Ep. 57 Does training until failure result in more gains? Let's find out!
from Barbell Machas
45m 27s
This episode explores the concept of training to failure in the context of muscle hypertrophy, clarifying the differences between technical, muscular, and task failures. The discussion emphasizes that muscular failure—when the primary muscle reaches its limit—is most important for stimulating growth, especially through the recruitment of high-threshold type 2 muscle fibers. Research indicates that both high- and low-load training to failure yield similar hypertrophy when volume is matched, but low-load training specifically relies on failure to activate the fibers with the greatest growth potential. The size principle explains why lighter loads require failure to recruit higher-threshold units, while heavy loads already recruit these units early, making failure less critical. For trained individuals, training close to failure becomes increasingly essential to maximize hypertrophy. However, this approach must be adapted for beginners and older adults due to safety and injury risks. The episode also highlights that hypertrophy relies on mechanical tension and metabolic stress, not just failure, and advocates for a balanced training approach that combines moderate-to-heavy loads to maximize muscle growth while protecting joints. Ultimately, training to failure is not a one-size-fits-all strategy; it should be tailored to individual experience, goals, and health status, with best practice emphasizing volume, proper load selection, and progression over time.
Hey guys, Dr. Arvin here, Luke Lango here and you are listening to "Bubble Mataan!"
So I hope you guys heard our previous episode whereby I talked about
Covid and if you're test positive and how do you get back to physical activity and
things to be done if you're vaccinated and how do you get back to physical activity,
I know it's quite a lengthy one. Luke was complaining. But you know like everything that I do look,
I always have a tendency to explain what I'm talking about because I don't think
people should be blindsided with the correct information. I don't want to just give you a statement
telling you like this is what you should follow and that's it. I want you to be able to understand
why I'm where I'm coming from. Yeah and and I have nothing wrong with that. In fact, I don't think so.
I think if you guys had the episode you didn't hear much of me speak because I was actually just
generally like oh okay because I was also listening as well trying to gather information
like so that I too can be able to pass it on to people who ask me questions in my DMs as well.
Yeah and yeah basically we want we want to make sure that you guys out there listening get the
best content, the best structure. We don't want to bore you. We want to make things interesting.
We want to make things educational. We just want this episode. They want this like entire
podcast to resonate with our audience in any meaningful way. Yeah. All right. Okay, let's get back
to the episode today. So today I'm going to talk about trained failure. Now this is much
relation to our hypertrophy series. Okay, so I'm just continuing the the continuum of hypertrophy
series. Yeah. Okay, so this is one of the things that is going to be important to talk about
training to failure whether training to failure is important or not. Okay, now what is training
to failure? Training to failure is basically what happens to a muscle, muscle goes to failure which refers
to the point at which the strength training set at which you can no longer perform a set with proper
technical proficiency. There are different types of failures, right? Yeah, there's different kind of
failure but this is we're talking about technical failure. Technical failure. Okay, so so you're
so if you have a predetermined range of motion, basically you're not cutting short the range of
motion beyond like a certain percentage or the technique that you're using is not going off.
Okay, so before we move on from there, are you going to explain the types of failure? I mean,
just to give people a little bit of context like technical, mechanical, so people know what you're
referring to. Okay, yeah, I'm not going to but since you asked, I will. Okay, so when we're talking
about technical failure per se, we're talking about range of motion and the technique you're using
for that particular exercise. Okay, now when you're talking about mechanical failure, it could be
for multiple reasons. Okay, so that's why you have things like a drop set which is just dropping the
loads and there's a mechanical drop set whereby you change the dynamics or the movement pattern of
your hands. So let's say we're doing a lateral raise. Instead of your hands out wide, you're bringing
your hands in is to reduce the mechanical disadvantage. Okay, and you can continue with the same load but
because the mechanical disadvantage is reduced, you're you're actually doing somewhat of a mechanical
drop set. Okay, so that means you have a shorter arm span. So it's easier to perform the lateral
raise with the same load. So this is also a form of failure because you can't put your hands out wide
anymore and you bring it closer. Okay, so that is actually a mechanical drop set. So there's a
mechanical failure as well. Now, most people use these terms interchangeably like mechanical fails
in technical failure. But just to be clear, there's what it means. The other thing that you can actually
have is a task failure. Now, task failure depends where you read or what you read much like an OTS.
So the semantics can be different based on who is talking about it. Now, when it comes to hypertrophy,
I prefer to use these two terms when it comes to failure which is task failure versus muscular failure.
