from Publishing Rodeo: The Good, The Bad, and the Bloody Ugly
1h 33m 17s
The podcast explores the hidden realities of the publishing industry, revealing systemic inequalities and flawed practices that disadvantage authors. A major issue is the imbalance in contracts, where clauses like rights of first refusal and non-compete clauses severely limit author autonomy, income, and career flexibility. Many books fail to reach bookstores on time, especially in the UK, resulting in missed list placements, lost sales, and damaged author reputations. Publishers increasingly rely on trend-driven, insider, or platform-based deals, favoring authors with existing audiences or industry connections over merit or originality. The UK’s bestseller list system rewards "crate" success, leading to a cycle where books vanish after initial success and authors are left without visibility or sustainable income. Additionally, industry insiders frequently secure deals, creating conflicts of interest and undermining fairness. Environmental excuses for print cuts are dismissed as manipulative and inconsistent with real-world sales. Overall, the system is not meritocratic—authors face unbalanced power dynamics, lack of transparency, and structural barriers. The podcast emphasizes that while the industry claims fairness, the reality is a rigged environment where authors must constantly navigate hidden biases, poor contracts, and opaque decisions. Authors are urged to seek independent advice, diversify their paths, and challenge the status quo to protect their rights and careers.
Still wearing the same old underwear?
Chances are it's time for an upgrade.
Start with Tommy John, a 2026 men's health editor's choice
in best men's underwear.
Experience exceptionally soft fabrics,
a fit that moves with you,
and all day comfort across our premium underwear,
sleepwear and loungewear.
One less gift to worry about,
one more reason to treat yourself.
Own gifting season this black Friday
with 50% off-site-wide at TommyJohn.com/holiday.
And use code holiday.
Hi, I'm Sunny Dean.
And I'm Scott Drakeford.
And this is the publishing radio podcast.
In 2022, we both launched debut novels
in the same genre with the same publisher in the same year.
But despite having very similar starts,
our books and subsequently each of our careers
went in very different directions.
That pattern repeats itself throughout the industry over and over.
Why do some books succeed while others seem to be dead on arrival?
In this podcast, we aim to answer these questions in many more,
along with how to build and maintain an older career.
Everyone signing a contract deserves to know
what they're really signing up for.
In an industry that loves its secrets,
we'll be sharing real details from real people.
We'll cover the gamut of life
as a big five published author
from agents to publishing contracts, finances, and more.
So actually, at the time of recording this,
I have not yet edited or released our last episode
that we made many, many moons ago.
I don't even remember what we talked about last time.
Oh, my God.
I think I would have to check.
I think I was looking,
it was in the run-up to the launch of my book,
my second book, like it was before that.
I think it was before launch.
You should have just thrown that out unedited then.
I had no time.
I had the craziest period, like just from kind of March
until two weeks ago.
It's been a little bit insane.
I think it was, yeah, I had like book launch engagement stuff.
If I ever get married again,
I'm not doing that in the same year as a book launch.
(laughing)
Yeah, wedding stuff is continuous edits, writing, pitching.
Is it a bit of a weird one?
Because I do remember the lead up to launch
and when we were making that episode
and I was worried about how that book would go
and already feeling like the signs were bad.
So it is a bit surreal to now be making this episode
before that one is like edited,
although I will end up releasing them.
We'll release them in order, but probably close together.
That means someone listening to first hear me
being kind of like anxious about it
and then second hearing about how it didn't really go that well.
So I think there's a, well, kind of.
I'm not sure on the US side,
but there's like a whole variety of things
to talk about there.
Yeah.
But yeah, basically we're recording this episode
because the number of things that made us mad
lately have built up enough for there to be an hour.
And also because we release one every sort and then, you know,
the adverts pay for the hosting, which is always great.
There you go.
Yeah, I'm very sorry anyone is putting up the adverts.
The reason I do that is because it's just a,
it can kind of continues background cost
to keep it hosted in life as a resource.
And it's not a massive cost,
but it's nice that like a couple of adverts basically
covers the time and effort and hosting.
Yeah.
So without anyone having to donate
and we don't have to do Patreon bullshit,
which I can't be arsed with.
Do you, yeah, honestly,
do you get to choose the ads or they just throw in like,
God knows, it could be like condom donkeys.
Awesome.
I think you can exclude some things.
I can't remember now if I did exclude anything.
I think there were a couple of petty things like,
I'll comment for now.
I think I might have,
I might have like deselected gambling.
I don't know, I hate gambling ads.
I get them on Amazon Prime.
Yeah.
Do you remember back in the old days when paying
for streaming services when you didn't get adverts
because that was the entire fucking point of the streaming service?
Yeah.
But yeah, all the adverts I get on Amazon Prime are for gambling
for some reason and I love them.
They're so manipulative and awful.
Anyway, other than that, who knows it, you know,
it's that's between you and God,
your adverts.
It's not your algorithm.
I was just going to say maybe we could start saying some weird shit
and see what kind of ads we get placed.
Maybe people start complaining.
Baby Jesus doll.
The Mormon church ads.
They do advertise too.
That's the funniest thing, man.
Anyway, okay.
Where are we starting?
I guess we can start with where we are,
which is we hope to be somewhere else.
We both hope to have new contracts
or to have re-contracting lockdown.
I guess I'm going to start with where I am
because I think that's probably like the elephant in the room.
Yeah.
And essentially, you know, in the lead up to,
so for book eaters, pretty much everything that could go right
for that novel did.
That was a pretty difficult success to repeat.
And we definitely didn't repeat it with girls 1,000 faces.
And I think there's probably a few reasons for that.
And one of them is it's just not as high concept.
It's not as timely.
There is that second book debut buzz drop, which happens.
And I mean, there is also a lot going on on the UK side.
But basically, I got the sentence very early on, you know,
that it was not going to be good on the UK side.
My original team wasn't gone.
Harper had moved.
Is continuing to move in a different direction
from the types of books I published.
And yeah, you know, very obviously I didn't make Sunday Times list.
That's partly because I didn't have books and stores.
So there seems to be like a massive problem with this
and try out at the moment, which is just getting worse for some publishers.
And I'm not entirely sure why it's something to do
like the distributors they're using or the distribution.
But I had no books and stores and release dates.
So I only had whatever broken binding TCM.
And we didn't make lists from that.
And I haven't really sold a huge amount of hard back in the UK.
And it's one of those weird things where like,
I think my first royalty check came in because I'm massively
out on the whole contract UK side.
And it paid about 23k, which is mostly special editions.
But my book is still a commercial failure in the UK,
which is a really, really weird thing in publishing, isn't it?
You know, you can get a decent royalty check
and still be a commercial failure relative to expectations.
And so all of that to say that basically the other thing that happened this year
is I started the process of reconstructing,
which I was nervous about because you know,
book eaters did okay. Actually, book eaters did very well.
But I wasn't obviously getting that vibe from girl to thousand faces.
So I went into both my publishers and I was like,
here, look, here's a bunch of ideas.
You know, I want you to pick what you think is the most commercial.
I'm willing to do any of them.
If you have other ideas, let me know.
You know, if none of them, you don't like them, that's fine.
They did pick one that they were both keen on.
And it was, you know, we've disgusted.
And it was, it's basically like a kind of speculative thriller horror/thing set in Scotland.
And it's kind of like, it takes the premise of Groundhog Day and says,
okay, but if the woman remembers it's not romantic comedy,
it's a horror novel, you know, it's horror story.
So that type of thing, sort of like time loop story that deconstructs in.
I wasn't, that wouldn't have been my pick,
but that's the one that they thought was the most commercial.
And it went to acquisitions.
And I did like a pitch deck and a synopsis.
And all these sample pages in a really short amount of time
because, because everyone also dithered so long on it.
And they shot it down.
And that means I have been dropped on the UK side from my books,
which I was expecting a low offer because of how girl the thousand faces did.
And the fact that I'm not willing to write romanticity or dark fantasy.
I wasn't expecting a no offer.
And it's one of those really annoying things
because I was thinking of walking away anyway from Harvard,
just because I don't think that like one of the recurring things
which we'll get into later with the titles,
is I think they're moving more and more at the moment
into a certain type of genre fiction
that I'm just like desperately trying to get out of.
But they fired me before I can quit.
So I was like, well, thanks.
Can I, can I just--
Yeah, I mean, no one's, sorry, gone.
No, no, no, I'll finish up and then I'll jump in.
Well, now it's just, I guess when I was, I'd been feeling really more and more uneasy
because so at the height of like book eaters being acquired
and when I had the original editor who was really, really keen for the type of fiction
I wrote, not just that book, but she, you know, she acquired me
and like Nick Binge and Kachionis Silver and a few other people
who all write in that kind of speculative commercial vein.
