Ep. 1871 - Russell Brand Just Got Railroaded By The Courts
56m 21s
The transcript critiques the prosecution of Russell Brand for sexual assault allegations as a politically driven campaign rather than a legitimate legal inquiry. The case, which led to a 10-year prison sentence, emerged after a 2023 documentary that targeted Brand for his criticism of pandemic-era lockdowns and left-wing policies. Key allegations span over two decades, with most first surfacing after the documentary, and lack credible forensic or eyewitness evidence. Many accusers changed their stories, and some admitted to being emotionally affected or embarrassed by their own behavior. The prosecution failed to meet the legal standard of "beyond a reasonable doubt," especially given the absence of contemporaneous evidence or police reports. Critics point out that the case is inconsistent with how other serious crimes—such as child sexual abuse or murder—are prosecuted, with offenders receiving far lighter sentences. This suggests systemic bias, particularly against those who challenge the political status quo. The narrative also highlights broader issues in sexual assault trials, including reliance on hearsay, lack of victim anonymity, and the difficulty of verifying claims decades later. Ultimately, the case is presented not as a fair legal outcome, but as a political hit job that exemplifies how moral panics and media narratives can fuel wrongful convictions. The transcript also links these issues to broader themes of power, accountability, and the dangers of unchecked political retaliation.
People keep saying that real communism has never been tried. Well, it was.
Moscow, 1938. Arrests in the night. Confessions forced out of innocent people.
The Daily Wire's newest movie, Confession, is a story about just that.
It's out right now, only on The Daily Wire.
153 million driver's license scans are for sale on the dark web right now.
A breach like that doesn't wreck your life by itself.
But when someone uses your information, the cleanup becomes your job.
Unpaid.
Hours on hold with banks that won't help you without an account number you don't have.
That's what Aura is for.
Aura alerts you fast if your info shows up in a breach,
then locks your credit and provides U.S.-based fraud support 24-7.
You may not be able to stop all of it, but you can stop doing it alone.
Get started at Aura.com slash Daily Wire.
That's Aura.com slash Daily Wire.
The conviction of Russell Brand for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault
is a difficult topic to discuss for a few reasons.
For one thing, as is often true of these alleged rape cases,
it involves graphic details that are uncomfortable to hear
and even more uncomfortable for me to say out loud.
I'd rather not talk about these kinds of stories at all,
much less do I want to recount with specificity
the kinds of gross sexual behavior that we'll have to talk about today.
But after sentencing on Monday,
Russell Brand is now going to spend the next,
the better part anyway, of 10 years in prison.
So it's a big story and an important one in its way.
So it's worth discussing.
It's also a grotesque travesty of justice for reasons that I will explain,
which is the real reason, above all else, that we need to talk about.
Now, to be clear, there's no question that Russell Brand is,
or at least was, a degenerate sex fiend
who bears a large degree of responsibility for his fate.
Brand appears to have exercised essentially no restraint at all
for at least 10 or 15 years of his life.
Now, had he been even moderately civilized in his behavior,
he'd probably have been a little bit more civilized.
He'd probably be a free man right now.
So this is not exactly a Brett Kavanaugh situation
where the narrative is a total ludicrous fabrication at every level.
At the same time,
and we need to be able to hold these two realities in our heads simultaneously,
it's also obvious that the prosecution was a mockery and a sham,
and Brand did not receive anything resembling a fair trial.
Now, he may have put himself in a position to be railroaded by a kangaroo court,
but he didn't receive anything resembling a fair trial.
Now, he may have put himself in a position to be railroaded by a kangaroo court,
but it doesn't change the fact that he was indeed railroaded by a kangaroo court.
Brand may have been a sexual degenerate
with the discipline and self-control of a chimpanzee,
but that's not in itself illegal in this country or the UK.
And if it were, a huge number of other people
would be sitting in a cell right next to him,
including many of his accusers, as we will see.
The fact is that there was more than enough reasonable doubt
to acquit him of all the charges.
There's no question about that.
And we all know why this case was brought in the first place.
Brand broke away from the left during the COVID hysteria quite publicly
and became a conservative commentator.
So they came up with allegations from nearly two decades ago
and tried to destroy his career and his life, and they succeeded.
This is what the sentencing looked like,
just to give you an idea of how absurd these proceedings were.
We're going to bleep some of this stuff out
because it's, as will be the theme today,
it's graphic and disgusting,
but here it is.
Watch.
You invited her to your house a few days later.
There you put on a condom at her request
and had sex to which she consented.
You then flipped her over, removed the condom,
and without asking, forced your into her,
causing her great pain.
She asked you to stop, then asked you again loudly,
you replied, and I, quote,
I want you to feel my pain.
You replied, and I, quote,
She was distraught and in severe pain.
The bed was heavily soiled by blood and faeces.
You told her it was her mess and made her try to clear it up.
Shortly after, you went off to get ready, then went to work.
She was driven to a nearby underground station,
by your driver, who for some reason had tissues ready
to hand to her as she wept.
So we're talking about claims from the first year
of the Obama presidency.
There's no independent evidence for any of it,
but because the jury reached a guilty verdict,
the woman's version of events is now sacrosanct.
The judge will pretend, as the jury did,
that everything the accuser said is completely truthful.
He doesn't have to do that, by the way.
And throw out guilty verdicts if they're absurd enough.
But, of course, the whole point of this trial
was for the establishment to get revenge on Russell Brand.
So, you know, and that's what was going to happen,
and that's what did happen.
Therefore, we're all supposed to act as though guilt
has been established beyond any reasonable doubt,
which is why reporters in the UK are now hounding
Russell Brand's father for some reason
and reacting with stunned amazement
when he suggests the verdict could possibly be wrong.
Watch this.
It's a very unfair question.
Is this the type of man that you raised?
Leave the man alone.
They're nasty, aren't they?
Don't answer the question.
Do you have a message to the victims?
The victim?
What victim?
What, Russell?
Not Russell, his victims.
The girls, you mean, who chased him and harassed him?
He was convicted by a jury.
I don't care.
I don't care.
It's a system.
We don't believe the justice system.
I don't believe it on the basis of what I've just watched.
