Fake ‘Alien Signals’ Drove Him Insane... (ft. Greg Bishop)
1h 42m 31s
Paul Benowitz, an electronics engineer living near Kirtland Air Force Base, reported seeing glowing UFO-like orbs flying over mountains and claimed to detect alien signals. Believing he was on the verge of uncovering a secret government program, he built radio equipment to monitor transmissions and began filming the phenomena. However, his experiences were systematically manipulated by U.S. intelligence agencies, particularly through the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (AFOSI) and the NSA. These agencies monitored Benowitz, feeding him disinformation—including fabricated documents, false videos, and staged stories about alien bases, dinosaurs, and Soviet espionage—designed to exploit his growing paranoia and validate intelligence operations. He was also subjected to spy training and psychological tactics, including being told he had access to secret information. Despite his efforts, the information he received was largely fabricated or misinterpreted, leading to a breakdown in his mental health. His case illustrates how UFOs were not a cover for conventional technology, but rather a strategic tool in intelligence operations—used to probe, manipulate, and extract information from individuals with a strong interest in the subject. Benowitz’s story, part of a broader Cold War-era disinformation strategy, reveals how psychological warfare and deception were central to covert activities, turning personal belief into a valuable intelligence asset.
UFOs are a Swiss army knife for intelligence. They can use them for anything. We were seeing lights like out somewhere on the base like lifting up up off the ground and then flying over mountain and going down and they were just blowing orbs and he said that he could look through binoculars and sometimes see like Air Force people or somebody walking around them before they took off. He built apparently a setup and started listening to transmissions coming from the base. He said there were dinosaurs and like old like Roman battles and stuff. The Air Force had taken him in a helicopter, flown him up to Northwestern New Mexico and showed him stuff saying look that we think there's something going on here and they actually put jeeps and like water tanks and all kind of stuff in this place as props. And then he starts to kind of lose his mind is that is that right? Yeah as things get worse he went there with a camera and took pictures. Benos was there with like a rifle and a pistol and he said you know they're coming you have to come in the house right now. The idea that UFOs are a cover for just prosaic technology is totally wrong in fact it's the opposite prosaic technology is often used as a cover for you. It's an interesting discussion. Yeah probably both in fact it's demonstrably both. Imagine the Benowitz operation as a 24 hour long stage play and Benowitz is five minutes in one scene not even five minutes. I'm here with Greg Bishop who is the excellent author of Project Beta and most recently it defies language and I know you to be a very hard headed UFO journalist investigator who sometimes reports on things that fly in the face of what the believers of everything want. And the first kind of great example of that is in Project Beta where you documented this guy named Paul Benowitz who's this earnest industry man in aerospace and he is driven kind of crazy by the Air Force Office of Special Investigation specifically this counterintelligence agent named Rick Dodie and it makes for an amazing kind of dramatic thriller. I'm excited to get into the weeds with you. Thank you for being here. Thanks thanks for inviting me. Benowitz wasn't involved in aerospace and he was already kind of unstable to begin with. It's just the Air Force AF OSI and other people just encouraged it made it worse. There you go. Which is no excuse. Everybody says oh he was perfectly okay. No he was kind of heading down that road. It's just when somebody in power tells you something. Yeah. It's like oh well that must be right so you just keep you know. Well didn't you have a company that sold components? They still do. Yeah. His sons still run it at least one of them and a thunder scientific temperature and humidity instruments. Okay. I think it's it's humidifiers and and things to monitor temperature and humidity in like highly you know corrosive or what are environments like on submarines or on aircraft or whatever. So that's he actually had as far as I know contracts with the military for these things along with a bunch of you know scientific organizations and stuff and he both lives in his office is near Kurtland Air Force base like basically across the street or what's the his house is in the four hills area of Albuquerque which is on the border of the north side of Kurtland Air Force Base. Okay. And his office was near the Wyoming gate of Kurtland Air Force Base so at work or at home he was always like right next to the base. So and the company's still there if you go there there's a big science little sign that says thunder scientific. And I think his son one of his sons is still the president and I'm not sure if his wife is still alive. Cindy I think her name is or was but yeah that's on like I said it's just if you you could walk out his front door and down a street like two minutes and you're at the fence that says you know government facility do not trespass all that. So this is the late 70s Paul Benowitz is living in working around Kurtland Air Force Base. What's he like as a person? The people I do know that knew him such as Bill Moore, Dodie and Gabe Valdez. Those are three people I talked to who knew him and mostly because I was talking about that period they talk about him getting more and more frightened about stuff. But I've seen pictures of him before all this started happening. And he's got this mischievous look on his face. He looks like a he looks like a grown-up kid. There's a I've seen a picture of his application to APRO or a real phenomenon research organization. And he's just kind of standing there like I know it's it's kind of like wow that doesn't look like Paul Benowitz I think of him as like this scared paranoid person. But you know in the picture which is just a snippet of somebody he he looks actually pretty pretty happy and funny. There's a picture of him in the Albuquerque Journal or Tribune one of the two in 1981 or two. He looks way different. He has long hair and a big beard and he's kind of sitting there. He looks very serious. And it was just a profile of him in his business. And you know about childhood or was he was he a generally credulous person who believed in other sort of you know crazy lore growing up. I don't think so. The only thing I knew about and I can't remember who I found this out from as he liked to read Wild West novels. Okay. You know also he was a private pilot. He had a pilot's license also I think he did aerobatic flying which made me feel closer to him because I have a pilot's license too and I've done some aerobatic flying. But it's just you know there's not a lot on his background. People actually said well why didn't you get into his background. What was just your question. And I said well nobody that was close to him wanted to talk to me. Right. Obvious reasons. Yeah. Because it's like we don't want to dig that up again. So he's living and working near Kriotland Air Force Base. Kriotland Air Force Base has an interesting history in just UFO lore. I believe it was managed back in the day by the Sandia offshoot of the Atomic Energy Commission. Oh okay okay. And and so a couple of places where it shows up in UFO lore just to kind of set the set the scene for people maybe take this with a grain of salt but you have Bill Steinman who is a UFO researcher who writes about the Aztec crash which is a very controversial crash. Yeah. I have his book I talked him on the phone once actually. Oh wow I want to hear about that because he seemed like a very interesting guy. He was actually people don't know this. He was a skunk works employee and he was pushed out of that I didn't know because he was so interested in this topic. And then he could never really get a job in aerospace again but he writes about Kriotland Air Force Base with respect to a guy named Eric Henry Wing because he was interested actually in the Kingman crash. Yeah which is associated with Operation Upshot not hold this nuclear test in 1953 and Nevada then Nevada test range and you know have this Arthur Stancell this guy who's on the right definitely worked at right airfield at the time. Yeah. And he sees his name in the records because he was this witness of this crash he sees a body like a you know four-foot body mortar or whatever in Kingman and he Steinman looks him up sees his name in the record next to a guy named Eric Henry Wing. Yeah. Eric Henry Wing was head of special studies at you know right airfield. He was German. German studied with Viktor Schalberger actually. Okay that I didn't know. Yeah. And people say well why is his name Wang and I found out and I think this is true because of the because of among East Asian you know barbarians came through Germany. Fascinating. And so he had this Asian name he wasn't he was German but he had this Asian name because of you know something that happened in what the third I mean sorry like the third century or fourth century. Yeah yeah. There were there were people named Wang that came through there and just kind of until a hunt. Yeah. Yeah. I was going to say it's all the hunt. I'm sure not sure he made it to Rome but yeah. Yeah. So a long-goal hordes did but apparently that's where his name came from. That's go ahead. No no amazing. I love it. I love the historical detour. So his name he's apparently moved from Wright Patterson or right airfield to Kirtland Air Force Base and I believe there's even some sort of complex near Los Alamos that's like named after him but that's it like he's kind of scrubbed from the internet otherwise. Yeah. Steinman like most people do that kind of work. Bill Steinman gets in touch with his wife Maria Wang and she says oh yeah he worked at Kirtland Air Force Base he worked on some you know secret UFO related stuff. Yeah I think they came and also came and took a bunch of stuff out of his house when he died. Interesting. I didn't like that that tells a story where the Navy goes in in New York and pulls all the stuff out of storage but the same thing I believe. That's interesting. That's definitely factual in the case of Tesla. So yeah and then John Trump Trump's Donald Trump's uncle actually looks at the Tesla files to see if they can get that. Yeah. Crazy history but okay so they yeah Raid Wang's house Steinman
speaks to Maria Wang, she says, "Yes, he's working on all sorts of spooky stuff." And he was managed by Henry A Kissinger. So that's pretty crazy. And then Henry Kissinger is actually on record meeting, doing these, like, kind of meetings this guy, Don Cotter, who was head of advanced research at Curtlyn Air Force Base. In 1962, he was convening these interdisciplinary groups to talk about UFOs. Talk about, we don't know. You know, kind of, you know, national defense security and geopolitics. And Kissinger is on record being there. So that's the backdrop. Otherwise all we know is Curtlyn is working on a probably advanced aerospace. And at what point does Benowitz start to think that he's picking up some sort of alien signal or, you know, he's detecting UFOs? I think at 77 or 8, he was seeing lights and Chris Lembert describes this in his book, too. He was seeing lights, like, out somewhere on the base, like, lifting up off the ground and flying over a mountain and going down, but they were glowing orbs. And he said that he could look through binoculars and sometimes see, like, Air Force people or somebody walking around them before they took off. Then they go straight up, go over them out and go down, and it's not clear as to whether they were doing things that were unconventional or just kind of doing this, because if they went, "Zoop!" And they were like, you know, then you kind of like, "Whoa." So he saw that for a while and then he started filming it with eight millimeter cameras and then later video, early video. And because of that and also because he was doing hypnosis with this woman, Merna Hansen, that said she was abducted or something had happened to her. You know, at that point, Bud Hopkins' book hadn't even come out. So one of the people that knew about this kind of thing was Leo Sprinkle and also James Harder. There were two psychologists and they both worked with APROW. And as I said, Benowitz was a member of APROW, a very phenomenal research organization. Okay. This is a UFO research group. Yeah. They're in Arizona. It was run by Jim and Coral Lawrence and who had split off from the Midwest UFO network, which is now the Mutual UFO network. Move on. Yeah. So they started their own group which they said was, I think, was more scientific. Anyway, Paul joined them. I've seen his application. It's kind of cool to just see what he was saying about himself. Anything interesting that he said? They said, "What was it?" He just said, "I can help with some of the technical aspects." Yeah. Master's, I