Go back

Dems win another Senate seat

18m 30s

Dems win another Senate seat

Mary Peltola’s historic win in Alaska marks a significant shift in Senate dynamics, making her the first Alaska Native senator and a key step toward Democrats securing a supermajority in 2028. Her victory stemmed from deeply local, community-centered campaigning that resonated with rural and Indigenous voters, despite a nationally difficult political environment. While not a decisive Senate majority gain, it strengthens Democratic momentum and signals a broader trend of anti-establishment, populist appeal across the party. On the House floor, Hakim Jeffries secured the Speaker nomination with strong bipartisan support, though internal divisions remain over progressive policy goals and Israel-related stances. Democrats face ongoing ideological splits between center and progressive factions, while Republicans grapple with a redefined identity in the post-Trump era. Campaign finance dynamics are shifting, with donors increasingly directing support to competitive, home-state races. The midterms have intensified debates over party direction, with both parties now facing pressure to adapt to a political landscape defined by voter demand for change and accountability. Ultimately, while the 2024 elections did not resolve deep ideological divides, they laid the groundwork for more strategic, identity-driven political realignments in 2028.

Transcription

3248 Words, 18043 Characters

English
The Democratic Party's majority in the Senate has grown. Mary Peltola has flipped a seat in Alaska. She's the first Alaska native elected to the Senate and the second indigenous woman ever elected to the Senate. Today, we're digging into the latest on Alaska's Senate seat and we'll also take your questions about campaign donations, the filibuster, and more. It's the NPR Politics Podcast. I'm Danielle Kurtzleben. I cover the White House. I'm Sam Greenglass. I cover Congress. And I'm Tamara Keith. I cover politics. OK, so Sam, let's start with that Alaska Senate seat. I looked it up the last time there has been a Democratic Senator in Alaska was 2015 with Mark Baggage. So how did Mary Peltola pull off this win in that state? Well, I think the simple answer is fish family freedom. That was literally the slogan for the Peltola campaign. And what I mean by that is she made it a super hyper local race, even in this moment when the national environment was so difficult for Republicans. And she also traversed every part of this state by boat, by plane, even by snowmobile, and made it to some of the most far-flung parts of Alaska, which are home to many Alaska native voters that swung the most toward Democrats from 2024. And Tam, how big of a deal is this win for Democrats in Alaska? It's a big deal. Now, if this had been the 51st Senate seat, the Democrats won, that would be a bigger deal maybe. Could you imagine if we were still waiting for control of the Senate to itself? That is, on election night, the thing that I was most thankful for is that we were not waiting on the outcome being in this one far-flung state that takes a really long time to count votes. You know, the other thing I will note here is that for all the Dan's Sullivan drama, if you add up both Dan's Sullivan's and the other guy on the ballot, they still don't equal the number of votes that Mary Peltola ultimately got. This did not go to rank choice voting. She got more than 50%, just barely. Now, on the house side, there's a house race in Alaska that has not yet been called, hasn't been finalized, and looks like it is going to the rank choice tally, which will be interesting, but again, sort of academic at this point because the house majority is so massively huge for Democrats. One thing I want to add too is, okay, so Alaska was not the majority maker for Democrats in the Senate this time around, but it does set them up for success in 2028 because remember, Senate seats are six years, and Democrats would very much like to get four more seats so that they have a super majority, 60 votes in the Senate and allows them to circumvent the filibuster and pass a ambitious agenda. Right, and the Republican map for 2028 in the Senate is pretty rough. They're going to be defending seats in swing states, and they're going to have to try to flip seats in Democratic states. Okay, well on that note, I want to swing to the other side of Capitol Hill, the house, where Democrats nominated Hakim Jeffries of New York to be Speaker of the House with no challenger for the nomination. And so it appears that he's on a glide path to, first of all, being the first Black Speaker come the new year, so this could be a very historic event. But besides that, Sam, I wanted to ask, what should we take away from this? Does this mean that the House Democrats have fallen neatly in line behind Jeffries or are Democrats in array? Or is it not that simple? So if you just look at the numbers, the vote was 251 to 11, so 11 voted against Jeffries. And I think two Democrats did not vote at all. Seven of those 11 are newly elected progressives who came out with a statement saying, you know, there's still more work to be done to ensure the direction of the party is what their constituents are demanding in this particular moment. But even the vast majority of the congressional progressive caucus got behind Jeffries saying that they'd made significant progress since election day with him on laying out a bold progressive agenda. So I think you're right that for the most part, the caucus got behind Jeffries in a unified way. Now, this is not necessarily what's happening over in the Senate where there's a challenge to the Democratic leader, Chuck Schumer. And so that vote at the beginning of December is shaping up to be much more fraught. So Sam, I know we have seen progressives push back on Jeffries on any number of issues. What kinds of things do divide the Democratic caucus right now? I think some members are asking for an even bolder agenda, more significant strides toward passing Medicare for all, for example. Though I should note that this week, Jeffries did come out saying he supported some steps toward that, such as lowering the age of eligibility for Medicare, allowing children to stay on Medicaid for longer, adding dental vision and hearing, things like that. That were cheered by many progressives within the caucus. Another dividing line has been Israel. Jeffries has gotten support from APEC and is a packer of Israel, and that has become a real dividing line within the Democratic caucus. What stands out to me about this incoming class of Democrats is just how diverse they are. And what I mean by that is how many of them come from districts that President Trump won by double digits. How many of these Democrats, they're all up for election in two years, and many of them are going to be under a lot of pressure to show results, to focus on affordability, to actually be more moderate at the same time that you then have these very progressive DSA-aligned candidates who come in, but come in as a smaller share of a very large majority for