Now to make it clear when I say muscular failure, we're talking with the primary muscle. So we're talking
about say squats. Okay, squats. Yeah, so a bicycle or no, easier is a row. Okay, let's say a
row, for instance. So if you're doing a bent over above a row, the muscle you're trying to work
on is say at this point, the rhombods and metraps. Okay, now, if the rhombods and metraps fail during
the academy, you can't do a pull anymore because the rhombods and metraps can't retract the scapula
anymore. That is termed as a muscular failure. If you're doing a Bulgarian split squat, your quads
just can't do another extension. That is a muscular failure period. Now, what is the difference with that
and task failure is when you're doing a bubble row, the one that fails is your grip and not the muscle
that you're working on. That is a task failure. When you're doing Bulgarian split squats, you can hold
the dumbbell anymore and you stop because of that, that is a task failure. Okay, so when we're talking
about hypertrophy, the most important thing that we want, we want to achieve is getting the muscle
closer to failure and not stopping the exercise because of task failure. If you're hearing ambulance
behind us, it's because ambulance are moving, I think. Yeah, on a daily basis, I will see at least
five ambulances driving with me when I'm walking into work. Okay, COVID season. Anyway, yeah, so that's
that. So when you're talking about hypertrophy, it is important to keep in mind that whatever exercise
you choose should be towards achieving muscular failure. Okay, that means, so that's why when the
debate goes on like, oh, squat is the king of exercises, squat is the best leg developer and then comes
look, lingo and says, no, I can do it with hex squats, I can do it with leg press. And the
floor is like, no, but squats is the king of exercises. And you're like, no, with hex squats, I can
take the muscle to them failure with leg presses. I can do an extra five reps without worrying my back
crumbling. Okay, that is the difference because with machine-based exercises, I'm not saying that
freeway exercises are bad, they are fantastic for hypertrophy. But when you add certain machine-based
sizes or certain assisted exercises, you can really throttle the muscle towards failure and not be
stopped by a task failure. So what is the problem with like things like squats? It's like instead of
your quads feeling fatigue, you stop because your back feels fatigue or your shoulders can take it
anymore. Okay, yeah, and don't don't believe someone when it says like, oh, when I squat, I only use my
quads and I I move my body, I adjust my body in such a way that I use my quads. No, no, no, no, no,
don't go shit. Yeah, you're not squatting enough. Yeah, don't try to pull some story out of your ass
and then tell me that, oh, I use my quads because I don't fully lock out at the top, I keep my knees
bent, my ankle, my ankle here, my torso here, my degrees here, the sun and moon aligned in one side.
That's how I use my quads more, I'm sure. Yeah, so yeah, so when even when I talk to
you with my hypertrophy seminars, this is one of the things I want to highlight, it's like you have
to make decisions based on what you want to achieve. Don't be emotionally biased with the exercise
simply because you have some feelings for it, okay. If you tell me bendable bubble rolls are the
best for back, because I will tell you a tea bar with a chest support is better simply because
I can really smash my back without worrying of my low back giving way or my hamstring feeling fatigue
because of holding the position. That kind of thing. So I'm not saying that bubble rolls are bad,
I'm just saying that probably there are other ways you can also achieve the same thing, okay. Now,
you will see that many grades will use the best of both worlds. If you look at Tom Platt's, he does
haxquads are crazy, okay. They do CC squats and so on and so forth. The haxquads is a great exercise
to build your quads because you can smash those quads, okay. So those are things that you have to
understand the difference between a task failure and a mask failure. If you need to wrap, use wraps
in order for your, the bar to stay on your hands longer, do it because the target here is hypertrophy.
Not whether you can do bubble rolls and hold the bar longer. It's different if you're a power
lifter. Powerlifting, you cannot use wraps during the competition. So it makes sense that you train
deadlifts without wraps because you want your grip to be that strong. It's important because if
you can't lift because your grip is weak and not because your hands are glued or back are weak,
then you are failing the exercise because of something that could be also fixed, all right. So it's
a bit different in that way. So when we train the failure, right. I think you mean straps, right?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So for you, those are the listening wrist wraps and wrist wraps is very different.
It is a strap strap. This one I'm putting you not going to the gym for two months. So straps
is what you see most people who wrap a piece of material around their wrists and then around the bar.
Yeah. A wrist wraps is something they wrap around just their wrists to provide support.
Correct, correct, correct. Thanks for correcting. Even I didn't catch that. Yeah, all right.
Anyway, yeah. So, so many, we're talking about training the failure, right?
This is something that I came across when I was reading like many of frontels articles as well.
Training the failure becomes increasingly important if you're using lighter loads compared to heavier loads.
Okay, let that sink in a bit because when you're using heavier loads, chances of you recruiting
higher threshold motor units are much higher from the get go. Say you're using an 80% one RM,
which is probably an eight wrap max, okay? Chances are by the time you hit your third wrap,
you're capped out already. You already recruited every fiber that is, okay? At this point,
what is increasing is just the signal strength, okay? So the chances of you achieving similar
hypertrophy to someone who's training to failure using the same load, say 80%, you train to failure,
I train to two reps from failure. The difference between our hypertrophy might not even exist.
Okay? Now this is different compared to someone who is training with 40% 100 max versus
you who is training 80% 100 max. If that person doesn't train to failure, chances are
they will not get any hypertrophy or very, very little hypertrophy compared to you.
So what are the difference here? This is a hand-man size principle. If you have never heard
it, you're going to hear it for the first time. I should have spoken about it many
times actually. So hand-man size principle tells you that whenever you're actually recruiting
the muscle fibers, it's always going to recruit from the lower trachomeo to units, the higher
trachomeo to units, depending on which loads you choose. If you're a person who's
going to train with lighter loads, say you're doing a rehabilitation, you only can work
with 30% 40% 100 max, chances are you're going to use lower trachomeo to units first.
And lower trachomeo to units governs or controls type 1 fibers mostly. They are more aerobic
fibers. They are more fatigue resistant fibers. They're more mitochondrial-based fibers.
