Go back

Ep. 960: Illegal Sheep Nuts and Another Record Buck Controversy

1h 19m 7s

Ep. 960: Illegal Sheep Nuts and Another Record Buck Controversy

The podcast explores a series of interconnected wildlife-related controversies, from illegal breeding operations to questionable hunting practices and state-led wildlife management. A Montana guide, John Luton, faced a $20,000 fine for selling a big horn sheep nut sack for $400, underscoring the extreme imbalance between small financial gains and significant legal penalties in wildlife crimes. This case is linked to Jack "Jack Shoe Barf," who ran a secretive breeding operation, illegally importing Marco Polo sheep genetics, breeding hybrids, and selling semen to high-fenced hunting operations. His activities include smuggling genetic material, forging documents, and breeding a pure Marco Polo sheep, which he later sold. A hybrid sheep escaped from his Montana ranch and remains unlocated, raising concerns over disease spread. The story also touches on the validity of Sam Ayupa’s world-record white-tailed deer, which is under scrutiny due to missing hunting permits, unverified dates, and lack of meat processing—key red flags for legal and ethical compliance. Further, the Ayupa family’s ties to the Chicago mob, including a known mobster uncle, add a layer of intrigue to the narrative. In Oklahoma, a controversial plan to release CWD-resistant deer into the wild, championed by agricultural officials, faces backlash for lacking wildlife oversight, regulatory clarity, and ecological risk. These cases illustrate systemic issues in wildlife enforcement, including poor accountability, blurred lines between agriculture and conservation, and the need for stronger ethical and legal standards in hunting and breeding.

