Ep. 1856 - DEEP DIVE: How "Civil Asset Forfeiture" Is Robbing Americans Blind
41m 17s
An air taxi pilot, Kenneth Jupy, was wrongfully convicted and forced to lose his $95,000 airplane after transporting a few beers to a dry village in Alaska. Though the beer never reached its destination and there was no evidence of criminal intent, the state seized his aircraft under a law that allows forfeiture of planes used in alcohol transport. The Alaska Supreme Court upheld this punishment, claiming the offense caused widespread societal harm due to alcohol consumption, despite a lack of connection to actual crime or harm. This decision is widely criticized as an unconstitutional overreach, violating the Eighth Amendment’s ban on excessive fines and cruel punishment. The case highlights systemic abuses in both criminal and civil asset forfeiture, where property is taken without due process or criminal conviction, often based on flimsy or speculative links to crime. Similar examples, such as DEA seizures of passengers’ bags without probable cause or hotel confiscations, show how these practices enable government overreach. The U.S. Supreme Court is now reviewing the case, offering a vital opportunity to rein in unconstitutional property seizures and restore balance to property rights under the Constitution. The case also reflects a broader cultural and legal shift where government authorities, instead of respecting individual liberty, use broad prohibitions to justify punitive measures. As public awareness grows, this case serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of protecting personal property from arbitrary government seizure—especially in the face of outdated and hysterical policies.
people keep saying that real communism has never been tried well it was uh moscow 1938 arrests in
the night confessions forced out of innocent people the daily wire's newest movie confession
is a story about just that it's out right now only on the daily wire
fan duel is now available everywhere in the u.s
so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places
make this your most rewarding season ever with fan duel age and location restrictions apply
product availability varies by market see fanduel.com for eligibility gambling problem
call 1-800-GAMBLER we've covered our fair share of extraordinary injustices on this show but aside
from the scenarios where people died horrible deaths nothing comes close to the sheer unbelievable
insanity of the absolute mockery of justice that we're about to talk about this is a story
that has obvious ramifications for your rights to own private property which is among the most
important rights that you have and because it's about to go to the supreme court uh you need to
know about it so we'll talk about today in april of 2012 an air force veteran named kenneth jupy
who was in his late 60s at the time was running an air taxi company in alaska called ken air llc
he made his living by transporting food and supplies to remote areas of the state as well
as by ferrying tourists
and other visitors around and on this particular occasion a woman chartered his services to fly
from fairbanks to beaver where she planned to celebrate her husband's birthday it's a journey
of a little over 100 miles typically takes around 45 minutes to complete because there's no road
linking fairbanks and beaver the only alternatives to flying are taking a boat via the yukon river
if it's summertime or dog sledding in the winter so the woman hired jupy to fly her to
beaver in a 1969 cessna 206 airplane which he owned so it was a routine job but everything
changed for kenneth when the alaska state troopers decided to search his plane before takeoff during
the inspection the authorities discovered to their horror that there were three cases of beer
72 beers in total in the plane's cargo that was a problem because beaver is a so-called dry village
meaning it's illegal to purchase
or even possess alcohol there and under alaska law if you attempt to transport alcohol into a dry
village like beaver you're committing a crime even if the alcohol never gets there and there
was some dispute about whether uh he was even aware of the fact that there was alcohol in his
plane according to the government's version of events one six-pack of beer was packed in a
grocery bag and would have been visible in plain view as jupy was loading the plane but according
to him the beers were packed and closed and he was allowed to fly the plane and he was allowed to
close boxes and he never opened the boxes at any point unfortunately though for him a state trooper
testified that he saw jupy opening and closing the boxes while loading the plane and therefore the jury convicted
him of the heinous crime of attempting to knowingly send transport or bring less than 12 gallons of
malt beverage into the village of beaver even though the beer never actually made it to beaver he was
charged with attempting to facilitate the transportation of the alcohol into this
sacred town and that's all it took as punishment he was sentenced to 180 days in jail with 177 days
suspended as well as a three thousand dollar fine with fifteen hundred dollars suspended he was also
put on probation for three years meanwhile though his company was hit with a ten thousand dollar fine
with eighty five hundred dollars suspended and you would think that that would be enough but it's
actually more than enough for the minor violation that was committed but the court didn't stop there
this is where the story takes a very sharp turn into the absurd jupy and his company were also ordered
to forfeit the airplane that was supposedly used in the commission of this offense that's because
in alaska there's a law that requires the forfeiture of any plane that's used in the
commission of this particular crime now for some reason boats get more protections than planes
under this law but not sure why that is but that's the way it is so his airplane which was valued at
over ninety five thousand dollars and which he depended on for his livelihood of course
was seized by the state
the police department wanted uh. a new aircraft i guess and so they just took his plane and meanwhile
jupy would have to find another airplane
his company only had one other plane so this was like stealing a man's horse in the desert you know it's
