Go back

Family Dysfunction Leads to Murder: Who Killed Gary Farris?

1h 27m 10s

Family Dysfunction Leads to Murder: Who Killed Gary Farris?

The disappearance of Gary Ferris, a 6'5" father and community pillar, in July 2018 on his 10-acre farm in Georgia became a complex and emotionally charged case. Initially, concerns centered on his known health issues and "spells," but the discovery of a bullet in his ribcage and a missing gun shifted the focus to homicide. Melody, his wife, was the primary suspect due to a history of financial disputes, emotional outbursts, and an affair with Rusty Barton, whose phone records revealed frequent contact with her and confirmed she knew about his death. Key evidence—including phone tracking, CPAP machine data, and blood traces—established the murder occurred on July 3 between 9:30 p.m. and 1 a.m., with only Melody and Scott at the property. Melody’s lack of emotional reaction to the discovery, her false claims about the farm, and her possession of a second-person credit card and birth control further exposed her guilt. Despite challenges in proving physical means of moving Gary’s body, the prosecution argued she had both motive and opportunity. Scott’s early suspicion of a missing gun and deletion of trail camera footage raised suspicion, though no direct link to murder was proven. Melody was eventually arrested in 2019 and convicted in 2024 on charges including malice murder and concealing a death. The case underscores deep family dysfunction, emotional manipulation, and the difficulty of proving intent in high-stakes domestic violence cases. While the physical evidence remains circumstantial, the timeline, motive, and emotional inconsistencies culminated in a conviction, highlighting how family dynamics and hidden relationships can drive tragic outcomes.

