Go back

Even Trump Admits His Immigration Crackdown Went Too Far. Why Is It Still Happening?

15m 12s

Even Trump Admits His Immigration Crackdown Went Too Far. Why Is It Still Happening?

Tim Miller from Bullwork shares two harrowing immigration stories to highlight the inhumane treatment of lawful immigrants by the current administration. First, Karen and her family from Venezuela, who entered legally under humanitarian parole, were unlawfully detained after being handcuffed and threatened by immigration agents. Her daughter Charlotte was separated from her and held for 16 days in a detention center with no access to food, medical care, or education. Second, Dr. Anne Lewani, a nurse and professor in San Francisco, was detained despite having a legal work visa and no criminal record, and was transferred across states without transparency—possibly deported or held in Louisiana. Both cases reveal systemic abuse where non-threatening, community-serving individuals are detained instead of being processed fairly. Miller argues that the detention practices violate basic human rights, exploit private prison profits, and contradict American values. He calls on Democrats to demand that all such cases be resolved remotely to prevent custody in abusive detention centers. These stories serve as urgent evidence of policy failure and a call to action for political leaders to end inhumane immigration enforcement.

Transcription

2475 Words, 13819 Characters

English
Hey, everybody. It's Tim Miller from the Bullwork. I've got two more horrific immigration stories. I want to go over with you, in part because I think it's important for them to continue to get attention for their own sake in the hopes that we can try to get these people who have come to the country, followed the rules out of hellhole internment camps. And also, because I think it's important that I can buck up the Democrats in Congress to continue to put pressure on the administration over this. There's a press conference today in D.C. where there were some members as well as some activists out there talking about the importance of following through on what Hispanic voters, I mean, there are a bunch of things, a bunch of reasons why Hispanic voters moved in shocking numbers to the Democrats, but certainly one of them was the way that their communities are being terrorized as administration. And it's important that that not gets pushed down the agenda or pushed off the agenda, given the other stuff that the other items that maybe have bigger constituencies in D.C. So I want to talk about it for a couple of those reasons. And also, because you're going to see people throwing around this. Oh, Donald Trump said we went too far, which was obviously bullshit. But it's like, okay, well, here you go. Here are the examples. They're still going too far. And it's time that the administration be pressured to change how they're treating people that are not the worst of the worst. So here are two stories. First one I want to talk about because of something right here in New Orleans. There is woman named Karen, who has a seven year old daughter named Charlotte, and also husband, the whole family is from Venezuela. They came here through humanitarian, parole in 2024. You know, basically the traditional thing that the shining city on the hill was based on during the regular administration, the idea that people could flee, communists tell holes, and come to our great land of opportunity as long as they're willing to follow the rules or card, and maybe get a little bit of a bite with the American dream. This family wanted that. The family celebrated Charlotte seventh birthday in Disneyland recently. She owes many mouths and stitch and toy stories. She's already embracing American culture. But Nat right now, that young girl is locked away in the Dilly Family Detention Center that we've talked about a lot on this YouTube page. The conditions there are horrible. And the way that this family was treated is unimaginable. It's about two weeks ago now, on the morning of October 26th, Karen dropped Charlotte at school and drove to her place of work. She and her husband both work as Walmart delivery drivers. Important, needed, honorable work, work that I avail myself of here in New Orleans. Her family is active in their church. Karen has never been arrested. Again, they came in on humanitarian parole. This was not an illegal entry. So after she dropped Charlotte at school, she started headed to Walmart. Ice vehicles boxed her in in front and back. She told her lawyers, "I thought they were going to crash into me." Agent shouted at her to open the car. They violently pulled her out of the car and handcuffed her. She was yelling, "My daughter, my daughter, I thought it was a nightmare." Again, even if you're at the view that we should be taking away humanitarian parole from people who are fleeing torture and oppression and privation in the country, in the communist country like Venezuela, why is this necessary? Why is it necessary to handcuff somebody and shackle them and treat them like they are some kind of criminal? After she shouted for her daughter, the agent refused to take her to her daughter at school. She was held in a garage for many hours here in New Orleans. She was allowed one short phone call to her husband around noon. She said the agents threatened her. Told her she would suffer if she was going alone to Dilly. They told her that she should sign some paperwork that would give permission for her daughter to be sent to Dilly as well. Karen was afraid. She didn't know what to do. She wanted to make sure she could at least be with her daughter. She signed the paperwork. Charlotte was brought to her then by the ice agent. Slay to that day, 6 p.m. that night. The two of them were put on a plane. Karen said she was threatened by the officers and that if she did anything wrong or stepped out of line, that she would never be able to see her daughter again until she was grown. They landed at Dilly at 3 a.m. They went 10 hours without any food and now they're at this gross detention center where there's been reports of contaminated food, no schooling, or medical care. There have been at least 60 children held there 100 days or more, which is far past the limit. And now we know this family has been there, what? 16 days. So coming up on that 11, 16, 17 days. Here's a picture of the family one more time. The idea that this little girl needs to be in an internment camp for 16 days rather than in school with her friends is absolutely crazy. If you have the view that I am that they should be allowed to live in this country, then obviously they shouldn't be there. Even if you're of the opposite view, even if you're of the view that this family should be deported, like while their case is being handled, while the paperwork is being handled, what purpose is there for them to be detained in a disgusting detention center? Like we're paying for their detention right now. And we're not paying that much because they're barely getting the sustenance that they need to live. But like we're paying for the guards paying for the contracts. And that's part of why they're doing this because, you know, the prison, the private prison contractors want money. But like the American taxpayers are paying to keep this little girl in her American flag 22 in a detention center. Why? Like let them live their life, let them work at Walmart and do their deliveries, go to church, you know, be with their family. Like and in the end, if Steven Miller's reign of terror means that they have to go back to Venezuela, then deal with it then, you know, like there's no reason to have a militarized response to this family. They're not a danger to anybody. They're serviced to the community here in New Orleans. Okay. They're an important part of the community. And so like the whole thing is disgusting. This message is brought to you by Tempo Meals. The past few weeks have been pretty damn busy. I feel like my whole calendar has been swallowed up by meetings in Mania not to mention all the elections and the election coverage. It's only going to get more intense though as we head to the end of the year. And I just don't have time to do much meal prep. Thankfully, Tempo's kept me fed while everything else piles up. Every meal is perfectly portioned for lunch or dinner. And