn't we, in the Ricardian podcast? So, this is where or that this is the idea that any increase in government expenditure that increases the budget deficit leads to a corresponding decrease in consumption. And the reason for that is households save more because they think their taxes are going to rise in the future. Yeah, yeah. Which is a really, it's a good evaluative point to make an essay. It is, but I think it might be an example of Ricardian vice. There's a logic to it. Yeah. But is it actually borne out by empirical reality and all, like, the hood not? Rather than Phillips, by the way, and I know you said, you know, what can Phillips tell us about the effectiveness of fiscal policy, I did want to bring in a bit of Keynesian thinking, I don't know if Phillips is associated with sort of Keynesian, but and I wanted to bring in a concept, which I think a lot of people are familiar with. And that is the multiplier. Yeah, yeah. And certainly Keynesians would argue that running a fiscal deficit is essential if you're in a time of significant economic downturn. You need expansionary fiscal policy at that point. And in a sense, not only do you get the initial injection of government spending, reduction in taxation, that will reflect the economy to a degree, but you'll also get a disproportionate impact due to what's called the multiplier. Yeah. So in some respects, one person spending becomes another person's income. So there's a kind of ripple effect from any injection of government spending. Let's say the government builds a new hospital. So obviously that might be you know, 50 billion, sorry, 50 million worth of spending or something like that. Well, all the people who built that hospital will now have an income. They might spend it in local restaurants and cafes and so on. So there will be that knock on effect. And then the people in the cafes will have more money. They might spend it at each stage, the sort of ripple gets smaller because of what we call withdrawals. Some of the money is saved. Some of the money is spent on imports going out of the economy and some of it is taxed. So the ripple gets smaller, but there is a disproportionate impact of government spending. Now what I was looking up is sort of estimates that the size of the multiplier and there's a really good article on the economics observatory website. But in normal times, so let's say you're not in a recession and the fiscal multiplier is estimated to be pretty small, maybe even less than one. And the reason for that is obviously government expenditure needs to be financed. And that might lead to kind of things like crowding out. Crowding out. I mentioned crowding out. Yeah, we should mention crowding out, anything to do, isn't it? Yeah. So crowding out is a concept which is used to counter the idea that a government should borrow money out. And the way I always explain this to kids in classes, let's imagine we've got a bucket in the room. It's filled with all the nation's savings. Now, savings aren't entirely in a sort of open world economy, the only source of sort of borrowing either for firms or for governments, but let's say the government for whatever these sort of savings or sources of finance come from, the government is going in and sort of plundering that bucket. There is obviously then less available for the private sector. I've firms to borrow to spend on investment, be it new technology, new factories and so on. You can imagine we've got this bucket full of sort of potential sort of investment funds which people can borrow. The government's like, got its elbows out, it's elbowing the private sector firms out of the way. So during normal times, if you like, the argument is that the government borrowing too much money will crowd out the private sector. Also, if it's sort of normal times, if the government does expand the economy, well, there might be an offsetting in response by the central bank. The central bank, by the way, okay, if the government's going to chuck loads of money in the economy, we're worried about inflation. We might raise interest rates. This is exactly what's happening now. Yeah, it was under the expected, yeah. So in other words, the expansion we physical policy is met with account of eight lean power of a contractionary monetary policy. So really good article actually, we must tweet it, but on the economics real observatory website about that. However, the physical multiplier can be quite high when you sort of head in sort of difficult times. If you've got what's called liquidity constraint consumers, like the people who might spend more, if they're able to borrow, and that would increase the size of this multiplier. If the central bank, you know, the bank rate is already near zero, and again, the physical multiplier will have more of an impact. If the economy is sort of less open, you know, it's in a period where it's not as open to sort of world trade, or very simply if the economy is in a recession. And at that point, the multiplier can be really quite big. There's one estimate by our buck and Gorodnichenko in 2012, that it could be as high as 2 or 3 during a recession. And again, there's various studies about that, you know, how during a recessionary period, or if labor markets are slack, you know, not too high, you know, there's unemployment, then the physical multiplier can really be quite powerful. It is interesting isn't it, because there's always this chat about crowding out, but I mean, we have mentioned this before. I mean, that's