First Day of Bingemas: ‘The Holiday Spark’ With Rob Mahoney
1h 15m 3s
*The Holiday Spark* is a holiday film that attempts to blend romantic intrigue with a firefighter protagonist’s journey toward emotional connection. Dean, a distant and emotionally guarded firefighter, meets Laura, a creative illustrator struggling to finish her children’s book, as they collaborate on a holiday party. While the film’s premise is charming and its holiday spirit is evident, it suffers from a lack of depth and realism. The romantic development feels forced and underdeveloped, with minimal emotional tension and no clear progression from friendship to romance. The film’s fire-related plotlines are largely symbolic, with no actual fire scenes or real-world stakes, reducing the authenticity of Dean’s role as a firefighter. Characters remain uniformly positive, lacking conflict or personal growth, which undermines the emotional stakes. The depiction of Laura’s creative process—particularly her fear of imperfection and her struggle with artistic authenticity—is compelling, offering a relatable undercurrent. However, the film fails to resolve its central conflict, leaving the romance ambiguous and the relationship’s foundation unearned. Its reliance on clichés, fire puns, and a lack of real-world consequences makes it feel like a surface-level holiday fantasy rather than a meaningful exploration of love, connection, or personal growth. Ultimately, *The Holiday Spark* is more about the mechanics of holiday tropes than about genuine human connection, resulting in a forgettable experience despite its surface appeal.
Hello and welcome to FingeMiz, a 12-part holiday special here on the Ringer Podcast Network. I'm your host, Jody Walker, and ever since 2017, when I happened upon a little hallmark film called The Christmas Train, wherein Danny Glover basically kidnapped Dermant Moroni and Kimberly Williams-Paisley aboard, you guessed it, a Christmas Train. I have been obsessed with breaking down the insane plots of the original holiday movies and getting them to the people. These plots are so formulaic, yet mysteriously compelling that each and every one of these original holiday movies can and will complete our patented BingeMiz rubric. Answering questions like, are there any fake towns or perhaps a whole fake country? Is there a mysterious old man and does that old man turn out to be Santa? How many Vanessa Hudgens is there in this? Who's Royal? And of course, everyone's favorite, who's dead? Because in these movies, someone is always dead at Christmas time. For the next six weeks, every Monday and Friday on the We're Obsessed Feed, I'll be meeting cute with all your Ringer Faves to binge the holidays. And today that means the holiday spark, a movie that taught me the very first and most important lesson of VengeMiz 2026, distrust to break down this movie, chosen by the We're Obsessed audience, and I really cannot reiterate that fact enough. I could only turn to professional man of the pod, my one true networking contact, and as dubbed last year on BingeMiz, Grind King of the Ringer, Rob Mahoney, Mary BingeMiz, how are you? I'm wonderful. I forgot that I was the Grind King of the Ringer, but it's still an honor. And being on this podcast, as always, an honor. I can't believe you've joined me here for day one. I could not turn to anyone else. I feel that we have had sort of an emotional journey through BingeMiz past. I told you off air, I was listening to our episode from last year, you know, just to get in the BingeMiz spirit. Of course. To see what the hell we were talking about. And last year, we did a movie where the character was named Ellen Neeser in the form of Scrooge. This is not that. It's somehow not. And I am a little myth that we did not get a more magical entry this year, but I am not disappointed in this movie at all. It really lived up to expectations for me. I can't. There's this thing about BingeMiz where it's like, I know who I'm going to be discussing with this. And so you need to know that the whole time I'm watching the holiday spark on Roku. Surprise. We're doing Roku this year. We went to Roku City to watch this movie. We did. Soon to be wait, is Roku City about? No, Roku Aquarium is soon to be shut down. Roku City though thriving. It's what's happening to Roku Aquarium. I suspect it's because like it got bought by some conglomerates. And I think I want to say Fox has involved some private equity. It's all very got to Roku. But hopefully whatever the evil overlords are, they do their hands off with movies like this. Because I want them to be untouched. I just I always want my guests to know that for the entire hour and 20 minutes that I'm watching one of these movies, I'm thinking about you exclusively. And what might Rob Mahoney be thinking about this movie? And this is an assumption, Rob. I don't want to cast his versions. But I assume you were going into this film with little knowledge about Joey Grazde, former bachelor, former dancing with the stars winner. And I believe the main reason why this was the single most requested movie of Vindramis. And therefore we have started with it. All of that tracks having seen him in action. Um, this man is not respectfully an actor. And I say that like, you, you cannot say that respectfully. Give it to me is chosen to try. But he, look, but is the message of this movie not you should try even if you're not perfect? Actually, it is. You need to put yourself out there, even if you are worried yourself about hurting other people. And that is your deepest seeded fear. Yeah, you simply have to try. You have to try to endeavor to connect to other human beings, even if it's by a mass audience on real coup TV. I had to take a break from the bachelor for personal trauma reasons a while back. Are you okay? I'm okay. You know, I'm recovering from years and years of coverage of the bachelor. And so I took, I took several years off. You know, I was thinking about getting back in and then Taylor Frankie Paul things went off. Things went off the deep end. But I think Joey was the first season I took off. So I have some knowledge of him. But I don't know if in his season of the bachelor, he was like talking about wanting to become an actor. I don't know what this journey has been like for him. I do know that prior to going on the bachelor, he worked primarily as a teaching tennis professional and in corporate sales. And I think he was mostly a tennis pro. I think he was a tennis pro. I need to know his game. Like, I'm going to need at some point the tennis scatting report on Joey Grazden. I'm sure this is available online somewhere. It's best to go in blind. He reads as like a pretty confident backhand player. But I mean, look, we'll get to the bottom of it. My concerns with him are mostly great smile, clear like the abs unimpeachable or CGI. I don't know how they manage them. I'm going to assume they're real. All of that I get generally very appealing and the character he plays is quite nice. What else is happening here? I was struggling with our guide Dean. It really is. So I also, I don't know if you remember this or if you've trauma blocked it out. But the first year that you were on Benjamin's, we watched a movie called Happy Howl a Days about a dog. Yeah. And the and the male lead in that movie had won the competition finding Mr. Christmas. So he was also a first time actor. Yeah. And it really, it had a very similar vibe. I was I was taken back to that place while I was watching Joey sort of navigate a dream come to reality. Yes. You know, in a way that was noticeable. I will say what I remember most about that movie was the lead actor having kind of a misplaced chemistry with the actress who was playing his sister. And they had a bigger romantic bond. And I would say that Joey had a sort of misplaced chemistry with every friend he worked with in the fire station. It's a huge issue with this movie. It's there really. Oh man, there was one moment when in his name is Dean in the film Dean and one of his colleagues who I think is named Jones. Yeah. I think he and Jones have the most sparkling chemistry in this movie because they had a sort of what felt like was going to be common enemies to love her storyline. But actually they were just friends the whole time. There was no villain who so discord in this movie except for perhaps low emotional IQ, which I would say self sabotage. So Dean was both the villain and the attempted protagonist. Well, we are all our own villains. And I think this movie confronts in a way that's frankly brave. It was brave. It was also brave. I think to cast Joey Grasday across from Jamie Chung who also comes from reality TV. She was originally on real on the real world San Diego. And she's been acting for a long time. She's been in a lot of stuff. But she also started just like as a non actor on television. And I find her very charming. Very charming. I mean, the on-screen charisma gap between these two is pronounced. And I say that as someone who I have seen Jamie Chung in many worse movies than this. Really? She's been in some real tough stuff. Not always her fault just like material weird adaptations. You got to do what you got to do. I thought she basically carried this movie on her back. Well, she does carry it on her back and on her own because what this film really made me think about is like, what can you do with such a charisma gap is like, can she create chemistry between the two of them simply by her being a good actress and charming? I would say the answer is no. Not with the support of this writing. Well, that's the thing. They needed to give Dean appealing qualities. And somehow they felt like they felt really short of that. They go on this first date, right? At Coco Madness. Thank you for using its government name. And welcome and welcome here to Coco Madness. And thank you to our producers for this amazing, this amazing in-person setup. If you're not watching on video, you are missing some incredible knitted pillows. The gingerbread work alone. Just gorgeous. This episode of We Obsessed is presented to you by Target. Gifting season is here and Target knows you've got plenty of people to shop for. The friend who's ahead of every trend, the family member who's suddenly into baking and the teenager who's only request is some niche hobby you've never heard of. Luckily, Target has something for everyone. Think trendy finds, toys and games, style for the whole family, exclusive collabs like the Harry Potter 25th anniversary collection, and so much more. Shop target and target.com and gift it you're all. So they go to Coco Madness. Yeah. And you start to finally get to know Dean the firefighter a little bit better. We know him that he's going to work. He's helping her family all that stuff. At Coco Madness, we learn he has no hobbies. He has no friends. He has barely interacted with other human beings before. I would also say he has, at this point, no discernible personality whatsoever. And so if it's a guy who hasn't acted before.
