EP. 065: More than Meds - Exploring Physiotherapy for Migraine Management with Kerstin Luedtke
from Physiotutors Podcast
52m 6s
Migraine is a complex neurological condition defined by specific clinical criteria, including unilateral, moderate-to-severe, pulsating headaches lasting four to 72 hours with associated symptoms like nausea or photophobia. Around 10% of cases involve aura, often visual, occurring before the headache. Research indicates that the hypothalamus acts as the primary trigger, initiating a cascade through the trigeminal system and brain regions responsible for pain and dizziness. While migraine is not fully understood, evidence suggests central sensitization and reduced inhibition—similar to other chronic pain conditions—but patients remain functionally normal between attacks. Genetic factors contribute to susceptibility, though no single gene explains migraine; environmental triggers like stress or diet are often subjective and may reflect pre-attack sensitivities rather than direct causation. In physiotherapy, neck musculoskeletal dysfunctions are common and treatable, with studies showing that manual therapy, education, and aerobic exercise can reduce headache days by two days. However, physiotherapy does not cure migraine and should be integrated with medical management. Physiotherapists play a key role in managing symptoms, improving posture, and promoting patient self-management through education and lifestyle advice. Despite its potential, physiotherapy is currently underrepresented in migraine guidelines, especially in Germany. Ongoing research focuses on patient experiences, learning mechanisms, and large randomized trials to validate the effectiveness of physiotherapy. Patient feedback reveals that current care often lacks education and active engagement, highlighting a need for more patient-centered, evidence-based approaches in migraine treatment.
Hi and welcome to Physiotutors Podcast episode 65 with Dr. Kerstin Lütgei.
Kerstin is a physiotherapist, maniotherapist and professor at the University of Lübeck, Germany.
She has published over a hundred papers on a variety of topics and has done extensive research
on migraines, which is our topic of today's episode.
Hi Kerstin, welcome to the podcast and great to have you. Thank you for having me.
Sure, I have prepared a lot of questions, so let's start.
Let's start out. Could you please give us a brief definition of migraine headaches?
Yes, migraine headaches are classified within a very comprehensive overview provided by the
International Headache Classification, or the International Headache Society's Classification
System. And a migraine headache exists if you've had five, you need to have five attacks and
they need to fulfill certain criteria. And the criteria are that the headache lasts four to
72 hours. It needs to be unilateral, moderate or high intensity. It needs a pulsating quality
and it gets worse with physical activity. And the other issue that you really need to have to
fulfill migraine criteria is you need to have associated symptoms. And these could be nausea
with or without vomiting or it could be phonophobia and photophobia. And only if you fulfill these
criteria, this is called a migraine headache. All right, and there's also a special category
within the migraine sufferers. And that's a migraine with aura. What is that and how many people
who have migraine also experience or are symptoms? Yes, sure. This is an interesting question,
because I think one of the mysteries about migraine are that only if you have aura is migraine,
which is absolutely not true. Migraine with aura is only one subcategory of approximately 30 different
migraine subtypes. And so if you have migraine with aura, what you usually have is visual symptoms,
most of the RS are visual. And it can be like a unilateral flickering or it could be colorful lines
through your field of vision, different types of visual phenomena that people describe.
This occurs before the headache comes on, usually like 30 to 60 minutes before the headaches comes
on. In rare cases, this can be sensory, so something like pins and needles. There's a very rare
type of aura, which is like a hemiplegic aura. This is one subtype of migraine, which is
the only one that we know the genetics of. It's strictly familiar and it's called hemiplegic migraine,
so this is a very scary aura, but this is extremely rare.
Or you said, "How many?" I forgot a part of the question. It's approximately 10% of migraines
are first that do have aura. Okay. And at the moment, what is the leading path of physiological theory
behind migraine headaches? I think there's still a bit of a discussion going on, right?
There is some discussion, although we have to say, compared to other pathologies,
we have understood migraine fairly well. The main driving physiological changes occur
in the central nervous system. And there's one structure, which is even sometimes called the
migraine generator, which is the hypothalamus. And to the reason why it's called that is in one study
where people have been migraines have been scanned for 31 days, each and every day in the MRI
scanner. And receiving visual or olfactory or painful stimulation in the scanner, the outcome was
that even before people knew they're going to have a migraine, around about 48 hours before the
headache comes on, the hypothalamus was the first structure to react to these stimulation. So it's
the first structure of our body that we know of where migraine tech starts. And this is why they're
called the migraine generator. From here, it's triggered all over. One of the main areas is the
trigeminal nervous system. This is responsible for all the symptoms that we know,
responsible for the pain. Because it elevates the duamata, which is the structure that calls
headaches, also responsible for anything that we feel in the face. Possibly triggering something
to the neck, which is probably something that we're going to talk about later. And also triggering
other structures in the brain, responsible for the hypersensitivity, responsible for the feeling
of dizziness or nausea and all the known symptoms of migraine. So it's starting in the center of
the brain. And it spreads from there, changes the vascular system, for example. But that's not the
course, but the consequence. Okay. And maybe as a follow-up question, how is the hypothalamus of
migraine sufferers different to the hypothalamus of people who don't have it?