Transcription

15288 Words, 80457 Characters

English
(upbeat music) Hello everyone and welcome back to another episode of True Cram with Kendall Ray. Thank you so much for joining me today and if you're new to the show, then welcome. So guys, today, oh my God, the case that word me talking about, I can confidently say it has just had my head spinning. This case is just riddled with family drama and dysfunction and lots and lots of finger pointing. Today, we're gonna be talking about the murder of Gary Ferris, who is a father of four, a very well-loved man. He was known as Big Daddy, which I will explain. And you may have heard this case referred to as the Ferris Wheel, which is a name that their family is not all that fond of, but that is definitely what the media has dubbed it. We do have a lot to go over this one is quite complicated. Like I was saying, we're gonna be talking about Gary Ferris and he was born on June 27th, 1960, into Scumbia. Alabama, to his parents Betty and Jean, along with his three younger siblings, John Patricia, and Sherry. Now, he was a lot of things, but one thing that really stood out to me was just how everyone spoke about his work ethic and his drive. He received his bachelor's degree from the University of Northern Alabama and his Juris Doctor degree from the University of Alabama Law School. And while there, he was the editor-in-chief of the Alabama Law Review. And on top of that, like I mentioned, in the beginning of the episode, he was a husband and a father. And he and his wife actually met when they were just teenagers. And her name is Melody. And by his sophomore year in college, the two of them were married and pretty quickly had their first child. Now, Chris was their first born son, but he was followed by three more kids, Scott, then Emily, and then Amanda. And while Melody was home with the kids, Gary was at the office. After graduating, he first joined the law firm Burr and Forman. As a commercial real estate attorney in Birmingham. And then in 2013, due to his success, he moved his family to the Atlanta area, where he was asked to open a new branch of the firm. And Gary was a hard working family man through and through. I mean, I truly mean it. And when the kids were growing up, family vacations were always tied to places where he had work seminars, but despite his long hours and very demanding responsibilities, as you can imagine, he still made time to coach baseball teams and attend school events. He was still very involved in his kids' lives. And they said they remember their childhood as a very happy one for the most part. They had kind of a traditional setup, you know, a dad who worked to provide for them and then a loving mother who took care of everyone. And Gary, like I mentioned at the beginning of the episode, was nicknamed Big Daddy because he was just this big, friendly guy who everyone adored. And when I say Gary was big, I mean that literally. He was like six foot five and weighed about 300 pounds. And he would think that it would be quite difficult for someone that size to go missing, but Gary did. So that brings me to July of 2018. And I think to best understand the nature of his disappearance, you'll need to understand a little bit more about their living situation. So when he and his family moved in 2013, Gary bought a 10-acre hobby farm in Alfa Reda, Georgia. Now this really seemed to be Melody's dream, okay? So they had horses, goats, chickens, and it was exactly what she had always wanted. And in 2018, that's where the two of them and their son Scott were living. And by that point, the kids were all grown up and several of them already had families of their own, but Scott ended up living in this kind of apartment like studio converted situation above the barn after serving in Iraq. And he worked on the farm, taking care of the animals and the property. So that's kind of how that arrangement came to be. So with all of that in mind, let's go to July 3rd, 2018. And on that day, everything was very business as usual. It was a Tuesday and Gary's oldest son Chris stopped by with his daughter so she could see her grandparents and say hi to the ducks that lived on their pond. And she had asked her grandma if she could spend the night, but Melody said no. And then at some point, her and her dad went back home. The next day, though, was the 4th of July. And of course, here in America, that's a holiday. And so the two of them came back over due to the holiday. And this night, she was allowed to sleep over. And I believe one of her cousins was also being dropped off. And so it was the two of them playing on the farm the whole day. And then they were going to have this sleep over. And they were very excited about it. And at some point, the two of them wanted to find their grandfather. They wanted to find big daddy, but they weren't able to. Now, it's important to note that this property was so big that you could definitely go a full day without seeing someone who was living on the farm or who was at the farm at some point. However, the next day, July 5th, there was still no word or sight of Gary. And that's when everyone started to worry. So that morning, between 8.30 and 9, Scott says that he woke up and just started his day as usual. He went down to the barn to check on the animals. Then he got ready to leave the property to go get a haircut. And as he was on his way out, he noticed that his sister Amanda was sitting on the porch talking with their mom. So he decides to stop and say hi to them. And this is when Scott says that his mother melody told him that they couldn't find Gary. Now, Scott didn't think that his dad could have gone that far because he could see that his RTV and his Mercedes were still parked at the house. And if Gary was going to go anywhere, he would have taken one of those two vehicles. Also, Gary's physical health wasn't that good. And basically, it was a well-known thing that if he was on the property, he was going to be using his RTV. So Scott figured he had to be close by. How far could he have gotten, right? But according to Melody, neither she nor Amanda could find him. So long story short, he decides to start looking through the house and see if he could find him or maybe even any indication of where he might be. And immediately, there were two things that stood out to him. The first being his dad's CPAP machine was still next to his bed, which Gary slept with a CPAP machine every night. He had sleep apnea. He needed it. So this immediately tells him that his dad hasn't left for long if he did leave. He hasn't gone on a business trip or anything like that because he would not leave without a CPAP machine. And the next thing that stood out to him was the fact that his dad's wallet wasn't on the dresser, which, according to Scott, the only two places Gary kept his wallet was either in his pocket or on the dresser in the primary bedroom. Now, it's important that you know that the primary bedroom was not where Gary actually slept. And this is going to become obvious quite quick in this episode, but Gary and Melody's marriage was not a happy one at all. The two of them had sort of divided the house up. He actually had a whole different part of the house where he lived pretty much all the time. If he was home, he was there where he was like out on the farm stuff, but they were rarely spending time together. So he kind of had his own sort of man cave situation set up and that included his own bedroom, his own living room space. And all of this was downstairs just off of the kitchen area. However, according to Scott, Gary still used the primary bedroom to store some of his things. But anyways, when Scott sees the CPAP machine and no wallet, he thought that was really, really weird. And then he thought it was even weirder when his mom approached him saying that she had the wallet. And I guess she told him that she had found it in his car. So at this point, alarm bells are starting to ring for Scott because it looked like his dad should be home, but he wasn't anywhere in the house. And like I said earlier, Scott felt like how far could he have gotten without his two vehicles and in the health that he's in. And he also knew that Gary wasn't in the barn because he didn't see him there all morning. And he was there earlier. So initially, Scott's mind is going towards something has happened to Gary. Like he's had some type of health episode somewhere on the property. Keep in mind, again, this is a huge property. He thought maybe he had a heart attack or something like that. And he was out on the farm somewhere. And to explain his health a little bit more, Gary was a smoker. And apparently, he also drank a case of Mountain Dew per day. So there was that. But in the years leading up to all of this, he had also developed what he had called these spells, where he would get very weak and just sick out of the blue. And no doctor could ever diagnose him with anything. And three months prior, he actually ended up in the hospital with one of these spells. So now that he's missing, like I said, Scott was worried that he was having some sort of health episode, one of these spells, something along those lines. And so after looking through the house, he gets onto the RTV and starts searching the property, which I can imagine would be a very, very scary feeling. And this is roughly around the time that Amanda ends up calling Chris to let him know what's going on. And he was actually already on his way to the farm, because if you remember, his daughter had spent the night there, so he was coming anyway to pick her up. And his reaction was very similar to Scott's. He first wanted to know if his vehicles were there, and he wanted to know about his wallet and CPAP machine. And if they were still at the house, and when he found out that all of those things were still at the house and Gary wasn't, he came to the same conclusion as his brother. Worried that something happened to him and he is somewhere on the farm. So he rushes there to help everyone else look for him. [MUSIC PLAYING] Now, when he got there, he sees Amanda and Melody are sitting on the front steps outside the house, and so he, just like Scott, starts looking around the main house area. But eventually, he makes his way outside. And when he does, he sees his brother and mom walking towards the tree line. And that's when something clicked in Chris's brain. A few days prior, Gary had mentioned that there was a burn pile somewhere on the property that he was planning to set on fire. Now, if you don't know what a burn pile is, it's just a pile of dry vegetation that farmers and people will intentionally set on fire to get rid of dead branches and leaves and stuff like that. And I guess Gary was known to make these quite often and really loved a good burn pile. So when Chris saw them walking that way, he remembered that that's where his dad was planning on burning a bunch of stuff. But before he even got the chance to make it over there, Scott and Melody had already made the discovery. According to Scott, he had just finished checking the trail cameras, which is important. We'll come back to that later. And he was already making his way over to the pond area. And then he gets a call from Melody. She wanted to know if he had thrown a dead goat on top of the burn pile. And Scott said, no, I did not. And so as soon as he got over there, that's when he saw the bones. I guess he gently lifted up the corner of what looked like a skull. And as soon as he saw teeth and an eye socket, he just knew right away that this was his dad. My father had come up listening, and we just searched the properties of a small farm. And I just found something here to find that does look good. There was a huge bone brush now, just something to find that could be him. I don't know. All right. Now shortly after this call, emergency services arrived, and considering Gary's body was almost entirely ash and bone, they could tell that the fire had been burning for a while. And right away, they began to investigate, starting with Melody. The lead investigator brought her back over to the house, and that's when she shared what she knew. Now, according to her, the last time she saw her husband was on the evening of July 3rd. It was around dinner time, and he had come into the kitchen asking if she was going to make them something to eat. But she says she told him that there was already food in the fridge, and that if he wanted to eat, he'd have to go and get it himself. And she also mentioned that this was the night he lit the burn pile. Melody said that she remembered telling him that if he needed to put it out before he went to bed, so that it didn't actually catch the whole property on fire. So he started the fire before you guys discussed it. It was long back to say, I mean, I don't know, I mean, when we were in and out discussing all that. But, you know, I mean, at some point time, when we were discussing the jar, and they said, why did you start that fire and I know what difference does it make? Well, because it's hot, it's orange, it's July, it's, you know, I give you 100 reasons. You set miles on fire less than four, you didn't know, I just don't know if they hear you back off some fire. And then after that, he walked downstairs, and she figured that he was going to go check on the burn pile before going to bed. And according to her, that is the last time that she saw him. Now as for the fourth, Melody said that she didn't see him at all. But she also said that it wasn't that abnormal to go a day without seeing one another, considering they slept in separate bedrooms, and because