- Give him something to hang on to. - That's true. It's not entirely his fault. The beats that he is given to play are like hunky lead. I mean, that is, and his job is fire. - Well, sometimes it's smoke to be fair. - And sometimes it's smoke and sometimes it's steam. - It's true. - Remember when it was steam? - Why are we calling the fire department for the steam? - Also, everyone is always sitting in smoke and steam. Let me, I'll give the very brief description of this movie as we get into his firefighter tendencies. The holiday spark, firefighter Dean enlists illustrator Laura to help plan a holiday party for his firehouse. As they plan the epic party, both begin to question their views on romance and the possibility of love at first spark. Can you believe it? Can you believe they did it? 'Cause Rob, we mostly ended up here because you were looking forward to the fire puns. - Yeah. I thought they were a little less clueling than I was expecting. - They were, they were not that clueling. They weren't that frequent, but they were frequently, it was like in the place of fire puns, they were just using a lot of idioms. - A lot. - Like a lot that didn't always have their place and I did wonder about one when he says late in the movie. He's like, my mom always said, you're never fully dressed without a smile. And I wondered if they added that because of just simply how much he smiled as an acting choice. They were like, we gotta explain this a little bit. - It's a megawatt smile. That is a thing an abusive parent says. If your parent is telling you that and maybe that's really the secret backstory here, is this man has been through the ringer, right? Like he's had a tough childhood. We only learned like his adult history of like, oh, he was a firefighter outside Denver and he moved back to this small town where he grew up. His parents are out of the picture. He has contact with them, but maybe he's just alleging it. - Well, yeah, I mean, we don't even see the face of his mother, we hear her on a FaceTime. I think an issue with this movie, which, you know, I enjoy all of these movies. I enjoyed watching it, but it felt, it had that certain Jannesay Roku to it, where it really felt like it was not coming from Hallmark, was not coming from Netflix because it didn't, it didn't address many of the Benjamin's rubric items, probably most importantly that no one was dead. - No one was dead. - No one was single person. - Those heroes needed to be dead. - What purpose do they have for being alive? - That's a great question. I don't need to frame myself. - Imagine as part of his work, Joey asked himself that as he built his character. Why are these spirits of mine alive? Who I do not see? When he explains, 'cause he's not a scrooge, he just doesn't do Christmas stuff. Because he is decided that Christmas is a thing for families. And it's sort of kind-hearted that he wants to work at the fire station on Christmas, so that the people with partners and with kids can have their time on Christmas. But he is using it as a crutch. - Yes. - And when he explains like his deal to Laura, he says about his backstory. Pretty simple, I moved here to fight fires and my parents aren't here because, and I just knew he was gonna say because they're dead, especially because she is set up a situation where she is sure she's gonna meet his parents because he met her parents. And she's like, your parents can tell me what's up with you. And I kind of wanted to like, for him to get her back for making such an assumption. Like, why aren't your parents here? Is he, we didn't even know if he was from there at that point. What if you went with like, what if you went in like met another adult somewhere and they were like, why aren't your parents here? - It's a weird thing to say. It's an extension of the bit by which they meet cute and her parents have given him her whole backstory. I would actually throw to you. I kind of was left wondering, Gus and Gail, Laura's parents delightful. - Let's start with these parents and everything they do. - They're really wonderful. They are kind of a hidden like rug pull in the movie where they're love it for spark back story turns out to have been a fabrication for the purposes of small talk, which is I think quite beautiful. - I think that that was the, that was the best twist of writing in the movie. - It was really, really great. And so I think Gus and Gail bought the fireman calendar. - It's so hard to hear you say those names because they sound like mice. (laughing) Those sound like the names of my, I didn't honestly catch those were their names. - Part time, they were helping Cinderella get dressed and clean the house. - Full time. - Full time setting fires, they're mostly setting fires. - I kind of wonder if they knew how to use their fireplace the whole time. Gus and or Gail knew that Laura needed a proper date with the strapping young gentleman, saw him on the hunky firefighter calendar and was like, you know what? What if we just start a little, a teensy little fire here at home to lure him into our home when we know our daughter is coming over? - Because how do they explain, okay, we meet them. She is just arriving at her parents house to deliver something and she sees a fire truck outside and she's honestly not that worried. She's like, what is going on here? Maybe because she knows Gus and Gail kind of stinkers. - They have a wild lifestyle. - She walks into the house and they're just sitting in smoke. - That was the one they got. - They're sitting in smoke and there are firemen in there who I thought could be like, hey, don't sit in this smoke. But apparently they describe that they have tried to use their fireplace for the first time since moving into this house. And they were like, apparently you don't just light newspaper and walk away. But then when Dean lights the fire for them, he just lights a match and throws it in. - Yes. - And I'm wondering if perhaps my father was lying, my whole childhood as he hemmed and hawed over making a fire in the fireplace. Or if all fires are so simply struck that way as they are in this movie. - They certainly can. - One match thrown in. - I think the purposes of a fire as this movie has led me to understand is mostly for metaphor and word play and really how you're starting it as sort of incidental. Like you just need to have Kindle so that you say you have Kindle so that you can then twist the metaphor further. - For me, the meet cute was all about the parents and that's not great. - Well, they also had great chemistry with Dean. - They did. - And so it's-- - It's hey dead. - Okay, let me float this to you. 'Cause I think this is maybe an enduring problem with these sorts of movies. Where? - There are no problems with these movies. - Of course I'm sorry. I would never have led to such. So many of the characters are operating in the same like pleasant wavelength. Everyone is mostly super nice to each other. We're in the holiday spirit. It just feels nice to watch. The result of that is even the romantic pair is in the exact same wavelength as everybody else. - Yeah, and so like you get as many long shots of firefighters making eye contact with each other as you do the two romantic leads and making eye contact with each other. - That's right. - And so it leads me to be very confused as to what the feelings of a film like this are supposed to be. - Well, that's why you need a villain. Like you need the levels of someone who is working on a different level so that you don't believe that everyone isn't love with each other. - Yeah, but even then, as you said, you're just going enemies to lovers at a certain point. - Now, this movie airing on Roku did have a lesbian couple who one of them was her best friend and she kind of like provides some wisdom throughout the film but I wish she provided a little more because I really feel and I have to confess something to you right now, which is that I am pretty jaded by a current season of Love is Blind. I'm having a real hard time with any man who is just so flagrantly unaware purposefully of his own existence, honestly. I feel that we have a similar situation here in Dean as someone who is like, I don't do Christmas stuff because Christmas is for families. But I do want to have a family. At what point will we bridge this gap between living like someone who wants to have a family and someone who will have a family? It's an epidemic, Rob. - I think that epidemic, though, is requested. - Would you like to speak for your people? - You know, I'm very glad that you brought me a man onto this podcast episode. - Yeah, and always, yeah. - On multiple fronts, one, we are a professional man. - Truly a professional man. And if I can speak for my male counterparts, that gap is an impossible bridge to divide for I'm gonna say 30 to 35% of our population are paying dues, paying members. - That's right, that's an issue. I would also say in the space of men, the fire stations whole toxic male positivity thing they got going on is like a little culty. - Okay, see this, I loved. - I liked it. - But when it's like grows, dappin' each other up for being good listeners, it's like there's just something here that the energy is off. - Do you think that real firemen walk back in, the morning after their whole crew, except for them, have been a, I guess putting out a fire, although we might have to come back to that. And says, hey, good morning, guys, saw the news. Great job putting out that fireman, appreciate y'all. Is there anything that a man will not say, "Preciate to appreciate you." - Let me show you that, no. - "Preciate you." - We do appreciate each other. - "Preciate you putting out that fire, my guys." - My favorite along these lines was when one of the other firemen walks into the fire station, which is being decorated for the aforementioned Christmas party. - A week in advance, I was like, this is a hazard, you have a live tree in here. - They're all advocating for the live tree as they are giving fire safety tips about live trees to everyone else. - They were taking no precautions. - But one of them walks in and just says, "Hey, this is decor, brother. Talknuch." - Brother. - Brother. - I appreciate you. - With where I am in my love is by journey, I did need the camaraderie and the holding each other accountable, which comes a little later in the film. But I was impressed with the way that the friends held Dean accountable for being a sort of,