It's probably the key question that we're still trying to understand. Well, I think
the most accepted theory at the moment is that the brain is constantly adapting to anything.
And the brain is constantly active. So there might be cyclic changes within the nervous system,
which are totally normal. And it swings up and it swings down. It becomes more sensitive. It
becomes less sensitive, which is probably a very normal procedure. But what changes the system
or what explains why people with migraine then develop an attack at other people's
don't is probably because there's a lack of inhibition. So there's nothing stopping
that sensitivity. Usually in our system, when things become more sensitive, at the same time,
the inhibition system is starting to work. And so it keeps things in balance. And this is
probably what is disturbed in people with migraine. That is, this sounds a bit like chronic pain to
me. If we talk about central sensitization, like a lack of inhibition. Definitely. Definitely,
there are similarities between what we know about chronic low back pain, for example, which is
probably more study disease. And people with migraine, there's one big difference. And that's
in between attacks. Migraine patients are probably very similar. Or you have to look very
hard to find any differences to people without migraine. While we know from people with
chronic neck pain, chronic low back pain or CRPS or phantom limb pain, all those other chronic
pain models that have been studied that there's no in between attacks. There's probably changes
which are more or less intense, but it's tonic. Very interesting stuff. And I think we already
started discussing a little bit about risk factors. So what could be a reason that people,
first of all, develop migraines, but also what are risk factors that trigger migraine episodes?
I don't know if you want to split your answer. Probably study with your first question.
Not really know. There is people who say that everybody can develop migraine attacks.
There's another pool of people who says it's a genetic disease. There has been genetic studies
where they found, I think it's about 130 or something gene genetic changes on people with migraine
compared to people without. Most of these are known genes, so they're known changes that we know from
depression, from chronic pain, from other diseases. So there's nothing specific for migraine,
except for that one type of migraine, which is the familiar hemiplegic migraine. That's the
one that we know. But in terms of normal migraine, there is no real genetic explanation, but there's
genetic differences. One of the hypothesis could be that if you have got all these differences,
you might be able to develop an attack, but you don't necessarily have to.
That probably explains why there's a high prevalence in families. Usually people who have
migraine have at least one first line family member who also suffers from migraine, which is a
difficult thing to say because there's a prevalent disease. The likelihood of somebody else having
migraine is high. So there's no real explanation, but there could be one. So a genetic predisposition
and then other things occurring in life. Maybe there's even a learning factor to it, but I think
starting a discussion if I say that. Question number two was what triggers the attack, right?
Well, if you ask people with migraine, I think everybody can tell you triggers. And these are the
common things that everybody knows, like stress, but people with migraine don't have more stress
than other people. Everybody has got stress. That's normal. But it's what people say. So a high
levels of stress,
or even the dropping from a high level of stress, which triggers that very
unpleasant sensation of weekend headaches. The other thing that people say is
weather, but then again studies were not able to confirm any weather changes, at
least not any sort of pressure changes from a high to a low or from a low to a
high, did not correlate with migraine diaries. The other thing that people say are
specific foods or drinks like alcohol or coffee, that sort of thing, chocolate,
citrus fruit, these sort of foods. The problem is that researchers would really
like to trigger migraine attacks. So attempts have been made to trigger migraine
with let's say it will be very useful to give somebody a piece of chocolate, then
put them in a scanner and be able to record a migraine aura. Migraine aura is
very understudied because it's very difficult to catch it. And if we could do
that by triggering it reliably that we're really good, but it never worked. So one
of the explanations at the moment is that possibly what people call a migraine
trigger is a symptom of the prodromal phase of migraine, which means that let's
say if the migraine is coming on and we know your hypothalamus is already very
active, this might trigger the desire for specific foods, for example. I've had
a patient and I think I have to tell you because it was very, for me, it was
very convincing because she said she never drinks any alcohol for years. She's
never had any alcohol, but when she knows she would like to have a glass of red wine,
she knows on the next day she's gonna have a headache. And this could either
be a self offering prophecy or it could be the desire for red wine, which is part
of her normal migraine attack. The other thing is that people are more, this is
something that's indefinite, more hypersensitive in the prodromal phase of the
attack, and maybe then sort of the same level of stress or the same weather or
anything that sort of surrounds us all the time is maybe just perceived as more
stressful or more unpleasant or and that might be or that might lead to the
interpretation of this being a trigger to an attack. But this is hypothetical.