exactly the kind of cruel and unusual punishment the constitution prohibits
unfortunately in this case the plane was returned to him while the proceedings were playing out but that's not
always what happens in these kinds of cases
so here's jupy now eighty three years old explaining what happened in his
own words this is from the alaska news source listen
but the whole case will henge around a six pack of beer
uh. they
they uh. found me guilty
uh. and uh. uh. and finally fifteen hundred dollars and uh. three days in jail
and uh. so
and they took my airplane
so uh. a low misdemeanor
was
which gave a maximum ten thousand dollar fine
uh. you know it cost me a airplane worth almost at that time almost a hundred thousand
dollars
uh. so
but the whole thing hinges around that six pack of beer
it was my intention to fight this thing to the very end until there was no fight left
and uh. i was aware of the institute for justice
and i contacted them and they decided to take me and represent me in the
u_s_ supreme court
and uh. so
there
they're very good attorneys very good people
and uh. so that's where we are now
it's important to me uh. you know what
i just want to give up but i don't want to be falsely accused of something
and uh. there are a lot of inconsistencies in this thing uh. i'm not going to go into
that but
but uh. uh. and at this point
it's not only me but it's the whole country uh. you know there have been a lot of abuses
of this uh. excessive fines and forfeitures
over the years
and uh. and it's time to uh. you know kind of put a stop to it and
and so uh. uh. i'm not i'm not doing this for me personally now i'm doing it for the country actually
uh. is the way i feel
and uh. this will affect every law enforcement agency in the country
uh. they've abused that power
uh. for a lot of years now and it's just getting worse and worse
so if i can do that that's i'll have done my job
so as you heard he appealed all the way to the supreme court of alaska because we still
have
something called the constitution in this country last i checked and according to the
constitution quote
excessive bail shall not be required nor excessive fines imposed
nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted
this prohibition is also applied to the states under the fourteenth amendment and by any
rational definition
the seizure of ninety five thousand dollars worth of personal property
especially for a fake crime like this
is clearly an excessive fine it's a punitive measure to seize property
because of a criminal act
and as jupi just said the maximum fine under alaska law for transporting alcohol into a
dry town
like beaver is only ten thousand dollars
but in this case
the government was getting nearly ten times
what that fine was supposed to be
nevertheless in the single worst court decision uh. that
we've read recently uh. even worse than
many of the things contagi brown jackson has produced
the alaska supreme court
upheld the seizure of the airplane the court found that it was not an excessive
fine to steal this guy's ninety five thousand dollar airplane
because he transported a few beers that didn't even belong to him
this is one of those rulings
where even if you don't have a law degree and even if you can't read the
english language you know it's absurd on its face but we'll go through it anyway
because it's
truly a monument to human stupidity
and it marks an evolution in the government's ability to steal your
property at least for the moment
the alaska supreme court began by
talking about a nineteen ninety eight supreme court case where a guy tried to
fly out of l_a_x_ bound for cyprus
with three hundred and fifty thousand dollars in cash
and he didn't declare any of it even though he was supposed to fill out a form indicating
that he had more than ten thousand dollars
and as a result the government seized all of his money
even though they had no proof that any of it was involved in criminal activity
in fact they acknowledged that it wasn't
in a five to four ruling with the majority opinion written by clarence thomas the supreme
court gave the guy his money back
they determined that under the constitution it was a violation of the eighth amendment
to effectively fine someone three hundred and fifty thousand dollars
for such a minor offense it was a pretty straightforward ruling and that logic naturally
should apply to the case involving this alaska pilot
and his beer
it wasn't even his beer and the plane
and uh. the alaska supreme court though disagreed they said that he had
done something far more serious than the guy who boarded the plane from l_a_x_
this is a direct quote from the decision of the alaska supreme court quote
while jupy was uh. convicted of only one instance of alcohol import
importation unconnected to other criminal activity the nature and extent of the crime
is more serious
he knowingly transported a six pack of alcohol in plain view while acting in his professional
capacity as the operator of an air taxi company and the pilot of the airplane. This factor suggests
the forfeiture of his airplane is not grossly disproportional. So in the view of the Alaska
Supreme Court, if you're a bush pilot who's transporting some woman's groceries, and those
groceries include some beer, then you're engaging in downright dastardly behavior. You're basically
a hardened criminal, and they have every right to throw the book at you. Now, in their opinion,
it's much more serious to have beer in your plane's cargo than it is to leave LAX with $350,000
in undeclared cash. Now, of course, this is totally backwards. The guy who's flying to Cyprus
with 350 grand in cash, if we're being honest, is a much more likely candidate to be some kind
of drug dealer or some terrorist or criminal or something, as compared to the bush pilot with some
beer on board. That's not to say the government has any right to take the $350,000, but just as
matter of common sense, someone
transporting that kind of money could theoretically be engaged in some kind of hardcore criminal
activity, at least hypothetically. The beer, on the other hand, well, that's about as mundane as
it gets. There are people in Alaska who drink 18 beers a day and don't think anything of it,
especially if you live out in the middle of nowhere in Alaska. What else is there to do?
