Sally Hayden’s new book, *My Fourth Time We Drowned*, exposes the hidden horror of the migrant crisis in Libya, a direct result of European policy. It began with a Facebook message from a young Eritrean man describing life in a detention center marked by starvation, torture, and inhuman conditions. Drawing on real-time messages from hundreds of refugees, Hayden reveals that EU-funded agreements with Libya have effectively turned the country into a transit hub where over 90,000 people have been returned to detention—conditions described as concentration camp-like. These centers, run by armed militias, are rife with abuse, including rape, medical neglect, and forced labor, with preventable deaths occurring regularly. The book also exposes systemic failures by international agencies like UNHCR, which are underfunded, misled by EU narratives, and complicit in downplaying the crisis. Hayden highlights deep structural issues, including colonial legacies, global inequality, and the misuse of EU development funds to secure borders instead of protect lives. Despite the personal risks—threats, criminal investigations, and professional backlash—Hayden’s work provides a rare, human-centered account of refugees’ daily struggles, emphasizing both the brutality of the system and the moral responsibility of Western nations. The book challenges readers to confront the truth behind headlines they’ve long ignored, urging greater awareness, accountability, and empathy in the face of a crisis deeply intertwined with climate change, inequality, and historical power imbalances.
(upbeat music)
- Welcome back to The Irish Times Women's Podcast.
I'm Kathy Sheridan.
Coming up on today's episode,
we have a heart stop in conversation for you,
with award-winning Irish Times journalist Sally Hayden,
whose new book, My Fourth Time We Drowned,
has just been published.
It's a profoundly important book
that tells the story of the shocking migrant crisis
in North Africa, which the Western world
has effectively turned a blind eye to.
It's based on interviews and real-time text messages
between Sally and hundreds of refugees
who tried to reach Europe,
only to find themselves trapped in the brutal
inhumane detention camps of Libya,
funded scandallously by Western money.
Sally's investigation really began in 2018,
when she received a Facebook message
from a young Eritrean refugee
who has been held in one of those camps.
As the weeks and months passed,
more messages poured in,
painting a picture of the horrendous conditions
these people were living in,
and how the entire crisis was actually a result
of European policy.
I began by asking Sally how she came
to start writing on migration issues.
- Yeah, I think probably like a lot of journalists,
I didn't go out of my way to report on migration.
I was working as a staff journalist at Vice News
from 2014 to 2016.
I was a desk reporter,
so I just covered the daily world news,
and there were dry onings happening
in the Mediterranean pretty regularly,
and various other kind of tragedies like that,
but I did the reports obviously,
but I didn't understand really what that means.
You hear these headlines over and over again,
you don't actually comprehend the meaning behind that,
and actually it can become so routine
that you almost don't even notice them anymore,
which I know is also terrible.
But in 2015, my editor then in London sent me
out to Calais in France,
where at the time David Cameron had just come out
and said there were swarms of migrants
who were trying to enter the UK.
And so this was basically one of my first big,
chance to leave the desk,
and I'd been given one thousand business cards
by Vice, which I had never really had the chance to use.
And so I just went over and I started meeting
everybody that I could.
The people that I met came from loads of different countries,
like Iran, Syria, Eritrea, across Africa,
across the Middle East,
and I was just handing out business cards
and telling people to keep in touch,
to tell me if they knew of anything we should be covering,
'cause we wanted to not be writing these headlines
that were totally meaningless,
but to be actually explaining what was going on
and who were the people behind that,
and why were they moving,
and what were the complexities
that weren't being conveyed, basically?
Yeah, so that was, I mean, that was when I started
reporting on migration, but I didn't.
The topic of the book,
I mean, it starts with a Facebook message,
and it wasn't one that I anticipated at all.
So it was August 2018.
I just got a message to Facebook from a man who said
that he was locked up in what he said was a prison in Libya,
and that he was with 500 men, women, and children,
and that they had been abandoned
in the middle of a war zone, basically.
They had no food, no water.
And that's the genesis of the investigation
that the book begins with.
So that was a while.
I already had a bit of knowledge about various refugee-related
issues in different countries,
but this was a big shock for me,
because basically what he said was that they had all been left
there as a result of European Union policy.
And so that kind of sparked me into action.
I wanted to know more.
Just tell me a bit about that sender, Sally,
the man who wrote that text.
- The guy who wrote the first text,
at the time he said that he was a 28-year-old.
I mean, he was a 28-year-old,
but what I worked at afterwards was that people share phones.
So actually, initially I was getting messages from one person,
but then there would be other people
who were actually having input into those as well
in terms of just trying to convey the situation inside.
So the initial guy was an air tray in 28-year-old.
He had fled indefinite detention in the air tray
as known kind of some say controversially,
but as the North Korea of Africa,
it's a dictatorship, there's slavery-like conditions,
mandatory military service that last your entire life,
basically, no freedom of speech,
and huge numbers of people have escaped.
It's a very tiny country beside Ethiopia.
A lot of people might not have heard of it,
but it's constantly been in one of the top nationalities
of people who do try to reach here.
And the initial message, it said, "Hi, sister Sally,
"we need your help.
"We're under bad condition in Libya prison.
"If you have time, I will tell you all the story."
And so for me, as a journalist, I always say,
you know, I can't help you.
I don't want people to get confused over what my role is,
but I said, of course, you can tell me what's happening.
So that's what happened.
We just started talking and talking.
He sent me selfies, GPS locations,
actually contact details even for his family members,
'cause I was so skeptical at the beginning
that this could be real.
And eventually, I had contacts in Tripoli in Libya.
I didn't know that much about Libya, to be honest,
but I had contacts there,
and I contacted a Libyan journalist and said,
"Could this be true?
"Are there, is there a war that's just broken out?"
And he said, "Yes."
And I said, "Is it possible that there are 500 refugees
"and migrants locked up in a building in this area?"
And I told him this summer when he said,
"Yes, there is actually a detention center there."
