Ep. 1852 - This Is The Greatest Scam In American History. It's Time To End It.
44m 6s
Social Security is facing a severe financial crisis due to a shrinking workforce and declining fertility rates, with projections showing only 78% of benefits will remain by 2032. A large majority of older Americans—89% of those over 65—oppose reforms, insisting on protecting current benefits through higher taxes on younger workers. However, this creates a deeply unjust system where young people, especially those earning around $40,000 annually, pay up to 12.4% in Social Security taxes, while retirees receive 4 to 7 times more than they contributed. Critics argue the system is a Ponzi scheme, where older beneficiaries are paid from younger workers’ taxes, and that decades of political decisions—such as expanded welfare programs and tax cuts without spending controls—have created a burden passed to future generations. Historical proposals like Bush’s individual retirement accounts, which would have given younger workers control over personal investment accounts, were rejected due to fear of benefit cuts. Despite the system’s flaws, older voters resist reform, often claiming personal sacrifice while ignoring the fact that their generation helped create the unsustainable structure. The consensus is that the system must be reformed or phased out to prevent future collapse, with younger generations bearing the cost of a flawed legacy. This shift demands not only fiscal responsibility but a reevaluation of intergenerational fairness and the long-term health of the economy.
people keep saying that real communism has never been tried well it was uh moscow 1938 arrests in
the night confessions forced out of innocent people the daily wire's newest movie confession
is a story about just that it's out right now only on the daily wire
fan duel is now available everywhere in the u.s
so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places
make this your most rewarding season ever with fan duel age and location restrictions apply
product availability varies by market see fanduel.com for eligibility gambling problem call
1-800-GAMBLER when a phd student was investigating the state gambling industry in west virginia he
made a pretty remarkable discovery a grand total of 43 million bets were placed by just 16,000
gamblers using a 16-year-old gambler who was a gambler who was a gambler who was a gambler who
used a single casino app in the span of one month so a very small number of people are responsible
for a staggering amount of betting and interestingly enough these bets spiked on specific days every
second third and fourth wednesday of the month now why might that be i mean you wouldn't expect
wednesdays to be a particularly big day for betting or for anything else but consistently
week after week that's what the researcher observed and then after doing a little digging
he realized what was going on wednesdays are
going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling and gambling is going to be a really big
day for gambling and gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for gambling and
gambling is going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling and gambling is going to be
a really big day for gambling and gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for
gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling is going to be a
really big day for gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling is
going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for
gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling is going to be a really big
day for gambling and gambling is going to be a really big day for gambling and gambling is going to
even pretending to care about the implications. Now, if your response is, well, these people paid
into Social Security so they can spend the money however they want, well, then you're missing two
very important points. First of all, no, these people did not pay into anything. They paid a tax
to the government, which then immediately spent their money. The payouts they're receiving in the
form of regular checks are coming from working taxpayers, many of whom need the money to survive
not to blow it on gambling. And secondly, on a related note, Social Security is unsustainable.
The system depends on an ever-increasing number of workers who have to fund this Ponzi scheme
with their tax payments for an increasingly elderly population. And yes, Social Security
is quite literally a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment plan where older
investors are paid to spend their money. from money collected from newer or more recent investors. And this is exactly how Social Security
works. But there's a problem. Well, many problems, but this is a big one. Fertility rates in this
country have plummeted. We don't have enough workers paying taxes, and therefore the Social
Security Trust Fund is set to run out in the fourth quarter of 2032. And once the reserve
is exhausted, only around 78 percent of scheduled benefits would be provided. And if the
government tries to solve the problem by printing money, it will cause inflation, which will
ultimately cause Social Security distributions to rise even further, since the benefits are
adjusted based on the cost of living. In other words, whether you want to cut Social Security
benefits or not, something has to give at some point. Sacrifices will have to be made.
There's no getting around it. The only question is, who is making the sacrifice and in what
form and when? According to a recent survey
from the Cato Institute that's getting a lot of attention today, a large majority of boomers have
decided on their preferred solution. They know who should make the sacrifice. And the answer
is their children and their grandchildren. Listen to this. Quote, an overwhelming 89 percent of
Americans over the age of 65 said Social Security benefits should be protected at current levels,
even if it means higher taxes on younger workers. And it's not
only Americans aged 65 plus who prefer the solution. Roughly 84 percent of those aged
55 to 64 preferred higher taxes on younger Americans, while 74 percent between the ages of
45 and 54 agreed with it as well. In other words, the closer Americans get to retirement, the more
likely they are to favor protecting today's benefits at the expense of younger workers,
who will end up paying higher taxes to keep it afloat. So that's the plan. They're going to
have to deal with it. More than half of the household net worth for 35-year-olds. And this is a very important point,
so I'll repeat it. We are taking huge amounts of money from young families and giving it to
older people who, on average, are 10 times wealthier. Now, of course, that's an average.