See, we've got social media.
It's easy to find the right people.
Go on Facebook and see the sort of things. You're saying the jury is corrupted.
Well, I'm saying it's possible.
Are you saying it's not possible?
I believe in the justice system.
Isn't that what we're supposed to believe in?
Are you saying you couldn't go on social media
and look at what people are saying
and find people who are attacking us?
Are you saying that?
Or do you understand you could?
Ron, do you think your son will be able to cope in prison?
Yeah, he's strong.
He's strong.
How do you think Laura will hold up?
She's strong as well.
That clip is circulating all over social media
among leftists and journalists who are horrified
that Russell Brand's father didn't immediately
throw his son under the bus on camera
and declare that his son is a rapist.
And note the question from one of the insufferable
reporters on the scene.
Is this the type of man you raised?
Now, it's interesting.
You'll never hear that question posed to the parent
of any, say, violent, murderous thug in that country
or in the United States.
Or this one.
Carmelo Anthony's parents, for example,
spent a lot of time on camera in front of reporters
over the course of many months.
And nobody ever threw,
is this the type of man you raised at them?
Quite the opposite.
They were allowed to play the victim.
Basically unchallenged.
Now, in the case of Russell Brand, though,
once the jury reaches a guilty verdict,
the allegations must be true.
And that's actually how a lot of people think.
It's like the system couldn't possibly produce
an unjust result.
So therefore, once the jury convicts,
you know, you can hound the man's father
like,
a snippy HR lady.
Now, of course,
the truth is that all of these people decided
Russell Brand was guilty
the moment the charges were brought.
Really, before that.
Really, they made up their minds
as soon as the British media establishment,
led by Channel 4 and The Times,
decided to target Brand for destruction
because of his political and religious beliefs.
This case was tried in the media
long before it went to court.
I mean, there's no universe
in which Russell Brand received
the impartial jury that he was entitled to.
The whole episode is reminiscent
in a certain ways
of the bogus Cornell 7 case,
where the accuser sent
numerous text messages
about how much she enjoyed herself
in the frat house
before getting disinvited
from a Halloween party
and then retroactively deciding
that she had been raped.
Now, Cornell's still in the process
of tearing itself apart
over those ridiculous allegations,
despite the presence of what's
what's called affirmative consent
many times over.
The Cornell scandal is
obviously a political football,
which is why New York Democrats
and the media establishment
have spent so much time on it.
They see the allegations
as a way to mobilize female voters
and strike back at the patriarchy.
And they don't care about
how flimsy the allegations are.
Now, of course,
in the case of the Cornell 7,
it's not just that there's no evidence
that they committed a crime.
I mean, there isn't any evidence.
It's that there actually is
direct evidence that exonerates them.
And that's what makes that case
so particularly egregious.
As for Russell Brand,
there isn't the same kind
of exonerating evidence.
But in a court of law,
even in the UK, in theory,
that's not the standard.
Innocent until proven guilty
is the standard.
It is still the standard,
at least on paper.
So the onus falls on the prosecution
to produce evidence
actively proving its case.
That's where the burden of proof lies
and must lie.
And no matter what
the obviously tainted jury said,
that burden was not even close
to met in this case.
So how flimsy is the case
against Russell Brand?
Well, we're going to go point by point
through all of the details.
And these will be details
that,
as established,
will be uncomfortable
and pretty gross to hear.
But I want to start
with a quick primer
on how all cases involving
rape and sexual assault
in both the US and the UK
are stacked against the defendant.
So think of it this way.
If you are brutally assaulted
in the UK or the US,
you're not entitled to anonymity
if and when the suspect goes to trial.
Your identity as a victim
is a matter of public record.
Along the same lines,
if you're defrauded
or blackmailed or robbed
or burned,
or armed in an arson attack
or carjacked
or injured in a DUI wreck
or nearly murdered,
Your identity is not hidden. Everybody will know who you are. The media can report on your name and
your background. You don't get any privacy on that score. Not because you did anything wrong. You are
in fact the victim of a horrible crime. But in a functioning country with a worthwhile legal system
and basic protections for the freedom of speech, there's no getting around it. The victims of
crimes, even really bad crimes, are a matter of public record. It's just the way things are in
a transparent, open society. But there's one major exception to this rule. Starting around the 1970s
in both the UK and the US, it became fashionable to hide the names of alleged rape victims and
sexual assault victims from the public. In the UK, it's a crime to reveal the names of these
alleged victims. In the US, thanks to the First Amendment, it's easier for journalists to publish
the names, but courts still try to hide it. And the theory is that without this anonymity,
accusers would be uncomfortable coming forward. So to accommodate
these accusations, we need to find a way to hide the names of the victims.
Accusers and their desire for privacy as a practical matter, it becomes impossible for
journalists and independent investigators to look into the accuser's history to see if they have a
history of lying or of criminal activity or anything like that. It would be impossible to
find out if, say, they were tied to any specific political movement or activist group, which is
not a small thing when you're making an accusation against a major political figure. These are
possibilities that we should be able to look into. It doesn't mean it's going to be the case,
but it's certainly possible that a person for political reasons or other reasons
could make up claims and we should be able to look into that.
This is a trade-off you might be inclined to accept since defense attorneys are still
entitled to know the name of the accuser and they can conduct their own investigation.
But there's yet another way that the deck is stacked against defendants in both the US and
the UK. It's extremely hard, if not impossible, for defense attorneys to know the name of the
accused. It's extremely hard for defense attorneys to introduce any evidence in court about the
accuser's history of prior sexual activity. And the idea is that feminists want to prevent jurors
from thinking along the lines of, well, she's a slut, so she was asking for it. Now, the problem,
and of course, jurors shouldn't be thinking along those lines, but the problem is that as comfortable
as it may be for feminists, the problem is that a woman with a pattern of acting whorishly and
sexually degenerate behavior is, in fact, a less credible accuser. That doesn't mean that she
was not raped or that it couldn't be true. It doesn't mean that at all. It just means that
her testimony is less credible. Her behavior patterns are relevant when trying to ascertain
what actually happened and the credibility of the accusations, especially when all you have
are accusations, especially when there is no evidence and it's just this person claiming,
one thing, and another person claiming another. So past history becomes relevant and not decisive.
