Go back

Ex-CIA Agent Reveals How To Tell If Someone Is Lying To You

29m 5s

Ex-CIA Agent Reveals How To Tell If Someone Is Lying To You

The conversation explores how to detect deception not through facial microexpressions—proven ineffective in real-world settings—but by observing the consistency between a person’s words and their body language, particularly during feeling questions that activate the creative rather than logical brain. Honest responses are immediate, natural, and emotionally authentic, while lies show hesitation, struggle, and cognitive dissonance. The discussion emphasizes that relationships are fundamentally transactional, meaning both partners must recognize and value what they gain from the relationship to maintain trust and connection. To build deeper understanding, active listening, open-ended questions, and nonverbal awareness—such as tone, pacing, and body language—are essential. When confronted with potential deception, silence is a powerful tool; liars react emotionally and try to deflect, while truthful people remain calm and open. Ultimately, the key to effective communication and relationship health lies in mutual understanding, emotional validation, and the courage to have difficult, honest conversations grounded in shared values—not in spotting lies, but in building trust through transparency.

Transcription

5159 Words, 27383 Characters

English
Welcome to We're Talking. This week XCIA agent Andrew Bustamonte and Communication expert Jefferson Fisher join us for a fascinating conversation about the psychology of Communication how to read people and the subtle signs that can reveal when someone isn't telling the truth How can you tell if someone is lying? There's an idea out there that you can tell if someone's lying just by looking at their face. It's something called Micro expressions. Yes, micro expressions aren't really true. They don't work in the field They work in an interrogation setting because you can control the environment that the person is in But they don't work out on the street. They don't work around the dinner table They don't work when you're on a date because the person isn't being controlled by the environment So you have to use a different strategy to find out if someone's lying to you the strategy that we use is we we that the content of what they say Against the way that they say it. Okay, so one of the tools that we use this as an example is something called feeling questions When you ask somebody a feeling question You're you're talking about feelings. How did you feel when you broke your leg for the first time? How did you feel when you saw your child? How did you feel on your wedding day? How did you feel the day that you got a divorce when you ask a feeling question? It goes into the creative cortex of the brain before it goes into the logical cortex Okay, it's different than if I ask you what's two plus two that goes right to the logical cortex if I say hey Do you remember when you were eight that's the logical cortex when I say how did you feel when it goes right to the Creative cortex which is ten times faster than the logical cortex, okay? So if I ask you a feeling question, I already know you are genuinely responding to my question But if you're trying to lie You're forcing the question through your logical cortex at the same time. Hmm. This is good. This is good So when you ask those feeling questions and you see the struggle on someone's face you see the struggle in their body language and their Trying to sort through like I felt sad, but I don't want to tell you I felt sad I was with another girl, but I don't want to tell you I was with another girl I'd like to more than I liked you, but I've got to find a different way of saying it you can see that Struggled whereas when you ask somebody honestly and they answer honestly Their whole face responds with the emotion they're feeling. I say I see so the key is to almost baseline With a variety of these feeling questions Maybe throw a logic in there one or two and then you hit in with the actual question and you see what the processing time is and the question should be a feeling question correct But you want to see what the processing time is because an honest response to a feeling question requires almost no processing time Okay, it's almost instant in body language and in verbal response, okay, right? Whereas what you're really trying to identify isn't the lie you're not trying to identify if the fact is true or not You're looking for the struggle in the response and then once you see it once that doesn't make them a liar But it shows that they're sensitive to that line of questioning. I see and now you can You can break the pattern with a different question or you can dig into a deeper with a follow-up feelings question And you can really start to hammer them and you can start to look for those signs of Deception we use that with my boys To use that with my sons tonight So does this connect with in the research I saw here that you've talked about all relationships are transactional That seems like that. That's That connects so is that your belief that every relationship ever love Romantic love platonic love Relationships with parents with children your children. It's all transactional Our relationship, Andrew it's transactional. Is it why why does transactional mean that we can't be cool? Why does transactional have to mean we can't actually feel love? It doesn't mean that when you take it through to its logical conclusion things can be transactional and Okay transactional and and Arguably it is the transaction of the relationship that makes it more reliable because when you transact Your natural instinct is to transact in order to get something of superior value in return. Yes, right? So it's this idea that I'm going to invest my time in you because I care about you. Yes But more importantly, it's because you benefit me in some way and it's the benefit that you return to me that keeps me investing