There are plenty of elderly grandmothers who are poor or struggling, and there are some 35-year-olds
who are wealthy. But at a population level, the numbers are what they are. To have an overwhelming
wealth of young people, you have to have an average of 10 times wealthier. And that's an
average. So the majority of people in the older, richer group calling for tax hikes on the younger,
poorer group is just despicable, frankly. It's pure selfishness. Young families already have
to deal with an economy where everything is exponentially more expensive than it was for
boomers at the same age. Older people clamoring to raise taxes on the young on top of it all
is just perverse. It's the exact opposite of how these things are supposed to work.
Now, personally, I would agree to a plan to, say, phase out Social Security over the next 25 years,
even knowing that if we put that plan in place right now, it would mean that the system will end
right at the moment when I would start drawing a check. The system is broken. It's not working.
It's headed for the edge of a very tall cliff. Something has to be done for the sake of future
generations. Again, sacrifice is due. It's not going to happen. It's
going to have to be made by someone at some point. There's no way around it. And I would
rather make the sacrifice myself than force my kids to make it. I would take the loss if it meant
that my kids and grandchildren aren't subjected to this scam for their entire lives. I just can't
for the life of me understand or relate to the older people who don't feel that way and wouldn't
be willing to make the sacrifice for the sake of their descendants. It's a totally foreign mentality
to me. I find it baffling.
Setting my kids up for the future is one of the only things I care about anymore.
I understand that for a lot of people, it can be a legitimate challenge to save for retirement on
top of raising a family. But if the choice is between securing your own retirement and ensuring
that your children have the chance to live in a stable country that isn't owned by China,
how is that a choice at all? How would you decide when you've considered all your options that the
best way to make your own kids? Wouldn't you do everything in your power to make their lives
easier if you had the opportunity to do so? Or maybe I should ask it this way. If you had to choose
between making your life harder or your children's lives harder,
is it not extremely easy to choose the former? Already, Social Security by itself is an enormous
burden on young people to a degree that most people don't understand unless they're in this position.
So let's break this down. If you're a young person making, say, $40,000 a year, which is a little bit
under the average for someone who's 30 and not college educated. So a lot of people that are
around this age are in this boat. So if this is what you're making, you currently pay around 15.3%
for the Federal Insurance Contributions Act tax or FICA. And that breaks down to 12.4% for Social
Security. So that's basically a month's pay after taxes. It's a huge amount of money. Okay, this is
not a small amount of money. It's not a small amount of money. It's not a small thing for a lot of young people. This is a major financial hardship
for young families. It's potentially the difference between being able to afford
a house or not, the difference between being able to pay off your credit card debt or not,
the difference between getting a necessary car repair or not. Social Security is an incredibly
significant financial burden for young working families. And all to prop up a system that almost
certainly won't be there, at least in its current form, when they're older. And all to send checks
to retirees who, on average, are much wealthier than they are and who, and this is important,
are receiving much, much more from Social Security than they, quote, paid into it.
On average, boomers will get paid more than double what they put in. And that's including
inflation and interest. In raw dollars, they're getting four to seven times what they put in.
And the cost for young families, again, is real ongoing financial distress.
FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places.
Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply.
Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER. You know, I can remember what that was like personally. Social Security is
no skin off my nose at this point in my life, but I remember very well being at an income level
where being able to opt out would have been legitimately life-changing.
And on top of that, the Social Security tax caps out after you've earned around $184,000. So high
earners, people making hundreds of thousands of dollars a year or more, get to dodge Social
Security tax on a significant percentage of their income. Meanwhile, we're making people earning $40,000 a year pay around 6% from every
paycheck. It's an insane system. You know, it's not fair. And the thing is, everybody knows it.
When I made this argument on X, as you'd expect, I got a lot of replies like this one. This is from
a guy who, and I know it sounds cliche, but I'm not making this up, has golf clubs in his profile
picture and the words real estate in his X handle. Here's what he says. F you. They made us pay into
that system for this guarantee of retirement pay. I would have rather invested in a system that would
have invested the money in the stock market and I'd be much better off. Well, there are a few problems
here. First of all, nobody stopped you from investing in the stock market. If you never did
that at any point in your life, that's on you. If we're going to lecture younger people to pull
themselves up by their bootstraps and take responsibility for their own choices, fine.
But then the same tough love mentality should certainly be applied to adults twice their age.
So if you're sitting here saying, oh, I didn't invest in the stock market for my entire life. Well,
you could have. Whose choice was that? I mean, how's it any different from a young person who's
complaining that, oh, I have terrible student loans. And most older people, especially if
they're Republicans, will look at the younger people and say, well, you know, sorry, that was
your choice. And I agree with them, by the way. Like, you know, sorry, I know it's tough, but you
can't take that debt out. That's on you. I mean, if we're willing to say that to young people who
made a choice when they were like 18 to take on, you know, what would choose what would turn out to
be a really bad investment of a college education for most of them, if we're willing to look at them
and say, well, you know, sorry, tough luck. Then what's wrong with saying that to someone who's 67
years old? A grown ass adult.