a concept called crowding in. You never really hear about that, but that is a great example of crowding in, because what the government is doing is bringing people with them. If I start spending, that means businesses might start spending as well, because they'll feel confident that the economy is going to be boosting a little bit more, so they might invest a little bit more, and so they start bringing people. So that kind of makes sense. Yeah, and you go back to the Osborne years, and if you make the comparison between the US and the UK, so it's obviously an awful financial crisis in 2008, which affected America and the UK. Really quite severely as sort of economies, whichever, sort of large financial sector. particularly the UK but you know America as well. But the policy responses at that point were quite different and the UK government quite quickly went for a you know kind of retrenchment you know a period of austerity. But if you're already in a sort of a downturn then you know it maybe it doesn't make sense that you could have potentially if you're in a recessionary period got quite a lot of bang for your book through an expansionary fiscal policy and actually the US took a lot longer before it engaged in retrenchment perhaps when economy had picked right back up and you know there wasn't as much impact of an expansionary fiscal policy but I suppose what I took from that is there's quite a bit of evidence that we went too soon for an austerity package. Well and Ed Bulls suggested otherwise didn't he? No he did yeah he did yeah but he wasn't realistic but there you go um should we I mean is there much to say about other Phillips I mean I suppose why we we mentioned Phillips there is just the fact that I suppose if you've got quite I know not much spare capacity within your economy as with monetary policy because it's a demand side policy yeah if you're boosting you know demand you're going to come into problems in terms of the trade off between inflation and unemployment yeah yeah that's the reason why we mention that I mean yeah I mean let's be honest with you implicitly sort of mention that have we in that if there is a tight labor market in other words if unemployment is already quite low and you engage in an expansionary fiscal policy the likelihood is inflation more wise yeah okay cool we've done that thing yeah okay what does fiscal drag mean and then are there any other policy peculiarity peculiarities I could say that work I'd like you to explain fiscal drag uh fiscal drag thank you yeah okay well this is where if I get this correct I hope I do where uh basically as your income goes up yeah you get dragged into the different tax brands yeah and so what's normally happened in the past this is quite topical at the moment isn't it because as basically people's incomes arise rising the government at the moment have frozen the tax bracket yeah and so what it means is that a lot of people who think they'll be kind of gaining yeah these people you know increases in income will not because traditionally the tax brackets have gone up by inflation yeah he's now decided they're not going to so people get dragged into this higher bracket yeah which means they're paying more tax government should get more tax yeah and actually yeah and actually it's just because they're nominal earnings have gone up wrong yeah they're real income because of inflation yeah and the similar thresholds for things like where people can gain certain benefits you know if they're held the same yeah people's nominal income rises and they'll be less entitled to certain sort of trial benefits and so on yeah so yeah interesting I mean it's a quite cheeky way of um of getting because it's quite stealthy isn't it yeah yeah you know you know we're not putting up anything yeah yeah because of yeah the nominal increases then people will be paying more exactly exactly uh any other policy peculiarity is can you explain the poverty trap this is sometimes isn't it where people who connect sort of have marginal tax rates of about 80% can't they yeah I suppose it's being on benefits yeah if you and then you work an extra hour or two hours something yeah and then you'll lose you'll lose certain benefits is a kind of cliff edge that you that you fall off and actually we it's quite interesting because Milton Friedman when we look at Friedman is negative income tax was a kind of way of trying to avoid yeah sort of the poverty trap but it is a big problem because you you do I mean literally whenever you get someone on talking about obviously poverty and then that number of hours worked you'll always hear someone say it's not worth me taking on an extra two hours because of ex-wife's head and and so it is a massive issue that does need to be addressed and the way to address it is not to basically make benefits worse if it makes it because it's kind of tackling the one way you need to have a better kind of transition that needs to be kind of cautioning doesn't there so that people are encouraged to work without initially losing sort of all their benefits because be you know that would be irrational wouldn't it yeah and one thing we should also mention here related to policy peculiarities is the Lafrica because he's obviously in the news recently because of again Kuarteng's budget this idea that you could probably say that a lot of it was based around the Lafrica this idea that this is kind of sense that if you lower income tax or corporation tax even though it might seem kind of