in you By bringing it to the forefront by bringing it to the the prefrontal cortex the logical mind Now we can identify that it's happening and we can identify what it is that we value from the relationship Which allows us to optimize the relationship? Okay, well with my wife and I because we both went to the same school of training Now we can both continually optimize our relationship because we can speak It's apparently about the idea of the transaction, right? It doesn't mean we don't love each other If anything it means that we can love each other more because we Objectively know we're getting something from this relationship that we would not get if we didn't have each other So with you and your wife being transparent what's an example of a conversation that you've had where you feel like You're getting superior value and she feels like she's getting superior value. So We just got back from a family trip to veil We all went to veil to see the leaves change. It was one of my few weeks off of the road where I was able to be with the family instead of Traveling away without them and we're up in veil and it's in the mountains in Colorado. It's beautiful My wife is a homebody. So we have a very nice condo and she's staying in the condo and she's drinking her hot tea and she wants to watch Netflix But it's fucking gorgeous outside and the kids my son is a carbon copy of my wife So he's got his hot tea right next to her. I love it. Very British Love it and my daughter is just looking at me like what are we gonna do because I'm not she's not about to sit inside and watch Netflix She wants to go to the pool. She wants to go to the park. She wants to go for a hike. Yes So I take my wife and I'm like we got to go girl. We got to get outside and I fight It's like a struggle to get her put on your hiking boots put on some warm clothes I know you're worried about the time. I know you're worried about what we're gonna eat for dinner. Just trust me Let's get out the door and of course I'm getting my son out the door too 10 minutes after we get to the park Everybody's on cloud nine. Okay, right? Everybody's happy my wife is over the moon. She's in all of the aspen trees. Whatever else It's a great day. We get home at about 7 30 at night We feed the kids real quick and I'm like we should watch a family movie We should it's been a such a great day. You guys wanted to watch a movie earlier. Let's watch a movie now and my wife's like no Bedtime's coming up. We need the kids to go to their go to bed at a normal time So they wake up at a normal time so we can have a good day tomorrow and I fight her and I'm like no it's been a great day like If it's if they go to bed an hour later, that's not gonna be a big deal right She is keeping me From making a mistake that's gonna damage us in the future. Okay. I am getting her to have an experience in the present That she would have otherwise missed and that has always been our chemistry Even in our shadow cell operation She kept me from taking reckless risks and I kept pushing her To find newer and more interesting targets So I push her risk tolerance she pulls back my unnecessary risk taking and that is something that we give each other Nobody has ever been able to pull me back off the brink nobody has ever been able to hold me back from what I want to do And even though I can fight and argue with her and I can I can accuse her of Of you know being a wet blanket and being a party a party pooper and yet all this stuff She she takes that criticism And she already knows it's the right choice. Yes, so then the next morning when everybody wakes up happy and I'm like Shit girl you were right. She's right. I think this is the number one issue with relationships is the inability or partners The inability to have these hard conversations and harder the conversation the higher quality of of the relationship But even that in itself People don't want to have you know, so how do you coach how do you tell the person who Knows they're not getting the benefit in the transaction. They know that satisfaction is low They know they need to have the hard conversation How do you equip them to have that conversation you can't have a hard conversation unless you understand The perception and perspective of the other person There is something that you value about the relationship There is something that they also value about the relationship and there's no guarantee that the two things are the same So if you're coming into a relationship and all you're thinking about is what you value You're missing 50% of the problem you have to look at what they value if you can't understand what they value You have to ask them okay. Why are you in this relationship? What do you value you might be shocked even if you think you know and you ask the question, you might be shocked what they answer. Maybe what they love about you is that you say nice things to them. Maybe what they get out of the relationship is a sense of peace and comfort. My wife swears that she gets better sleep with me in the bed than without me in the bed. I get horrible sleep with that woman in the bed, but it's so valuable to her. How am I going to how am I going to say no? I'll just spend a couple extra hours in bed if I need to, right? But you have to understand what the value is so you can speak to that value in the hard conversation with them. Hey, if you want to continue sleeping with me in the bed, I need you to come out with me more on date nights on Friday. I know it's easy for you to stay home and I know it's easy for you to turn on Netflix and I know it's easy for you to stay in pajamas. But I think you're beautiful in a dress and boots and just let me take you out once a month to start and that would mean a lot to me. Yes. And now she knows exactly how to fulfill my value and she knows that I recognize what she values. I even know she even knows I recognize that she values staying home and watching Netflix, which will do three Fridays a week a