Ep. 121 | The Mysterious Murder Of Kathleen Peterson | The Staircase

Olen Shannon Maldonado, käsintehtyjä artesaanitua teita myyvän jaujialahjakaupan perustaja. Valitsin Shopify, koska alustoja testatessani totesin sen ehdottomasti yhdeksi helpokäyttöisimmistä alustoista. Minulla oli tärkeää pohtia kehittymistämme tulevaisuudessa. Kaikki myyntiin tarvittavat työkalut, kuten varaston suunnittelu ovat kätevästi dashboardissa. Aloita ilmainen kokeilu Shopify piste komsi vustolla. Verustin pyöräilyvaatteita valmistavan ornotin vuonna 2013. Mielestäni parasta Shopify saan se, että voimme harjoittaa liiketoimintaa ilman teknistä osaamista. Voimme hallinnoida yrityksen taustajaristelemiä ja frontendia sekä myydä verkossa, vaivatta. Jos Shopify olisi pyöräilyvaruste, se olisi mielestäni itse polkupyörä. Sillä asiat hoidetaan ja meidän liiketoiminta me hoituu Shopify'sssä. Täällä on laittaa Nuremna-Kiralinaa, mutta se on kokeilu, joka on kokeilu. Ja se on hienoa 5 joittaa joku suurin 3 famuus. Ja se on kokeilu, joka on kokeilu, mutta on kokeilu. Mutta on kokeilu saa jatkoin saa jatkoin 2001. Se on kokeilu, että se on kokeilu, että se on kokeilu, että se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu 2 sekä, että se on kokeilu, mutta se on kokeilu. Täällä on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu, mutta se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. Ja se on kokeilu. scenes. And she was a board member of the Durham Art Council and threw her weight behind the American Dance Festival and the Carolina Ballet. And she was part of fundraisers and put real effort into making each party feel like something people wanted to attend. Not just, you know, like another obligation. They quote, "She was the Martha Stewart of Durham. She actually prepared the food for her parties," unquote. Jimmy Gibbs, the columnist, told the Durham Harold Sun. And cooking was where Kathleen unwound. And her annual tradition was a round of shortbread cookies. Each one finished with a layer of powdered sugar. "Oh, I love shortbread so much. It makes me hungry." And she had a signature past a salad she brought to dance festival events. And she was just described as spontaneous and fun and had a tremendous sense of humor. And Caitlin also said of her mother, quote, "It was really easy to just kind of fall into amazement of this person who could just keep you entertained and laughing," unquote. And by the time Kathleen landed back in Durham after her divorce, she had a career on an upward arc, a daughter she adored, and the life she was actively rebuilding. Now the two families found each other by accident. And Michael split from his first wife Patricia in 1987 and brought two young girls he'd been raising, Margaret and Martha Ratliff, from a late family friend with him to Durham. And Clayton and Todd, his biological sons, were still living with their mother Patricia in Germany at the time and would eventually follow him to the States. So at around this time, Kathleen and Caitlin landed on the same street after Kathleen's divorce, from Fred. And Caitlin first bonded with the Ratliff girls, and their friendship is what pulled Kathleen and Michael into each other's orbit. And Caitlin remembered the moments the adults made it official. The family gathered her and asked what she thought about Martha and Margaret moving in with them. And to Caitlin, it sounded like a permanent sleepover. And Kathleen had a one-on-one conversation with Caitlin and told her this was their family now. So the two households merged within a couple of years. And by 1997, both divorces were behind them, and Kathleen and Michael got married, and they actually purchased their house together years earlier. So in August of 1992, Michael and Kathleen bought the property at 1810 Seedor Street in Durham's Forest Hills neighborhood. And it was a 11,000-plus square foot colonial revival mansion. Oh my god. Originally built in 1940 on a four-acre parcel, and the front hall was anchored by a staircase that hung from above in a sweeping arc. A design local said to be unmatched anywhere in the region. Five children from three different families lived under that roof, and the house was naturally always busy. So the picture was just admirable. A big house in a respected neighborhood, a blended family that just worked, and two really accomplished adults who were deeply in love. And everyone around them just echoed it. And once the kids left for college, Michael and Kathleen filled the house in other ways. They threw parties, showed up at fundraisers, and built a social life around the people they love spending time with. And Michael had what the New York Times called a theatrical personality, and the Seedor Street mansion gave him a stage that matched it. And Kathleen's energy matched his from a different angle. And her sister, Candice Zamperini, remembered how effortlessly she managed should all say, "Not only did she raise these children and have quite an accomplished corporate career, oh dinner for 50, she'd do it." So she's basically a superhero. So friends saw a couple that genuinely enjoyed each other's company, two people whose warmth together seemed easy and so unforced. But naturally, as every picture perfect family has their flaws, there were some seams. And in 1999, Michael ran for mayor in Durham. During the campaign, the truth about his purple heart surfaced publicly, and his claim of being wounded in combat fell apart. And he lost the race. And with it, a piece of the public credibility he'd spent years building through his columns and civic presence. And Kathleen carried pressure of her own work with her. And Nortel Networks was shedding staff due to the declining economy, and she worried she'd be next, and the finances kind of told their own story. The Peterson's had accumulated around $140,000 in credit card debt. And Michael hadn't