Go back

Ep. 2104 - Did Iran Ground All Our Flights?

58m 20s

Ep. 2104 - Did Iran Ground All Our Flights?

A sudden nationwide air travel ground stop is traced to a technical failure in the FAA’s outdated communication system, likely caused by a router upgrade that overloaded an aging network. Officials state there’s no evidence of a cyberattack, though the incident reveals deep systemic weaknesses in U.S. infrastructure. Politically, the episode analyzes the Republican Party’s midterm losses as stemming not from policy failure, but from a damaged public perception—specifically, the Iran war being seen as a repeat of George W. Bush’s foreign policy, which eroded trust among independent voters. Key figures like Nick Fuentes are criticized for claiming electoral influence, but their impact is shown to be negligible. The discussion centers on immigration, emphasizing that debates must shift from documentation to substance—assimilation, economic contribution, and cultural integration. The author argues that while the GOP has suffered setbacks, its core agenda remains viable, and future success hinges on winning over centrist, non-ideological voters through clear, non-racist messaging. The episode concludes with a broader political insight: realignment is a process, not a collapse, and the Republican Party must rebuild through internal cohesion, not blame.

Transcription

9926 Words, 55222 Characters

English
There are two kinds of confession. One, the state forces out of a prisoner. The other, a man makes freely before God. Confession, written by The Daily Wire's very own Ben Shapiro, is about a man in Stalin's Moscow caught between the two. Confession is now streaming only on The Daily Wire. Join today to watch. We've all heard radio advertisements about owing the IRS money. They lean on fear and try to frighten you into calling. Tax relief advocates does things differently. Whether you owe $5,000, $50,000, or $500,000, TRA offers an actual solution. Do not lose hope. TRA could reduce or even eliminate what you owe the IRS. Their passion is taxes and helping individuals and businesses settle their IRS problems. They've earned over 1,000 five-star Google reviews and an A-plus from the Better Business Bureau. There is no need to fear the IRS any longer. Substantial relief programs are available that can give you a fresh start, so do not delay. Visit TRA.com. or call 800-575-4908. That is, once more, 800-575-4908. Tax relief advocates, real solutions for real people. Progressive's accident response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected. Progressive is here to help when you can't. with Progressive's accident response. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions. FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. This episode is brought to you by Cardiff, America's favorite small business lender with over $12 billion funded since 2004. Plan under three minutes for same-day funding up to $500,000 at Cardiff.co slash Knowles. The second nationwide ground stop since 9-11 froze all air travel in the country precisely as I was walking into Reagan Airport to catch my flight from D.C. Did the Iranians shut down our airspace or was it just government incompetence? And which would we prefer it to be? I'm actually not sure which one I would rather. Then Democrats win the Alaska Senate race, meaning the Republican midterm loss is officially now worse than the Democrat loss in 1994. We are looking at the biggest blowout in half a century. Lots of people are trying to capitalize on the loss for their own benefit. As we saw at the Christian Nationalist Conference over the weekend, we'll go through a little bit of that. And finally, CNN claims that black fathers are more present in their children's lives than fathers of any other racial group. I'm Michael Knowles. This is the Michael Knowles Show. Welcome back to the show. Everyone, as I mentioned, is trying to explain the midterm loss for the Republicans in the most convenient way for their own group. And so Joe Rogan is joining into this. Joe says that President Trump lost the podcast pros and more than that. So we'll get into exactly what's going on because now with the declaration in the Alaska race, this is officially worse than 1994 was for the Dems. This is this is the worst one for the Republicans since the 70s. So we'll get into it first, though. As the airline passenger, I must weigh in on this flight craziness over the weekend. I flew into D.C. You recall I was broadcasting from D.C. on Friday. I flew in Thursday night. It was supposed to be a very quick trip. My sainted wife, sweet little Elisa, was juggling my four children at home. I was going to be home on Friday. I'm walking in. I leave a meeting. I was walking into Reagan Air Port and my phone starts blowing up. People adjacent to the government, people totally outside of the government saying, man, I hope you're not in the air right now. So what are you talking about? Nobody seems to think anything's wrong at the airport. And then I look and there is a nationwide ground stop on all air travel. So no planes taking off anywhere in the country. Planes that were in the air had to land. Planes that were flying into the country from internationally were being dealt with on a case by case basis. This is only the second time we've had this since 9-11. Extremely unusual stuff. This on the heels of my going viral, thanks to the New York Post, because of a video I made at a different airport three years ago in which I complained that robots were trying to charge me a tip when I went to buy water at an airport newsstand. So I actually blame myself. Was it the Iranians? Was it government incompetence? It may have been me because I don't know. I don't know. I irritated the robots by going viral as the airline passenger fuming over the robots at the airport. Maybe they decided to get their sweet revenge on me by shutting down my flight along with 3,500 flights across the country. In any case, it was pretty wacky. Luckily, I was able to get a hotel room, went right back into D.C. All the flights were done. They kept getting canceled. There are still issues going on with our air system because of what happened on Friday. So what was it? Most people's minds, I think, went straight to this has to be a cyber attack. We're in this very direct war with Iran right now. The Iran war is actually a proxy war with China because we're in a broader Cold War with China. Some people were blaming AI systems for the flights going down, although the Cold War with China that we're in actually centers significantly around AI and the AI arms race. Beyond the Cold War that we're in with China, we're also in another proxy war with Russia in Ukraine. So it's very, very plausible that this was a cyber attack. However, you have DHS Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, who come out from the White House, say as of now, there is no evidence of a malicious attack. About cybersecurity, once again, we're still looking at it. We're not ruling out anything. What it appears to be right now is as Secretary Duffy and FAA was going in and putting patches into the system, they were putting new equipment and new technology, and that new equipment, new technology just wasn't, it was overwhelming the older system, which is why Secretary Duffy made it very clear the patchwork doesn't work. We need one complete system. We need someone to come in and. Okay, you got to love politicians. Here's Mark Wayne Mullen. He's got Sean Duffy right next to him. He goes, yeah, so the main thing that I've concluded from this, is it was all Sean Duffy's fault. Duffy there is like, wait, why are you blaming me for? It's not my fault. You're saying, okay, well, one explanation is that it was a systems upgrade, but we've got this very, very old system that many US presidents from both political parties have allowed to decay. And so you try, you have to upgrade it a little bit. You have to patch it a little bit with the money that Congress appropriates for us. And it's just not enough. We need a much larger overhaul of our communication system. But you have the one cabinet secretary saying, no, it was that other guy's fault. Totally wasn't my fault. So then Sean Duffy was making the rounds on the Sunday shows. Once again, people not totally buying Mark Wayne Mullen's explanation, even though I guess in some ways it would be better if it were not a cyber attack. But if this were just the government not knowing how to upgrade the systems, if this would just be our structure for airline communication being so decayed that we can't fly planes around the country, that might actually be worse than a cyber attack. So here is Sean Duffy. This is Sean Duffy giving as straight an answer as a politician is going to give on the cyber attack angle. Are we convinced now there was no outsider nefarious actor that was overloading that router that caused this ground stop? Yeah, if I can just first say, we took the extraordinary measure of issuing a ground stop. And I want everyone to be clear in America that my number one priority is to make sure that you get to your destination safely. And when we have inconsistencies in our network, we're going to shut it down. I'm going to make