the property was also so big. Although she says that the only reason that they slept separately was because his seep hat machine was loud, and she conveniently just leaves out the part where their marriage was in absolute shambles. And she did tell investigators about these spells that Gary was having, and how sometimes he would spend entire days unable to do anything because of how sick he was. And she did make sure to mention that Gary was also a smoker, who drank more than 12 sodas per day, and that he was on blood pressure medication. And of course, all of that suggested that he may have accidentally just fallen into the burn pile during some kind of health-related episode. And her story had some overlap with Scots, mainly that he had also last seen Gary on July 3rd, that the fire was lit that night, and that he wasn't a very healthy guy. However, those were the only similarities, because it was clear right from the jump that Scots had a different theory about what happened, and he was quick to point the finger at his mom. And when I say quick, I mean quick. In like 13 minutes of law enforcement arriving on scene, he mentioned that a gun was missing from the property, and suggested that she may have something to do with it. And specifically, he said that he found a pistol in a cabinet drawer behind the couch in the downstairs living room. And when he went to look for it, it was gone. Now it didn't take long at all, before a discovery was made that seemed to support what Scots was saying. Okay, so while the scene was being processed, a fragment of a bullet was found lodged in Gary's rib cage. And of course, with this discovery. Any idea that Gary had some type of health issue, or one of these spells and had fallen into the burn pile, went right out the window. And this was information that investigators kept to themselves at first. They first swabbed Scots in Melody's hands for gunshot residue, which did end up being negative for both of them, and then they brought them to the station to continue being questioned. And this was the point where investigators shared their findings. So Scott, someone that told us about a month and a half ago, they saw the pistol in the basement. The AT&T guy was there to do some repairs, or to do something, who was trying to find a remote, found a pistol. That pistol's not there anymore. Where? In Melody. There was. There's only thing about a pistol. So you were the last one to see Gary alive until then, right? Now in her interviews, Melody swore that she did not hear gunshots the night of July 3rd. She did say she remembered hearing the sounds of fireworks and firecrackers, which is very common even the night before 4th of July, the whole week of 4th of July. I feel like I was hearing them every night, even where I lived, like in the suburbs. But of course, that could be a very convenient lie. And then when she was asked if Gary had any issues with either of their sons, she was very quick to point her finger at them. And according to Melody, it really just all came down to money. She explained that her husband was basically an ATM to Emily, Scott, and Chris, and claimed that all of them were stealing from and taking advantage of him. So all of their kids except Amanda. She said that Chris had been caught stealing checks from him, and that Emily was married to someone who had been in and out of jail for theft. And I'm not sure if that meant stealing from Gary though, but anyway, Melody placed just a huge emphasis on the fact that her three kids were using their dad for his money and that it was causing a ton of problems within their family. And she specifically really emphasized Scott. She said that they had a bunch of tension and had recently gotten into a big fight. And when it came to guns, she said that Scott was the one who had a pistol. And she also pointed out that this pistol that he had, he claimed, was stolen from him years ago. But that she had seen one in the barn at some point. "My dad had some pistols, but in a Scott's name, and I don't know what's left of it. I don't know. I remember Scott, he was in the military, and Scott took them to Colombia where he was. And I didn't know that there was a pistol over the barn for a while, and I haven't seen it in a long time. It's got to be it, put it away." "Do you remember what kind of pistol were, why, don't we have that gun?" And she also made it sound like Gary was just finally fed up with all of their behavior and that he was going to stop being so forgiving when it came to their spending. And I guess there were text messages between Gary and his kids that alluded to him cracking down, which based on that, it sounded like this could have been a financially driven murder with many of them having a possible motive. But investigators also had to consider other usual motives like infidelity, for example. However, Melody was adamant that there was no unfaithfulness in their marriage. Someone was good in that department, and she also said that Gary didn't have any life insurance, and there were no assets in her name, therefore making it seem like she wouldn't have anything to gain from this. But her son's on the other hand, she said they definitely did. And Scott and Chris completely denied her accusations, though, sure their dad was very generous with his money, but they said it wasn't anything like what Melody was trying to make it seem. Scott, for example, says that he earned his dad's money by living and working on the farm, whereas she said he wasn't working at all and was simply mooching off Gary. Now as for Chris, he denied her accusations of theft, and he said that any money he did receive his dad was in good faith. Now, the two of them were not hesitant at all when they were asked what they thought happened. They both agreed that their mom should be looked at. They explained that Melody loved soap operas. She loved the show Days of Our Lives, I believe it was, like the soap opera, right? And she wanted to live the soap opera life, like everything she did was very dramatic. And she was someone, according to them, remember all of this is coming from them, but she was someone that you did not want to piss off. And if one person upset her, they all took the brunt of it, and it took very little to anger her. Plus, according to Scott, there was that missing gun. So based off of their calculations and just their experiences and how they felt, all of this pointed to Melody. However, investigators did find it a little odd that Scott brought up this missing gun before he even knew that his dad was shot. And that is certainly weird, isn't it? They also found 38 caliber ammunition in Scott's dresser, which is the same caliber as the ammunition used on Gary. And to be clear, that's not to say it was a matching bullet. I don't think they were ever able to actually determine that, but it was the same caliber. Although that being said, Scott explained that sometimes heinous friends would go out shooting and it wasn't uncommon for ammo to be left behind. And then another weird thing investigators noted about him was the fact that he had deleted all of the images from one of their trail cameras. So remember back when Scott was looking for his dad initially before they found him in the burn pile, one of the things that he did was go check their trail cameras. But apparently when he didn't see anything suspicious on it, he just deleted the footage, which is undeniably very odd, right? It's very suspicious. But Scott said that it was just kind of a habit that basically he was constantly deleting the footage to free up space on the SD card, and I don't have a trail camera, but I've talked to other people who have them. And if there's nothing interesting on the trail camera, oftentimes you delete it. So when there was nothing on the trail camera, but like a few squirrels and raccoons, he just erased it, which is weird in this specific situation when your dad is missing, you would think you just want to save that footage. And also you would think you wouldn't even have the time or like the thought to delete that footage in that moment, but anyway, it's definitely not looking good that he erased it. And I'm sure you're starting to get the picture here. This investigation is quickly turning into a finger pointing match between everyone in this family. And so in order to try and narrow down who could have done it, investigators really needed to start by trying to understand the timeline of when Gary's murder took place. And the boys were able to help add context to this timeline. So like I said earlier, Chris had come by on the third to let his daughter hang out and play. And he says that he last saw his dad around 4.45 pm. And if you remember, Gary mentioned to Chris that he was going to light that burn pile, which was also corroborated by Scott. He says he last saw his dad that day around 1 or 130 pm at the Cherokee Ranch restaurant. But after that, he went to the lake with friends. And then after that, he was at one of their houses until about 10.55 pm because that's roughly when he said melody called him asking if he could come home and help wrangle some horses that had escaped. But by the time he got home, which was about 11.30 pm, they were already back where they belonged. And this is when he said he saw the glow of the burn pile in the distance. So now there are three witnesses saying that they saw a fire that night. So investigators were confident at this point that the fire was started on the third. But what they didn't know at this point was what time Gary was put into the burn pile. So in order to determine that, they needed to look at the crime scene. And I'm not talking about the burn pile, I'm talking about a hundred yards away inside the house. So based on blood evidence, they found inside the house. Investigators thought this is where the shooting took place. However, since this was a suspected shooting, you might think that there would have been a decent amount of blood somewhere, especially considering that there wasn't a bunch of blood found in or near the burn pile itself. But when investigators did bluestar testing inside the home, the blood they found was minimal. But of course, minimal isn't nothing. Droplets of blood were found in the kitchen, leading down the stairs towards the basement area where Gary, as I explained, spent most of his time. There was also some blood found on the wall by the front door and evidence that some blood had been cleaned up, although it wasn't clear how much. But that wasn't all. While they were processing the downstairs living room area, a crime scene investigator found a spent bullet casing at the edge of the rug, which further suggested that he was shot inside. The odd thing though was that there weren't any holes in the wall or in the floor to indicate that bullets' trajectory. And there also wasn't any blood near where it was found. It was almost like someone had just dropped it there, maybe while cleaning up or something, because the place they found it just felt super random. It felt maybe like an accident. Regardless though, investigators used all of this to develop a theory, which was that the first shot was fired in the kitchen, and then Gary was shot again as he came down the stairs and out the sliding glass door. And if that's the how, they still need to know when. If they can figure out a window of time for the murder, then they can try to match it to whoever was at the house. And interestingly, Gary's CPAP machine ended up being a big help. It turns out that this machine recorded user data. And it was able to determine that he hadn't used the machine on the night of July 3rd. It also showed them that he normally went to bed between 11 p.m. and 1 a.m. And also that he never went a night without it. And because he didn't use it, they were now certain that he was killed sometime on the night of the 3rd. And knowing that Gary's phone was tracked to a restaurant that night, which placed him back at home around 9.30 p.m., they think that he was killed sometime between 9.30 p.m. and 1 a.m. And the only two people that we know were home that night were Scott and Melody. Of course, that being said, Scott, as he explained, wasn't home until 11.30 that night. And Scott's story about his timeline that night definitely checked out because a surveillance camera outside of his friend's house captured him leaving just around the time he said 10.55 and it was about a 30 or so minute drive back to the farm. Still though, of course, that doesn't rule him out. And after all, if Gary was shot in the house, but then ended up on the burn pile, he had to have been placed there and considering how small Melody was, it's hard to conceptualize at least at first how she could have gotten her 300-pound husband all the way out there. But Scott, on the other hand, made a little bit more sense because he was built a lot more like his dad, so in theory, he would have had the strength to move him. But there was something that he and Chris had told investigators that made it difficult for them to turn their attention away from Melody. And that was the name, Ted Wiley. Big shocker here, but it turns out that Melody was not honest with investigators when they asked her if she had an affair, turns out that she did have an affair with this guy named Ted, who had been dating Gary's sister for over 20 years. And this wasn't a one or two-time situation, okay? She would spend weeks at a time with him and it was actually no secret to Gary, so it's surprising she tried to pretend that there was never any unfaithfulness because it was pretty easy to uncover this. And to