It makes sense though. Okay and by the way I forgot to mention this in a
beginning if you have any specific articles and mind or authors feel free to
throw out names because we always have a transcript and we will link all of
the articles in the transcript so people really want to dive deep, they can
look them up so no problem. I mean if you mentioned that the they call it the
mother of all studies, which is the one where people have been scanned for 31
days. This has been done by a girl called Laura Schulter from the Hamburg Research
Group and I think this is a study that's really worth reading because the
effort has been put into scanning people for 31 days each and every day at the
same time of the day without any medication that is recommitment so I think this
is probably the most worthy one to read. Yeah definitely going to read that after
our podcast record. And we already touched a little bit on prevalence when we
talked about heredity. How prevalent are migrant headaches especially if we
compare to other forms of headache? Well numbers change obviously because you
can only count people who have entered the medical system somehow and these
numbers are always sort of around 15% prevalence globally. One year prevalence
is obviously a little higher. Sometimes it's up to 20% but around about that
numbers. Okay and comparison to tension type headache. It's basically it's
probably number two right? No it's actually the other way around. There's two
types of tension type headache. One is the episodic tension type headache which
is probably the most prevalent headache type of all. It's what we have when we
say we've not slept enough or we hadn't had enough water or something like that.
This usually fulfills the criteria for tension type headache if diagnosed
according to the international classification of headaches. But this type of
headache because it responds to medication it's usually gone within a few days.
It's not that high intensity usually never enters the medical system so
numbers here are only based on self-population studies. The other type of
tension type headache, the chronic tension type headache and chronic in this
case means more than 15 days a month. It's a little bit of a different
definition to the chronic pain definitions that we know from low back pain.
It's not the months that you have had something but the number of days you have
headache in each month. That is extremely rare. But these people suffer a lot
because a lot of these people have got headache every day which is really
annoying. It's not high intensity, they don't have to lie down, they can't
function but it's really annoying and it doesn't respond to any of the
medication that we know. Not to the acute medication, not to pain medication, not
to preventive medication and it's a lot easier or a lot harder, I should say, a lot
harder to treat than chronic migraine in comparison. So I would say a
episodic tension type headache is about 80% of the population. Chronic tension
type headache around about one, possibly. And the headache type that
physios really love the cervical genic headache because it's easy to treat
and it responds to physiotherapy treatment. The bad news is this is a lot
wearer than we think. I always ask groups, what do you think? How prevalent
is cervical genic headache? And I usually get numbers between 20 and 50% and
it's round about possibly between one and four percent if we follow the
international criteria. Yeah, I was aware of that number. Sorry. Through
through through Rene Acastin. Yes. And I think the 80% that I had in mind was
exactly based on what you said, episodic tension type headache. I think it was
a study by Stolfner who did an analysis. And if we look at the typical migraine
patient, is he or she male or female? What age group? What are other
typical characteristics of this typical migraine patient? Yeah, it's still the
case that migraine is more prevalent in females than in male. Not sure whether
this is contact to the medical system, whether male suffer in silence, I don't
know. But probably two to one that's that sort of numbers are reported. Where
the normal sort of migraine career is that a tech start with puberty. So round
about the ages of 11 to 13 possibly a bit later in May than in female. And it
usually accompanies papers throughout their productive life years, which is the
one reason why it's always considered economically very relevant because it
reduces sort of work days. The whole productivity, it's also a burden on
family life because the years where you raise children and where you're
responsible at home, they're affected by the migraine disease. And in a lot of
cases stops in females with menopause. So yes, might be a hormonal
contribution to it. But that's not the only explanation because then may
it wouldn't be able to have migraine. But it usually stops around at age with
exceptions. Okay. And if I move on to my next question, I think we already kind of
answered it. But maybe you want to add something else to it. And the question
was to what degree do we see commonalities between migraine patients and
other chronic pain populations? So we talked about migraine basically
having an episode than nothing than an episode while in the chronic pain
population, it's like an ongoing thing. What else would you like to add to that
question? Yes, we've done actually some research ourselves about this
because there's common comorbidities, you should say, like depression, anxiety,
that sort of thing. I think we need to be a little bit careful with the
interpretation because it might be consequence and not cause of
chronicity. What we have looked into is whether migraine patients have a
larger two point discrimination threshold on the episode I could find. This is
something we know from back pain that the sort of tips of a caliper have to be
further apart to be able to distinguish them as two separate tips of a caliper.
