Fatherland with Paweł Pawlikowski and Raymond DeFelitta (Ep. 632)
from The Director’s Cut - A DGA Podcast
43m 50s
Pavel Pavlikowski’s *Fatherland* is a deeply personal biographical drama exploring the strained relationship between Nobel Prize-winning writer Thomas Mann and his daughter, Erica, during the Cold War. The film centers on a five-day road trip across divided Germany, symbolizing both physical and emotional fractures. Pavlikowski describes his filmmaking as an organic, intimate process—avoiding industrial methods and instead focusing on emotional authenticity, visual simplicity, and the spaces between moments. He emphasizes collaboration with actors, such as Hans Sischler and August D., who bring profound literary knowledge to their roles, though Pavlikowski deliberately reduces their knowledge to keep characters grounded and human. The film is shot with long, unbroken takes and minimal close-ups, using environment and subtle movement to create a sense of quiet realism. Through real-time editing and constant creative revision, Pavlikowski refines the narrative, inventing new scenes and adjusting structure mid-production. His approach, rooted in emotional truth and visual economy, reflects a broader philosophy: filmmaking as a form of living sculpture, where the audience experiences life through moments of silence and subtext. This method, honed over years, results in films that feel both timeless and deeply human, resonating with themes of family, history, and existential survival.
I mean, in this case I had like such good actors, like Hans Sischler, you know who plays Thomas Mann, he actually knows Thomas Mann's work inside out.
He was even the voice of Thomas Mann's diaries, you know, in a podcast.
So, you know, I had to kind of reduce his knowledge of Thomas Mann, so he could be like normal.
But we just found the tone with him.
[Music]
Hello, and welcome back to The Directors Cut, brought to you by The Directors Guild of America.
In this episode, a writer and his self-imposed exile to return home to his country and family,
and director Pavel Pavlikowski's Biographical Drama, Fatherland, which was screened as part of the DGA's Global Cinema Series.
The film centers on the relationship between real-life Nobel Prize-winning writer Thomas Mann and his daughter, Erica, during the height of the Cold War.
Embarking on a road trip across a Germany and Ruins, they face not only a divided fatherland, but also a deep fracture within their own family.
In addition to Fatherland, Pavlikowski's other directorial credits include the feature films, Ida, Cold War, Women in the Fifth, Last Resort, and My Summer of Love.
Following the Global Cinema Series screening of the film at the DGA Theatre in New York, Pavlikowski spoke with director Raymond De Felida about filming Fatherland.
Listen on for their spoiler-filled conversation.
So, interestingly, we were watching the end credits, and of course, I said to Pavlik, you know, the opening credits were quite impressive, too.
It takes a lot of people to make a movie, and we all know that, but your movies are so, so intimate,
so peculiar to the intimate moment, and in some ways I was watching, we watched Ida again this weekend.
And I said, this is a movie that's about, it's not about the notes, it's about the spaces between the notes, as this is very much.
So, there is all this hardware we have to make a movie, and there you are making that intimate story.
I guess my question is, you know, how do you do it, and how do you keep that focus on it, because your movies are so peculiar and essential to the moment between people?
It's a process of inventing the story, and story with layers, and with possibilities, and about something that's on one's mind, and then like honing it, and distilling it, and distilling it to something that's quite simple.
And which can be told visually, which can be told without plot devices, and, you know, doing scenes that are just there to get you from A to B, you know, just trying to distill it to really strong scenes and strong characters and strong relationships.
And it's a process, you know, it doesn't actually happen entirely at the script level, you know, the script is kind of crucial, of course, you know, to get the whole thing down, so everyone knows what we're talking about.
But then this distilling goes on through the whole process, locations, scouting, looking for actors, talking to actors, rehearsing a bit, changing the script.
And the time is as a useful tool, you know, having enough time to prepare it, it took like five, six months to find the locations, to find the extras even.
So the longer you spend with your story, which has to be strong anyway, to start with, but the longer you spend the more time you have to fish out the boring bits, the useless bits, the functional things.
To home in on things that are really possibly very strong.
So it's a, it's a, it's a very peculiar process, very, it's not an industrial process, it's kind of, it's the opposite of, you know, the kind of industrial process with division of labor, whether right, the right something, and, you know.
And then the director comes along and, anyway, so, but it's like a long organic process with which involves close collaborators from an early stage, so.
