Exchange fund + §351 following Treasury's Notice and Rev. Rul. with Cache's Srikanth Narayan
17m 4s
Exchange funds like Cash use Section 351 transactions to contribute concentrated stock positions into ETFs, deferring capital gains by gaining immediate diversified exposure. This structure is grounded in long-standing industry practice and mirrors traditional master-feeder models designed to improve diversification and reduce tracking error. The process does not involve a plan to achieve tax avoidance, as there is no agreement with authorized participants or a deliberate strategy to manipulate portfolio composition. Index sync is used to improve benchmark tracking by onboarding stocks that fill portfolio gaps, but this feature has been paused during regulatory uncertainty to ensure investor protection and compliance. The transaction avoids triggering §852(b)(6) recognition because no redemption or swap agreement exists, and the primary motivation is access to diversified assets, not tax avoidance. Treasury’s notice on 351 and ETF strategies highlights concerns about potential abuse, but the exchange fund model operates transparently and in line with established tax principles. The industry emphasizes clarity, prudence, and professional accountability, advocating for a nuanced, rules-based approach that distinguishes routine, legitimate portfolio construction from abusive practices. With no material change in portfolio structure or intent, the transaction remains non-recognition compliant and aligned with both tax law and investor interests.
As you know, the notice asked about exchange funds that are utilising 351 transactions,
and this is an area that we pioneered if 852b6 were completely repealed.
It wouldn't change the motivation for why we would put it into a 351 transaction.
That's SriKhanth and Ryan, back for the second part of our two-part series on exchange funds.
I'm Brent Sullivan. This is the Albatross. Part one of my conversation with SriKhanth went well
beyond exchange fund basics, so check it out. On September 28th, 2026, Treasury requested comment
from the industry and mentioned exchange funds in the context of Section 351 transfers.
Today, SriKhanth explains how his company, Cash, is getting Treasury up to speed.
Just for folks who are catching up, so we're talking about Section 351. This is seeding an exchange
traded fund. If we look at this from beginning to end, I have a concentrated stock, let's say I'm
an investor, I have a concentrated stock in one position, and then I contribute these shares
to a Cash exchange fund. Cash exchanges a little part of that portfolio for shares of an ETF,
and I wait all the way until the end. I wait seven years for the anti-mixing
board rules to lapse, and then I withdraw cost basis of all of these ETFs and the individual stocks
that you'll receive at the end. It's cumulatively equal to the concentrated stock position that you
put in, so the gain has just been deferred and it has not gone away. The magic of the partnership
wrapper actually is that we can combine assets for mutual benefit, usually greater than the sum of
the parts. This is like the intended utility of a partnership, writ large, not just in like
marketable securities, but in general, that is what a partnership is for. Can you tell us what the
composition of the withdrawn portfolio after seven years, what that looks like? The exchange funds
themselves continue to fundraise every two weeks and onboard stocks that fit the mandate. So,
at any point, we have a mix of single stocks and some portion of it in a broad ETF,
the way that we think about this portfolio is that there is a central balance that is
stabilizing the portfolio and then there is a lot of stocks that sit on top of it that we can
tilt towards which of our mandate that we want. We want to mask that 100 index or benchmark,
we tilt the portfolio towards that particular benchmark by onboarding certain stocks.
So, at the end of seven years, what we give back investors is the representative slice of the
portfolio that roughly matches the risk metrics of the master portfolio. If you could unpack
what how index sync works and maybe start with the problem that it solves.