think, in electrical engineering. Okay. That's right. He said that he can help with some of the technical aspects of, you know, if they wanted to, you know, if they had any kind of equipment they wanted to use to start, you know, doing what people now do now, which is to detect UFOs. And it's been going on for years, but we just got into the point last 20 years where you can actually have an automatic system that's pretty accurate. So he said that about his expertise, but he also, the other thing I thought was kind of fascinating. They said, "What's your favorite UFO book?" And he said, "Books by Heineck." That's all he said. Okay. He was later Heineck apparently visited his house. Yeah. And that's how he got in touch with, at first, Leo Sprinkle and Sprinkle came out to interview, to help him regress this woman and figure out what had happened to her. And Sprinkle, after being there, I think the second time he came, he said, "Benham's was there with like a rifle and a pistol and he said, you know, they're coming, you have to come in the house right now." And this was before he even contacted the Air Force, I think. Wow. So he was already exhibiting signs of paranoia and, okay, crazy. You know how we're always diving into the edge of science and consciousness on this show? Lately, I've been thinking a lot about aging, not just in terms of years, but in how it actually feels in the body. Slow recovery, lower energy that middle-aged fog that sneaks up on you. I feel like I can barely go out and drink alcohol anymore. That's why I started using something called "Qualia Centolytic" and it's been a major shift for me. Let me explain. As we age, our bodies accumulate what scientists call "sinescent cells", also known as zombie cells. These are worn out cells that stop dividing but don't die. They hang around in your body, draining your energy, clogging up your recovery, and generally making you feel older than you are. "Qualia Centolytic" is a first of its kind supplement formulated with nine plant-based compounds designed to help your body naturally eliminate these zombie cells. It's not something you take every day, just two days a month. But it supports your body in aging better at the cellular level. Since I've started taking it, I've felt sharper, lighter, and like my body's resilience has come back online. It's vegan, non-GMO, and grounded in serious research. Experience the science of feeling younger. Go to "QualiaLife.com/Jessie" for up to 50% off your purchase and use code "Jessie". Again, that's J-E-S-S-E for an additional 15% off. That's q-u-a-l-i-a-l-i-f-e.com/Jessie, J-E-S-S-E for an extra 15% off your purchase. Thanks so much to "Qualia" for sponsoring this episode. So he does. He sees these sort of orb-like things going over a mountain right next to Kirtland. And then does he detect anything else like any sort of signal? And it wasn't at that point, as things progressed, he started putting up equipment to detect signals because he thought, "Maybe I can hear what the aliens are talking about." Because he called the Air Force and said, "Look, there's stuff flying over the base." I think it's aliens, and I want to tell you about it, and I've got films, and so the base was like, "He's not supposed to be watching this stuff." So instead of telling him, "No, no, I get out of here, you know, that's nothing. It's national defense or whatever, security." They said, "Well, we'll come on down here and show us what you got, because I wanted to see what it was." You know, is it something we're working on that he's not supposed to see? Obviously, it's something we're working on, because he's pointing the camera at the base. So I talked to a guy at the NSA who was not there. His name was Tom Dooley, I actually talk about him in the book. But he had a colleague that was at that meeting, the first meeting with Benowitz, where they had all the security people, and maybe the commander of the base, I'm not sure, but it's certainly all the security people, and some of the military and civilian people, I guess, in charge of different projects at the base, because they wanted to see what he's looking at. And he told me, "By the end of the meeting, everybody started leaving, and by the end of the meeting, it was like three or four people left, because they're like, "Oh, that's not ours. That's not ours." So they can care about it. People that were concerned stayed there, and the only one I know of is the guy that was ahead of AFOASI at the time, I think. And he said, "Hey, Paul, this is interesting. Why don't you keep telling us what's going on?" Because I wanted to see exactly what he's saying, when he's seeing it, and then eventually convinced him that he was working with them. So he trusted them, so they could basically tell him whatever they wanted, and keep an eye on him, and people keep asking, "What do they do that for?" And I said, "It was far more valuable to them to find out what he was seeing, how he was seeing it." If anybody else could do this, even though he was an electronic genius, and who he was talking to, like anybody could just write him and say, "I'm a UFO researcher, and what are you doing?" And then they could check up on the person, maybe he's a Russian or Chinese or otherwise asset. So it's basically so they could get a handle into, "What do these people, who does he know? What is he telling them? What is he thinks going on?" And of course, he tells somebody from another country, from an adversary, and they'll get clues as to what's being worked on, and they can concatenate that with other information they're getting from other sources, so it's another source of information. So I want to make sure he wasn't some sort of security leak inadvertently, because I didn't think he was an alien or anything like that. They just thought he was kind of an outlaw crazy scientist guy, which he kind of was. And in keeping in touch with them, they could keep a lid on that stuff, and I think that's why they contacted Bill Moore. It's like, "Well, you're a UFO guy. If you cooperate with us, we'll give you some secrets, we'll give you some documents." And they did, but just about all of them turned out to be crap. So let's explain that. So Bill Moore is a UFO researcher who's kind of starting to reach peak prominence at that time, I think, in '79 or '80. He had just written, oh, written the Roswell incident. Roswell incident. The first book about the Roswell, correct? Which really put it on the map before that it was not, you know, before him and Stan Friedman '79 made it. Yes. Stan kind of discovered what was going on, and then he helped, he was like Bill's research. That's right. Yeah. Nobody mentioned this bill at the Roswell festival. That's right. He's why they're doing all this. Right. Him and Stan, actually. Yeah. Well, it might be because of his. Yeah. The souring of events. Which we'll talk about. He was kind of, you know, really starting to ascend in UFO world as a good researcher. Yeah. He was also the Philadelphia spare man. Yeah. And he was on the board of APRO on APRO, too. Okay. That was the other connection. Okay. So, he is ascending, and then what happens is he gets sort of co-opted by. Um. County Intelligence. Yeah, basically. He got a letter that was sent to APRO, and APRO looked at it and said, well, why don't you check this out? It was just basically from this guy who said they were on patrol. Somewhere in. It might have been New Mexico, I can't remember, but he said we're on patrol. We saw this UFO.
really weird everybody got freaked out and I just wanted to write somebody. Bill checked it out and he told the Afro people it's BS. This is just this is somebody's fake letter. It was supposedly a military person that wanted to get this information out and Bill checked out and the guy didn't exist. He did find out the incident may have happened but not in the way the guy said. So he just said we'll ignore this it's BS and a few months after that he was on tour doing radio shows for Roswell incident. He was at one radio station and they said there's a call for you. He thought that it was a prank call and he just basically hung up on him. So he goes to Albuquerque the next stop on his book tour he goes into the radio station. Same thing happens. Same voice and he's like okay this is a lot a lot of effort to put in for just a hoax. So he started talking to the guy and they said you know if you're interested come and meet you know at this certain time and so that's when he met I think the first meeting he had was with Dodie and the guy known as he called Falcon which was apparently was a retired CIA agent called Harry Rositsky who has since passed away and I think he was like do you know anything about him Rositsky? Yeah you go look him up and you will know more than I do because a lot of stuff has come out about him since I first let's come out who he was what he worked on his specialty was Soviet operations he had he had he'd come out of OSS okay and World War Two and I think he'd worked with Reinhard Gailan and some of the Nazis afterwards to set up intelligence networks in Europe because because of the Russians and he'd also you know he'd also been in Afghanistan I think and it was monitoring Soviet radio transmissions there he did a lot he was basically was there one of their Soviet experts and so in the late 70s early 80s when this when the period we're talking about they pulled him out of retirement to help run this unofficial operation against the Russians and Chinese whoever else and they needed somebody from the UFO like research community has kind of a contact so they approached I think a bunch of different people and a few of them said yes and Bill was one of them do we have any sense of what Dodie had so Dodie's obviously gonna play this sort of villain role in this whole story you know he's the main kind of you know Air Force Office of Special Investigations agent who enters Benowitz's life and you know plants all sorts of BS and and kind of screws with him mentally do we know anything about his history up until that point who Dodie's yeah I don't know too much about it all I know is what he said and it's like it's what am I gonna do with what he said he said he was a guarded Area 51 I have no idea trying to take that a face value well I he also said I think his father worked at Area 51 are you familiar with that history Dolan told me that Richard Dolan yeah I think maybe yeah well Dolan will probably know yeah another I don't think he ever mentioned that but you know he could he would probably take stories like that and kind of you know yes and match them another interesting data point on Dodie I know very little about him before the Benowitz story but he shows up at Mario Woods's okay so Mario Woods is at Ellsworth Air Force Base in South Dakota in 1977 he's a Missile Security Officer and he not only sees a craft I see this light off to my east he claims that these beings walked up to him he then gets a hypnotic regression and he discusses being inside of a craft wakes up 10 miles away you know and I think it's it's it's don so like hour it was like the whole night had elapsed yeah and his partner Michael Johnson's in a catatonic state I even tried pulling his hand off that steering wheel and he has no idea what's happened to him and he then is debriefed by you know a slew of official you know people at Ellsworth Air Force Base and one of the guys is Rick Dodie next to him was this new OSI guy named Rick Dodie interesting yeah because the first time I saw him was on ancient aliens and I said I know that guy he was at my debrief hmm so that's kind of interesting as well well here was that 77 year two before yeah well maybe if if true that's probably why Dodie was tracked into this right because I think he has an interest in the UFO subject because I believe just like we all do it's just that his job was to mess with people concerning it totally which he enjoyed the weird part is it's like there's Mario's is one of the strongest cases you know I'm like you I think a lot of UFO stuff is bullshit but Mario's to me I've spent a lot of time with the guy it just pattern matches to one of these nuclear cases where like clearly there is an overwhelming nuclear pattern that goes above and beyond in my opinion the ability for humans to coordinate so it's interesting that Dodie was probably part of a debrief around a real case yeah and then is also involved in this sort of yeah insert himself as you know a counter-ental guy in this other case yeah well maybe when that stuff came up they're like well either he said something or this guy knows you know this is just speculation yeah and Rositzky apparently hand picked all these people to be part of this operation I asked more about it once and he said well think of it as a giant because what he said was the Benowitz thing was one cog in a giant wheel connected to a bunch of other giant wheels that you would never notice the only reason it's notice is because it's UFO people have kind of made it into a big a big story not that it isn't but you know there are a lot of other parts of this counter intel that was going on in the late 70s early 80s before the Berlin wall fell and all that that people don't know about the only reason this came out is