Ep . 137 | Inside the TWISTED Polygamist Cult of Samuel Bateman

This is Blue from the UPS Store, with a very special holiday announcement for small business owners. We're open! Let's be real, your deadlines don't take holidays. So while the other guys are checking out, the UPS Store is here to pack, ship, print, shred, notarize, and check more things off your list all year long. With over 5,500 locations, there's a Blue near you at the UPS Store. Shredding services are provided by Iron Mountain as is. Visit theupsstore.com slash shredding for full details. As most locations are independently owned, product, services, prices, and hours of operation may vary. See store for details. Oh, oh, oh, O'Reilly! Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on? Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE-certified master technicians. And if you need help, we can recommend a shop for you. Ask for O'Reilly Veriscan today. Auto Parts! In some faiths, one man speaks to people on God's behalf, not just as a guide, but as the final word. He says what is true, and he says what you can and can't do. For one community on the Utah and Arizona line, however, that man was gone and had been for some time. Nobody had taken his place, but the silence wouldn't stay empty for long. This is the story of Samuel Bateman. Crime, conspiracy, cults, serial killers, and murder. All things that I love to consume, and I know you do too, you sick, twisted, beautiful, intellectually minded freak. And today we are talking about a pretty infamous cult that I feel like nobody knows about. Because it happened after another infamous cult that I have already gone into. So without further ado, let's unbuckle our seatbelts, go Mach 5 down the highway, slam all the brakes, and bust the windshield into this cult together. Let's take a quick break to talk about the most relentless stalker in my life. Her name is Baby, and she's right behind me, isn't she? She is, she's sleeping, aww, she's so cute. But every morning at around 6am, she'll be sitting directly on top of my chest. Staring directly into my soul. And her motive is that her bowl is empty, and she's pissed at me because she wants her smalls. Now smalls is fresh cat food. Protein packed recipes made with preservative free human grade ingredients you'd find in your own fridge. Delivered right to your door. And every recipe is at least 80% animal protein and gently cooked so the nutrients and the flavor actually survive. And since we switched her, her coat is way shinier. She doesn't hack up as much because she usually like scarfs all her food. And sometimes she throws up. She doesn't do that anymore. And honestly, she just has way more energy. And I actually don't mind scooping the poop out of her litter box anymore. Because it doesn't smell like wet garbage. And it's not just me, because Forbes ranks smalls the best overall cat food. And after switching, 88% of cat owners reported overall health improvements. And if you're spooked by commitment at all, smalls is risk free. They'll refund you if your cat won't eat it. But I bet you they will. I almost tried it at one point, I'm not gonna lie. But your cat's health and longevity starts with what they eat. And for a limited time, because you are a crime conspiracy cult and murder listener, you can get 60% off your first order, plus free shipping and free treats for life. When you head to smalls.com/cccm, that's 60, 6, 0% off your first order, plus free shipping and free treats for life when you head to smalls.com/cccm. Thank you so much to smalls for sponsoring the video and supporting the channel. And let's get back to it. All right. So I know I have gone over what Mormonism is in past videos. We have talked about it. We've talked about Warren Jeffs. I've gone over Mormonism over in this video and another video, I believe. But I'm going to do a quick recap and then a quick recap on Warren Jeffs. Cause this is all very relevant to the case we're looking into today. So in 1823 in Western New York, a young man named Joseph Smith said an angel came to him. And the angel's name was Moroni. And he spoke of golden plates buried in a hill close by with ancient writings engraved on them. And Smith said the angel gave further instruction and that four years later, he dug them up and translated them into English. And they became the Book of Mormon, published in 1830. And it tells of an Israelite family who crossed to America centuries before Christ, taught by the same sort of prophets found in the Old Testament, the Bible. Now Smith founded his church that same year, and it is known today as the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. And the nickname Mormon is taken from the book, but the church would rather people didn't use it. Especially now, they actually just recently came out with saying like, don't call us Mormons. So I'm just saying this all for history sake. I don't want to offend anybody. Now there were many revival preachers in America at the time, but Smith claimed something none of them did. Through him, he said, God had restored the true church and reaffirmed the faith that other denominations had strayed from. Today, the church runs out of Salt Lake City, Utah, and membership is nearly 18 million. And its members have rules against alcohol, tobacco, coffee, and tea. And the faith puts its weight on family life, respect for authority, and sending its young people out as missionaries. And obviously that's a general recap. There's obviously a lot more to being in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, but that is just general. I think if you want to learn more, I have a video about it, right, right there. Go look at that door over there. Now, one belief called continuing revelation is of great importance. And the church teaches that God is still calling prophets to this day. This is important for this case. Now, Joseph Smith took his authority directly from God and every president of the church since has held that same authority to receive a revelation and steer the faith. Basically, they could just like change the rules whenever. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. God tells them to. So accordingly, members formally uphold the president and the quorum of the 12 apostles alongside him has prophets, seers, and revelators. And as the church's fourth president, Wilford Woodruff, asserted, quote, the Lord will never permit me or any other man who stands as president of this church to lead you astray, unquote. So the office is not just for show. The man holding it can change what? The whole church practices. Basically, on God's own authority, though, it's not his. It's God. All right. And this is not a hypothetical scenario either, because it has happened over plural marriage, for example. In 1831, for example, Smith prayed over an Old Testament practice. One man married to more than one woman. And from this, he said he received divine instruction to reinstate it as a religious principle. And he practiced it himself. But the public. Only learned of it under his successor, Brigham Young, who had already taken the church west to Utah by then. And then the federal government spent decades trying to stamp the practice out completely. And by 1890, it was seizing church property. And consequently, Woodruff began to see that the temples and their practices within them were at risk at this point. So in September of 1890, he issued the document known ever since as the manifesto in the church. So in 1904, President Joseph F. Smith went further. And anybody who performed a plural marriage or entered into one would now be excommunicated. Basically, kicked out of the church. And some of those thrown out afterwards gathered into movements of their own. And they are the people sometimes called fundamentalists. This is what we're getting into. This is what the case is about. And in fact, more than 150 separate