sure you get there safely. And that was the measure that was taken on Friday. But to your question about what's happening in the network, we have the router. It's at the L3 Harris Lab in Florida with FAA staff. We are doing a full review of the router and the process that was used in El Dorado, Texas. The FBI is offering assistance. President Trump actually had the whole of government on the phone on Friday. Was anyone saying that? We have seen footprints. Was anyone hearing chatter? Was this a cyber attack from a foreign nation? We have no indication that that was at play here. We think it was the installation or the router that was the bad actor. But we're open. If we see something else, we're going to continue to investigate with our federal partners and law enforcement. But at this point, we don't think that that was the cause. It was the router or the installation. So no definitive answer here, though I think Sean is being as candid as he can be, which is no, there's no indication right now that this was a malicious attack. The issue had to do with this router being installed to patch some problems with the system that has been decaying for many years. But then you have a good question there, which is, well, okay, why did the router overload the system? It wasn't like the router just sprouted arms and started punching holes in the walls. What was it about the router? And what it would have been is that too much data were flooding in, too many data, I guess, if we're going to be pedantic about it, were flooding in and overwhelming this old system made of copper wires. And okay, well, why were all those data flooding in? Could this have been an attack from a foreign adversary? Was this caused by some new system, an AI system that was just too much for our infrastructure? Was it Mark Wayne Mullen's fault or Sean Duffy's fault or President Trump's fault or the Mueller's fault? And none of the explanations right now are all that plausible. Because, okay, if the issue is data flooding on the Federal Telecommunications Infrastructure Network, data flooding in at a rate of about a thousand connection attempts every four to five seconds, then you have to ask yourself, okay, did they not see this coming? I don't totally buy that. Where did the flood come from? We are at war now with like at least three hostile powers. But who knows? I mean, you never want to underestimate, forget about just government incompetence. You never want to underestimate the fact that the United States has a lot of data flooding in their infrastructure. And so, you know, we're not going to talk about this. Even the decayed state of our infrastructure, whether we're talking about roads and bridges or whether we're talking about copper wires. So it could be that. There's just this other coincidence, which is the day before Microsoft had this major, major outage that shut down Outlook and other software for 430 million users or something like that. That happened just the day before. Microsoft saying this has nothing to do with the airline problem. They said the Microsoft incident was a technical issue, not related to cyber. They're AI agents. It was introduced by an issue during an earlier network capacity upgrade that surfaced following recent network change. So notice here, a lot of people, the Democrats just want to blame Sean Duffy and the Trump administration. Conservatives who are a little more conspiracy minded want to blame Iran or China or something like that. But let's focus on the Democrats for a second. Notice that the explanation from the government for the airline problem is basically the exact same explanation from Microsoft over their software problem. Oh, yes. Well, there was a systems upgrade and data flooded in and it just shut the whole thing down for about 24 hours. Okay, hold on. Now we've got conservative government and liberal private company, Microsoft, and we've got exactly the same problem. The argument that it was not a cyber attack beyond just what the government's telling us, the argument that it was not a cyber attack is if it were a cyber attack, this would be a cause of belly to escalate the war on Iran. Don't forget, President Trump is signaling that he's going to escalate the war in Iran. Big headlines that J.D. Vance, who is one of the great voices of restraint over the Iran war, he's now just being put fully on domestic policies. Trump is not going to have him negotiate to get another deal with Iran. That's at least the signal. Whether or not that's true is a secondary point. But every signal that Trump is sending is he's going to escalate the war in Iran. So if he wanted to do that, a cyber attack from Iran would be a good cause of belly. It would be a good way to mobilize the public to escalate the war in Iran. But that doesn't totally take you all the way because if Iran or China or anyone were actually able to hack into our FAA system and shut down flights, that would cause such a public panic. That would cause such a loss of trust in the institutions of the United States that it wouldn't be worth it. That would be a kind of a Pyrrhic victory politically. So the short answer is we don't know. Plus, you see all this stuff going around about people prepping. Walmart shelves were empty a week ago. You're hearing all of these exercises on military bases. There is a reason that the conspiracy theorists are skeptical of the government's response here. However, I have a similar answer on this that I do for the Epstein issue. When the Epstein issue was really, really coming back up about a year or two years ago, I said, guys, either Epstein is what everyone says he is, which is, I'm sorry, what the official story on Epstein is, which is, he was just a really rich guy with a bunch of sexual perversions who happened to have a lot of rich and famous friends. Or Epstein was something else, in which case we're never going to learn any more about it. Either what they're telling us about him is true, in which case we know everything about him, or he's something else and we know everything we're going to know about him. That's kind of how I feel about this airline shutdown. It's entirely possible, entirely plausible. This was just a software issue. But again, they say, okay, it was a domestic issue, it was a software issue. So then people said, okay, well, was it AI? They said, no, no, it wasn't AI. It wasn't this particular software. Everyone's being very, very vague about it. But if this were a cyber attack, and we are in multiple wars right now in great power conflict, if it were that, we would not know. In any case, I am now fuming over the flights even more than I was when the robots tried to make me tip. What does this mean domestically? Well, the balance of power is shifting. The fact that this is all happening midterms, too, it's just the fact that it happened on Friday the 13th, even it now occurs to me, the timing is all very, very coincidental. What does this mean after the midterms? Well, the Democrats are feeling their oats. The Democrats are in the strongest position that they have been in, in a very, very long time. This is the biggest midterm upset in probably 50 years. We'll get into Alaska and the blame game. You got Joe Rogan and some of the podcasters pointing fingers for the blame game. You have a Christian nationalist conference that took place over the weekend. Very illustrative conference. I haven't seen the whole thing, but there were some very interesting moments that I haven't seen anyone else talking about. And then John Fetterman might flip to become a Republican. So we'll get into all of it. First, I want to tell you about Cardiff. Okay, you own a business and you just get offered the biggest contract you've ever gotten, a hundred thousand dollars. But the trick is you need $30,000 in cash in order to contract. What do you do? Do you say no? You say, no, thank you for the best business offer I've ever gotten, but I can't fulfill it because I don't have access to cash. No. What you do is you call Cardiff. You go to cardiff.co slash Knowles, K-N-O-W-L-E-S. What Cardiff does is it gives fast same day funding up to half a million bucks to small businesses or medium sized businesses, maybe even a bigger business, where you get the bank rates without those bank rates. So you go to the bank and it drags on and on and on, and you lose the contract and your life falls to pot. Don't do that. Just go to Cardiff, cardiff.co slash Knowles. If your business has been around for at least a year and you're doing at least $20,000 per month in revenue, go to cardiff.co slash Knowles slash Knowles, and you can get up to half a million dollars in same day funding. Cardiff.co slash Knowles. Fast funding Cardiff. Borrow better. As her opponent. So you have the Democrat Mary Peltola against Republican Dan Sullivan running against another Republican, followed by another, yet another Republican running as an independent, also named Dan Sullivan. So the hope is that confused voters split the vote among the Dan Sullivans and the Democrat is able to win. Very crafty trick. The Trump DOJ had threatened to contest the election if the Democrat won by fewer votes than the other Dan Sullivan got. However, that won't be an issue here because even when