In the conversation with Maggie Nick, she shares her journey from being a good child to becoming a trauma therapist and parenting expert. Maggie helps individuals recover from relational shame trauma and perfectionism by creating a safe space for them to address their emotions and stop seeking constant approval. Good kids, who often suppress their emotions and feel the need to be perfect, can face challenges in adulthood due to the pressure of maintaining a facade of goodness. Maggie emphasizes the importance of acknowledging the impact parents have on their children and highlights the need for parents to create a supportive environment where emotions are validated. She discusses how patterns of behavior in childhood can impact adult relationships and the importance of setting boundaries and recognizing one's own needs. By understanding and addressing these dynamics, individuals can break free from the cycle of people-pleasing and perfectionism.
Transcription
11542 Words, 61836 Characters
Hello everyone and welcome back to our last episode in this series, series one.
Don't worry, common thread and hot and heavy on series two with answering your questions.
That will be out next week. But for this week, I am delighted to be joined in conversation
with Maggie Nick, who is a self-confessed, recovering, burned out, overachieving people
pleasing perfectionistic pushover and shape-shifting chameleon, a recovering good child,
turned trauma therapist, parenting expert and cycle-breaking mom, who knows exactly what it's
like to grow up as the one nobody ever needed to worry about. Maggie, I'm coming back to talk to
you about that because that is statement in itself is huge. She spent years believing her overachieving
people pleasing and perfectionism were just her personality until her therapy at 25 reveal that
there were actually lifelong relational trauma responses. Now though that her rebellious online
community camp lovable and its signature good girl rehab membership, Maggie helps recovering
good kids finally feel safe and stop feeling guilty worrying about what other people think and trying
to be perfect all the time. She's a leading voice on good kid trauma, also known as relational
shame trauma and she's on a mission to have the world release the crushing shame, the whispers,
there's something wrong with you. Maggie, good to have you here. Hi, thank you so much for having me.
So lovely to say with you again. Yeah, it is. It's great. I want to jump in and go back to that piece
because the doubtful that is to say right, they burned out overachieving people pleasing perfectionist
push over and shape shifting chameleon. How hard it is even to get my mouth around those words,
not to mention what it's actually like to live and carry that right and that idea of that being
the good kid. So I'm going to throw it to you if you can explain a little bit about that child
that no one ever needed to worry about. So many of us were right, we were an old soul. We were a
delight to having class. Old head on young shoulders. Old head on young. Sure. You're really mature for
your age. Yes, yes, I am. And that's a red flag like this is the thing and it's going to be a real
challenge. I mean, it's already been a challenge with my work because I think parents just think good
parents have good kids. A good kids feel like evidence that I was a good parent. We're like, okay,
I've just got to roll my sleeves up and punish my child, you know, every time they're disrespectful
until they stop being disrespectful and now they're a good kid. And look, they always behave and
they never push back. And yes, I've done a good job. Like it's so insane how that is the opposite
of the reality. So many of us were were good and we were quiet and we were easy and we always,
always, always behaved and we were so responsible. We were so disciplined, we basically raised ourselves.
Yeah, right. We're the one that everyone can count on and we wear that like a gold star, but nobody
ever checks on us. And we so many of us have come into adulthood just being exhausted from proving
our goodness with the overachieving and the people pleasing and the perfectionism and, you know,
going into fight flight, trying to say no, shapeshifting into whatever level version of us,
somebody will be okay with like this work in my work in this book, my upcoming book Good Kids
is about the invisible trauma and the cost of always being good. So many of us will spend our
whole lives recovering from a lifetime of bottling our emotions, literally performing calm.
Like we're not calm, we perform calm. Well, we constantly scan the room like a hawk and we scan
everyone for the slightest sign that they could disapprove of something we're doing or be
disappointed and be mad at us and this like crushing fear of being a burden, like feeling like we're
always in trouble. The child that is the one you never need to worry about is the one I'm most worried
about and I need parents to wake up like we we are so concerned with our kids. You are a disrespect
for who are challenging us and I'm not saying those kids don't need support. I'm not saying they
don't have some shame trauma from being made to feel like what is wrong with you. That's another
discussion, but when I have a parent call and they have multiple kids in the family's gone through
a divorce or a death of a loved one and they're wanting to get usually the defiant child in for
counseling, I'm always like, is there a child who seems just fine? And they're like, oh yes, my oldest
or oh yes, my daughter or oh yes, the middle one. And I'm like, tell me more and they're like, yeah,
I mean, you wouldn't even know anything happened. I'm like, I need to see them first. Like that's
the one I'm most worried about because that child is suffering silence, that child is suffering
alone, that child is performing fine, but they are not fine. A child cannot be fine after going
through something traumatic like that, but they're they're hiding it and they don't feel safe to tell
anyone because they wouldn't be a burden. You know, we've got to we've got to be attention to these
kids and check in. When we were talking about that at the beginning and the good kid, the mature one,
the responsible one, the one that's that is fine. The first thing that I thought of when I was
listening to you talking was who else has the really big emotions in the family that there's no
space for this child to have theirs? Where are the adults in the family that are parenting this child
or where actually are the parents being the big kids themselves and having the big emotions
and the big tantrums that the child has to skip neglect over our condition to abandon themselves
and not be playful and not get to experience what it is to be carefree and they have to grow up so
quick. So I'm looking at this as neglect towards the child, but actually then looking at where are
the parents and which of the parents are the ones that are explosive in their emotions that the
child is walking on egg shells around. And then typically what I see is if it's not another parent
that are as explosive, it's where is the other parent that then is enabling this behavior and the
child is being the parent to their parents. You know that mic drop. Yeah, that's exactly right. I
mean we and I do talk about this in the book. There's actually I don't know if you I'm sure you do
because you're an expert in this subject, but I stumbled upon research that confirmed a pattern I've
seen with clients. I feel like when I have a really it's any person who has the kind of good kid
presentation. Sometimes they start as a bad kid and then they end up being a good kid or sometimes
they were always kind of going to be the naturally more compliant, more easygoing child good kid.