Transcription

12570 Words, 67628 Characters

English
This is an I Heart podcast guaranteed human late season has a way of testing how badly you want to stay out there when the wind picks up in the temperature drops. First lights new full curl down parka is built to keep you hunting. It uses 900 fill power muscovy down and high q x reflex fabric to help retain body heat. The full curl is built for cold cold late season hunts stay focused on the hunt not the weather check it out at first light dot com that's f-i-r-s-t-l-i-t-e dot com Welcome to the news show everybody this week we've got a Montana big horn sheep hunting guide and some considerable heat for selling big horn nut sacks containing as nut sacks do genetic material Spencer shines some light on the new us record ayupa yeah the ayupa buck controversy okahoma's plan to release cwd resistant deer isn't as clear cut as most lesser news organizations would like you to believe plus a whole bunch more but first we're going to dig into them sheep nuts what's your problem headliner no i'm dropping it i'm like i'm not gonna sit oh i didn't notice a headline thing yes it's the one the sea miller band you hate well not only spill yeah i want to talk about that for five minutes i decided i wasn't going to subject Steve to the poor man's weird owl version of a band that he hates yeah i explained to Seth for ten minutes why should he ever become aware of steve miller band how why you just start hating that why should you hate him set well he only know he already knows a guy named steve miller the one he's talking about okay who did him wrong in high school no no son of a gun from from high school no no no no which one of you wasn't listening hey graduate i'm pretty sure you graduated with my mom in high school that's what i meant i'll workshop something new but until then all right yes that's my okay so a bunch of recent headlines about a hunting guide in Montana named john luteon being fined twenty thousand bucks for selling a nut sack a scrotum off a trophy-sized big horn ram salt this nut sack to what the media is calling an alternative livestock ranch up near great falls Montana now this okay if you've read about this in the news it's being treated as this kind of singular event but this is part of a much larger much more gravy rich story that's been simmering for years about the ranch the alternative livestock ranch which is which is called sunriver enterprises it's around 215 acres so a small property as ranches go this place has been owned by an elderly fella named Arthur or because of jack so Arthur jack shoe bar for we're gonna go with jack from here on out here's a picture who for you people watching the video that's a high fenced here i don't know what he's got there and i noticed it it looks like it's dead but then it's got its eyes covered up which makes me think it's maybe sedated that's a high fenced yeah so interesting interesting story here over the years this guy jack shoe barf has been involved in various schemes to buy cell and breed freak critters did he sells the high fenced shooting operations um mostly down in texas now one new source you guys have run into ours technica now no they do a lot of technical reporting what they mentioned how people then track the animals on these shooting these shooting places which cracks me up because uh they they're shot he produces these he produced goats and sheep that he sells to these high fenced operations okay all the way back in 2013 up until about 2021 shoe barf jack here had been conspiring with with others to illegally import genetic material from Marco Polo sheep so this is the world's largest argolli sheep from curgostan into the us okay he it seems like years ago he had oddly he dispatched his kid up to curgostan to kill a Marco Polo sheep and he kills one and then smuggles home because when you you can import parts but you have to go through the society's process and all this kind of stuff but he him he sneaks home the nut sack off the Marco Polo sheep but the genetic material wasn't viable just the sack or the test he's included i'm sure no no yeah the the scroll the whole complete scroll the the genetic material wasn't viable he went back on another hunt and brings back smuggles back genetic material so now this guy has illegally obtained tissue samples and seaman and he like he likes strikes a deal with this cloning place okay and eventually gets 136 embryos and is able to implant these embryos this this dude is doing like you know sometimes you read about a poacher and he does something real bad but at the same time you recognize he was out he was good at what he did as much as it you shouldn't point that out do you follow me yeah i thought you're gonna say like someone made an honest mistake but no you're you're like patting them on the back like not patting them on the back you post real well buddy i'm pointing out that he he's a breeding and i'll get into this he's a breeding enthusiast and was able to do as wrong as what he did might be was able to demonstrate a rather exceptional bit of technical prowess in his deceptions real high barrier to entry and he cleared it yeah it'd be like you know if you're watching the movie and i'm not equating this to to be in a serial killer but when you're watching like if you're watching a serial killer movie they'll often point out how sort of shrewd they were this big part of serial killer things is there very you know they're like technically proficient murders you following me he's making that point this guy's figuring a lot of crazy stuff out at his place up by great falls now to back up a little bit this guy was in the air force moves the great falls just a big air force base and great falls and he starts breeding fish and pets at his home back in 1961 it opens up this place called jacks pet center in 1966 now if you were to go in and here fills got a picture of it up here this is all backstory if you were to go in and type up jacks pet center as i did earlier today you will find a lot of online consternation about the conditions of this pet store people just really not like in jacks pet center and want to see jacks pet center shut down yeah that looks justified a lot of people point out the poor condition of the monkey cage and Montana made selling monkeys wrong but apparently they kept some monkeys in the back very upsetting to a lot of clientele a lot of online consternation about jacks pet center eventually as he gets into breeding pets and fish to supply this pet center he starts licking his lips about selling stuff to shooting operations high fent shooting operations he eventually births at his place in Montana outside of great falls he births a genuine like a pure marco polo sheep so now he's sitting in possession of this sheep which he doesn't have he actually sought legal permission to have the sheep and was denied that permission then he starts obfuscating what he's doing and forging these various documents to engage in this whole sheep business he's selling straws of semen off of oh i forgot this little detail when he breeds this pure marco polo sheep he names it Montana mountain king and start selling straws of semen out of state for high fence shooting operations who are then implanting it into various other sheep or guys are driving up sheep to him to have Montana mountain king inseminate their sheep to then drive them back to their high fent shooting operations to go and sell them to clients i imagine a client is like someone in Texas with a high fence. Exactly. So you'd assume. Yeah. That's what he's feeding. Mostly in Texas. Right. High fence shooting operations who are advertising, you know, these opportunities. There's also a big one in Oklahoma that I read about a lot where they'll advertise like World Record. This and that, you know, kind of drugged up standing there. Guys come down and kind of pretend to hunt it. Eventually, this guy gets in a bunch of trouble. They euthanize a bunch of these critters. He's what's funny is it points out that when they euthanize a bunch of these sheep, the meat was donated to needy families in Montana, which is a strange detail. Hmm. Do you be sitting there eating some burger and a few, that's like, uh, yeah, Marco Polo hybrid in your burger over the years he had a couple of disease outbreaks on this place, okay? Which is part of the problem why you're not supposed to do this because what decimated Rocky Mountain big horns in the first place is like pneumonia coming from domestic livestock and making its way into wildlife. Since this past year, a couple months ago, in September, he had a some kind of big horned sheep hybrid, escape his place wearing a ear tag, the FWP, that's Montana Department of Fish Wildlife and Parks, they put all these notices trying to get people to call in and report the location of this hybrid sheep that escaped his place. Here we are 60 days in, no one's found that damn sheep yet. Oh, I didn't know that. As far as I know, now I texted, checked with people, they put out feelers, it seems as far as I know, it's been unnot been located. I was reading where someone from the someone from this breeding operation has a theory about what happened to it, which differs than the theory that FWP has about what happened to it, but it's whereabouts are I believe to be unknown. So back to this new headline about this hunting guy named John Ludon, who again was just buying 20,000 bucks, so here we sit in late 2026, where he did goes all the way back to the, goes all the way back to the height of this breeding operations sheep crimes is in October 2019, Luton was guiding a client who killed a big horn sheep. A lot of his operations take place up in the Missouri break, some kind of assuming he was hunting up in the Missouri breaks. The client kills a big horn. He cuts off the nut sack from the client's big horn and brings it and sells it to jack the breeder. I've read that he sold this nut sack for 400 bucks. The trouble is I read it from a guy that I don't know how the guy would know that, and I can't corroborate how he knows that price, but there's a room, at least a rumor out there that he only got 400 bucks for this thing, but has been investigated ever since, and so now here we are seven years down the road, and the guy has gotten a 20,000 dollar fine for Lacey Ag violations, and then a one year prohibition on commercial hunting, commercial trapping, accompanying people, commercial hunting, commercial trapping. From the Montana state news bureau, they reported that he sold the testicles for $400. They did. Okay. So that's legitimate. Yes. Doesn't seem like a lot of money. No, this is one of those. We got into this last time with the bobcat poachers, where people, they're not, like, if you go to rob a bank, and you say, like, man, if we pull this off, we're going to walk out of here with, or those dudes just did that crypto heist, like, if we pull off this crypto heist, and we could make, we could steal 600, or sorry, we could steal $6 billion in crypto. There's that. But if we get in trouble, there's the caught, the fine, or the jail time, and you sort of look and you're like reward risk, oftentimes with wildlife crimes, you find where there's the exceptionally low reward, an outside, outsized risk, meaning you get 400 bucks for a nut sack, and your fine is 20,000 bucks. And he probably just thinks, it's like beer money, it's no big deal, probably no big deal. There's an interesting story that this guy was connected to. So I looked him up, here's