groups have split away over the church's history. And some of them behind a new prophet. And some of them to hold on to polygamy. Now, since then, there has been confusion about the word Mormon. Because it is a nickname for Latter-day Saints. But it often gets mistakenly given to polygamist groups that have nothing to do with the church at all. So I want to make that clear. And the church has been very pointed about. That in public. As President Gordon B. Hinckley at the October 1998 General Conference stated, quote, I wish to state categorically that this church has nothing whatever to do with those practicing polygamy. They are not members of this church. Most of them have never been members. If any of our members are found to be practicing plural marriage, they are excommunicated. The most serious penalty the church can impose. Unquote. So the people who were cast out didn't think they had done. Anything wrong. Because to them, the manifesto had never been a revelation. Remember, it was kind of just a law that was passed. It wasn't God's word, allegedly. And as Willie Jessup, who would later speak for the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. It's a mouthful. I'm going to call it the FLDS. Told National Geographic, quote, the LDS issued that manifesto for political purposes. Then later claimed it was revelation. Unquote. And instead, their own authority came from an older revelation. One they said. that God had given a church president named John Taylor in 1886, handing a chosen few men the right to keep performing plural marriage forever. How convenient. But anyway, they settled in Short Creek, a scrap of desert country straddling the Utah and Arizona line. Now, polygamist families started arriving in like the 1920s and 30s, drawn to the isolation of the geography. The Grand Canyon was between them and the rest of Arizona. And the nearest lawman, a hundred miles off in Kingman and a state line running near the settlement to step across if trouble came. So in 1935, the mainstream church gave them the option, renounce plural marriage or be cast out. And almost all of them refused. They got too used to the life, you know? And then in 1953, Arizona police and the National Guard drove into Short Creek, carrying out the biggest mass arrest of polygamists in the history of the United States. And the town held around 400 people and 263 of the children were taken into state custody. However, photographs of them being pulled away from their parents turned the country against the raid and the polygamists went underground and stayed there. So the group took its formal name in 1986 when a tax accountant named Rulon Jeffs incorporated it as the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, known ever since by its initials, the FLDS. And at the start of the 21st century, it had around 10,000 members, some 6,000 of them in Short Creek, the largest FLDS community there was. Now an FLDS woman's dress was pastel, long sleeved and cut to the ankle so it covered the white religious garments underneath. And the color denoted the wives of the same husband. And red and black were forbidden outright, red because Christ would return wearing it and black because it belonged to Satan. Now nearly all the children were homeschooled, often by one of the wives while another ran the kitchen and a third did the sewing. And despite their tradition and rules, however, most adults carried cell phones and drove late model SUVs. So there's that. Now an FLDS woman's job, above all else, was to bear children and keep bearing them. Bear down, bear them children. Double digit children, even 16 and more, were pretty ordinary. And the family she built was meant to stay together for eternity. Carolyn Jessup, a former plural wife described it, quote, "I was completely unprepared because I had absolutely no life skills. Most women in the FLDS don't even know how to balance a checkbook, let alone apply for a job. So contemplating how you're going to navigate in the outside world is extremely daunting," unquote. And that was by design. It's the cult territory. But until Rulon Jeffs, the FLDS had been run pretty loosely with a group of high priests guiding it. But he ended that and instituted the one man rule policy. And when Rulon died in 2002, the office passed to his son, Warren, who this video is about up here. And by then there was almost no limit on that rule. And among Warren's first moves was outlawing swimming, television, popular music, and even Christmas. He was the isolation king. And additionally, there were to be no toys, no games, and no pets in the house. And salvation at its highest level was reserved to men with at least three wives. And Jeffs himself, the prophet, of course, decided who married whom. And he could change that too if he wanted to. If a husband was judged to have strayed, his wives and his children could be reassigned to another man. He could be reassigned to Jeffs conveniently enough. And in January of 2004, for instance, Warren Jeffs ordered 21 men expelled and their families handed over. And the community just went along with it because that's just what they knew. And all of that authority rested on a trust called the United Effort Plan. The pioneers and patriarchs of Short Creek set it up in 1942 to provide for the wants and needs of the community. But what it grew into was ownership of the town. The parks, the streets, cemeteries, the schools, the meeting houses, the farms, and the houses. The houses people lived in. So the members essentially didn't even own their own homes. The trust did. And the prophet, Warren Jeffs, piece of shit sicko, ran the trust. And therefore, being thrown out of the faith meant losing the roof over your head with it and just anything else. Like you would just be thrown out with no life skills, basically, and no money. So it was not really an option. I mean, it was an option, but it didn't look that great. Now, eventually, a Utah court took the trust off the FLDS leadership in 2005 and handed it to a manager answerable to the court instead of the prophet, Warren Jeffs. And the assets came out to about $110 million. And of all the groups that broke away, the FLDS became the biggest and best known. And some of the others settled within a few miles of Short Creek. Now, the man running the biggest of them was Warren Jeffs. So, by the time the outside world understood what was really happening inside the FLDS, Warren Jeffs had 78 wives, many of them just 12 or 13 years old. And he kept his own priesthood records. And in 2005, he wrote, quote, "If the world knew what I was doing, "they would hang me from the highest tree," unquote. Sounds like a godly man to me. Just kidding. And he spent years as a fugitive and months on the FBI's "10 Most Wanted" list. Before, police pulled him over outside Las Vegas in August of 2006. And a Texas jury convicted him on August 4th, 2011. Spoilers, sorry. If you, just go watch the Warren Jeffs video, 'cause it is absolutely insane if you haven't seen it. But the two counts were sexual assault of a child under 17 and aggravated sexual assault of a child under 14. And DNA proved he had fathered a child with only a 15-year-old girl. And prosecutors played the jury a recording to find out whether or not he was the father of a 12-year-old. And the only serving they said was him assaulting a 12-year-old, just absolute filth of this earth. And he got the maximum on both counts, life in prison for the 12-year-old and 20 years for the 15-year-old, and one sentence to be served after the other. And he is still serving his sentences at the pole edge unit near Palestine, Texas. And he first becomes eligible for parole on July 22nd, 2038. And he's a member of the church. And every week, his brothers visited and officials suspected the watches and pens they carried were recording devices. And meanwhile, he sent letters out in code collected by wives who