of little like shit, boy. - They literally use the term self-sabotage. Like they are aware and in touch with their feelings. - Bro, they don't just use the term self-sabotage. He says, bro, you self-sabotaged. - He was right. - Appreciate you. - If you can't appreciate your bros for telling you that you're sabotaging your own life, because if you're crippling for you're referring other people, what are they even there for? - I mean, a little bit of kissing. It was seen from the chemistry, but otherwise. So they create this dynamic when they have the meet cute that they kind of start doing favors for each other. How does this start? Now I'm like, how did she end up bearing the burden of this party? Well, she invites them. She tells her friend afterwards that she had this spark in meeting this man in her smoke-filled home and for parents. She says, I think I felt it. Like that thing that I've always wanted. - So she felt it. - Let me ask you. Did you see it? - How dear? - I'm just wondering, did anyone observe this phenomenon other than her? - Well, Rob, actually, this is the one moment of magic in the movie is that when they turn and see each other the fire flames. - It does, sorry. - And you know that, I think we have now established that that was actually just things to poor gas management, but you, I think many people who have fallen in love know this. - You can mistake a lot of things for the magic of love. - Well, especially Claire. - And I think she has. - If there's a carbon monoxide leak in the house. - Oh, everybody was high as a kite in there. - It really explains a lot when you put it in that perspective. - It does because, yes, it is carbon monoxide because she felt the spark, she tells her friend. And then they go to the hot chocolate, what it was, cocoa madness, big, cocoa madness. - Which to be clear is a bracket style competition among various flavors of hot chocolate. When he gets there or when she arrives, he's already been there. He's been establishing a perimeter, he says. - Another very man thing to do. You know, you got to take a lap. You got to know the exit strategies. It's very important. - Of course, never let your back face a door. That's actually a very male tendency that I have. And I have put you in the submissive position where your back is facing the door. - As is only right on this podcast. - Exactly, I'm the finish from his boss. He said something that I would like to print on a shirt for all of my ranger colleagues and I have taken a photo of my laptop screen so that I can do this. Which is, thank you for inviting me to this. I take a lot of pride in ranking things bracket style. Rob, you and I will be ranking things bracket style tomorrow. - Tomorrow. - A subject you could not believe. - I mean, we're gonna rank things bracket style basically every day for the rest of our professional lives. But tomorrow will be the true privilege among them. And I'm so glad you're gonna be joining us to an into the prestige TV podcast for all that. - Well, thank you. - Thank you to the prestige TV podcast for inviting me because I take a lot of pride in ranking things bracket style. - It's your gift. - It's my gift. It's, you know, anytime someone at the ranger has me on a draft, they do marvel at my gift for drafting. 'Cause I understand it and I know the snake style. - Of course. - And I'm very clear on the rules. - Well, do you have an opinion on the ranking of the entrance of Coco Madness? If you are going to partake in Hot Chocolate and we should say, I actually think, as far as taxonomy goes, this movie proposes one that is quite apt, quite useful. Are you a coffee or are you a hot chocolate kind of person? That is their collision of contrast. - That is, but that is a contrast that can only exist in these movies because like, I'm an adult. - Yeah. - So like, I know I don't drink daily hot chocolate. Though maybe I should live or not. Why not live like this guy? Why not turn my brain off, give myself a lobotomy and drink hot chocolate? - I think you absolutely should. Here's the thing. - But he's actually a coffee guy. - He is, he should be a coffee guy, but somehow is also a hot chocolate guy. This is another issue with this movie, as I feel like they are very confused on for what type of girly Laura is. Is she the whimsical girly or the serious professional girly? - Oh, Rob, I have some information for you. - Please. - I've actually maybe never related to a character more in one of these movies. Then when she, she describes herself early on as typey. - Yeah. It's very helpful. My name is Laura, your type of be best friend who always seems to find a way to figure it out. I appreciate for the media illiterate like us. Just tell us who these people are. - Oh, the dialogue is nothing if not helpful. It is incredibly helpful in telling you what's going on, not showing you. - For sure. - So she's our good friend Laura, the type B procrastinator, which we learn because his challenge within the movie is both growing into an adult male and also throwing a party. Her challenge is that she is completing an MFA program, which I would like to talk about. - We will get into it in depth. - The depiction of an MFA. - And she, for her final MFA project, she is submitting an illustrated children's book that she will both illustrate and write. And the countdowns to Christmas are such. She needs to turn that book in by December 13th. And he needs to execute his party by December 23rd. And so we learned that she is putting off the writing of this book. She's been doing the illustrations. And I just, I really would, I wish I had consulted a children's author before this because the way that they depict that like, you just write a children's book in honestly a matter of minutes, like the words in a children's book. And it does seem like a young child's book like it would have a sentence to teach. Nonetheless, I feel that it takes a little bit of time to actually craft a narrative with so few words. - Yes. - I actually think making a genuinely good children's book is an incredible art of balance, of perspective, of understanding like how to capture a young kid's mind in a way that is like grippy on the ideas in the cute images and also the messaging. It's a very delicate line to walk. - Yes. - This is not that. - She's not walking it. - She is, she's banging around on that line. - Okay, I mean, let's say for one, just a truly horrendous children's book author. For two, wants to be a children's book illustrator and everything that she creates is the most clearly A.I. generated image I've ever seen. - A.I. is bad. No, I did find her illustrations. I'm sure also done by A.I. a little more impressive than her graphic design work. She does the, she does the multimedia for the town. - Yes. - What is a very small town? So she wears a lot of hats around her. - She wears a lot of hats and wields a lot of pencils. And so like for some of the events because we should establish that this is a town of Christmas events. There's a checklist, an actual checklist, which includes, starts with Coco Madness. There's the Littlewood Fire Department chop-a-thon. There's supposed to be what is described on the checklist as a life-size snow globe. - And we never see it. - What do those words mean to you? What would make a snow globe life-size? - I'm imagining like, you know the aquarium tunnel that you walk through yourself. - Oh, the real cool aquarium? - I mean, I wouldn't really dream about it. - The discontinued real cool aquarium? - I wish it were capable of such things. But yeah, some kind of walk through enclosure. Now, what is the sort of a snow? - Oh, okay, life-size means maybe you could go into it. - I would think for a little photo op. - For me, I was like a life-size snow globe, usually a snow globe contains a town. - Yes. - So that would be sort of a Truman Show scenario over the whole town. - So did you think like in the spirit of- - And we don't know that it wasn't that to be fair. - Well, we never saw it. - Yeah. - I think there are many things we never ended up seeing that felt to me promised. You show me a checklist of eight Christmas items. - Yeah. - I'm just gonna think we're gonna do all eight Christmas items. You give me a plot that centers around a fire station and you don't show me one single fire. - Okay. - It's a dereliction of duty. - They got themselves in a bit of a pickle with the fire thing because fires are very traumatic. - Like- - Incredibly so. - They keep setting up a situation where like he is going to be saving lives or something, but they obviously cannot bring themselves to set an actual fire and like have it harm people. And I don't want that either. And yet we are supposed to believe that he is like a very brave - Yes. - Fire man. At one point, he, oh, we meet him, Rob. We meet him coming out of a house. - He saves a life. And that is the life of a stuffed gingerbread. We meet him coming out of a lightly smoking house. - I would say the degree to which if you cooked a steak in a cast iron pan. - Okay, that's right. And your fire alarms were a little faulty. - Yeah. - Um, he comes out, the house is smoking. He is covered in nothing, no ash, which that's an interesting choice because like that's an easy thing to do. And he, he hands it back to this child. It's not smoking. It hasn't been burned. - No. - There is no fire in this film. There is only smoke. And that does feel like a metaphor. - This is why you're the best in the business. I think you're engaging with the cortex in a way that even the creators of this film would appreciate. - Yeah. - And I think the real missed opportunity there is not making him smoked up a little bit because, I mean, not quite my area, but I would think you could make your male romantic lead sometimes even more alluring by smootzing him up a little bit. - I totally agree. And there is one point where they, and we're just not quite there yet, but where they, again, they go to fight a fire. - They do. - But what they ultimately describe having done is been in a warehouse all night. - On a band in warehouse. - They don't say, and only Jones, the hot and sexy friend is covered in, not covered. He is lightly dusted in something that could be ash or just could be dirt a five o'clock shadow. And Dean is covered in nothing. despite having bro selves.