his Instagram page, it's funny because when I looked him up, a lot of people, I know. Well, three of them, and I texted all of them. A lot of people I know follow him, and follow him as a big horn sheep enthusiast on Instagram, he's wild sheep 24/7, 365, and I have no idea. Like, I don't know if he was broke, I don't know if he even understood what he was getting into, whatever, but this connection date, this individual is connected to a really interesting big horn sheep story that came out of Montana years ago that I want to touch on, because it was so that the circumstances of this story were so peculiar. The Montana Department of Fish Wildlife in Parks was investigating a big horn sheep guide for doing various practices that various illegal practices, one thing he had been involved in was filming without a permit, okay, so not a pretty low scale violation. They sent out an undercover agent to go on a big horn sheep trip with him. So here's an undercover guy posing as a big horn sheep tag holder. All the undercover agent is out hunting in 2008, this is 2008. While the undercover big horn tag holder is out hunting, they do witness some violations for one finding big horns with an airplane and using two-way communications to communicate the whereabouts of the sheep and trespassing on private land. That's passing without permission, okay? So this undercover agent is documenting these crimes, which again, these are not felony level wildlife crimes, I'm not excusing them, but it ties into the story in the end, because eventually the undercover guy is presented with a shot opportunity on a giant sheep. And he deliberately misses, but then they keep the investigation open. He's presented with another shot opportunity the next day, deliberately misses and misses again and misses again. The hunt goes on and the undercover guy starts to fear that they're going to be on to him if he continues to miss, like they're going to recognize he's deliberately missing his shots. So the undercover agent's words where he felt tension in the group at that point. I'm sure he did. Yes. As I was witness to him miss the Arda and there was tension in the air, so non-place by Steve. So I'm joking, but so he to keep his undercover status and keep in mind, this is such a coveted tag, your odds of drawing this tag are way less, well, your odds of drawing this tag are expressed in 0.0 something percent. When the governor's tag gets sold, the governor's tag holder always hunts this area. These governor's tags go for a quarter million. They've approached a half million dollars for a governor's tag in this area. This isn't once in a lifetime, this is once in 500 lifetimes, a thousand lifetimes, I don't know. It's an experience that is annually, it's an experience that is tested in the financial market annually and annually consumers value this experience into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. The undercover agent and trying to keep his cover kills a 204 inch big horn. He says that it was a hundred yards away at that point, he couldn't miss a fourth time, which brought a lot of, which brought in intense criticism of this operation to be. You decided to kill an animal, a top end trophy class big horn. I see one article describing it as the state record at the time. Another article from recently said it's the third biggest in state history. So it's somewhere between one and three, like breaking 200 inches with the big horn is huge. Guys are going to be happy with a 180 inch big horn. So he kills a big horn that like let's just, I mean, that that would have a half million dollars value on it to a governor's tag holder in order to keep his undercover thing going. Not when they're investigating like a murderer. But a trespasser and a user and a legal user of two way radio communications. So all of the focus on that little bust all shifted to this particular operation with intense criticism of the people involved in this operation. And in a jury trial, the guy was acquitted. There were three different folks charged. All three had jury trials where they walked away without being charged with anything. And mostly, because it was verbalized that the FWP went too hard in this case. They way overstepped what they were trying to pull off here. Yeah. Like something, you know, and again, it's just, it's just violations that a game warden out doing normal operations, violations that a game warden is just going to find quite easily outside of needing to do an elaborate sting operation that results in the death of a potentially state record. Big horn sheep. And so that's the guy who sold the testicles. It's also the guy who got the $5,000 fine for filming without a permit. Yeah. To back up to Jack real quick, for all that stuff I was talking about, he did with the Argolly sheep and all that. He wound up with some fines. I think his fines were in the tune of around $21,000 total. He was sentenced to six months in federal prison, but the guy was already 81 years old. In the end, seemingly because of his age and health considerations, he was just put on probation, never served a day of jail time. To address the $400 one more time, Luton said that the $400 from the buyer was not for the testicles. It was gas money. And that was paying. That was $400 for him to deliver the testicles and he was just doing it for free. But that that was not believed by the folks who gave him the charges. He did cash to $400 check though. You know what that's like? You know how you can still in Mississippi, you can still kill deer with poison arrows. Okay. When you buy deer poison in Mississippi, to put on your arrows, it's a sedative. It sedates that any contact that, it's like, it's like a, imagine a little condom that sits behind your broad head. Any contact that powder has of that deer's vascular system, if you so much as nick that deer, that deer's dead, it's a sedative that stops it's breathing. Anyways, a friend of mine was telling me when you buy that poison, it's not that it says it's legal. It just doesn't say it's not legal. The only state is the weirdest deal. They don't like talking about it. They don't like anyone talking about it down in Mississippi. But when you buy that poison, the bottle of the poison comes and clarifies that you are not buying the contents of the bottle, you're buying the bottle. It just happens to be, this is like this gas money thing. Yeah. It's like, you're not buying the poison, you're buying the bottle, which happens to be full of a powder. Yeah. I think it was a common thing in New York City when we became legal. You couldn't deliver weed to somebody, but for like a hundred bucks, you could deliver somebody a bag that had like a Wendy's hamburger in it, plus an ounce of weed. And so that was happening quite often where folks were, you know, getting food deliveries that also came with some weed. Yeah. That's a real titillating tail. You like that one, don't you? Yeah. It's got a good hook because anybody, you bring up a big horn nut sack, fill, pull up a big, just just for people to see. Well, fill, pull that up. Big horn ram from behind. That is a Rocky Mountain oyster. Yeah. Yeah. We just need to just quickly while he's pulling that up. This is actually sent in from a listener, Chad Crossley. And we get, we get so many great stories sent in by listeners. We want to say thank you. And so in this case, we'll send Chad a mulchry cell cam. And if you have a great news story that you think we should cover, write in the media podcast at themediator.com. That was such a good story. I think we should sweeten the pot. Oh, what else would we give them? I don't know. Like send them with something nice. I don't know. Like some t-shirts. I don't know. Okay. I'll put a little swag back together. Yeah. I got a question. Something that looks like we're being real nice, but those nations call us the same. The fastest I could get. No. No, no, no. That's the worst part. I've ever seen. Omar, what's your question? Is that a female? That's a titillate. If you guys are that undercover agent, what would you do to get yourself out of shooting that big old ram? How to turn to when I was said, buddy, we ain't actually hunting. Yeah. If you haven't gotten the, if you haven't put it together, I'm, here's my badge and, and I'd like you to set your weapon down. Yeah. I'm afraid. And this whole thing's over. I'm afraid I'd have folded just like that agent. I don't know. I don't know. And I've been like son of a gun. What was I to do? I think I would have taken something that would have made me cause me like to have the runs and be like, I gotta go really bad. I wonder where I was said, this is gone far enough, man. Let me level with you. Yeah. I'm undercover and I'm the one with the gun. I wonder if that ram's hanging somewhere in like a court house or something. I'm sure the FWF is better. That's better. It's double trouble. They're all there standing out in front of a school. Yeah. It's like a university background. You need gas money to haul that sack around, man. Do you have taken three quarter time to pick up the haul that sack? All right. Anyways. That story is over. This is Clay Nukem and I've got some exciting news about a book that I've been working on for the last three years. It's called American Bear and it's available for pre-order now. The book is part biology, part American history, part personal memoir, but 100% the big story of American conservation. You'll learn about Native American ceremonialism with bear, the bear grease oil trade, market hunting and the reasons behind the unprecedented resurgence of the black bear in modern times. If you order American bear between November 9th and December 9th, you'll receive a sign by me, American bear postcard that you can put under the Christmas tree if you wanted to give this book as a gift. American bear is now available for pre-order at Americanbearbook.com and ships on February of the 9th. The postcard will ship right away. American Bear at Americanbearbook.com. Thank you so much. We're on to our news. The other day. Did you bring this up? Yeah, I was texting you about how I could have shot a bear, but I don't have a slug for my shotgun. Yeah. Nate was pointing out, he's outgrowing something and comes around to corner and there's just a bear standing there and there he is like some idiot like some idiot with nothing but a bird shot. He said if I had a slug, I'd have had a bear. I shared a story with him about him. I've always heard. I had always heard about but never experimented with what's called a cut shell. And I was explaining to him that I knew the concept of it even as a young man where you take a shot on shell and you take your pocket knife and you score the plastic right up ahead of the brass. Oh. I think my own man needs to talk about this. You score the plastic up ahead of the brass until you're almost through a girdle cut and you shoot and the whole damn thing comes out. So it doesn't open up the end of the shell. Yeah. You take the whole end of the shell with you. One day, me and my brother Dan are sitting in, we were not in my cup. I was brought up in Dalton Township. We were over in Lake Township, sitting on a place called Orange Lake, Duck Hunt. And we look up and here's a buck coming down the beach of the, coming down the shoreline of the marsh, heading right to us. It was deer season, not like Ayupa here. It was like legit deer season. And we start trying to very quickly fabricate a cut shell. But the deer before he got to his veered off