month. Yes. Right. But you have to have that hard conversation. When you can do that, the most powerful thing, whether you want to call it motivational or manipulation, when you show somebody you understand their point of view. Yes. They cannot resist. They can't reject it. I am walking away from this conversation with many thoughts, many skills. But I am definitely going to commit to better understand the perception, the perspective of everyone I'm dealing with. So if you're coaching me on how to do that, because I truly want to become a master at this, what should I be doing? Is it literally looking at their body and thinking, what are they feeling in this moment, etc. But what's the checklist that I should be going through? So there's we can get into great complexity if we choose to, but I'll keep it very simple for you, because I would imagine that based on your experience and where you are in your life, you already do the big things already. You have to listen more than you talk. That's a challenge for a lot of people. You have to ask open-ended questions. Because when you ask an open-ended question, you are inviting the person to talk more than just a short simple answer. What's happening is you're giving the other person the impression that they're interesting. Okay. And people love to be interesting. And the more interesting, they feel the more they're willing to share. Yes. So all that time that you're receiving the information, you are actively getting a picture of what that person is. You're building what we call in assessment. You can layer into that assessment, verbal cues, how fast they talk, how loud they talk, what their vocabulary is. You can layer in physical body movements, body language. Are they leaning forward? Are they looking uncomfortable? Are they looking cold? And then you can start to imagine, oh, here's this person. It's the end of the day. And it's a Friday. And I know they have two kids. They must be wondering about their kids. And they, I know they have a long drive to get home. You start really picturing and thinking these things. And then you can validate your ideas by asking an open and a question about the thing that you're assessing. I see. And then do you just allow that rabbit trail to go like you just continually. And is that what you would do with targets? Is you would just sit down and just continue to profile them? Profile the superpower at CIA is not about guns or tech or gadgets. It's about systematizing natural curiosity. Okay. Just naturally finding something curious about the whole world around you. Even when you're sitting across from an extremist Islamic kidnapper, you can still be curious about them. You can still be genuinely curious about why they do what they do, what they eat for breakfast, whether they're going to have for dinner, what's their favorite type of coffee. I see that you're wearing this brand of sandal and not that brand of sandal. You can ask an infinite amount of questions because it doesn't matter what they theologically or ideologically believe at their base between their two ears. They're the same pink computer that runs you. Yes. And it's all about being so naturally, so intentionally curious that you gain what we call informational superiority in the relationship. Hey, Paul. What's up? What is that of this? Caliver. Okay. Gross. See, that reaction right there, we talk about some pretty uncomfortable things on the show, but put an organ on a table and apparently that's where we draw the line. Okay. But why do we have organ meat here? There are actually some of the most nutrient dense parts of the animal yet. We treat them as the part we'd never want to eat. Never really thought about it that way. Do you guys eat at home? We do. I eat them. My boys eat them. My wife eats them. We love them, especially on travel. But I really think about when we're at home and making sure they're getting the nutrients they need because we just don't have a lot of time. But most people aren't suddenly going to start cooking organ meat, which this new brand organized understands. They've started sponsored our show and we've been trying it out. Add it to smoothies, soups, even your coffee. It is easy. So you'll say we don't need to eat this roll of it? Not anymore. Over 200,000 families have tried it already. Get organ nutrition into your family's routine to do it. Just use my code talk for 15% off your first order. Head straight to organise.co/talk. I think when we are in thinking about the conversation that we're going into, a lot of the times we're thinking, okay, is this person going to be lying to me? Could be a spouse. Where were you last night? So in terms of preparing to spot the lie, is there anything that we should be doing, priming ourselves, etc, in the preparation of that? Or is it more so just in the action of what's happening? You see what I mean? Aside from calming yourself, aside from already trying to have this surprise attack, that's what typically goes wrong. Somebody feels like you're walking them into a trap. Then all of a sudden the argument becomes about the trap you set them in. Not about the actual lie that they add. You see that with, with, I mean, really any relationship, spouses, boyfriend, girlfriend, where they set themselves up to lie. They want to catch them in the trap. It's not the great way to do it because then the, then it's like, well, you altered my world. You set a trap for me. How dare you? I can't trust you. And then you've just given them ammunition. So I'd get rid of the surprise. How do you feel about body language in helping with effective communication? Well, let's say you're on a first date. You want your body language to be as open as you can be. If you're somebody who's just like, oh, no, it's really good to, really good to meet you, love to meet you. What does it say? It says everything that you're closed. You know this. Everything else says that you're open. I'm open to new things. I'm open to new conversation. I'm