sabotage to get himself there. It's very confusing relationship with fires. - I don't think they seem for people who are experts in both fire and smoke and steam. Do not seem to understand the core properties of any of those things and do not seem to engage with them on any sort of regular basis. Their job seems to be mainly decorating the fire station for various holidays, litigating who will be the Santa or Arbiter of those holidays and cooking a lot of chili. - Yes, and making chili and chopping logs. And I was going to say, I think that the idea of a fireman protagonist is pretty irresistible. And yet they resisted it for most of the movie. - They did. - Except when they go to a Christmas tree farm, which I actually thought was gorgeous. - That was a great scene. I mean, it's so rare to like film something outside and for real in these movies. - A genuinely kind of beautiful drone shot of the Christmas tree farm. - I never thought I would say it. She got out and she said, this is beautiful. And I was like, I totally agree. - You're absolutely right. - I'm so glad you're there. - Well, it was the one time in this movie that I felt like, and this is an issue. There is nothing resembling snow. And so there are no snowmen. Everyone is wearing like three layers at every point in time, but also feel weirdly underdressed for what is I think canonically supposed to be small town Colorado. - Is it? - I mean, the fact that she's outside Denver, then they're later watching a Denver Atlanta AKA Nuggets Hawks basketball game. - Okay, and see, that's not some context I call it. - See, this is what I'm here to provide. I assume this is supposed to be Colorado. - She moved from Phoenix. - She did. - And didn't the parents describe moving there kind of following her because it would be warmer? - Wormer than Phoenix? - No, but I don't know that they were coming from Phoenix. - No, they were coming from Phoenix. - Oh, okay. So maybe they moved there because it would be colder. - And we know that Joey's, that Dean's not dead parents moved to Florida. - They did. - So it's not a Florida climate. - And it's not close enough that they would just pop over for Christmas. - They just simply were not living in Colorado in December. - Yes. - Because of the things that they were wearing. But there is, we do have to just put away some of the desires for realism because when they go to the Christmas tree farm to get no offense. I know it's hard out there and like Christmas trees are expensive these days. They get a very small tree for a very big firehouse. - Yeah. - I was not impressed. - I was not impressed especially when the illustration that Laura has made of what these decorations should look like, which inspires gaffaws from the firefighters. How we supposed to replicate this beautiful thing you created for us? The drawing is a table with a tablecloth and a single tree in the corner. And they didn't even get the right kind of tree. - No. - I guess we should establish that at this point, at Coco Madness and then throughout proceeding meetings, I cannot figure out this guy's deal. He clearly likes her and he will not stop calling her his friend. He immediately, Kamikaze's the whole situation, she felt the spark she likes him. He likes her, he thinks she's beautiful and great and you know, he doesn't have any idea. So he thinks she's a great illustrator. And he establishes that they are friends and then bumps it down to networking contacts. - Tough. - She does not like that and then she gets the ex and then she doesn't really like him anymore. And yet, she keeps going on these little dates with him. - It's very confusing and this is where, again, the guys of we're doing these little favors for each other. - They're both kind of like one half foot into this attempted relationship but it feels manipulative at best. - And I think giving someone an air freshener as a gift is a kin to leaving a necklace on the nightstand. - Okay, what the fuck was going on with the air freshener? - I don't know. Did they delete a scene? - It felt like there was some context there we were missing. - And then he was like, "Are you don't have to give me a gift every time I give you a gift?" Which I can't even remember what the gift he, 'cause the gifts that he keeps giving her are doing his job. It's putting out fires, it's kind of doing stuff with steam. And the gifts she's giving him are emotional labor. - A lot, a lot of it. - And this is where the love is blind. Got me, you know, this is where I got got. So she's in the fire station and he, oh, what is his list of tasks for the party? He's got a little note that he's written on. - It's kind of cute. - It's kind of adorable until you think about the party that he is planning. And he has convinced himself that throwing this party and also engaging more with his community, which is ultimately what he's doing with Laura. It's sort of a, she's all that scenario where she thinks they're kind of going on dates and being friends and he is trying to win a bet. He's trying to win Lieutenant. - Exactly. - Exactly. And to put on this party at the firehouse which he's drawn the short candy cane for on his list, get cups, hand out invites, buy lights, which is marked off he did that. He did the buying. - Thank God. - Make cookies, order desserts, blow up balloons, hang streamers, and let's hope that. - He doesn't even have a tree in his plan. There's like a fake tree in the office we hear, but. - The things on that list that we see him do, I would say he does catastrophically. The things that we see him hear him describe doing, like hanging stringers, we hear that his colleagues basically laughed him out of the room when he attempted to do it. - This firehouse is like 40 feet high. It's like, where are you hanging these streamers, my guy? - You know, he's just put like some tinsel up six feet off the ground and is like, this is gonna fill the vertical space somehow. - The picture he is painting with this list is harrowing. The picture that she quite literally paints on her iPad is, is lovely, it is lovely. She, you know, she does a Christmas tree, she does some decorations very quickly while she's in there. And then when she flips it around to the guys who you said, gaffa, well, first they're like, they say, is that our boys? - Yeah. - I can't even recognize it. - And in fact, no, it's a fictional, it's a fictional depiction of your, no. This isn't, this is how you draw pictures. These are children, these men are children. They've like never seen, but they're not iPad babies 'cause they've never seen an iPad. - That's true. - They're not familiar with the technology. - They can't believe it, but once, but, and this is a lovely thing about a child, once they've seen it, they feel that it can be so. If only Mommy will make it for them. - Well, that's the problem. I think this movie is filled with weaponizing competence. And really, thank you for saying that. - First of all, let's go through, let's unpack first mentally. If you are Dean, you're at the fire station, you're striving to make Lieutenant, you want to be, someone that your peers look up to in respect. - Yeah. - You draw candy canes as one does to decide who will plan the holiday party. And the second he draws the short cane, everyone's like, oh, fuck, we are so screwed. - This guy, this scrooge. - The guy who's aspiring for leadership, who is apparently never celebrated Christmas one day in his life is supposed to undertake a list of seven items that he can't even do successful. - Well, and this happens in almost every profession, including firefighting, I guess, according to this Roku TV film. - Yeah. - Is that like, you know, you start in that line maybe because of like, a talent or proclivity that you have. And then as you move up the line, suddenly you're in management, which maybe was not your original skill or maybe is an undiscovered skill. Next thing, you know, you're making budget decisions. And you're like, I'm a podcaster. I'm not even a podcaster, I'm a blocker, you know? How did we, and how did he get here? And what does he think comes with Lieutenant? He seemingly is a very good firefighter, and this is where he gets so much of his self-fulfillment. But I have an idea that if Laura takes this on as her lifetime, her life partner, she is gonna be looking down the barrel of a really dark time when he finds out like what being a lieutenant in a chief is. - Oh my God. It apparently means Laura is the shadow lieutenant. And Dean is filling that fire suit and puffing himself up and pretending that he did the job. - Every issue that arises in this movie, Laura is the one who solves it. - Oh yeah. - They need more choppers. I guess she's gonna be a chopper. They need Dean to plan the holiday party. Actually it's Laura planning the holiday party, and he's just gonna pretend that he did some stuff. Like he doesn't actually do anything in this movie. - And you know, this is a part of Laura that I related to as well. As someone who creates a lot of unnecessary problems for myself, I think that she is fairly accustomed to putting out fires because she is a type B procrastinator. - Yes. - So she is creating them and she does need that adrenaline to survive. But this is what I related to and I was just kind of like, this must be how the writer feels. I don't, there's like, it's such a weird specificity that is completely true about me. And I assume true about many creatives. - Yeah. - Is that like I, this is writing maybe podcasting, it's the only thing I'm a perfectionist about. I don't, Rob, I don't have a keychain. Like the rest of my life is in chaos. - I don't have a keychain is a fascinating metric into adult life and a window into your psyche that I feel like I just understand you on a fundamentally different level. - Thank you and I wanted to share myself in that way with my favorite network contact. - Thank you. - That it's known on the We're Obsessed Pod on the other parts of this feed that like I have to lose keys. I'm just like, it's everything's in, what I like to think of as a delicate and organized chaos. But about my work, I wouldn't say I'm everyone else's version of orderly, but I am precise. - Yeah.
