EP. 237 - GEORGIA: FAMILY ANNIHILATOR: MARK ORRIN BARTON
105m 43s
Quince stands out for its high-quality, durable, and timeless everyday clothing made from premium materials like Mongolian cashmere and organic cotton, offered at a fraction of luxury brand prices. The brand’s thoughtful design and ethical values have made it a favorite among consumers, with many retaining pieces from early purchases. Meanwhile, BJ’s Wholesale Club promotes savings through a $20 entry fee and bulk discounts, appealing to cost-conscious shoppers. In entertainment, *The Devil Wears Prada 2* and the psychological thriller *Undertone* are highlighted as fresh and critically acclaimed additions to streaming platforms. The narrative of Mark Barton, however, serves as a cautionary tale: a man shaped by emotional neglect, paranoia, and a need for control, who ultimately committed a violent crime against his wife and mother-in-law. His descent began with childhood trauma and mental health issues, fueled by insecurity, a toxic marriage, and financial motives, culminating in a brutal murder. The story underscores how trauma and isolation can lead to destructive behavior, and how a person’s inner world—shaped by abuse and fear—can manifest in extreme violence. The case illustrates the dangers of emotional manipulation, financial greed, and unchecked power, offering a stark contrast to the curated, positive narratives of fashion and entertainment.
You know those pieces in your closet that you find yourself reaching for over and over again?
The sweater that somehow works with everything, the jeans you know will always fit you just right?
Well, those are the pieces that earn a permanent place in your wardrobe,
and that's exactly what Quince does so well.
Now, Courtney and I have talked about Quince many times before in the past,
and we continue to choose to work with them because we not only love their clothing and
what they produce, but we also love the ethos behind the company.
Quince makes elevated everyday essentials using premium materials like Mongolian cashmere,
organic cotton, and washable silk.
The designs are timeless, thoughtfully crafted,
and made specifically to be worn again and again and again.
Their 100% Mongolian cashmere sweaters start at just $50,
giving you the softness and quality you'd expect from a luxury brand without the luxury price tag.
Courtney and I both still have Quince pieces back from the first time that we shopped with them in
2024, and honestly, they have held up,
incredibly well, and honestly, if you want to invest in clothing that will be both
very comfortable and very stylish, and something else that's great is that everything at Quince
is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. Find the fall pieces you'll reach for the most
at Quince. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers, or go to quince.com
slash america. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns,
now available in Canada and the UK too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E
dot com.
dot com slash america.
Hank joined BJ's Wholesale Club the day he became a father of 30.
I coach football.
Now Coach Hank saves up to 25% off grocery store prices,
30 pounds of pasta, 3 cases of protein bars, 75 sports drinks.
And that's just pregame.
He knows teamwork, and BJ's knows savings.
This is your home, Coach. Home of the save.
Join for just $20 at BJ's dot com slash mesquite and save 10 cents per gallon for 6 months.
Open soon. Limited time offer, new members only.
BJ's, home of the save.
Hello!
Look what TJ Maxx dragged in.
The Devil Wears Prada 2 is now streaming on Disney+ and Hulu.
We are digital. We are downloadable. We are streamable.
The fashion event of the year is certified fresh.
Pull yourself together. We have work to do.
Critics say it's smart and witty, and the perfect sequel.
That's all.
Get runway ready for The Devil Wears Prada 2 on Disney+ and Hulu.
Today's episode is presented by A24's Undertone, in theaters on March 13th.
This is the scariest movie you'll ever hear.
It follows the host of a popular paranormal podcast who becomes haunted by terrifying recordings mysteriously sent her way.
The feature debut of writer-director Ian Twassen has left critics raving.
Bloody Disgusting's Joe Lipset wrote in his Four and a Half Skull review,
"This was the last time a movie made every hair on my body stand up, but Undertone got me good."
Hear for yourself and experience Undertone in theaters Friday the 13th.
Get tickets now.
The following podcast is not suitable for all audiences.
We go into great detail with every case that we cover and do our best to bring viewers even deeper into the stories by utilizing disturbing audio and sound effects.
Trigger warnings from the stories we cover may include violence, rape, murder, and offenses against children.
This podcast is not for everyone.
You have been warned.
When you are looking for a partner, there are a lot of things to consider.
Are you attracted to them?
Are you compatible?
Will they help you build the life you want for yourself?
For Deborah Spivey, Mark Oren Barton seemed to check all her boxes.
He was charming, brilliant, ambitious.
He had big dreams for himself.
So Deborah took his hand.
He agreed to walk through life with Mark by her side.
In the beginning, they looked to be the perfect couple.
They had two beautiful children together, Matthew and Michelle.
They were wealthy.
Mark had an amazing job.
But soon enough, his mask began to fall.
By the time Deborah got to know the real Mark Barton, it was too late.
And sadly, Deborah wouldn't be the only woman to fall for his lies.
So this is the story of Mark Barton.
Mark Oren Barton.
I'm Courtney Browen.
And I'm Colin Browen.
And you're listening to Murder in America.
Murder in America.
Murder in America.
And for Truman, discipline was the easiest one to give.
You see, Truman was a career military man working his way up the ranks with the United States Air Force.
Anyone who knew the family knew that Truman was what you would call a strict disciplinarian.
He could be harsh, often cruel.
Now, being a disciplinarian was necessary at work, but at home it didn't turn off.
In fact, it seems that it intensified.
With his son, Truman believed that the harsher the discipline,
the punishment was, the better.
What those punishments were, exactly, we don't know.
But years later, Mark would write about the fears of the father being transferred to the son.
Whatever happened in the Barton house, it left psychological scars on him as he grew up.
Scars that, by all accounts, his mother continuously tried to heal.
She was the gentler parent, the kinder one.
She tried to soften the blows.
But in a house where Truman's decisions were law,
there was only so much she could do in the shadow of his rules.
Offering her son his favorite candy after getting a talking to.
Rubbing his back when he was sent to his room without dinner.
Offering him comfort when home felt like a prison.
Things were even further complicated by the fact that their home was constantly changing.
Mark was born on an Air Force base in Germany.
But his father's career took them ping-ponging across the United States and world on different military assignments.
Finally, when Mark was 11 years old, he became a soldier.
At the age of 11 years old, Truman retired from active duty and took a civilian job as a contractor at Shaw Air Force Base in Sumter, South Carolina.
For the first time in Mark's life, there would be no more moving, no more packing up and saying goodbye.
The Bartons were staying put, and they had picked a good place to do it.
If you know anything about Sumter, you know it's a military town.
Shaw Air Force Base is one of the largest military installations in the country.
For a military kid like Mark, who had spent his whole childhood bouncing from base to base, the people of Sumter were his people.
He found himself surrounded by other kids with backgrounds just like his own.
It was a perfect place to put down roots, to make friends, to have a normal childhood.
But there was one problem.
Mark didn't feel normal.
By all accounts, he was a smart kid.
Brilliant, even.
He excelled academically.
Especially in math and chemistry.
Teachers loved him.
He was focused, driven, always had the right answer.
He could solve problems that stumped his classmates.
But socially, Mark was having some serious difficulties.
He was described as emotionally distant, withdrawn, cold.
At lunch, he often sat by himself.
At recess, he stood on the edge of the playground, watching other children play, but never joining in.
He didn't know how to connect with people.
He didn't understand the unspoken rules of friendship.
And so, while his classmates made friends, Mark didn't.
His peers could tell something was different about him.
And kids, as we know, can be cruel.
Mark was ostracized.
Left out of birthday parties.
No one picked him for teens.
He became the target of the kind of casual cruelty that children inflict on anyone who doesn't fit the mold.
When you're a kid, you're a kid.
When you're a kid and you're rejected by your peers, it plants seeds of resentment.
And it starts to make you think that the world is against you.
Mark's feelings of isolation and anger grew so overwhelming that heading into high school,
he began to see a psychologist, Dr. Harry Taylor.
Dr. Taylor heard what others had said about Mark.
He was a quiet, withdrawn, socially anxious boy.
As the doctor sat in his office preparing for his final session with Mark,
he expected to be met with a timid boy.
had to be coaxed out of his shell someone who wanted to be liked who people pleased
who was shy to the point of silence. But that's not who walked into Dr. Taylor's office that day.
The boy that sat in front of him, arms crossed, jaw tense on a leather sofa, wasn't scared or sad.
He was angry. He shook his head and clenched his fists as he said,
I just don't understand what the problem is with the kids at school. Why the hell can't I just fit
in with them? Dr. Taylor had faced this problem a million times. It's something that many teens
all over the world face. So, he offered a solution. Mark, why don't you try out for a team
or join a club? It could be a great opportunity for you to be a part of something to connect with
people. Mark scoffed. I'm an outcast. Why should I try to participate? Dr. Taylor gave him a simple
answer. He wouldn't be an outcast if he found people with similar interests, if he made an
effort to be friends with people or be a part of something bigger than himself. In response,
Mark sighed and flicked his wrist like he was broken.
The conversation ready to move on to the next topic. This was a common theme for Mark throughout
his life. His belief that he shouldn't have to mold to the world. The world was supposed to mold
around him. With every session, Dr. Taylor could see the anger in Mark growing from a simmer to a
boil. At first, it was complaints about not being able to fit in. Then, it was digs at the people
who wouldn't accept him. And finally, it was just pure rage at society as a whole and the perceived
social rules of the world.
Rather than use that anger to fuel any change, Mark decided to use it to rebel. He began confessing
to Dr. Taylor that he had dark urges. In one session, looking up at the doctor with a blank
expression, he confessed, whenever I go anywhere, I size up how to break in where the money is and
how I can steal it and get away. Dr. Taylor dug in, trying to understand where this obsession was
coming from. Was it a cry for help? A desire to be seen, to be understood? Or was it the opposite?
A need to slink into the shadows and become them, to prove to everyone that he really was what they
thought he was. There was a sense of pride in Mark as he explained that he was smart enough to get
away with whatever he wanted. In his notes, Dr. Taylor wrote down that Mark fancied himself a
master criminal. And in time, daydreaming and gloating about those plans didn't satisfy him
any longer. He needed to act on them. It was 1969. Mark was 14 years old, a freshman in high school.
And he was somewhere where he wasn't supposed to be. His watch ticked into the late night hours
as he prowled outside in the dark. His eyes were locked on a local drugstore. He scanned the
sidewalk in the local homes, but it was all calm. The streets were quiet. The nearby houses were
dark. There was no one watching him, no one to see what he was about to do. Now, whether he broke a
window in the business or had stolen a key, we don't know. But somehow, Mark broke the window.
The aisles were lined with items free for the taking. In the back of the store, the pharmacy
was chocked full of every drug you could possibly imagine. You have to remember, this was the late
60s. Things like Quaaludes, amphetamines, and Valium were prescribed to anyone without hesitation.
