Dr. Jamie Merich shares her deeply personal memoir, *You Lied To Me About God*, which explores her journey through spiritual and religious abuse, trauma, and healing. Organized thematically rather than linearly, the book reflects her understanding that trauma disrupts chronological memory. Merich emphasizes authenticity, self-trust, and the importance of "vibe-checking" therapists—highlighting that safety must be self-determined, not imposed by labels like "safe space." She critiques institutionalized spirituality and religious authority, showing how early programming in conservative religious environments erodes trust in one’s inner voice. The memoir also promotes accessibility, with all books priced under $20 and free educational content available. Merich advocates for diverse voices in mental health, peer mentorship, and non-traditional healing models, especially for trauma survivors. Her work challenges clinical gatekeeping and encourages openness, blending lived experience with clinical insight. This aligns with the podcast's mission of using role-playing games and community spaces to explore mental health, trauma, and resilience. The book tour includes public discussions on spiritual abuse, and Merich highlights the power of community, voice, and self-reliance in healing. Her broader mission is to redefine therapy as a community-centered, inclusive, and trauma-informed practice rooted in lived experience.
Hello and welcome to Roll 4 Resilience, a podcast with a mission to explore how we can use
role-playing games like Dungeons & Dragons and Final Fantasy as tools to facilitate personal
healing and growth. I am your host, Effector of Change, and I use He-they pronouns.
I am a lifelong gamer and a licensed clinical social worker.
On this episode of the podcast, I will be interviewing Dr. Jamie Merich, who has a new memoir coming out,
titled "You Lied To Me About God." We are here. We are live. Welcome to this train, y'all.
This is Dr. Jamie Merich. If y'all don't know, Jamie is a wonderful, amazing EMDR therapy colleague
of mine. And she's written a lot of cool stuff. She's written a lot of cool stuff in the field.
And I have the honor of getting a special copy of her newest book, which is titled,
"You Lied To Me About God." And it is a memoir, which is a little bit of a different style than
Jamie typically writes. It's been a treat. It's been a treat to get through it and hear about your
experiences and the way you've organized it. So we're just going to spend the hour just kind of
chit-chatting together about the book, about what you're doing. So this is part of Jamie's book tour.
Yes, it is. The one thing I didn't have prayed hair to head at time. Do you have a specific
like link if anybody's interested in purchasing said book? Well, truly it is available wherever
books are sold. The book is distributed with anyone around the house, so you can actually buy it
through Target or Walmart if that's your jam. A lot of the independent booksellers have it.
I just dropped for you in Yarchat. You can share it with the streamers Anthony.
Redefinetherapy.com. Or my name, JamieMarriage.com is a good website to go to. You can click on the
book image there and there's all kind of options of where you can purchase it. So wherever it's
easier for you to buy books and where you also have an audiobook that is coming out with it.
And that was really another layer of the healing to be able to narrate the audiobook of my memoir.
And so if you are an audiobook person, I would say get the audiobook because we're just really happy
with how it turned out. And so you actually married the audiobook? That's awesome.
I did. Yes. A couple books ago, a few books ago, my books got to the level where I was given
audiobooks in my contract. And I had some voice talent do the first few audiobooks largely because
I was out of time. But then when dissociation made simple came out, I said, this is too personal.
I need to be able to read this myself. And it was just such a beautiful experience doing that.
So for the memoir, I got, I got the audiobook right to read my own.
Excellent. Excellent. So if you also know this little podcast is called Role for Resilience,
where we are chit chatting about the intersection of mental health and role playing games like
Final Fantasy, D&D, things like that. And we kind of have lots of conversations. I run an
actual play channel, we play D&D for the edition. But we also like to participate in special events.
This week, folks might know is mental illness awareness week. And there is a raid train that we've
been participating in. We're going to have a slot tomorrow. As part of that, we're going to kind
of check this interview again and invite some more people in to have some conversations about
spiritual abuse and how does that impact our mental health, which is fantastic.
And to my knowledge, Amy, you've never been on Twitch, is that right?
I have never been on Twitch. I love that it's out there. I have some friends who are on it.
I think I am kind of at my maximum potential for platforms. But who knows? Maybe you'll convince
me to join Twitch too. Maybe. Maybe. It's like a time over here. The communities that get bill are just, they're very unique. They're very unique. And I've seen some
people, some people do a lot of gaming on their streams. But for instance, like the train that's
going on right now, people are talking about their experiences with depression, ADHD, autism,
just like being out there and showing up for each other. It's really, really fantastic.
I think that's quite beautiful because I mean, social media and media in general can certainly come
with its downfalls. But when I hear like what you just shared about how communities can gather and
share knowledge that has often been kept in very elite places, I know this is worth it to be able
to connect this way. Yeah. So I guess, I guess I want to question I have for you, Jamie, is like as
as you were getting ready to write the book, one thing I noticed right in the acknowledgements,
right, is you've got a whole bunch of folks that you listed on your journey who have been there,
who have been with you. This is not your first wheelhouse in publishing, right? You've been
even doing this for a little while. So at what point did you really think that it would be a good
idea to just switch out of the clinical headspace and just write your experience in this memoir?
Such a good question. A lot of my clinical books do have what I call a memoir-ish quality,
where I share from lived experience. And sometimes I've had to fight publishers on that.
Occasionally publishers, we'll say you talk about your own experience too much, you have to be
more clinical or the Atlantic books the publisher I'm with now, even though they're not specifically a
memoir publisher, they have allowed me to be more personal, which is why I like working with them.