Who's saying, well, but I never invested any money. Maybe you should have. That's exactly
what you would say to someone half your age and do say, what's the difference? Second, if you admit
that it's a crappy system, then you should want nothing more than to fix it for the sake of your
descendants. But instead, you know, it sounds like you want to get whatever you can out of it and
leave your grandchildren holding the bag. And meanwhile, your generation spent decades voting
for politicians who would prop up the very quote system that you're now complaining about. Again,
where does personal responsibility factor in here? There was also this response, which was less
vulgar, but still outlandish in its own way. And I'm reading this because it's fairly representative
of the kinds of feedback you get anytime you try to talk about solving the social security problem.
Anytime you try to even broach the subject, you get hissy fits. You get temper tantrums
from grown people.
That's what you get. And that's what this is. Usually I agree with you and I'm a staunch
Republican, but if you take away my social security, I'm a Democrat for the rest, uh,
for the first time in my life, I spent my entire life planning for retirement with social security,
a major part of it and paid into the systems as a young person. So the older generation could have
some support. I'll make a deal with you. Pay me back every penny I put into it. And every penny
my employers put into it on my behalf at 5% interest that you can take away the monthly checks.
Okay. So he's willing to make a deal as long as the deal
involves paying him all of his benefits. This is the extent to which many older people are
willing to offer concessions and social security. They'll make a deal as long as the deal involves
giving them everything they want upfront and making sure they have to sacrifice not one
single dime. Even while 89% of them are saying, absolutely. I think younger people should have
to sacrifice their money. It's just a morally abhorrent position. I'm sorry. It just is.
And if they don't get what they want, as you just heard, they'll vote for communists who want to
come down the country that their grandchildren will have to inherit. Who are you punishing?
You're going to punish your own descendants? You're going to elect terrorists who plan to
open the borders, release all the criminals and destroy the United States as we know it
solely to protect your retirement. This is childish and petulant and outrageously selfish
demanding that the government steal from young people the way it stole from you. I mean,
admitting that it's theft. Well, they took from me.
So they got to take from these kids. Threatening to destroy everything if they don't do that. It's
such an abhorrent position that I'm surprised people aren't too embarrassed to say it publicly,
but this is a common sentiment. According to this guy, he spent his entire life planning
for retirement with social security as a major part of it. And to be fair, there are probably
many people in that boat. I get it. This is where I go back to the younger people who have college
debt.
Yeah, you're in a tough spot. I get it. That was a mistake, though. You should not have planned
your whole retirement around a government program. That was a mistake. You shouldn't
have done that. It was a very foolish decision. There was never any guarantee that social
security would remain solvent for any significant period of time. Everyone knew it was a government
program administered by incompetent government bureaucrats. And no matter how much you paid
into the system, you were never allowed to log into any account.
And see your balance. That should have been your first clue. Okay, that was your big clue that,
in fact, you had not paid into anything. Your money was gone. And the moment you realized that,
you should have started planning for your retirement on your own without depending in any
way on social security. And before you start ranting that it's unfair, I agree. But this is
exactly the position that young people today are in. They are having their money taken from them
for a system that they know probably won't be there for them. And they're not going to be there for
them. And that if you're an older person, you also know, you damn well know that this probably
won't be here for the younger people. But you're not going to be around when that happens.
And so younger people, they know that they have to plan for their retirement separately.
How can you expect young people to do that for themselves while at the same time getting angry
when younger people ask you why you didn't do that for yourself? And if you did do that for
yourself, well, then again, why should younger people be forced to finance their own money?
Why should they be forced to finance a retirement that you already financed?
Now, yes, it's wrong for the government to steal your money and give you an IOU in return,
which is basically what social security is, but that's what happened. That's what happened.
And if you pretended otherwise, then you made a very serious mistake.
The question is who should have to pay for that mistake? Should a young worker making
40 grand a year have to pay for it, for your mistake? And when you consider that
collectively, the older generation spent many decades voting exclusively for politicians who
would prop up this failing system, it becomes hard to see them as a victim of it. You could
have fixed the problem or at least tried to fix it, but you didn't. You didn't even try. I mean,
in fact, like for decades, if any politician has even mentioned a word about making any changes to
the system, you screamed at them and voted them out of office or threatened to. When you own a home,
you must know that eventually something expensive is going to break. You don't know what it'll be and
you don't know when it will happen. Maybe the water heater goes out. Maybe the furnace decides
that the coldest day of the year is the ideal time to stop functioning. I think it's crucial to have
a plan for that before you're standing in your house with no hot water, desperately calling
repair companies and discovering exactly how expensive homeownership can become. That's why
homeowners should know about HomeServe. HomeServe offers home protection plans for different systems
in your house.