So just to explain the importance of Libya,
Libya is pretty much the country that,
if you have Africans from across the continent,
fleeing waristic tailorships, sometimes droughts,
like anything that they want to reach Europe,
Libya has become a kind of transit point.
So people gather in Libya and then try
to cross the Mediterranean Sea to get to Europe.
So the central Mediterranean route is the name of that route,
and it's known as the deadliest migration route in the world.
So this is what they had attempted before they were locked up.
- And Sally, so now you have something
that the vast, vast majority of journalists do not have.
You're sitting in your flat in London,
but you have direct, painfully direct access
to people inside that detention camp.
- Yeah, exactly, and so I mean,
I don't know what anyone would do in a situation like this.
You have people who are literally just begging you for help.
They were saying, "Please tell the world,
"tell people that we need to be rescued.
"You need to get us help."
And so I tried, first of all, I didn't say anything publicly.
I tried to contact the UN NGOs as well
that we're working in Libya.
Just asking, can anyone help?
There seems to be a group of 500 people
who are totally defenseless.
And they were worried that they were going to be kidnapped
by smugglers or traffickers or militias or bombed
or anything that bad that can happen in a war zone.
And basically the answers came.
No, it's too dangerous for all of our staff.
They can't get there.
And so, for those first few days,
it was just me in contact with these group of people.
And actually, I mean, I have to commend the Irish Times.
Initially, I started posting things on Twitter.
I started posting the messages on Twitter
just trying to get any help.
And then the Irish Times also published a report
which got a lot of traction.
And yeah, that was, I mean, that was my introduction to this.
And Sally, I mean, the book is actually painful reading.
I can't emphasize this enough.
I also want to say that it's a huge work of serious journalism.
It's not just a surge of emotion and anger,
but the details in it are horrendous.
And we were talking about extortion, rape, torture, murder.
Just tell us a little bit about what you're learning
from these people.
Yeah, sure.
I mean, and I think that I should say I'm grateful
to anyone who reads it basically
because I know that it's not an easy topic.
And it's a hard read.
And I know that you said there's been a lot of praise for it.
I'm also grateful to those people
because I think they were willing to do that
because they knew that it's not a topic
that people unnecessarily gravitate towards.
The big reason that I thought that it's important
to, first of all, that I spent, I mean,
four years of my life now documenting this.
And also that I thought that it's important
that other people know is because all of these people
that emerged were there in this detention center,
this, you know, what they called a prison
as a direct result of European policy.
And so what I hadn't fully realized
or fully appreciated is that, you know,
we've all heard of the European migration crisis
like 2015, 2016.
And then it seems to have died down, you know,
in the public consciousness, people think it went away
effectively, but actually what has happened
is that the EU has been entering into deals,
first with Turkey and then with Libya to keep people from reaching the shores of Europe.
Europe. And so one way that they did this in Libya, in the central Mediterranean, Libya
is in the functioning state. So it's hard to have a proper deal with them, but they basically
built up and trained and equipped the Libyan coast guard, spending tens of millions of
euro on them so that they could carry out interceptions of boats of refugees. And that's
illegal under international law to return people to a place where their lives are in danger
if it was a European ship. But if it's a Libyan ship, it becomes legal. So effectively the
Europe has basically pulled out its certain rescue assets, like there currently aren't certain
rescue vessels, you know, sea vessels in that region. But it's conducting surveillance,
they're flying drones, helicopters, planes above the central Mediterranean to spot boats of
refugees, and then giving that information to the Libyan coast guard who then pull people
back into Libya. So since 2017, where then 90 days in men, women and children have been
returned to Libya. And when they get there, they get locked up indefinitely. So that detention
center that I was first in contact with, it wasn't the only one that's what I realized quite quickly.
There are a series of different detention centers. And people are locked up indefinitely,
they don't have any legal recourse, they don't have any way of challenging how long they stay,
they don't even know how long they'll be locked up there. And these detention centers have
been compared to concentration camps by Pope Francis among others. So effectively we have a
situation where people who are trying to seek safety are literally being locked up indefinitely.
And many are dying inside those centers as a result of trying. And this is, for me, the point
of the book, it doesn't start with that point of interception because that's the point for me that
I believe Europe is undeniably ethically culpable because this is European policy that is
sending people back there. Sally, just go back a bit there and just tell me what you were
hearing from these people who are in detention because to a lot of people, as you know, in Europe,
this made perfect sense. Pay other governments to keep those people over there. It's their
sort of vaguely their home territory. Sending them over here is going to cause unrest and resentment
and all those things, you know, overwhelmed hospitals, etc. So to a lot of people, as you know,
this made sense. But tell me what was so wrong with Libya, that made it so dreadful.
So the issue with Libya is that Libya is not a functioning state. It's effectively a state that's
being run by militias. I'm sure a lot of people know about the history, but 2011 there was a
revolution to Aestu Gaddafi who had been in power for decades. And actually, like NATO and
foreign countries were involved in that. And one of their considerations when they got involved,
I mean, I have a quote from David Cameron at the time was speaking about trying to, as well,
stem migration that they taught at this point. It was better if they got involved so that they
could stop migration and stop Libya becoming a failed state. But actually, that's pretty much what
happened in terms of it becoming a failed state. And so you don't have a government that has
oversized. So the detention centers are being run by separate militias, even though they're aligned
with the, I mean, there's multiple governments, but they're aligned with the triply-based
government, which is backed by the UN. But actually, they're being run by militias. And so in each
different detention center, there are slightly different, there's different management. You know,
there can be different rules. But essentially, they're kind of profit-making entities who are also
like military, you know, they have, they keep weapons there. And they see this. It's what, I mean,
some experts say they've gone from a monetization of movement. So smugglers were driving
before this deal to a monetization of captivity, which means that militias are profiting
from keeping refugees captive. Yeah, probably this should come with an audience warning, but
pretty much every kind of atrocity you can imagine was and is happening. This is an ongoing
situation. Yeah, rape, torture, starvation, medical neglect. You know, denial of water, for example,
like maybe the water can get turned off for a day or two days, just as a punishment.