And I knew, probably for the last 10 years, I have had a book in me about spiritual abuse and religious
trauma. But when I talked it out with my long-term editor, I told her, "Shana, I can't do this unless
it's a memoir." It just felt dishonest to do it unless it was a memoir because the spiritual trauma
I experienced really was the core trauma of my life. And I've become a fan of memoir, I've read a
lot of memoir. I also kind of had some fear around writing a memoir because both of my parents
are still alive. My brother is still very much alive and he's an active Catholic priest. So I had
to do some work around what I'd be okay with pissing people off if I truly wrote a memoir. And I
remember even talking to a good friend of mine who's also an attorney on my team. And we're like,
well, here are the options. You either wait till everybody who's in the book is dead or you take a
breath and just do it and just put your voice out. And being able to put my voice out like this
is the byproduct of 20 years of therapy and getting to this place of I have to be okay speaking
this no matter what the consequences are. So that's how this evolution happened. And I am truly glad
my teaching, if you will, on spiritual abuse is out in the world in this way. So the I haven't read
all your books. I'll be honest. I'll be honest. I'll be honest. But I have read quite a bit of
dissociation made simple and obviously this book. And one of the things I really liked about your
style, especially in dissociation made simple, for example, is it's like, okay, so you're Dr. Jamie,
right? Like you've got you've got some crads, you've got some letters and you've done a lot of
training and you've got some certifications. Like you're kind of a big wig in the world of EMDR
therapy and creative expression. However, when I read that book, I was just like, oh, you are not
putting yourself above anybody. You are just as much open and honest about your experience as
everybody else. And so I think you had like what 61 contributors or something that helped you
create dissociation made simple. And to me, as a trauma therapist, specifically who treats
dissociation and complex trauma, to just see the diversity of experiences and opinions on all
these major topics in the field was breath of fresh air for me. Thank you for appreciating that
because there are certainly a lot of people who don't and the ivory towers or people who
really do benefit from the us versus them polarity in mental health. And I mean, I feel part of what
makes me effective at my work, whether that be clinical work or teaching is that I have lived this.
It's not, it's not theoretical to me. And the whole reason I even got into this line of work is
because my first recovery sponsor suggested that I would be good at it. It's nothing that I don't
know. It's been very hard to separate the two. I mean, I have had a learn to separate the two
obviously when professional ethical boundaries are at play. And I believe I do that well when I'm
one on one with a person. But as I have gotten more privilege in my position, I mean, thank you
for saying I'm kind of a big deal. But I think what that means is those of us who are in those
positions of power and privilege do need to start coming out and keep it at real. And that's a lot
of what I decided to do in dissociation mid-symbol. Yeah, when I was in my my graduate program,
so I have my masters in social work. Great. So go to my very first counseling,
one-on-one class, if you will, and we're learning about things, we had to videotape ourselves,
and I learned that I do this a lot when I talk, and I still do this a lot when I talk,
and it's fine. But one of the things that I found really challenging is here I'm being told
Bye, bye, bye, okay?
white man, how we need to be a blank slate in the room, right? Like we need to not talk about
politics. We need to not bring up religion. You know, we've got to, because we're going to,
we're going to push people out if we do that. And I was like, this is, so I finished, I was in
grad school, I finished in 2015. And so like my whole life or my whole clinical career has been
nothing but political, right? Because events that are happening in the world around white
Christian nationalism are our mental health. And so I really appreciated that information that
you put into you lied to me about God is just kind of outlining just your own personal experiences
with those themes, because it is something that's relevant even today. And a lot of clinicians,
I think are really challenged with how do I navigate self disclosure? What do I share? What
don't I share? And I, to me, I just, I feel like that's a really amazing piece to just explore
your raw feelings that you were going through during some of these trivial times we've been going
through. Yeah. Thank you for, for seeing that. And I, yeah, so many big feelings. Tell us all your
feels. Oh, let me see what what is coming out the most with that. I mean, I was certainly raised.