and so we never like tested our cut shell. And I was sharing this story with Nate. And I said to this day, I don't know how well it actually works. And I, I think I was cutting back my tomatoes at the time, found it very unlikely that that was real. But YouTube heard me, the gods in the algorithm, and they fed me this video. Yeah. Check this out. Go ahead and play it. You'll see that he sounds like a villain from a cartoon. He's showing two shells and a cool look and shotgun. I was picturing the cut closer to the brass. Yes, right below the wide. Oh, so I was wrong there. Well, listen to the guy from it, usually for shooting birds or clay pigeons or whatever else. This is the same round, but it's cut all around here now. This is an old idea. It's kind of like a poor man slug. Yeah, the cut is almost halfway up. Yeah, so not at the brass, but below basically, he's cutting it at the wide. It's a one piece. This whole piece will fly out completely. Oh, no, he cut it all the way up. Yeah. Oh, we might not have got our buck anyway. Okay, so he's loading it in his short little shotgun. Yeah. Now he's putting a regular shoot a different way this way. I have some faith in it. Oh, listen, man. Wait till he gets down range. He's got a sweet shooting range thousands and thousands of tires. Small typical bird shot pattern. And it's the same bird shot. Wow. He does in one simple thing. Yeah, looks like a slug. And I think it's kind of get more perfect at this. Now, if you're wondering why, if you're irritated that we're talking over Boris there, Igor, it's because we have to or else we get in trouble with the YouTube gods. Yeah. You have to editorialize a video or else you get in trouble. Right. They can give and they can take away. Do you think that would penetrate a buck? We can just bought one of assumed his trajectory. Yes. That looks like what you would have been in our laps. What are they shooting? There's a riot. Just like a. Yeah, I feel like it would have that effect. We're like, real bad. I really want to do an experiment on this one. Oh, you know what? Let's do that. Let's just shoot some cut plugs and do a little cut shells and do a little experiment. I wonder how accurate you can get with them. I don't know. I mean, that didn't get 20 years. I was raised to know about it. I don't know how it was like part of what I was known knew about in high school. I had an opportunity. And then it just never came up again. So yeah, we should like do some ballistic jet. We still have some stuff laying around. We could find it. We should make some cut shells and do some ballistic gel test and see. Part of the problem, I think, is you'd want like a picture that you made that you took a tungsten round high brass tungsten. That's a whopper. Yeah. But if you're shooting some dove load, you know what's it really going to do? That's what we got. You can catch it. The baseball probably not a better ways out. You catch the baseball. Should I like freeze a ham off of a deer for this experiment? Would that be better to shoot than gel? I don't know. Do you really want that all like that? I don't know. I want to know the answer real bad. We should start with ballistic gel. All right. Talk to me out of it. Save the bone though. Maybe. Now we're talking scapula. I can go on the other side. All right. We ran our mode, our appeal for emoji designs. Your news. You know, if he goes by the drop, it's totally fine. The drops are so subtle. Well, you never wait for him. It's by design. People wrote in like a conspicuous absence of fishing emojis. People we were soliciting emojis because we're going to make what's called in the business a sticker package that you can just download and it'll be sweet emojis. Because I was lamenting that there's no tough titty emoji and that's the only emoji I would use to my kids. I would just send them that every time they ask you about something. And I'm like, no, they're like, but and I'd send them that emoji. So one I was wondering how you would make a tough titty emoji like what would it be if you were going to make it into what other emoji should exist. A lot of guys wrote in with tough titty emoji ideas that surround tough to the tough to tip mouse like a rosy the riveter body with a tough to tip mouse head. Yeah, basically, but I don't think I don't like that. It's to my kid isn't going to see that. And know what I mean by that. There were two Chris something more direct. Yeah, Kristen Nichols wrote in she said a cow or a cat tea squirting milk into a kitten's mouth. John Ren and Stimpy style. I don't like that. The zane wrote in and he said an old hand with saggy callus teats dragging on the ground. I like that. Yeah, that's kind of the direction. But I'm thinking a hog. The hog with saggy teats. Yeah. Well, I think of a tough titty. I'm thinking of a hog. Yeah, fair along. It's got to be something that you can you can understand what's going on in such a small little. So a guy was like, there should be an emoji of a hunter in a tree stand, which just means, hey, man, I'm a hunt. A tag soup emoji, a skunked emoji, like maybe just a skunk spring. I kind of like that. I like that. Hey, what happened this morning when you guys were out duck hunting. Right. Just sent him a skunk, spran. A big buck down emoji. He suggests a dead bleeding bark, but I don't know. It'd be a lot to fit into a little emoji. Yeah. I like the idea of a buck doing that high kick. Or a hunched up one busted, you got busted. So a dough stomper blowing. That's tough. A emoji of a bear shitting in the woods. It would be used as affirmative. Okay, because that's synonymous with affirmative. A strap of ducks. Main and yellow. Okay, we've limited out a misshot emoji. So you have a target with the arrow way off. Could be a useful emoji. And then there's a backpack with a hindquarter in it. Very few fish and emojis. So if you have things that you wish was an emoji, send them in and we're going to continue until we get about a dozen good emojis and then we'll make our emoji sticker package. Send in to the media podcast of the media.com. Okay, overspenser for the IUP buck entry. Now, this is a buck that for a minute was the country's biggest white tail bark. Yeah, when it was killed in the early 1990s, it was the world's biggest typical white tail. Because it didn't come on folks's radar until 30 years later, though, it now just has the title as the biggest buck in the United States. And we reported on it as being this newly found US record white tail. And now appropriately so there were a lot of red flags that I think were noticed by people as the story is being laid out. Because a feson hunter who says, I'm only a feson hunter. I don't know anything about these old deer kills, you know, a world class buck. It puts it in his basement for 30 years and an electrician finds it. And he's like, oh, that old thing. Yes, yeah. And so now we were answering some of those questions as to how that came to be. And maybe there's some nefarious things that happen. Yeah, yeah. Okay, so we're going to. We're going to hear the latest on this, but like officially. Well, here, yeah, where does buckle officially stand? I'm going to talk to Craig Mitchell, the Illinois Department of Game and Fisher DNR. They open up an investigation. They had a 36 page document that Craig has gone through. He's interviewed some other folks about this. He is closer to this story than maybe anybody in the world. So we're going to talk to Craig. All right. Tell you the way. All right, joining us on the line now is outdoor writer Craig Mitchell, he has been reporting on the Sam Ayupa buck that we covered on the new show last month. And Craig has some new developments to share for listeners who aren't familiar. Here's a real quick summary. Sam Ayupa is a hunter and Illinois who killed one of the world's biggest white tails in the early 90s. Nobody knew about it until 2023 when an electrician saw the bucket Sam's house. He encouraged Sam to get it scored and it wound up being the biggest typical white tail ever killed in the USA with a measurement just shy of 208 inches. But now some questions are being raised about the deer's validity and we have Craig here to talk about it. The first red flag Craig is a really big one did Sam Ayupa have a dear license in 1991 the year he claims to have killed it. Thanks big Spencer. I really appreciate you having me on. Just a kind of back pillow bed. I think it was Steve a couple of weeks ago when this first came delayed on meat eater news. He was even commenting that something smelled fishy and of course he was right to answer your question. It's it looks like he didn't. The 36 page DNR report that the Illinois Department of Resources put out basically says that they cannot verify that he didn't fact have a tag for 1991 the year that he put forth as the year he killed the buck. Okay. Now this is led to more issues regarding the day that he killed it unravel that forest, please. Yeah, this is the kind of this is what kind of really set this whole thing off into a high speed chase, if you will. In 19 sorry in 2023 Boone Crockett came out with an article about the buck in that article they highlighted a kill date of August 20 sorry November 28. When it took I guess two years for everything to be validated by Boone Crockett for the official record book and when they did. And their records now said that it was a kill date of November 1st. So I did a little bit of digging. And if you go back in the Illinois deer hunting regulations for 1991, there were only a handful of dates in which you could actually shoot a white tail with a firearm. And neither of those dates, November 1st or November 28, would have been within the legal season. And how did we line? How do we end up with those two dates, November 1, November 28th? There's very different answers to when the deer was killed. Brastically. And for the purposes of, you know, a legal harvest, it's the dip well. Both of them are constitute poaching, but I mean, the dates are everything. And basically, the November 1st date, essentially, after we, we, we, we, we, we, we, who in Croc, it's been very tightly, but about this whole thing. And what they were able to tell us was that November 1st was listed as essentially a placeholder date. Basically, they chalked it up and you find this in repeated interviews, interviews with James Martin, the antler collector. Everyone seems to repeat the same thing that, you know, he's 85, he's an old man, and his memory is not great, which, you know, fair enough. But even when the DNR officers presented him with this evidence about only November 15th, 16th and 17th being the legal days, none of which were the first or the 28th, he just commented or responded with, okay, all right. So even that is, there's a lot of things going on here. All right. The next red flag is regarding want and waste laws. What do we know about the meat from this book? I think, honestly, all dates and let's, let's just go with the assumption that he, for some reason, didn't remember the date, didn't remember the year. I think what really grinds my gears the most is the disrespect to the buck. The DNR records indicate, in fact, we have Sam Ayupa quoted as well as his mysterious hunting buddy, who was mentioned in the stories as well as the court that they just took the head and left the meat. And that was, it was literally as cold and calculated as that they didn't elaborate any further to quote them they left it. Yeah. That's, that's too bad and it's just another red