We don't know exactly what Mark stole, but given what happened in the next few years of his life,
it's not far-fetched to imagine that the shelves in the back of the store were the ones that peaked
interest. Though, his theft didn't go exactly as planned. Before he knew it, the red and blue
lights of cop cars flooded the dark store. Mark's heart raced. It was the first time he was
surrounded by police, but it would be far from the last. Now, we have no idea what came of this
incident. There doesn't seem to be anything about it on Mark's record, so it's assumed that the cops
gave him a slap on the wrist and sent him back home. However, we don't know what happened.
We do know is that the punishment he received from his father was severe. Yet, it wasn't enough
to stop him from pushing further and further into a life of crime and danger. In 1972, Mark was 16
years old, and he had developed a new obsession. Gone were the days spent dreaming of ways to break
into buildings. Now, Mark was using his analytic, scientific mind for something else, synthesizing
drugs. In a book, he discovered that the seeds of mortality were the seeds of death. Mark was
told that the seeds of death were the seeds of death, and that the seeds of death were the seeds
of death. In the book, he was told that the seeds of death were the seeds of death, and that the
seeds of death were the seeds of death. The effect was meant to be similar to other drugs that were
becoming wildly popular in the counterculture movement at the time, LSD and mushrooms.
And, like the rebel Mark wanted so desperately to be, he decided to try going down the rabbit hole
himself. Mark ground hundreds of morning glory seeds in a small bowl. Then, using chemicals he
researched, he strengthened the psychedelic compounds in the seeds of death. Mark was
told that the seeds of death are the seeds of death, and that the seeds of death are the seeds of death.
When he took his first dose, he expected a sense of freedom, an escape from reality,
a profound experience or epiphany. Instead, he got the most frightening experience of his life.
The floor was drenched in a thick, slithering fog. Mark's heart pounded so loud that it felt
like it was going to burst out of his chest and paint the room red. His mind raced in circles that
didn't make any sense. Where was he? What was he doing here? And what the hell was the creature
that was staring at him? Mark's heart pounded so loud that it felt like it was going to burst out
of his chest. Threatening him. Taunting him. Now who he went to for help, or if he even did, we don't know.
Was he ranting and screaming so much that his parents called the police?
Did they pick him up and take him? Or did he run out of the house, terrified for his life,
until some stranger called an ambulance to come get him? Regardless of how, just a few hours after
Mark took the drugs, he was lying in a hospital bed, his mind fried, and his body exhausted.
Dr. Taylor described it as an overdose. He suspected that the chemicals Mark mixed in
with the toxin exacerbated the effects. Essentially, he had poisoned himself,
and the effects seemed to follow him for years to come. Dr. Taylor wrote,
quote, it did something bad to him, end quote. He also noted that after this experience,
Mark would never be the same again. From that point on, he turned into a frightened, paranoid,
and obsessive young man.
He was plagued by visions of demons emerging from the floor, and he believed that the only way to
rid himself of them was to worship God. He became devoutly religious to a disturbing degree. He
carried a Bible with him everywhere he went. He would interrupt people in the middle of
conversations to preach to them, and he would rant on and on, telling people frantically that he was,
quote, working on finding all of the answers, end quote. By the time he graduated high school in
2003, Mark had fully cemented himself as a different kind of outcast, not the one that
people made fun of, the one that people avoided. Dr. Taylor relayed in the book Murder at the Office,
quote, he didn't make any sense. The drugs blew him away, end quote.
Throughout all of this, Mark's parents were devastated to see their son's descent into drugs.
He was their only son, he got straight A's, he was a semi-finalist for the National Merit Scholarship,
and he had gotten accepted into the U.S. Department of Justice.
They didn't want to see him throw all of it away. They hoped that moving to Clemson,
three hours inland, would force Mark to make better decisions. Maybe the change of scenery
would help him make new friends, find new interests. His parents felt there was nothing
they could do but trust he would turn his life around. But, as the saying goes,
wherever you go, there you are. Mark's first semester at Clemson was soured by his mental
decline. At the semester's end, he was hospitalized in the midst of a psychotic episode.
He heard voices, saw things that weren't there, and was unable to separate reality from his
hallucinations. Thankfully, after being hospitalized, he finally got on medication
and intense therapy to combat the psychotic symptoms he was experiencing. And it seemed
to keep delusions and paranoia at bay. But there was still a problem at the base of it all,
his fascination with recreational drugs. A fascination that only exacerbated his mental
health struggles.
After his stint in treatment, Mark decided to try college once again. This time a little closer to
home at the University of South Carolina. There, he pursued a bachelor's degree in chemistry.
In his apartment near campus, he took practicing chemistry seriously, though it wasn't for class.
Soon enough, Mark's fascination with synthesizing drugs progressed from psychedelics to more
dangerous substances. In this case, he decided to try chemistry.
In this case, methamphetamine.
Now, initially, he wasn't manufacturing it for his own use. He was making meth to pursue a goal
that would follow him all of his life. Wealth. The higher the risk, the higher the reward.
And Mark was all about chasing that reward. He began to make a name for himself around campus
and on the streets for selling meth. He was also earning himself a good chunk of change doing it.
though, just selling the meth wasn't enough.
Mark began to dip into his own supply.
Maybe he was trying to silence the demons
that he had started seeing years prior,
or maybe it began out of curiosity.
Whatever it was,
when he picked up that pipe for the first time
and took that first inhale,
he was swept away by the euphoria.
That instant, the rush of pleasure and elation he felt
kick-started an addiction that he was helpless against.
He began using more than he was selling.
Pulling up in his apartment for days on end,
skipping class,
and disappearing from the world entirely.
By the end of 1975,
Mark's money from selling meth had dried up.
Anything he made, he was keeping for himself.
And soon, he couldn't even afford to buy the chemicals he needed
to create the meth.
So that's when, once again,
Mark found himself staring in a darkened drugstore after hours.
The details of this break-in are as foggy
as the first break-in back when he was in high school.
But this time, the consequences were much more severe.
As Mark tried to pile drugs into his backpack,
the red and blues of police cars flooded the pitch-black store.
Unbeknownst to him, he had triggered a silent alarm.
Within minutes, police descended on him,
throwing him to the cold tile
and handcuffing him behind his back.
Once again, Mark found himself sitting in the back of a cop car.
As a result of this robbery, Mark was placed on probation.
If he made any more missteps, he would be put behind bars.
And to many people's surprise, Mark actually got his life together.
In 1979, he even graduated from college
with a Bachelor of Science degree in chemistry.
And somewhere along the way, Mark met someone.
While working part-time as a night auditor at a local hotel,
he crossed paths with a young woman named Debra Spivey.
She was a fellow student, and she saw something in Mark Barton.
Now, with what you've heard about Mark,
it may be hard to imagine what there was to see in him.
But that might be the most unsettling thing about him.
Mark was charming, likable.
People close to him claimed that there were two versions of him.
An incredibly calm, kind man,
who was quick to joke and make everyone around him feel special.
And then there was the other Mark.
A cruel, callous, selfish person,
unafraid of hurting anyone,
as long as it meant he got what he wanted.
At first, he only showed Debra the warm side of him.
He showered her in compliments, made her laugh.
He showed her how much potential he had.
He was brilliant and hardworking.
He could give Debra a good life.
So, after over a year of dating,
Debra Spivey became Debra Barton.
On the outside, it seemed like the drugs, crime,
and mental health struggles were a thing of the past.
Mark was a good man, and together,
he and Debra were on a path towards the American dream.
After their wedding, the pair moved to Atlanta, Georgia,
where they tried making a living in a big city as fresh graduates.
For a while, they both jumped from job to job,
hoping to make their big break in their career field.
And in the mid-80s, that break finally came.
Mark landed a job at a chemical manufacturing company
called TLC Manufacturing.
Starry-eyed and excited,
the couple moved to Texas,
to pursue the opportunity.
Finally, Mark was going to be putting his brilliant mind to good use.
And by all accounts,
it seems that's exactly what he did.
He began working there as a chemist,
but within five years,
he had climbed the ladder up to a general manager.
His salary was about $86,000 a year.
And remember, this was the 1980s.
$86,000 is a great salary now,
but back then, it was serious money.
With it, the couple bought a nice house,
and Mark was at the top of his career ladder.
To anyone watching,
Mark Barton had completely turned his life around.
And then came the kids.
In 1988,
Deborah gave birth to their first child,
a son who they named Matthew.
A few years later,
they welcomed a daughter, Michelle.
Two beautiful children,
a successful career,
a loving wife.
If the Bartons lived in your neighborhood,
you might be a little jealous looking at them from the outside.
But beneath the surface,
Mark's mask was starting to slip.
The control he had maintained over his darker impulses
was beginning to crack.
And Deborah was the one who saw it first.
Slowly, Mark became paranoid.
Not just a little suspicious,
obsessively paranoid.
He started accusing Deborah of cheating on him,
of flirting with other men.
He questioned her constantly.
"Where have you been?
Who have you been talking to?
What have you done?"
He monitored Deborah's every move like she was a suspect in a crime.
She wasn't allowed to leave the house
or even use the phone without his permission.
When they did go into public,
Mark tried his best to make her feel small.
He didn't call her darling or babe or even by her name.
Instead, he constantly referred to her by the nickname he had given her,
"stupid".
Every time Mark and Deborah went on a trip or visited friends,
he would call her that,
right in front of her.
He would say things like "stupid" and "I will be over at 5:00".
He'd say casually, "come on, stupid, we're leaving now".
"Stupid, what are we having for dinner?"
It was relentless.
It made the people around them uncomfortable.
Deborah was a very capable woman, an intelligent one.
But bit by bit, Mark was tearing her down.
To make matters worse,
she was hundreds of miles away from her friends and family.
And,
she was pregnant again.
But sadly,
at some point after having Matthew and Michelle,
Deborah suffered from a miscarriage.
Losing a child that she wanted so desperately
brought her unimaginable pain.
But instead of comforting his wife through her grief,
Mark made it worse.
He belittled Deborah.
He even blamed the miscarriage on her.
But why?
Why was Mark so cruel to the woman who loved him so much?
Well,
later on,
Mark would admit that Deborah was smarter than he was.
And he hated that.
He said he felt like he had to be perfect around her.
That if he was anything less,
he felt emasculated.
That insecurity he felt wasn't just in his marriage.
Mark Barton was insecure about every aspect of his life, especially work.
His long-term secretary remarked,
"He thought people were out to get him.
When you got on his bad side,
you stayed there."
And it's here where Mark began to unravel at work.
He was convinced,
that his colleagues were plotting against him.
And to prove it,
he recorded all of his phone calls with them.
We're talking thousands upon thousands of recordings over his time working at TLC Manufacturing.
For the most part,
no one knew about his obsessive recordings aside from his secretary.
But soon,
it was impossible to hide his escalating behavior.
When Mark had been climbing the ranks of the career ladder at TLC,
he was known for being a calm presence and a good problem solver.
But in 1989,
in the role of
manager,
he became anything but.
Any problem that he struggled to solve would throw him into a rage.
Those forced to work beneath him were subjected to his anger.
In "Murder at the Office" by Brent C. Doonan,
he writes,
"Most of his co-workers thought of him as not necessarily mean or rude,
but as having an attitude similar to a spoiled child."