earned a dollar from writing in three years. So the family's finances ran through Kathleen's paycheck, and three of the five kids were in college now, so it was getting expensive. Now to mention, six rental properties the couple owned were bringing in less than expected. And Kathleen held Nortel stock options that had peaked above $2 million, but had dropped to less than $50,000, which is scary. So they were described as living above their means. And other financial records painted a less dire picture, because they reportedly had cars, furniture, and teeks, and other assets that brought the couple's total worth to roughly $1.5 million. So it's not like the couple were completely broke. They had, you know, $1.5 million in assets, but obviously there was some financial strain. So on December 8, 2001, Michael and Kathleen settled in to watch a movie together, America's Sweet Hearts. And they'd been in a good mood all day. Earlier that day, Michael had gotten word about a possible movie deal involving one of his books, and the two of them treated it like a reason to celebrate. Because it may have been a long shot, but the possibility alone was enough. So after the movie, the two of them took their wine outside and sat by the pool. And at some point, Kathleen decided to head inside. She had a conference call scheduled early the next morning and wanted to get some sleep. And Michael didn't follow her in, and instead he sat by the pool with his pipe. And he wouldn't come back inside until around 2.40 in the morning. And by his account, he spent a few hours alone in the yard after Kathleen went to bed. And by the time he came back inside, Kathleen was on the floor at the bottom of the back staircase. And she was injured and unresponsive. And he would tell a neighbor afterward that it must have been an accident. That Kathleen had been drinking wine and had taken Valium, and that she must have slipped and fallen. And he told the same thing to police. She'd mixed alcohol with medication, lost her footing on the stairs, and had gone down hard. And at 2.40 am on December 9, Michael dialed 911. And he told the dispatcher that his 48-year-old wife had had an accident. And the dispatcher would ask several follow-up questions. And at around 2.45 am, just minutes after the first call, Michael called 911 a second time. And this time, he reported that Kathleen had stopped breathing. And in the span of roughly five minutes, the situation had gone from breathing injured wife to something far worse. And emergency responders arrived at the Peterson home on Cedar Street shortly after. And blood on the front walkway caught the attention before they even made it to the door. And Kathleen was on the floor at the foot of the staircase face up. And she was wearing a sweatsuit, and she was surrounded by blood. And Michael was there beside her, covered in blood himself. And Kathleen was unfortunately pronounced dead shortly after. And the cause was head trauma. Let's take a quick pause to talk about one of the sponsors of today's video. And that is Surfshark. Now Surfshark isn't just one app. It's a whole security kit for your digital life. My favorite part is the email scam checker. You paste in any sketchy email sitting in your inbox, I have a lot of them. And it tells you whether it's a scam or a phishing attempt. And there's also a web content blocker for parental trolls. And alternative ID, which masks your real name and contact info so you can use generated details on sites you don't trust. So way less spam and way fewer data leaks. Everything you browse stays encrypted as well. And it locks down your webcam by default. Yes, people can actually hack into your webcam. So creepy. And one subscription covers unlimited devices at the same time. And Surfshark just reached coverage in 100 countries. The only VPN to do it. So go to surfshark dot com slash call me Chris and use code call me Chris at checkout to get four extra months of Surfshark. There's also a 30 day money back guarantee. So it's completely risk free. That's surfshark dot com slash call me Chris using code call me Chris. Thank you so much to Surfshark for keeping me safe online. And for sponsoring the video and supporting the channel. And let's get back to it. So Michael was on the floor with Kathleen holding her body and crying. He later described the moment to found her quote. That was the worst. I mean, that was worse than anything in war unquote. But the blood was kind of telling a different story than the one he'd given on the phone. I mean, he was panicked in that moment so you can, you know, excuse some mistakes in what he's saying. But what it looked like was that the blood on the staircase in walls had already dried, suggesting it had been there for much longer than a few minutes between Michael's 911 calls and their arrival. And Durham police detective Art Holland looked at the scene and knew something was wrong. And he told investigators quote, I've seen falls. I've had family members fall and to me it didn't look anywhere like fall. And Kathleen's sister pandas eventually got inside the house and saw it for herself and said quote, my sister's blood is washed and cools up against the wall. I mean her blood was everywhere, unquote. And there was also a swipe mark on the wall. One that looked like somebody had attempted to clean up blood and hadn't quite finished the job. And blood was also found on the souls of Kathleen's feet. And additionally, investigators collected two large drops of blood from the back patio. A spot completely removed from the staircase and from where Kathleen's body lay. And the side door that opened onto the patio had a blood stain on it as well. And the kitchen sink held a few drops of blood as well. And Michael's shoe print was found on the back of Kathleen's cap. And fingerprint expert Joyce Petska examined the impression