Go back

Ep. #074: Philosophy and Love: Are we complete without love?

from Shot of Philosophy

17m 20s

Ep. #074: Philosophy and Love: Are we complete without love?

The host continues the Shada Philosophy series on love, reflecting on Thich Nhat Hanh's teaching that commitment is positive and that sharing suffering with others through love is worthwhile. Drawing on a wedding ceremony's emphasis on togetherness, the host describes relationships as an "us" larger than either individual, sustained through mutual attention and care. He then turns to ancient Greek concepts of love—eros, philia, and agape—and revisits the myth of humans split in half searching for their other half. Though he long rejected the myth as promoting a negative sense of deficiency, he now sees value in it: everyone is incomplete, and that incompleteness motivates growth. Perfection, as Pema Chodron suggested, is a kind of death. Citing The School of Life's How to Find Love, he explores the "instinct for completion"—the attraction to people with complementary qualities. He illustrates this with a close friend who helped him become more comfortable in social settings and challenged a childhood belief that "there's always a jerk." He argues that opposites may attract but polar extremes are unsustainable, and that partners should balance each other while remaining compatible. Finally, he encourages listeners to reflect on where they feel incomplete and to have imaginative, honest conversations about growth and future plans, concluding that the ancient Greeks were, in a sense, right.

Transcription

3542 Words, 19372 Characters

English
Speaker 1Hello, everybody. How you doing? Hope all is well. This is Prayersopolis. Welcome back to another episode of Shada Philosophy. And today we're going to continue talking about love. So I was reflecting a little bit on what Thich Nhat Hanh offered last episode with compassion, equanimity. I really enjoyed reading that and sharing it and thinking about it and speaking about it. Because I think what he's offering, again, as I hope I conveyed yesterday, is really sort of an encouragement to look at commitment as a positive thing. The idea that we could share our suffering with someone else and that we can be helpful to others in their suffering through loving them, I think is a really good thing to do. That should, I think, resonate with everybody because we all suffer and we should all want to help others. I think what made, among other things, what made the wedding ceremony so nice, once again, was that the priest offered that when he was offering the advice given to him by the elderly couple. The emphasis was on togetherness. The idea of almost a sense of oneness, right? Being one thing. I would like to think of relationships as I'm me, you're you, then we come together to make this third thing, like this us thing, that is larger than the both of us. It's bigger than the both of us. And through commitment, we cultivate this love, we take care of it, we give it the attention it deserves, we give each other the attention we deserve, and we can flourish in a relationship. And I think, as I said yesterday, it's interesting to sort of think about or divide this notion, this notion of the self as individual and the self as someone in a relationship. So I want to talk a little bit about the ancient Greeks today, and even just the Greek language in general, because I think in Greek you have different types of love, right? You have eros, which is romantic love, philia, which is like, I think, family, friendship, love, agape, which is like, sort of like a divine love. So for me, that's a great way to understand the complexity of love. And I think a lot of our reflections, I think, are sort of the same. And I think that's a great way to understand the complexity of love. And I think a lot of our reflections on this topic will apply to many different types of love. But the ancient Greek conception of romantic love, or one of them among many others, of course, that I always used to challenge and disagree with, but now I'm revisiting and sort of understanding it in a different way, was the idea that we were all born with four arms and four limbs, then the gods cut us in half, and we're searching our whole lives for our other half. I've never liked that. I've always thought that was sort of encouraging myself and others to portray or, not portray, to understand themselves as being incomplete and as being deficient, and that's not a good thing. But what I realize is, as I'm reflecting on today, I'm going to share a little bit from The School of Life, a great book called How to Find Love, that I find very interesting. A little bit from them on this, and I think there are actually some truth to that. And I think, for me, maybe my immediate or immediate and then sustained disagreement with that was a fear of the idea of love. I think it's a fear of being incomplete when really we're all incomplete. Which is to say, if there's a way in which you'd like to grow, there's a sense that there's some incompleteness there, and that's fine. I think for me, and this is, as I'm reflecting on it now, kind of a little bit ridiculous, because I've always loved the myth of Sisyphus. The first time I read that, I was like, "Oh, this is it. This makes sense. I agree with this." Well, the myth of Sisyphus, to me, one of the major implications is like, well, you're never really done until you are. Until your life's over, things are still there. Until you're done, you're incomplete. At least sort of, right? So I think for me, I was interpreting this idea of incompleteness in an overly negative way, that might have been a defense mechanism, right? Over the idea that like, I want to feel like I'm living in abundance. Well, you could live in abundance and still be incomplete. The incompleteness actually gives us something to do. I think maybe weeks ago, even, we talked about Pema Chodron, right? Perfection is a kind of death. So, you know, perfection and completeness are kind of similar. And the more I reflect on my own life, the more I realize, like, you know, I have been helped in a lot of ways to grow in directions I wanted to grow, but just, you know, I wasn't growing effectively. And I could think of a lot of different types of relationships that have really helped me through that, or with that process of, again, up until now, I would deny that I was, quote, "incomplete," but this process of being incomplete, being okay with that, and then growing, right? So I think the ancient Greeks, when they said, you know, "You're looking for your other half, and, you know, you're searching for completeness," more to me now, when I take a step back, implies that love helps us pursue a sense of completeness that otherwise we'd really struggle to achieve by ourselves. I can't remember who said this. It wasn't me, and I'm sorry for not remembering, but it was something like love helps us do things we couldn't do by ourselves, right? And helps us become people we wouldn't have become otherwise. Without this other person. And again, we could extend it to family, friends, right? These other people. I think that's a really cool idea that works nicely with this notion of interpreting incompleteness in a slightly less dramatic or drastic way, right? And just accepting the