knew how to read them. And Sean Keveny, a Justice Department attorney said, quote, "We have evidence he continues to direct day-to-day operations of the church, including things like excommunicating individuals and directing what women should be placed with what caretakers," unquote. Now, the followers who stayed in the church for a year and a half were the ones who had the right of way. And Sean Keveny, who was serving in the church at the time, was the only one who had the right of way. however, did not stay. And practicing FLDS members are now thought to be only a small share of the people living in Hilldale and Colorado City. Now federal prosecutors said the church had been running both towns as an extension of itself, with anyone outside the faith, refused building permits, water hookups, even police protection. So in 2017, a court put both towns under supervision and pulled the church out and their governments and their shared police department. And since only the prophet could arrange a marriage, none had been arranged since Jeff's arrest in 2006. Then by the end of 2011, word had come down that couples were to stop living as husband and wife because Jeff's had declared every existing marriage just void. So husband and wife could share a house, but nothing more until he came out of prison and resealed them to each other again himself. So by 2019, no marriage had been performed in 13 years and families were growing frustrated with a prophet who could not answer them. And into that silence walked a man from Colorado City named Samuel Bateman. And that brings us to our subject of today's video. So Bateman was born in Colorado City around 1976. No exact date of birth has been made public though, and very little is known about his childhood. But his father's name was Deloy Bateman, who was raised inside the household of Leroy S. Johnson, the prophet who led the FLDS before Rulon Jeffs. Johnson sent him to college, which was uncommon for anybody out of Colorado city and he came back and taught science at the town's public school and by 2003 he had been in the district for 20 years on a salary of around 33 000 now most days he would start before dawn he would get five of his teenage children out of bed at two in the morning and an hour later they were at school and in his laboratory ahead of a dozen classes he would teach that day but the town didn't want what he was teaching and john doherty who spent months reporting on colorado City, wrote that most people there did not believe in evolution or dinosaurs, or that America had sent men to the moon. So education past the eighth grade was widely thought just completely unnecessary, particularly with older men by the age of 16, which is so. fucking wrong. And then the church came for Deloy's children and its leaders tried to take four of the children he had by his second wife. And Deloy would not make them the property of the church. And he challenged Rulon Jeffs over the custody of them. And for that, he was branded an apostate. So he left the FLDS and 14 of his 17 children went with him and his three eldest stayed behind. And the eldest of those was Samuel. So around that same time, Samuel's beliefs in the church was getting stronger. Years later, Deloy said, quote, my own kids were taught that I'm the son of Lucifer. Can you imagine? They can never see me again. What's the difference between that and death? I lost a good share of my family to that man. I'd like to see them sometime, unquote. So Samuel's mother is not named in any occasion. of his life that I could find at least. And what schooling he himself received is also not available that I could find. But what I could find is that he showed no early signs of violence or cruelty. And Wendell Jefferson, a son of Warren Jeffs, who left the FLDS himself, remembers Bateman from those years. Quote, you know, when you have a group of friends and you have that one person and they really want to join the group of friends. That's how he was toward my brothers, trying to to the circle of the Jeffs family, unquote. So he just he craved that that that notoriety, that popularity, that power already at a pretty young age. So for most of his adult life, Samuel worked ordinary jobs. He was a machinist, then a realtor, and for a while a motivational speaker. And inside the church, there was no record of him holding an office, a council seat or any position of trust. And a Salt Lake City Tribune photographer caught him in November of 2007 on his way out of St. George Courthouse, where Warren Jeffs was being tried. But he appeared to be there only as one of the faithful. Now, whatever contact he had with Jeffs himself is not documented anywhere. And the only account of it comes from Bateman years later. And he said Jeffs told him to invoke the, quote, spirit of God on these people, unquote. Now, nobody else has ever confirmed it. A lot of these guys are full of shit, you'll come to know. And he would be married to one woman and they had a daughter and at least two sons. And the daughter was the youngest of the children. And by 2019, he was struggling pretty badly financially. And Esther Bistlein, an FLDS member who knew him, remembered him talking, quote, about the fact that he had no money, unquote. And that year, ahead of a day trip to a Utah ghost town, he sent a text message saying, quote, if where we are going tomorrow requires pecuniary additions, I am apologetic in saying that I am in the middle of some dire straits in my financial world, unquote. So on the 13th of February that year, he told his wife and his daughter that the two of them belonged to him and that he intended to marry the daughter. Yeah, I hate this man. And she, at this point, was 14 years old. And around the same time, on a drive back from Canada, he asked her whether she had been praying over the man she would marry. And he gave her 50 dollars and two bags of Doritos and promised her an airplane ride. And he told her that, quote, if his feelings were right, he would make her have a child, unquote. And they told her not to talk to her mother about it. Now, her mother, however, refused to agree to any part. And her lawyer, Charles Seifer, filed with the court, quote, thereafter, there were multiple incidents of violence between the Burnham and Bateman, in which the father acted, angrily to Burnham's refusal to approve his plan to have sexual marital relations with their daughter, unquote. So on February 25th, a court granted her an order of protection and Bateman was barred from contacting either of them. But that didn't stop him from trying anyway. And Seifer said he may have used his sons to reach his daughter and asked a family friend to write to her on his behalf. The letters, according to the filing, argued that her father's incestuous desires were inspired by the divine and in line with what the family believed. Also, witnesses saw him talking to the girl after a horse riding trip at a ranch outside Colorado City. And her mother found footprints around the property and thought he had been watching the girl. And then in April, she found her daughter with a mobile phone she believed Bateman had given her so that he could keep talking to her. Now, the marriage was dissolved that year, and the court ordered him to pay $1,271.50 a month in child support. Still, he was never thrown out of the FLDS, though he did eventually choose to leave it. And by the end of 2019, then he had no wife, no daughter, and no money and no standing in the church he was raised in. Let's take a quick pause for me to make a confession, okay? I am a salty sweet person. Kettle corn, salted chocolate, that flaky salt on top of a ooey gooey brownie. Oh my God, my mouth is watering. I carry sweets in my purse like people carry around hot sauce or gum. So, when Kachava came out with their new salted caramel flavor, I was in immediately. It's a plant-based whole body shake. Two