Including options for things like plumbing, heating, electrical systems, and water heaters.
Regular homeowners insurance often doesn't cover the normal wear and tear that
that can lead to these kinds of breakdowns.
Plans start at just $4.99 a month.
You choose the plan that fits your needs and budget.
If something covered by that plan goes wrong,
you can call the 24-7 hotline to start the repair process.
And this isn't some obscure service.
HomeServe has nearly 4.5 million customers,
a 4.7 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot,
and an A-plus Better Business Bureau rating.
The point is simple.
You already know that owning a house comes with unexpected repairs.
You can either prepare for that fact now
or wait until something breaks and prepare for it
while water is pouring through your ceiling.
Well, I prefer the first approach.
Your next costly home repair could be coming.
Act now and get protected before a breakdown with a plan through HomeServe.
For 50% less your first year,
go to HomeServe.com slash Walsh to find the plan that's right for you.
That's HomeServe.com slash Walsh for 50% less.
Savings compared to renewal price void in Florida.
Listen up.
There are enough people listening to this show right now
that if they don't vote,
it could swing key states in the 2026 election to the Democrats.
And everyone listening knows
every single ultra far-left Democrat socialist
will be showing up to vote this fall.
Democrats are fired up and we can't let them win
because if we lose,
they'll undo everything our movement has fought for.
I need you to vote early so that you can bank your vote
and fight back against the left's turnout machine.
If you live in the critical Senate battleground states of Maine or Ohio,
early voting,
it's already underway starting this week.
Go to GOPvotes.org right now and find out when you can vote.
Making your voice heard is easier than ever.
You can get election reminders,
look up your polling location,
and pick a date to vote early.
Go to GOPvotes.org today.
Paid for by SLF PAC,
not authorized by any candidate or candidates committee.
You know, as a practical political matter,
I'll concede that it's extremely unlikely,
verging on impossible,
that either party is ever going to reform Social Security,
much less anybody.
I don't think we're ever going to reform Social Security,
which is what needs to happen.
But it's not going to happen.
I know that.
This is a political dead end
for exactly the reason that this guy states.
There's a substantial number of people
who will vote against any political party
that touches Social Security in any way.
We're not just talking about ending it.
Any attempt to reform it at all,
to make it potentially solvent
or to make it so that it will still be around
maybe decades from now,
any attempt to do that
is met with fear.
And I think that's a very, very important thing.
Right?
Retirees become like BLM.
It's like, we're going to burn everything down.
Even if we're hurting our own kids,
we're going to do it.
When George W. Bush tried to privatize the system,
it was a political disaster
that was shot down within 60 days.
But his proposal was highly sensible
and actually pretty moderate,
all things considered.
He didn't want to shut down Social Security
altogether at all.
What Bush wanted to do
was allow younger workers
to divert 4% of their payroll taxes
from Social Security
and into an individual personal account
that they controlled.
And the personal account would work like a 401k.
You could choose from a limited number of investments,
mostly tracking the total stock market.
In exchange, the workers guaranteed
Social Security benefits,
which are invested in Treasury securities
with a much smaller return,
would be reduced proportionally.
And meanwhile, the government would have to borrow
around $2 trillion over 10 years
to make up for the shortfall of money going into Social Security.
through normal contributions.
That seemed, you know,
shockingly high to people at the time,
but now we routinely run deficits
of that size every single year.
Assuming the stock market account
grew at a rate of inflation,
you know, plus 3%,
workers would benefit from this new system.
And otherwise, if the market's underperformed,
it would cost them money in retirement.
So here's how he tried to sell the plan
to the public all the way back
over 20 years ago.
Listen.
Government has made a commitment
and you have made your plans.
These promises will be honored.
George Bush's plan
strengthens Social Security.
It guarantees everyone at or near retirement
every dollar of their benefits.
No cuts in Social Security.
And the Bush plan gives younger workers
the choice to put a small part of their Social Security
in sound investments they control
for higher returns.
This generation will save Social Security.
Now that was right before Hurricane Katrina hit,
which distracted everyone and killed the proposal.
We're going to call it a day.
But there was no chance it was going to succeed anyway.
The unions and the AARP opposed it,
mainly because their members didn't understand
how the stock market worked.
And Bush's poll numbers began to tank
as Democrats convinced seniors
that they'd lose all their money.
So the program never even made it
to a congressional vote.
This is one of the reasons everyone talks about,
oh, we need real solutions.
Look, it's one of the reasons
why real solutions don't happen.
Because on the rare occasion
where anyone in a position of power
actually proposes something
that might be some kind of solution,
might have some kind of, you know,
effect on a major problem,
like they get screamed out of the room.
That's what happens.
And Bush shifted his focus to Hurricane Katrina
and no one talked about the proposal ever again.