it's ready in just two minutes. So instead of scrambling to figure out what to eat, selling for that sad desk lunch or grabbing something on the go, I have a real meal ready in no time. They have more than 20 recipes to choose from every week all made with nutrient rich ingredients. So there's plenty of variety and you never get bored. And whatever your health goals are, there's something for you. Tempo offers protein pack meals with more than 30 grams of protein, fiber rich, calorie conscious, gut support, and GLP one smart options. For a limited time, Tempo is offering our listeners 60% off that's 60. Your first box, go to Tempo Meals.com/Bullwerktakes. That's Tempo Meals.com/Bullwerktakes for 60% off your first order. Tempo Meals.com/Bullwerktakes rules and restrictions may apply. You know, the administration doesn't want these stories told. And you know, there's another category of people that just kind of want to paint with a broad brush and act like all the people in these detention centers are, you know, people that were slimming across the Rio Grande or, you know, drug dealers or whatever, the people that were doing crimes, they just weren't caught. And like, it's just not true. Like story after story of the case is this. So people that came legally followed the rules had their status stripped away from them by the government, even though they came the appropriate way. And then we're treated no different than they were MS-13. It's fucking sick. Get this little girl out of the detention and get her into the classroom and get her back in her house so she can sleep in her bed and play with her toys and eat healthy food. Like that is should be the minimum requirement in every country. And when the Democrats take over in January, they should be demanding that everybody that is in a situation like Charlotte and Karen be able to adjudicate their immigration issues from their own home rather than from the concentration camps that we're running. I want to talk about one other story that has gotten a bunch of attention, but I haven't had a chance to talk about it in detail. And that is the story of Dr. Anne Lewani. She is a nurse and professor at the University of San Francisco. She has been in custody now for nearly two months. Also here in Louisiana, she was sent from California to Louisiana, put a picture of her up on the screen here as well. She had a work visa that was applicable here. So she was working legally. In 2013, she had had kind of a complicated [BLANK_AUDIO] ruling where she did receive a final order of removal, but also the immigration judge granted her protection in the form of withholding of removal. So basically she'd overstay the visa in 2013 but the judge granted her a withholding of removal because of dangers back at her home country. She had again a legal work visa here through 2029. She is a community member in good standing in San Francisco, but she is again, in service to the community as a nurse and as a professor. The students at the school have been just outraged and up in arms trying to draw attention to this. I've had several of those students and their family members reach out to me about this case in particular. Outside of the classroom, she continued working on the front lines as a nurse during the COVID-19 pandemic. You know, we talked a lot. There's a lot of praise of the front line workers that were putting themselves at risk particularly in those early days of COVID-19 where we didn't know the nature of the spread. Others kind of left and decided that they wanted to protect their own safety, didn't go into work, totally appropriate. Not Dr. Lonnie, she went in and continued as a nurse during the COVID-19 pandemic. The dean of students at the University of San Francisco School of Nursing said that her absence has been profoundly felt as much of interviews with students talking about how sick they are to think about the fact that she's now been in detention for 20 days, worse in this case. Not only is she in detention here in Louisiana. Again, like why? Why are we paying for this? Why are we doing this? Like a nurse and a professor in San Francisco who is no criminal record is like shackled and then put on a prison plane and sent across the country to Louisiana. Again, the answer is because the private prisons want to have prisoners 'cause that's how they make money. And because the judges in Louisiana are gonna be more amenable to the administration's demands that these people stay in detention than in other districts where their habeas is gonna be more likely to be granted. So that's why. So we've trapped this person, kidnapped her basically and sent her to another state. But I actually have to amend that. Her lawyers aren't 100% sure she's in Louisiana because she was in the database for a while and they watched as she was moved from one detention center to another across the country. Again, the fact that this starts in San Francisco it's something very remiss of the internment camps is reading about Japanese internment and how families are trying to keep up with where the other family members were and they're moved from California, then to Nevada, then down to Mexico. And this is basically what's happened with Dr. Alani she was moved across the country and then now she's disappeared. So I guess it's possible she's been deported back to Africa. It's possible she's in Louisiana and the administration is just not being transparent. They're using this as a way to keep lawyers away from being able to get her habeas rights and get to their client. The administration is going through huge loops, costly loops to keep people who are no threat to their community, who are the opposite, who are attribute and contributing to their communities to keep them in these camps. It is horrible. Dr. Alani should be back in San Francisco teaching and nursing students at USF. Karen and Charlotte should be back with their family here in New Orleans going to work at Walmart, going to school like none of these people are any danger. There is no reason to be keeping any of them detained and it is absolutely incumbent on the politicians that have taken over power to try to get these people their freedom back. 'Cause it's fundamentally un-American that they're being treated. It's inhumane and it does not make any sense across any vector, like privacy, national security, law and order costs, like there's no reason, okay? Except for Steven Miller being an inhumane son of a bitch and the private prison industrial complex needing widgets in their camps so that can make money. It's disgusting. So anyway, please share these stories with your rep, with your senator, it does make a difference and we're gonna be keeping updated on Dr. Alani's story on Charlotte and Karen and on all the other cases we've been covering here in the weeks to come. Appreciate it.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. A family from Venezuela, including a seven-year-old girl named Charlotte, was unlawfully detained for 16 days in the Dilly Family Detention Center after being handcuffed and forcibly taken from their home in New Orleans.
  2. Karen, the mother, was threatened by immigration agents and coerced into signing paperwork allowing her daughter to be sent to detention, despite having no criminal record or illegal entry.
  3. Dr. Anne Lewani, a nurse and professor in San Francisco, has been held in detention for nearly two months, unlawfully transferred across states, and possibly deported, despite having a legal work visa and no criminal history.
  4. Detainees are being held in conditions marked by lack of food, medical care, education, and basic human dignity, with over 60 children held past the 100-day limit.
  5. The administration's policies disproportionately target lawful immigrants and community contributors, with no evidence of safety threats or legal violations.
  6. Private prison contractors profit from detention operations, creating a financial incentive to maintain long-term incarceration, even for non-criminal individuals.
  7. The Democratic Party must demand that immigration hearings be conducted remotely to avoid the use of internment-style detention centers.
  8. These cases highlight systemic inhumanity and a violation of fundamental American values, exposing a political and institutional failure in immigration enforcement.

