Go back

Episode #019: "Fate leads the willing and drags the reluctant." Seneca

from Shot of Philosophy

9m 41s

Episode #019: "Fate leads the willing and drags the reluctant." Seneca

This reflection explores how Stoic ideas about love, growth, fate, and control can be applied to daily life. The speaker begins by suggesting that we can learn to love ourselves, others, and life itself despite flaws and imperfections. Drawing on Epictetus, they argue that self-scrutiny should be practiced with kindness, because examination reveals where growth is needed, and growth is essential to keeping love alive, echoing Thich Nhat Hanh's claim that love begins to die when it stops growing. The discussion then turns to amor fati, the aspiration to love one's fate. The speaker offers the example of a businessman who, watching his factory burn, told his son to fetch his mother so she could witness such a large fire, immediately reframing disaster as opportunity. The key question, they suggest, is not whether such a response is realistic but whether it is useful and good, a point connected to Kant's emphasis on goodness. The speaker also considers fate through Seneca's line that fate leads the willing and drags the reluctant, illustrated by the Stoic image of a dog tied to a moving cart. They acknowledge struggling with expectations and the desire to control outcomes, and encourage letting go of what is beyond our control while still acting deliberately. Finally, they recommend philosophical journaling as a practice for cultivating this balance and protecting inner peace.