I'm going to keep it very real with you, because I know I can on this, on this channel and this
platform. If you want to be a D10 Jamie, go for this is Twitch. This is Twitch, great. I love it here
already. So I was, I was raised as mission with a lot of those same ideas, like blank slate,
there's certain things you don't talk about, especially politics, maybe religion. And what was
interesting is even as I got into my first mainstream counseling job, kind of at a group practice,
at a group agency, all of the therapists there who had clients that had anything connected to
spirituality or religion that they wanted to talk about, they sent them to me, because oh,
you're the one who's willing to go there with them about this. You know how many drag queens I
was referred. I'm like, you realize they talk to each other, right? Right. Right. And so it was like
anybody who had too much trauma, anybody who had too much dissociation, anybody had too much
spirituality. And I just kind of shook my head that if we as clinicians are giving lip service
to this holistic idea, we have to be anyway. So, so there's that. But even as I came up through
the early decade of my first decade as a, as a, as a trainer, I didn't keep it as blank slate
or as neutral as I could at least in my public life, because I live in Ohio. It up until 2016
was a swing state. You would have people in both directions who were therapists, who were clients,
what not. And because I grew up conservative and still had a lot of people in my life in conservative
religion, I really did try to appreciate that folks, and I didn't get as political as I could of
in the early days of my career. And I think that's true of a lot of queer folks who want to be safe,
who want to stay safe in the profession, who want to stay safe publicly, who don't want to make
too many waves. I certainly made waves in the MDR world, but politically, you know, I kept it
pretty neutral. And then Donald Trump got elected. And I knew I no longer could dial it in,
in the way I needed to, because when 2016 happens, when the election happened, it was also happening
at the time my marriage was absolutely nose diving. And it was my second marriage. It was a marriage
I had no business being in. I do reference some of it in the memoir. It was also about a year and a
half after my most public coming out that I did as bisexual. So even coming out happened in
stages. And then in 2016, I decided to, not 2015, to come out fully, which meant I had to come
out to my family finally. That was fun. I say that very sarcastically. And then when he got elected,
I just, you know, I was immediately kind of convicted with some guilt that like I didn't fight
hard enough for my people and those, those who don't have a voice because as a person of privilege,
I would be relatively fine, no matter who got elected. But then I started to feel like maybe I
won't be so fine, especially if I'm more open, you know, with, with my queerness. So as the director
of a training institute, any MDR therapy, I started making some very bold choices about even
addressing in my MDR training that you, you can't hide behind that anymore of, you know, politics,
that it doesn't really matter because I'm here to be a therapist no matter what. Clients may need to
know who you voted for to feel safe with you. Clients may need to know where you stand on thing
to feel safe enough with you because after the 2016 election, I had a complete meltdown. Part of it
was because of the marriage, but a lot of it was because I suddenly had this 24/7 reminder of
everything that was wrong with my upbringing in front of me and seeing so many people in my family
just, just rise to support this person who I see as a monster. And so in getting back into therapy,
I had to look for any MDR therapist again who knew dissociation, who knew a lot of things,
but ultimately I couldn't pull punches. I had to know right up front where she stood politically,
who she voted for. And she told me just in very plain terms, I grew up evangelical, I get what
this means for people who've experienced narcissistic abuse to have no Donald Trump as president.
And I've just been phenomenally grateful that I can work with a therapist where I don't have to
hide any of that. And yeah, so in my trainings, I discuss that I'm not saying that automatically
people with one political party can't work with another because I've seen it happen in my training
groups. But my point is we can't shut down clients when they ask, when they really do need to know
who they're sitting with because matters are very important for a lot of us.
So for the viewers at home, I had a really interesting experience at the Emdria conference.
I think it was, oh, was it last year? I can't remember. The last year they were before,
the one that was down in Washington, D.C. And they had this really good conference app. And so there
was like all these like forums and meetups, people could connect with each other. And we had like a
little special like queer EMDR therapist luncheon meeting. And so that was just nice to be in space.
I know Jamie was there. I was there to connect with other people who are just, you know, we're on
little bubble. But then, yeah, exactly what I'm going to reference. Then we find that there's a Christian
EMDR therapist subgroup getting together. And they're like starting to like, I don't know vaguely
talk about conversion stuff in their group. And so JV is just like poking out. I'm asking some
questions, getting in there. So let me, let me go there. And I just dropped in our chat. And you
could share it on on the Twitch side if you want an article that I just wrote where I referenced
this very thing you're talking about. And my new article is called Define Christian.
Because I have learned in the last few years, whenever people congregate in Satan, we're Christian
EMDR therapist using the example that you're bringing up. My media question is how are you
defining Christian? And where I, you know, feel some energy around this is even after everything
I've went through with spiritual trauma on both the Catholic side and the evangelical side,
I take no issue with Jesus Christ. I take no issue with, you know, my theology around him may
be different. But I still have no problem dare I say calling myself a Christian. But in modern
America to lead with I'm a Christian or to say that I identify as a Christian, it has a lot of
hateful charge to it and connotation to it because of what, you know, certain forms of Christianity,
especially the kinds that are aligned with Trumpism have become. So yeah, I've basically, there's
this meme going around like, are you a Jimmy Carter Christian? Are you a Donald Trump Christian?
Yeah. And so in this group chat that you were referencing of a quote unquote Christian EMDR
therapist, that's that's what I led with. Like how are you defining Christian? Because I,
I just know that for a lot of people that label in modern America to say I'm a Christian,
mean I'm not okay with LGBTQ people being who they are. And the reality is there are a lot of
LGBTQ+ Christians who are coming out of the closet about that thing and some have never been
in a closet about that that, you know, let's kind of take back Christianity here and let's
challenge this notion that yeah, because there's some ugly stuff that happens with people who
call themselves Christian therapists, Christian EMDR therapists. They also wrote a blog about that
not too long ago, like dear Christian therapists. Here are some things we would like you to know,
especially those of us who have been hurt by Christianity. So thank you for reminding me of that
episode. It was a fun part of our career. A fun part of our career. Absolutely a good time.
I, I will say Jamie, don't identify as Christian I was not raised in a
family that really pushed those views. I was baptized. That was about it in
terms of like the interaction there. But I'm thankfully from a town. So I'm from
upstate New York, which similar to some of the vibes I imagine in Ohio, where
you've got some of these pockets of liberalism surrounded by a bunch of red
that's my area too. So there was an openly queer LGBT service member that had
passed away in the in the region years ago. And so Fred Phelps and his little
God hates Fags group decided to come to town to try to protest as they
used to do all the time in the West Rob Baptist Church. And the Christians of
my region gathered together and drowned them out and chased those fools out
of town. And so to me, I think that just having had that experience we're
observing it was very healing for me as a as a young queer person when I heard
about that to learn that like, okay, it's not all Christians. That's good. Most
definitely there's there's a couple great resources I want to point people to if
you're not aware of them. There's an organization called takebackchristianity.org
which is organized by a group of progressive pastors who
theologically could take down a lot of these people like the West Rob Baptist Church
and other maybe more mainstream evangelicals and Catholics that still
promote a lot of hateful messages. I also go to a festival I can't get there
every year but it's a really cool experience in North Carolina as a wild goose
festival. And it really is a gathering of all things progressive Christianity.