To be clear, there's no allegation that the pilot was drinking or anything like that. He's just
carrying the cargo. But to the Alaska Supreme Court, that's somehow a very big deal. And in
Alaska, on this court, make it clear that they're deferring to the elected officials in Alaska who
have apparently determined that alcohol consumption is a plague on the state. Again, this is from the
court's ruling. Quote, the nature and extent of harm caused by Jupy's illegal alcohol smuggling
is far greater. Alcohol abuse in rural Alaska leads to increased crime disorders such as
alcoholism, conditions such as fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, and death, imposing
substantial costs on public health and the administration of justice. Within this context,
it is clear that the illegal importation of even a six-pack of beer causes grave societal harm.
This factor strongly suggests that the forfeiture is not grossly disproportional.
Taking into consideration all the factors discussed above, we conclude that the forfeiture
of Jupy's airplane is not grossly disproportional to the gravity of his offense. It's a six-pack.
A six-pack arriving in a town is going to cause grave societal harm. Social order will
break down because of a six-pack of, you know, Heineken or something. I don't know what kind
of beer it was. So notice what's happening here. They're identifying all kinds of problems that
are caused by alcohol consumption in aggregate across the entire state, and they're acting like
this one guy is responsible for all of it. If that were the case, then, you know, maybe I could
see an argument for taking his plane. If he was single-handedly responsible for all the alcoholism
and fetal alcohol syndrome and DUIs and domestic abuse in the entire state,
then sure, take his plane. But in reality, he's not actually responsible for any of that.
This is no different from taking someone's car when they go five miles over the speed limit on
the grounds that 40,000 people die in car accidents every year. It's completely ridiculous. It's like
reverse collective punishment. They're going after one guy as if he somehow caused the actions of
millions of other people. That's not to downplay the idea that alcohol can cause problems, big
times. But in general, there's a genuine hysteria about alcohol that's taken hold in parts of this
country, which we've talked about before on the show. In the span of about five years,
the experts went from telling us that red wine will, you know, save our lives or at least make
us healthier, to telling us that a single drop of alcohol will increase our risk of cancer.
There's no safe amount. It's incoherent. And we also talked about the book, The Alcoholic
Republic and the central role that alcohol played in the colonization of America and the founding
of the United States. Simply a historical fact that when our country was doing well, people were
not deathly afraid of alcohol. So that's something for the town of Beaver to consider, I suppose.
In any event, whatever you think about the modern day prohibition that towns like Beaver have
enacted, there's no reason to destroy this pilot's livelihood over it. The logic on display here
contradicts many different cases from around the country, including Tim's versus Indiana,
which was decided just a few years ago. In that case, the state of Indiana,
tried to seize someone's $42,000 Land Rover SUV, saying it was used to transport heroin.
The guy purchased the car legally with funds that he acquired legitimately.
But ultimately, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled that it would be grossly excessive to seize the
car, even though it was used to transport heroin, since the car costs $42,000 and the maximum fine
under the law was just $10,000. But in Alaska, they're doing things very differently. And now
a group called the Institute for Justice is representing the pilot. Supreme Court has just
agreed to hear this. And they're going to do it. And they're going to
hear the case. The Institute for Justice, by the way, also says that it's in the process of
appealing a $437,000 fine the IRS imposed on a retired professor for failing to file a one-page
form informing the agency of his legal foreign bank account. So they're doing the Lord's work,
as far as I'm concerned. And with this case, they have a real opportunity to change the law
on these asset seizures. The government simply cannot be allowed to take your property
without any justification whatsoever.
That's what the government has been doing all over the country for a very long time.