So, we've got the NASDAQ 100, S&P 500 growth, S&P 500 and each one of them is trying to
build a portfolio that mirrors their respective benchmarks and you're able to get for each one of
these funds, maybe 96% of the way that 94% of the way that 90% of the way there. But the last
few percentage points is where it is almost an impossible chasm to cross and what we do is take
this percentage of the portfolio and contribute back to the ETF so that we fill some of these holes
in the jigsaw puzzle that we're trying to assemble. The way that we think about index sync
is that it is a portfolio management tool that is completely optional. If the stocks that we're getting
are very well diversified, we probably don't even need to rebalance or like take some of the edges
off because it's already tracking within our mandate of this is the risk level that we want,
this is the tracking error, this is the beta, this is the correlation, all of these different
metrics that would constantly tracking. How do you manage that risk while you're trying to
construct that portfolio? It's always going to be pretty choppy. And we use a lot of different
tools to help these portfolios stay at the risk levels that we want. One is this always on risk engine
that is looking at every enrollment that comes in and tells each and and roly how much of their stock
were willing to onboard and when they're willing to onboard it so that importantly it grows in
a smooth manner while keeping the portfolio itself within the risk bounds that we want. The next one
is dynamic pricing. Whenever a certain stock comes in, let's say somebody brings in Costco. Costco
is one that is a large part of the NASA 100 and traditionally that is one that has been on the
hard side for us. So we might say for Costco, we are willing to offer this particular discounted
price for the entirety of the seven years and that helps convert a lot better and fills in
a lot of these holds. On the other side, we have certain stocks that are oversubscribed by hundreds
of 200X capacity and will have a small increase in price there to take in those particular stocks
at a very moderate pace. As your network expands, more people learn about what cash is doing and
that's individuals and advisors, does it make it somehow easier to find the right shares or is
it just always Costco is just always going to be hard to find? It is a network effects business
and the more people that are participating in the network, the better the pool is and every investor
that joins makes like the experience itself better. So the larger the network, the better the
product. As distribution expands, the word of mouth itself preps to further corners of the market
and we get hundreds of different stocks coming in from all parts of America and that's how we
are able to grow so rapidly but also grow in a very balanced manner. In addition to network effect,
the other part of this business is that it's a scale economy business in that once you reach a
certain scale, again, taking in stock becomes a lot easier and you're able to grow the portfolio
and provide this benefit to more folks.
Treasury releases two documents that are near and dear to both of us. Notice 2026-62 talks about
a bunch of ETF strategies that Treasury is interested in and some private fund strategies. They also
release revenue rolling 2026-20 and 2026-20 deals with Section 351 contributions to ETFs and I think
in the notice they mentioned the exchange fund variant. So through one means or another, they're talking
about the thing that we're talking about now. So assets get contributed to an ETF and then the
assets, let's say within a very short amount of time, we're talking about in some cases a matter
of days, weeks or months. So short amount of time, those assets are redeemed in kind through
an authorized participant and through 852 B6, 311B recognition is turned off. So when the assets are
normally contributed or redeemed in kind to an authorized participant, that would be a realization
event. And so what we have is realization without recognition and the recognition is when this thing
hits taxable income. So maybe you can tell us a little bit about how your team read this.
Let's start with the revenue rolling. The revenue rolling targets an ETF that is seeded with assets
that do not fit the ETFs mandate. And shortly thereafter, they work with an A to transition
the portfolio to one that the ETF actually wants. And to do this, they use A52 B6. A52 B is a central
part of like the ETF industry and allows ETFs to rebalance tax efficiently. And in a way,
that's how all index funds work. It is a linchpin to the ETF industry. Here in this particular
use case, a 351 ETF conversion was being used to create a new ETF with assets that the ETF did not
intend to hold. And quickly thereafter, work within an AP to recycle those securities for a portfolio
that it actually wanted. That is the primary, I would say, target of like the revenue rolling. And
that is what the notice also talks about. The revenue rolling is quite clear that this is a
problematic area. And I think there might have been some questions around how exchange funds
have used 351s. That is why there was a notice asking for comments on how exactly this works.
As we've laid out in our letter, A52 B6 itself is in consequential to our structure since the day
that we contribute to the ETF, we're getting the diversified exposure and we're not managing the
portfolio. We don't have any relationship with an AP and there is no agreement to swap out any
part of our portfolios. You hit on the three elements here that I think in the revenue rolling
that are super important, the first thing was that there would be evidence of a plan. And planning,
you know, we work in tax management, you know, we do analysis in tax management, everything is a plan.
So what does this mean? It means a plan to achieve an ends that Congress did not intend.
And there were a couple different evidence
factors as it might point to evidence of a plan. And one of them was the quick turnaround.