And I think her leaving changed that direction of the imprint
plus the romanticity trend and things like that.
And at the time when book eaters was acquired,
there was a brief period of time where Harper wanted to re-contract her away.
And where my agent at the time was like, yes, next time, you know,
we'll be asking for like 100K instead of 33K.
And to go from that in a couple of years too,
we don't want you at all.
Actually, you're not worth anything.
And, you know, your ideas aren't very commercial.
Is,
kind of a head flip. But you know that is the industry and that. So now I'm in the position
of I'm waiting to see what Tor will say. I mean that's really tricky when to talk about
because it's not a great practice to talk about business deals when they're ongoing.
I think Tor generally pretty keen like I think they're a very different speculative home
than Harbor at the moment. They publish a lot of that kind of fiction and for me they're
a good fit. I know people have had their issues with Tor but like for me they have always
been a good fit and a good home. Well yeah and I mean yeah. I have been on the wrong side
of you know the Tor opinion plenty and I will just say that they have done a good job
with your books and with a lot of books to be honest and from what I can tell the US side
has gone really well. So just to offer if I may, yeah sorry, were you done can I offer
a few thoughts on that whole process? Well I guess the last thing I say is that the
one part do you find frustrating is I said to my agent well what are we looking at when
we go into this store, this deal from Tor and he wouldn't, he could not give me an answer
he's like I don't want to speculate. So you know we are waiting for an offer and we don't
know if it will be good, if it will be bad, if it will be one book, if it will be four
books, it will be an increase it will be the same which is effectively decreased after
six years of inflation. We don't know what kind of like what that commitment and energy
will look like and we hope for the best and everyone will always say nice things but
everyone you know like my Harper editor like part of why we did all that work is because
I do think she was keen. Start with Tommy John a 2026 men's health editors choice in best men's
underwear experience exceptionally soft fabrics a fit that moves with you and all day comfort
across our premium underwear, sleepwear and lounge wear one less gift to worry about one
more reason to treat yourself own gifting season this black Friday with 50% off site wide
at Tommy John dot com slash holiday and use code holiday. But the rest of the team aren't
in my sales just don't support it at Harper. Well I do think part of that is because there
is just like a lack of interest in the book from the wider team on the UK side and that's
just that's life. But yeah sorry I will let you have a word in now. Oh no no problem at all
and I mean yeah I mean the the performance on in the two different markets is super interesting
and does go to show that the opinion of a very few people at a publisher even after acquisitions
even when you're in contract can have a huge impact right. But yeah you you ran through
a lot of stuff so what what was I going to say. Yeah okay so you framed a few things in
there really in a really interesting way so for one thing book eaters obviously did really
well right and I hadn't looked at your obviously this isn't an exact one to one for sales but I hadn't
looked at your good reads for a while for the girl with a thousand faces and I mean you're almost
to 7000 ratings what's it been five months five and a half months so 7000 ratings that I mean like
that's not the 60,000 the book eaters got it's not the more than 60,000 that I think it should have
but that's also not bad either right and I think I do think that this is the kind of book that
will will grow a following over time just because it's very good. I will say that I'm not sure
the title does enough marketing on its own for that book and what it is like I don't think it's
super obvious from the title or the cover that it's a semi horror I don't know how you'd even
even qualify it but I do I do wonder how that has played in because I've thought about that a lot
with you know my own title send in changing the title of my debut from Rise of the Mages to
Iyer which is what I had wanted all along for this broken binding release anyway all that to say
you you kind of framed it as a a commercial failure but I don't know I guess I just don't
see it that way because I still have optimism for you and for that book in particular just because
I think it's so good. So I mean your reviews slow down after the initial burst don't they?
so I will say that the people that it landed with it did better it has a like better
star rating I think it had different kinds of reviews there were I think for if you particularly
wanted a book that changes genre on you third of the way through and then you know changes back
a couple of times that's that's what you get so you're going to be yeah yeah I mean like it's sold
almost certainly it's sold a lot more copies than books that have hit the Sunday Times for example
and even you know USA I don't know about New York but yeah I mean if it come out two weeks before
it would have been number eight on the Sunday Times I mean it's just one of the I mean it's one of
those weird things like there there are books I've seen some books for like every book in the series
will be number one on the Sunday Times and none of them sold as much as like you know other books
are like number five later in the year and it's just it's a reflection of where you are because it's
a bell curve yeah and yeah I mean you couched it a little bit and maybe you want to cut me saying
this but straight up in this book didn't hit the Sunday Times and has not sold well because Harper
did not get the book on bookshelves by release day like that's that's the end in short and long
and short of it right like I mean yeah that's hard if they're not there I mean it's wider sale I
think my agent was saying to me that fantasy sales are pretty soft in the UK then again I mean
I think the audio did better in the States I really don't know I think I will actually know a lot
better at the end of this month when I have a sense of tour royalties and again it's not the did
it did awful but it's that how does it do in relation to book eaters and I would say at the moment
like it's probably somewhere between 30 to 50 percent less than book eaters is what I would say
I mean there's a lot of stock left on eight or wise it's not really shifting so I mean I'm keeping
an eye on it and I'm trying not to worry about it I I think publishers can be a bit weird and that
they often base sales unlike your first book or your first few weeks or your best cell I don't know I
don't I'm hoping that they baked in at least one dud into their calculations and I think the
sci-fi like they are being more careful with it which is a whole thing like we discussed the title
and so just to give listeners some context so I have a third book that's out next October
so it's a year from now and and there was an ongoing argument about the title that lasted seven
months we had to hand in we had a deadline for handing in the title as it had to go into retailer
sites so the book will appear in stores and stuff on October the 14th and we we got that sorted on
October the 13th so it's really really under the door but but the heart of that argument was
essentially that my two different publishers had two different ideas about marketing and positioning
and what they thought would be best for the next book and one of them was wanting a very very
genre title where they're like it's clearly post-apocalyptic and the people that want the post-apocalyptic
book will get the post-apocalyptic book with the post-apocalyptic things happen in the post-apocalyptic
landscape and then the other publisher which was tour was like no no we want like the book where
people who who hate sci-fi will be like but it's not sci-fi it is like a literary leaning book
that's set in Texas and there happens to be an apocalypse and we can pretend that we're very
intelligent and and not like a dirty genre reader and we'll buy it so they they wanted a title
that was like much more neutral and confident and that was like the heart of the discussion and I
think part of that is like them wanting to nail that positioning that title that cover next time
I do think that it is quite a smart book I mean it certainly has post-apocalyptic speculative
genre elements right more than a I don't know like a station eleven or what have you so it fits
better with genre than than a lot of those literary crossover post-apocalyptic however I do think
it has very strong elements of those literary deep characterization meaningful plot meaningful theme
and and mechanisms so I mean I I don't think tours wrong for that I really like the title you all
landed on I think it makes a lot more sense than of those generic genre titles that I fucking hate
out there so they're so bad like there is something to be said for a title that is just
just like dead on descriptive of what the book is,
communicates like the gothic,
the whatever gothic titles, right?
There's a lot to be said for that,
where it's just like, okay,
you look at the title and the cover
and you know exactly what you're getting with that book.
That makes sense.
But when it's just a genre title of vanilla genre title
just to have a genre title and that formatting,
God, I fucking hate that so much.
I was gonna say on the subject of titles,
and generic titles there were a lot of titles
that I wanted for my freighter's daughter horror,
historical horror, historical fantasy horror,
whatever the fuck it's gonna be categorized as.
And I really like God's that plague us.
But it ended up going out on sub last week
as accursed shores because something
that is extremely descriptive and tells the in this case,
the editors getting the submission exactly what it is
and what the story's gonna contain is important
on some level.
And I think that's gonna probably permeate down
to the commercialization and publishing process
should I get an offer?
But I won't like, I won't, I won't.
I think your book is about freighters.
So for me a title focusing on the gods took away from that,
I will say, but then accursed shores
doesn't really showcase her either.
And obviously you know this, but listen to that.
So the title I'd originally called my manuscript
"The Silence of Heaven" because it made sense
in the context of the book.
And I do understand why they push back against that
because it could also, like that sounds like
it could be a Christian memoir.
There are quite a few books that are called that.
There are no books called "The Morrow,"
which is the one we ended on, and that's fair enough.
- It's kind of funny that we actually had the exact same issue
with both of these titles.
We both went for like a, some small reference,
I guess, to something religious or biblical or what have you
and both made the wrong choice for that reason.
- Yeah, but also I think the thing that convinced me
was that I was trying to make like a title for samplers
in Canva, and I could not make that sequence awards look nice.
Long titles are really difficult to do well.
- Yeah.
