The Battle of Bull Run (Manassas) marked the first major engagement of the American Civil War and revealed the deep unpreparedness of both sides. With inexperienced troops, poor coordination, and a lack of standardized uniforms, the battle unfolded with confusion and chaos. Union General Irvin McDowell advanced toward the Confederate lines near Manassas, only to face strong resistance along Bull Run Creek. Initial Union gains were quickly reversed when Confederate reinforcements arrived via rail, a critical technological advantage. General Stonewall Jackson’s aggressive leadership and the Confederate defense at Henry Hill turned the tide, leading to a decisive Confederate victory. Though the Union suffered heavy casualties—2,700 total—Confederate losses were lower at around 2,000, highlighting the war’s devastating scale. The battle shattered the notion that the war would be short and easy, demonstrating its long duration and intensity. It also boosted Southern confidence, with Confederate leaders believing they had proven their military superiority. The episode also touches on human-interest details: friendly fire, the tragic death of an 84-year-old woman during the battle, and the ironic fate of Wilmer McLean, who abandoned his home after the battle only to later build a historic house in Appomattox. Overall, Bull Run was a pivotal moment that set the tone for a prolonged and brutal conflict, reshaping military strategies and public perceptions of both sides.
Hi everyone. If you've been injured in an accident, listen up. We have legal professionals
standing by right now to speak with you for free. Get connected to an attorney to find
out how much your case could be worth. Call 800-712-2300.
Pay-to-turny advertisement, dramatization featuring paid actors and spokesperson. 1-800-the-law-two
is not a law firm. Consultations are free. Responsible attorney Kevin Denish, Santa Monica,
California. Participating attorneys listed at 1-800-the-law-two.com/sponsors.
The Civil War was the most important event in American history. That's because it decided
what kind of nation America would be and whether or not the promise of universal liberty would
really be fulfilled. And what decided the outcome of the Civil War was its battles.
Welcome to the Key Battles in the Civil War podcast.
Hello everyone, welcome to this episode on the most important Civil War battles. In the
previous episode, James and I discussed the background of the Civil War, the decades of
slow-boiling conflict, the Cold War between the North and the South, where there were diverging
views on where the future of America would go. Would slavery die a slow natural death?
Or would, as Southerners hope, have constitutional legal protection so that it could remain
in perpetuity in the South? While that conflict was never resolved, so that brings us to the
Civil War, and that brings us to the first battle. So James, can you set us up with what you
deemed to be one of the most important battles of the Civil War?
Sure. We're going to talk about the first major battle of the Civil War, which was the
Battle of Bull Run, or Manassas, as it was called in the South. We'll talk about the two
names a little bit later. Later, of course, it's going to be known as First Bull Run and
First Manassas for the obvious reason that there's going to be another one there later, but
that's in the future. At the beginning of the war, after the firing on Fort Sumter, and after
Confederate states seceded, and you had now 11 states in the Confederacy, both sides were
woefully unprepared for war. I mentioned in the last episode that the whole US Army only had about
16,000 people in it, and most of those were in the West, and then a lot of those ended up
resigning and quitting, basically quitting the Army and joining the Confederate Army.
The United States Navy had only like 90 ships, but only about 40 of those were even serviceable,
usable, and most of those were way off in other parts of the world, and so only about three or
four were actually ready for immediate use against the South. Both sides are going to have a steep
learning curve. Both sides are going to have a lot of preparation to do, and unfortunately not
enough preparation is going to be done at the beginning, as we will see. At the beginning of the war,
the general and chief of the United States Army, the highest ranking general, was a man named
Winfield Scott. If you know anything about US history, you know about Winfield Scott. Basically by
this time, he's an American institution. Everybody knows who he is. He went back as far as the
War of 1812. He had become a general by the end of the War of 1812, so this is almost 50 years
prior to the Civil War. He was a very young general, but nevertheless, he was a general. He had
participated in the infamous Trail of Tears, in which 20,000+ Cherokee and other Eastern Indian
tribes were forced to go west to what is now Oklahoma. Scott was part of that. He wasn't a
decision maker. He was just carrying out orders, and he had been one of the two main generals in
the Mexican-American War. He had led a brilliant amphibious assault, captured the city of Veracruz,
and then marched westward and captured Mexico City, bringing the war to an end. He had run for
president in 1852 as the wig candidate. In fact, he was the very last wig candidate to run for
president. I didn't win, of course, but by the time of the beginning of the Civil War, when Fort
Sumter was fired upon, he was 74 years old. He was a gigantic man. He was about six foot five
in an age when people weren't even quite as tall as they are now, weighed well over 300 pounds.
He was physically very ill, but mentally, he was still all there. And Lincoln said, "Hey,
come up with a plan to win this war." And so he comes up with a plan, and the plan basically
involved strangling the Confederacy to death. He wanted to, number one, get control of the Mississippi,
north to south, have complete control of Mississippi, cutting the Confederacy into. He wanted to
put a blockade around the Confederacy so that supplies couldn't get in, and they couldn't trade
with other countries. And he wanted to capture the major Confederate ports, which it also shut down
imports and trade. And then he said, "Then and only then, if necessary, we'll send troops in to put
down the south." So it was basically like a giant siege. We're going to put the entire Confederacy
under siege. And his critics called it the, or even some that liked it, called it the Anaconda
Plan after the snake that squeezes you to death. And one thing that was Scott, he may have been
really old, but he was very experienced. And he said, "This war might take up to three years,
and this war, it may take 300,000 soldiers." Everybody just laughed and said, "You've got to be
kidding me. We're going to go down there and whip the rebels." The thing is, is that both
Northerners and Southerners had a complete lack of respect, or at least most did, obviously not everybody,
but they, there was a lack of respect for the other side. You know, the, the Southern culture had
always been a martial culture. We're fighting, dueling was popular, and people rode horses a lot,
and they hunted, and all that. And so everybody knew how to fire a gun. Because of this, the Southerners
thought that one Southern soldier was worth at least three Yankees, if not more. And you know,
the Yankees, they're just a bunch of desk clerks and storekeepers and things like that.