you add up both of the Dan Sullivan's votes, the Democrats still won. So this is a pretty bruising election story, and the 2026 Republican midterm loss is officially worse than the 1994 Democrat midterm loss. This doesn't mean that Republicans can't win any time in the future. It doesn't mean that the party is totally collapsed. It doesn't mean that the Republicans can't win in 2028. Don't Don't forget, two years after 94, Democrats get destroyed in 94, and then they come back forget, two years later, the Republicans can't win. with a resounding victory for President Bill Clinton in 1996. So the doomerism is a little premature right now, but this is now, at least on the Senate side, officially worse than it was for the Dems in 94, though it's not quite as bad on the House side. Whose fault is it? Joe Rogan points out, just from his own vantage in podcast world, Trump clearly lost the podcast bros. He had the podcast bros in in 2024 short two years later he loses them all and the election was about more than that but like they didn't just lose the podcast bros they lost most of the country like when you get into a war that no one wants to be in when you got militarized police in the streets wearing masks and no id citizens they did some good things they closed the border and then crime dropped significantly that's those are good things it's not a good thing to have the border wide open or anyone, including terrorists, can come in. Also, not a good thing to snatch people out of their fucking taco stand that have been in the country for 20 years and are nice, good people that are loved by the community, but they just don't have the right paperwork. There's a lot of scumbags that happen to be born right here in this patch of dirt that we keep letting out of jail. And you got these hardworking people that did nothing wrong other than make their way over here when it was okay to do that, which was a lot. Like, for the last four years, they allowed anybody to get through. And if you just snatch those people up now, like, what did we just do? You just let all these people in. And some of them are good people. Filter it out. Okay. All right. Hold on. Totally, totally disagree with Joe's last point here. But he's making a crucial, very important, very insightful point about electoral politics overall. That last point he's making is ridiculous. He goes, you know, they're snatching people out of the taco stand. These people never did anything wrong. Well, hold on. They did. They violated one of the basic laws of our country. They came in illegally. He goes, no, no, no. But they came in when you were allowed to do that. Well, you were never allowed to do that. It was always against the law. And these people knew it was against the law. It's just that Biden and the Democrats ignored the law. They subverted the law. But they knew everyone it was always against the law and everyone always knew that. And that, you know, they're hardworking people. Some of them are hardworking people. A lot of them mooch off of welfare, but some of them are hardworking people. There's no question about that. But immigration policy is about more than just being hardworking because countries are about more than GDP. Countries are about more than just an economy. We're not all undifferentiated economic units that just serve mammon and filthy lucre. We are a nation. We are a people. And a polity is about more than just money. Even if it were the case that the illegal aliens contribute so massively to the economy, a very dubious proposition in itself, even if that were the case, the illegal immigration issue is about much, much more than that. So I think Joe is totally wrong on the last point, but he makes a very, very good point. He illustrates a really good point at the top. He says, you lost the podcast, bros, Trump. You had us. People who were Bernie-supporting, supporters such as myself in 2016, people who were kind of libertarians. One of the defining features of the true libertarians is that when the rubber meets the road on the crucial issues, they always vote with the Democrats. They always, they kind of sound kind of conservative a lot of the time, but at the crucial moments, they'll run over to the left. So you lost some of these libertarian types. You lost these independents, late-breaking independents, some of the maha people. In other words, you lost these really unreliable voters if you are a Republican. These are not people that you should be counting on if you're a Republican. They're not part of your base. They're the secret sauce that gets you over the finish line, maybe even gives you the popular vote. But they are in their very nature as independent, centrist, libertarian, not ideological voters. They are not reliable. So why did Trump lose them? Joe goes on and he says, well, it's the Iran war and it's the images of the immigration policy. And I think he's especially right when it comes to the Iran war. This is why this is the key political principle here that explains why the Iran war was so politically disastrous. Forget about disasters from a national security standpoint or a grand strategic standpoint. There is a strong argument that the Iran war could have been good from a grand strategic standpoint. A point that I granted even as I opposed the war before, during, and after. I said, no, no, if it works, this is one of the great grand strategic victories. This would be totally genius. Remake the world order. The war could be justified. The mullahs certainly have it coming. I'm not just some anti-war peacenik by any chance. I opposed it on practical grounds, on prudential grounds. But the reason that politically the Iran war was so disastrous is because you need to give people permission to vote for you. Rock-ribbed, right-wing conservatives, they were always going to vote for Trump. And they were basically always going to vote down-ballot Republican. But the low-propensity voters, the voters who sometimes vote Democrat, sometimes vote Republican, the independents, the podcast bros, podcast bros who almost by definition go where the audience is. Their chief incentive politically is to just do whatever is even slightly more popular at any given time. For those guys to vote for you, you have to give them permission to vote for you. You can't make them feel like a racist or something. So if you're going to win them over on the immigration issue, you need to make them feel like this is just common sense security. It can't possibly be because people who have a foreign culture, who speak a foreign language, don't assimilate well into your country. And they upset your traditions and your national institutions. That's too much. That feels a little too racist. You have to make it just about you know, criminals, gangsters, basic rule of law. You need to give people permission. One of the ways that Trump gave this independent voter permission to vote for him is by saying yeah, I'm a Republican and you hate voting for Republicans because you have all these memories of George W. Bush, but I'm not like George W. Bush. I'm a totally different kind of Republican. That was what gave the Joe Rogans of the world, permission to vote for Trump. And what was so disastrous politically about the Iran war is it made Trump look like George W. Bush. Even if that's unfair, even if it's an imprecise analogy, in the minds of that voter, it made Trump look like George W. Bush. And it made that voter feel foolish because that voter had to tell himself, even though that most people want the Republican policies. Most people, most people want good schools, an end to the weird sex stuff. They want foreigners basically out of the country. They at least want a smaller percentage of the population to be foreign. They definitely want to close the border, but they want more than that. They don't want their downtown to look like a foreign country. But they feel uncomfortable saying that. This is true even of liberal voters. You know, liberal voters who talk about all the diversity that they love and how, you know, it's so cultural and enriching to have street tacos and they, you know, capital, they love DEI. All those liberals who are rich enough move to the suburbs and they send their kids to schools that are the least diverse in the country and they, these working class heroes on the left, they will live in the richest zip codes in the country. They want nothing to do with poor people. They want nothing to do with racial minorities. They are far less diverse in most of their actions and behaviors than your median conservative voter by a long shot. But they speak differently. There is a huge chasm between their stated preferences and their revealed preferences in politics. And this was the real explanation, I think, of what happened in the midterms. Is that because of the Iran war as the chief symbol of this, with downstream effects like rising energy prices, rising energy prices, which raised the cost of everything, which also made that median, that independent voter feel foolish because at the very least, even if he didn't want to touch the immigration issue, he could say, well, I'm voting for Trump because Biden made everything too expensive. Downstream effect of that, prices went up because