And we've tried that in the episode I could find of migraine patients, and it was
indeed larger than in people without migraine. This was published in Journal of
headache and pain. Then another study that we did, but that's very
preliminary data, is looking at the left right
recommendation.
of migraine patients compared to hazy controls regarding heads and faces, so
and we found that the accuracy of detecting and the speed, so if it was once
weight or response time was worse and people with migraine than had the
controls and what else have we looked at? Well, but just very recently a treatment
approach which was based on education and something that we know that works really
well in chronic pain patients and we've adapted that to migraine, so we've
included all the knowledge about pathophysiology of pain, but added to that the
pathophysiology of the hypothalamus and the trigeminal nucleus and the
the connection between the trigeminal and the cervical system, so added
physiological knowledge that's important for the migraine disease and we
found that adding the education gives us another two days reduction of migraine
symptoms which is I think a nice add to what we can do in physiotherapy and if
that works that another is probably another proof that we have got a chronic
pain aspect to the migraine disease. Okay, so we talked a lot about the
backgrounds or we were laying the groundwork so to say let's move on to
diagnosis and my first question is always what are red flags that we have to
consider? I mean we touched on the hemiplegic migraine, so I think stroke would
be one red flag maybe to consider. What else would you like to rule out when
you see a patient who presents to you with a possible migraine? Yes, you can
see me thinking. There's quite a lot of reported criteria, I think the most
well-known are the SNOOP criteria which have got something to do with the
severity of symptoms, so if there's a sudden onset of severe headache that
could point towards a red flag which might be like a bleeding, for example,
obviously stroke is another one. Brain tumors obviously another one that would
become obvious of migraine symptoms or headache symptoms change over time
and if they turn towards something that's not known. So a person who's got the
same attack with the same criteria and known headache is not scary, but it's
supposed to be scary if something changes if it gets worse in the
density, worse in frequency if there's a sudden new pain and if there's
associated things like systemic fever for example neurological symptoms that
would be the most common red flags. Okay, thank you for your answer and if we move
on and we talk about the diagnosis is there anything else besides the ICD age
three criteria that we talked about that you would consider in your in your
approach? Well we're in physiotherapy setting you so I think you're probably
interested in musculoskeletal structures and and this is how it all started
really because I'm not sure how much you want to know about my own biography
but the reason why migraine is interesting is because while I did my PhD on
dead pine I was working in a workgroup under the head of department of the
headache clinic of Hamburg University Hospital and we had discussions all the
time. It's the neck contributing to migraine or not and my physiotherapy
background screamed yes yes yes headache is always so I can find and and his
neurology background was saying no life stops at the Oxford there's no life
south of the Oxford and and so we decided we have to look into this and the
literature was surprisingly limited there was hardly any information and so we
started investigating by developing a consensus-based battery of tests there
was so many different tests and it all didn't make sense so we had to ask
experts what would you do how would you assess the swikers fine and people with
headache so there was 11 tests that experts agreed on in the consensus
statement which was published and was a deathy procedure and I will provide you
the reference. I've seen and read the paper so I can put it in there so I'm
certain of that. If I could just remember the years but yes the other thing that
we rendered as we used those 11 tests and investigated approximately 170
people I was the blinded examiner I didn't know whether people had migraine or
not half of them migraine people were episodic half were chronic and once
it were people without headaches and both of us the neurologist and I were
really surprised to find that over 90% of migraine patients had muscular
skeletal dysfunction that we can detect as physios and that obviously opened a
lot of questions is this important could it be a cause could it be a
contributing factor is it something that maintains a tax could it trigger a
tax or is it just a consequence that just because people half repeated the
tax and they have all those pains so do they change because of that and
obviously that's a lot a lot harder to answer than just assessing the next
of people and the muscular skeletal dysfunction set again is published and here
in other years 2016 and the Genoa cephalalgia because this has been cited
quite a lot and but does this differentiate migraine from cervical genic head
I probably not this is a little bit disappointing because we were hoping to
find a test and other groups have repeated and some people say that maybe
the flexion rotation test where we are testing C12 mainly in rotation could
differentiate between cervical genic headache and migraine but in my sample this
was positive too so I sorry this this test also does not really distinguish
between the two populations I do still think and it is part of the
criteria for cervical genic headache that the headache needs to be able to be
provoked by maneuvers that we do so if we let's say hold extension lateral
flexion for example whatever you want to do so I could quadrant or any other
test or manual test if you want and you can provoke the typical headache that
I would say strongly provides information about this might be cervical
genic headache and not so much migraine but referred pain to the head not because
this is something we found in my patients to eat so there is no real
distinction I think the other headache type probably interesting to try to
distinguish as tension type headache we know that people with tension type
headache have got tension this is in the name in the masses of the neck but
again contradicting common knowledge it's not the cause so the tension in the
neck is not the cause of tension type headaches tension type headaches are
primary headaches so again they are starting in the in the brain and the
tension in the neck is a symptom we can help people reducing the symptom but
this is probably a different thing you probably got to ask me about
approach it's to treat but yeah this is more of a diagnosis so I think as
physios we should really rely on the IHS classification based mainly on the
unimnestic criteria and assessing the neck makes a lot of sense because it
helps us do we treat or do we not treat as physios as if yes how so the test
that we have or the the dysfunctions that we can see they are not really
different in different forms of headache right that's true this could be
summarized like like like that but we do see certain dysfunctions that we
don't see in healthy people definitely yes yeah that's a very shot off a
long answer yeah that's very generous so what kind of dysfunctions if you can
briefly summarize what kind of dysfunctions do we see in then let's say the
headache sufferers so migraine migraine nurse and other headache sufferers
and compared to the healthy population yeah and that study in Safer Aljad 2016
we found that six of the 11 proposed tests were statistically
significantly different between migraine and has the controls and that was the
assessment of the opposite I guess fine using manual testing and we added a
manual test that we a lot of you probably know from Dean Watson which is called
reproduction and resolution and it just generally means that we hold a manual
test ask whether this is provoking typical symptoms and if it's sustained the
pressure whether those symptoms disappear again very similar to trigger point
assessment really just sort of more focused on on joints so that's the second
test and the trigger points and the neck and the face, they were significantly different.