And the Northerners tended to think of Southerners as ignorant and just a bunch of dirt farmers for
the most part. So both sides thought they would just march in and just whip up on the other side,
and the war is going to end. Scott said, "No, that's not going to happen." And it turned out Scott
was right. In fact, he didn't even know the half of it. So both sides very quickly tried to
assemble armies. They, well, okay, I don't know if this is the time to say this, but I'll go ahead and
say this. Today, like if we, let's say, think about World War II, when, when we had World War II,
they recruited the US government, recruited soldiers, but they came directly into the regular army,
or the regular navy. At the time of the Civil War, you didn't do that. You had state
militias, and then you had volunteer companies. So basically, somebody who's a prominent
local citizen, maybe a powerful, like a mayor of a town, or a prominent lawyer, or businessman,
could just say, "Hey, I'm going to raise a regiment of volunteers." And once they got their
regiment collected, they would become the colonel, the commander of that regiment, and then they
would be designated like the first Ohio, or the second Virginia Regiment, or the 23rd Mississippi,
or whatever. And then they would go wherever the central government wanted them to go to.
But, and a lot of these, we talked about militia companies. Militia companies had existed since,
really, before the Revolutionary War, but by the time the Civil War, they really didn't
hadn't done a lot of fighting. They were social clubs where people went and sat around,
drank beer, and told stories. It's your elks lodge off to war, basically.
Yeah, so the point is, is that the overwhelming majority of these new recruits were completely green,
by green, of course. I mean, they were rookies. They didn't know what they were doing.
But eventually, you have a large number of troops that are marched down to Washington,
and the first, an army, a union army coalesces around Washington, and President Lincoln
selects to be their commander. He selects General Irvin McDowell. McDowell was a West pointer.
He had been educated in the military arts. He had been an army officer for over 20 years,
but he had never commanded troops in combat. He would have been a staff officer or a desk officer.
He was most famous, not so much for knowing how to command troops, but for his prodigious eating
abilities. He just ate and ate and ate, and there was a famous story where one time he was having a
meeting with, or actually had dinner with some of his own staff officers and somebody,
one of the locals brought in a watermelon and put it down in front of him, and all these officers
thought, "Oh, this is great. We're all going to get watermelon for dessert." McDowell cuts it up,
and he eats the entire thing himself, including the seeds and the rice, so he could put it away
the food.
he realized he wasn't stupid though he realized that most of these troops barely even knew how to march
or how to fire a rifle but northern journalists did not realize that and politicians didn't
realize that they didn't these guys knew even less about war than these new recruits or general
McDowell they were demanding that Lincoln send an army they said look they looked at a map and they
said there's Richmond it's 100 miles from Washington just send several thousand guys down there
march him down to Richmond and take it over and that'll be the end of the war and so this cry
develops in the press and among politicians on to Richmond it becomes a rallying cry McDowell
says to President Lincoln he says I need more time to train and he said quote my man and I are green
and have little experience but Lincoln replies you are green it is true but they are green also
you're green alike which you know that's actually a good point the southerners were just as unprepared
as the northerners but so the union sends two armies in northern Virginia the first one the larger
went under McDowell has 35,000 men and their deploy just south of Washington to protect the capital
the other a smaller group of about 18,000 men was sent to the Shenandoah Valley which is 60 miles
to the northwest of McDowell's army it's off to the left as you look at a map it's off to the
I should say west more precisely 18,000 men go to the Shenandoah Valley and they're under a 69-year-old
general Robert Patterson very old man who also was a veteran of the war of 1812 now for our listeners
what I want to do throughout this series is try to do what I call a mental map because
it's very hard to understand what's going on in these battles if you don't have a map in front
of you but I realize a lot of our listeners may not have a map if you're driving your car please
don't pull out a map of Virginia so let's do this visually so the state of Virginia I'm going to
grossly oversimplify it but I'm going to reach back into my math background and I'm going to say it
looks almost like a right triangle okay everybody know what a right triangle is I think we're going
to get 90 degrees in fact if I've got any real math geeks out there it's almost like the five
it's a 512 13 right triangle but anyway take the right triangle and flip it upside down so that the
longest side the hypotenuse is on the bottom the short side is on your right as you're looking at it
and the longer leg of the triangle is left it's slanting down does that make sense so that
there's a point at the top two sides slanting down and the bottom is flat and if you're from
Virginia I apologize I know this it may be an insult to say it my state is a triangle but
that's going to work pretty good for our purposes so Washington DC is near the top point it's a
little bit down the right side so Washington is in let's say the northern part of Virginia it's
actually not part of Virginia but it's it's right at the border there shut into a valley is off to
the left side as you're looking at a map of Virginia where this right triangle that I've imagined
here and it kind of points it goes from southwest to northeast there's two there's the Blue Ridge
Mountains on one side and the Appalachians on the other side between their beautiful valley I've
been there before and it's breathtaking land but it's also a nice avenue for soldiers to march up
from the let's say southwest Virginia and march up and it spits you out at the Potomac River almost
so it's kind of like a like a knife sticking up toward Maryland which stays with the Union we'll
talk more about that next time so opposing Patterson's army in the Shenandoah is 12,000 men under
General Joseph T. Johnston and the Confederate army there's another Confederate army
closer to Washington it's near the town what is now the town of Manassas back then it was a
railroad crossing 20,000 all right so let me say that again so imagine your map just south of
Washington you have 35,000 Union troops under McDowell they are opposed by 20,000 under Beauregard
the hero of Fort Sumter well hero if you're a southerner he was the commander of the troops that
fired on Fort Sumter now he's in Virginia and he's opposing McDowell and then to their left
or to their west you have two more armies a Union army with 18,000 under Patterson and another
army of 12,000 under Joseph T. Johnston all right so hopefully that makes sense to people that are
just listening and not able to if you can look at a map by all means do because it helps a ton but