According to these co-workers,
there were several occasions where,
in the midst of a dispute,
Mark would pick up the item closest to him and throw it across the room.
His colleagues would scatter into different offices,
knowing that there was nothing to do at that moment but to avoid Mark.
There would be no convincing or talking him down from whatever he was upset about.
The only thing they could do was get away from him,
let him cool down.
So, over time,
Mark went from being a beloved,
dedicated member of the team,
to a leader who unsettled the people around him.
But like any job,
there were some co-workers who Mark butted heads with more than others.
One, who we will refer to as Tom.
He filled Mark with paranoia.
For some reason,
Mark was thoroughly convinced that Tom was planning his demise.
He would always rant to his secretary that Tom was "out to get him."
On the stressful days at the office,
he'd pace in front of her desk, hissing,
"He's trying to get me fired.
He's trying to ruin my life.
Everyone sees it."
The panic in him was palpable,
but it was completely misplaced.
His secretary had no idea what Mark was talking about,
sure, Tom butted heads with him on occasion,
but that's normal in any workplace.
In reality, Tom hardly even thought about Mark.
But Mark was certain that Tom was coming for his job.
So, wanting to come out on top,
he decided to sabotage Tom, first.
Tom had no idea what was happening.
He paced on the loading dock of TLC manufacturing,
heart racing as he waited, and waited, and waited.
TLC depended on Mark,
and Mark depended on chemical deliveries every few days.
Those chemicals allowed them to create the compounds
that they sent off to their own clients.
Clients who depended on them.
The entire work pipeline hinged on the deliveries being on time.
But this delivery truck was late, and Tom was panicking.
He was the guy in charge of scheduling the orders.
He never missed any.
It was his top priority to not only get things on time,
but well ahead of time.
But that day, the truck never came.
It didn't come the next day either, or the next.
Tom's superiors were upset,
but he was certain that he had submitted the paper on time
with the correct delivery date listed.
Yet, when he contacted the company,
the date was different.
He figured it was a one-time fluke,
but then it happened again and again and again.
Week after week, the deliveries were late
and all eyes were on Tom.
But surprise, surprise, he wasn't to blame.
In reality, Mark had been taking the order forms
that Tom carefully put together.
And behind everyone's back, he changed the dates,
making every single delivery late.
Soon enough, the people at TLC began to realize
what Mark was doing.
And when they found out, they were done with him.
On September 13th, 1990,
Mark was officially fired from his position.
The paperwork stated he was fired due to a quote,
deficit in his managerial,
management capabilities, end quote.
Upon learning of his termination,
Mark burst out of the room, infuriated.
He was convinced that he didn't do anything
to deserve the firing.
In his mind, as he suspected all along,
the people there were out to get him.
And in his rage, he decided to get back at them.
Mark's breathing pulsed in the cool night air.
All was silent, aside from the crickets
in the woods around him.
He shouldn't have been where he was.
But he didn't care.
To him, what he was about to do was justified.
So he took the first step and broke into the loading dock
of his former workplace, TLC Manufacturing.
From there, he slipped into the break room,
moved to fridge, and then shimmied through a window
to access the executive suites.
He sat down at the computers owned by the same people
who had fired him.
He worked his way through the files,
downloading every confidential piece of information
he could get his hands on, formulas, clients,
client lists, and financial documents.
Then, with them safely downloaded on a floppy disk,
he wiped the hard drives off the computer.
Everything the company needed to run
was gone in the blink of an eye.
But Mark wasn't done yet.
He rustled through the filing cabinets,
taking every hard copy of the documents
he had just deleted off of the computer.
Then, armed with what he needed to destroy
the people he felt had betrayed him,
Mark slipped out the same way he had come.
Cravings are not just a matter of time.
Things aren't just about nicotine.
They're about the habit, the hand-to-mouth motion,
oral fixation, the momentary pause.
And when that loop is broken, cravings spike.
I quit vaping about seven months ago in May of 2025.
And let me tell you, having a Fume device with me
when I quit vaping was, in my opinion,
one of the key things that helped me break the habit,
break the loop, and start a whole new journey
into a healthier life.
Fume is a flavored air device designed to help people quit vaping.
And smoking by breaking that hand-to-mouth pattern.
I know how hard that is to break.
It's simple, natural, and honestly kind of genius.
No nicotine, no batteries, no vapor.
Just a weighted, twisty, fidget-friendly tool
that gives your hands something better to reach for
when cravings show up.
Like I said before, I know the feeling.
I know how hard it is to quit.
Not only have I quit vaping,
but I've also quit using pouches.
So, quitting nicotine was a major struggle for me.
A lot of listeners online know that I've been sober
for about two and a half years now.
I went to rehab.
I got completely clean, got my act together.
But even coming out of rehab,
nicotine was something that I was still using.
And when I decided to quit,
having a fume device with me was an absolute game changer.
So this recommendation comes from an honest, earnest place
where I truly believe if you want to quit,
well, you have to want to quit yourself.
But if you're at that point,
having a device like this with you,
especially a fume device,
can be extremely beneficial.
When you grab a Journey Pack,
you'll also get a free gift just for using our code AMERICA.
So, fume has already helped over 700,000 people
take steps toward better habits.
And now it's your turn.
Use our code AMERICA to get a free gift
with your Journey Pack.
Head to tryfume.com, that's T-R-Y-F-U-M.com
and use code AMERICA to claim your free gift today.
And now let's get back to the show.
- You know those pieces in your closet
that you find yourself reaching for over and over again,
the sweater that somehow works with everything,
the jeans you know will always fit you just right.
Well, those are the pieces that earn a permanent place
in your wardrobe.
And that's exactly what Quince does so well.
Quince makes elevated everyday essentials using premium,
premium materials like Mongolian cashmere,
organic cotton, and washable silk.
Courtney and I both still have Quince pieces
back from the first time that we shopped with them in 2024.
And honestly, they have held up incredibly well.
And honestly, if you want to invest
in clothing that will be both very comfortable
and very stylish and something else that's great
is that everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80% less
than similar brands.
Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers
or go to quince.com/america.
Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns,
now available in Canada and the UK too.
That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.com/america.
- This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp.
I have a question for you guys.
If you could wake up tomorrow and be better at one thing,
what would that thing be?
Some people might say they wish they were better
at keeping their plants alive.
Some people might wish for a better attention span
so that they can put their phone down.
I wish I could get better at falling asleep.
Sometimes that's just so hard for me.
But honestly, you have to know,
better is a feeling that is defined by you.
And for BetterHelp, it's a BetterHelp therapist
who really gets you.
It's a focus on global emotional wellbeing
with thousands of therapists and millions of members
in over a hundred countries.
I've talked about this a million times before,
but if you've never tried out therapy,
BetterHelp is a great place to start.
Basically, all you have to do is fill out
a basic questionnaire with some of your wants and needs,
and almost immediately you can get matched up
with a fully licensed therapist
and begin your therapy journey.
I think that everybody can benefit from therapy,
whether you're the happiest you've ever been
or in a deep depression.
It doesn't hurt at all to have a conversation
with someone that you know cares.
So if you want to start out your therapy journey today,
you can sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com/mia.
That's betterhelp.com/mia.
- When employees arrived at TLC the following morning,
they were stunned, but immediately they knew
who was behind the burglary and theft.
They contacted local detectives
and told them all about Mark's erratic behavior
over the past few years,
including a chilling statement he made
when he was forced to turn in his keys the day he was fired.
According to his ex-supervisor,
as he placed the keys in his hands, Mark scoffed,
"There are ways to get inside the building
"without using keys."
Everyone, including police,
believed that he had proved that statement right.
He confronted Mark about the burglary.
He claimed he had no idea what they were talking about.
Exasperated, he snapped,
"I don't know what you're talking about.
"Anyone could have broken in through the loading dock."
But there was a problem with that statement.
Police hadn't mentioned that the suspect had snuck in
through the loading dock,
which meant either Mark was the one who had done it
or he was the one who had sent someone to do it.
The detective shared a knowing glance and dug deeper.
As the questioning grew more and more intense,
Mark's wife, Debra, came home from work.
She stood in the doorway,
stunned to see two detectives sitting in her living room.
Eyes narrowed at her husband.
Debra asked them, "What's going on?"
Angry, Mark told her,
"I think I stole the formulas from work."
Right there was yet another slip up.
Police hadn't mentioned what documents were stolen.
And right then, they had no doubt that Mark was behind this.
Now, rather than tip him off any further,
detectives walked out of the Barton family home,
determined to get a warrant for his arrest.
Just a few days later, they returned with one in hand.
That day, Mark Barton was arrested
on charges of felony burglary.
But within hours, he was released from jail.
Evidently, he and his ex-company, TLC, had made a deal.
They would drop the charges against him
only if he returned all the files he had stolen.
Mark agreed.
And from there, he was released,
released back to his life
without serious legal repercussions.
But his reputation was destroyed.
No one was going to hire a guy who got fired
and then burglarized his former employer.
So the Bartons packed up and moved again, back to Atlanta.
While there, Mark found a new job as a salesman
at a chemical company called Lintec.
It wasn't $86,000 a year, but it was something, a paycheck,
to start over, but it was at
Lintec where Mark Barton met
someone who would change everything, the receptionist at his new office, a 21-year-old
woman named Leanne Ling. She was beautiful, hardworking, and humble. In her kindness and
patience, Leanne made Mark feel powerful. Now, Leanne was married, but her relationship with
her husband had been crumbling for quite some time. So, just three days after meeting, Mark
and Leanne kick-started a whirlwind affair. Mark was 38, married, with two young kids at home.
He should have known better, but he didn't think of his wife or kids. Instead, he thought only of
how Leanne made him feel, powerful, desired, important. Mark wanted to hold onto that feeling
for as long as he possibly could, regardless of what it could cost him. And he wasn't subtle about
pursuing Leanne and trying to impress her.
As their relationship grew, he started going to a tanning salon. He bought new clothes, started
dressing nicer, acting younger. He was listening to music he had never been interested in before.
He was a 38-year-old man desperate to impress a 21-year-old woman, and everyone noticed,
especially his wife, Debra. One day, Debra was doing Mark's laundry when she discovered a strand
of blonde hair. There was a problem with that. Debra was a little bit of a girl, but she was
Debra's hair was brunette. So, whose hair was it? What woman was getting so close to her husband
that her hair would end up on his shirt? When Mark came home that day, she asked him that very
question. Whose hair is this? But once again, Mark blew it off.
It's the dog's hair, he said. You're being paranoid, stupid, he told her.
Mark later told anyone who would listen that Debra was the jealous type. He claimed she was insecure,
which is a bit ironic, considering that it was Mark who didn't allow Debra to have friends,
to go places, or even to make phone calls without his permission. Yet, here he was,
painting her as the paranoid crazy spouse when she actually had every reason to be suspicious of him.
In reality, Debra knew that something was wrong. She knew her husband was lying.