- But yeah, there's only a few I can think,
like how high we go in the dark,
they manage to make that one look really, really good.
If you've ever seen that cover, it's really good.
But yeah, not a lot of them.
So anyway, yeah, titles, discussions,
we are all over the place as always,
but just matter, we can always edit.
- Just let it roll however it comes out.
So one thing that I wanted to talk about
a little bit on the subject of publisher failures,
in your case, it was your UK side publisher
not getting books to book stores on time.
The crazy thing is, still wearing the same old underwear,
chances are it's time for an upgrade.
Own gifting season this black Friday
with 50% off-site wide at TommyJohn.com/holiday
and use code holiday.
That's not an isolated incident, right?
Like I've seen at least a dozen authors
in the last one to two years posting
about how their book didn't get to book shelves on time.
So they weren't gonna have a chance at hitting list
and people were canceling pre-orders
because they weren't getting it on time or what have you.
Like it's a big, big deal for authors
and yes, it's a big deal for publishers as well.
They don't wanna lose sales,
but they are diversified, right?
They have dozens if not hundreds of titles
coming out every year.
An author, well, most authors only have one per year
at most coming out.
So if a publisher fucks up, that's a big deal.
And let's be clear, they'll say it's our distributor.
Oh, our printer didn't get it on time, blah, blah, blah.
But like you have so much lead time with these release dates
that not knowing that your book
isn't gonna hit the shelves well before that happens.
And I mean, like they can slide dates,
they can do a whole bunch of stuff even last minute
to not do any of that, to not be keeping track of that,
not be on top of that, not have back up whatever
you need to be doing to get books on shelves on time.
That's crazy.
And the worst part of that is that,
that people will post and say, oh, well,
do you have any recourse?
Like, surely the publisher's gonna make that right somehow.
Nope, publishing contracts.
All the ones I've seen and all the ones I've signed,
primarily protect publishers.
Authors have a duty to perform.
There's a whole bunch of language about what the author
has to do and what the author has to turn in, et cetera,
by certain dates.
But essentially the only things that publishing contracts
require of the publisher is to quote unquote publish it.
And sometimes it's by a certain date,
but there's no real stipulation of what happens
if it's not and dates get pushed all the time
with no consequence.
All they have to really do is publish it
and there's rights reversal clauses in most contracts,
but they have such small amounts that they have to hit
in terms of sales per year to keep your rights under license
that they're basically meaningless.
So I have thought a lot about a few contract clauses
that I would love to see in my own contracts,
but that I don't think are gonna happen,
especially for somebody in my position without leverage.
I don't think they're gonna happen
until and unless authors as an informal collective,
'cause as far as I understand,
a formal collective bargaining collective is not allowed
in publishing for whatever reason.
I think we should be fighting for them
as an informal collective.
And I can go into those unless they're too boring to mention.
- Yeah, well, I mean, you've made me think of two things.
So the first is that actually book eaters had similar,
but for different reasons, problems in the UK side,
getting into stores, which was caused by,
when book eaters came out,
water stands and black wells had merged as companies
and they had massive, massive, massive issues.
And we talked about at the time
that basically Harper got around it
by stalking the books themselves
and kind of like sending them out manually to stores,
but I was a priority for them at the time.
And that means we kind of got through it.
This time I wasn't a priority.
I mean, but I was aware, you know,
other books were getting into stores,
particularly because I launched in the same week
as a much, much, much bigger Romanticie book
that was put out by, you know, someone who will probably
talk more about this later by an industry insider author,
essentially, as in people who work in the industry
and get a book deal, which happens so much in the UK,
and it drives people's family insane.
- Oh, we're not talking about that.
- It was a huge book.
And there were a whole bunch of things with it.
Like, firstly, my publication date was moved
from later in the month to that month.
And maybe this is me being paranoid,
but like, you've got to launch something,
you can't spread everything out, right?
Some books have to overlap.
And I got shifted, I got moved around
with another bigger author,
and I think that was done so that that bigger author
didn't clash their release with,
the publisher didn't want to clash their release
with like their big lead debut.
And so instead I came out in the same week
as the big debut, which obviously ate every list
and award and so on, and had all the money thrown at it,
it was definitely in stores.
So that might my ramble of that is they can,
if your book is high enough on the ecosystem,
it can be done.
And on one sense, it's like, that's fine,
like that's life, that's the food chain.
I'm in a different place in the food chain,
or rather, in different places of the world,
like in the States, I'm higher up in the food chain
and the UK I'm lower down,
which is a really odd experience to see both sides of that.
And for some of my friends, it's the other way around.
But that therefore it's on me to try and move
to a different environment where I'm in a different place
in the food chain, that's what you're always looking out
for yourself.
- Well, the crazy thing is you shouldn't have to be
at a certain place in the food chain
just for your publisher to want to give you
the best chance to succeed.
Like in theory, your incentives are aligned, right?
You make money, they make money.
It shouldn't be that hard.
And people from the outside, and even people
who think they're on the inside
who haven't gone through this personally,
or who have mostly had a smooth time of publishing.
So I think like no shade to all these big authors
that have their podcasts and their Instagram,
whatever the fuck, where they're talking about,
Oh, this is how publishing works.
You know what?
I'm glad it works.
works that way for you, but Jesus fucking Christ, like for most people, it's not just,
"Oh, you got to make sure incentives are aligned." And then your publisher's just going
to do all this great work for you. Like, nope, stuff gets lost. They are overworked. And
when the push comes to shove, somebody's going to get the boot. And it's, yeah. Like you
said, your place in the food chain matters as an author, unfortunately.
It's just, yeah, I think if you think of your book as like a little creature, and every
imprint is a different ecosystem, and that ecosystem depends on the team that's currently in
that particular jungle. And you have to find the ecosystem that's better for you. And
like if I wrote different books, I would probably do better where I am. But there is, there
is just no world in which I write, romanticy, because I just don't, I'm just like the least
sentimental person ever, I don't care. I'm so not romantic. But the other thing I was
thinking of is when you're talking about contracts. And I was thinking about this a lot. Like,
there has been so much discussion with me and my agent about, there's like some different
books that I want to write, maybe, which may or may not come under the, the tour contract
or, you know, if the YA or middle grade. And then we have to think about like non-compeets
and it's just going to step on toes. But on the flip side of that, you know, an option
is supposed to take 30 days. Seven months is not 30 days, right? So like the, well, the
title took seven months, but the, the option has also been kind of, I guess it's more five
months, been ongoing since like May. And there's just like that as standard, you know, the
option often takes months, maybe on the two weeks or four weeks that publishers are supposed
to have no consequences or issues for them for disregarding that. But if I go and choose
to disregard a non-compete clause, which by the way is not legally enforceable, you know,
there are repercussions to that relationship because the dynamic is what it is.
Yeah. Okay. So yeah, let's talk about this because this is something I want to talk
about a lot in a lot of different places to a lot of different people and make it a popular
thing. So publishing contracts almost always have two things that trap the author more than
people think they do. One is what you just mentioned the non-compete clause, right? Which
is really interesting because at least in my contract. And so publishers will have
boilerplate contracts and agencies will have boilerplate contracts and then they'll, you
know, negotiate from there. And very rarely will they ask or listen to an author who wants
certain things, but I'm going to start pushing that harder. In my contract, which I believe
is mostly an agency boilerplate, they like pretty specifically exempt most everything
from the non-compete, right? Like I can even write about my same characters that are in
the license work if I want to. The non-compete is fairly toothless. I know we've talked to
some people even in our, you know, discord group that have more robust non-compete, which
sucks, but non-compete can be whittled down to be fairly toothless. However, and I will
say this, non-compete makes sense, right? If a publisher has licensed rights to a work
and they are putting money into those characters that world, that work, it makes sense for
them to say pretty basic things like, hey, you know, don't turn this YA fantasy character
into a, you know, sex fantasy hardcore erotica with the same characters in world with another
publisher or with an indie book that you release, right? Like it makes sense for them
to want some protections around what they're investing in, right? So I will say that the
worst clause that they put in that actually traps people, traps authors particularly is
what you talked about the right of first refusal, right? Or an option clause, people call
it an option clause, but what it is is just a right of first refusal. So the publisher
says, hey, we want the exclusive right to look at your next work that's not under contract
for 30 days before another publisher can bid on it, right? And it doesn't mean you have
to accept that bid that they make on basically what would be a preempt, right? Of you going
out wide again with your next work that's not under contract. But in practice, what they
put into these clauses is a stipulation that they have 30 days to look at it, but it's
30 days from, at least I think in mind, 30 days from the time that you have not just turned
in the last work that's under contract, but that they have accepted it. And I'm sure some
are based on publishing dates and what have you. So I don't still wearing the same old underwear,
chances are it's time for an upgrade. Start with Tommy John, a 2026 men's health editor's
choice, invest men's underwear, experience exceptionally soft fabrics, a fit that moves
with you, and all day comfort across our premium underwear, sleepwear and loungewear. I don't even know whether those are legal or not, but I am going to push. Nobody sticks
to them. But I mean, that's insane, right? And especially if the right-of-first refusal
is overly broad, like fiction, all fiction, right? Instead of it being very specific
to your next work of whatever category and subcategory that this is, right? Because they
want to be able to bid on that. But it's just meaningless from their perspective. It doesn't
help the author in any way. It literally only traps authors and limits their ability to
put out more work and to put that work on the market and get fair market value for that
work. It serves no beneficial purpose. I don't know of any publishers that are like actively
making that happen. You already have that relationship with the author. You already
have an end to be like, "Hey, author, we've really liked working with you on these first
three books. We'd like to pay you money in this amount to keep working with you on similar
books, different books. Doesn't matter. You already have that relationship. In theory,
you're talking all the time. Like, there is no need for these option clauses and write
a first refusal. And they cause authors so much stress and so much harm. I think we should
get rid of them completely." Yeah. And I think as well because, you know, you can't
submit an option whenever you want, right? So you can't be like, often that discussion
has to be initiated from the publisher. So if you have something you've written, which
doesn't really fit, like, say you're mostly right, fantasy, and you want to write like
a YA sci-fi, which is technically covered by the option clause, but isn't really something
your publisher is wanting to do. You can't submit it and like burn that option. Or if you
do, it apparently is harmful. But you can't do that to then take it out somewhere else.
