Dave Chappelle Celebrates Charlie Kirk Assassination, Says Charlie Is IN HELL w/ TJ Harker & Mike ter Maat
2h 2m 40s
Dave Chappelle’s controversial remarks at a Madison Square Garden show, in which he claimed to feel better after Charlie Kirk’s murder and joked that George Floyd would be “laughing so hard he can’t breathe,” ignited a major backlash. Critics argue the statement was not a joke but a deeply offensive and inappropriate dismissal of a political assassination. The incident revealed a growing cultural rift, where both sides are seen as crossing moral boundaries: the left criticized Chappelle for mocking a death, while the right accused the left of glorifying violence and victimization. Many fans walked out, and prominent figures like Jennifer Welch lost 26 sponsors after laughing at a tweet about re-excavating Kirk’s body. The conversation underscores a broader crisis in American politics—increasing polarization, the erosion of empathy, and the normalization of politically charged mockery. Critics warn that such behavior signals a dangerous shift toward "assassination culture," where political death is treated as entertainment. The debate also highlights the limits of free speech, as private companies and public figures face real-world consequences for offensive content. Ultimately, the incident reflects a deepening political divide where trust is broken, and both sides are accused of hypocrisy, with the concern that societal norms are sliding into a state of escalating hostility and moral decay.
But now I'm sure all of you have seen the story Dave Sheppell mocking Charlie Kirk's assassination over the weekend at a sold out show at Madison Square Garden. Now many people are saying he told a joke. He did kind of, but his first statement wasn't a joke. He said that ever since Charlie Kirk was murdered, he's felt better. That's not a joke. That's just him saying he feels good. And many people stormed out of the event. I don't know if it was like everybody, but fans filmed themselves leaving saying he was just complaining about politics for like 80 minutes, which is what we do. So if you want to watch people complain about stuff on the internet, you come to us. Dave Sheppell is supposed to be a comedian, I guess, but he did add a joke. He said, "I'm sure Charlie Kirk is looking up at us, laughing so hard he can't breathe," which is, I would call it a joke, but it was a diss. And there's a difference. This is why it sparked a lot of outrage. A diss is when the people are behind you and you're insulting someone so that you can laugh at them. It is a kind of joke, but it's someone else's expense intentionally. And the issue, of course, Dave Sheppell was imitating, was making a play on Tony Hingecliff's joke about George Floyd, in which he said quite literally the exact same thing, which is sparked a massive controversy with people on the left saying, people on the right are hypocrites because they don't support free speech. Of course, I'm going to break it all down for you. We here at Tim Cass are going to break down for you. So you can understand, I'll just say that right. No one has principles. I just literally don't think anybody does. It may be here and there. I might have some, everybody might have one or two, but everybody is largely operating on moral structures, which is not based on principles. Hence, you're going to see these things be very, very different. So I'll say two things right at the top of this show. I don't care why Dave Sheppell did it. Charlie was my friend. Have a nice day. There's the door. That's it. Dave doesn't own me anything, but I'm going to say this again. I don't care what you think the moral argument is, the principled argument for a speech doesn't fly when you say the death of my friend made you feel better. You can leave. I'm done with you. Okay. You can apologize. Maybe you can come back. But I'll say that, you know what? Let me just save the rest, but I'm going to say that right off the top. Okay. Now we'll have a big discussion about whether or not this is more of the principles. You know, I'm going to add this to the intro. We are in, we are, we are looking at a bizzara world. That's what it is. The left is bizzara, America. Why? George Floyd was a career criminal who victimized people violently was in the process of committing a crime and doing drugs behind this behind the wheel of a vehicle, actively resisting arrest. And the guy who showed up after all of this, Chauvin, by all means, I don't think he was completely innocent, but he shows up after George Floyd resist the rest as I can't breathe put me on the ground. And they put that guy in prison for the rest of his life as well as the rest of the officers. It wasn't a good situation. I don't think anybody should be commended for it. But we are looking at people like Dave Chappelle who venerate career criminals, people who hold with pregnant women at knife point, who, who chew speed balls, methamphetinal by in the wheel of a car. That's who they venerate. And they celebrate and they build statues for and they mock Charlie Kirk, model citizen, political activist. He had opinions. Some of you didn't like. That's about it. He did everything by the rules with a smile in his face and open arms for all people disagree with him. And they shot him in the throat. They killed him. So this is this state of this country right now. We got a bunch of other news. Hey, a vehicle rammed the white house today. It broke through a security barrier slamming to a sign. A guy came out screaming, secret service, a national guard brought him down while he screamed. Hey, that happened again a few days ago. A second guy apparently jumped the barrier today too. Holy crap. It's just so crazy, isn't it? And then you got Jennifer Welch, the I've had it podcast. She's lost an estimated 28 sponsors because she she pulled up a tweet where someone said we're going to dig up Charlie and do it again and then laughed for like 30 seconds. So we'll discuss this culture war. Then you got Russell Brandt with send us the prison for 10 years. Donald Trump is talking about amnesty holy crap. When it rains, it pours man. We got a couple of guys joining us tonight to talk about all this and so much more. It's actually a serendipitous to have you both here. In fact, with this subject matter, you want to introduce yourself? Yeah, my name is thanks for having me on. I'm TJ Harker. I was a state and federal prosecutor for many years. I've been recently commenting on a variety of public issues involving law fair for a variety of different outlets, American mind chronicles, the federalists. When I was a prosecutor, I handed a whole a whole bunch of different trials, espionage frauds, some of the largest trials in the country in 2021. Not the largest, but two of the largest. The largest was the trial of Officer Derek Chauvin, which you referenced earlier. Yeah, and I think I think it's important to get to the truth of this because again, as I stated, we're in bizarre, we are, we are, we are looking, the left is a bizarre version of America in that Derek Chauvin for whatever, whatever your criticisms of him are, they believe some weird fantasy nightmare reality of what really happened. And I want to, I want to break that down because I do believe this is obviously why Dave Chappelle chose to mock Charlie Kirk the way he did. But again, there's a bizarre element. So yeah, Mike, how's it going? Who are you? I'm very pleased to be here. Enjoyed talking to TJ in the green room, found out all about him. He was a prosecutor. I was a cop. We never worked together, which is probably a good thing now that I think about it because we were going down some rabbit holes there. Long-term Republican, long-term professional economist worked for the White House, worked for a few other agencies, taught in the universities for a while, had my own business for a long while. As a second career, I became a cop. I worked on the road for 11 and a half years in South Florida. Around the time I joined the Libertarian Party out of fiscal disappointment with the Republican Party. Served as the Libertarian Party's vice presidential nominee in 2024. My team and I rejoined the Republican Party, joined the Republican Liberty Caucus last year, and very excited to be now launching a campaign to earn the vice presidential nomination of the Republican Party. A campaign that's never been run before, which is probably everything you need to know about whether or not it's a good idea. It's a fantastic idea, but this is just to be the vice president in 128. To run and earn the nomination in 2028. We want the national delegates to weigh in on who they would like to have as the presidential nominee rather than just blindly deferring to the presidential nominee as has been tradition. Yeah. Interesting. Great to have you. Great to be here. Yes, who's back? What's up, guys? My name is Alad Eliyahu. I'm a journalist. I do some White House reporting. It's good to be back to him. It's a beautiful studio. You guys have upgraded. That's it. Well, right? You were hanging out the press briefing and with Dana White, huh? Yeah. It was very cool to see him there. It's always very cool to see the president in the flesh, and unfortunately, we're not getting Dana White as our press secretary. To be frank, though, the president doesn't need a press secretary. He's his best own, he's his own best press secretary. He also takes like 20 questions a day. So more questions than any press secretary would. But anyway, Phil, what's up? It takes questions, but I'm not so sure that he actually gives answers. He answers the questions that he wants to answer. Yeah. It takes 20 questions, gives 10 answers. Exactly. What's up, everybody? My name is Phil. I sing for all that remains. What's going on over there, Carter? Going on, man, I'm pumped a lot. I'm pumped that you're back, and I'm glad to have you all guests, and let's just get right into it. Phil, before we get started, we got a great sponsor for you guys. It is kete.io. Head over to keet.io/timcast.io. My friends encryption matters. And so does framing of the camera, which we don't have right now. That's too bad. But encryption matters. Kete is a peer to peer encrypted messaging and file sharing app. So you can talk to your friends. That's some creepy middleman taking all your data. Now, these big companies, they like to come out, and they say that their apps, they protect your data, but they still centralize all that information on servers, and it can still be accessed, and your metadata and other things can still be found. They can still figure things out. That's why kete is great. It removes that central message infrastructure. It's free and to end encrypted messenger built on peer-to-peer technology. You can send messages. You can send files, make audio or video calls without a company server holding your conversation history. It doesn't require your phone number or email. It doesn't collect your metadata. So go to keet.io/timcast.io. Download it today. Thanks for sponsoring the show, boys. And don't forget, go to castbrew.com. Use promo code IRL20. You'll get 20% of all the coffee you buy, including subscriptions. I recommend Appalachian Nights. This is, I personally blended this. It's my own personal formula for coffee. I love it. It's the best coffee you'll ever had. At least, I think so. We've got a bunch of other flavors. We got Dr. Alekstein's Big Booty Latina Love Potion available now at castbrew.com. Check out all our flavor drinks, cake cups, bottled water, you name it. Let's jump into the news. But now I'm sure most of you have seen the story. Dave Chappelle's Charlie Kirk joke at MSG draws rebuke from Erica Kirk. She indeed stepped up and talked about what happened. I do believe that we have the the clip here. I'm going to play the clips for you can see the joke for yourself and then we'll break it all down. Here you go. Here's the viral clip. It's just a feeling. Well, he's got more. That wasn't the only thing he said. He closed out by saying there's actually didn't close out, but he added this.