and confirmed it matched his shoe design and wear pattern. And Petska described the impression as consistent with someone pressing straight down, not sliding or shifting sideways. And his shoes and socks sat on the floor right next to where Kathleen lay. And in the kitchen, an open-wind bottle in two glasses were sitting out on the counter. And Michael's fingerprints were on both glasses and the bottle. And Kathleen's fingerprints weren't on either that they could find. And Michael had blood on his clothes and his skin. And at one point, he went to wash his hands, but officers pulled him back. And responders were no longer sure they were actually looking at an accident. So at the house, the on-seen medical examiner looked at the gashes on the back of Kathleen's head and initially thought a fall could explain them. But the sheer volume of blood gave everyone pause. In medical examiner Deborah Ratish performed the full autopsy and found seven deep lacerations across the top and back of Kathleen's scalp. And the autopsy also revealed that Kathleen's body had been deprived of oxygen in the time before death. And the report documented bruises on her face and arms along with contusions across her back and the back of her arms. Her legs, knees, feet, and ribs showed no signs of bruising at all though. And the thyroid cartilage in her throat sustained a fracture. And Kathleen's fists were gripping clumps of hair. And there was blood lodged under fingernails. So forensic pathologist Dr. Tom Sporen explained the severity of those lacerations saying, quote, "Skelt lacerations can bleed very, very profusely. So it is possible she could have had some of her death hastened by blood loss from these scalp wounds." In other words, she did not die instantly as a result of having received these injuries, unquote. And he was blunt about what the wounds looked like to him saying, quote, "This type of complex lacerations and evulsions I have not seen with falls," unquote. So despite the lacerations in her scalp, Kathleen's skull was intact, with no fracture, no brain injury and no swelling. In most blunt, forced cases, those injuries go hand in hand. In the toxicology report, put Kathleen's blood alcohol at 0.07, barely below the legal limit for driving, and showed volume in her blood at a standard therapeutic dose. And as mentioned, Michael had told the neighbor that she'd been drinking wine and had taken a volume. And the toxicology report confirmed that much. And once the autopsy was complete, the medical examiner conclusion was direct, and it said, what happened to Kathleen did not match a staircase fall. In radish rule, the cause of death as blunt force trauma. And for Kathleen's daughter, Kaitlyn, the autopsy report changed. And she later said, quote, "You need to read this. You need to understand that mom, she did not die from falling down the stairs. She was beaten to death," unquote. And investigators in the medical examiner now agreed this was not an accident. So as the investigation widened, detectives pulled on every thread they could find. And the first thread involved a fireplace tool called a blow poke. Which, if you're not familiar, is a tool you blow through a long metal tube to feed oxygen to the fire, with a hook on the end for repositioning logs. Now the Peterson's owned one, a gift from Kathleen's sister, actually. Between the several cuts on Kathleen's scalp and the sheer amount of blood in the stairwell, it was believed she'd been hit with something. So investigators considered the blow poke the most likely candidate. But there was one problem, and that was that it couldn't be found anywhere in the house. And the second thread came from Michael's computer. Because when investigators pulled the data, it was a massive haul with 1165 email fragments and records showing visits to roughly 8,700 websites. And among those were homosexual pornography sites and correspondence with a male escort who went by Brad. In the most recent exchanges went back to September of 2001, putting them just three months ahead of the night Kathleen died. Michael and Brad had never actually met in person, and one of the emails conveyed the scenario. Michael told Escort he was "very by" and went into specific detail about what he was looking for. And in another, he insisted his marriage was solid, "I've got a dynamite wife who I love. I'm sorry, I like men and women." And there was no evidence that Kathleen knew about any of it. And even without proof that she knew, the emails could be used to challenge claims that the Peterson had a story book marriage. Investigators had a theory about what might have happened that night. And Kathleen's co-workers, Helen Prislinger, had sent an email to Michael's address at Kathleen's request earlier that evening, and Kathleen opens Michael's computer to pull up that email and stumbles across the escort messages or the pornography and a fight breaks out. And the third thread ran through the couple's finances. Unlike we spoke about before, the financial strain had already been documented that a credit card debt and dwindling income Kathleen carrying the household on her Nortel salary. Kathleen carried a $1.4 million dollar life insurance policy. Also, as she'd originally named her first husband Fred at water as the beneficiary, but after marrying Michael, she changed it to him. And on top of that, around $384,000 in additional Nortel payouts hung in the balance. Deferred compensation, pension funds, and 401k savings, etc. Investigators believed Michael might have killed Kathleen to collect on the policy. And with 11 days left before Kathleen's death, Michael sent an email to Patricia in Germany about Clayton and Todd's spiraling credit debt, urging her to look into a $30,000 home equity loan to bail them out. He told Patricia he was worried sick about the boys, then wrote, quote, "It