open to a new relationship is as long as the nonverbal matches the verbal. That shows more trust. It shows more security. There's, there's not a learning sign that's going on. So the nonverbal language, your body language is incredibly powerful. And it's the same thing with your tone. You can say the same thing, same words, but it all sounds different depending on your tone. We can say, okay, eight different ways. If we wanted to express eight different emotions, that your tone is, to me, the biggest driver of communication. Yes. And also, this is going to sound like I'm just, this is the Jefferson gas option. No, no, but also something that you do, which is outstanding, I believe, in your communication, is your pace. So remember when Barack Obama was running for president, and what stood out to me was his pace. And I started to look at pacing. And I saw that in terms of, I think words permitted someone correct me if I'm honest, but I think it was something along the lines. If he was, he was at the lowest end of the scale. It's like 120 words per minute. And I noticed that that pacing, what it did is, to me, I interpreted that as he's more confident in what he's saying. And I've noticed that your pacing is on the lower scale. And I believe every word you're saying. You're great because it's all alive. That's great. No. Yeah, that's exactly right. Pace, pace, tone, pace are huge. People don't pay enough attention to that. That all has to do, when you say pace, meaning how fast I spit out words in Texas, we speak pretty slow. Yeah, that's just the way in New York, speak very fast. Come on. One of the most nerve-wracking experiences I ever had was like a New York deli. And oh my gosh, if I didn't know exactly what I wanted, it was, what are you doing get out of here? Yes. Yes. All right. Fair enough. Fair enough, so pacing is probably important. Yeah, big time. And it's not that you have to speak slower all the time. That's not what I'm suggesting. It's when you need to have conversations with importance. If you want to sound really intentional, I really want to feel like I'm somebody in this conversation. I have my feet firmly planted, speak slower. 'Cause you can't do anything with it. If we're talking really, really fast, things will get missed. I think about, and it's the same thing with your nervous system, like you, you've been around people that are always anxious and they talk anxiously, all of us, and you feel anxious. If you're around people who are slow, like there's a reason why you're like being at your grandmother's house. Things move slow. There's not a rush. It's just that sense of comfort. So we look, if there's one thing that the world needs more of, Paul, it's calm energy. Good, clean, calm, energy. The kind of energy that just makes you feel like when you walk in, your burns are lifted. When you can walk in and you feel like you can just be yourself, the person that, when they hear you, they go, "I wanna follow that person." I wanna listen to that person. Because you're not trying to push. You're not trying to shove. You just are. And that's the kind of person that people are naturally drawn to in communication. Yes, yes. Now, you just mentioned something that I have to go back to 'cause the land on my mind is what we're talking about in body language. You mention that the issue is being incongruent in essence. So you could say, "I'm open, but if your arms are crossed, "you're signaling that you're not." Yes, when people are like, "I'm listening." Right, you think they're listening? No, where you're not. So if my arms are crossed, my legs are like this and I'm like, "I'm having a hard time listening." Yeah, yeah. Then that's, I'm being congruent. And that's, that's fair play, right? Exactly. So then my question then is, can you use that in other elements of communication by language, or should I say body language and the verbal, to detect a lie? Look at that. So in essence, how do we spot a liar? Oh, spotting a liar is, I, yeah. If you want to spot a liar, first look at their body positioning. That's, again, it's not 100% science. It's communication, there's nothing that is to it. Love, it is the shift. So a lot of times in a deposition, I might be asking somebody a question. First thing they do is they shift, meaning they're uncomfortable. They haven't moved for the last six questions, but the one question I ask that I know is one that could be, they might try to shift on is the one that they're going to naturally shift their body because they don't really want to answer the question that I'm asking. So I see this, we put the frame by listening. This is in the realm of me as an attorney, trial attorney, asking questions of a witness, typically an adverse witness, meaning they're against me, and we're in a lawsuit I'm asking them questions in a deposition that are under oath. So any answer that they give me, I can use in a court of law. So it's still under oath, even though a jury is not present. How do I spot somebody who's lying? One, typically, is already have the evidence. Same thing in relationship. You might already have the text. You might already have the video, the picture, the whatever. And you're now going to ask them something, and you're going to see them shift. They will also begin to ask questions to your question in a very casual way. I might ask them, you were texting when you were driving, and then they might go texting. You know, there was a simple question. And using a very simple question, they've now tried to use a very simple question back, as if like, yeah, texting the word I used. You know what I'm talking about? It's because they're trying to give themselves more time. That's one way you see it. Or one of the best ways I've seen, if you want to catch a liar, is to use silence. Again, we're going back to the power of the pause, Paul. When somebody says something that is a lie, and you know what to be a lie, liars cannot stand the silence. Because it tells them you're not