Now you may be wondering what that joke was? Well, we got the clip for you. Crowd of you. You've done good, though, Kevin. The black community is so proud of you. Right now, George Floyd is looking up at us all laughing so hard that he can't breathe. God bless you, Kevin. Indeed, this sparked massive outrage among, basically, everybody. Now, I'll say a couple of things first off to kick this conversation in high gear. The first thing he said about Charlie Kirk getting murdered made him feel better was not a joke. Literally no joke there. He's just saying it. Many people who walked out, they filmed themselves walking out. There's a couple of people that have gone viral for this. They said that he was just basically ranting for like 80 minutes. He wasn't making any jokes. He was just complaining about Trump and racism and Charlie Kirk and insulting him. Apparently he mocked Jesus, too. I don't know exactly what was that in that capacity. But several people were like, yeah, there was no punch line. He was just basically saying he hated Charlie Kirk, was calling him racist and things like this. So right now the big debate is whether or not the right supports or opposes free speech. So I'll say a couple of things for all of these people. You've got, I'm going to shout out my low order thinker libertarians, not all libertarians, just the low order thinker ones who don't have any moral foundations other than liberty. Check out Jonathan Knight's moral foundation research. You'll be surprised at what some of these people support. They believe in principles. Well, I am going to disabuse you of that notion. There's no such thing. Okay. To be fair, there are sometimes somewhere almost no one operates on principles and those that say they do are lying. Some do 99.9%. Don't and it is no exception in the culture war. This is to say I say this with total duration to most people who are activists in the culture war. But I will all say this with respect to those who are cognizant of this. Humans operate on moral frameworks, not principles. This means there is a line. Some people think you should not cross and others think it's fine to cross. That is, when you insult when a society denigrates a career criminal drug abuser who was resisting arrest, we say, yeah, well, that's who we should mock. A society draws its line saying those people should be derided to discourage people from doing those things. And you venerate the men who stand up for righteousness for good, for order, for making this country stronger and more prosperous, particularly when they are murdered in cold blood. So that's a moral distinction. It is an absurd and stupid notion to argue I have a principle that you should never mock the dead. Know there are terrorists and murderists and child rapists and we want society to know that should you engage in those behaviors, we will mock you and your legacy will be a dirty diaper. And those that stand for good who will sacrifice themselves for what is better, we build statues in your honor. That's always been the distinction. So you got the low order thinker libertarians calling conservatives hypocrites. But don't get me wrong, you got conservative hypocrites claiming Dave Chappelle was never funny, which is just ridiculous considering he's the most famous comedian in the world. But I'll throw it to you guys. Let's get the conversation going. What say y'all? My opinion is clear. I think Dave Chappelle was funny. I thought he was very funny. I don't think he's funny anymore. I still think he's funny. I just think this wasn't funny. This wasn't funny. I understand most of the show wasn't funny. I don't think ranting about politics is funny. And I certainly don't think what he said was funny, but in fairness, and Tim you pointed this out. I don't think he was trying to be funny. He was trying to be a jerk. And I think he succeeded. So a few things here. First and foremost, I think Dave Chappelle was at one point one of the funniest comedians around. I think the Chappelle show was one of the best shows around in its prime. Ever since Chappelle kind of aged more, he stopped kind of telling jokes. And now his comedy special have just turned into these annoying, obnoxious lectures that I really hate. And comedy pretends nowadays I feel like, or for a long time, pretend to be truth tellers, but are just usually obnoxious assholes. And I think that's what the case is here with Chappelle. I think he knew what he was doing. But I think this is also very clearly an obviously conservative bait. I think he knew what he was doing because he was like quoting this rat cliff joke. And he knew he was going to hit the conservatives with the freeze. Or what's in his clear back to Congress. Whatever same difference. He knew that he'd be able to hit the conservatives with like the free speech argument and say that they're a bunch of hypocrites. I think we just at this point, the culture is so messed up in how bloodthirsty and excited and how people laugh at the pain of the Kirk family. The Kirk families become a punchline. Erica Kirk's become a punchline. And it's like, it's a sad sick joke. And people think violence towards Charlie Kirk was justified across the country. I feel as though many people in the Democrat party think that was justified. They think the Luigi Mangio's stuff is justified. And where does that leave us as a culture and society? It leads us towards. Tim's not favorite thing, but what he says very often. Civil war. Where else does this go? And like again, we'll see deranged people. They're deranged right wingers and left wingers. Where does that leave them? I think where does that leave them? We just talk quickly about whether or not there is actually hypocrisy here because there's not. So let's like disregard that premise entirely. The first amendment protects five things. The freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly, freedom to petition the government for redress of grievances and freedom of speech. Freedom of speech means you are secure in your right these of either government to say what you want. But that has nothing to do with whether we can criticize other people for speaking publicly, shame them, remove them from the whole public square. It just means that the government can't stop that. Yes, but that's not the argument being made right now. The argument being made right now is that the right argued for the right to free speech as it pertained to offensive jokes and now are not arguing for it because they offended. No, we are arguing. Well, I am arguing that you should have the capacity to speak freely. These are the government. The government should not be able to stop you. But correct. When you exercise that, right, you are also bringing upon yourself the opportunity to be mocked out of the public square. And my strictly limited point here is this is not hypocrisy. This is not paradoxical. There's nothing inconsistent about those views. The free speech, right? The first amendment only protects you from the government. We'll break this down. The cancel culture war centered around social media companies and other companies, either firing employees or censoring and banning people. These were private companies doing it. The left argued you have no right to free speech on a private platform owned by other people. Now, I actually disagree with that. I think that when Twitter or X owns the has the monopoly on the public square, there has to be some capacity by which individuals can participate in public. So I've never agreed with this free speech, you know, this leftist argument or whatever it may be. But the argument made by conservatives was Facebook shouldn't censor people. So there's a difference between when Dave Chappelle in 2019 was calling out political correctness to the height of cancel culture. I called him a hero. Why? Because cancel culture was banning people for literally any reason like Zubi who got a suspension on Twitter for saying, okay, dude, he didn't misgender someone. Someone responded to his argument, someone, okay, dude. And they said misgendering that's cancel culture. Sarah Silverman got fired because she did blackface 10 years before. So she was going to be in a movie like I'm 10 years ago. She did blackface. There was a race car driver who lost sponsors because his dad, his dad said the N word in the 80s. That's insane. John Schneider, Papa John got fired from his company that he founded because he complained in a phone call that Colonel Sanders said the N word. Oh, he actually said the word though. Heaven forbid a guy say racism is bad. Nope, they fired him for it. That's cancel culture. Dave Chappelle standing up at the height of all of that and saying, I'll offend you if I want to. That's heroic because it was an irrational broken system. Today, Dave Chappelle is offended because Tony Hinchcliffe said a joke about George Floyd and everybody laughed and he's hurt by it because he doesn't like that George Floyd died and George Floyd Floyd's family was hurt by it. Now, I don't like the idea of making fun of people who die. I am I am sad by the death of George Floyd. I wish he did not die. It should not have happened. But there is a distinction here. Dave Chappelle was not doing this to prove a point. That's I to find a opinion, but I disagree with that psychoanalysis. In my view, I think Dave Chappelle is personally hurt when he watches Tony Hinchcliffe make that joke and everyone laughs because today, even his mind, George Floyd was an innocent guy murdered by the police and we're laughing at him and we're laughing at the pain he's experienced. The problem is Dave Chappelle is factually wrong and there's no idea what he's talking about. This would most liberals do and how most liberals are. They live in a bizarre world of fake information. They don't even know what they're talking about half the time. So instead of looking into what happened, Dave Chappelle is an emotional knee jerk reaction. Thanks. George Floyd was an innocent guy who was brutally murdered by the cops instead of a career criminal who was resisting arrest still should not have died. But I digress. And so he says, if you needle me, I'm going to needle you and therein lies the problem. If we if we are to exist in a radio or want a society where there is always an escalating tit for tat, I hope you guys have bought your safe and ready meals.com emergency food because my fear after Dave Chappelle said this is that someone's going to try and kill him. Why? Because this is the most brutal mockery of Charlie Kirk's death. I have heard yet and people were buying t-shirts covered in his blood and Dave Chappelle went before was 30 some 1,000 people in men's square garden and said when people I don't like are killed, I feel good. Now there's going to be someone out there who cried and mourned the death of Charlie and they're going to say I'd like to feel good too.
That's the problem with what Dave Chappelle just did. He's open to the door on himself, me, and anybody else is in the public commentary space. That's why it's principally number one wrong to do. No one is going around suggesting that you murder people like George Floyd. Dave Chappelle got on stage in front of the world and said it's good when you kill, and that is messed up. - It is messed up. The other thing that's messed up, and you did a good job of explaining the second comment that he made about the joke about looking up at us, the first comment that you showed us, however, that in which Dave had said, "I feel better," right? I think that may come from a different place. I think that Dave is really upset about the fact that we have a conservative culture in America, in which a lot of people like Charlie Kirk actually believe in a certain set of values, and it drives Dave crazy. I think that he really resents a whole lot of thinking of a conservative nature. I am not convinced that he doesn't feel better over this. I think Dave is messed up, and I think he's a part of this victim culture that we have in all too many circles in the United States, where we lift up victimhood, and we praise people who have failed, and I think that that's where Dave is coming from. - You know, one of the things I find fascinating about this too is that I was looking it up, that Charlie Kirk actually tweeted out in support of Dave Chappelle when he was attacked allegedly, but I'm like, "Not a ledger, it's not a camera." - Attached by this trans-crazed person. And like, I don't know, no good death was punished, and alpha kind of messed up. The one silver lining on this, though, is when you played the first video, you could actually hear some people gas and take it back. I'm like, there was this one woman like, "Oh, that's kind of messed up." So it is a little bit heartening to hear some of the responses. - Well, it is, and good for you for pointing that out. - There's videos of people walking out of the venue. - Yeah, there wasn't a lot of cheering. A lot of the crown seems a little stunned. Like, again, there was no look like that's messed up. - Like that's messed up. - What that suggests is that the Overton window has shifted the last five years. That now, that never would have happened five years ago, that a left-wing comedian, and I agree that Dave Chappelle is very funny, that he would have made a comment that was politically inflammatory, and that anybody would have walked out or suggested anything to him. - It wouldn't have been considered politically inflammatory. - Exactly, correct. - Apparently, according to some of the people that were there, they said that when people started walking out on them, like they were grounds, they were jeers, some people cheered, some people yelled, "F Charlie," when people started walking out, Dave apparently complained, "This crowd sucks." That's according to one person who was there. - Yeah. - Look, this whole, the idea that woke his dad that there is not a culture war going on in the United States, there are a lot of people on the right that thought, "Oh, Donald Trump won the election, "and we are going to have control of the culture," et cetera, the conservatives or people on the right, I think it's probably a better way to describe it. They don't have control of the culture, but they do have influence now. And I think that that's kind of been the way that it's always been. There was a time where if you said something that was politically correct, like in the '90s, you could get people trying to boycott you and stuff, this was generally if the right didn't like it. And then the pendulum swung. And the left kind of took over the culture. And then by 2010, you could lose whatever for saying the wrong thing, 2012, whatever it was. But there was always kind of a stalemate, right? The right had enough influence to be able to actually threaten to boycott or threaten to get people fired. The left then became ascendant and then they had all the influence. But I think now it's kind of gone back to the situation where, look, if you say something insensitive, there is enough energy on the right and enough energy on the left where you can get some kind of social consequences. And now it seems David's-- - I think what's going to happen now, you've got this viral clip of James Carville saying, Democrats were lying the whole time. They don't care about affordability. They want revenge and they want to humiliate Trump. We're going to have two, so here's what's particularly scary. As Democrats are now saying, they're going to go after any companies that supported Trump. They're going to go after any media personalities that supported Trump. They know they can't go after the government because Blanche and the government have the DOJ. So they're going to legally jam up anybody supported Trump. They want to erode the base from beneath him. Todd Blanche said, or I'd be careful how he phrased it, but he basically was like, if they start going after the Trump administration, illicitly he's going to go after them. So I'm just going to say it like this. The New York Times published an article a few days ago saying we're in the fourth great crisis of America. Oh boy, I wonder what that sounds like. And they make reference to the Civil War and World War II and the Great Depression. And I'm like, right. And the article was about the political divisions in this country. When Dave Chappelle gets up on stage and says, I feel better that Charlie Kirk was murdered, that's assassination culture. I would not be surprised again. And I hope Dave takes care of himself. I hope he's got security and all that because we don't want any violence. But I'm going to say it again. The