So they don't have much hypertrophic potential. They do, but very, very little. It's the bigger
guys, the bigger higher trachomeo to units, type 2 fibers, type 2A fibers and type 2X fibers,
which has the most potential to hypertrophy. So when you're talking about hypertrophy,
you need to go to that zone. You need to bring the muscle to that zone. You need to bring
a recruitment to that zone. You need to develop enough tension to bring your training to
that zone. So when you're using lighter loads, it's going to take more reps for you to
reach that. I will talk about a couple of reasons that was done to prove this particular
concept. So therefore performing resistance training exercises sets to momentary muscular
failure. It's thought to be necessary to recruit all possible motor units. I hope that
is understood. Now, the question at hand is, is there a difference between train people
and untrained people? It's something I'll talk about in a bit. So what causes a muscle
to go to failure? Fatigue. Whenever you're reaching any kind of technical failure for
a particular load, you're reaching fatigue for that particular load, or you're reaching
difficulty to do that particular load. As the fatigue increases, recruitment maxes out,
contraction speed reduces, mechanical tension reaches its upper limits for a particular
load. So that's what causes a muscle to go to failure. This technical failure, I'm
not talking about your muscles ripping or tearing and those kind of things. Now, do you reach
muscular failure at the similar points for a particular weight for a particular weight
all the time? Not necessarily. That means if you could do 100 kilos for 10 reps today,
will you do 10 reps the next time you come? There are many confounding factors when it comes
to how we feel or how we perform on a particular day. Whether you fought with your girlfriend
or was work longer. Under your sleep terrible and so on. A lot of things can actually confirm.
Basically, when you are testing your 10 reps max, it's hopefully done in the period where
you were the fittest or the best to perform it. It's not necessary that you will perform
at the same level every day, but you will perform in that same region almost every day.
It means you might get 9 reps one day, you might get 11 on a better day and so on. So yeah,
so it depends on which set you're doing. If you're doing set number one, you're not
necessarily going to get 10 reps on set number five. You might get 9 or 8. That's where
auto-regulation comes in. How long within sets you're resting? Are you resting a minute?
Are you resting three minutes? Are you resting five minutes? The longer you rest, the better
you recover is the possibility to have constant amount of repetitions from set to set increases.
So yeah, you so you will not reach same amount of failure from set to set based on even the
rest periods. We have seen that in studies. That's called as rap decay. Whether it is your
first or your last workout. Are you talking about your first workout? Are you talking about
the fifth workout of your day? The amount of fatigue you have accrued along the way with
other workouts could actually cause this workout for you to get lesser repetitions. So if
you put your benches, your last exercise instead of your first, chance of you getting 10
reps 100 kilos is probably going to reduce. Probably going to get 8. So that's another thing.
And how much systemic fatigue have you accrued? Which training session is the fifth training
session of the week? Are you ramping up your fatigue? Is all your training really that
hard and so forth? A lot of things are taken into account because it is not just that straight
forward. Okay. So whatever judgment you do is based on that. So so not all failures are
treated equally. Okay. So as I as we discussed earlier and look broader the question. So it's
all primed must all failures are primary muscle related. No, task fillers are more to supporting
muscle failures. And technical failures are muscle failure is more related to the muscle
at hand or the primary muscle. So what actually happens when the muscle is fatigue? Higher
threshold motor units are recruited earlier. Basically when your muscles are starting to get
fatigue, your chances of recruiting higher threshold motor units from the very start or
earlier increases. But how does it make sense is save you're doing a set of 25 repetitions
and you took all sets to almost failure. Okay. So you're doing four sets of say 25 repetition
laterals. For instance, okay. So the first set you probably can get 25 repetitions say
23 repetitions say two reps from failure. Your second set you might not be able to get
23 repetitions because that first set was already metabolically fatiguing. You're creating
a lot of lactate, a lot of hydrogen, a lot of phosphates and so on. So that that particular
fatigue because of metabolic metabolites and also the calcium sensitivity and so on so
forth. Okay. It's it's far more detailed than that. Okay. Basically you're developing
some fatigue. It causes your body to actually reach higher threshold motor units a lot earlier.
Maybe from the on the 20th wrap, you're already there already. Okay. And as the as the sets
progress, chances are if your if your respirers are really short as well, your fatigue levels
increasing. So the need to bring in the higher threshold motor units earlier becomes evidently
more possible. Okay. So that's something that can happen because the amount of five, amount
of force that a fiber can produce when it's fatigue starts reducing when you are you're
reaching a higher level of fatigue. Okay. So this is actually one of the reasons why we get injured.
If you watch a football game, most of the hamstring injuries don't happen on the first minute.
It happens maybe about the 48 minute of a half or after the 70th minute of the second half.
Okay. Simply because they're fatigue. So that means the possibility of that muscle to produce
force or to lengthen eccentric force to be produced at that point when the fatigue is reducing.
And when you expect it to act the way it was in the first minute, chances are you going to tear
the muscle. Okay. That's why injuries happens later in a half because of fatigue. Okay. So
if I hope that makes sense. So the central nervous system has to ramp up signals in order to produce
the same amount of force. Okay. So if say it was going at 60% CNS hm potentials in order for you to
lift 100 kilos on your fourth set or your fifth set, it has to ramp up maybe to 80% of signals going
down in order for you to lift 100 kilos for 10 reps because fatigue is coming in the way.
So each muscle fiber has lesser potential to produce higher amount of force because of fatigue.
Again, it's not so straightforward but it's one of the reasons why fatigue causes higher recruitment
early on. Okay. So that's actually the reason why metabolic sets or how metabolic sets work.
So it's a good way to bring in higher threshold mode units when you're training. Okay. So as we know
that there are three two main reasons for why hypertrophy happens. Mechanical tension and metabolic stress.
Massage damage is questionable at this point. Okay. So these two ways are how we actually train to achieve
hypertrophy and if you're using the metabolic way to actually train, you are also going to develop a
lot of mechanical tension by just towards the end of the set. All right. So when it comes to hypertrophy,
there's some caveats that needs to be met. Okay. Number one is recruiting as much higher threshold
mode to units as possible. Okay. Listen to this part because this part is important. Okay. So recruiting
as much higher threshold mode to units as possible. There are particularly units. These are particularly
units that involve the type two muscle fibers and that have the highest potential for hypertrophy.