As the pilot put it, quote, I'm thrilled that the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear this case
because this case isn't just about me or my airplane anymore. I'm in my 80s now. I've been
fighting this for over a decade because I see it as my duty to ensure that the Bill of Rights
actually means something in protecting against government overreach. So to be clear about this,
the case in Alaska is about criminal asset forfeiture, which is to say the government
taking your property after you've been convicted of a crime. And so the U.S. Supreme Court has
taken your property after you've been convicted of a crime. But the Supreme Court's ruling in
this case also has implications for civil asset forfeiture, which is a concept that maybe you've
heard about. John Oliver did a viral show about it a little over a decade ago. In civil asset
forfeiture, the government doesn't even need to secure a criminal conviction. In fact, it doesn't
even matter if you've done anything wrong at all. Instead, the government can sue your property
directly if there's reason to believe that it was involved in criminal activity. This is called an
in-rem action. Now, the burden of proof is that the government can sue your property directly if
in these civil cases in federal courts is called the preponderance of evidence. Sometimes the states
have established their own standards, but that's generally how it goes. And this means that the
government must demonstrate a 50% or greater likelihood, so let's call it 51%, that your
property is substantially connected with some criminal activity, meaning it was used to
facilitate that activity. So the normal standard of beyond a reasonable doubt, which applies
during criminal trials, is not relevant here. It's a very relaxed standard, and the government
takes advantage of it all the time. I tell my kids to finish what they start all the time. It's
basically my entire parenting philosophy if I had to boil it down. And I repeat it until they're sick
of hearing it. So I should probably mention that if there is a degree you started and you never
finished, Grand Canyon University offers more than 100 online undergraduate degrees, so you can begin
college or go back and finish on your own schedule. And these aren't empty promises about accessibility.
It's a school that combines career preparation with a Christian worldview, a free market, and open
discourse. GCU's accredited MBA program is 100% online, designed to shape leaders through servant
leadership. It's easy to say higher education is outdated, irrelevant, but at Grand Canyon
University, they don't settle for the status quo. They shatter it. GCU's accredited MBA program is
100% online and is designed to shape leaders through servant leadership. GCU can help you take your
passion and scale your business to serve your community. This is purpose-driven education. Take action. Find your
purpose. Grand Canyon University. Visit gcu.edu. The midterm elections are here, and if the DSA Democrats win,
they'll push a radical socialist agenda and drown President Trump in endless investigations. We've seen their playbook
before. They tried impeaching him. They tried putting him in prison. They tried everything. Don't let them win, because if we
don't let them win, we'll have to do everything our movement has fought for. We need you to vote early. You can bank your vote and fight back against the left's turnout machine. Go to GOPvotes.org right now. Find out when you can vote if you live in the critical Senate battleground states of Maine, Ohio, or Iowa. Early voting is already underway this week. Making your voice heard is easier than ever. You can get election reminders, look up your polling location, and pick a date to vote early. Go to GOPvotes.org today. Paid for by SLF PAC, not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. There was a case out of Michigan
where a woman lost her car because her husband hired a prostitute while he was driving it,
even though the woman had no idea he was doing that. There was another case out of Massachusetts
where the government tried to confiscate an entire hotel because some of the guests were selling drugs,
although that particular attempt failed because the hotel didn't really facilitate the crimes.
There was a famous case along these lines in 2008 called United States v. Approximately 64,695 Pounds of Shark Fins.
Yes, those were the two parties in the case.
So one party was the United States, and the other party was approximately 64,695 pounds of shark fins.
The case was based on a situation developed off the coast of Guatemala in 2002
when the Coast Guard stopped a U.S.-flagged vessel.
The Coast Guard found the shark fins on the ship, even though there were no shark carcasses to go along with the fins,
and it soon became clear the vessel was a shark.
was buying shark fins from various fishing vessels, presumably so that they could
use the fins to make shark fin soup, which is apparently a delicacy in some parts of the world.
The problem is that under a very specific law called the Shark Finning Prohibition Act,
it's illegal for fishing vessels to buy shark fins in that way. So the Coast Guard simply took
the shark fins. In case you're curious, the seizure was eventually overturned because the
vessel was determined not to be a fishing vessel within the meaning of the law. But
even when you eventually get your property back, it can take a very long time.
Here's another one from a few years ago. The U.S. Supreme Court will now consider a case that
involves civil asset forfeiture in Alabama. The state seized a woman's car after her son was
arrested for marijuana possession during a traffic stop in Mobile County, and it took almost two
years for the woman to get her car back. The question before the Supreme Court,
should there be a probable cause hearing prior to the state seizing your property?
On February 17,
2019, Satsuma Police pulled Taejon Cully over on I-65 and arrested him for possession of marijuana
and drug paraphernalia. Ten days later, the state filed this complaint, seeking to seize the
9mm gun he had on him during the stop and the Nissan Altima he was driving. Even though,
according to the state's own complaint, the car belonged to his mother, Halima Cully,
who was not charged with a crime. Twenty months later, Judge Young-Peter ordered the state return
the car to her.
That's crazy.
Dom Soto is a defense attorney who did not represent Cully, but says the state overuses
its ability to seize property connected to crimes before anyone is found guilty.