She just couldn't prove it. Meanwhile, Mark was making plans. In June of
1993, he and Leanne took a trip to Charlotte, North Carolina, a romantic getaway. One where
Debra was left at home, caring for their two babies, wondering where her husband really was.
He had told her he was on a business trip. Really, he was meeting some of Leanne's childhood
friends for the first time. At dinner one night, they all toasted and indulged in a nice long meal
together. After a couple drinks, Mark confessed to them, I've never loved anyone more than Leanne,
and by October, I'll be free to go.
At the table, everyone awed and marveled at the couple's love. What they didn't know was that Mark
was still married. Debra was alive and well. And he was sitting at a dinner table, telling people
he would be free to marry his mistress by October. That was just four months away.
Around the same time, Mark did something even more troubling.
He took out a life insurance policy on Debra. A big one. $600,000. He had originally won the
$1 million, but he couldn't afford the premiums. So, he settled for $600,000. The insurance agents
were curious why Debra wanted such a big policy. Mark replied, quote, it's her idea. I used to be
the president of a company, and my wife began to enjoy it. She felt as time went on, she became
as important as I was. She developed an extreme sense of self-worth, end quote. And it gets worse.
Around the same time, Debra was in a relationship with her husband, Mark. He was in a relationship with
Mark. He was taking out life insurance on Debra. Leanne took out a $250,000 policy on her own
husband. Two policies on two spouses, taken out within weeks of each other by two people who were
having an affair and talking about getting married. Clearly, that's not a coincidence.
But at the end of August 1993, Leanne left her husband. After that, she moved in with her sister,
waiting to start her
new life with Mark. Now, all that stood in the way was Debra.
Meanwhile, Debra was completely unaware of what was ahead. Sure, she knew that her husband had
been acting strange. She suspected that something was going on, but Mark had convinced her that she
was just paranoid, that everything was fine. Plus, Debra and Mark had children together. They were a
family with a picture-perfect life. By then, she had dedicated 14 years to this man, and she wanted
her marriage to work. She had no idea what was going on. She
continued forward. On Labor Day weekend of 1993, Debra was incredibly excited to spend some time
with her mother. Debra's parents, Bill and Eloise Spivey, had recently purchased a lot at Riverside
Campground on Weiss Lake in Cherokee County, Alabama, a peaceful spot along the lake where
they could go fishing, relax, get away from everything. Debra's mother, Eloise, loved to
fish. It was her passion, and she wanted to share that with her daughter. So, on Saturday,
September 4th, Debra and Eloise drove out to the campground together. Just a mother-daughter trip,
nothing fancy. They'd stay in the camper that sat on the family's lot, spend some time together,
and make a few memories. Meanwhile, Mark stayed home in Georgia with the kids. At the time,
Matthew was five and a half, and Michelle was just two. They weren't used to their mom being
away. Mark knew that. But based on what happened next, it seems his kids' feelings didn't matter
to him.
That weekend. It was Labor Day, after all. Families everywhere. There was even a country
music concert at the campground that Saturday night. People were drinking, laughing, and having
a good time. The music was loud. Loud enough that you probably couldn't hear much of anything else
over it. Debra and Eloise were seen around the campground that day. They were friendly,
chatting with neighbors, enjoying themselves. Nothing seemed out of place.
The concert went late that night. Neighbors returned to their campers around 11.30 p.m.
Some of them continued to sit outside at picnic tables. But no one had any idea that by morning,
this fun campsite would be swarming with police.
The next morning, Sunday, September 5th, 1993, many of the campers at Riverside went to a church
service at a pavilion across the road. Around noon, after the last hymn was sung, two campers
emerged from the church and noticed something strange. Eloise's red Thunderbird was still
parked outside her camper. This was odd. The night before, Eloise told them that she planned
on leaving early the next morning to take her grandkids to Six Flags. So, she should have been
gone by then. Concerned, the two women walked over to check on her. They knocked on the camper door.
No answer. They tried again. Still nothing. So,
they opened it. At first, it was the smell. Thick. Metallic. For a moment, they worried that
maybe there was a carbon monoxide leak. Eloise had mentioned something about how her stove had
been giving her trouble. They called out her name and stepped inside the doorway. But that's when
they saw something that'd be etched into their memory for the rest of their lives. It wasn't
Eloise. It was her daughter, Deborah. She was lying just inside the entryway.
For a moment, the woman stood there frozen. Then one of them let out a scream. Hearts pounding,
they ran to get help. And within an hour, the campground was swarming with sheriff's deputies.
Some began to work the scene. Others were tasked with something even harder.
When Bill Spivey answered the phone at his home in Lithia Springs, he expected it to be his wife,
telling him why she was running late. Instead, there was a gruff, emotionless voice on the other
end. A million thoughts flooded Bill's mind. He begged the police to tell him what had happened,
but they refused, telling him they just needed him there as soon as possible.
He contacted his son, John, and his son-in-law, Mark. And together, they made the long,
tense drive to the campground. When they pulled up to the RV, Detective Danny Smith was waiting
outside for them. Getting out of the car, Bill had to hold on to Mark and John to steady himself.
His knees were weak. Every step was wobbly. All the color had been drained from his face.
Yet, a gentleman, he shook the detective's hand and thanked him for calling.
As Mark took Detective Smith's hand, he remarked, seemingly out of nowhere,
I've never been here before. And with those five words, Detective Smith had a person of interest.
Mark didn't ask about his mother-in-law and wife. He didn't even seem concerned.
In fact, there was a pep in his step. Meanwhile, Bill Spivey,
stood beside him, growing more pale by the second. He knew he was facing the most horrific moment of
his life. He had to walk into it. Had to look up at the detective and ask, what happened?
Detective Danny Smith later recalled that Bill was so unsteady, he was sure he was going to fall.
So, he put his hand out, bracing the man's shoulder. His eyes were heavy. He was taking
big, gasping breaths to try and calm his racing heart.
Detective Smith squeezed Bill's shoulder and told him,
your wife and daughter are dead.
Then came the crying,
the pain in its most human display.
Well, at least from Bill and his son, John.
Mark, however, showed very little emotion,
which immediately raised red flags for detectives.
And that small interaction they had,
they knew that they needed to look
into Deborah's husband, Mark Barton,
because what they found inside the camper
pointed not towards an attack by a stranger,
but to someone close to the women.
Someone who had finally snapped.
Inside the camper,
detectives found Eloise in the back on the bed.
She had been hit around 10 times
with a heavy clawfoot hammer.
Wounds covered her face, torso, and arms.
Her blood painted the floors, walls, and the bed.
It wasn't a quick or clean attack.
It was an attack fueled by pure uncontrolled rage.
But the worst of it,
the most savage brutality,
had been directed at Deborah.
She had endured around 20 strikes to the face
with the same hammer.
Her skull was completely split in two,
exposing her brain.
Her long brown hair was matted with blood,
sticking to the wounds that marred her face.
In the book, Murder at the Office,
the author recalled that both women appeared like,
quote, misshaped lumps of raw hamburger, end quote.
Detective Smith later stated, quote,
to stand there and beat someone to death with a hammer,
bam, bam, bam, 15 or 20 times.
You have to be pissed off, end quote.
But Deborah and Eloise were lovely women,
kind, smart, members of their community.
Neither of them had a mean bone in their body.
They had never done anything criminal or shady
throughout their entire lives.
So why would someone kill them in such a violent way?
Are you ready to have your mind blown?
I want you now to imagine that in front of you
was a locked door,
symbolizing all of you.
All that you know.
Everything you've been taught in your time on Earth.
The lies your government has fed you.
With my podcast, The Conspiracy Files,
I now give you the door's key.
And once you've listened to the show,
you finally unlock this door and step inside.
Beyond the door is another dimension.
A dimension of false narratives.
A dimension of hidden evidence.
A dimension of truth, lies, and murders.
You're moving into a land of both shadow and substance,
of deadly secrets and explosive ideas.
You've just crossed over to a new world,
and you've crossed over into The Conspiracy Zone.
I'm your host, Colin Brown.
Join me now on this journey into the world
of secret pedophile rings, government cover-ups,
and suspicious suicides
on my new show, The Conspiracy Files.
Available now on all streaming platforms.
Deborah Spivey Barton was 36 years old.
And the truth is, sadly,
we don't know much about who she was.
All of the news coverage focused on Mark.
And Deborah, she became a footnote
in her own murder.
But she deserves to be remembered.
So, here's what we do know.
She grew up in Lithia Springs, Georgia,
alongside her brother, John.
Her mother was her best friend.
They did everything together.
Exploring the outdoors, fishing, shopping,
and above all, laughing.
She met Mark in college,
married him in 1979,
and had two children with him.
And for the sake of those kids,
she stayed with him, even when things got bad.
Through it all, her mom was her confidant.
Deborah's mother, Eloise Powell Spivey,
was 59 years old.
She'd been married to her husband, Bill,
since they were young.
She and Bill had two children together,
John and Deborah.
He would later say,
my wife was my best friend.
I'd known her since she was a little girl.
Bill was a retired FAA supervisor.
He had been an Air Force fighter pilot
during the Korean War,
then spent decades as an air traffic controller.
When he retired in 1985,
he and Eloise had fired her.
They finally reached the stage of life
where they could do whatever they wanted.
And what Eloise wanted to do was fish.
The girl loved to fish more than anyone I ever met,
Bill chuckled to reporters.
So, they bought a lot at Riverside Campground on Weiss Lake.
A little slice of paradise
where they could spend their weekends
casting lines and sitting by the water.
That's all Eloise wanted.
Peace with the people that she loved.
They pictured spending the sunset years of their life
sitting on the dock,
listening to the call of birds,
and the lapping shoreline.
But now, all their dreams for their life came to an end.
Police needed to figure out why.
Surprisingly, no one around the campsite
heard a thing the night before.
The camper next door was so close,
you could practically reach out and touch it.
But whatever happened inside was somehow silent.
No screams, no bangs, nothing.
But throughout the investigation,
there was something that stood out to detectives.
As we mentioned,
Deborah's murder showed clear signs of an overkill.
Whoever took her life seemed angry, passionate.
But the killer tried to make it look like a robbery.
Eloise's purse had been dumped out.
Two rings were taken from the bodies,
but everything else was left behind.
Other jewelry untouched, credit cards still there.
There was even an envelope on the counter,
which had $600 in cash inside.
The bills were poking out.
Practically begging someone to come and take it.
Eloise's.32 caliber revolver
was also laying right there in the kitchen,
completely untouched.
What kind of robber leaves behind $600 in cash
and a loaded gun?
Even further, there were no signs of forced entry.
The door wasn't kicked in.
The windows weren't broken.
Investigators started asking questions.
Who would want to hurt these women?
Who had motive?
Who had opportunity?
And one name kept coming up over and over and over again.
Mark Barton.
Detectives were confident that he was their guy.
They were even more confident
once they learned about his affair.
That was his motive.
As they began to look into things even further,
they learned that Mark stood to gain $600,000
from Deborah's life insurance policy.