The next caveat is you must achieve high levels of mechanical tension. Okay. So this is not necessarily
low dependent as fatigue increases mechanical tension experience by each muscle fiber. Fibers also
increases faster. Okay. So it is important to understand you can reach mechanical tension in two
ways. Number one is metabolic stress. Number two is just using heavy loads. Okay. So now the question
is in that case, if I was doing a clean injure, can I hypertrophy from that? Yes, you can but not
to the point where someone who is doing a traditional shoulder press or a deadlift will. Okay. Why?
Because the point of a clean injure is to move the bar as fast as possible. Now if you have seen
the force velocity curve, okay. Power movement is somewhere in between. Okay. When speed is high,
the amount of force produced is low, but recruitment is high. Okay. Because the perceived effort for you
to lift that bar is extremely high, because you're going to pull that bar with all your might. Okay.
So the brain will create a high signal to clear that bar. Okay. So the recruitment is going to be
super high, but each fiber will not be able or will not produce as much tension as someone who's doing
a traditional deadlift. Okay. Because you're not moving the bar over a second, you're moving the
bar over five seconds. So you're more time for recruitment. When you're more time for recruitment,
you're more time for tension develop. So you can clear more
So, if you see, if you watch any weight lifter,
there are clean and jerk weight versus their deadlift weight.
It's different, probably by 60-70%, okay?
So, if you see that the clean and jerk is say 70 kilos,
their deadlift is probably about 100, okay?
So, it's because of that.
Because those recruitment is high,
they can't produce much force.
So, you have to reduce the weight.
So, when the question is asked,
can you hypertrophy from power, from like explosive movements?
Yes, you can, but the amount you can hypertrophy
is not going to be as high as someone who's doing traditional training.
I hope that's understood.
So, two of these caveats have to be met.
Mechanical tension and recruitment.
Not necessary to have high mechanical tension with higher recruitment,
but if you have high mechanical tension, you have definitely higher recruitment.
Okay? So, yeah.
So, let's go down to what the research says.
Okay? So, there are a couple of papers that I've talked about,
whether you need to train the failure or not, okay?
And it depends whether you're trained, untrained,
and set the same host of studies were done in males.
Okay?
And most studies were done in younger population.
So, we don't have much about a adolescence.
We don't have much about the late 40s people who are elderly.
So, we are making a lot of assumptions.
Based on some of the studies you have done,
whether you will apply to someone who's 60 years old.
You're training a 60-year-old auntie.
Will you still have a training to failure?
Chances are no.
Okay?
But we don't have enough research to back that up.
So, we are making a decision based on best practice.
But isn't like training to failure relative?
It is. It is.
It's relative.
But you get it now.
See, if a 60-year-old lady, will you train her to 100 from failure?
Just because you want to hypertrophy her.
You get it now.
So, are you sure that the dorms that you will experience after that will be so bad
that it will affect her daily living?
Which is more important, you know?
So, the practice that you use with these people
will be different than training a 30-year-old or 20-year-old.
They probably will be able to deal with dorms and so on and so forth.
It does really affect the activity.
So, we have to use a little bit of best sense.
Yeah, also mainly because once your elderly people in their 60s
all have already existing conditions like sarcopenia,
the reduction in loss of muscle, osteoporosis, osteopenia,
And not only that, they also have things like degenerative tissues,
digestive tendon, degenerative ligaments, you know, like meniscus and so on and so forth.
So, it's not going to be just that straightforward with them.
Yeah, it's not.
Yeah, you can train them to failure, but they end up with some meniscus injury after that.
Because of that.
Because of that.
A lot of things has to be considered.
So, what I'm saying right now is best practice based on fit individuals.
Okay.
Healthy individuals.
Yeah, so it's difficult for me to start targeting each population that's around there.
But so, using your best knowledge with those people is important.
You know, if someone is obese and training for the first time,
for the first six months, do you train them to failure?
Do you think that's the best practice?
Get it now.
So, they come back with the next session.
You know, those are the things you want to ask.
Compared to training me and look.
You know, we are different.
We are geared different.
Those kind of things.
So, those are the things we are thinking about.
Okay.
So, let's talk about what research is right now.
So, I'm not going to go back to like the 1980s research and what Kramer did and so on.
So, for the 1990s research and so on.
I'm going to come up with something which was a bit more earlier.
I mean, recent.
Sorry.
So, so, let's obvious.
I did a, I hope I said the name right.
Less VCS.
How do you spell it?
L-A-S-E-V-I-C-I-U-S.
They had to make his name difficult.
Yeah, his name is Thiago.
So, I'm going to say Thiago less.
You should just say Thiago less.
No, but you know, in paper, you have to use the last name first.
So, when you say at all, it's always the last name at all.
This is his first name.
It's also equally as unique as his last name.
It's okay.
So, so, in 2019, the people was released in General Strength and Conditioning.
So, what they did was, they wanted to answer this question whether you need to train to failure or not.
Okay.
Take in hand that these were untrained individuals.
Basically, they are physically active but they are not resistant trained.
Okay.
So, they took 32 untrained males, divide them into four groups.
Basically, it's four limbs.
Okay.
So, when we're talking about some studies, we're not using the person.
We're using the limb.
Basically, your right is versus your left.
Okay.
So, if you're in the high, high load group, your left will say do high load to failure.
The right will do high load to not to failure.
Okay.
So, basically, it's limbs.
Hope you guys understand that.
It's weird, I know.
So, four groups.
Four groups of limbs.
But these 32 injured divided into two groups.