Summary:

Tim Miller from Bullwork shares two harrowing immigration stories to highlight the inhumane treatment of lawful immigrants by the current administration. First, Karen and her family from Venezuela, who entered legally under humanitarian parole, were unlawfully detained after being handcuffed and threatened by immigration agents. Her daughter Charlotte was separated from her and held for 16 days in a detention center with no access to food, medical care, or education.

Second, Dr. Anne Lewani, a nurse and professor in San Francisco, was detained despite having a legal work visa and no criminal record, and was transferred across states without transparency—possibly deported or held in Louisiana. Both cases reveal systemic abuse where non-threatening, community-serving individuals are detained instead of being processed fairly.

Miller argues that the detention practices violate basic human rights, exploit private prison profits, and contradict American values. He calls on Democrats to demand that all such cases be resolved remotely to prevent custody in abusive detention centers. These stories serve as urgent evidence of policy failure and a call to action for political leaders to end inhumane immigration enforcement.

FAQs

Karen, a Venezuelan immigrant, was unlawfully handcuffed and detained after dropping off her seven-year-old daughter Charlotte at school. She was held in a garage for hours, threatened with deportation if she didn't sign papers, and eventually sent to the Dilly Family Detention Center where Charlotte has been detained for 16 days without proper food, medical care, or schooling.

The family was not involved in any criminal activity and came legally through humanitarian parole. Detaining them for 16 days in a detention center with poor conditions, no access to education or healthcare, and threats of permanent separation from their daughter, violates basic human rights and is contrary to American values of fairness and dignity.

Dr. Anne Lewani, a nurse and professor in San Francisco, has been in immigration detention for nearly two months. She held a legal work visa and was granted protection from removal due to risks in her home country. She was transferred across states and her current location is uncertain, with reports suggesting she may have been deported or is held in Louisiana without transparency.

These individuals are law-abiding, contributing to their communities, and have no criminal record. Their detention appears to be driven by political and financial motives, such as private prison profits and administrative pressure, rather than national security or public safety concerns.

The treatment of families like Karen and Charlotte, and professionals like Dr. Lewani, contradicts core American principles of justice, fairness, and the protection of civil rights. Detaining peaceful, law-abiding immigrants in harsh conditions undermines the promise of opportunity and equal treatment under the law.

The administration should allow these individuals to be adjudicated on their immigration cases from their homes, not in detention centers. Advocacy efforts should push lawmakers to end the use of internment-style detention and ensure access to legal representation and humane treatment.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.