They also learned that he was going around telling people
that he would be free to marry his girlfriend by October.
So by then, Mark Barton quickly became their prime suspect,
the only suspect.
And eventually, police showed up at Mark's home
wanting to ask him some questions.
When Mark sat down with them in his home,
they asked him to describe his whereabouts
on the day that his wife and mother-in-law were killed.
I was home all day with the kids.
So you never left the house?
No, I never left.
But as the detectives pressed further,
Mark's story changed.
Actually, I did leave the house.
I went to a movie that night
and then ate at a restaurant.
But police wanted proof of this alibi.
They asked him,
do you have any receipts from that night?
But of course, Mark couldn't give them anything.
He would later change his story again,
saying that he was job hunting around town,
but he couldn't prove that either.
In his final story to police,
Mark claimed that the only people he was with that night
were his kids,
but he couldn't prove that either.
The children were young.
They would have been asleep.
Investigators knew the campground
was only a two-hour drive from his house.
He had plenty of time to make the trip and back
before anyone noticed he was gone,
but they couldn't prove it.
That day, as the police left Mark's home,
they decided to peek into the windows of his car
sitting in the driveway.
It was an old beat-up Toyota.
But when they did,
they discovered a shocking sight.
There appeared to be blood soaked
into the floor mats.
And because they were visible
without entry into the vehicle,
police were permitted to take them for testing
without a warrant.
Mark watched, cold and detached,
as they removed the mats from his car.
But detectives were faced with a dilemma.
They needed to search the car for more evidence.
They needed to use luminol
to see how much more blood was hiding inside.
However, they couldn't do that without a warrant.
They would have to come back
for it.
There was nothing they could do
but sternly tell Mark
not to touch his vehicle
until they came back.
While the police were zeroing in on Mark,
Deborah's loved ones were focused
on laying her to rest.
She and her mother Eloise
were buried at Sunrise Memorial Gardens
in their hometown of Lithia Springs.
Mark was there.
So was Detective Jerry Wynn.
Wynn tried to stare Mark down
from across the cemetery,
but Mark wouldn't meet his eyes.
At the funeral,
there was an overwhelming feeling of unrest
because he was dead.
Because Deborah's killer was still out there.
But unbeknownst to everyone,
something big was coming.
Just hours after the funeral,
investigators showed up at Mark's door
with a search warrant.
Finally, they'd be able to spray the car
to test for more blood evidence.
Now, if you don't know what luminol is,
it's a chemical that reacts with blood.
Even if you've cleaned a surface,
even if you can't see anything with the naked eye,
luminol will make blood glow in the dark.
The investigators sprayed luminol
inside Mark's car.
And immediately,
they started to see a glow.
Positive reactions on the ignition switch,
on the seatbelt,
on the steering wheel,
on the console,
on the gear shift,
on the driver's side door.
Blood.
Everywhere.
But there was a problem.
The car had been cleaned.
The stains remained,
but the DNA evidence
that the blood contained
no longer existed.
Investigators confronted Mark,
asking him why he had cleaned the car
when they told him not to.
He shrugged and told them,
I don't know.
I don't know.
I don't know.
Spill the soda.
When investigators asked if he knew what luminol was, he said no, but then he added with a
dismissive laugh, I've seen it on one episode of Columbo. Mark Barton had a degree in chemistry.
He had worked as a chemist for years, and he was claiming he'd never heard of luminol,
one of the most basic tools in forensic science. When confronted with the blood evidence in his car,
Mark had no real explanation. He just shrugged and said, if there's a ton of blood in my car,
why aren't you arresting me? Why aren't I in handcuffs? He was taunting them,
seeing how far he could push, and soon he decided to take things even further.
A few days later, Mark claimed to have suddenly remembered something. He contacted Alabama
investigators, and he told them that he had cut his finger to the bone the summer before his wife's
death. If there was blood in the car, he said, it was his own blood, not Debra's, not Eloise's,
just a simple accident.
But if that were true, all Mark had to do was provide a blood sample. Now, police couldn't test
it against the blood they had discovered with the luminol, because Mark had compromised it.
But they could still test it against the floor mats they had taken into their possession. If his
blood matched the mats, he'd be cleared. It was simple, but Mark refused. He wouldn't give up
blood samples. He wouldn't give a saliva sample. He wouldn't take a polygraph test.
When his own father-in-law, Bill, the man who had just lost his wife and daughter,
was treated as a suspect, he immediately offered to take a polygraph. He told investigators,
quote, whatever it takes to get you off my back and look for who did this, let's do it. But Mark,
he refused, telling police this. First of all, I've taken a lie detector test before,
whenever I sought employment at the 7-Eleven convenience store, and afterwards, I felt raped.
I felt violated. For whatever reason,
investigators weren't able to get a warrant for Mark's DNA. And from there,
police found themselves at a dead end, one that they had made themselves.
Georgia investigator Jerry Wynn was appalled by how Alabama handled the case.
He believed there was enough evidence to arrest Barton. He said investigators failed to follow
up on crucial leads. Like, for instance, there was a witness who told police that,
on the night of the murders, a man who looked like Mark Barton stopped him and asked for
directions to the lake.
In fact, there was a witness who told police there was a man who looked like Mark Barton
and asked for directions to the lake before Deborah and Eloise were staying. Investigators
never followed up with this witness. They also tipped Mark off on the fact that they were going
to come back and search his car. And they truly thought that warning him not to clean it was going
to work. And because of all this, despite the circumstantial evidence piling up, despite the
changing alibis and the destroyed evidence and the massive insurance policy and the affair, Alabama
investigators didn't make an arrest.
They couldn't place Mark at the campground that night. They had no fingerprints.
The murder weapon was never found. And without physical evidence directly tying him to the crime,
the district attorney wouldn't press charges. But to everyone who looked at this case,
it was very clear what had happened. The story that investigators came up with looked like this.
On the night of September 5th, 1993, Mark made the two-hour drive to the Riverside campground
in Cherokee County, Alabama. Perhaps he left the children at home by themselves.
Perhaps he had someone.
Like Leanne, watching them. We don't know. But by the time he arrived at the campsite,
it was late. Most of the people there were sleeping, including Deborah's mother, Eloise.
But Deborah was still awake. She was still winding down inside when she heard a soft
knock on the camper's door. Deborah opened it to see her husband, Mark. She was confused as
to why he was there, but she let him inside. However, soon after, he raised a hammer over his
head and brought it down onto her skull. The attack was so brutal, so violent, that Deborah
didn't even have the chance to scream. No one around them ever reported hearing any sort of
struggle. And right there, within that small trailer, Mark continued attacking her until she
was dead. For Mark, Deborah was the woman standing between him and the life he wanted. So all of his
rage, all of his hatred, was let out right then and there. But at the end of the day, he was not
But at the end of it all, with his wife dead on the floor, there was still one thing standing in
his way. In the other room was Deborah's mother, Eloise. From what he could tell, Eloise was still
asleep. If she had woken up, she hadn't come out of the room yet. But Mark couldn't take the chance.
So, he stepped over Deborah's body. He walked the narrow hall towards the back bedroom.
And there, while Eloise slept, he attacked her as well.
She never got up. Never screamed. Never even made it off the bed.
Following the murders, investigators suspected that Mark ransacked the place,
making it look like a robbery. Then, he got into his car, leaving traces of blood all throughout.
From there, he made the two-hour drive back home. Now, if investigators would have done their jobs
correctly, they likely could have proven the story we just told you. But sadly,
that's not what happened here. Mark got to continue living his life. In fact, everything
seemed to be going absolutely perfect for him. Deborah was no longer in the picture. The police
didn't have enough evidence to arrest him. And within a week of Deborah's funeral, his mistress,
Leanne, started spending the night at his house. She was sleeping on Deborah's side of the bed.
She was helping raise their children. And they weren't even trying to hide it. A month after the murders,
Leanne's divorce from her husband was finalized. Six months later, she and Mark officially moved
in together. Leanne's sisters were terrified. Police had told them that Mark was a suspect
in his wife's murder. The sisters begged Leanne to be careful. Police told Leanne's mother,
get your daughter away from Mark. He'll hurt her. Many members of Leanne's family never had a good
feeling about him. Her sister, Dana, would later say, quote, I could tell he was phony, just the
way that he acted. I felt that he did have something to do with his wife's murder, end quote.
But even with her family's warnings, Leanne didn't listen. She loved Mark. She wanted a life with him.
So she stayed, hoping for her happily ever after. After Deborah's murder, her two children,
Matthew and Michelle, really struggled. They were still very young, but they had just lost
their mother. They were trying to navigate life without her. And now this other woman had taken
their mom.
Michelle Barton was two and a half years old. She was in daycare. The workers there said that,
for the most part, Michelle was your normal kid, toddling around, playing with toys,
making friends, and exploring the world more and more every day. She was a bright kid, a happy kid.
But one day, she told a daycare worker something disturbing. She had no idea just how important
what she was saying was. She pointed to her genitals and told them casually,
Daddy touches me there. I don't like it.
Immediately, Georgia child welfare officials opened an investigation. The Douglas County
District Attorney's office got involved, and as part of that investigation, Mark Barton and
his daughter Michelle were ordered to undergo a psychological evaluation. And afterwards,
the psychologist was so concerned about his findings, he contacted the District Attorney,
David McDade, directly. Not about the molestation case. About the murders. He said Mark Barton was,
quote,
capable of homicidal acts and thoughts. It was on the record. The Douglas County District Attorney,
David McDade, would later describe his reaction to that evaluation. He said,
It was disturbing enough to have a trained psychologist and competent prosecutors
reporting these things back to us back then. It's absolutely chilling to think about it now.
But despite the psychologist's warning, despite the molestation allegations,
despite everything, nothing happened. The case was closed.
There wasn't enough evidence to prosecute Mark for sexual abuse. Michelle was too young to be
considered a reliable witness. And so, Mark Barton retained custody of his children.
In May of 1995, a year and eight months after Deborah's murder,
Leanne and Mark got married. Now, he just had to wait for the money. The insurance company
wasn't stupid. They knew Mark was a suspect in his wife's death. They knew the timing of the policy.
They knew about the affair. So, they refused to pay out. But Mark sued them. The case dragged on
for years. But eventually, in 1997, the insurance company decided to settle. They figured if they
brought the case to trial, a jury might sympathize with the grieving father of two young children.
At the end of the day, there were no charges against Mark. If the police couldn't even
prove that he murdered his wife, then they'd have to pay him. So,
in the end, they paid out $450,000. They forced Mark to put $150,000 of it in a trust
for Matthew and Michelle. But the rest? Nearly $300,000? That went straight to Mark. Blood money.
Money from a woman police believed he had murdered. Money he would use to fund his next obsession.
After marrying Leanne in 1995, Mark tried to settle into a normal life.
But things weren't going so well.