people who shut up for Charlie Kirk's funeral. The people who believe in more than just who Charlie was. I want to make this distinction. When Dave, when George Floyd died, people tried to burn the country down. In fact, it was like what, $45 billion in damage nationwide. And 30 some odd people were killed after George Floyd died. When Charlie Kirk died, there was no riot. But that anger is pent up. And people still have it. And George Floyd is trying to throw fire onto that, onto that powder keg. That's what terrifies me. To say this to so many people who have not reacted to the murder of someone they, they, they followed, they cared about or someone that many of them loved. With no, with no reaction. To see this man, I want to make sure people understand how, it is painful to watch these college kids wear the freedom shirts covered in blood for Halloween. And they all did it. They were doing it all over the place. The young woman who went and told the poem about the Kirk Reversary, how they memified the murder of this guy, the murder of him. And conservatives still have not reacted with violence. They are being meddled every day, and they are being spat on, being told we will kill you, and we will laugh, and we will get away with it. What scares me the most is that Dave Chappelle is one of the biggest possible personalities on the planet. And he decided he was going to give permission to everybody, that he was going to look into the eyes of every Charlie Kirk fan and say, I feel good about this. OK. I fear someone's going to say, OK, David, feel so good. Let's see how good you feel. That's what I'm worried about. I think the point you made in the beginning, how the government is going to be going after businesses, going after private citizens, and stuff like that, to try to cool the impulse for either political activism or to be involved with the administration. I think that signals the most stressing-- Let me put it like this. What we are seeing right now with the Democrats, those people you saw on the street throwing Molotov cocktails eight years ago, those are the people in Congress now, they won. You've got 25 confirmed gender nonconforming individuals who won in this midterm. These are people who I guarantee you were out marching in those streets. Not suggesting they were doing anything violent. And not just them, but in this wave, you are getting people who 10 years ago were the fringe activists who were marching in these streets that were engaging in violence or whatever might be George Floyd six years ago. I guarantee you, these people were in these protests. What you are seeing right now at the federal level is what happens when the street level activists who throw bricks get federal power. I warned about this in 2018. Everybody was telling me it's not possible. It'll never happen. The security apparatus in the United States government would never allow it. And we are literally here right now with street level far left activists holding the reins of political power. I said it before, and I'll say it again. Populations don't change their politics. Their politics are developed as children, as young people, and they grow into the political system. That's why Nick Fontes is getting 80,000 concurrent viewers and getting half a million to a million views per show, despite being banned everywhere. Young men who followed him, developed those politics are now entering the political space with those politics. What we are going to see is, here's what I described that. Back in the day, the left and the right were very close to each other with an overlap. As time went on, they slowly started to move away from each other. The younger generation is down here. The older generation is up here. You take two boomers, they're going to grant a lot of things. You take two Gen Z, and they're not going to grant anything. As the boomers die off, and our generations move, the center of American politics is getting spread further and further out. To eventually, we get stuff like this. Dave Chappelle, gloating over the murder of a guy for politics. So what comes next? Well, a 20-year-old who protests becomes a 30-year-old who runs for office, becomes a 40-year-old president, becomes a 40-year-old member of Congress, who becomes a 50-year-old who passes a bill saying, "Go lag the right." And eventually, you get two vehicles, two black SUVs, speeding down DC towards the police station. Two men jump out, run up to the building, and scream, arrest that man at each other. And then the police are going to make a decision. And depending on who controls law enforcement and violence makes it determination. If this is to continue, with the Democrats threatening to go after private citizens for their political opinions, or slotkin, saying she'll go after junior staffers, then the end result is fairly obvious.
in my opinion. Either the right says, guess you win left revolution. The left now has more than enough state legislatures to overturn the electoral college, eliminating a constitutional protection. And they make it blocked by the Supreme Court because there are some arguments against how they could pull this off. But, functionally, they could eliminate the electoral college in 20, in 2028. In which case, that's a revolution. That is the dissolution of our constitutional government when they rip that through a secondary means. Will the right just say, guess you win? Will the left then take 2028 and make Puerto Rico DC, Guam states, the Virgin Islands add eight new Democrats senators so the right can never win again. Probably will they pat the Supreme Court? Probably, maybe they won't, maybe it's one big game. I don't know. My point is either the right rolls over and you get a revolution or the right says no when you get a civil war. I think there's more options than that. Deliberate. You're not wrong that there is a large proportion of the Democratic Party that is crazy. I appreciate the fact that on the left, they would argue similarly about our party. And it is true that the parties have moved farther and farther apart. Indeed, I often say that our politics have broken into two camps. On one side or the crazy is on the left and the crazy is on the right, who are driving our politics away from each other toward conflict and an inability to resolve issues. And that's wrong. And that's wrong. You are wrong. Well, I don't think Donald Trump is a former liberal. Elon Musk is a former liberal. Tulsi Gabb was a former liberal. R.K. Jr. was a former liberal and they're all on the same team. And they're on the same team of moderation and the people defending Charlie Kirk are standing up against violence and the people gloating and celebrating it are insane. The right is composed or was of a mix of political views from libertarian to moderate conservative independent. And the left is a cult. The left does have cult elements. The right has cult elements too. The right has a problem is that our team are all the normal people. And then we have this other political class team in America that has an interest in conflict on the left and on the right who dehumanize the other side to your point, who this is, you know, Dave is an example of someone who is not on my team. And that's not because he's on the left and I'm on the right. It's because he's crazy. And he doesn't want people to get along and which political leader on the rights advocating for death and gloating over the murder of leftists and left personalities. Nobody that I know of. But the left is doing it entirely. So went again, when you say the right has their extremists who want conflict, no, they don't. Well, they don't want murder, but the left does. Right. So that's that's absolutely. There is a big difference. You are absolutely allowed to insult, mock, and belittle people for their politics and be mean about it. I wouldn't recommend it. I don't like it. But crossing the line is when you murder people and gloat over their death. And that's the left. So when people on the right say, I think the left is crazy or they're a cult or you're an idiot, you're a moron. Well, that's, that's a crash, but acceptable within, within politics. When the left says it's good that Charlie died and they feel good and they, they wear Halloween costumes of bloodspot on their necks. That's the people advocating for murder and death. The right does that. Well, there's a huge difference, but I don't think it necessarily means the next couple of years, they're going to eliminate, for example, little electoral college. I just don't think the Democratic Party has a shit together. So fish, that's not one of the words I'm not allowed to. You can just find it. I don't think that they have their act together enough to accomplish anything. Remember that the Democratic Party did not this week earn a mandate to do anything. Yes, but we're talking about state legislatures that they are, they are the voters to enact the national popular vote. They don't have a mandate either. No, but Democratic Party doesn't have a mandate. Every, every blue state that's gotten a legislative majority has passed the, the Interstate Compact and also, and now we've got, we've got six more states that just reach that, that blue majority. I do not think the trend says they would not do it. And I'll be real, real good to be fair. We have seen this in Congress time and time again, where the Democrat leadership will go to one person, say, spiked the vote because we want the issue. It's possible. The only problem is their, the, the national popular vote Interstate Compact is two states to over the thresholds to accomplish it, which would mean the Democratic Party would have to convince two of the six not to vote on what they've campaigned on. Maybe, maybe, how does the compact work? It's that whatever, whoever would win the national popular vote, they'd commit all their electoral votes to pledge to, you know, subvert the Constitution to your point about a mandate though. The, the people that were elected like the Democrats, they, I think it's highly likely that they believe that this is a mandate. They don't look at this and say, and I, because I get the sense because I've talked to some of my friends that are actually on the left and they don't get the sense that this is because of the war and because of inflation and because of gas prices. They get the sense that this is a repudiation of Trump, that people don't like Trump and that people don't like Trump for all of the reasons that the Democrats don't like Trump. It's not because, you know, I can't pay my bills. I don't have, you know, the prospects of getting a home and I'm, you know, 25, 30. I don't, you know, I don't like the Iran war. He promised that we wouldn't go to war. I agree with you from a conservative or from, from a realistic perspective, they don't have a mandate. But according to the left, they do. And that's really their perception matters in that that's all they need to behave in a way as if they do and they have the numbers to do that. So they might get people that are dis, you know, that really don't like what they do. They might get people that would kick them out of office because of the things that they do. But the things that we're talking about, things like like expanded the court, the things like overriding the, you know, the state compact, all of those things, they would do. They'll get rid of the things. I think plenty of them would. The problem is that they're not organized to do so because they don't have a majority of people who ran on those issues. Organism ran on this, some ran on that, but they're just organization is messed up at this point. Is it required for what they are? The right is the disparate group of very, of eclectic political beliefs. The left is not. The left is a cult. Take, if I'm sure you've seen the graphs showing that the right has all these different camps spattered all over the place and they all tear each other's throats apart. The libertarians broke from Trump a while ago over over the war in Iran and the Epstein files. On the left, they're all hyper centralized around one cluster. This means you are going to see what we call the standalone complex and I think you do. That is, you do not need to instruct a Democrat as to or a liberal as to what is the appropriate course of action towards victory. You do not need to go to a polling location and tell the liberal when you're, when you're doing signature verification, throw the, throw the Trump in the garbage or throw the Biden in the, in the winners. They just do the right doesn't do these things. You get the consequences of a conspiracy without the meeting of the minds. Exactly. And that's called a standalone complex. And that's what I think we largely see with the left. I think that this can be understood in another way and I agree with a lot of the points you've made. But the United States is deep in crisis right now. And it's deep in crisis because one political party does not care about the institutions that exist in the United States. Hold on, hold on a second. So it doesn't care about those institutions. It doesn't care about the form of government and it doesn't care about the rule of law. And the other side does care about those things, but they recognize that in order to stop the first side, they might have to do some things that break those rules. And the right does not know how to do that. And it doesn't know how far can we push the rules, how far can we bend them, what tactics can we use in order to send a message that the other sides of lawlessness will not be tolerated. There are some techniques that can be used, which would be a third option from versus rolling over versus civil war that can be deployed. And some of them are now being deployed for the very first time. We'll see what happens. Well, one, for example, would be Jeff Clark's organization called Operation Oversight, which is functionally a law fair campaign brought by the right. So what it is is not using the spirit of the law. For example, when the left tried to take John Eastman's law license, the former advisor to President Trump, they were technically complying with the letter of the law, but not to complying with the spirit of law. Same thing with the indictments of Donald Trump. I wrote about these issues extensively. We can do the same thing. We can comply with the technical literal meaning of the law and use the processes and the institutions to send a strong message to those who would engage in lawlessness that you personally will pay a price. Let me make this more specific. It is not enough to make general arguments. We're not going to persuade people by general argumentation and effective reasoning. That is not effective. What is effective is communicating to Jack Smith personally that you personally will incur legal bills defending your legal license, which is what the National Civil Liberties Alliance originally did. Brought a lawsuit against him on behalf of Marshall Blackburn, the state of Tennessee. We can do things like that. And if you impose specific costs on specific left leftist activists, on them specifically, not on the movement generally, but on specific human beings, then you can cut potentially the health. I would say two things to that. We're not going to catch up to the smarter kids in class by going slower than they are. Correct. And you're not going to take out a murmuration of birds with a rifle. So what the left represents, I would describe, they actually, this is really funny. We pulled up an organization called a murmuration. They called themselves this. They are a fluttering group of thousands of birds aimlessly fluttering about just somehow watching each other and moving the right direction. This is why their arguments are incongruous. It's why one day women with a Y is the appropriate spelling and then one day women mix in with an X is the appropriate. Yes, but, but, but that's it. Let me give it another example. When Donald Trump cut off funding through USAID, the consequences were very real. And so that, here's a good example. When you go to a county fair and you're supposed to guess on how much a cow weighs and 10,000 people guess, it's a common misunderstanding that the median happens to be correct on that bell curve. A lot of people bid too high, a lot of people bid too low, but in reality, what happens is most people do not know how much a cow weighs and a few people know a lot. And those guys get it right. That murmuration is not just some group mob organization that's emerging like spontaneous order. What's actually happening is that there are a few heads to this hydra.