because I had to do with UFOs so people are interested in that subject obviously but what he said the other thing he said to me later was imagine the Benowitz operation as a 24 hour long stage play hmm yeah it's like you and Benowitz is five minutes in one scene not even five minutes that's how much of the entire because when people UFO people and researchers et cetera hear about this they're like oh my god it's so important like it was a tiny little piece in a big wheel that was working with a lot of other things to like here's one more way we can you know mess with and and vet out Soviet assets and that's what he was using it for I don't think Rizitsky gave less of a crap about UFOs all he care about is what he could do with it is another thing I put on a t-shirt you know what you know UFOs are a Swiss army knife for intelligence I can use anything yeah we're just talking earlier that and you could insert UFO like I find this interesting with like the JFK assassination if you were a counterintell agent you would say that the JFK assassination was only you know it was only UFOs like say you wanted to detract from the fact yeah that it was you know nuclear you know that that JFK wanted to defame the American nuclear arsenal that you get rid of the CIA and so they retaliating or whatever you throw people down the trail with this thing UFOs and then it's you can track the people that talk about it with respect to UFOs UFOs are sort of a proxy for somebody's kind of irreverence towards you know earthly authorities or something an open-mindedness generally you know you can track Soviet spies or traitors or whatever take something that people have a really strong emotional attachment to but no way to prove any of it and that's a big ass wrench in the in the toolbox because if you're emotionally attached to something you can be let around by the nose so sometimes when people get excited it's like detach your your emotions from this because you're not going to see the bigger picture if you just if you're just looking at this thing well not only that you're making yourself susceptible to your own talent exactly so I just it just it's snowballs you know totally this episode is sponsored by one of my new favorite products oh do this is one of the coolest internet products I've seen lately it allows you to start a full-scale business from your laptop it's not just a website builder or CRM it's a full suite of tools that all seamlessly integrate and speak to one another oh do gives you everything in one connected platform sales inventory accounting e-commerce whatever you need it works together out of the box so whether you're selling a physical product launching a media company like me running a nonprofit or scaling a startup it's all you need in one simple system what I like is their philosophy unity makes creative strength it's true in systems and it's true in teams oh do help simplify the chaos of running something complex so your creative focus stays sharp it's really a beautiful and simple product so act on the idea you have don't keep putting it off you can start with just one app and it's literally free to try there's no downside if you want to upgrade later the service will scale with your needs head to odu.com to get started that's od o o pronounced odu and follow at odu.official on Instagram or at odu on TikTok now back to today's episode so okay before we get into the kind of the meta analysis of how these mechanics work let's talk about the details so more is basically his ascending
and see is being used against him. We're gonna give you secret info if you comply with us. - Yeah. - And then at what point does Moore interact with Benowitz, and at what point does Dodie directly interact with Benowitz? - I think more interacted with him just through Appro, and it was very soon, I think, after he was contacted, because he said that, oh, there's another part of this story. The reason they met with him after that phone call is he was one of the few, 'cause they sent that letter out to different people. That supposed letter from somebody in the military that had seen the UFO at close range. And he was one of the few that said, this is BS. Before he met with Rositsky and Dodie, they gave him one more test. They gave him a memo showing that there was some sort of a UFO sighting, I guess, in Central or Southern New Mexico in the late '40s or early '50s. And it was, I believe it was called, it was part of a project called Silver Sky, 'cause a memo was called the Silver Sky memo. He went and checked it out and found out that was BS too. So he, like, when they finally talked to him, they said, you're the only person that just, you actually went out and found out that this stuff was false. And they kind of, for some reason, they wanted somebody who had an investigative mind, like, could kind of dig out whether something was BS or not, or was a false swagger, not a whatever you want to call it. And that's why they picked him. - I think Bill Moore was a pretty decent UFO investigator. Like, if you read the Philadelphia experiment, you know, I don't know. It's, I haven't corroborated whether all of the details that he discusses our right. And I have reason to believe there's a lot of counterintelligence around the Philadelphia experiment. This is, again, this case in the 1942, where, you know, a ship was rumored to be zapped from a Philadelphia Navy port to Norfolk, Virginia. - Yeah, time travel, whatever. - Time travel, Thomas Taylor's round. - There's a movie made of it. - The Charleston was in it. - And the rumors that the sailors in the ship were fused to the hull and you have all these screams. And then you have this guy coming out later, saying he was a time traveler as a result of that. - Yeah, Carlos Ayende. - Carlos Ayende is the guy who leaked the story to Morris Jessup, who was a pseudonym. The real guy's name is Carl Allen, who was a merchant marine and Navy merchant marine. - Yeah, the Carl so you end up, yeah. - And so, anyway, interesting story. And Bill Moore writes about this whole story and like, I think a pretty, you know, hard headed, you know, maybe you get some things wrong. But like, he's a good researcher. He's not, I don't think he's a bad researcher. So, but he seems to lend a lot of credibility to the fact that Rositsky and Dodie can give him secret information. So he's gonna comply. - Well, at least somebody that Rositsky knows is going to hand him dossiers of stuff. - Dossiers of stuff. - He had to go, one time he was told in the middle of this, he said, go to this hotel room in upstate New York. There'll be somebody there to meet you. They just gave him an envelope with all these old documents in it and said, you got 20 minutes. - Yep. - 'Cause what can I do? And they said, anything you want, you just can't keep the documents. - Wow. - So he had a 35 millimeter camera. He just couragefully took pictures of all of them. - Whoa. - Crazy. - And this happened more than once in various forms. - Yep. - And that was the exchange for keeping tabs on people and saying what this person doing, what are they thinking? As he told me later, and actually he told other people, none of them ever really amounted to anything. - Yeah. - The MJ-12 stuff, the Eisenhower briefing memo. When he first released the report on them in this book called the MJ-12 Papers, the thing actually said compelling but not conclusive. That's all it said. And then after a few years, he said, I don't think almost anything I was given was actually true 100% UFO information. - Yeah. - It was all either around it or completely made up. - Yeah, yeah, yeah. - And he said he kind of felt, he kind of felt used and cheated. - Sure. - How does Moore and Dodie proceed to trick Benowitz into believing he is detecting more than he is when it comes to alien signals and UFOs? People are gonna argue with me, but as I recall it and I wrote, Benowitz was his own worst enemy. The only problem was he had people around him not contradicting him and encouraging him. And then occasionally saying something, the only thing I know that Bill Moore did was, he was told to give Benowitz a document called the Aquarius document or memo or something like that. And it said it was, there was a little different pieces of UFO like examinations of footage. Like this looks good, this doesn't, apparently from some government source. And one of Benowitz's or two of Benowitz's films are mentioned in that, I know that because you look at it and you go, oh, it says I think Albuquerque or the current one or something like that, but their analysis analyses of his films in part. And they were encouraging. It's like, well, this is unidentified. We don't know what it is. But Moore was told to give that to Benowitz, he said, hand him this document. As far as I know, or he never admitted it to me, he never actually went to Paul Benowitz and said, look into this, this is important, this was leaked to me. He was basically, they're just kind of monitoring him as far as I know. But Paul Benowitz was so excited about what he was seeing and so convinced of whatever he thought became reality. That it was really easy just to mislead him with a little push here and there. Well, that's own interesting. Paul, why don't you look into that a little further? Instead of, don't worry about that. That's not part of anything. Everything was encouraged as long as it pushed him away from any secret projects or information. And you see Benowitz start to get more and more fervent in his interest. And he's doing flights around Archoleda, Mesa, where he thinks maybe there's some underground. Like they showed it to him because they wanted him to pay attention to that rather than to Kurtland anymore. It's like, let's just drive his attention away from there. And to, in furtherance of that, and, you know, Dodie told me this, I think Moore told me this, and then a few people around the area, around the Hickory Apache area. Paul was very excited when he told him that the Air Force had taken him in a helicopter from Kurtland, flown him up to Northwestern New Mexico to the Archoleda, Mesa, which is on the Hickory Apache reservation, and showed him stuff saying, look, we think there's something going on here. They actually put jeeps and like water tanks and all kind of stuff in this place as props. So he would be concentrating on that. The funny thing is that apparently, there was some sort of crash up there within that period after that. So there was a stealth fighter or maybe it was a drone or something that definitely crashed there. But he never took pictures of it close enough where you could tell what it was. Oh, no, he got up there after they'd cleaned it up. So you see like this burned area and Gabe said they went up there and found, you know, broken up brush and evidence that something had been picked up and a pen that said US government property on it. So something happened there that was very important. And maybe they just thought, you know what, this is even better because now he's really going to concentrate up there. And he made drawings of what he thought he saw. And I included those in the book. And they kind of morphed depending on what he was thinking at the time. He had like one version of it. And then he said it was a craft that the aliens had given to the United States government and the government was flying and they didn't know how to do it and it crashed. And so it gets more and more Byzantine and complicated and you know, and his paranoia builds. And is there a good prosaic explanation for the orbs that he initially saw going over that mountain next to Kirtland or the only thing I can think of and based on what I was heard and on Chris Lambrite's book X Descending, it was some sort of project either with drones or some sort of unconventional flying objects that had some sort of glow to them. Whether you can ascribe that to having like a lighter than air with a light in it or, you know, Chinese lantern type thing or some kind of weird energy or something like that, I don't know. But they seemed, apparently they seemed solid and they didn't move like airplanes and they tested them at night. - So how was he detecting any sort of signals to begin with coming out of the base? - Because he was an electronics engineer and he built things to pick up, I guess a wide range of radio signals. Probably centered on the military bands of signals, not just like FM or AM or shortwave or anything. And he built an antenna array. He had all these machines for analyzing the signal. And he built all this from scratch. Nobody had any of this stuff. Or he jury read some of this stuff from his lab. But he built apparently a setup and started listening to transmissions coming from the base. Which is a huge problem if you're trying to be a security person at Curtlyn. You know, people shouldn't even be listening to this much less inventing machines and equipment to listen to it in the first place. Because if he's doing it, other people can do it. So that's what they were worried about. But he thought he could pick up, as far as I remember, he thought he could pick up transmissions that aliens were beaming either to each other or to the military or something. And why did he think whatever he was picking up was alien?