scoops, and you've also got protein, fiber, greens, and a lot more in one deliciously simple shake. So, there's no fillers, and there's no nonsense, and no artificial flavors, colors, or sweeteners. It's also non-GMO, no soy, no gluten, no preservatives. And caramel, or caramel, if you prefer to say that, is salt's perfect sidekick. All the craving, none of the sugary drawbacks. And when I first drank it, I just feel like I'm drinking a dessert, but it's really nice to know that I'm actually getting fiber and protein and a bunch of other really good stuff. So, embrace your salty side and go to kachava.com and use code CCCM for 15% off your first order. That's Kachava, K-A-C-H-A-V-A.com. Using code CCCM. Thank you so much to Kachava for sponsoring the video and supporting the channel, and let's get back to it. So, in early 2019, Bateman started spending his time with a man named Moroni Johnson. Johnson had grown up in Short Creek, too. He and his wife Julia married in 1995, and in 2001, Julia's sister joined the marriage as a second wife. Now, there were eight children from Julia and Moroni's relationship, and the two men began teaching something the FLDS had never allowed. A woman, they said, could pray and receive revelation about her own marriage without needing the prophet to guide her. Julia later said, quote, "This was not well received by the FLDS," unquote. No, she didn't fully support this new doctrine. It was received very well by people who had been waiting 13 years for permission to marry. Remember, Warren Jeff said, "Nobody can marry in the FLDS until I get out of jail." But that's still, you know, well, gosh, it's too soon, but like 15 years out, or not even, but it's still like 12 years out, which is crazy. But Julia noted, as others felt, quote, "We wanted children and sex. I wanted a baby. It was a common sentiment," unquote. So that year, Moroni started taking more wives, but Julia still didn't accept unions that Jeffs had not approved. Quote, unquote, "It was a devastation," she would say. Quote, "We were leaving the church and not being obedient," unquote. And then Bateman went further than doctrine, and he told the families that the reason nobody had heard from Warren Jeffs was that Jeffs was dead, or translated, which in the faith means taken from mortal life into an immortal one without dying. So Samuel Bateman was the prophet now, he would say, and Jeffs would be heard only through him. So having claimed that, he began asking for things. He wanted their money. He wanted them to testify in the religious context about him. And of course, he wanted more new wives. So later in 2019, the Johnsons moved from Short Creek to Nebraska for work, and Bateman followed them out there. And other FLDS families moved to Nebraska too, and Bateman started marrying. And by the end of 2020, 13 women and girls had been married to him. Meanwhile, Bateman's recruiting campaign for more wives and followers spread through Arizona, Nebraska, Utah, and Colorado, and the people around him began calling themselves Samuelites. Jesus. So in 2020, the FLDS leadership responded to and reprimanded Bateman with a revelation of their own. The revelation confirmed that Jeff was, in fact, alive in prison and was the only prophet. And it called Bateman and his followers, quote unquote, "gross and wicked men." And the revelation read, quote, "Father yet lives, and is the mortal keyholder prophet on this world." Unquote. I feel like I'm just reading like a big D&D thing or something. A really fucked up D&D thing. But anyway. Now, Esther Bistlein watched the split happen from inside Short Creek. And she remembered the families who followed Bateman communicating or visiting people in Short Creek and looking at the FLDS, quote unquote, like were weird for still writing to Jeffs in his cell. Quote unquote, "Why would you do that?" She remembered them saying. Quote unquote, "Why would you do that?" Listen, I'm going to settle this. You're both fucking weird. Okay? Both fucking weird and gross, and I hate it all. But I'm going to still read. I digress. So of Bateman's teaching, she said, quote, there were so many things about it that just didn't line up with our FLDS beliefs, unquote. And in 2021, Bateman brought some of his people back to Short Creek. And he now drove a Mercedes. And he had more than a dozen wives and could fill two SUVs with them. And he would tow a flatbed trailer through the red dirt roads with his wives sitting on it in two rows singing. And one woman who watched him do it said he was showing them off. Quote, like they were his prize horses, unquote. Now, whether Bateman truly believed he was a prophet is a question these years don't fully settle. I'm going to safely say he's just a full of shit piece of shit. But that's my opinion that several of the people who followed him came to one answer. They later said that he had been taking advantage of the fact that Jeff's was not there. And another answer is simply that. He was doing what the world he was raised in had taught him a man could do. Which was to say God had spoken to him and wait to be obeyed. Now, regardless, what we can see is just how much Bateman's life had changed in a very short period of time. It only took two years before he had been homeless and broke and family-less. Now, life seemed to be looking up for him. And he had multiple wives and a Mercedes or multiple cars and a house. And it's just crazy. Now, Bateman had amassed about 50 followers. He had taken at least 20 wives for himself, with 10 of them being under the age of 18. And of the 10, most were younger than 15. Again, fucking monster. Disgusting. Waste of oxygen. Literally just a Warren Jeffs 2.0. And most of the wives came out of just two families in the group of his followers. And his male followers paid for him. And they handed over their own wives and their own daughters to be married to him. Julia watched it happen to her family twice. In Nebraska in 2019, he took her oldest adult daughter as a wife. There was no ceremony. And the young woman was never asked in front of witnesses whether she agreed to it even. Julia said she thought it was wrong. And the other followers shunned her for even saying that. And then Bateman and Julia's oldest pressured another one of the daughters to also marry him. And Julia said that her second daughter told her she didn't want to, and wanted to wait. And she said she could see it turning into something forced. But still, Bateman ignored that and married her anyway, because he could. And the youngest girl he showed off as his wife had been born in 2011. That meant she was only nine years old in late 2020, when Bateman pulled up outside a house in Colorado City with a car full of women and girls, and introduced her to the family. And introduced all of them as his wives. Now, around that time, a couple named Christine Marie and Tolga Katas were being led inside the group. And she ran a charity that worked with people in Short Creek while he was a filmmaker. And Bateman let him bring a camera along. What they saw included a confession of the occasion the group called the atonement. Bateman allowed three grown men in the group to sleep with three of his wives, all, while he stayed and watched. And the youngest of the three girls was 13. God had told him to give up, quote, the most precious thing he has, unquote, he would say, which was, according to him, his girl's virtue. And he told the girls they had given it up for the Lord and that God would repair their bodies afterwards. So in November of 2021, in the back of his own Bentley, he explained the occasion to Marie, while she recorded him and he called the three men he had ordered to do it, quote, unquote, wicked bastards. And he also said, quote, I've never had more confidence in doing his will, it's all out of love, unquote. And on a second recording, he went through it again and said that watching had