Episode 4: A Bad Angle

Stoy your day with the MSNow Daily Newsletter. Each morning, read sharp insights from the voices you trust catch standout moments from your favorite shows. The second Trump administration has gone to unprecedented lengths to radically transform America. Stay up to speed on our latest podcasts and MSNow events and get fresh perspectives from experts shaping the news. It's everything you love about MSNow, delivered to your inbox. Sign up at MS.Now. [MUSIC] Ladies and gentlemen, I come to you on a mission which is unprecedented in radio broadcasting. A mission which is unprecedented in radio broadcasting. Kind of sounds like melodramatic radio age hyperbole, I know. But the speaker was in fact doing something unusual. We had essentially just been handed the airwaves at NBC, at the National Broadcasting Company, set loose to say whatever she wanted. Now, that was unusual because she didn't work for NBC. She wasn't a reporter or a paid commentator or a politician or even a well-known public figure. And random people don't just get to jump on a national radio broadcast whenever they feel like they have something to say. But the woman behind the mic that day, she was someone who was in a unique and interesting situation. I am the widow of Ernest Lundin, United States Senator for Minnesota, who was killed in an airplane crash on August 31, 1940. The widow of Senator Ernest Lundin, her name was Norma. When Norma Lundin took to the airwaves that Sunday in May 1941, she and her family were very much still in the throes of grief. It hadn't even been a year since her husband had died in that terrible, mysterious plane crash. But that's not exactly what Norma wanted to talk about when she stepped behind the mic that day. What she was there to do really was, as she put it, something unprecedented in radio broadcasting. Only a few days after the husband and father we loved had been laid away. The storm of malice broke. This is the man who, after the grave, had closed on him and he could no longer defend his good name, has been ruthlessly slammed by repeatedly suggesting that Senator Lundin was not a loyal American. This statement is malicious and autotrociously false. In the wake of the plane crash that killed Minnesota, US Senator Ernest Lundin, a scandalous story had begun to unspool about how the Senator was tangled up with a Nazi agent. He was under federal investigation for effectively colluding with a hostile foreign power. These allegations were being reported by crusading journalists, some of them with national reach. And it was a hot story, the worst civilian air crash in US history. A Senator killed three members of the Justice Department on the plane with him killed in the same crash, the cause of the crash totally unclear, reporting on his ties to the Hitler government, which was soon bolstered by legitimately shocking photos that emerged of Senator Lundin standing under a giant swastika banner. In late 1940 and early 1941, the Ernest Lundin story, it started off bad, it took a heart right turn, but then it just kept getting worse and worse all the time with each new revelation. And after about eight months of reading these reports about her deceased husband in the papers, hearing about them on the radio news, normal Lundin decided that she'd had enough. The dead cannot be hurt by vilification. It is those who love the dead and who all the years of their lives will bear his name with pride. They are the ones who feel the force of the dagger driven into the back of the dead. Normal Lundin made her case defending her husband, passionately and directly to the public. She also went right after the journalists who she said were responsible for the smears against him. A pair of Washington colonists had written a two department of Justice agents where on the plane with my husband when it crashed, that they had been assigned to watch him. The whole accusations of this nature are emphatically denied in the letters of the attorney general Jackson and Jay Edgar Hoover. Norma contacted the news networks directly, demanding that they put a gag on any journalist who wanted to talk about her late husband. And sometimes they did. We found correspondence from a vice president at NBC telling normal Lundin that he personally had intervened to delete mentions of Senator Lundin from two different broadcasts. Norma threatened to sue one radio journalist who had reported a story about her late husband. She complained to the radio stations who carried his reporting trying to get him taken off the air. She threatened the sponsors who advertised on the broadcasts in which he appeared. And even beyond going after reporters, Norma denied what was inarguably clear to anyone with eyes. Picture of Senator Ernest Lundin standing under that giant swastika. Norma had an answer for that. She said it was a big misunderstanding. The number of photographs of my husband were taken while he was speaking. One of those photographs was taken at such an angle as to convey the impression that my husband was standing beneath the swastika as a matter of fact. He was standing under the stars and stripes. I have beside me four photographs proving the truth of my statement. It was just a bad angle, just a misunderstanding. Don't believe your lying eyes. But normal Lundin was just getting warmed up because what had really ticked her off was not just the reporting that her husband was being tailed by the FBI or that he was under investigation for