But I'm always like do you have a narcissistic parent or do you have an addict parent? And like
there's interesting research. Have you seen it that like establishes that pattern that it's starting
to be documented in the literature the way the experience of having a parent struggling with addiction
and the experience of having a parent who struggles with narcissism in particular, but I think it
I think they do speak to all personality disorders. The way it presents very similarly. Like it's the
inconsistency. Yeah, I haven't seen the research to back that up, but what the way I describe this so
is if I have in one hand and narcissist and if I have one hand a parent that is an addict,
they're addict and the narcissist they're akin. They're so similar. It doesn't mean then that when
we take the addiction away from the person that is addicted that we're going to be left with a
narcissist if they're going to do the work. Right. And the difference is is that here with the
addiction, let's say the addiction is alcohol, the person that is suffering with addiction,
they will lie still manipulate because it's all about the drink. Everything will revolve around
them and about the drink and about them getting their needs met and they don't care who they hurt
and it's going to get in the way of them in getting their needs met. The narcissist, although then this
isn't alcohol that's in the center of this, but this is them in the center of it. So it's all about them.
They will lie, steal, manipulate, they will never take accountability like they addict and they will
blame, steal, twist, manipulate, blame everybody else that it's everybody else's fault.
They're both the martyr and the victim in that to avoid all responsibility and accountability.
So yes, when I see what my clients, the wounds that they present and the behaviors, the trauma
responses that they have, but the behaviors from the parents with addiction and then with narcissistic
behavior, it's one and of the same, although it presents differently. Right. Right. But I feel like
in the intake, I'm always like, all right, is your, you know, I'm like waiting for it, waiting for
the evidence. And I think you nailed it. Like from the child's perspective, you know, the parent is
very inconsistent. Sometimes the parent is warm and friendly and loving and kind and able and
willing to meet their needs. And then other times inexplicably, without any warning, they're not.
And like that is so the relational trauma and the relational shame trauma of making that child
feel like, I'm not worthy of having my needs met. My parent, you know, is disgusted by me, annoyed
by me, who I am deep down. Like it's, it's really interesting. So I think we do see that as an
origin story of her good kids, right? The parent with the addiction, the parent with a personality
disorder, but I specifically see narcissistic and borderline. It's like the two predominant.
And then I think the high needs sibling, right? Whether it's behavioral or medical situation
in the family where the parent is so exhausted and overwhelmed already. Maybe they're a single parent,
maybe they're just completely overburdened, trying to work multiple jobs without a lot of family
support. And so there's this child that's like, well, my mom or my dad has already got so much,
I can't make things harder for them. They're already dealing with my brother and my sister and
all this going on with him. So I've got to be good and I've got to make their life easier. And I've
got to watch their mood and take care of them. And when they're sad, I've got to make them happy.
And when they're overburdened, I've got to anticipate their needs before they even know so that
they are okay. It's like this role reversal that we talk about so much in our work where like the
parent is the child and the child is the parent. Oh, it's exhausting. When I separate that out when I
think of what you're talking about in terms of periods in a child's life, so there if somebody is sick
in the family, if somebody does have high needs and even if that's extended financial difficulties,
there when you're talking about not having a support system. And when I think of actually children,
adult children of the narcissistic family, when they have had to protect themselves and either one
they've been discarded in the system for speaking up against it or if they have gone lower, no contact,
them not having this support system. When we're conditioned that this is normal to either rely on
your child emotionally or for being a parent to the other siblings, what's different in those
situations or I separate out from then a narcissistic parent is one the weaponization of their emotions
and the exploitation. So there's one in a parent recognizing and going, I struggled and I felt
or I did and yes, that put a burden on you and yes, I'm sorry and yes, if I could go back and do
it different and I see that and I see what this did on you and how can I make this up to you and as
soon as I could change it, I did as opposed to a narcissistic parent will deny twist, blame, shame,
will project onto the child. We'll see that the siblings won't get on in the in the family dynamic
because there's like a divide and conquer in the siblings. So there's this whole other projection
piece that happens as opposed to if I'm going through a difficult situation and the children have
to step up and be older for a little bit. When I get on my feet again or when things are different,
I will regain the control as the parent and take back that place even if I've temporarily kind of
stood out of us. Well, I think, I mean, the like zoom out, the 30,000-foot view of what you're saying is
number one, like as a parent, we have to acknowledge the impact that we have on our kids. I fuck up
all the time. Me too. I love that you say that. Like daily. And I'm so sick and tired of this narrative
in the gentler, conscious, whatever healthier parenting community. Yeah, I'm 10, almost 11 years
into my parenting journey. I'm an 11-year-old almost in an eight-year-old and I feel like when my
oldest was a baby and I was like, oh shit, I gotta heal myself. I'm just gonna do all this over again
and that'll crush me. I felt like all of the information out there was like, okay, so just like
don't do that. And I'm like, okay, great. And so then what's time I would try? And sometimes I could do it,
but then there were other times where I would just explode like a volcano, pop like a balloon.
I never experienced rage in my life. I don't think as a person, I mean, I was such a raging good kid
and just bottling everything. But then parenting comes and like, you know, my kid there is being
unreasonable or entitled. And it's like, my nervous, it's like, oh my god, your mother's back. And it's
like, shut her down. I don't fucking think so, right? Or like, my kid's doing something that I couldn't
have done. And so then I'm like, oh my god, stop! I have to shout you down to protect you from what
would have happened to me. It's like, it's so much. And I just, I am so sick and fucking tired of
this narrative that we should just be able to know better and then do better. I repair with my kids
every day. I probably apologize like once a day. Like, I fuck off. I'm thinking wild on once a day.
That's an improvement. But here's the thing, right? And this is when I reached out to you this time,
because it was after that right. So parenting after abuse, especially if you were the good kid and
now have to enforce boundaries with your kids. And this is to any of the listeners that are parents,
but anybody that's not a parent, this is an important conversation. Because I think Maggie,
incorrect me if I'm wrong, because what you're saying is actually is, and what I see and what I know
to be true, is that our children will highlight to us a dynamic that is already happening in our
other relationships. So here, if I am uncomfortable with other people's big emotions in childhood,
if I have had to fix my parents' emotions or if my parents were coming to me with problems,
then I had to be the fixer and be the good kid. Now if my kid is a big emotion,
I'm going to be triggered so much that I want to fix it, but I'm not going to be able to do that. And
that is going to cause a different sort of friction in the relationship because I'm silencing them.
But this will already be happening in your other relationships just in a way, because you're not
living with those other people. You're not aware that it's happening. Or in terms of boundaries.