And that's too bad because it's very clear
that workers would have much more money
for retirement today
if this proposal had passed.
And crucially,
that's money that they would actually own.
You know, imagine a worker in his 20s
making 40 grand a year
who began paying for a job
and participating in Bush's program
when it became available in 2005,
if it ever did.
The market crashed in 2008
and then it recovered a few years later
and went on a 15-year bull run.
With Social Security alone,
he'd get a check for around $2,500 a month
when he retires.
Under Bush's system,
his monthly Social Security check
would be reduced to around $2,000 a month.
But he'd have something like $300,000
in a personal retirement account
that he controls.
That's a massively better position to be in.
It's a better system.
We could have had that system.
You know, but the mass of voters at the time,
especially older people, retired people,
didn't want it.
Wouldn't have it.
Wouldn't even consider it.
You know, and if you were in that position,
you could safely withdraw 4%
from their retirement account every year,
which more than makes up the difference
in Social Security payments.
And the kicker is that when he dies,
he can pass that money to his family.
It's generational wealth.
On the other hand, when you die,
all of the money you supposedly paid in
to Social Security is gone forever.
Your spouse can collect your benefit until they die.
But after that, no one will ever get that money.
It's just gone.
It's just gone because it's already gone
because you never actually paid into anything
in the first place.
And again, Bush's plan was very modest.
You could only put 4% in a private account
and only with certain restrictions.
If people were simply allowed
to put all of their Social Security tax,
including employer match,
into a retirement account,
which is obviously what the system should be,
starting at age 18 and retiring
at 65, then they'd retire
with around $3 million based on historical
market returns.
Pretty much everybody with a job would be a millionaire.
It's astonishing to think about,
but it's true.
These better ideas and better
systems were available
and had been proposed before
Bush and since, but
boomers nearly unanimously
opposed all of them, which is
why, again, it's a little hard to stomach
the claim that they were scammed
by the system and now we have to keep it intact.
So they get paid out because, you know,
fair is fair.
Yeah, they were scammed, scammed, sure,
but for the most part,
they categorically opposed any effort
at all to fix the scam.
Bush's doomed Social Security reform
was merely a last-ditch effort
to fix a problem that boomers
and their predecessors created
over a period of many years.
This is something, you know, people don't talk about anymore,
but it's important to go into some detail here
so that you fully understand how older generations
have sabotaged the economic process
of young people in this country
and why they did it.
This is not, I know when we talk about this,
it's generational warfare.
It's not generational warfare, it's just history.
Okay?
This is what actually happened.
And when you see that, you'll see why it's necessary
to take decisive action to reverse the damage
that they've done.
But we can't do that unless we're willing to talk
about what the damage was, and I'm sorry if that's, you know,
if that's going to be offensive to some people,
but that's just it. I'm sorry.
Some really, really terrible decisions were made.
And, in fact,
these were decisions that were made by, you know,
not made by young people today.
They weren't around for it.
And a lot of young people are making their own bad decisions,
but not these.
Finding a T-shirt that looks good, feels well-made,
and doesn't cost a car payment is harder than it should be.
Somewhere along the way, shirts became either $12
and see-through after two washes,
or $90 and sold by a guy who calls it a capsule.
My producer got tired of that and found Mack Weldon
after listening to this show.
They make classic menswear that looks good
without being flashy or complicated.
Their Air Knit X collection follows that same philosophy.
Breathable nylon mesh with four-way stretch,
so it moves with you without bunching, sagging,
or feeling restrictive.
It's lightweight, moisture-wicking, and odor-fighting,
but still looks like regular, well-made clothing.
They've got Air Knit X in T-shirts, polos, undershirts, socks, and more.
And if you need something with sleeves and buttons,
their Tech Linen Button-Up is breathable and wrinkle-resistant.
With a relaxed fit so you can skip the ironing,
it's all made for guys who want to stay comfortable all day
and still look presentable without putting any more thought
into getting dressed than absolutely necessary.
Go to MackWeldon.com and get 20% off your first order
of $125 or more.
Promo code WALSH.
That's M-A-C-K-W-E-L-D-O-N dot com.
Code WALSH.
When you're a kid and somebody asks what you want to be
when you grow up, you just say something.
Astronaut, vet, professional, dinosaur.
or maybe nobody checks your qualifications.
It's the one truly free marketing
of ambition. Well, at some point, that turns into an actual decision, and a lot of people
just never finish making it. If there's a version of that old plan still sitting in the back of your
mind, Grand Canyon University has online undergraduate programs in nursing, business,
education, and technology. The grown-up version of whatever you said you wanted to be back then,
they build their program around the free market along with a Christian worldview and open
discourse, and they back it up with real scholarship and financial aid so a private
education doesn't have to be out of reach. Whether you're starting college or going back,
after years away, GCU is built to help you get there and figure out what your purpose is while
you're at it. At seven, nobody checks your qualifications, but at GCU, they help you earn
them. They say higher education is outdated, irrelevant, but at Grand Canyon University,
they don't settle for the status quo. They shatter it. GCU's accredited MBA program is
100% online. It's designed to shape leaders through servant leadership.