First labor as well, that was pretty common. People being used as human shields. So work kind of
breaks out intermittently in Libya. And refugees tend to be kept close to weapons stores. So that
basically the militias are trying to use them, I guess, to stop them from being hit. And there
have been, I mean, in 2019, there was a direct hit on top of a whole full of refugees and migrants
and an unknown number died at least, I think 54 were said by the UN, but it could have been more.
So yeah, it's, I mean, it's like pretty much every sort of horror you can imagine, honestly. And
then you have also children, you know, at the time that I started reporting on this, there was
600 and 40 children in detention. They're not getting an education. They're also going without
food, you know, pregnant women, some as a result of rape, who aren't getting food, who can't
breastfeed. And yeah, you have pretty regular deaths, like one detention center that I reported on
someone died every fortnight on average from a lack of food and medical neglect. And it included
there was one woman that I met, Fatima, whose son first died of appendicitis. So she begged for
three days for him to be given healthcare and nothing happened. He then died. And then her husband
died weeks later. I think of a stroke. And she said that was brought on by the stress of losing
their child. That's what she's taught. And so, you know, these very preventable deaths that
that are taking place that aren't being counted because there's no registration system. It's not
like people's names aren't there. So even when there was a direct hit on that one detention center
where, you know, the air strike on the detention center, I think one person was officially identified
out of everybody who died. And the rest were just breathed in unmarked graves and we still don't
know their names. So it's like, really, it's not, you know, you can call them camps, but what you
might imagine is not what this situation is. You see, this is the problem. I really feel Sally,
we didn't know enough about that. And this is the astonishing thing about your journalism. You
brought us inside that. I mean, you write that one man count to 29 people he had seen die.
You know, women watching their husbands being murdered. You got a message saying, please help.
Today, one person was self-dead, killed themselves by petrol because they felt so hopeless
about the UNHCR, the UN High Commission for Refugees. So Sally, I feel a terrible
sense of helplessness. What is reading this? But also what I get from you is a sense of anger
as you count out the flaws and failings of the UN, the IOM, the various bodies whose job we think
it is to stop this happening. So tell us about that. People who don't know your work and who don't
know about the responsibility of the UN and all of this. Tell us what that is first and then tell
us what actually happened. So I think what I tried to document here and I didn't have preconceptions,
like I said particularly in going into this. I tried to document exactly what I find and what I
heard and, you know, had multiple sources for every claim and all of that. What emerged was this
picture of a, you know, of a whole system that has basically been set up to make sure that we're
not hearing refugees voices. So I know that you said, um, some of this is shocking and actually,
I really hope that, you know, I hope that people don't turn away and just feel like they're hearing
the same thing again because this information was very hard one over, you know, many years and that's
because effectively, we have set up a system. This is European policy, you know, but then if you
interview the European border force or front tax, they'll say, well, at that point of interception,
we, we don't monitor what happens to people after that. You know, so they'll say, yeah, they do,
you know, do the surveillance and everything to have people intercepted. But at that point, they,
you know, they say Libya is a sovereign state. We don't have a role in monitoring what happens to
them. And so I thought that it's important that I document that. And one big factor in that,
and this again is European Union policy is the United Nations the way that it's being used.
And, um, I realized this pretty early, like when you ask a European politician or, you know,
a commission spokesperson or whoever, about the policy of, of interceptions, they'll say that
they don't approve of detention centers, but that they're funding the UN to try and, uh,
improve the conditions inside them. So they'll say they want them close, but at the moment,
the best they can do is fund the UN. And quite quickly, a lot of UN staff started contacting me,
and particularly, um, like you mentioned, the UN refugee agency. So that's the agency mandate to
protect the rights of refugees. So their role basically is representing refugees in, you know,
in high level meetings, uh, you know, where possible giving them proper documentation, things
like that. Um, and they are active in Libya, but they're
receiving a lot of EU funding and basically what a lot of staff members started telling me,
as first of all, it's very difficult for them to function there. Actually, most of their staff
are based in Tunisia, not even inside Libya. So they don't have full oversight of what is happening.
They don't actually, or this was very clear to me pretty quickly, they didn't have direct lines
to the refugees inside the detention centres because it became that I was passing on information
about what was happening inside of them, two staff there. Secondly, staff who contacted me
and a lot wanted to speak anonymously, you know, they don't want to lose their jobs. They felt
that they were actually being used to whitewash the implications of European Union policy because
publicly, UNHCR will regularly thank the EU and say things like, thank you so much for this funding.
We got to do this for refugees in Libya. It's so great, blah, blah. You know, it's very donor-focused.
Even there was one day that they said something like, it's friendship day. We want to thank the EU
for their work, you know, their support for us in Libya. And it's not being mentioned here that,
actually, it's Europe, that is behind the policy of sending people back. And so if you heard that,
you know, and you don't know that much about the situation and you're not hearing from the refugees
inside detention about what they're going through, you might think that everything is okay or it's
getting better or, you know, it's improving in some way and actually, now it's been five years
and the conditions remain, you know, absolutely horrific. And it's best if they read the book to
understand properly because they're not the most eloquent. But I just thought it was a fundamental
piece of the puzzle because a lot of the time, even with that first group of refugees that contacted
me, UNHCR released a statement where they said, after a few days, they removed to another
detention center. And a statement went out saying something like they'd been moved out of harm's
way. And actually, the new detention center they were in became the front lines of the conflict
very quickly again. And they were again abandoned by the guards they were with and they were again
left without food and water. But people were then seeing this UN statement online and going,
oh, don't worry Sally, they're safe, you know. And I was like, no, they're not. That's not,
it doesn't reflect what's actually happening. So part of this book was kind of, I don't know,
I guess, you know, I'm a journalist. So I just document, but just documenting the difference
between that story of the on the ground experience of the people who are most vulnerable and what
is being said by, by people in power.
Now, Sally, what comes across? And I think what's almost as shocking really is this image of corruption
and arrogance on the part of the UNHCR. Am I correct in that? Am I right about that?