because it didn't comport with anything he could conceptualize. So just the fact that it was kind of anomalous. There was never actual message. It might have been from what I've heard and what I've assumed, which might be wrong as it was a telemetry for missile guidance or something like that, and it was microbursts. So they sounded like, and he would slow them down. And he thought he was hearing patterns in it and saying these are the aliens doing this. And he was using this setup, and Gabe told me about it. He said he saw that setup. But he also saw the setup, apparently, after Jay Allen Heineck showed up. So what Bill told me-- and of course, everybody's like, well, he's telling you this because it's this information Heineck wouldn't do such a thing. Some time I believe in the early '81 or so, maybe even earlier, '80, '81, something like that. Jay Allen Heineck showed up at Paul's door with a computer. An entirely built already-made computer and said, this will help you with the signals. And Bill told me that since Heineck knew that Bill was doing some of this spy stuff somehow, they went to-- or he told him enough that Heineck kind of got it. Because Heineck had been employed by the Air Force since the 1960s. And apparently in the early '80s, he was still on the payroll. He just wasn't doing very much. But it sounds like he was complicit in this whole thing, where-- Yeah, but I think that he didn't know what was on the computer. Otherwise, he had a conscience. He might have said, I don't want to do this. OK, so the given the computer, Benowitz then starts to pick up even more on this computer. So at some point, somebody at the base or at any number of intelligence agencies that had presence there to make sure that the security was tight decided, why don't we just give him a computer with stuff on it and let him pick it up, and then have it. Because he thought the Air Force was cooperating with him, like he was bringing in information they needed. He was, but not the kind that he thought. So he thought he was doing sort of vitals-- Yes, exactly work too. That's exactly what he said for these alien signals. He said, we're interested in what you're doing, Paul. Please keep talking to us. Tell us what you're doing. It's important for national security or whatever. And he's like, OK. But I think even more explicitly he picks up certain messages that he interprets as, like, we've given the US eight crafts or something like specific things. Yeah, he starts decoding things and the decoding are basically based on his parodolia about what should be coming out of those messages. Parodolia, by the way, for the audience, is seeing a pattern where it doesn't exist, which is a human tendency. Yeah. It's an evolutionary thing. You've got to see patterns so you can survive. Yes. So-- but it does us as disservice when it's things like this, because you can make patterns out of stuff that don't exist, so that's what he was doing. As you know, I'm always on the hunt for things that help me stay sharp, focused, and full of energy while I'm diving into life's mysteries and making this show happen. And I've got to say, Mudwater has completely transformed my mornings. Back in the day, I used to struggle with that post-coffee crash. And let's not even get into the caffeine jitters. Mudwater gave me the smooth, steady energy I was missing. It's packed with functional mushrooms, like lion's mane, chaga, and racie, plus turmeric and cacao, all working together to keep me focused, calm, and grounded. Honestly, it's like coffee went on a yoga retreat and came back zen. What I love most is that it's not just about replacing coffee. It's a whole new ritual. It's a simple, nourishing way to start the day. And I actually look forward to it every morning. Every ingredient is USDA certified organic vegan non-GMO in their zero sugar. It's energy that doesn't mess with your sleep or make you question your life choices at 3am. Ready to make the switch to cleaner energy? Head to mudwater.com. That's m-u-d-w-t-r.com and grab your starter kit today. Right now, our listeners get an exclusive deal up to 43% off your entire order, plus free shipping and a free rechargeable frother when you use code Jesse. That's right, up to 43% off with code Jesse at m-u-d-w-t-r.com. After your purchase, they'll ask you how you found them. Please show your support and let them know we sent you. Keep your energy natural and refreshing all year long with mudwater, because life's too short for anything less than clean, delicious energy. - Did you get any other messages? So something about possibly eight crafts that the U.S. have retrieved? - I'm not sure if the stuff that I put in there in the book has deciphered code. - Okay. - I'm not sure if that's before or after the computer. - Okay. - It might be after, because it seems really detailed. - Okay, so what else did he receive generally? - Just that there were aliens from another planet. They were here, they were trying to establish a base. They needed earth women or something. It sounds like a science fiction movie. To propagate their race, their planet was dying. - Wow. - All this stuff and that they were at some point going to take over and so that's what really scared him. And I think he was saying that before and this computer just basically said, "Okay, let's take what he's saying and just prank it up." - And across the street, there maybe are some NSA officials. - Yes, maybe that happened. I mean, the person that told me that was Bill. And since he's my friend, I trust him. The people say this about Bill. It's like, "Why do you trust him?" It's like, "I've never found him to be lying to me ever." I've known him for what? 35 years or more? - Well, if never lied to me once. - If anything, is Bill need to off himself at Moofon and say that he was complicit and wrongdoing is probably maybe some sort of indicator that you should trust him. Also, I don't know why he would make that up. I mean, that seems, if you were to, you know, in-cept signals into a mainframe computer, the NSA would be the ones to do that. I mean, that they're signals intelligence. That's what they do. - Yeah, exactly. So, somebody programmed it for him. Heinrich brought it to the door. He hooked it up and then started immediately seeing these messages. He also saw pictures. He thought he was looking into the alien planet into the future and past of the Earth. He had a little oscilloscope, or at least at CRT. - Oh my God. - Analog CRT with the scans. - And. - What is CRT? - Cathode Ray Tube. - Okay. - Like old TV screens. - Yeah, got it, got it. - And somebody had just put this video in there for him. Gabe told me he went over there and saw some of him. He said there were dinosaurs and old Roman battles and stuff, but they were probably from old movies. - Mm-hmm. - But they were all garbled and weird and Gabe said he saw this. So somebody was beaming this junk at him. - Oh man. - And apparently they set up across the street and to send these signals into the computer that would be decoded in the way the computer was designed to decode them. And he thought it was coming from inside the base 'cause I think they probably just sent him at the same frequency. - And then he starts to kind of lose his mind. Is that right or? - Yeah, as things get worse, he starts losing sleep. He thinks there's gonna be some sort of alien invasion. The woman were in a Hanson that he had come into his house in the '80s talking about, she was talking about being abducted and going to this underground facility, which really, that stuff is, I don't know if it's true or not, but it's formed so much of a UFO lore afterward. So a lot of stuff happening at the time that Paul was dealing with just became part of the UFO lore. And yes, there's independent people that have said that this happened to them. I don't know where they get the information. Maybe it's been disinfo-beamed at them and said to them too. I don't know. But a lot of the tropes kind of started back then. He said there was an alien base underground at the Arctual Automation. He went there with a camera and took pictures of what he said of things going in and out of the mountain, but they basically, they're just like blurs. And it could be something, but it also be camera artifacts. Who knows? Nothing I've seen of the pictures he took up at the Arctual Automation Area really amounted. There's no like clear, like Billy Meyer looking picture. But, you know, a couple of the things he videos he took in at Curtlyn show, there's one of them that looks like a saucer kind of like this. And there's a PSA Pacific Southwest Airlines playing flying behind it. So who knows what that thing was. But as nobody came in and said, Paul stopped me, you know, Jesus, Bill said he tried. He did give him that Aquarius document. And it actually mentions access only to MJ12, which is the first time anybody said anything about MJ12 was in this fake document, the Aquarius document. - Wow. - And it says, quote, MJ hyphen, T-W-E-L-V-E, unquote. - Whoa. - Yeah. So somebody was trying to plant that in the culture then to like, you know, 1981 or whenever he got this document. But Bill was told to give him this. This is the only documented thing that document at least by Bill where he said, they told me to do this and they told me if I didn't give him that thing that the deal was off. And he read it, he knew what it was. He's like, this is a pretty ass. So he went to Paul's office. And he was trained. They gave him spy training, Bill. They had him doing other stuff too. They had him like, you know, passing mail through and doing, you know, stuff with Soviet spies on our side. spy.
in the Soviet Union. They would send postcards and he'd have to like read them on a telephone call exactly and then take them to another post office and mail it from that post office to the next post office spy stuff. But he said that he finally, because he hesitated, it's like, I don't know if I want to do this. He said it was like, you know, you're a kid, they tell them off, he says, I won't just stand on the corner and look, tell me if this car comes by and then the next week, you're burying bodies, you know, kind of thing. It wasn't that bad, but he's like, he kind of just gets warmed into this structure, this intelligence structure. So he said that he took the finally, he said, okay, you know, I'm going to give it to Paul. He goes down to his office, tells, you know, meet me at your office in a certain time. And he takes him, he says, get a radio and they go in the supply closet, he said, and he turned the radio up and he gave him the thing and said, I was told to give this to you, take it with a grain of salt. And he said, as far as he knew, Paul never said anything about it and he just put it in his safe at work. So he did this with Paul. Paul took it, didn't say anything about it, but it certainly affected his mindset and his thinking. It's like, oh my god, I'm important, they're paying attention to me. I'm getting the secret information. What happened was his family got worried about him. They're like, geez, you know, he's not doing his work. He's staying up all the time. He's chain-smoking, like he'd smoke a whole pack of cigarettes over lunch while Bill talked to him. He's like, Paul, it's like, yeah, yeah. Everybody was telling him to calm down while knowing what was causing what was going on. They're like, you know, Dodie said he even told him. Yeah, but he couldn't, he couldn't control, you know, I don't know if you've ever been in a paranoid state where just everything makes sense, everything that's as arrayed against you, every conversation you hear, William Burrow's talks about this. It was a great lecture he talked about this. But yeah, I think in UFO world, you can get into this sort of solipsistic mindset where you know, this is all an illusion or whatever. I mean, if there are other beings and I mean, it becomes this, you're living in the Da Vinci code or something. Yeah, exactly. And he couldn't get out of that loop, but his family's just like, oh my god. So they actually put him in a mental health facility for like a month or so because there's these, I've heard people still say, he died in a mental institution or he killed themselves like, no, his family was worried about him. They put him in a minute like a mental health facility for like a month or two. Tell he calm down. And when he came out of it, he was still interested in this stuff, but it wasn't running his life. That's good. And then I think he realized probably from talking to his family and maybe even Bill, like just, you know, if you don't want to code on early grave, please relax. Yep. And Dodie then comes out and admits I befriended Paul that was tasked to do that. And I sent him down the wrong path. And I would continuously feed him passage material, passage material is classic kind of spook, you know, I don't know if he did or not, but I wouldn't put it past. I don't I don't know if Bill was privy to that or anybody I talked to was. And Dodie didn't tell me that. Maybe because he didn't want to say that. I just mean passage material, not in terms of documentation. I just mean like wrong information. Oh, yeah. I mean, he could have done that anytime. Paul said, like I said before, Paul would say, this is happening. Dodie, think, yeah, you know what? I have indication that that's happening. Maybe you should check it out. Right. I mean, that kind of thing. And it just kind of builds on itself. Yeah. And and John Lear, who's obviously implicated in the Bob Lazarus story and sort of, you know, says all sorts of insane things around this time. You worked for Air America and all this stuff. So I think John Lear was like Benowitz part two because he communicated with Benowitz after this. Right. So yeah, that's the interesting thing is in some ways, John Lear seems like he was fed maybe a ton of disinformation, but he also meets with Benowitz. Are you familiar with this? Yes. Did you know that? Yeah. And then Benowitz. No, multiple times. So Benowitz got mad at him and said he didn't want to talk to him. Right. Yeah. I can't remember what the breakup was about. But yeah, Ben, he met with Benowitz a few times. I'd just like asked him questions. And maybe John Lear was subject to the same disinfo as Benowitz. Or do you think he was tasked with both? Okay. You know, not because I could sit here and say that's what happened, but the indications to me is is from his actions. And what he, you know, what I was told that when I was told he went with Benowitz and how is and how Benowitz reacted to him. And also the fact that I think somebody asked Lear at one point about something about, God, I wish I knew exactly what it was. I know who told me so I can ask them. But he said, well, John, what about, you know, all this stuff up at, you know, the underground base up at Archulet, Amesa and the Hickory Apache. And this, you know, this big firefight and all that. And I don't know if it was that story, but Lear said, oh yeah, I made that up. He actually said this. He literally says I made that up. To incompetence or at least, privately to this one guy, right before one of those first congressional hearings about UFO stuff in the, I think it was in the early 90s. It was, it might have been one of the ones that Greer set up. I'm not sure. But yeah, I mean, Lear admitted this. And because of his, you know, previous background, flying for our America, which he touted a lot saying I was one of the, you