Speaker 1The last couple of years, we saw more change than in the last 10 years for the asset class. When I got here two years ago, if I were to call a wealth platform or a financial advisor, my call was blocked and I would put on this spam list on their phone. Fast forward 14 months. Now we have hundreds and hundreds of inbound calls. A big problem, which is we have more calls and interest than hours in the day to deal with them. It's been an incredible 180 degrees change, more than what I've ever seen in my career.
Speaker 2I'm Ted Seides, and this is Capital Allocators. My guest on today's show is Peter Mintzberg, CEO of Grayscale, one of the world's largest digital asset managers that was founded in 2013. Peter joined Grayscale two years ago after a career in strategy and M&A at Goldman Sachs, Apollo, and BlackRock. He saw digital assets as the next step in the evolution of traditional finance. Our conversation covers the rapid mainstream adoption of digital assets, Grayscale's transition from its pioneering trusts to a broad ETF platform, and opportunities beyond Bitcoin and Ethereum. We discuss active management in digital assets, the evolution of blockchain applications, and changing regulatory environments. We then turn to Peter's view of what comes next, including the convergence of AI and tokenization, personalized portfolios, and a future where the distinction between liquid and illiquid assets fades away. Please enjoy my conversation with Peter Mintzberg. Peter, great to see you. It's a pleasure. Thank you for having me. Why don't you take me back to your background that led to you coming into this
Speaker 1world? I'm originally from Brazil, grew up there. I have this memory of going to the supermarket with my mom in the morning because the prices were cheaper than in the afternoon. Talk about currency debasement. If I were to connect the dots backwards today, that's probably why I ended up having a career in asset and wealth management. The experience with currency debasement, the experience with hyperinflation, the experience with confiscation of assets by the government was intense. After you had that experience, how did you get involved in finance? My career has been almost entirely in asset and wealth management. I came to Grayscale from Goldman Sachs. Before that, I was at Apollo and BlackRock. I always did strategy and M&A. In that job, you're primarily looking for future tailwinds so you can position the asset manager for growth. That's half of the battle in asset management, finding the currents and positioning the company. Two years or three years ago, it was very clear to me that digital assets was going to be the next wave of growth in asset management. I wanted to be part of it, so I decided to join Grayscale.
Speaker 2Before we jump into that decision, those are big steps. BlackRock, Apollo, Goldman, and strategy. We'd love to hear some of what you did and what you learned.
Speaker 1My last job before coming here was head of M&A and head of strategy for asset and wealth management. It was a combination of. Identifying trends, positioning the asset manager to serve them, then executing on it both organically, in some cases inorganically. When inorganically, the job was to find interesting opportunities and then go execute on that. The biggest difference versus a banker is that I had to live with the results of my work. That gave me more perspective in terms of selecting the deals that I wanted to work on and executing on them.
Speaker 2What were some of the strategy initiatives that you pursued? I've done it all, several
Speaker 1years of it in three big organizations. It ranged from blue sky strategy, which is let's find a business we're not in, get into that and how do we do that, all the way to the more standard corporate strategy planning, what are we going to do next year, what would be the priorities, everything in between. If you ask about strategy and asset management, I've done it all.
Speaker 2What did you find works well in that? What did you see in any of the initiatives you're pursuing? I'll tell you what doesn't
Speaker 1work well and as a result, what I learned from it. The typical ivory tower type of strategy where you sit down and you look at big flows and you project them on the forward and you try to then draw conclusions from it, it sounds nice, but it doesn't work as well as the second approach, which is client-based. More often than not, clients will tell us what they want and what they're missing. That's a better starting point. Then top-down for strategy and asset management.
Speaker 2Take me back a couple of years. You're sitting in this big strategy seat at Goldman. You make the decision that digital assets is the next wave. What was that decision process?
Speaker 1I did not leave traditional finance. I moved to where traditional finance was going. It was clear that the same way you saw transformation in asset and wealth management over time, first with mutual funds that pulled investment vehicles off. Then we saw offering benefits to clients that didn't exist before. Eventually, ETFs came to fore with intraday liquidity, lower fees, transparency. Then we saw private capital with idiosyncratic returns, lower correlation. Digital assets is the next step of that natural evolution of asset and wealth management as opposed to a separate thing.