I mean, she moved into the home of
a woman who was just murdered. Everyone was suspicious of Leanne and Mark. Everywhere they
went, people whispered. Leanne's own family didn't approve of their relationship, and after a while,
their marriage started to feel the effects of this. According to people who knew them,
Leanne would leave Mark periodically. After the honeymoon phase died down,
she began to see Mark's true colors. He was mean and domineering, but every time she left,
she always came back. This toxic marriage was taking a toll on her. One neighbor recalled
Leanne as a woman who was afraid to be herself when her husband was around. He intimidated her.
He wanted his way with her. And Mark's mental health was deteriorating too. He was becoming
more paranoid, more depressed. He believed people were following him, that they were tapping his
phones, that the world was out to get him. Now, Mark had always had these problems,
but with the weight of his alleged crimes hanging over him,
his mental health was even more serious. Mark's mental health was becoming more and more serious.
He needed something else to focus on, to distract him from the demons that had been
following him all of his life. And then, he discovered day trading.
In the late 1990s, everyone was talking about the stock market,
a place where regular people could make millions trading tech stocks. Mark saw an opportunity,
a chance to prove to everyone that he was a winner. And he had the money to do it.
In April of 1998, he signed up for classes at All Tech Investment Group, one of the day trading
companies in Atlanta's Buckhead district. The founders of the company, Brent Doonan and Scott
Manspeaker, were thrilled to have him on board. They had just started the company, and Mark was
so eager to join that he inspired confidence in the team. At first, neither of them were sure that
starting All Tech was the right move. But with Mark's enthusiasm, they believed even more
strongly that they were onto something. After he completed his required courses to work with them,
which covered technical analysis, reading charts, and understanding the timing,
he was a fixture in their office. And it couldn't have come at a better time.
The market was on a historic run. The Dow had just crossed $10,000 for the first time.
The Nasdaq was soaring. Tech stocks were minting millionaires overnight.
It felt like free money. All you had to do was get in.
So Mark sat down at a desk at All Tech, deposited $100,000, and started trading.
Brent, the co-founder, thought Mark had all the energy and positivity that they needed.
And truthfully, he also had the money. After welcoming Mark into the office for the first time,
Brent pulled Scott, his co-founder, aside and told him,
We seem to really click, Scott. This guy's loaded and experienced, and he seems like a really good
guy. The two sat Mark down in their office for a more lengthy discussion on his first day,
and Mark told them, I would like to trade in big blocks, as I like to call them.
Brent and Scott were both stunned as Mark went on to explain what he meant.
While most people traded maybe $100,000,
on any given day, Mark preferred to do so on a much larger scale,
often trading anywhere from $3,000 to $5,000 a day. It was high risk, high reward.
But Mark seemed like just the man to handle that. He had an air of confidence about him.
And having just started their business, Scott and Brent needed that.
They happily welcomed him aboard, where he became one of the office favorites.
For Mark, this new way of making money was exhilarating. And in the beginning,
thanks to Debra,
he had plenty of money to spend. After making a risky investment, he would sit at the computer
all day, watching his money go up. On the days where he would win, it seemed like he was on cloud
nine. He felt invincible. The other traders had given him a nickname, The Rocket, because when
his bets paid off, he was explosive, loud, animated. He had a kind of childlike excitement to him
that made the office feel less than comfortable.
And even when he was losing, he would shrug, crack a joke, and say,
that's just the name of the game. But there was a problem with that. While initially Mark was
lucking out, by early 1999, he was losing far more than he was earning. In March of that year,
the company's founders, Scott and Brent, were in the business of making money.
Brent realized that not only had Mark drained his entire account, but he also owed them $11,000
because he had been trading on the margin. Now, by this point, Scott and Brent were friends with
Mark, but they knew they needed to sit him down to have a talk. When Brent addressed the money he
owed, Mark gave Brent a playful nudge on the shoulder. He told him with a laugh,
don't worry, I'm good for the debt. He acted like it was no big deal. Brent believed him.
Ever since he had met Mark, he had proven to be a capable guy, one who was resilient and always
able to make things work. And in April, one month later, Mark seemed to prove his assumptions right.
He paid off his debts and refilled his account. Where he got the money, we have no idea. But for
Brent and Scott, it was a relief. They wouldn't have to have that awkward conversation with a
man they considered a friend, because Mark was back on top.
However, that high didn't last long. Soon enough, Mark fell into the same trading patterns that had
got him in debt the last time. And by June, he had not only drained his account again,
but this time, he owed Scott and Brent $30,000, triple the amount he had owed them a few months
prior. So, on a simmering summer day in the middle of June, they knew it was time to confront Mark
once again. Brent sat him down and asked, Mark, what happened? Mark replied, Brent, I'm so sorry.
again. Instead of swinging for singles or doubles, he was trying to crush some home runs.
Surprisingly, the conversation wasn't a very dramatic one. According to Brent, Mark was calm,
eager to take responsibility for his actions, and he told Brent that he was going to go back to work
as a chemist, get the money he needed to make up the losses, and come back to pay his debt.
Then he clicked off of his computer and walked out of Alltech, his head held surprisingly high
given the circumstances. In his journal, Brent wrote,
Through it all, Barton had managed to remain strong in the face of adversity.
His smiling face and obvious addiction, the thrill of trading, had been evident from the
moment he walked into our office a year before. In the year or so I have come to know Mark,
I don't recall ever seeing him upset. I hoped his positive outlook would help him
through this tough time, and I hoped to see him again, under better circumstances.
But it wasn't just Mark's finances that were suffering around the
time. His marriage was crumbling, too. His old co-workers at Alltech remember hearing the way
he would speak to Leanne over the phone. While he still worked there, Mark would leave voicemails
where he would say, Leanne, it's me, you can pick up. It appeared to Brent that Mark only allowed
Leanne to answer if it was him calling, which is exactly what he did with his first wife, Debra.
But over time, his colleagues said that Mark started mentioning his wife less and less.
What was happening inside their house has never been made public.
But back in April of 1999, when Mark first drained his accounts, Leanne packed up her belongings and
she left him. Now, like we had mentioned before, she would leave him from time to time. But this
time, she actually got an apartment of her own a few towns over in Stockbridge. We don't know the
details on exactly what happened. Perhaps she found out that he lost most of their money day trading.
Maybe he was treating her poorly, like he used to treat his wife, Debra. Whatever it was,
it was enough for Leanne to leave him, at least for a few months. You see, Mark may not have had
money, a job, or much going for him, but he did have one thing that Leanne loved dearly,
his children, Matthew and Michelle. In June of 1999, after Mark was forced to leave Alltech,
Mark called Leanne and told her that he was at risk of losing his house due to his
debts. She was distraught. Matthew and Michelle had gone through so much throughout their lives,
and the thought of them being kicked out on the street because of their father's irresponsibility
was heartbreaking. So, Leanne agreed to give Mark a second chance. Soon after, he and the kids moved
into her small apartment, abandoning the home they could no longer afford. The kids, Matthew and
Michelle left the apartment and went back to the apartment. Leanne and Michelle left the apartment
and went back to the apartment. It was mid-July, and for the first time in a long time, things were actually looking up for Mark.
Rather than pursue chemistry, Mark decided that he had no option but to go back to day trading.
Despite the fact that he owed debts to Brent and Scott at Alltech, he strolled right across the
street to another day trading company, Momentum. On the application to trade with them, he claimed
his net worth was $750,000. But that was a lie. It wasn't even close. Regardless,
he put down $87,500 to start trading. And this time, Mark told himself, things would be different.
In the beginning, they were. The market was climbing. Day after day, the numbers kept going
up. On July 16th, the Dow hit $11,209, a record high. The S&P was up over
15% for the year. And Mark? Mark was winning. Out of the 15 days he'd traded at Momentum,
he ended up in the black on four
of them, meaning he made a profit. Maybe he started to believe this was it,
that he was finally turning it around.
that everyone who doubted him, Leanne, Alltech, all of them, would finally see that he knew what
he was doing. Then, on Monday, July 19th, the market started to fall. At first, Mark probably
told himself it was just a dip, a correction. It happens. The market goes up, the market goes down,
you ride it out. That's what smart traders do. But Tuesday came, and it kept falling. Wednesday,
Thursday. The volatile internet stocks Mark had been on were dropping. And Mark wasn't the kind
of trader who cut his losses. He held on, doubled down, watched the numbers on his screen turn red.
By the weekend, Mark must have been a wreck. But he couldn't stop. Day trading experts always say
you have to know when to fold, when to take your losses, and live to fight another day.
But Mark left his positions open. He'd go home at night with his money still on the table,
exposed to whatever the market did while he slept.
And every morning, he'd wake up to find out how much more he'd lost. The next week was even worse.
Monday, July 26th, the market was still sliding. By now, the S&P had dropped over 5% from its peak.
The Nasdaq was down nearly 8%. And Mark was drowning. He started coming into momentum
more often now. Not sporadically like before, but desperately. Frantically trying to dig out
the hole he was in. Trying to win back what he'd lost. What he'd
always wanted. Almost had. But it was slipping away. All of it.
On Tuesday, July 27th, 1999, Mark was at momentum again. Same terminal. Same screen full of red
numbers. Same pit in his stomach. And that pit was there for good reason. At that point, Mark owed
momentum $185,000. That's on top of the $30,000 he owed Brent and Scott back at Alltech. And that
day, Mark was at momentum again. And that's on top of the $30,000 he owed Brent and Scott back at
Alltech. And that day,
momentum had enough. They walked up to him and interrupted his trading. They told him he needed
to put up $50,000 immediately, or they would close his accounts. It was a margin call. When you borrow
money from a brokerage, and your losses get too big, they demand you pay up. Now. And if you can't,
they close you out. But Mark didn't have $50,000. He didn't have anything close to that. However,
he wrote,
wrote them a check anyway. Maybe he thought it would buy him one more day. But he was wrong. Mark
was officially completely wiped out. In a little over two years, he had lost all $300,000 of Deborah's
life insurance. That's about $600,000 in today's money. Everything he had worked for, everything
he had likely killed for, was gone. Mark had no income. Leanne, his 27-year-old wife, was the only one
supporting their family. She was working 70 hours a week, selling cleaning supplies to bring home the
$45,000 a year the family survived on. Meanwhile, her husband, the man she had trusted, gambled away
their future. And now, he was determined to take that future away permanently. In his narcissistic
mind, he had lost everything, which meant they had to as well.
After the $50,000 check at Momentum, Mark walked out of the office and started his car. A car that
he could no longer afford. But that didn't matter now. Nothing mattered now. His hands tightened on
the wheel as he turned out of the parking lot of Momentum, heading towards an unexpected place.
The local Toys R Us. He browsed the aisles, filling his cart with toy after toy. Anytime he saw
something his children would like, he threw it in the cart. There were arts and crafts kits, a doll
for Michelle, an army man, and a toy for his wife. He had no idea what he was doing. He had no idea
what he was going to do. As Mark drove home, he knew what he was going to do. He would give the
kids their toys, snuggle them, laugh with them, and then do the unthinkable. That night, he pulled
up to the family's new apartment, got out of his car, and presented his kids with all the toys
they could dream of. Matthew and Michelle were elated. They played with their new toys and
told him it was time to go to their scout meetings. At that point, Michelle went to her
brownies meeting with a close friend and her parents. Meanwhile, Mark attended the boy scout
meeting with Matthew. During the meeting, he smiled. He cracked jokes. He made plans for the
future and acted like everything was fine. Like he hadn't written a check he knew would bounce.