anyway so let's see what's McDowell going to do oh do you have anything you wanted to add
Scott or any questions of yeah I think that that's a good summary and just one quick thing I'll add
those numbers you gave of the inferior Confederate forces that's a good sample of how battles
like this are going to continue to play out over the war there are the south is numerically inferior
but the way that it can win this war and what some grand strategist understood and what historians
some even argue today that it was conceivable for the south to win was by not giving into a war of
attrition to make Union victory so costly that the Union would become de-spirited and give up
so it wasn't they just had to simply not sacrifice too many soldiers and by doing so they could
win they wouldn't go north they wouldn't march on Washington nothing like that but make the loss
is so unbearable that it simply couldn't continue sort of a way the Afghans would take out the
British in the 19th century and one other thing to your point on how inexperienced people were and
how private gentlemen would raise up these militias this goes back to our presidential fight club
where we had all these presidents of the 19th century who were generals they were colonels they
had very high military ranks but they never had any battlefield experience we can't scratch our
heads well I did at least and this is the system they came out of they might be these
part of this machine politics or this old boys club where yes you're an officer but it was the
equivalent of being a at the Elk's lodge and this is also a period when the Second Amendment we
understand it to be in the right to bear arms but equally important Second Amendment is to form a
well-regulated militia nowadays the militia duties are mostly rolled up in the National Guard
and we think of militiamen today as kind of these kooky guys out in the woods and you know not kind of
in the borderlands of what's legal but back then the militia was still this I guess you could say
ragtag assemblage and it wasn't systematized the way that the National Guard does today so that's
a good overview in the description I just wanted to underline that yeah absolutely let me also just
piggyback on what you said I didn't include that in the notes but I should have you were absolutely
right to say that the south just they didn't have to necessarily win win they certainly didn't have
to conquer the north they didn't have to take over one northern state a tie goes to the Confederacy
the Confederacy all they had to do was stop the union from taking over a ton of their territory
and killing their armies and just wear down the north and get north to the point where they were
ready to give up and that almost happens a few times they're drastically outnumbered the the
northern armies have way more guys they have the north has more industrial capacity better technology
the military leadership is about equal originally in the east at least the south has an edge
but the the southerners very much looked on the americans in the american revolutionary war as an
example i mean think about the revolutionary war the british empire had the most powerful navy
in the world they had one of the most powerful armies they had even more of an overwhelming
advantage over the colonial then the north had over the south but and yet they won because they
just made the british sick of it they wore they dragged it out and the british just couldn't
defeat them so that was the inspiration for the south definitely yeah and there you could point
to examples as a student of history of fabian maximus fabius maximus i forget which one going head
to head with Hannibal of Carthage he just fights this war of attrition are Vietnam war you know exactly
if you can win this war of attrition if you can stretch out supply lines too far as you can demoralize
your better equipped better armed opponent why couldn't happen is the operational logic they had
all right so let's see how this battle comes about mcdowell takes his 35,000 soldiers and he starts
marching them toward boreguards army of 20,000 and his goal was to cut the crucial railroad junction
at manassas and then march on to Richmond on to Richmond right so boreguard sees this force coming
he realizes he's way outnumbered so he backs up he makes a strategic retreat and he goes back
to manassas and there he could protect the railroad and the road to Richmond manassas is only
25 or 30 miles southwest of Washington so they're very very close in fact in some ways today the
town of manassas that's grown up is kind of a suburb of Washington so boreguard finds a really good
[BLANK_AUDIO]
position, there's a creek called Bull Run. That's where the name is going to come from.
So Bull regard deploys this army of 20,000 along a six mile wide line right behind Bull Run.
And if you think of this, I just want to draw, Bull Run is going roughly east to west or west to east.
And so think of the Northerners coming down from the north. If you have a mental map,
they're coming down from the top of the map and they're going to hit this creek
and then the Confederates are behind it. A body of water is always a good defensive position
because obviously the other side can't get to you until they across this water.
And it makes them very vulnerable when they do that.
Now Bull regard realizes that he is outnumbered.
And so he sends a telegram to Joseph Johnston, who as we mentioned earlier was in the Shenandoah Valley off to the west.
And he said, "Please send reinforcements at once."
The Union General that was opposing Johnston in the valley, the Shenandoah Valley was, as I mentioned,
the Union General was Robert Patterson, but his job was to prevent Johnston from escaping.
It's Johnston with a tea, by the way. So let's see if that happens.
Now, a lot of the funny thing about this battle, it's not funny, Ha Ha funny, but it's ironic,
is that a lot of Washington's high society, so politicians and other wealthy people,
they go out to watch the battle. They take picnic baskets, they take champagne.
They're going to sit there and they're going to watch the blue coats whip up on the rebels,
or at least they think, like it's a ballgame or something.
McDowell, he gets pretty close to Bull Run Creek and he sends one division.
I'll talk about what a division is in a minute. For now, it's just one part of his army.
He sends it on his left, which is on our mental map. It's on the right-hand side.
It's the east. He sends a division to probe the Confederate defenses near Blackburns Ford,
which is one way to cross the river, one place where you can cross it.
It's on the Confederate right, the east side, the battlefield, as I mentioned.
But they get driven back. They were repulsed by a Confederate brigade under James Longstreet.
And I just can't resist adding that one of Longstreet's, we're going to talk a lot about Longstreet in the future.
But one of his subordinates was a man named Colonel Jubal Early.
My great, great, great, great grandfather. No, I'm just kidding. There's no relation.
My personal favorite general, Jubal Early. We'll talk about him too later.
McDowell decides, "Well, I can't get across there. They're too strong, so I'm going to go the other way."
So he's going to send some group around the other side.
Meanwhile, in the Shenandoah Valley, Joseph Johnston's army slips away.
Patterson lets them get away. And they board rail cars headed for Manassas.