Speaker 2What did you see in what's happened with the digital asset world over the last couple of years that told you that now is the time? It's been transformation.
Speaker 1It's been a new era. An incredible 180 degrees change, more than what I've ever seen in my career. What's the reason why people are getting more interested in digital assets? First and foremost, it's been a well-performing asset class over the long term. There is volatility. We believe the returns are commensurable with volatility there. That attracts a lot of people as equities forecast today in the mid-single percentage points of returns. Fixed income on a real basis. You're lucky if you have a fixed income. If you're making any money, there's no combination of five and one that gives you the seven that most investors are looking for. People are going up into the right in the risk return curve. Things like illiquids, private and digital assets is part of that movement.
Speaker 2Take me back to Grayscale as a platform. Walk me through the history of the business and where it is today.
Speaker 1Grayscale has been a pioneer in digital assets. The firm has about 13 years of track record. Which I'm. I'm told translates to 100 years in traditional finance. Starting all the way back in 13 with first publicly traded Bitcoin fund, the first publicly traded Ethereum fund a few months later, all the way to more recently, the first ETF that holds multiple tokens, staking ETFs. We have the broadest and largest range of ETFs that offers staking. It's a long history of innovation.
Speaker 2The biggest change over the last couple of years has been this movement. To the ETF. And there was the original Grayscale trust that was the one way wealth advisors could access Bitcoin in particular. What's happened in that transition from a trust to an ETF?
Speaker 1What happened at that point in time was the entry of incredibly large, well-established asset managers into this space. Credible, high quality institutions, which had two effects. One, it created more competition. In a space that Grayscale was basically alone. Second, importantly, it de-risked the asset class because many investors saw these names they've been working with for 20 plus years. They are validating the asset class now. We saw more competition and we saw also more market growth. So the pie got bigger, even though there is more people playing it right now. Where does that stand today? We have been in direct competition with all these large players. Now for over two years, if you were to do a mark to market to this morning, we have the number one market share in every market where we compete on a revenues basis. We have also the highest organic growth rate across the board on this growth products that we have been launching since conversion. We have top of the league table margins. We're doing okay. It's a source of pride for all of us at Grayscale to be competing with this giant, out there and getting these results that we're getting, considering that we have 130 employees.
Speaker 2How did you think about the strategic side of pricing? I guess some of these big players come in and decidedly want to be the low cost provider in the space. You were coming from a position where being the only product, it was more expensive to put it together than it would be in an ETF.
Speaker 1We address pricing in a combination of different ways. You're probably referring more to Bitcoin. and maybe Ethereum as well, with GBTC and ETH. We have a BTC ETF, we have an ETH ETF, we have four ETFs covering Bitcoin and Ethereum. The rationale there is for clients that want tactical exposure to Bitcoin or Ethereum and are more concerned about the size of the ETF, the trading of that ETF, and are not holding that for the long term, we have products for them, the GBTC and ETH products. For clients that want to buy and hold, they are more concerned about the total fees, not as much about liquidity, not as much about size of the ETF. It's a buy and hold strategy, minimizing management fees. We offer BTC and ETH. That has worked incredibly well for us. We reached an AUM level with BTC that was incredibly high. Now it's one of the top performing products across all digital assets, and the same is true with ETH.
Speaker 2What has been changed? Challenging in the transition to the ETF world in the last couple of years? The challenges we had
Speaker 1before were twofold. One was access for clients, two was education. When we converted and Grayscale led the conversion into ETPs or ETFs for digital assets, the access problem was largely solved. The challenge that still exists is education. We've been investing an enormous amount of time. We've done roadshows with hundreds of financial advisors, helping them understand what is this asset class about? What kind of a risk profile the products have? It's not for everybody, given the volatility. Where does it go? Does it make sense? How do you manage the volatility of the portfolio if you incorporate it into your client's book? It's getting better, but it's the type of work that is going to take a long time to establish itself. How
Speaker 2have you thought about the portfolio? What are some of the products that you want to offer beyond Bitcoin and Ethereum?