Well, the problem with that is pre-trial taking. It gets all involved in excessive fines. There's
a $15,000 car. Sometimes they take people's homes.
So the reason this woman was eventually able to get her car back, even though it was technically
involved in the commission of a crime,
is the innocent owner defense, which many states have. And the idea is that she owned the car,
and she had no idea that it was being used to commit a crime, but it took her nearly two years
to get her car back. And the Supreme Court eventually ruled that there was no problem
with this delay. So you didn't commit any crime, but the police can take your car
for nearly two years anyway. The court ruled that you're entitled to a timely final forfeiture
hearing when the police take your stuff.
But you're not entitled to separate preliminary retention hearing to determine whether the police
can hold on to your car in the meantime while the process plays out. This is the power of civil
asset forfeiture. It's prone to all kinds of abuse. It has indeed been abused many, many times.
Now, it's not to say that civil asset forfeiture is the worst thing in the world. It's used to
seize assets from gangs and terrorists, even where a criminal case would be difficult or
impossible to build. I mean, if the police discover,
you know, an abandoned vehicle with drugs in it near the Mexican border,
obviously they should be able to seize it. So there's some nuance here that gets lost,
but the guardrails have been non-existent in recent years, which is why this pilot in Alaska
lost his plane. Again, yes, that was criminal asset forfeiture, not civil, but both criminal
and civil asset forfeiture are subject to the Eighth Amendment when the forfeiture is punitive,
which is to say when it's intended for the purpose of punishing someone. Under our Constitution,
the government can't. Use any kind of forfeiture to exact an excessive fine. And with this case out of Alaska,
the Supreme Court has the opportunity to establish some clear, bright-line rules
on where the boundaries are when it comes to determining what, you know,
fines are considered excessive. According to a decision by the Alaska Supreme Court,
it's not excessive to take someone's plane away for transporting a few beers,
because in aggregate, alcohol causes mass casualties and despair and whatever.
And if that's. If that's the standard, then it applies to civil asset forfeitures as well.
But the Supreme Court can and should shut down this standard, which is totally ridiculous.
When you're determining what kind of punishment to give someone, you should only look at what
the person actually did without holding them responsible for every other crime that's
tangentially related and that was committed by millions of other people who have nothing to do
with you. If the Supreme Court sets this standard, then it will apply to both civil and criminal
asset forfeiture. It will end some of the worst abuses,
of civil asset forfeiture, which have attracted a lot of attention over the past decade,
and for good reason. Already, we've seen a lot of progress in this regard. This is from Reuters back
in 2024. Quote, the U.S. Deputy Attorney General has suspended a controversial civil asset forfeiture
program by the DEA that targeted unsuspecting airline passengers and subjected them to
potentially unlawful seizures of cash from their bags. And one such example, a DEA office
tapped an airline employee as a confidential source who tipped off agents any time they were caught.
Agents, any time a passenger purchased a plane ticket within 48 hours of departure. Agents would
use that last minute purchase as a justification to then approach those passengers and try to get
the passengers to agree to let them search their bags. In cases where the agent searched and seized
cash, the confidential source received a cut of the proceeds from the seizure. This program,
which is ridiculously corrupt, was terminated completely. On one hand, you can argue that it's
reasonable for the government to subject a passenger to an unlawful seizure, but on the other hand,
you can argue that it's reasonable for the government to subject passengers to texture
screening if they buy a ticket within 48 hours of departure or pay in cash or something like that,
maybe. But this program was very different. What's happening here is that after passengers
go through security, the DEA is dragging them off of their flights, potentially making them miss the
flight, unless they agree to waive their rights and have their property searched. And they're not
even looking for drugs or bombs for the most part. They're looking for cash to confiscate.
In practice, here's what this looks like.
This was obtained by the same Institute for Justice I mentioned earlier. The DEA was tipped
off by an informant, and they're looking for cash to confiscate. And here's how that goes. Watch.
Set your bag down, and then you can walk on the plane. You can do that.
You're not with the, what do you call it? I've seen these videos.
I'm the DEA. I'm the government.
That's great. Do you have legal ability to search?
Yes.
I was in Cincinnati on a business trip.
And I had gone sick the prior night, so I had to rebook my flight to a last-minute flight back to New York.
He had basically just asked me for ID and to search, if he could search my bags.
And when I started to decline, he pulled out his badge and said that he was with the DEA.
I'd almost imagined that this had to be some kind of mix-up.
Oh, that's my, hey.
Where's your bag at?
I don't consent to search, sir.
You don't have to consent. Where's your backpack at?
was going to take off because we were well past the kind of gate closing time at the time he boarded
you want to watch the dog yes please i would like to watch them come out
well i followed him off the plane because he had my backpack and i wasn't going to leave an
an airport with my work laptop, my passport,
a lot of my documentation from work,
and so I didn't have a choice.