So in this case, as in my previous film, my DP and my production designers were involved quite early on, and they became part of the looking for locations and, and just kind of like narrowing it all down to the good bits.
But in the end, it's something that I've I've like developed over over time, you know, just trying to not to the prosaic thing and just explain everything, but just find stuff that's that's resonant and trying to build a film.
Out of these bits, as a result, my films are getting shorter and shorter, I'm afraid, but, but, you know, hopefully they, hopefully they won't get much shorter than this.
I know I was going to say one of the pleasures of watching your movies is it's such a pleasure to see a movie that you actually wish were longer.
Yeah, but your films are admirably under 90 minutes, I think.
Yeah, under 90 that's become my thing, but it's not like some ideological thing I have, you know, it's just the result of the way I work.
I also find a lot of films too long, but that's a separate issue.
I also don't see a lot of close ups, in fact, I don't think any, you don't believe in the close up and you feel like you're very close into some, but, but I think there was some, but, but never like close close, there's always something happening in the shot behind some always some extra business with extras or something that framing us or, you know, some part of landscape.
So, but, but you still, because of the language of the film, you still pay attention, so it's not like you need to have close ups, I think, you know, when you start a film with a six minute shot of the guy sitting on the floor, talking the phone.
And people don't leave this in them, you know, then you know that you can sort of, you know, they're going to stick around on those who leave them, you know, just as well.
Yeah, so, so basically it's kind of, it's like establishing a method or a type of language where people like tune to another thing.
So, another way of watching, so, so they find their close ups, you know, and I give enough time and space for the audience to enter that shot in the world.
So, I think, I think what I found watching, rewatching a number of your films this weekend was I pay a lot more attention to the less you cut.
And, and so what I just in a very practical level want to know is what do your producers think, do you shoot anything else or is that just what you shoot?
No, this is what I shoot.
I think, well, no, I'm a, my producers are friends, you know, they're friendly, they like what I do, thank God by now.
I think on Eda there was a bit of, there was a bit of panic, but, but because Eda won an Oscar, you know, so you are helps.
You know, but it's like they give me space, you know, it was interesting because I've never worked with these actors before. So, the first shot we did was this very difficult, complicated, driving shot through into Frankfurt through the ruins.
We shot that in Poland in, in a city in Western Poland.
And, and it was a kind of, it was a great piece of road that was a bit, you know, there was a German, it had German architecture, so it was kind of perfect, although it was in Poland, but it was a bit that used to belong to Germany.
It was run down, so we didn't have to, we didn't have to do too much to make it even more ruined. But then we created these little scenes there, artificial ruins, a little marketplace shops and all sorts of stuff.
And I had like 120 or 30 extras who were very handpicked, you know, so very good, they all kind of tested individually. And they did little scenes, you know, doing, like going about their business.
And the actors who were watching it, they said, God, this is so fascinating. Why don't you pan the camera there or, you know, or do a close up or something.
And I thought that was interesting, you know, because they, you know, the natural instinct is to show everything that's kind of good that's been done, but I thought, you know, but.
But the idea was that we just kind of see it, by the way, you know, as if we don't pay attention, we just, we just take it for granted, you know, the camera is just pointed in one direction, and we see that with the corner of our eye, but the overall impact is important.
Also, because the shot is quite long, you do actually, or I goes to different things, so, so you do see stuff.
I remember the perverse, that's kind of sense, sense of being perverse, you know, not actually focusing a lot.
all these good bits, you know, just kind of like letting it, you know, come and disappear behind.
So it's interesting to me too that you have the amount of time to prepare your movie.
And I guess, I mean, we're sitting in a room full of crafts people, we're filmmakers, we're
directors, producers, assistant directors, UPMs. I think what probably is on a lot of our minds
is where does this process start? Where does your screenplay start? Where does the financing start?
And when you talk about the months that you have to prepare, I guess the question is, what's
your green light? When do you get to really know that you're going to make this movie?
I think we already spent money before the green light, you know, just kind of on spec, because
very often when I feel there is like, the film has the critical mass to happen,
I kind of convinced people to go with me, even though we haven't quite got the money.
And also have a really good team who are keen to work with me. So I had a very good
Polish production company with very young, motivated people who went out in one of them anyway.
Or two, went out looking for extras in these different locations where we were shooting
and photographed and, you know, that was five months before filming. I think we had some money for that.