So they're going to get there pretty quickly because they're not just marching, they're riding a train.
And this is kind of interesting because this is the first time that troops were rushed to a battle by rail.
And I think this is ironic because the North had way, way more railroad mileage.
And yet the South is the first one to take advantage of this relatively new technology to get the soldiers from one place to another really quickly.
So Johnston's, Johnston's 12,000 are going to join Beauregard's 20,000 making 32,000, so the two forces will be roughly equal.
Hey everyone, Scott here. We're going to take a very short break for a word from our sponsors.
Christmas is coming fast. If you're still trying to figure out what to get the people you love, crosswalk can help.
The crosswalk holiday gift guide is full of gifts that point back to Jesus.
There are devotionals, bibles, books, kids' gifts, and handmade finds for dads, moms, kids, teams, and even your pastor.
Give something that lasts beyond the wrapping paper. Visit crosswalk.com/giftguide today.
Hey listeners, it's Kelly from Life Audio. We know life gets busy, and sometimes it's easy for your faith to get pushed to the side.
That's why we created the Good Word, a free weekly newsletter designed to give you a moment to slow down, be encouraged, and reconnect with what matters most. God's Word.
Inside you'll find devotionals, guided prayers, podcast recommendations, and other faith-built content we think you'll love.
No ads, no clutter. Just good content to help you stay rooted in God's Word throughout your week.
Sign up for the Good Word today at lifeaudio.com/thegoodword. That's lifeaudio.com/thegoodword.
I'm glad you mentioned that, just kind of as an aside, with a railroad that the Civil War, something people don't realize, was a period of tremendous technological innovation.
We think of World War II with the atomic bomb or fighter jets, but here, like you said, railroads become critical for supply lines, steamships going up and down rivers.
You have air reconnaissance for the first time, with hotter balloons. This is, I would say, the most important thing, canned food.
A logistician would, he would have wepteers for joy a century or two earlier if he could have seen that innovation.
More important than any rifle, any weapon, beating your troops with canned food, that right there is what makes planers we put joy.
Absolutely. Now, I want to take a side note here, kind of an excursus or just kind of step off to the side.
I'm going to discuss a few terms that Scott and I are going to be throwing out a lot. In case, I mean, not all of our listeners are probably big experts on military stuff.
So, real quickly, there's three basic types of units that are going to be used in Civil War combat.
The first is infantry, and that's basically ground troops. It's just men with rifles marching around, shooting each other.
Cavalry, and that is people on horses, horse soldiers, which had been around for a long, long, long time.
It's not going to be around too much longer, just another 50 years or so after the Civil War.
Cavalry is not as important in the Civil War as it used to be. For combat, it is very important for scouting and for reconnaissance.
But we'll talk a little bit about Cavalry as we go along, and then you have artillery, and artillery is just big cannons, are not just not individual cannons, but entire batteries, a battery is a unit of several cannon.
Now, let's also talk about how armies were organized. I'm going to use some of these terms. I'm going to try not to get too much into the nuts and bolts of, okay, so the third Ohio regiment did this in this bubble.
I'm not going to, I don't want to get too nitty gritty, but I do want our listeners to know that the basic unit of an army in the Civil War was a company.
A company was roughly 100 men, commanded by a captain, and I'm going to put an asterisk by all these numbers, and hold on a second, I'll explain why I'm doing that in a minute.
But a company was supposed to have 100 men, and it was commanded by a captain, and then you would put 10 of these companies together, and you'd get what's called a regiment, a regiment had 1000 men theoretically at least, and it was commanded by a colonel.
A brigade would have two to four regiments, that's the next level up, okay, so again, company has 100, put 10 of them together, you get a regiment, then you take two, three, four regiments, and you get a brigade, so it would have two to 4000 men, usually under a Brigadier General, that's a one-star general, and then you would put two or three or four brigades together to be a division, and that would be under a major general, which is a two-star general.
And then later you had bigger units still called core, C-O-R-P-S, like the Marine Corps, and that would be two or three divisions, so 30 to 40 to 50,000 men, and then an army was two or more core, and army was the largest unit, and in the south they were typically commanded by a four-star general, and the north you didn't have, you didn't have any generals higher than two-star until grant is promoted later on, but more on that later.
So the army is the largest unit within an army, let's go back down, so the army is the biggest, then within an army you had two or three core, a core is divided into two or three divisions, or maybe four sometimes, the division has brigades, three or four, brigade has three or four regiments, and a regiment supposedly has 10 companies.
Now, here's the asterisk, these are paper strengths, these are the strengths of the units at the beginning of their formation when they're first founded, and not even always that.
But as we know, when you have, as one general famously said, war means fighting and fighting means killing, so as people got killed off these regiments, and all these units got smaller and smaller, and the army didn't replace them.
Like in, let's say, World War II, Vietnam, if a regiment shrank, then the army would just send more people in to fill in for the ones that had been killed or wounded, but that didn't happen in the Civil War, they preferred to just make brand new regiments.