- The agent again insists
that he does not need David's consent to take his bag.
But without probable cause of a crime,
DEA agents cannot seize your belongings
against your will, period.
- Okay, so when you buy a last-minute ticket,
we get alerts.
We come out to any and all flights,
doesn't matter who you are, race, sex, nothing, right?
We come out and we talk to those people,
which I tried to do to you,
but you wouldn't allow me to do it.
- Am I under suspicion of a crime right now?
Do you have probable cause?
- So, we have a lot of money and drugs
going out of every airport to New York.
- Okay.
- It's an influx of it.
- Okay.
- Okay?
So that's my--
- Am I being suspected of a crime?
I just want the speed report.
- I don't know.
- Do you have probable cause for a search?
- I have probable cause for a dog to walk up
and smell your bag, yes.
- Like, how high my lawyers are going to be
taking this up with you?
- You didn't take your bag off like I asked you to?
I don't have to. I asked you if I was being detained, and I can walk away if I'm not.
You can, yes, but not your bag.
I have followed the Constitution very vigorously.
I asked you to put your bag down.
You don't have rights to my bag. I don't know who you are.
So the DEA agent, without any probable cause, has now seized this guy's property without his consent.
He tries to claim that he has probable cause because the passenger didn't immediately surrender his bag,
and because airports are used for drug activity, and because the guy bought the ticket within 48 hours of departure.
But that's not remotely sufficient for probable cause, and the passenger knows it.
So to end this standoff and to generate probable cause, the DEA brings in a dog.
And based on the footage, it looks like they signaled the dog to alert on the bag.
What if you could delay your next two mortgage payments?
Imagine putting those two payments in your pocket and finally getting a little breathing room ahead of the holidays.
Well, it's possible when you call American Financing Today.
If you're feeling stretched by everyday expenses, groceries, gas, bills piling up, you're not alone.
Most Americans are putting those expenses on credit cards, and credit card rates are insane in the 20s or even 30s in some cases.
American Financing can show you how to use your home equity to pay off that debt.
Their salary-based mortgage consultants are helping homeowners just like you restructure their loans and save money every month.
There are no upfront fees to find out how much you could save.
Their customers are saving an average of $800 a month.
It's like a $10,000 raise without having to change jobs to get it.
Call today.
American Financing, 866-569-4711.
That's 866-569-4711 or visit AmericanFinancing.net.
slash Walsh. NMLS pound 182334, NMLSconsumeraccess.org. Visit AmericanFinancing.net
slash Walsh or call 866-569-4711. Average savings based on borrowers who save over $199.99.
Watch this closely here. So I was waiting by the jet bridge for about five minutes,
and I remember seeing the dog handler pop up through one of the kind of airport gates.
And at first, you know, he pointed the dog towards my bag, and the dog took a smell and
just ran straight past it. A few seconds later, he started, you know, clicking his fingers,
and the dog started coming back, and I saw him basically gesture at my bag.
Number one. You see that? You got it recorded. Don't edit that part out of the video either.
You can learn it on your bag. Okay. Now, this is your legal right. You can allow us to look at it,
or you can tell me no, and we can write a search warrant. We can apply for one. I don't know if
we get one or not, but we'll apply for one. I don't consent to be searched. So you don't want
us to search your bag either? Okay. All right. Well, then we got
to take your bag back. So do you want to sit with us in the PD while we try to get you back? I don't
get a warrant on your bag today? What do you want to do? I don't consent to be searched, sir. I'm
sorry. With the questionable dog alert, the agent now claims that he can easily get a warrant to
search the bag. David continues to refuse to consent to a search. We know our law. We know
what we're doing out here, and what we can and cannot do. It's a piece of paper that will
literally stay with us. It just says that you're allowing us to search it. If you want to sign your
name, it says that we can search it, which I don't know why it's so difficult. We'll search it. If not,
it's the same thing I just told you. Think about it for a minute. I know you're irritated. I know
you're annoyed, and I'm annoyed, too, that you caused such a scene for something so silly.
The law actually doesn't distinguish between bodily property. I'm being detained now because
my bag isn't taking my property away. You're not out in the public. You're in an airport.
This is a public area, for what it's worth. Your bags are not. They're different than your person.
There are some canine handlers and police officers who are watching the show right now,
and they'll have feedback on whether this looked like an appropriate way to handle the situation
or not. But from what I understand, the appropriate procedure is for the handler to walk the dog
around the general area of the object. In this case, that's what happened initially.