of the Iran war. Now I feel foolish. Oh, wow, gosh, I really did vote for a Republican who seems like George W. Bush, even though they're different. Trump and Bush are very, very different. But that's the perception. Okay? If there is one takeaway politically from the midterms, it has to be that permission structure. A successful Republican in the future is going to give permission to enough voters who are not reliable, who are not usually on your team to come over and vote. And on issues, you're often going to appeal to them in different ways that you're going to speak to them. So, that's Rogan's take on it. Now, there was a Christian nationalist conference over the weekend. A lot of interesting speakers there, but the one who's going viral is Nick Fuentes, who now infamously called for voters to vote for Democrats in the midterm elections. He's taking a lot of credit for the Republican law, plus in the midterms, because he wants to destroy the Republican Party and then reshape it into his image. Very, very interesting speech that he gave. I'd like to see the other speeches from this conference. I haven't had time yet. But there was one little admission there in the speech that I think really undercut his argument and gives you a lot of insight into what actually happened in the midterms. We'll get to that in a second. First, I want to tell you about Helix. There's a lot more to say. First, though, go to helixsleep.com slash Knowles, K-N-W-L-A-S. The holidays of the season, when everyone voluntarily destroys his own sleep schedule. You stay up late wrapping presents, wake up early to travel, eat an enormous dinner. Then you act surprised when you're exhausted by noon. The problem is that holiday sleep debt tends to make everything harder. Travel feels longer. Children seem louder. Your patience becomes one more thing you forgot to pack. That is one reason I love my Helix. Sweet little Elise and I have not just one, but multiple Helix mattresses all throughout our home, including in the new guest room, which I'm sometimes sleeping in with the new baby, and I was on the road, I got caught in all that crazy air travel, and then I slept fine. But then I come home and I get to sleep on my nice bed. Helix has more than 20 mattress models. Their two-minute sleep quiz considers your sleep position, comfort preferences, and support needs, then matches you with the right fit. Helix delivers it directly to your door with free U.S. shipping. You get full 365-night sleep trial and the Happy with Helix guarantee. That is an entire year to make sure that you love it. You won't need it because you're going to adore your Helix mattress from the moment you get it. Go to HelixSleep.com slash Knowles for up to 30% off during Helix's Black Friday sale. HelixSleep.com slash Knowles for up to 30% off. HelixSleep.com slash Knowles. Do not lose hope. Visit TRA.com, that is TRA.com, or call 800-575-4908. TRA.com. So there's this Christian nationalist conference that took place down in Texas. It was put on by Joel Webben. There were a bunch of speakers there. I haven't had a chance to look at all of the speeches, though. There are going to be a lot of similar kinds of conferences, including among all the different subgroups. There are going to be like five Christian nationalist conferences, and they're all going to disagree with each other. And then there are going to be more establishment conferences and business Republican conferences and foreign policy conferences. We're in this moment, Fuentes made a good point on this, because as President Trump is coming to the end of his second term, it's kind of like the death of Stalin. And so after that, you're not going to necessarily have a charismatic figure or anything like Trump, but you're going to have the people who institutionalize some kind of idea, some kind of ideology, some kind of platform. And that's what everyone is fighting over right now. And the way to begin fighting over it is to try to explain the midterm losses. Now, you got to give. We're going to have credit where credit's due. Fuentes has great rhetorical skill. I mean, he is a really talented rhetorician. He's very funny. Sometimes he talks about me a lot. And so I don't I don't watch the show, but sometimes I get the clips and he'll be making jokes about me. And I will be laughing at him because he's funny. He's got good rhetorical skill. He's got decent political insight a lot of the time. But there was one little bet that he took in his speech that I think severely undercut. The argument that he is trying to make about the midterm. See if you can pick it up. So when we talk about 26, that's not us. We did not lose. It was the Republican Party that lost. And that's a good thing. I'm glad it happened. Just a show of hands, by the way, how many of you guys voted for Democrats in this election? I just. I just want to say, oh, it's barely anybody. Seriously, everyone just raised their hands. If you're watching at home, every single person just raised their hand. No, but I understand where you're coming from. You guys are in Texas. And I know that James Tallarico is one of the worst, not just one of the worst Democrats. He's one of the worst people living right now. There it is. This was, you know, I give him credit in the way that I give Trump credit for going into the Iran war, which. I disagreed with, but I saw the argument. This was a big gamble because this is going to be a consistent theme at a lot of these conferences, trying to shape the future of the Republican Party and the right in America. Fuentes's whole claim to relevance in this moment is I cost Republicans the midterms. I told all of my listeners to go out there and vote for Democrats. And my listeners are mostly young men and Republicans. Lost young men. And therefore, we can conclude that is because of me. They did what I told them to do. They went out and they voted for Democrats. So Republicans, you better listen to me because I'm calling the shots now. And so at the conference. With guests nationwide of the people who are most likely to listen to Fuentes. He says, how many of you went out and voted Democrat? It was so great that the Republicans lost and the Democrats won. How many of you went out there and voted Democrat? And two hands go up. And there's like one third hand that kind of like half goes up when no one else is putting it up. And he laughs about it. What else is he going to do? He says, oh, wait, it's nobody. None of you did. And then he makes another joke. He says, no, no, hold on for the cameras back there. Everybody just raised their hands for the cameras back there. Everybody raised their hands. They all voted Democrat. See, so I made them do that. And you got to listen to me now. And but then he tries to recover. You can tell he swallows hard a little bit. There he goes. No, no. But anyway, you're in Texas. That's why it's Tallarico is so bad. I guess. I guess the conference took place in Texas, but people flew in from all over the country. These are national conferences. So that doesn't explain it away. This was, as I say, I'm not just trying to dismiss him or deride him in any unfair way. But that was a rhetorical miss. Because if I were him right now, I would be doing everything I possibly can to make it seem like I swung the election, that I was the one who got the young men not to vote for Trump and to vote for the Democrats. Therefore, the GOP has to listen to me. At the conference of his most devoted young male listeners, nobody did what he said to do in the election. It didn't. He is now laughing about the fact that he had no effect electorally in the midterms. That's not coming from this guy's enemies. That's not coming from like Mark Levin or something. That's coming from him on the stage and in the audience. So the. Issues that he sometimes talks about, those played a role in the election, not denying that the demographics that he's talking about, like the young white men that played a role in the election, no doubt about it. But there is a little bit. I was just in the beltway. You know, I was just for a little bit longer than I intended to be because of the FAA shutdown. And there is in the political consultant class, there's a little bit of a Fuentes panic that this guy is totally held the GOP hostage. And I think, no, look, he's he has a lot of enemies. He has a lot of enemies. He is very funny a lot of the time, even when he's making fun of me or saying things that are very offensive and it's kind of shock jockey or whatever. He's got some political insight, no doubt about it. But. I don't know that he moved a single vote in the election. That was kind of the punchline of the whole thing. And then I would go a step further, even beyond him and some of the panic that the consultants are having about this one, you know, 29 year old podcaster, however old he is. Think about Rush Limbaugh. Rush Limbaugh. Is the broadcaster of his generation and a multiple generations. Way, way bigger for his generation than someone like Nick Fuentes is for his. So who knows? Maybe he'll grow and become more mainstream or whatever. Rush Limbaugh had 15 million listeners at any given time. OK, and like at a time when communications were more centralized, so you could have a bigger audience. Now it's much harder to do that. He had 15 million listeners. This guy and he was basically unrivaled as the broadcast leader of the American right. And when it came to picking candidates, nominees for presidential elections, he basically never got it right. 