But basically, I'm not quite sure, but I think I have very good producer, producers. But one,
in particular, Eva Puszczynska, who creates the Polish producer, who creates that kind of space
and who manages to make everyone feel that this is going to, this is okay, this is going to happen,
you know, and people trust me as well, you know, like in Poland, especially, you know, because I made
that three films in Poland that kind of worked. So it's kind of also like building on what we've
done before, you know, it's like certain continuity of work with a group of people.
But there were kind of like, there was politics throughout, of course, because they wanted
somebody wanted me to cast somebody more famous, you know, that the usual kind of thing. But I kind
of knew that it's going to be fine, you know, they've already spent enough money not to back out. So,
you know, we just keep, so we just keep going. There was a bit of nervousness, of course, you know,
among the financiers. What's the man family involved in this? No, only through the diaries and,
you know, the books. Interesting. I'm curious too, that you, you've made a trip, I think people
now call it a trilogy and probably it'll go further than that of films about that piece of Europe
and where you're from, all before you were born. And I'm curious as to whether you've meant that or
whether you've, you know, I think this is 1948, I think. Yeah, yeah, you've been working about
stories in that world before just before you were born. But let's know about that. Yeah, I was,
was made a set in '62, so I was kind of, I was around, you know, and a lot of the images
and the music and songs I remembered. And the jazz, because you're jazzed. Yeah, in the 1960s,
I was a big, yeah. Yeah, so either was kind of like a weirdly an nostalgia trip, although,
you know, it's a pretty grim film, but there was an element of nostalgia.
Cold War was kind of inspired by my parents, so I, so yeah, in the photo albums of my family albums
and just imagining that period. And it wasn't, you know, but I grew up into that world, you know, so,
so the divided Europe divided world, the world, it was there when I, when I, when I, when I was born
and grew up. So it just always felt familiar and, and my parents were shaped by, by the generation
of my parents. And, and with, yeah, and it's a kind of form of escapism as well, you know, kind
of running away from today, which I have no idea how to make films about. So I don't know. I mean,
it's a, yeah, it's just looking for a world that were in 3D, you know, in a kind of analog world,
I can talk about stuff that's on my mind now, but without having to make a sci-fi film.
I think, I think Cold War, if anyone here hasn't seen it, I, I recommend seeing it instantly when,
you know, when you go home. Cold War has one of the most heartbreaking endings of a film you'll
ever see. And it almost kind of is a closed parentheses. I don't know how you really look at life
beyond what those two people say at the end, what, you know, look what we did to each other.
It is quite extraordinary. And yet it seems to me you're asking the same questions here in this film.
What do people do to each other? How do we, how do we respond in family? What, you know,
how does our lives play out? I'm not sure I have a question here or not. I know it's philosophically.
I just see it in your work. It's true. I mean, there's no answer to it, but yeah, it's about
like life and death and love and all that family. Yeah. And history as well, you know, but is it,
but ultimately, like this film when I watched it, after I finished it, I thought, God, it's about
to be or not to be, you know, in the end, because the clouds at the beginning, this whole monologue,
it's about, you know, how, how do I go home? You know, I can't go on. And Thomas Mann, although he's
irritating in some ways to some people, and a bit narcissistic here and there, but actually he is
on the side of life, as he says. He's against the romantic death cult and so on. And he's like
answering the question of the first thing in a way, you know, love, life, and so on. So there,
I mean, it is about like that stuff, you know, like life is kind of difficult, impossible,
especially in these times. Today, it's impossible in some other ways, but like, but we go on, you
know, how do you go on? Why? So art has something to do with it. Yeah. Clash wants the film in a way.
You begin with him and you never forget him. Yeah. That's the, that's the idea. It's like a
prologue. And then he leaves a strong, he's got the longest scene as well. And it's a, but the whole film
is a kind of triangle love story, you know, with the one piece of it missing. It's about the father,
son, brother, sister, and daughter, father story. And it's a classical triangle, you know, they all are
divided and split inwardly. And that's what carries the film. It's the kind of emotional backbone
of the whole thing. Although it has this other, you know, political, philosophical layer too,
I suppose. But kind of fusing the two things have made me make it interesting. I tend to think
the two that your other films have a political undercurrent, but you don't really need to know
anything about it. Your films are about the people in the, you know, and so that, that kind of
makes me interested in, I think that you were initially approached by the Thomas Mon biographer
for this. And you decided that you didn't want to do his story. You wanted to find a story
within that. I might have. It was the producers, you know, producers sent me the biography written
by Kon Toibin about Thomas Man. And they wanted a, so I'm going to biopic of TV series, I don't know.