And the dog walked past the object without alerting. Then the handler pointed directly at
the bag while making some kind of noise with his mouth, a kissy noise, as they described it. And at
that point, the dog walked past the object without alerting. Then the handler pointed directly at the
dog and alerted on the bag. It looks like a very unscientific, fraudulent process. And it's
confusing as well, because as you heard, the DEA agents tell the guy to record the dog with their
phone. They don't see any problem with what they did. They seem to convince that based on this
dog's behavior, which seems designed to appease his handler more than anything else, that they
can easily get a judge to sign a search warrant for the bag. And in the meantime, this guy will
miss his flight. It's enough to make you think all these drug-sniffing dog tests should be banned
completely, since it's easy to abuse. At least the ones that are in the airport, I mean. Especially
if someone isn't recording with the video. They're like lie detector tests. There's simply no way to
tell if the handler is sending some kind of coded message to the dog. It reminds me of the story of
Clever Hands, a German horse who made the rounds in the early 20th century, impressing everybody
with his ability to do arithmetic. So they might ask the horse, what's three times two? And the
answer was six times, and the crowd would go wild. So a little bit of like a Charlotte's Web thing,
but with a horse. A government commission apparently investigated this and couldn't
discover any fraud. And even when the horse was separated from his handler and someone else was
asking the question, the horse got the question right. But it turns out, of course, that the horse
was simply reading body language. If the handler didn't know the right answer, if the horse couldn't
see the handler, the horse would get almost every question wrong. Its accuracy rate would drop from
89% to around 6%.
So the horse was paying very close attention to the handler's body language and the reaction of
the crowd, which would relax when, you know, he got the right number of hoof stomps. So that's all
it was. Still a really smart horse, though. We'll give him that. Drug detecting dogs can work the
same way. You know, I'm not denying that these dogs can be accurate, but if the handlers want to use
the dog as a pretext to conduct a search, if they want the dog to alert, that's very easy to engineer,
to get the dog to alert. So that's a really smart horse.
to comply. And that's what we're seeing here. How often does that happen? How often does it happen
in airports? One of the problems with asset forfeiture in practice is that it leads to
these kinds of abuses. When the government invokes this doctrine, some very absurd scenarios can
result. People lose their airplane over some beer. And, you know, in other cases, people get
pulled off airplanes because they, you know, bought their ticket at the last minute and the
incentive structure is perverse at a fundamental level. It's stacked in favor of the government's
right to take your property when the balance of power under our constitution should be on your
side. And the fact that we're seeing this abuse of power in Alaska to punish a guy for transporting
some beer is insane. I mean, this is a news report from the 1980s where people reacted to laws
against drinking while driving. Watch. Any attempt to restrict drinking
and driving here is viewed by some as downright undemocratic. It's kind of getting communist when
a fella can't put in a hard day's work, put in 11, 12 hours a day, and then get in your truck and
at least drink one or two beers. They're making laws where you can't drink when you want to.
You have to wear a seatbelt when you're driving. Pretty soon we're going to become this country.
People used to think that DUI laws were anti-American.
And they reacted the same way, by the way, to seatbelt laws.
And now they'll take away everything you own in Alaska if you're caught anywhere near a sealed
case of beer. That's 40 years of progress for you in one video. People used to have a much more
expansive views, a view of their own freedom, much more expansive. And in turn, at least
nominally, the government used to respect your property rights, to some degree, because they had
to. But they just don't anymore. This is a problem that's persisted for a very long time. And now,
many years of increasingly bizarre and unconstitutional scenarios, it could finally
be ending. In December, the Supreme Court is going to hear arguments in the Alaska case.
Decision will likely be made by the middle of next year. We'll finally learn straight from the
high court whether or not the government can steal $95,000 from you because you put a few
cans of beer in your airplane. Under our constitution, we all know the government
can't do that. But as to the much narrower question of whether five justices on the
front is a question of whether you can rely on the judicial system to protect the property you've
spent your whole life working for, well, that's something that we'll find out in just a few months.
These are rights and privileges that many of us took for granted, but we simply can't do that
anymore. This is one of the main reasons we're releasing our latest documentary, The Real History
of Communism, for free on YouTube on Friday. It's a deeply researched narrative of the Russian
revolution and how quickly the Bolsheviks took power. It can happen much faster than you think, like we
talked about yesterday. And that's why you should watch that on Friday. And then when you're done
watching that, The Daily Wire has a new movie also related to this coming out on November 11th
set in Stalinist Russia called Confession. Now, I saw this movie a couple of months ago,
and I can tell you genuinely it's a very well-made, serious piece of art
with easily, far and away, the most impressive cast ever assembled for a
quote-unquote conservative film. In fact, I really wouldn't call it a conservative film at all.