And I just think for a lot of us who have grown up with especially Christian
spiritual abuse, it can be reparative to see people who identify as Christian
who are very much walking a very Christian path say this is not okay. How
queer folks have been treated, how other marginalized folks have been treated.
So yeah. Thank you for the resources. So where? So Jamie, I have one major
contention with your book. Go on. One big concern that I think you need to stop
them from printing it and fix this error very soon. So I love how you put little
footnotes throughout the book to just add some context to different concepts.
But I only saw like one time in the book you had a nice little Jesus foot
no. Okay. So instead of like the asterisk because there was two I think in the
same section they added a little cross to give like a little factoid. And I'm
like, it was kind of like a VH one pop up video moment, right? Like here's a
little thing if you didn't know about, you know, Christianity. And I'm like,
you should have done that consistently through the tax that would have been
golden. I may have to take that up with the copy editor because yeah, I remember
that's making me laugh because she brought that up as like, well, in MLA
formatting or Chicago style formatting when you're doing footnotes in this way,
the cross would come as a thirst. So yeah, that could have been fun.
No, I just thought that was hilarious. I'm like, was that intentional when I saw
early on? But yeah, I wish this all right. It's interesting to me what people
notice because I know a very good Jewish friend of mine read the book and he
he's somebody who still identifies culturally Jewish, but he's not
particularly religious. And his thing with me was, why did you capitalize God
throughout? Because he said, for me, God, you know, I still, when I believe in
it's lowercase. And I think I did end up mentioning it somewhere in the
preference, like if it's better for you to refer to God as lowercase with, but
he, you know, I ended up getting into a fascinating discussion about even
punctuation and capitalization around God. And I wrote a poem later after I had
drafted the book, basically saying, God doesn't care if you capitalize their
name. So it works for you to capitalize it. Great. If not, and I think you know,
I also go on my rant about how for me today, God is gender fluid.
I definitely re-tweet, re-tweet, re-tweet, I agree.
Thank you, my friends.
Absolutely. So I know I think we've we've had some some correspondence about it
before, but I do recall in the book that theme about people claiming to be
safe. And and how much that makes my nervous system activate when that
happens. And so that is something we talk a lot about on Twitch because some
people make it their brand to have a channel that is a queer safe space, a
bipox safe space. And I think some people are using that language for good
reasons, right? They would they want to do to do that. But I know for me, that
sets off my, my culty alarm vibes when I see that kind of languaging. So what
would you say just on that, that notion when people are trying to curate like
what kind of community they want to make on a content creation space or if
they're trying to build a platform and they want to be inclusive, what would
advice would you give them? Yeah. So a little bit of I will get to my advice.
One of the reasons that I bristle when I see like the safe language, I think
the intention is good. I really want to emphasize that for folks who are
using that like this is a safe space for XYZ. The problem in that fundamentally
though is you are telling me what to feel. I don't like when therapists do it when
pastors do it, when yoga teachers do it, the whole year in a safe space, I don't
know that yet until I come in and sort it out for myself. And so I know some
people have asked me, what do you think about the whole brave space thing? I'm
like, that still kind of makes me cringe because again, you're telling me what
the feel or what to expect. I mean, I think there's there's a couple things you
can do. I would love to see a creator tagline something like come and decide
for yourself if you feel safe here. I think open space could be nice. More
generals, full of more neutral, but fundamentally safety is something we model as
creators, as leaders in spaces, as therapists and people will decide for
themselves if I feel safe or safe enough there. So I mean, I think we can like
for example, my company, Institute for Creative Mindfulness, I deliberately made
a choice to have a rainbow logo. So some people may read into that and be like,
you know, I don't want anything to do with them because they're obviously, you
know, a bunch of squares. Cool. We probably wouldn't want you here anyway. Or
wouldn't feel safe with you here. So but then again, you know, just with
keeping the rainbow flag doesn't necessarily make you safe if you're not backing
it up with action. So I don't know if if I have a real easy answer other than
safety is something you model, safety is something you vibe. I think you can have
on your site something like a positionality statement that indicates what you
stand for and that might help people feel okay enough to at least come and give
it a try. And I even like that that sentiment of like come and hang out and
decide for yourself. I like that. Yeah, I agree in total. So like on Twitch, like
one of the things that you can do is called a channel plant redeem. So as you're
hanging out in a stream or if you're participating, you earn these points. And
then you can click the button and then things can happen and every stream is
different what they do. And so two of the buttons I have one is trans rights or
human rights. And so if someone spends the channel points, a little graphical
pop up, it's probably disabled for this stream if anyone's trying to do that. But
a little graphic pops up. I have another one that said this Black Lives Matter. I
have one that's called a pronoun party. And so like everyone can kind of talk
about their pronouns if they'd like to in shot. And so to me, it's a show versus
tell situation, right? I'm going to do what I can to show where I'm coming from,
where my exclusiveness is. But I can't necessarily say, hey, like, you know, you
should feel welcome here or you because you can't tell someone how they need to
feel. It just doesn't work that way. So it's interesting about this is just
reminding me. And I think I tell this story in dissociation made simple not
not the memoir that I noticed as I was kind of coming up in the profession and
making myself a little more known with my teaching and whatnot, I would feel an
immediate sense of this person is cool if they were a professional who were
a nose ring. And that's a good vibe. Right. Yeah. And so around 2014, now I'd
always wanted to get I just had a little nose stud in. I had always wanted to
get my nose pierced. And I remember going to the parlor with my friend and
good getting attached. And I'm like, maybe I should get my nose pierced today. And
you know, I heard that little voice from my mother in my head saying, what are
people going to think professionally? And the voice came up in me that said, if
people aren't going to listen to you because you have a nose ring, they're probably
not going to be the type of folks know to listen to you. So I want to be clear. I'm
not saying you have to have a nose ring or tattoos to be cool because I
also find people who who share their tattoos publicly are at least people, you
know, I feel okay about approaching initially, at least in the profession. I
love to use that phrase and the vibe check. The
because ultimately you know who you vibe with.