flag in a series of many here about, did even have a license, it seems like the answers know, did he kill it in a legal gun season, also seems like the answers know, and we have, you know, direct quotes from him saying they did not take any of the beat. Now, in your reporting, you revert, you reviewed a 36 page document regarding an investigation that was done by the Illinois DNR. What was the conclusion of their report? Ultimately, the investigation focused on the hunting without a deer tag and want and waste. As I mentioned before, the historical deer records, I might not have, but the Illinois historical deer records, they couldn't find a deer license for 91, just 89 and 90, but not 91. So unfortunately, due to the time that has, you know, expired, it's been 30 years, the statute of limitations has expired. So, both their investigation, although the investigation identified significant discrepancies concerning the recorded harvest date, deer permit and post harvest handling, the wanting waste, the actual date and year of harvest could not be established. The investigation could not establish that the deer was lawfully harvested under the Illinois deer hunting regulations. So, in a nutshell, they confirmed that there was, in fact, wanting waste, a waste of medicine, and they couldn't also verify that it was harvested legally. Does that mean from their standpoint that this is over with, this investigation is done and there's not going to be any charges for Sam Ayupa? Correct, correct. Again, statute of limitations expired. I know the DNR was very, very interested in making sure things were set right, but unfortunately the law is what it is, and you know, that time has elapsed. Yeah, since these things have come to light, have we heard anything from the antler collector? Jamie Martin's a really nice guy. He was, you know, kind enough to respond and correspond with me quite a few times, but after I reached out with the final news, as well as notification of the meat eater article that came out last week, he's kind of gone quiet. So, I'm not sure what the status of the $30,000 rack is. I can't say that based on the DNR report, they were concerned about him being defrauded, but Jamie Martin infatically said that he felt really good about it. He had receipts for the purchase, but I mean, you got to feel bad for the guy for about two weeks there. He had the investment of a lifetime and yeah, what the status is for that now. Now, you also attempted to interview Sam for this story. How did that go? Not well. I'm kind of speak with him directly for the better part of three and a half years. Like you do to his age, his son also named Sam has been playing gatekeeper and fair enough. I don't know the specific argument situation these days, but what I did reach Sam Jr. His son, he immediately requested that I sign an NDA and on disclosure agreement in order to speak with him with the family. I immediately asked why that would be necessary about, you know, for a hunting and fishing story or a hunting story in this situation. And he just said, I'll get back to you. And that was the last thing I heard from him. Fortunately, though, I would be able to reach some other IU family members who have been more forthcoming with validating some of this information. Yeah, I think we're the only ones that Sam hasn't talked to at this point because he has a lot of quotes out there with other, other writers. Now, Boone and Crockett has been paying attention to all of this. What is their current stance on the deer? Unfortunately, you know, for Boone and Crockett, it's an organization's foundations dependent on accurate details and of course valid fair chase records. So I was surprised that they weren't more eager to investigate this. I mentioned, I reached out in 2023 when this first kind of peaked my interest. And they just basically gave me a carbon copy copy and pasted section of their fair chase rules. When I reached out again in 2024 and 2025 and kind of was prodding a little bit harder, they kind of just claimed up and continued even on the phone just to repeat it to me. We utilized the information provided in the affidavit. So even even two weeks ago, when I knew this was going live and I had the DNR documentation, I reached out again to try and get a quote and again they repeated the affidavit statements. But eventually they were, they did finally give us a comment and they said that we received the report from the DNR and we're following our procedures to review the information contained within that report, but there have been no updates since. Okay, so as of now, it is still recognized by Boone and Crockett as the biggest typical whitetail ever killed in the United States. As of right now, it is and you know what, considering with the statute of limitations being expired, personally, my personal opinion is the only justice that could be had is to revoke it from the record books. I mean, it violates their own fair chase guidelines and I'm confident that they'll do the right thing. Yeah, an interesting detail I saw in your most recent article about the Sam Ayupa buck was, you had saw in the 36 page report how Sam had asked the game warden or the detective, well, is my buck still going to be in the Illinois record books, he said something like that, correct. Absolutely, and it kind of paints a different picture from a guy that was quoted repeatedly is saying, you know, just a bird hunter, I don't care about dear, well, you know, first of all, just taking the antlers or the head as well as, you know, 30 years later. One of the few questions he asked was whether or not it was going to stay in the record books, you know, I don't buy it. Yeah, all right, in some new and some new reporting that you just wrapped up, and this is an article that is now live on the media.com, you talk about Sam's connection to the Chicago mob through his uncle, Joey, tell us about that uncle. This, this was the connection that blew my mind, so not only is his uncle, Joey, Joey Ayupa, a very, I mean, he works for Capone, I mean, he was one of the, at one time the head of the Chicago mafia, again, works for Capone back in the day, early in the day, in his career, he went by Joey, a bride didn't want to get this figured that an Italian sounding last name would close doors not open. But he was a boxer, he worked for Capone, protecting his prostitution and gambling, rapids, he was connected to everyone from Dillinger to some really influential murders. Now, the FBI were only able to associate with him, he was never convicted of it, but you know, Team Street, Alan Dorfman, Mafia boss Sam, Giancana, these are some big names in the mob world that he was, you know, those are just the ones that the FBI was able to connect him with. But I mean, documents just to give you an idea of who this guy was on multiple multiple FBI document documents, he is quoted as being one of the most ruthless killers and hoodlums in the Chicago area, so this wasn't, you know. some guy hanging out on a street corner. This was a, you know, mob leader in every way back to the world. And on top of all of that, he was an outdoorsman and his nickname was Doves. Tell us about how he got that moniker. Yeah, this is, again, a very interesting story. He loved the outdoors. Now, to quote his nephew, Nick, who I've spoke to, and I won't use the exact same verbiage, but he's an effing huge outdoorsman. He loved to fish, but he really loved to hunt. And he'd go all over the place fishing in Bimini, Dubs in Texas, Fesins in the Midwest, and of course, Dubs in Kansas, which is where the story comes from. So in 1962, Joey, as he often did, would go off into the woods to blow off some steam and often hide from law enforcement. And he went with a crew of guys to Kansas. When all was said and done, reports vary between 1,000 and 1,400 morning dubs were shot by this crew. The newspapers the time reported that they used auto loaders and shot them off of telephone lines and three limbs. And eventually when he pulled into his driveway, being such a big mobster, the cops were watching, and they basically nabbed him as soon as he pulled and he was driving with his wife. When they popped the trunk, they found 562 dubs. My goodness. The legal limit limit was only 24. So he ended up doing three months in jail and had to pay a few fine. But you know, the nickname stuck Joey does. Okay. One other great story you cover in your article is about Joey's link to the world record muskie. Tell us about that. Yeah, again, the story, what's Steve's famous phrase makes it on gravy. And again, it just gets deeper and deeper. But I'm sure a lot of your read. In fact, you guys have got a great article. The mediator does on the muskie, the muskie wars and and anyway, I'm sorry. And this world record muskie caught out of Wisconsin written by Pader and he did some great reporting on this. Thank you very much. That's a big inspiration for me, especially for this story. But the story goes, Joey Ayuku was hiding out in Wisconsin and he was hiding out from a congressional hearing. Now, not one to miss out on a hunting or fishing opportunity. He went down to the local Chippewa flowage, which was a restricted fishing zone, not that he cared. And the story goes, he caught this enormous fish, ended up putting a boulder to in its head and stalled it to Lewis Spray. Simply because he couldn't take credit for it if he was hiding from Congress. So he thought, you know, why not make 50 bucks? And he sold it to Lewis Spray, who was a unknown associate. He was in the ball with prohibition and bootlegging. And he was also a record chasing. So he knew that he could sell it to Lewis Spray and get away with it. Now, that story has not been 100% verified, but it has been verified by a few different individuals, including Spence Petros. His Ayupas fishing buddy, Pepsi Bonano, and as well recently his nephew, Nick Maechek, who also confirmed that his uncle did in fact actually for whatever. Okay. Those are some great details. Now, with all of that said, Craig, have you found any connection between the Mafia and the biggest typical white tail ever killed in the United States? I mean, it's important to say that the sins of the uncle are not that of the nephew. The Ayupa family certainly took care of their own. To give you a couple quick examples, Ayupa, before he went to jail, he was made famous in the movie Casino. So the famous Casino skimming scam of the late 80s, early 90s, he ended up going to jail for that. Before he did that, he put all his family, all his wealth, his property into something called Rosemar Realty, which was named after his mother, and all of his family members live in properties owned by Rosemar Realty. Not only the homes, but he is family, so the town hotel in Sistro, which was once Capone's hideout, which later became Joey Ayupas hideout. So brother Sam was listed as a secretary on the investment firm that owned that. So that would have been Sam Ayupas father. Story goes that he also owned the Yorkshire Quail Club, which Ayupa, Joey Ayupas wanted to keep a low profile. Supposedly used Sam Ayupas and his father's names to take out all the required hunting permits with the state of Indiana. Wow. So yeah, there's going to be a great piece on that with a lot more information. Obviously, you can check it out at themeditor.com. Okay. Last question here. You've been following this story closely. Is anybody in the world? So I want your take. Do you think the Sam Ayupas buck was poached? If it walks like a