1992, after the Reagan era, you know, you had George H.W. Bush had essentially Reagan's third term in the 1992 election. Rush Limbaugh picked Pat Buchanan. He ran against George H.W. Bush, Bush won. 1996, it wasn't quite as hotly contested and Limbaugh didn't like Pat Buchanan at that point. Rush did like George W. Bush and George W. Bush did win. So there was one mark for Rush. Then in 2008, Rush hated John McCain. He trained his rhetorical canons on John McCain the whole primary. McCain still got the nomination. People liked Rush. They listened to Rush. In those days, we didn't have the clips going around, but the people would listen to the Rush Limbaugh show. 15 million listeners. Didn't matter. When it came time to vote, it didn't actually move the needle. I love Rush. I got to guest host for Rush as he was dying. I then had a radio contract on another network, so I was only able to do it the one time so as not to compete with the network that I'd signed with. But it was great. I just totally adore Rush. Rush is the man. But I'm pointing out 2008, 1992, his voice didn't matter. 2008, when he was training it all on McCain, didn't matter. 2012, Rush wanted Santorum. He hated Mitt Romney. Mitt Romney got the nomination. 2016, Rush backed Ted Cruz, not Donald Trump. Cruz lost. Trump got the nomination. So there's this kind of panic. People feel this anxiety because it is true that the Trump era will come to an end at some point or other. And we are trying to set exactly what the next institutional kind of conservatism will be in the absence of a charismatic leader who makes it basically all about himself, the Sun King, or Napoleon. I'm mixing French metaphors. But that's Trump. It's all about him. And I guess my point is everybody can take a little bit of a chill pill. Everyone's going to duke it out. But the midterm losses, I think, were relatively easily explained, which is structurally the Republicans were always going to lose. And then the Iran war meant they were going to get clobbered for reasons that pertain to the direct consequences of the Iran war, but also the symbolic effect of the Iran war. So it's not about one guy or this guy or this, that, or the other thing. The various factions of the right are going to duke it out. That is what the right always does. Trump era was in many ways an aberration. It was a pulling away from the usual state of play, which is you have the neocons and the paleocons and the traditionalists and the libertarians and the more fringe actors too, all duking it out and fighting. That has only just begun. It's far from being solidified. Okay. Speaking of realignment, John Fetterman might become a Republican. So in that, if Fetterman became a Republican, then even though the Democrats won the Alaska Senate seat, Fetterman would flip to be an R. So actually it would make the Republican loss in 2026 exactly the same in the Senate as it was in 1994. For that reason, I think I want it. But people are also getting overly excited about this. This is the theme of the show is, hey, everyone, quit getting so overly excited. Guys, calm down. It's a marathon, not a race. Don't worry. This game has only just begun, but we'll get to whether or not Fetterman is going to flip. First, I want to tell you about Policy Genius. First, though, go to policygenius.com slash Knowles, K-N-W-L-E-S. The holidays have a way of making you think beyond the present year. You look around at your family and imagine the celebration still ahead. Graduations, weddings, grandchildren, Christmas mornings when someone else finally has to assemble the toys. Well, there are many, many of these moments that I certainly want my family to keep having and that I think you want your family to keep having. Part of being a father is thinking about how to provide for them even if you are no longer there. The still needs to be paid. The kids still need an education. You want your family to have room to grieve without immediately wondering how they're going to pay the bills. That is why life insurance matters and why it helps to have someone walk you through your options. Policy Genius is an online insurance marketplace where you can compare quotes from some of America's top insurers side by side for free. Their licensed team explains coverage amounts, prices, and terms, answers your questions, and handles the paperwork to help you find a policy that fits your needs and budget. Make a smart move today to help protect their tomorrow. With Policy Genius, you can see if you can find 20-year life insurance policies starting at just $276 a year for $1 million in coverage. Go to policygenius.com slash Knowles, K-N-W-L-E-S, to compare quotes now. That is policygenius.com slash Knowles. Do not lose hope. Transcription by CastingWords The NVIDIA scandal, taking out the head of NVIDIA, is not really about him. This was a highly coordinated play in the paper of record, the New York Times, clearly coming from the Intel community, to take out the CEO of NVIDIA, more or less as collateral damage, to get Howard Lutnick, the Commerce Secretary, to get Donald Trump the president. It's part of a much better established pattern of politics, which is to try to get Trump after the midterms when he's particularly weak. In any case, though, I picked the wrong pun. I tried to do a Wang pun, like the Wangs are doing all sorts of inappropriate things, but Don Wong, chef's kiss, it's beautiful. Is John Fetterman, Democrat senator from Pennsylvania, about to flip to the Republicans? Check it out. Is there a red line for you if the party does go far left that you would walk away? Yeah, absolutely. It would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen, that has really made his, name being very anti-hostile to Israel. You know, if you are going to be angry or hostile towards any countries in the region, why not make that, you know, Iran or Hezbollah or Hamas as well, too? And now, why? Why? Both in the House now and the Senate now, their first instincts are to punish Israel and to withhold these kinds of aid. Why? Why isn't your first instinct to say, let's hold Iran accountable? Okay, so the reason he wants to flip is because he supports Israel and the Democrats hate Israel and basically hate the Jews as well. So it's like deeper even than just foreign policy for the Democrats. There is a legitimate growing anti-Semitism, much more pronounced than it is on the right. And that is why John Fetterman wants to flip to the Republicans, which is fine. Great. Yeah, I certainly oppose Jew hatred. I'm, I'm broadly supportive of the state of Israel with a lot of caveats and nuances to it. But that's it. Okay. That's not going to help us all that much. This is why I haven't been able to get all that excited about John Fetterman's various Fox News hits over the last two years. It's like, it's great. Anytime someone within the Democrat party is criticizing the Democrat party, that's fine by me because it creates turmoil and wonderful. But if, if the only issue that Fetterman would flip on, is Israel, an issue, which is a wedge now in the Republican party as well, because the older Republicans strongly support the state of Israel, the younger Republicans by younger, I mean, under the age of 50, certainly under the age of 40 are a little more skeptical of the state of Israel. That doesn't really help us. Fetterman on border security is pretty good. He does think that we should lock down the border. He's kind of, he's, he's sort of like the podcast for us on this. Yes. He thinks we should lock down the border. He's spoken open. He's spoken openly about legal status, pathway to citizenship, the dreamers. So again, he'll be totally unreliable when, whenever the rubber meets the road on any legislation, possibly even on impeachments. He certainly doesn't have Trump derangement syndrome like the rest of the Democrats do. But if you're, if you're pinning your hopes on this one Democrat Senator flipping to be Republican, just, just know he's only flipping because of an issue that is relatively unimportant in the minds of most Republican voters. It's not going to, not going to do that, much in terms of realignment. So now back to the Republican circling the wagons, let's get back to the immigration issue, which is still going to be a major driver. As I said, I said at the night of the election, people accused me of cope on it, but I, I think I'm, I'm right about this. I do not believe that the Trump agenda was what was rejected at the midterms. I said it day of and the morning after. And I think, I think I said it on Fox news at like 4 a.m. the next morning. It wasn't the agenda that was rejected. I don't think that all of a sudden the midterm voters showed up and they said, you know, we really like transing the kids and flooding the country with foreigners and criminals. And we really like high taxes and inflation. What the voters rejected was the perception that Trump himself has diverged from his agenda. Whether