If I'm not able to say no to people, I might be overextended and then I might be burned out and then
I might hide for them or not answer them or what do I do in this. But if we don't say no to her,
kids we're going to raise really entitled children, we're going to create such
concernation and such a battle here with our children that we're not going to be able to turn away
from that we have to face. I have a whole section in my book about how people
pleasing shows up in parenting and when I was writing it, I thought it would just be like
a couple of paragraphs. Then I ended up being this, like, it just kind of took on a life of its own
because it is so- It is a life of itself. Fucking hard. Yeah. It is. I mean, I feel like I could
and probably will one day write a whole book on this. I was kind of floored, honestly, when I sat down
to really walk through it because I think when you have spent your life as a people pleaser,
most of us had a parent, at least one, who had a temper. We did the walking on eggshells and we
literally are finding a way to meet our core need for safety by just never upsetting anyone.
We're like, "Okay, I'll just over-explain my boundaries. I'll make sure I'm always just
I'll shapeshift into like whatever you need me to be and I'll just never ruffle feathers."
And then you have a toddler who is actually extremely emotionally healthy. Yeah, I get overwhelmed
and they blow up. They don't stuff it. They don't pretend they're fine. They don't perform calm.
They're like, "Dude, I'm overwhelmed. Get out of the way. Let me blow up." But we have spent our lives
never feeling safe to allow that to happen when our child is yelling at us. Like, I find myself
sometimes right in the moment. It's like little mags is in there and she's like, "I didn't do
anything wrong. Why are you yelling at me?" Like, it's like, little me is like, "Oh, it's stop."
I tried so hard to not upset you and why are you yelling at me? It puts me right back into my
inner child. What I noticed for me is that I can have such patience, such empathy. I can...
So there, see if the scream and toddler or my kids are a bit older now and I can have such empathy
to a point. And what's happening is that I'm not noticing my sense is getting overwhelmed.
I'm not noticing the cues where I need to take a break because I have been trained to focus on
the other person so much until they're okay. So I will have such compassion. I'm not talking
Mary Poppins, you know, but I have such compassion up to this point. And then and my job is actually to
how do I recognize me before that? Because then I get to like that breaking point of,
"Okay, this is enough." Yeah, yeah. Well, and I think I think so much of that when we look, like,
zoom in physiologically, like when we think through fight, fight, fun, freeze, right? People
pleasing as fun response. And like we do tend to see that children will tend to naturally gravitate
towards fight and flight and fun and freeze with their exceptions. But like, I would say the
overwhelming pattern that we see is the bad kids, the difficult kids, the ones that push back
are the fight and flight kids. And the good kids are the fun and freeze kids. And so when we've
spent a whole lifetime, only ever fawning and freezing. And at some point, your nervous system is like,
I, I have healed enough. I have faced some of myself. I've started, you know, creating and cultivating
safe relationships of subgone to therapy. And our nervous system is like, I think it's safe enough
to allow fight response. And it literally opens the door to fight response. Like that is, I want,
I feel like I have this conversation over again with clients. Like I know how much shame we feel when
we do blow the fuck up at our kids. Same. Like the shame, you get bitch slapped by shame after you
blow the fuck up at your kids. Same, same, same. Okay. Not saying it's a great thing. But I'm saying
when you have spent your life bottling and suppressing every single emotion and performing fun
and performing calm. And then you're, you start healing and your nervous system is like, okay,
but like I can't and won't hold it anymore, right? And so we, we have had a fight response when we've
turned it inward, right? We get vicious and brutal with ourselves. You've always had it. And now it's
like an outward fight. And that is actually evidence of healing. But like you said, I feel we have
such a responsibility to our kids to break these cycles that our parents didn't know they needed to
break, didn't even know there were cycles or generational trauma or anything, not to justify their
behavior. But like different time they didn't know we do know now, right? And so I think we have to do
this where we get curious after we, like every time I lose it with my kids, I'm like, what just
happened? And I sit with it. And I'm like one of the busiest people you've ever meet. So if I can
find five minutes to do this, everybody can just saying. And so I do like a five minute check-in.
And I'm like, what happened? And I'm like, Oh, I made food. My daughter said she didn't like,
she said she loves this before. So now it feels like what? And it makes me feel like I'm not good enough.
It's a little me that needs to have a release that needs to just like stomp her fucking feet that
like I'm so tired of feeling that good enough. And if I can honor that those feelings that I
suppressed decades ago and just get them out, like don't you feel like it's a seesaw? Like it's like
the more we've bottled when it like when we get triggered, it just boom. And it's like this over
reaction. And if we can just like release it, then it's like we've cleared that. And it doesn't have
to come out again because we've released it. Absolutely. There's there's so much that I want to go on,
but first and foremost, I want to say to you how refreshing it is to hear somebody speak about
this honestly. And I know and thankfully in my own life, in my own circle of friends, I have other
honest mothers who talk openly and honestly about the struggle, who openly talk about, you know,
when I fucked up and we in turn hold them accountable, but also, you know, are meeting them with
compassion and understanding and honesty ourselves. Because this is the part about people pleasing when
we're masking with other people. And then when you have this facade that only everything's
wonderful and my child is great and my child would never or I would never, you're setting yourself up
for this failure rather than recognizing it as normal. But also if you're the only one sharing
your own struggles in your group and you are met with other parents, other mothers saying,
no, this is perfect and everything's great. I just called bullshit. I called bullshit even if
somebody has grown up in a good enough home, if they're going to tell me that their kid doesn't tantrum,
if their patients isn't tried, if they're not tested. In fact, if they tell me that they never
fuck up or never apologize, that is a red flag. And I'm looking at them wondering there's actually
something else going on here. The reason that I will know that this is bullshit and that you've made
a mistake is because you're human, plain and simple. I don't have to know anything else about you,
but because you're human. And so even in this way, you just share in your honesty, Maggie,
how this will shift the shame for the listeners, because I guarantee you that they will think that
they're the only one and that there's something wrong with them. And the biggest fear that they have
is that they are traumatizing their kids. Oh, 100% and that they are being abusive.
Well, in the reality is we are traumatizing our kids sometimes. I just feel like can we just admit
that? Can I as a parenting expert just say that I'm probably trying like, I think trauma is not what
happens is what happens or doesn't happen before, during and after. And so I have a 100% track record
of circling back going, hey, can we talk about what happened? That's like three cycles right there.