duck, cracks like a duck, it's probably a duck. I know it's corny, but in my opinion, Sam was out peasant hunting, got struck by buck fever in a one and a million chance, and he took it. Unfortunately, I don't think it was within the legal parameters, and I do believe that it was. Yeah, there's just, there's too many red flags that the deer sat in his basement for 30 years that, you know, it seems as though he didn't have a deer license. He the day he says he killed it wasn't within the season, didn't take any of the meat. It seems fairly caught and dry at this point, even if the Illinois DNR is not going to be writing a ticket for it. I agree. All right. You can read more of Craig's reporting at the meat eater.com has two most recent articles cover all of this in greater detail. Thank you for joining us, Craig. This is Clay Nukem, and I've got some exciting news about a book that I've been working on for the last three years. It's called American Bear, and it's available for pre-order now. You'll learn about Native American ceremonialism with bear, the bear grease oil trade, market hunting, and the reasons behind the unprecedented resurgence of the black bear in modern times. If you order American bear between November 9th and December 9th, you'll receive a sign by me American bear postcard that you could put under the Christmas tree if you wanted to give this book as a gift. American bear is now available for pre-order at American Bearbook.com and ships on February the 9th. American bear at American bearbook.com. Thank you so much. Thank you so much, Spencer. Take care. You too. Okay, Nate Mason. Oklahoma's CWD Resistant Deer Proposal. Man, tell me more. Glass Spring and Oklahoma let a pen raised white tail out into the wild on purpose without permission allegedly to fight CWD. And now the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife has written rules for future releases and the fine print is very, very interesting. Yeah, they put the headlines on this are like, Oklahoma, okay, is it to release CWD Resistant Deer? And then they kind of skipped all the part. Oh, contrary, we've covered this extensively as it's progressed. Our very own Jordan Sellers did a great right up at Meteor.com if you want even more background, but for those of you who haven't followed it, this is kind of a classic case of a state legislature attempting to use Serp control of wildlife management. And so I'll give you a quick rundown and then we'll get to these new rules that Department of Wildlife has proposed. Who's who? There's government agencies. Oklahoma legislature, it's your state house and senate. They passed the 2024 law that created this deer release program to fight CWD. And eventually they will vote on the Department of Wildlife's new rules in February. The Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conservation, which we'll just call the Department of Wildlife, is the state wildlife agency. It runs on hunting and fishing license sales plus federal Pittman Robertson, Dingle Johnson money. And there's no state tax dollars that fund them. It's run by the Oklahoma Wildlife Conservation Commission. Eight members appointed by the governor and staggered eight year terms. And then finally, the Department of Ag, Agriculture Food and Forestry, which we'll call the Department of Ag, is a state ag department and it regulates deer farms and captive deer and the legislature funds it with state tax dollars. This is all important. There's three main legislatures you want to know. Representative Nick Archer, he's written a lot of these bills that we've covered. And he would like to cut the Department of Wildlife out of this release program and give control to the Department of Ag. Representative Scott Fettgatter, he is a lame duck. He's until December and he's a representative and deer breeder who has pushed this deer breeding legislation. And then there's Representative Rusty Cornwell, who's also a deer breeder, but he has recused himself from the voting procedures ostensibly on moral rules, moral grounds. And that's the best I can tell. Rusty is like legit, like I shouldn't be involved in this. That sounds like, yeah, that he sounds like an interesting guy. Yeah, I'd like to talk to him to recuse himself. Yep. There's two lobbyists you need to know. There's white tails of Oklahoma, which is a nonprofit that promotes deer farming and hunting ranches in Oklahoma. It lobbied for and celebrated the Genetic Improvement Act. And that's headed by Chris Ezel, a longtime president, and he's also president of North American Deer Farmers Association, who's recently spoke against the Department of Wildlife Rules, which we're getting to. And then there's the Oklahoma Wildlife Management Association. - That might be a good guy to have on the show. - I'd be interested, he just retired as president. So maybe he'll talk. There's an advocacy group that advocates for preserves, hunting ranchers, captive deer breeders, folks on property rights and legal interest. The family that's intertwined there is the Brewster family. There's three generations of lobbying, both at the federal and state level. Bill Brewster was a former US congressman. He later lobbied for captive deer breeding. He did lobby for like international hunting rights and he's done some good stuff for hunters. And he also served as the OWDC or the Department of Wildlife Commissioner and he's a deer breeder. He died in 2022. Carol Brewster, his daughter has taken up the flag. She runs Brewsters and Associates, which is an Oklahoma City lobbying and PR firm. It's a registered lobbyist for the Department of Ag and her other clients include pharmaceutical companies. Finally, Dr. Chris Seabury, he's a researcher in Texas behind kind of the deer breeding program that we've talked about, the genetics behind how this could work. And Dr. Jennifer Malmberg, who's a researcher at USDA, National Wildlife Research Center, she modeled the population dynamics for the Oklahoma commission that proves or disproves if this could work. Okay, those are all the players. Quick timeline of how we got here. 2024 CWD Genetic Improvement Act, representative Nick Archer from before drove this. It started as a feral swine bill that I don't fully understand, but it was gutted and rewritten last minute to let captive deer that are allegedly resistant to CWD out into the wild. This was kind of a last minute change. It passed the legislator 69 to three and it caught wildlife groups pretty flat footed. They just didn't think it was going to happen. What this law does, it allows the release of captive deer bread to resist CWD that have the SS gene. So what is the SS gene? Briefly, CWD is a misfolded protein on the every deer carries called the pre-on protein. One spot in that protein gene, codon 96 comes in two versions GRS, most wild DRGG, deer with S copies, especially SS get infected less readily and the disease progresses more slowly. However, they still can get CWD, they will still die from it, they just have a resistance, not an immunity. This idea was modeled by Dr. Seaberry on sheep farmers who bred scraping out of their flocks, but it has never been tested in a wild herd. Fast forward to spring of 26, the Department of Ag released two deer in Wagner County. The Department of Wildlife was not involved, did not have input in the rollout and there's no information on how this happened. There's no tracking afterwards, there's no kind of follow up on how this is going to go. - Department of Ag to state or the fed? - Department of Ag is the state, but it's the organization that's funded by the state legislature and covers deer breeding does not cover the part wildlife. - Yeah, it's a real church and state division here between, like, and I get it, I understand the Department of Agriculture controlling deer breeders and facilities 'cause those deer aren't wildlife, they're livestock. - Exactly. - But, yeah, it's a weird one for them to then take their livestock and cut it loose into the, cut it loose into the purview into the responsibility area of the wildlife department. - And that's the way the laws are written right now, as convoluted as that may be, that's how it's written. - Yeah. - And after that release in, I think March of '26, they archer, represent an archer, try to pass another bill which would have moved the permitting authority from Department of Wildlife. So basically the authority to let those captive deer loose from wildlife to Department of Ag, which he controls the funding for and he has more sway over. Allegedly, his rationale was that the Department of Wildlife was moving too slow and they weren't following the mandate of the legislature. A coalition banded against it. This was led by Catherine Appling-Pooler of the NDA, who's contributed a lot to this. Oklahoma's five tribes all said no, the Oklahoma Wildlife Commission, which normally doesn't take positions on anything legislative, but publicly oppose this bill. And then hunters, the hunters calling their legislatures, they pushed against it. It still passed the House, but the bill died in the Senate in committee, which is crazy because the author of that Senate bill is the head of that committee and he still got shut down by his own committee, nine to three. So the Senate don't want it. Our stance, so all that in the past, is our stance has generally been as like meat eater. Is this isn't going to work and it's a cash grab by the deer industry. The math doesn't work on the population modeling. Dr. Moundberg mentioned before is laid out. They would even releasing 7,500 resistant deer in a year for 10 years would have no effect. - Can I clarify the thing? - Yeah. - I understand what you just said about, I don't know that it's a cash grab. Okay, I should say, let me clarify that. - My personal, I don't not speak for anybody else here. My personal view on it has been the point that you make right here. The state of Oklahoma is sitting on 750,000 deer. You cutting loose one, two, a dozen, a few thousand isn't gonna move, isn't gonna have a genetic impact. That would be a very, very, very slow play. It would require, it seems like centuries to play out. That's been my view. - Yeah, and I guess it's an extrapolation on my part that the only people who think this, who want to go forward with this right now, because the science doesn't exist, is lobbyists and people in the deer breeding industry. - Which is always confusing. - Right, and so, we'll get into the CWD denying conversation, but it's not like there's a bunch of researchers and hunters who say, yeah, go for this. We want it tomorrow, we want to run an experiment in the public trust herd. It's guys who have a vested interest in releasing 7,500 deer. - And then there's a point that's brought up by wildlife professionals, that if you take these SS deer, there could be other genetic differences with these deer, susceptibility to other diseases or behavioral differences, which kind of puts them in a weird position, 'cause on one hand they'll be like, well, that won't be effective. 