being in cooots with a Nazi agent or that he made a practice of standing under a big swastika banner. No, the thing that Norma was really set on denying first and foremost was the allegation that someone other than her husband had been writing his speeches. In you enders have been made that a certain individual wrote my husband's speeches. This is a deliberate falsehood designed to mislead. No one wrote my husband's speeches. He was fully capable of writing his own and he wrote his own. And that right there, that is where normal Lundin slipped up. Because not only did she know for a fact that the allegation was true, that in fact an agent from Hitler's government really had been writing speeches for her senator husband. She knew that it was true and she knew that she herself had just hidden away the evidence that would prove it. That evidence would not stay hidden forever. This is Rachel Maddo Presents Ultra. His initial idea is that he's going to have a US senator spreading Nazi propaganda on the floor of the Senate. The biggest names really were public congressional politics. They all fall under the spell of this sort of Nazi propaganda operation. I'm here on the address deliberately for a meeting of the American First Committee. This group of people, if they were anything first, it was their own political success and careers first. It's really a scheme of genius in some ways. I think we would say evil genius. Episode 4. A Bad Angle After the plane crash that killed her husband, normal Lundin traveled to Washington, DC. The history books remember the senator's widow as a tall, confident, well-spoken woman. She had a taste for flamboyant hats. And less than 48 hours after her husband had died. She, in one of her memorable hats, marched into his Senate office in the US Capitol. Again, this was less than 48 hours after the crash that killed her husband. But when she turned up at his office, she wasn't there to comfort his staff or to speak with his colleagues or collect his personal effects. She didn't want the photos of the kids off his desk. She was looking for something very specific. She told the staff that she wanted the "viric" files. She asked them to give her the "viric" files and she took them away with her. That was all she asked for. Here are historians Nancy Beck Young and Bradley Hart. Normal Lundin directed upon her husband's death to have given to her all the "viric" files. This was a closely guarded sort of set of correspondence that the normal Lundin did not want out in the wider world. The "viric" files. "viric" was not some kind of code word. It was the last name of a guy, a guy named George Sylvester Viric. Senator Ernest Lundin and George Sylvester Viric were old friends. And that "viric" file that the Senator's wife was looking for and that she took away so soon after her husband died, that file contained more than a decade's worth of correspondence between Lundin and Viric. In the immediate wake of her husband's death, normal Lundin had a good reason for wanting that correspondence to never see the light of day. Because George Sylvester Viric was not the kind of person who ought to have been a longstanding close friend and work collaborator with a sitting U.S. Senator. Viric is a spy for the German government, part of his responsibility being cozying up to those in power in U.S. politics to gather as much information as possible and to try to get them to do things that will forstall U.S. entry into the war. That's Viric's portfolio from Germany. George Sylvester Viric was an agent working on behalf of the fascist government in Germany. He was kind of their top banana here. They funneled millions and millions of dollars through him and his various U.S. efforts on behalf of the German government. His very, very well-funded mission in the United States was twofold, to try to keep the United States from getting into World War II, but also to soften us up, to mess with us, to make us just less effective as a country by finding and exploiting what the Germans called "Cernels of Disturbance" in the United States. In 1941 in New York, a big academic study was done of Germany's propaganda efforts here, to try to figure out why the Hitler government was putting so much effort, so much money, into propaganda targeting Americans. What was Hitler trying to do? The study explained that Berlin had charged German agents in the U.S. with finding these "Cernels of Disturbance" which were described as "racial controversies, economic inequalities, petty jealousies in public life, differences of opinion which divide political parties and minority groups, even the frustrated ambitions of discarded politicians." These agents operating in the U.S. were tasked with finding those things and exploiting them here in the interest of what they called "national demoralization." And George Sylvester Vierich was the top German agent in charge of executing that mission in the United States. This was Vierich's life's work. He was very good at it. And he was a high-profile person. His work, his identity, it really wasn't a secret. He basically operated in plain sight in the United States for years. This is a man who is a fairly known quantity. This was in no way a secret. And Lundy must have known that the man he was dealing with was at least pro-German if not actively working on behalf of the German government. One of the reasons Vierich operated so successfully for so long had something to do with the way he did business. He