make matters worse, she had also secretly withdrawn a $50,000 home equity line of credit without his knowledge. Which he eventually did find out about and is what prompted him to file for divorce. She had been away with Ted for quite a while at this point and Gary had enough. He wanted a divorce because quite frankly, Melody sucks. But somehow you guys, this wicked witch, was able to convince Gary to stay with her and he withdrew his petition to and their marriage. And he basically just told their kids that they needed to forgive her as well. And so they did. And the reason I call Melody a witch, I call her witch for so many reasons, but I feel like she also had some type of spell over Gary because it sounds like he even bought the farm for her. As I mentioned, that was really her dream to have this big farm. And he did that, he bought the farm after all of this had happened in order to try and save their marriage. But he was never able to fully trust her again after this. Of course, because why would he? And because he didn't trust her at all, investigators found out that Gary had been tracking her spending because he was worried that she was outspending his money on other men. And one text from Gary to Melody in March of 2018 reads, "Your profligate spending must stop. Every day, and between you, Scott and Chris, I cannot keep up. You treat me like I don't exist, which is offensive, given how you repeatedly betray me." So investigators started to wonder if maybe Melody was becoming increasingly angry at him for tracking her spending when their kids seemingly had free reign. And then they also learned about something that blew my mind, okay? So they figured out that Gary had a hospital visit back in April that year. And it was prompted by one of those spells that he had, which, according to Chris, this spell came after a heated argument between his parents. Apparently, after they got into this big fight, Melody brought Gary a big plate of cookies as like a peace offer. He couldn't resist, I mean, the man loved his cookies. And so after he ate them, his throat started to burn and he began to feel sick and Gary even told Chris that he thought that she had poisoned him. Now, I have to be really clear here, there is no proof of that, but in my opinion, I think that is what happened. I think this was a failed poisoning. Again, no proof. But the timing and circumstances, I think we can all agree are very hard to ignore. But the biggest red flag that they found so far was what they found in her purse, which was birth control and another man's credit card. But it wasn't Ted Wiley's credit card. Remember the man that she had had an affair with before? It was some other guys. This card belonged to a man named Roy Barton, and no shock here, but of course, Melody completely downplayed this situation. In one of her interviews, she said that it was an old credit card that she hadn't used in over four years that had been given to her by her cousin Martha Jane, who was married to Roy before he passed away. And she was adamant that if investigators looked into the car that they wouldn't find any purchases or activity over the last four years. But let's be real, investigators knew that she was lying through her damn teeth. So they get pressing her and pressing her and finally she started to open up. And it was gradual, but Melody eventually explained that months and months prior to all this, she was seeing a guy named Rusty Barton. So yeah, now we have another name. Now Roy was Rusty's dad. And she said that he, Rusty, had given her the credit card for emergency use only because he knew how controlling Gary was about money. But of course, Melody made it sound like this relationship was not that serious at all. It was only after investigators found out that he had given her a secret phone. And once they looked through all the records from that phone, they could see that her and Rusty were talking like all day every day. So of course, investigators decide it is time to pay Mr. Rusty a visit. And at first, they didn't get much out of him, which wasn't for lack of trying. They went pretty hard at him during their line of questioning and he went just as hard back. Rusty was angry because he said he didn't know anything about the murder, but investigators were just as mad because they didn't believe him. However, he did have an alibi that proved that he couldn't have been the one to physically do it. But here's the thing. The more they looked into his phone records, the more suspicious Rusty seemed. For one, he had changed Melody's name in his phone to XO, which they thought was strange because she actually had an exo tattoo that she claimed was a tattoo for Gary. Like they had already asked her about this exo tattoo and she was like, oh yeah, that's just me and Gary's thing. But now it's looking a little differently because it's looking like that tattoo was for Rusty, which means that they had to have been serious if she was tattooing something in honor of him on her body. Then they saw that he had been googling wedding bands. And that is not it, you guys. Man, I gotta say, I am just continually blown away by how people are so dumb when it comes to Google searches. This one really was excellent. Thanks Rusty for the laugh here because he Googled if the police have a cell phone number, can they get all your text messages? And how police get your text messages? So at this point, not looking good for Rusty. And of course, he does have an alibi. He couldn't have been the one to physically do it, but investigators felt like he had to know more than what he was saying. And therefore they wanted to keep a close eye on him. And not long after this interview, they found more evidence proving that he had lied. He had initially told them that he had last spoke to Melody about a week before the murder. But they found that he spoke to her three times on July 3rd for a cumulative 114 minutes. So of course, they end up going back to Tennessee where he was living to question him a second time 'cause this is not looking good. And this is when a struck gold. Get this, you guys. Rusty ended up telling them that during a phone call with Melody around 2 a.m. on July 4th, she told him that Gary was in the burn pile. - Let's talk about that conversation that I've been filled with. So probably the last minute of the last conversation, she said, Gary is in the burn pile. No, she said he is in the burn pile. And I said, what? And she said, he's in the burn pile. And I said, I do not say another word and do not tell me anything that I do not need to know. - Now, if you remember, Gary wasn't found until the 5th. On the 4th, she's acting all confused, doesn't know where he is, hasn't heard from him. The kids are looking for him. So the fact that she allegedly told him this on the 4th that he's in the burn pile, it was suggest that she knew that he died before anyone else. And of course, this made Miss Melody the prime suspect real quick. And they thought that now they had Rusty on their side because he had agreed to record their conversations going forward, but this dipshit ended up telling her that the police were recording them and then he bought her another phone so she would feel comfortable talking to him. That's right. (upbeat music) He clearly just didn't give a shit that he was suspected of murder because they continue to date one another and speak all the time after all of this. And it turns out their relationship was a terribly kept secret. Turns out the two of them had known each other forever, but they had become romantic in 2014 when Melody started taking care of her second cousin, Martha Jane. And Martha Jane was married to Rusty's dad. And remember Martha Jane, she comes back into things later on in a very big way. Now long story short, Rusty's dad had gone sick and so did Martha Jane. So Melody started going to Tennessee to take care of them. And this is how she ended up with Roy's credit card. Roy, as a reminder, is Rusty's dad. But then her visits became personal, if you know what I mean. And everyone knew that she was doing this, including Gary. And get this, you guys, when her daughter Emily got married in 2016, Melody invited Rusty to the wedding and spent most of that evening dancing and flirting with him. And if you're watching this episode, take a look at this family picture from the wedding. I mean, the looks on Gary and Melody's faces really just say it all. And as he should have been, Gary was super disturbed by it all, but he didn't want to ruin his daughter's day because he was a good dad. And so he sort of just had to suck it up and let it happen. But yeah, by this point, she is definitely number one suspect on their list. And investigators continued to interview the kids to collect more information about her. And they were able to learn just how angry she was with Gary seemingly all the time and how little it took to set her off. In fact, just two days before he vanished, Scott said that his mom came screaming out of the house, yelling at Gary for leaving dirty plate downstairs. So when he says little things set her off, they all were saying little things set her off. That's a great example of it. A dirty plate like center over the fucking edge. She literally smashed it on the ground and said, "I can't wait until that man's dead. I can't wait until I don't have to live with him anymore." And Gary even record a short video of the aftermath of it all, which was so eerie when you think about the fact that he was killed just a day or two later. - When you lay the plate, forget to take it upstairs. A minor 10, 10 per day from. Of course, I had separate of nine and it was six for me. So I'm sure I'll be feeling poor a year, in that minutes, mostly. - This is just heartbreaking and so, so scary. I mean, the fact that he said, he'll probably start feeling sick after eating her food literally, dude, makes the pair on my arms stand up because he knew, Gary knew that she wanted him dead. And the reality is, Melody stood the most to gain. Even if Gary had become more critical of their children for spending his money, it wouldn't make sense at the end of the day for any of them, especially Scott, to have him killed. In the state of Georgia, Melody would have legally obtained the property in the event of his death, and the property is what she said he was after. And clearly, they didn't have the best relationship to say the least. So if Scott was the one to kill his father, he would have just been sabotaging his own life because his mom definitely wouldn't have continued to let him live there with such financial freedom, right? The dots were just not connecting logically, or physically, and listen to this. When investigators pinged Gary's phone to try and get a better understanding of the timeline, they saw that his phone had movement at 5.52 a.m. on July 4. It was moving around for roughly an hour, and then at 7.21, his phone was at the burn pile. It then moved towards the house and then ultimately stopped pinging at 9.05 a.m. Now let's not forget, investigators were certain that Gary had to have been killed on the night of July 3, because he never knew. used to see Pat Machine. It's the only timing that would make sense. So think about it. The only reason that his phone could have been moving to and from the burn pile is because the killer was the one moving it around. And Melody was the only person who was home early that morning. Scott had left just before 7am to go play golf with some friends. And then, like we know, he went to the lake and then over to a friend's house. Melody also left the farm that day, but not before Gary's phone was seen moving around. So everything at this point, even if circumstantial, is pointing at her. And so finally, on June 18th, 2019, they were able to make an arrest. And Melody, funny enough, was actually with Rusty in Tennessee when they got word that the arrest was coming. And he drove her to the police station so she could just turn herself in. And I found it sort of interesting that it took almost a year to arrest her because it sounds to me like they had most of this evidence pretty early on. But I guess the real hold up was the autopsy. And it's just horrible to think about. But because of how badly burned his body was because he was out in that burn pile for so long, it took a while for them to make a positive identification on him and confirm his cause of death. But once they got that, though, they arrested her for malice murder, felony murder, aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, concealing the death of another, and making false statements. And honestly, it was really Rusty's admission of what Melody told him about Gary being on the burn pile that convinced them of her guilt. And I'm sure Melody was pissed at Rusty for that. But at the end of the day, getting justice was not easy, and it did not come fast. It actually wasn't until October of 2024, so almost a year ago now that Melody went to trial, which was over six years since the murder took place. During that time, she was out on bail, living her life, and the Ferris family became even more divided than they were before. Scott, Chris, and Emily all agreed that their mom was responsible for their murder of their dad, whereas Amanda, the youngest, didn't waver in her support for their mom. Which is really interesting when you think about it, how Amanda was the one sitting with her mom, comforting her when they couldn't find Gary. And mind you, she was the only child that Melody never seemed to point the finger at. And it was always the others that she said took advantage of