What was not different maybe changed to the other side as posture, I had forward posture,
a range of motion, that sort of thing, the shoulder muscles were not different, the physiological
testing was not different, so I think mainly the most prevalent finding really was the joint
and the muscle dysfunctions, that was my great.
Looking at tension type headache, I would expect the joints not to be that significantly
different from healthy people, but I would expect pronounced findings and neck tension
and the trapezius muscle and probably levitis-capular muscles, possibly other muscles, not really
that well described.
I think Tisa Fernandes de Las Panias did some studies on tension type headache and looked
at trigger point assessment and treatment.
So if it could Janic, I would expect a reduced range of motion, clear unilaterality and
easily provoked headaches through cervical postures, I think this is the easiest distinction
between those three.
Okay, and I also read a paper where you were involved in your group, so you as a group
of authors recommended to also assess vestibular function and postural control impairments.
Can you talk to us about that?
Yeah, that's a very interesting line of research.
I'm not the leading researcher on that, that's a colleague or former colleague of mine, Gabriella
Cavallio.
She is from a study group in Sao Paulo in Brazil and a SNOW professor in Germany in the south
of Germany in Freiburg, Fort Fangen and her interest was on postural control of migraine patients
because they found that indeed dizziness is one of the very common associated symptoms
during an attack and even interictually, so in the time without any symptoms.
And when they started to investigate, they were really surprised that if you put them
onto a balance board or if changing virtual reality environments around migraine patients,
they sway a lot more than people without migraines.
So that was the start of a line of research and one of the most convincing studies was
done in the MRI scan also, functional and brain imaging, where they showed a simulated roller
coaster right, not a very nice thing to watch, so it makes you feel that if you're writing
on a roller coaster.
And migraine patients reported a lot more dizziness in nausea while watching that video.
And also you could see that the cerebellum responded more.
And this sort of links nicely in another line of research of another colleague from the
Hamuk study group that has already looked into anatomical changes in the cerebellum in
migraine patients and now functional changes.
And we can indeed see that parts of the cerebellum are altered in migraine patients which
nicely explains why there are these postural and dizziness associated symptoms that people
report.
Okay.
And as a follow-up question, but this is different than vestibular migraine as a diagnosis
I guess.
Thank you for asking, I forgot about that part of the question, and vestibular migraine
is a subtype of migraine, so this is classified.
Has only recently actually been introduced into that classification system.
And in vestibular migraine, this is real vestibular symptoms, meaning the room is spinning
around you while the posture is way, it's just a very subtle change that people might
not even be aware of.
And you only find it when you are very specifically investigating it, so this is two different things.
The research that I was talking about was done in normal, not vestibular, subtypes of
migraine.
And it's more pronounced, again, as surprising in migraine with aura than it is in migraine
without aura.
Okay.
Interesting.
Okay, we talked quite a bit about diagnosis and about differences between different headache
forms.
Let's move on to treatment.
How effective is physiotherapy or manual therapy in a treatment of headache?
Are we better than other professions or approaches?
Better, no, but we can contribute.
I think if we agree that this is not a neck disease, it makes a lot of sense that physiotherapy
will never be a cure for migraine.
And this is important to acknowledge and it's important to tell patients because we don't
want to raise any expectations that we cannot further.
So I think this is a good starting point.
And every migraine patient needs to be able to treat attacks with working acute pain medication
and it would be unethical to take this away.
We have got the triptoms which are very effective in a majority of patients.
