Facebook Whistleblower Fears Zuckerberg More Than Musk | PBD Podcast #888
1h 54m 59s
Mark Zuckerberg wields unparalleled control over Facebook through a unique voting structure, holding 60% of voting power and allowing him to remain in charge despite massive financial gains. The company’s leadership is stagnant and reactive, with frequent personnel shifts and a culture that discourages dissent, leading to employee burnout and mental health struggles. A controversial shareholder deal enables Zuckerberg to cash out billions over eight years while preserving full control, raising ethical and structural concerns about power concentration. Internal investigations reveal that Facebook’s algorithms prioritize engagement over safety, enabling misinformation to spread unchecked—especially in vulnerable regions like Myanmar and India. A key issue is the Crosscheck program, which shields high-profile individuals from content moderation, allowing harmful content to go viral. The company's response to real-world crises, such as ethnic violence in India and the January 6 Capitol riot, was delayed and emotionally driven, with decisions made at the last minute by Zuckerberg, undermining accountability. The platform’s design enables manipulation of public discourse, with political actors and foreign groups weaponizing content to influence elections. Employees face intense pressure to remain positive, creating a toxic environment where dissent is punished. The broader implication is that Facebook’s centralized model lacks democratic oversight, risking societal harm through unchecked influence, misinformation, and the suppression of critical voices. These systemic flaws highlight the need for more transparent, decentralized, and ethically governed social platforms.
Mark Zuckerberg is the only voice that matters when it comes to Facebook. Mark Zuckerberg is making a case for putting super intelligent AI in a hands-by-everyone. Just my mistake, and I'm sorry. Do you think Zucker's evil? I worry about Mark a lot more. I worry he burns the candle at both ends. People around Mark are there because Mark wants them to be there. They make Mark a good, they tell him whatever story they need to tell him that lets him be able to accept the way the world is. And that's not good for any human being. Zucker announced yesterday that he may be leaving California because of the well-tax that Rokana knew some others may be pushing in the state of California and it's already something that's on the ballot that may take place. The deal that the board cut within this morning is shocking. He's made it so that over the next eight years he can cash out tens of billions of dollars and still maintain complete control over the company. This is just to make the world more open and connected. Negative motives long-term. Do you worry about this much power to Zucker Elon? We don't need AI any smarter than the AI we have today for it to be incredibly disruptive. The only reason we are not seeing more chaos right now with the level of AI we have right now is just because people aren't trying. So I appreciate you for coming down. I'm a pleasure. We just watched your movie, the movie that's based on your story with the social reckoning. I think Mikey Madison plays you. The movie was very interesting on what happened with Facebook. And even the guy that played Zuck, who's a very well-known actor, he was in the judge. He's been a lot of different, yeah, he crushed it. And my favorite scene was the scene where they're challenging him to get ready for the hearing and they're getting under his skin and they brought Bill Burr that was really getting under skin. Very interesting movie. But before we get into the whole story, something just broke that I think it's a good idea for us to start off with. So yesterday, New Mexico, because of the Cambridge Analytica story that happened in 2018, which we had Britney Kaiser on the podcast, I think like eight years ago, she talked about it. They're ordered to pay $25 billion penalty to New Mexico. Same time, while that happens, the next day today, I think nine hours ago, story broke WSGA that Zuck announced yesterday that he may be leaving California because of the well tax that Rokana knew some others may be pushing in the state of California. It's already something that's on the ballot that may take place. I think the proposition 40 is that they're announcing. So then the board came out and they tried to give them a new agreement. Eight years, 20 billion, still keep the control. Maybe talk about the importance of those two happening at the same time. I think it's more than 20 billion, so the thing that people should be aware of. So one of the reasons why Facebook is so unique is you have one person, Mark Zuckerberg, who has 60% of the votes to control the company. So in most big companies, like even Google, which is one of the most concentrated companies in the world, you have two people who have most of the votes, three if you tack on Eric Schmidt. I think for anyone who's ever been married or in a relationship, once you even have a second person who you have to negotiate with, it really, really pulls you back to reality, right? Mark Zuckerberg is the only voice that matters when it comes to Facebook because he has those voting shares. The deal that the board cut within this morning is shocking in that they basically came in and said, "Okay, so right away, these A-class shares, which most people have, we have B-class shares, where you get 10 times as many votes, and then we're going to do these C-class shares, where everyone who has an A or B-class share is going to get one of these C-class shares that have no votes." And the reason why this matters is it means Mark can now progressively sell half of his fortune and not lose any control of the company. And he tried to get this deal all the way back in 2017 and the shareholders blocked it. They were like, "No, no, no, you either get to be the king or you get to be rich, you don't get to be both. But the fact that he is now basically taking the money off the table. Because he didn't ask for Justin up to pay his 5% wealth tax, he's made it so that over the next eight years he can cash out tens of billions of dollars and still maintain complete control over the company. Yeah, and so this was, even though he only owns 13.6% of shares, right? Is this the old Peter Teele structure of the founder shares where you get four times amount of votes per 10 times the amount of votes? They used to be 10. I think they lose it four times our still 10. I don't know what the current best practices, but in his case, it's 10. At that time, you used to be 10. Yeah. Jake. Okay, so in, so Zuck still has those shares. So they are also asking them to stay near the headquarters because of the AI in California. They don't want them to leave. Do you think it's going to go through? Because they're allowing them to take 20 billion dollars off the table. Oh, so they've already done it. You have to remember, so because he controls the company, the Chan Zuckerberg entities, the other things that hold these votes today, they already voted on it. Like, there's not going to be a big shareholder vote. This is done now. This is done now. So this is not it's going to happen. This deal is broken. This morning. It's done. He's standing California is not leaving. Yeah. So Zuck is not leaving California eight years to be near the headquarters. Yeah, because you know, the, I think it was yesterday where Sergei Brin announced that he's saved 15 billion dollars by leaving to California to Miami but lives in 174 million out of house. So the timing of all these stories that are going on. What do you think about the wealth tax? Do you think it's a good idea? Yeah, it doesn't, as a like an applied math person, it drives me a little crazy from the perspective of like, it doesn't raise that much money, right? Like, think of how destructive it has been to California. A 5% wealth tax does not cover like almost any of the gap on like a 10-year basis. So I think it's been very harmful in terms of the level of disruption that's caused for how little benefit it got. And my understanding was they never expected it to get this far. They thought it was just like an negotiating play. And that's your tactic like, hey, if you guys don't do this, we're going to tax you. And yet, it all ran away from them. Oh, shit. So that's what I've read. Got it. So even though it was, if you guys don't listen to us, we're going to attack them. And then this was around December of 2025, I want to say, when I first heard about this, that was a 25 or 24. It could have been 25 where they need to get this many votes. And they actually ended up getting the votes and so ended up being on the ballot. And by June or something, they had a certain number. Do you think for somebody who is there with a lot of billionaires that are, you know, the Holland podcast talked about us a lot. Shamaat was very vocal about this, which is not really a 5% tax. It's really closer to an 8% to 10% because if a lot of them are tied to stocks, I have to sell my stock appreciation and have to sell the assets. And then, you know, me leaving could hurt the job market. So you're not fully supportive for it. Well, I think the issue is like the, the gap it's meant to close is issues around health premiums. Right. So they have these health obligations for public employees. So in California, there's very lucrative public pensions, public health obligations. This is for teachers, firefighters, nurses. These are, these are people who do hard jobs. They're important for society at the same time because the budget of California has been mismanaged for decades. Right. This is not a problem that happened in the last year or two. This is a decades-long problem. It's only giving me a liability that is going to explode more in the next 20 years. A wealth tax may plug the hole for one or two years, but it is not a sustainable solution. And so given the level of disruption, I think it is very attractive to go after billionaires. Like it's easy to be like, oh, just take it from them. But it's not going to address the larger issue, which is the California's budget, isn't a really unhealthy place, especially when I look for it, ten years. How did they get to a place like that? You're a math person. How did they screwed up so bad? I used to live in California 24 years. Yeah. So I think a big part of it is it's always easy to say we will catch up in the future. Right. Because remember, states don't get to run deficits. They have to, they can only accumulate so much debt. They can't declare bankruptcy easily. They can't print more money. Like at the federal level, they'll be in print more money. So if you say get cheaper salaries today because you promise someone to pension in the future, you can be like, oh, it's going to be fine. We're going to be able to catch up within the future. But those obligations come due eventually. And if you haven't planned for it over time, then maybe stuck with someone else gets stuck with the bill. So let's go to the story. You're in Silicon Valley. You're doing your thing. You career oriented. You high school debate. You were known for that. You did great. And then you're at Facebook. And suddenly, you get to this point where you're like, oh, this data with Instagram that's coming out and how it's harming young girls. And I think we need to tell the public about this. Maybe walk me through the story of what happened before you released the 20-something thousand-up document. So in the January 2019, I get this email from Facebook saying, hey, have you ever considered working at Facebook? What are you at that time? Where was I at that time? I think I was on a break. So I was looking at-- I was thinking about doing a startup. It's like when these things in Silicon Valley. Sometimes you leave a thing and you're like, oh, I'm going to take a few months and decide what I want to do next. And I get to see them off from Facebook. And they're like, have you considered working there? And I wrote back-- I had to reread my old email when I wrote my memoir. And I maybe wrote a less polite email than I should have. But I was very courte about how I would never work at Facebook. In the email you said that. The only thing I would ever work on on Facebook is misinformation. Because in 2016, I had a friend go way off the deep end. So he had been a Bernie Sanders supporter and Bernie lost the primary. What you shouldn't have. So that's part of what happened. You should have beaten Hillary. It was very weird what happened there. He was down there. The DNC, yeah. And so he was sufficiently upset about what the DNC had done and all the other weird things that happened around Hillary. That he was looking for comfort online. And over the course of six months, he just disconnected from reality. The last conversation I had with him was after the 2016 election. And he was talking about things like George Soros writing the world economy.