taking the bait. Liars like fast-talking. They like it. They like to argue a lot. They want to make a big spectacle. Why? Because, or they're smoke, there's typically fire. So if they can make enough smoke, if you can argue enough about it and get you emotionally wrapped in, get you crying, get you yelling, well, then it makes it almost more existing in your head that what they said is actually the truth. In other words, we're arguing so much about it, it has to be true. So when you can just suck all the smoke out, when you can actually be able to use silence. So if you were to ask me something, and I knew it to be a lie. So let's say you told me a lie, and I just responded with nothing. Yeah, I'm just listening to you. Let's say I don't know. Did you go to the So-and-so's dinner on Saturday night, and you did, and you said, and you said no, because you don't make me feel bad. And you go, no, just sit with that for a second. Now all of a sudden, you're gonna feel what? Expose. Yes. You're gonna feel very exposed, so they give you nothing to grab onto. I didn't go to the dinner, I won't. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, well, because, yeah, it's the same. Think of walking out on a plank, on a pirate ship or something. There's nothing else for you to grab onto. You are fully exposed, spotlight on you, because I've given you nothing to grab onto. Often you'll hear a liar, repeat a question back in the term of, oh, you don't, I mean, what you don't think I did. Do you think I did? But why would you think that I did? Because they're trying to get you to share the narrative. Yes. So let's put it in my legal perspective, and I see this with witnesses a lot. There are a lot of people who lie. Paul, I don't know if you know this. He's just think nobody is gonna catch 'em. And I might say you've been texting the day of the accident, and they'll say texting? Like, yeah, he were texting the day of the accident. No, I mean, I don't think I wouldn't text me. I don't, I never text. There's a big cue right there. The never are the always. Anytime somebody says never, always, it's very telling, because they, it's hardly ever true. Anytime you have a never and always and a argument, or you've done it just now, I have an argument about whether they always are never of, I've done it. Like you insert another argument into the conversation. And so typically, what I like to respond with, Paul, for anybody listening is you can say this, say something feels off. So you have that silence, say something, something feels off. Usually, the people who are telling the truth will go, okay, what's going on? Or they don't really mind, why? Because the truth has nothing to hide. They won't get really upset about it. Liars on the other hand have this big emotional reaction, big emotional reaction. They'll take a level two to a level 11. What you don't think, what you think I'm lying? You think I would lie and just have this big, huge thing. People would tell the truth, all from much more confident. Oh, okay, I'll believe what you have for real. Believe whatever you want to think, because they know that the truth doesn't need it. The truth doesn't need an excuse. And so that kind of thing is what's going to keep you. So I like to say something feels off, or I'm going to have to come back to this conversation later. That one really bothers them because they don't like, oh, I got to do this again. I already told my lie. Yeah, yeah. Or you give them an out. You give them a little out and it sounds like this. If you went to the dinner, let's say it's the side you're doing downstate. Like if you went to the dinner, it's okay. You go, yeah, I went to the dinner. I do this with my kids. This is my kids, a lot with their brushing their teeth. My daughter is the worst when it comes to admitting to brushing her teeth. She will both face lies to me. All the time I'll say, do you brush your teeth? She's like, yeah, yes, sir. So, do you brush your teeth? I didn't hear the faucet up there. I still really quietly brush my teeth. I'll say, if you didn't brush your teeth, it's okay. You can still go do it. And she'll go, I need to check my toothbrush. A sick shit is, so that's just me. She needs to go brush your teeth. Oh, guys, so give them the out. I love the silent peace. And what I'm taking away, you tell me if I'm correct in this is that, typically if the person has not lied, they'll be okay sitting with that silence. Exactly. And if you want to hear the full unfiltered stories from today's guest, you can check them out on the We Need To Talk page. Drop a like, leave a comment, and hit subscribe. See you next week. (upbeat music) [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Microexpressions are ineffective for detecting lies in real-life situations like conversations or dates due to lack of environmental control.
  2. The most reliable method to detect deception is by comparing the content of a response with the person’s verbal and physical processing speed, especially through feeling questions that engage the creative cortex.
  3. Honest responses to feeling questions are instant and natural, while lies show struggle, hesitation, and inconsistent body language.
  4. All relationships are transactional—each partner gains value, and understanding mutual values is key to healthy, intentional connections.
  5. A strong relationship is built on open communication, mutual understanding, and the ability to have difficult conversations grounded in shared values.
  6. Nonverbal cues like body language, tone, and pacing are powerful indicators of honesty and emotional state, with congruence between words and behavior being essential.
  7. Liars often avoid silence, use distractions or rephrased questions to deflect, and react emotionally when confronted with doubt.
  8. The most effective approach to detecting deception is not about spotting lies outright, but observing discomfort, inconsistency, and emotional reactions in real-time responses.