didn't just churn out propaganda and disinformation himself, although he did do plenty of that. His real talent was recruiting sympathetic Americans to do the work for him. Recruiting Americans sometimes with cash, but sometimes just with his charm, with his powers of persuasion. And some Americans didn't need much persuading. They were all in on the cause. George Sylvester Vierich, the man who's been prominent for several years as a Nazi propagandist, had a real man. Do you remember Francis Moran, the leader of the Christian front in Boston? With the thousands and thousands of Nazi propaganda books and leaflets and pamphlets that he disseminated all over Boston and the Northeast. While that material was supplied to Francis Moran by George Sylvester Vierich. And then it was Moran and his chapter of the Christian front that so energetically distributed it. That was classic Vierich, material created by or approved by the Hitler government in Berlin, provided to viciously anti-Semitic groups linked to both street violence against American Jews and also violent armed plots against the US government. Vierich, using kernels of disturbance here in American life, to drive us apart from one another, to drive us apart from our allies, to destabilize life here at home, to scare us, to make fascism seem like it was on the march and on its way here. And maybe we should welcome it. Vierich supplied the Christian front, another violent, ultra-right group, around the country. He supplied high profile and low profile members of the America First Movement, Costa Coast. He operated all over the country in the lead up to America entering World War II. But his biggest, boldest, most successful operation is the one he ran from the seat of American democracy itself. His initial idea is that he's going to have a US Senator spreading Nazi propaganda or anti-war propaganda on the floor of the Senate. When George Vierich was looking for a member of Congress to rope into his new scheme to have the Hitler government advance its work through the US Congress, Senator Ernest Lundin was perhaps an obvious first target for him and in more ways than one. I have never heard of German or a German-born American, with a goal to ask that we help Germany, but red, yellow, brown, black and white races all are expected to die for the British Empire. I warn the American people that we cannot defend America by defending old, decadent and dying empires. Senator Lundin had built his career on being outspoken against the US joining foreign wars. It was something close to famous for his opposition to World War I, that's when he had first gotten to know Vierich. And then in the run up to World War II, he was basically the poster child in the Senate for leaving Germany alone to just do its thing. But Senator Lundin was also someone who always had money on the mind. In his time in the Senate, he was accused of demanding kickbacks from his employees. His employees would get paid a salary by the Senate, but he would then demand that they hand over a portion of that salary back to him. Lundin was someone who was maybe hurting a bit for money and open to questionable sources of financial support. He sees Lundin as an easy mark. The deal that Vierich was offering Senator Lundin, it was a lucrative one. Once Lundin was approached by Vierich, Lundin was all in. Vierich told Lundin that he had a plan by which they could make some pretty serious cash. Vierich would arrange for speeches that he wrote for Lundin to be printed in major American magazines and newspapers. The speeches would run as articles under Lundin's byline as if the Senator had written them himself. And they'd get paid for it. We have a US Senator with a quite literal German agent of influence sitting in his office, writing speeches for him, writing pieces that are paid pieces. And when he speeches are published, he's actually splitting the profits with this German agent of influence. This wasn't just pocket money. This was a whole new second stream of considerable income for the Senator. Vierich wrote speeches and articles for Lundin about how our supposed allies were weak and hypocritical and corrupt and doomed, how American democracy was corrupt and rigged, how the fascist government in Germany was strong, how the United States government should stay out of Germany's way. Vierich would supply this material, supply these speeches to Lundin. Lundin would take them and read them verbatim on the floor of the Senate. The relationship that the two of them come up with is that Vierich will function as speech writer for Lundin. That's a charitable way of putting it. Vierich wrote Lundin's speeches. Lundin might have added a comma or changed the spelling of a word, but Lundin did not do any significant or even mild editing to the prose provided to him by Vierich. What we know is true is that Vierich is receiving much of the material for these speeches from the German embassy itself. Lundin from the archival record seems to be making great use of what Vierich gives him. George Sylvester Vierich as a highly paid, highly ranked agent of Hitler's government, he had his marching orders. He was trying to sow dissension among the American public about the war effort and about our own system of government to spread misinformation that was favorable to Germany and disfavorable to us and our allies. And while he was doing that, he was also weedling his way into the heart of American power. Vierich's plan was working. He did