So we've been shit under the rug. Hey, can we talk about what happened? I start the conversation.
Right. I approach with curiosity and humility and like a determination. Even that you are taking
the responsibility that you are starting the conversation. You are going towards the child. My job
as your leader, I know it's like five cycles. Yeah, like literally. Thank you for it. I feel
like people think I'm exaggerating. You know, I'm serious. Like that's literally like five different
generational cycles of trauma just to be the one to start the conversation. Yeah. And then I lead
with some context to explain my behavior, right? I was bottling my feelings. I hit 10, my body,
you know, the bubble burst. And I can see the impact it had on you. Because I, the words I'm sorry
are important. I'm not saying they're not. But I feel like for a strange adult children, myself being
one of them, like I would love to hear my mother say she's sorry. But the words that would mean so
much more where I'm sorry, I hurt you, um, acknowledging the pain that she has caused. Instead of all the
fucking gaslighting or your therapist made that up and oh my god, I'm so sorry, I'm not the perfect
parent. Like just being a parent who can say, I scared you. I hurt you. I can see that. And it
matters to me. And I'm sorry that I hurt you. Yeah. And I think in that the examples, my language when
I go to my kids is I'm sorry I overreacted. I shed it there and I absolutely shouldn't have. That
was me that got stressed. And no matter what was happening, that was up to me today. But you didn't
deserve that. You didn't deserve that. Yeah. That's it. We literally teach our kids whether they're
lovable or not feels like an oversimplification. But like parents are like, I don't understand it. I
show up to every kid, every one of my kids games. I'm there for them. We eat lunches, we eat dinners.
Like I feel like I'm so present. And then my kid will tell me that they feel like I don't love
them. And they're just like wanting to throw their hands up in the air. And I'm like, the other stuff
matters. It really does. But when we parent the way our parents parented us without being intentional
and noticing the places where our own emotional triggers and unresolved trauma is going to hijack
us. It caused us to shut them down or give them a silent treatment, right? Or yell at them. We have to
be in this place of being able to hold that we did the best we could and we hurt them. We did the
best we could and that was scary for them. We did the best we could and we made them feel disgusted by
them. We made them feel like they there was something wrong with them. We made them feel like we didn't
love them when they were like that. Like that is what my child counseling clients will sit on my couch
and say, my mom doesn't love me when I'm like that. The first time a teenager said that to me,
I like almost passed off. I'm sorry, what did she just say? It's like she's like my mom doesn't
love me when I'm like that. That's how it feels on the kids ends. And we've got to have
raging empathy for ourselves here because we are fumbling around in the dark with no roadmap,
no handbook, no modeling on how to do this. So many of us feel called to parent in response to the
way we were parented. We kind of know on some level what we needed and we can correct it. I certainly
have in several places. But we have got to be so endlessly patient and loving to ourselves
that like I see you trying and I know you're doing your best. But the reality of the situation is
we are going to come in with that energy and make our kids feel unlovable sometimes. And again,
like I do it too, but I always circle back and say I do love you. Even when things are hard and I'm
sorry that I made you feel like I didn't. It's that acknowledgement piece. And when I think of
the narcissistic parent, there's just crickets. That is just empty and not only that, but when the
child comes to the parent, whereas you're talking about actually you being the parent coming to the child,
when the child, as the child or even the adult child comes to the parent, it's been denied,
it's been twisted, history's been rewritten, they're being blamed and shamed, marked humiliated,
scorned. And so there's this added layer of abuse and harm. And so I just want to go back to what
you had said earlier, do I think that I can cause trauma and harm my kids? Absolutely. And I say that
unequivocally because for me to recognize that is important, right? Because other than that, I'm
standing certain that, no, I never cause harm. I'm perfect. And that's a problem. But I want to
highlight the difference between that and the difference between abuse. And because abuse, when I
think of a narcissistic parent, is something that is repeated and ongoing and intentionality
and a projection. And there's such a lack of self-awareness from the parent. Where's your
even talking about that, taken the five minutes and reflect and going, what did I do? So even there,
the mornings used to be very difficult for kids getting them out to school. And actually,
what changed was they ended up getting a bus. And because the bus was kind of their responsibility,
they didn't want to miss it. Whereas that they get in the car thing was so difficult. And because
we always had time, that was never a priority for them. So even that's interesting. But I remember when
we would have a bad morning and one that repaired that I would make in the car going, oh, I got really
stressed in there. And that's on me. And I'm sorry, right? So recognizing I shouldn't have shared it
or whatever that was, I would reflect and honestly think and go, okay, what can I do different tomorrow?
And that would be responsibility on me for, let's say, okay, I could go to bed earlier so I can get
up earlier and, you know, make the lunches because the kids were small at this stage. But even in terms
of, okay, well, where's their responsibility? I can ensure that they put their shoes beside the door
or that they hang up their coat and that this is not going to be an argument. So this is not about
berating and shaming myself, oh my god, I'm awful and this is no good. This is really practical ways.
And whatever I would implement would work really well for the next few days or weeks that we would
fall back into the cycle and I would go back into it again. So it's this piece about taking
accountability that when we cause harm, and I think when you're saying that trauma a kid can experience
can be the harm. And I suppose I'll ask you, do you see that difference? Do you see a difference
in that than in abuse and let's say in the abuse from a narcissist? Oh, a hundred percent. I mean,
I think to your point, a narcissistic parent cannot access self-awareness. Yes. Cannot access empathy.
Yes. And therefore cannot engage and repair. Yeah. Right. Like I think the repeated, like the thing
for me when a new client, I just feel like when you're in that new phase and you're kind of assessing
things, like what I'm looking for is when somebody's describing something that feels like a narcissistic
or borderline. Yeah. And it's like, is there repair? When the child says mom, you hurt me, does the mom say,
oh, I'm so sorry about that. Yeah. I didn't mean to hurt you. Here's what I'll do different. Like that's
that piece, the ability. And I want to be so crystal fucking clear on this that like I see
personality disorders through the lens of internal family systems theory and parts work,
where it's extreme protector parts. Like I do not, as a clinician, think for one second,
that narcissistic parents have like, you know, are making conscious level choices and like,
enjoy this. Like I do think there's a weird satisfaction when, you know, like my mom gave me the
silent treatment. There's parts to me sometimes that want me to make my kids beg for forgiveness and
give them there's like this weird satisfaction. And I think it's very like we get very vulnerable to
that to the parts that want to hijack and like try to work out how the fuck that happened in childhood
and what that meant about us and like trying to just kind of work it out. And those parts can hijack
us and it can feel satisfying in a weird way. But it's not happiness. It's not contentment. It's not
peace. It's like trauma, right? It's like gnarly, unstable energy. And so I really see our parents
and those of us who have parents who presented as someone with a personality disorder as unhealed trauma
with extreme protector parts. Yeah. And there is a highest self in there, but the highest self is
mostly protected like in the situation room behind bulletproof glass. Like every now and then
the highest self will peek out and you're like, oh, look, you do love me. You, you are a good person.