And I, yeah, I don't want to make a biopic because it's kind of, you know, they very rarely work.
And I don't make them. But there was this one fragment of Thomas Man's return to Germany in 49,
which was, which really rang a bell. And it hooked me. But it wasn't a story yet. It was the
real, you know, it really happened. But it, but his return took weeks and he went around different
cities. And he was with his wife, Katia, who was much less problematic than Erica. And he was
with a chauffeur and the, and Klaus committed suicide five months before. So I basically just kind of
played fast and loose with the facts, but kept the character, some characters and,
and shaped it into a kind of five day road movie. A bit like with Eda, you know, it's like, I was
going to say a road movie, really, yeah. Is that a genre you like? No, but it helps me to kind of
simplify things and to, and to combine like a movement with other things. And it helps me to keep
it very simple, you know, here he traveled from West Germany or Western part of Germany,
which is an American zone to the Soviet health East Germany, where a new model of society is
emerging. And the trip is kind of quite haunting in itself. And during it happened all these things
off stage as well, you know, so, so it was a kind of, you know, which, you know, a brave attempt,
you know, I wasn't sure it would work, but it felt like something that's worth doing. And,
and with this method of taking away, taking away, taking away, suddenly, you know, started feeling like
it's, it's working, yeah, as a, as a story.
again because we're a room full of filmmakers I think just a couple of really
blatant questions how many days and how much money they were 34 filming days
not all of them full because we moved around quite a bit they were like 17
locations it was difficult to find good bits of architecture and good locations
and and ten million euros which is what like twelve million dollars or eleven
or twelve million dollars yeah so quite a lot for Poland 34 days consecutive
or no I had five day weeks and I and I asked for like a weeks break before the
final five days because I edit as I shoot I from the very beginning you know
everything I that we shoot I like put down and after five days filming and one
day of rest I edit and I see how the film grows and I kind of stop paying
attention to the script which I have in my head somewhere anyway and I'm
looking at the film and what a bit like a documentary you know and where you
know where is it strong what do I need to like where do I need to add some
salt and pepper or what scenes in the future that I haven't shot that probably
not needed but what other scenes could be useful so I invented like five or four
new films four new scenes in this while I was shooting I mean scenes that were
shot in a small room with two people so they didn't you know take much logistics
with a guy kept the two hotel rooms I told the production immediately don't
you know leave the dressing in these two hotel rooms and because I know I have
to change some stuff or add some stuff there so so you know quite a few scenes
were kind of invented there's a result of what I was seeing in the film so so
then this leads me to want to know about your your collaboration with the
actors and when that starts it feels to me that your your method is fluid your
your writing your your creation and your and it feels to me like your actors are
in on it way early earlier than most filmmakers are but you you know you talk
about that yes it's important to cast well you know so I I tried to cast well
and I'm very happy with the whole cast and they all act as a difference so with
a canstitial replace Thomas Mann you know he was so Thomas Mann that you know
it you know I could just invent a new scene I say okay in fact I that scene with
a cigar you know he plays way play does this magic trick and that wasn't
described so I asked him to learn this this trick you know in his spare time
and he did and he was game to do it he loved the whole thing Sandra at the
beginning was a bit thrown by me kind of changing the the dialogue sometimes
or just doing something slightly differently but soon she because she's a
theater actress who likes who likes her text you know to be properly fixed and
she can make even bad lines work you know but I tried to avoid bad lines you
know I said kind of let's just like let's just well actually maybe we you know
she let you know if they're bad lines and yeah not necessarily I mean she is
amazing she can make everything work you know but you know but I could tell
it's not it's better if we don't have this or that or if we just drop a few
lines and change something so she had to get used to it but she did very quickly
because she's amazing and and and and and Klaus I was deal who's at the
beginning he was just like a perfect partner actor you know because he was
like a jazz improviser it's not an improvised scene but like when we were
like working it up he was you know I said sit here move your body here I'm
gonna do this maybe I do this I let's drop that line let's just let's make a
mess of this rather stodgy monologue you know it was actually wasn't so well
written you know like but we can make sure and not even rehearsal because it's
no time to rehearse but because we were just this one shot and I wasn't going
to do any coverage we had a bit of time to kind of fill our way into it and he's
a brilliant brilliant actor you know he was just so he brought so much of his kind