Some patients respond to enzymes, so and sometimes triptoms are more effective, so this is
something that has to be tried out.
If the attacks become more frequent than preventive medication like antidepressants or anti-epiletic
medication works really well in some patients, there's a new medication for severe sufferers
which is based on antibodies, CGRP antibodies, which seems to be very effective.
So this is the baseline.
What can we do as physios?
If there are dysfunctions in the neck, I will treat them.
The theory behind this is if there's no deception coming into a system which is already sensitized
by ongoing pain or by repeated pain experience, that cannot be good.
And I'm sure that this contributes.
And we know from research that people who have neck dysfunctions, they have a high level
of disability and a higher frequency of attacks, so it does make sense to treat neck dysfunctions
if they are there.
This is why we need that battery of test because we need to find out what's there and how
we can approach it.
And from that study that we did last year, published 23 in Sephiraya Ja by a doctorate student
of mine, Ruth Meiser.
She added education, as I already mentioned a little bit earlier, and she found that adding
education to Menus therapy reduces headaches by another almost two days.
So we have got a reduction through Menus therapy.
There was no control group, so everybody got better, which could be the effect of being
in a study.
So we kind of really claimed that that worked.
But adding education made a lot of sense.
And there's another study, a little bit older, 2020 in Sephiraya Ja reports.
Where we compared guideline-based aerobic exercise, it's a recommendation found in every
migraine guideline internationally, and we compared that with Menus therapy, but this
was open labels, so people could choose what they wanted to do.
And we found that both interventions reduced migraine or headache days from approximately
eight to ten days a month down to six to eight days, so by another, by two days, which
I think is nice because people say every headache day less a month is worse coming, so yeah,
so we can contribute, but we cannot cure.
Okay.
And would you say that physiotherapy or Menus therapy or by those approaches, we are trying
to remove or reduce triggers that could potentially trigger a migraine attack, or is the migraine
there, and we accept it, but we also know those people have a lot of issues in the neck,
so we treat the neck because it's like a comorbidity or a thing that is often found.
Do you know where I'm getting it?
Well, I'm not sure what I can answer this because this is really difficult to distinguish
by any sort of study design, I mean triggers, it makes sense to record triggers for a certain
movement and maybe something that relates to the neck, let's say if you've been in a long
meeting and you had to sort of look towards one side of your neck because the screen or
the speaker was there and that triggered the attack, if that sort of occurs repeatedly,
then it would be easier to say that the neck is a trigger.
It's definitely a no-sysception, I mean there's structures that are sending information
to the brain, and the brain responds to it and decides whether it's important or not.
So I think the answer to your question is I don't know.
Okay, so it's probably not fair to say to a patient, okay, you come in with a migraine
so I'm going to treat you and our goal is to decrease the triggers.
Well, no, no it's not.
Our goal is to reduce the additional nosy
section that's coming from the neck.
OK.
Can you maybe take us through your management approach?
You touched on aerobic training.
We also talked about menuotherapy.
What is your approach?
Yes.
I mean, obviously following guideline recommendations,
because this is for guidelines up for.
And they recommend the aerobic exercise looking at the literature.
Actually, it's surprisingly low effect sizes, but they're there.
So there's an effect and recommending this makes sense.
Then again, patients always say, I don't want to do any sports
because it's triggered my migraine in the past.
And that again, it needs explanation.
And this is where the education comes in.
So doing sports in those 48 hours,
where your system is sort of swinging up towards hypersensitivity.
I don't think that sports makes a lot of sense.
This is a period where if possible, with using any sort of stimulation is good.
After the attack or in the sort of safe times in between attacks,
sport definitely makes sense.
I mean, it always makes sense.
And we have physios, we are promoting activity anyway.
Working mechanisms not clear, possibly through the immune system,
possibly a little bit through endogenous opioids,
but it's probably less than we think.
Possibly self-efficacy.
That's a lot of mechanisms.
Then the other thing to recommend is anything to do with relaxation.
It doesn't have to be posed as a metric
because a lot of people are annoyed by that.
But it can be anything that is perceived as relaxing.
It can be a walk in the woods, walk with a dog.
It can be sitting on a sofa with your partner.
But doing it deliberately makes a lot of sense.
And also trying to find relaxing times in a stressful day makes a lot of sense.
Psychologist, I've just had a presentation
where he said that water intake makes sense,
but not because of the water, but because the sort of procedure of drinking
gives you a few seconds out of your stressful whatever you're doing.
And I think that could have a point.
So those things recommending is good.
Education include anything you know about neurophysiology.
The more people understand what they've got, the less fetching it is.
So knowing this is not a stroke, knowing this is not a tumor,
knowing why it hurts, knowing why it takes so long to disappear,
knowing where associated symptoms are coming from,
is a good thing for people to have this knowledge
and it reduces symptoms itself.