cost him a great deal personally. So in Colorado City, the group had two houses, the followers lived in the large one known to them as the Blue House, and Bateman kept it strong. He kept its top floor for himself and his wives, and nobody else was allowed up there. He lived with his wives in the smaller one, the Green House, and it was crowded. And Katas would describe, quote, there are 24 ladies and him sitting there, and every day there would be two girls in the back crying. And the next day it's another two girls, unquote. Bateman also spent time in a small warehouse the group had. And Torrance Bisline handled the money for the group. He was a very successful businessman. And he bought Bateman his fancy cars and covered his legal costs. Meanwhile, Liddell Bisline, Jr. supplied girls for the group, his own daughters amongst them. And among the women Bateman had married were Naomi Bisline, Dawnay Barlow, and Maretta Rose Johnson. Now, Maretta was under 18 when he took her as a wife, and she had a child seven months after her 18th birthday. Now, Bateman traveled frequently, going back and forth to Nebraska. Where a portion of his followers lived, and abroad for conferences to Canada and Mexico. And it would later be alleged that between May of 2020 and November of 2021, he and others moved minors across Nebraska, Nevada, Utah, and Arizona for sex. And inside the group, he ran a system of confession and punishment. Followers had to confess anything they had done wrong out loud, and he passed those confessions around. And the penalties ran from being put in a timeout to being shamed in front of everybody to sexual activity. And he told them each one had come from the Lord, of course. And he said God wanted his followers to take part in sexual acts, the children included. So when Arizona child welfare workers started coming around, he tightened things up. cameras up and he asked julia johnson whether she had been talking to the police and he gave code names to his wives and the group set up places to hide out in the desert and he also moved his messages onto signal an encrypted app that keeps them off the phone company's records and he would turn the families in on each other too when julia's teenage daughter got pregnant he cut julia completely off from her daughters. And she was still living in the blue house and she was ordered to keep clear of the greenhouse where her daughters were located. And her own daughters were even messaging her with obscenities. And then Julia noticed the long religious underwear the wives had always worn had been swapped with lingerie. And the adult women in the group weren't only victims of the abuse itself. Julia admitted that she had been present when Bateman engaged in sexual activity with other followers, including the underage ones. And she described going numb as the girls he married got younger, even her own daughters. And similarly, when welfare workers asked to speak to two of the girls alone in 2021, the girls' mothers refused and said there was nothing wrong going on. Equal monsters in this story, the mothers. It's unbelievable and unfathomable. I just. It's disgusting. Now, in day-to-day life, Bateman continued to assert his divine influence to his followers. He told them he had, quote, impressions of Heavenly Father's will, unquote, and he used the impressions to get his wives and his followers to submit to him, and they called him Father. The influence also spread to the children, and in February of 2021, Gattas filmed a talent show at the Blue House. Thirteen women and girls sat around Bateman, and a few men sat on the edges of the room. Two of the girls picked up guitars, and Gattas asked them how old they were, and one of them said, we're both ten. And then two of them sang for Bateman. The song was about loving father. Girls in the group kept journals, and several had written about sleeping with Bateman, kissing him, and touching him. All right. Before we get back to the case, why are guys the hardest people to shop for? Like you ask them what they want and they're just like nothing. And two weeks later, he's showing you some gadget he bought for himself. It's like, that's not very helpful. So this year we're getting ahead of it. Okay. Because Ridge has basically solved gifts for guys because they have their five in one travel power bank and the cables are actually built in. Not to MagSafe wireless charging, an Apple Watch charger, lightning, and USB-C. So he can charge everything he owns without a tangle of cords. 20 watts and 10,000 milliamp hour battery. That's up to three full phone charges, by the way, for the guy whose phone is somehow always at 10% like my man's. And it's part of their biggest sale of the year right now at ridge.com slash CCCM. And besides getting it as a gift. I'm a wallet person. I keep Ridge's tracker card in mind. So I'm not screaming in my house now, have you seen my wallet? I can't find my wallet. I just spiral out of control. It doesn't happen anymore. So shop early without the stress. Ridge gives you a 99 day risk-free trial. So buy now and give it in December. And he has until February to decide. And if a power bank isn't his thing, then they've got wallets, tracker cards, phone cases, and luggage. There's a gift for every man in your life or honestly for you, screw them. And for a limited time, Ridge is having their biggest sale of the year. So head to Ridge.com slash CCCM to get up to 49% off. That's Ridge.com slash CCCM for up to 49% off. Plus qualifying orders can score holiday extras like gift bags and classic cuff beanies while supplies last. And after you purchase, they'll ask you where you heard about them and please let them know that I sent you. All right. Thank you so much to Ridge for sponsoring this video and supporting the channel. So in Short Creek, a number of residents had called law enforcement about Bateman. Sergeant David Wilkinson of the Hilldale and Colorado City Police Department said, quote, reports were coming from a lot of different directions, unquote. And the first of those calls on record came in November of 2020. And on the 23rd, a woman phoned the Colorado City Marshal's office to say that Bateman had married the granddaughter of a friend of hers, a minor. However, someone close to Bateman assured the Marshal's office that Bateman had married the granddaughter of a friend of hers, a minor. That quote, the stories were just rumors, unquote. And when officers had a conversation with the girl herself, she denied having any relationship with him because obviously he had groomed her at this point. And that's all she knew what to say. And a second call came one day later, this time from the actual grandmother naming another girl that Bateman had taken as a wife. And that granddaughter had been born in 2011. And she added that his own daughter, who was born in 2005, might be the daughter of Bateman. And she said, well, I don't know. I don't know. I don't they let him go. And in December of 2020, his daughter was interviewed by local investigators. And she handed them a document of her own, which was called a Journal of Events. And in it, she had recorded the dates her father brought each new wife to meet her, the young girls among them, who were called mother. And Arizona's Child Welfare Agency, the Department of Child Safety, had tried to visit the group several times as well. And in May of 2021, two of the girls had parents who would not talk to the caseworkers at all while denying anything improper was going on. And the caseworkers asked to speak with some of the girls alone as well. But the mothers would not let them be interviewed in that way. How the fuck is this happening? Parents lie. Adults lie. They should be able to, the law should be able to take those children away to talk to. It's just, the justice system failed these children. And it's abhorrent. So back in 2015, a flash flood killed 13 women