that's a fair perception or a false perception is immaterial. That was my point on the semiotic quality of the Iran war, that it takes a lot of time to figure out how to deal with it. And I think that's, I think, takes away the permission slip that people had given themselves to vote for Trump because he's not George W. Bush. It takes away the permission slip to say, well, I'm just, I care about these domestic policies and the Democrats have totally lost their way on this. The downstream effects of the Iran war, raising the prices of everything takes away that permission slip. So I think that was what it was, but I think the Trump agenda is still pretty sound. The thing that was able to retake the Republican party in 2016, as I've said many, many times over the years, I think that is still politically quite strong. So immigration is going to be a big part of this. And I think it's going to be a big issue in 2028. Marco Rubio has said repeatedly, he's not running for president, that he's endorsed Shady Vance to be the Republican nominee. However, after the midterms, everything's on the table. Some are still hoping that Marco Rubio will run. And so at a Federalist Society speech, which went very, very well, Rubio got big plaudits on this. He did a great job, but he gave a little insight into his view of immigration and the American identity. The United States, we're not a common ethnicity. We're not a common race. We're not bound. You know what binds us? That we're all, I truly believe this, America is a nation. We are all the descendants of go-getters. If you think about whether you came here on a ship that sailed across the Atlantic, whether you came here because you refused to accept the restrictions of their nation of birth, whether your ancestors overcame the horrors of slavery and after that of segregation, we are the descendants of people that refused the limits and said, we're going to continue to strive and build for ourselves a better life. That blood literally runs through our veins. That's who we are as a people and as a nation. And I think America will always be a nation that welcomes people from other places, so long as we have certain rules and controls and restrictions in place that determines how many people can come, when they can come, who can come. Every sovereign nation makes that. Okay, this is good. This is good stuff. With a few things I don't like. love. But generally, this is really, really good stuff. about American identity, any focus on heritage, even down to Marco Rubio using the image of bloodlines, this, many in the squishy right would say, this is far-right, fascist, blood and soil, nationalist rhetoric. Well, you're getting it from Marco Rubio, guys. Is Marco Rubio a fascist now? Come on. He says, no, no, no. The identity of a country obviously has something to do with heritage because a nation is its people and a people is defined by its perseverance through time and in space. A people is not just one slice. It's not just one generation. It's not atomized individuals. The nation is the extension of the family. That's why patriotism is the extension of filial piety. So he says, okay, it runs through our veins. You have explicit blood and soil rhetoric, but it's not a race. And it's not a nationality or an ethnicity, whatever exactly we mean by race. It's not even some new race that was created in the 18th century. The American people is defined as a hereditary group that descends from go-getters. So that's a pretty clever definition. Yes, it's the go-getters on the Mayflower. It's the go-getters that landed at Jamestown. It's the go-getters that came from Southern Europe to Ellis Island. It's the go-getters who have come more recently, even from Latin America. Does that include illegal immigrants? Maybe it does. They are go-getters after all. They are. Well, say whatever you will about the illegal immigrants, the ones paying off the cartels to come through to be economically prosperous. They are go-getters. Does it include the Somalis? They're go-getters too. This is where it starts to break down. This is where the civic nationalist rhetoric starts to lose its strength, I think. The Somalis, just Ilhan Omar. Ilhan Omar's criminal family shows up and they're just fraudsters down to their bones. They're marrying their brothers and they're the Somali population in Minnesota and elsewhere. They're defrauding the government. They're setting up these fake companies. They are go-getters. That is impressive, but what are they going to get? That's what I want to know about the American nation and identity. They're descendants of go-getters. Okay, what are they going to get? Rather than the proceduralism of being a go-getter, I want to focus on the substance of substantive goods of what they are going to get. The big problem with the way that conservatives have talked about immigration for the last 50 years is that we focus too much on procedure and not enough on substance. Well, you know, the way we used to talk about it now, I think that's basically too unpopular. The way that we used to talk about it was, well, if you come here, legally, that's good and we want more of it. But if you come here illegally, that's bad and we want less of it. In other words, the only permitted question on immigration was whether or not you have some document. It actually seeded the point to the left, which is that what defines the illegal immigrant is that his lack of documentation. But I don't think that's true. I think the more relevant questions are, what do you believe? What relation do you have? How easily will it be for you to assimilate? How many people like you are already here? Which, if they're already here, there are too many that will make it more difficult to assimilate. What language do you speak? What church do you go to? You know, these are really, what jobs do you do? How can you contribute? These are pertinent questions. Those are substantive questions, though. And so that same problem, focusing only on procedure, not on substantive goods, you do see that in the Secretary of State's speech here, which is, okay, well, you know what? They're go-getters. That's a way better, closer definition that will help advance the immigration conversation. But we still don't totally have the substance. What are they going to do? What are they going to get? The pilgrims came here to establish a shiny city on a hill. That's ultimately what the Puritans did. And the pilgrims who came on the Mayflower did a relatively similar thing. And what the Mayflower ultimately gave us was a great cigar company, and you should get yours before Thanksgiving. But what were the immigrants of Ellis Island coming to get? It was a little different than what the Mayflowers were coming to get. They weren't brownist, separatist Calvinists. And some of us would say that's actually a good thing. But what were they coming to get? Was it just economic all our nation is about? What are the Guatemalans and the Venezuelans and the Mexicans across the border illegally coming to get? What are the Somalis coming to get? Because there's a big difference between coming to get a new Jerusalem on Cape Cod and coming to get Medicaid dollars that you're diverting to your fake autism center in Minnesota. Very different things. And we cannot avoid the substantive conversation. Okay. I know I mentioned at the top of the show that CNN is claiming that black fathers are present in the household at higher rates. than fathers of any other race. That was my tease. That's what I'm teasing. We're going to have to get to it tomorrow because I'm already running very, very late. The rest of the show continues. Now, it's Movie Monday. You do not want to miss it. Become a member. Use code NOLSKIN at WLES to check out for two months free on all annual plans. Father, I used to feel Christ. I cannot feel anything here. They take me out of my bed and they brought me here and they tell me nothing. What have I done? Article 58, counter-revolutionary activity. That is all I know. They have to deal with so many enemies of the state, all of whom claim they're innocent. Who protest, who cry. There are no answers here. Other than the ones they put in your mouth. You'll break. Today is your opportunity to demonstrate your loyalty to the people. You'd like to know why I'm here? Of course. Of course. But you already know, don't you? You must believe in something greater than the party. You will remember your duty. I've told you I know nothing. They growled like a feral animal. You stink of failure. You want me to lie? Still a drunk. Damn you! They all break. Maybe. ♪ ♪ We've all heard radio advertisements about owing the IRS money. Do not lose hope. They've earned over 1,000 five-star Google reviews and an A+ from the Better Business Bureau. Substantial relief programs are available that can give you a fresh start. So do not delay. Are you ever shopping online and suddenly a discount that helps you save pops up? It makes your day, sometimes even your week. Want that feeling month after month? Well, new customers who save by switching their home and auto insurance to Progressive save hundreds. Cue your happy dance. Get your quote today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states. ♪ ♪