Like his world wasn't collapsing all around him. Like he wasn't about to take innocent people down
with him. That night, Matthew excitedly talked about the swimming badge he had just gotten.
He had plans for camping in the future, for earning more badges, going on more adventures.
Somehow, his father felt nothing as he listened to his son plan a future that would never come
to fruition. When he picked up Michelle from her meeting, he found her in the parking lot
of a local park, running alongside her close friend Natasha. Michelle was beaming. Even in
the dark of night, anyone could see it. Because she was illuminated by the glow of the fireflies
she was chasing. She was carefree, enjoying a warm,
Georgia summer night alongside her friends. And once more, her father watched her. And he felt
nothing. He knew, then and there, that he was going to still go through with his plans. He
loaded the kids into the car and returned with them to the family apartment. Moving boxes still
lined the hallways and rooms. Leanne decided to take Mark and his children in, despite the
cramped space. It wasn't home yet, but they were getting there. Or so they thought. Leanne
came home that night, like every night before it. Exhausted, and pushed to her absolute limit.
It was just the start of the week. A week where, undoubtedly, she would work the hours of two
people, just to keep a roof over her family's head, and food on the table. Mark was supposed
to be looking for a real job. He was supposed to be making an effort to pull them out of debt.
But that night, coming in through the front door, Leanne just saw a man unwilling to change. A man
who was digging for a job. And he was looking for a job. And he was
digging for a job. And the kids deeper into debt, lies, and danger. All to feed his own ego. She couldn't take it
anymore. The feelings of pure exhaustion, of anger, of betrayal, they were all simmering to the
surface. And she had to let them out. Now what words were exchanged between the two, we'll never
know. What we do know, is that their argument didn't stop their obligations. There was dinner
to make. There were kids to be tucked in. So, swallowing her pain,
Leanne helped get the kids ready for bed. She brushed Michelle's hair and listened to her talk
about her new baby dolls and toys she had gotten that day. Leanne reminded her son Matthew, who was
lost in a pack of Pokemon cards, to brush his teeth before bed. Then, she said goodnight. She
kissed her babies, told them she loved them, and then crawled into bed herself. Slowly,
the weight of the argument with Mark, the weight of her long day, it all faded into
the mattress. Leanne tucked the blankets up around her. She always hoped the next day would
be better. She was positive that way. In spite of any challenge she faced, she chose to believe
that tomorrow would be a brighter day. And with that, she drifted off to sleep.
Just down the hall, her babies. Her whole world. The reason she stuck around. They were dreaming.
But someone in the house was still awake. And he was kick-starting a nightmare that would
last for days. As his wife slept, Mark reached into the closet, grabbing a claw hammer from his
toolkit. The same kind of weapon that was used to kill Debra, Mark's first wife. But tonight,
the hammer was heavy in his hands as he crept down the hallway, past the rooms of his sleeping
children. He opened the bedroom door. A flicker of light shone across his wife,
bleeding in from the crack in the door. Her chest was peaceful,
rising and falling. She was asleep. Defenseless. Mark had a chance there. A million chances.
He could have closed the door. He could have walked out of the home. He could have left Leanne
to do the only thing that mattered to her. Raise their children. But Mark didn't do that. Instead,
he stepped closer and closer and closer. Until he was standing directly above Leanne. Towering over
her.
And then the first hit came. There was the crunch of bone, the squish of muscles and brain matter
exploding into a mess. And with the sound, the blood, the horror, there was finality. Leanne
wasn't dead from the strike of the hammer just yet. But there was no going back. So Mark hit her
again and again and again. He kept smashing the hammer into his wife's face, crushing her skull
beyond all recognition. Until finally,
he fell still. The bloody hammer hung in his grasp. His wife was dead. She hadn't had the chance to
defend herself. She hadn't had a chance to scream, to call for help, to react. He had done what he
had always done. Taken advantage of her, of the love she had for his children. And he struck when
she was at her most vulnerable. Leanne was just 27 years old when she took her final breath. The only
person with her was Mark. He was the only person with her. He was
with her was the man who vowed to honor and protect her.
she trusted to do just that. Instead, he delivered the fatal blows and then he grabbed her by her
feet. He dragged her dead body out of sight, stuffing it into the closet. But looking at her
there, crumbled and shoved behind the door, he realized it wasn't enough. He went to the kitchen
and grabbed a trash bag. He tied it around her head so he wouldn't have to look at what he had
done, so her blood wouldn't pull into the carpet beneath her. And then he wrapped a blanket around
her before he closed the closet door. Next, he crawled into bed, the same bed he had just murdered
his wife in, the same bed that was splattered with her blood and brain matter. And then Mark
went to sleep, unbothered by the fact that he just committed a monstrous act and he was sleeping
in the evidence of it.
Now, we know there will be comments about,
Leanne being the other woman. And there are a lot of people who speculate on what Leanne knew
about the murder of Mark's first wife, Debra. But because that investigation was handled so poorly,
we have no answers regarding that. But we do know that Leanne did not deserve to be murdered.
She started dating Mark when she was 21. Mark was 38. He was manipulative. He knew exactly what to
say to get what he wanted. And in the end, Leanne is still a victim in this story. She clearly made
mistakes. She's a victim of her own. And she's a victim of her own. Most people just have the privilege of growing beyond them, of evolving, and of becoming their
best selves. Leanne wasn't awarded the chance to live a full life. It was snatched away from her.
Still, she was so much more than her relationship with Mark Barton. Her sister and cousins called
her Goldilocks. Her father called her Honey. She had grown up in Lizella, Georgia, running barefoot
and wild beneath crepe myrtles and rows of peach trees. Her sister, Dana, loved seeing her become
a mother. Then later said,
We should have been two old ladies in a shoe, for we had a love of children, and we should have had
a dozen apiece. And Leanne proved just how true that was. She was Matthew's soccer mom, Michelle's
Girl Scout brownie leader. She taught Sunday school. These weren't her biological children,
but she loved them like they were. She loved them so much that, in spite of her own reservations
about Mark, she decided to see things out with him. Her father would later say,
She couldn't separate from them. That's the
reason she died. He admitted to the Macon Telegraph that he didn't like Mark from the start, saying,
My God, my wife's got harder hands than he had. Limp. And he didn't look you in the eye either.
He would never address his first wife's death with me. We were reassured, as I guess any child
would do, that Mark was innocent of, I don't want to say the accusations, but what he was
suspected of. I never bought it. As the interview went on, he looked down at the cigarette in his
hand. He paused and told the interviewer,
We never had any photos of him in our home. All along, his suspicions had been right. And in just
a few hours, the whole world was going to know what he had known all along, that Mark Barton was
a killer. When Mark woke up on Wednesday morning,
Leanne's body was in the stage of rigor mortis, sitting in the closet just a few feet away from
him. Yet, he stood up, put on his slippers, and walked out to the kitchen to start his coffee.
Enough. Matthew and Michelle woke up and wandered into the kitchen like they always did. But instead
of being greeted by Leanne, they saw their father. He made them breakfast as they played with their
new toys. For that entire summer day, those two children lived in a house with their stepmother's
body hidden in a closet. They went out for dinner that night at a nearby restaurant.
One chair sat empty. I'm sure Mark told them that Leanne was out for the day, that she was busy
doing something else. And once they came back home, it was time for bed. Wednesday night, July 28th.
Matthew probably didn't want to go to bed just yet. He was 11. It was summertime. There were
video games to play, cards to trade, things to do. But eventually, he climbed into bed. Maybe he was
thinking about his friends, about what he wanted to do tomorrow, about the endless summer stretching
out ahead of him. Michelle, who was in the kitchen, was in the kitchen. She was in the kitchen,
probably went to bed easier. She was younger. She had her teddy bear. Maybe Mark tucked her in.
Maybe he read her a story. Then, he turned off the lights in her room, and he left.
Matthew and Michelle went to sleep that night, feeling safe. In their beds, in their home,
with their dad just down the hall, ready to keep the monsters at bay. Soon, Matthew drifted off,
that deep, heavy sleep.
That children fall into so easily. The kind where the whole world disappears, and is replaced by
vivid, colorful dreams. He probably never woke up. Never knew his father was standing over him.
I hope he never felt a thing, as his dad cracked the blood-soaked hammer over his head. We can only
hope that he was somewhere else. Somewhere without pain. But Mark struck his son again, and again,
and again. His head was later described as, quote, beaten to a pulp. But that wasn't enough for Mark.
After bludgeoning his son, he stumbled into the bathroom and turned on the water in the tub.
It wasn't to clean his child's blood off, despite the fact that he was drenched in it.
It was to ensure his son was dead. Mark made his way back to the room and picked Matthew up.
He then set him down in the bathtub, face down. For the next,
few moments, he stood over him. He watched as the water engulfing Matthew turned pink.
Matthew David Barton was 11 years old. He had a whole life ahead of him. He was a boy scout.
He played soccer. He liked video games. He was about to start sixth grade, and was slated to be
the smartest in his class. People who knew Matthew remarked that, while he was a kid, he had a mature,
serious air about him. He was protective of his sister. He felt responsible for her, and given what
happened in his short life, that makes perfect sense. Matthew had already lived through more
tragedy than most people experience in a lifetime. He was just five years old when his mother was
murdered at that campground in Alabama. Too young to really understand what had happened. Too young
to know that his own father was the prime suspect. All Matthew knew was that one day his mom was
there, and the next day she was gone. After Deborah's death, Matthew was
raised by his father and Leanne. She became the only mother
he really remembered. She was at every soccer game. She drove him to scout meetings. She was
the one who showed up, while his father, Mark, was spiraling. And now, both she and 11-year-old
Matthew were dead. Sadly, Mark wouldn't stop there. Back inside the apartment, Michelle was
fast asleep. She cradled her teddy bear in her arms. It was the bear she couldn't sleep without.
The one that made her feel safe, when mommy and daddy weren't in the room
with her. She still believed her daddy would protect her from anything. Instead, he stood
over her with a hammer in hand. And just like with Matthew, he struck her in the head again
and again and again. But once more, that wasn't enough. He had to make sure that Michelle was dead.
So, he picked her up. He walked her over to the bathtub, and he set her down beneath the running
faucet. Michelle
Elizabeth Barton was eight years old. She was a brownie, one of the littlest Girl Scouts. Michelle
was about to start third grade, and she had already made a reputation for herself. She was a known
jokester. She loved to laugh, to play pranks, to make others crack up. Michelle didn't take things
too seriously. She was just happy. She had a best friend named Tiffany who lived nearby.
They went to Girl Scouts together. But that bond had been forever severed.
Inside the apartment, both of Mark's children were dead.