Transcription

1873 Words, 9842 Characters

English
Speaker 1to be loving, right? The same way we can learn to love ourselves and to love others with our flaws, with our imperfections, right? Because everybody's imperfect, right? We can learn to love life in a similar way, right? We can learn to learn from our flaws and work with them and same thing with life, right? We can learn that sometimes, again, things are out of our control. We can attribute that to fate. We can maybe attribute that to other people expressing their will because we're not in control of them either, which I think we could just for argument's sake, put that in with fate, right? And we can learn to influence the world, offer the world new choices perhaps through our behavior. The same way with ourselves. Epictetus famously says, we should learn to scrutinize ourselves with kindness. That's sort of what love is, right? Because that scrutiny leads to growth and growth requires love. Wait, what? No, love requires growth. And I almost think the other way is true too, to an extent, but let's not get into that. Thich Nhat Hanh famously, right, in his book, How to Love, wrote, you know, when love stops growing, it starts to die. Scrutiny helps growth because you figure out, right? We could almost switch that word because I think that has some negative connotations. Switch it to examining, right? If you want to grow, you have to figure out where you need growth. You have to figure out how have you successfully grown in the past in order to at least do that optimally, right? So when we talk about growth, we have to figure out how have you successfully grown in the past. When we talk about fate leads the willing, that, you know, doesn't necessarily mean that we're led in a way that's loving, but wouldn't we want to be? I think amor fati at the very least could be an aspiration. And I think it goes beyond simply characterizing something as terrible. And I even think it's more profound and it's deeper than just like finding the silver lining, right? There are a lot of great examples of this. I think Ryan Holiday provides a lot of great examples of this in his books and in his book, How to Love. And one, I think, and I'm not getting this right, but it was a businessman who like their factory went on fire and it was going to just destroy the factory. And there's nothing you could do about it. And he was like, just standing outside the factory, like watching it get engulfed in flames. And his son came up to him and like, you know, in a panic state. And he told his son, go get your mother. She'll never see a fire this large in her life. And he sort of like took it as, you know, almost immediately flipped it into an opportunity, right? Well, now I'm not going to get bored because I have to restart this whole thing again. And I think there is some naiveness there, right? Or some naivete there. But the question is, is it useful? And I think the answer is yes, because he's not, you know, totally damaging or destroying himself emotionally in that moment. Now he has another sense, a greater sense of direction than simply saying, oh, this is shit. So the question might not even necessarily be, is it realistic? The question might be, is it useful? Is it good? Right? Immanuel Kant in his Metaphysics and Morals, right, talks about goodness being the most important thing. And I've got some problems with Kant. We can argue with Kant as we can with pretty much any philosopher, a number of things. But ultimately, I think that's a really cool point. Even truth, which is very important. We might have to ask ourselves, now, this doesn't necessarily fit into the Kantian worldview, but I've thought about this a lot in the past. Like, a lie can serve as a way to prove that it's not true. And I think that's a really good question. Obviously, right? We could all think of examples. Now, a selfish lie, a lie that you, you know, you tell just like to protect yourself when you've done something wrong, or a lie you tell to avoid being judged by others, like that, those are probably problematic, right? So we shouldn't make a habit of lying. But you can lie to protect someone. You can lie and save someone's life. You can lie and save your own life. Right? So of course, we can think about this idea that maybe to embrace what Seneca is saying, that at times, we have to be led by fate, we have to allow ourselves, right? We have to maybe, and this is something I struggle with a lot, we have to detract from our belief, or decrease the intensity of the belief that we can take action in the world and things will go our way. Right? So if you're someone who struggles with that, which I struggle with personally, right? I don't think I struggle to take action. There are other people that need to be encouraged to take action. I think I struggle to realize that sometimes actions either just like don't work out, or I also struggle with expectations. Right? So sometimes, let's say if you feel like you make demands on the universe, you make demands on other people. This, I think, is a great quote to kind of relax a little bit. Right? And I love the idea from Marcus Aurelius, too. You know, nothing for him, he says, is possible God and good luck. And maybe you don't believe in a higher power. Okay, say luck. Luck is real. I think I've already mentioned this on the podcast, right? We do not make our own luck. That's naive. And I think that's naive and not helpful. Something could be naive and helpful, and something could be naive and not helpful. I think that's naive, but it's also not helpful because it's kind of arrogant, in my opinion, to think that luck doesn't exist. I control luck. Wait a minute. Really? I don't know about that. Too much. Too much going on in the universe. Too many other people expressing their wills as well, in my opinion, and I stand by this, to think that luck doesn't exist or that it exists, but it only exists as a result of me doing things. Right? So I think the Stoics, as Marcus was saying there, too, would agree that luck is its own sort of entity. Like, you can't control it. We need it. It has to aid or help us in our endeavors in life. Right? So for me, I think on the 18th, when I wrote this, I was probably reminding myself to just be led calmly, to acknowledge what's out of my control, and understand that fate is real, at least to some extent. I think I'm trying to encourage myself to believe that, so I can learn how to let go. That's also a great Stoic perception, right? That we have to learn how to let go of our control. Again, over the things that we cannot control. Right? We can't control a lot of things. Right? So I think that's a great Stoic perception, right? Right? That we can't control a lot of things. Right? As we've already discussed. This is a great quote, I think, to highlight that and to encourage us to live it. You know? Fate leads the willing and drags the reluctant. Also, a little bit reminds me of the Stoic conception of free will. Right? The dog with a leash attached to a cart. The cart is universal. The cart moves. You know, this isn't a huge dog. The dog can either run alongside the cart. The dog can maybe even run alongside the cart. The dog can slowly jog behind it. Or the dog can refuse to move and hurt. And, you know, I want to say hurt itself, but it's the universe also. Right? So the dog, by staying, will create a scenario in which, you know, it's going to suffer. So I like that idea a lot. I think, for me, I would like to think we have a long leash so we can move around freely. Right? But there's certain things out of our control. Once again, there are certain movements of the universe that are going to pull us. And we have to make a choice, back to Amor Fati, how we relate to that pull. How we relate to that event out of our control. Will we try to make something good of it? Will we try to love it and grow with it? Or will we just fight it? So that's sort of a question. I know I like to end on questions. That's kind of a question. Right? How do you relate to events out of your control? How do you balance between accepting things out of your control, accepting things, and taking action on them? And I think things right because we have to keep in mind that balance is at least for aristotle is virtuous so even i think we often in our culture too we admire the action takers and that's overall a good thing i would say but ultimately it could also be a bad thing there there is a lot to be said for people who are good at learning how to sit back and powerfully so i would say acknowledge that this is out of my control this will not affect my peace because i think also when we let our peace get affected negatively we then start becoming more difficult to be around and we start maybe making decisions that aren't fair for other people as a result of our own unfairness to ourselves it's unfair to not know how and when to say it's out of my control let fate lead this also maybe this is kind of returning to my earlier half of this episode that kind of turned into a little bit of a rant what journaling i call it philosophical journaling it's not i don't think that's a new idea but what type of journaling do you do and how might that help with this with this set of issues right so like i said i walked us through my day-to-day planner my kind of more philosophical personal one than my work as a student and you know i'm always hoping to write something trying to write something new so that's like where i'll do my author stuff too and then my physical journal that i used to kind of create a for exercise so maybe adopt a practice one of those or another one whatever but uh keep this in mind too right kind of two episodes for one today sort of went on a little bit of a rant there all right well hope this was helpful thank you for listening and i'll talk to you soon