of mental plasticity and physical plasticity and he respected the fact that
the image is the image so so he wasn't you know some actors they don't like to
be imprisoned in a shot like I do but he kind of he totally got it that it's a
that it this is the tableau you know and within it I have a certain amount of
movement freedom but not entirely so every actor is different and then you know
the actor who plays the communist future minister of culture a very great actor
David Streizov he tends to be a kind of comedic actor which I didn't know
because I cast it lately but so so I took kind of stripped down the comedy and
just released this kind of well-meaning baby face you know intellectual
baby face so basically you kind of sculpt with each actor differently you know
because they're all very different different different characters but when you
create a kind of a good atmosphere on the set and kind of laboratory
conditions you can you can you know you can do it and and everyone gets the idea
that this is how it's working that we're not gonna do coverage where you can
just you know we're gonna shoot from different angles and we cut the thing
and it works somehow you know it's got a work in this shot in this framing in
this light and that's the kind of that's the tight rope that we walk but it
releases good things in actors you know when they're good so so if an actor says
if you say that was that was great cut and an actor says can I do one more yeah
absolutely absolutely no but you know but we were like on the same page you know
so it was clear what the film is you know so there was no like narcissistic
moments where somebody wants to do a bravura number you know like nobody
actors or anyone or DP or you know there was just like the film actually dictates
what it is you know from a certain moment when I watch your films I I sense that
everyone is essentially in the same orchestra in the same band everyone is doing
the same story and anyone who makes a film knows at the end of the day you don't
know what went on in making it yeah I guess I'm I guess I'm just asking do you
ever wonder later when you look at a film how did we get there because your
films are so formal and beautifully composed and they feel they feel they feel
so worked out in a in a very natural way you can't imagine them any other way
and yet you must go through quite a mess yeah quite a mess to get there but it's
not like I guess it's not a big mess to get it's not an absurd mess you know it's
like you know it's we're getting that you know I mean the prep is the thing you
know like it's the more you can imagine the film earlier find the locations get
everyone into the mood and and introduce a certain tone on the set the the
better you know then then we're all kind of which you know you still change
things and for example there's this you know because you know the trick is you
know you create a certain kind of you know a style of beauty images you know I
love to tell films and images but you don't want to kill life you know so that's
that's the that's the kind of balance to strike you know you don't want to
strangle or live and make it like just tableau pictures so so actors do you
know have their own some autonomy and different actors have different degree of
autonomy and for example with Sandra who's super intense and wonderfully you know
she there's no empathy passages with Sandra she has to be plugged into the
socket you know she like she has to work from with it and yeah so so there was
there was like one scene where you know where she shouts at her father in the end
she she loses it I shot it and it was good but I thought when I put it in I kind
of knew it's too soft you know so I re-shot it just her angle and she wasn't
sure she said I don't think she'd ever do that you know I'm not sure okay I'll
do it I said Sandra if it doesn't work I'm gonna not use it don't worry so just
trust me and she said okay and it worked really well you know the film needed
it I knew it needed it because I looked at how it was kind of shaping up so
that so there's a bit of dialogue you know with the with the with the actors
they're the living material I mean it's all kind of a bit like sculpting but you
sculpting with living you know with with humans so and that's important that
they are alive you know because I because I can imagine in fact I know that a
lot of people watch my films and they say God it's just just just so cold and
formal I can't get into it there's no emotion okay other people break in
tear break down in tears you know already halfway through that so so you can't you
know I mean
And it's like, it's, yeah, it's, you know, you just have to make it for, you know, for
yourself and people who kind of receive on the same frequencies, you know, as a music
is.
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, your films feel to me like music, they're going to, you know, you go, you're going
to hear, I don't want to verbalize it, what I just, what I just heard you say, which is
wonderful about acting is sculpting, you know, and that's what your films really are.
And to me, their sculptures, they're beautiful and they're, and they, and they, and they
when you watch them, and as, as I've seen several of them a couple of times now, a few times
now, they mean something like good sculpture does a little different each time you see
it.
And I, and I think it's your, it's your ability is a filmmaker to step back and not show
us, but let us, let us learn as you watch that, that's, that's really quite remarkable.