and children in the state of Arizona. And it's abhorrent. And it's abhorrent. And it's the two towns which initially brought christine marie in to help she had been raised mormon and had studied cults for years and her own former husband had claimed to be a prophet and the marriage had been abusive and in 2016 she and her husband tolga katas left las vegas for a small stucco rental in hildale and there she started a charity called voices for dignity which served anyone who came to the door whether they were staying in polygamy or leaving it and she handed out school supplies and food and for flds members uneasy about using the internet she went online and found housing information for them now her own estimate of the number of people she helped in short creek ran to about 2 000 and of that number a few dozen at most ever left polygamy now bateman had come into their lives in 2017 two years before he claimed to be anybody in fact her charity was one of the things that had helped hold him up in 2019 while the divorce with his first wife was going through and for some years katas had been at work on a film about how flds people actually lived and bateman heard about it in 2021 and to katas he looked desperate to get in on it and what bateman wanted was youtube videos of himself and neither of them was willing to hand him a platform but still marie decided they should film him anyway because she thought quote they'll get used to it and we'll catch them with some evidence unquote so throughout 2021 they filmed bateman his family and his followers day after day and the recording marie made in the back of the bentley that november was the first thing she took to the police and she called police as soon as she got home and said quote-unquote i got the bombshell you've been waiting for she had spoken to wilkinson about bateman multiple times wilkinson said quote there were allegations but we did not have any witnesses coming forward and giving details of specific crimes that were occurring unquote because what the department had lacked was somebody describing a specific crime and bateman had now described one himself in the recording at least however wilkinson felt the small department did not have the resources this case needed and so in the summer of 2022 the fbi was asked to take it over finally and that same summer marie listened to bateman belittle moroni johnson and it left her frightened for his safety as well as her own and she hoped that she might feel more protected by making things official quote-unquote i kept saying i want to be official marie was signed up as an official fbi informant and agents told katas to send in whatever footage he judged useful and katas said quote every day there was so much evidence that was being turned in it was terabytes of stuff unquote now the two of them doubled their time inside the group from 20 hours a week to essentially the equivalent of a full-time full-time job and katas even lost income by turning away paying film jobs marie said quote the more sam's followers loved me the more i went home and cried unquote meanwhile juliet johnson had begun turning up in marie's yard where her small son could play with the animals marie kept her animals as a way to steady herself and the people who came to her so on a friday in july of 2022 julia said out loud to marie that she was afraid of what bateman might do marie said she told her quote following samuel to hell is not doing right unquote and julie answered quote it isn't and uncle warren says a woman does not have to follow a man to hell unquote and marie then told her about the prophet in her own past and said quote you're going to save your children all of this is to save your children unquote and julia said afterwards that this was the moment that was the turning point for her and she told the fbi everything she had already said to her husband quote we're following a false prophet and he's leading us right to hell and i'm not going to go there anymore unquote now warren levi moroni and julia's son met with marie and katas in secret as well and he said quote starting in 2019 sam married seven of my sisters ranging in age from 20-ish down to nine years old every one of them referred to him as the devil unquote and around that time marie learned what bateman had been teaching about people who crossed him and certain unworthy people had to die in order to be saved he taught and their blood had to be spilled to do it the teaching was called blood atonement and it framed the killing as a kindness and marie asked him who qualified for it and bateman said quote people who intentionally go against the prophet unquote aka himself and marie described the situation quote that would include me we were on pins and needles unquote so on the 28th of august 2022 at a gas station on highway 89 at silver saddle road a department of public safety motorist assistant reported an enclosed trailer with people inside children among them and a trooper found him a few miles on out on interstate 40 and the trooper saw what the department later described as quote children's small fingers moving in the gap of the rear trailer door unquote bateman eventually pulled over his suv carried two women plus two girls younger than 15 and a box of ammunition sat in the suv's center console three more girls were shut in the toad trailer aged 11 12 and 14. the trailer had no air vents and it was august in northern arizona one of the hottest places in the united states of america their toilet was a bucket with a trash bag in it and a toilet seat on top and there was a couch and camper chairs back there none of it fixed down and no seat belts and then the rear doors were also not properly latched the women and girls told the trooper they were on the way to phoenix or tucson but specifically they were headed to scottsdale to a seminar on real estate run by a motivational speaker grant cardone and the girls had been on the phone with bateman for nearly the whole drive detectives tried to speak with the whole group but only the oldest woman said anything and bateman was booked into coconino county jail charged with child abuse on three counts and from the jail he started making calls he got several of his wives on the line and the young girls among them and told them to delete signal remember the app that blocks any sort of phone companies from seeing what is being said quote unquote the whole thing delete every message right now and he also demanded that every woman and girl obtain a passport and his wives tried to delete his account and deleted their own and a search warrant came through two days later and then on the first of september his family put up $150,000 in bond and he walked out. Why are bonds a thing? I will never understand. So Christine Marie rode along the back of the vehicle that got him from jail, phone in hand, recording. And he got in beside two of his wives and asked, quote, "What I was wondering, is there a way to factory reset a phone?" unquote. Marie said, quote, "I sent it to the FBI before we even got out of the car," unquote. And his followers, meanwhile, were collecting a paper shredder for his wife's journals. And five days after that, a federal grand jury indicted him. And the three counts were tampering, destroying records in an official proceeding and destroying records in a federal investigation. And not one of those counts was about the children though, which is baffling. And federal authorities wanted to know whether children had been taken from one state to another for sexual activity. But what they could prove that week was the evidence destruction because he had ordered it on a recorded jail phone. And the following Tuesday, the 13th of September, the FBI would go in. And a week or so earlier, Katas had told Bateman that people might be watching the property and offered to fly a drone over it for him. In reality though, he was diagramming