Whoops, I'm losing my AirPods.
The other thing is definitely looking at the neck
and treating what you find.
So if there are muscular symptoms, treat soft tissue.
If there are joint issues, treat joint.
If there's anything else, you find and posture,
range of motion, whatever, treat and measure.
Measure using a headache diary.
I think it's the best thing to do.
Have people eat a diary so that you know what you did,
whether it may tense and how large the effect sizes.
What else can you do?
Recommend anything that any large changes of any sort.
So don't skip meals because it could be a contributing factor
of blood sugar levels go up and down and up and down all the time.
Which also means that carbohydrates are probably worse
than proteins and fat because it makes the blood pleasure,
the blood sugar go up and down too much.
Any else, homeostatic sleep, don't sleep longer.
It weekends, but get up at the same time
if possible every day.
Stress, so if the weeks are really stressful,
maybe it's a good thing to respond to emails
on Saturday morning so that stress is not going down.
Oh, that's ugly.
So anything that you can do to keep things stable
is a good recommendation.
OK, yeah, I think it's funny if we talk
about treatment approaches and different pathologies,
more and more comes down to a holistic approach.
If it's a migraine or something else,
basically all the recommendations or what experts are saying
is, OK, we have the dysfunctions, but also look at sleep,
also look at stress levels, also look at alcohol intake
and so on.
So yeah, it's I think we are broadening our horizon
in physiotherapy a lot.
Well, can I be bad to recommend that people
look after themselves, right?
Definitely.
And a quick question to the aerobic training,
if someone is really active already,
is that added benefit if they move more?
Or would you say, OK, you are a really active person,
so don't expect any benefit from that.
I remember one study, and I have to give you the name
Saita, which found that high intensity training
is better than moderate.
OK.
There's one systematic review while they are manual at all,
I think, 2022.
They found that strength training is superior,
but this is based on a very low level of evidence.
And I would say that both make sense.
Again, this is people looking after themselves.
There's always a good recommendation, yeah.
But you don't really have to go and say,
people need to run marathon, I don't think so.
No.
OK, and slowly coming towards the end of the podcast,
are you currently researching any particular topic,
regarding migraines?
And if not, is there any hot topic in migraine research
at the moment where everyone's talking about
or that is really interesting for you
as a researcher at the moment?
I think we still haven't really got this point home yet
that muscular skeletal system is important.
One of the things I'm really upset about
is that the German guidelines have not
included physiotherapy, or menu therapy, or exercise,
or anything like this.
That would include us as a profession
and to the migraine management.
I'm hoping this will change with the next version
of the German guidelines.
So the other thing that we've just looked into
is learning mechanisms, because we have to be a little careful
because you cannot say to somebody
you have learned to have migraines, that's probably not true.
But maybe pain behavior can be influenced by learning.
So if you've seen a mum who had migraines,
and she always had two days of duties
that could be maybe a nice thing to have,
or it could be behavior that people copy.
So we have just looked into can we induce a noticeable,
our placebo suggestion, probably not as much as we thought,
which is interesting.
So I think that because I'm a physiotherapist,
I think my main interest is still in the muscular skeletal symptoms
and its contribution.
And I really, really, really want to do a large RCT
treating migraine patients with physiotherapy.
And to either be convinced myself that it doesn't work,
or to convince others that it does work.
Yeah, looking forward to that.
That's a lot of work.
OK, I'm going through my list of questions
and I've asked it also, I always ask our guests,
is there anything that you would like to add to the podcast
or is there anything we haven't touched on
that you feel like is really important to get out there?
I think it's the migraine patients perspective,
which I think is not studied enough.
So we've done a lot doing medication research
and now looking at people's muscular skeletal systems
where we haven't asked them enough.
We did a survey and asked about experience
with physiotherapy, for example, and although it's not
on the guidelines, always every migraine patient
has been to see a phasal, but what they have received,
a treatment is a little bit disappointing.
So a lot of massage, a lot of passive,
very little education.
And I think involving patients in our research
as demanded by all the big grant and situations,
for example, anything international is always required
in patient contribution, but I think we could do this better.
Also as far as the hours.
OK, so there's some more qualitative studies.
Well, yes, it could be qualitative
by interviewing our surveys, could be quantitative
by just asking for numbers, but hearing them is a good thing.
OK, yeah, then I'd say last, where can people find you
if they want to?
want to know more about you or if they want to get in touch with you.
Well, that's very easy. I'm a professor of physiotherapy at the University of Lübeck,
which is a very nice mid-eversity in the north of Germany, so come and visit.