and they can be cut off. They can be brought to justice. They should have been prosecuted in the last two years. I wrote about that extensively. And then if you prosecute two or three people specifically, like for example, Jack Smith and others, that would send a very strong deterrence message. I agree with you generally, but I don't think it's coordinated enough to act as a group. The murmuration still requires the first bird to move in a particular direction. - Well, no, no, the murmuration is all the birds snap respond to each other. There is no one bird. - Well, there's, right. Whether or not the analogy holds up or not. (laughing) - I'll defer to you on the structure of the murmuration. - Why isn't Trump doing it? - Well, that's a totally separate question. Now it's probably too late for him. It may not be too late in 2028, but I don't see how the Republicans can possibly win 2028 without Texas. - Well, that's a good point too. Here's what I would say. If you are Todd Blanche at the Department of Justice, your opportunities now to bring effective lawsuits or criminal cases among other things are limited. And the reason they're limited is because you're seeing mass defections. You know that you're gonna be law-fared and you know that the criminal litigation itself will take longer than two years in most cases, which means you're banking on J.D. Vance or Marco Rubio winning. So that's a career gamble that most people will not take. - Trump's going to prison January 21st, 2029. - Well, the New York State criminal convictions are pending. That's just frozen until he's out of office. - There is absolutely the concern that the left would continue to subvert the American system of governance by seeing those prosecutions through. Yeah, there's no doubt. - Well, there's a conviction. - Yeah, right. I'm not spewing that. - Yeah, I mean, you're talking about the check fraud. - The moment he's out, what's he gonna do? These are state-level charges. And the court's just like, we'll see. - There are other things that can be done though. Let's, so for example, the full faith in credit clause of the United States Constitution requires that one state abide by the laws of another state when it comes to the enforcement of those laws in that other state. So if you're in Florida, for example, and New York issues are warrant for your arrest, then Florida's supposed to comply with it. But there are intelligent ways that Governor DeSantis could tell Donald Trump, well, no, hear me out though. If you truly, you asked, is there a third way? - I don't say anything, but my reaction was visible. - You're right. Well, let's-- - The Sanctus is never going to protect Trump. - Well, let's, maybe the state of the great state of Tennessee would come through. And you don't have to explicitly-- - Be Byron Donald's, it doesn't have to. - Yeah, so this, yeah, that's right, it could be Byron Donald. So the specific, the specific tactic in that case would be come and get him. Now you don't, that means you're not delivering him up. You're not using the state law enforcement authorities to deliver him to the border of Tennessee or to New York. - We talked about this when he was initially charged. - I'm not saying that this particular tactic would or would not work. I'm saying there's a little bit of creative problem-solving. By the right, we'll come up with 10,000 different tactics that are asymmetrically useful, meaning they impose too large of a cough on the other side to follow through on. - They're not-- - We just don't do it. - They're not going to catch up to the head of the class by going slower than them. When Donald Trump was indicted initially, I made that argument. Ron DeSantis can say, come and take him, come and take him. And Donald Trump could have responded with, you are free to come and serve me at my home. And Ron DeSantis could have said, state police will not allow a fraudulent charge because there was no underlying crime to the falsification for an upgrade. - But this is five years later, right? - And so the question is, Kim-- - And at the time, they didn't know anything. - Yeah, no doubt, they didn't know doubt. And it worked out all right. It worked out all right. - It didn't. - Well, Trump was-- - Trump's lawyers were arrested. - Yes, well, now was arrested. - And they were given no protections. - I'm talking about now, 2024, the charges were dropped. The prosecution in New York saw itself through. But nevertheless, all things-- - No, those convictions are pending. - But today, more Americans are aware that the West is in crisis. And so the question is not whether they did it in 2020, but will they do it now? And the answer is not, the question is, just because they won't do it in every specific instance doesn't mean that they won't do it in many instances. - I think the reality is palpable, visible to literally everybody who understands going politically, the right will do nothing. They've never, and they won't now. And there's no reason-- - People who walked out of the Chappelle show wouldn't have done that five years ago. That, to me, is the most stunning thing of this. - I disagree. - In my, in my world, when I talk to what I call my "normy friends," who are right-coded, but basically "normy Americans," the Charlie Kirk murder was the one thing in the last 46 years that has broken through to them. I say 46 years 'cause I'm 46 years old. Nothing else. No arguments about the Lafracure or theot currency or fractional reserve banking or abortion. Nothing else broke through. The Charlie Kirk's murder did. And in my experience, no, but maybe one or two handful, but there would not have been groups walking out. And that's a plus is fine. I'm gonna wipe pill on that. - We've got this story from Variety. I've had it podcast host Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan apologize for laughing at Charlie Kirk joke. We regret it. As of right now, Gina Milan says, Jennifer Welch is I've had a podcast. 28 brands have pulled or ended their sponsorships. Now, we can see that two of them may have already ended their sponsorships before. But for those that are not familiar, Jennifer Welch on her show pulled up a tweet where someone said we're gonna dig Charlie Kirk up and do it again. And then she just started laughing for like 30 seconds. Then she claimed the guy who killed Charlie was a Maga guy, which is a lie. And since then, she has lost directly 26 sponsorships according to this post. Now, the last I saw from Colvet was it was like 22. So I think 20 it makes sense. However, cozy earth and quince. Did I say that? They said that they had their last ads with her months ago. So they may not have ended their sponsorships. They may have already been ended. But that means there's 26 companies that have broken from her show because she mocked the death of Charlie Kirk. So the question remains right now, if we want to be optimists and I am, here's what I am hoping the Democrats realize that by winning the center in this midterm, they need to chill the F out, drop this stuff, condemn these people and keep the Joe Rogan's and the Shane Gillises because this is the kind of stuff that makes the middle freak out like you were just saying. I hope the Democrats take that lesson and say, hey, if we chill out, we might win more elections and have more power and get more of what we want. The problem is then they get in 2028 and more of what they want is communism. So I'm still hoping at least it chills things out for a little bit. The question will be right now with the direct ramifications against this lady mocking Charlie Kirk. Will anything happen to Dave Chappelle? Will he lose, will he lose shows? There was a great post. I saw a loose business. I saw a great post. They said, does Robert Kraft now come out and demand that all of his, all the stadiums and all the arenas pull Dave Chappelle? Is that how it works? It's like, I think it is how it should work. No, I mean, it's how it should work. It's that particular thing is not going to happen, but Dave is going to lose business. Just like they should have and did lose business. I think more people are, more big businessmen tycoons are waking up to the fact that this is a winner takes all gambit. And it wouldn't surprise me if you do start seeing some selective commercial enterprises like that say, what do you mean by winner take all? Winner, this isn't, we are not having a discussion right now, but what marginal tax rates should, I mean, this is not what this is. Like the boomer politics of the last 50 years are dead and buried. That party on the right is never coming back. Right, this is a question about what does it mean to preserve the principles of the American founding? What does it mean to be an American? What does it mean to have a civilization? What is the West about? And if you cannot close your venue to a comedian who's subverting the West, then you're just not serious about winning. I think a lot of people still think we need more civility in politics, but a greater percentage, which is nonsense, but a greater percentage of people today are now saying, holy crap, everything is at stake. We need more, we need more duels in Aaron Burren. We need gloves on. Well, I will say this, no, I want more civilian politics. I want, I am, I am a liberal guy. My politics on the political spectrum, we're talking about tax policy and marginal tax rates would be liberal leaning. But these conversations don't exist anymore because right and left no longer are about whether you want a higher or lower tax rate, certain trade policies. I'm gonna come out and say this, it was a guy, it was a viral video where a roofer. He says he was MAGA and he switched and voted part, he was part of the blue wave because Trump was deporting his illegal day laborers. - Who's the guy in Texas? - Is he in Texas? - Well, the one I saw was in Texas, but he was a business owner. - He's on the roof and he's gonna be, yeah. And my point was, when I was young and a liberal, that's the guy we wanted locked up. The business owner who put hundreds of thousands of his pocket while exploiting day laborers illegally, the left supports him though. He votes for Democrats. - Yeah, the teamsters and the labor unions are not on the left any longer. I mean, that's, that, they may not be on the right handle. - The leaders are, I mean, I don't know about them. - The leaders are on the right handle. - Yes, I'm on the right handle. - I'm talking about the ranking fire. - The left is behind things they should be opposed to, but for cult-like reasons. So, why do you say they should be opposed to them? That's not what today's left is. Today's left is fundamentally revolutionary. - I'm saying, if you go back to 2010, the left would have looked at that guy in the roof and said he's evil. The left protested the world trade organization. - Right. - And then in the left, like the Occupy Wall Street types. - Yeah, I mean, that was the Occupy Wall Street. This is early '90s into 2015. We're talking about 25 years of liberal policies that he raced overnight because of Trump. - The, what I would say is, I disagree with that in part. There were still people on the left who thought, we want to protect American jobs, protect the blue collar, worker back in the 1990s and early 2000s. - That's what I'm talking about. - I'm saying, they should oppose the guy in the roof. - But the, the tendencies of the far-left political movement of the country in 1998, 1999, what you'd call woke to the 2000, 2005, were already there. - I'm talking about the Democratic Party. I'm talking about liberals. - No, they, I mean, they were there already. Like the far-left, we look, look, look. - This is not the case. - Bernie Sanders in 2016. - Hold on a second. - That open board is a Coke Brothers proposal. - No, okay, five. But Bernadine Dorn was a part of the weather underground. She's now a North-Western law professor. - She was a aggressive 70 years. - Over the Democratic Party have done so in the last 10 years. - No, no, no. - I point is, when I was at Occupy Wall Street, Everybody.