And growing up in the kind of religions I did,
I was very much told not to trust that,
that that was the devil talking,
that was the body, the flesh talking.
And I've had to learn to trust that,
what I consider to be my inner voice,
which I think is in my beliefs
that's ultimately a gift from God,
but it is worth trusting.
Now I am worth trusting.
And if you were in a place where there's a big label at
that says this is a safe place and you don't feel safe,
trust that.
- Yeah, I always think the body knows sometimes
what the brain don't know yet, absolutely.
It was interesting as a parallel though,
as it was reading through your memoir,
you talk about your journey into the world of yoga.
And it's funny to me, 'cause like I've had a lot of clients
that talk about what works, what does it in terms of grounding
or getting their body moving, mindfulness stuff,
and for some people, that doesn't work for them
to just sit and meditate and listen to a thing.
And you brilliantly described that
in dissociation made simple, why?
'Cause it's an invitation to continue to dissociate
for some people, right?
- It can be, yeah.
- Makes sense, makes sense.
Why, that's not always the thing.
But one of the things I've always told folks,
especially if they're new into psychotherapy
or EMDR therapy of like why yoga doesn't work
or sometimes yoga does work,
it's like, well, it depends on who's teaching, right?
It really depends on what that practice is.
If you have a practitioner I think that is giving you
an invitation and is asking for permission
and is very gentle, you're gonna vibe with that perhaps.
If you have someone who's telling you how to move your body,
who physically gets involved in that process,
that's not gonna go well for folks
who have a history with trauma.
- Yes, let's go there though,
because I very much agree with that, especially now.
But there are some trauma survivors,
especially religious trauma survivors,
because they don't trust themself.
Believe that teacher is telling me exactly what to do.
They're going to be my ticket to salvation,
'cause even when I got what you're referencing in the book,
when I got involved with the ashram,
there was a lot of me that was like, this is right.
But the other kind of parts of me were like,
but maybe you're missing something.
Maybe you don't have the spiritual knowledge
to kind of fly on your own.
And I think a lot of us feel like
because we don't trust ourselves or missing something.
So I can tell you this from training there,
a lot of therapists don't like training with me,
because I don't tell you exactly what to do.
I give you a lot of knowledge, a lot of insight,
a lot of lived experience,
a lot of here are some things you can try,
even in following a protocol.
And students ask me questions,
I answer a lot with it depends.
And that drives a lot, that drives a lot of people crazy,
because I'm not telling them exactly what to do.
And honestly, being a clinical trainer all these years
that I have, I now understand why people join cults.
That's a lot for me to put out there, right?
But I think it fundamentally comes from this thing we have.
Sometimes it's trauma that does it.
Sometimes you're not enoughness, that's the anxiety promote.
But a lot of it comes from the church.
A lot of it comes from the religious institutions,
the spiritual institution,
that you have to put your trust in someone else
or something else in order to be an okay human.
So if you are, I say all that to say,
if you're that kind of person who has kind of gotten into
a yoga school where, but they know better.
So I'm gonna go along with it.
But your inner voice, your gut is telling you now, trust that.
- Yeah, the joke I always tell people
who were new to that is like,
so yoga's cool, a lot of people really like it
and people seem to find it engaging.
But I think that sometimes yoga can be a little culty.
So we've just got to be discerning
on how we're entering that space.
And as soon as I like make that reference,
most people are like, yeah, it makes sense.
- You got it.
- Yeah, it's, to me, it's also interesting this parallel
of showing versus telling in terms of like a vibe check
or a sense of safety.
I think you said in the book something along the lines
of like you don't get to call yourself insert yoga title.
I don't remember what it was, right?
- Yeah, yeah.
- You get called that by other people
who have been able to work with you and identify, yes.
I want to work with this person because they give to me
what I need or they're the way that they teach speaks to me.
I don't know exactly how that works.
But to me, I think that you think that you're on the head.
- Yeah, you don't get to call yourself a guru is what it is.
And that's authentic yoga teaching
that it's the people who proclaiming it to be a guru.
And I often feel that your gurus would never call themselves
a guru because, yeah.
- I have sometimes the same feelings about folks
who say, I'm a mental health advocate.
- Yes, yes, I am a thought leader.
I am a mental health expert.