manage to turn a sitting U.S. senator into a paid mouthpiece for a foreign fascist government. But that was only step one. He wanted this propaganda effort to have a broader reach, much broader. So what Vierich has done is he's realized there's a way to gain the American congressional system against itself. This was the early 1940s. There was no Facebook, no Twitter, there was no news on TV. There were newspapers, the radio, newsreels at the movies, and then there was the mail. If you were trying to reach Americans in their homes, if you were trying to influence Americans' opinions and political leanings and fundraise and all the rest of it, you sent the mail. And members of Congress, importantly, were able to do that for free. It's a congressional privilege that's called "franking," which still exists today. And the old-fashioned idea behind it is that members of Congress should easily be able to communicate with their voters back home about what they're doing in Washington. It should literally be free for them to send their constituents mail about any official government business. What George Silvestre Vierich figured out was that he could weaponize that against the American people. What Vierich realizes is that members of Congress have unique privileges relating to the words that they speak on the floor of the House or Senate and to the congressional record itself. He starts asking for huge numbers of these speeches to be printed, which are printed at government expense, of course. Then he actually adds to this and begins asking staffers to provide him with frank envelopes, which can be mailed through the U.S. Postal Service for free. So Vierich would get pro-German speeches from the Hitler government, from the German embassy. Senator Ernest Lundin would then deliver those speeches on the floor of the Senate and to them into the congressional record. Vierich would then order Lundin staff to print off gazillions of copies of those speeches, which would then be sent in prepaid government envelopes to unwitting members of the public. Vierich would stand in Lundin's office and use Lundin's Senate phone to make phone calls to conduct their Nazi business in the United States, disseminating Nazi propaganda to unsuspecting Americans and it's not costing us German Nazis a single rexmark. American tax payers were paying for Nazi propaganda with American tax dollars. Bold! By 1940, George Silvester Vierich and Senator Ernest Lundin were a well-oiled two-man propaganda machine. It went on for years, right up until the day Lundin died with one of Vierich's speeches in his pocket. And for this scheme to be truly successful, Vierich needed his propaganda to go beyond Senator Lundin's reach with his constituents in Minnesota. Vierich needed to reach large numbers of Americans to start turning the tide of public opinion away from US interests and towards Germany. He needed to reach millions of Americans. To reach that kind of scale, he needed more speeches, he needed more prepaid envelopes. He was going to need more senators. He realizes very quickly that one senator isn't enough here. That's next. Start your day with the MS now-daily newsletter. Sharp insights from Voices You Trust, stand out moments from your favorite shows and fresh perspectives from experts shaping the news. The first day of the press conference, the president of the United States, was a stack of smoking-gun-evidence, in the hopes that that secret would follow Senator Lundin to the grave. Normal Lundin is going all spoused proud, and my husband was not a Nazi. Saying things like that to the press. But historians who've studied this have made the very obvious point. How could she have not known his connection to Vierich and the Nazis in that demand for the papers? There is what could be read as an acknowledgement of guilt. Despite her efforts to hide her husband's relationship with Vierich, her removing the documentary evidence from her husband's office right after his death, despite Norma's best efforts, the secret was getting out in the press. And soon, in court. The previous 12 months had shown that the federal government, time and again, was behind the eight-ball when it came to this gathering thread at home from the ultra-right. The plotting and planning of extremists in this country who were inclined toward violence, and in many cases, hooked up with the Hitler government. The Justice Department had failed to convict the members of the Christian front who tried to overthrow the government. They had failed to act on advance warning of explosions at American munitions plants planned as sabotage. Private activist groups operating outside law enforcement were tracing stolen US military weapons and complex violent plots involving homegrown violent fascists with help in financing from Berlin. Amateurs were turning this stuff up, not the authorities. To make up for lost time, to get out from behind the eight-ball, the Attorney General finally decided to appoint a special prosecutor. And to start paying attention to these kinds of threats to our democracy. The prosecutor who was appointed was named William Power Maloney. William Maloney was an experienced federal prosecutor. He'd spent years at the US Attorney's Office in the Southern District of New York, handling high-profile federal cases of fraud and corruption. William Maloney had managed to run up an eye-popping 400-to-nothing record as a prosecutor there. He'd never lost a case. And as soon as he was