But, but I have to enjoy it when I'm shooting.
So I mean, like, you know, the whole thing is about like when you are shooting, you know,
you, you all the time are reacting to it, say, was this, was this good enough, you know,
was it strong enough?
Was there enough of a subtext, you know, twist, or was this shop grow, you know, expressive
enough, you know, so there's a kind of a constant kind of like given, given take, you
know, and I'm trying to avoid this situation, which I have experience in, when I was making
films in the past, you know, like you just kind of say, okay, it's fine, it's good, it's
good enough, let's move on, you know, and, and we'll cut our way out of problems.
So like, you know, you try to avoid that, you try to make everything and, and do the quality
control all the time, you know, not quality control in a technical sense, but am I liking
it, you know, is it magical, am I, does it give me goosebumps, you know, that kind of
stuff, I mean, not everything can give you goosebumps, but, you know, but as much as possible,
yeah, it almost seems to me, I thought this this weekend when we, we watched Cold War
and, and Eda, I said, Eda, I said to, to my partner, I don't even know how you make
this film, it's so, it's all about the moments between the moments, did you ever feel when
you're making your films have this, this sense of, do you wonder sometimes, did I get it?
Is it fair?
It's my moment there because a lot of your, your movies tend to be about the moments
that are in between the moments.
Because I cut as I shoot, I kind of more or less know what I'm getting, in my recent,
you know, recent, my last 10 years, recent film.
So I'm trying to, like, be sure when I'm shooting, on Eda, I kind of knew that the last third
of the film doesn't work, the way it was written and the way it was scheduled already.
So I was like, on Eda, I was panicking, you know, I was thinking, God almighty, you know,
the film is going to be, it's so good up to here.
And then I've got this like, stupid, like, stupid, plotty thing that, you know, later.
So, and I was, and my idea was, as always, to have like five days in reserve to just get
my way out of trouble.
But because of the budget, which was tiny on Eda, I didn't get these five days.
But then miraculously, I was rescued by a snow disaster.
You know, the snow fell and we had to stop filming for two months, but literally.
And because I didn't have famous actors who'd go on to other films, I actually kind of had
time to sit down and rewrite the last third, find new, a couple of new locations.
I mean, the ending was always what it was going to be, but how to get to the ending.
But I kind of knew it wasn't working when I was shooting, which was kind of like, I was
a bit like a poker player, you know, pretending I, you know, it's all going well, but I go,
but I've learned that, you know, like I can tell when, I can also tell when the script,
you know, is just about right, but not quite right.
That's why I give myself this, you know, possibility of shoot, shoot something at the end.
On, on Fatherland, I was supposed to have five days at the end.
Of course, these days disappeared because we had like weather catastrophes and, you know,
location fell through and whatever.
So in the end, I just had like two days at the end of pickups or new scenes in these two
rooms, you know, which didn't cost anything to keep.
So with these, but these two days were already kind of just enough to kind of, to make the
whole thing, you know, work.
So with experience, you can have you keep your nerve more, but when I'm like supposed
to teach young directors how it's done, I don't, don't do it like me because it's like
a, I've managed to get a kind of enough elbow room to like continue my method because
these films, you know, have an audience and I keep going and I kind of know how to maneuver
whereas I wouldn't wish it on, on anyone to live in this kind of anxiety, you know, like
how the, how am I going to get to the end?
That's the tradition.
I see Ignatica Holland mentioned in your, in your, and credits sometimes and I imagine
she was a teacher.
Oh, yeah.
No, no, she's a friend, but she's much more competent than the director of the research.
She knows how it's done.
I'm kind of just rediscovering the wheel or reinventing the wheel with every film.
We, it is such a privilege to have you here and I think we have just a couple of minutes,
but if there's a couple of questions, we'd, we'd love to take them.
I was, this recording of Bach on, on the organ you're talking about, yeah?
Yeah.
No, no, I did it.
I mean, it's not an old recording.
It was like I, I just got a friend who doesn't even play the organ.
I asked him to play that chorale on an organ as badly as possible.
I mean, he's a good pianist, but I might just use like, it's a really bad version of,
of Bach.
Yeah.
Well, that was the idea that it's sort of, it's, it's a broken organ and the organist
is just a village organist, you know, but he still plays a great piece that kind of affects
everyone.
Another question, anyone?