know, he's got an intelligence background. So CIA cargo pilot. Yeah. So he, you know, he very well may have been tasked to check up on Benowitz and feed him more stuff after the fact. But you're giving Jalen Hainake the benefit of the doubt. Only because what I know of him is that if he knew that's what it was, I don't think he'd have done it. I'm not so sure. Well, I don't know. I don't have a ton of reason to believe. It's just a guess that my only, you know, I think of that, you know, a documentary, UFO's past, present, and future. Emma Negger's? Yes. Robert Emma Negger and Rod Cirling's doing the, you know, um, narration. I interviewed Bob a couple of times on my show. Interesting. Yeah. I'd love to. He was a cool guy. I liked him. Seems like a cool guy. Well, he, it seems like he was maybe one of the first examples of this, you know, using UFOs as a strategy to sort of lure people in because he is in communications with Norton Air Force Base. And I believe he goes there and everybody there's talking to him about UFOs and they're telling him that they are going to give him, uh, you know, the Holland land land landing exactly Al Magordo earlier, um, I think in the, in the, in the 60s. And so he gets all excited and they say they're going to give him footage and they keep saying they're going to give him footage. They're going to give him footage. And then the footage never really appears and he's, he's actually, he is shown a little, he says. I think he was or is, um, it want his, like one of his partners, Bob Schardel or think something, uh, saw it. Yeah, Alan Sandler, another guy. What did you see on the film? Was it color? Was it black and white? It was black and white. I'm sorry. You know, my friend, but it was nothing other than what we ended in the book. We see this around thing and it wasn't that stable. Funny part. And it landed in a door open and guys come up looking like they were outer space guys. Yeah, it was Sandler. So one of them actually said this. I think even emanager says he saw it briefly or something and then you have this video that ends up, you have mostly like this animation rendition and you have his past, present and future that they have to do because they know the real footage. Yeah. But there's also a little bit of footage and that footage has now been debunked as an F4 and an F, the F4 came out I think in like 59 or something. So it was like right, like it was probably like not, you know, well known at the time. And it was definitely flying, you know, around all of them. And so I almost feel like the first kind of, you know, Rorschach test, you know, uh, throwing people off the trail. Was that documentary? And Jalen Heineck is obviously a big part of the documentary. So yeah, was Jalen, Alan Heineck used in that documentary as well. I don't know because he was through this whole thing. He was still getting a check from the Air Force. Well, that's what I was saying. That's what I'm saying. So I don't know. But yeah, does that mean you know what you're doing? Does that mean somebody tells you everything that's going on? Well, we're getting a check. I don't know. But one other data point about Jalen Heineck is, you know, Jacques Vallet was like his kind of understudy, his assistant. Jacques Vallet finds this Pentacle memo in the blue book files. Yeah. And he goes to Jalen Heineck and he's like, what the fuck? Because the Pentacle memo is like this whole, you know, Battelle Memorial Institute, secret UFO research program that is looking at, you know, these hot aerial hot spots presumably around nuclear, if you look at what was happening at the time. And Jalen Heineck is like, wait, what's going on? Like, you're not allowed to, apparently you weren't allowed to mention the Pentacle, you know, uh, this is written by a guy named Howard C. Cross. You weren't allowed to mention that program in the Robertson memo or Robertson panel, which creates a Robertson memo, which is basically the Constitution of blue book. It creates the mandate for blue book to kind of explain away and rationalize, you know, this stuff. And then Jalen Heineck or Vallet comes out saying, you know, I was convinced that Jalen Heineck actually, you know, didn't know about the Pentacle memo and this other thing. But like, I don't know. There are all these cases where Jalen Heineck has to like play dumb. And I'm like, I don't know, dude, I think you might have known a thing or two because he seems like a smart guy. Yeah. So, oh, no, I don't think he was dumb, but not being told something doesn't mean you're dumb, it just means you don't know it. No, I know, but it's like, you know, maybe three times where he could be complicit. Yeah. Oh, yeah. And I'm like, how many other time, you know, those are just three times that I know. I'm pretty sure he showed up at the computer. I'm pretty sure he gave it to better with, I don't know. Yeah, the crux.
says, does he, did he know what was on the computer? Did he know, what did, what did he know and when did he know it? So I don't know, there's no way to find that out. I tried to ask QFOs when I was writing the book. Do you have any correspondence with Heinrich during this time? And they said they'd helped me like three times. I never responded. They probably just thought I was a crazy person. Yeah. Well, far be it for my to try to off, you know, a UFO legend in Jalen, Heinrich, he's definitely contributed to the field. I'm going to air on the, on the side of like what I'd like to think, which is basically my whole MO because unless something convinces me that something's one way, I'm going to, I'm going to think the thing that makes me feel better until I get contributing, because you know, if I don't, because if I don't, I go down the paranoid path. Yeah, but I view the thrust of your work as inconvenient truths that you are laying out before people. And I like that. I mean, that's an interesting way. Well, I checked up on the stuff myself. That's why I believe it. If I hadn't checked up on it, if I hadn't written Project Beta, I would probably doubt it more. Because, you know, I didn't experience, I wouldn't be an experienced what I experienced. I talked to the people I talked to. Yes, I don't know if I was lied to, with Dodie, I know I was lied to a few times. So like 95% or more, 97% of what he told me is not in the book, because there's no way to tell, and the stuff where I just got it from in, it was relevant to the story. I said, Dodie's the only person that told me this. One other interesting data point is in 1982, Rick Dodie gets in touch with another UFO researcher Linda Molten-Howe, and she's shown a bunch of documents around presidential, you know, knowledge of UFOs and aliens, as well as Project Arnet, which involves accelerated evolution of humanity, with alien intervention, is that right? But I don't remember. Okay. See, a lot of stuff I wrote about, more stuff has come out since then, some of which is accurate, some of which isn't, and you may very well be right. I do not know what was in those documents. I thought I had something to do partially with some of the Academy of Relations stuff she was doing, but it was a bunch of different. Yeah, I know, I believe it had both, but this is based partially. She was very excited. I actually talked to Tom Adams, I think, afterwards, who was Academy of Relations research, and she went up and visited them right, like a couple days after that, and she was like over the moon. She's like, "Oh my God, I saw all this great stuff, it's so important," and so she took the bait at the time. I don't know what she thinks about it now. Yeah. Well, she was later interviewed in a documentary, and she was like, "I just don't want you to paint this, that the whole UFO thing is BS. I was tricked in this one instance, but the idea that UFOs are a cover for just prosaic technology is totally wrong. In fact, it's the opposite prosaic technology is often used as a cover for you. It's an interesting discussion." Yeah. It's probably both. In fact, it's demonstrably both. Oh, there you go. Yeah. Sort of, you know. But that's, yeah. It's separate from the UFO issue itself, which, you know, people think that after I wrote that book, you think it's all like military, it's like, "No. There's no way that the entire UFO phenomenon is military or intelligence connected." So you just use some of the UFO stuff is genuinely anomalous and by genuinely anomalous, I mean, not explained by prosaic atmospheric conditions. Oh, definitely. And not explained by a military attack, advanced movement. Definitely. Yeah. I mean, there's so many hundreds of thousands of things that have no connection to the military, anything. I agree with that, too. And I find it frustrating that this case that you write about, so, so, well. It needs to be contended with as a modality of how UFOs are used from a counterintelligence perspective. And you need to have those sets of goggles on when viewing everything in the UFO world. But you can't throw the baby out of the bathwater. Yeah. In some ways, that's maybe even the goal that, like, you're losing if you think the whole thing is fake. Yeah. Well, there's that belief thing again. If you believe something so strongly, that's all you're ever going to see. And so there's people, there's all kinds of opinions about it, whatever people's beliefs are. But the project beta, I mean, I wrote it because, well, because I made the proposal and the publisher said, let's do this one. Yeah. You know, Patrick Weige and Simon and Schuster said, let's do this one. I said, okay. But so many different weird accusations I've had about it's like, oh, you're cooperating with the government. Yeah. No, I was trying to tell a story. That's like saying that some, that's like saying that Vincent Boulierci cooperated with Manson. He's just writing a story about it. Yeah. A very opinionated story. But that's a weird analogy. Because I think Boulierci, who's the lead prosecutor to the case, wrote "Helter Skeleton." Okay. That's it. Toronto Rivera was cooperating with Manson. There you go. Oh, okay. So they had that weird interview on TV. Because the Boulierci thing, like if you read like chaos by Tom O'Neal, you kind of are like, Boulierci had some ulterior motive with the whole thing. Oh, yeah. Oh, he wrote it. He wrote a book about the Kennedy assassination that said that Oswald did it and there's no way around that. That's right. Yeah. So for your sake, I just want you to be clear. No ulterior motives. Yeah. For you. Yeah. No, not for me. Okay. What am I saying? If you report on anything, it means that you agree with it or disagree with it. It's like, no. I don't agree or disagree with what I put in the book. I think I think a lot of stuff that happened was absolutely morally wrong and shouldn't it happen? Yeah, of course. You're documented. But I'm not going to put that in the book or say anything about it. I've had people like, when I first started doing this and lecturing about it, it's like, why don't you tell, you know, why didn't you just say how wrong it was? It's like, what am I supposed to do? Tell you what you're, what it was moral and is not. Yeah. I think you got a better sense of what's right and wrong than, you know, I would give you, I could, that I would be assuming. It's also, I didn't. I mean, I'm just, you should know as much of the facts as you can and you make up your own decisions based on that. I think you're also in UFO world, you're kind of setting yourself up for failure if you polymerize everything because you're setting yourself up as the arbiter of right and wrong and truth and truth. And then you're going to get stuff wrong. Yeah. You're dealing with the most speculative stuff. So there were times where I've, I've attempted to make videos like the most steel manning I've done are like, you know, it's like I did this piece on Harold Malmgren and I'm probably going to come up with like a rebuttal on, you know, surgery. Oh yeah. Because that was that big D, D Johnson thing about it, which I'm happy to address now. I think it's excruciatingly obvious that Harold Malmgren was CIA and, you know, he says my agency a bunch of times and his daughter goes to the State Department and he's holding Paul Melon's walking stick, which he didn't buy at a yard sale. Yeah. And, you know, so Paul Melon's one of the founders of the CIA. He says Tom Farmer is his best friend, the general counsel of the CIA. He's this like spooky trade representative in all these cases. He was helping formulate the presidential daily briefing. Yeah. So the guy with CIA, you can a lot of debunking is based on the most likely thing, especially the UFOs, lets the most likely thing as a prosaic explanation. So that's the explanation and we're going to do anything we can to work yourself towards that prosaic explanation because that's that you work from a point of view rather than from us. Well, I've seen which UFO people are completely guilty of. I've seen his diary. I don't think it's a fake diary and Richard Bissell is all over it. Richard Bissell's the founder of Area 51 and the guy who he claimed to get briefed on other world technologies from. And he's, you know, even D. Dean Johnson admits that he's in his phone book or whatever. So there's connectivity there. He says in a 2024 interview before me, I was at the IDA, but that was a cover for my real work for the joint chiefs and the Pentagon. So all I'm saying is everybody in the audience believes that, you know, probably the CIA killed JFK. And if you really connect the dots, who called the shots there? It was Alan Delis at the Brown Brothers Heraman. You're talking about this time where you can't just do a FOIA from the FBI and know that if the person who got their cue clearance through the CIA, you have no idea if they have their cue clearance. So it's ridiculous. So I just think that plus like a few anecdotes about, you know, certain people not being aware of him or whatever is insane as a sort of like a whole debunk. And then there were a lot of, I thought, I thought, well, I know of it. It sounds like the, he did the, I think he and a few other people tried, no, it wasn't him, but the Travis Walton case. Yeah. And they're, and they talk about this fire tower and it's like, it was right next to the road. It's like, no, it's not. It's over a hill. You think they're so stupid. They don't know what a fire tower is. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You know, just stuff like that. Not, I'm not saying the whole story is true because of that. I'm not either. The debunk is so ridiculous on the face of it. Yes. I got, I, one of my friends stopped talking to me because I said, get better evidence if you're going to debunk. No, it's true. Actually, I like debunks. I like skepticism. Yeah. It's, it's not like a, oh, I don't, I don't not want to see a debunk. No, I want to see a good debunk. Well done one. I agree. Which takes as much as, you know, not everything, but takes as much into account as you can. And, and answers all the different doubts. I agree. No, it's like a Kendrick and Drake, you know, this, this is back and forth, get, except it's great. If you do the debunk and then I'll do the debunk of the debunk and we'll get better and we'll get to the truth. If you win, fantastic, because we're getting closer to the truth. So I think it's all, it's all good and it's all love. But yeah, it's about, it's, it's not a good debunk in this case. It's just not. No. And then there are issues with it, you know.