Democrats, a large majority that might actually be more ideologically closer to the center. I think one problem that Jeffries and Schumer both have is this was an election when people were demanding a change to the status quo. There was intense anti-establishment fervor, whether you were running as a centrist or a progressive. And Jeffries and Schumer for many voters have come to represent the establishment. And there was a push for change. All right, we're going to take a quick break. And when we come back, we will open the listener mail bag and take some of your questions. Welcome back. And now let's open up the listener mail bag. I have it right next to me right here, and I'm going to dump it onto the desk. And let's see what you all have been wondering about. We're going to start actually with a voicemail, so I can't, it's not tangible. Here's a question from Patrick and Zurich. Does the US debt issue have any political salience? Will it ever be addressed by either political party? I love this question, because the debt doesn't seem to be taken up as a serious concern much these days. So, Tam, what do you think? A couple months ago, I called Mick Mulvaney, who was a congressman, went on to be a chief of staff for President Trump in the first term. But he was just like the ultimate deficit hawk. And he was also the president's budget director in the first term. And I asked him about this because it does seem like most of the time elected officials completely ignore the deficit until sometimes it becomes politically convenient, usually when you're criticizing the other party. And what he told me is that voters simply do not reward people who spend less and that when politicians talk about wanting to make cuts, they only want to cut other people's priorities. So, what he said is that Republicans always want to spend more on defense, Democrats always want to spend more on social programs. And so, ultimately, nothing really gets cut, nothing major happens. And his other point was that in Washington, problems that are distant don't get fixed. Only problems that have become an absolute crisis get fixed. So, I think the answer to Patrick's question is, I guess we have to wait until it's an absolute disaster, though there certainly are plenty of deficit hawks out there shouting from the rooftops. This would seem to be especially a Republican concern, because Republicans are the party of smaller government, the party that has traditionally focused more on spending less. So, Sam, are Republicans talking about this at all? Well, we should also note that Republicans grew the deficit with those big tax cuts in the one big beautiful bill act that they passed last year. And on the Democratic side, this is becoming a bit of a conversation too, as they talk about not only reversing cuts to Medicaid and SNAP that were made in that legislation, but also restoring enhanced ACA subsidies that expired and maybe even expanding health coverage more broadly, though some Democrats are saying, "Well, Republicans weren't so concerned about the deficit, so why should that stop us from passing these programs that will help people?" Mm-hmm. All right, we have another question. This one is from Karen. She asks, "We get so many requests to donate to campaigns in states where we don't live and vote. Does donating to these make a difference?" I mean, I imagine it does, but Sam, let's start with you. What do you think? So, yeah, Republicans, especially, often ding Democrats for the proportion of donations that come from out of state. I'm thinking in Georgia, a state that I covered for four years, the Republican nominee for Senate this year, kept calling Senator John Ossoff, the Democrat, the third Senator from California, because of all the donations he was getting from out of state. But at least in that case, the reality is for a candidate, like Ossoff, that massive fundraiser, Hall not only helped him win Georgia by double digits at purple state, but it also allowed his campaign to help out candidates down ballot like Governor-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms, who maybe wasn't pulling in as much money and helps carry her through to victory as well. Yeah, I mean, it feels like this all just goes hand in hand with just that trend of nationalized elections, where suddenly someone in Tennessee can be very invested in whether James Talarico wins or loses in Texas. And the the age of viral campaign videos, uh, bringing, you know, making it rain with small dollar donations is very much a thing. You know, there are plenty of wealthy donors like Elon Musk who pour money into outside groups and can just like drop all this money into a race and advertising and other things. But in the end, money sent directly to candidates is much more useful than money that goes to outside groups who can, you know, drop a bunch of ads, you know, it turns out that there are a lot of other uses for campaign funds and also that candidates with the funds they raise directly get better rates on TV ads and things like that. You know, I wonder if any of this is going to change now that Democrats expanded the map so much, because I think the reason a lot of people might donate to a candidate out of state is because their state is not competitive and they don't really see a reason to kick in that $15 for a candidate that's definitely going to lose. But now if you're a Democrat in a state like South Carolina or Kansas or Texas, you know, maybe you see, uh, your money being put to better use in 2028 and you're going to give it home rather than sending it somewhere else. Oh my god, that's a fantastic point. Uh, wow, this this year upended a lot of things. Uh, all right, let's go under our next question. This is from Duncan in Pasadena. He has a question about the Senate filibuster. There are compelling arguments on both sides for and against, uh, removing the filibuster and I'm wondering why do I never hear anyone talk about just maybe lowering the, the baths to say 55 votes in the Senate instead of 60 would something like that be possible and would it be more likely to get support rather than abolishing the filibuster completely? That is a fantastic question. Sam, what can you tell us? Yeah. So I hadn't really thought about this before. So I did a little digging before we hopped on the line here and one thing I learned from the Brennan Center is that the threshold actually used to be higher than 60 votes. It was at two thirds majority or 67 votes until a change was made in 1975. So this idea has been floated before, particularly in 2021. You might remember this was the time when President Biden was struggling to get stuff passed because of a few holdouts even within his own party. Um, one political scientist who has written on this is Steven Smith at Arizona State University and he basically says the reason is that people who support eliminating the filibuster entirely think that just bringing down the threshold would undercut their argument for majority rule over protecting the minority rule and also that there are so many different ideas for tinkering with the