Ah, I mean, I guess I don't know if I can use the word arrogance, but like I said, I had reported
on migration as well before this. And I actually went to Sudan in 2017. I got a grant. So
Sudan neighbors, Libya, and Sudan would be on the route for a lot of air trains, Ethiopians,
Somalis, who try to get to Libya, they go through Sudan. And I went to Sudan in 2017 to look at
at that time already, they had agreed to spend like billions of euro. It's called the Trust Fund for
Africa in 26 African countries basically to stop migration. And so we were trying to figure out
where this funding was being spent. And when I got to Cartoum, I started meeting refugees and
none of them want, like none of them knew about the EU money, but they all wanted to talk about
UNHCR corruption. So, you know, we have all this rhetoric about people should, you know, not jump
the queue or those basically limited refugee resettlement for what's meant to be the most vulnerable
people. I mean, there are far fewer spaces offered than there are refugees. And it's worth
saying that 87% of refugees are in developing countries. There's 26 million refugees at the moment
in the world, I think. But anyway, in Cartoum, the refugees were all saying that basically,
UNHCR staff were asking for bribes for them to be considered for resettlement. And those went up
to $20,000 for a family. And I investigated this for 10 months. It wasn't something that I could
have imagined, you know, that that was happening. So it took me 10 months. I ended up speaking to
former UNHCR staff in Sudan, as well as a lot of refugees. And I published the report in May
2018. And two days later, UNHCR suspended the whole resettlement program from Sudan saying that
they were conducting a fraud investigation. And they did find one staff member guilty in the end
of soliciting bribes and abusing power. But for me, this, this again, you know,
I challenge my preconceptions because as a journalist, you're supposed to question whose voices
are we listening to. And a lot of the time it is UNHCR staff that will tell us what we should
believe about the situation for refugees. And at least in Sudan, I had seen that then, at that point,
that there was, there didn't seem to be scrutiny on this organization that, you know, many people
were telling me that there should be. And so if you had refugees, they're not trusting in that
process. That would be the only legal process they have to be resettled to a safe country.
If they don't trust in that process, of course, they're going to take an illegal route, you know.
If they have the means to do that, I mean, what they were telling me is it's less expensive
to go through Libya than it is to go through UNHCR at that time. So.
Sally, what outraged me at that point is that you were being accused of being the enemy and
of peddling fake news in one case by the UNHCR office in Tunis. You know, while, while dozens of
aid workers in Libya were telling you that the UN agencies had allowed themselves to be used by
the EU effectively, whitewashing the brutal system, you have been called the enemy. I mean,
I know you don't like to bring yourself into this. I'm well aware of that. But just, I mean,
it's, it's adding another layer to all those difficulties, I suppose, for the refugees themselves.
If, if you're not being believed on top of everything else, if they are smearing your name,
where does that leave the world? Yeah, I mean, I don't know. It's, it's very tricky. I think,
yeah, I think that people, if they read the book, they'll, they'll understand a bit more of the
complexities. But yeah, as a journalist, I mean, this has been a hard story to report on and this
is why I really, you know, I am so grateful to anyone who reads it and I also encourage them not
think that this is information that they've read before because, for example, while I reported
it on this, I received quite serious threats. And I was also under criminal investigation for a
year. So, you know, for me, it's been quite a frightening and isolating experience. I'd say working
on this. And yeah, I don't know. I just, I just think that everybody needs to know about this.
And I think there wouldn't have been those efforts against me if this wasn't such a, you know,
such a top, like a topic that's being silenced, basically, or that people don't know about.
Like, so, yeah, it's, it's complicated. Of course, it is. All of these things have a huge gray
area. But at the same time, a death threat, the death threat. And it's one of the things that's
made it impossible for you to report from Libya itself. And there are various machinations around
that. Tell me a little bit about your efforts to get into Libya. Yeah, so initially, like I said,
I just got this message out of nowhere. And I started posting these messages on Twitter. And that
Twitter tried got literally millions of views, I guess it went viral. So pretty quickly, I ended up
in a situation where I was being contacted by all sorts of people with more information, but also
became quite, you know, I was going on BBC, you know, on Al Jazeera. I was being asked to talk
about this a lot. And I didn't try to go to Libya at that early stage because I just didn't really,
first of all, I thought that I was getting a lot of information as it was. And secondly, I didn't
even really understand how I could kind of use it to go there. And then I was getting like anonymous,
you know, messages on DMs, like saying that my life was at risk. And then I talked about trying
to go about six months later. And at that point, then I was meant to go to the Libyan border in
Chinesia. And that was when I received warnings from intelligence agencies of two countries,
saying that my life was in danger or it appeared to be in danger. Anyway, if I went to that place.
And so then I didn't do that. I got really scared and just stayed away from North Africa generally.
The warnings said don't go to North Africa. So that's what I did. And then I tried, again,
early 2020. So I had been writing the book, you know, and I was thinking, I can't publish a book
that talks about what happens in Libya in case people try to say, you know, you didn't go there.
And so they just won't, you know, even though there's so many sources, there's so much evidence,
I've talked to so many people there constantly. I didn't want anyone to be able to say, you
didn't go. And so this not believed in them.
information basically. So I tried to go again, early 2020, I applied for a visa and then
obviously COVID happened. And then I tried again, I think late 2020, I applied again. And
then I was kind of put on hold. So there was a period of about four months where I was being
told every week, oh, next week your visa is coming, next week your visa is coming. And
eventually I was told right before the book deadline, no, you're not getting a visa. And
then that was the end of that. I just figured at that point I can't go. And I strangely
actually about two weeks before it got published, I got a very strange email. I don't know if
this is real or not offering me a free trip to Libya from the Libyan government saying
that they're trying to change their narrative on migration and that they'll give me access
to anywhere I want and that they'd also offer me renumeration for going on the trip. So
I don't know if that real or not, but it was very strange to get two weeks before the
book came out. That is very strange indeed. They obviously had some intramation of the contents
of the book, Sally. Sally, what's interesting for those of us who grew up with the image
of heroic frontline war correspondents and did a teeny bit of war reporting ourselves
maybe and learned how constrainy it can be to try and cover serious eruptions on the ground
because you can't be everywhere. You're only getting a small part of the picture. But
it's how you've transformed that landscape. I know you did a lot of traveling and we'll
talk with that in a minute, but a lot of this most important information was coming into
you on a screen in your London flat. What was that like? You were there. I don't know if
you live alone or what your circumstances are. But what was that like to be receiving
this extraordinarily shocking information on your phone from real people in real time?