They're not the only details that matter, but it is relevant. So why can we talk about Russell Brand's
pattern of behavior, which, as I've already said, is not good? Why can we talk about his pattern of
behavior and no one else's? Women can lie. That does happen. And a woman with a history of behaving
in uncivilized ways may be even more likely to lie. So are the women lying in this case?
That's always a possibility, something you have to look into and think about. So to answer that
question, let's start with the accusations one by one. First, it's important to point out that Brand
was actually acquitted of several of the charges against him. In particular, a woman claimed that
Brand raped her in a hotel room during a labor party conference in 1999 after meeting at a cabaret show.
Her identity remains hidden from the public. There's no evidence to substantiate her claim
whatsoever, aside from a photograph that proves they met, which obviously doesn't prove anything
about the crime. And again, this was more than 25 years ago. Brand says it was consensual. She
says it wasn't. And that was it. And the jury found that there was not evidence beyond a
reasonable doubt. So he was acquitted. It's absurd the prosecution even attempted to charge
the case. And the fact that they did bring that case by itself should make
you wonder about the strength of the other charges. Speaking of patterns of behavior,
we already know they brought charges on cases where there's zero evidence of any kind,
which tells you they're just throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks.
Which, by the way, you don't do when you have one good solid case with real evidence. You
don't need to pile on a bunch of other cases where there's no evidence at all.
Next, the jury acquitted Brand of attempted indecent assault in 2001, where he allegedly dragged
a woman towards the bathroom at MTV's London office and attempted to sexually assault her.
The woman testified that Brand wanted to use the bathroom. And when she showed him where it was,
he turned aggressive. The whole incident allegedly lasted 20 seconds. Quote,
this person went from someone jovial and friendly to suddenly turning into this wild-eyed maniac
trying to pull me into the toilet. His demeanor changed. He grabbed my forearm and he was leaning
into the door. It was quite forceful. The grip, it took me unawares. I wasn't expecting that.
Now, the problem is that the jury didn't know what was going on. They didn't know what was going on.
The woman didn't report this incident at the time. There's no evidence to support her claim.
You know, he didn't actually do anything sexual aside from supposedly grabbing her arm.
And she only made the accusations after watching a 2023 documentary accusing Brand of sexual
misconduct. So with the benefit of about 22 years of hindsight and a documentary, she finally
understood what had happened. After watching that documentary, she testified, quote, it brought
everything back to normal. And she said, well, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't
know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't
I thought I'd managed to get away. It could have been very different. I thought it was the right
thing to come forward. Again, this is total nonsense that should not have been prosecuted
in the first place. And then there was an allegation from the summer of 2004, which is
more serious and also more bizarre. As the story goes, Brand was at a party at a bar in Soho.
He was introduced to a young woman who had been drinking heavily, who worked at MTV.
Without warning, he allegedly lunged forward and squeezed her breasts. And the woman put
it, as she put it, Brand, quote, literally just grabbed my boobs with a weird, maniacal
grin on his face. And then maybe you're noticing a pattern in these accusations. Brand allegedly
pulled her towards the toilets. All of this happened in a crowded bar and somehow no one
noticed or cared. And then in the privacy of the bathroom, Brand supposedly attempted
to get her to perform oral sex on him using force. And then she leaves the bar in Brand's
activity. Within hours, the woman tells a friend and a producer that Brand had attempted to sexually
assault her and not that he had raped her. Then over the years, her story changed in conversations
with various acquaintances, and she began to become more certain that he had actually raped
her. And after the documentary aired in 2023, she finally filed a police report nearly two
decades after the fact. First time a report was filed. Now, what's amazing about this allegation
is that the jury rejected the rape allegation because according to her own contemporaneous
statements, she was not raped. She never even mentioned it for years. And on top of that,
there was, of course, no physical evidence whatsoever. Nevertheless, the jury still
convicted Brand for sexual assault for supposedly grabbing the woman's breasts in the bar without
her consent. So they reject her claims that he raped her in the bathroom, but they believe her claim that he
grabbed her breasts without consent. This is totally incoherent. Again, going back to patterns
of behavior, you're saying she lied about the one thing, but you believe she didn't lie about the
other? That makes no sense, especially when you're. So a woman, according to you, the jury,
lied about one thing, didn't lie about the other. And there's not even reasonable doubt about the
other thing you didn't think she lied about? I mean, the fact that she lied about the second thing
does not at least create. Some doubt that a reasonable person might have about whether she was telling the truth about
the whole story? So it doesn't make any sense, but that's what they settled on.
You know, there's a fairly easy way to determine whether a product is actually popular at the
Daily Wire offices. If you put it in the office kitchen and see how long it survives. Well,
balance of nature has been failing this test spectacularly, or I guess, no, passing it.
Anyway, the guiltless snacks. Disappear. People keep the products at their desks and the whole health system has become one of those
things you see around the office because people genuinely use it and like it. You go to the area
where the editors sit and these red and green bottles are everywhere. And frankly, that makes
sense. Our days move quickly. Yours probably do also. Nobody needs another complicated routine
before the morning commute, school drop off, first meeting or first news alert of the day. Balance of
nature keeps it simple. Their whole health system brings together 47 ingredients of real whole
fruits, vegetables,
spices and fibers in one straightforward routine. Three food side capsules, three veggies, capsules,
and two scoops of fiber and spice. It's easy to incorporate into the day and easy to keep doing
when the schedule gets hectic. And if you've been hearing us talk about balance of nature on
the show, but haven't tried it yet, the new offer makes it a pretty, pretty, pretty good time. Go to
balanceofnature.com and subscribe to the whole health system. Use promo code WALSH for 35% off
your first subscription order. That's 35% off.
balanceofnature.com with code WALSH.
The holidays are a time to show how much you care about your family by showering them with gifts.
Some of those things will be useful. Others will be forgotten in a closet by February.
But one of the most important things you can provide your family cannot be wrapped and placed under a tree.
It's the assurance that they would remain financially protected if something were to happen to you.
Life insurance is not the most cheerful holiday subject. Neither is replacing the furnace.