Like it was just like, and we couldn't even have a conversation about was this a conspiracy theory, because he was so disconnected from any kind of new source that had a connection to reality. And the, so I say like the only thing I'd work on is misinformation. And they come back to me like we have a job for you. We have this thing called civic misinformation. And so I assumed, being its 2019, my with like this very US centered, you know, I'm a normal Silicon Valley tech person. I don't really think of the rest of the world. I'm just thinking about Silicon Valley. I show up expecting to work on the US 2020 election. Like getting things, me a lockdown, maybe information operations, foreign interference that kind of thing. Oh no, no, no, no. I find out the thing I'm gonna work on is all misinformation beyond third party fact checking. So third party fact checking is like hunter Biden laptop, right? It's like journalists get paid to go write fact checks and Facebook decides what Ken and Ken have been said. So imagine only 300 stories get fact checked a month. Like it's very, very few. Facebook talk. - What do you mean? - So Facebook talk is this huge game about how these fact checkers are the thing between you and chaos. And yet they're only fact checking a few hundred stories globally every month. - This is in 2019. - This is in 2019. - So at that time they don't have a way of fact checking stories automatically. These are manually fact checking. - Oh yeah, they're paying $3,000 to a journalist to go and research it and write a little thing. I mean, like no, the Pope did not endorse Donald Trump. - Got it. - Yeah. - 300 only a month. - Yeah, a month. - A multi trillion dollar company. - Yeah. - Interesting. - So, but there's a bigger problem, which is like billions of pieces of content are produced over the course of a month. And in places like Myanmar, places like Sri Lanka, places like Ethiopia, you know, African countries, Southeast Asian countries. Facebook isn't just like a thing we go and like look at pictures of cats on. It is the internet. And I had been completely oblivious to the role of like how Facebook had evolved in some of the most fragile places on Earth. So here I am never having really thought about the idea that algorithms could cause violence. Because remember, I probably got this job was I used to run the recommendations the algorithms for Pinterest. Like what's the most dangerous thing that comes out of Pinterest, right? Like maybe make a bad dinner. Like maybe you make some fashion choices you shouldn't have made. Like what's the most dangerous thing that comes from this algorithm, right? The, so I get to Facebook and I'm sitting down every day with these researchers who are going into these places and watching civil wars happen because of misinformation. So fast forward a year later. And they dissolve the whole part of the company I work in, specific integrity as a whole. So misinformation is under that. Misinformation is under that. But by the time that happens, I've already been moved between three separate projects because inside of Facebook things are so chaotic. People are regularly reassigned every six months. That's cultural. That's cultural, yeah. So you know if I'm doing this, I only have six months here. Yeah. And why do they do that way? I think part of it is a lack of like conviction. I think it's like a, I think it's a little bit like one. So when you don't have market constraints, right? Like when you have to make profit and you have a 10% profit margin or a 5% profit margin, you have to constantly work on execution. When you get 35% profit margins because you've locked in with a monopoly, you get sloppy. Inside of Facebook, they know the reason why their company succeeds is because your friends are there. Like your friends aren't going anywhere. You're locked in. Anything can happen. That's what they think. Yeah. OK. And as it is, sometimes companies move positions within six months because they want to make and more all around persons that can move you up in better executive positions. Well, this is the wild thing. So because the company is so flat and so static-- so remember, the one voice that matters inside Facebook is Mark Zuckerberg, he has 60% of the votes. The next tier under him are people who are there because they make Mark feel good. The next tier under them are basically the same people who have been there for five years, right? Like the people who are running the company are the same people who have been there since day one with Mark or came in five years after that. So there's very little movement above-- like maybe you'll get promoted once or twice. But the company is flat and static because there's nowhere to go. Now, would you say the way the employees look at Mark is he loved, respected, liked, feared, or trusted? How do the employees view him? So within the part of the company, I worked it within-- I think there was kind of an acceptance that Mark was in charge. But it made things kind of chaotic. So I'll give you an example. Maybe three months before I joined, there was a situation in India. So Modi is the prime minister in India. He had started making comments about Muslims that referred to them as like insects or rodents, like language that is otherizing. Modi. Like Modi, yeah. And he's actually making these comments. Yeah, public comments on Facebook. And these are considered precursor comments to ethnic violence. Like when you start talking about an ethnic group in your country as like vermin, this is like on the step. Documented, he said these things. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Because their feud would pack a stand and what they have maybe part could be done. Well, he's also like a Hindu nationalist. Sure. This is a big part of his political power. When people study how ethnic violence happens, you first start out with this kind of like delegitimizing language, and you go from there. So this conversation came about, I mean, like, oh, interesting. He has started doing these things. What does Facebook do if he starts posting? You should kill the Muslims. Like, what do we do? This is a reasonable question. And so a task force was formed. So 40 people spend six months trying to figure out, at what point can you not allow a national leader to post on Facebook? What's the threshold where you're like, OK, we're not going to let him coordinate a genocide on our platform, right? Like, what is that bar? Because I think everyone agreed. There's some bar. Who knows? Like, we can have a conversation about where's that bar, but probably like calling for the death of the Muslims in India is probably above that bar. And so-- They all agreed, all 40 agreed? So yeah, so at the end of six months, they've talked to people in ads and public policy and government relations. And there's literally a genocide group inside of Facebook. It's called social cohesion. All these different people, people with PhDs, they write a proposal. They come to one final thing. They present it to Mark on like a Friday. He says, I don't like this. I can do better. He goes home. He writes a policy. He comes out and he announces it on Monday. How would that make you feel? Like, if you know that like, 40 people have like hashed this out and argued about it and like consulted people inside the company, outside the company, figured out a thing that they all can agree to over six months. And your leader goes, oh no, I can do better over the weekend. What's his better? Well, the challenge with his was it wasn't implementable. So he said, we will never sense the voice of a politician. And the only problem with this is in some jurisdictions, your local dog catcher is an elected position. Do they count as a politician? I mean, they're an elected official. And how did he qualify that? Did he say if it's a world leader, if it's tier one, tier two-- No, elected official. That's it. Yeah. And so the problem, and part of the reason why this policy was not suggested originally, was like the advertising team doesn't know who the dog catchers are. There's like in the United States alone, there's hundreds of thousands of people who have elected jobs, right? Now, what percentage of the three and a half billion users on Facebook are from India? Oh, from India. Oh, great question. Can you pull it up? I'm curious. Because I would say, hey, we have to be careful with the clients that we have any users that we have in India. Something can selfishly now to see maybe that's what it is. I don't know. So I know only 11% of users spoke English when I left in 2021. Only 11% of users on Facebook spoke English. Yeah. And that's a big part of it has to be India, if that's the case. OK, so in your-- and the 40 people that were part of that, you said the cohesion, social cohesion-- So that was one of the groups with social cohesion. And how did they react to Zuck saying I can write it better? So my boss-- so he's the head of civic integrity. I can't tell you exactly what social cohesion did. I can tell you what my boss did. So my boss called together all 200, 300 of us into a big conference room, big auditorium, and showed us pictures of an MRI of his spine. And like-- This is your boss. This is my boss. So imagine you're sitting there and like everyone knew this policy was coming. They knew it was a big deal, like across the art. I didn't even work on this policy, and I knew it was coming. So when the news came out that like market-written is own thing and announced it, I think all this all together. And my boss gets up there and he starts showing us MRIs of his spine. And we're all like, what is going on here? Is he going to quit? And he's talking about how he worked so hard that he heard his own back, how much he's given for this company, how much he's sacrificed, and how disparaging it is. He's showing this to you guys. How many people are in the room? There's like 200 people in this room. Oh, so this is a heavy way. This is a heavy way. And he reports directly to Mark. He's like one step down. And he's up there talking about how much he has personally sacrificed for this mission. He's showing us his spine. And we're all like, God, he's going to quit. There's only one way this talk ends. And the last minute, he's like, but no, we must fight onwards. So people were really devastated by having it be like, we've just told you there is a risk of people dying at like a huge scale. And to be clear, within two years of that, you had the ethnic violence in Ethiopia that was fan by social media and half a million people died. So when was this with this position? By the way, it's 12% to 13% of users are from India around 300 to 400 million people are from India. So when was the date of Modi making the comments? It's like April, 2019. April 29. So if we go April, 2019, Trump is president, right? And Modi and Trump are somewhat close. They did an event to get. I don't remember when the event was. And they've become formal state dinner. Right. I remember there's something. And there was also a live event that they were to get. I can't remember what it was. Maybe it was after that.
So that happens. Elected official, if they say anything, they can't be removed. How much longer after that did Facebook and Zuck agree to remove Trump off the platform? - After January 6th. - After January 6th. So were you there to see what was behind the decision-making of feeling comfortable to remove Trump? - So by the time that decision came down the pipeline, I had already been moved. So as soon as I was telling you, I never thought I would work on ethnic violence. Within three months of getting that job, they moved us back into the United States to focus on misinformation sent to targeted groups, because police officers had been found that I'm a Russian foreign interference, like a Russian foreign information operation kind of thing, was sending targeted misinformation to police officers. And within six months of that, I was on to a different sub-project. And three months after that, I was on to counter-espionage. So by the time January 6th came up, I was working within threat intelligence on counter-espionage, just because I told you Facebook is chaotic. - Six months? - Constantly moving you around different. - So now, but I'm sure entire company is talking to each other. When that decision was made, did you guys know that was gonna be this, you guys were the second to ban them, right? I don't think you were the first. Trying to see who was the first that banned them. I think it was Twitter that banned them first, and then it was Google, then you, YouTube, then you, one of those. I don't remember how it was, but what was the internal decision? Was it, oh shoot, Twitter just did that. Let's follow the lead, or was it, you know, this is what we're doing, no matter what Twitter and others do. - All I saw, so I only had visibility at the level of like, I was within the group of people that was getting updates. But I was not like in the warm room itself, like I remember this is a virtual thing, 'cause it's still drink COVID, like everything's still locked down. All I do know is I documented what protections were on at 10 a.m. on January 6th, and what protections were on the next day. So we had a list of maybe 35 to 40 different little knobs you could turn on Facebook to make it like less viral, less heated. This is not like specific ideas. This is like how should the platform perform overall? In terms of those 35 to 40 knobs, where they were set on election day versus on January 6th, because all of the measures had been turned off, like it was back running at 11, 12, right? On at 10 a.m. on January 6th, maybe 20% of those had been turned on. By January 7th, all of them had been turned back on. So people had just like been asleep at the wheel, like people had not been paying attention to it until there was actively rioting happening in DC. - Do you think it was a right move to remove the president off of Facebook? - I think given the circumstances in that moment, like he had an opportunity, he had many opportunities to say, go home, like deescalate, and he chose not to. I think in at least that localized moment that was an appropriate decision. I think I'm very cautious on whether or not hard actions, like exclusionary policies are appropriate. Like that has never been, like a big part what I brought out was on how content moderation doesn't work, right? Like the concept that AI can save us in that way is just a lie. But I think in moments where you actively have leaders leading to like fanning the flames of violence, it is appropriate in the short term. - So short term for you would be what? 24 hours, 40- - Probably a week or two? - A week or two. - But let them back in after a week. - I think in software engineering, we have a concept known as progressive back off. So if you have a situation where like, let's say your server is not responding. So you're asking a server to send you something, you might first ask every minute, then you might ask every two minutes, they might ask every four minutes, they might ask you progressively go longer and longer. You could imagine waiting a couple of days and seeing what they do, because maybe they need a time out for a day or two or a week. And then if they come back and they're like, hey, I was really wound up. It was clearly not the right thing to do to attack the capital. That is a very different thing than saying you can never come back again. - Yeah, so I think if you wanna go back to the timeline, Twitter did it first on J6 account. They suspended for 12 hours and then removed three tweets. And then Facebook and Instagram followed suit for 24 hours and then Snapchat indefinitely suspended Trump's account. And then Facebook and Instagram extended the suspension, lasting at least through the presidential transition and Twitter became the first of three, these major platforms to announce permanent ban of Trump's personal account. And in January 13th, Snapchat made its ban and everybody else followed suit. And how long did the ban last? Was it two or three years? I feel like it was a couple of years that he couldn't get back on. - Yeah, I don't think that's appropriate. - To not keep them on for that long. - Like permanent bans are not appropriate. Because like-- - He read for people or for elected officials. - I think for people, like I think this idea, like I think right now we have