Speaker 1We have the broadest product platform in digital assets. We've over 40 tokens represented. We believe there are 40 million tokens out there. We've been selective. It's one in a million. Most of them, in our opinion, are not investable. They are not representative of anything we want our clients to put money on. There are interesting tokens out there. We found 40 of them so far. We follow a dual process to identify them. There is a traditional finance type of screening, competitive environment this token is in. What is the management team associated with it? There is also a known chain analytics review. We look at the governance. We look at the tokenomics. We look at the programming language, how differentiated it is. The combination of both leads us to the products we believe are compelling enough to be launched.
Speaker 2If you look at the 40 tokens that you've created products for, walk me through some of the breadth of the projects that they're working on. It's across the board.
Speaker 1We have decentralized AI tokens. We have privacy tokens. We have Bitcoin. Each one of these 40 represent a different ecosystem, a different economic foundation, different trends in the marketplace. You have to double click and understand what you're investing in. That's why clients appreciate working with us as specialists as opposed to a broad based asset manager, because that's all we do. We wake up every day. Day in the morning to think about these things.
Speaker 2As you look at the underlying activity in tokens or the last couple of years with all of the interest in AI, you don't hear as much day to day about everything that's happening in the blockchain ecosystem. We'd love to hear some of what has been happening underneath the covers.
Speaker 1There is a ton happening. For the first time in years, we've seen applications going mainstream, whether it's stable coins, tokenization is picking up. We have exchanges like Hyperliquid. That run on blockchain and are growing fast. We have about 40% of Fortune 500 companies declaring they're actively working on blockchain initiatives to increase efficiency. There is a lot of innovation going on underneath the cover. And there is also things that have been around for a while that are now resurfacing. One example is Zcash. Zcash is a Bitcoin-like product, but with privacy features. As people realize that everything you do on blockchain is public, it calls the question how you get privacy. Let's say you're going to payroll on Bitcoin. Suddenly, all salaries can be public. Not everybody wants that. Zcash has similar features to Bitcoin, constraint supply, a certain number of tokens, but it does have privacy options. We launched Zcash. Zcash ETF, it grew to over $700 million of AUM in a couple of weeks. Even things that have been around now, Zcash has been around for a few years, are resurfacing based on new trends in the marketplace. What are some other examples of things like that that are getting a lot of traction? Hyperliquid is getting a lot of traction. Hyperliquid is a decentralized exchange. If you don't pay attention, you might not know that it runs on blockchain. It grew very fast. They have a lot of money. They had about 11 employees. That got a lot of people's attention. And Hyperliquid is the token that represents the economics of the exchange. Another product we launched recently, and it grew to over $100 million quickly.
Speaker 2How have you thought about delivering the difference between a beta in the space and selection of securities or alpha in the space?
Speaker 1From a portfolio construction or tactics perspective, today the market is primarily index. There are active plays out there. I don't think that the black stone of digital assets has been created yet. It's something we're working hard at Grayscale. We plan on launching our first active products sometime in the next few quarters. We've been making investments. We want to be disciplined and rigorous about it. There is more alpha opportunity today in digital assets than in public equities. It feels like how the stock market used to be, that if you do your research, travel and visit the factory and talk to the CEOs, you can develop a view and create alpha based on that view. That's where digital assets are today. We want to be able to offer that to our clients.
Speaker 2How does the regulatory regime, which we've now had some bottleneck in government towards the Clarity Act, affect what you're doing?
Speaker 1The regulatory regime is critical. We live today in the most favorable regulatory outlook for this asset class ever. It's important to keep perspective on that. Compared to what existed, say, three or four years ago, these are the good times. These are the times where innovation is supported by the environment we're in, where innovation is in the U.S., we're launching products, we're developing the business. It would be better to have the Clarity Act so we can ensure that the current situation is sustainable over the long term. The SEC and the CFTC will do their job in terms of ensuring innovation is happening in the U.S. All the entrepreneurs are supported. And the clients are protected at the same time. Hopefully, this can be codified in a way that gives people more of a sense of sustainability over the long term.