Yeah, I mean, for me that was also very shocking. I've always been of that attitude that if
you can go to a place you should go there, you know, I don't like reporting where I'm
remote. I would avoid that, but in this situation it basically wasn't possible. So just to explain
like the way that people eventually my number or my contact details, my name, my social
media was all passed around about nine different attention centers or a 10 at one point I was
into a trip. And I'd be getting messages every particularly at night because the guards
would be watching, so phones aren't allowed. The guards would be watching during the day
making sure that no one is on a phone. But at night people would hide on your blankets
and they'd start sending messages. And so it would be about 11 maybe at night. Suddenly
my phone would start pinging, I'm pinging and I'd be getting messages updates from the
day from all different attention centers. People telling me what had happened to them that
day, anything they had seen, anyone who needed medical help. And yeah, it was just
strange. And a lot of that I didn't report. I mean, that's why I wrote a book partially
because at the time it was too dangerous to reveal a lot of that information because
the people were in like danger, danger at that moment, you know, there were situations
where if I published a report guards would come in the next day and sweep for phones or,
you know, confiscate the phones if they could find them or, you know, people were actually
in danger of being tortured. And so of course, I'd discuss with the sources, you know, do
you want this published? How much information should we give? But there was a huge amount
that I couldn't put out. And yeah, I mean, it was just a very strange, strange period
in my life, honestly. Like it went on for, I'd say about a year or two, like one or two
years where I was like constantly on the phone. I could be anywhere, you know, my friends,
I remember at my friends child's birthday party, a one year old birthday party, I suddenly
started getting messages that there'd been an airstrike in the outskirts of a detention
center. And I had to pass that on to different agencies. And it was like, you know, suddenly
my friends are like, Sally's, you know, Sally's really awful to be around. I left, you
know, I went to a music festival in the early days when I didn't realize this was going
to continue. And I left a few days early, so I just constantly just was on my phone just
trying to guide this information. And yeah, I don't know, like that, that was the strange
part for me was that there wasn't those communication channels between the refugees and the aid
organizations, for example, or anyone else in the early days, it seemed like those just
didn't exist.
Yeah. I think, Sally, one of the most telling lines I read actually was in the financial
times review of your book where the writer said, "Reading is like being besieged by a desperate
crowd." Yeah, it's journalism of the most urgent kind. And that was how I felt reading
it, but I then tried to imagine what it must have been like for you in the middle of the
night, getting these besieging messages, and knowing that you were one of the very few
voices listening. So I know you hate these questions, but how did you mind yourself during
those times? I mean, I think I don't have a good answer to that because I, like it was
very stressful. So I mean, even now, but now I think there are more activists definitely
that have gone involved or more even organizations that are in more direct contact with refugees
from what I know who are in detention. But at that time, like it was really, I just, you
know, even if I got on a plane because I travel a lot for work, if I got on a plane, I'd
have to tell sources, like I'm not going to be available for five hours. And they'd be
like, "But what if something happens? Like what are we meant to do? You know, who will
we contact?" And I'd be like, "I don't know. I'm really sorry, but like there's no way
to get internet on the plane." One of the strangest I described in the book actually, the strangest
experiences was, "I got brought to Tunisia. I got in a word for an Irish time story from
the European Union for a journalism. And they flew us to Tunisia and neighbours. They
be asked. So I was, I think, 200 miles or something from this detention center that I was
reporting on. But they brought us to, it was, it was European politicians. They brought
us to a cathedral. And basically, we all, you know, went up on stage to receive our
awards. There was no Wi-Fi there, and I didn't have a SIM card. And so the whole time I
was panicking, I wonder what's happening in this detention center. And then we had European
politicians kind of handing out what, like there was wine and canopies and saying, "Isn't
it lovely that we're in these sumptuous surroundings?" And this was an award for migration reporting.
And I remember they wouldn't let any of the journalists speak. The journalists were
very uncomfortable about it. Because we were saying, you know, we're showing on the back
of, the screen at the back of this cathedral were like images of refugees, you know, in
horrific situations. And then we were all being praised. And then there were people giving
us canopies, you know. And for me, I had actually told, I mean, I try as a journalist never
to make promises. But in this case, I thought that we were all going to say something when
we accepted the award. And for me, I wanted to say, like at the moment, I'm in contact
with a group of refugees who are in desperate need for help as a result of European policy.
Because I felt very uncomfortable that I was receiving an award from the EU, you know,
and wanted to highlight that. And of course, we were kept away from the microphones, all
of us. So, yeah, it's weird. I'd only described it briefly in the book, but that really messed
with my head a lot, to be quite honest.
I'm sure it did, because I think one of the things, you know, I mean, at one point, I
think to refer to journalists as can be vultures. And we've all seen that, you know, covering
a big story. We've seen the one, the glory seekers. And we've seen the ones who are second
guessing themselves all the time. And the ones who are in the middle who just know they
need to meet a deadline. And so there's many different kinds of journalism, which I think
isn't sufficiently recognized either. But in terms of second guessing yourself, Sally,
that must make it infinitely harder for you to report on, on stories. Because if you,
if you go into this with an era of certainty, as many journalists do, and they know the
scene and they know the actors and they know all the rest, obviously that's much easier.
You take an angle and you write. But in your case, it's constant, constant second guessing.