Gary. It was never Amanda, which was actually something that Amanda had said since the beginning. During the interview process early on, she had mentioned that she was worried about her brother's behavior towards their mom. She even said that Scott had been making threats against Melody, including threats about burning the house down. And for whatever reason, she just couldn't believe that her mom would do this. And I definitely would love to hear your opinions as I go through everything that happened during the trial, which is a lot. And if you're new here, this is just a reminder that I am not a lawyer. I will not be able to give you a step-by-step breakdown of the trial, or we would be here for a long time. And like I said, I'm just not an expert enough to do that. But I'm here to share the big picture of what went down during this trial because it was a rollercoaster. And here's what the prosecution's big picture was. They believe that Melody killed Gary on the night of July 3rd during the time that she said that she was wrangling up those horses on the property and that the shooting first transpired in the kitchen during some type of argument. And then based on blood evidence, they believe that Gary then began to move downstairs into the living room area where he was possibly shot at again. And then he went out the sliding glass door where the trail of blood ended. Now, I'm sure a lot of you have been thinking about this wondering about this. How the hell did Melody get Gary down to the burn pile? And this was one of if not the biggest point of contention during the trial. And I mentioned it earlier, but Melody was small and Gary was not. Again, he was six foot five, about 300 pounds. He's known as big daddy. Wouldn't it have been pretty difficult for her to move his body to the burn pile from the house? And yes, it would have been difficult, but difficult does not mean impossible. During the trial, the jury heard testimony from Scott that their father's tractor was not parked in an area where he normally left it. Suggesting, of course, that it may have been used to move him. And they even did a forensic examination, of course. And they found spots of Gary's blood on the side of it. However, it seemed like it wasn't a significant amount of blood. And they didn't find blood or DNA in the front bucket part of the tractor. You know, the part that is used to lift things up, which is where you would expect a body to go if it was used to move a body. But then there was Gary's RTV. And they did find evidence of Melody's blood on the gear shifter. But besides that, there wasn't any DNA to suggest that it had been used to move a body either. The defense also pointed out the grassy area just outside the living room that was still perfectly manicured, meaning that if the tractor or RTV had driven on it, they would have been able to tell. However, there were some tractor tire marks down by the burn pile. But to the defense's point, those marks could have easily been found all over the property. So who's to say that they were related, you know? But anyways, even though it would have been difficult, the prosecution argued that Melody was still the one to move him. Even if it meant rolling him there. And not to mention, it was downhill. And so they believed that she was the one who did it. They argued that she was the only person with the means, motive, and opportunity to kill Gary. And they say her motive came down to money, sex, and starting a new life. Ultimately, her and Gary's relationship had been contentious at best, and she found someone else that she wanted to be with more. And rather than leave her husband and lose her luxurious life, they say she killed him to have the best of both worlds. After all, his $2 million dollar life insurance policy was going to be hers in the event of his death. Certain questions. You do not have to ask yourself was Gary murdered. He was. You do not have to ask yourself was Gary Ferris burned on a burn pile. He was. The question you have to ask is, who did this? The evidence demands an answer. And the answer is close. Is that hand? It's close to me. It's close to you. It was close to Gary. That brings us to what we call means of motive and opportunity. Let's first talk about opportunity. The reason why you strike the brawl down and you will see at the times in this case, when he was killed and when his body was moved, when things are going on, the only person is going to be at that house, the only person is her. And what else? Just her means. Means is how can you have done it? Because the question you're going to have in your mind is going to bowl down to this case is how did that little lady get that big man on the burn pile? She's cowgirl, fun girl, her daddy owned a hardware store growing up. She's ran around it. She had ropes, leads, straps, and toe lines. The dimensions they have are attracted. They also said they had, tell you they had an RTV. Moved. In my business, there's nothing new under the sun. Let me introduce you to a person called Rusty. Rusty and a defendant became romantic in about 2014. They were loved. They talked like junior high kids in love for the first time, all the time. They had a regular pattern. When you see the opportunity, the means and the motive. Money, sex, new life, the truth. The saddest it is, as hard as it is, is that the defendant murdered and desecrated her own management. Now that a fence on the other hand would want you to believe that Melody knew nothing about her husband's financial situation and that she was totally oblivious to his income and that he had no problem with how she spent money. And a big part of their argument for why the jury shouldn't find her guilty had to do with the questions that they said were still unanswered. And one of those questions, of course, was how Gary got to the burn pile. And then another question had to do with the murder weapon. Where was it? Because investigators never actually found it despite an extensive search effort. But what they did find though, was 38 caliber ammunition in Scott's room and Scott's room only, which they pointed out was never thoroughly searched for blood. In fact, they said that Scott's room was messy, but his bathroom was uncharacteristically clean. And so at the end of the day, they argued that Scott was the person who should be on trial. They said that he was the one who wanted Gary gone so that the farm could finally be his. And the one thing they pointed to a lot was how quick he was to call it a homicide. And if you remember, he had mentioned a missing gun before a bullet was even found in Gary's ribcage. And then of course, all of us and that the jury have to consider the fact that Scott definitely would have been able to move the body far more easy than his mom would have. And not only that, they also pointed to how suspicious it was of him to delete that trail camera footage that I told you guys about earlier. On top of that, the defense was adamant that investigators acted with confirmation bias, and only looked for evidence against Melody because that's who they wanted to be guilty. They even said that there was a perfectly reasonable explanation for the blood drops that were found inside the house. According to the defense, those droplets came from Gary being bit on the ankle by a dog. And considering how little blood was actually there, they said it wouldn't be reasonable to assume that it came from a gunshot wound. Now one thing that I did find to be particularly interesting is that on the morning of July 4th, Ms. Witch over here, Melody ended up going over to Wallyworld. And why did she go to Walmart? Well, apparently she was out of bleach of all things, and on the stand, one law enforcement officer actually testified that he remembered smelling cleaning solution as soon as he entered the home. And his testimony was one of many powerful ones that was given throughout the trial, including testimony from their neighbor, Terry, who said that in 2016, Melody texted her, quote, "I hope he dies alone and a gruesome death." The jury also learned that she told Chris there was no point having a funeral because, quote, "Why have a funeral when there's nothing left?" Melody was just incredibly cold when it came to her husband dying, and the thing she said about wanting him to die, leading up to his actual murder. And just how cold she was was reiterated through her kid's testimony. Chris, Scott, and Emily all took the stand to testify against their mom and made it clear there were long-standing marital issues. Each of their testimonies reflected a very troubled marriage and family life, namely due to the actions and infidelities of their mom. And Chris literally said that his dad once told him that every day of his life with Melody was the worst day of his life. Let that sink in. That's incredibly sad. And also, don't forget, Chris was the one that Gary confided in about Melody possibly poisoning him with those cookies that resulted in him going to the hospital. He also talked about his mom's affair with Ted Wiley, which, at one point, prompted Gary to file for a divorce. And he also said his dad had always been open with him about their marital problems, and this was just one instance of that. Well, my dad told me, as he was kind of suspicious, my brother, I believe, was the one who initially had those suspicions. But my suspicion, I always thought Ted Wiley was just a little bit to, I don't know, I guess maybe flirtatious with my mother. Who is, who is Ted Wiley? Ted Wiley was actually in a relationship with my aunt Sherry. And how did you know, how were your suspicions confirmed? When I was living in Buckhead with my ex-wife, Chinna, and my father told me, he's like, I need you to come up to Alfredo tonight and have dinner with me. It's like, okay. And he sat me down. He said, Chris, I don't think we're going to be able to have Christmas this year. And he began to explain that why we wouldn't. He told me that my mother had withdrawn, I believe, $50,000 from a home equity line of credit without his knowing about it, or just, and he told me, I don't know if we're going to have Christmas this year because of this. At any point did your mom leave your dad? Yes. Can you tell the jury about that? She would leave and be up in Florence, Alabama for months at a time, weeks, sometimes weeks, sometimes months. How did you know where she was going? My father would tell me. Was that around the same time as the Ted Wiley? Yes. Affair. Mm-hmm. Is that what prompted your dad to file divorce papers? Yes. Did they end up getting divorced? No. Do you know what happened? She came home? He called me one day and said, she's coming home, I want you to forgive your mother and accept her back. Did you do that? I told him I wouldn't. And as we know, he suspected that his mom had something to do with the murder very early on. They told me that they found a bullet in my father's rib. And now this was being treated as a homicide. And there were some follow-up questions and they asked me, who would anybody ever benefit from your father being killed? And I was very frank. I said, well, yeah, I mean, my mom, and whoever he's related to is forced financially. I mean, at this point in time, my brain had kind of already switched to thinking something had happened to him that wasn't falling in a fire. Why didn't it switch? Because of my mother's behavior, when the police were there, and just how she was acting. What was that behavior? It's not like somebody whose husband had just been found in a burp pile. Now as for Scott's testimony, there was obviously a lot to be said. And to summarize it, he spent a lot of time speaking about the events that took place between July 3rd and July 5th, which included the moment that he discovered his dad's remains. And I've just got to say, being the one to discover your dad's remains in that condition is just horrendous beyond words. I feel so, so bad for Scott in one of his interviews. He was talking about how he wouldn't wish that experience, even on his worst enemy. And God, I just truly can't imagine what that would be like. Ultimately, you did find the right year fathers, aren't you? Yes. How I found it, like I said, I was going to check the other side of the pond, you know, across the dam, and I started walking that way, and I believe I got to either halfway across the dam or got to the other side, and then Melody called me. And she called me and asked, "Have you thrown a dead goat on the burp pile?" I might know, we haven't had anything to die, and also I wouldn't throw it on the burp pile. And she said, "Well, come up here and look at this." So I was like, "Okay, well, I turned around and started walking, and I see Amanda walking. She was almost kind of like right in front of my dad's office, coming from the burp pile area, walking back up towards the driveway. She was walking there, and Melody was standing over near the burp pile. And I walked up and looked, and I could already start seeing bones. And then I looked down, and it appeared to me that it was the inside of a skull, the backside was gone, and you can see like the little blood vessels, I think it was, but it didn't look like a rock or something, so I grabbed a very, very small corner of it, and I lifted it up just enough to where I saw teeth and I saw it, and I immediately put it right back. And I was crouched down, and she was standing right there next to me, and I raised up, I put my hand on, you know, cross your chest, and push her back and go, "These are human remains. I am calling 911 right now, and Melody's allowed down here." And one thing that Scott