blue-gill triple prime, I think, according to Jeffrey Kruekshank, who I'm in touch with, who's analyzed this stuff really deeply. Apparently, Johnson's actually kind of really scared. He realized he got a lot wrong when it came to, that the booster's trajectory could not have, you know, it wasn't at all near the plume. And then it's funny, you have disagreements between the debunkers now, where my buddy, Merrick von Randenkamp, who I think is great, but I think he's wrong in this case, said it was the instrumentation pod. And D.D. Johnson's like, "No, it's not the instrumentation pod. It's the booster." And then Jeff Kruekshank shows that it's not the booster or the instrumentation pod. So I think there's a lot of things like a dog with a bone until, you know, it's obvious that they don't have it anymore. That's right. So anyways, all of that's to say, I could be wrong. I am not, you know, I'm not the arbiter of truth. I'm covering things. I do feel a little more inclined to defend a guy who just died, who's 89 years old, who, to me, this is probably the softest, most qualitative point I'll make, but just pattern matches to a great statesman who really helped the US in an earnest way over decades and was kind of a quiet operator. Yeah. So that's, that's all I'll say on that. Yeah, I see an analogy of how I feel about Bill Moore. It's like, I know him. I know his motivations. I know his, you know, political stance. I know his moral code and all of it fits with what he said. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And it also fits with how, how upset he gets with people that get it all wrong and then haven't been through it. Well, I empathize for that, with that or sympathize. You know, and I'll, I'll even say this now. I, I would bet that I would say I'll bet I would bet that in the future I will have to retract a thing that I cover. Of course, I mean, you are dealing with the most speculative topic on the planet. I mean, I have to. Yeah. So it's like, I will get stuff wrong. I guarantee I will get stuff wrong. That's the only guarantee. And then like, if I get stuff right, then it's like the most important stuff ever because it's like so uncorrelated with the consensus reality that, you know, you're contributing in this exciting way. So I think that's the way you have to view everything. You can't take yourself too seriously and attach your ego to any of this. Yeah, that's the problem. I mean, it's really hard to detach your ego from whatever opinion or research you've done. So getting back to the chord story. Okay, so so so so Rick Dodie then comes out after this whole saga. And he says that I am now on the side of the truth. And you see him on, you know, UFO Twitter or whatever. And you see him, you know, getting interviewed on Gaia and, you know, saying we have this many alien races and these were these crashes that really happen. They see these extraterrestrials, these four and a half foot tall gray colored entities. He even recently said that Luella Zondo was part of Space Force disinformation or something. And so he's going after some of the other, you know, whistleblowers in UFO world. What's up with Rick Dodie now? And is he at all trustworthy? The first chapter of that book that I gave you, it defies language. The title is the chapter of the chapter is you play the game or you get nothing. And I believe and what that means is you can be paranoid that somebody's going to tell you BS or just info or lead you down a path or whatever. But if you're not in the game playing, you know, if you're not sent at the table playing cards with people that are just handing you bad cards all the time and occasionally a nice one. You'll never get anything. So, and I think that applies to Dodie, maybe a little less now than it used to because I think less of what he says is either true, relevant or whatever. And I think that's mainly because he likes messing with people. That's his personality. He's basically, you know, he's a troll. He likes it. He likes messing. I mean, as far as I can tell, he probably won't want to talk to me again after this. He made a statement a few years ago. He never wanted to talk to me again. Wow. Because I said something about the SERPO thing where, apparently, there was some exchange with some other planet and some other stars. Yeah. He was a document leak. It was more like an info leak that was coming through a couple sources on the internet. And it involves like hydrogen isotopes or something and exotic propulsion and some spooky science. And that I'm not sure of all I remember was it was basically was like the, the last scene in close encounters where a bunch of people from the earth go to another planet and then some of the aliens come here. So the SERPO thing was planets, SERPO sent a bunch of aliens here and we sent a bunch of humans to their star system in exchange in the 1970s. Do you think, do you think any of this is, have you heard of cicada 3301? No, it's okay. So it's this weird like online scaverger hunt puzzle that involved complex mathematics that was presented in 2014. And I'm going to screw up some of the details but like very high level, I think it involved like you had to solve it. You needed a serious math, you know, aptitude. Yeah. And a lot of people think that the whole puzzle was set up by the NSA or CIA and it was like a recruitment or a tool. Yeah. Do you think some of this stuff that's coming out through Dodie or other people is some sort of initiation path? Or do you think it is all passage material to catch bad actors or a Rorschach test to test people's belief structures? I don't think it's so much at that anymore. It's more like when I first saw that article in 2017, the New York Times article, the Kane Blumenthal thing. Yeah. The Elizondo in it. The first thing I thought was what new project are they trying to ingrain within the with the trying to what's it called mix with the UFO subject and for what purpose? So I didn't think it was a purpose. Do you have a top candidate for what that project might be? And do you think that the 2017 article was sort of of the same variety as whatever happened to Benowitz? No. I don't think it was a Benowitz thing because we live in a different time where information is disseminated in a completely different way than it was then. But do you think those, you don't think those three videos that came out? I don't think they were faked. I'm pretty sure they weren't faked. Okay. But I think, you know, Rorschach blot again. Swiss Army knife again, get something that everybody's interested in. There's a lot of emotion around it. There's no real idea about what it might be and then use it for whatever you need to use it for either to deflect or direct attention. And I think, and this is just me being dumb. At the time, and I think still, although in the last few months, it's probably messed up now. I think there was a cold war going on with China and they're just trying to keep it from going hot. I have a friend that lives near Los Alamos. This friend told me, you want a job? And I said, what? She said, Los Alamos is hiring. I said, I don't have any of those skills. It was a woman. She said, you can write English competently, can't you? It's like, yeah, you edit video. They need those people. I said, why? Why does Los Alamos need those people? She said, there's a huge nuclear arms race going on right now. And they're building bombs like mad. And I just thought it sort of coincided with what all this big build up with the, and I don't know if it's directly related. But I think the UFO subject right now is being used as a as a fulcrum to figure out what people think, where people's attention can be drawn. I mean, it's just, I see it as this giant like social experiment seeing, you know, how can we use this to our advantage? Right. And on top of that, there's a technology advantage. There's a advantage where you have some technology that might look like that. And that can be, you know, attention can be directed towards or away from that. And, you know, I know that sounds vague. But I'm not privy to that information. I mean, you probably had other people on here that probably know a lot more than I do about that. But my suspicion is that it's being used for political gamesmanship, covering up defense tech, black projects, all that stuff. Well, it's definitely being allowed to be amplified at the very least. And I look at some of the people. And I think it's a metastasized and that it's all over the place now because somebody probably thought, let's just do this little thing and now it's because I guess the time has come and it's become this big thing. The other thing I think, and I'll fit, I won't interrupt you. But the other thing I think is it is crowdsourcing expertise around the subject. So people with the training and the equipment and the motivation, but we're scared to before, are going to concentrate on the UFO subject and put some expertise to bear on it, which was discouraged in the past. Now that stigma has been lifted. I think that's right. That's a good thing. That's a total good thing. I also think one of the things that I got interested in through the UFO subject, but in some ways is the most out of left field and uncorrelated with kind of consensus ufology, like really came out of left field was the town's and brown stuff around like, you know, gravity manipulation experiments. Oh yeah, he said that he was really impressed.