assigned to this new job by the Attorney General, Maloney began putting the pieces together, starting with Ernest Lundin and George Sylvester Virich, and what sure seemed to be an improper relationship there. Lundin might be dead, but George Sylvester Virich was still out there. And so, newly appointed by the Attorney General, William Power Maloney decided to move quickly. He executed a court-ordered search warrant on an apartment belonging to a DC publicist, the guy who they believed to be Virich's employee in Washington. As far as prosecutors could tell, this DC publicist and Senator Ernest Lundin and Virich the Nazi agent, they'd all been involved together in a scheme to secretly disseminate pro-Nazi disinformation and propaganda. The German agent would provide speeches to Senator Lundin. Lundin would then deliver them on the Senate floor. They'd get tons of copies made. Then the publicist would run logistics on getting those copies mailed out to the public. So, when federal agents raided the publicist's apartment that day, what they expected to find was a bunch of stuff involving Ernest Lundin. They expected to find evidence of that scheme that they knew about. Notes, documents, records of payments, other evidence linking this Nazi agent to Senator Lundin. That's what they were expecting. But what prosecutor William Power Maloney actually found during that raid, it set him back on his heels. Because apparently, it wasn't just this one Senator. This one recently deceased Senator Ernest Lundin, who had been involved. Looking around the publicist's apartment that day in Washington, William Power Maloney took in the site of hundreds of documents and envelopes, bearing the names of all sorts of members of Congress. Republican congressmen Stephen Day of Illinois, Democratic congressmen Martin L. Swini of Ohio, Democratic Senator David Worth Clark of Idaho, Republican congressmen George Tinkam of Massachusetts, Republican congressmen Jacob Thorkelson of Montana, Republican Senator Gerald Nye of North the Coda, it just went on and on. Philips bearing the names of Senator Rush Holt and Senator Burton Wheeler and Congressman Claire Hoffman and all sorts of others. They were all being held in that DC apartment, raided by William Maloney that day. All these sitting members of Congress, from both parties, all of them, Maloney now realized apparent participants in this operation funded and run by the Hitler government to disseminate Nazi propaganda to the American people. How many members of Congress were in on this thing? How far did it go? With the help of his pal, Senator Ernest Lundin, George Sylvester Verick had roped in dozens of sitting members of Congress to help him launder and disseminate Nazi propaganda using the resources of the United States Congress. We have a number of the biggest figures in American politics in this period, men who were truly household names. The biggest names were Republican congressional politics. This turbocharged Verick's operation helped him transform his scheme from a two-man band into kind of an assembly line of Nazi propaganda being pumped out of the US capital and into the mailboxes of unsuspecting Americans from coast to coast. What Verick does is he combines this incredible power of essentially unlimited copies of the congressional record, printed the government expense, envelopes their pre-Frank to get mail to government expense. The American taxpayer in this period is paying for well-meaning Americans to receive Nazi propaganda that's produced by George Sylvester Verick and his allies and being mailed through the US Postal Service and essentially their own cost. I think we would say evil genius, but it's almost something from a James Bond film. The scale of this operation, it kind of takes your breath away. How many Americans were actually receiving Nazi propaganda in their mailboxes as a result of the scheme? We believe it's millions of Americans. Millions of Americans receive pro-Nazi anti-interventionist content in this period. Millions of Americans. The members of Congress who were working with this Nazi agent, they were members of both the Senate and the House. They represented a bunch of different states up and down the political spectrum. They were mostly Republicans, but also some Democrats. But besides their connection to this German foreign agent, they did all have one other thing in common. All of those members of Congress tied up in Verick's scheme. All of them were associated with something called the America First Movement. The American First Committee started up in 1940 as a pressure group to try to stop the United States from getting involved in the Second World War. America First, that tight little patriotic sounding populist slogan, was both a don't get involved in the war rallying cry and a good profile-boosting vehicle for members of Congress who for whatever reason were opposed to Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who was just an electoral juggernaut at the time. In 1940, FDR was running for an unprecedented third term as U.S. President. America First becomes a grab bag of everything anti-Rosevelt. Many of the members of Congress who have been involved with the Verick scandal and tend towards the anti-interventionist, anti-Rosevelt side of the aisle, find themselves as prominent figures in America First. Republicans are just feeling very defeated as if there's nothing that they can do to stop Roosevelt. And I think that for some playing footsie