Go back

Episode #004: "Is the blueberry bitter? Then throw it away. Don't demand to know why such things exist." Meditations by Marcus Aurelius

from Shot of Philosophy

6m 36s

Episode #004: "Is the blueberry bitter? Then throw it away. Don't demand to know why such things exist." Meditations by Marcus Aurelius

The speaker reflects on Meditation 50 from Gregory Hays's translation of Marcus Aurelius, adapting the original example of a bitter fig into a personal one about blueberries. The core message is simple: if a blueberry is bitter, throw it out; if a thorny bush blocks your path, walk around it. There is no need to demand an explanation for why such things exist, since anyone who understands the world would laugh at someone shocked by sawdust in a carpenter's workshop or leather scraps in a shoemaker's shop. The speaker connects this to absurdist philosophy, especially Albert Camus, arguing that some things are simply chaotic and senseless, and the only meaning we can make is to move on. Life inevitably contains things that are annoying, difficult, or even terrible, and we must learn to distinguish among them rather than treating minor annoyances as catastrophes. The speaker notes a personal tendency to overanalyze and tries to explain rude behavior, and recommends instead dropping such futile efforts. The talk also warns against commiserating with negative people, since misery feeds on itself, and invokes the Stoic idea of leaving wrongdoing where it arose so that others' rudeness does not ruin your day. Unless a situation is egregious, the best response is to notice the bitterness, maintain your own virtue, and calmly keep moving forward.

Transcription

1410 Words, 7715 Characters

English
Speaker 1Hello, everybody. How you doing? Hope all is well. Welcome back. Today, we're looking at page 111 in the Gregory Hayes translation of Mark's Related Meditations, and this is number 50. I'm going to make some alterations here because I eat blueberries. So he tells himself here, number 50, is the blueberry bitter? Then throw it out. Are there bushes with thorns in your way, on your path, walking somewhere? Then go around them. That's all you need to know. Nothing more. Don't demand to know, quote, why such things exist. Anyone who understands the world will laugh at you, just as a carpenter would if you seemed shocked at finding sawdust in his workshop or a shoemaker at scraps of leather left over from work. So I'm going to stop this one here because I love this first section, right? So to me, this is a huge or potentially. It's actually a hugely influential set of ideas for leading a happier life. I personally like this so much because it really resonates with me. I have a tendency to overanalyze things and to try to explain things and understand them. I think Albert Camus also as an absurdist has kind of helped me with that. It's like sometimes shit is just absurd. Sometimes things may be. And this is obviously an oversimplification of that philosophy. I'm not saying that's the only thing it's saying. But for me, it's sometimes things are just chaos, and I'm not saying that's the only thing it's saying. But for me, it's sometimes things are just chaos, sometimes things don't make sense. And the only piece we can make maybe is what Marcus is saying here, which is move on. I switched the beginning of this to blueberries because I eat blueberries regularly. And one thing you know about blueberries if you eat them is sometimes you get a sweet blueberry, sometimes you get like five nice sweet blueberries in a row, then you're going to get a bitter one eventually. So you don't just stand in your kitchen like yelling at the blueberries or yelling at your fridge or worse, like yelling at a higher power. You just kind of keep it moving. You go to the next blueberry, right? But in life, we have difficulty applying that. And I think again, as I try to sympathize with Marcus, I feel like he probably wrote this right after somebody was rude to him, or something went wrong. Right? Just go around them. Keep going on your on your path, right? But the idea of a, like a thorny bush, right? If you're walking the street, or even better, maybe there's a hole in the ground, right? You don't stare at the hole for 20 minutes. You walk around it to get to your destination. And then you get to your destination. And then you walk around and you get to your destination. Right? So how can we apply that philosophy to life? I think is what he's asking himself here. And I think that's a really great question. How can we spend less time focusing on the negative things that just don't make sense, or the things that are just bitter, right? We don't need to, again, we taste it to even characterize it as bitter. We're noticing something, but we don't want to live there. Right? So I think this is great advice for people who might be overly pessimistic, right? Because it's normal to have some pessimism in life. Some things in life are terrible or horrible. Right? And so I think that's a really great advice. Some things in life are just kind of bad. Some things in life are annoying, right? We one, have to learn how to make those distinctions. So we don't treat things that are just kind of annoying as if they're catastrophes. That's a problem. Right? And especially with things from that annoying to just kind of difficult range. We have to learn maybe from Marcus here as he's trying to learn from himself to just throw the blue, like throw the blueberry away. Just walk around the hole in the ground, walk around the thorny bush, instead of sitting there and characterizing it and trying to explain it. I was recently talking to a friend of mine trying to understand one of their coworkers and I'm like, this is a waste of time. I'm like, we're never going to know. Like, let's just drop it. Let's change the topic to something happier, to something more productive. Right? If you find yourself commiserating with people and I love, I don't love the word for its meaning, but I love the word for like it's etymology, right? Well, not etymology, whatever. When you look at the word, you see co to mean with, and misery is like right in the middle of that word. Right? So to commiserate, it's like you hang out with people and everyone's just negative. And that negativity like always fuels itself, right? Misery needs company. And Marcus, I think here is like, no, it doesn't. I can walk around this thing. I can throw this blueberry away. And then I love the second part where he's pretty much talking about the universe. It's like, oh, some of the things in the universe, and this is not something I think the Stokes would necessarily agree with. So I'm not sure if this is what he meant, but this is one of my interpretations, right? Especially from that more Albert Camus absurdist view. Some of this stuff is just absurd. We shouldn't look for a reason behind it. Because in looking, right, we're not going to find it. And then you could make a reason and move on. And that might be the happier, more effective way to do it versus again, cursing a higher power, cursing the people around you, cursing yourself, just learning to move on from things, I think is what Marcus is trying to encourage in himself here. Right? So what are the things I think that, you know, that stop you in a sense, right? What are the blueberries you yell at? Maybe that there's things in your life that you frequently try to explain away, right? So for me, when people are like rude to other people, that really baffles me. And I'll get into a conversation like, well, maybe when they were a kid or I'm like, okay, this is some people are just rude. Let's move on. And as long as we're not rude, and this is a very stoic idea, right? Leave the sin where it arose. So as long as you're not rude, right? And of course, there are times, you know, when we have to respond to rudeness to correct it, right? If rudeness starts getting into something that's, let's say more offensive than rudeness, like simple rudeness, then of course, it might warrant a conversation or even, you know, a little bit of a conflict, right? Of course, right. But ultimately, I'm once again, here talking about smaller examples, just for this, for the sake of this conversation, right? As long as you're not rude, right? You can maybe even calmly correct the rude person. And you maintain your virtue. Right? So how do we learn to not imitate negativity? And not only that, but leave it where it arose, like, which is to say someone else's rudeness, again, unless it's an egregious example or a horrible example, really shouldn't ruin your day, really shouldn't ruin your morning. And I think that's, again, what Marcus is trying to convey to himself here. Just move past it, man. It's a part of being a person. It's a part of being on the earth. It's a part of being around other people. We're all imperfect, right? So we're going to have these moments. So what's the best way to handle it? Again, sometimes, like I said a moment ago, it might require some, you teach somebody calmly. It might require you teach somebody not so calmly. And that might be, those might be the righteous, just things to do, of course. But I think for our own spiritual well-being, we have to learn how to calmly throw the blueberry away. So I like this quote a lot. Hope this was helpful. Thank you for listening. Take care. And I'll talk to you soon.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The speaker discusses Meditation 50 from Gregory Hays's translation of Marcus Aurelius, replacing the original "fig" with "blueberry" to illustrate that bitter or unpleasant things should simply be discarded.
  2. Marcus advises going around obstacles like thorny bushes rather than demanding to know why they exist, since understanding the world means accepting such things as natural.
  3. The speaker connects this idea to absurdist philosophy, particularly Albert Camus, suggesting some things are simply chaotic and do not make sense.
  4. People should not treat minor annoyances as catastrophes but should distinguish between what is annoying, difficult, and truly terrible.
  5. The speaker warns against commiserating with negative people, noting that "misery" sits inside the word and that negativity fuels itself.
  6. A Stoic principle is invoked
  7. The speaker admits to overanalyzing things, such as trying to explain rude behavior, and recommends dropping such futile explanations in favor of moving on.
  8. Marcus's advice is framed as a practical path to a happier life