with you're like digging into that towns and brown stuff. You know Bill Moore, interview G-Towns and Browns? - That's why I want to talk to him, because I know he did. And I made that movie, "The Cosmic Conspiracy," about what I'm doing. - I may have his notes from that. I'll look for them for you. - Thank you, man. That means a lot. Yeah, I appreciate that. So with the brown stuff, - Yeah, people don't know who he is. - Well, I'm also, I'm convinced that, you know, I've signaled to no end that like, if I am doing anything that like seriously hurts like American national security or like, you know, get, you know, then like I want to know. - Yeah. - But nobody, nobody said anything. So it's like, it's just like, you know, sort of empty on the other end. So at that point, somebody I imagine has made a call on high that like we're gonna allow some of that stuff to come out too, even though, you know, completely organically looked into it and kind of, I think corroborated a lot of his stuff. - Yeah. - And somebody probably made a call that like, you know, I'm not like extremely well versed in like, some of the high level theoretical physics around it that at least saying this guy created this topological physics effect, you know, we're probably past the point of like, that being okay, not okay. - The byfield brown effect, yeah. So you could be right that like, there are these like, surprising but adjacent things that UFOs give you a framework for. That like, you know, for maybe whoever in the Navy or whatever was hoping for that. - Yeah, they want like energy unlocks and they want more surface area and even if you don't know what UFOs are, it's gonna push but Hopkins of all people. - You have a whole secret science kind of initiation. - Having a recording of him from 1987 or something, I videotaped him for a documentary and he said, you apologize, or UFOs are dragging us kicking and screaming into the science of the 24th century. - It is, yeah. - And it's kind of happening now. - I agree. Well, John Mack would talk about, you know, how to the Harvard psychiatry department of friends with Bud Hopkins, you know, who would see all these, you know, abductees. He would talk about how UFOs would inspire tech because it would look like, like you had the airships of the 1890s or whatever. It would look like tech that was just about to come out. And, you know, Bill Lear is quoted in 1956, you know, he was the father of John Lear and invented the first, you know, - Lear jet, yeah. - Yeah, Lear jet, first private jet basically. And he said, you know, I believe anti-gravity is possible because UFOs display them. And so that, to me, is just this really important thing where it's like. - I think it's kind of a chapter on anti-gravity and project beta, actually. - Oh, yeah, that's right. - About that memo from the British, whatever society of gravity research or something. And it was released something. The copy I saw was stamped right, Patterson Air Force based on it. And it missed about like five pages. Like there's this big legend about the missing five pages. - Yeah. - Where it's like, it was achieved in the mid-century in and then it cuts off and then it's like. - Well, we know that right airfield was sponsoring the Chapel Hill Conference in 1957 at University of North Carolina with the top theoretical physicist in the world. And at the same time, the UNC Chapel Hill was sponsoring Towns and Brown's work on anti-gravity. We know that right airfield had a dedicated team of people working on anti-gravity, which included Lewis Whitton, father of Ed Whitton, who was at Martin Corporation's RAS, their anti-gravity division. And he says in an interview live that we have tape of, he goes, I was hired to do gravity for by right airfield and that's what I did. - The reason there was a laboratory at Wright Field was to find out what we were doing and to help us do it. And I got a contract for Wright Field to do it. To do gravity, which I did very happily. - And you have Josh Goldberg, who's a PhD from Syracuse, who's a top physicist also working on the theoretical underpinnings of anti-gravity. - Yeah. - So we know that this stuff was extremely invoked in the '50s and who knows? It may have been done or partially done. I have a friend that was in the Air Force and he said that when the stealth fighter lands, people go in and pull panels out of it and put them in briefcases and go away. And he said the rumor was that some of those were anti-gravity just to help it fly in a different way that not totally to gravity, but to help the avionics. - Yep. - That's a rumor. - That is possible. I go back and forth on that with like the B2 for example, where I don't see a ton of hard evidence that the poll of the-- - No, there never is. But maybe that rumor was given to me just to see who would talk about it before that we come from. It's just one of those things where you pour die down of like 50 pipes and you see where the die comes out, you know? - Yeah, well I track the brown stuff very closely and I think his work did make it into the B2, but the aspect of his work that made it into the B2 is electric fields in their ability to manage airflow over an air frame and for a tactical advantage when it comes to reducing the lift to drag ratio. - Right, okay. - So that's all I've ever found on a really first principles level and then there's a bunch of ways. - Yeah, that might have been what they were talking about. - I think so. - But maybe it's mixed in with the brown legend because of that. - Yeah, well I know that I'm pretty sure 95% that brown stuff made it into the B2 bomber. In fact, Floyd Oedlam who is the majority owner of Northrop who funded Brown's work in the '60s paid Brown $4,000, or I don't remember, $2,000, $4,000 a month as family the same amount until he died. - Yeah. - Until the '80s. - Yeah. - So I mean, that to me-- - That to Catalina or whatever. - Yeah, exactly, good memory. Yeah, so I don't know, it's fascinating. UFOs really are, you've made this analogy to me on the phone before it's like if you have a bunch of pipes and the pipes represent, you know, possible weeks in intelligence, you pour some dye in the pipes and you see where the dye goes. And UFOs I think are used as a tactic for that where it's like, you sprinkle in a UFO here that's, you know-- - Or a rumor about a UFO or some case or whatever. And you see it's like, don't talk about this. Then you see who talks about it. - You see who tracks, yeah, exactly. And then you see who's trustworthy. - It's funny, a long time ago while I was working on this book and before that from Knowing Bill, if somebody tells you don't talk about this, I always think it's a test. - Me too. I always think, and that's happened to me before. It's happened to me on a thing that was later debunked publicly, and I was like, I know what you're doing. - I know you're telling me this 'cause-- - Yeah, I want to see if I'm gonna leave. - Stuff about the TickTack incident and Pilots whose names hadn't been released yet. I was told, don't talk about this. - You were, you were. - Yeah, and then like six months later, bam, their names are out there. - Yeah. - And I think whoever told me-- - So in your case, it was true. - Yeah, it was true. - So you were given like David Fravers' name before the TickTack incident, or something? - Before I think of Alex Deedrick and a couple others. - Whoa, that's crazy. Interesting. - And I talked to Alex Deedrick later, but I didn't tell her that. - Can you say who gave you that information? - Nope. - There we go. - Pass the test to whoever did that. That's wild, crazy, interesting. - Yeah. - Whoa. - And it doesn't mean I'm hooked into any like great network or anything, but that's, you know, and it used to be a lot this would happen. Now about once or twice a year, somebody will tell me this. - Yeah. - Lynn Buchanan, who I've known for a long time, the Army Remote Viewer. - Yeah. - He told me like eight or nine years ago that he had met with an alien. - And he said, "But don't talk about this to anybody." He's like, "Why'd you meet with the alien?" And he said, "Well, they wanted to see if I could communicate with it 'cause I was one of the remote viewers." He said, "But don't mention." And I said, "All right." - He said-- - Then like five years later, he said it online somewhere. So I can say it now. - Whoa. - Really? - Yeah. - So he's still on record claiming that he's met an alien. - Yeah. - The remote viewer. - At least I hope it came out, 'cause I saw it later. He had mentioned it in somebody's interviewer on a podcast or something. - Did he meet the alien? - I don't know. He didn't tell me. It was probably on a base somewhere, at least he wanted me to think that. - Wow. - I don't know Lynn really well, but I interviewed him in like 97 or something. So I've kind of, we've been meeting every once in a while since then, and every once in a while he'll, that's the only thing he ever told me, don't mention it. And I said, "Why'd you tell me?" He said, "It's for your information." - Wow. - But there's so many little bits and pieces of information like that that just float around. And I think a lot of 'em are just kind of like, throwaways of something that used to be important. But it isn't anymore, but then they become this lore in the UFO community and then they just stick and they grow. And you know, it's just, it's, you know, fertile ground for any weird rumor like this to grow. - Do you suspect, like, Diana Pesolka, she came out with a quote, where she was friends with Chris Bloodse, who had all these UFO interactions. I, by the way, I'm not in any of the drama. I love Diana Pesolka and I love Chris Bloodse. - Yeah, man, I'm the same way. - So, but Diana Pesolka came out and she said, "I think Chris Bloodse is a modern Paul Benowitz." Chris Bloodse claimed to, you know, have an interaction with this goddess Hathor and see also an alien craft and-- - And a bunch of government. - People are very interested in him, which is, like, they're pretty demonstrably true. - No, that is demonstrably true. You know, he'll say like, I'm-- - So, kind of the same dynamic, I guess. - So, Dee, do you think it is the same dynamic? Do you think they're just genuine friends, or like, what do you think they-- - I think whoever is interested in the subject thinks he may be a key to the answer or part of it. And when that happens, then they just become friendly until I've had this happen and you probably have too. Somebody comes from the government, tells you something that nobody else knows.