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. A nationwide air travel ground stop occurred due to a system failure, likely caused by a router update overwhelming an outdated communication network, with no evidence of a foreign cyberattack.
  2. The incident highlights deep flaws in U.S. infrastructure and governance, with officials citing systemic decay and inadequate upgrades as root causes, though blame is split between political figures.
  3. The midterm election losses for Republicans are attributed to the perception of Trump’s Iran war policy as resembling George W. Bush’s style, undermining his appeal among independents and centrist voters.
  4. The political fallout includes a sharp rise in conservative factionalism, with figures like Nick Fuentes promoting voter disengagement from Republicans, though his claims lack electoral impact.
  5. Immigration and national identity remain central issues, with debates over assimilation, economic contribution, and cultural integration shaping political discourse.
  6. Despite the perception of political collapse, the author argues that the Republican agenda remains viable, and realignment is driven more by perception and policy than by a single event.
  7. The episode underscores the importance of "permission structures" in politics—success depends on winning over independent, non-ideological voters through clear, non-racist messaging.
  8. A recurring theme is the failure to address substantive questions about immigrants’ contributions and integration, instead focusing on procedures like documentation.

Summary:

A sudden nationwide air travel ground stop is traced to a technical failure in the FAA’s outdated communication system, likely caused by a router upgrade that overloaded an aging network. S. infrastructure.