So by the end of the war you had regiments that started with maybe 900 or a thousand and they ended up with like
200 or 100 so it's just to say somebody had 10 regiments under their command does not automatically mean
Does not automatically mean they had
You know 10,000 people probably a lot less
All right, and then one of the thing on terms
I'm going to use the term union Yankee blue coat and federal. I'm going to use us all
interchangeably because
You just get tired of hearing the same thing union union union. Okay, so
So when I say Yankee, I don't mean that disparagingly
But that's what the southerners tended to call the northerners, but the southerners I'll use Confederate a rebel or gray coat or
Well, there's I don't have another one for that
gray coat because most of the Confederate army were gray uniforms
At least the coat and most of the union war blue coats and then finally
You had volunteers versus regular army as I mentioned before the regular army at the start of the Civil War was 16,000 soldiers
The regular army units are obviously a bunch of those left to go the Confederacy
So let's say I don't know you maybe you had about 10,000 or 11,000
A lot of these had to stay out west, but the ones that actually did come to fight in the Civil War they they kept them all together
So which was probably not a good idea so instead of
You know
Spreading out the the regular army troops so that they could train these new volunteers
They they kept them together as kind of elite units
So most of the units that fought the Civil War were volunteer units and we mentioned that earlier it would just be a bunch of guys
You know like maybe Scott rank Scott ranks is hey, I'm a professor. I'm gonna get together 1,000 of my students
And now I am Colonel Scott rank of the second Kansas volunteer regiment and then it's got survives
Maybe eventually it'll become a general, but I would be the most pathetic fighting force in the entire war
Well, you know you're quick study you might actually surprise yourself. Anyway, so that's just some military terminology that I'll be using throughout this series
Where do you think Scott? Yeah, and
Thank you for that really great breakdown because I still stumble over those terms
One other thing I wanted to mention is that a
Lot of what informs this structure of the military and not just the structure
But a lot of the tactics and strategies that come out has to do with a short Pudgy French man by the name of Napoleon
Napoleon is obviously been dead for a very long time by the time the Civil War happens
But his influence casts a very long shadow among the
Instructors and the military strategists in the United States
That's because what we mentioned earlier is that many of the general officers on both sides of the war
receive their military training at West Point and
You can actually pinpoint the influence to one professor named Mahan
Who was a professor of engineering and the art of war from 1830 to 1871?
Mahan actually studied in France. He knew French. He started Napoleonic clubs in West Point studying French was popular there
And he passed on this fascination to his cadets a lot of that transfers to Lee and we'll see Lee later and
I don't know a lot about the Civil War, but one area
I do know is where Lee kind of falls short in some areas of using Napoleonic tactics in a age where that doesn't always work
But one of the first things Lee does upon assuming command he establishes an army corps modeled on
Napoleon's he creates a cavalry corps and relies on subordinate officers to fight the battles while he
Remains in charge of the overall strategic plan
So this is a very Napoleonic understanding of how to wage battle and
How you put troops in different areas
You defend distant borders and all other sorts of things. So
We'll come back to that theme a lot more when we look more specifically in tactics of battles later on and people
Likely, but that's something that figures into how armies are configured. All right, so look good
Let's go on now to the actual battle itself. We've seen McDowell has marched down from Washington toward the railroad junction at Manassas
He had 35,000 troops as we saw we saw that
Beauregard had 20,000 so way outnumbered he
He spreads them along the South Bank of Bull Run Creek and he calls for reinforcements and Joseph Johnson who was west
Off to the west in the Shenandoah Valley puts a lot of his man pretty much almost all of his men on trains and they start
Heading as fast as they can to bull run
McDowell had sent a little force just a minor of division
To probe the Confederate defenses on the east which if you're still doing the mental map. That's on the right-hand side
You will only single-handedly jumps out and defeats the the blue coats, no, I'm just kidding, but
But James Longstreet general Longstreet and and early in some of his other subordinates push back the federal
So McDowell says no, it's too strong there. So he sends a bunch of his brigades remember brigade is about maybe
two thousand three thousand four two to four thousand let's say he sends them over to the stone bridge
Which is on the Confederate left or the west side of the battle so all the way on the other side of the Confederate line
He says I can't go over on the east so I'll try the west
Their job is to keep the Confederates busy so they don't really do a full-scale attack
They just kind of do what's called a demonstration where you march forward and you shoot a little bit
But you're not really trying to
Push back the enemy and then McDowell sends several other brigades around the Confederate
Left as a flanking maneuver and that's a thing we're gonna see again and again in in Civil War tactics as a flanking maneuver
Whereas instead of hitting your enemy head on which usually results in disaster for the attacker
You try to go around the side and try to get behind them
that way
If it works you have troops in front of and behind your enemy and they'll get surrounded and they'll have to surrender
But these troops were inexperienced as we mentioned all them were they were also exhausted from several days marching
They had marched from Washington and taken forever to get there
They make it to a place called Sudley Springs, which is on the far west of the Confederates and it is behind them
So they do succeed
In starting to get around and to turn the Confederate line
Well a group of Confederates in the middle they learn about this flanking maneuver and they rush to stop them
And they meet at a hill called Matthews hill
And the the Confederates that are there they're trying to stop the advance of these union troops
And they're way outnumbered but they attack
Confederate armies were famous for being very aggressive in general not not all of course
But a lot of them were and so they're not gonna just sit there and wait
They're gonna take the fight to the Yankees so they do and
So a fight breaks out on the left side
Or the west side and both sides rush more forces into the battle lines and one Confederate brigade is led by a man named General Barnard B
And we're you'll see why I mentioned his name in a minute
Uh the Federals ultimately have many more men in Canon
But the rebels hold them for about two hours despite being outnumbered the the
southerners put up a good fight and they're finally reinforced forced to retreat off of the one hill called Matthews hill to another hill called Henry Hill
It's to the east or to the left out on our mental map
It's called that because there's a house on top of it
That was owned by the Henry family surprise surprise
And it looks like
The northerners are winning they've pushed back the southerners that they're they may well succeed in getting around the left side of the
Of the Confederate line and McDowell even rides up among his troops crying victory victory
So it's looking really good um
For the north at this time
Um
Let's go to the afternoon of this is July 21st by the way July 21st 1861. I failed to mention that earlier
The Confederates regroup reform on the backslope of Henry Hill
And they're joined by a brigade under a man named General Thomas Jonathan Jackson
Uh, and he's going to have a really big future uh general Thomas Jackson
Was a west point grad like a lot of generals as we've already mentioned
He had fought in the Mexican War and done very well
He had gone on
State in the army ended up being a professor uh, he got out of the regular army
But he was made a professor at the Virginia military academy and
He was very interesting character. We don't have time to go into all of his personal quirks
But extremely religious man. He saw himself kind of as one of the old testament warriors in the past like a David or
Gideon or somebody like that um
Jackson marches in there with his brigade and their fresh and they have a large number of
And they just
Establish a firm position and General B his troops are all disorganized and they they've retreated from the other hill
He finds Jackson. He tells him general. They're they're beating us back
Jackson calmly replies sir
We will give them the bayonet
and B turns around and he hollers at his troops and he says
There is Jackson standing like a stone wall rally behind the Virginians and that term stone wall becomes
Jackson's nickname and here a legend is born.