GCU can help you.
Take your passion and scale your business to serve your community. This is purpose-driven
education. Take action. Find your purpose. Grand Canyon University. Visit gcu.edu.
Okay, so in the 1960s, at the height of the civil rights movement, LBJ's Great Society and
War on Poverty created massive entitlement programs, including Medicare and Medicaid,
which provided health care to the elderly and the poor, respectively. The SNAP or Food Stamp
program was also created, along with the Department of Housing and Urban Development,
which funneled billions of dollars towards public housing.
The SNAP program was also created, along with the Department of Housing and Urban Development,
which funneled billions of dollars towards public housing, rental assistance, vouchers, and so on.
Then there was the massive expansion of the public sector, where the government went out of its way
to create jobs for Black workers, from the postal service to the DMV to the transit system to those
random unmarked government office buildings where, you know, you wonder what anyone does there. The
answer is they don't do anything. All of this was on top of Social Security, which was created
decades earlier. Now, none of this happened. We would not have any national debt today. We'd have
a massive government sector. We'd have a massive government
surplus. We would have saved trillions of dollars every few years, going back decades. And on top
of that, we wouldn't have had to make any interest payments on our debt, which have compounded for so
long that these interest payments now exceed our annual defense budget. What does this mean in
practice? Well, with a massive national surplus, we could have eliminated or reduced income and
payroll taxes for most Americans. We could have done that. We could have no income tax. We could
have issued an annual dividend to everyone to make it easier to buy a home or start a business. We
could have invested in a lot of different things. We could have invested in our own country to an unprecedented degree. But in the name of civil
rights and attempting to integrate Black Americans with the rest of society and the interests of
waging a quote-unquote war on poverty, LBJ and the Democrats created all of these massive programs.
And here's the key point. When the opposition party, quote-unquote, took over, instead of
scaling these programs back or finding some way to pay for them, namely by raising taxes,
if you're going to keep them and pay for them, that's the only way to do it.
Everything intact. Ronald Reagan won landslide victories by promising tax cuts without any
meaningful reduction in government spending on all of these welfare programs. He explicitly
promised to keep the social safety net for the elderly, and the boomers were thrilled. They got
more money in their paychecks, and in the immediate aftermath, all of the major economic indicators
turned positive for a time. This was Reagan in 1985 taking a very premature victory lap. Listen.
In 1981,
he announced that the American people would have to pay a huge tax cut to make their living.
And Reagan said, "We're going to make a huge tax cut to make our lives better. I'm going to
make a huge tax cut to make our lives better." And Reagan said, "I'm going to make a huge tax cut to
make our lives better." And Reagan said, "I'm going to make a huge tax cut to make our lives better."
And Reagan said, "I'm going to make a huge tax cut to make our lives better." And Reagan said,
"I'm going to make a huge tax cut to make our lives better." And Reagan said, "I'm going to make a huge
tax cut to make our lives better." And Reagan said, "I'm going to make a huge tax cut to make our lives
better." And Reagan said, "I'm going to make a huge tax cut to make our lives better." And Reagan said,
Now, what Reagan doesn't mention here is that by 1985, federal receipts had dropped to 17.2% of GDP
compared to 19% in 1981. So the government was taking in much less money relative to the size
of the economy. And meanwhile, federal spending was going up, creating a very large deficit of
5% of GDP. So our economy was expanding, yet the federal government was still running a huge
deficit. The budget was not remotely balanced. And then just one year later, Reagan poured gas
on the fire, signing an amnesty bill that granted a pathway to legal status for millions of illegal
aliens. He claimed it would ultimately reduce illegal migration, but of course, it accomplished
the exact opposite result. Foreigners realized the U.S. government would reward them for invading
our country, that we didn't have the willpower to deport them. So in just a few years, low-income
Mexicans took over large portions of California, which as a result, will never again elect a
Republican like Ronald Reagan. In addition to permanently changing the landscape of American
politics,
this demographic transformation put millions more people on our welfare rolls, and the deficit
continued to grow. Ronald Reagan would then become, of course, deified by future generations
of Republicans and disgust among conservatives with the same reverence we have for George
Washington, even though the fact is he helped to bankrupt the country and he kick-started the
illegal immigration crisis that has destroyed countless lives. As Christopher Caldwell writes
in his book, The Age of Entitlement, quote,
Actuarial and from a human capital perspective, the quarter-century after Ronald Reagan's
election should have been the easiest time to balance the budget in the history of the
public. The entirety of the vast baby boom generation, making up 38% of the population,
was in its productive years. There were relatively few retirees and dependent children to tend
to. The country was, until the Iraq War after 2003, at peace. It set the rules for the global
economy, but since baby boomers were due to leave the workforce between 2010 and 2030,
big obligations for Social Security and Medicare loomed. These would go,
et cetera. Instead of meeting those obligations, the boomers and Reagan Republicans chose the path
of least resistance. Quote, the borrowing power of the baby boom generation was invested in avoiding
the choices that the confrontations of the 1960s had placed before the country. We should understand
that Great Society as the institutional form into which the civil rights impulse hardened,
a transfer from whites to blacks of the resources necessary to make desegregation viable.