really made clear is that his mom's reaction to all of this just was not normal, and I think we can all agree. Like Chris, he didn't think that she was acting like someone whose husband was just found dead in this horribly gruesome way, like just burned to basically nothing left in a burn pile on his own property. Anyone else who even had a little bit of love left for their spouse would just be destroyed by that, and he said that her tears didn't seem genuine at all. It was almost like her reaction was just completely fake. She didn't get angry with anybody, and she should know I didn't notice any of her freaking out or anything like that. The only time that I saw her actually trying to kind of show some emotion is after the deputy and the paramedic came back up from the burn pile to say, "Yeses are human remains." And then just the way that she started acting, I've seen my mother cry, I mean hundreds of times throughout my life and all. It appeared to me to be fake. Up until that point, has she cried or anything? No. And when he was asked the toughest question of all, Scott cried when he was asked if he had anything to do with his father's murder. Scott, would you look at the jury and answer this question? Did you murder your father? I absolutely did not murder my father. Without a doubt, I'll love to. Look at me. Do you have anything to do to help your mother dispose of and burn your father? Absolutely not. Tell me I'm not me. No. Like I said, I'll love my father. He was the backbone. He was the backbone to our family. And I think seeing him like that, it says a lot. I mean, my heart really, really goes out to Scott and everything that he's been through through all of this. It's just horrendous. Now, when Emily testified, she talked a lot about their marital issues as well. But their marital issues as well, including testimony about the affair with Ted Wiley. She also discussed the $50,000 home equity line of credit that her mom took out without Gary's knowledge and how things were really never the same after this. And one thing that I thought was really interesting that she shared was how her mom was very insistent that she hand over the letter from the coroner that confirmed his death. Because this letter could be used to claim his $2 million life insurance policy. And then of course, Emily had to describe the painful moment when she found out that her dad was missing. She was living in Tennessee and she had gotten a call from Chris. So she left work, grabbed her husband and their daughter and they drove to the farm as fast as they could. And Emily remembered actually having a strange feeling because on the fourth, she had sent a picture of her daughter in a family email thread. And Gary never replied, which was very unlike him. He loved his grandchildren, he loved his kids, and so he always replied to pictures of them. And she even said that Melody was asking her if she had access to Gary's bank accounts while he was still missing. And her obsession was just hard to ignore. And Emily described her mother as being hostile about it after his death. But her opinion and the opinion of her brothers was definitely not shared by their sister Amanda, who testified for the defense. I will say it seems that Amanda was torn at this point and of course that's just my opinion based on her testimony. It doesn't seem like she was outright saying that her mom was innocent no matter what. I mean her testimony was more like I'm going to believe she's innocent until she's proven guilty. And it's fair to say that you're biased in favor of your mom. I wouldn't say I'm biased in favor, I believe that somebody is innocent into their proven guilty. So would you say that you do believe in your mom though? She has told me that she's not guilty and all I can do is believe that until somebody can prove she is guilty. So I would like to believe that my mother had nothing to do with this. She also talked about her siblings' habits with their parents' money, including Chris' alleged stealing and how Scott leeched on them. And she did corroborate that dog bite that the defense said Gary sustained. Amanda's testimony was honestly really emotional because you can see how torn up she was about this. She said that she lost her whole family that day. And regardless of who she believes or what she believes, my heart truly goes out to her because it's a hard situation to be in. And she did lose her whole family that day. I understand wanting to believe someone you love, especially your parent, couldn't have possibly done something so horrific to your other parent. That must be hard to wrap your mind around and accept. Now switching gears a little bit, I wanted to talk a little bit more about Melody's affairs. Since I was part of the state's motive, it was obviously a big focus during the trial and rightfully so. First starters, they brought Ted Wiley in to testify, but I'll be honest, he didn't add much more than we already knew. He explained how they met, the extent of their affair, and there was some discussion about money that she had given him over the years. But he didn't have much information to offer on her financial situation. Rusty's testimony on the other hand was a lot more insightful, and it was interesting because it almost sounded like he was trying to protect her, which makes sense. In the early parts of his testimony, he talked about how the two of them met, which if you remember, was through his stepmom and her second cousin Martha Jane. Then he somewhat hesitantly described there and the frequency with which they spoke and saw one another, which was a lot. Tell the jury how that happened, what was going on? We were just in close contact with each other, almost day in, day out, trying to handle everything, and it just became a thing. So your relationship with her started in 2014? Yes. Did you know she was married? I did. Did you know she was married to Garrett? I did. In the beginning, I think, did you all meet there mostly? Well, I don't remember how often we ended that. I don't remember. Did it progress to meeting weekly? At times. She met more than one time during the week? It's possible that we did. I do not recall that we did, but I'm. You wouldn't dispute if. No. That was the case. No. Again, I know there's records. But you did love her in the past, correct? Correct. You were in love with her, fair side? Yes. Because she was in love with you, fair side? Yes. How many times a day? Tell the jury how many times a day would you talk to her on the phone? Whether it's by voice or by text messages? All but out all day. Almost every day? Almost every day. But of course this trial wasn't about the affair. It was about Melody killing her husband. And as we know, Rusty did play a big part in her arrest. But what's interesting, however not really surprising, is he seemed to flip flop on what side he was on. If you remember, he agreed to record his phone calls with Melody after Gary's murder. But then he ended up telling her that the police were recording the call. Which he admitted was very suspicious. So why are you having these other phones to talk outside of the phone calls? I wanted to make her comfortable, so I could find out if there was anything that wasn't known. You wanted to make her comfortable? So you just had to go buy these other burner phones, the law enforcement didn't know that you all were talking? Correct. You agree that's suspicious, right? Or should he? Yeah, very suspicious. And there was also a pretty suspicious phone call between the two of them after Melody got arrested. You are? No. Well, you know, back a long time ago, I said stop talking. I haven't done anything. I know that door would. Somehow the other, you know, what you keep talking about, you're going to single handedly hang me. Now, if she really hadn't done anything, there wouldn't be anything that Rusty could say that would hang her. Which does make me wonder what he knew. And what's wild is he admitted on the stand that she told him not to speak to police. Take a listen. You can ask me the question, did she talk to you and tell you not to talk to law enforcement because they were trying to get information on her? I don't think it was spread out for anybody to want that it was just don't talk. But we know that he did because not long after the murder, Rusty had that infamous interview where he told investigators that Melody said that Gary was on the burn pile. But here's the thing with that though, he recanted the statement more at least the timing of it. He said that Melody did say those things, but it didn't happen when he first said it did. Initially, he said that she told him that before Gary was reported missing. But then he changed his story and said that the call didn't take place until after Gary was found. And I think the timing of it, obviously, matters a lot. And he recanted that statement just a day after the jailhouse call that I just played a minute ago. Take a listen. On July 24, 2018, while meeting with your attorney who was present and detective Hayes and Sergeant Putt, you told them that the defendant probably the last minute of the last conversation, she said Gary is in the burn pile. No. She said he is in the burn pile. And I said what? And she said he's in the burn pile. And I said do not say another word and do not tell me anything. I do not need to know those were your words to law enforcement in July the 24th of 2018. Is that true? Yes. And at the time that she made a statement to you that she said she said on July 4th about two o'clock in the morning, Gary had not been reported missing yet. Isn't that true? Yes. In July of 2018, you never came back and said I need to recant that that was wrong. Not in July of 2018. Correct. And he didn't do that, you actually didn't recant until your statement in June of 2019, isn't that true? That is true. And after she was arrested a couple days later, you then get in contact with law enforcement and want to tell them something, is that true? Yes. So this meeting in June of 2019, after the defense bear arrested and you were with her and all that, what did you tell law enforcement that what was wrong with the first statement about being on the burn pile, how did you retract that? What did you say? I don't know that I said a date, I just said that I had gone to Martha's house, Martha had told me, and then while I was there, Melanie had called and then she told me it. Do you ever say they could have been July 9th? I do not know what day it was. But looking at the calendar on the floor there, July 2019, you talked to the GBI, excuse me, the sheriff's office with the TBI on July 10th of 2018, you grew with that, right? Yes. And then you talked to him again on July 24th of 2018, you grew with that, correct? Yes. And on July 24th, 2018, you tell them, Melanie told me it carries in the burn pile, I don't want to know about it, don't want to talk about it, right? Yes. So you're saying that, at some point, you got the date wrong, would it have been before the 24th? Yes, it would be before the 24th. Was it closer to the 9th of July or a different date? I don't think anything transpired on the 9th of July. So tell us, what day did this conversation happen where the defendant said it carries in the burn pile that she says a different date from July 4th at 2 o'clock in the morning? I do not know the date, but I do know that it happened after the detective's case and Sergeant Pope had been up because after they left, I went to Martha's house and that's when it was, so it would have been after that. Now, the defense would basically go on to say that he was under arrest the first time that he made that statement. And the investigators were getting up in his face and they basically pressured him into it. But what many believe is that Rusty was telling the truth the first time. And only after speaking with Melody, did he decide to change his story. And I've just got to say, I believe scenario 2. And we know, from phone records, that the two of them spoke on the phone three times the 9th of July 3rd going into July 4. Which is when prosecutors argue that Gary was killed and that's what makes sense to me, I'm sure it makes sense to you. And don't forget Melody and Rusty lied about having spoken that day, which is just extremely sketch. So to me, there are just too many instances of them lying to ignore. And the truth at the end of the day, if it is the truth, it isn't hard to keep it straight. And really guys, the truth is Melody and Rusty were starting to plan their life without Gary around. Now, I'm sure there will be varying opinions on whether or not he knew, which is fair. I mean, I'm not totally sure either way, but I do think it's safe to say that Rusty was anticipating Gary's death. He told the jury that Melody told him that Gary had a soft-egas cancer. So they were starting to discuss what life might look like together once he died. There was talk of wedding bands and also that they were going to wait six months after his death to start dating publicly. And it's possible that Rusty really believed this whole cancer bit. Plus, it's not like he was ever charged with anything to suggest that he was in on it. So I definitely want to hear your opinions on that one because just because he wasn't charged doesn't mean that he wasn't involved. But there's just not any evidence to show that he was. But like I said though, it's clear in my opinion, allegedly, Rusty knew that Gary's life was coming to an end. Whether he knew how that was going to happen, I don't know, but he knew. Regardless though, I do think his testimony actually helped the prosecution quite