And so there is sometimes this aspect, if they don't want you to, they don't want it,
but they don't want it and we'll still have it either. You're just like, okay, we need
to diversify them. It's literally just trapping. Yeah. And the only intent that they could
possibly have in wanting to trap authors in this way is to make them desperate and to
get them to sign their work over the next time for the least amount of money possible.
It is literally just pressing and suppressing author earnings and author careers. There's
no benefit. That's apparently why they're not legal because they're not supposed to be
able to prevent you from earning an income, but in practice, they are something you have
to continue with. So again, let's talk about them as different things because they are
different. I think in certain states in the US, not at a federal level, not at a country
level. In certain states, I think that's what a British person told me for here. I think
non-compete are not enforceable/illegal. Obviously, they're not illegal because they're still
writing them in. Well, that wouldn't necessarily preclude it, but I would assume their legal
people are smart enough to not put actual illegal language in their contracts, but they're
probably not enforceable, right? Which means that there hasn't been a law pass that says,
hey, you're doing illegal things if you put a non-compete clause in a contract. But
what's happened is they've been ruled in a court, so there's existing precedent, legal
precedent for those not being enforceable, right? However, I do not know of that being
the same case for option clauses. As far as I know, those haven't been litigated to the
same extent, and all of those existing cases for non-compete have to do with other industries.
It's not like this has been litigated in the publishing industry because for the most
part, authors who have money to be litigating these things are treated very well by publishers.
And agents aren't going to be quick to be suing publishers on these things because agents
make their money by being in good with all of the imprints and editors that they can,
right? So all the people that these things affect are
in a pretty poor place to be able to litigate it, which again is what these corporations are
counting on. So I do not believe that the option portion of these contracts is necessarily
unenforceable. There may be a case and they might try, even if there is a case to enforce this,
even though it's anti-competitive, I just don't know of any precedent that would protect us here,
which is why I think we should be paying very, very careful attention to what is said in any
option clauses written into contracts and/or just insist that there not be options. Because again,
it's like, what author is going to work with a publisher and have a good time, sell a lot of
books with that publisher, and then be like, no, I don't want to work with you anymore, right?
Like, that's just not the way the world works. Like, just do a good job, don't fucking suck it,
everything you do, don't try to bleed us dry, and we'll probably work with you again. Like,
where authors aren't the most crony people around. Yes. Like, every author in the world,
what they want is to be picked up for their books to sell well and just keep signing contracts
and writing books. Like, very few of us are going around like, oh, no, I need to, I need to get the
last dollar I can from, you know, the next publisher and blah, blah, blah. Somewhere, obviously,
I'm not going to say that none of us are, but that's not the general rule. So, long story short,
fuck option clauses. Let me just get thread one second. Yeah, no worries.
Yeah, so you're talking about how you think option clauses should be banned. So, that brings me
kind of something that encompasses both the things we've discussed already, and a few other things.
There's something I think that should be revisited, at least in the UK. And that's the way that our
bestseller lists work. Because one of the things that we've been, I've been talking a lot about
with a lot of British authors. And some Americans is the way that crates have dominated
genre fiction in the UK. And I think it's, I don't know, it's to the point now where it's like
crates don't help you, right? They're almost like a poison chalice because once you get in a
crate, the publisher is like, I'm glad we don't have to do the marketing unless it's a lead title,
in which case they build on it. So, you get these books, they get in the crates, they hit the Sunday
Times, they disappear into the fucking abyss. You never hear of them or they author again. The
publisher caches in the check, comes time to re-contracting, they turn around kind of like they do
to mean say, well, your crate sales don't really count because they're not repeatable even if they are.
And your other sales are terrible because, you know, nothing else has been done, it's like,
push the crate. And then that author just like disappears into the either, never heard from again.
And meanwhile, you know, what they continue to chase and acquire is whatever will be the
next book that can be in the next crate. And I just don't really see any way out of that other
than possibly changing our system so that like the US, like the New York Times, if you get into a
crate, it does not count towards the list. And I think that would be an interesting shakeup again
in the UK. I don't know if it would actually be positive, like I can't guarantee that, but I do kind
of think maybe we're at the point where if that doesn't change, the trend chasing is going to be
out of control if it isn't already. It is already. Yeah. And I mean, this goes into a whole other
thing that we've talked about quite a lot, how publishers more and more are looking for
the easiest possible path to sales, right? And so historically, there have been all these claims of,
oh, you shouldn't write to trend because that trend will be over or no, we don't write to trend,
we just look for the best books, blah, blah, blah. But that's clearly not the case, right? Like
being picked up for a crate changes your career in a very significant way. And as some people
have mentioned, publishers are treating crate selection as their mechanism for marketing,
for getting the book out into the world for determining the fate of a book, right? Which is
crazy because like, yeah, it's between 10 and 30,000 sales right off the bat. That's amazing.
But at the same time, like publishers have the money. They have the reach to do that. They could
get that many copies out pretty easily if they wanted to, if they wanted to put the money
behind a book that they really believe in, but they don't. These crates do, but they don't. And
this ties very closely into other things we've, other trends we've talked about.
Those being one, deals going to people with platform. More and more, we are seeing publishers
give a lot more attention in acquisitions to, and again, this is something that they have
disavowed. They have claimed is not the case. But so, so many
debuts in particular are going to influencers or podcasters or children of famous authors, or
I mean, who's that? I mean, I don't want to name names because I'm sure they're a lovely person.
But wasn't there a child of a pretty famous UK author or actor actress something that released recently?
There is two. There's two at the moment. Yeah. So anyway, I'm not even trying to call them out
because I'm not and I'm not trying to say that their books aren't wonderful and that they shouldn't
do it. Like we've we talked about before we hit record, like I would love it if my daughter decided
she wanted to write and became an author in her own right. And hopefully by that time I've found
some level of success. And if I could lend, you know, my name and my my knowledge, et cetera,
to help her in some way, I'm going to do that. So like I'm not I'm not blaming people for this.
However, from the publisher side, that is weak as fuck.
Start with Tommy John, a 2026 men's health editor's choice invest men's underwear,
experience exceptionally soft fabrics, a fit that moves with you, and all day comfort across our
premium underwear, sleepwear and loungewear. One less gift to worry about. One more reason to
treat yourself. Own gifting season this black Friday with 50% off site wide at TommyJohn.com/holiday
and use code holiday to have not just that this happens, but to have the majority of your money,
not even just acquisitions, but the majority of your money going to these sure bets,
regardless of what their books look like, whether that sure bet is from their name, their connections,
their platform, their, you know, indie sales, whatever the fuck it is, that's that's weak as fuck.