Desegregation was the most massive undertaking of any kind in the history of the United States,
like any massive undertaking that required endurance, patience, and prohibitive expense.
Almost everyone who did not benefit from it was going to be made poorer by it. The best evidence
we have is that it was too much for most Americans from the beginning. The rhetoric that brought
Reagan to landslides was, among other things, a sign that Americans were unwilling to bankroll
with their taxes the civil rights and welfare revolution of the 1960s and the social change
it brought in its train. So the boomers simply enacted tax cuts without cutting entitlements and
government spending.
The tax cuts, Caldwell writes, provided a golden parachute for the white middle class,
allowing it for one diluted generation to recreate with private resources a Potemkin version of the
old order. Now what? Well, people who weren't even born when these decisions were being made
now have to pay for those decisions. This is generational theft at scale.
Quote, by 1989, the year Reagan left office, according to an estimate by the economist
Roy H. Webb of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, the government's unfunded liabilities,
mostly for Social Security, Medicare, and veterans benefits, had reached four to five,
I should say, trillion dollars and would rise exponentially if nothing were done. Nothing was
done. By the time of the 2016 election, a calculation of those liabilities, similar to
Webb's, ran to at least $135 trillion. Ten years later, some estimates pegged those liabilities at
over $200 trillion.
And while no politician wants to talk about a solution to this problem because it would destroy
their political future, I'm not running for office. So here's the truth. A lot of the online
boomer hate is cliched and undeserved. Hating or scapegoating an entire generation is a ridiculous
practice and certainly unhelpful. There are plenty of boomers who are great people. My parents are
boomers. They're great people. But that doesn't change the fact that taking huge chunks out of
the paychecks of young working Americans in order to pay for the retirements of older Americans
who have a net worth several times higher and who elected the politicians who bankrupted the
country, all to prop up a system that everyone knows likely won't be there when those younger
people are retirement age themselves, is morally abhorrent and economically insane. Everyone knows
it. But we're held hostage by elderly politicians who refuse to surrender power,
and older voters who, as a group with exceptions, obviously, simply don't care enough about the
financial and cultural future their grandchildren will inherit. And here's the other truth that I
mentioned before, but I'm going to reiterate. On average, boomers are getting paid more from
Social Security than they ever, quote, paid into it. A lot more. Like double. And that's counting
inflation and interest. In particular, low earners and couples with only one breadwinner receive
benefits that are many times greater than their contributions via taxes. And raw dollars,
they'll get, again, four to seven times what they paid in. And if they're married with spouses who
never worked a day in their lives or paid any payroll taxes at all, those spouses are getting
up to 50% of the benefit as well. And all the while, younger workers who cannot afford to keep
this system afloat are being forced to do so anyway, even as they struggle to afford what
should be the basic features of life in the most powerful country in the world, features like a
house and a little bit of a property, you know, and a car. So we have a problem, a massive problem.
Something has to be done. We have to start somewhere. And here's one compromise that would
at least stave off insolvency and save billions. What if you get back what you paid in, quote,
But no more. Young, struggling families will not be forced to finance a 250 percent return on your, quote, investment.
And that seems reasonable, doesn't it? I mean, it doesn't go nearly as far as I would like, but it's a compromise, a fair compromise.
It negates any claim that you didn't get the money back that you, quote, unquote, paid in.
And it would resolve the most pressing problem, which is that we are running out of money, not just for Social Security, but for everything.
And yet I suspect that this compromise will not be satisfactory.
Why is that? Well, because this debate actually has nothing to do with getting back what you paid in.
The real demand is for a lot more than that.
As that poll from Cato demonstrates, the real demand for many older, on average, wealthier Americans is to extract as many resources as they can,
even if those resources come from young people who cannot afford to pay.
What's so insidious about entitlements is that no one ever, under any circumstances, wants to give them up.
Ever.
And Social Security is no exception.
But at the risk of disappointing the folks who have, you know, made casinos very happy on Wednesdays,
the unavoidable fact is that sooner or later, this particular entitlement will come to an end.
Will. It has to.
The only choice now is whether it ends in financial disaster.
Or in a deliberate, phased wind-down that gives your children the same opportunity you had,
which is the chance to save money, buy a home, and start a family that one day will do the honorable thing
and pass its wealth down to the next generation.