is simply not possible for me to discuss this with Kathleen." Michael sent an email to a family friend on December 3rd just six days out from Kathleen's death, venting about the Nortel situation saying, quote, "Poor Kathleen is undergoing the tortures of the damned at Nortel. They've laid off 45,000 people, she's a survivor, and in no trouble, but the stress is monumental there," unquote. So if Kathleen lost her position, the household had almost no other income. And the fourth thread reached 16 years into the past. And when Michael and Patricia were still married and living in Germany, one of their closest friends was a woman named Elizabeth Ratliff, and she worked as a second-rate teacher at a U.S. Department of Defense School, and her husband George Ratliff had died in 1983 during a secret military operation overseas, and leaving Elizabeth a widow at a young age. And after George's death, Michael fell into a routine with Elizabeth. He started showing up at Elizabeth's house almost every night once dinner was over, washing dishes, reading bedtime stories to her two little girls, and then heading back. And he was the last person to see her alive. And one morning in 1985, someone found Elizabeth Ratliff dead inside her home at age 43. Her body crumpled against the lowest steps of a wooden staircase, and the German investigation ruled it a natural death. A cerebral hemorrhage had struck and she collapsed on the stairs. And she had cuts across her scalp, the same type of laceration found on Kathleen. And German authorities blamed them on the tumble down the stairs, and the staircase was streaked with blood from bottom to top. And in the days leading up to her death, Elizabeth told people she'd been suffering from intense headaches and had a doctor's appointment lined up for the next week. And her daughter's Margaret and Martha were two and one year old when their mother died. And the Peterson's were Elizabeth's next-door neighbors, and after her death, Michael and Patricia brought Margaret and Martha into their home and raised them. So for nearly two decades, Elizabeth's death remained a closed case in Germany. And then, Kathleen Peterson died at the bottom of a staircase in Durham, and investigators started looking backward. And in 2003, authorities exhumed Elizabeth's body in Texas. The medical examiner from North Carolina performed a new autopsy and reached a conclusion that overturned the original German finding. Elizabeth had not died from a cerebral hemorrhage. She had died from blunt, force injuries, and the ruling was homicide. So two women connected to the same man found at the bottom of staircases years apart, both with lacerations to the head. Michael Peterson had been the last person to see both of them alive. So four days after Kathleen died, a memorial service was held at Duke Chapel, the towering Gothic Cathedral, at the center of the campus where both Michael and Kathleen had gone to school. She was buried at Maplewood Cemetery, in an obituary ran in the local paper, and for a brief window, the story was still one of grief rather than suspicion. And then 11 days after Kathleen's death on December 20, 2001, a grand jury indicted Michael Peterson for first degree murder, and he turned himself in after the indictment came down. And the charge rested on the medical examiner's determination that Kathleen's injuries ruled out a fall. Peterson was a former herald son columnist, a novelist, and one time candidate for mayor. And Durham already knew his name and that recognition pulled the local media in hard. And as the case moved forward, the attention only grew. And Caitlin's first instinct after losing her mother was to stand with her stepfather naturally. She believed what Michael had told everyone that her mother's death was just a terrible, tragic accident, a freak fall on the stairs and nothing more than that. And it took a few days before Caitlin could bring herself to walk back into the Cedar Street House. The staircase where her mother had been found was boarded up. And the kitchen hadn't been straightened up. Hard flowers and casseroles that covered the counters alongside bottles of wine and liquor that grieving friends and neighbors had dropped off. Christmas now was only days away, but nothing in the house reflected it. At that point, Caitlin had no reason to doubt Michael's version of events. And no one had publicly confirmed that the autopsy findings were inconsistent with a fall. So at this point, she was grieving her mother, surrounded by people who loved Michael and believed him. But Caitlin's disbelief didn't hold. And as the investigation proceeded and the evidence mounted, the picture she'd accepted began to crack. By October 2002, less than a year after her mother's death, Caitlin had completely shifted far enough to take legal action. And she took on the role of a state administrator and brought a civil wrongful death suit against Michael. And the filing made her position clear. She no longer believed it was an accident and she intended to make sure Michael could never profit from what happened. And Peterson's biological sons, Clayton and Todd, took the opposite position, and they stood by their father from the beginning and never wavered. And Michael would maintain his innocence and his sons accepted that without qualification. And Margaret and Martha Ratliff raised by Michael since they were small, also remained loyal to the man they called dad. So the family that had looked so unified from the outside was now split along the fault line of Kathleen's death. So jury selection began on May 5, 2003, nearly a year and a half after Kathleen's death. An opening statement followed on July 1, and George Orlando Hudson presided over the Durham trial, which, in the week, deemed the city's longest and perhaps most sensational trial to date. And testimony stretched across 