Stonewall Jackson.
There you are.
That's a story.
That is one of my favorite stories, yes.
So the Union Army is still back on the first hill that we mentioned, Matthews Hill.
And they need, they're planning to attack the Confederates on the Henry Hill, but they
delay for like two hours that they take their time, they're disorganized.
As we mentioned, they're, they're green, they're rookies.
They finally move to attack the Confederates on Henry Hill, but the attack is piecemeal.
In other words, not everybody attacks at the same time.
One regiment comes up, then another one, then maybe two, but they don't all join together
to attack.
They send eleven cannon crews.
They take up positions on both sides of the Henry House.
The Henry House is on top of Henry Hill and on the top story, or it's a two story house
on the second floor.
There's any four year old widow named Judith Henry, she's lying on her deathbed.
The Union Artillery are decimated by their Confederate counterparts, so the Confederate
cannon are tearing up the Union cannon.
Union infantry move in to try to shore up the Union cannons, but they're driven off by
a Confederate cavalry commander named J.E.B. Stewart.
James, you will, a brown, I believe, Stewart, he's going to have a big future too.
And Confederate infantry finally decide we're going to take those Union cannon and they attack.
Jackson tells his men to yell like furies.
And this is another famous Civil War legend, the rebel yell, the famous rebel yell, which
I'm not going to try to do one, but it was basically from what I've read, it's screaming
like a banshee, just a really high pitched yell which scares the crap out of the Union forces
that hear it.
Union infantry rush in to meet these southerners who are attacking and screaming like
furies.
The fighting goes back and forth.
But as I mentioned, Johnston's army had been sending troops over via rail and they began
to arrive and they, so they're fresh, they're ready to fight.
They joined the Confederate army and they gained the upper hand and they start pushing the
Federals back.
You do have some federal reinforcements arriving, but it's too little and it's too late.
The Confederates are flanking them, in other words, they're getting around their side and
they're pushing them down the hill and the Federals began to retreat.
They retreat very quickly, they cross back over, suddenly forward in the stone bridge and
they bug out and they start heading back to Washington.
The disorganized Confederates chased them and the federal retreat largely turns into a
route.
Now, I always tell my students, I said, you know what a route is, of course, no hands
go up.
So I say, okay, there's two ways to retreat.
One is with your backing up, you are facing your enemy, you're going slowly, you're shooting
as much as you can, that's an organized retreat, you're with your companions.
A route is when you just run for your life, every man for himself, you toss stuff off
to the side and that's exactly what Union soldiers do.
Some of them toss away their gear, they toss away even their guns.
And these civilians, remember how we talked about civilians came down to watch the show?
Oh yeah, champagne and picnic baskets.
Oh yeah, well, it doesn't work out too well.
They start to flee too and they get tangled up with the army and it's just a really big
massive mass, it's a disaster, not now, not all the federal troops panic and run for
their lives.
Some of them do more or less organized retreat, but a lot of them, they run like heck and
they don't stop until they get to Washington.
Jefferson Davis arrives on the field and he urges the army to pursue the Federals, but
the Confederates, as we said, they're just as green as Lincoln had said, they're just
as green as the Federals, they're too disorganized, they're tired, you know, it's hot in Virginia
in July, they're exhausted and they just are not able to pursue very far.
So turns into a major Confederate victory, it looks at first like the Union is winning,
but then the Confederates turn the tide, do in large part to the reinforcements that came
via rail, Joseph Johnson's troops and it turns into an absolute Union disaster.
Yeah, I'd like to see some assessment of this because there's a lot of things I'm curious
about, so what are some resulting consequences that you see some of the main points?
Well, there's several, first of all, the level of the deaths and the casualties and I'll
define what a casualty is in a minute, but just the massive carnage was something that
Americans had never seen before.
It was the bloodiest battle in American history up to that time.
Now let me define what a casualty is for those who are not big experts on military history.
Occasionally is somebody who is either killed, somebody who's wounded, somebody who is captured
or missing and missing just means they probably ran away, they got lost, they might have
crawled off and died and nobody ever found their body.
But the Union casualties totaled 2,700, 2,700 soldiers, 500 killed, 1,000 wounded, 1,200
captured or missing and that 1,200 captured or missing, that's huge.
There were a lot of Union prisoners taken.
Confederate casualties told about 2,000, so less than the Union, they had about 400 killed,
about 1,600 wounded, but only 10 captured or missing.
The Union Army ends up being demoralized, they end up back in Washington and there they're
going to have to regroup and they're going to have to undergo much training.
It's really a baptism of fire and both sides realized that their opponents were determined
to fight and would be no push over.
We talked earlier about how both sides did not really respect the other side but now they
gained some of that respect and they realized the war is going to be much more deadly and
longer than was originally believed.
One example I didn't mention this early but when Lincoln called for 75,000 volunteers on
April 15th of 1861, these were 90-day volunteers.
Everybody thought well we don't need them, 90 days is plenty, we'll go whip the rebs
in 90 days, no problem.
Well guess what, the next group of volunteers he asked for or three year people they realized.
Winfield Scott was right after all and the South seized the battle as a vindication
per secession and proof that their soldiers were superior to the Yankees.
In some ways it inflated the South's, well it's kind of a mixed message.
The South realizes that Yankees are not all a bunch of whims, they're not all a bunch
of pasty face clerks as they used to say and shopkeepers and factory workers who've never
fired a gun but at the same time they did run, they panicked.
We whipped them and so the soldiers in the Confederacy, at least this army, this particular
army, they realized we are better and we can win.