Responsible adults occasionally have to think about things that aren't cheerful.
And PolicyGenius makes finding the right coverage straightforward.
It's a free online marketplace where you can compare quotes from some of America's top insurers side by side.
Their licensed team can answer your questions, handle paperwork, and advocate for you throughout the process.
Make a smart move today to help protect their tomorrow.
With PolicyGenius, you can see if you can find 20-year life insurance policies starting at just $276 a year for a million dollars in coverage.
Head to PolicyGenius.com slash Walsh to compare quotes now.
That's PolicyGenius.com slash Walsh.
Ash Walsh. Nevermind the fact that the prosecution had precisely zero eyewitnesses to this alleged
sexual assault, which is pretty odd since they're claiming it happened in the middle of a packed bar
in Soho. Instead, to the extent the prosecution had corroborating witnesses at all, it was people
the woman contacted after she left the bar. Maybe you're seeing the problem here, right?
If I claim something bad happened to me, and then I call 10 people and say something bad happened to
me, tell them about it. Those 10 calls are not additional evidence to support my claim. Now,
the fact that I made a call at all right after it allegedly happened may amount to weak
circumstantial evidence of some kind. It proves at least that I didn't make it up years after the
fact, right? So it's something. But it certainly doesn't qualify as definitively,
because it doesn't prove that I didn't make it up immediately after the fact. I told someone right
after, so that means I didn't make it up 20 years later, but I could have still made it up then.
But at any rate, if the fact that I made a call at all amounts to arguably weak circumstantial
evidence, not enough to convict anyone of anything, I cannot strengthen the evidence
by making 20 additional calls. It really doesn't matter how many calls I make. 20 witnesses,
may amount to 20 times the evidence of one witness, but 20 people who heard me recount my
version of events does not amount to 20 times the evidence of one person hearing me recount it.
And things get worse when you look at what this accuser actually told her friends after leaving
the bar. Again, she later changed her story about being raped. First, she said Brand had merely
groped her before changing her story to rape. But even the groping allegation is suspect,
because she wasn't very specific when she talked to her friends. This is from Scott,
Sky News, recapping witness statements or alleged witness statements relating to this incident.
Quote, a man who also went to the 2004 party at the Soho bar says he recalled Brand exiting the
toilet followed by a woman who could not remember her demeanor. He said hello to Brand, who looked
straight through him with a blank expression, the witness said in a statement. The second statement
came from a witness who said the third accuser called him distressed on the night of the alleged
rape. He recalled seeing red and telling the accuser to go to the police, but she didn't want
to at the time.
In a third statement, the man who held the 2004 Soho bar party described a conversation he had
with the complainant in the week after the alleged rape, during which she told him Brand had got
pushy and aggressive towards her. The last statement of the day was from another friend
of the alleged victim who had called her on the phone saying Brand had attacked her.
So we have claims that Brand was pushy and aggressive, even that he attacked her,
but nothing specific about what he actually did. And that didn't come until nearly two decades
later.
After a documentary, a collaboration between Channel 4 and Times, aired on television.
Okay, just as a general rule, you're bringing up allegations and claims of a crime 20 years later,
because you saw a documentary that inspired you. Already, at the very least, your allegations are
extremely suspect. And you better have very, very, very good evidence. No reasonable person could look
at this case and say, oh, this is a crime. And if you're not, then you're not. So this is another theme of these allegations. They all came out after this 2023 Channel 4
documentary, which set the narrative. And that includes the most serious charge Brand was
convicted of, which allegedly took place in 2009 at Brand's house. Now, before we go into that
allegation, here's a clip of this 2023 documentary. I've referenced it a few times. So I want to give
you a sense of what it actually looked like.
And so here it is. Watch.
I met up with him. We walked through the door. And then again, things got very intense, very,
very quickly. He was like, so how many people have you had sex with? And I said, no one. Like,
I've never had sex with anyone. And he got an erection straight away. And he was like,
oh, my God. He's like, my baby, my baby. And picked me up and cradled me in his arm.
I was like a child. I was stroking my hair. He's like, you're like my little dolly.
Russell engaged in the behaviors of a groomer. Looking back on it, I didn't even know what that
was then or what that looked like. He would try to drive a wedge between me and my parents,
taught me to lie to them.
Alice recalls how Brand was treated. She said, I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't
and made her feel after she'd had sex with him for the first time.
When everything was over, one of his friends came round to the house.
They both drove me to the tube station.
I felt like a little kid being dropped off somewhere.
He reached his hand behind the car seat
and was holding my hand behind the seat like my mom does when she's in the car.
And it made me feel like, yeah, I felt very small.
I felt like a little kid.
Okay, so this is an anonymous woman using the name Alice
who claims that Brand groomed her and sexually assaulted her when she was a minor.
Obviously a very serious allegation.
Russell Brand was not charged for any of that.
There's no evidence to support it,
so the prosecutors couldn't bring it to trial at all.
And given the quality of the cases they did bring to trial,
that's saying something.
Nevertheless, inspired by this ridiculous documentary,
a flood of additional accusers surfaced.
And here's how the New York Times describes the most serious case
where Brand was convicted of rape.
Quote,
The rape charge he was convicted of concerned an encounter in 2009.
The woman in question told the jury that she had gone to Mr. Brand's house
for consensual vaginal sex,
but that Mr. Brand had at one point removed his condom
and had anal sex with her without her consent,
ignoring her pleas to stop and leaving her bleeding.
So now we're re-litigating the precise sex acts that this woman consented to
versus didn't 17 years after the fact.
We're trying to determine exactly how these two people were communicating
in this particular moment 17 years ago.
So this was a, even according to the woman,
a consensual sexual encounter that led to a specific sexual act
that she says she did not consent to,
even though she consented to it.
She consented to the overall encounter.
And again, here we are nearly two decades after the fact.
There's just no possible way to litigate this.
There's no way at all to prove in a manner even approaching beyond a reasonable doubt
that one particular sex act between two people
who consented to engaging in sex to begin with was non-consensual.
Now, it's not to say that the thing she's describing couldn't have happened.