everybody opposed open borders. Bernie Sanders was our guy and he opposed open borders. Now you've got a business owner exploiting laborers to put money in his pocket and the left is cheering for it. - Well, let me phrase this a different way. Let me come at it a different way. I totally agree with you that the left is supporting open borders and would have been taking a different stance 50 years ago. We might disagree on one of the timeline. - 10 years ago? - I wouldn't agree with 10 years ago. - Well, I gotta say it again. Bernie Sanders, I'm not saying there wasn't a guy on the left who would do it. - He was the candidate for the left. - One candidate, let me finish this point though. - Let me finish this point, which is that the thing that controls the left's movement today and 20 years ago is not policy like how do we raise the minimum wage? How do we help the blue collar guy? That hasn't been true for 25 years, even if Bernie Sanders, who was an octogenarian then, was saying those things. And now he's of course flipped his turn. It was something else. They were motivated and this is to your cold point. They're motivated by something very different than argumentation and effective reasoning or by bettering the material standards of the Americans. They're motivated by a psychological desire to, as Batman would say, watch the world burn, okay? That's what it comes down to. If you can't contribute to productive society, then it has to be. - You are referring to a faction that just came into power. That 10 years ago was not. - Well, I mean, you think they weren't in power in the 1960s? I mean, the country that burned, the people that burned down the country and the Vietnam War were largely on the left. Yes, they were. - The activism power to your point. - Lyndon Johnson's great society program was one of the direct contributors to this. - Lyndon Johnson wasn't burning buildings. - The president himself, neither was Bernie Sanders, but very clear in the United States. - Indeed, that's my point. Bernie Sanders opposed open borders. - Well, if I sit down. - Maybe we're talking past one another. I don't disagree that Bernie Sanders is a small model. - What I am saying is. - What I'm saying is that the corpus of ideas that leads to today's modern left, the one that wants to exist. - There's a small faction outside of mainstream politics and has slowly taken over. - It existed in 1960s America and the great society product. - Sure did. - And it got the president of the United States elected if you think Lyndon Johnson was elected the first time around. But my point is, the president of the United States, who was a Texas Democrat, by the way, after stealing the Senate seat as Robert Kerra well documented, but Lyndon Johnson. - What percentage of the country at that time was going to church on the weekends? - I don't know the answer to that question. - It's like most. - It's substantially more, but we're still talking tens of millions of Americans who bought, I mean, these were the blue-- - So again, yes, I agree with talking past each other, because what I'm saying is the Democratic Party opposed these things 10 years ago. Trump came in and anything Trump is further against. Trump entered as a moderate, so they decided to go the extreme other direction. - If you're saying that Trump, Trump or engagement syndrome is real, I agree. - Yeah. - And what I'm saying is the left wanted Bernie Sanders as their candidate who explicitly said, open borders a Koch brother's proposal. And many people who wanted Bernie, myself included, abandoned the Democratic Party because they put in Hillary Clinton instead. They cheated. - The people who run the Democratic party, yes, the big business Republicans, if you were to use the political divide of the 1990s, you would say that liberal activists had, you know, politics make strange bedfellows. Big business Republicans were alive with liberal activists, right? They both wanted, you know, certain things that made themselves political bedfellows. Today, that's very different. My point is that in the 1950s and 1960s, you could go back even earlier than this. The body of ideas saw protecting the little guy, the blue collar worker as an instrumental technique. It was not something they believed in. It was an instrumental technique to help overthrow the American order. And this is the fruits of that. The current small faction bubbled up and took over in the last 10 years. - Well, I'm just disagreeing on the time, but I agree with the principle. Yeah, the point at which the curve became visible to most Americans was in the last 10 years. - So many of us were commenting on it 25 years ago. I mean, I was having the same discussions in 2000. Like, the left wasn't wrong because their marginal tax rates were too high or because their, you know, the fractional reserve banking system was out of control. Those were also true. The Republicans were partly to blame for that. But they were crazy because they envisioned a totalitarian penopticon. When I was arguing against the left in 2000, I was using that terminology. This is a cult. I was using that terminology. I used the phrase anti-human death cult at least 10 years ago in writing and probably longer than that. 20 years ago. - It's always been now. - Yeah, that's my point. The nature of leftism is fundamentally a psychological issue. Now, the average voter to your point who votes democratic is think in the 1950s, 1960s, even the 1970s and 1980s, is seeing an opportunity to better their material standards. They see the plutocrats at the top. They think they're being exploited. They saw opening China with Nixon was bad for them. You know, that we didn't bring about a liberal Republican democracy over there. That totally failed. They're right about all those things. But that is not the corpus of thought leaders at the center of the Democratic Party. It never has been just like it wasn't with Lenin and Trotsky 120 years ago. - Who was it doing with Lenin and Trotsky? - It was Lenin and Trotsky. That's what I'm saying. They're the idea. But, you know, it wasn't like most Russians were on board with the Trotsky idea of the communist revolution. - Yeah, nobody knew, in fact. - There was something like what, 20,000 Bolsheviks in 1918. And by the end of the year, there were 3,000. - The word "menchavik" means majority. Bolshevik means minority. - And the other way around, excuse me. That's a good example of manipulating language to affect the public's perception of politics. - But what people need to understand is that I believe there was what? What was it, was it 100 million Russians in 1918? Was it, I don't know the answer to that question. - Maybe not, maybe 60. Let's get the hard number. - At the most, we died. - TJ, it seems to me that the distinction between leftists who want to support the little guy. - 150 million. - And leftists who want to tear down institutions is a bit of an artificial distinction. - Yeah. - I think they go hand in hand. - Yeah, that's what I want to make. - And I think that there's different people who pursue, you know, different groups of policies and maybe have different motivations. I think it all comes from the same place. I think it's just, just to wrap that point up real quick. Sorry, 150 million Russians in 1918 and about 250,000 Bolsheviks instituted 70 years of a death cult. - Yep, yep, yep. - I mean, in the end of 1918, it was about 20,000. And then rapidly throughout the year, they generated about up to 300,000. And then, because they had 300,000, they went and killed Tsar Nicholas, took over and then destroyed the government. - And the reason that you thought that there were fewer Russians then is because you would imagine, like, most nations, it had grown. - Right, but it has not. - Oh, because they killed everybody. - Yeah, they, not 250 million Russians, but 250 million people died from communism. - There's less people today in Russia than there was in 1918. - Well, they're same with Japan, bro. - And they're going to be fair, it's worth, or two. - There can't be too many nations who can make that claim. - Yeah. - Yeah. - China. - Yeah. - I mean, China's got a lot of people, but they killed a lot of people, yeah. - No, no, China has many more people than they did a hundred years ago. - Yeah. - And they're killing a lot of people too. So, you know. - I mean, so what are we talking about here? We're talking about this because, as I said, the West is deep in crisis. And it's a strange thing to say that ideas matter so much, but the ideas as Richard Weaver said, ideas have consequences. And the fact is, at some point, the software that's loaded in some person's head is so wildly different than the software that's loaded in another person's head that they have irreconcilable differences. They disagree on first principles. The problem that the United States of America faces right now is that those people are our countrymen. So, we don't know what to do about that. They know what they want to do about it. They want to kill you. That's what they did with Charlie Kirk. - I don't think they do. - No, I think a lot of they do. - I disagree. - I think not every ordinary left-wing voting Democrat wants to, but a lot of them do. And they want you gone. And their thought leaders definitely want you. - I think that they want the institutions gone because they see the world differently. - No, they want to kill people. That's very, very generous. - Very, very, very justified violence against you, depending on what you are in particular. - I don't think you can back that up. - Well, the tens of billions of dollars following the Floyd riots were not caused by rightists. The tens of points from half an hour ago, you'd be hard pressed in the last 60 years to identify a right-wing riot. I mean, I don't think you can name one other than January 6th. And that's like $38 a day. - No, but you aren't changing. - Everyone always says when you go from most leftists want to kill you. - No, but no, I'm just saying. - And I'm giving you room for a-- - No, no, I would have been against it. - That's a fair point. But I would say they do want to kill you, yes. - Well, here's the way I would say it. In America, if you break the population into three groups, and we were talking about this beforehand, 80% of the people are just concerned about their daily lives, right? They've got to pay their mortgage, mow their lawn, raise their kids. And when politics comes around, they think about it only because they want to identify what's in their interests and what's in their community's interests and into a lesser degree, what's in the national interest. - And the other 20 vote left. - Right, but the other 20% are split in two factions. And both of those factions are fighting with one another to control the minds of the 80%. One faction is saying we're going to use argumentation and effective reasoning. That's the right. They've been-- these are not hard and fast rules. There are exceptions, of course, but that's not relevant. They have lost in the last 60 years, even though they have won all the policy arguments. Their arguments are connected, their premises are connected to their conclusions by logical reasoning. The other side is not doing any of that. Sometimes they mimic the language of argumentation and effective reasoning. But they are totally dominating the culture world. - Let's use a break. - This is a real example. - Let's use a real example. Twitter in 2016, they implemented a rule sometime around here that said, "If you misgender somebody, they will ban you." Now, I ended up having a conversation with the executives of Twitter over this rule where I called them biased. They argued they were not. And I said, "If you ask someone what it means to misgender, "a liberal will tell you if a trans person says it's she her "and you use he him, you're misgendering." A conservative would tell you, if a person is male and you say her, you've misgendered. You've opted to ban half the country. That is a bias. That leads us to one big question. Why did Twitter decide that if you are on the other side of their moral worldview, they will strip your ability to speak? It's actually quite simple. It's a question, it's an analogy I love to state. Would Carl Benjamin or Dave Rubin ever lead a violent riotous mob with baseball bats and crowbars and guns to Twitter HQ? No, of course not. Would Antifa in the far left? Yes.