idea that we, in love, have to grow. Thich Nhat Hanh, right? Great quote. I always say this. When love stops to grow—no, when love stops growing, it starts dying. I love that idea because it's motivational. And the more I'm saying this, the more I'm not agreeing with the ancient greeks more easily because that's like saying you're incomplete you need to grow love needs to grow right so when we're in love and when we love others we have to prioritize helping them develop in ways that might be healthy and then also prioritize allowing them to offer us stuff offer us care attention love information even right that is going to be helpful for our growth in the pursuit of a greater sense of wholeness or completeness i actually was just having a conversation with my roommate who's been a very close friend of mine for a very long time about how he's helped me grow a lot in regards to my ability to just like be in social situations um i was never really like a huge party person i have a small family so i feel like when i'm around a lot of people i just get a little bit like kind of just edgy i guess would be a way to put it or i just don't want to be there and he's the opposite of that and he has helped me tremendously even just thinking of how comfortable he is helps me realize okay there's nothing here that's like uh let's say there's nothing here that's inherently negative there doesn't have to be something wrong nothing has to go wrong actually even this is this is funny i challenged one of my family members recently because one of their mantras is like uh how do i put it nicely on the podcast um there's always a jerk let's put it that way i'm kind of tempering that a little bit there's always a jerk right which to implies like whenever you're with other people this is what sartre said too right hell is other people i think starch is a little more general i actually can agree with that a little bit more to an extent but i challenged my family member because the idea of always bothered me i was like you know that's kind of a negative thing to believe right that there's always going to be someone who's rude there's always going to be someone who's a pain there's always going to be somebody causing a problem that's not something we should carry with us i think so my friend has helped me pursue completeness or wholeness in a way where it's like i no longer believe that because as a result of even quite simply him just inviting me out to places frequently enough where i was like i'm not going to keep saying no i went and i you know i got evidence i'm okay everything tonight went fine we're all together for hours at a time and everything was fun everybody was cool i had a good time so it challenged and this is when i say it's a mantra from a family member i mean it's one that i heard i've heard since i was a child right so i kind of assimilated it took it into my way of and just believed in it and really it wasn't up until recently that i really started questioning it that the conversation i told you about a moment ago where i challenged a family member happened two days ago or maybe three days ago and i was like you know that's not really true right like this idea of always is actually really problematic because you start to view the world as a place where there is constantly going to be some type of problem and that's just not true right we talked a little bit i think weeks ago about murphy's law whatever can go wrong will go wrong it's a similar idea it's not true it's in a literal sense untrue it's not true it's not true it's in a literal sense untrue but i had to go out and gather evidence and my friendship really helped me do that and i no longer have that belief it comes up here and there i have to you know let's say uh how do i put like kind of like discuss it or engage with it here or there but ultimately you know it's something i've come to challenge so this has been a friendship and this is someone who i love as a friend who you know he's really helped me and guided me towards the growth that i've needed that's helped me become a better person a happier person definitely a less anxious person so on that note let's see what the school of life has to offer once again the book is called how to find love and this is about this idea of completion i love this idea the chapter is called an instinct for completion one of the most powerful forces within love is the instinct for completion all of us are radically incomplete we lack a range of qualities in our characters psychological but also physical we might be missing calm creativity practical know-how wit strength or sensitivity it is as if somewhere within us we recognize this incompleteness and experience an attraction whenever we enter the orbit of someone who possesses a complementary quality through love we seek to make good a defect and to complete ourselves i think this is a great paragraph and as i said earlier in the episode or this discussion right we need to have conversations like this in school i think a philosophy classroom is a great place to have this conversation once again we love the philosophy of love and this is a great place to have this conversation once again and we love wisdom and philosophy. Wisdom is what we just offered with this book, love. That's a piece of wisdom. It's practical knowledge we could use. Well, think for a minute. How would you like to grow? Think about the people in your world. How are they helping you grow? I think a great exercise for those of us who might be looking for a fulfilling relationship or might be looking for growth in our current relationship, once again, revolves around philosophical meditation and self-writing. Take a moment. How would you like your relationship to be? How would you like to spend time with this other person? What would you like to offer them? What type of growth would you like for them to encourage within you? What are the, you know, he said traits, characteristics, right? What are the traits and characteristics that you think are your strongest for a relationship? What are your weakest? And how would you like this other person that you, let's say, would like to meet or the person that you're currently with? How would you like them to, let's say, represent those characteristics? Or how would you like them to maybe not have certain characteristics? What don't you need? I don't need somebody who's intense. That's it. I don't need somebody who's strong. I don't need that. That's a bad move. Not the move. I need someone who's more relaxed, right? Someone who prioritizes time with family and friends, right? Because I have a tendency to prioritize that, but I also really prioritize work. I also need someone who prioritizes work to a large extent because they wouldn't really want to spend time with me if they couldn't understand why I like to work a little bit on a Saturday and a Sunday, right? So these are conversations about completing ourselves, but also completing our lives. Because for me to have a balanced life, I need someone who says, okay, stop. Come on. We're going to go to my mother's house. We're going to go to your mother's house, whatever. And that's important, right? This idea of completion too, for me, kind of makes me think of the word balance as well. One of the largest myths around love, I