That'll do it for the show today. Thanks for watching. Thanks for listening.
Talk to you tomorrow. Have a great day. Godspeed.
Every significant movement in history has started with protesting.
You're a traitor!
Uncle Tom!
This is our generation's civil rights!
I have no idea what the protest is about.
Bingo!
Given the current climate, should a figure as polarizing as Clay Saunders even be allowed on campus?
Uh, can you hear me okay?
Saunders is a close personal friend of Chancellor Friedman. This is a decision I cannot fight.
Islam will conquer the West.
As-salamu alaykum.
Are we paying attention?
They've taken over the building. They're downstairs.
And they've blocked the doors.
I seek forgiveness from Allah, the Almighty.
We cannot run and hide.
Muhammad is the messenger of God.
There is no God but Allah.
What do you say we turn those SOBs into a fine red mist?
As we move, one man will cover while the other guys go.
They call that leap project.
Stretch your mouth and listen.
You need a course in safety.
Safe weapons handling.
Watch out, here I come.
So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are.
Including these places.
Age and location restrictions.
Price and supply.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Observe.
The North American dad.
50s.
Great polo collection.
He enters his vehicle information on Carvana.
An offer appears in minutes.
Remarkable.
He squints, reads it again, smiles and says,
Dang, that's a good offer.
The highest form of approval.
No haggling.
No hassle.
No one called him.
Boss.
He's still on the couch.
Astonishing.
Sell your car today on Carvana.com.
Pickup fees may apply.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Social Security is a financially unsustainable system, with benefits projected to fall to 78% of scheduled levels by 2032 due to a shrinking workforce and low fertility rates.
A majority of older Americans (89% of those over 65) support protecting current benefits at the expense of higher taxes on younger workers, who are already burdened by high payroll taxes.
Younger workers, especially those earning around $40,000 annually, pay a significant portion of their income in Social Security taxes—up to 12.4%—while retirees, on average, receive 4 to 7 times more than they contributed.
Critics argue that Social Security is a Ponzi scheme, where older beneficiaries are paid from the taxes of younger workers, and that the system has been deliberately maintained through political inaction and voter resistance.
Historical decisions, such as the expansion of welfare programs in the 1960s and the tax cuts under Reagan without spending reductions, created long-term fiscal burdens that younger generations now bear.
Proposed reforms like George W. Bush’s individual retirement accounts were rejected by retirees who feared losing benefits, demonstrating deep generational resistance to change.
The current system fails to provide real ownership or financial control over retirement savings, with money effectively lost due to lack of transparency and accountability.
A growing number of Americans advocate for a phased, equitable wind-down of Social Security to prevent future fiscal collapse and ensure younger generations are not exploited.
Summary:
Social Security is facing a severe financial crisis due to a shrinking workforce and declining fertility rates, with projections showing only 78% of benefits will remain by 2032. A large majority of older Americans—89% of those over 65—oppose reforms, insisting on protecting current benefits through higher taxes on younger workers. 4% in Social Security taxes, while retirees receive 4 to 7 times more than they contributed.
Critics argue the system is a Ponzi scheme, where older beneficiaries are paid from younger workers’ taxes, and that decades of political decisions—such as expanded welfare programs and tax cuts without spending controls—have created a burden passed to future generations. Historical proposals like Bush’s individual retirement accounts, which would have given younger workers control over personal investment accounts, were rejected due to fear of benefit cuts. Despite the system’s flaws, older voters resist reform, often claiming personal sacrifice while ignoring the fact that their generation helped create the unsustainable structure.
The consensus is that the system must be reformed or phased out to prevent future collapse, with younger generations bearing the cost of a flawed legacy. This shift demands not only fiscal responsibility but a reevaluation of intergenerational fairness and the long-term health of the economy.
FAQs
The system is unsustainable due to low fertility rates, a growing elderly population, and insufficient workers paying taxes. It is projected to run out of funds by 2032, and beneficiaries receive significantly more than they paid in, often four to seven times over.
A majority of Americans aged 65 and older, along with those aged 55-64, support protecting benefits even at the cost of higher taxes on younger workers, believing it ensures their own retirement security.
On average, retirees receive more in benefits than they paid into the system—up to four to seven times their contributions—due to inflation and interest, which means the system is not a savings plan but a form of government investment.
Young workers pay a significant portion of their income in payroll taxes (up to 12.4% for Social Security), while many of them earn less than older retirees and face financial hardship, making the system unfair and regressive.
George H.W. Bush proposed allowing workers to divert 4% of their payroll taxes into personal retirement accounts. The plan was rejected by retirees and unions who feared losing benefits, and it was abandoned amid political opposition and public fear.
Because it relies on younger workers' tax payments to fund benefits for older retirees, with no actual savings or investment returns, and the system is fundamentally unsustainable due to demographic shifts and declining worker contributions.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.