- Yes. - In fact, they do this all the time, but to be fair, you're an executive at Twitter, and you are staring at the screen, and you're sweating because people are screaming, you go, "The guys on the right "will never lift a finger," but the guys on the left are threatening to murder me. - Look at your ad rate up here. This, or you don't have it up there now, but the point is the sponsors did withdraw. That is to bring the white pill back just a little bit, 'cause I tend to agree with you. I'm only pointing out that just now, whether it's Jeff Clark's organization or pulling sponsors, we are realizing how to do the asymmetric warfare. Sponsors pulling their advertising money is something to do. - And the problem now that needs to be understood is while this is a good sign, we should remain optimistic. It needs to be stated that following the midterm elections, many big tech companies are not gonna be split again, and they're gonna ask themselves, "Who is going to kill me and my family?" That being said, Stephen Miller was just made chief of staff, they may still fear Todd Blanche and Donald Trump. So now what's going to happen as the big tech companies pulled back from censorship recently, they may take their foot off the gas and just say, "We're gonna try and do nothing because if Trump, "if the right loses in 2028, we're dead." - They're hedging their bets. - So they're gonna have to back off. When Trump won 24, all the big tech companies took their thumb off the censorship scale. We saw it, we saw it with Elon buying X. Nick Fighters is back, Alex Jones was permitted to certain platforms, still largely banned, but a lot of people got their accounts back. These big tech companies saw the writing on the wall. This right is, I'll put it like this. In order for the right to win, they need a 67%. In order for the left to win, they need 40%. Right now, the right with this, we are seeing the right has 70 plus percent of the population on their side as it pertains to Bud Light with Dylan Mulvaney. Shane Gillis didn't like the cancellation, but with this midterm election, everybody woke up and went, "Oh crap, I think the left is bigger and more culturally relevant." And the left certainly believes so. So I'll put it like this, if the election did not happen, or should say the day before the election, nobody had in their mind that Donald Trump was cook that Mago was over. Despite the fact that the election results show us, they are. This means that every Republican who got Trump's endorsement danced around hippie-skippy happy that they got it. And then they all lost. Now this means that going to 28 doesn't matter if the election results fake real or otherwise, the perception is, Trump is toxic, stay away from him. That's going to ripple with advertisers. It's going to ripple with politicians. So come 27, 28, when people are starting to run for office, they're going to say, "I hate Trump." I never supported the right. Oh, they were terrible. There's also the inverse proposal. The Fuente's proposal. Many of the young men, we saw about a 20% bump in young men voting in the selection, which is nuts. And I do believe not that Fuente's, Nick Fuente's, make that happen, but that Nick Fuente's is the avatar of the Gen Z anger that exists there and why they're voting. So follow what Nick is saying, not, I'm not suggesting, I'm not condemning nor condoning, I'm saying, the people who follow are politically active and listening to what he has to say. They voted Democrat. They helped that blue wave is entirely possible that what we see now with Trump bringing Steven Miller is that Trump starts to believe maybe I should have gone harder and these young men would have voted for me instead. The question, everyone's going to ask themselves, did Trump lose the midterms because he went too far or he didn't go far enough? Because many Trump supporters are saying he didn't arrest enough people. Depends on the context, because he definitely went too far when it comes to the mourner end, right, like that did, that if that didn't happen, then I lied. I got, I got, I got to disagree. I think he's right. I remember when it was 15 days, I remember when the war was supposed to last two weeks. The context matters to him. If Trump reasoned the Republican Party lost is because Donald Trump made so many bad decisions. As it pertains to the Iran war, my argument stands, Donald Trump either didn't go hard enough or went too hard. And it is, the question is, should he have put boots on the ground and nuked it and ended that war in 45 minutes? If Trump nuked it, you would have had six months of clear, of clear no war before the midterms, who knows what would have happened. I'm not suggesting he should have, and I don't think the war was good. And I think it's evidenced by the election. My point is there are people, there are neocons arguing, Trump didn't do the job. That's why they're rejecting him. The, the, the, that's wrong. The idea that you could, the idea that you could solve Iran in two weeks or a month, that is a farce. There is no way that, that even that, he was riding high on the Nicholas Maduro kid. Yeah, and even that, even a nuclear bomb doesn't solve Iran and the people that don't want war would have lost their minds if he'd, if he'd have dropped a nuke. All right, I was in terms of, no, there's no arguing the merits of a ground invasion nuclear bomb are immaterial to the argument that some people say Trump went too far and some say he did not go far enough. They are certainly neocons arguing that Trump's half-measures, as this is a fact, literally the neocons, Mark Levin, Trump's negotiation attempts, the terrorist regime failed. And if he just went in and did the job, he would have won. But he's making the argument. He's making the argument. I don't, I don't, I am not arguing the merits of the war. I am arguing the political atmosphere and the people's arguments on the ground. The point of the point that we're debating is what would have changed the results in the midterms and he didn't lose the neocons. And that's immaterial to what I'm saying. I agree, I don't think the war was a good idea. I don't think he could have solved the problem. We're in agreement. My point is, there are neocons in media saying he didn't go hard enough. There are libertarians saying he went too hard. There are groipers saying he went too hard, but he didn't go hard enough domestically. The question people need to ask right now, what we are looking at for the Republican Party is they're going to try and, they're going to try and parse through whether they went, they went too far or not far enough. And the, and the Mark Levin faction of the Republican Party, which exists, are going to suggest Trump didn't go far enough. And the groipers are going to say he went too far and the libertarians he went too far. - I think it really depends on your ideology because if you're a groiper you probably think he didn't go too far in the immigration stuff, but if you look at the, I hope people actually voted, like he lost the Hispanic block that he won over. And there's a few different things too. Like a lot of pro-life people thinks he was way too pro-choice, the immigration. - Yeah, I, no, you can't. You can't finish your point, I just want to. - No, that's, there's like a few things that were really dividing, I think, his coalition. - A lot of them. - You could read into whatever you want, but one more thing. He was elected president and the president, the party in power usually loses the midterms regardless. - Yeah, but this is, this was a big loss. But I think there is something to say too about like, people reading what they want into this loss. You could blame it on the Epstein files, you could blame it on the Iran war. You could say ice has been too aggressive and he had to fire Chrissy Nome and they looked really bad. You could say that the party in power always loses in the midterms. So it's really like pick your poison. - I actually want to try to do something. - But I think it's, it's not one or the other, right? To reach 30% approval rating, that's an achievement. You have to piss off a lot of different types of people. It's not just, with all due respect, it's not just a matter of, did he go too hard? Did he not go hard enough? No, you have to, you have to get tariffs wrong. You have to get the war wrong. You have to get ice wrong. You have to get the Epstein files wrong. You have to do a lot of work to reach 30. Scrooing up one or two of those things when too hard didn't go hard enough. That's what I thought. - Now think about that for 30. You've got to piss off this group, this group. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I'll think about that. How do you piss off everybody? Because certainly one thing, someone likes one thing, someone doesn't like, right? - Economy. - So, so yes, Donald Trump's approval rating tracked one for one with gas prices. - Yeah. - You could look at the chart and look at the inverse gas prices for his approval rating. But I will stress this. The reason why Congress has a low approval rating is not because people don't like Congress. It's because Congress has a collective body can't do anything. But when you look at the polling for individual members of Congress, they poll very high. Donald Trump, they're pissing everybody off, means he did, means there's an interesting spattering of, he didn't go far enough and he went too far. For instance, how do you piss off the immigration diehards and the anti-immigration people? The anti-immigration people are mad because Trump wasn't doing mass deportations. And the pro-immigration people were mad that he was too harsh on the ones he did do. - And the real? - The question is, did he go hard enough or not hard enough? - You've got these issues like legal and illegal immigration. You've got a fiscal debt that's approaching $40 trillion. And you've got other issues that, like those two are existential. The problem is, all of them face exactly the same problem, which is there is no way to solve them that commands the majority of the country. And yet, you solve them with a good economy and with gas prices. - Well, hold on. - This is, but you don't solve. - You don't, you don't, you don't, hold on. Just let me get this out. All the stuff that we're talking about are all narrow issues that are, that there are some people that feel very strongly about. None of these narrow issues become, - Well, it's like a deal. - There was people feel like there was one, and they said exactly what you've got in there. - And they got in there. - And it was Bill Clinton who said it's the economy stupid. - I'm talking about Jim Carter. - Jim Carter. - I'm talking about Bill Clinton. - Yes, that's true. - My point is though, that that worked in 1990. If the point that you're making is that all things governance-wise are easier when everybody is wealthy, then yes, I agree. But if the point is you wish to preserve the Western civilization and the American identity, then it's simply intractable. - And I have to agree, when we look at Gen Z men voting in an outsized proportion, like it's a, so you see a bell curve. The young votes low, that 40 year olds are high, and boomers go low. We see a spike from 18 to 24, and then it goes down and then up. This younger generation is hyperpolitically active, and it's not 100% because of gas prices. It is about the West and America, which does tie to their economic standing. But I want to make one point that I was trying to make before, as it pertains to kneeocons, because people
people base their world view on a view count publicly displayed, they do not understand what is happening around them. Many people go online and they see a post of millions of views and they assume that must be popular opinion. Well, I'm going to let all of you know right now Ben Shapiro does about a million per episode on his audio podcast. People look at his YouTube channel and they say, "Wow, Ben Shapiro's views are gone. This anti-Iran pro war guy is like losing and nobody likes him. You get Tucker Carlson, he's through the roof." And then when you actually see Ben Shapiro's numbers which are published by The New York Times, you go, "How the-- does he do 7 million podcast downloads per week? That's massive." Ben Shapiro's world view may not persist on YouTube for whatever reason, but the dude is printing on the Spotify apple side of things. For whatever reason, whoever's listening to that. So do not discount the Neo conservative vote and those who wanted Trump to blow Iran to smithereens of the nuclear bomb or whatever. Well, I think a lot of people agree, even if you don't agree with going to war with Iran, that Iran should not have nuclear weapons. And I think that was a lot. No, I don't care. Well, that was a point I think the president was trying to focus on and asked if he would do it again. No. I think that's right. I think it's easy to say. Let me just add one point to this, which is, nobody said this recently, which is this, it is conceivable that he has succeeded and the consequence was you lost the midterm status graphically, but, but it could be worth it, it could be worth it and history will write that verdict, not us. You know, I don't believe for a second that what he did was about nuclear bombs. I just do not. Then what was it about? Petro dollar. You do not see an administration spend its entire existence, securing oil around the world and then have one off in the corner nuclear program, especially when Iran is threatening the petro dollar. So strongly destabilize in the region and the deal for the United States as it pertains to Saudi Arabia and other countries to the petro dollars that we are the world police. And we will shut down international terrorism to ensure your country can trade in exchange you buy oil through our system. Iran has violated that for generations and they were they were funding the militia groups with the rebels. They were bombing the Red Sea Saudi Arabia as a great shout out to our Tim Kess members who first pointed out, so I agree, go likely goes to Trump and says, we can't ship anything out of Hormuz or the Red Sea because of Iran. If you want a petro dollar deal to be re-opt because it's expired, you're going to go and blow up the smithereens. That's why Donald Trump resettled oil in the Gulf. That's why he secured Panama. That's why he took Venezuela. That's why he cut off Cuba. That's why he wants Greenland. That's why he wants the Northwest Passage. I do not think that when you look at the entire picture, this gigantic jigsaw puzzle, looking at a unicorn with one piece missing and you go, that piece missing is probably a nuclear bomb. I'd be like, no, it's probably oil. That's why Israel and Trump has said it. I mean, oil. Israel obviously made it Iran because Iran's funding of Hamas and rebel groups threatens Israel. Israel then wants to go to attack. The U.S. is an ally to Israel, so like Marco Rubio said, Israel was going to go in. That was going to lead us. Iran was going to target us in response, so we weren't going in with them. I think it's fair to say the U.S. was pressured to start this war because Israel wanted to go in. I think Israel's interests are obvious. And I think Donald Trump's interests are obvious when you look at the big picture of everything he did. And I think the nuclear weapon thing is a lie because