So, 16 in one group.
Okay. So, that's the confusing part.
So, these 32 individuals were divided into two groups.
Yeah.
Either you're a high load group or your low load group.
In high load group.
High load group.
Or low load group.
Or low load group.
Yeah.
So, if you're in the high load group, you say we're doing extensions here.
So, it's the right leg extension versus the left leg extension.
Okay.
So, the right limb is going to be trained to fail.
The left limb is not going to be trained to fail.
And this applies for the upper limbs as well.
I know.
They're basically training on leg extensions.
Oh, so there's no-
There's this protocol using leg extensions.
Okay. So, this, okay.
Okay.
So, there are going to be two groups.
And each group is subdivided into two more groups.
So, hence why you have four groups.
So, there's high load, trained to failure.
High load did not train to failure.
There's low load trained to failure.
And low load did not train to failure.
Okay.
And that's it.
Okay. So, the low load group did 30% on an arm.
The high load group did 80% on an arm.
Okay.
Now, the group that did not train to failure.
Did 60% of the repetition.
The group-
The limb that did to failure.
So, if I did 10 reps for leg extension on the right leg.
I only did six reps for the left leg.
Okay.
Same load.
Just number of repetitions were different.
Okay.
So, they used 60% as a-
As a not training to failure.
Okay.
Okay.
Now, so, in order to make it-
To reduce the confounding factors, they even matched the volume.
They made-
If the right leg did three sets, the left leg had to do five sets.
In order to match the number of-
Yeah.
The ultimate and yeah.
Number of repetitions done-
Yeah.
All together.
Okay.
So, they-
The volume was equated in here.
Yes.
Volume was equated.
And just trying to-
I'm worried if I just say volume was equated-
Well, understand what the hell is volume is equated.
Yeah.
So, when volume is equated, basically you're matching the sets and repetitions.
Okay.
So, if I did three sets of 10 repetitions on the right leg which trained to failure.
The left leg had to do five sets of six repetitions.
Yeah.
So, it all ends up being 30.
30.
Yeah.
The volume is equated.
Yeah.
Okay.
So, volume was equated in this study.
Okay.
So, it's an eight-week protocol.
And they wanted to see how much a hypertrophy was attained.
And how much of strength was attained.
Okay.
So, the strength part is going to shock some of you.
Okay.
But, this is where the direction of the evidence is moving.
Okay.
Now, the group that trained with high-road-
High-load training to failure.
High-load did not train to failure.
And low-load that trained to failure.
All had similar hypertrophy.
And we have said this before.
If you picked a load between 30% to 85% 100 max.
If you trained it close to failure, you will gain similar hypertrophy.
Okay.
So, would you say that. So, would you say that's like the highlight of your episode?
Yeah.
Okay, good.
Good, then.
No, I mean, that's a good one.
And kudos to you for simplifying that equated thing.
Yeah.
That's like, ask you pointed out like, "Could you explain what equated means?"
Yeah.
Not bad.
Looks like Dr. Arvind is actually finally becoming more and more easier
with his complex terms and layman terms.
All right.
So, the group that actually did. The first three groups, besides the group that did low-load with not failure.
Okay.
All had about hypertrophy, but six to seven centimeters squared.
Of cross-section area.
Yeah, cross-section area of increasing the quads.
Okay.
Six to seven.
So, the group that did not train the failure with low-loads, which only had two.
Oh, okay.
So, there's almost three to four times more.
Yeah.
Okay, on average.
Okay.
So, you can see that the vast difference.
But you see the group that did low-load by train the failure.
They had almost similar to the group that trained high-load.
Okay.
Now. So, I will explain about that later.
Stop more details of later.
And the one RM increment were definitely predominant in the group that did high-load.
But what's more interesting is, the group that did not train the failure
had similar one RM improvement as the group that trained the failure.
So. So. When it comes to hypertrophy, it has been said that training the failure is important.
Training. But when you're using high loads, I'm talking about 80% 100 max.
Your recruitment is already high from the get-go.
Okay.
So, when you volume equated, okay.
When you volume equated, chances are you're going to gain same amount of hypertrophy in the end.
Okay.
That means you have to do five sets.
You know, you cannot just stop at three sets.
Six repetitions on three sets, then definitely. If they didn't volume equate, chances are the group that trained the failure probably had more hypertrophy.
Okay.
But because they volume equated and we know that volume is one of the most important determinants of hypertrophy.
Okay.
The effect was the same.
Okay.
Okay.
So, with high load training, it is not really important to train the failure as long as the volume is equated.
Okay. But when it comes to low load training, it is a must to train to close to failure or to failure.
Okay.
In this study, the training really far from failure, which is 60% 100 max.
So, why did I say close to failure?
So, Nobrager had already studied in 2018 and found that despite you training the failure or not to failure,
with low loads of high loads, you will get similar hypertrophy.
But the difference in this protocol was, they did use 30% and 80% 100 max for the low load and high load.
but the difference was the group that did not train the failure stopped
about 1 or 2 reps. saya atau felia. Bersiapnya mereka pergi ke tempat. jika saya bawa kata-kata, saya bawa kata-kata. dan awak buat 10 repetitian, awak takkan. tidak berkata, awak nak berkata, mereka berkata. dia berkata, "Apa berkata, kita berkata. sebab mereka tahu awak dah berkata. dia berkata, "Apa berkata, "Apa berkata, "Apa berkata. dia berkata, di dalam kelihatan.
Jadi, itu jika mereka tahu. it wasn't actually training to
feel that that was the only way
to get a hypertrophy training.