We did the right thing, we didn't get beat.
Everyone's got here, one more brief word from our sponsors.
That is just as an aside from in military history, going back way into the ancient world
through the medieval world, a lot of combat death or casualties don't happen when there's
a melee or the two are meeting in open pitch battle.
When you see a slaughter, when you see a lot of a side killed, it's almost always in this
route when they're fleeing.
An organized retreat will be a fraction of the casualties of a route, but an armchair
tactician might say, "Well, why don't you do it organized?"
Well, tell that to someone in the pitch of battle and gunfire going around, especially
to someone who is not trained, which is the critical element here.
What you mentioned, James, about the feeling of superiority, I found a quote from the
enrichment examiner editorial on September 27, 1861, that talks about this confidence
swelling through the Confederacy, and it says, "The battle of a NASA is demonstrated
at once and forever the superiority of the southern soldiers, and there is not a man
in the army from the humblest private to the highest officer who does not feel it."
The enemy know now that when they go forth to the field, they will encounter a master
race, definitely a term that has different connotations in the 19th century than 21th century.
The consciousness of this fact will cause their knees to tremble beneath them on the
day of battle.
So yeah, it just sounds like they're drunk with pride after this first battle.
Yeah, not a lot of humility there.
They're going to learn differently pretty soon, but for now, let them think that, huh?
Yeah, before we wrap up, I want to bring out a few things that are kind of like trivia
or human interest.
Just things that will make this battle even more interesting.
One thing that was a big problem is that neither side had standardized uniforms at this
time.
Some Confederates wore blue.
In fact, General Jackson, Thomas Jackson, who becomes Stonewall Jackson, at this point,
he was wearing his old army uniform, and it was blue.
Some Federals wore gray.
Some wore red.
There were units called fire zoos who tried to dress like they were Turks or something
or Algerians, zoos, some wore plaid.
There were Scottish units.
I know there was even one unit, I looked it up, but I forgot the name.
There was one unit in North Carolina that wore like revolutionary war style uniforms, like
three corner hat on the super long coat.
men didn't have a uniform, they were civilian.
close. And this lack of a standard uniform on either side led to a lot of confusion. Sometimes
like here you are a federal regiment, and you see these guys coming up towards you in blue,
and you think, "Oh great, they're coming here to reinforce us," and all of a sudden they
start shooting at you. So there was a lot of mistaken identity. There was even friendly fire.
Now the name of the battle, the North called it the Battle of Bull Run, which was, as we mentioned,
the name of the creek that ran through the battlefield, the South called it the Battle of Manassas
after the nearest town or railroad junction. And that's a pattern that's going to hold up through
most of the Civil War. It's very confusing for someone who is first studying the war because
almost every battle has two names. And to this day every now and then if you say the Battle of Bull Run
to a proud Southern, and they'll go, "Oh, you mean Manassas." But another thing too that I think
is very interesting is that the two main generals McDowell and Beauregard, they were classmates at
West Point. We talk about one of the cliches of the Civil War is that it's a brother's war, brother
fighting brother, and sometimes not literal brothers, but a guy you went to school with. You sat
right next to him in class, and now you're ordering troops to fire on his troops. We're going to see
that again and again. Let's see. Oh yeah, McDowell also not only was he a classmate with Beauregard,
but he briefly served under Joseph Johnston when they were in the regular army. So that's another
thing too is a lot of, we saw how Beauregard was firing on his former instructor at West Point
at Fort Sumter, and here we see McDowell is fighting against his former commander. Just one other
thing too. Well, actually, I've got two things. I lied. I got three things. I'll try not to do
more, because I don't want our listeners to get impatient and turn us off. But before McDowell
marched toward Manassas, he made his headquarters in Arlington, Virginia in the home of, and you guess,
Robert E. Lee. Robert E. Lee lived in a really nice house on a plantation in Arlington,
just across the Potomac from Washington, DC. And McDowell takes it over and makes it his headquarters,
and it ends up being permanently held by the union. And later it becomes the site of Arlington
National Cemetery. In other words, the union is not happy with Lee for what he did for jumping
ship and joined the Confederacy, and they stick it to him by making his house a cemetery,
basically not his house, but his yard. Another thing is we talked about the Henry House at the top
of Henry Hill where Jackson stood like a stone wall and rallied the troops, and which were the
side of the beginning of the victory of the Confederacy. Well, Judith Henry was killed by federal
artillery. Poor woman was 84 years old. She was on her deathbed, but she gets outside of her
house. She's on her deathbed. Yeah, exactly. The Confederates had set up a sharp shooter nest in
the second floor of the house, sharp shooters are what we today call snipers. And so the union
didn't appreciate the fact that people were shooting at them and picking them off from this house.
So they said blow it away. And so she's killed by a union shell. And finally, this is I think
that the the most ironic and interesting thing or one of them about the war is that one of the
houses that was on what ended up being the battlefield was owned by a man named Wilmer McLean.
Wilmer McLean had an ice house. And at one point, Beauregard made it his headquarters. And he
was having dinner. And he said himself later, a comical effect, there was an artillery fight going
on. Beauregard says a comical effect of this artillery fight was the destruction of the dinner of
myself and staff by a federal shell that fell into the fireplace of my headquarters at the McLean
House. So Beauregard's about to have supper and so much for that dinner. But what's really,
well, yeah, what now? And he really liked supper too. So he probably took this very personally.
Yeah, damn, so hungry. But Wilmer McLean was kind of, he survived the battle, but he was shook
up, obviously, as you would be if if if union shells are landing in your house,
Wilmer McLean decides after the battle, he's going to abandon this house. He's going to move to
another place. He says, I'm going to move somewhere way, far away from all this fighting far down
in Virginia, somewhere that I will never have to deal with this war again. So he goes down and he
buys a house in a place called Appomattox courthouse. Oh, Wilmer, you are irony follows you around like
the child of Alanis Morissette and Oh Henry. So absolutely. And so that house is going to have a big
future, but I will not give it away right now. Well, yeah, I mean, there's a million things we could
do. And just one other thing I'd like to mention, James, as you were describing the difference between
casualties and fatalities that there were 2700 union casualties, 2000 Confederate casualties,
approximately 900 killed, but then there are many we don't know about. So it's much larger.