So here's my favorite definition I ever heard
the word expert, this is from Niels Bohr.
That an expert is anybody who has made every mistake
they possibly can in their field
and has lived to tell about it.
I'm seriously paraphrasing him.
But I think fundamentally experts are people with experience.
Experts are people who have learned from their mistakes
and can share from them.
So, glad we're having this discussion.
- This is some good, this is a good.
So another theme that I've kind of noticed throughout the
the raid train that's been happening this week
that people talk about, there's a lot of people,
obviously you're talking about their experiences
with diagnosis and their symptoms.
But some people are sharing their stories
about what their experience has been like interacting
with people like you, people like me.
They interact with therapists and it doesn't feel good
or it doesn't get them the results they're looking for.
And what would you say, Jamie, are some suggestions
that you would give to folks in terms of like vibe checking
a professional, you know, somebody who we might seek out
for psychotherapy or psychiatry or anything related to that?
- It is a great question.
Before I answer it, I want to acknowledge that this answer
is from a pretty privileged place because I have access
to a variety of mental health providers,
a variety of holistic providers, so I'd have to pay cash for.
And a lot of people who may be on the platform
and on social media just don't have that access.
Or their benefit or their insurance
may be really limited in what it covers.
That being said, you have every right
to interview the people you're seeking out for surfaces.
You can schedule an initial appointment with a therapist
and that doesn't mean that person has to be your therapist.
You have every right to kind of check them out.
Now literature suggests three sessions.
But if you're feeling unsafe like after one,
you don't have to go back, but if after three sessions,
it feels like you got a good thing going on.
That's a pretty good predictor of outcome.
The kind of crude metaphor I make
is it can kind of feel like dating.
I mean, don't date.
- Are you the same one?
Are you the same one?
- I hate, but yeah, feel it out.
And if it's like, yeah, this just isn't working.
Yeah, trust that.
I've also been phenomenally privileged, lucky
that I've had good fits with the people
who have been the main healers in my life.
My first sponsor who kind of came to me,
I didn't really go looking for her.
And then the two main therapists I've worked with,
they were recommended by people I trust.
So maybe that was part of why it felt like a good fit.
I do think websites in the modern era,
you can feel by off a website and help people present themselves.
My friend is sitting here in the room with me.
And I remember when she first went on psychology today
with her profile picture.
She's like, do you think this looks too unprofessional
if I leave my glasses up on my head?
And I'm like, no, I think it sends a message that like,
I'm accessible.
I'm not trying too hard with an overdone headshot.
So yeah, you can feel out spaces, I think, virtually
and see how you connect.
I think another point that really needs to be said is,
obviously I'm a professional therapist.
I believe in psychotherapy when it's done well.
But I also believe in what an early interviewee
and an early book of mine said, which is that
bad therapy can be worse than no therapy.
And there's also a thing that modern psychotherapy
does not have the market cornered on healing.
So if you're getting your healing
because you're getting community on a platform like this,
I don't put it down.
For some people it is working more
with a shaman or a spiritual teacher.
You know, therapists can often get really opinionated
about life coaching, but I know some good coaches
that are out there who are doing well in their scope
and in the paradigms that they have.
I know there's a whole movement like in the plural community
in the DID community, especially because we've been so mistreated
by a lot of clinical professionals
that peer mentorship may be the way to go.
And I adore the peer movement in addiction recovery.
And I say that with the full recognition that, no, I'm not everyone's cup of tea.
And I don't think every therapist has to be, but I do hope that people are able to
trust their judgment and end up with the fits that do work for them.
I think that this idea of vibe-checking, I guess, is our theme.
Yeah, that's a great theme.
It is a great theme.
I think you have to vibe-check your therapist.
You have to take some time to suss them out, get to know them a little bit.
And if it's not a right fit, I would totally endorse that concept, that bad therapy is
worse than no therapy.
It's alarming.
As an EMDR therapist who does typically work with more complex presentations, I've done
a lot of cleanup for EMDR therapy that has not gone.
Well, for some folks before.
And so, I totally endorse that perspective, absolutely.
The way that you wrote your book, Jamie, to me was really interesting, because when I've
read memoir before, oftentimes, it's kind of a narrative timeline, right, where you're
kind of going from beginning to end, and you're kind of getting a little bit of vibe of this
story.
But I imagine your brain is just a little more creative than the average memoir right
there, because that's not how you organize this book.
Yeah.
Can you tell us a little bit about the themes?
We're going to set that way.
Yes.
So, I'm a big theme person.
Like we just said, vibe-checking is our theme.
And I am a thematic organization, thematic history taking, even when I speak EMDR therapy.
I am adamant that getting a chronology may not be safe, and it may not be possible, because
of the way trauma gets disorganized in the brain, we may not be able to keep a clear timeline.
And so, part of why I chose to organize the memoir thematically was even in a more
field state.
I don't think linearly.
I don't think in learning your terms.
And it just made sense, as I was organizing the memoir, to organize it along theme.
So, like what Anthony is referencing is, chapter one is the wounds of warfare, kind of giving
the basic definition of what spiritual religious trauma means.
Chapter two is about family roots, chapter three is about moral development, chapter four
is about sex in the body, that was one of my favorite chapters to write.
I have a chapter about queerness, chapter about the role of the feminine god.
And I know people who want linear may not like a book that's organized that way, but
you know, it's my memoir.
Yeah, it's your book.