Yeah. I mean, so to be honest at the start, when I started reporting on this, I wasn't
second guessing myself, like at least about my role, I was thinking my role is just to make
sure that everybody knows about this. And that was in contact with my sources. They were
saying, tell the world, you know, we need the world to know that we're humans. We need
the world to know that we're in help. We need our lives saved. And ideally, our evacuation
to a safe place as well. And so I just felt like my job was to report that this was happening.
But one thing that I noticed happened pretty quickly was that basically I started to
be praised a lot. I started to receive awards. And I started to see my career advancing
as a result of reporting on this story. And that, I mean, is actually very uncomfortable
when you're doing, you know, when you're in touch with people who literally have not
moved from a single room in, you know, a year who aren't seeing sunlight, they're not
getting food, they're not getting water, you know, and then I'm starting to get more
and more offers to go to this place, you know, do this thing, receive this award.
And I think, yeah, I taught in this book, I mean, it's important that I scrutinize myself,
and I don't even know that I've done it well enough. But I don't think that I'm a, you
know, it's not like I'm the good one, and everybody else isn't. So like I also said that I'm
complicit, the fact that we have a system where, you know, refugees, and a lot of this is also racism,
isn't it? And I talk in the book about where, when you have a white face in the front of something,
that can attract a lot more sympathy, you know, like when Corolla Riccata was arrested,
the sea captain of sea watch, and there were suddenly thousands of people in the streets protesting,
and she says herself, like that's, you know, why were they protesting for me and not for, you
know, the tens of thousands of refugees who are being forced back to detention or drowning or dying
in Libya. And for me, I feel like that as well, I feel like, you know, I'm obviously a white person,
you know, I'm privileged, I can travel, like a disgusting amount with pretty much a total freedom,
you know, I have to get visas, but they got approved. And that's, you know, that's just not
comfortable. And I think it's important for, for all of us to question ourselves, but,
but yeah, I say in the authors, not like really the person who benefited out of this was me.
One of the things that I'm doing, I am donating a portion of the proceeds of the book to
refugee supporting initiatives, and I thought that that was important because I've reported on
migration long enough, and I've seen, you know, a lot of situations where it tends to be the
privileged white person who's the one who's making a living or who's profiting off, even speaking
about this situation. So yeah, I don't know, I don't tell myself as innocent in this, and this
is well, but at least I, you know, I thought that I was doing something necessary and documenting
a lot of this. In terms of racism, Sally, are you constantly asked about Ukraine and the
welcoming arms for Ukrainians compared to other people who are in desperate straits? Yeah,
I've been asked out in pretty much every interview, but I do think it's interesting. When I finished
the book, Ukraine hadn't happened, yes. And so, so it's not mentioned in the book, but at the same
stage, it was, it was pretty shocking for me. I mean, obviously, what's happening is completely
horrific, you know, and that's important to say, but also that people were being welcomed
in such huge numbers because, you know, we have the European migrant crisis that, you know,
what you call the European migrant crisis in 2015, that involved 1.3 million people claiming
aside them in Europe, and now I think it's six million Ukrainians or something have crossed
already. And when you look at those numbers, I mean, I know of course it's going to be a
challenge to make sure people are set up and get the support they need and everything, but
also the fact that 1.3 million people caused this huge securitization of borders,
these policies that are sending people to their deaths, you know, that that really is kind of
shocking. And yeah, I mean, I don't know if you can say it's all racism, that's certainly what
sources that I ask about it say, that they have actually found it quite painful, people who have
managed, because it's this small number that actually managed to make it to safety in Europe,
you know, a lot of people die on the way or they, they get locked up where they get stopped
at various points. And the ones who have made it to Europe, I've been talking to a few of the
people who were in detention and they'll be up for a few years who are now in different countries.
They were saying it's quite painful to watch this. Welcome for Ukrainians, just because they
know that their country people weren't offered the same, you know, they're thinking of the ones who
died because of the European policy, rather than because of trying to, just trying to flee home.
Yeah, I think one of the important lines somewhere in the book is that developing countries
shelter 87% of the world's refugees. So it's not the West, it's developing countries.
Sally have you been asked about the Rwandan solution? Yeah, and I actually reported in Rwanda
for the book and also for the Irish Times a few times. There's a whole chapter on Rwanda in the
book. So basically, I mean, the UK is doing something kind of specific in that they're sending
people on a one way trip or they're at least trying to, but Rwanda was already used by the EU
and the African Union and UNHC or as a transit location for refugees in Libya.
Like, so a small number are chosen for evacuation. There's a small number of evacuations every year.
And those people tend to be taken to another country where their asylum claims are processed
and they get assigned to a Western country that they can be sent to. And Rwanda became one of those
countries in 2019. So it's an EU funded scheme that basically evacuates down there. They stay there
for like six months or a year or however long and then they go along to another country.
And I visited there and I talk about it in the book. I mean, I got journalists accreditation
before I went. But then I tried to get access to the camp that they were being held in and I was
basically stonewalled for a week every day. They say, come back tomorrow, come back tomorrow,
come back tomorrow. Then I was told that I could come back another time and basically they had given
me accreditation just because they believed that I will write good things about them. And Rwanda's,
I'm sure a lot of people know. I mean, it has a very trouble past, but now it's a dictatorship
and a police state and there isn't really freedom of speech there. And certainly with the UK deal,
I think that there's a big question about whether there's going to be proper scrutiny of what
is happening to people. Yeah, so I document in the book there was a case in April 2020 where again,
you know, initially the refugees from Libya arrived. They were so happy to be out of Libya. Rwanda,
you know, it is a dictatorship, but it's like relatively safe in terms of being on the streets
and things like that. But then there was a situation where a minor boy in the camp said that the
police chief in charge of the camp had basically attempted to rape him. And he, and this was reported
to me, I actually didn't report it publicly at first. I went to government sources. I told some
people, you know, people I know in Rwanda, like what should be done because the boy wanted to,
you know, the police chief was still wandering around. He wanted to make it complaint and just
make sure that this man wasn't there because he was frightened. And what happened was the Rwandan
police force actually before there was an investigation came out on Twitter and said that the boy had
been lying. And then there was no proper investigation. Then I reported on it for the Guardian newspaper
actually. And then the state associated media and newspaper came out and said that I write refugee
porn basically started attacking me and saying that I was a bad journalist. And then I,
that I write refugee porn. And so I think that, I mean, it's just one tiny experience, but it
shows you the level of control there is there and that there isn't freedom of freedom of free media,
you know? And so if you send people there, it's not, it's, it's, it's not going to be scrutiny.