counterintuitive because you think oh you're not going to get as much tax in because of incentives you might actually increase your tax revenue because there'd be more firms setting up more people paying tax more people wanted to work because they can keep more of their money and so this idea that you can lower taxes and increase government spending because you get more tax revenue the only problem is is that it's never really being proud to work as well I think it's interesting before George Bush and George Bush senior was going up against Reagan he called it a voodoo economic problem and certainly there's been some quite I suppose the reason why you know why what how in theory could this work so why could you gain more tax revenue by lowering taxes as you said it could incentivize people either to sell new businesses or work more hours it could also lead to falls in tax avoidance and tax evasion in theory you could maybe get less of a brain drain as well people might not move interestingly there was quite I was reading quite an interesting study about because obviously in America you've got different taxes in different states so in some respects it's quite a some some natural experiment to see what are the impacts do high wealth individuals move from state to state if the taxes are high in one state then there are another and the study I was reading I must try and look it up and but it's not suggested it had far less impact than you might think which in some respects it's not surprising because in some it's a bit like geographical immobility people live in a particular place their family live there they're settled do they really move to another country I mean obviously you do get that get that with some sports people moving to Monaco but you start to get this in the 80s wouldn't you like Labour getting Phil Collins is going to move to Samsung and you're always thinking oh god damn yeah it's never anyone not good you know you think oh I've got to do though yeah well quite a few people didn't know they're stones and stuff like that but it's interesting do you forget I'm in a marginal race of taxation at that point we're way higher way higher than I know but I'm glad that you pointed out that thing about who said food economics first I read this article from Kate Andrews who is an old IA person they're right to expect data who and she said about kind of sort of talking about trust and quiet saying about how she goes over about how left wing commentators had described you know this stuff as voodoeconomics and I was like reading the thing in what the famous left wing commentator George Dubu Bush you know Dubu it says that oh yeah yeah yeah so he's like incredibly incredible to write that you like thinking anywhere that's very only forms okay so that's the Laffer Curve is there anything else I suppose not I think so I mean the thing sorry going back to the Laffer Curve obviously how that kind of links in with what is known as trickle down economics and then again you give people rich people money it would trickle down for real economy and that will create that kind of you know increasing demand in the economy generally right okay let's move on how does fiscal policy conflict with monetary policy and how does it relate to supply sigh policy okay that's quite a big question yeah so we've kind of made some of it already yeah we have yeah monetary policy in the UK operates in that we have an operationally independent bank of England so our central bank is given a target of achieving inflation of 2% plus or minus 1 so currently inflation is way above that so sort of October 2022 at about 10.1% and this is largely though to be fair due to cost push inflation so a lot of import prices and energy costs have gone optometically due to the Ukraine conflict that's had a significant impact on both energy and food prices so because of that increase in inflation the bank of England has begun gradually to engage in a contractionary monetary policy so very simply increase in interest rates the interesting part about that I suppose is that it's in a bit of a quandary in that the inflation is not really caused by on could argue excessive demand some people would say it is caused by excessive demand so for some people it's kind of an unwinding of the quantitative easing that's in part or contributing if you like to the inflation amongst people it's like well come on it's cost prices but for some people that say yeah but there are some people with spare cash after sort of COVID and you know there's a lot of QE and maybe Maybe that's beginning to sort of. So fill her into the system and so on. But where do you look at it? If you do increase the bank rate, so the bank has recently increased its sort of central rate, that encourages people to save, it discourages consumption. And also indirectly, it does reduce some of those cost-pushed-precious pressures because in theory it should cause the pound to get stronger. With the reason for that being if our interest rate is higher than other sort of countries around the world, then all of the things being equal. There should be a flow of funds into the UK economy, what we call hot money. Now, that's what should happen in theory. But people aren't gonna buy pounds and UK products, even if, so UK financial products are government debt, even if the interest rate is high, if they feel that the UK economy's becoming a bit of a basket case. Right, and we'll come onto that in a minute. By the way, the Bank of England was