I do matter to you. And then yes, put back in the situation room and the protector parts come back out.
Yeah. Yeah. They cannot access or sit with that self awareness because that will bring the shame.
And that was the part that that was unsafe for them. So I mean complete agreement. I just wanted to
highlight this for the listener because just the fear that they have that I am like the narcissist
apparent. And this is why one of the things that in the book that I co-wrote, you're not the problem,
I wanted to highlight what abuse looked like because when somebody can't identify what abuse is
and when this is normalized, and now, well, if I do something that is somewhat similar,
well, then I am the same as them. And so it's been able to separate that out and recognize,
like you said, those parts that no self-awareness not able to take accountability, not able to self-reflect,
not able to have empathy, not able to see your child as a separate self and a separate individual.
So any of the parents listening now, if you think about your own kids and if you think do you know
them separate from you so that you're not projecting on your own wants and dreams for them,
when I think of, you know, what job your kids are going to get. Actually, do you know what they want,
what they're interested? And if they're young, this will be really unrealistic and it will change
and change repeatedly. But like, are you interested in that part of them? As opposed to the narcissistic
parent, it is a projection of them, that extension. Yeah. Well, and I think I 100% and I think
there are, like, I have a subset of clients who come to me with an adult child, generally, who they
describe as narcissistic or borderline. And that's, I don't know if you've worked, I've worked with
a bunch at this point now and it's always such a dance working with those clients because they are so
fragile in terms of the shame piece. They feel responsible, but they're also like, but I did the best I
could. And I think this is one of the interesting ways where intergenerational trauma and especially
relational shame trauma, this piece can present. I think there are parts of me that want me to make my
kids beg for forgiveness that would feel that weird satisfaction. They're parts of me that want me
to shut my kid the fuck down the way I was shut down. And it's again, it's the way our brains
make sense of things. They play, they explore, they try to see it from the other foot.
There are parts of us that want to do those things. That doesn't mean that we are our parent,
but our parts that, like, all of our protector parts in IFS, like, in my experience tend to be very
young. Like, my parts with, like, my history with the narcissistic borderline mother, my parts tend
to be like four, five, six. I notice most people, I work with younger than 10, for sure. And so you have
this 10-year-old part who's thinking like a 10-year-old and trying to make sense of this and 10-year-olds
are very black and white. They are very simplistic in their thinking. They can't critically think,
they can't zoom out and see the big picture. And so it's like, oh, there's that part again that feels
like I'm my mom. There you are. Thank you for trying to protect me. Here's where it's different. I
you know, went around and apologized, right? I didn't do that. Like, it's okay that I'm struggling
with this. Like, when we are flooded as a parent, and when all of our suppressed, bottled, unprocessed
trauma comes exploding out of us, like, or when we take stuff personally, right? That's one of my, like,
crosses. One of the things I'm really working on right now, it's not taking ship personally. And,
like, trying to just see that my child is overwhelmed and children act out stress. And this is not
personal. It does feel really familiar in a very painful way. And my parts are all, like,
ready, right? And I like, I got you. I'm suited up. If you need me, I'm just like right here, you know,
but I think our children can remind us of our youngest selves and our children can remind us of our
abusive parent. And sometimes the way that we move through that as a healing person can be perceived
by our child as inconsistency or rejection or even abandonment. Like, that is just the reality of
the situation. And so I think just an awareness there. They're like, oh, when I shut down because I
didn't want to scream at my kid, that might have felt like abandonment to my child. So I just need
to acknowledge that. I need to go and say, Hey, I felt overwhelmed. I was trying not to yell at you,
but I wonder if me shutting down made you feel dismissed and made you feel like I didn't love you
right then. Is that how it felt for you? You know, and being brave enough to, like, it's safe to tell
me if that's how it felt for you. I want to know. I want to know so that I can apologize. I want to
own my behavior. I want to own the impact I'm having on you. Like, that is what that is such a clear
differentiator from our parents who are personality disorder, right? Is that just that the willingness,
the desire to own and apologize for the ways that I've heard them. You're right. And it is this
acceptance piece that it's happened. It's believe your children. And yes, I have worked with adults that
have come with, especially with adult children. There's where the dynamic has been set up and
typically the client that is coming like that has not held boundaries, has enabled behaviors,
has not stood in their own authority and their own kind of power. And I look at how they are in
relationships. So how they are being treated in relationships and how their child has modeled that.
But I do be very aware of language that if a parent is common saying that a child is the narcissist
because then what that sounds like is that they're absolving themselves of all responsibility and
saying like my child has this disorder that I have nothing to do with and now I'm being the victim
in that. And I don't agree with that rhetoric. And what I find is the narcissistic parents
don't come to therapy or if they do, they don't last. Before I was public at all, I would have had
handful of these clients show up, but they wouldn't have stayed. Oh no, they storm out and slam the door.
And I would have done it gently and respectively and and with kindness and empathy, but I would have
held them accountable and reflected back to them what I was hearing, what they were telling me and
even that they couldn't handle that. So I think now when somebody comes and they are recognizing that
they're one because even of a parasocial relationship that they have with me, there's more trust
in what I'm saying and they're more willing to sit with the resistance of what they're feeling.