a bit. Even though he was pretty resistant with some of his answers. And I know this has been a long episode, so thank you for sticking with me. But we still have two more witnesses to go over. And this next one is going to shock you. And the witness is Martha Jane. Now, me notes sound like Martha Jane's testimony would be super shocking, but oh my god. Because the shocking part is that she wasn't slated to testify as in that was never the plan. She had actually been at home just watching the trial on TV. And she ended up calling the Sheriff's Department because she believed that Rusty Miss spoke on the stand. At one point he had been asked about his guns and he said that none of them were missing. He also said that no guns were missing at Martha Jane's house either. But she said that that was not true. In the midst of the trial, she gets in contact with the investigators and says there's something heavy on her heart she's got to share. And then she eventually shared it with the jury as well. And that information was that a 38 caliber pistol was missing from her house. Now, this gun was actually a gift from her husband in the 70s and Melody was one of the few people who knew where it was. Now, the defense did try to argue that Martha Jane was just lying on the stand because she was embarrassed to learn about the affair on TV. But that seems like a pretty aggressive thing to lie about if you ask me even if she was pissed about the affair. And unfortunately, we may never know if Melody took that gun or not. Seeing as the murder weapon to this day has still never been found. And lastly, I need to mention a woman named Angela Phillips. Okay, so she was Gary's longtime secretary and she also took the stand. And there were two notable things that she said that I just had to mention. So one thing that she mentioned was that after Gary died, Melody called her to say that Gary had one of his spells and fell. Suggesting that his death was accidental, but she said that just didn't make sense to her. She claimed that even though he would get unexpectedly sick, it was never to the degree that he would have fallen into a fire and then been unable to get back out. Like, he was weak at times, but not that weak, which leads me to the next thing that Angela said. And this is so, so eerie, but she said that Gary once told her, quote, "You'll know what to tell Dateline if I die mysteriously." I mean, come on, isn't that just wild? And then his case was covered on Dateline, which is, oh my god, insane foreshadowing if you ask me. And she did have more to say, but those two things were definitely what stood out the most. Now, for closing arguments, everything was pretty standard. The state was strong in their conviction that only Melody could have done this and the only outcome that makes sense is her being found guilty. And the defense continued to reiterate that there were too many questions unanswered and too much reasonable doubt. During closing, though, there was this reenactment, if you will, where the defense attorney brought in these like big bags of salt. He very dramatically throws them all down into this burlap bag to emphasize how heavy they are, and then he starts pulling on them. And he only gets a few feet before he throws his arms up and says, that's all I got, and acts like he can't catch his breath. And his point, of course, being that it was hard for him, a 180-pound man, to drag something that weighs 320 pounds. And obviously, he's making the argument that if he's struggling to do it, how could Melody have moved Gary's body 100 yards? Take a look. And that's all I have. I think it is. And I gotta say, I know that he's just doing his job, and it was creative. I'll give him credit for that. But I just found it to be kind of funny, silly and goofy. I mean, I think we can all agree. It's a bit ridiculous, and it looked a little, um, there was some acting going on. But when it was all said and done, the prosecution just had a stronger argument. And after three days of deliberating, the jury ultimately found Melody Ferris guilty on all charges. And there actually was a point during deliberations when they told the judge that they were deadlocked, but he encouraged them to give it another try, go back in there, figure it out, and that's when they came to their decision. And some jurors actually spoke out later on, and they said that the cell phone data was really what persuaded them that it only could have been her. And this is actually a really interesting theory that one of the jurors had come up with and shared. Um, but they theorized that maybe she forced him to walk to the burn pile at gunpoint, which would explain how she got his body there. Which, I mean, once I thought more about that, I think it definitely could be possible. And I really want to know what you guys think of that theory. Now when it came to Melody's sentencing after not speaking at all during the trial, she gave a very unexpected and wild speech. Now that hearing took place on December 5th of 2024, and rather than start asking for mercy, Melody took this as her opportunity to further point to finger at her son, Scott. Now her statement was 20 minutes long, and I'm surprised that she was able to go on that long, and I just had to play some of it for you, even though it's 20 minutes. We're obviously not going to play 20 minutes of it right now, but you can always look it up if you want. But I had to share some of it because it is wild. And Jill, I think 2018, six years, five minutes ago today, again the worst nightmare that I could have ever imagined. Not only my world, but my world. of my family's world was absolutely destroyed at the hands of one person. I want to make sure that my children, my grandchildren, and Gary's family, and to be honest, at this point in time, the entire world who has built this. I have waited for years to make this statement to everyone. I want the world to know who did this. I have always heard that the courtroom is the last place you're going to get the truth, and has that ever been proven to be the truth in this case? Not only did I not do this, but who did? I know Scott killed his father. He took my husband, the father of Chris, Emily, and Amanda. Scott. This is unforgivable. Scott has spent entire life of loving and protecting you, but this I refuse to cover for you. My mother begged me to take the blame for this. She said after she talked to you, after Gary died, that she knew you had done it. Her exact words were, you are his mother, you have to take blame for this. The judge even did have to stop her a few times and redirect her because she was bringing up allegations that weren't even verified, weren't even part of the trial, so it was only in the last five minutes or so that she did start asking for mercy. I spent 18 plus months in the Cherokee County, J.M. over something that I did not do. The last thing I thought that that was the last thing I could do to Gary or him to get justice for him. I can't remember thinking, it's okay that I sit here. I just want answers. That's all alone, and I still haven't got them. And I don't think that I ever will. And that scares me to death. I know that in my heart, body and soul, who did this, and I'm begging for help. I'm begging you, Judge Cannon. Please do not send me to prison for something I didn't do. If I had done this, I would take this charge gladly. If it would bring Gary back, I would gladly go to prison. Please do this for Gary and my family. I have missed years with the people that I loved yearly. I do not want to wait years for justice, years that I may not have. I know this is something that you may never have seen before. And I plead with you to row this verdict out. Help me get justice for the correct person. His pedestal sounds, I want to be there to watch him change and shackle and brought to justice. I plead with you. I'm begging you, not for me, but for Gary and my children, and my grandchildren. Now people in their lives just couldn't believe that she would stoop to that level at the end of all of this, that she would really blame her son and leave him with that much pain. And if you're watching this episode, you probably saw Scott. He was in the courtroom and he looked absolutely stunned. He said it took everything in him not to burst out in court and just maintain as much calm energy as he could as his mother is accusing him of the murder of his father when she is very clearly guilty. Here he is ready to close this chapter after everything may have been through over the last couple of years. And his mother is taking it as one more opportunity to try and drag him down and make other people believe that he did this. And to insist that she's taking the fall for him is just evil if you ask me. It's so so brutal. I can't imagine saying that to your own child, knowing damn well that you did this and I 100% believe that she did. I'm sure maybe there's even some of you who wonder. And that's fair in my heart of hearts and my brain, I guess I could say, I don't know. I just, I feel very strongly that she is responsible for Gary's murder. So for her to sit there and try to put all that on her son as probably the last interaction that the two of them will ever have, yeah, it's just evil. I don't think there's any other word for it. And luckily the judge saw right through that bullshit. And in the end, he sentenced that wedge to life in prison with the possibility of parole in 30 years. But she also received an additional five years for concealing his remains and five more after that for making false statements. So even with her parole eligibility, she'll be well in her nineties before she even got the chance to be released. So chances are she's getting life in prison. She's not gonna see another free day or at least I truly hope that that is the case. And of course, because she's melody, she is still maintaining her innocence to this day. And she said that she's not gonna stop fighting until the truth is revealed. Now what's interesting too is the lead detective on the case said that as soon as she was found guilty, all the sudden she started making up all these crazy things about Scott, which sadly doesn't shock me, but my heart really hurts for Scott that his own mother is willing to do that, knowing damn well what she did. And of course we do see people doing that a lot as some sort of last ditch effort, but it just hurts when it's your own mother. Now this has been a very long episode. So thank you to all of you who have stuck through till the end. I really, really want to know your thoughts on this one because I have so many. I had to kind of limit my commentary to some degree or else this was just what have been an unbelievably long episode. And I'm not going to end here with some big outro since we've been going long enough. But I like I said, I really do want to know your thoughts in this case, so sound off in the comments. And I guess what I want to know the most is do you think they got the right person? Or was this investigation botched like Melody said, do you think Scott is actually the one who killed his father? I gotta say, I strongly disagree with that right off the bat. And I just feel bad for Scott that he even saw us to deal with those allegations. But if you feel differently, I want to know why. So let me know. And let's have a chat in the comments because I'm eager to know what you think. That is going to be it for me today, guys. Thank you for joining me for another episode. And make sure you follow the show on Spotify and Apple podcasts. It really does help me out. If you want to watch the video version of this show, you can find it on my YouTube channel, which will be linked, or you can just search Kendall Ray. I will be back with another episode soon, but until then, stay safe out there. (upbeat music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Gary Ferris, a 6'5" father of four and a well-known community figure, disappeared on July 3, 2018, from a 10-acre farm in Georgia after being last seen around dinner time.
  2. Initial concerns focused on a possible health episode due to Gary’s known conditions, including sleep apnea, smoking, and unexplained "spells," but evidence of a gunshot wound quickly shifted the investigation.
  3. A bullet fragment was found in Gary’s ribcage, and a missing gun was discovered in Scott’s home, leading investigators to suspect foul play, especially given Melody’s prior accusations of financial exploitation by the children.
  4. Melody, Gary’s wife, admitted to an affair with Rusty Barton, provided a credit card belonging to another man, and showed signs of emotional manipulation and anger toward Gary, including threatening behavior and claims of being poisoned.
  5. Critical timeline evidence, including Gary’s phone movement and CPAP machine data, confirmed he was killed on July 3, between 9:30 p.m. and 1 a.m., with the only people present being Melody and Scott.
  6. Scott’s early claim of a missing gun and his deletion of trail camera footage raised red flags, suggesting possible cover-up, though no direct physical evidence linked him to the murder.
  7. The prosecution argued Melody had the motive (money, control, new life), opportunity (she was home during key hours), and means (using a tractor or RTV to move the body), despite the physical difficulty of moving a 300-pound man.
  8. In 2019, Melody was arrested and charged with multiple counts of murder, and in 2024, she was convicted after a lengthy trial, with the jury ultimately believing her guilt due to motive, opportunity, and disturbing inconsistencies in her testimony and behavior.