with fascists was a good idea. They thought. This idea that there was American unanimity against the Nazis. This sort of wishful historical nostalgia we have for an era in which Americans were supposedly all on the same page about the need to fight Hitler for the need to pull together to meet this grave global challenge. That is a tidier, happier memory than what is justified by the real history. In reality, a number of the most high-profile America First members of Congress were in cohorts with a paid agent of the Hitler government who was supplying them with propaganda intended not just to keep the U.S. out of World War II, but also to divide Americans along political lines, racial lines, religious lines, class lines, all in the interest of national demoralization. George Verick and the Nazi government were using the America First Movement and America First members of Congress for those ends. If they could advance their career by playing footsie with Nazis and if that meant winnowing away the strength of American democracy, then so be it. In the year following the death of Senator Ernest Lundin, newspaper and radio journalists began to figure out what exactly Lundin had been up to with this German agent, George Verick. Despite the loud protests of the Senator's widow, Norma Lundin, on the radio, her threats to sue reporters into submission, her attempts to gaslight the American people that her husband wasn't really standing in front of the swastika. Despite all of that, the details of her husband's relationship with this Nazi agent, those details began to get out. But the other members of Congress, that band of America firsters who were all in on it too, they were still flying under the radar. No one in the public knew that they too had been aiding and abetting this paid agent of Hitler's government. Not yet. Justice Department prosecutor William Power Maloney had identified the threat. He had begun to identify those who had been involved in the scheme. Thanks to that raid on that DC apartment, he now had the names and literal receipts of the other members of Congress who had been involved. Armed with that information, William Maloney took action. George Silvestre Verick, well-known publicist, has been indicted by a grand jury which pictures him as using congressional francs to send out his material, special prosecutor William Power Maloney. Book of Vyric is one of the most serious menaces to this country. William Power Maloney arrested and indicted George Silvestre Verick. He was criminally charged for his role in the scheme that he ran through Congress, which was a shot across the bow to all the members of Congress who had helped Verick carry out the scheme. It immediately led them to start wondering, were they next? Many of these men began sort of searching their own files trying to find out what their legal exposure might be. Once George Verick was arrested, the members of Congress who had participated in this scheme, they knew that prosecutors were onto them. They knew that William Power Maloney was very likely hot on their trail. So at that point, they had two options. Fess up, give up the game, cooperate with the investigation, or try to burn the whole thing down. They ultimately chose option two. Senator Burton K. Wheeler of Montana, the leader of the America First Committee, has threatened to demand a congressional investigation of the way the Justice Department has been handling the prosecution of Nazi sympathizers. This is a moment of great political danger, I think, for these men. Wheeler used his position as a sitting member of the United States Senate to lobby the Justice Department to fire Maloney. And that is next time. Rachel Maddo presents Ultra, is a production of MSNBC and NBC News. This episode was written by myself, Mike Yarvit's and Kelsey Desiderio. The series is executive produced by myself and Mike Yarvit's and it's produced by Kelsey Desiderio. Our associate producer is Jumeris Perez, archival support from Holly Klokchen, sound designed by Tarek Fuda. Our technical director is Bryson Barnes. Our senior executive producers are Cory Nazo and Laura Connoway. Our web producer is Will Femmea. Madeline Herringer is our head of editorial. Archival radio material is from NBC News via the Library of Congress, which you really should visit. Have you visited it? With additional sound from CBS News. A special thanks to historian Bradley Hart, his excellent, excellent book is called Hitler's American Friends, the Third Reich's supporters in the United States. Highest recommendation, 12 stars out of 10. You can find much more about this series. You can see what we mean about Norma Lundin's hat problem and that just a bad angle photo of her husband all at our website. msnbc.com/ultra Cut B4 sounds like a dynamite record. This 20612 side A from box T41-26 May 18, 1941, 11 toyty to 11.45pm in NBC Blue Network. Mrs. Ernest Lundin speaks and apparently she's speaking in reply to certain statements about her husband made by Walter Winchell in his broadcast. This promises to be good. As President Trump continues implementing his ambitious agenda, follow along with the MSNow newsletter Project 47. You'll get weekly updates and straight to your inbox with expert analysis on the administration's latest actions and how they're affecting the American people. The American people are basically telling the president that they are not okay with any of this. Sign up for the Project 47 newsletter at ms.now/project47.