Your question is about collaborating with actors and reversing prior or, or how do you
do it?
I, yeah, I, I try to rehearse a bit, you know, but it's not like rehearsal with, uh,
in situ.
Unfortunately, it'd be great to rehearse in situ, but there's never time.
I cast well, uh, that's some key.
And then, um, then then we talk, yeah, then we talk for sure.
I mean, in this case, I had like such good actors, two of whom, uh, like Hans Sischler,
you know, who plays Thomas Mann, he actually knows Thomas Mann's work inside out.
So, you know, he's just, I had to kind of, he kind of reduce his knowledge of Thomas
Mann, so he could, he could be like normal and alive, um, but we just found the tone with
him, you know, he wasn't a million miles away from the real thing because he's a real
writer and intellectual and a super kind of erudite and elegant without having.
So I didn't need to rehearse much, you know, um, just to find the tone, you know, but
then because I don't move the camera much, you know, once you set up the shot, you kind
of like, uh, you have the freedom to kind of, to, to, to massage it and to place as well.
So, um, with Sandra, there was a bit more talking, you know, to kind of, uh, just to talk,
you know, and, and we did readings around the table as well, which, which, you know, helps
me to listen to it and just spot some problems or possibly better ideas.
With Klaus, uh, in other words, August D. who plays Klaus, I just met him once before and
I met him just to say hello and, you know, I love you to be in my film and I met him once
for like, uh, maybe an hour away sat on the floor and kind of were, you know, in a, in an
office and tried to kind of, you know, do that text.
The beauty was that he, he knew Klaus Mann's books really well, you know, the, the, and
nobody else knows them much, you know, it was kind of rare, um, stroke of luck, you know,
and not only did he know them, he liked them and he, and he brought that kind of, uh, or,
kind of associative, random, um, literary style into his monologue, uh, because Klaus Mann
and like Thomas Mann, who had beautifully chiseled prose, Klaus Mann was more hectic and,
you know, he had, you know, he, of course, he went in the opposite direction to his father.
But anyway, so I had an actor who kind of knew that stuff, you know, much better than I did,
because I only knew one novel by Klaus Mann. Um, so, you know, so my work was made easier by the
fact that I cast where, you know, and I was lucky and Sandra is a genius, you know, so she kind of,
she even, when she saw the, you know, the thing in the script even the situation,
you know, there wasn't much to be discussed, you know, I mean, like it's clear what the task and
these scenes is, you know, what the subtext is, what the, um, so then, you know, there's a little bit
of rehearsal, but not like serious rehearsal, because like serious rehearsal, for me, very often kills
the thing, you know, so, so actually by the time you shoot it, you know, everyone is too, too,
like limited to what we rehearsed, you know, and to restrain. Um, no, this film I didn't.
you know, I mean I like six, seven maybe. I did more than I needed to because I had a lot of
a time when the actors were in the foreground, I had extras doing stuff, you know, and extras were
kind of important because I wanted that kind of historical background to be present all the time.
So very often, sometimes not often, I kind of had to redo it for some stupid reason that
somebody was smoking in a fake way or something, in the background, something. But in Cold War,
I did quite a lot of takes. You know, I would be getting famous for doing like 30 takes, you know,
here and there. Without coverage. Without coverage. Yeah, I mean, it's just quite extraordinary
that way. Because there's stuff happening and they do that stuff and there's music and there's
all sorts of things going on. So it was rehearsal, but also, you know, sometimes one actor is firing
and the other one isn't, you know, I was just trying to make sure that everything worked in no one
shot. So, you know, different actors, you know, depends, you know, some actors are great beings,
spontaneous, and then you have to just kind of work around them and capture that. Other actors can
repeat the same thing over and over. You know, other, you know, it's just whatever works, you know, there's no,
I mean, this one, you know, everyone expected me to do many takes, but I didn't, you know,
plus high actors were really like spot on. We have time for one more question. Anyone?
On the credits. I Italy and Greece and the credits. Well, it's just the madness of credits these days,
you know, I mean, we did have a Greek cop producers, you know, put some money in, put money in it.
And then I was hoping to have a shot of can on a rainy day, you know, for the very beginning.