this notion in our society that like there are good people and there are bad people and that denies the chance for growth and change. - So take the two extremes politically, let you say, some would say Hassan Piker, America, dessert of 9/11, or Nick Fuentes, he says what he says. You're from the position that let them speak, let the audience decide for themselves. - I'm of the position that you can give people timeouts. The idea that that person doesn't change, that they're not gonna be different in a year. They're not gonna be different in six months. Like I think it's one of these things where we're saying like, hey, you have to have roles in social spaces. Like there's a saying, if you create a space that bans witch hunts, the problem is it becomes full of only witches, right? We need to have roles, but the idea that people don't change or they don't grow, that excludes a future. And in the United States, we have this idea that we can cancel people forever. Like we need to have consequences, but we need to have the idea that like someone can come back and say I'm a different person. And so an indefinite ban doesn't give you an opportunity to grow and change. - Would you consider yourself a freedom of speech absolutist? - I, that is a very inflammatory phrase, right? So there's just a question of like, let's say you do see something like an ethnic violence incident like Myanmar. Are you really telling me that the, so we know now that the Myanmarese government sent governmental officials, people in their military, to Russia to learn how to run information operations on their own people. They came back, they triggered an information operation, they built it for years, saying let's kill the Muslims in our country. I think it is appropriate for Facebook to cut off that speech. Like I don't think you, your tool, I think private entities have a right to say I don't have to be part of killing someone else. At the same time, I don't think it's appropriate to, I think people need to be more uncomfortable than they are today, right? Like. - Due to free speech. - Yeah. - I think it's a question of, we don't get to grow and change if we are not challenged. And this idea that there are ideas that are too dangerous for us to talk about them, that is a great way to stop having ideas. Like we need to be able to, like my husband likes to say that we have a very traditional marriage in that it used to be, people were married to people who didn't agree. Like you'd have a Republican marriage to a Democrat and that almost never happens anymore. And I would say both my husband and I are political orphans. Like we are part of the large number of Americans who don't really associate with either party. But we definitely don't agree politically either. Like we're both like very opinionated people in our own different ways, but we can have arguments and learn from each other. And I think that is one of the greatest gifts that the world has, the idea that you can be exposed to an idea that challenges you and makes you think and you both grow and you both change. - So maybe, let me restate what I'm thinking you're saying is when it comes down to violence, that is, - Calls for violence, yeah. - Calls for violence. - I think reasonable people can say, I don't have to participate, I don't have to platform you. - So reasonable people would say, I understand if Facebook or Twitter or somebody takes them down, okay. Now, the suspension for Trump, I think the only one that still has it is Snapchat. They still haven't lifted it. Twitter's lasted one year and 10 months and he came back November, 19, 2020, to I think a month after Elonbot X. Facebook was two years and a month, 763 days. Instagram same day, YouTube was two years and two months, a month after the other guys didn't, Snapchat hasn't lifted it. So, - Yeah. - So you would have only kept them off for one week. Now, let me ask the-- - I would come and see what he does, right? 'Cause if he comes back after a week and he starts delegitimizing the election again and calling for violence, then you have to be like, okay, now I have to go for two weeks. Like, are you actually acknowledging that you lost the election? - Where was the part that we called for violence? 'Cause I think a couple part of it was, I remember when they called the police, there's a clip of Nancy Pelosi talking to her daughter, I don't know if you've seen it in the car or not. It was like, you know what? Call, I call them off. You know, she's like, whoa, why are you guys even documenting this? So Nancy Pelosi didn't want to send the security in and BBC and some of these guys got sued because of the way they cut the clips to manipulate and showed that Trump said this and yet they didn't show the whole clip. So they lost the lawsuit. Even to the point where the CEO of I think BBC had to step down if I'm not mistaken, the lady, am I saying it correctly, please fact check me. It was either the editor-in-chief or the CEO of, it was a lady that stepped down and she quit and she didn't want to say anything about it. So now that we look at the story that some of it was the media manipulating what Trump really said, does your position change with that or does it state the same? - So I wanna be real clear, I have not looked in great depth that what Trump did on the day of January 6th. I can tell you a great depth what we knew inside of Facebook was going on In terms of like the much larger thing that drove Junior 6 was not Trump, it was that
that a group of people actively weaponized Facebook. So for example, the most prolific inviteer to stop the steel groups, one person invited 300,000 people to stop the steel groups. Or for example, we had groups of people. So in Facebook, you are not allowed to found two groups or three groups where you have to stay the same eight mods, same eight admins who own the group, and they all have basically the same name. And the reason for that is if I get you to join those three groups, I can send you three times as much content. You had a small number of people who founded 20, 30 groups each, and flooded people's feeds with content. And one of the things that I have a huge amount of empathy for the people who stormed the capital that day is a lot of those people said the exact same thing. They said, my feed was full. It was completely full of content, saying, I know exactly. So I'm saying that I can't tell you the great details on exactly what Trump did. But I'm saying that for if there are calls for that. And so I'm not going to be able to defend Facebook's policies on what were these act where I said it. - Yeah, to realize, I mean, that was a moment that divided America in a big way. So if you can you go back to the previous chat GBT when you pulled it up. So this is the one. So the top two BBC executives resigned over the controversies surrounding that the BBC's misleading, editing of Trump's January 6th speech. They resigned before Trump formally filed his lawsuit on November 9th. So the BBC director general, Tim Davy, the broadcaster's high ranking executive, and Deborah Tornis, the CEO of BBC News because they manipulated the clip. And can you ask what they did? Because it was a, he put a, this is it. So if you watch this, I'm so glad you're seeing this. If you go for it. - We're going to walk down to the capital. - That's BBC. - Then I'll be there with you. And we fight. We fight like hell. We're going to walk down to the capital. And we're going to cheer on our brave senators and congressmen and women. - We're going to walk down. - That's it. - Do you have the sentence after that? - Can you pull up what he's saying? - There's a longer format of this clip. - I also think if you could ask chat GBT like can you give context on like what were the, what were the public statements that Facebook said or why they did this? Because like I told you, I'm an information operations person. I don't deal with individual pieces of content. But what's important is to go back and look, they made a movie about your story and what you did with Facebook. And the person that started played you was an Academy Award winning actress. And there was a, so this is a massive story. It's divided a lot of people that went through this. And it kind of takes me back to, and we're going to do that. So I want you to see exactly, and I want you to see exactly what the speech was afterwards. - But I want to do a key tiny, just remind you, when I came forward, I left Facebook in May of 2021, right? Like I started, most of my whistle blowing happened in April, May of that year. The reasons I came forward didn't involve January 6th. They can't involve systemic, well no, involve systemic weaponization of platforms. So I worked with them threat intelligence. And like every day the thing that I worked on was China and Russia in Iran and North Korea actively weaponizing the platform. - Yeah, but the part, the part that's very important on what you're saying, I totally get that. But you started off when I asked a question from you said, you saw a friend of yours. - Yeah, of Hillary Clinton did what she did to Bernie, and they kind of bullied him out. I wanted to see a Bernie against Trump. That's what I wanted to say. - Yeah, and they were manifesting me. - Because I think that's the message we all wanted. Like, so then your friend went from there to, like, sorrows and all the stuff that happened. And which by the way, some of the stuff with sorrows makes sense. There's some real investigation that's done. This is not the, you know, he said in an interview with LA Times that I fancy myself as a god. I don't know a lot of people that say stuff like that. - So my friend said he funds violent revolutionaries. And like, I was a Cold War studies minor in college. Like, the revolutions that he was referring to. Like, people did things like cold flowers and public squares. The idea that like, if you are having a revolution where you have people basically doing civil disobedience is a violent revolution. Like, it's things like that where like, we-- - The guy is not allowed in his own country, Francis. Soros is not allowed in his own country. Think about, I mean, he had some restrictions where his own country is like, we don't let this guy come back here because of how divisive and manipulative he was. - Overly involved in the political process. - Overly involved and funding some charities that are going and creating havoc in streets and protesting and riots that become chaotic. And he needs that noise to kind of do what he does. Yeah, what is this one here? Oh, is this, okay. Anyone you want, but I think right now, we're going to walk down to the Capitol and we're going to cheer our brave senators and congressmen and women and we're probably not going to be cheering so much for some of them because you'll never take back our country with weakness. You have to show strength and you have to be strong. We have come to demand that Congress do the right thing and only the elected electors who have been lawfully slated, lawfully slated. I know that everyone here will be soon marching over to the Capitol building to peacefully and patriotically make your voice assert. This is very different than what the news played 24/7 and they brainwashed us. And because of the way they cut the clips, they silenced the president. He and his speech says peacefully and patriotically. So you can see how a lot of people could be confused with this. - You scroll back up real quick. It's like I'm just a president. Today we see what stands for integrity. - Are you reading in the bottom? - Yeah, so I want to be clear. So it's one of these things where I think one thing that is captured well in the movie is that Facebook, so one of the things we learned from Sarah One Williams' book, so she had a book called Carol's People that came out maybe a year ago, a year and a half ago. So Sarah One Williams has been basically banned by Facebook. So she has, they've sued her for $200 or $300 million. It's like a police silencer. But she came into the company right when Arab Spring was going on. It's a similar period of time in terms of Facebook is right in the middle of violence. Whether or not we want to connect them or not, we can have a conversation on that. But I think one of the things that movie captured well was back in Arab Spring, back in January 6th. They didn't think they were going to have the ability to influence anything, right? Like they're in Facebook. They're like, we're in place for connecting people. Like we were, like it's much bigger than that. - And so it's one of these things where I think on January 6th, because there wasn't the kind of thoughtful preparation. So the point of having a task force of 40 people go and talk to elected officials and talk to the advertisers and talk to all the different stakeholders is that you can have a plan for what to do if shit like this hits the fan. But if you say, oh no, no, no, no, we don't need to do anything. Like we can just be, you know, for example, if we say, were we free speech absolutists? I hope you actually have the conviction to be a free speech absolutist, because otherwise you're going to make an emotional last minute decision. And in the end, what happened on January 6th was nothing was done until he got scared enough that he did something. - Who? - Mark. The only person whose decision might happen. - But even he was brainwashed. - Yeah. - Even he was brainwashed. - And do you really want a single person making these decisions? - Him, Zuck. - Yeah. 'Cause that's what happened. Like he, Trump got taken down because at some point Mark got scared enough. - So instead of him, who would you have rather be making that decision? The government, how would you have set it up? In your ideal-- - I mean, I think in my ideal world, we have social media platforms that are less centralized. 'Cause right now, this is a private company that's to do whatever they want you with our policies. They'd be less centralized. They would be more democratically governed, right? Because right now, there's lots of things about Facebook that the reason why it could even be weaponized is because it was optimized to grow and for virality and for maximizing the number of advertising impressions you look at. If you have smaller places that are more run by the people who actually use them, you have less systemic risk, and then it matters less whether or not a single person is seeing something in the flammatory on them. - Yeah, but where I'm trying to go with this is, maybe your friend was right. Maybe your friend in 26, by the way, is he still in the same position today? - No. - Yeah. - He is more independent libertarian type? - He moved to, he left the Bay Area for Indiana with some people who, I like, I don't wanna say, he got like some very politically extreme people. He ended up meeting a lovely woman, he ended up going back to church. He has a farm now, they have ducks. - He lives with some kids. - He lives a simple life now. - Okay. - And I called him when I did 60 Minutes 'cause I knew that I had talked about him on 60 Minutes and I was like, hey, I want you to know, I talked about you in the abstract. - No name, just the list. - No, yeah. And he was like, I'm actually fine now. I met this girl and like many people who go off into the fringes. The thing that brought him back was people. - Oh, no question. - Yeah. - But where I'm trying to go with this is the following. So I'm still a registered independent till today. Okay, just so you know, I went from a Democrat to Republican to a registered independent myself. I think Bill Clinton was a good president. And I know, oh my God, I can't believe you say this. Take Monica Lewinsky and all the other stuff out. Not a fan of his wife. But I think Bill was a good friend. I've met him, you know, we've had our conversations. - You say that again? - Yeah, him and Nude worked together and he was willing to go talk to the other side. I think I liked that, I'm good with that. - I wish we did more of that. - Oh, he's fully, fully, but a part of this, we have to ask how we got here. I think the part that I saw a lot of people who were liberals who left to become independent libertarian and then they voted Republican is what they thought happened with Russia collusion. Then they're like, oh shoot, Hillary was behind it. 35 million out of that. I didn't know this thing here. Yeah. She's wouldn't.