think, or especially, let's say, romantic love, is that opposites attract. Okay. Let me be clear. I agree with that, but that really isn't sustainable. Or maybe I should be more specific. Polar opposites attract, but that's not going to work well over the long term. Because when, for example, I talk about prioritizing work, family, and friends, as I said, if I'm, let's say, I want a little bit of an extreme, I am a little bit of a workaholic. I think that's an accurate assessment. If you're on the other end of the extreme and you're not passionate at all about your work or your career, you really dislike the idea of work, you would see me, let's say, making time for time on a Saturday to research for an hour or something and really be against that. We fight over it, right? Then that's not going to work. So I think you have to be, let's say, maybe on opposite sides of neutral, but close to each other relatively, right? So it's more about a relative type of balancing each other out in order to have a sustainable relationship. And you're going to influence each other no matter what. Whenever you spend people, I'm sorry, whenever you spend a lot of time with people, I feel it's very difficult for them not to influence you. And ultimately you want to be around people who you could say, yeah, they are influencing me. I'm aware of it. I'm choosing to be influenced. And those are good influences. These people bring the best out in me in ways that I couldn't bring it out of myself. I think that's a really healthy realization to have about all of our love relationships, family, friends, and significant others. So take a minute, right? As we said, as we always say, right? Self-righting. Where might you feel a little bit inclined? Where might you feel incomplete? And my example for this is I've always struggled, let's say, or that's a strong word, but I've always wanted to be more comfortable at a party, right? My friend Dave helps me do that. And our friendship has helped me significantly. So that would be a quality of mine in my character, or let's say in my psychology that I've worked on tremendously because of him, right? Also, I would say to stick with this, I'm definitely missing a sense of calm. Other people in my life bring me that 100%. Creativity, I feel like I'm pretty good on that. I encourage other people to get creative. Practical know-how, problem for me. Other people help me with it for sure. So take a minute, maybe identify some of these traits. And again, maybe craft a vision of relationships, friendships. Maybe you want to guide them in certain directions. Maybe you're looking for new friends, family relationships, same thing. You want to guide them. Maybe you're single. You want to think about a significant other. I think it makes sense to have a vision of relationships. Maybe you want to have some imagination in all love relationships. I think love, to a large extent, in many ways, requires imagination. Me asking you, where could you be more complete? That's an imagination exercise. It's an exercise in thinking of ourselves in ways that will encourage us to grow into something different, right? I think similarly, you want to craft, if you're with someone, again, back to the wedding, right? They have an image of their lives together, I'd imagine. They've thought about these things. What would it might be like to have kids, what it might be like to have kids or not have kids, right? What it might be like to live over here, over there? How would your career impact the time we spend together and vice versa? These are all exercises in imagination that I think really are important for sustaining and even, let's say, starting healthy relationships. We have those conversations, I think, most consciously, or we articulate them most clearly in the context of romantic relationships, for whatever reason. And just even stick with that for a moment, right? You definitely need to have that conversation with somebody you're with. You need to have that conversation with somebody you're with. If you're on totally different pages about what the future might hold, you have to both sit down with your imaginations and then sit down with each other and really see what you might want to have in life five years from now. I think that's a really healthy and important conversation to have if you want something sustainable and something healthy. And again, even that, for me, revolves around completeness. For me, my life, this is a bit personal, but whatever. For me, my life would be complete with a family. I really am looking forward to being a father and having children. That's important to me. I'm looking forward to being a father and having children. I'm looking forward to being a father So I conveyed that, right? We need to convey these things. And again, it revolves around completion of a life, what will make life full, what will make life balanced. And I think it's profoundly philosophical to sit down and lovingly have a conversation with somebody where you ask them about what they would like, how they might want, or let's say, how they might, yeah, I think want's a good word, how they might want you to help them grow and vice versa, and how you might want to grow with them, how they might want to grow with you when you're building a future together. So you know what? The ancient Greeks, kind of right. That's my major conclusion today. And I'm a little bit angry with myself because for years I've been teaching that that's too dramatic. And as a half Greek, I'm like, you know, my inclination is pretty much always to say, listen, Greeks, calm down, you know? But actually, I think it's pretty interesting. We do things with our loved ones. And I'm speaking now about general love, but also about the one person, our significant other, right? We become people as a result of those relationships that we have with our loved ones. And maybe we're not have become otherwise. And that should be a positive, healthy thing. Hope this was helpful. We might keep talking about love this week. I'm enjoying this. So we'll see how it goes. And again, check out this book, How to Find Love by the School of Life. It's a great book and definitely insightful. Thank you for listening. And I'll talk to you soon.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The host continues a series on love, building on Thich Nhat Hanh's teachings on compassion and commitment as a positive force.
  2. Relationships are framed as a shared "third thing" larger than the two individuals, cultivated through mutual attention and commitment.
  3. Ancient Greek distinctions among eros, philia, and agape help capture the complexity of love.
  4. The Greek myth of split beings seeking their other half is reinterpreted positively: incompleteness is universal and gives us room to grow.
  5. The School of Life's "instinct for completion" suggests we are drawn to people whose complementary qualities address our deficiencies.
  6. Love requires growth, echoing Thich Nhat Hanh's idea that love that stops growing begins to die.
  7. A personal example shows how a close friend helped the host overcome the inherited belief that "there's always a jerk."
  8. Sustainable relationships need compatible—not polar-opposite—partners, plus honest, imaginative conversations about shared futures.