Speaker 2As you put on your strategy hat in this seat, how do you think about where all this heads the next couple of years and how you want to participate in it? All the change we've seen
Speaker 1in the last two or three years, it'll pale in comparison with the next two or three years. We're going to see 20x more change in the next two or three years. The reason for that is. Two big trends that we've seen so far of AI and tokenization, which are still fairly incipient, if you take a big picture perspective, and have been operating almost independently, are now converging. No one knows where this is going to be. The exciting opportunities that come from this convergence are going to be transformative for the industry overall. What does that convergence mean? You think about tokenization. You think about tokenization from one side, which is most assets will be tokenized. What does that mean? It means that assets today that are only investable by a subset of clients become investable by mostly everybody. Second, assets that today are not investable can become investable as well. We might have 40 billion tokens sometime soon once everything becomes tokenized. On the other side, you have AI. AI will help create portfolios. Portfolios of one. If you go to a major warehouse today, more often than not, they're going to risk assess your tolerance and profile. You're going to find yourself in a certain model portfolio. AI will let us build a portfolio for you based on your needs, your plans for the future. It's not going to look like anyone else's portfolio. The idea of this hyper-customization for clients of exposures, the explosion of different types of portfolios, the explosion of different types of investment opportunities, both will come together because there is no way a human being can intermediate this. You're going to see a new set of asset managers coming to fore. We're working hard at Grayscale to be part of that business. Grayscale has been in the business of making things hard to invest investable. We've been in the business of finding compelling investment opportunities in digital assets. That's where the world is going. The market, in a way, is coming to us, not the other way around.
Speaker 2What do you see as next on the horizon of an asset that's been difficult to access that will become accessible through tokenization?
Speaker 1The next is exposure of U.S. equities to international investors in an easy format that is happening. I don't think we have landed on a specific format that will work yet, but while on its way, we're going to see also illiquid exposures that are hard to get out becoming more liquid. This whole topic of liquid versus illiquid is going to disappear. Private credit, private equity, infrastructure. Beyond that, the limit is your imagination. We can't securitize cash flows, people's incomes or buildings. Then there is the combination of all this into portfolios, which is going to be interesting as well.
Speaker 2If you look at it at the asset level, several years ago, there was the beginning of part of a real estate asset would get tokenized. What's happened with some of the tokenization of things that are thought of as illiquid today?
Speaker 1Private health funds did as well. I don't think they took off. They were a little ahead of their time. Now we're starting to see the market moving in that direction. There's still a lot of work to do in terms of providing people access and building the portfolios, education as well, similar to what we have done in ETFs. How do you create
Speaker 2the standardization required to get horizontal scale in one of those verticals?
Speaker 1That is a key challenge of tokenization today because it seems like there's so many different companies launching their own tokens. We're going to see a lot of different companies launching their own tokens. We're going to see something similar to an exchange there where whoever captures liquidity first will win. The others eventually will go away. We're not there yet.
Speaker 2When you're out talking to institutions about the high-level case for digital assets in their portfolio, what are the key points today that are resonating?
Speaker 1Two years ago, it was, why should I touch this? Why should I invest? The question has changed. How should I do it? The question is not as much, should I invest on this? Anymore, but is 0% the right allocation to this? That's the question that we try to answer with
Speaker 2them. So as people are laying out these different options, what are the pluses and minuses of the different ways people can participate?
Speaker 1A lot of people like the ETFs. That's how that business captured tens of billions of dollars so quickly. They like to see their portfolio in one place. First of all, many people don't want the inconvenience of having now a separate login and a separate account in a separate exchange. Financial advisors like the ability of doing planning, seeing the full picture in one place. Tax laws, harvesting, all that stuff becomes easier in a format they're used to. From an exposure perspective, clients would start with Bitcoin. They heard about it. Their friends bought it. Someone in the family bought it. Eventually, they start asking, what's past that? Depends on the investor. We have a subset of our clients that have been with us for 13 years. They bought GBTC. Early, they're sitting on 400X returns. They're more used to the asset class. They are a little bit up and to the right in the risk return curve. Tell me about incipient tokens that have the potential to get market traction over the long term.