planning on engaging in what we might call quantitative tightening. Yeah, so its plans were to sort of buy up government bonds, sorry, instead of buying up government bonds, it used to as part of the QE process. It was hoping to sell assets from the bank's balance sheet and therefore reduce the money supply. And that would be part of its approach to bringing down these high rates of inflation. Quite a good FT article by Jagget Chadhar about what the bank's plans were. This has all been sort of scuppard by the fiscal event, which caused a meltdown in the market for government guilt, so government bonds, if you like. The bank at that point felt that to intervene in the guilt market, so rather than sort of selling bonds, it's had to buy them up again. And some people have said this is an example of what we call fiscal dominance. And this is where central banks use their monetary powers to support the price of government securities, in other words, guilt and so on. And they're trying to keep interest rates low in the economy really to reduce the servicing costs of debt. And in simple terms, what that means is the Bank of England is, in effect, devoting itself to supporting the government's fiscal policies, rather than sort of controlling inflation. Inextremist sort of fiscal dominance would be when the bank sort of prints creates new money to support unfunded government spending. But I suppose in this particular case, it was like, well, we've got all this unfunded tax cuts coming through, the markets take fright, and then the Bank of England feels it has to step in. So rather than acting as the sort of guardian of inflation reduction, it's then trying to protect the government's ability to borrow money on financial markets. So a bit of a mess. Yeah. But I mean, it's always worth, isn't it, people are thinking about that. They were always sort of too-sized to coin, isn't it? So you've always got to be thinking about the whole situation, fiscal policy, and market-money policy, hopefully working in tandem. Yeah, and many are kind of arguing at the moment. It's like a push me pull me in it. Yeah. I mean, it's always going to be a bit of that, you know? In some respects, I think, you could say that, join the Osborne, well, no, maybe they're working in a complimentary manner. But sort of, in Osborne's period of austerity, bank rate was really low. Yeah. The idea was, oh, yeah, well, we're going to rein incumbent spending, but we're going to try and encourage consumption investment through very sort of slack monetary policy, if you like. There's an interesting argument about why you don't want governments to have budget services linked to that. Because if you've got a budget surplus, where is the deficit coming from? And it means it's coming from private people. So you just end up having lots of people in debt. And who's best to actually take on debt is that the government, or is it us as the people? And so actual fact, it's probably better to have the government in debt rather than us. So it's kind of an interest. And that's definitely the case. I mean, you could see during Osborne's time is that, yes, he worried about the government's debts, but didn't care at all that we were just building up and building up this massive debt. Private in debt. Yeah, private debt. So it's kind of an interesting one I think about. You did mention in the question as well, how can fiscal policy act as a supply side? Yeah, I was wondering whether she just not talk about that. No, no, no, I think it's relevant. So because in a sense, fiscal policy can, if you sort of cut income tax, cut corporation tax, it can have a theory and sense of the fact. It can encourage higher productivity. But we should say probably what supply side policies are. Well, supply side policy is anything which sort of, well, something's laid out by the government to try and improve the increase the capacity of the economy to produce. Often they're focused on productivity, each one will increase output per worker. They could, in a very broad sense, it doesn't just have to be sort of tax cuts. It could be like building new roads, your infrastructure and things like that. That can increase the economy's capacity to produce. If you think about what Quartan and Trust felt they were doing, they felt they were engaging in fiscal policy as a supply side policy by cutting income tax, corporation tax, and all of this. It will have massive incentive effects. There are quite a few people who would have agreed with their general direction of travel. But it's more this kind of, you know, timing, yeah, ignoring the current context of high inflation and existing high debts meant that almost there are, you know, people on the, you know, conservative economist classical, in neo-classical economists who would say, look, these might be the right policies, but the timing of it is not right. And they were around violence, that's the thing. And it's a classic, again, I don't know, you know, too much A level economist here, but like, great kind of short run versus long run evaluative point to make, isn't it? Is that whenever you're discussing supply side policies, pretty much half the time you're probably going to look at some short run aggregate demand effect before the long run aggregate supply effect comes in and that's got to be managed well. Yeah. And it looked like at this moment in time I was going to have a big AD impact before 80, two or three, maybe eight years down the line, you'd get this kind of supply side