But again, it's yeah, it's very telling how much they're willing to obviously go back to self-reflect,
engage, take accountability because even in what you were saying there about the inconsistency,
the example that I had given earlier, I was inconsistent in that. So I am really calm and
empathic and lovely and then there gets to a point that I'm overwhelmed and now I'm like enough,
that's it. And although not like the narcissistic parent, there's no withdrawal of kindness after
that, there's no silent treatment, there's no verbal abuse, there's none of that. But that's still
as inconsistent what I'm doing. And what I'm teaching the child is if I needed to hold boundaries,
what I'm teaching them is no, you can keep going and going and going and going and going and then
there's the point where mama's like enough. And actually the question is, what did I need to do
earlier? What did I need to do to manage that? Where did I need to hold boundaries? What did I need
to do that it didn't get to that point and where do I need to be consistent with that? I think the
consistency that I'm more concerned about, like I try and I feel like I have like this mantra where
I'm like she's not your mother, you're on Florida, you're a mom now, be the mom. Like I feel like just
to try to bring myself back into the moment because I feel like I say that who's the parent,
all the time to myself, who's the parent? Right. And my parts can float me away and it's like all
of a sudden I'm a little Maggie again and like fighting for my life is what it feels like and so I have
to like stick on that. I get into power struggles. Yeah. When I think of the people,
please are I think of anxious attachment style. And when I think of me, I actually was well able to
access my fight response. For me, I was the protector of my mother. The thing about growing up in
that was that it wasn't safe to love or care for anyone else because she would be so jealous.
So I would fight on her behalf and protect her and that avoidant that not to let anybody come too
close to me and keep people at arms lent. But I absolutely have that ability and always have to
stand up for myself and actually my thing is in relationships is it's so familiar for me to actually
fight and advocate for myself. It's actually recognizing and healthy relationships. I don't have to
keep fighting for myself and that when I continue to fight is actually when do I need to walk away?
With my kids, their over correction might in terms of the I wasn't asked anything about me or ignored.
So I can ask my kids too many questions and it's actually given them space so it's even the
they're coming in from school. How was your day? Who are you sitting beside? What did you play?
What was good? What was bad? And it's like Katie back the fuck off, right? Be interested,
but this idea like don't smother them. Like let them also come to you. This is why I have dogs
because like I would smother my kids. I have a golden retriever and another snuggly dog because I feel
like I give them my like smothering love so that my kids I'm a better mom because my smothering goes
to my dogs. Okay, and so here's the bit. Yes, it's a responsibility to go to our kids when something
is wrong, but this is to allow our kids the freedom to come towards us and they're my kids and I when
they're telling me stuff, I have to actively in my head go, okay, Katie, back off. Don't ask loads of
questions because you're going to scare them off and I'm like, oh really? Oh, okay. And you know,
I might ask one or two questions, but if I keep asking them loads of questions, they're going to
shut down. Yep. And the part around boundaries is an overexplaining. And not wanting to set them off,
like being too afraid to hold that boundary because they're going to blow up and that's going to make
your nervous system feel like you're in danger. Yeah, or or more of me that I don't want to be the
narcissistic parent and say, well, just because I said so. Well, because that's the way it is. Right.
And no, and don't answer back because my kids actually they can come up with really good, really good
reasons why let's say are, you know, bedtime is a really good one to talk about, right? Maybe why
they should stay over later. And there are some of the times it's reasonable and I'm like, okay,
you have gotten a year old or okay, that is fair. And it's this piece. It's actually okay. Where are we
negotiating? And then where are my kind of non-negotiables? And without fighting, removing that fight
from me and just saying, no, no, ask an answer. No, I've said no, no, that's it. Yeah. Take that one
step further. Like our parents acted like showing anything on our faces other than pure delight
that they told us no. Right. If we looked upset, looked disappointed, it was like stopping just
respectful. It was like literally if we showed the impact of life on us, we were called disrespectful.
Right. And so I think my one of my biggest challenges, like I'm working through not taking
shit personally. That's like a really hard one for me because my mother just takes everything
personally and it's blueprints is deep. But and as I'm healing, right? Like I, it's like stuff is
coming up to the surface and I feel like you get more triggerable the more you're healing. And so
it's just dicey. But I think the thing that I try to just remind myself is like children resist
you release to regulate. Like the resistance is a part of how they regulate. And so our parents
shut down any sign of resistance. And they accidentally and inadvertently shut down
our ability to release stress and regulate our bodies. That's why we walk around like a volcano
about to explode or bleed about to pop whatever and if you want to use like the are literally
raising children who are trying to be emotionally healthy in a ways that we were never allowed to
brutally shamed for. And we have to make space for when I tell my kid no, it's like the answers no.
And like we need to own the fuck out of our no, but not in a punishing way, not in a silencing way,
not in a dominating our kids in the submission kind of way. Just a the answers no. And it's okay
for you to be sad that I said no. It's okay for you to be disappointed. It's okay for you to be
mad at me that I said no. The answer's still fucking no. Like that. And that is one of the the things
that I'm most proud of as a parent as I feel like I like army crawled through horrific conditions
through my healing to get to a place where most of the time I can hold my no in that space.
I can allow them to be pissed. I can allow them to storm off. I don't believe that we need to shut
every every little bit of that down. I think they're lines. They're not going to like call me names.
They're not going to be aggressive physically verbally. Like I think there are lines here. We're
not going to be destructive. But like we've got to allow our kids to show the impact to like get
those feelings out. And when our kids are having this like huge meltdown over something that seems
so tiny. It's not about that. Yeah. They've been bottling all their feelings. And now they have no
more room. Their cup is full and their body is getting it out. Like we need to just trust and believe
that this overreaction makes sense in the context of it's the last straw. They don't have any more space.
Their bodies just trying to get it out. And they found an outlet here. I'm not in the lungs so much. I
think that part is acceptance that what has happened has happened. Whatever that is. And I think even
in terms of your right hold in boundaries and even there when you're talking about like name,
calling or them strumming off. I would add to that that if your child is that dysregulated and does
call you that name does slam the doors and think and even you know when teenage years. That is not
the time to implement and hold a boundary when they're dysregulated. When they are out of their
rational brain, you cannot speak reason to them. So allow yourself that space. Just stop and even see
what happens with them because if you have been a healthy enough parent, if you have modeled to them
actually what repair looks like and apologize after you lose in it, they will have learned this. So give
them the time. I call this. I say don't like throw petrol on the fire. If a fire has happened and
there's an eruption, your only job in that moment is to not throw petrol on the fire and erupt it.