13 and a half weeks before the case finally went to the jury. And the state's case was in the hands of Durham District Attorney James Harden, an assistant district attorney, Frieda Black, sat on the prosecution table with him. And Harden was on the DA, whose office Michael had repeatedly targeted in his herald son Collins. And now he stood across the courtroom from the man who'd spent years criticizing him in print. Peterson's defense attorney was David Rudolph. And according to the state, Peterson bludgeoned Kathleen with a blunt object and then arranged the scene to pass for an accidental fall. And their proposed motive was money, specifically the 1.4 million dollar life insurance policy on Kathleen's life. And Harden and Black pointed to the couples growing credit card debt and argued Peterson saw the payout as a way out. And Rudolph countered with a version that fit the physical evidence differently. And he would say, quote, "No one thought Michael could have ever harmed Kathleen." And indeed, there was never a shred of evidence that they had ever had so much as a loud argument, unquote. And also, the defense argued that Kathleen lost her footing at least twice on the poorly lit back staircase, and each time her head cut the sharp molding on the way down. And she'd been wearing flip flops and had consumed wine and volume that evening. And Rudolph turned the autopsy against the prosecution. Seven lacerations covered the top and back of Kathleen's scalp. And there was no brain injury and no swelling. And he backed the claim with data, pointing the jury to state autopsy records covering 257 killings going back to 1991, and arguing that nothing about Kathleen's wounds matched a beating death. And blood splatter evidence formed the backbone of the prosecution's forensic case. And their expert was Duane Dever, an analyst with North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation. And on the stand, Dever walked the jury through blood patterns found across the stairwell's walls, and on Michael's clothing and on Kathleen's. And he told them, all of it pointed to one conclusion she was blooded into death. And his testimony carried considerable weight with the jury. And the blowpoke had loomed over the case since the investigation began, right? And prosecutors had argued it was the most likely weapon, and its absence from the home suggested someone had removed it. And then, late in the trial, the defense produced it. And Rudolph entered the blowpoke into evidence himself after it was found in the Peterson's garage. It was fully intact, undamaged with no trace of blood. So the prosecution's theorized weapon had been sitting in the house the entire time untouched. But the actual murder weapon was never identified. And the prosecution also brought Michael's private life into the courtroom, when the findings on his personal computer were deemed admissible. And they floated the confrontation theory from earlier, where Kathleen found the emails and photographs and an altercation followed. And a male escort took the stand and testified about his email exchanges with Peterson. And prosecutors used the correspondence to challenge the defense's portrait of a happy stable marriage. And free to black, put the photographs from Michael's computer in front of the jury. And this was her word for what they depicted, quote unquote, filth. Now the defense pushed back on the theory, pointing out that the bulk of those messages sat on a part of Michael's hard drive Kathleen had no way to reach. And if it's attorney Thomas Mayer called the confrontation theory pure suspicion and a whole lot of babies without any evidentiary support, you know, circumstantial. And criminal law professor Kevin McMunnagall of Case Western University assessed the prosecution strategy as a double-edged sword. And he said the evidence was pretty relevant in terms of how happy their marriage was and whether or not they were arguing, but it also was very prejudicial. And he added, quote, you could imagine, especially back then, there could be some jurors who would condemn him for that and maybe decide the case on an emotional basis, unquote. And Peterson himself reflected on it years later saying, quote, what happened in that trial could not happen today. It's just simply not possible for Harton and Frieda racing around showing these pictures, he's guilty because he's bisexual, try that one today in court, unquote, he would go on to say. And he blamed Judge Hudson for allowing it and called it a very homophobic trial. And the prosecution turned to Elizabeth Ratliffe's death, arguing that the parallels with Kathleen's death were too stark to ignore. After Ratliffe's body was exhumed, Dr. Deborah Ratdish performed a second autopsy on the remains. And she was the same examiner who had autopsy pathlean and her finding was identical, death by beating. And the jury would see footage of the exhumation and photographs of Ratliffe's body in the coffin. Peterson understood the damage and who would say later, quote, I think a lot of it had to do with Liz. You're watching the TV and they're at the graveyard. Then they bring the body back and it's filmed all the way. It didn't have any effect on the jury. Are you kidding me? That and the homophobia, here are the photographs of Liz in the coffin and the filth, the filth, the filth, hell, I would have probably convicted me, unquote. Caitlin had once stood beside her stepfather. By the time the trial began, she had crossed to the other side. And she sat through every day of testimony listening to both the prosecution and the defense lay out their cases. And afterwards she would say, quote, the only thing that I have to say about this trial and all the subsequent follow-out is that if there was any closure to possibly come from all of this, it came after sitting through the entire trial and listening