It's to say that you need to prove
to reasonable doubt, and there's no way you could do that.
And they didn't in this case.
I mean, if there is any way to prove it, they didn't do it.
Not even close.
And once again, shockingly enough,
there are many reasons to believe that she's not telling the truth.
Every detail that's been omitted by the New York Times is actually highly relevant.
So first of all, this woman first met Brand at a comedy show.
And even though she had a boyfriend at the time,
she voluntarily went backstage with him and engaged in a threesome.
Which, by her own admission, involved oral contact with Brand's backside.
So, within minutes of meeting this comedian,
her face is in an unspeakable place.
As I warned you, this case would require us to talk about some really gross things.
And here we are.
Now, the fact that she would do this with a man she doesn't know
I mean, a man she doesn't know
has only just met
and she's immediately doing that.
That does not in itself prove that her later accusations are false,
but they do mean that she is every bit the sexual degenerate that Brand is.
And that fact does make her a less reliable narrator.
It just simply does.
Okay, and so then when you come. Many years after the fact, and make some claim,
and the only evidence is what you're saying,
well, we're going to look at that and go,
well. You're not the most credible narrator on this thing, are you?
And she enjoyed this experience somehow so much that she later went to Brand's house
for the express purpose of engaging in consensual sex.
She said she was excited and flattered by his messages to her.
Clearly, she wanted to keep the relationship going.
But we have no idea what happened once she got to Brand's house.
This happened so long ago that text messages and phone calls aren't available anymore.
The only evidence is that after the fact, she supposedly told several people,
including her parents, that she had been assaulted.
And for example, her father says that she told him that, quote,
they were having sex.
She asked him to stop.
She kept saying she had been assaulted.
The father told the court in a statement, quote,
I turned to her in the car and asked if she asked him to stop.
And she said no several times.
I said, you've been raped.
That's rape.
So to recap,
she tells her father what allegedly happened.
He then informs her that she was raped.
Another friend gave similar testimony.
He said, quote,
I told her it wasn't right and it was rape.
So in other words, all these people who were not there, obviously,
are not witnesses,
are now telling this woman that she was raped
based on her description of events after the fact.
So she didn't use that word, but other people did.
One friend testified, quote,
things took a sudden turn when he turned her over.
She said that she thought or assumed
they would go into doggy style.
He then proceeded to enter her anally from behind.
This was how the whole trial was conducted.
Witnesses constantly delivered hearsay testimony
about what this woman allegedly told them 17 years ago
about a sexual encounter that had happened
just between the two of them that nobody else was there for.
This allegedly happened in 2009,
but she never went to the police.
Instead, she went to a clinic mainly to get checked for STDs.
So there was no rape kit or allegation of rape.
Quote,
The court heard that the accuser was concerned
that she could have contracted a blood-borne virus from Brand
and that she attended a sexual health clinic to have tests.
A nurse at the clinic gave a written statement,
which was read out in court by a prosecution lawyer.
The witness said the accuser had told her
that Brand had anal sex without a condom
and she didn't want that and didn't consent to it.
Now, this is true.
You have to wonder why the police were not informed right away.
You know, it sounds a lot like the nurse at the time
was under the impression that a crime had occurred
or had under the impression that no crime had occurred,
which is why the police were not involved.
And why might that be?
Is it possible she was under the impression
that the victim had consented to this whole encounter
and was more upset about the condom issue?
Is it possible the nurse believed that the accuser
may have regretted a consensual encounter?
These are not rhetorical questions.
I mean, why did everyone stay quiet?
Why did everyone stay quiet about this until 2023
when the police report was finally filed?
This is very similar not only to the Cornell 7 case,
but also to the case out of Canada
where those hockey players had their lives destroyed.
Just like in those cases,
as uncomfortable as it may be to admit,
it's entirely possible, based on the evidence we have,
that this woman felt disgusted by her own behavior
and how Russell Brand was discarding her
or treating her like an animal, as she put it,
and to cope with those things.
With those feelings, it's possible she told her friends
that she was a victim as a way of getting sympathy
after an uncomfortable but not illegal sexual encounter.
This would also be consistent with the fact
that she didn't go to the police.
She recognized at some level
that she voluntarily went to his house,
even though she had a boyfriend.
She voluntarily engaged in degenerate,
repulsive sexual conduct.
And she suspected that, based on her pattern of behavior,
nobody would believe her story.
It's a totally plausible version of events.
Now, she could also be telling the truth.
Can't rule that out.
But again, in a court of law,
she could be telling the truth
is not even close to enough to convict.
If there is a totally plausible alternative scenario
that the prosecution was not able to rule out
with any degree of certainty,
then you cannot convict.
By definition.
And if a jury does convict anyway,
the judge should throw it out.
It's not a valid conviction.
A jury is not allowed to just dispense with,
you know, reasonable doubt as the standard.
And if they do, you can throw the conviction out.
Now, the closest the prosecution got to forensic evidence
with respect to this charge was the fact
that Brandt had apparently labeled this woman in his phone.
His phone contacts with a code indicating
that she was a memorable experience.
A woman who was open to anal play
and also a casual sexual contact.
That doesn't really tell us anything one way or another,
at least in terms of crimes.
If anything, it suggests that she was
receptive to all this and actually gets even worse.
As Irish News reports,
when the accuser was thinking about telling her story
to a journalist,
she wrote in an exchange on Facebook the following.
This is what she said.
In Facebook message.
I'm not sure my story has much in it.
I feel I was an idiot.
I was young and stupid.
And then she went on to say that she is
probably as much to blame.
So that was what this accuser was saying
about her own story as recently as a few years ago.
By her own version of events until it changed,
there was no crime committed
and she was as much to blame as he was.
If that doesn't at least,
amount to reasonable doubt,
then the term reasonable doubt has no meaning.
By the way, in case you're confused,
there is another allegation,
which was not charged as a crime involving a woman
who says Brand raped her in Los Angeles in 2012.
This allegation also didn't come out
until the 2023 documentary,
but this allegation does have some actual evidence.
So for one thing,
the accuser did go to a rape treatment center
shortly afterwards.
And secondly, we have these text messages.
Brand says,
I'm sorry, that was crazy and selfish.