What a great women, then, when you go and say okay, maybe COVID, you know, COVID, you better get the shot and all this stuff and then Bobby Kennedy, who's a guy that's a, his last time's Kennedy, he's been a left, you know, he's criticized Trump, all these guys. He then goes there, so it's up with, am I forced to take the shot? And then the last one was, is when, you know, guys like Elon, Elon was always on the left. Elon was always a liberal, supporting a bunch of different things, Rogan. Totally. How did these guys, all of a sense of, wait a minute, you're trying to brainwash me by, you know, keeping in formation and manipulating me through media, I'm not gonna play this game, you lost me now. Yeah. It doesn't mean Rogan's a 100% Trump got to people. So a lot of people were turned off by the amount of manipulation and brainwashing, and I also think even Zuck was in the middle of it, and he's like, I don't know if I'm part of this. So do you think there was a little bit of credence of all the manipulation that media did, that some of the people on the left left? I think, I think, for a number of those people on the left, it wasn't just this question of like, are there ideas that are okay or not okay? And to just repeat again, a big part of what I brought out was about how Facebook claimed that they could tell you what ideas were good or bad, and they could take the bad ones off, and that was all lie. I cannot do that, and we can talk about why, but it just doesn't work. But the place that we were at as a country in 2020, like very much was like a very black and white lens. Like there were good people, and there were bad people, right? And the channel that was left available that you had to walk to be a good person, got smaller and smaller and smaller. And I think one of the good things that has happened over the last couple of years is that the space of range of what is acceptable behavior is wider than it was in 2020, and even a co-author name AOC has said, woke 1.0 was crazy. And I think that kind of intolerance, that level of moral purity that they expected from people or they would cancel you, is a very, very exclusionary thing. Like it's very hard to constantly be in this prison of behavior and say like, if I do anything outside of it, I may be canceled forever. And one of the things I worry a lot about kids these days is kids are terrified of being canceled. Like they're terrified of doing the wrong thing and ending up on the internet and having everyone tell them they're horrible. And as a result, their lives get smaller and smaller and smaller because they're always on stage. - So maybe walk me through when you were having a meeting with Wall Street Journal and you're like, ah, should I do this, should I not? I don't wanna do it. I know what you're asking me. Maybe I should and then all of a sudden you're like, I have all the documents, I took all the pictures. I'm coming out, I think the world needs to know. What was that process? - Sure, so when I originally came to Jeff, my main issue was we had done internal research where we had talked to political parties in Europe and they had said, hey, we are intentionally running different political positions to post you changing the algorithm. So the idea that a private company can make a decision about what information we get to see or not see and that public entities, public political parties are saying, we don't give voters the same options because of choices you made in Menlo Park. That seems like a thing that the public had a right to know. So initially that was my big focus was saying like, hey, they know what's going on. They're not telling people, our elections are being influenced even in the options that get to choose. I worked with Jeff. We always try to leave this part slightly ambiguous. I've been told my lawyers not to give too many details. Exactly on timeline on a variety of things. But the vast majority of what I brought forward came out in just the last few weeks. So it was one of these things where I cared a lot about these questions on platform design and algorithms and how content censorship AI's work, that kind of thing. In the last couple of weeks, that's when we started grabbing things like the stuff around kids. That's stuff on teen mental health. I knew that I had no business case to touch that. Like I worked on foreign governments interfering in the United States and interfering around the world. I had lots of reasonable business cases to touch that information. I never worked on kids' mental health beyond like child predators. And only then like in the larger threat intelligence framework. And so when we started grabbing that kind of information, I assumed Facebook would catch me. That's when it happened. That's when I assumed they would, well, they never caught me. Like we got all the way out the door before they ever realized it. Like I'd take a look at that. Ever get close, even the other girl that sat right across from you, she kind of had with that scene where she comes and she tells you there's the chip. Did that ever happen? That never happened. That never happened. So that's just movie. That's just movie. Okay, got it. Were there other people involved internally trying to help and just stuff? Just you. Yeah. And did anybody like, you know nowadays with HR softwares, you can, everybody wants, you know, sentiment. They want to know, you know, like almost a minority report to find out, we're about to lose Francis. And based on email communication in it, she's probably 90 days away from quitting. And she's hit tier one crisis month for the company. Let's have a conversation with her. Did anybody approach and say, you seem very unhappy? So I think I had that moment in my first six months at Facebook. So when I was working on ethnic violence, like more hands on, when I was working on people targeting Americans with these targeted misinformation campaigns, the level of seriousness that the company brought to it, I was very concerned that not enough was being done. Because remember, I am watching things like, I have friends who work on the ethnic violence team and they're getting depression and having to talk about going on medical leave. Like it's that bad, right? People are feeling suicidal because like the company is, is like the reality you learn inside the company versus like what you can do, the gap is so big, right? During that period of time, that's when I kind of clued in that it was unacceptable to be unhappy inside the company. Right, like they made it very clear that like, you were not allowed to be negative. And so after about six months in, I realized, oh, if I want to continue working on Facebook, and that's like a brown one COVID hit, and I was like, oh, I don't want to lose my job. You cannot visibly ever be unhappy with the company. And so at that point, I kind of like strained up and flew right. Like I was just-- - Like you were acting, you were being fake or? - I would say I chose what to focus on, right? And the good thing was that I had gone shifted at that point 'cause remember, they move you around constantly. So you never get very deep in any one thing. At that point, they had moved me on to modeling how much influence anyone on the platform had. So like at that point, we were trying to identify who, not just elected officials, like let's say you are a labor organizer. Can we identify that you have effectively power on Facebook? - And would you guys give a score to that person? - We would give a score to everyone. - Like almost like that back in the days it was a website called Cloud, if you remember Cloud, the case. - We kind of were calculating Cloud scores for everyone. - And you have that on the back. - We made a prototype of it. I got moved off onto threat intelligence towards the end of that summer. So we made a prototype that was actually quite interesting. - And it's private, it's yours not public. - No, yeah, so we put it in place because Facebook treats influential people differently than it does average people. - So one of the big revelations I brought out was about a program called Crosscheck. So Facebook had been public about the idea that this thing called Crosscheck existed. They had never disclosed the details of how you got on Crosscheck. So you probably are on Crosscheck, given the amount of influence you have on the internet. So if you're on Crosscheck, your celebrity, your big elected politician, Facebook will not apply any of the content moderation tools to your content. You will end up in a human queue that will take days. So by the time someone actually looks at your content, you will have already gone all the views you're gonna get probably. 80, 90% of the views you were gonna get at any now. But no AI. - It takes 24 hours plus. - No, yeah, yeah, yeah. Back then I was taking 70, you know, three days. Yeah. And this was a huge problem. Like I'll give you an example. There was a Brazilian soccer player who sexually assaulted a woman and she came out and accused him. And he turned his fans on her. Like basically actively called for them to go after her. And because he was in this special queue, it took days for them to get to his content. And like she got death threats. She got people show up at her home. Like all kinds of stuff happened because he could call for violence against her and by the time a human looked at the content, it had been days and days down the road. Right? So there's this question, which is, Facebook has these different programs in place to protect, say, a local politician, state level politician. If we don't have data sources that can tell us, this is who needs protection. We have to figure out on our own who needs protection. 'Cause some of the other things are things like making sure you have an extra recovery phone number or like we make sure you turn on two factor authentication 'cause you're more likely to get hacked. You know, the intention of that project was to make sure that the people who needed protection got protection. So on the back end, did you have the highest cross check score on influence for people with Trump number one who was Elon ranked? So my focus was not on people we already had data on. So we, Trump would already have been under like one of our major federal politicians. There were like 35 different lists that might be how you'd get on cross check protection. If I'm in a room, I could see the ranking of who's the most influential to the least. Yeah. For the prototype that we built. And you probably see it moving like this, right? But we only focused everyone who already had protection. We filtered them out 'cause we're like, oh, you're already protected. So we focused on everyone beyond them. And so, for example, I remember one of the people in our top 10 was a national medal of freedom winner, right? Like she's, she's, she's gone returned more than like a million acres of Native American land, right? She's very, very influential, but she is not elected official. Those are the kinds of people who we didn't know about until we mined them for influence. Did you reach out to them or you just watched them? they didn't know you're doing.
doing this. You're just watching that. So my specific job was just to find them because there are other parts of the company that provide them with protection, because I'm just a data scientist figuring out like, can we find the people with influence so that then the parts of the company that give them special treatment can give them special treatment? Yeah, because I remember something happened with Facebook where guys who were making 30, 40,000, $100,000 a month would Facebook revenue that was coming and all of a sudden it's split. Yeah. And you know, to a fifth. And a lot of people that were relying on that income, they lost it. I don't know what the event was. So that's a huge deal. Like most online news sources had this happen to them. So you remember this one, this happened maybe 2021, 2022. Right. I remember that. Facebook came and said we are no longer going to prioritize the news. And so all these online news sites suddenly lost all their traffic. And revenue. And revenue. Yeah. Yeah. Traffic is revenue. Was that intentional? I think Facebook, when they knew that they were facing in some countries like Canada, for example, Canada has put in place laws that say, hey, Facebook, like your business is built on distributing the content of people who didn't pay. Like if you want there to be a news ecosystem, you have to give at least a little bit of funding to the news sector. I think Facebook looked at them, looked at the Australians and basically said, well, we're just going to distribute less news because we don't want to risk having governmental interference in the future. So when you were going through blowing the whistle on Facebook and you're dealing with Jeff, Jeff's, you know, he's a known guy in the space. I hope I'm saying he's much more competent than with the movie. It was. They made it seem like he's a dummy. Yeah. Okay. That's good to know because I was not convinced you're going to be that guy and be as dumb as they made him out to be not dumb, but it's like oblivious. Yeah. It's what I'm saying. So he knows what he's doing. So while you're going, was it, did he at all tilt you? Did he at all influence you to go like, did he say something like, hey, you're about to change the world? You're going to be on everything. Do you want to take this or was he kind of like encouraging, discouraging? You sure you want to do this? What role did he play? So I'm handcrafted across five Italian factories with build or technology and her foot. It may be the most comfortable shoe you will ever own. Introducing the all new FLB shoe, finished a new chocolate curates a leather made to move, built to endure, designed to impress. I never intended to come forward publicly. So like that decision was made like six weeks before the first Wall Street Journal article, maybe maybe six weeks, maybe four weeks before the first Wall Street Journal article came out. So he definitely, he definitely counseling me against coming forward publicly. But like when we were in the thick of it, I like, I never really wavered on that I was going to provide him with materials. The question was like, were we like when we started out like, I think I probably never expected to work with him for more than a month or two. And like I never thought we would bring out 20,000 pages of documents. Like I never thought we would end up being the reason why 47 states sued in one against Facebook. You know, like I never saw this future in front of us. But he was real, one of the things he told me that I was very, very grateful for. And I've always carried with me. As he's always said, you can stop anytime you want to. Like you owe no one anything. Like this is not, you know, like at some point it's not funny anymore. Don't like you don't have to be a public whistle. So that happened. That happened. Was there ever a flirtatious moment between the two of you or not? No, he's married. Oh, he's married. I didn't know that. And the thing that I think is so sad about the movie is so the place we actually met. So we didn't he did not live in a hotel. He lives in Oakland. His wife is a garden designer. And we, the place we actually met most often in San Francisco was his wife has built this glorious garden. Like they, they rescue cactuses. Like they go down to like, like Joshua Tree. And like, like people will say, like, I'm going to cut this cactus down for my front yard to them. I wouldn't want it. They will go and rescue cactuses. They have like these giant cacti and like, uh, trellises with flowers. And it would never look realistic on camera. But like that's where we met rescue cactuses. Yes. You can rescue a cactus. How do you read? Because it's not going away. How do you? So like, um, uh, if a cactus like lays on the ground, it can like put down roots. So you can like take an arm off a cactus and re-plant it. Oh, wow. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So imagine like the place that, so it's like cold in San Francisco. It's like dreary foggy. And you get to go in a nice sunny Oakland because remember the, the rich used to have their summer homes in Oakland because sunny and more pleasant. I don't know that. Yeah. Um, so, you know, um, so, um, that's where we met. Wow. Okay. Yeah. And so the, the, when, when you're at a point, you're like, I'm going public with this. Mm hmm. And you know, I'm going to go and I'm going to be on camera and they're going to see my face again. I know who, Francis, I'm going to be doing that. No. Did you get any weird calls? Did you get any weird visits? Did you get any weird texts? Did you get any weird people wanted to talk to you or no? So no one knew who I was until the day of 60 minutes. Right. So we, um, the only people who knew who I was was, was like the Wall Street Journal. So they knew my name. Um, and the, that, that scene where the, like the Francis Hound character comes in and like meets all the Wall Street Journal people, like that actually happened. That did happen. Um, the, um, my, my, um, my lady has a mean as she was. So, so his actual editor is a dude. Um, and, and I actually, was you a jerk? No, he's wonderful. Um, so, are you just being in deployment? No, I'm, I'm like, like, like, I was, I was telling Jeff, like, I thought it was the little sad because like his editor was like, as much like a part of the team almost, right? Cause like, we'd have to call him and defend what we were doing, right? Cause like we'd call him up and be like, we found this thing. It's like, you know, and, and, and the job of an editor is to be skeptical, right? And the job of the editor is to be like, do you really? Is that really true? Like, how can you prove that? Is that it? And so, um, having someone who is skeptical and is like the wall you bounce things off of is how you have better ideas. And so I, I, I feel like the, that role is missing from the movie. Interesting. Yeah. And, and your experience now with Wall Street Journal leaving them, what's your level of respect and credibility for their approach and how they do things? I thought they did a really good job. Um, the, the one thing where, um, I think they, um, I don't know what happened on the inside. Um, but I think they got a bunch of pressure because, um, there were like 11 stories all done right ago. And after the first say week came out, they were like, oh, we can't publish anything more for a while. Like one of the big places of conflict was, um, Jeff had, he had a team of like four journalists who worked with them and they had fleshed out these giant stories that were out of the files. And by the time we had to open things up to the rest of the press consortium, um, he was, he was like, uh, chomping at the bed. Like he wanted to be able to publish these stories. And I don't know what was happening inside the journal that they held him back because he could have been the one who broke more big stories than he did. But they didn't let him actually push out the door until sometimes weeks or months later, some of those stories. Was there anything that was left out? It was left out. I mean, the fact that the press consortium published lots more stories, um, there is all this question of scale, right? So the Wall Street Journal has a certain level staffing and they have a certain focus. And so there's going to be stories that are relevant, say, only in Poland. So, for example, um, there was, uh, a couple of stories around, um, politically influential people that came out of some of these questions, these cross check documents that those stories are not going to be published by the Wall Street Journal because they don't care about Polish politicians. Um, but the paper out of, you know, Warsaw is going to publish them. Got it. So now they did come out. I think when that was going on, Facebook came on and says, you weren't a senior executive who worked it for less than two years. You never attended the decision making meeting with C-suite executives. You acknowledge it during your congressional hearing. Zuck said your allocations were false. I think he responded publicly on October 5, 2021. He rejected the allegation that Facebook knowingly prioritized profits over user safety. Then Facebook said she wasn't an expert on Instagram's effects on children. Andy Stone emphasized that Agen, uh, uh, hadn't personally worked on Instagram child safety research. Mm-hmm. Zuck said most of us just don't recognize the false picture of the company that is being painted. His response was that, uh, Francis and interpretation failed to acknowledge the company's extensive investment in safety research. Zuck says your accusations unfairly characterized thousands of employees who genuinely care about protecting users. Uh, these are some of the things that he took. Do you agree with them on what he said? But what I find so funny about the, um, the, like, we don't agree with this characterization thing is one of the things that came out from the lawsuits against the company about Instagram was an email from Adam Asari to Mark Zuckerberg and a couple of other C-suite folks about Instagram and child safety. They came out, uh, the email happened like one or two weeks before, um, the first story was published in the Wall Street Journal. And the reason why this timing is so interesting is we gave them three weeks to do, um, comment, right? Like the Wall Street Journal was, was, was cautious enough and parent enough that they didn't give them three days to do comment, um, they give them three weeks. So sometime between when they were tipped off that these stories about kids and Instagram were coming, a week or two later Adam Asari writes to Mark and says in order for us to actually do a week, claim we're doing publicly to protect kids. We need another 45 people working on kids. And the CFO writes back, there's no money to do that. This is document. This is a email that came out through the court cases. And they have since claimed, oh no, no, no, we actually did fund that later on. But like the email thread that we have, like we don't, that allegedly how it all has got funded is via verbal commands. Um, there's no paper portrayal saying this every day.