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Learning to love ourselves and life involves accepting flaws and imperfections while examining them with kindness to support growth.
  2. Growth requires honest self-examination, and when love stops growing it begins to die, so scrutiny should be reframed positively as examination.
  3. Amor fati can be an aspiration that goes beyond finding a silver lining, as shown by the businessman who reframed a factory fire as a fresh opportunity.
  4. The useful question is not always whether a response is realistic but whether it is useful and good, echoing Kant's emphasis on goodness.
  5. While habitual lying is problematic, lies can sometimes protect or save lives, showing that truth and goodness can conflict.
  6. The Stoic image of a dog tied to a moving cart illustrates that we can choose to run willingly with fate rather than be dragged reluctantly.
  7. We should release the arrogant belief that we fully control outcomes or make our own luck, since other people's wills and chance both shape events.
  8. Balancing acceptance of what is out of our control with deliberate action is virtuous, and protecting our inner peace helps us treat others fairly.

Summary:

This reflection explores how Stoic ideas about love, growth, fate, and control can be applied to daily life. The speaker begins by suggesting that we can learn to love ourselves, others, and life itself despite flaws and imperfections. Drawing on Epictetus, they argue that self-scrutiny should be practiced with kindness, because examination reveals where growth is needed, and growth is essential to keeping love alive, echoing Thich Nhat Hanh's claim that love begins to die when it stops growing.

The discussion then turns to amor fati, the aspiration to love one's fate. The speaker offers the example of a businessman who, watching his factory burn, told his son to fetch his mother so she could witness such a large fire, immediately reframing disaster as opportunity. The key question, they suggest, is not whether such a response is realistic but whether it is useful and good, a point connected to Kant's emphasis on goodness.

The speaker also considers fate through Seneca's line that fate leads the willing and drags the reluctant, illustrated by the Stoic image of a dog tied to a moving cart. They acknowledge struggling with expectations and the desire to control outcomes, and encourage letting go of what is beyond our control while still acting deliberately. Finally, they recommend philosophical journaling as a practice for cultivating this balance and protecting inner peace.

FAQs

It means accepting flaws and imperfections while learning from them and working with them. Since everyone is imperfect, we can extend the same patience and kindness to life itself.

Because scrutiny leads to growth, and growth requires love. Examining ourselves kindly helps us identify where we need to grow without damaging ourselves emotionally.

It suggests that accepting what is out of our control makes life smoother, while resisting it causes unnecessary suffering. The Stoic image of a dog tied to a moving cart illustrates this: you can run alongside it or be dragged.

Amor fati is the aspiration to love one's fate rather than merely tolerate it. It goes beyond finding a silver lining by actively choosing to grow from events outside our control.

The key question may not be whether it is realistic but whether it is useful. Reframing can prevent emotional self-destruction and give a greater sense of direction than simply declaring the situation terrible.

Luck is treated as its own entity that we cannot control but often need. Believing we make all our own luck is naive and unhelpful, since too much in the universe and in other people's wills is beyond us.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.