I hope that you can forgive me.
I know that you're a lovely person.
X.
And later that morning,
the woman writes back saying,
Brand is scary and dangerous and adds,
quote,
when a girl says no, it means no.
Do I have to go and get myself tested?
Last time you asked me condom or no condom,
when I say condom,
that doesn't mean it's optional.
Brand then replies,
I'm very sorry.
You don't need to get tested.
Not my original idea,
which was more sex.
I'm embarrassed by my behavior.
Now, the allegation says,
the irony is that this is the best evidence
that's ever been produced against Russell Brand.
It has nothing to do with the charges
he was just convicted of.
He has not been charged in that case.
Now, you can make the argument
that Brand is apologizing
for violating the woman's consent,
which would obviously be rape.
He says, I'm sorry, and that was crazy.
And she replies by calling him scary
and saying, no means no.
Now, on the other hand,
in that exact same exchange,
she's upset that he didn't use a condom.
So,
it's also fair to read the conversation
as Brand apologizing for not respecting
her wishes about the condom.
That's probably why, again,
she didn't go to the police
and why this was never charged as a crime.
And the statute of limitations has expired on this,
so it can never be charged.
At least under California law at the time,
if two people are having consensual sex
and one person disregards the condom preference
of another person,
it's not necessarily rape
because rape requires using force or threats
or duress or incapacitation, etc.
None of that seems to apply here
based on the text messages.
But this is all irrelevant to the alleged crimes
that just sent him to prison for a decade.
Now, there's two other convictions to talk about,
one of which relates to an alleged episode
where Brand, quote,
had put his head in a woman's groin area
after insisting on a massage.
This allegedly happened in 2009.
And once again,
the allegation only surfaced with the documentary
and there's no forensic evidence to support it.
But the jury may have found it more credible
because the woman apparently made a formal report
to her employer at the time about the incident
with her version of events.
Brand was also, quote,
found guilty of sexually assaulting a woman found,
a second woman at a radio station in 2004, 2005
after the woman said Brand had kissed her
and groped her while people watched.
Now, this allegation, like all others,
was only brought to the police after, again,
the documentary.
And once again, there's no contemporaneous evidence,
forensic or otherwise.
Even though this supposedly happened
with other people watching,
there was no publicly reported evidence
of the testimony I could find
in which they corroborated her account.
Nevertheless, the jury apparently thought
that Russell Brand had decided to sexually assault someone
in full view of several witnesses.
And that's how desperate he supposedly was,
even though women were throwing themselves at him constantly.
Christmas shopping gets harder every year.
Trying to predict exactly where each family member is in life
in order to find the right gift for them
is not an easy task.
Personally, I think the best gifts
are the ones that are the most important.
They're the ones that they want
but might not splurge on themselves.
I mean, I don't buy the gifts in my house.
My wife does all of it,
so actually Christmas shopping is really easy for me.
I don't do anything.
But still, Bowling Branch is worth considering.
I'm going to tell my wife all about it.
I've talked about their bedding before
and the quality really is excellent.
Their signature sheets are made from 100% organic cotton
and they're incredibly soft and breathable.
I've had them for years and never looked back.
They also make beautiful throw blankets,
robes, and comforters that make great gifts,
especially this time of year.
And frankly, a really nice blanket.
like it seems like a much better gift than another gadget no
what he needs. Right now, you can get early access to Bull & Branch's best sale of the year. Be the
first to shop 25% off plus free shipping and extended returns at bullandbranch.com slash
Walsh with code Walsh. That's Bull & Branch, B-O-L-L-A-N-D, branch.com slash Walsh. Code Walsh
for early access to 25% off. Exclusions apply. What if you could delay your next two mortgage
payments? Imagine putting those two payments in your pocket and finally getting a little
breathing room ahead of the holidays. Well, it's possible when you call American Financing Today.
If you're feeling stretched by everyday expenses, groceries, gas, bills piling up,
you're not alone. Most Americans are putting those expenses on credit cards and credit card
rates are insane in the 20s or even 30s in some cases. American Financing can show you
how to use your home equity to pay off that debt. Their salary-based mortgage consultants
are helping homeowners just like you restructure their loans and save money every month. There are
no upfront fees to find out how much you could save. Their customers are saving an average,
of $800 a month. It's like a $10,000 raise without having to change jobs to get it.
Call today, American Financing, 866-569-4711. That's 866-569-4711 or visit
americanfinancing.net slash Walsh. NMLS pound 182334, nmlsconsumeraccess.org. Visit
americanfinancing.net slash Walsh or call 866-569-4711. Average savings based on borrowers
who save.
Over $199.99. But that's the claim. Now, what's obviously going on here is that
the 2023 documentary was a political hit job that led swarms of women to
come forward with these stories and potentially invent memories that simply didn't happen,
which is a common phenomenon, by the way. It's happened many times throughout history. It's not
that unusual. There was something called the McMartin preschool panic in the 80s when a mother
accused a California preschool employee of molestation. And after that allegation,
children came forward with all kinds of insane claims about underground tunnels and hot air
balloons and occult rituals and so on. Nobody was ever convicted of anything. The evidence was all
compromised. Then there was the satanic panic on top of that. People are very impressionable,
even as adults. And if you tell women that a famous man is a serial abuser who's endangered
everybody he meets, then inevitably some of these women will come forward and claim the man abused
them. And if you tell women that a famous man is a serial abuser who's endangered everybody he meets,
in some way, even if it didn't happen. Some will do it for attention. Some will do it because their
memory is genuinely capable of changing in order to fit a narrative. 17 years is a very long time.
People can fill in the blanks with scandalous details that didn't happen. And make no mistake
about it, that documentary was only released because Russell Brand betrayed the left.
Whether you think it was guilty or not, this part is certainly true.