Lying in a bathtub, their heads beaten to a pulp. When Saul was said and done,
Mark picked his son up out of the water. The image of Matthew's injuries are horrible to
think about. But right there in that bathroom, Mark grabbed a towel and he dried him off.
Then, still wet and bloodied, he dressed Matthew one last time, brought him into his bedroom,
and laid him down on the bed. He tucked him in like he was sleeping.
He placed Matthew's Game Boy next to him, like his son had just fallen asleep playing it.
Next, Mark walked back to the bathroom. Back to the tub. Michelle was still lying there,
face down in the pink water. He reached in and lifted her small body out.
She was so light, just eight years old. He held her against his chest,
her wet hair soaking through his shirt. He carried her down the hall to her room, laid her
on the bed, pulled the covers up to her chin, placed her favorite teddy bear on her chest.
The teddy bear she believed would protect her and keep her safe. He lifted the blankets around her
head, wrapping it around the sides like a halo. If you had walked into those rooms without looking
too closely, you would have thought that they were sleeping, peaceful and safe. In reality,
within 24 hours, Mark Barton had
his wife and two young children. He spent the rest of that night alone in the apartment. His
wife in the closet, his children, and their beds. Three people who had trusted him, loved him. Three
people whose lives he had ended with his own hands. This wasn't a man in a crazed frenzy. Mark was
calm and calculated. After killing Leanne, he went about his life for another full day. He made
breakfast. He talked to his kids. He watched them play with the toys he bought. He tucked them in at
night. And the whole time Leanne was in that closet, that kind of coldness, the kind of
detachment, most people couldn't do it. Most people couldn't function. But Mark did. It was
as if nothing happened. When the sun came up on Thursday, July 29th, 1999, Mark sat down at his
computer. It was 6.38 in the morning. And he started typing. What he wrote on that computer
was a confession, an explanation of sorts, a suicide note. He printed it out and left it on
the coffee table in the living room. This is what it said. To whom it may concern, Leanne is in the
master bedroom closet under a blanket. I killed her on Tuesday night. I killed Matthew and Michelle
Wednesday night. There may be similarities between these deaths and the death of my first wife,
Deborah Spivey. However, I deny killing her and her mother. There's no reason,
for me to lie now. It just seemed like a quiet way to kill and a relatively painless way to die.
There was little pain. All of them were dead in less than five minutes. I hit them with a hammer
in their sleep and then put them face down in a bathtub to make sure they did not wake up in pain.
To make sure they were dead. I am so sorry. I wish I didn't. Words cannot tell the agony. Why did I?
I've been dying since October. I wake up at night so afraid, so terrified that I couldn't be that
afraid while awake. It has taken its toll. I've come to hate this life and this
system of things. I've come to have no hope. I killed the children to exchange them for five
minutes of pain for a lifetime of pain. I forced myself to do it to keep them from suffering so
much later. No mother, no father, no relatives. Now in this next part, Mark writes something
strange about his son, Matthew. Something he fears Matthew inherited from him. Something that Mark
seemed to have inherited from his father. Something
he fears Matthew inherited from his father. It read
this. The fears of the father are transferred to the son. It was from my father to me and from me to
my son. They already had it and not to be left alone. I had to take him with me. Mark never
elaborated on exactly what he meant by that. But according to him, whatever darkness he carried in
himself, he believed he passed it on to his son. And rather than let Matthew live with that burden,
he decided to kill him. At least, that's what he did.
That's what Mark wanted everyone to believe. Even in killing his own son. He has to somehow rewrite
the narrative to make himself the hero. But in his note, Mark went on to say this.
I killed Leanne because she was one of the main reasons for my demise as I planned to kill the
others. I really wish I hadn't killed her now. She really couldn't help it and I love her so much
anyway. I know that Jehovah will take care of all of them in the next life. I'm sure the details
don't matter. There is no excuse, no good reason. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't
know. I'm sure no one would understand. If they could, I wouldn't want them to. I just write these
things to say why. Please know that I love Leanne, Matthew, and Michelle with all of my heart.
If Jehovah is willing, I would like to see all of them again in the resurrection to have a second
chance. After typing this note, Mark walked through the apartment one last time. He stopped
at each body, and on each one, he placed a handwritten note. The note on Leanne read this.
I give you my wife, Leanne Vandiver Barton. My honey, my precious love, please take care of
her. I will love her forever. The note on Matthew read. I give you Matthew David Barton, my son,
my buddy, my life. Please take care of him. And lastly, the note on Michelle read. I give you
Michelle Elizabeth Barton, my daughter, my sweetheart, my life. Please take care of her.
He called them his honey, his buddy, his sweetheart.
His life. And yet, he killed them all. I wish I could tell you that our story ends here,
but it doesn't. At the very end of Mark Barton's suicide note, it read this.
I don't plan to live very much longer, just long enough to kill as many of the people that
greedily sought my destruction. You should kill me if you can.
That's right. The murder of Mark's wife and children wasn't enough for him. In fact, it was just the
beginning. That afternoon, the afternoon of Thursday, July 29th, 1999, Mark walked into his
closet. He reached over Leanne's body and grabbed a pink polo shirt, a pair of dark shorts and white
sneakers. Then, after getting dressed, he grabbed his guns. Within just a few hours, Atlanta,
Georgia would be the site of a horrific and deadly mass shooting. One that was aimed at the very firm
where Mark Barton lost everything.
If you want to listen to that episode now, head over to our Patreon. You can listen to that episode
and every episode of ours early and ad-free on our Patreon. You can find the link in the
description of this episode, and if not, we'll see you next week for the 1999 Atlanta Day Trading
Massacre story. For today's episode, we will be making a donation to the National Alliance on
Mental Illness. NAMI is the nation's largest grassroots mental health organization, and
dedicated to building better lives for the millions of Americans affected by mental illness.
If you'd like to learn more or make a donation yourself, you can visit NAMI.org.
On Patreon, you can get early ad-free access to all of our episodes that are here on the main feed,
and you can also get access to additional bonus episodes of the show that will never be posted
anywhere but on Patreon. These are full-length episodes of Murder in America, exactly like the
story in the episode that you just listened to with both Courtney and I, with the same level of
script writing and sound design and research and care that goes into our main show, but these are
bonuses for those who just want to get started. If you'd like to learn more about the show,
choose to help support the show on Patreon. So, thank you guys who have signed up, and thank you
all who help and have helped to keep this show afloat over the years. Also, don't forget to
follow us on Instagram at Murder in America to see photos from every case that we cover here on the
show. And be sure to leave us a five-star review. We love hearing from you guys. We love seeing those
five stars, and it helps our show grow. It just helps us so much if you can leave us those reviews.
So, yeah, thank you guys if you've done it already, and thank you in advance to those who are going to
do it after hearing this. Anyways, y'all, I'll see you next time. Bye.
Well, I hope you all have an amazing rest of your week and a great weekend if you're listening on
Friday. My name is Colin. Thank you all for tuning in. I'll catch you all in the next one.
Have you met my kids? And with BJ's gas, she gets there for less.
They call me the road warrior. This is your home, road warrior mom. Home of the Save.
Join for just $20 at bjs.com slash mesquite and save 10 cents per gallon for six months.
Open soon. Hello. The Devil Wears Prada 2 is now streaming on Disney Plus
and Hulu. We are digital. We are downloadable. We are streamable.
We have work to do.
Critics say it's smart and witty and the perfect sequel. That's all.
Get runway ready for the Devil Wears Prada 2 on Disney Plus and Hulu. Rated PG-13.
Every night, all year long. Plus a 25% bonus toward your daytime use all summer.
It's a first of its kind plan created for how Texans actually use energy.
Discover how much more you could save with free nights and cool summer.
TXU Energy. Energy for everything.
Visit TXU.com for more information. Rep number 10004.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Quince offers high-quality, timeless essentials made with premium materials like Mongolian cashmere and organic cotton, priced 50–80% lower than luxury brands.
Quince clothing is durable, stylish, and designed to be worn repeatedly, with customers reporting that their pieces have held up well over time.
The brand aligns with a values-driven ethos, resonating with consumers who value sustainability, comfort, and craftsmanship.
BJ’s Wholesale Club offers members up to 25% savings and a $20 entry fee, with benefits like 10 cents per gallon savings on groceries and access to bulk items.
The film *The Devil Wears Prada 2* is now streaming on Disney+ and Hulu, praised by critics as a smart and witty sequel.
*Undertone*, a new horror film, is a critically acclaimed psychological thriller about a podcast host haunted by terrifying recordings.
The true story of Mark Barton reveals a man whose childhood trauma, mental health struggles, and deep-seated insecurity led to a violent crime.
Mark’s abuse of power, obsession with control, and eventual murder of his wife and mother-in-law are tied to a pattern of emotional manipulation, financial gain, and a broken sense of self.
Summary:
Quince stands out for its high-quality, durable, and timeless everyday clothing made from premium materials like Mongolian cashmere and organic cotton, offered at a fraction of luxury brand prices. The brand’s thoughtful design and ethical values have made it a favorite among consumers, with many retaining pieces from early purchases. Meanwhile, BJ’s Wholesale Club promotes savings through a $20 entry fee and bulk discounts, appealing to cost-conscious shoppers.
In entertainment, *The Devil Wears Prada 2* and the psychological thriller *Undertone* are highlighted as fresh and critically acclaimed additions to streaming platforms. The narrative of Mark Barton, however, serves as a cautionary tale: a man shaped by emotional neglect, paranoia, and a need for control, who ultimately committed a violent crime against his wife and mother-in-law. His descent began with childhood trauma and mental health issues, fueled by insecurity, a toxic marriage, and financial motives, culminating in a brutal murder.
The story underscores how trauma and isolation can lead to destructive behavior, and how a person’s inner world—shaped by abuse and fear—can manifest in extreme violence. The case illustrates the dangers of emotional manipulation, financial greed, and unchecked power, offering a stark contrast to the curated, positive narratives of fashion and entertainment.
FAQs
Quince offers elevated everyday essentials made with premium materials like Mongolian cashmere, organic cotton, and washable silk. Their clothing is designed to be comfortable, stylish, and durable, and everything is priced 50 to 80% less than similar luxury brands.
Courtney and the speaker have kept Quince pieces from their 2024 shopping trip, and they have held up incredibly well over time, showing strong durability and quality.
Quince offers free shipping, 365-day returns, and app-exclusive offers. It's available in Canada and the UK, and everything is priced significantly lower than comparable brands.
Quince's 100% Mongolian cashmere sweaters start at just $50, offering luxury-quality softness without a high price tag.
Mark Barton, once a successful chemist, became paranoid and emotionally unstable due to a combination of childhood trauma, mental health struggles, and an affair. He murdered his wife Deborah and mother-in-law Eloise at a campground in 1993, motivated by jealousy, financial gain, and a deep-seated need for control.
Mark became increasingly paranoid and aggressive at TLC Manufacturing, recording colleagues' calls and sabotaging employees. His erratic behavior led to his firing and later, a burglary of the company, which triggered a criminal investigation.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.