or very few people know. And then they say, you know, I'm telling you this first, not Linden do is, 'cause we know each other for years. But just because they want you, they want to flatter your ego and get your confidence and find things out. And I'm not saying that, you know, same event or whoever the people that are talking to them are like, you know, we're gonna get all of his information and throw him down, you know, throw him out with a trash. No, I think they're genuinely interested. And they genuinely think something some useful information can come from him. And if they're friendly with him, they can get some of this information that could be useful. Either both for their own personal quest and knowledge and also for whoever they might be working with or for. Totally. I don't think, you know, some-- Not to say that all those people are wonderful and moral, but-- (laughs) Yeah, but I don't think you can immediately jump to the conclusion that they are modern rick doties, either. I think-- No, no, no. It's a different identity. You can be in the government and earnestly want disclosure and usually if you're in the government, they're caveats to your earnest desire for disclosure that involve national security. But yeah, I don't think-- I don't paint them of all of them with this evil brush. I don't think you can-- That's not how the world works. I don't think you can a priori impune anybody's motives unless they prove to be really, you know, bad actors. Yeah. And if they do and they're working in intelligence, they're not always bad actors. It's always something or other. And that's why I, you know, I think, you know, for my-- they said, what do you think of Richard Dodie? It's like, I don't hate him. Yeah. I don't think he's evil. I just think he was doing his job and he likes messing with people and that's it. Also. And what he did, some of the things he did, were morally wrong and he knows it. Also, if we have, you know, take it face value that we had a remote viewing program for 23 years at the very least, we probably have covert remote viewing programs now and take it face value that some of that remote viewing was effective, you have a guy in North Carolina who is claiming these like remarkable stories around kind of a miracle healing that he's experienced and, you know, messages that he's getting involving prophecies. If you take the first thing as a real intelligence modality that obviously needs to be corroborated by other intelligence modalities, you're going to take seriously this dude in North Carolina. Yeah. And you're going to be probably very interested in that. You've got antenna up and you're correlating all kinds of different information, most of which might be BS. Sure. But the stuff that isn't is worth all the others coming through this stuff. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. The thing I've found too, I don't know if you've found this, but sometimes people inside the government are more conspiratorial than people on the outside. They're like, you assume that because they've seen it. That's right. They see it all the time. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Once you're in this for anything where you get a little glimpse into how some famous person or somebody that's not too many people know or a government operative, when you see what's going on with them, just get a little glimpse of it. You realize how much what we all see and in the news and all that has already been decided like months or years before. And it's not like, it's not some conspiracy. It's just the way the world works. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You're not for you and I are only privy to a certain amount of information and other people are privy to less and other are more way more. And there's, and you know, it's kind of our, you know, you and I are interested in say, what are those people about us doing? What is coming down the road? How is that going to affect us? What does the past look like because of that? What does the future look like because of that? Who does it affect, you know, should I be emotional about this? Is there a moral issue with this? I want to know all these things. And so I've got antenna up just like these weirdo government people and I've learned things from them too, you know, just how to operate and how to think. And part of that, like you said, is being a little bit paranoid, but only a little bit because I've been a lot paranoid for about a year and I didn't like it. That's, a lot of paranoid is never good. I made this documentary with David Grush in September of 2023 after he'd testified before Congress. He said that he, you know, gave over, like, I think, like hundreds of pages, maybe over 1,000 pages to the, you know, intelligence community inspector general, you know, experienced reprisals based on his blowing the whistle. And he brought forward 40 people directly to the ICIG who had, you know, worked on this stuff first hand. And we're still in this sort of liminal space, even though he did all that, which is kind of crazy. I just wanted to put enough out there, touch on all the most sensitive parts, like the biologic side and like things that really need to come out. Yeah. But I don't want to overly disclose because it's not my job. I don't know him well. I don't even know if I know the details about, remember the details about what he was saying, except to, you know, shore up that the government is interested in the subject has been for a long time and a lot deeper than we think. Well, the substance of what he said is that we have non-human bodies, pilots, craft, we have, you know, craft in our possession that we have. Yeah, I'm remembering. Yeah. Crash is on record. He talks about the magenta crash, 1933. He even kind of talks about, you know, possible agreements, I believe, in the Ross-Quilthard interview. And then he says he has all these first-hand witnesses. And again, like I know him to have a very idetic sort of memory and to be a very, you know, intense kind of, you know, as mild autism, you know, researcher. So he does, you know, definitely not fit the pattern of some of these other really slick and smooth savvy guys. So it's interesting. Yeah, but the mistake I think people make with Grush and other people is that they want to know if they're telling the truth or not. That's not the question. I think the question is, is what they're saying relevant and can connections be made with what they say to other things that things have been said and also documentation if you can get it? It's just kind of this, it's a, I keep using the word concatenation, but it's a kick out nation of all this stuff together. And when somebody says, well, I think that person's lying, it's like, why? Because he said this, it's like, he said like 500 things. Yeah. So you're saying everything he said is lie based on this one thing you think is a lie or if you've proven his lie or is wrong or inaccurate. That's not how the world works. No. It's especially not how the UFO world works. Yeah. I think it's tough being in that whistleblower position because the more you say, the more surface area exists on, you know, what, yeah. The more it's also viable, there's more ways for people to get their hopes in and pull it apart. Yeah. And it's going to happen. It's not like you're commenting on, you're not like a sports commentator. And yes, people are like, this is the truth. And if you say one wrong thing, yeah, well, that's different because I always had that analogy people, I look at that analogy people made it with. This was brought into a court of law, then, you know, it'd be proven. It's like, no, wouldn't because we know about murders and robberies and stuff. This is dealing with something we can't bring in a lab and prove it. And not many people had experience with, so it's a whole different thing. And it's throwing all these different definitions we have. And, you know, I hate the word ontology, but throwing everybody's ontology into questions. Yeah. It's like, how much of this he's going to let into your life? How much of this is relevant to you, you know, is it just like, you know, is it just like talking about movies and TV shows or something? Or does this mean more? I think it means way more. But I also don't know how much of this stuff is going to much more of it. It's going to come out because I think that every time the government says, hey, let's look at UFOs for a while, when the usefulness of looking at it and having it in the public has gone, bam, it's gone. And then suddenly, everybody's like, well, what you were just going to tell us what it was. And this has been the longest and the strongest I've ever seen it go on. And so I don't know what the end game is, but I have a really strong feeling that as soon as whoever gets what they need to get, or it's not useful anymore, yeah, that faucet's going to be turned off. I hope I'm wrong. Yeah. Because I'd like to see something, although the disclosure thing still kind of irritates because my one quote about it, and I keep saying it, and I could take it for years, disclosures like asking the parent that always lies to you to tell you the truth. Just this one time, and if they don't tell you what you want to hear, they're lying. I love that. Well, there are two vectors though. There's like, is the government ever going to like let some of this stuff ultimately out in the way of like showing you a craft and what do they know? And what do they actually know? Like do they actually know anything as far as like some metaphysical world view that it's super concrete as opposed to, you know, maybe not. Maybe it's just, I mean, if I'm wrong for that. It's too much to admit it because it's not explainable in terms that people would understand so what's the point. And it's much more useful the way it is now, which is that Swiss Army knife that I was talking about. Yeah, but I do think so. There are two different vectors. There's the government vector. I do think if we just follow it up on some of David Grush's, you know, face value claims, that would be like really exciting if we could like corroborate, you know, some of those. And it's crazy that it still exists in this liminal kind of kind of kind of space. The UFO exists in a liminal space, so it drags everything else along with it. Right. Right. Right. I mean, that's the model it's coming from. So it's going to be fighting that the whole time. Yeah. Right. Sure. Prove this liminality to me, break, you know, collapse the waveform. I don't know if that's going to happen. Well, that, yeah, I mean, then you're getting into deeper stuff, which is so that there's a government vector, and then there's like a belief consensus reality vector. And like, most people believe that there's aliens that exist and UFOs are real, most people believe that.
- Yeah, no, it's like probably over 50% of America. So if there's some other version of reality that is egregoric in nature, where you are literally-- - Gonna create the-- - Manifesting things in your purview, then the amount of momentum that I see now has to turn into something. And I don't know what that turns into. - I don't know either. But like that Whitley streamer quote, where he said the government was keeping it secret 'cause if enough people believed in it, would it allow it in? - I think he said that in-- - Communion? - No, it wasn't in communion. It was in his majestic. It was his semi-fictional account of the Roswell crash and everything after it. - Right, right, right. - Really good, a lot of metaphors in there, which are still relevant and nice. I still go back to. - I love it. Well, I'll check that out. - Have you had Whitley on? - I have. - Yeah, it's great. - He's always a good interview. And people, at contact, I got to get up on, I got to speak at contact. I wasn't scheduled. - Amazing. - But I got up on stage 'cause Dean Alliotto showed his film, Alien Perspective. And one of the first things I said, when I was asked me for a statement, I said, and I've said this before, you know why people say, do you believe Whitley streamer? I said, I believe him in the way I believe, you know, the Beatles or the Foo Fighters or Van Gogh or Jackson Pollock. He's a great artist. - He's a great artist telling you the truth of how he sees something that has affected him. - Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I think that's the case of, you know, when it comes to a lot of experience here. - And then people say, well, then he just made it up. And it's like, no, art doesn't come from nothing. It comes from the artist's feelings. It, his or her life experience, everything. And the way Whitley's explaining to us is the way an artist would explain the abduction phenomenon to us. And it's in a way that nobody else talks about it, like he does. And I've, I've enjoyed it from the beginning. - Well, that's a beautiful note to end on. Greg Bishop, thank you so much for coming on. Thank you for your work. Everybody go out and buy Project Beta, as well as it defies language. And yeah, thank you, man. - Thanks a lot. - All right. (crickets chirping)
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Paul Benowitz, an electronics engineer living near Kirtland Air Force Base, claimed to observe glowing orbs and UFOs flying over mountains, sometimes with Air Force personnel visible.
Benowitz built radio detection equipment and believed he was picking up alien signals, interpreting anomalies as transmissions from extraterrestrial life.
The Air Force and intelligence agencies, including the OSI and NSA, monitored Benowitz, using him as a tool to gather intelligence on UFO-related activities and to test psychological vulnerability.
Benowitz was fed disinformation, including fabricated documents like the "Aquarius memo" and fake videos showing dinosaurs, Roman battles, or alien bases, which contributed to his growing paranoia.
He was subjected to psychological manipulation, including spy training and staged encounters, designed to feed him false narratives and deepen his belief in alien contact.
His mental state deteriorated as he became increasingly isolated, paranoid, and convinced of an imminent alien invasion, leading to hospitalization and loss of normal functioning.
The case reflects a broader pattern
Benowitz's story is part of a larger network of disinformation campaigns, where psychological manipulation and deception were central to counterintelligence efforts during the Cold War era.
Summary:
Paul Benowitz, an electronics engineer living near Kirtland Air Force Base, reported seeing glowing UFO-like orbs flying over mountains and claimed to detect alien signals. Believing he was on the verge of uncovering a secret government program, he built radio equipment to monitor transmissions and began filming the phenomena. S.
intelligence agencies, particularly through the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (AFOSI) and the NSA. These agencies monitored Benowitz, feeding him disinformation—including fabricated documents, false videos, and staged stories about alien bases, dinosaurs, and Soviet espionage—designed to exploit his growing paranoia and validate intelligence operations. He was also subjected to spy training and psychological tactics, including being told he had access to secret information.
Despite his efforts, the information he received was largely fabricated or misinterpreted, leading to a breakdown in his mental health. His case illustrates how UFOs were not a cover for conventional technology, but rather a strategic tool in intelligence operations—used to probe, manipulate, and extract information from individuals with a strong interest in the subject. Benowitz’s story, part of a broader Cold War-era disinformation strategy, reveals how psychological warfare and deception were central to covert activities, turning personal belief into a valuable intelligence asset.
FAQs
Paul Benowitz was an aerospace electronics engineer with a master's in electrical engineering. He lived and worked near Kurtland Air Force Base in Albuquerque, New Mexico, with his office located close to the base's Wyoming gate, making him frequently exposed to military operations and activities.
He reported seeing glowing orb-like lights lifting off the ground, flying over mountains, and descending, sometimes with Air Force personnel visible before or after their flight. These sightings prompted him to start filming the events with 8mm cameras and early video equipment.
Yes, he built a radio listening setup to detect signals from the base, believing he was picking up transmissions from aliens. However, the signals were likely military telemetry or microbursts, which he misinterpreted due to pattern recognition biases and lack of technical understanding.
The Air Force initially dismissed his claims but later invited him to show him his equipment. They eventually conducted a meeting with Benowitz, where officials acknowledged his observations but claimed they were not part of any classified program, suggesting they were monitoring rather than engaging with him.
Rick Dodie, a counterintelligence agent from the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (AF OSI), deliberately fed Benowitz misinformation and psychological pressure, planting false documents and stories to manipulate and destabilize his beliefs, contributing to his growing paranoia.
Yes, he was given a fabricated document called the 'Aquarius memo' containing false claims about UFOs and MJ-12, which was designed to influence his beliefs. These materials were part of a broader disinformation campaign to mislead him and assess his credibility as a potential intelligence asset.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.