get funded, but Adam is very sad. In order just to do what we say, we're doing publicly, it would take 45 more people. What is for the people that don't know? Adam's role. How much power does that have? So he's the head of Instagram. He's the head of Instagram, yeah. Okay, and so on the findings for Instagram with specifically young teenage girls, what patterns did they notice? So I would say there's a range of things that I brought out, and there's a range of things that we know now from the court cases. So what initially kicked off a lot of the storm around Instagram and kids was a series of focus groups, the Facebook ran, with teenage girls where they ask them questions like when you feel bad about your body, does Instagram make you feel worse? And that's like where the famous stat of like 65% said it made them fall worse or 35% or whatever. What has happened since then is much, much larger scale studies have been leaked. So this man named Arturo Behar, who was the first engineer on safety at Facebook way, way, way back in the day like 2009, 2010. He left the company when he had kids, like basically retired, came back when his daughter was 14. So he, she and him like to fix up cars together. They made, she made an Instagram account about fixing up cars. And when he looked like this guy, yeah, Arturo Behar, he's wonderful. When he came back to work for Facebook. So he, she's, she started posting on Instagram about the cars. He looked at the comments and it was a bunch of middle-aged men talking about his 14 year old girl's body. And he's like, how is this possible? Like she's talking about this car she's fixing up. How is she getting sexually harassed? Like, why is she getting sent nude photos that she didn't ask for? They must not know. Like that was his immediate, immediate response. Like when I was at Facebook, they cared about safety. They must just not know this is a problem. So he returned to Instagram around the time that I was coming forward as a whistleblower. So he joined maybe a year before I came forward as a whistleblower. And at the same time that Facebook was making these public statements saying, this is not what's happening to kids on the platform. He was running surveys of 100,000 children on the platform. So this is 13 to 15 years. As an insider. Yeah, he's running the studies right at the same time. And the results that are coming back are things like one in eight girls between the ages of 13 and 15. Let's be honest, kids lie about their age on Instagram. So this is like 10 year olds. One in eight girls between 13 and 15 said they received an unwanted sexual message in the last seven days. So he's sitting there being like, wait, they're saying publicly that nothing's wrong. And I'm asking 100,000 children. So I'm getting real responses on like, are you getting bullied? Are you seeing violence? Has violence been committed against you? Like what? Like he's seeing the raw data. And then the company is saying publicly nothing is wrong. And that's why he came forward as a whistleblower. How much of that investigation did you guys on the inside? Like the workers, the executives. How did they handle Instagram with their own daughters? Did they just say, you can't, my daughter doesn't, my daughter's not on Instagram. What did they do with their personal lives? So at the time that I came forward, just like 2021. So this is, this is I think part of the systemic problem of Instagram and Facebook, which is in Silicon Valley, people have kids a little bit older. Facebook was founded by a bunch of 19 and 20 year olds. When you add those two facts together, it means that even at the time that I left the company, which is 2021, Mark's eldest child was nine. Adam and Sarah head of Instagram's oldest child was nine. So they could say publicly, like seriously, my children are not on these products because they're not old enough. Ignoring the fact that like 30% of seven to nine year olds are on social media. Today, Adam and Sarah says, my kid is on social media because she's like, I don't know, 14 now, right? I don't know how they use the products with their own kids, they put time caps, do they look at their kids' phones, do they use other kinds of software to supervise their kids on on their devices? I don't know. How much of the honest do you put? Curious for you as an insider, how much of the honest do you put on parents versus Facebook to platform? So one of the really big challenges with these these apps is I think you can safely have kids on social media, but it requires a level of oversight from parents that not all parents have the time or energy to execute or technical sophistication, right? It's things like, you have to sit down with your kid at least once a week and look at their feed with them and talk to them about it, right? And that's an awkward conversation, like how many 14 year olds want to show their mom their Instagram feed? None of them. None of them, right? Or you have to do things like you can't let your kid charge their phone in their bedroom at night because they're not going to go to bed. Jonathan, high talks about the action. Huge, huge, huge, huge lever you have. But that means you have to fight with your kid every night to make sure that their phone stays in your room. Sure, you have a two-year adult daughter when she's 14. Are you going to let her be on Instagram? And I'm assuming Instagram will not be Instagram in 12 years given the rate of how things are changing. Will she be on some on the internet? She'll almost certainly be on the internet. I'm assuming even in the next five years, we are probably going to have like AIs that ride along with kids in a much more active way. And I think that is going to really change how we view children on the internet. If she was 14 today, would you let her be on Instagram? No, I would not let her be on Instagram. When would you let her be on Instagram? Somewhere between 14 and 16. I'd have to know the kid. I don't know if I'm even doing it. My oldest son is 14, about to be 15. He's still not on Instagram. To give you context on why it's so important for parents to have really awkward conversations with their kids about these technologies is the things that kids do online, they don't stay online. And one of the things that is happening at higher and higher rates is sex torsion. So 14-year-old boys get messaged by supposedly very gorgeous women and lured into situations that I. Sure, you're dangling and then we're on the next day in school. It was a movie that did this, disconnected. Can you type in disconnect or disconnected? You know who's in it? The guy from. That's the one. Disconnect. Disconnect movie is the sister walks into the room. The brothers is about to commit suicide because a girl he's in love with in school. The three bullies that were bullying him send a picture of her as if it's her profile. Yeah. And they send a private part picture of just any girl naked without the face on her and says, "If I send you mine, will you send me yours?" He sent his with him in the picture. The boys were released that in school the next day. And then he came in committing suicide wanting to commit suicide and the sister found him. It's terrifying. But that depiction in that movie. That's realistic. I think every parent needs to watch this movie. So to me, my challenge becomes. And then it went step worse now they're doing it with AI. So your kid might not even expose himself and they'll generate a photo and say, "Hey, see this photo with your face on it. We're like, you're doing something that seems. What do you do with that?" Well, I think one of the questions is who should have access to your children? One of the things that has been a big change this happened as a result of the kids' lawsuit is one of the things that came out from. This is really sad. One of the things that came out as a result of the kids' lawsuits was when we talk about the algorithm on Instagram, there's not one algorithm. There's a bunch of algorithms. So yes, there's one that picks out your posts. But there's also one that suggests hashtags to you. And there's one that suggests people to you amongst other things that it suggests. The one that suggests people to you, one of the ways it prioritizes who is suggested to you is based on what friends you've accepted from that list before. So if you are a 55-year-old guy who likes 13-year-old girls, the algorithm will continue to show you more 13-year-old girls. And it will show you not just 13-year-old girls. It will show you 13-year-old girls who actually accept friend requests from 55-year-old guys. Stop it. Yes, because those are the highest probability. Today? So now it doesn't because the lawsuit. So now kids are opted into private accounts by default. Oh my goodness. Because should your kid get shown to some random stranger? Till when was it doing that? It depends where in the world are you were. That gets one of these questions of Facebook complies with local laws. So if you have a country that says kids get private accounts, you have more private situations. I think we can thank the Australians because the first beginning to close down those holes didn't happen until Australia threatened to ban social media for under 16s. And that's only like two years ago. What if Florida do? Florida made a decision. The center said something about under 16 you can't be on social media. Can you find a way? I think they appealed it. Who appealed it? I'm edited. And they won? I don't know. I don't know where it doesn't look her in state law. Florida say long down. Under 14 are banned from creating holding social media. 14 to 15 teens are allowed to have accounts only with parental consent. Target a platform. The law applies to social media says they use Florida. Santa's drove this. So you support this. So I believe we can design social media that is good for kids. We do not have a system of incentives in place right now that encourages companies like Instagram to actually comply. That's a weird question. Who do you think politically protects young teenage girls more? Conservatives or liberals? Oh great question. Because even Jonathan Hyde was asked this question. I wonder what you say about this. Well right now it's kind of wild. So like for example the Kids Online Safety Act is the main piece of legislation at the federal level that is in the Senate. You know it has over 75 co-signers. So it's like both Republicans and Democrats are supporting it and yet it gets stuck in the house. And I think so far we have seen more right leaning states be willing to step up and take action. So I think Utah, Florida, and Texas have all done things. So when it looks we can look at just the legislative history. Definitely the right has done more to protect kids online but in the left. I think they understand better that kids that the internet is not an unadulterated like a pure good right there.