you can't go to the American people and say, we want to be the world police and want to secure an international trade by which we blow people up around the world so that we have more money than everyone else. They're going to go not interested in that. I agree with you. And I think that we've had a whole lot of discussion here that maybe wasn't meant to let President Trump off the hook, but in effect does. Well, the way that he went into the war was poorly thought out, poorly negotiated, poorly strategized. And at the end of the day, poorly executed. It was an abject, complete, unregated failure. I agree. I don't understand why they didn't just sign right now. And he said, in the beginning, he gave us three or four different reasons. He finally settled on the prevent them from having nuclear weapons, right? Now he says it's irrelevant because they can't get a nuclear weapon and that's why he's not going to bomb them more. That's what he said. And that's like his way of claiming victory and trying to like not get into a problem. That's right. But it's demonstrable evidence that he was lying to us. I don't understand. Say that again. He says the other day. He says a couple of days ago, they can't get a nuclear weapon. So maybe I won't bomb them anymore. That was the reason why we launched the second phase of the war according to him. So that they wouldn't be able to get nuclear weapons. Right. Yeah. So that's what's going on here, which he said is where they move into the nuclear program. The whole thing is a complete disaster. And that's just one aspect of what's been going on. I don't disagree with you, but it's not because he needs to finish the job is what I think it comes down to. Why? He says he doesn't. Why? Because if he doesn't finish the job, then a wounded regime in Iran would try to rush to a bomb as their next logical step. If you're the leader of your country, what does finish the job? What's unfinished about it? They have to declare that they won't try to get nuclear weapons. Or we need to install a new regime that will say that they won't get nuclear weapons. We, the United States of America. So we should be monitoring the situation and going and bomb them when they start to develop a nuclear warhead. As they have been, as they already have nuclear facilities, they've already been deboming them for no good reason today. Well, the enrichment is why we've been bombing them in their missile, but Trump just told you that he knows there's a lot of different things. So when you try to string, I don't care. Let them have a nuclear weapon. Why should I care? Why? Because of Saudi Arabia, Americans and the funded terrorists proxies that have killed American troops. If Iran wants to launch a nuclear weapon, we'll nuke them. Right? Yeah, but that's way too far. That's very bad. I don't know if you can let him. Where it's like, you care about to have us. Listen, listen, I feel like to the American people, the reason why this, I do not believe the war is the principle reason why Trump laws. I think it's a factor. I think the ancillary effects, gas and diesel, diesel shortages. And to the people who pay attention to this, no one, no one believes it's about a nuclear weapon. And I'm sick of the lies from the Neocon punits being like, they're going to get a nuke. Shut up. No, they're not. There's a funny meme that shows Papyrus paper from ancient Egypt that says Iran is 30 days away from a nuclear weapon. Like just spare me. Dude, tell me it's about oil. And I'll go, oh, I guess. What do you make of? They're nuclear facilities enriching uranium. I don't care if they're trying to do it. Okay. No, no, no, listen. Yes, they're probably trying to have a nuke. But the justification that we have to go in is a preemptive war against the people for enrichment. No, I can't. The next step is Saudi Arabia said they would develop nuclear weapons. That's my opinion. Iran does. So then what? Saudi Arabia is going to get nuclear weapons. Then nuclear weapons will proliferate throughout all the Middle East and a bunch of radical Muslim countries will have nuclear weapons. Yep. I don't like the idea of that. Yep. And maybe that makes me islamophobic. But I don't think a bunch of radical Muslim countries should have nuclear weapons. It was a dumbest thing to allow Pakistan to get that far. And with the more countries that gain these nuclear weapons, a war will break out eventually between us and these countries. And now they will have nukes and that will be a huge problem. I agree. So the question that says that to America, the current regime was founded on anti-Americanism of taking over our embassy in Iran and holding them hostage. And I think you know, people are willing to overlook it because we don't, we either forget about the history or it was too long ago to care. But I just don't, I don't believe that people can argue for mutually assured destruction except. See, I don't think mutually assured destruction is all encompassing. I've made this argument as it contains to Russia. If Russia needs to, they'll use tactical bombs. Strategic bombs, maybe not. But tactical bombs. You don't think Iran would? Iran absolutely would. I think they'd use a dirty bomb. I think they would use a tactical bomb. I agree with you 100 percent. We cannot allow Tehran to control a nuclear weapon. Okay. But then how do we prevent them from getting a nuclear weapon? You do what he did the first time, what President Trump did at the first time. You bomb, you create pickaxe mountain, right? Okay. We have no weapon. Were you happy with the original bomb? Hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. We have no weapons that can take out pickaxe mountain. We don't need a weapon to take out pickaxe mountain. How do you do it then? We can't do, hold on, hold on, hold on. How do you stop nuclear enrichment under, under a mountain we cannot destroy. I mean, we can blow it up with a nuke. We can murve it. That'd be insane. Right. But you can, you can shut it down effectively. How? Yeah, you bury the entrances in the exits with, yeah, this is, this is the inherent problem right now that even Trump has discussed. We don't know how to do that. I don't think it is a complex underground. I don't think we could do it militarily. I think we absolutely could do it militarily. We'd end up playing guacamole and I think the technology for, we don't want to have to bomb Iran every six months when they open up a new nuclear facility. But it's not six months, it's every six years and I'm okay with bombing them every six years. And that's, yeah, no, that sounds like, what is it forever war? That truly sounds like a river war. You need to do it fast and get rid of the regime and install a regime that agrees not to get rid of the Iranian revolution, I know it's dirty word, but we need to get rid of the current. I know. No, no, no, no. The regime is not 90 million people. No, stop. There are 90 million Iranians. I did not say that. It is a country of 90 million people. It is not Iraq and Afghanistan. You are not bombing that country out of its politics. It's not possible. Not going to happen. I think we could regime. Not through air strikes. Not in a reasonable cost. And with 90 million people, you're talking like World War II levels of death. The only thing that the American people like less or dislike as much as gas over $4 a gallon is American coffins coming home. Yeah. Well, I think the issue here is here. We're stuck between Iraq and a hard place. It's, we agree that, well, Tim doesn't that they shouldn't be getting a nuclear weapon. But what's the way to actually stop that? If they don't want to stop that, then we have to do it with the-- We're doing it regularly with President Trump.
No, Tim thinks he's lying. Tim probably read about that. (laughing) According to President Trump, he's already accomplished this. No, but he obviously didn't, because then he would have just said victory and were done. Which is what he's saying today. What he said yesterday. I don't think he truly believes that. I think he's just saying that. Right, he's lying. He's lying. He's lying because he needs the out to be able to get out of the war without accomplishing all of his goals. I'm gonna say that. There are military ways to prevent them from getting a nuclear war ahead. I disagree. I'm changing the regime or by just playing guacamole. Yes, guacamole. I'll make a word term, not mine. I mean, that's a term, not mine. You're mowing the grass to use the Israeli terms, but that's a very different concept. It's essentially what you'd be doing. The reason that we're talking about Iran not getting a nuclear weapon is because we think that there's an us end of them. But when we talk about an us, we're talking about something that we wish to share with our countrymen, some body of ideas. And I think the set Iran aside, the problem is the nation is bankrupt. It's bankrupt morally. It's bankrupt fiscally. It has a debt that it cannot sustain. It has an entitlement mentality that it cannot sustain. It's fighting amongst itself. And the reality is, we simply cannot afford whether we have the money to do so or the ships, you know, the surface level ships to do so or not as beside the point. What are we fighting for? Why is it that we want to prevent Iran from having nuclear weapons? Because we're in the global oil. In a whole spot. But that's begging the question, what is it that we are preserving? And that is the question. I'm sure. That's an American agenda. Hold on, again, that's begging the question. We're not just, we're not here in America just because we all agree that we want to get rich. There's some body of ideas. This incident-- Be rich in prosperity. Hold on, that's not begging the question at all. No, no, if you say that the reason we want to win is because we want to win, then unless you're saying that the reason we want to win is because we want to get rich. Okay, so that's what we're saying. What we're saying is actually quite clear. Iran is outside the petrodollar system and will not agree to our terms. But why do we wish to preserve the petrodollar system? The United, because it makes us rich for nothing. Okay, so what I'm saying is that-- People are wealthy without manufacturing. And we are the world police in exchange. What a listen. Hold on, the context that we're in, right? The talk that we had already tonight is that we have really polarized politics. We have economic problems. We're not trying to get rich. We're trying to prevent Americans from getting very poor. And that's when revolution-- So let me agree with that point, but I think it's part of a larger point, which is that there's something here that's worth preserving. How is it that five of us can sit in a room? I've never met you, gentlemen, before. And we can have a shared body of cultural knowledge that we can just presuppose that the other people have. That's what it means to be an American. And that is the thing, or any nationality, of different cultures elsewhere. Our particular culture has-- we could draw parameters around it. We could say, this is what it means to be an American. And most Americans share these views. The problem is that is under assault. That's the things that you're trying to protect. That's the thing that's at issue or at stake when you're saying, can Iran have or have not a bomb? And the point that I'm making right now is discussing whether or not we can go to Iran sounds like an episode of the McNeil Leher news hour from 1994. It's simply not germane to the crisis that we face. This is an-- we are in an existential crisis. It is. Our own countrymen do not agree that the United States that you know should continue to exist. OK, so we need to solve that problem. So we need to solve that problem. And now I will lay out the big picture for you. The American people in 2024 said the first-- the number one issue was the economy. The second was immigration. Outraged over Joe Biden's immigration policies, they elected a Republican trifecta. To be fair, the Supreme Court was already there, but they brought in the House and the Senate and the presidency. Donald Trump said, your wishes, my command, and began deporting people. He didn't even deport that money. And instantly there was a backlash. Guy in the roof comes out and says, whoa, he deported my day laborers. What everybody was mad about, they didn't want to face the truth. I've given this point on this show. And I'll say it again for those that didn't hear it. And for you, we sell American made skateboards. American skateboard factors are going out of business. They're going to China. They've been going to China for 20 years. The skateboard industry is in collapse. The pros are not working for DoorDash. We told the people who watched this show, we only make our boards in America. There is a notification saying there will be delays because of this. And we got a decent percentage of our people demanding refunds because it took too long. Tim, you're exactly right. And I think at this point, we now need to say to Americans, if you wish to preserve the identity of what it means to be an American, then you're going to have to sacrifice. And so in the reality is, that means that actual human beings in the United States, American citizens are going to be have to say-- So I'll finish the point that I was making. OK, go ahead. That the reason, at least one of the presumed reasons, Donald Trump goes to war with Iran and nuclear weapons is a far since laughable, is that the petro dollar has expired. Saudi Arabia is off the deal and threatening to go cut deals with China and Russia instead. All of a sudden, we find ourselves shoring up the Gulf of America, renaming it the Gulf of America, taking out Venezuela, getting back our oil assets. Isolating Cuba, pacifying the entire Caribbean, renegotiating Panama and the Northwest Passage. It looks like Trump is setting contingencies for when the petro dollar falls. Because when it falls, the economy is going to fall 10x. So if you thought it was bad enough, that what we're dealing with is war and high gas prices, what happens to this country, regardless of your shared moral foundation, when gas goes to $15. Well, no, wait, hold on a second. I would flip that exactly around and say, we can predict what will happen to the country based upon the scope of the shared moral foundation. If we have a shared cultural consensus, then we will survive and we will succeed and rebuild. If your dystopian future comes to fruition. But if it does, enough shared moral foundation for 100 years. Well, I wouldn't say 100. I would say since the great society really began eroding, but we're nitpicking the time again. My point is exactly the same, though, which is the situation is dire. If you do not share your first principles with your countrymen, then you do not have a country. And if you are unwilling to do the hard things to preserve your country, like removing immigrants who don't belong here, then you're not going to preserve your country. And if you're unwilling to do simple things like deport people or cut your social security by 15%. So then there's no reason to go to Iran. You're not willing to do the easy things than you shouldn't be doing the hard things. Let's put it like this. You're in your house and your family is sick. And you're saying we all have shared values, but sooner or later, we'll all be vomiting