The other thing that is weak as fuck is handing deals to industry insiders, which as I understand
it has always happened at a pretty solid clip, but it seems particularly bad, as you mentioned,
in the UK right now. So we, I mean, we touched on this a little bit last time where we actually
went through and looked at all the recent deals listed in Porsche's marketplace. And I have since
expanded that from 2025 all the way down to 2026, 2024, 2023, and kind of looking at them. And
I think it's, I was initially started thinking, I want to see how many self-pub books are being
picked up as debuts. To be honest, not that many, like not as many as I thought, there were,
there were probably more industry related, even in the US though, it was only about I think 5%,
however, I think the UK is worse and, you know, we discussed this a little bit because we don't have
publishers marketplace in the UK. So not everything gets announced, right? Things that,
announcements which are important get put in the bookseller, but the bookseller is not like publishers
marketplace, it's curated. So you can submit a deal announcement and they can say yes or no,
if I think it's newsworthy. And that means that the bigger and more newsworthy deals are the ones
you tend to see and quite a few of them lately, at least in our genre, have gone to people who work
fairly high up in publishing. And so I've got, I mean, I've got so many thoughts on that. So
I mean, first I'm going to say, okay, only I think like 5% of the ones we could find in recent
recent years on the US side were obviously like this person is an editor. However, so 0.1,
there are deals that happen on the inside which don't get published as such. So I've told the story
before but like I used to know someone through a writer forum who their family was able to support
them to get an unpaid internship in New York working in and big five office. They used that
internship to pitch their novel to their boss who was an editor, used that offer to get an agent
and then took it on water sub and got them an auction. They got seven figure deal and their book
did really well, right? And that is not going to go into publishers marketplace and be reported
as an industry insider deal, but it is. And then you have other deals where it's like, you know,
people use pen names or they'll be allowed to preempt, you know, slide under and they won't
mention the fact that it was also like six figures or that like you know their agent became an
editor and bought the book from them or whatever. I think there are quite a few that happen
and there are some that are more obvious than others. But the other side of it is that like
it would just be really nice if you could ever see some kind of admission from folks in publishing
that it is a privilege that it is an advantage because the kind of the way they spin it is
like no no you still have to go through all the things and run all through just like you and it's
like but you're not an author just like us. Yeah. Like if you were an editor or a marketing
you know top figure and you could have publishing deal your experience is going to be so different
right. So no one is ever going to come to you and say we're not doing arcs for environmental
reasons. No one is ever going to come to you and say like here's your marketing meeting and it's
just like a PDF of how to use Instagram. Yeah. Yeah. You know that the lies and the level
of bullshit is not the same. It is not the same experience. Yeah. You know your colleagues not
going to go four months without answering your emails because you work in the same fucking office
you're not going to get ghosted in that way. It's just also on the subject of that environmental
that excuse which is a real one that you hear sometimes when publishers are like we're not
going to do arcs for environmental reasons. That's insane. I just have to say that is the dumbest
fucking excuse. Like you might be my favorite publishing excuse because because what do you mean
you don't want to turn books like trees in the books. That is the industry. That's the industry.
Where are you in publishing if you don't want to print things. Yeah. That's insane. Now I can joke
about this a little bit because it's not a line that has ever been used against me but I want
people in publishing to know that if you have ever said that line about we're not going to print
arcs for environmental reasons. Nobody believes you. No authors believe you. They're not going to
tell you so because the power dynamic doesn't allow them to call you out on that bullshit statement
but they do not believe you because it is obviously nonsense. If a novel suddenly starts selling like
a million copies or a hundred you know billion copies or whatever, no publisher and the history
you've ever until the end of the heat death of the universe is going to turn around and go oh no
I'm sorry we can't print more books because we're environmentally conscious now. I'm the
fucking Lorax and I speak for the trees. There's just this utter insanity like I think what
particularly grinds me about that excuse is because it's so obviously manipulative you know it's
said with the intention of like well you don't want to be that author who hates trees do you
save the environment and then the owner just becomes on you to be really nice about it.
But it's so cowardly and manipulative and I hate it so much. That is lit. I mean I got
I was told when my debut happened or barely happened is we're not doing that anymore because
nobody's in offices and it's like do they not have houses? Do you not have their address because
if they're working they're working from somewhere but yeah I think one other thing to point out is
that this isn't even about the frequency because obviously cold queries still work at some
some rate. Client subs or unknown subs still work at some rate like we are both examples of that
at different deal sizes but we're both examples of that but it's not just a matter of the frequency
it's a matter of what kind of deals these people are signing so again people with pre-existing
platforms people with you know like whatever indie backgrounds with a lot of sales whether those
sales came organically or not and then people who are inside of the industry. If you look at those
just those three categories of you know publishers picking up people for other reasons then just
purely what their book is and you look at not just the frequency of those pickups but the amount
of money going toward those pickups as a percentage of you know money going to debuts or even just
money going to acquisitions period it's big right like the example you just mentioned of a UK
publishing I don't know if you'd call them an executive but high up in the leadership of a UK
publishing company recently signing a deal they didn't just sign a deal they signed a major deal
right in the US and then a six-figure deal in the UK and it's like there are three of them in
Frankfurt that at least there are three of them this week I think that announced and there's
been loads throughout the year yeah exactly and so it's again it's not I mean like the
yesterday your lady was a podcaster before she wrote that book right and sold that book and again
I'm not look we're as guilty as anybody we're sitting here recording a podcast right it's not like
it's not like we wouldn't take these advantages if we had them it's not like I'm discouraging people
in the industry or discouraging people from publishing it Indian then going try out if they get
traction or discouraging people from from pursuing a platform if you want to do those things
that's great it's the fact that we're told that those are not the determining factors and that
it's all meritocratic when it is very clearly not yeah just a a matter of merit right not
every book not every author is getting the same shot that others are and so it's a rigged game
and they want to pretend that it's not and I mean also we said this the start before recording and
I think it bears mentioning here like to me a publisher picking up someone who's got a large
platform is actually at least a fairly sensible business decision because you've proven that you
can build an audience that you have a readership yeah that makes sense to me to exploit obviously
when they do it at a stupid level like the Mr. Beast thing which really did not work out well for
Harper comments that was really stupid spending 15 million is never going to work out or however
you know started 10 million the auction whatever went to that was never going to work out well
I think the editor thing and the industry and decide everything bothers me more because there's
all the other stuff that goes on with it it's the fact that you then become competition with your own
authors yeah you know it if an event comes up and they're like we're looking we're looking for
fantasy authors and that this this literary festival and someone who works in the industry is a
lot better place to put themselves forward for that yeah and an author is who can't picture for it
and if they only have one slot are you really going to give it to your author you're going to give
it to yourself and if you appear on that like do we actually know that you even tried to to pitch
someone other than you know yourself so there's a whole yeah and I there are some agents I've seen
online who are really really defensive about this and really cagey and they always say things like
it hardly ever happens but when it does happen you know that's every industry and it's like okay but
I would complain about it regardless yeah just just from our how many people do we have in our
discord now like ten ish I mean there's there's more and other discords and like my agency discord
and stuff there's but I'm just saying from this this this small discord that we have that I'm in
10 10-ish people we have what four or five now that have had editors or you know close I guess
people at the publishing imprints they work closely with or that have some hour over how their books
do four or five examples of six people who have editors or publishing people that have gone
on to publish their own books that's a crazy rate yeah and the other thing I would say is that like
you know industry folks can dismiss it and because no one is ever going to talk about it they'll
say they're doing nothing wrong it's like okay but then if you talk about everyone it like it's
mad at you but people don't like it you know it is definitely a source resentment yeah I promise
I'm absolutely certain that the vast majority of authors find it incredible still wearing the same
old underwear chances are it's time for an upgrade start with Tommy John a 2026 men's health
editors choice investments underwear experience exceptionally soft fabrics a fit that moves with
you and all day comfort across our premium underwear sleepwear and loungewear one less gift to worry
about one more reason to treat yourself own gifting season this black Friday with 50% off site wide
at Tommy John dot com slash holiday and use code holiday irritating particularly like when it's
your own I mean this one doesn't happen so much but when you're in your own imprint like an editor
gets picked up within that kind of so it's the level of incestuousness is crazy yeah well and I mean
it's it's conflict of interest right like you said yeah that's the biggest issue and again it's like
from their perspective I get it if I worked in publishing because I loved books I would want to
publish too and I would take that advantage if I had it and I know that publishing your own book
doesn't pay enough to quit your full-time job so like I can't I can't fully condemn the people
doing this however the industry has to recognize that there is a huge conflict of interest
and that the authors that these people work with are being disadvantaged or at the very least
have a reason to believe they're being disadvantaged by these scenarios yeah so it's it's not a good
look and I think especially if publishing gets more and more risk averse and they take fewer chances
and the chances they do take are like yeah platform insider celebrity yeah
- It's just, it's not going over very well.
- In a lot of scenarios, it makes sense for the publisher.
Can't really fault the people who are being picked up
'cause it's like who's not gonna take a good deal
for something you've put your heart and soul into.
But on a systemic level, it's, yeah, rough.
And again, the whole point of this podcast,
the whole reason we take the time to do this
is trying to tell the truth about what you're going to encounter
in this industry, whether people on Reddit
are gonna appreciate what we're saying or not.