Again, you know, all of this is attempts to evade scrutiny, isn't it? And you see that again in
Rwanda. Sally, a few things before you go, you make no policy recommendations and that's not your job.
But if you had a magic wand, where would we go with this?
I mean, for me, honestly, I just taught the most important thing is that European people know
this is happening. I, you know, I know that people stay here, reports of drylings in the
mad straining and things like that, but I honestly don't think that the majority of the European
public are aware of, you know, the implications of this policy that 90,000 people now have been
sent back to detention centers that have been compared to concentration camps that people are
dying, that, you know, women are being raped, that this is happening in our names. And that was,
for me, knowledge is, you know, knowledge is important. That's why I'm a journalist. We need
to have the facts before anything else can happen. And so I just hope that Europeans informed
themselves because this isn't something that's happening far away. This is a result of, of us,
you know, this, and it's also the complacency of Europeans. And I do think that people generally
are kind, you know, like I believe in, I believe that people have, like, great, most people are
kind anyway, they don't, they wouldn't approve of this necessarily if they knew that it was happening.
And so, of course, I'm a journalist, I'm not an activist, you know, it's not my place to,
to propose anything, but I do think that it's, you know, it's still being objective to say that
you need to inform yourself about this. That's perfectly objective and entirely our responsibility.
Sally, just, a much broader question, I suppose, because people will always say, when you say,
it's the, it's the West, it's Europe's fault for paying Libya, paying Turkey to keep people
in appalling conditions and all that. And then you'll be, somebody will inevitably say, well,
you know, it's to stop them coming, let them stay at home. Why can't Europe help them to stay
at home? And then, I know you mentioned the legacy of colonialism, that this is what African
children grow up with is, is, is, is, is hearing, learning about the legacy of colonialism.
while. Europeans spend most of the time trying to suppress all information about colonialism.
So is there something there that we should be looking at too?
I mean, I think that, yeah, there's, I mean, it's a lot of big issues, isn't it? But I think a
lot of this comes down to global inequality as well. And as we all know, inequality is vastly
increasing. And I think that there are big questions to be asked for. Anyone, no matter what,
what their political view, and there are questions to be asked about the spending of European money,
because this is our money. Like I said, the EU is spending billions of, billions of euro through
the trust fund for Africa across 26 countries that, that money is earmarked as crisis, like crisis
funding. So there is in proper oversight on how it's being spent. And from everything I've documented,
there are huge concerns about the fact that this money is going towards securitization of
borders in a way that's actually propping up militias, propping up dictatorships, increasing
suppression of people rather than improving their lives. And I think that whatever your viewpoint,
you know, the spending of money, like if we're making the situation worse through these kind of short
term, short term measures, or you know, basically what's kind of like an attempt to stop the far
right gaining power. So you just throw money at the problem, but then actually you're propping up
militias or making countries more unlivable or oppressing people further. People will always find
a way to move if they're, you know, not safe, or if they're, if they have to, basically, if they're
forced into it. And so yeah, maybe the questions are like how, how to improve those conditions.
One of the really, it shows you that you can't anticipate where a story will take you. One of those
moments for me was I went on a rescue ship for this, for this book. And I spent, it was meant
to be a month long mission. It ended up being pretty short, but we've sailed off the Libyan coast.
And I had anticipated, at that point I'd been reporting on this three year and a half,
I anticipated that we'd get, you know, people from detention centers, even I was wondering,
I wonder, well, we, well, any of my sources come on this ship, you know, that would be,
you know, I wasn't communicating with them or anything, but I thought maybe that would be
really exciting if it just happened by chance. And actually, the people that came on
board were Libyans. And they said that they were fleeing Libya because Libya had become
unlivable because of the militias that there was just militia, real, the militias has so much
power now. And nobody can live basically without being involved in the militia. And it's just
become hell on earth. And for me, that, you know, that really epitomized also these big questions
that now if, you know, so much, so much European money is pumping into Libya and Libyans are fleeing,
you know, because they're saying that the militias are making things unlivable. That's, you know,
that says a lot, I think. But yeah, there's obviously more in the book.
There's only so much we can cover. And all I can say is that it's an extraordinarily enlightening
book. It's extraordinarily responsible, Sally. As I keep saying, it wasn't written in a spade of
anger or emotion. And less listeners are doubting what they're reading. There are 65 pages alone
of notes and references, just in case you doubt what you're reading. And a list of acronyms,
which is very useful, and a guide to the kind of terminology that defeats us all at some point,
migrants, refugees, asylum seekers, expats, which I think is a great word. The difference between
trafficking, smuggling. I mean, this is a, this is a book that, to me, encompasses everything.
And probably the largest issue of our time. It's probably on a, on a power with climate change.
And it's all indeed intermingled with climate change, Sally, isn't it?
Yeah. And I think, sorry, one thing that I should say as well. I mean, it's not just a book,
it's not just like a list of horrific things happening. I try to get in the human stories of people,
you know, love stories, family ties, things that, you know, even, even jokes up, people were
telling inside the detention centers. Like, I think that that was very important for me because
those were things that I couldn't fit in media reports. And so a lot of it is just also about
what life is like when you're, when you're going through this situation, like the day-to-day of
just being locked up somewhere and having to make it through, you know. And I hope that some of that,
you know, it's not just, it's not just a terrible list of tragedy, you know, because I don't think
that's, I don't think that's fair to people who are there either. No, it makes it very readable.