'Cause you can't, it would take millennia or whatever, to change the genetic makeup of this population. So then you'd be like, okay, well, then also take millennia for any negative attributes that these deer carry to be integrated into the population. So it's kind of like a chicken or the egg, sort of thing, but people do point out that like, well, what else is weird about these deer? - Right, they've been created to have 300 interacts. What else is that beneficial for the wild? And that population study doesn't even factor in, maybe these guys, like maybe these bred deer suck at breeding. - Sure. - You don't know. - That's the thing people bring up. - And to your point, the two stakeholders I spoke to, down their Matt Gamble and Catherine Appling-Pooler, they said they're not dogmatically opposed to this idea. There's just no evidence that it works. And I'm not like, don't run an experiment on the people's deer, you know, run an experiment on your own deer, demonstrate that it works. And then we can find a way to study it and test it. - And as you go through this, I would like, I will share a couple more things because the scenarios that are acceptable for this, as you'll get into, when I look at those scenarios, I'm like, dude, try anything. But this takes us to where we're at right now. So thanks for bearing with me with a quick history lesson. The Department of Wildlife's proposed rules, because those two that were let out, they were very unhappy with that release 'cause they didn't have any oversight into it and it kind of snuck by. Here's a couple of the stipulations. The land to receive a permit to release these quote-unquote CWD-resistant deer that are bred by a captive deer industry. You have to have at least 1,000 contiguous acres, private, owned outright and entirely in Oklahoma. The releases are only allowed if harvest has fallen below 50% of the 10-year average. Or CWD prevalence is over 50% and the commission declares there's no normal deer population. Basically, the herd has to have already been wiped out. - That's a lot of fine print. - That's just the start. - It's amazing to keep, it's amazing that news organizations skip the fine print and just basically said, "Hey, they're gonna be cutting all these deer loose." Because these are very specific scenarios where you're allowed to do this. - Neighbors, you have to have written sign off in an affidavit from every landowner within three miles, which is roughly 1,800 acres. You can't be near a state line. And if you are, you have to get out of state landowners to sign off of it. Before you release your deer, you have to test that you have to have a live CWD test showing that it's not detected. because there's no such thing as a negative CWD test. And every deer, on every deer you release, and the deer must come from USDA certified herds. After that, you have to mark and track them, blaze orange ear tags in both ears, plus a USDA tag, a GPS collar may be required paid for by the landowner. You have to pay a $500 permanent fee, and then there's stipulations about when it goes on, testing afterwards, and the commission will review your permit. You gotta jump through a lot of hoops to release these deer. But it even goes on. Seems like it's impossible. Dose of any age bucks under 24 months. For five years after the release, for five years, every deer that dies or is killed on the property gets CWD and genetic testing paid for by the landowner. If you want to release these deer, you got to really want to release these deer. And the scenario is like in those scenarios, and I might come to regret this as I learn more about this. In a scenario where you're killing 50, the harvest is 50% of the 10-year average, and 50% of the deer have CWD, where I'm sitting at this moment right now, understanding what I understand. I would be like, please, that's Armageddon. I'd be like, please go ahead, go ahead. It's that bad. And as researchers point out, at 50% infection rates, it ain't getting better. So sure, I don't know. Maybe I'll regret saying that, but I would be like, right now, like I said, it's Armageddon. But I don't think that people are gonna be able to fulfill these obligations. - No way. - We'll see. - I would only wonder, is there a way around this, just like the guy sold the testicles, but he didn't sell him. He got $400 for gas money. Can somebody go cut captive deer loose and be like, those are my pets, or like, I don't know. They accidentally got loose. The gate was left open. - You'd have the same issue, 'cause they're managed by a livestock. You know, you'd have the same issue. - All these same things. - All of this, someone would be cute. - Consumably. - This wasn't for CWD. It was just the gate was left open, and-- - I don't think you'd end up making any money off it then. So I mean, if someone was like altruistic and really believed this work, then sure. But I'm not, my feeling, and this is just my feeling, I don't think anybody actually believes that. - Pleased what? - That this program will lower CWD. - They must believe it, or else they wouldn't do it. What is in it for them? - The expanding the captive deer industry. - It doesn't expand the captive deer industry. You're taking captive deer and making them wild. There, but they're buying this captive deer to go cut 'em loose all over the state. - The thing, when I was trying to think of what would be a motivation, if you were, if you were to, let's just say, that, well, first off, if you have a high fence captive deer place, that doesn't mean that you, that doesn't mean you don't care about CWD. A person is just a general deer enthusiast. Loves deer, and they happen to love 'em in offense as much as they love 'em outside of offense. I can't say that that person wouldn't believe, hmm, that's a good point. But here I have a thing that could help. And maybe it's a long shot. Maybe it doesn't make much sense. Maybe I just find a way to dismiss the math as people do in life. People that buy a lot of tickets are dismissive of the math. Like, they dismiss the math, and they feel like they're doing a positive by helping a bleagered population of deer that is stricken with CWD. But when I did search for, like, what would be a motive? Outside of wanting to help deer, I used to think it would be that you were taken giants, okay? That you're taken giants. And even though this also, if you went to a geneticist, like, this would also probably be ineffective. But like, you're taken giants and you're kind of goose in the local population. You might think you are. You might think you're turning loose these big giant stud bucks. And in all of a sudden, you're gonna have big giant stud bucks running around the local sanitary and stuff because all the deer are gonna get huge. I could picture a person thinking that. So that's what I used to think. But in this, you can't release them over 24 months anyways. So you're not even, you don't even have time to really confirm that he's some giant exceptional stud buck. And at the same time, if you have a giant exceptional stud buck, are you gonna let it go? So the whole motivation thing, I have a hard time calling into questioning the motivations 'cause I don't see what's in it form. I feel like it's just the normalization of the deer breeding industry. Yeah, if I put a totally cynical hat on. I wear a pretty cynical hat. I could put, and I have put this hat on. I could see that it would say that a deer breeder might see, here I've been over all these years. My community has been vilified. And this problem has been blamed on us. We've been treated as though we're the ones that are being reckless. And then here we are, quite ironic, isn't it? That we hold the key to solving this issue, which is our pet deer. That might feel like vindication to somebody, maybe. They're doing the Lord's work, maybe. But the motivation thing is, I would, we would have to get somebody in here who can talk about it. If you're one of those deer breeders, I'd love to talk to you. This guy might be the guy. - Reverend, I don't know if Rasty Cornwell. - No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. The guy that was the president of the, oh, Chris Ezel. - Maybe. - He might be doing a good job explaining it. I can't speak to the motivation thing. The most obvious motivation to me is that they wanna help the deer population out, maybe. - Right or wrong. I think that that seems to me the most likely thing, rather than it's some like Mach Abellion play, like I don't get what the play is. - You letting your deer go? - I got, I just wear a tinfoil hat all the time. All that to say, the legislature needs to pass us in February, 2027, whatever you think it is, right into your state representative, that down there in Oklahoma and tell them what you think. But to sum up, no one's released squat. - No. - That's a high bar, it's a lot of red tape. It's like, yeah, it's like someone handed the thing. You're like, here's the rule or here's the general thing. Like, it's okay now. You just need to make the rules and they go like, I'm gonna make a set of rules. It's like saying to your kid like, oh, no, no, no, you can go out of your friends tonight. You need to mow, weed the garden, clean the whole house. And then, like vacuum all the cars, call your grandma. - Call your grandma, call your grandma. - And then, feel free, yeah, feel free to go out. Okay, thanks everybody for joining the new show, we're tuning in next week for more breaking news and analysis at the meat eater podcast, the new show. Thanks for joining. (upbeat music) (upbeat music) - The best part of a whitetail sit is often the part you have to earn. The temperature drops, nothing's moving. In climbing down, start sounding pretty good. The difference between seeing it through and climbing down early is about heart, but it's also about heat. That's why first light built whispered down. With 900 fill power miscovy down, box bathful construction and quiet water resistant fabric, it delivers serious warmth without weighing you down. First light whispered down, pack light, stay longer. Check it out now at firstlight.com. - This is an iHeart podcast, guaranteed human.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. A Montana hunting guide, John Luton, was fined $20,000 and banned from commercial hunting for selling a big horn sheep nut sack for $400, highlighting a severe mismatch between the reward and legal risk in wildlife crimes.
  2. Jack "Jack Shoe Barf" operated a secretive breeding operation that illegally imported Marco Polo sheep genetics, bred hybrids, and sold semen to high-fenced shooting operations, particularly in Texas and Oklahoma.
  3. Jack’s operations included smuggling genetic material, forging documents, and breeding a pure Marco Polo sheep named "Montana Mountain King," which he sold to commercial hunters, raising ethical and ecological concerns.
  4. A hybrid sheep escaped from Jack’s ranch in Montana and remains unlocated after 60 days, prompting ongoing wildlife agency efforts to track it amid concerns over disease transmission.
  5. The case ties into broader wildlife crime patterns, where low financial rewards and high legal penalties reveal systemic issues in enforcement, particularly in cases involving private breeding and unauthorized genetic trade.
  6. A separate story involves Sam Ayupa’s alleged world record white-tailed deer, which faces serious doubt over legality due to missing hunting permits, unverified dates, and lack of meat processing—raising questions about fair chase and record validity.
  7. The Ayupa family’s ties to the Chicago mob, including connections to Joey Ayupa—a notorious mobster and outdoorsman—suggest possible deeper links between illegal activities and hunting practices.
  8. Oklahoma’s controversial plan to release CWD-resistant deer into the wild, backed by agricultural rather than wildlife authorities, reflects a conflict between state agencies and raises concerns about ecological risks and regulatory oversight.