filibuster short of getting rid of it that it could get super complicated to find a route that could get enough buy-in from enough senators and so these ideas haven't really gone anywhere. Yeah, I think that we are going to enter another era of discussion of getting rid of the filibuster, you know, every few years. And certainly there was a lot of pressure from the president to Republicans to get rid of the filibuster. And now I think they're probably pretty happy to have it be in place. Absolutely. What's old is always new again. We just have this is Washington. We have the same conversations over and over. Yes. Speaking of things, we hear over and over. Here's a question from Adrian. Adrian asks, every election cycle is now called the most important election of our lifetimes. Do you feel that that has hindered and helped? I believe Adrian is referring to when candidates say, vote for me. This is the most important election. Tam, do you think that motivates voters? I think that voters are telling themselves that this is the most important election of a lifetime. Sure. Again, and again, and again. And the stakes have certainly felt incredibly high. The candidates have talked about these elections in existential terms. I will say, though, that President Trump asked people to vote like he was on the ballot. In particular, he asked Republicans to vote like he was on the ballot. And they just didn't go for it this time. I mean, reading this question, I also had to think, I don't want to outright poo poo the idea that the elections in our lifetimes have not been super important. I mean, I imagine if you are a voter who thinks about, for example, January 6th, the erosion of democratic norms, these elections may well feel super, super important. So it's not necessarily crying wolf here, right? And if you're a Republican who is super worried about the rise of the DSA or left wing Democrats, then this election would have been really important to it. It just turns out there weren't enough of them. You know who I hear this the most from is from Millennial or Gen Z voters who have come a political age just in the last decade or so. And I think for a lot of those people, it really can feel like every election is the most important election of their lifetimes. I talked to a Millennial chair of the Macomb County Democrats this summer who said, yeah, it feels this way every cycle and it's going to feel that way again in 2028. But I've also talked to a lot of voters who have kind of become numb to some of this messaging even if it might be true. Maybe it's not a compelling reason to vote if you're an infrequent voter. And honestly, we didn't see a whole lot of that message this time from Democrats. There was less focus on democracy is on the line in favor of an argument focused on Democrats are going to make life more affordable for you. Okay, let's do one more question. Our final one, this is from Richard. He wants to know, what are the futures for the Democratic and Republican parties post midterms? You know, and he's an easy question. Do these midterms change the way either party decides to operate going forward? All right. This is the big one. Let's start with Tam. Okay, so I was just on the phone this morning with a Republican who did not have all the answers, but suggested that 2028 is going to determine the path for both of these parties. The most important election of our life time. But the 2028 is going to be wide open. Maybe Democrats because of these midterms have a little bit of a head start on figuring out who they are in a political reality where Donald Trump isn't the dominant figure. They're going to have to try to do something resembling governing and happening in agenda for the next two years. But Republicans are also going to have a potentially very wide open primary, especially because the midterms made JD Vance look a little bit less inevitable to Republicans. So I think that because this was such a dominant win for Democrats, it is forcing more of a conversation among Republicans about, well, you know, what does a post-Trump reality look like? What does the Republican Party believe in? Is it Reagan's Republican Party? Is it Trump's Republican Party? Is it something else? We don't know. It will probably be the Republican Party of whoever ultimately wins the nomination. And I think the same could probably be said on the Democratic side. Sure. Sam, what do you think? Yeah, for Democrats, I don't think that these midterms necessarily resolved any of the debates over the direction of the party in terms of, you know, left versus center, moderate versus progressive. But a theme I did see resonate outside of those ideological constructs with this populist anti-establishment, status quo, busting kind of sentiment. And I think that is going to be something all kinds of candidates are going to try to appeal to going forward, especially as we head into 2028. Okay. Well, I think we got it. I think we solved it all. So let's-- Oh, yeah. Yeah. Right here on the MPR Politics podcast. All right. We are going to leave it there for today. I am Danielle Kurtzleben. I'm Sam Greenblast. I cover Congress. I cover Politics. And thank you for listening to the MPR Politics podcast.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Mary Peltola won Alaska’s Senate seat, becoming the first Alaska Native and second Indigenous woman elected to the U.S. Senate, driven by a hyper-local campaign centered on "fish family freedom" and extensive outreach to rural and Native communities.
  2. Her victory, though not a majority-maker for Democrats in the Senate, strengthens Democratic positioning for 2028 by securing a critical seat and advancing their goal of achieving a 60-vote supermajority to bypass the filibuster.
  3. Alaska’s race did not use rank-choice voting, as Peltola received over 50% of the vote outright, and the close margin highlights the significance of local voter engagement and demographic shifts in conservative-leaning states.
  4. In the House, Hakim Jeffries was nominated as Speaker of the House by a wide margin (251–11), marking a historic first for a Black Speaker, though some progressive members remain critical of his agenda and stance on Israel.
  5. Internal Democratic divisions persist over policy priorities like Medicare expansion and Israel, reflecting broader ideological rifts between moderates and progressives despite a generally unified endorsement of Jeffries.
  6. Voter fatigue with the "most important election" narrative and the rise of anti-establishment sentiment suggest that political messaging may be losing impact, especially among infrequent voters.
  7. The nationalized campaign finance model—where out-of-state donations support candidates in non-competitive states—has become more strategic, with Democrats potentially redirecting funds toward home-state races in 2028.
  8. Republicans are facing internal uncertainty about their party’s identity post-Trump, with midterms exposing vulnerabilities and prompting debate over whether the party will return to a Reagan-era or more populist, Trump-aligned vision.