Never been. Come and visit. It's pretty common summer because it rains a lot. Otherwise,
you'll find me on the internet, including email addresses and anything you need to get
in touch. Are you on social media? I am not really as much on social media as I should be.
We have got a Facebook page from the German Association for Physioscience. The German
name is Deutsche Gisele Schaft für Physiotenup. He listened Schaft.
Did he appear to be a DGPTW? This is where you can find our activities towards increasing
physiotherapy science awareness in Germany. That's another maybe interesting page, but I think
a lot of that is German language, so not internationally. Okay, so it's best to reach out to
you via email, you'd say? Yes, please. Okay, all right. Kerstin, to close off the podcast,
let's say thank you so much for your time and your knowledge, of course, and it was a pleasure
to have you. Thank you very much for having me. Sure, it was great. And thanks a lot, as well,
for everyone listening out there to this episode. And as always, to access the transcript and
additional resources, make sure to download our new and free Physiotutors app and benefit from
more useful physio content. Also, if you enjoyed this episode, hit the subscribe button or follow
our podcast on Spotify or Apple Podcasts. And also consider leaving a review if you really
enjoyed it. And with that being said, this was Kai for Physiotutors and I'll talk to you in the next
episode. Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Migraine headaches are defined by specific criteria including duration, intensity, pulsating quality, worsening with activity, and associated symptoms like nausea or photophobia.
Approximately 10% of migraines involve aura, typically visual phenomena occurring 30–60 minutes before the headache, with hemiplegic migraine being a rare, genetically linked subtype.
The hypothalamus is considered the "migraine generator," showing early activation before headaches, triggering a cascade involving the trigeminal system and brain regions linked to pain and nausea.
Migraine patients show signs of central sensitization and lack of inhibition, similar to chronic pain conditions, but unlike chronic pain, between-attack periods are generally normal.
Common risk factors such as stress, weather, and food are not consistently proven; instead, they may reflect prodromal symptoms or heightened sensitivity during migraine phases.
Physiotherapy can help by treating neck musculoskeletal dysfunctions, improving postural control, and reducing disability, though it does not cure migraine.
Education about migraine pathophysiology and lifestyle modifications—including sleep, stress, and diet—significantly reduces symptoms and improves patient outcomes.
Current research emphasizes the need for patient-centered studies and better integration of physiotherapy into migraine guidelines, especially in Germany.
Summary:
Migraine is a complex neurological condition defined by specific clinical criteria, including unilateral, moderate-to-severe, pulsating headaches lasting four to 72 hours with associated symptoms like nausea or photophobia. Around 10% of cases involve aura, often visual, occurring before the headache. Research indicates that the hypothalamus acts as the primary trigger, initiating a cascade through the trigeminal system and brain regions responsible for pain and dizziness.
While migraine is not fully understood, evidence suggests central sensitization and reduced inhibition—similar to other chronic pain conditions—but patients remain functionally normal between attacks. Genetic factors contribute to susceptibility, though no single gene explains migraine; environmental triggers like stress or diet are often subjective and may reflect pre-attack sensitivities rather than direct causation. In physiotherapy, neck musculoskeletal dysfunctions are common and treatable, with studies showing that manual therapy, education, and aerobic exercise can reduce headache days by two days.
However, physiotherapy does not cure migraine and should be integrated with medical management. Physiotherapists play a key role in managing symptoms, improving posture, and promoting patient self-management through education and lifestyle advice. Despite its potential, physiotherapy is currently underrepresented in migraine guidelines, especially in Germany.
Ongoing research focuses on patient experiences, learning mechanisms, and large randomized trials to validate the effectiveness of physiotherapy. Patient feedback reveals that current care often lacks education and active engagement, highlighting a need for more patient-centered, evidence-based approaches in migraine treatment.
FAQs
A migraine headache requires five attacks that last 4 to 72 hours, are unilateral, moderate to severe in intensity, pulsating, worsened by physical activity, and accompanied by symptoms like nausea, vomiting, photophobia, or phonophobia.
Migraine with aura involves visual or sensory symptoms, such as flickering lights or pins and needles, occurring 30 to 60 minutes before the headache. It affects approximately 10% of migraine sufferers.
The main theory involves the hypothalamus, often called the 'migraine generator,' which becomes active 48 hours before a migraine attack. This triggers the trigeminal nervous system, leading to pain and other symptoms.
There’s no proven structural difference, but migraine sufferers may have a lack of inhibition in the nervous system, leading to increased sensitivity, which resembles central sensitization seen in chronic pain.
Commonly reported triggers include stress, changes in weather, and specific foods like alcohol or chocolate. However, these may be symptoms of the prodromal phase rather than actual triggers.
Migraines affect about 15% of the global population, making them less common than episodic tension-type headaches, which are found in about 80% of people.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.