the house and its entrances for the FBI. Bateman said, quote, "That is so smart. This is why God sent you to me. You're so smart," unquote. So the morning of that raid, Katas arranged to meet Bateman at the warehouse saying he wanted to film an interview. And Marie was dropped at the greenhouse. And Bateman showed up to the warehouse with three of his wives. And then the FBI made their move. Katas said, quote, "There were like 25 people who were in there in a second," unquote. And agents pinned Katas to a wall the same way they pinned Bateman so nobody in the room would know. And agents went to the greenhouse next and called the women outside with their hands up. And Marie was inside recording and walking each of them out through the front room. Quote, "I felt as if I was walking them to freedom," unquote. Now, agents confiscated electronic devices from three properties. And the devices showed the group still talking on signal, which had never actually been deleted. And the next day, the 14th, the Arizona Department of Child Safety took nine girls into custody. And on the 15th, in Federal Magistrate Court of Flagstaff, Bateman pleaded, "None." "Not guilty." And his lawyer, Adam Zickerman, said he was no danger to the community. However, Judge Camille Bybles ordered him held as the case progressed through the courts. We love to see it. And she noted he was a pilot and a survivalist with followers and overseas contacts who could raise money for him on short notice. Again, clapping for this judge. And she also said the position the young girls were in concerned her. Quote, "Courts have a tremendous interest in protecting people who can't protect themselves." Unquote. So on the day of the raid, his family and followers gathered around to listen to him call from police custody. And Naomi Bistlein, Donna Barlow, and Maretta Rose Johnson continued forward with operations for him in his absence. So the nine girls that were taken into custody were split between group homes with sisters kept together. The FBI believed they kept talking to one another in a shared signal thread. And forensic interviews were carried out. With the girls at the Children Welfare Agency. But not one of them described being abused by Bateman. Because at this point, I mean, they're completely brainwashed. Though one said she had been present and partially nude at one of the group sexual encounters. So agents went back to five of the girls whose journals had been taken in September. But those five would not fully take part in questioning. And the FBI believed the older girls had told the younger ones to stay quiet about Bateman. And the girls said, "I can't talk to you." So on the Sunday after Thanksgiving, the 27th of November, eight of the nine left their group homes. And one girl stayed behind. Bistlein, Barlow, and Johnson collected the other eight and drove them to California and then to Washington. Johnson, at one time, had been one of the younger girls herself, taken as a wife under 18 and had since turned 18. Bateman was in a federal cell by then. And that night, he video called one of his adult wives and the call was recorded. And the video showed two women driving and they told him they had two of the girls with them using code names E1 and E2. And a later call showed two of the child wives sitting behind them. And he called again the next morning and asked why W2 was not with them. And that was the girl still in Arizona custody. And his wife told him they tried. And Bateman said to get that girl because it puts pressure on him when they are scattered, unquote. And then the camera panned off the two women and onto the eight girls. Johnson told him in another call, quote, "We are helping you," unquote. But a credit card gave them away. It had paid for an Airbnb in Spokane, Washington, booked from Tuesday through Friday. So on the 1st of December, four days after the girls left, Spokane County Sheriff's deputies found Johnson and all eight of them there. She was arrested walking out of the rental with the girls. And the nine went back into state custody. And this time nobody was told where so as to keep them safe. And a 22-page complaint charged Bisline, Barlow, and Johnson with kidnapping and with obstructing a federal prosecution. And two weeks later, a grand jury indicted the three of them on four counts each, adding conspiracy to both charges. And kidnapping alone carried punishment up to life in prison. And until then, Bateman had only been charged with tampering and destruction of evidence. But that December, however, Bisline, Barlow, and Johnson were folded into his case. And kidnapping and conspiracy counts landed on all of them, including Bateman. So the first superseding indictment took Bateman from three counts to seven. And then in May of 2023, a second superseding indictment charged him with producing child pornography. And it described him traveling between Arizona, Utah, Colorado, and Nebraska, and having sex with the girls regularly, which they had been looking to prove for some time. It also brought in seven more of Bateman's followers and the sex charges with them. So by January of 2024, a third superseding indictment had taken the case to 59 counts, 52 of them against Bateman himself. 18 counts were for enticing minors into sexual activity through interstate commerce, and 12 for transporting them to engage in sexual activity. Now, ultimately, the kidnapping was what finally opened the case the government had not been able to build in September. So Bateman took a plea deal in April of 2024, admitting to two counts out of the more than 50 felonies he faced. One was conspiracy to commit kidnapping, and the other, a conspiracy to move a minor between states for criminal sexual activity. And he acknowledged he had taken 20 wives, including the 10 underage girls, in spiritual marriage, he would say, and admitted his purpose had been to engage in sexual activity with minor girls. Now, prosecutor Demetri Sampson wrote that the deal existed to keep his victims off the witness stand, and because he had taken responsibility for his actions. But still, they ended up on the stand anyway, describing the abuse at the trials of two of Bateman's male followers. And the sentencing was on December 9th, 2024, in a federal courtroom in Phoenix, before Judge Bernevik Bateman was in a jail jumpsuit, his wrists in shackles, and Marie and Katas were in the room. And Sampson put photographs of the 10 underage girls up on screen, and named each one of them. The courtroom looked at their young, smiling faces. The youngest had been nine. Bateman was not a man of God or a prophet, Sampson argued, but a man running a ring that sexually abused children and coerced them into marriage. Because he and two of the men following him had seen the vacuum Jeff's left, and made him profit for the purpose of obtaining, quote, "new wives, sexual activity, and more children," unquote. And Sampson wrote, in a sentence, quote, "These men were not victims of the FLDS teachings. "They created their own ideology "to serve their selfish interests, "and they elevated the defendant as their new leader "to accomplish their goals," unquote. And without a few brave people who went to the police, the men, quote, "fully intended to grow this conspiracy," unquote. And parents of the abused girls were in the courtroom, but they were there for Bateman, rather than for their own daughters. And Sampson said, quote, "These girls have become the adults in the room, "and they are the role models for others "that their parents should be for them," unquote. Now, Bateman's attorney, Brian Russo, asked for 20 years served at a treatment center, and he cited a psychiatrist the defense had hired, who called Bateman, quote, unquote, "mentally ill and delusional." And that psychiatrist's opinion, as Russo put it, was that Bateman's, quote, "upbringing in a certain lifestyle was an indoctrination "that normalized certain behavior that is, quote, "otherwise criminal conduct," unquote. Then the girls spoke, and one of them had been 14 in 2021, when Bateman chose her as a wife. And her mother was one of his followers and handed her over like a piece of meat. And within weeks, he began having relations with her. And she said to him, quote, "I wasn't old enough to consent, and you know it," unquote. And she had brought a list written on lined paper and red ink of everything she had done since his arrest. She is in high school, she got her driver's license, she wears the clothes she wants and dyed her hair and she performed in a school play and she said quote now you can see i never needed you and i hope you get everything you deserve which is absolutely nothing unquote and another who was 17 by then said she was speaking for the child she had been who felt like a quote slave unquote and had no voice she spoke for the nine other girls too who suffered quote at the hands of the man sitting in the defendant chair today you hurt me deeply what you did was evil it was wicked and shameful you left wounds that will never heal in my life unquote and then she turned and looked at him and a third had been nine in 2020 when he took her as a wife and began abusing her she said quote as a child i had no understanding of what was happening to me i was too young my innocence was stolen despite what you think i am no longer a little puppy running to your every command i am a proud young woman continuing to grow older and stronger every day unquote now given his chance to speak bateman shook his head and said nothing now bernovic was not moved by the psychiatrist and she said quote you are the one who manipulated the rules of this religion you are the one that made yourself into a prophet so to speak and used that to victimize these women and girls who as the government points out are now survivors unquote and she sentenced him to 50 years plus supervision for life now outside the courthouse marie and katas held each other and marie said quote justice was served i'm proud of the flds women that were strong enough to take a stand against abuse and i'm proud of every one of those girls that spoke up unquote and liddell jay bistlein jr who had handed bateman two of his own daughters at nine and eleven was convicted at trial and sentenced to life in prison and torrence bisline who had paid for the cars and raped one of the teenage wives got 35 years the sentencing guidelines had called for him to receive around 11 years but samson called that wildly inappropriate and the judge agreed bernovic told him quote you were not isolated like some of the other defendants there has been no showing of remorse unquote josephine bisline two of whose daughters were among the victims got 15 years and leilani barlow who buried her underage daughter to bateman got six years and danae barlow who deleted the messages and drove the girls out of arizona got time served six months of house arrest and three years of probation less than the government had asked for which is and naomi bisline and maretta rose johnson each got time served and three years of probation so bateman is currently still serving the 50 years and the supervision after it lasts the rest of his life and exactly where he's going to be serving the 50 years of probation and the supervision after it lasts the is being held however is not clear st george news reported he was in federal custody at florence arizona but the bureau of prisons listed him in march of 2026 as not in its custody which can mean he's being transferred or located at a county or private facility and meanwhile the three felony charges from the initial traffic stop arrest in which bateman was towing that trailer sat unresolved for nearly four years and the case finally reached a coconino county jury in june of 2026 and the case was brought to court in june of 2027 and the case was brought to court in june bateman represented himself and he told the jury quote i have a clean slate a very clean slate so please keep that in mind i am not a child abuser unquote just lying through his disgusting teeth and they took just half an hour to bring back a unanimous verdict convicting him on all three counts and then on august 25th 2026 judge joshua steinlage sentenced him to another 24 years to be served after the federal 50. and steinlage cited the insane the girls had been in along with other factors. Bateman, still representing himself, did not ask for leniency. Quote, I love these dear people with all my heart, and I had no intention in the entire world to harm them, unquote. And one of the girls from the trailer, 14 at the time, told the court that when she was 12, he had taken advantage of her sexually. She said she had needed therapy for, quote, things that should have never happened to me as a child, unquote. And in a statement afterwards, the county attorney, Ammon Barker, said, quote, today's sentence is about accountability for the harm done to these young victims. It also ensures that Mr. Bateman will never again be in a position to harm a child, unquote. And to a number of his followers and adult wives, he is still the prophet. He has allowed many calls a day from prison, and he makes them. And Rachel Dretzen, who directed a Netflix series about the case, called Trust Me, The False Prophet, said prison had strengthened his hold rather than broken it, and that his followers considered him to have been martyred. And Marie said, quote, that communication with him is like an IV of indoctrination. It's like they're getting fed certainty right into their veins, their belief that he is talking to God, unquote. And of the adult wives, only Naomi Bistline and Maretta Rose Johnson testified against him. Bistline still lives in Short Creek and passes away. And she's still alive. And she's still as followers in the street from time to time. And all nine of the underage girls, however, have left, thankfully. And they were taken out of the community and placed in foster care. And every one of them testified. Short Creek is not what it was now. The court supervision that pulled the church out of the town's governments and their police department was lifted in the summer of 2025, nearly two years earlier than expected. And those still practicing the faith are now thought to be a small minority in the towns. And the compound, the faithful built for Warren Jeffs, is a rental property now. And behind its walls, he had kept a vineyard and a hairdresser from St. George bought the land, taught himself winemaking and built a tasting room on it. And Hildale's mayor is Donya Jessup, a former FLDS member and the first woman to run the town. And she says many of the 10-foot concrete walls around the old compounds have been torn down. Marie is actually still there, living in the same small town as the women who have not left town. Those women deserve a life of freedom. They deserve to find true love. They deserve to know what reality is. You can't be free if you're living in a world of fiction, unquote. And that is the case of Samuel Bateman. It's very, a very tough case to look into. You guys did suggest it. So please let me know what other cases you would like me to deep dive into. Let me know what you guys think down in the comments. And until then, I will see you beautiful face. And please don't forget to subscribe to my channel. And I'll see you in the next video. Please, please stay safe out there. All right. Bye. We believe that better happens together. We're a locally owned bank built on relationships and personally committed to your success. Our community bankers are ready to make quick decisions. No big bank bureaucracy, just a custom approach to help you thrive from business loans to mortgages and everyday banking needs. Harmony Bank provides a secure modern experience with a We're Harmony Bank, where better happens together.