There are lots of dark quarters to the internet. And one thing that's really complicated is, like I said before, I don't believe we should just exclude children from the internet. At the same time, we have not seen these tech companies being willing to do the changes they need to do to make these places safer kids. So when you have a conflict like that, are you more biased towards action or are you more biased towards continuing to negotiate with these companies? And I think the states like Florida have said, we're not going to negotiate anymore. We're just going to put our foot down. Which you support. I think until, I think until we see these companies being willing to make changes, I think one of the only ways to practice is banning. So, let me ask a different question to see how you, so let's just say you get hired by Disney and you're working with Bob Eiger or Chapec or even the news guy that they have Josh Di Amaro or Kathleen Kennedy. Let's take any of those executives you're working with. And you see a pattern with Disney all of a sudden coming up with all these LGBTQ characters in cartoons. They've never done this before. First time ever, a character in a Disney cartoon or movie said, I am gay was 2019, I think. I just had Bob Eiger pick on here a month ago, and we talked about this. If you, if a Francis Hagen is working at Disney and you're noticing the pattern of the more LGBTQ characters you put in cartoons to meet your ESGDI score is increasing the influence of kids identifying as gay or part of the LGBTQ, not as an adult, but as an eight-year-old, nine-year-old, ten-year-old, twelve-year-old, do you find that inappropriate? Do I find inappropriate? So the question is, are they depicting adults that are LGBTQ or they aren't getting kids to tell them you may be, maybe I am LGBTQ. Sorry, who are the characters that are putting in one of the parents in the Disney movie is gay? I want to be young kids are gay, not adults at all, and girls kissing girls, young girls kissing girls, I think I like girls, I think I like boys. I think for children's media, it's all a question of what age range are you targeting? I don't think in movies targeting four-year-olds, you have eight-year-olds kissing, that kind of thing, but that's just my personal bias. I don't think you should say, I think we sexualized children too much in our culture. That's one of the major, unfortunate things that has come out of Instagram is we no longer have tween spaces, like it used to be we treated in depictions of media, kids who were twelve to fourteen, differently than we did at sixteen-year-olds, and now all the ten-year-olds want to be twenty-five years old, right? So I think I don't have enough context on the Disney thing of like who this queer character is. I'd want to see like, what, what are the, what's their rationale, why are they including- They should say they're doing that, let's just say you're doing that, you're, so let's, politically, I try to see where you're at politically, I think you're, you got a libertarian side to you. I'm an anti-statist, yeah, I fear the government, yeah. Yeah, I think you have a libertarian side to you, you're a crypto person, you live in Puerto Rico, so you probably don't like high taxes, COVID, got you to leave California, you probably want the freedom, too much control, you don't like, again, I'm speculating, but at the same time, you love our kids. You love your kids, I do as well, and you're all about education, that's great. You have supported AOC in the past, I gave, I have given money to Rand Paul, not Rand Paul, Rachel and Paul. Ron Paul. Ron Paul. Oh, really? Okay, so, he came to Google, way back in the day. Yeah, you know, he raised like six million dollars on my space in 24 hours and, oh, or, it was the record, it was crazy, yeah, sure, so I have you there, right? Which means, uh, uh, I think if we admit Romney today, we'd all be really happy with Mitt Romney. Wow. Because think about it, like, if we, if you had to choose between any of the politicians that are currently on the national scale in Mitt Romney, everyone would pick Mitt Romney. Mitt Romney. Think about, like, how, like, think of how much chaos there is today, if you had to choose between chaos of today and Mitt Romney, how many Americans would choose Mitt Romney? I think a lot of Americans would choose Mitt Romney. Over with Trump. And I would, I never was Mitt Romney, in the last two years, I'm like, God, what if we had Mitt Romney? Your husband is doing something to you. Let me tell you, I don't know what conversations you guys are having with this debate. Maybe it's my, maybe it's my, maybe it's my, maybe it's my, like, so I went to Harvard Business School. So I'm like, I'm a practical person. Like, like, I get that vibe from you. Yeah. I get that vibe from you. So, to me, like, I try to be, I have, you know, I run multiple businesses and we have employees that come from many different backgrounds. The part to me was, don't manipulate, like, the BBC stuff, when the CEO had to step down. He never said, well, you claimed he said, and you got sued and you have to pay money to Trump, which is embarrassing. Don't contact Facebook and Google and Twitter and say, hey, don't release the New York Post story about Hunter Biden laptop. That would have made a difference in the election or else they wouldn't have gone wrong. That never happened. Elon buys Twitter. They do the Twitter files by Matt Taibe and, you know, Barry Weiss and all this other guy. We realize, yeah, the Biden administration and then Zuck comes out and Zuck says, they would call me and say this if he said that on the, I think it was a Rogan podcast and all this stuff. I mean, then it was the LGBTQ stuff. Why are you so concerned whether my kids are going to be gay or not? If a person's gay, they know they're gay, leave them alone. They'll become gay later on alive. You don't need to try to impose and then stats came out recently that the number of teenage girls identifying as lesbian has the highest drop-off in the last 12 months. Why do you think that is? Well, because finally Trump came in and said, okay, stop with all this stupidity. Disney lost $200 billion in valuation. Nike just went from $261 billion to $50 billion dollar valuation. You know, Netflix's flatline a little bit would all the different things that they try to do. And maybe common sense is like, leave the kids alone. Know my kids don't need to be targeted by 55-year-olds that are liking 13-year videos. And I think that part, a lot of people on the left that were common sense and ones on the right, or maybe someone's on the left that's pro-choice. And I'm pro-life. Okay, great. But we can agree on these certain areas. I think that's the part that I had. And maybe a lot of Americans that Promswood, why are you trying to make cartoons and movies towards kids? Leave them alone. So I'll give you an example of where are the things in terms of interventions on social media that I think have interesting opportunities that they're not in the discussion. So one of the documents that I brought forward out of Facebook was an experiment where they said, hey, there are some people who even though they disagree politically, they're really good at talking to people who are different than themselves. Right? Like we can look at it. So this is one of the things that I think most people are not aware about Facebook. Facebook had a score for every person. Is that the cross-strike program? No, this is a different program. So is this who's the most reasonable and willing to talk? So imagine for every one in the United States, we have a score of where we think you fall on the left to the right. Everyone has that. How would a some Facebook has that for everybody? Yeah, so they have at least for the United States, I don't know if they have it globally. The imagine we look at it and we say, interesting, you are on the left, you are on the right. But you're really good at getting positive comments from people different than you. So during COVID, there was like an epidemiologist. What an important data to have. Interesting. So there was an epidemiologist, for example, during COVID, they got famous for being able to talk to people on the right. So she was on the left, but she was an epidemiologist. I don't remember her name, but she got famous on YouTube because she was willing to take people seriously and meet them where they were and like have open conversations. Right? So let's say in general, we can look at the data and say, hey, there are some people who are able to get people who are different than them to put likes on their posts or get them put comments on their posts and they comment back and like very clearly, they are connecting with people different than themselves. If you say, you know what, that's a really hard skill and it might not show up in likes and reaches. Maybe the hardest skill. What if we, when we see this pattern taking place, we just presume your content is a little better on average and we give you a little tiny boost? What happens to the ecosystem as a whole? It turns out when you make just that one change, you say, hey, people who are good at talking people different than them, let's give them a little tiny boost. You get less violence, you get less hate speech, you get less misinformation. Right? So there's a lot of these things where we don't have to go in there and pick individuals, topics and say, you can't talk about that, you can't talk about that. But we can come in there and say, hey, like maybe we should not prioritize things that have super long chains of reshairs and maybe we should reward people who can talk people different than themselves. There's a bunch of these things where these are systemic interventions. And the question is, who has the right to know they exist and who has the right to chime in on, of all the different ways we have to solve these problems, which should, which should be the tools in our tool chest that we go to? That may be the most important data that I would want, I mean, that's a, for any marketer, for anybody running for office, different demos who to target, for Facebook to have that kind of a data. It's scary. It's powerful. It's super powerful. Yeah. Is it fair to assume that both Google and YouTube and Twitter has access to that as well? How different would they be than Facebook? Yes. So it requires you to have enough staff to actually go and check, right? And one of the challenges right now is when, where you look at where the money is within the industry, 75 cents of every dollar that's spent on advertising for social media goes to Instagram, Facebook, or YouTube. 90 cents of every dollar of profit goes to Instagram, Facebook, or YouTube. So anyone who is outside those three platforms is working with much, much less money to do anything. So Twitter, because they run so thinly, I bet they don't have that data, just because they don't have someone who's gone and computed them. The question is, does Facebook still do that today? Because it's possible as-- How much does it cost to do this, by the way? Is it a big cost? No, just you need to staff someone on it and develop the model.
Like a person like a person someone has to go and like spend a month or two You don't think you long would do that. I mean, he longs got the engineers from Tesla to transfer over to the question Is it a priority for him? If he's involved in elections, massive priority form. Don't you think like it? If he just didn't you just give like 185 million honors or something to add on who was Tallerico or Massive a month If you're given that kind of money you better have to date on the back end to believe that maybe Tallerico has a chance of losing That Paxton can beat him or else why would I put my money there? Yeah, so I would assume he probably does Do you think Elon buying X was good for society that at least somebody from the other side Owned one of the big social media platforms Um, I think Twitter was slowly falling apart like like one of the things that is good about Elon buying Twitter is like He is just better at technology than most other people are um and I think Twitter was going to be in a situation where they were gonna They there's a chance they will have gone bankrupt or they could have gone bought by someone even worse Right like think of think of yahu like yahu buying time remember that right like what did yahu do to tumblr? They kind of ran into the world. Well, I think yahu was one of the people that they were saying could potentially buy Twitter I see those kinds of things like like people who are even worse at technology than Twitter So I think the fact that Elon bought it and it is still life today like that is an asset to the world Like we as we we do need we do need discourse And Twitter plays a right is making a lot of people angry Twitter plays a role for conversation that it is not filled in any other space today And so the fact that it is still a going concern and I think we'll be a going concern going in the future. I think that is a positive thing Um, I think the fact that he fired like all of his safety people all on the pathway to getting there that caused Like mark has been very open that he fired his safety people because Elon was able to and nothing bad happened to him He he brought a few them back because he realized he needed him I don't know you know the stories like I messed up. Hey can you come back Um, but in the case of of of mark like you know after I came forward and said hey like you're not investing in non-English safety Like only 11% of users speak English yet like you spend half the screen it says half the safety budget on English speaking Like you're clearly only doing this like look kind of okay in the United States so you don't get regulated Like you have to care about people who Facebook is the internet for what person is the when you say 11% is only speaking yeah What percentage of the revenue Facebook gets is when you're speaking customers? I'm sure Because then you have to target the English speaking customers if the other guys are not buying why would I target them? Well, I think the issue is like um, and this is one of the things that I raised and in the filings was Facebook went into places like African countries Southeast Asia when the internet was just being born And said if you use Facebook, we will pay for your data If you want to use anything else, you're gonna have to go pay for yourself and understandably alternatives to Facebook did not emerge Right so so Facebook is a much much larger share of the internet in those places than anywhere else because Facebook came in and made sure that competition did not take place Um, so the question is if you have a situation where people it's hard harder for them to leave than on the English speaking world Um, and you're treating them worse Like what are your responsibilities, especially when you have something like me and more take place Right, so that that's the question the question is you intentionally took on this extra responsibility by like killing your competitors or like making sure they weren't born Um, like should you have to deal with the mess you created Um, and so the situation was you know, there's 3000 languages in the world Facebook was choosing to use content, but like they didn't even have people who could um, get messages Like when when the Myanmar genocide happened one of the big things the the UN flagged was there was only one person in the entire company who even spoke for me So as people were getting shot or like as these messages were going, I didn't know this is a heavy job This is why I do think Zuck is evil. You think it's an evil person. I don't think it's evil. Yeah Same or Elon you don't think neither one. It's just yeah, what do you think Zuck is you think and I I think Elon The difference in Elon mark is actually really really important like I've watched um videos of like Elon hanging out at SpaceX, you know, like like when they were covered um when the the the Missile touchdown and didn't blow up right like you just see him interacting with his employees Elon is a much more fully formed adult than Marcus. What does that mean? Mark became CEO when he was 19 years old. Oh right. He has been surrounded only by people. He chose to be around Interesting since he was 19 years Um, and I it's a heavy burden by the heavy burden, right? And they they say, you know, power is the ultimate drug um in the addiction community they say the age of which you start using is the age of which you stop emotionally maturing So if you dry out when you're 35 you still make you still solve problems like a 19 year old Right, and um, you know, when we look at the emails that came out through the um court cases or just his testimony. We'll give you an example um uh, and the When uh snapshot start doing augmented reality filters. This is like I'm a cat that kind of thing um Instagram rolled out augmented reality filters and one of the filters that rolled out was one that let you simulate plastic surgery So let you mark up your face as if you're about to get plastic surgery and Understandably people wrote it and said do we really want 13 year old girls Imagining themselves being marked up for plastic surgery Like if we want to normalize the idea that you should get plastic surgery for small children um, uh, and The They went and we're like, okay, we're gonna go talk to experts So we'll bring much to trans psychologists. We'll consult outside people inside people They paid like 20-25 Experts to like give their opinions on like what is the impact of making the successful to kids Across the board on the inside and the outside they said even even if this wasn't bad And it is bad um, it's a really bad look for us to be promoting this And it goes up to mark and mark says i think it's patronizing to restrict access to this to kids And like when he got confronted at um, the court case so he had it to give testimony They asked him do you still think now that you know all the more that you know because this happened in like 2019 or something Do you still think? It's inappropriate to like not have this be available for 13 year old girls and he goes i still think it's patronizing Physician didn't change his he doesn't he he's not in circumstances Is that tell you he's a true