day after day to all the evidence on both sides. And after the closing arguments, when all was said and done, I felt confident that I knew what happened. I knew what happened to my mom, unquote. And Margaret and Martha Ratliffe remained on Michael's side throughout. Michael never took the witness stand. Looking back, he called it a mistake, quote unquote, "Oh, absolutely, I wish I had testified." And jury consultant Margie Fargo had pushed more for Michael and his family to testify, believing it would humanize him in front of the jury, but Rudolph would not allow it. And he reasoned that putting Michael or any of his children on the stand meant the prosecution could reopen every damaging thread on cross-examination from the bisexuality to the escort remains to Elizabeth Ratliffe's death. And on top of that, the Purple Heart Fabrication gave prosecutors a ready-made narrative. Michael Peterson was a liar. And Rudolph wrote, quote, "I believe to this day that the right decision was made. I don't believe his testimony could or would have made a difference in the end." The trial was not fair, unquote. And on October 10, 2003, the jury returned its verdict. And the verdict was, guilty of first degree murder. And the judge handed down life without parole. And Michael, at this point, was 59 years old. And he showed really no reaction when the word guilty filled the courtroom. And he faced his family in the gallery and spoke to them directly saying, "I love you." And Margaret and Martha collapsed into each other crying, and Rudolph announced to the court that an appeal was coming. And officers cuffed Peterson and walked him out of the courtroom. And by the time it was over, the Peterson case had become one of the longest, most expensive and most viewed trials in North Carolina history. So as some of you may know, most attempts to quit vaping or smoking fail for one reason. You try to kill a habit without replacing it. And if you've ever tried to just stop, you know how fast that falls apart. I have plenty of members of my family that have tried to quit smoking and have failed again and again. And it's usually around day 5 when the cravings hit and your hands don't know what to do with themselves. Well, that's exactly why fume works. Now fume is a flavored air device, no nicotine, no batteries, no vapor, and it's a weighted, fidget-friendly tool designed to satisfy that urge to reach for something without giving in to old habits. So when a craving shows up, you reach for fume instead. And it comes in flavors like crisp mint, which is my favorite flavor, and it honestly just kind of feels like a reset button, not that I've ever had issues with vaping or smoking, but for me, it's honestly just a fidget hand to mouth thing, and it just feels refreshing. And fume has already helped over a million people take steps toward better habits, and now it's your turn. So use code cccm to get a free gift with your journey pack at trifume.com. That's tr-y-f-u-m.com code cccm to claim your free gift today. Thank you so much to fume for sponsoring this video and supporting this channel, and let's get back to it. So Michael was sent to Nash Correctional Institution in North Carolina, and his legal team challenged the conviction again and again over the years that followed, but every appeal was rejected, including the homophobia angle. And in 2006, the North Carolina Court of Appeals rejected his claim that judicial mistakes in admitting evidence denied him a fair trial, ruling the errors amounted to "hermless error." But in 2009, an unlikely alternative explanation surfaced. In T. Lawrence Pollard, filed a motion arguing that Kathleen had not been beaten by her husband, but attacked by an owl. And Pollard was described as a respected North Carolina prosecutor living next to the Peterson's at the time of the killing. And Pollard proposed that a barred owl had struck Kathleen outside the Cedar Street mansion, and kept lying at her as she ran through the front door. And according to Pollard, the owl's talons caused wounds severe enough to kill her, and Kathleen blood out at the base of the stairs. And he pointed to the pattern of lacerations on Kathleen's scalp, which he claimed matched the spacing one would expect from barred owl talons. And a state Bureau of Investigation Crime Lab report had cataloged a single microscopic feather. And Pollard's motion also cited additional feathers recovered from hair clutched in Kathleen's left hand. And investigators also recovered two small fragments from Kathleen's skull that were never actually tested, but which Pollard believed could have been pieces of an owl's talon. The theory got its most thorough treatment in 2023 when Titi Smith published death by talons did an owl murder, Kathleen Peterson. And even Smith wasn't sold at first. And he described his initial take on the owl theory in his words, quote, "a crazy idea," let me rephrase that, "batch it crazy," unquote. But after examining the case, Smith reversed his opinion, and he wrote that no other theory holds up as well as the owl once you look at the evidence on its own terms. And Smith went so far as to acknowledge that Michael's account of the evening almost certainly wasn't true, but he still pinned Kathleen's death on the bird. And Mark Pinsky reviewed the book for the indie week, bringing decades of experience covering murder cases to his assessment, and he wasn't buying it. And he wrote that the book's argument relied on owl feathers, pine needles, and pieces of talon. And people found the idea fascinating and absurd in equal measure, but it never got Peterson back into a courtroom. Meanwhile, a scandal was unfolding that carried real legal consequences for Peterson's conviction. A Duane Diver had been an 18-year veteran of the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation by the time he took the stand