And the other thing here is like we have a material change in the portfolio, and we're
doing it quickly. But what you're saying is that the contribution, at least the cash
is making, that the 852 B6 part of it, that those parts don't happen.
Since we don't manage the ETF, we cannot speak to how or when the 852 B6 might be involved.
But what we say is 852 B is not the motivation to make these contributions. And on day one of
many of these ETFs, we're already getting the diversified exposure that we wanted out
of this particular transaction, very similar to how the traditional master field structure
would contribute a diversified portfolio and get a broader diversification.
The way a traditional master field structure works, you aggregate a diversified portfolio
and you contribute 100% of that diversified portfolio into an intermediate fund, which
contributes 100% of that portfolio into the register fund.
So we've got like a couple of different elements here. The one is that there's a precedent
in place, this master feeder structure, where the overall reason for that is to improve
the diversification of the fund and it's to minimize tracking error.
And then the other element here is that what Treasury is interested in, really this 852 B6
in conjunction with 351, that that intersection doesn't actually come into play, because
you're saying, well, we're just using 351 as a change in form.
That's correct. We are contributing diversified portfolios into an ETF that gets more diversified
and that there's a rule that has been around since 97 and has been used widely across
with its fund managers.
If I go from end to end, I started concentrated, I went all the way to the end and I'm withdrawing
this diversified portfolio. Is there a way that this could be considered a step transaction?
When IRS is authorized to look at a transaction beginning to end, collapse all the steps
and say, oh, it looks like you went from concentrated to diversified over time, oh, therefore it's
taxable. Could you just help us understand the nuance?
The step that would be in question is the operative step that we talk about, where as
soon as there's a contribution, it is being transformed into a portfolio that wasn't
really contributed and you're getting a material change in the portfolio itself. If you go
back to the steps before that, those steps have been around in lot for the longest time.
I would say I'm not a tax lawyer, but they have been part of the code itself and what
industry is adopted.
The code is written in a certain way such that the transaction's qualify for non-recognition
for very specific purposes. In the first transaction would be individual security into
partnership, that's section 721, that is like long established, that's really not treasury
specific interest here. Then the next transaction would be contributing that small slice to a
new ETF. Again, 351A is what we're talking about now. Again, that alone is also not treasury
specific interest. Treasury is interested in the overlap between 351A and 852B6.
If 852B6 were completely repealed, it wouldn't change the motivation for why we would put
it into a 351 transaction. What we're getting is an aggregation of these diversified portfolios
through this 351 transaction and access to all of these jigs or pieces that were enabled
access through organic means. Got it. Okay, I really like that. You can take away 852B6.
For our purposes, it's actually not relevant. We want access to the broad investor base.
The one other thing that's changed is you've paused index sync and I'm curious about why
as you know, the notice asked about exchange funds that are utilizing 351 transactions
and this is an area that we pioneered. So we didn't want to continue doing index sync
while there was some ambiguity or clarifications that the treasury wanted. And ultimately,
we are responsible to our investors and we want to be prudent stewards of our capital,
prudent stewards of their capital. Before we launched indexing itself, we worked with
multiple law firms and studied what other exchange funds have done and how we could
structure something similar. It took about 18 months. We got a lot of opinion letters
and our council has written and explained how all of this works in their critical comments
as well. The way that we think about it is this is squarely within what all the other
exchange funds have done. This is long-standing practice among the exchange fund industry,
but we want there to be a lot of clarity and we've offered to talk to the treasury about
this. Yeah, I think investors really appreciate
clarity, at least the asset managers and the advisors that I speak with are very keen
to follow the rules and they just want to know specifically what the rules are. And so,
if there's anything, if there's any request for an industry to treasury, it's clarity
really helps. And if there are questions that industry can answer, then I think treasury
or at least now is the time to try to fill them in and then hopefully there's a back and
forth behind the scenes to try to figure out what the least disruptive way is to capture
abusive behavior and not routine behavior. Definitely, I agree with that. It's an interesting
space and we just want to be thoughtful. And you said you said the nerdiest phrase ever
which I use all the time, which is that we want to be prudent stewards of capital. It's
so boring, snooze-fest, but it's so true. Professional accountability is what this entire
industry relies on. Definitely. That's part two of two with Sri Kanta Ryan founder of Cash.