So like stomp up those stairs after the morgue. Then what did you just? It's for you. Your job is
to regulate yourself in that moment that you're not going to throw petrol on the fire and come back to
that and it is important. If they don't come back to that later on or the next day be like what did
you think of your behavior yesterday? I didn't like that and that's you know and then talk to them
but you're coming to them from a rational reasonable regulated place. Yeah. I 100% to all of that. I
find myself saying oh they're dysregulated. Like the more unreasonable they are or the more
explosive it is. I find my I try to like have my highest self be shotgun and be like girl he's
dysregulated. Let him walk away. Like give him a minute. He needs your help right now. He needs a
mom right now. Like that. He needs your help right now. Right. Like he like he has lost control. Like his
his impulse control is offline and like a lot of parents will just dig deeper and more but they'll
pile on the punishments and it's like but he has lost control. What he needs is like he needs you to
hold him steady and hold the know and let him thrash. Yeah. Let him resist your release to regulate
and he will regulate and come back and be like why was I so mean to you? Why did I hurt you? What is
wrong with me? And you're like nothing. You are seven. You are three. You are 16. Your impulse
control and offline. That happens sometimes. Happens to me right? The other day I said something
that I didn't mean and I snapped. It happens to all of us and what do we do? We come back and we
own our behavior and we apologize. Like jumping back to earlier, you were talking about
being a consistent. Like we're going to be inconsistent sometimes. Like the goal is not to be
consistent. The consistency that I'm more worried about and I think I started the sentence and
ever come back to the consistency that I'm most concerned about. Consistent. You circled back.
We got there. I try not to yell. I try not to let my rage which is it just feels like a monster
inside of me. I try not to let my rage come out. I try to like oh I'm feeling it's coming. I need
to walk away. I need to just engage but the consistency that I'm most concerned about is repair.
Like period. Like I do my best to not yell and when I do yell and it's when not if when I do yell,
I repair every fucking time. 100% of the time in my children's lives. They have always gotten
the apology from me. Sometimes it takes me a little while. Sometimes I walk into that feral space where
I just feel like a feral animal and I'm just like rabid and just like animalistic as the rage.
It's like so much right? It's like I'm me. This is knowing laughter. I'm not laughing at you.
This is knowing it after. I'm the parts of me and I'm the rage and I have a shame and I'm I just
feel like it's almost like primal. I move into the space and as it takes me a little while to come
back down but like the consistency that we need to be most concerned about is when we fuck up
we own our behavior. We own the impact we had and we honor what our children deserve. We say
you didn't deserve to be treated like that and I'm sorry and I like no matter what you did.
No matter because there's this belief that my kid knows how to push my buttons but who is the
parent? Where are they? No matter what you did. I shouldn't have and so that is the part with
owning it but I want to go because air kind of aims are very similar than when we're talking about
parenting and I think this is where you know we're talking about accountability and responsibility
which is so important but then it's also like lower your expectations for yourself as a parent.
My expectation is not to create joy and create connection. My aim is to let's have a good
enough morning. Let me not shout. Yes. I call it a checho. Let's not have a checho this year.
In my head. I'm not saying this to my kids. Yeah. And even when I'm thinking let's not have a checho
like I might like put on the radio. They're not of us are dancing around the kitchen, right?
But let's not have a checho and then I'm able to engage with them in a different way.
But if you set such unrealistic expectations for yourself that now in the morning we are going to
be this like cozy family. We're going to have a great day. Yeah. Oh yeah. I know. No I could I think
you're just setting yourself up for failure. Well it's almost like the more you bring that energy,
the more your kids are like whoa what's that energy about? Yeah. They are hyper attuned to our
energy. There's Janet Gonzalez Meena I think it's her name. I excited this in my book. She has
said have you heard of the boundaries bridge analogy? No. I think I found it in Janet Landsbury's
book. No bad kids. Oh I've I've expanded it a little bit from what their original Janet came up
with it. But it's this idea that if kids are walking on a bridge, we're the guardrails, right? And
they need like strong guardrails to keep them, right? Like if they're walking without guardrails,
think about how scary that makes their body feel, right? They can't feel safe. They can't feel stable.
They can't feel steady and they can't feel secure. I love that because they're their own
independent, like they have their own autonomy, what walking across that bridge, that's solid.
And so the way that I've expanded this is that we are the planks too. We're not just the guardrails.
And if you and I were walking across the bridge, high up, and one of the planks gave a little bit,
our brain would be like what the fuck was that? High alert, right? Threat, our nervous system would
be detecting a threat to our survival because we could fall through, right? And so then we would test
the next plank and the next one and the next one. We'd be like, are you good? Are you going to be
stable? That's when kids are like fucking with us and like manipulating us and pushing our
buttons. It's because we had an overreaction. We were the wobbly plank that gave and our kids are
literally escalating to seek consistency. They're like, are you going to be my leader? Are you going
to tell me no and hold it? Like when we say no and then we like because they escalate, give up,
it feels like they just kicked the plank through. That doesn't feel safe and secure for them.
Like them escalating is not their fault. It's our fault. Right? Like it's us not being stable enough.
And like we can also in the same breath be like, of course, we're not stable enough because
look how we were parented and look how we're trying to parent. Like same, same, same. But like we have
got to learn like when my kids catch me at a nine out of 10 and I don't have the space for the
frustration and I explode like a volcano, I can expect that they're going to test that a little bit.
They're going to be like, okay, I'm going to try it again this time. Are you going to be able to
stay calm? That's not them being manipulative. That's their nervous system and their brain identifying
a threat and like being over attuned to our energy and like trying to make sure that we're good,
that we've got them. They are testing their safety. That's what testing boundary is. They're testing
their safety. What is the limit then? I need to know the limit that I can go to the next time.
Is that safe? And are you safe enough to hold those limits? Isn't that so powerful? It's one of
the most profound. It's so powerful and that image is huge. I'm really I'm really glad. So the
the book is in transit to me. I can't wait to read it and I can't wait then to get you back on
the next year. It's out in January, is that right? End of January, yeah. Yeah, which is really
no time at all. Wait, is it going on pre-sale before? Yes, it's actually out now but we haven't
like loaded the cover and everything on all the places yet. But it's technically open now for
pre-orders. Well, you will be able to find all Maggie's handles in the show notes that I will have
here. And Maggie, as I said, has her online community camp lovable and its signature good girl. We
have membership. The one thing I do want to finish on is just by asking you then as the burn-dead
over-achieving people-pleasing professionalistic pushover and shapeshifting chameleon, you talking about
this then when I think of it in terms of relational trauma and how your kids have highlighted then this
internal relationship with yourself. How has this changed or in what ways are you willing to share
that this has changed then in your other relationships? Or have you noticed that it has?