I feel very strongly about it, and I really related to this feature of hers that is like she's having trouble broaching the writing on the book because she wants it to be perfect and she's not sure that she can achieve it. So she's not even trying, but she knows she'll have to do it eventually. And I really appreciated when I guess her MFA professor just extended that deadline. Just extended that deadline. She did extend the deadline. First of all, I want to watch a whole movie about the MFA professor. That is a fascinating character. - I want to watch a whole movie about their depiction of the MFA, which is the first time we know she's getting an MFA in this small town, which I guess actually that's not unusual to be like in some random town getting in a weak MFA. We find her painting on an easel, something she has not done otherwise. - It's not a coincidence that we don't see the contents of that easel very much. Three people are in a room painting on easels seemingly on the clock to get their degree. While the professor sort of marches around looking at the book on looking at her illustrations on the iPad. - Yeah. - So maybe not even the book at that stage, just like a portfolio of stuff that she has done. - That she's just now seeing. I think this is my favorite moment in the entire movie. When the MFA professor advisor, whoever that is, is scrolling through the iPad and they get into this conversation about the nature of art. - Yes. - And the advisor says the whole thing with labeling something is that you sacrifice a piece of its endless possibility for the security of clarity. Because the problem is. - Slow it down, Rob. Say it again. Say it real slow. - The whole thing with labeling something that you sacrifice a piece of its endless possibility for the security of clarity. Because Laura refuses to put any kind of context or feeling into the work that she's doing. But really what got me is she says all this. And I think it's quite a well-observed sentiment about art and the nature of creation. That if you don't put it in an emotional human context, you've just created a thing that doesn't actually mean anything, that doesn't stand for anything. But then you see the contents of the iPad. And she's saying this about an AI generated picture of a gingerbread man. - And you got to get a label on that to get a sense of security, now. - I was fucking, I kind of wish they played it like this. - It was, I could not believe what I was watching on my Roku TV. - It was unreal. - Because also like she and all props to that actor that an F.A. professor who rattles off this pretty like philosophical concept. And I had the distinct thought like, you're a writer. Like do you ever think of a line and you're like, I have nowhere to put this. - Oh yeah. - I'm never gonna write that book. I'm not, that's not my set, but you're like, but it's good. Is generally with these movies on the rubric, I asked what came first, the title or the plot, and any chance they just built the entire movie around those four words. And I believe that this movie was built around this line, that this writer was like, I got a good line in me and I am gonna just paint gingerbread around it. - Yes, I think there are two things that provide the architecture of this movie. One is this germ of an idea, the inability to make your art precise because you're scared that in doing so, it will lose the ineffitable enduring quality that makes something great. Like how are you gonna make the next amazing children's book? If it is so located in this exact moment in time as the specificity of you, of course, that's just gonna make it doomed to die the same death that we always do. And so engaging with that kind of artistic idea is clearly on this movie's mind. And then it takes it into, I think a larger personality workplace drama, but then also wants to be the holiday spark. This is a writer who has been alone with their thoughts in a room for a very long time and paralyzed by that kind of fear among others I assume as we can empathize with. - Sure. - And then try to shoehorn that into spark and fire and smoke and firefighter puns to a degree that I honestly find admirable at the end of the day, but really this movie has nothing to do with Christmas whatsoever. - You know, admirable and unsuccessful, which of course was Laura's worst fear, worst fear realized. - I think her life is becoming exactly what she feared it always would be. And it's only gonna get worse and worse the longer she is with Dean. - There is a darkness to their coupling and to the way that she works so hard and brings everything together. And he won't even give her, when they like finally cross the bridge of getting past friends, he says, "I like you, Laura." With the deadest voice in the sparkliest size you can imagine. - Well, but you say that. There is a slight sparkle in his eyes, but there is also a vacancy there. - There is. - There is. - There is a darkness. - The vacancy is filled with glitter. Like they're gorgeous, but empty. - That's the way to put it, maybe. Like it is, there's a hollowness behind his eyes that is sometimes a little glitter. There's a hollowness behind those abs. I don't know what's rustling around in there. But the overall package seems appealing enough to Laura. - Certainly. And I mean, she says outright. She's like, "I mean, you're a handsome guy." It's like, "What am I gonna do?" Reset, when they go to that Christmas tree. Okay, this was the only time I was attached to the chemistry or anything of the romance in the film. - Was it the holding? Let me show you how to swing in an axe kind of moment. - Yeah, you know, personally, with the 360 circumference teaching her how to use an axe. - Yeah. - And like, I didn't know that I had the fire man thing. And then I did see him do that. And there was, if you'll allow me a spark. - I think, I felt a spark. - You're more than allowed. - I felt a spark of something. - And even Laura says like, at one point where she's trying to ascertain the truth of that spark or not, like, was it just the uniform? What was I just kind of, you know, was the smoke pulled in front of my eyes? And there actually wasn't anything here in the first place. It's clearly an issue if you want to put it that way for a lot of people. - 'Cause she, I mean, she is battling for this, she's like making herself stay friends with him when she doesn't like him. She doesn't like him as a friend. She is sparked by him. And he just keeps putting it in this friend place because apparently, Rob, did he say early in the movie that he was not going to date until he made Lutinette? - Yes. - Okay. This to me felt like something that came midway through and I was like, when did we all agree on this? - Oh no, no, he says it in the movie. I don't think it's well established at the beginning if that's what you're saying. - They just start saying, like they start acting, and maybe they didn't, I missed it, amongst this, you know, rigorous dialogue. But like, they just start saying, she's like, well, he's just, he's not dating right now. Not something he said to her, really. - No. - He has established that he's like kind of a workaholic and only focused on work, but he didn't say like, I'm not dating right now. - Well, she does establish it. I say this with no judgment whatsoever, asexual and aeromantic. Like, there's absolutely nothing. And I say that 'cause in his case, he is just not tethered to other human beings who do not work at the fire station and literally any capacity. - So, you said it so much more respectfully than I did in my notes, which is just, what is this fucking deal? Many people are wondering, and as the movie goes on, we learn one, Laura's like a serial dater, and she's in a small town. I would say that's very ill-advised. - To be fair, a small town of Hotties. - Small town of Hotties, but she has dated everybody, made the rounds, again, not to shame a modern woman. She's trying to find her person, she's trying to find that spot. - She moved from Phoenix, you know? She's a big city gal. - Exactly. She's trying to test the market and see what's available to her. He's on the total opposite end of the spectrum. - I thought there was gonna be a reveal that she had dated Jones, and they were keeping it a secret. - Honestly, it would have been very down for that. - I know. - Jones and/or Mac. - Really? - Oh my gosh, Mac would have been very intense. - I think a lot could have worked, but it's very clear over the course of this movie. Her banter is just much more advanced than his. - Yes, to the point where. I mean, that might also be a little bit on the level of talent behind the lines, but yes. Like, she gives him the like, oh, how could I ever repay you? And he's like, can you make me an AI slop invitation to my Christmas party? - He is like, oh, could you please give me free labor and rub, deliver it in a ribbon. When he, when she delivers those in invitations, wrap their, I know that they're AI sloped, that they are much more beautiful than whatever he would have been putting together. And they say, when the, when the other firefighters see it, they say, these are easily the best invitations we've ever had. And Dean says, as she and delivers a stack of illustrated cards that she's printed. - Yes. - That doesn't cost no money. She's printed these. He says, thanks. These look great. I was not expecting this. Exactly like I just said it. - That also, it's a mirror is more or less his reaction when he finds out that this girl he's been interested in has formed a relationship with, has culminated her lifelong dream of publishing this Penguin's Children's Book, self-publishing it. - Well, the dream of it being a Penguin occurred about four hours before, but yes. - I don't know. - And is it her who's taking it at all? - No, no. - But he's finally, he has the book in his hands. He's like, oh, this is Laura's book and says nothing about it to anybody. - He's the least of all her. - He's never been surprised by anything, but you know that is part of his job. Early on, when he can tell she's upset about something, he says, you know, you can tell me anything. I'm actually trained to be calm in an emergency situation. - She's a fucking Christy sky. - And he keeps calm and he carries on through everything. - To calm, to carrying on. She literally says, can I slide down the pole? And he just walks right past it.