effect coming in. Yeah, and they're always got that balanced. Yeah, so in a sense, they're thinking, oh, we're creating Singapore on 10, this is kind of low tax culture, which is going to encourage investment. But if you are in a situation where inflation's already sort of double digit in your effect, as you say, the short run impact would be to pump more demand into the economy, then everyone's like, what? Yeah, crazy stuff, crazy. So should we end it there? Okay, last question. What books would we recommend and why? Well, over two here because I know you've got a few recommendations. Well, the thing is, we've got to point out that a lot of the time we do like the same books. We do recommend them. And they do kind of cross over. So again, we've talked about Dunkin' World and there's too many years of money through. Excellent. Yeah, strongly recommend them. So I think with the monetary policy one, the deficit myth one, it's an interesting one, isn't it? Stephanie Kenton's book about whether you would argue it's fiscal or monetary policy, even though it's kind of like modern monetary theory, it sort of does relate to fiscal management. And yeah, so kind of a couple of new ones. I mean, if the undercover economy strikes back by Tim Hartford, there's always a really good book on macroeconomic. David Smith, even. No, no, no, I'm doing undercover economy strikes back. That's Tim Hartford. How was it? Yeah, yeah. Why was he under a cover mess then? I thought that was David Smith. No, no, no, no, no, that's Tim Tim. And then we have got David Smith book coming up here. Oh, I guess so. It's just recommended by your wife. She's called Something All Turn Up. She says it's a brilliant book related to fiscal policy. So we recommend that on her behalf. And also last time we talked about how a day of this, the Chancellor's Tales book. Right, yeah. And he got in contact with us. Did he? Yeah, and said, it's not that book anymore. Or there is that book out there, but he's got an updated book called The Chancellors Steering the British Economy and Crisis Times. Oh, that sounds fascinating. And I would assume that is a book to read related to fiscal policy. Yeah, good. Okay, excellent. Johnny Good. Now you know what time it is? Pete, what time is it? Poetry time. Oh, you can't escape it. You can't escape it. Okay, for a big intake of breath, yeah. It's called A Fiscal Policy Poem. All right. Well, that's what it says on the tin. Yeah, exactly. Is it cool? No. You wish to learn about fiscal policy, I see. Well, let me help you. I have a degree. It's all decided that the treasury under the jurisdiction of his majesty, a good way to remember his G&T. The G stands for government and how they spend your money on things like police stations, hospitals and universities, building infrastructure and libraries, developmentator poor countries, benefits to the less well-off and OAPs, as well as supporting us through emergencies. The T stands for tax, which they get from your salary, or when you buy something with VAT or from the profits of a company, or when you fill your SUV or drink a bottle of Shabli or import stuff from overseas, or when a loved one falls on their knees. It can help with government objectives like inequality or dealing with different externalities and, of course, helping with the economy. But don't ever think that people will agree. So that's it, really. That's the policy. Now, you can be the next Zahawi Rishi. quasi, I mean hunt or whoever it might be. (laughing) - Oh, it's painful, it was painful but we got through it Pete. - Yeah, we got through it, okay. We'd like to thank everybody for listening to Fiscal Policy Special and we'd like to thank Nick as always for all his help with regards, podcasts. Please get in contact with us via Twitter and Instagram and email, email at www.entregimeo.com. It's that time of the year as well that you might be thinking about sending Christmas cards. So if you want us to send us a few of our economics Christmas cards, we can get them in a post for you. Just drop us an email. - Yeah, we'd love to do that. So, hope you enjoyed that everybody. Hope you like the lot, thank you very much. Good evening. (upbeat music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Fiscal policy involves government spending and taxation to achieve economic goals, typically outlined in the annual budget or fiscal events.
  2. The UK budget traditionally follows a spring timing, but recent changes due to political transitions have led to fiscal events without Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) oversight.
  3. In the UK, income tax and National Insurance are the largest revenue sources, with VAT as a significant contributor, while taxes like corporation tax are relatively smaller.
  4. Taxation has shifted from progressive to more regressive over the past 20 years, contributing to rising inequality, as seen in the UK’s increasing Gini coefficient.
  5. Public spending is dominated by social protection (especially pensions), followed by health and education, with education facing financial strain due to rising teacher pay demands.
  6. Budget deficits occur when spending exceeds revenue, and persistent deficits contribute to national debt, which grows through government borrowing, often via bonds.
  7. Automatic stabilizers (like benefits and progressive taxation) help cushion economic downturns, while discretionary fiscal policy can be used to stimulate or cool demand.
  8. Fiscal policy effectiveness is debated