That if Russell Brand had remained a leftist and had spent the early 2020s attacking Trump or
whatever, none of this would have happened. None of it. But that was the whole purpose of
the documentary, to kickstart a moral panic. This is from The Guardian in 2014 in their article
labeling Russell Brand a hero of 2014. Quote, Brand's openness about his flaws,
make him a good leader, and allows those who admire him to be good followers. He's the best
thing that has happened to the left in years. A year earlier, The New Statesman, another left-wing
publication, named Brand as a guest editor. They were building him up as a serious, revolutionary
thinker on the left. The issue of the magazine included contributions from Naomi Klein,
Noam Chomsky, other high-profile figures. But Russell Brand was leading the charge. He was the
and then he made the mistake of thinking for himself once the COVID lockdowns began.
And in the left's mind, that's when he had to go. And these are lockdowns that everybody,
even the public health establishment at places like Johns Hopkins, now admits were a complete
waste of time. They destroyed lives. They destroyed the economy for no reason.
In 2020, Russell Brand was one of the few people who was saying that out loud. And
he was also pointing out how COVID was being used to create a surveillance
state. He was correct about all that. But this is what led to the eventual hit job.
Stuff like this from 2020. Watch. The pandemic has taken surveillance of
workers to the next level. We are being observed while we work more than ever,
even though people working from home has achieved more efficacy and better results.
Is the pandemic being used as a tool to create a surveillance state?
Now, by 2021, Brand was routinely publishing videos about the worst abuses of power during
the lockdowns. And you have to keep in mind, for Europeans, this was stuff you were simply
not allowed to say out loud. They don't have a First Amendment over there. They throw people
in prison for jokes. Criticizing the lockdowns was blasphemy. The left in this country didn't
like it if you did that. But for them, it's a whole other, it was heresy.
And so they simply couldn't let it stand. And Russell Brand knew that.
And he did his show anyway. And an audience of millions of people watched these episodes. Watch.
You won't be going nowhere if you're in Australia, though. You can't move a muscle. Let's have a look.
Stav Ruler pabst and Max Blumenfall in the gray zone, right? Those statewide lockdowns have eased
in Australia. The country is constructing internment camps for those who test positive
for COVID, along with their COVID negative close contacts. Harley Hodgson, an Australian held for
14 days in one such camp, despite repeatedly testing negative for COVID, said of her experience,
you feel like you're in prison. You feel like you've done something wrong. It's inhumane what
they're doing. I suppose that the argument is that the coronavirus is so lethal, so deadly,
any measures necessary in order to protect human life must be taken.
Some people would contest that that brings to the forefront a lot of questions about liberty,
the standard of life, potential hypocrisy in other areas. Are we always
concerned about preserving and respecting human life? And what about the qualitative
component of life? I don't know. These are questions for all of us to consider.
Now, these videos drove the left-wing establishment insane. In 2022, The Independent wrote,
quote, how did Russell Brand go from stand-up stardom to peddling YouTube conspiracy theories
with a series of alarmist videos tackling issues like COVID and the Russian-Ukrainian war?
The comedian has reinvented himself as a popular online,
current affairs guru. When did Russell Brand decide comedy wasn't enough for him?
He couldn't believe he wasn't staying in his lane. And in fact, by 2022, he was starting to openly
embrace Fox News and right-wing populism. And the elites in Europe were not going to tolerate that.
So in late 2023, The Times, The Sunday Times, and Channel 4 released that documentary based
on anonymous and unsubstantiated accusations that had been circulating for years.
And the floodgates opened. Now, to be clear about this, I'm not saying Russell Brand was a good
guy. I'm not saying he never made mistakes. I am saying that this trial was a political hit.
That is inarguable. And the sentencing is a travesty of justice on top of that.
And here's how bad this is. Even if they had proved their case beyond a reasonable doubt,
which they didn't, which is the thing that makes this a travesty of justice. But even if they had,
the senior sentence, in the UK anyway, would still be clearly politically motivated.
Now, if they had, he would deserve to go to prison if they had proven him behind a reasonable doubt,
which they didn't. But if you look at how other sexual assault cases have been charged and
sentenced in that country, you see a very interesting contrast. Muslims have been running
rape houses and organized rape gangs.
Most of them have not received anywhere near 10 years in prison. And this is a documented fact.
For example, a Muslim named Mohammed Ali Saltane, 26 years old, was convicted for, quote,
having sex with two teenage girls, one of whom was 13 years old. His sentence, seven years.
Less than Russell Brand. Meanwhile, Mohammed Yunus, age 61, quote, allowed his flat to be used as a brothel by allowing
a man to have sex with a girl who was being controlled as a prostitute. His sentence,
less than three years. Tanvir Ahmed, 40, was convicted of, quote, controlling a child
prostitute. He also received less than six years in prison. Then there was, quote, there was a
Mohammed Islam Chowdhury, 54, who was convicted of, quote, paying for sex with a Telford school
girl. His sentence, two years and six months. In fact, you can find killers, people who have in
fact, intentionally murdered other humans who have received less than 10 years in prison.
Consider the case of this 28-year-old individual who goes by the name Katie Yaumans.
Now, Yaumans, who claims to be a woman, although it's impossible to tell with how the media reports
these stories now, so I don't know, but admitted stabbing a man to death during a domestic
disturbance. There was one stab wound in the upper chest. He was left to die in a hallway.
Yamans didn't call for help.
sentence five years and three months. That's it. The judge said that Yalman's had lost control.
So what are you going to do? Call it manslaughter, let her out or him or whatever in five years.
Now, meanwhile, Russell Brand didn't do anything remotely like that.
He didn't sexually abuse children. He didn't murder anyone in cold blood,
but he gets double the sentence. Why? Why would you even double the sentence of all those
Muslim child rapists that we just listed off? And there's a bunch of others that we could name too.
Why would you do that? There's only one reason is that he made the mistake of challenging the
communists who run the British government. That was his real crime. And every fair-minded person
knows that. No one seriously believes that even if Russell Brand is guilty of everything they
accuse him of, that he somehow deserves double the punishment of child rapists and murderers.
It's completely insane. It's indefensible. And this is what happens when you step out of line.
They don't want anyone questioning their authority to impose nationwide lockdowns and ban all civil
liberties because they intend to do it again. And Russell Brand is going to prison for a decade as a
message to every other commentator in Britain. The point of this prosecution was to shut down
dissent and it worked. Certainly in Russell Brand's case, it worked.