Close to failure actually gets you to
similar hypertrophy regardless of whether
you use high loads or low loads.
So that's why in that study
both groups are all four groups
in that particular study, all achieved
similar hypertrophy.
As compared to a Thiago study.
In Thiago study, 60% is really far off.
ia sangat cepat.
So, a group that did. Even if it's volume-equated,
with low lows, they did volume-equated.
They did. Fundamentally, second, the group that did fail,
they did 34 repetitions,
the group that did not train the failed,
did 19 repetitions,
but did five sets instead.
Despite being volume-equated,
it still did not get enough hypertrophy.
You know why?
Hanuman-size principle.
Because when you train so far away from failure,
which is 60%,. saya hanya tak dapat memakai kemungkinan. dia memakai kemungkinan yang mencari. dia mungkin memakai kemungkinan yang mencari. Mungkin, anda boleh just like a refresher
untuk people listening out there.
Type 1 dan Type 2.
Okay, so Type 1 fibus,
okay, to be simple,
there are two types of fibres
in two types of skeleton muscle fibres in our body.
Okay.
So, when you talk about skeleton muscle fibres,
you're talking about the muscles that are attached
like your quads and your biceps and so on and so forth.
Okay, so Type 1 fibres are
very aerobic dominant fibres.
Basically, they are very good with oxygen.
They require oxygen to function.
They are very strong on using fats
dan kemudian lelaki.
Dan kemudian lelaki.
Dan kemudian lelaki.
Dan kemudian lelaki.
So anyway, yeah. So there's type 1 fibres, they're very very oxygen-dependent.
So type 2 fibres, there essentially, we talk about 2 types.
And especially more than, there's subtypes in here.
Okay, so there's 2A and 2X, okay?
So the majority of the fibres that we actually possess after we start training is 2A.
Because 2X, it's very strong.
It's very high threshold motor units, but it's super easily fatigable, okay?
Jadi maksudnya, tetapi semua maksudnya cakap dengan perlukan.
So basically type 2x has very poor fatigue resistance.
Ya, so what happens if the body is,
whenever you start training, the body actually shifts the type 2x to type 2a.
Okay?
So type 2a fibers are more fatigue resistant.
They are more glycolytic and creating based muscles.
They are very strong muscle fibers as well.
They are very high-trashable motorion as well.
And both these type 2 fibers have very high potential for hypertrophy.
So that is a different type.
One fibres don't have as much potential phypertrophy,
but they are good long lasting muscles
for mostly like postural work and so on.
Okay, so your postural muscles
which are maintaining your posture like your soleus
is 80% type one fibres
because in order for you to send upright
you need your soleus to work
like day in day out,
every hour, every minute.
Unless you're sleeping.
Okay.
So as compared to your gastrocnomies
which helps you jump and leap and those kind of things.
Okay.
So those are the difference between those two fibres.
Okay.
so when we're talking about hypertrophy, we're talking about triggering type 2 fibers
you need to get to the higher threshold motor units
so
so that was the two studies that I thought was very important to highlight
now in 2020, Gerjik et al with Brachionfeld actually did
a meta-analysis of all the studies that existed until this point
okay so there were 15 studies taken into account
so what days they summed up in the end was
when it comes to hypertrophy, generally higher threshold motor units are
dikiruta 0.60%
di 100 max.
Okey.
Anak-anak sempat dikiruta 0.85%
more gets recruited
and it caps off at about 80-85%
and anything beyond that is an increment in rate coding.
Okey.
Rate coding is just the strength of the signal
that's coming down from the brain.
Okey.
The higher the rate coding,
the bigger the signal,
the bigger the output.
Okey.
So that's all that is.
So. Recruitment is not enough,
as I said earlier,
unless mechanical loading is involved too.
setelah teman-teman di teman-teman,
kamu harus mengembangkan teman-teman
kerana teman-teman di teman-teman,
teman-teman di teman-teman di teman-teman
dan teman-teman di teman-teman di teman-teman di teman-teman di teman-teman di teman
kemudian, lelaki kelihatan dan kelihatan-kelihatan memiliki masalah-kelihatan
memiliki kelihatan-kelihatan dan itu adalah kira-kira-kira-kira.
So, when we talk about time and attention, the current concept that we are talking about
is that five reps from failure, it's only those times that actually take into account
into hypertrophy.
So, that is the reason why, if someone asked you, if that is the case, why not I just
5-5 singgalkan
di 90% 100 bank
because it's super high mechanical loading
it's super high recruitment
but it's super low on time and attention
okay?
So yes, you can hypertrophy with using super high loads
okay?
Number one is you will not have enough time and attention
okay?
Number two is you're probably your joints and your ligaments
are gonna give way soon
okay?
If you keep training that way
so that's why it makes sense for us to train
with moderate to high loads
in order to achieve hypertrophy
So doon confused hypertrophy training with strength training.
They can be overlapping areas but you will see majority people who are huge
will definitely train in modern loads as well.
Because you want to combine the usage of metabolic components
and mechanical components in order for you to achieve the best amount of hypertrophy
and at the same time it makes sense for your joints, your ligaments
also be able to recuperate using loads that were a bit more moderate.
jika kita hanya mencari, mencari semua kelihatan dengan dia,
sebagainya semasa kata-kata kamu akan mencari.
That's why we will do chest press,
we will do flies or dumber presses with 10 red maxes,
because they are easy on the joints,
but they are harder on the muscles.
So when you want to hypertrophy,
you want to be harder on the muscles.
Don't damage your joints.
Makes sense, right?
- Yeah.
- So, the last question I want to add, how long already?
- About that.
Uncle, that's it.