This is how my brain operates, and one thing I tell readers at the beginning is, if you
do go through and read the whole book, maybe notice which chapter most gets your attention,
which theme most gets your attention.
Yeah, and maybe it's because, you know, I have a plural mind, it's just easier for me
to think that way.
A memoir I've read, I love it when it's more about theme and not pure chronology, not
pure narrative.
So, thank you for noticing that.
Yeah, each, even each little subsection in the chapter, Simmy, it almost felt like I
was like on your website scrolling through your blog and just getting little nuggets of,
you know, just, just thoughts or things that you like to share put out into the world.
And like, I get to the end of a section, and I'm like, I feel like this rise in my chest
like, oh, she's going to get to something good.
She's going to say, there it was just before the section ended, I'm like, that's so good.
So I really, really enjoyed that, that, that piece.
It kept me wanting to continue to move forward, as I was getting to those little rises and
falls throughout the narrative there.
It was excellent.
And I think especially as somebody who works with complex trauma, you know that the brain
is not this linear place.
No.
So if you did want a real kind of raw look into my mind and my experience, there would
be nothing about it that's linear.
So you got your thematic organization.
So the book is coming out very soon.
I think next week, October, October 15th, next Tuesday, yes.
Five days away.
Five days away.
So I just want to plug.
If you all are interested, do check out redefinetherapy.com.
Make sure you pop over there.
Like Jamie said, you can pick up the book at Walmart, at Amazon, at Target, wherever you're
getting any of your major books from.
And I think the price point, that's something that I know, Jamie, you've done really persistently
throughout your writing career is to not make it a textbook, to make it accessible in terms
of the books that you write.
And I, you did it again with this one.
Yes.
I have a commitment that any book that I write or publish, I don't want it to be over $20.
Unfortunately, I did two books with a more academic publisher that, and it pains me to sell
the books for that much money.
It really does because I, and I don't think it's undervaluing what I do, like it's a privilege
to be able to make it in some way doing books, but I, I want knowledge to be accessible.
And if people can't afford the book on redefinetherapy.com, I repost all my interviews that I do.
Many articles that I do, so I do like to put a lot out there that people can get at no
cost too.
Yeah, I, I, I don't know if you know this about my stream, but I have a timer that goes
off periodically of different resources.
I also have a card that lists like different databases or ways to find a therapist.
And one of the number one links that I always leave at the top of my coping skills, I have
to update it now because I know you've repranded.
Yes.
MadeSimple.com, it is amazing resource.
Yeah, trauma trauma made simple.com still directs to redefine therapy.
So if you're still using the trauma made simple.com, I still own the domain.
But yeah, redefine therapy is just kind of, I just had too many websites, but I wanted
to condense them a little bit.
And I mean, I think a lot of what my brand has been about is redefine therapy.
And in a fun story about that, it was an earlier book I did Dancing Mindfulness that came
out in 2015.
And it was the only book I did with a more spiritual publishing house that's now defunct and or
they were absorbed by another publisher.
And I had a wonderful editor, I only had a chance to work with once.
And I was kind of writing the ending chapter saying that it's not so much what's happening
in therapy offices that is exciting me.
If what's happening in therapy, like in community, like what you're doing here on Twitch,
what happens on social media, what can happen in, like in this case, the Dancing Mindfulness
program that I had kind of created and the space of that, you know, we showed up in.
And the editor comes back to me and the title, he's made a title suggestion for the closing
chapter is redefining me.
And I was like, I can't do that, I can't put that out there.
And it's like, why not, why not call it redefining therapy.
And then, Holly, a friend of mine who was doing social media at the time, she started
using a hashtag redefined therapy.
And I've rolled with it.
No, it's, it's a fantastic hashtag.
I, I've heard your interviews, I think, on a modern therapist's survival guide.
And I know those folks over there have definitely, like, loved, redefined therapy, they've totally
embraced that model.
Absolutely.
Very fun, very fun story in Montana, where I'm at sitting for this interview, doing an
EMDR training, Kurt from the Modern Therapist's Survival Guide, he's actually one of my assistants
for this training.
Oh, somebody.
Yeah, he's training to be faculty with, with my group by C.A.M. and he's assisting me
for this training.
And yeah, I plug that, that podcast all the time, Modern Therapist's Survival Guide.
It's, it's just some good real talk about a lot of issues in therapy.
Yeah, one of my favorite episodes on theirs, when I learned about Maslow and his cultural
appropriation.
I was like, right, oh my God, a pyramid makes no sense to wonder, it was a teepee the whole
damn time.
Exactly.
Yeah, Curtin, Curtin Katie, do some, they go there, they do, they do, no, I, they're doing
good work out there.
Now that the book's coming out and it's kind of, you know, maybe you're getting towards
the close of your book tour, what's, what's next in the era of redefining therapy for you?
What we're finding out next, as we really don't know, yeah, this is actually kind of the
start of the book tour.
If you're one of the first main, main events we're doing, that we got two weeks where we're
doing book event dates pretty hard and they continue in the November, you know, I, I really
don't know.
And it's a great question, because I'm still exploring how much I want to be a part
of professional psychotherapy, because I, I've won, especially the bisexual person, I've
won live with this foot in both worlds.
Like I've, I've, the joke is often we feel too queer for straight people, too straight
for some queer people, right?
And I think like with the therapy professions, you know, I'm too rubble for therapists.
And I still value a lot of what it means to be a therapist.