And of course, you can't shoot in can. Looks nothing like can of the past. And I found the place
in Santa Margarita and on the Ligurian coast, which kind of had a good bit. But I wanted the, the
problems to be, you know, tossing about in the wind and the sky is being, you know, dramatic,
and it never happened in the way that was good for months and months. And it was just like a second
unit. And then I was in Athens once completely by accident. And then any fantastic storm. And so I
kind of took a car drove around the Athens River as it's known. And there was some palm trees. And
so I asked the local producer to organize a camera and a cherry picker. And then and we just shot
these two palm trees in the wind that you see behind the window in Claus's hotel room. But as a
result, we have 15 credits, you know, like a driver of the cherry picker. It's like like the assistant
to the producer, you know, it's madness. But everyone's wondering whether it's all this money going,
you know, shooting all over the world. And it goes to those opening credits and the final credits,
some of the longest credits ever. That's what filmmaking is about. But the less money you have,
the more credits, you know, because you have to be nice to people, you know. What a great, great privilege
it's been to have you here. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Thanks for listening to another DGA Q&A. The director's cut is available wherever you listen
to podcasts. And please share, subscribe, rate, and review. We'd love to hear your feedback.
And you can help fellow film buffs find the show. Thanks again for listening. And we'll see you next time.
This podcast is produced by the director's guild of America.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Director Pavel Pavlikowski emphasizes a deeply intimate, organic filmmaking process that prioritizes emotional resonance over plot devices and industrial efficiency.
His films are distilled through extended pre-production and on-set experimentation, with scenes and structure evolving organically as the film is shot and edited.
Pavlikowski avoids traditional rehearsal, trusting actors’ spontaneity and allowing the film’s tone to emerge naturally through collaboration and lived-in performances.
Key actors like Hans Sischler and August D. bring deep knowledge of Thomas Mann’s work, which Pavlikowski carefully balances to ensure authenticity without over-accurate biographical fidelity.
The films rely on long, unbroken shots and environmental detail to create a sense of realism and immersion, simulating the quiet observation of real life.
Pavlikowski’s process involves constant self-assessment during filming, where he edits in real time to refine the film’s emotional core and identify necessary changes.
The narrative structure of *Fatherland* is shaped by a five-day road trip, focusing on the fractured family dynamics and political tensions of Cold War-era Germany.
His films are described as "sculptures of emotion," blending political themes with personal family stories to explore universal questions of love, loss, and survival.
Summary:
Pavel Pavlikowski’s *Fatherland* is a deeply personal biographical drama exploring the strained relationship between Nobel Prize-winning writer Thomas Mann and his daughter, Erica, during the Cold War. The film centers on a five-day road trip across divided Germany, symbolizing both physical and emotional fractures. Pavlikowski describes his filmmaking as an organic, intimate process—avoiding industrial methods and instead focusing on emotional authenticity, visual simplicity, and the spaces between moments.
, who bring profound literary knowledge to their roles, though Pavlikowski deliberately reduces their knowledge to keep characters grounded and human. The film is shot with long, unbroken takes and minimal close-ups, using environment and subtle movement to create a sense of quiet realism. Through real-time editing and constant creative revision, Pavlikowski refines the narrative, inventing new scenes and adjusting structure mid-production.
His approach, rooted in emotional truth and visual economy, reflects a broader philosophy: filmmaking as a form of living sculpture, where the audience experiences life through moments of silence and subtext. This method, honed over years, results in films that feel both timeless and deeply human, resonating with themes of family, history, and existential survival.
FAQs
He distills the story through a long, organic process, focusing on strong relationships and intimate moments, often removing unnecessary plot devices to keep the narrative simple and emotionally resonant.
He avoids close-ups and favors long, unbroken shots that allow the audience to immerse themselves in the environment, using the surrounding world and subtle details to convey emotion and atmosphere.
He casts actors who deeply understand the material, such as Hans Sischler, who knows Thomas Mann's work, but intentionally reduces their knowledge to keep the characters grounded and realistic, relying on spontaneity and chemistry on set.
He edits as he shoots and often invents new scenes mid-production, using the footage to assess what works and what needs to change, resulting in a flexible and evolving film structure.
Inspired by Thomas Mann's return to post-war Germany, the film explores themes of family, love, and political division, reflecting Pavlikowski's recurring interest in Cold War-era Europe and human relationships.
Pre-production takes several months—often five to six months—for location scouting, casting, and building the film’s atmosphere, with filming usually lasting around 30 days, followed by extensive editing and refinement.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.