It does have an important message, a conservative message, but this is a movie that is trying to be
a good film, not just a good conservative film, which is what we need to be doing, in my opinion,
and I think it succeeds. The cast includes Rob Lowe, who does tremendous work, James Franco,
who will surprise you in the villain role. Also, Nick Nolte's in it, Jennifer Jason Leigh,
Emile Hirsch, who I think does a fantastic job, many others. Even the small roles have recognizable
and talented actors.
Dean Norris appears in kind of a cameo role, probably my favorite cameo performance in the
film. And we'll end the show today with the trailer, and take a look, and we'll see you
tomorrow. Godspeed.
Thank you.
And shake, because you're dependent on drink. You're sick as all over you.
Have you ever seen a child starve to death, Professor?
No.
I have.
Fan Duel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are,
including these places.
Make this your most rewarding season ever with Fan Duel.
Age and location restrictions apply.
Product availability varies by market.
See FanDuel.com for eligibility.
Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
This holiday, all plans, even unlimited, are just $15 a month.
A holiday deal this good obviously deserves an enormously expensive holiday song,
like All I Want.
Right. Okay, we can't afford that.
You know what? Forget the music budget.
We're going to stick with whatever's in the public domain.
Give it a try at MintMobile.com.
Dash switch.
Upfront payment of $45 for three months, $90 for six months,
or $180 for a 12-month plan required.
$15 per month equivalent.
Taxes and fees extra.
New customer offer for initial plan term only.
Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy.
See terms.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Kenneth Jupy, an Alaska air taxi pilot, was wrongfully convicted and fined for transporting beer to a dry village, despite no intent to distribute alcohol or harm.
The Alaska state court upheld the seizure of his $95,000 airplane, arguing that alcohol consumption causes widespread societal harm, even though the offense involved only a six-pack of beer.
This ruling violates the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against excessive fines and cruel and unusual punishment, especially given the minor nature of the offense.
The case highlights a broader legal problem
The U.S. Supreme Court is set to review the case, offering a critical opportunity to establish constitutional limits on government property seizures.
Similar abuses occur in other cases, including DEA seizures of passengers’ bags without probable cause and the seizure of a hotel due to drug-related guest activity.
The Alaska decision reflects a dangerous overreach where individuals are punished for actions disconnected from actual criminal behavior or broader societal harm.
The case underscores the need to protect property rights from government overreach, especially in cases involving minor or non-criminal conduct.
Summary:
An air taxi pilot, Kenneth Jupy, was wrongfully convicted and forced to lose his $95,000 airplane after transporting a few beers to a dry village in Alaska. Though the beer never reached its destination and there was no evidence of criminal intent, the state seized his aircraft under a law that allows forfeiture of planes used in alcohol transport. The Alaska Supreme Court upheld this punishment, claiming the offense caused widespread societal harm due to alcohol consumption, despite a lack of connection to actual crime or harm.
This decision is widely criticized as an unconstitutional overreach, violating the Eighth Amendment’s ban on excessive fines and cruel punishment. The case highlights systemic abuses in both criminal and civil asset forfeiture, where property is taken without due process or criminal conviction, often based on flimsy or speculative links to crime. Similar examples, such as DEA seizures of passengers’ bags without probable cause or hotel confiscations, show how these practices enable government overreach.
S. Supreme Court is now reviewing the case, offering a vital opportunity to rein in unconstitutional property seizures and restore balance to property rights under the Constitution. The case also reflects a broader cultural and legal shift where government authorities, instead of respecting individual liberty, use broad prohibitions to justify punitive measures.
As public awareness grows, this case serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of protecting personal property from arbitrary government seizure—especially in the face of outdated and hysterical policies.
FAQs
Kenneth Jupy, an air taxi operator in Alaska, was convicted for transporting beer into a dry village, Beaver, despite never delivering the alcohol. He was fined and had his plane seized under a forfeiture law, leading to a legal challenge over excessive punishment.
The Alaska state law required forfeiture of any plane used to transport alcohol into a dry village. Even though the beer never reached Beaver and Jupy didn’t know about it, the government seized his $95,000 airplane as a penalty.
Under the Eighth Amendment, excessive fines and cruel punishments are prohibited. The seizure of Jupy’s plane for a minor, non-criminal act is considered excessive and violates constitutional protections against unjust property forfeiture.
The Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case to determine whether the government can seize property for a minor offense, especially when the punishment is disproportionate to the crime and not based on actual wrongdoing.
Civil asset forfeiture allows the government to seize property without a criminal conviction, based on a 50% likelihood of criminal connection. It is often abused, as seen in cases like a woman losing her car after her son’s arrest, or passengers being searched without probable cause.
The government must show a preponderance of evidence—51% likelihood—that property was connected to criminal activity. This is a much lower standard than the 'beyond a reasonable doubt' required in criminal trials.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.