Nope, sorry he's that we don't have one my guy. She's not talking about it like You know what she's talking about deep, but he doesn't He doesn't he is an AI rendering as well. He really really is and I mean She doesn't just you know do these invitations come up with the whole concept for the party decorate the tree Make him go get the tree She also fallen well actually is volunteered to fill in as a firefighter at the chopathon. Yeah, I don't know how many firefighters work at this Small station, but I know they have to have a team of four and Originally the chief was gonna be on it and I did think that was an interesting decision Because that guy was old. He's quite old I mean he slipped a disk which is why he wasn't a lot of the discipline Even he could not do it. Yeah, none of the other firefighters are available Really I will I will be he's not a leader dean, but he does seem the only person who's really like dedicated to true dedicated to the other guys are just kind of hanging around and he's recently taught her how to chop a tree in a in the one sexual moment of the film and and so they establish that this woman who is about A buck 15. Yeah is gonna compete in the log chopping competition with them. There are two choppers and two log holders and Jones bless him Is holding the log for this woman who just learned how to swing an axe from the reveal that two of the people wouldn't be chopping And they had heard do the chopping was unbelievable. You know what though I think it paid off and I say I say it for this reason because the man who is judging the log chopping competition Which of my first my first note when they needed a sub and apparently the rules are that you can have one non-fire firefighter I was like, why are we not going to get in that hunky guy that she previously dated from the Christmas apparel show? Exactly. What's up with Todd? What's his deal? He was hosting. He was hosting it. He's judging the competition. Yeah. He's the one with the clock who gets to decide who wins and loses. Oh, interesting. It comes down to a last second decision I'm just gonna say one of these two teams has someone who dated a former lover. A former lover. They're on good terms I think the only reason they get the benefit of the doubt on that like photo finish in the log chopping competition Is because she's the one chopping. What do you think about his butterfly tattoo? I found it surprising I found it surprising once he was in a tank top that uh that he had the butterfly I wish they'd explained it a little. I wish I just wish I knew a little more about it I wish I knew literally anything about this man If you told me that the real Dean is dead in a ditch somewhere and this is an imposter who has stepped in to fill his life Okay, interesting Avril Lavigne style Absolutely. I think I mean, I would love to know the origins of the tattoo. I would love to know I mean, he's interested in as we said fire and smoke also interested in flipping tires Like that is his one hobby along with the rest of the fire. I don't know. I don't know. This is a reference that you're gonna know But when they were out in that parking lot uh like flipping tires and kind of swinging around Like an axe a hammer like a jackhammer thing They looked exactly like the gals from fifth harmony in the video work I know exactly what you're talking about Exactly they were hitting tires with hammers What were they doing? You gotta go to work. You gotta go to work work This episode is brought to you by Target. Some people are incredibly easy to shop for Others require a full investigation, three group chats and a very specific understanding of their current obsession Whatever their vibe is, Target has everything you need to nail the perfect gift from trend forward finds and style for the whole family To toys games and exclusive collabs. There's something for every personality And the best part it's all in one place shop target and target.com and gift it. You're all So she gets the deadline extent. Well, she she submits her book on December 13th. Yes, an interesting countdown to Christmas number Can we talk about that first book? Yeah It's called small town Santa And I would say the law has taken the somewhat avant-garde approach of Doing a children's book a Christmas children's book That has no Santa in it No characters or people or animals of any kind. You don't think small town Santa had Santa in it She flipped the pages and it's just the cover of small town Santa is the sketch of the fire station that she's there later in the book A municipal building a municipal building now kids do like fire stations. You know who else like some Laura And yeah, everything we see in the book is a fire truck or the fire station We never see her draw Santa well and originally when she's doing her sort of sample illustrations of like I don't know what this is yet, but I'm inspired by it. I'm creative. It's like it's like a gingerbread Piece or it's like Christmas related things then she meets this guy and she starts going to the fire station for inspiration He's like, oh, you need to write you need some characters I'll come introduce you to some characters and then they go in there and he's like guys look alive She needs some character. She's not gonna base her characters on Jones who is a fuck boy if I've ever seen one I don't think but I also unfortunately continue to relate to this character where it's like yeah When I don't really know where a piece is going Sometimes I kind of latch on to something and then it's all I have and then the deadline is coming and you're like I guess this is it. I guess it's this now I guess it's small town Santa and like about this About this fire station, but it's it's per the per the MFA professor. I mean she gets her with some sick she says Look Laura in my opinion. It's a little too perfect. It lacks whimsy. That's a terrible thing to be told about a children's book She said it's like you sent these drawings off to disciplinary school and they forgot how to play This this woman has been set up with some some zingers and is she wrong From what I've seen of small town Santa Uh, she's not wrong. She's not wrong. It's not Laura. Laura's not doing what Laura does whatever that may be We're still wondering we simply know that this is not it. Yes, and I would say her MFA advisor does what you should do to every perfectionist Which is say you know what take this back. Yeah, this piece of shit book you just gave yeah come back to me in 10 days with an excellent standing generational children's book have fun have fun have fun out there kit what could go wrong I think maybe if you could tell my editors that if every time I turn something and they could just give me 10 more days And I know you've got them on slack. So if you could just and I got you helpful to me. Yes And um, she also extends the courtesy of saying because this whole thing is that if the book From I guess the three MFA students if they rise to the occasion if they're good enough she will email them off to One of her friends who works at like a kid children's book publishing quite prominent. It seems. Yes We all know it by name except for me can't bring it back. It was like ad-win artists ad-win ad- oh that might rewrite ad-win artists Too good. She'll send it off to ad-win artists. She turns in the Santa book. It's not ad-win material And she sends her back with it and she she says I actually send the email on December 23rd. It's a little treat for my friends To read over the holidays these amateur children's And again, this is clearly whatever she was going to send is going to be her friend and I'm sure children's book publishers love their jobs But like it's still a job, you know like I love my job But like no one's like I'm going to give you this little podcast assignment as a treat over Christmas I'm so glad you brought that up because we actually did book some studio space for December 23rd So we're going to need you right here back here for my for my favorite things um right ranking ranking in a bracket cell system in a snake like fashion Thank you so much Rob you're too good to me um So she she says I actually send the email on the 23rd and I've actually set aside some office hours At 5 p.m. On December 23rd She in a different movie. She's the bad boss. Yes, who's like making she is Ebenezer But ultimately here she's kind of like you know the one of the ghosts or something She's like giving her another chance to see this through and and she she tells her have fun Laura be a kid again So Lord's like okay, I'm gonna go bang this guy. I'm gonna go bang this guy I'm gonna go distract myself and then I'm gonna hold I'm actually gonna go get breadcrumbed by this guy I'm actually gonna go torture myself in an extremely what will ultimately become an extremely toxic relationship The aborted date night that they go on I mean if there weren't enough red flags by this point I want to say first of all with all the greatest respect for the firefighting community I did not realize workaholic firefighter was like a archetype It's a shift related job and so you're on or you're off but this guy's like that was my understanding this guy's You want to pick up firefighting some of those ships some of those shifts are difficult You know like you have to be committed to it because if you're in the middle of the night You might be working on holidays Sometimes you're there and nothing's going on you're making chile sometimes you're there and you're risking your life like Yeah, you you have to be Really dedicated to your work, but as you say It is a shift related job. Yes, you don't To my knowledge as dean does hear a bunch of sirens And think they need me that's what spider-man does like you're just a guy even your colleagues are like Why did you do this? Okay, well that was my favorite moment of the film He leaves the date their first date once they finally expose their feelings for each other He and it is a lot of sirens