Summary:

The host continues the Shada Philosophy series on love, reflecting on Thich Nhat Hanh's teaching that commitment is positive and that sharing suffering with others through love is worthwhile. Drawing on a wedding ceremony's emphasis on togetherness, the host describes relationships as an "us" larger than either individual, sustained through mutual attention and care. He then turns to ancient Greek concepts of love—eros, philia, and agape—and revisits the myth of humans split in half searching for their other half.

Though he long rejected the myth as promoting a negative sense of deficiency, he now sees value in it: everyone is incomplete, and that incompleteness motivates growth. Perfection, as Pema Chodron suggested, is a kind of death. Citing The School of Life's How to Find Love, he explores the "instinct for completion"—the attraction to people with complementary qualities.

" He argues that opposites may attract but polar extremes are unsustainable, and that partners should balance each other while remaining compatible. Finally, he encourages listeners to reflect on where they feel incomplete and to have imaginative, honest conversations about growth and future plans, concluding that the ancient Greeks were, in a sense, right.

FAQs

The episode mentions eros (romantic love), philia (family and friendship love), and agape (divine love). These distinctions help capture the complexity of love.

He initially disliked the myth because it framed people as incomplete and deficient. He now sees incompleteness as natural and as something that gives us room to grow through love.

It is the idea that we are all incomplete in various qualities, and love attracts us to people who possess complementary traits. Through love, we try to make up for our defects and become more whole.

He agrees that opposites can attract, but says polar opposites are not sustainable long-term. Partners should be close to each other on important matters, balancing each other relatively rather than being extreme opposites.

His friend repeatedly invited him to social gatherings, which gave him evidence that being around many people can be fine and fun. This helped him challenge a long-held negative belief that there is always a jerk in every group.

He suggests philosophical meditation and self-writing: ask how you would like to grow, which traits are your strengths and weaknesses, and how others could help you grow. Then imagine the kind of relationship and future you want.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.