at Peterson's trial. But his credentials were thinner than his courtroom confidence suggested, and his formal training amounted to a zoology degree and two blood stain analysis courses. And he had never actually joined a single professional organization in the field, so the unraveling started in 2010. And a man named Greg Taylor received a 1993 conviction for the murder of a woman near downtown Rayleigh. And at Taylor's trial, Diver took the stand and told the jury that Taylor's vehicle had "chemical indications for the presence of blood." But what he left out, according to later findings, was that additional testing using more advanced methods had come back completely clean. So there was no blood. And in 2010, Taylor walked free after having been locked up for 17 years. In that case, triggered a broader reckoning, and that same year, an independent review found that the SBI's blood analysis unit had produced distorted or outright false evidence across multiple cases. And an independent audit examined 229 criminal pieces handled by the unit. And auditors flagged five cases as deeply troubling. And Diver's name was on all of them. And the SBI terminated Diver in 2011, citing allegations that he had given false testimony across multiple trials. So on February 14, 2011, Peterson's attorneys filed a motion for a new trial. And by December of 2011, Superior Court Judge Orlando Hudson had thrown out Peterson's conviction and granted him a new trial. So Hudson had sat on the bench for the original 2003 proceedings, and now found that Diver's testimony had been materially misleading and deliberately false. Diver had overstated what he was qualified to do and sold the jury on methods that weren't as reliable as he made them sound. And Peterson's attorney Jim Cooney now drove the point home during the appeals process. And he divided the full trial transcript into two file folders and brought them both to court. And Diver's testimony filled one folder. And every other witness in the trial fit into the second. And Diver's was thicker. And Cooney told the judges that Diver, quote, was essentially a fraud, unquote. And that if the jury had known it, the outcome would have been different. So he called Diver the critical witness and by a wide margin, the most significant one in the entire trial. So Michael walked out of prison on December 16, 2011. And he had served eight years at this point. And a judge placed him on house arrest while the case moved forward. The prosecutors fought to preserve the original verdict. And the North Carolina Court of Appeals upheld the new trial order in July of 2013. However, the state Supreme Court declined to hear the case. So as attorneys pushed to get the case thrown out altogether, pointing to failures in how physical evidence from the original investigation had been stored. And that motion was denied in November of 2016. So a new trial scheduled for May 2017, but it never happened. And instead, on February 24, 2017, Michael stood in the courtroom at 73 years old and entered an Alfred plea to voluntary manslaughter. And under the Alfred plea, the defendant doesn't admit guilt, they say, "I still maintain I didn't do this, but I recognize you have enough evidence that a jury could find me guilty." So Peterson still said he did not kill his wife. And Peterson left the court house that day as a convicted felon. But because the plea carried credit for the eight years he had already spent in prison, he was free. And Kevin McMonagall, that criminal law professor from earlier, weighed in on the nature of the deal saying, "A lot of people think it's bad because if a guy is going to be punished by the government, then somebody ought to establish that he committed the crime, either a jury or he should admit it." McMonagall pointed out a consequence most people didn't think about. The moment Peterson took that deal, the system lost any reason to keep investigating what actually happened to Kathleen. And for someone facing the prospect of returning to prison, the temptation of a deal like that was hard to resist. So the case had been open for more than 15 years and the Alford plea closed it without resolving the central question. And the case's reach extended well beyond the courtroom. An Academy Award winner and French filmmaker John Xavier DeLesstrade began filming Peterson and his family shortly after he was indicted. And the footage became the staircase, a docuseries that first aired in 2004 and gave viewers a front row seat to Michael, his family, and the defense team as they moved through the murder trial. And the cameras came back in 2012 and 2013 when his crew documented the legal battle to overturn Michael's conviction and turn the footage into a two-hour follow-up. And three additional episodes were later made for Netflix. The Netflix picked up all 13 episodes in 2018 and put the Peterson case in front of millions of people who had never heard of it. And there was also a private entanglement inside the production. And DeLesstrade's film editor Sophie Brunei fell in love with Peterson during the making of the original series. And their relationship lasted more than a decade spanning the original documentary and its follow-ups. While this may or may not have made a difference, it should be noted that Brunei edited the footage that shaped Peterson's public image while romantically involved with him. I'd say that's a bit biased. TBH. And HBO Max followed with its own dramatized version, also called the staircase, could be any more creative, okay? Which drew from DeLesstrade's original documentary series. So when Michael was free, he wrote three books. And he also stayed in touch with his first wife Patricia. And for a time, the two of them lived together again. And Patricia eventually passed away and Michael moved to Reno, Nevada in 2024. And as attorney David Rudolph, once