And I just think it's kind of funny when you talk about what it feels like for people to be
locked up and those kind of conditions. And while you were writing this, we were complaining bitterly
about suffering from pandemic lockdown. So it's all relative, isn't it? Yeah, I actually had my,
I mean, I know I was saying that I'm privileged to be able to travel for a lot of, I think when I
got the book deal, I was in Uganda. I was there for about seven months when they shut the borders
because of coronavirus as well. So yeah, and we had a travel ban, you couldn't even travel between
cities for a lot of that. So I ended up in one small, small city and then north of the country.
And yeah, I mean, that was, yeah, it shows that these things, I mean, I think also coronavirus,
that was another thing that I was thinking maybe we'll make people more empathetic, but the Ukraine
war and coronavirus, you can certainly see how someone's life can be turned around or things can
change in a very short space of time. And it's been incredibly frightening for all of us, but
I also hope maybe that makes people have some more empathy for people from other countries who
have been experiencing these sorts of things, but you know, have necessarily had them appreciated
by those in other countries. Sally, thank you. I know you were up in the middle of the night,
marking the US launch of the fourth time we drowned, as I say, an extraordinary book. And I know
you're midway through COVID and and bearing up extraordinary well. And I don't know where you go
from here or if you maintain this pace that you're at or if you're going to continue working in
this world, are you in that particular field? Yeah, well, I'm actually since November, I'm on
contractors that are times Africa correspondent. So I'm working a lot for you guys, but yeah,
I need to go back to an African country. I'm not sure exactly where I'll go next, but I was just
in Somalia, so I'm sure some people read my reports from there. And again, that was a story that
was interlinked with this. But yeah, I don't know, just carry on. Reed, Sally, at the Irish Times,
everybody, Sally, thank you so much for your time and for getting up to talk to us with your
COVID and all and the very best of luck with all you do. It's very important work. Yeah, thank you
for having me and thanks for reading the book. And that's it for today. Thanks to our guest, Sally Hayden.
Remember, you can subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. We are on iTunes, Spotify and
all good podcast apps. Also, if you want to get in touch, we're on Twitter and Facebook at IT Women's
Podcast or email us on the Women's Podcast at IrishTimes.com. The Women's Podcast was produced
by Rochie Nangle, Suzanne Brennan and Jennifer Ryan with J.J. Rowling Unsound. Until next time,
thanks for listening.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Sally Hayden’s investigation into the Libyan migrant detention crisis began with a Facebook message from a 28-year-old Eritrean man describing horrific conditions in a Libyan prison.
The book reveals that European policy—specifically EU deals with Libya and Turkey—has intentionally returned migrants to dangerous detention centers, effectively making Libya a transit point for a deadly migration route.
Detention centers in Libya operate under militia control, with rampant abuses including torture, rape, starvation, and denial of medical care, conditions likened to concentration camps by figures like Pope Francis.
Despite widespread awareness of the crisis, international bodies like the UNHCR and IOM are underfunded, misaligned with on-the-ground realities, and often whitewash EU policies, while corruption in refugee resettlement programs is exposed.
The crisis is deeply rooted in colonial legacies, global inequality, and a lack of accountability, with EU funding used to militarize borders rather than protect vulnerable populations.
Hayden’s reporting, conducted remotely via real-time messages from refugees, provided unprecedented access to the suffering of detainees, though it came with significant personal risk, threats, and professional backlash.
The book emphasizes human stories—love, family, daily survival—alongside systemic failures, challenging readers to confront both the horror and the moral responsibility of European policy.
It argues that public ignorance and complacency in Europe are central to the crisis, and that true change requires transparency, accountability, and a reevaluation of global migration and development funding.
Summary:
Sally Hayden’s new book, *My Fourth Time We Drowned*, exposes the hidden horror of the migrant crisis in Libya, a direct result of European policy. It began with a Facebook message from a young Eritrean man describing life in a detention center marked by starvation, torture, and inhuman conditions. Drawing on real-time messages from hundreds of refugees, Hayden reveals that EU-funded agreements with Libya have effectively turned the country into a transit hub where over 90,000 people have been returned to detention—conditions described as concentration camp-like.
These centers, run by armed militias, are rife with abuse, including rape, medical neglect, and forced labor, with preventable deaths occurring regularly. The book also exposes systemic failures by international agencies like UNHCR, which are underfunded, misled by EU narratives, and complicit in downplaying the crisis. Hayden highlights deep structural issues, including colonial legacies, global inequality, and the misuse of EU development funds to secure borders instead of protect lives.
Despite the personal risks—threats, criminal investigations, and professional backlash—Hayden’s work provides a rare, human-centered account of refugees’ daily struggles, emphasizing both the brutality of the system and the moral responsibility of Western nations. The book challenges readers to confront the truth behind headlines they’ve long ignored, urging greater awareness, accountability, and empathy in the face of a crisis deeply intertwined with climate change, inequality, and historical power imbalances.
FAQs
Sally Hayden received a Facebook message from a 28-year-old Eritrean man in 2018, describing horrific conditions in a Libyan detention camp. This message sparked her investigation, which included direct communication with refugees through text messages and interviews.
Libya has become a key transit point for migrants fleeing war and hardship across Africa. People gather there and attempt to cross the Mediterranean, making it the deadliest migration route in the world. However, Libya is a failed state run by militias, leading to inhumane detention conditions.
Through direct communication via text messages, she maintained constant contact with refugees in detention centers. She received messages at night when guards were not watching, allowing people to share updates about their conditions and needs.
Refugees face starvation, denial of water, torture, rape, medical neglect, and forced labor. Some detention centers have been compared to concentration camps, with reports of deaths due to lack of food, medical care, or from air strikes.
Sally argues that European Union policies—such as funding Libya and Turkey to return migrants—directly lead to people being sent back to dangerous detention centers. These policies violate international law and are ethically culpable.
She highlights that UN agencies like UNHCR are funded by the EU but often fail to protect refugees. Their reports are sometimes used to whitewash the situation, and there is a lack of oversight, with staff based far from the camps and unable to intervene effectively.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.