Summary:

The disappearance of Gary Ferris, a 6'5" father and community pillar, in July 2018 on his 10-acre farm in Georgia became a complex and emotionally charged case. Initially, concerns centered on his known health issues and "spells," but the discovery of a bullet in his ribcage and a missing gun shifted the focus to homicide. Melody, his wife, was the primary suspect due to a history of financial disputes, emotional outbursts, and an affair with Rusty Barton, whose phone records revealed frequent contact with her and confirmed she knew about his death.

m. , with only Melody and Scott at the property. Melody’s lack of emotional reaction to the discovery, her false claims about the farm, and her possession of a second-person credit card and birth control further exposed her guilt.

Despite challenges in proving physical means of moving Gary’s body, the prosecution argued she had both motive and opportunity. Scott’s early suspicion of a missing gun and deletion of trail camera footage raised suspicion, though no direct link to murder was proven. Melody was eventually arrested in 2019 and convicted in 2024 on charges including malice murder and concealing a death.

The case underscores deep family dysfunction, emotional manipulation, and the difficulty of proving intent in high-stakes domestic violence cases. While the physical evidence remains circumstantial, the timeline, motive, and emotional inconsistencies culminated in a conviction, highlighting how family dynamics and hidden relationships can drive tragic outcomes.

FAQs

Gary Ferris was a father of four and a well-respected family man. He was known as 'Big Daddy' because he was six feet five inches tall and weighed about 300 pounds, a physically imposing figure who was widely admired by his family and community.

Gary Ferris disappeared on July 3, 2018, after being last seen by his family at the farm in Alfa Reda, Georgia. His body was later found in a burn pile, and authorities confirmed he had been murdered.

His son Scott discovered the remains while searching the property after learning that Gary was missing. He found bones, including a skull, near a burn pile and immediately realized they were human remains, prompting him to call emergency services.

A bullet fragment was found lodged in Gary’s ribcage, and a spent bullet casing was discovered in the house. These findings ruled out a natural health episode and pointed to a homicide.

Melody had a troubled marriage with Gary, had an affair with Rusty Barton, and possessed a credit card from another man. She showed coldness toward Gary’s death, made false statements, and had access to him at the time of the murder.

They used Gary’s CPAP machine data, which showed he didn’t use it on the night of July 3, and his phone tracking, which placed him at the farm around 9:30 p.m. to 1 a.m., confirming the murder occurred that night.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.