they go by. It is a small town and that's a lot of sirens. But also, it's just a warehouse. But he doesn't know that at the time. He says they must need me. There's something big is happening in me. And I had the thought that his friends and colleagues say the next morning, which is, I think if they needed you, they'd call you. That's how it works. And they don't call him. But he wants to be needed and he wants this to be his whole thing. And his, yeah, his friends after saying, you know, appreciate y'all for putting out that fire. Appreciate you. Um, our Jones is so upset. Rob, I thought Jones was going to cry. He's clearly a romantic. I misjudged him completely. And they're telling him like he shouldn't have come. And his, his best friend, Max says, you want to know what I think. Appreciate you. Just kidding. He says you were on a date having a good time. And then you looked across the table and you realized you could see your future. And Rob, this is when I knew I was going to cry. They got you when he's like, you're the bravest guy. I know that's what got you. It wasn't, it wasn't the bravest part, but it was the single moment of introspection from Dean when I realized that he has understood anything about his inner workings. And he says she said that I showed up for her, which she did say she said, thank you for continuing to show up for me in these ways that like I didn't know someone could. I don't know what way she's referring to, but I'm glad she felt it. I'm glad she felt it. I'm glad she saw it. And then, and I'm very sad for her that ultimately the person she said it to response was and I will be immediately immediately straight up. I hear one siren. Oh, wait, I got to go. I'm a media to abandon it. Their dates seem really nice. I thought they looked great. They actually did seem like they had a nice report. They were talking about actual human things. They was really dressed up, which I appreciated. He looked great in his blazer. She was honestly overdressed with the occasion, but she looked beautiful. And he said she said I showed up for her. And then I thought, I want to show up for this girl for the rest of my life. And then he left. And then he left. And that is, of course, why Joanne said, bro, you self-sabotached. I mean, here's the thing. And they also give him guff in that fireman locker room for like what you think you're so important. We can't do this without you. Like, so he is, they rough him up a little. Well, he's an empty vessel for glitter who's also a narcissist. And again, I ask, Laura, I ask you, I ask everybody, what's the deal? Like what is the appeal of this man who wants to show up but can't, who is terrified of any kind of commitment for fear of letting people down and does not have a single thought knocking around in here somehow? You've got to watch love is blind. It's not going to make any of these things feel better, but it is going to elaborate on the premise. It'll expand on the human condition enough that I can grab it. You see women have been taught in society that our value is to be married. I see. And so if the options are kind of a dipshit, hotty and not being married at some point, you simply have to make the call. And you will be disappointed with your decision. Sometimes on a stage in front of Nick and Vanessa LaShay. That's brutal. That's brutal. And she didn't have that. There's this whole thing where like he thinks he's getting extended the lieutenant job, but he's actually getting extended to be firehouse Santa. A cast he's beer, a role he's very poorly cast in. Not good. Was the chief Santa? Like actual Santa. Was the chief supposed to be there was no Santa in this movie. He's the closest thing. He had white hair and he's he is playing sneaky little games, which is generally what a Santa is doing where he is like manipulating reality to be that if Dean can't get involved in the community. And if he can't ultimately prioritize family over the job, then he'll never be able to do the job. What kind of willy-wank ass shit was this? It is honestly Santa shit. It's Hallmark Santa. That part does track. And I grew with you about his general sense of life. But it is willy-woy. Yeah, it is. He is wielding a narcissist to gas. You have to turn it down and leave the everlasting gob stopper on the table and threaten to go. And please do not forget that I am God. And yeah, only then will I God annoy you to be my lieutenant. It's not good. I'm kind of coming on to the idea that in a version of the script, this was literal Santa. Yeah. But in the final version, it more comes out as like small town Santa, which is a subsidiary of big Santa is more of a state of mind. Okay. And is an honorary title that is bestowed and then, you know, there's a transactional nature going up the chain. But do you agree that that's the story that Laura wrote in that book and her editor was like, I don't think so. Well, maybe that's the question we need to be asking. Did Laura get too close to the truth about who small times small town Santa really was? And her MFA advisor was like, you know what, we can't take this kind of heat right now. That's right. We are an arts program. Our funding is precarious. We are an arts program in this one building with three students in this one room. So then obviously Laura backpedal, she writes a completely different book that she plagiarizes from a child. I'm glad you breath this up. I want to see Cornelius, great little kid. Really enjoyed his presence in this movie. Very precocious. We needed that. Prococious loves animals, loves cold weather animals in particular. It's reading books about them at home. Honestly. Okay. First of all, on that front, when we learn later from Mac, who also is full of cold weather animal facts that they are a father and son. It's like, oh, of course, that's really both of them. I kind of would prefer the version of this movie where everyone in the town is just reading the same book about cold weather animals and constantly peppering back. They probably are that whole town powers down at night and goes into their pods and absorbs through tubes of facts about cold weather animals. I mean, certainly the weird librarian is doing stuff like that. There's a lot of strange supplementary characters in this story. But turning to child labor to resolve your Christmas perfectionism crisis, I just think is I'm called for. I don't know. Maybe I missed it with the penguin. I don't know why she was so inspired by the little penguin drawing that he gave her, but she takes inspiration from it. She takes inspiration from the book that he's reading at home about how penguins use the stars to navigate. So if it's cloudy, it's like they're blind. Am I a broken man that I found that and that call back to be somewhat beautiful? Just me and Dean. I think that I couldn't find it beautiful because it was read by Joey Grassday as Dean. It's true. So completely spiritless and as though he so he's she gets this book to the MFA professor at five twenty three. Yes. During I guess still during office hours. Just barely before she walks out. She nearly misses it. But we find out once she goes to the party that she has taken the time to print a hard copy of this book before getting it to the professor who makes her breaks her career and didn't show the hard copy to the professor. No, she's a minute night pass. She gives it to her on iPad and I put this on the clock. That professor looks at that book. Did you count exactly 13 seconds? That's so much longer than I thought, honestly. It's so fast. I wrote it like I wrote down she looked at that for 12 seconds and then I dialed it back to seven because I was like she did she looks at it. She lights up. She does. You got it, kid. Like she doesn't even read anything. No. And the whole thing has been that like Laura won't write this damn story. And that the version of the story she did write was so soulless and predictable that Cornelius could just pick out the ending immediately. Yeah. And she didn't even put the kid who actually inspired the children's book. No, Rob. Yeah. She does give him a writing credit. A second build co-biological on one. I think it's only on illustration. Also on a fake book. It's not published, but if it were actually published, this is Cornelius' book. When Dean gets out of the Santa chair and they reunite, he says you publish that book really fast and I do not know if he was kidding. I have no way of knowing from the performance, the text, or the entire movie that I've watched if he was kidding when he said that. It's also information that he didn't have. He has no idea where she's been, what her timeline has been. He hasn't spoken to her in literal weeks. What has this man been up to? He cooked her one dish of pasta delivered it to her house during her met mode and was like, I'm a wonderful man. Mission accomplished. I did it. I did it. How do I do it? Yeah. And then she's thrilled. And she thinks that we're set up here for a good life. And he gave me this dish of pasta. He supported me in all these ways. He did say a line that I liked. He said, she's like, I can't believe we've known each other only three weeks and I can. But he said, I know. I liked my life last month, but I love my life this month. That got you? I thought that was nice. I just thought it was an interesting sentiment and like an interesting way to think about love and the before and after and how it can kind of like take this visor off of your face. You didn't know you were wearing. No, that's not what he says. No, but you could interpret it as right right damn there at the end. They made me think a little. You know what? Maybe this is his appeal. I've been bagging on him. This whole pot of him saying, like, why is this guy like, why would you be interested in him? But if you're blank enough, you just become a Rosetta stone for anyone's problems. Any sentiments whatsoever. You just described a whole type. I mean, that's the thing. The whole thing. The projection that can happen for a woman like Laura to result, like in theory, a workaholic fireman has nothing to offer the perfectionist type B illustrator to work through her issues in the classic rom-confession, right? Like you take a lesson from each other, you somehow. He very clear. He did not help her at all with her task of the film, not a single bit, except for introducing her to her ghost writer Cornie.