I mean in every way. Relational trauma which is just such an invisible and insidious form of trauma
in our field. Like I had a video series a couple years ago called Things I Thought Were My
Personality that It Turned Out to Be Trauma Responses. And they're all relational trauma responses.
But I had so many mental health clinicians be like, "Not everything's a trauma response." And I just
wanted to be like, "Girl, just Google Relational trauma." Yeah, listen and make form a trauma here.
Yes, not everything is trauma responses. But when you're somebody like me with a history like mine,
these are trauma responses. And so I think we heal relational trauma in relationships. And so I feel
like I am diagnosed with OCD. So my brain is just overthinking and constantly calculating. It's
getting better though. I do feel like the more I heal, the more I heal my nervousness and a deep
level. I feel like the volume goes down on the overthinking which has been lovely. But I feel like
I live and breathe this work. Like I'm cycle breaking with my kids. I'm healing little mags.
And I work with clients. And so it's just, it's like I'm constantly in this space. And you are to
feel like we live in this space. And like all day every day is this. And so I feel like
the universe, there've been some very just crushing and devastating friendship breakups and people
that have fallen out of my life. And it's been brutal. But then I kind of get to a point where I'm like,
"Oh, that wasn't a healthy relationship." Like that was the universe like taking care of me.
And like one time my highest self said, "I was pruning the bush." Like, you know, that was some dead
growth on there. Like that couldn't grow anymore. And so you deserve healthy, safe relationships
where you don't have to pretend where you don't have to perform fine and perform calm. And like,
I am making space for healthier relationships. And so I have seen like if I zoom out, there's a
drastic shift towards healthier relationships. And really kind of an unwillingness to tolerate
anything else in my inner circle. Oh, I love that. You're making, so for anyone because this,
anybody listen to this, I can't see it. You're like making faces like, "Oh, like is this okay? Where is
there? Yeah, I'm not, I'm not willing to tolerate it." Yeah. Yeah. Like if I, if I don't feel like I can
say no to you, you're, I can't and I won't have you in my inner circle. If you're gonna be shitty and
then not own that and repair, sorry, like we can be acquaintances, we can be co-workers, but like you
do not, I deserve better than that. And it's wild. Yeah, this is the piece about if we're going to be
honest with ourselves with our own internal experience, like even their inner parenting,
are we going to be honest with ourselves about how we showed up? And then are we going to show up
honestly in relationships? And you're right, there is going to be losses in that and there's
going to be pain and grief, but with that there is also such hope for healthy relationships
with our kids and also in the interactions that we're, that we're having. All of my closest friends
right now are extremely healthy relationships. Yeah. I don't have to like think through how to
word a text to not upset them. I don't have to like walk on eggshells. I don't have to stress if they've
not texted me back. Like the way that it, it is like relational safety at a physiological level. Like
the way my nervous system is just like, we can focus on ourselves. I don't have to be constantly
monitoring and watching everybody else like a hawk anymore. Like they're good. And if we have an
issue, the pattern shows me that they will come to me and we will have an emotionally mature conversation
about it and we will repair and then we will all move on. Like the way that it just helps me move
through life is like a more regulated person because I don't have to move into that hyper vigilance
and the anxiety of it all. Yeah, man. And then we're modeling that for a kid. Yeah. We're modeling that
they deserve that and we're modeling sometimes we have to walk away from relationships that are
toxic and that are treating us like shit. Like you don't deserve that either. And I hope with
you ever have a relationship that you will take a stand and advocate for yourself or for what you
deserve. And if they're not able to do that, I hope you will walk away. Like I feel so proud of that.
Maggie, what a what a good way to to end. I can't add to that because I believe so
strongly in what you said. It has been absolutely great to catch up with you. I am going to put
all Maggie's handles. Just share it there. Your handles on TikTok and Instagram for people.
So it's Maggie with perspectives and perspectical things kind of on by but I wear these silly glasses
that are turquoise and then camp lovable. Maggie, it's great. All this will be in the show notes.
I can't wait to receive your book and all I will say then is until I see the next time when we're
discussing it. Thank you, Katie. Thanks so much for having me. I love this. Thanks for being on and
everybody. I will see you next Friday with series two where myself and Dr. Ruth Callahan will be
answering your questions. See you then, bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Maggie Nick is a recovering good child turned trauma therapist and parenting expert.
Maggie helps recovering good kids overcome relational shame trauma and perfectionism.
Good kids often suppress emotions, perform calm, and feel the need to please others.
Summary:
In the conversation with Maggie Nick, she shares her journey from being a good child to becoming a trauma therapist and parenting expert. Maggie helps individuals recover from relational shame trauma and perfectionism by creating a safe space for them to address their emotions and stop seeking constant approval. Good kids, who often suppress their emotions and feel the need to be perfect, can face challenges in adulthood due to the pressure of maintaining a facade of goodness.
Maggie emphasizes the importance of acknowledging the impact parents have on their children and highlights the need for parents to create a supportive environment where emotions are validated. She discusses how patterns of behavior in childhood can impact adult relationships and the importance of setting boundaries and recognizing one's own needs. By understanding and addressing these dynamics, individuals can break free from the cycle of people-pleasing and perfectionism.
FAQs
These traits can lead to lifelong relational trauma responses and feelings of guilt, constantly worrying about others' opinions and striving for perfection.
Being the 'good kid' can result in feeling exhausted from proving one's goodness, bottling emotions, and constantly performing calm to meet others' expectations.
Parents should be aware of the invisible trauma and pressure faced by 'good kids', checking in on them and creating a safe space for them to express their true emotions.
The 'good kid' often internalizes pressure to be perfect, while the 'bad kid' may exhibit fight or flight responses. Understanding these dynamics can help parents provide appropriate support.
Acknowledging mistakes and actively working on repairing relationships with children is crucial, as children's behaviors can reflect underlying family dynamics and parental influences.
Childhood experiences of people-pleasing and suppressing emotions can manifest in parenting challenges, such as difficulty setting boundaries and handling children's emotions.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.