Summary:

The podcast explores a series of interconnected wildlife-related controversies, from illegal breeding operations to questionable hunting practices and state-led wildlife management. A Montana guide, John Luton, faced a $20,000 fine for selling a big horn sheep nut sack for $400, underscoring the extreme imbalance between small financial gains and significant legal penalties in wildlife crimes. This case is linked to Jack "Jack Shoe Barf," who ran a secretive breeding operation, illegally importing Marco Polo sheep genetics, breeding hybrids, and selling semen to high-fenced hunting operations.

His activities include smuggling genetic material, forging documents, and breeding a pure Marco Polo sheep, which he later sold. A hybrid sheep escaped from his Montana ranch and remains unlocated, raising concerns over disease spread. The story also touches on the validity of Sam Ayupa’s world-record white-tailed deer, which is under scrutiny due to missing hunting permits, unverified dates, and lack of meat processing—key red flags for legal and ethical compliance.

Further, the Ayupa family’s ties to the Chicago mob, including a known mobster uncle, add a layer of intrigue to the narrative. In Oklahoma, a controversial plan to release CWD-resistant deer into the wild, championed by agricultural officials, faces backlash for lacking wildlife oversight, regulatory clarity, and ecological risk. These cases illustrate systemic issues in wildlife enforcement, including poor accountability, blurred lines between agriculture and conservation, and the need for stronger ethical and legal standards in hunting and breeding.

FAQs

The story highlights illegal breeding and trade of rare wildlife, such as Marco Polo sheep, involving genetic material and smuggling. It raises concerns about wildlife trafficking, disease transmission, and the ethical boundaries of breeding and selling animal parts for commercial gain.

Jack Shoe Barf began breeding exotic animals, including goats and sheep, in his Montana property. He illegally imported genetic material from Marco Polo sheep and used cloning to produce embryos, later selling semen to high-fenced shooting operations, which raised serious legal and ecological concerns.

Luton sold a nut sack from a trophy-sized big horn sheep for $400, which was later cited as a violation of wildlife laws. Although he claimed the money was for gas and delivery, the fine of $20,000 reflects a disproportionate penalty, highlighting concerns about low reward and high risk in wildlife crimes.

FWP investigated due to illegal breeding, smuggling of genetic material, disease risks (like pneumonia spreading from domestic livestock to wild deer), and the escape of a hybrid sheep with an FWP ear tag, which remains unlocated after 60 days.

Boone and Crockett still recognizes it as the largest, but investigations by the Illinois DNR found serious red flags—such as lack of a valid deer license, harvest dates outside legal seasons, and no meat being taken—raising doubts about its legitimacy.

The plan to release captive deer with the SS gene raises concerns about unproven efficacy, ecological disruption, and blurring state responsibilities between agriculture and wildlife management. Critics argue it lacks scientific validation and oversight.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.