Okay, so the question, the last question I want to answer is,
does this also apply to training individuals?
Okay, when I say training at high loads, but further from failure,
60% from failure, 60% rap is quite far from failure.
Will it also apply with training individuals?
From the current evidence that is there, no.
Okay, that means if you are someone who is a very trained seasoned individual,
that means you've been training for a couple of years,
you are going to need to train close to failure.
Selepas itu, anda perlu mempunyai nombor agar study
yang berbual dengan 2 rupiah.
Jadi, saya telah mempunyai nombor yang mempunyai rupiah
itu when the potential for hypertrophy
yang mempunyai instrumental.
Jadi, if you're training for your first set,
your first method of the week,
first week, you train like 4 rupiah,
second week, you go 3 rupiah,
then 2 rupiah, then 1 rupiah,
or you tank it in the last week.
Okay?
That's one of the ways
we actually progress our repetitions to failure
for hypertrophy.
So, as you're getting more advanced,
Anda perlu mengembangkan kecil untuk mengembangkan kecil untuk mempunyikannya untuk mempunyikkan kecil perjalanan kecil.
Anda adalah 6 tahun untuk mengembangkan kecil untuk pertama kali, mungkin tidak sangat.
Kerana anda hanya mengembangkan kecil apa-apa-apa yang masalah dapat mengembangkan.
Tapi, jika anda mengembangkan kecil yang lain,
jika anda akan mengembangkan kecil dan 60% tidak akan mengembangkan kecil apa-apa-apa.
Jadi, dan kami juga hanya mengembangkan kecil.
Kita tidak dapat mengembangkan kecil untuk mengembangkan kecil.
Anda boleh mengembangkan kecil sekolah hari ini untuk mengembangkan kecil.
tetapi kemudian ada masalah, kalau itu adalah kata-kata,
orang kata, "Ketika kita berjumpa dengan kecil,
kamu akan mempunyai banyak masalah kecil,
kamu tidak akan mempunyai juga untuk kemudian,
dan kamu akan berjumpa dengan kecil.
Ketika kita berjumpa dengan kecil, kamu akan mempunyai kecil.
Okay?
Bagaimana mempunyai kata-kata?
Okay?
Saya akan berjumpa dengan kata-kata kalau kamu mahu berjumpa dengan kecil dengan kata-kata.
Okay?
Kamu mempunyai kata-kata terakhir, atau mungkin terakhir terakhir terakhir terakhir. dia tak mencari semuanya.
Saya akan mencari semuanya tak mencari. dia tak mencari semuanya tak mencari. 100 Max.
Your 100 Max is being gajed by you training to failure
or doing a 100 Max failure
or a 3 re max failure
or a 5 re max failure.
You need to own nowhere that line is.
And most of us who have trained to failure
who have trained to technical failure
will know like at 100 kilos
I reach technical failure at the 11th rep.
di sini, saya menggunakan perasaan yang lama, saya ingin menggunakan 80% perasaan yang lama.
dan saya tahu 80% 100 max adalah 80 kg.
Saya akan menggunakan, saya akan menggunakan 6 repeti.
Itu 2 latihan dari failure.
Jadi saya tahu di mana menggunakan perjalanan saya.
Tapi kalau anda tidak menggunakan perjalanan,
anda akan menggunakan banyak di Australia dan berkata-kata-kata
sampai anda akan menggunakan perjalanan yang anda tidak tahu
di mana anda akan menggunakan perjalanan yang anda tidak tahu.
Orang yang sangat berbual dari perjalanan.
Orang yang kita melakukan dengan orang yang baru.
Kita tidak akan menggunakan perjalanan yang anda tahu.
Di hari ini, let's do a bench press, five remaks, and see where your failure point is.
You can't do that when you work, because there's a whole other technical issue
when everything that comes into play.
So with new individuals, you need to do a bit of a guessing game, okay?
But a bit more season, if you get a power, if two comes, you get a training program
from you.
The person knows that, okay, my 100 max currently is 220 kilos.
So you know that, okay, the person has tested before.
The person know where that 100 max lies.
So we can use that as a starting point to figure out the rest of our training program.
70% atau 80% atau 90%
so we can use that figure
and obviously, WonderMaxis are a moving target
or FireMaxis are a moving target
as you get fitter, as you get stronger
it needs to be revised
My WonderMax 10 years ago
my WonderMax today is different
I can't be using my figure from 10 years ago
and trying to train
I'll probably be under training
so from time to time
we have a thing where we actually test our PRs
okay you don't do it every week
you might do it maybe every three months
you might do it every two months
to know whether that
So those are the things that you do.
So training the failure can be important for that particular reason.
But when the hypertrophy point of view, I would say that training the failure, do it only when it's needed.
Okay. Training close to failure is much, much more important.
And if you are trained individual, it becomes increasingly important to train close to failure at every set.
All right.
Okay.
And the last thing before I finish up, what are the downsides of failure?
di dalam kecil, di dalam kecil, di dalam kecil.
Lalu, di dalam kecil, di dalam kecil, di dalam kecil.
Lalu, di dalam kecil, di dalam kecil.
Lalu, di dalam kecil.
untuk mempunyai lebih lama.
So you want to do this game for a long time.
You want to keep a joints and ligaments
and everything healthy for a long period of time.
So when you come to choosing your training loads,
you want to mix and match when it comes to hypertrophy.
You want to do some modern loads,
you want to do some heavy loads,
because you want to get the best on both worlds.
You can just train all heavy or train all moderate.
Even Ronnie Coleman did heavy ass shit squats before.
So it's a combination of things.