joked that Michael's new home didn't have a staircase. Nobody's laughing. You f*cking idiot. And Michael has never stopped saying he's innocent. The Alfred plea let him acknowledge the state's evidence without admitting guilt. And he's held that line ever since. And he still insists he did not kill Kathleen. And HBO Max's version of the staircase earned multiple Emmy nominations. And Michael called it a collection of egregious fabrications and made clear he wanted nothing to do with it. And in 2025, Netflix re-released the original documentary series, putting the case back in front of a new generation of viewers. And more than two decades after Kathleen's death, the case still generates arguments in true crime forums, podcasts, and comment sections. And people who've watched the same footage and read the same documents land on opposite sides with equal confidence, and the family that once filled the Cedar Street mansion scattered in every direction. Todd Peterson, Michael's biological son, had stood beside his father from the moment of the arrest through every appeal and every hearing. And then years later, he reversed course in the most publicly possible, uploading a series of videos to YouTube in which he accused his father of killing Kathleen. So the son, who never wavered, was saying out loud now what prosecutors had argued two decades earlier. And Clayton Peterson, Michael's other biological son, took the opposite approach and went quiet, largely disappearing from public view. And Clayton carried his own history with the justice system having been involved in a criminal incident during his time at Duke, a fact that surfaced during the trial era and added another layer of complication to the family's public image. And Margaret Ratliff went on to make a documentary of her own. The film, called Subject, examined the experience of being a documentary subject and the cost of having your life turned into someone else's narrative. And Margaret spoke publicly about regret, about the parts of her life that had been shaped by cameras she didn't fully understand as a child. I mean, she'd lost her biological mother at two years old and then watched the man who raised her get convicted of killing the only other mother she'd known. Margaret told the Sydney Morning Herald she felt regret about growing up inside a documentary. And Martha Ratliff settled into a quiet life in Colorado, far from Durham and far from the cameras. And Caitlyn Atwater's path after the trial was the most deliberate of any of them because she had already filed that wrongful death claim against Michael in October of 2002 before the criminal trial even began. And that civil case eventually produced a $25 million settlement. With interest and other costs factored in, the total owed grew to roughly $30 million. And through a separate court filing, Caitlyn asked a judge to turn over all physical evidence from the trial so she could use it to enforce what she was owed. And as of the most recent reporting, she hasn't received a single dollar. The settlement exists on paper, but Michael has never paid it. And at one point, one of Michael's sons told his father to pick up his chips and go home to stop fighting, stop talking, and accept whatever version of freedom the plea had given him. And Michael didn't take the advice. He kept writing, kept giving interviews, and kept insisting the record was wrong. The Elford plea is the lock on this case and it turns in both directions. And believers in Michael's guilds see a technicality that let a guilty man walk free on a lesser charge after a tainted trial, and believers in his innocence see what happened when the system fails so badly that an innocent person decides a second trial isn't worth the risk. And everyone in between is left with something harder to sit with. And that is a legal ending that answered nothing. Two women connected to the same man were found at the bottom of staircases years apart. Her Kathleen's scalp had seven lacerations, a shoe print marked her calf, and the blood in the stairwell had dried long before anyone called for help. And her husband said he loved her, but he kept secrets from her that she never learned about. And the owl theory sounds absurd until you read the details, and then it sounds only slightly less absurd. And the blood splatter analyst, whose testimony helped put Peterson in prison for eight years, turned out to have been completely falsified evidence in multiple cases. And every piece of evidence in this case has been interpreted at least two ways. Forensic experts, attorneys, judges, and family members have all looked at the same staircase and seen different things. And Kathleen Peterson was only 48 years old when she passed away. And she was the first woman admitted to Duke's engineering school and a mother who built tea parties out of her grandmother's old dresses so her daughter's friends could feel like royalty for the afternoon. And she bled to death at the bottom of a staircase in her own home. And more than 20 years later, the question of how it happened still doesn't have an answer that everyone accepts. And Michael Peterson has maintained his innocence for over two decades now, through a American conviction, eight years in prison, a vacated verdict, and an outward plea that let him go free without ever requiring anyone to prove or disprove what happened on the night of December 9, 2001. So the case may be closed, but the question is not. And I mean, I leave it to you. I would love to know what you think about this case. It's an extremely interesting case. And I know a lot of people requested this case, so that is why I did it if you have any other cases for me to look into. Please let me know down below. I always read the comments. And until then, I will see you a beautiful face. All right. And stay safe out there. Okay. Bye. [Music] [Music]