It's, it's not a fair game, right?
Like playing the game by the rules is possible,
but it's probably not gonna go the way you'd hope.
You, we all should be looking for every advantage we can find.
- Yeah, I think to focus on something,
'cause something else on your list to discuss,
which kind of ties back into the great stuff,
is different ways of doing things.
So on the US side,
Girl Thousand Faces got picked up
by a sort of create company called ArtVark Books.
And they ran a crate in a way I had not seen before.
So firstly, because it doesn't count for a list,
there was no rush to reschedule a book.
It didn't have to like match.
You could go out in a slightly different month
from my release, which was nice.
- Yeah.
- But the way they work is they pay
an advance, and essentially they pay an advance to the author.
And then every month they put out,
I think it's like five, it might be four to five books.
It might be six, I think it's five.
- Yeah.
- Five books in different genres.
And subscribers can pick any one of those books
by default, and you can pay a bit extra to have more.
I think you can up to three.
If there's nothing that you like in that month of five,
you can pick stuff that they still have stock of
from previous months.
So they continue selling through old stock.
And it's just such a nice model,
because what it means is that, you know,
when you've got a choice like five or six books,
there's probably going to be something you like,
and you're not going to get the same stuff
that's curated within an inch of its life.
- Yes.
- You know, it's not just going to be romantic
every month or whatever.
You know, you can get the same types of book.
You can only pick the sci-fi and fantasy.
That's what you want.
You can only pick the litfic if that's what you want.
But then if there's ever a month
where you're like, hang on, you know,
I found see something a little bit different.
Maybe I'll make an exception for this book.
You have that exposure and you have that ability
to try it without kind of punishing the author
or punishing the book company for branching out.
So the whole thing just works really, really well.
And it doesn't sell the tens of thousands of copies.
It's some of the big crates in the UK, so.
But it's perhaps a more sustainable model.
And I do think it means things don't calcify.
Because one of the things that happens to the crates here,
right, is like, so when I, when I was first involved
in loomacrate, they were still putting up books
that had like, say, no magic in it.
A portrait of a thief was like a heist book.
And the readers fucking punish them for it.
They were all like cancelling.
They didn't take that month, you know,
companies left with extra stock.
And because the readership is a certain way,
it is pushed a lot of the crates to be like,
okay, this is our romanticism description.
This is our sci-fi subscription.
Because you all hate sci-fi.
This is our horror subscription.
Because you all hate horror, you know.
So there are, there's enough different subscribers
for those different subgenres.
But they, they don't intermix.
And they end up completely siloed.
There's a lady on threads a while ago saying
that she'd read 47 her fantasy books
and around, they were all starting to blend together.
And I was thinking, well, fucking hell,
just like read a different subgenre.
If only you could buy something different.
But if you're in a certain community,
if you're only buying like crate books, sorry, I hate you a lot.
You know, if you're only getting certain types of books
presented to you, you just feel like there's nothing
else on offer.
So yeah, I really appreciated our barks model.
I appreciated the thought they put into all the different
books they chose.
The fact there's something for everyone,
the fact that you can have stock that continues to sell.
So you're not just like a one-hit wonder here and gone.
And that was all really cool.
Yeah, that is awesome.
I like that model.
And I think I'm going to sign up for that.
It's because it's the code.
Yeah.
And we are not sponsored by them.
We would love to be our bark.
Hit us up.
We will talk about you as much as you want.
I mean, I probably will.
And they moved to UK because I think actually for me,
the attraction of them is the curation.
Rather than because normally if you sign up for a book box,
it's more or less about the goodies,
like the really, really fancy.
So if you're into super fancy covers, they are not for you
because they don't really do love custom editions.
It's the curation.
Here's why we chose these books.
Why we think you'll enjoy it, type thing.
Not just curation, right?
Don't they?
Yeah.
So in the USA membership is $18 a month accounts for one book.
So they're basically doing the audible model
where you can pay a subscription cost
that's lower than the MSRP of the book.
And because they have that subscription cost banked,
they can probably buy wholesale rates
and offer you a lower markup rate for the books
rather than what bookstores have to do
where they have to charge, sorry, bookstores love you so much,
but they have to charge more on top of that, whatever it is,
50%, 55% wholesale discount rate.
How much of your fucking hard backs?
How much are hard covers now?
A lot.
And like, let's, I mean, Amazon's the one
that typically gets to the bottom dollar,
but let's look at your book on Amazon right now.
OK, mine is like 30 bucks these days.
Right.
So in the UK standard hardback is 18 quid, 18 to 20,
which is about $24.25 US dollars.
It's not 30.
Your hard cover right now for me on Amazon is $24.06.
OK, mine would be $21 US dollars.
For a girl with a lot of cases, it's $20.
And I mean, they discount as they get build up stock
that doesn't sell and whatever.
I don't know exactly how mine came out that low.
I think because they didn't have any confidence in it.
I mean, no, I don't know.
But MSRP, the MSRP is $30.
So the fact that hardvark is offering straight up,
you can pay 18 bucks a month for a book
and $11 for each extra book.
That is very low.
That's pretty banging.
OK, yeah.
$11, especially if they're all hard covers, $11 for a hard cover,
they must be getting--
I mean, how are they even doing that?
Because as far as I understood, wholesale rates
were a 55%-ish discount, 50% to 55% discount off of MSRP
that they offer to bookstores, whoever.
They do print their own versions.
So all the books they have are printed by them.
They just don't print different covers generally.
So mine is the same cover, but there's
like an A on this line.
But it is a slightly different--
Yeah, so it is a slightly different printing.
Yeah, that's why you get an advance in royalties.
So I think they are printing them.
And maybe they've figured out a way to print them lower cost.
I have no idea.
But they are printing their own.
But yeah, anyway, god, we've given them so much press.
But it's just because it was a really interesting model.
And the other one I was thinking about a lot lately
is broken binding as a publisher because the whole-- we don't
count your crate sales thing.
Does not apply when they are the crate.
I just think that broken binding in particular
has a super smart model, investing in their art,
but also building the--
and I mean, Daphne's doing the same thing,
but building their subscription services at the same time
as their publishing houses and things like that
makes a lot of sense.
But Art of Arc is a slightly different model.
And taking the printing their own books
at a lower standard or whatever it is
they do to get the price down out of it, which
may or may not make sense on its own,
the model of having a subscription service
where you can pick out of a pool of curated books,
which in the case of a publisher,
you'd think that maybe they would offer something like that
where you could pick from their books
that they choose to publish, because that is a curation,
but not a lot do.
So yeah, a lot of models that could happen out there
that haven't at a high rate, but that
is one of the more interesting ones.
I'm going to have to look into Art of Arc.
Anyway, did you want to say more on that on Art of Arc
and those models?
I have two other contract things I wanted to mention.
No, go for your contract things.
I think they'll be interesting.
OK, so going back to the contract clauses
and I'm sorry if you have to splice this in back to there
or just let it run as we get to it, I don't really care.
So going back to those, we talked about right
of first refusal, which I think should go away completely,
non-competes, which I think actually
make sense from a publisher standpoint
and are very fair to include, but authors and agents
should be paying attention to and making sure
they are not too restrictive.
And don't restrict them from diversifying the work
that they're doing, the smartest thing you can do
is get more contracts with more publishers
for different kinds of books, see what works, try to get out there,
try to get some sales, build your brand, whatever.
Keep going, I'm just grabbing track, the most corner.
Yeah, no worries.
So the other two that I wanted to mention,
and we did mention a little bit, one is rights reversal.
So right now, most contracts have a rights reversal clause.
Chances are, it's time for an upgrade.
Start with Tommy John, a 2026 men's health editor's choice invest men's underwear, experience
exceptionally soft fabrics, a fit that moves with you, and all day comfort across our premium
underwear, sleepwear, and loungewear.
Own gifting season this black Friday with 50% off-site-wide at TommyJohn.com/Holiday and
use code holiday says something like you have to sell $100 or like $500 worth of these books
per period, whether it's per quarter or per year, it's a poultry amount.
And I think we should be advocating as an informal collective for much more robust rights
reversals so I think rights that are unused, it shouldn't take forever and goodwill on
the part of the publisher for rights that go unused to be reversed probably before publication.
Like there should be a cliff like maybe six months before the agreed upon publication
date or something where if the publisher isn't going to utilize special edition or audio
or foreign rights that they have under contract, there should be a reversal or at the very least
an option for a repurchase or something like that.
And I mean that's exactly what happened to me, right?
Tor took world English, I didn't know any better at the time, they took audio, I didn't
know any better at the time, they took special editions, and they didn't use any of them.