Sekarang di mana dalam kerana kita perlu mempunyai kata-kata.
Mereka perlu menyebutkan kata-kata dengan kata-kata.
Kemudian kita perlu menyebutkan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata.
Kita perlu menyebutkan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata.
Mereka perlu menyebutkan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata.
Mereka perlu menyebutkan kata-kata dengan kata-kata dengan kata-kata.
Jadi semua ini, dan probably training H,
asli, probably an elder, like 40 year old, and so on, 30-50 years old, that get.
So you need to answer those and those kind of things.
So a lot of things are still yet to be answered, but from best practice,
this is our best practice advice.
For hypertrophy, if you're training with low loads,
training to failure becomes increasingly important.
If you're training with high loads, if you're more training,
training close to failure becomes increasingly important.
So that would be my heart takes all my current evidence-based information that is out there about training to failure.
Yeah, another thing I think I would like to add on that I think is equally important is that training to failure is a concept that is most likely best applied on a caloric surplus or at least a maintenance.
Baiklah.
Jangan cuba doa.
Maksudnya, kami ada di dalam gambar.
Sebab di dalam gambar.
Bagaimana banyak gambar kamu di dalam gambar.
Bagaimana berapa gambar kamu di dalam gambar.
Maksudnya, sebuah gambar kamu di dalam gambar.
-Tak mengapa. -Tak mengapa.
Ya, saya lihat.
Ini semua kelihatan yang terbaik.
Kita akan berikan kelihatan yang terbaik.
-Tak mengapa. -Ya.
Dan kalau kamu berikan kelihatan yang terbaik,
terakhir yang terbaik,
ia akan terbaik di dalam kelihatan yang terbaik.
Dan kalau kamu berikan kelihatan yang terbaik,
ia akan terbaik, terbaik, terbaik.
Jadi, itu sangat baik kelihatan yang kamu berikan.
Jadi, itu adalah perkara yang kamu harus menghantar.
Saya teruk, ini yang sangat terbaik.
- Ya, ia berada-ada untuk saya. - Saya berada-ada untuk saya.
Dan, saya selalu, Guys, saya terima kasih kerana berada-ada untuk kami.
Baiklah, Guys.
Saya selalu, saya Luke Langgo, dan saya Dr. Arvin.
Dan anda berdua untuk. - Ba Belmatcha! - Ba Belmatcha!
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Training to failure—specifically muscular failure—means reaching a point where the target muscle can no longer perform a movement with proper technique, which is crucial for hypertrophy.
Technical failure occurs when range of motion or technique is compromised, while muscular failure happens when the primary muscle fails to generate force, unlike task failure, which is due to supporting structures like grip or balance.
For hypertrophy, it is more important to reach higher-threshold motor units (type 2 fibers) than to rely solely on high loads or low loads, as type 2 fibers have greater hypertrophic potential.
Research shows that both high- and low-load training to failure produce similar hypertrophy when volume is equated, but low-load training requires failure to effectively recruit type 2 fibers via the size principle.
Training to failure is more critical for trained individuals due to their higher threshold motor unit recruitment, whereas beginners may require more guidance to safely reach failure points.
Metabolic stress and mechanical tension are the two primary drivers of hypertrophy, and training to failure enhances metabolic stress, especially at moderate loads.
Heavy loads alone are not sufficient for optimal hypertrophy due to reduced time under tension and joint stress; moderate-to-high loads that allow time and attention are more effective.
Training to failure should be applied cautiously in older adults or those with pre-existing conditions, as it increases injury risk and may compromise daily function.
Summary:
This episode explores the concept of training to failure in the context of muscle hypertrophy, clarifying the differences between technical, muscular, and task failures. The discussion emphasizes that muscular failure—when the primary muscle reaches its limit—is most important for stimulating growth, especially through the recruitment of high-threshold type 2 muscle fibers. Research indicates that both high- and low-load training to failure yield similar hypertrophy when volume is matched, but low-load training specifically relies on failure to activate the fibers with the greatest growth potential.
The size principle explains why lighter loads require failure to recruit higher-threshold units, while heavy loads already recruit these units early, making failure less critical. For trained individuals, training close to failure becomes increasingly essential to maximize hypertrophy. However, this approach must be adapted for beginners and older adults due to safety and injury risks.
The episode also highlights that hypertrophy relies on mechanical tension and metabolic stress, not just failure, and advocates for a balanced training approach that combines moderate-to-heavy loads to maximize muscle growth while protecting joints. Ultimately, training to failure is not a one-size-fits-all strategy; it should be tailored to individual experience, goals, and health status, with best practice emphasizing volume, proper load selection, and progression over time.
FAQs
Training to failure occurs when a muscle can no longer perform an exercise with proper technique or technical proficiency, specifically when the primary muscle reaches its maximum effort.
Muscular failure happens when the primary muscle can no longer produce force, like quads failing during a squat. Task failure occurs when supporting muscles or joints fail, such as grip failure in a row or balance issues in a Bulgarian split squat.
Yes, especially when training with low loads, as it helps recruit higher-threshold motor units that have the greatest hypertrophic potential. With high loads, training close to failure is more critical than complete failure.
No, it depends on experience level and health. Beginners may need to train closer to failure to build muscle, while trained individuals should train close to failure at every set to maximize hypertrophy.
Lighter loads require training to failure to recruit type II fibers effectively, while heavier loads already recruit high-threshold units, making failure less critical as long as volume is maintained.
Yes, especially in older adults or those with pre-existing conditions like sarcopenia or joint degeneration, as fatigue increases the risk of strains or tears during high-stress sets.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.