Politically, the episode analyzes the Republican Party’s midterm losses as stemming not from policy failure, but from a damaged public perception—specifically, the Iran war being seen as a repeat of George W. Bush’s foreign policy, which eroded trust among independent voters. Key figures like Nick Fuentes are criticized for claiming electoral influence, but their impact is shown to be negligible.

The discussion centers on immigration, emphasizing that debates must shift from documentation to substance—assimilation, economic contribution, and cultural integration. The author argues that while the GOP has suffered setbacks, its core agenda remains viable, and future success hinges on winning over centrist, non-ideological voters through clear, non-racist messaging. The episode concludes with a broader political insight: realignment is a process, not a collapse, and the Republican Party must rebuild through internal cohesion, not blame.

FAQs

The ground stop was caused by a technical issue with a router installation in the FAA's communication system, which overwhelmed an older, outdated network. Officials say there is no evidence of a cyber attack, though the possibility remains under investigation.

No definitive evidence points to a foreign cyber attack. Government officials, including the FAA and DHS, state there is no indication of malicious activity, though the possibility is being scrutinized due to national security concerns.

The Iran war damaged the Republican Party's image by making Trump appear similar to George W. Bush. This eroded trust among independent voters who needed permission to support Republicans, contributing to the loss.

While some speculate about AI or software issues, officials attribute the problem to a data flood from a system upgrade, not AI. The old infrastructure was unable to handle the volume of data being processed.

Yes—both events involved network overloads from system upgrades. This suggests a pattern of infrastructure vulnerability, with both incidents stemming from outdated systems and failed upgrades.

Political messaging, especially on issues like immigration and national security, shapes voter perception. Voters are more likely to support candidates who appear to offer common-sense, non-racist solutions to these issues.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.