They didn't try to have an audio book made when we went and submitted audio to audio publishers.
It was very easy to sell, they had not seen it before, very obvious that they told me
that they were trying and they just did not try, right?
Same thing with trying to get it into the UK, they just fulfilled their basic obligation
of, yep, we published this and they're off the hook, right?
So I think there should be stronger rights reversal for rights that aren't used that are
under a contract.
But also for books that are still selling, I mean, I think we should be tying rights
reversal to a percentage of the advance paid maybe, I don't know if that's a fair percentage.
What do you mean?
Okay, so…
How that work?
Yep, and so this is just a first wild guess at how it could work, right?
If you sign a contract for $100,000 for three books, right?
And so the effect of $33,000 per book, in theory, I mean, because they just set a blanket
dollar amount right now, and that probably doesn't make sense to just set a higher blanket
dollar amount for most contracts, so it probably makes more sense to tie it to a percentage
of whatever you're signing those rights over for.
So say it was 10%, that publisher would have to sell $10,000 worth of that book.
And I don't know whether you'd want to frame it as sales or probably proceeds that go
to the author, effective royalties, whether they're counting against an advance or not.
If the publisher does not sell that book to the level that you are getting 10% of that
royalty, or I'm sorry, of that advance per year in royalties, I think we should be pushing
for reversal, or maybe it's 5%, and maybe it's tied per book or the contract level.
I'm not sure exactly what would make sense and be fair, but I think it is a shame that
there are hundreds, thousands of books out there that were published, they may or may not
have had support up front, and now they are just on the publisher's back catalog.
They hold on to these rights, and I don't even know what they would charge if authors
are trying to buy them back, but sometimes they do.
I mean, Buelman famously bought back rights to between two fires, right, and four rights.
But I've heard from some other people who have inquired about purchasing their rights back
that the publishers are actually asking quite a lot of money for them, despite the fact
that they are no longer selling because the publisher is not promoting them, and not
only are they not promoting them, they're not getting them on bookshelves, it's not like
they have physical books that they're printing and sending out, they've just put them on
their on-demand, print on-demand.
Yeah, yeah, they moved to POD.
Roaster?
Yeah.
Do you remember how to check for that?
What's that?
Do you remember, because Julia V was telling us how you can check if your books have been
put on POD.
I remember.
And there's a way to do that, we'll have to ask her again.
Yeah.
Basically, you can check, I think, possibly through Adelaise, to find out if your books
have been moved to POD or not, which is print on-demand, sorry.
Exactly.
But in no scenario does it make sense, especially if you're signing over rights for quite a
lot of money, in no scenario does it make sense for the author to have your rights sit
with a publisher forever if they are just selling 500 bucks worth of them per year with
very, very minimal effort.
I would hazard a guess that most authors would put a lot more effort and care into that
backlist if they stood to profit more from it, because I mean, an author can put their
shit on print on-demand, an author can put their book on Kindle easily enough, so I think
we should be advocating for stronger rights reversal clauses.
And the last one.
Yeah, that's interesting.
Sorry, go ahead.
I was just saying that's an interesting one, I'm agreeing.
So, and I mean, publishers aren't going to like that one, right?
Because they profit from having these books sit on their backlist, not much, because
they're not doing a lot of work to sell them, but they do profit.
They probably have a pretty solid income stream just from that enormous pool of backlist
books selling occasionally.
And then the last one that I've thought about, and I think this is, this is when I found
an article from like the authors guild or some of my, I can't keep track of all those groups
that are out there semi advocating for things that never happen, but more morality clauses.
So this is a big one, especially in this era of AI accusations.
So it seems like a good thing to have morality clauses in contracts, and it seems fair that
a publisher would put it in a contract that, hey, you know, the author can't do anything
to, you know, make it yourself.
Probably a Nazi.
Yeah, exactly, exactly.
It can't be a Nazi can't, can't use AI, whatever it may be, right?
I don't, I don't remember exactly everything.
Who is that, that author that got super canceled and Daphne had to look at how they could
drop them and it ended up being a morality clause thing?
Was it Caitlin?
What's her face?
I can remember them.
What did they do?
What, why'd they get super musical?
Oh, they were.
If it's the person I'm thinking of, they will review bombing other authors.
Oh yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So anyway, yeah, like it's not hard to think of plenty of cases in which a morality clause
could and should be invoked and an author should be dropped, right?
However, they are written to be so broad that authors can effectively be dropped by citing
these morality clause for just about any reason.
The way I've seen them written and implemented, and God, I should have come prepared with
this specific example.
But essentially, anything the author does that the publisher doesn't like, they can invoke
that morality clause and be dropped for that.
It could literally be anything.
And the issue is that if it's non-specific, you have very little protection against the
publisher deciding, hey, this book isn't selling well, you know, the first book of a contract
or something, or pay the industry, the trends pivoted away from this thing.
We just paid a shit ton of money for it.
And now we think we're going to take a bath, even though we signed a contract.
They could use a morality clause, whether it's valid or not, to get out of that.
So I think people should be really careful with what those morality clauses say.
But the worst part, and I'm not sure there's anything we can do about this because we
don't have that kind of leverage.
But there's nothing similar on the other side, right?
There's nothing that says--
>> The bullshit clause.
>> Yes.
There's nothing that says, hey, publisher, if you publish my work, you can't also publish
books by fucking fascist Nazis that are trying to take over our government.
You know?
>> I didn't mean anything that good.
I meant stuff like if you say that you don't want to publish works because you care about
the trees, because you're suddenly the fucking lower acts of bullshit, and you've waved
your option.
>> Yes.
I think there should be a separate bullshit clause.
of like, if you try to gaslight and lie to me about things, you should be liable for that, right?
Like, - Adverts don't have good ROI for books, you know, okay?
- Yeah, the amount of just straight up lying and gaslighting in the industry is insane.
It's the whole reason we have this podcast. But I'm talking about straight up morality clauses,
right? Because an author can be canceled and their contract can be canceled for a tweet
about something that is not invoked and that the publisher decides is going to make them look bad.
But the publisher can, on the other hand, go publish a book by JD Vance.
- JD Vance. I shouldn't say that when I have two books on sub and I'm pretty sure on sub to an imprint
that probably publishes his books, but that's exactly right. Like, honestly, for there to be
a very, very vague open-ended morality clauses on the author side and nothing like that on the publisher side
is insanely hypocritical and could be used to fuck you if political winds shift in a certain way,
right? And I'm not saying authors shouldn't suffer consequences for being asshats and for saying
or doing awful things they should. But the same responsibility does not rest on publishers as they are
trying to. - Still wearing the same old underwear? Own gifting season this Black Friday with 50% off-site-wide at TommyJohn.com/Holiday
and use Code Holiday. - Put on authors, right? All right, I think that's all I got. - Yeah, yeah.
No, that's fine. That was probably like a very decent therapy session. - That's all these are really,
right? - I think so. There's definitely an aspect to that. You know, I don't know, it makes me
laugh cranky, I guess. It's very easy to sort of sit around on Discord feeling
aggrieved by this, that, the other thing. - Yes. I think, I mean, I think that's why
people listen is because it's not like these things are secret once you experience it, right? But
nobody says no. - So people do? - I think that's true. One last thing, just because, you know,
I slash we do get messages about this. And we do get messages from a lot of people saying,
"Hey, thanks for saying these things." So I do think there's reason to put it out there.
But I've had questions recently about agents in particular from a whole lot of people who are
in various stages of looking for or even negotiating with agents and like, "Hey,
what do you look for?" I just wanted to add a quick note that I think the primary thing I've learned
in the whole agent search and seeing people deal with their agents or not is just go get a
publishing marketplace or is it publishers marketplace? Publishers marketplace subscription,
whatever amount of time you can pay for that you need it. Look for recent sales in your category
for authors of a similar level. Two imprints you actually want to be published by for amounts
that you would want to take for your book and go from there. So there are a lot of other things
that people look for that I don't think are super pertinent like street cred or
do they have huge authors of this that or the other sort? I think that the primary thing that
matters is recent sales in your category for authors like you simply because some agents do
seem to have an outsized ability to land authors at really solid imprints for good amounts of money
even if that author is a debut or early career or what have you. Some are just better.
Yeah. I think also author I think agents you know a bit like authors they transition in their
careers to different phases and that that's why you get a lot of people saying like you know a younger
agent who's hungry and ambitious at a good agency can be a really really good thing whereas someone
who's very very established has quite often not always but often transitioned into a career
management stage of their life where they're just managing their multi-million dollar clients
and they're not really doing a whole lot of acquisitions. Yes. And breaking your ground
they've got their hands full with their 42. Yes. Or whatever. Heaving client list. Yes.