believer or does that tell you it's just money because that doesn't tell me it's money That tells me he really believes in that position Or I mean like or so like there's other blind spot. Yeah, I think it's a blind spot thing So so i'll give you an example that they came up with new augmented reality glasses recently Right and the day after the day of there's a center view of them where the journalist is like hey, I noticed You now have augmented reality glasses. They don't have a camera So for context for listeners there's a lot of people who have been calling things creeper glasses Right because like people have been taking pictures in locker rooms and I just you know, I don't like it when I see some guys that are You know you're wondering hey, what do you what are you doing? What are you recording? What do you yeah? And people are covering up the light on them, right? Um, so the journalist was like, yeah I noticed you now have ones that don't have a camera is this because like you heard the feedback That like people are really freaked out by these because like people will attack other people in public for wearing these glasses Because like they're so they don't they don't they feel so the privacy is violated so much and he goes oh No, no, no, no, no, they're just so much cheaper Like you save like 140 bucks if you don't put a camera in them and like people There's always when people want the cheapest option and like there's so much lighter if you don't have a camera in them And like they look just like normal glasses So either no one told him how upset people are or he doesn't care and we just don't know And that's part of what's like so scary about him dabbling in like frontier AI stuff Is you know, I think the public's been pretty clear about how big an impact the creeper glasses that what do you think the long term? If you if we were to analyze and you know we're not psycho you know, you know psycho analyzing these folks but Negative motives long term do you worry about this much power to zuck or Elon? Do you worry? Do you think it's all positive? I worry much less so I I worry about Elon's well-being like I I Genuinely think Elon really tries like I again, this is probably a controversial opinion for some quarters Like Elon has invested so much in trying to advance things like he did electric cars because he cares about the environment Like it's very clear right or like he has done more for internet access than anyone in the world, right? They're more people through Starlink like I think Elon Genuinely believes and he has a history of executing and yes He is a showman and he oversells things and it takes him a lot longer to do things than maybe initially promises Lots of businessmen have that problem, right I worry he burns the candle at both ends. I worry He's also probably surrounded by people who don't give him enough bad news But I worry about mark a lot more right and part of that is Elon has to deliver like he doesn't own 60% of the voting shares He doesn't get full control He has to negotiate with other people and that means Elon stays grounded in reality much more than mark does The people around mark are there because mark wants them to be there They make mark feel good. They tell him whatever story they need to tell him that lets him Be able to accept the way the world is and that's not good for any human being Like that keeps you from going to grow and be a fully fleshed adult Who are the top three heavyweights at Facebook at meta if something were to happen to Zub who would be the three Heavyweights that could replace them could replace them I don't know now because like the shift AI like what is Facebook now like is the is the future of Facebook AI or is the future of Facebook social media They don't have a choice but to go to AI. Yeah, I think they don't I think I think there's a very good chance that the lawsuits are going to be so lucrative that they're going to have to split the company at some point And I think that'll happen. I think they'll probably have said they were trying to do that a few years ago Right who was a little bit Warren was that was presenting that I don't know who was but it was but that was that was a breaking it up That was like what sat and Instagram and all this stuff But you're saying even bigger than that because if the AI part of the company is like the part that has a future Right like you can imagine a situation where they say okay, um we will sell all
off the social media side of the company and Mark will continue to have full control over his AI side of his company. And with the new stock deal that he got just today, he can take out tens of billions of dollars each year and not lose any control over the company. He would still pay to 5% tax. He would still have to pay all that money. That's the one time thing. It's not every year. But that's still a lot of money for the guy, right? I get it. But right now he can only sell shares if he loses control. Do you think this work tax is going to pass? You think that's the most? I mean, if they're having these types of talks. Probably, I like that it's going to pass in California. Yeah. I try not to follow California politics anymore. They're very intense. I live thousands of miles away. I don't-- Really? It really isn't. Talking about AI. So we have Jacob Coxon on here. He's the guy that fell off from Anthropic that he was there for a few weeks. He was three years at OpenAI. He says, I think I'm resigning today because I'm worried about what's going to happen to safety. Do you have a similar position with AI? So I think the focus on the danger of AI five years from now is really misguided because we don't need AI any smarter than the AI we have today for it to be incredibly disruptive. We don't need AI smarter than today to run information operations at a scale beyond anything we ever saw in 2016. We don't need AI smarter than today to hack computers in really devastating ways. I think there's a bunch of websites that were out over the last few days because of the huge hacking. Yeah. The only reason we are not seeing more chaos right now with the level of AI, we have right now is just because people aren't trying. The reason the lights are on right now is because no one is trying to turn the lights off. The reason the water is flowing is because no one is trying to turn the water off. But we invade Iran. Well, the water stay on, like really invade Iran, like not the current, like, dabbling thing we're doing right now. That is the thing we should be talking about is what are we doing to heart and cyber security, what are we doing to get early access, like early detection on bio weapons, are we investing in broad spectrum antivirals, definitely not enough conversation on that. The idea that the AI is going to wake up and kill assault, I feel like there's a lot of things in that space where it's like, I haven't heard plausible war games. It's like, is this a suicidal AI? Like, you know, at least as of our level of automation today, they kill us. All the lights go off for them too, right? So I think it's good that we are talking about technology having a downside, but we need to be, like, doubling down right now on the things we can control because the danger is right now. It's not from the AI waking up five years from now. So you don't give that much credence to the fear porn? I think the focusing on the apocalyptic five years from now distracts us from doing things we need to be doing right now. But doesn't that create urgency? It's like, hey, let's go because shit could happen in five years. You don't need to be serious. I think we should be saying, hey, like, like, I think the much more pressing thing is like, so week or two ago, Axios leaked a story about the big AI companies war gaming, like red teaming situations around like the lights going out and like the Thanksgiving hat and that kind of thing. That is the thing that people should be asking lots and lots of questions about right now. Like, what is the federal government doing to make sure that the federal government is safe right now? I don't think enough. Like, that's the thing we should be terrified by right now. But like, will the AI wake up and decide like to snuff us out in five years? Because that is a problem that's going to happen in two months from now, not the hypothetical five years from now. And when we talk about things that are like apocalyptic, it makes us freeze. You know, when we get too scared, we stop acting like it takes away agency. Like, there's a lot of people who like get, like, when you get apocalyptic. Like, so like, all the talk on the pause, for example, right? Like, the talking about the pause at length versus talking about what are we doing to heart and cyber security right now? Those are two very different conversations. Something more. Right? So, I am a Cold War Studies minor. So, I have an engineering degree as my primary. I have a Cold War Studies minor. I focused on civil disobedience against civil defense. So, back in the early 1960s, late 1950s, we used to role play nuclear war, right? So, we'd like New York State, for example, pass law saying once a year we are going to simulate having a nuclear war, if you do not go into the shelters with everyone else, we can ticket you. Like, that level of, like, we're going to a role game. She's absolutely a thing New York did. Yeah, yeah. Rural thing New York did. What year was it? Wild. 1950, 40. Why not? 1962-ish. Okay. So, 1959, and this woman is having like a crisis of conscience. She's like, oh my god, and I just had a baby, like she's 21, because back then people had lots of babies at 21. I don't want to raise my child to live underground. I cannot do this. And she gave, put a roast in the oven for her husband, because she assumed she was going to get arrested, because that's what they did to people who did civil disobedience back then. I, she left her baby with the husband, they went in the shelter, she went out and sat on like a park bench. And nothing happened. It was like a very anti-antico-comactic, but the next day, she opens up the newspaper. And this woman named Janice Smith is sitting on this park bench in front of City Hall. And there's like big police officer looming over her. She's holding her infant. She's got a tallow on the bench next to her. Like, that, that idea that that was a new story, like a single person saying, I'm not willing to go underground, was a new story in the New York Times, shows you how different the circumstances. Right now, the talk on the pause says, hey, those people, the people who started those protests right then, within three years, they got a partial test of entry, right? Like, they organized and like, they started with like four people and they actually had like a hundred people and they actually had a couple thousand people. By the early 1960s, we had a partial test band treaty. We did not have a full test band treaty. The reason we had a partial treaty and not a full treaty was we banned tests in space, tests in the air, tests on land, tests in the water, we never banned them underground. We didn't ban them underground for another, I don't know, like five years, six years because we invented a technology called Fourier fast transforms. So you might have heard of FFTs? Fourier. Yeah. So FFTs. FFT. Yeah. You use them every day. So your video right now uses Fourier fast transforms in its codex, right? Like, it's a way of basically extracting out wave forms and things like that. We didn't ban nuclear tests underground because we couldn't tell if it was an earthquake or if it was a nuclear bomb. We don't ban things unless we can confirm that the thing is actually not happening. So when all the nuclear activists are like these people care, they knew the world was going to end. Like, that's what we have to ban it. That's why we need a pause right now. We did it before for nuclear weapons. No, we didn't. We didn't ban it until we had the ability to confirm that cheating was not taking place. And right now, tons and tons and tons of mental bandwidth is going into we need a pause and not into we need to be investing way more in cybersecurity. We need to be investing way more in broad spectrum antivirals. You know, these are the things that we have to be doing the work on right now. We are not having those conversations because we are talking about the pause. The pause isn't even what we did with nuclear weapons. Wow. Drives me crazy. Every time I hear about it. Cyber security. Yeah. Huh. Because it's one of these things we're like, I'll give you an example. We roll back in time to 1999. Like I'm old enough to remember why 2K, right? We realized we were running the world on software from the 70s. And we didn't we had literally said, well, it's going to take so long for a list to need four digits to have time that we can just do two digits for the year, right? So like 95 instead of 1995, right? You know, we invested huge amounts of effort, like tremendous amount of efforts across society to rewrite tons and tons and tons and tons of software to make it so we can do why 2K. We should be having that level of crisis about AI and cybersecurity right now. Instead, we're talking about the pause. Who is actually who is actually spearheading that conversation? Is there somebody out there that's saying we should be paying attention to this instead of the pause? So I think the situation, like if you were going to go talk to people who are doing activism in this AI space, I think what they would say is, sure, getting hacked sucks, right? Like, yes. Have a bunch of websites going on is bad. But like if the thing that we're talking about is the extinction of humanity, it's more important to talk about the extinction of humanity. And I think the main issue right now is like what the plausibility of what is that scenario. And so I think part of why we're going to distract it and not talking about those kind of like brass tax, like we have work we need to do right now to deal with AI. That stuff is less sexy. It will cost money. And if you are a nonprofit who has to go raise money from donors, it's a lot easier to raise money on. I want to say a few manage from the apocalypse. And so I don't think there's enough voices right now. They're talking about the, you know, not sexy, like let's make sure all the systems are hardened. But if you're the enemy, is that how you would attack? Would you go, like, even warfare change, right? We didn't know Russia is going to destroy Ukraine. Now we got these drones that we make. We got a half a million. I'm going to hit your, you know, warhead. I'm going to hit your ships. I'm going to hit you. You can move. So what do you want to do? I'm the small guy. And then Iran had their drones. So you kind of realize warfare has changed. It's not what we thought it's going to be right. Super change. So are we not paranoid about the right things? They're the way enemy or an Iran or China or Russia or somebody would attack us would be the power grid or we, you know, how would they do it? You know, if it's drones that throw us off and now you got Palmer Lockett that's building with these buildings. Have you had him on your podcast? No, we're having a conversation about going and seeing how he makes the drones. He's fascinating. He's fascinating. Yeah. I think it's fairly public knowledge that people assume that if we were to say attack, if there was a conflict between Taiwan and China, like China probably would attack American infrastructure, right, like, I think one way to
think about it is historically strategists have talked about the world as being land powers or sea powers. So a sea power is like England. You know, they're completely defended by the ocean all around them. Or a land power is like Russia. Like Russia has no clean boundaries. So sea powers don't have to invest a ton in their military. Or in their armies, they invest in their navies. They're able to focus on things like trade because they can reach anywhere. As long as they keep that maritime defense, they can have security within their society and stability. A country like Russia, because they have poorest borders, they are constantly having to fund the military. They have to have very different kinds of social structures. The United States has historically governed itself as if it is a maritime power. We were protected by the oceans on the sides. Mexico and Canada have not invaded us since the 1800s. We need to understand that we are no longer a maritime power. In a world where China can attack the homeland through cyber things, we are vulnerable in a very different way. Or where they can run an information operation and sound like they are a person from Iowa. Or like back in 2016, I kind of roll my eyes at the Russian foreign interference stuff because they weren't nearly as effective as the Macedonian teenagers who were running for profit, add-sense fake news sites. They had way more warm bodies that were working on that than the Russians were. And the Russians all sounded like Russians. Today you can run the same influence operation and run through clawed and you sound just like you're from Wisconsin. You sound just like you're from Minnesota. We are now vulnerable in a way that we haven't been vulnerable in 200 or 300 years. Do you think a country like China has been thinking about this for decades way longer than us because the way they control power is different than ours. Where they have so many Chinese nationals or spies within different parts of our ecosystem that they know exactly what's going on in America? When I was at Google, this wild thing took place, which was China hacked. I don't know if it was like 50 of the top 100. It was like 50 of the biggest companies in the United States. And only two of them realized they were hacked. So Google realized they were hacked and one other company that I don't know the name of realized they were hacked. And the level of intrusion that China did to get into Google was they clearly had spies inside the company that got the employee directory. They figured out who is in charge of the single sign on team. So this is like the team that basically controls access to things. They figured out who the guy's wife was. They had her sent him a link with like a photo album so that he clicked on it. This is the classic