Summary:

Fiscal policy, the use of government spending and taxation to influence the economy, is central to economic management in the UK. Traditionally announced in the spring budget, recent political changes have led to fiscal events without independent oversight from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), raising concerns about transparency and accountability. In the UK, income tax and National Insurance are the primary revenue sources, with a notable shift toward more regressive taxation over the past two decades, contributing to growing inequality.

Public spending is heavily concentrated in social protection—particularly pensions—followed by health and education, with schools currently facing severe financial pressure from rising staff pay demands. A budget deficit arises when government spending exceeds tax revenue, and such deficits accumulate over time to form the national debt, which now stands at around 106% of GDP, rising sharply since 2008 due to the financial crisis and pandemic-related measures. While deficits are often seen as a sign of fiscal mismanagement, economists argue that automatic stabilizers—like benefits and progressive taxation—help stabilize the economy during downturns.

Discretionary fiscal policy, such as tax cuts or spending increases, can be used to stimulate demand during recessions, though its effectiveness is debated. Theories like Ricardian equivalence suggest households save in anticipation of future tax burdens, potentially weakening the impact of fiscal expansion, whereas Keynesian multiplier theory supports significant short-term effects, especially during downturns when the multiplier can reach 2–3. Nonetheless, concerns about crowding out—where government borrowing reduces private investment—remain, and the policy response to crises has varied, with the UK adopting austerity after 2008 in contrast to more expansionary approaches in other economies.

Overall, fiscal policy remains a complex, politically charged, and economically significant tool in managing national economic cycles.

FAQs

Fiscal policy refers to the use of taxation and government spending to achieve economic goals. In the UK, it is typically outlined in the annual budget or a fiscal event.

A budget is a traditional annual event with independent oversight by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR). A fiscal event, used when a new government takes office, lacks OBR oversight and is often seen as a way to avoid scrutiny.

The largest sources are income tax, national insurance, and VAT. Income tax is the biggest contributor, followed by national insurance and then VAT, which is a sales tax on most purchases.

Progressive taxation increases with income (e.g., higher earners pay more), while regressive taxes take a larger percentage from lower-income groups (e.g., VAT and cigarette duties).

Social protection (including pensions) is the largest, followed by health spending, education, defence, and debt interest, which highlights the cost of borrowing.

A budget deficit occurs when government spending exceeds tax revenue in a year; a surplus happens when tax income exceeds spending. A balanced budget means spending equals revenue.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.