Yeah. Yep. So I mean that didn't have a whole lot to do with everything else. That just is
something that I have gotten in DMs quite a bit and just again recently and very interesting.
Yeah. Because I mean a lot of people are changing agents all the time. There's been a lot
of that in the past few years I think that's just that's just that people do that regularly. I mean
yeah it's not it's just a part of industry life changing agent changing editor more than we used to
I think people used to be a bit more you know you'd stick with the publisher of your life and
then stick with you for life. And now I was noticing there are quite a lot of articles and
frank for this year's like so and so it's been poached and it's like well they're not they've just
moved you know but anyway. Yeah I mean it yeah a lot of stuff happens in this industry behind the scenes
and I'm not going to get more specific than that at this time but yeah that's that's what I'd
book for is just inform yourself. I didn't know that until relatively recently the publisher's
marketplace was even a thing and I just think more people should know about the very little data
that is out there that you can use to make. If I'd spare cash I'd track myself on book scan on
publisher's marketplace but that's quite expensive. Yeah yep. But yeah that wasn't that wasn't
like a very funny episode but then we're not like a comedy podcast. I'm not sure why that you
you know I worry about that but the important thing it was just a good therapy episode and that's
really all that matters so thanks for your time again. I will I will get these edited and out
there. I just got a bit carried away today because my edits landed for my we should talk about
our books so because I've got a book coming out next year after all that and we're calling it
the morrow and I absolutely love it. It's the big sci-fi Philip K. Dick book tribute of my dreams.
It is America Americana music inspired. It is bluesy. It is certain Texas. It's surrealist and weird.
There may or may not be a little bit of cannibalism which is sort of part of the course with me
and I had fun even if it absolutely fucking bombs which you're probably well in the UK again
because why would they push me when they I shouldn't say that bit you know even if it's
fucking bombs I had a good time riding it but I hope it doesn't you know people keep saying they
want to buy sci-fi so if you if you actually mean that go fucking buy some sci-fi guys.
I think yeah one thing I'll say is I genuinely think that it appeals to or should
or will appeal to people who like the literary side of post-apocalyptic I think it will appeal
to people who like the you know walking dead version of post-apocalyptic it has a very very
solid plot and pace and genre elements that work with that more literary side of you know
characters who have a deep history deep background the what they're doing means something to the
world and to them. Oh I tell you well we're gonna we're gonna go and you're gonna talk about your
book that's on sub very briefly because you never know what editor might hear it so I'll say the
morrow that the one you know you can't even order anywhere but when it comes out it's basically
about a near future America where there is a disease a pathogen which if you catch it it
kills you in 40 days but until it kills you it removes your ability to feel pain psychological
and physical you can't feel pain most people experience euphoria they believe that they are
ascending not dying that they are like transcending their existence so it's you know being sick
is wonderful and the only treatment to it is a drug which gives you crippling depression
and chronic pain so that those two things are in existence and the main character is responsible
for both and he kind of sort of has ended the world and he's trying to fix it and it's you know
has all the usual fun things but I think you know you're also on sub with your Viking horror book
which I have read and was very good and also I remember when you sent it to me we need like a long
German word of this emotion I think I had like this this terror that I would read it and be terrible
but it's actually very good so that was really well thank you no you know when you're friends
and you're looking like oh my god what if I hate it I remember like when I read frances is
book the first time and I was like shit what if I hate it and it's fine it was really good
you just believe like thank god you wrote something good yes I do know exactly what you mean and it
it is really cool when you read a friend's book and you love it because you can really go
for it real hard with it but yeah it is really awkward when you know a friend writes a book that's
not necessarily your jam or what have you so yes thank you for that that is one of two books
I have on sub right now so yeah I'm sweating that one out a little bit it's been out for a week
ish to a first pool of imprints and editors I'm hoping that it is you know crossover horror
historical maybe even a little bit literary enough to appeal to more imprints than just pure genre
but I do I don't know I think there's a lot of history that we don't we as modern people don't
fully appreciate and what humanity has been like for most of our history right and what
ancient or even not so ancient belief systems led people to do and the things that they had
to deal with in their lives and in particular this story is about Freitas Eric's daughter who
and so it's kind of an alt history because the the quote unquote histories we have about her are
very vague and don't mention her very much despite her having led her own voyage to North America
after her brother leaf Eric's and did she was the each of each of the children of Eric the red
led voyages to North America so yeah the the general vibe is you know what if
Freitas and and this group of Vikings quote unquote Vikings right it's really just Norse people from
Greenland sailed to America and found that mythological creatures were real here and that's why
their settlements disappeared and that and they never took hold on this continent like later
European settlers did you know plus or minus Jamestown which may or may not be the subject of the second
book I want to write in that series but yeah I think it turned out really well it's really very
focused on Freitas and her daughter and family relationships in the midst of you know having to
sail to a new continent to escape one curse and finding horrible mythological creatures on the
other continent but we'll see maybe I'll have to indie publish it I have no idea well give it
more than a week which is all it's been maybe maybe the next time we record one of these because
there's enough of a gap something will have been for you know one or both sets of acquisitions
weren't we naive you should think that it might happen by today huh for one or both of us
for Saturday and all likely yeah but that's publishing indeed indeed yeah yeah
you've been listening to the publishing radio podcast with Sunny Dean and Scott Drakeford
tune in next time for more in depth discussion on everything publishing industry see you later
[BLANK_AUDIO]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Publishing contracts often favor publishers over authors, with weak clauses like rights of first refusal and non-compete clauses that limit author mobility and earnings.
Many books fail to reach bookstores on time, harming sales and list placements, especially in the UK, where distribution and timing issues are systemic and poorly addressed.
Publisher decisions are influenced by market trends, industry insiders, and platform presence, creating a biased system where certain authors have unfair advantages.
The UK’s bestseller lists reward "crate" success, leading to a cycle where books disappear from view and authors are left without long-term visibility or income.
Contracts lack enforceable protections for authors, with little accountability for delays or failures in distribution and marketing.
Authors face significant pressure to conform to trends, especially in genres like romantic fiction, which publishers increasingly prioritize over diverse voices.
Industry insiders—such as editors or agents—often secure deals, creating conflicts of interest and undermining merit-based publishing.
Systemic issues like environmental excuses for print cuts and lack of transparency reveal a broader culture of manipulation and risk aversion in publishing.
Summary:
The podcast explores the hidden realities of the publishing industry, revealing systemic inequalities and flawed practices that disadvantage authors. A major issue is the imbalance in contracts, where clauses like rights of first refusal and non-compete clauses severely limit author autonomy, income, and career flexibility. Many books fail to reach bookstores on time, especially in the UK, resulting in missed list placements, lost sales, and damaged author reputations.
Publishers increasingly rely on trend-driven, insider, or platform-based deals, favoring authors with existing audiences or industry connections over merit or originality. The UK’s bestseller list system rewards "crate" success, leading to a cycle where books vanish after initial success and authors are left without visibility or sustainable income. Additionally, industry insiders frequently secure deals, creating conflicts of interest and undermining fairness.
Environmental excuses for print cuts are dismissed as manipulative and inconsistent with real-world sales. Overall, the system is not meritocratic—authors face unbalanced power dynamics, lack of transparency, and structural barriers. The podcast emphasizes that while the industry claims fairness, the reality is a rigged environment where authors must constantly navigate hidden biases, poor contracts, and opaque decisions.
Authors are urged to seek independent advice, diversify their paths, and challenge the status quo to protect their rights and careers.
FAQs
Books may fail to reach bookstores due to publisher or distributor errors, such as missed deadlines or poor logistics. This can prevent a book from hitting bestseller lists, cause pre-orders to be canceled, and result in significant commercial losses for the author.
Publishing contracts often contain clauses like non-competes and options that limit an author’s ability to work with other publishers or publish new work. These clauses can trap authors, limit income potential, and suppress career growth without offering real benefits to the author.
In the UK, being selected for a bestseller list (like the Sunday Times) is a major career boost, but once a book is in a 'crate' (a marketing campaign), it often disappears from visibility. This creates a system where publishers prioritize trend-driven books, and authors may be dropped without fair follow-up opportunities.
Publishers often favor industry insiders or influencers because they already have established audiences or platforms, reducing marketing uncertainty. This creates a system where success is based on connections and access rather than the quality or merit of the book itself.
Such claims are seen as manipulative and inconsistent, as publishers rarely change their practices when sales surge. This excuse undermines transparency and reveals a lack of accountability, especially given that large print runs are often necessary for book success.
Option clauses give publishers a 30-day right to review an author’s next work, often before the author has a chance to pitch elsewhere. These clauses limit author freedom, pressure them into accepting unfavorable terms, and prevent fair market value for their work.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.