But we can't ignore the fact that Russell Brand did give these people more than enough ammunition
to take him down. Doesn't change the fact that it was a travesty of justice, but this is something
that for the men in the audience, if nothing else, this case provides a really good practical reason,
even beyond the moral reasons, to not be a sexual degenerate. You put yourself in a position
to be destroyed. Even years down the line. This applies to the Cornell guys too, who I think are innocent,
but they also had a gross orgy in a frat house, which set them up for the inevitabilities that
followed. And you especially cannot live that way for years and then turn around and try to be a
famous right-wing commentator. The system won't allow that. It will not let you leave behind a
life of sexual and moral chaos. And become a public critic of the same godless hedonistic culture you had spent years wallowing
in. Now, I'm not saying that a man can't repent and be redeemed and change. Of course he can.
God, after all, is merciful. But this world, the one we're all living in, is not.
So when you behave as Russell Brand did for as long as he did,
you've already written the check. And as his prosecution demonstrates,
it could take months, or it could take years, or it could even take decades.
But it's only a matter of time before they cash it.
Tomorrow, Confession premieres on Daily Wire at 7 p.m. Eastern. I'm excited for this one. You're
going to want to see it. And it is the best scripted film that Daily Wire has ever made,
I think by a long shot. You're not going to want to miss the pre-show with interviews from the cast
and Ben Shapiro, of course, wrote the movie. That happens tomorrow. Make sure you're there for it.
And I'll talk to you then. Talk to you tomorrow. Godspeed.
And they brought me here, and they tell me nothing. What have I done?
Article 58, counter-revolutionary activity.
That is all I know. They have to deal with so many enemies of the state,
all of whom claim their innocence, who protest, who cry.
There are no answers here, other than the ones they put in your mouth.
You'll break.
Today is your opportunity to demonstrate your loyalty to the people.
I would like to know why I'm here.
Of course.
But you already know, don't you?
You must believe in something greater than the party.
You will remember your duty.
I told you I know nothing.
And you growl like a feral animal.
And you stink of failure.
You want me to lie.
Still a drunk.
Damn you!
They all break.
Maybe.
Big banks don't want to fund your business, but Cardiff does.
My name's William Stern.
In 2004, I founded Cardiff.
To make funding faster and easier for small businesses.
In less than five minutes, your business could qualify for up to $500,000 deposited same day.
And there's zero impact to your personal credit.
Get started by going to cardiff.co slash dailywire.
Again, that's cardiff.co slash dailywire.
Cardiff. Borrow better.
Vanduul is now available everywhere in the U.S.
I'm in everywhere.
Man, I've been everywhere, man.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are.
Including these places.
Georgia, Houston, Cleveland, Minnesota, Buffalo, Lincoln, Chi-Town, Arizona, Tampa.
Make this your most rewarding season ever with Vanduul.
Age and location restrictions apply.
Product availability varies by market.
See vanduul.com for eligibility.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The prosecution of Russell Brand for sexual assault allegations is widely seen as a politically motivated campaign, not a fair trial, with the case being initiated after his criticism of left-wing policies during the pandemic.
The alleged incidents, including claims of rape and sexual assault, date back over two decades and were largely revealed only after a 2023 documentary, raising serious doubts about their reliability and timeliness.
There is no independent forensic or eyewitness evidence to support the core allegations, and many claims were made years later, with no prior reporting or police involvement.
A key flaw in the prosecution is the lack of credible evidence, especially given that the accusers’ narratives changed significantly over time and some admitted to being emotionally affected or embarrassed by their own behavior.
The trial and sentencing contrast sharply with other serious crimes—such as child sexual abuse by Muslim individuals or murder—where offenders received significantly lighter sentences, suggesting political bias.
The documentary that exposed the allegations was explicitly tied to Brand’s shift from left-wing to conservative views, indicating a deliberate effort to discredit him.
The case highlights systemic issues in sexual assault trials, including the lack of victim anonymity, reliance on hearsay, and the suppression of evidence that could exonerate the accused.
The case underscores how political agendas can manipulate social narratives, leading to false accusations and wrongful convictions, especially when victims are not independently verified.
Summary:
The transcript critiques the prosecution of Russell Brand for sexual assault allegations as a politically driven campaign rather than a legitimate legal inquiry. The case, which led to a 10-year prison sentence, emerged after a 2023 documentary that targeted Brand for his criticism of pandemic-era lockdowns and left-wing policies. Key allegations span over two decades, with most first surfacing after the documentary, and lack credible forensic or eyewitness evidence.
Many accusers changed their stories, and some admitted to being emotionally affected or embarrassed by their own behavior. The prosecution failed to meet the legal standard of "beyond a reasonable doubt," especially given the absence of contemporaneous evidence or police reports. Critics point out that the case is inconsistent with how other serious crimes—such as child sexual abuse or murder—are prosecuted, with offenders receiving far lighter sentences.
This suggests systemic bias, particularly against those who challenge the political status quo. The narrative also highlights broader issues in sexual assault trials, including reliance on hearsay, lack of victim anonymity, and the difficulty of verifying claims decades later. Ultimately, the case is presented not as a fair legal outcome, but as a political hit job that exemplifies how moral panics and media narratives can fuel wrongful convictions.
The transcript also links these issues to broader themes of power, accountability, and the dangers of unchecked political retaliation.
FAQs
The documentary 'Confession' explores the real-world consequences of political dissent and state repression, using a fictional narrative to highlight themes of loyalty, betrayal, and political persecution.
The trial was criticized for lacking evidence, relying on allegations made years after the events, and being politically motivated to silence a critic of the establishment's policies during the pandemic.
The allegations emerged only after a 2023 documentary, were not supported by forensic evidence, and included inconsistent or changed stories, with no contemporaneous witnesses or physical proof.
The media, especially in politically driven narratives, can create a moral panic that leads to women coming forward with unverified or fabricated claims, often without independent evidence.
Aura is a security service that alerts users when their personal information appears in a data breach, then automatically locks their credit and offers 24/7 U.S.-based fraud support.
Both cases involve allegations that surfaced after a documentary, lack of corroborating evidence, and a pattern of women changing their stories over time, raising concerns about credibility and fairness.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.