Speaker 2Early on, it felt like tokens could go everywhere. In the last couple of years, it's narrowed to financial use cases. What are you seeing in the breadth of ways that tokens are coming both into the financial world and into the financial world? Most of what we do here is related to the financial system.
Speaker 1We like investable tokens because that's the business that we're in. We don't tend to work on tokens that we can't offer to our clients.
Speaker 2When you put on your strategy hat here at Grayscale, what are the initiatives that you're looking to pursue going forward? A big push for us
Speaker 1is active management. What we want to build at is a big build, but we're not doing it. From an Ivory Tower perspective, our clients are asking us for active strategies. We're doing it based on their demand.
Speaker 2How have you built the organization to support the increase in demand?
Speaker 1We have an incredibly lean organization. We're running about 40 different tokens with close to $20 billion of AUM with 130 people. That includes multiple wrappers, multiple channels. We serve from individuals directly. All the way to sovereign wealth funds. We are trying to build a new version of an asset manager that is AI first, where we leverage distribution based on marketing and communications. The key governor of growth for us today is not the ability of the organization to launch products or to scale, it's more the number of hours in the day to push that through the system. How is AI working its way into your operation? We have multiple types of agents running AI for us, the usual suspects. We are automating quite a bit of things. We're careful with compliance and cybersecurity because of the business we're in. We have fully deployed at this point. It's already improving some efficiencies, particularly around operations. It's been helpful on some processes that were manual before. We keep now the humans at the end of the process to triple check everything because we have a fiduciary responsibility and I don't think AI is there yet.
Speaker 2As you now look a couple of years in the seat, what is consistent with what you thought coming in? What's been a little different?
Speaker 1Everything is different. One of the benefits of being in this new asset class is things change every day. There are news literally every two hours. It keeps it intellectually exciting. I tell my team all the time that change is coming to us whether we want it or not, might as well embrace it. What's on the next frontier for Grayscale? Our aspiration is large. We have a dominant position today as a crypto-native index asset manager. We want to build the active side of it and offer clients end-to-end solutions across the return spectrum on digital assets. What would make this a success a couple of years from now? We're fortunate to be in a strong position. We are number one in every market where we compete on a market share of revenues basis. We want to extend that into active. We want to extend our reach internationally. Most of what we do today is domestic US. If we get both right, we're going to be in an even better position than today.
Speaker 2Is it surprising to you that most of it is domestic given your history with hyperinflation and how that's happened in more countries outside of the US? That's how the company grew up.
Speaker 1We
Speaker 2have had so much
Speaker 1demand, so many opportunities in the US, which is still the biggest market in the world, that it has kept us busy. There's no question that there's a ton of opportunity in Latin America, Asia-Pac, and Europe. That's a part of our planning.
Speaker 2Peter, I want to make sure I get a chance to ask you a couple of closing questions. What was your first paid job and what'd you learn from it?
Speaker 1My first paid job, I was 11 or 12, was in a toy store. I was in charge of demonstrating the Rubik's Cube. That was the first wave of the Rubik's Cube in Brazil. I wasn't there to teach people how to solve it. I was there to demonstrate that it could be solved. Interestingly, I was paid in toys, which was the best possible thing as an 11 or 12 years old in a toy store. What'd you take away from it? Since then, I've been working on puzzles. The puzzles get more complicated and multidimensional. They're not three-dimensional anymore. Business is a big puzzle and we need to put the pieces together. That's what I do. What's the best advice you've ever received? Dream big, don't dream small. It's almost the same work to do one versus the other. That came from a private equity investor that sponsored my education, my coming to the US. The context of that is Brazil. I've been working on puzzles. That's what I do. That's what I do.
Speaker 2I'm an engineer. It used to be that getting the
Speaker 1right answer was all about doing the right math, getting to that answer. Over time, not working in engineering, but in business, I learned that sometimes you got to use your intuition and get to the right decision, or at least the most perfect decision you can with the limited data that you have. That is entirely okay. You can't be waiting for the perfect answer all the time. I'm an engineer. It used to be that
Speaker 2getting the right answer was all about doing the right answer. only and should not be relied upon as a basis for investment decisions. Clients of Capital Allocators or podcast guests may maintain positions and securities discussed on this podcast.