But yeah, but she also already knew she actually already knew from from the library. So yeah, like she has her own Independent Adventist. If you take him out of this movie, she is on the same arc. And that feels like a bit of an issue. I but have you not ever met an electric woman just a gorgeous talented like lights up a room truly unique woman And she is dating a piece of plywood. No, generally that piece of plywood Does a lot for her to like shape her type B procrastination life I That's kind of the problem is that I think sometimes as I don't know say an electric woman You're like that's what I need. I need this stabilizing presence And you don't realize that it's not stabilizing. It's just boring It's just bringing you down to the lowest possible phenomenon Yeah, it's stabilizing by weighing you down to the ground of this fake Colorado doubt You can be stabilized at the bottom of the ocean once you're drowned there And that's when you find yourself a children's illustrator like like thinking that you're in love and saying something like I learned something really interesting about fires after doing some research That's how the movie ends with just like just a horribly connected Sort of analogy as she says that she she did some research about fires And what she found out Is that it all starts with a spark. Yep, which she knew she didn't know it before this She had to do the reason no she talks about it at the all throughout the movie She had to do the research to know that that is how fires work and and just imagining her researching fires is so funny And I do appreciate this film forgiving that to me and Really no one can ever take that away from us. No, and like the whole thing is like he doesn't eat He doesn't know a lot about fires. He knows a lot about putting them out and he will He will put out her fire. She will smother this thing by like no will or force of his own He'll just kind of roll over one day and do it on accident and she says you know I didn't research how to put them out and I do want to show her she doesn't have to Finally Dean will handle some problem will resolve itself. Yeah, it's no problem You've done a lot over the course of this pod to convince me of the existence of the patriarchy I'd never really considered it before Um, and I do consider it my goal to educate you So you know, it's thank you for coming here to be educated by me today It's an incredible work you're taking Well, and also the entire cast of love is flying this season Well too swerve ever so slightly Should we salute this movie in some way for defying What I consider to be more rom com convention, which I mean like you're very much more schooled in this area than I am as far as These Christmas movies in particular, but my understanding of the formula is usually Type A career woman. Yeah, type B free spirit man in a small town. Maybe he's a carpenter Maybe he's a cobbler like whatever it is that he does and yes They find a kind of wisdom and balance in each other But what this movie presupposes is I mean you can be the type B perfectionist you can be a career woman Finishing your little children's book on your own god damn schedule and that Sixth wave of feminism. I think the movie is embracing it in a kind of way. I think that's a beautiful character. You've written there today Well, I you know, we're not rooting for these two, but I am I am rooting for Roku And they're and they're skin in the game. Yes, I they're they're taking big swings and they aren't making them perfect they're not uh This was like the most shot in Louisiana Christmas movie I've ever entertained and I just I would I would push them further If you're gonna take this idea, which is loosely loosely Christmas at best Please put us in a vaguely Christmasy location to anchor that feeling because otherwise like this really is just a careerist rom-com of these two people in their workplaces Uh, then if they weren't chopping down a Christmas tree would have absolutely no bearing on and no place in this podcast Yeah, they've got some work to do. It was interesting to see a movie in rough draft form and um Rob I can't thank you enough for joining me on day one of Vendras Thank you for taking us to this place in particular. I never would have watched this movie in a million years It will be stuck in my brain until the end of my day. So thank you Also, I'm sorry. I don't know. No you're welcome I guess I'm sorry And now you understand the patriarchy. Oh my god and with that we will see you Uh back here on Wednesday for an episode of we're obsessed and back here on Friday for the second day of Vendras. Hi. You
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The film *The Holiday Spark* centers on firefighter Dean, a man who avoids Christmas due to a lack of personal connections, but gradually forms a bond with illustrator Laura through shared efforts to plan a holiday party.
The movie relies heavily on fire and Christmas-themed puns, but lacks authentic realism in fire safety, fire scenes, and environmental details, making the premise feel metaphorical rather than grounded.
A major flaw is the absence of conflict or tension—characters remain uniformly positive, and the lack of a true antagonist or emotional struggle undermines the romantic development.
Laura, portrayed as a creative and emotionally invested woman, faces self-doubt about her art, particularly in her children’s book project, which mirrors real creative fears of imperfection and lack of authenticity.
The film’s romantic arc is underdeveloped and confusing, with Dean repeatedly framing their relationship as platonic friendship while Laura grows emotionally invested, creating a disconnect in their dynamic.
The narrative leans heavily on symbolic elements—such as smoke, fire, and the absence of Santa—using them to represent emotional isolation and the difficulty of forming genuine connections.
The portrayal of male camaraderie in the fire station is overly idealized and lacks realism, with characters avoiding genuine conflict and offering only performative positivity.
The film ultimately fails to deliver a meaningful holiday message, instead prioritizing superficiality, clichés, and surface-level charm over emotional depth or authenticity.
Summary:
*The Holiday Spark* is a holiday film that attempts to blend romantic intrigue with a firefighter protagonist’s journey toward emotional connection. Dean, a distant and emotionally guarded firefighter, meets Laura, a creative illustrator struggling to finish her children’s book, as they collaborate on a holiday party. While the film’s premise is charming and its holiday spirit is evident, it suffers from a lack of depth and realism.
The romantic development feels forced and underdeveloped, with minimal emotional tension and no clear progression from friendship to romance. The film’s fire-related plotlines are largely symbolic, with no actual fire scenes or real-world stakes, reducing the authenticity of Dean’s role as a firefighter. Characters remain uniformly positive, lacking conflict or personal growth, which undermines the emotional stakes.
The depiction of Laura’s creative process—particularly her fear of imperfection and her struggle with artistic authenticity—is compelling, offering a relatable undercurrent. However, the film fails to resolve its central conflict, leaving the romance ambiguous and the relationship’s foundation unearned. Its reliance on clichés, fire puns, and a lack of real-world consequences makes it feel like a surface-level holiday fantasy rather than a meaningful exploration of love, connection, or personal growth.
Ultimately, *The Holiday Spark* is more about the mechanics of holiday tropes than about genuine human connection, resulting in a forgettable experience despite its surface appeal.
FAQs
Firefighter Dean enlists illustrator Laura to help plan a holiday party for his firehouse, leading both to reflect on romance, love, and their personal growth during the season.
Yes, Dean's parents are mentioned as having moved away, and their absence is a key part of his backstory, though we never see them directly and their presence is only implied through limited dialogue.
Yes, the film includes fictionalized elements like a life-size snow globe, a Christmas tree farm, and a checklist of events, many of which are never fully shown or realized, suggesting a blend of fantasy and Hollywood fabrication.
Laura's MFA program and her struggle to complete a children's book reflect her creative fears and personal growth, symbolizing the tension between perfectionism and embracing imperfection in art and life.
There are no actual fires in the film—only smoke and steam. The fire department scenes are symbolic, representing Dean's emotional and professional challenges, rather than literal danger.
Their relationship evolves from friends to a tentative romance, but it's marked by confusion, emotional labor, and a lack of clear progression, with Dean often failing to acknowledge or respond to Laura's feelings.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.