I think we have to keep perspective on how many people really die in the civil war.
If we think about in the modern context of the Iraq war from 2003 onward, I don't know how many
American troops are killed a few thousand, I think if that's accurate. Now compared to something
like the Red Army and World War II, the deaths in the civil war minor, but it's I think is it the
most destructive conflict in American history? Yeah, the civil war, you know, when I was going
through schools in undergrad, they used to say about 620,000 were killed in the civil war. But in
the last 10 years or so, that's been upward, estimated upward. In other words, they now think it's
about 750,000. So at about 3 million men total on both sides served in uniform. So if you think
about that, 3 million men were in the Army or Navy, mainly Army, and 750,000 died. That's one
fourth. 25% died, not casualties died. And if you talk about wounded, it was well over a million.
I mean, for all the people killed in World War II, at least on the American side,
for the civil war, it's a much higher rate. This is total war on both sides. So the World War II
war effort of everyone taking part, how much higher would that have been when they're an equal
number of people getting involved, yet the population is smaller. So this is almost more on the
side of what Russia or the Red Army is going through in the civil war compared to the American
World War II experience. It just about is. I think I saw about, I don't know what the current
statistic is, but I know that I used to read that one out of every four adult white males in
the South died during the civil war. 25%. Yeah, so just the scale of all these things that were
rattling off compared to today with conflicts, it goes beyond the Iraq war, goes beyond the Vietnam
war. Yeah, and it's only going to get bigger and bigger. Yeah, this battle, as I mentioned, was the
had by far the largest loss of life to that point, but this is going to be small potatoes after
some of the other battles we're going to talk about, relatively speaking. Right. Well, a lot to
unpack here, but we'll do that in future episodes. Next, we will look at what is happening out west
in the border states. Thanks for listening to the key battles in the Civil War podcast.
Be sure to subscribe to the show and the podcast player of your choice and leave us a rating and
a review. This helps us grow and reach new listeners. You can also find maps of the battle sites,
shown on each episode, and plenty of other history info by going to key battles in the Civil War.com.
Thanks for listening and see you next time.
The historical Jesus podcast is the sweeping saga of the life and times of Galilean Jesus of Nazareth,
as well as the faith, religion, and church founded to honor and disseminate his acts and teachings.
Join me, Mark Vennette, on this fascinating journey through time exploring the many great works
of Christian theology, literature, architecture, music, and art inspired by the words and deeds of
Jesus Christ.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The Battle of Bull Run (or Manassas) was the first major engagement of the Civil War, revealing that both sides were unprepared and poorly trained.
Despite initial Southern confidence in their military superiority, the battle showed that the Union and Confederacy were equally inexperienced, leading to a mutual realization of the war’s brutality and length.
The Confederate victory stemmed from strategic reinforcements via rail, a technological advantage the South leveraged early, and the aggressive leadership of generals like Stonewall Jackson.
The battle resulted in heavy casualties, with Union losses at 2,700 and Confederate losses at around 2,000, marking the bloodiest conflict in American history up to that point.
Misunderstandings due to lack of standardized uniforms and mistaken identity led to friendly fire and confusion on the battlefield.
The battle highlighted the influence of Napoleonic military tactics and the role of West Point education in shaping Civil War strategy.
Key figures like Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee were connected by shared West Point backgrounds, emphasizing the personal and institutional roots of the conflict.
The outcome boosted Confederate morale, reinforcing their belief in military superiority and the legitimacy of secession.
Summary:
The Battle of Bull Run (Manassas) marked the first major engagement of the American Civil War and revealed the deep unpreparedness of both sides. With inexperienced troops, poor coordination, and a lack of standardized uniforms, the battle unfolded with confusion and chaos. Union General Irvin McDowell advanced toward the Confederate lines near Manassas, only to face strong resistance along Bull Run Creek.
Initial Union gains were quickly reversed when Confederate reinforcements arrived via rail, a critical technological advantage. General Stonewall Jackson’s aggressive leadership and the Confederate defense at Henry Hill turned the tide, leading to a decisive Confederate victory. Though the Union suffered heavy casualties—2,700 total—Confederate losses were lower at around 2,000, highlighting the war’s devastating scale.
The battle shattered the notion that the war would be short and easy, demonstrating its long duration and intensity. It also boosted Southern confidence, with Confederate leaders believing they had proven their military superiority. The episode also touches on human-interest details: friendly fire, the tragic death of an 84-year-old woman during the battle, and the ironic fate of Wilmer McLean, who abandoned his home after the battle only to later build a historic house in Appomattox.
Overall, Bull Run was a pivotal moment that set the tone for a prolonged and brutal conflict, reshaping military strategies and public perceptions of both sides.
FAQs
The battle was known as the Battle of Bull Run in the North and the Battle of Manassas in the South, named after the creek and the nearby town, respectively.
The Union army was commanded by General Irvin McDowell, while the Confederate army was led by General P.G.T. Beauregard.
The Confederate army used railroads to quickly move troops from the Shenandoah Valley to Manassas, making it the first major battle where rail transport was used to reinforce forces.
The Confederates were reinforced by troops arriving via rail, and their aggressive tactics, including Stonewall Jackson’s decisive actions, allowed them to push back the Union forces.
The battle was the bloodiest in American history up to that point due to inexperienced troops, poor coordination, and the intensity of fighting, especially during the retreat phase known as a 'route'.
The lack of uniformity led to mistaken identities and friendly fire incidents, as soldiers on both sides often misidentified each other due to mixed blue, gray, red, and even exotic clothing.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.