So, but I don't know, because there's so much about the field that frustrates me and writing
memoir, I think has gotten me to consider, maybe there are other forms of writing out there
for me, like fiction or continuing to write more in a non-plinical way, where I can still
have an impact teaching.
Yeah.
You're a wonderful writer.
are able to take all this gate-capped information that the institution
holds and just, here it is, guys.
Did you know about this?
- Thank you for that.
That means a lot to us that you noticed that.
- Absolutely.
You take what has been difficult.
So I have a copy on my bookshelf
back there of the haunted self,
which is the textbook about like--
- Dissociation?
- Yeah, and I'm just like, what, what is this?
What are they saying?
I don't, it's not accessible.
It is not helpful for me as a clinician.
I could never give a client to read that, right?
And then I pull out dissociation,
it's up on like, okay, yeah, that makes a lot of sense to me.
That's, that's well-worded.
I can't say I 100% endorse every single word
that you would put in your book
from my own clinical perspective.
But again, that's part of why I really liked how you did,
like this is a group project.
This is a collective putting together this experience.
Let's start here and let's go.
And the social justice and of your writing makes me smile.
It just does to see what you do there.
- And to that point, I think as a field,
we need to continue to support work by queer writers
and thinkers, by black African-American people
in other countries.
Like I want to shout out a really good friend of mine,
a Keela Riley Richardson, who's from Trinidad and Tobago,
who's just starting to make it as a therapy teacher.
And for non-US perspective is something,
I think a lot of us in the US have learned from.
So yeah, keep supporting people who look
like the clients we serve and the diversity
that our field is.
- 100%, 100%.
Jamie, thank you for joining us on this little podcast
of mine, I appreciate you.
And I know the folks have been excited to be here.
- It's been our pleasure.
Thank you for kind of being one of these first big
book launch online appearances we're doing.
And we'll probably share the podcast around.
- We do appreciate your time
and we're just gonna keep talking more people.
Go redefinetherapy.com, please.
- Thank you Anthony, have a good rest of your night.
Bye.
- Thank you so much, take care.
Thank you all for joining.
Get another episode of Roll for Resilience.
Again, I'm the Factor of Change
and you can find me streaming on Twitch at twitch.tv/affectorofchange.
If you'd like to support my work,
feel free to donate me a coffee at codashfi.com/affectorofchange.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Dr. Jamie Merich wrote her memoir *You Lied To Me About God* to authentically share her personal experience with spiritual and religious trauma, which she sees as the core of her life’s healing journey.
The book is thematically organized rather than chronologically, reflecting her neurobiological understanding of trauma and aligning with how complex trauma survivors process memory and experience.
Merich emphasizes the importance of "vibe-checking" therapists and practitioners, advocating for safety, self-determination, and the right to feel safe in any therapeutic relationship.
She critiques the use of labels like "safe space" or "safe for LGBTQ+ people," arguing they impose expectations and that true safety must be self-determined through genuine connection and trust.
Merich highlights the dangers of institutionalized spiritual authority, especially within religious institutions, and how trauma survivors often lose trust in their own inner voices due to early indoctrination.
The memoir and her work promote accessibility, with all books priced under $20 and free educational resources available to support mental health awareness and community healing.
She advocates for diverse voices in mental health, especially from marginalized communities, and supports peer mentorship and non-clinical healing models as vital alternatives to traditional therapy.
Merich’s journey reflects a shift from clinical neutrality to personal honesty, empowering clinicians to share lived experience and break down the divide between theory and lived trauma.
Summary:
Dr. Jamie Merich shares her deeply personal memoir, *You Lied To Me About God*, which explores her journey through spiritual and religious abuse, trauma, and healing. Organized thematically rather than linearly, the book reflects her understanding that trauma disrupts chronological memory.
" She critiques institutionalized spirituality and religious authority, showing how early programming in conservative religious environments erodes trust in one’s inner voice. The memoir also promotes accessibility, with all books priced under $20 and free educational content available. Merich advocates for diverse voices in mental health, peer mentorship, and non-traditional healing models, especially for trauma survivors.
Her work challenges clinical gatekeeping and encourages openness, blending lived experience with clinical insight. This aligns with the podcast's mission of using role-playing games and community spaces to explore mental health, trauma, and resilience. The book tour includes public discussions on spiritual abuse, and Merich highlights the power of community, voice, and self-reliance in healing.
Her broader mission is to redefine therapy as a community-centered, inclusive, and trauma-informed practice rooted in lived experience.
FAQs
The memoir is thematically organized around core experiences of spiritual and religious trauma, including family roots, moral development, sexuality, queerness, and the role of the feminine god.
She believes trauma disrupts linear timelines in the brain, and thematic organization better reflects how trauma is stored and experienced. It also aligns with her brain’s natural way of processing information.
She openly shares her personal experiences with religious and spiritual abuse, particularly from evangelical and Catholic backgrounds, and emphasizes how these traumas deeply shaped her identity and healing journey.
The book is available on major retailers like Amazon, Walmart, and Target, and through independent bookstores. A website, redefinetherapy.com, also provides purchase links and information.
She advocates for therapists to be transparent about their beliefs and political stances, as clients often need to know who they’re working with to feel safe and trusted, especially in times of social upheaval.
She recommends scheduling an initial session to assess compatibility, and if after three sessions it still doesn’t feel safe or effective, it’s okay to discontinue—bad therapy can be worse than no therapy.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.