Summary:

The speaker reflects on Meditation 50 from Gregory Hays's translation of Marcus Aurelius, adapting the original example of a bitter fig into a personal one about blueberries. The core message is simple: if a blueberry is bitter, throw it out; if a thorny bush blocks your path, walk around it. There is no need to demand an explanation for why such things exist, since anyone who understands the world would laugh at someone shocked by sawdust in a carpenter's workshop or leather scraps in a shoemaker's shop.

The speaker connects this to absurdist philosophy, especially Albert Camus, arguing that some things are simply chaotic and senseless, and the only meaning we can make is to move on. Life inevitably contains things that are annoying, difficult, or even terrible, and we must learn to distinguish among them rather than treating minor annoyances as catastrophes. The speaker notes a personal tendency to overanalyze and tries to explain rude behavior, and recommends instead dropping such futile efforts. The talk also warns against commiserating with negative people, since misery feeds on itself, and invokes the Stoic idea of leaving wrongdoing where it arose so that others' rudeness does not ruin your day. Unless a situation is egregious, the best response is to notice the bitterness, maintain your own virtue, and calmly keep moving forward.

FAQs

If something is bitter or unpleasant, simply throw it out rather than dwelling on it. The speaker uses blueberries because you occasionally get a bitter one, and instead of yelling about it, you just move on to the next.

When you encounter an obstacle, you walk around it to reach your destination instead of staring at it. Similarly, you should move past life's annoyances rather than stopping to analyze or complain about them.

Some things in life are simply absurd and have no satisfying explanation. Searching for reasons wastes time, much like a carpenter would laugh at someone shocked to find sawdust in his workshop.

It encourages you to stop trying to explain every negative thing and instead move on. It also helps you distinguish between things that are merely annoying and things that are truly catastrophic, so you don't treat small problems as disasters.

Someone else's rudeness should not ruin your day, as long as you don't imitate it. You can calmly correct the person if needed while maintaining your own virtue.

Commiserating means gathering with people to share negativity, and that negativity tends to fuel itself. Marcus suggests you don't need to stay in that misery—you can walk around it and move on.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.