Summary:

Mary Peltola’s historic win in Alaska marks a significant shift in Senate dynamics, making her the first Alaska Native senator and a key step toward Democrats securing a supermajority in 2028. Her victory stemmed from deeply local, community-centered campaigning that resonated with rural and Indigenous voters, despite a nationally difficult political environment. While not a decisive Senate majority gain, it strengthens Democratic momentum and signals a broader trend of anti-establishment, populist appeal across the party.

On the House floor, Hakim Jeffries secured the Speaker nomination with strong bipartisan support, though internal divisions remain over progressive policy goals and Israel-related stances. Democrats face ongoing ideological splits between center and progressive factions, while Republicans grapple with a redefined identity in the post-Trump era. Campaign finance dynamics are shifting, with donors increasingly directing support to competitive, home-state races.

The midterms have intensified debates over party direction, with both parties now facing pressure to adapt to a political landscape defined by voter demand for change and accountability. Ultimately, while the 2024 elections did not resolve deep ideological divides, they laid the groundwork for more strategic, identity-driven political realignments in 2028.

FAQs

Mary Peltola won by focusing on a hyper-local, grassroots campaign with the slogan 'fish family freedom,' and by traveling extensively throughout Alaska by boat, plane, and snowmobile to connect with rural and Native communities.

She is the first Alaska Native elected to the Senate and the second Indigenous woman ever elected, marking a historic milestone for Native representation and expanding Democratic influence in a typically Republican state.

No, Alaska alone did not give Democrats a supermajority, but it strengthens their position for future elections, particularly in 2028, when they aim to gain four additional seats to reach 60 votes and circumvent the filibuster.

Hakim Jeffries of New York was nominated as Speaker of the House with no challenger, and secured majority support despite 11 Democrats voting against him, signaling a largely unified progressive caucus.

Divisions exist over issues like Medicare for All, Israel policy, and the pace of progressive reform, with some members pushing for bolder changes while others emphasize moderation and practical policy.

The debt issue is rarely addressed until it becomes a crisis, as voters rarely reward fiscal restraint, and political parties often focus on spending priorities rather than cutting deficits.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.