like don't click on links. You don't know. Even this Googler clicked on the link from his wife because who's who's that hyper vigilant? It installed some kind of malware on his computer. It stole his credentials, which shouldn't matter because they're encrypted. They must have run basically a whole data center for a month to crack his credentials. Then they used his credentials to log back into Google and plant all the stuff that happened. That was the level of intrusion that they could do. And this is like in 2011. What damage did they do? Is it extract information or actual damage? I know that we had a fire drill where we changed all the passwords that were in the code base in like less than a week. So like imagine hundreds of Googlers all responsible for like basically changing how access controls are done throughout the code base because I think the whole code base was stolen. And this is like back in 2011. So imagine what they're doing today. Was Cheryl Sandberg there? Was she there? Cheryl was in sales. So she was not like a technical thing. Yeah, but I think she had already left her Facebook by 2011. Got it. Interesting. But this is the kind of thing where we should assume that China has people embedded in every major institution. Did they identify who were the internal people working at? I'm sure they weren't able to figure out who was the one who gave it over. Even with that thing, the prints were in left behind. Because if you have an employee directory, remember how I talked about how when I was a Facebook and I was getting documents, there are documents where I felt confident this will never raise a red flag because I work on issues around societal violence. But the second I looked at a document about kids or made a search about kids, I was like, oh, I must be on a list now. Rather, they must be watching me now. There's so many people who have a legitimate business reason to contact that person that just because he looked up his name and the employee directory doesn't mean like it would be always impossible to figure out which Chinese national the company is. If that was the case back in the days, how much worse do you think it is today would unthrobbing open AI all these other companies? I think given the geopolitical significance of AI and the conflict between China and the United States, I'm sure there are people inside those companies. I don't know for I don't have evidence, but given the level of severity of these situations, like I don't know how you would prevent it. So let's just say if somebody works over there and they know that there's Chinese nationals that are working and releasing information back, as a whistleblower yourself, what would you tell them? Let's just say they're watching this right now. They know. Like they know that their specific coworker is an actor. Yes. Well, I would encourage them in that situation like they should go talk to the security inside of Anthropic because like Anthropic, I guarantee you would love to find the Chinese spies inside of Anthropic. Tell me why. Why? Because they're engaged with competition with the AI companies in China, right? Like the number one thing that's threatening the valuation of Anthropic, right, is the AI models that are China. So they wouldn't want to know more than anything else. Got it. Last couple of things before we wrap up. Tell me about, you know, we heard about Nicole Shanahan, you know, she was like, "Oh, I was partying at this burning man and all that." What is this with billionaires? Partying at this burning man. What is that all about? Yeah. So burning man is, how did you describe burning man? I've seen the videos though. It's kind of. It's funny. So I was a ranger at burning man. So burning man is an arts festival. It's a self-created city that is built in the Nevada Desert every year. And there's a great documentary called "The Man Will Burn" that's on HBO now. I highly recommend it. It's about the years of COVID when they shut down Burning Man. Because even when the org did not go run Burning Man, the community of Burning Man went and re-created Burning Man in 2021. Did they get arrested? Did they do anything? They did not stop that they were warned. They were warned like you might get arrested on the way in, but no one stopped them. Like 20,000 people showed up. How many people typically show up if it was a non-COVID? It's like 75 to 85,000. Oh, so they still have 20,000 people to show up. Yeah, very impressive. And what is it? It's art. So people build a city. So it's like a crescent-shape city. And people bring large art installations and there's lots of interactive art. So for example, you might have a camp that serves bacon to everyone every morning. So after you've been out dancing all night in your hungry and something salty would be delicious. Imagine walking on the street and someone just gives you some bacon, right? But so both my husband and I, so even before I met my husband. Like this? This is what it looks like? Yeah, looks like that. And that's 75,000 people. 75,000 people. Are they partying? Are they hanging out? Are they talking? It's a huge range of things. So it's everything from like my dad really wants to go and volunteer for their airport. So they run the third largest airport in the state of Nevada for a week. I'm just so many planes coming in and out. And my dad wants to go and like he used to fly small planes. So he like a lot of PJs. But these are money people that are going to this. There's everyday people to go to this too. So this is like a woodstock. How different is it from the woodstock? Woodstock was chaos. There's a lot, there's a for for how decentralized and disorderly this is. There's a lot of order. So like, you know, you have individual camps that might be 50 people who self-govern their community. There's if you notice, there's like very clean streets. Right? So someone goes out there and lays out all those streets and puts streets signs up. And there's porta-potties that get cleaned every day, multiple times a day. So it's going to be dusty. It's like chaotic. It's not it's not going to, you know, Hawaii and going on vacation on the beach. The dust is a very alkaline. So it reacts with your skin. So like you have to like rinse your feet with like vinegar at the end of the day because it'll hurt your skin otherwise. So it's not easy, but it's like really, really fun and interactive. What is it? Business is being done. Deals are being done right. A lot of deals. A lot of deals get done. There's a lot of merges that that happen. After destruction, burning man's orgy dome back in 20. What is the orgy dome? Is that a naked lady in the middle? That is definitely a woman with less, actually, there's a lot of people in there with not very many clothes on. Is this a family friendly? Yeah, I know it's fine. It's so. Go a little bit lower in the story. What happened? Oh, windstorm. How funny. So the orgy dome blew down. Orgy dome serves in route to 8 to 10,000, 7,000 seconds. Exposed sexuality, but after 50 miles per hour of religion, then seven person boarded directors went to work after burning man ended trying to find a replacement for damage, 4,000 square foot structure. Oh my god. 10% of attendees make the right to the orgy dome or the course of a week. You imagine 7,000 people through it through it. What did it say 10% of what the bottom says? 10% of burning men attend these make their way through the orgy dome. Holy shit. Okay, so that's like 7,000 people. So it's kind of like what is the other thing that happens in Palm Springs? There's another one that they do. Coachella. Coachella, right? So Coachella has whaless infrastructure. So like people, I know people who go just because they like building like domes. Like every year they go and they put up a three-storey dome. It's not a concert like Coachella. So some people go just for the music. They like to go and they like to dance. There's people who are artists and they bring their art and present their art. There's some people like my husband's father, he used to run a camp that just fed artists. So his contribution to the playa was it takes a lot of energy to put a part. They'd show up and they'd drive around a little golf cart and they'd hand out free food to the artists as they set up their art. Right, that was his art. And then what's the thing that they do that they burn?
something at the end. So if you pull up the man, so every year they build this, this effigy called the man and they, they lighted on fire as like the last, the second to last event of the thing. This guy. Yeah, they, every year, land fire, they have fireworks, they've explosives, full, full, fire techniques. But you should watch the documentary, it'll do a much better job. I have to go watch it. It's very interesting. It turned out, so I didn't know my husband until I met him in Puerto Rico. So we had both lived in San Francisco, two blocks apart. We had both been Burning Man Rangers, so like the Boy Scouts of Burning Man. So like let's say you go to Burning Man and you have, you've been watching YouTube videos for 10 years, you're very excited about this. You show up, you set up your camp, you walk out on the playa and you see all these fantastical things all day and you come back at 10 PM and you realize you have no idea where your tent is. This is like a real thing that happens. Because of how messed up you are just because of how hard it is to find it. A bunch of other people set their tents up while you're gone, you got distracted. You're actually one street over, who knows, there's a lot of reasons you might not be able to find your tent. It's like 75,000 people's worth of tents, right? So it's, it's, it's, it drugs, sex, exhaustion, maybe didn't eat enough, maybe dehydrated. There's a lot of the reasons that you cannot find your way back to camp. But like the job of the Rangers is like when you've been looking for your tent for two hours and now it's like midnight and you still can't-- My job is to find your camp. My job is to walk around with you and at least make sure you have like a safe place to sleep that night. And is there a fraternity? Is it like a fraternity? Oh my god, I go to the Bernal. I'll see you next year. Is it that kind of a fraternity? So, so people do have like camps that they belong to year after year after year that are like, like, they're like, they're fraternal order. Like they say, I've camped with this camp for a decade. The Rangers are in some ways like that. It's a public service organization. Our way of giving back to the playa is by taking care of other people, you know? Very cool. Yeah. You know, they brought it up. They brought it up. Burning man. This is the first-- I know about Coachella. I know about, you know, back in the days when I was younger, we would go. But the thing that the billionaires that go, the thing that they are famous for are these things called pay to play. So, burning man is supposed to be self-sufficient. Like, the whole point is you bring in your own water, you bring in your own food, Coachella, you can buy your food, right? You can take an Uber and Coachella. So, this is truly a B.Y. Oh, whatever. Yeah, you're going to haul your ass all the way out there. At often, billionaires fly in, they don't drive in. They often have other people who come in earlier and set up all their stuff. And so, there's this question of, is that level of accommodation, is it aligned with like the-- The value. The spirit of burning man. I guess it doesn't, right? Because you don't really do anything. You don't really-- Yeah. You weren't involved in the third part. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I really enjoy this talking to you. And I truly appreciate you making time. Is there anything you want folks to go? Is there an article, site, is there somewhere that can follow you? So, I have a substack. So, there's Francis Sagan on substack. I need to do-- I need to do some form of social media. Understandably, I'm not a big social media person. The-- I think one thing I would leave folks with is if you have kids, the number one thing I can only leave you with is, even if you are skeptical that social media is in some way harmful for your kid, the thing I most hope you take from today is at least go and do a little bit more reading on the dangers of social media for kids. Because I think, oh, there's a lot of parents out there who feel like I have no option but to give my kids a phone. You can still give your kids a phone and be able to provide them with other supports. And so, you know, Jonathan Heitz book, the anxious generation, I think, is a really important read for parents. And just if I can leave folks with a little ray of hope of being like, please look into how your kids use technology. Don't assume it's neutral because we are actively waking up to the consequences of this over the last 10 years. Well, I fully support reading that book. We read it last year and it changed a lot of different patterns in the way of-- we're already very involved with the kids, but it gave you systems. I really like the way he teaches. And I think he's got another book coming out here soon as well. But, friends, thank you so much for your time. I'll be right here. This was Greg. Yes. Take care, everybody. It's magical that craftsmanship is a way of life. For those who move through life differently, from summit decks to nights that never need an occasion, every detail is considered, every step effortless, crafted from fine swayed and built with builder technology designed to move with you. Because true luxury isn't about being noticed, it's about how you feel when you arrive. The FLB icon lover made for the life you've earned.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Mark Zuckerberg holds ultimate control over Facebook due to 60% of voting power, making him the sole decision-maker in the company.
Facebook’s leadership structure is rigid and flat, with employees often reassigned every few months, creating instability and a lack of long-term commitment.
A recent shareholder agreement allows Zuckerberg to cash out tens of billions over eight years while retaining full control, raising concerns about concentrated power and corporate governance.
The company’s response to real-world crises—like ethnic violence in India or the January 6th Capitol riot—was reactive and delayed, with decisions made last-minute by Zuckerberg, undermining transparency and accountability.
Internal research revealed that Facebook’s algorithms and content moderation systems prioritize virality and profit over safety, enabling misinformation and harmful content to spread unchecked.
The platform’s "Crosscheck" protection program gives high-influence figures, including politicians and celebrities, immunity from AI moderation, allowing harmful content to go viral unchecked.
Employees feel pressured to suppress negative emotions, with the company culture discouraging dissent and leading to mental health issues and burnout.
The misuse of AI and platform design for political manipulation, especially in elections and fragile societies, highlights systemic risks and a lack of democratic oversight.
Summary:
Mark Zuckerberg wields unparalleled control over Facebook through a unique voting structure, holding 60% of voting power and allowing him to remain in charge despite massive financial gains. The company’s leadership is stagnant and reactive, with frequent personnel shifts and a culture that discourages dissent, leading to employee burnout and mental health struggles. A controversial shareholder deal enables Zuckerberg to cash out billions over eight years while preserving full control, raising ethical and structural concerns about power concentration.
Internal investigations reveal that Facebook’s algorithms prioritize engagement over safety, enabling misinformation to spread unchecked—especially in vulnerable regions like Myanmar and India. A key issue is the Crosscheck program, which shields high-profile individuals from content moderation, allowing harmful content to go viral. The company's response to real-world crises, such as ethnic violence in India and the January 6 Capitol riot, was delayed and emotionally driven, with decisions made at the last minute by Zuckerberg, undermining accountability.
The platform’s design enables manipulation of public discourse, with political actors and foreign groups weaponizing content to influence elections. Employees face intense pressure to remain positive, creating a toxic environment where dissent is punished. The broader implication is that Facebook’s centralized model lacks democratic oversight, risking societal harm through unchecked influence, misinformation, and the suppression of critical voices.
These systemic flaws highlight the need for more transparent, decentralized, and ethically governed social platforms.
FAQs
Mark Zuckerberg has 60% of the voting power on Facebook, making him the sole decision-maker in the company despite owning only 13.6% of shares. This is due to a structure where A-class and B-class shares carry significantly more voting power than regular shares.
Facebook uses a voting structure where B-class shares give holders 10 times more voting power than A-class shares. This allows Zuckerberg to maintain control even as he sells shares over time, including through a new C-class share structure that gives no voting rights.
The board agreed to a deal allowing Zuckerberg to cash out tens of billions of dollars over eight years while maintaining full control of the company through special voting shares, a move that was previously blocked by shareholders in 2017.
No, Mark Zuckerberg is not leaving California. Reports suggesting he might move due to wealth taxes have been clarified as false, and he remains based near the company headquarters, as confirmed by internal statements.
Critics argue that Facebook’s content moderation is inadequate and inconsistent, with only 300 stories fact-checked monthly globally, allowing misinformation to spread, especially in vulnerable regions like Myanmar and Ethiopia.
Facebook suspended Trump’s account for 24 hours, then extended the ban for at least two years. Critics argue the decision was reactive and that a more thoughtful, systematic approach was needed to prevent violence.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.