Summary:

The conversation explores how to detect deception not through facial microexpressions—proven ineffective in real-world settings—but by observing the consistency between a person’s words and their body language, particularly during feeling questions that activate the creative rather than logical brain. Honest responses are immediate, natural, and emotionally authentic, while lies show hesitation, struggle, and cognitive dissonance. The discussion emphasizes that relationships are fundamentally transactional, meaning both partners must recognize and value what they gain from the relationship to maintain trust and connection.

To build deeper understanding, active listening, open-ended questions, and nonverbal awareness—such as tone, pacing, and body language—are essential. When confronted with potential deception, silence is a powerful tool; liars react emotionally and try to deflect, while truthful people remain calm and open. Ultimately, the key to effective communication and relationship health lies in mutual understanding, emotional validation, and the courage to have difficult, honest conversations grounded in shared values—not in spotting lies, but in building trust through transparency.

FAQs

No, microexpressions are not reliable for detecting lies in real-world situations. They work only in controlled interrogation settings, not in everyday interactions like conversations at home or on a date.

Look for signs of struggle in their response—such as hesitation, difficulty forming words, or inconsistencies in their body language—especially when asked feeling questions that activate the brain’s creative cortex.

Feeling questions (e.g., 'How did you feel when you got married?') go directly to the creative cortex, which responds quickly and naturally. Logical questions (e.g., 'What is two plus two?') go to the logical cortex and are processed more slowly, revealing deception through struggle.

Yes, all relationships are transactional—both partners benefit from the connection. This doesn't mean they lack love, but rather that love is reinforced by mutual value and exchange.

Ask open-ended questions like 'Why are you in this relationship?' to understand their emotional needs and values, which helps build deeper, more balanced communication.

A shift in body position, crossed arms, or sudden avoidance of eye contact may signal discomfort or dishonesty, especially when questioned about a sensitive topic.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.