And if you like this kind of thing, join us at bassist point Seattle, a mini conference
on November 18th from 3 to 6 p.m. at Stoop Brewing in Capitol Hill, Seattle. The Albatross
is written and produced by me, Fred Sullivan, original music is by Paul Roberts. This is
not investment tax or legal advice. Head on over to taxalphainsider.com for more about
risk and tax management and about recent developments in industry and policy. See you next time.
[BLANK_AUDIO]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Exchange funds use Section 351 transactions to contribute concentrated portfolios into ETFs, deferring capital gains by obtaining diversified exposure without immediate recognition.
The structure mirrors traditional master-feeder models, where diversification is achieved through aggregation, not through manipulation of tax rules.
Index sync enhances benchmark tracking by adding underrepresented stocks to the portfolio, filling gaps in portfolio diversification and improving tracking error.
The transaction avoids triggering tax recognition under §852(b)(6) because no agreement exists with authorized participants to swap or redeem assets, and portfolio changes are organic, not planned.
Treasury’s notice on exchange funds and 351 transactions raises concerns about potential abuse, but Cash argues this is not a step transaction or tax avoidance scheme.
The industry emphasizes clarity and prudence, pausing index sync during regulatory uncertainty to protect investor capital and demonstrate compliance.
Unlike revenue rolling, which involves rapid portfolio transitions via 852(b)(6), exchange funds rely solely on 351 for diversification and do not use it as a tax-avoidance tool.
The long-standing practice of using 351 in exchange funds aligns with established tax precedent and industry norms, and removal of §852(b)(6) would not alter the legitimate business motivation.
Summary:
Exchange funds like Cash use Section 351 transactions to contribute concentrated stock positions into ETFs, deferring capital gains by gaining immediate diversified exposure. This structure is grounded in long-standing industry practice and mirrors traditional master-feeder models designed to improve diversification and reduce tracking error. The process does not involve a plan to achieve tax avoidance, as there is no agreement with authorized participants or a deliberate strategy to manipulate portfolio composition.
Index sync is used to improve benchmark tracking by onboarding stocks that fill portfolio gaps, but this feature has been paused during regulatory uncertainty to ensure investor protection and compliance. The transaction avoids triggering §852(b)(6) recognition because no redemption or swap agreement exists, and the primary motivation is access to diversified assets, not tax avoidance. Treasury’s notice on 351 and ETF strategies highlights concerns about potential abuse, but the exchange fund model operates transparently and in line with established tax principles.
The industry emphasizes clarity, prudence, and professional accountability, advocating for a nuanced, rules-based approach that distinguishes routine, legitimate portfolio construction from abusive practices. With no material change in portfolio structure or intent, the transaction remains non-recognition compliant and aligned with both tax law and investor interests.
FAQs
The 351 transaction allows investors to contribute concentrated stock positions to an exchange fund, which then converts them into a diversified portfolio of ETFs and individual stocks, deferring capital gains tax without triggering immediate recognition.
Over seven years, the portfolio transitions from a concentrated stock position to a diversified mix of individual stocks and ETFs, matching the risk profile of the original benchmark while allowing investors to tilt toward specific mandates.
Index sync fills gaps in a portfolio by adding specific stocks to better match a benchmark. It ensures the portfolio tracks the index with minimal tracking error by dynamically adjusting stock allocations based on market needs.
No, the contribution to an ETF via 351 is not a taxable event, as long as there is no plan to quickly restructure the portfolio through mechanisms like 852B6, which would create realization without recognition.
While the transaction starts with a concentrated position and ends with a diversified one, the IRS would not view it as a step transaction because the key change in portfolio structure occurs at the contribution step, and prior steps are established tax practices.
Cash paused index sync to avoid regulatory ambiguity and to act as a prudent steward of investor capital, ensuring compliance and clarity while awaiting further guidance from the Treasury on exchange fund practices.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.