and we're going to die. It doesn't matter what we believe or like, we're in trouble. Yes, we could be healthy in the future. Yes, we shouldn't defeat the junk food in the past, but right now we're in this predicament. If we do nothing, we die. I believe that Trump and his people are like, okay, well, if we don't re-re-up the petro dollar, we die no matter what happens, because you're correct. We do not have a shared moral foundation. I agree. Let me steal the antibiotics from our neighbor and bring it over. We will be cured and we can then start working towards exactly what you want. You know, for what it's worth, the point that you're making is largely an Austrian economics point. If your point is that once you are hooked on fiat currency, you can't just quit cold turkey than yes, I agree. That's a long-term problem. I argue with you. No, I agree with you. You're not going to get off. You're not going to get a shared moral foundation. Yes. And if the economy collapses, the country is done. Of course, of course, but there's other things that could are heading in the wrong direction anyway. And here, let me tie this to the Floyd riots quickly. The reason that the prosecution of Derek Chauvin is relevant is because it is built on and connected to a lie. When the trial of Derek Chauvin started, Al Sharpton said, on the courthouse steps in a national press conference, Derek Chauvin might be in the courtroom, but America is on trial. Why did he say that? He said it because there was a political movement, Black Lives Matter, defund the police, critical race theory, and all the rest that was existing in the periphery of mainstream American discourse. And it used the prosecution and conviction of an innocent man to catapult itself into the mainstream. And all of that is a body of lies. It's like a universal solvent that breaks apart the moral cohesiveness of the society. So you are correct. We lack a moral cohesive society. We lack shared first principles. What do we do to rebuild that? We start telling the truth about obvious big symbolic lies. Like, for example, like what? Methadone. Yeah, well, what does methadone have to do? Methadone is telling the truth about big symbolic issues. The prosecution of an innocent man or four innocent men. Thomas Lane, Alexander Cung, Two-Town and Derek Shovon. That is a lie. And it is a good lie for our purposes, because it is a symbolic one that we can tell the truth about. And if you can get more American-- Hold on, let me finish with a horse. Let me finish my point here. I'm very close, which is if you can get Americans to start speaking the truth about symbolically large issues, then they will begin to speak the truth about other issues that don't have symbolic significance. And you will be removed out of office right in two years. In two years. And in two years, but this is a generational fight, winning the cultural war of the 40-year battle. So if every two years, the economy must be strong for you to win that battle, what do you do? Well, listen to me. Listen, here's the point I would make. Every single father who has-- every single man who decides to have children with a woman is making a decision to make himself worse off today. And yet, we have 100 million years of homo sapiens and 10,000 years of civilization. I completely disagree with you. A father's deciding they're going to sacrifice their financial well-being today to make the future better. The conservative movement in America is about not discounting the future. It's about incurring pain today to make the future better. That is, I object to that in the strongest of terms, sir. It's part of a due object to the fact that parents sacrifice their children. No man's life is burdened by having children. I said materially worse off. No, it's not. Yes, it is, of course it is. Absolutely. I reject that premise outright. The bobbin meme that-- Look at social security. When parents separated from their children and relied on the state for their well-being. So if your argument is-- My argument is that if you wish to make the future better, you're going to have to sacrifice today. You're going to have to spend money to build a house. This shouldn't be controversial. If you want to make the future better, you sacrifice today. That's the nature of all economics. It's premise on that initial axiom. I will walk back halfway and say, I understand your point. But it is materially beneficial
to have children to argue to some-- - No, of course, yeah, because the future symbol is what I have to adopt. - And that's what I have to adopt. - Every young man should be told, the most important investment you can make for your betterment is having-- - Of course, I totally agree with you, but listen to the point that I'm making. If I have $100,000 right now, I could say, I'm going to spend this on hookers and cocaine. That is immediate appetite gratification. Or I could say, I'm gonna put it in the bank, put it in a $5.29, I'm gonna buy a small house, I'm gonna raise three kids, and 20 years from now, the kids are gonna be fantastic. I'm gonna have had a wonderful experience. The money's gonna be gone. It's gonna be converted from hookers and cocaine into the future productive citizens of America who share a universal ethos. That is a sacrifice that-- - That's a lot, a sacrifice. - Okay, I think we're talking past one other. I'm more-- - I don't know if that's a financial sacrifice. - I think the semantics matter on this regard. - No, but my point is limited to it's a financial sacrifice. It's a financial sacrifice. - When you really young man and say, "sacrifice," they say, "I have nothing to give." - No, no, when you say-- - But they do, they do, though. - We spend. - Yeah, I agree with you that, of course, having kids is huge, is a huge cycle. - Okay, but let me clarify. - We're talking about money today. - And I wanna clarify, what people need to understand financially, when you buy a physical object, you are not losing your money. The value is retained in your purchase. - No, no, that's for certain investment assets, but most of the things we purchase are consumables. The hookers and the cocaine are used up immediately. Their appreciation is 100% right now. - Ultra relates extremely important to tell young men that everything you buy for your child is not lost in value, or to my totally agree with you. Let me, there seems to be some confusion here. - Yes, because I wholeheartedly agree that investing in your children is good for everybody. - I'm clarifying, so let me just, I understand what you're saying. - Okay. - The argument I'm making is semantic. Young men must hear that when they spend money on having a family that is not a sacrifice, that is not even an investment. - I disagree with you. - The value is retained completely. - Okay, I'm not sure if we're like measuring this in an accounting sense, of course the value is, men are looking for a purpose, and a purpose requires that meaning be connected to sacrifice in a way that is achievable, even if difficult. Men want to lift heavy objects, figuratively and literally, and they want to raise families, and they want to be provided an opportunity to do that. And we should give it to them. The point that I'm making is that a very narrow point, which is all of us, men and women, boomers, Gen Zers are all going to have to make financial sacrifices in terms of how much social security we get, Medicare, Medicaid, what we want to do internationally with our military, et cetera, if we wish to have a fighting chance to re-unify. - There is not a single hooker, crack, or a mount of hookers that will ever bring you the kind of, or actually having a family. - I totally agree with you, and yet there are a lot of hair on that. - So those sacrifice, the problem is, and I'm gonna make the point, when you say to the world, young man, sacrifice for someone else, and they go, "Whoa, I'll rather do the hookers." I am telling you, hookers are nowhere near as emotionally satisfying and gratifying as your child saying, "Daddy, I love you." - I agree with you. - And why tell them they're sacrificing anything? - I'm not sure exactly the point that you're making here. - The point I am making. - I am agreeing with you that. - You're saying it's gonna be a sacrifice. - If I spend a hundred thousand dollars on hookers and blow, instead of my family, I would have to sacrifice from. - No, no, no, no, no. - Because the point is that I have no makers. - I agree with that. The point, and that's not a sacrifice. - All of civilization can be understood on a spectrum, if you want to oversimplify things of whether, or not we're gonna defer gratification or not. Are we going to defer gratification or not? This is built into the interest rate. It's a discount value. It presupposes planning. If you wish to sacrifice today, so that you could have something better in the future, and in like, along the way, then you must make a sacrifice. Now, you've got to give up something today. If you want to have a fishing pole tomorrow to increase your fishing productivity fishing, then you've got to stop doing whatever you're doing right now and build the fishing pole. - The argument is, it doesn't apply to family. - I think I agree with you. I'm not. I think it makes a difference. - I think it's a issue with your use of sacrifice. - Okay, fine. - It sounds like a waste almost. - Okay, so that's a better focus on kids. - That's a simple misunderstanding of the word sacrifice. A sacrifice is the thing that we do all the time when we're willing to. - I am saying you. - The paper here was willing to sacrifice. - You said. - The paper here, after he was able to. - He was willing to sacrifice his oldest son. - We completely agree. - And to let gratification. But the argument you made was that hookers feel better than family. - No, that wasn't the argument that I made. What I said. - I think it was a bad argument. - With all due respect. - But that's why I took a semantic issue with my own framing. - It was just an example of it. - It doesn't apply, and my argument is semantic purely. - Okay, well then we can move on. I think everybody agrees that the family is worth it. - I hope that you want something to agree with. - I forgot exactly how you were phrasing it, the social fabric in our country is starting to diminish and like. - Is that starting to diminish? - Or is it diminished? - It's largely eroded. - What do you think is the solution to help cure or prevent more erosion? - That is an important thing. - The first thing it is, and this is. I'm gonna give you a couple of examples. The first is a very tactical example in a day-to-day life. And next time your friend brings up sports ball after making a political remark that assumes you agree. You have to call them out. You have to say the hard things at the barbecue about whatever the issue happens to be. Immigration or the proper role of men and women or race. Because the truth is your guide, okay? If you're unwilling to speak the truth and you're not gonna preserve the civilization, that's one. On the other end of the spectrum, we have to understand that we must control the media apparatus and all the communication channels that communicate ideas. So what are those? They're online media, like Tim Show, they're print media, they're the university system. I mean, there's the phrase, the long march through the institutions for a reason, which the left has done for 80 years now. They control the university systems and they're indoctrinating your children. So what do we do? We recognize that ideas have consequences and that if we wish to shape the political discourse and preserve the nation and the West in general, then we've gotta change the ideas that are in people's heads. And we're not going to convince old adults to do that, but we can take tactical control of the institutions that shape ideas and expect to win in 25 years. Now, the petrodollar might destroy us in two years. - Well, sacrifice. - It might all be gone. - Universities are starting to go under because-- - Yes. - And they're starting to go under, in part, because they depended on US government shirties for their-- - I don't think it's necessary to jumble up the political aspect and the cultural aspect here. I think-- - Well, I don't think I'm doing that. I'm just saying-- - No, I think I'm just saying, when the battle is over. - I think your table has, you know, we're talking about, well, you gotta win an election. No, you don't. No, you don't have to win an election. In fact, I would argue that President Trump winning his election did not advance Western culture, did not advance conservative economics. - I think TJ would agree with you on that, like, that the-- - Yeah, to some degree. - Well, I'll process Western values. - It absolutely is. And when we make a mistake of believing that winning an election is gonna advance our culture. - Correct, that's not gonna do. - We're violating that principle. - We should send up advancing the culture. It feels like more, almost more than the winners. - When Bernie Sanders lost his impact on the culture and like the far left was immense. And it feels like he really helped-- - Here's a white pill. - All of the best movies. Hollywood is absolutely dominated by the left, as you know. But they accidentally make a right-wing movie every once in a while. And those movies do better than any other movie. And the reason is because they talk about men incurring incredible burdens. And I'm using the word sacrifice. Tim might use it preferred different word. But I think we agree with what I'm getting at there. And those movies resonate with the culture. And we need to make more movies like that. And we need to do the same thing in the universities and core purposes. Gonna give you an example. Lord of the Rings and Batman, like the Dark Knight series. Those movies are fundamentally about good and evil right and wrong, better or worse. Making, paying a price now in order to use the word investment. - Investment. To make an investment by enduring a hardship today. - I don't know the problem with the word sacrifice. - Okay, well, I'm gonna use investment now. - The reason I agree was because you said. - Sacrifice your hookers because family later. - Okay, that's-- - Hookers are better than family. - Okay, that was a bad analogy. - Yeah, I would say so. - That was my only-- - Yeah, yeah, fine, that's fine. - So, the greatest feeling I've had here. - My work here now is fundamentally that we have the truth on our side. We may have slight disagreements about what the best economic policy is, what the best marginal tax rate is. But once we're willing, you ask me what to do. We need to start speaking the truth about the hard issues like George Floyd. That's just one symbolic issue. What actually happened in that case? And if we can start doing that-- - But people do not want to open that pen door. - They don't want to, because they're scared. - Because they're afraid. And because the overtoned window has been set by the people who control the media institutions. - That's left. - Truth is less relevant than power. - No, I told you, I would say it's, they're both relevant. - If you, yeah, power is relevant. - You're not gonna speak truth. When every radio station says George Floyd was an innocent man trying out for his mommy, you walk in with someone and saying that's not true, they're gonna say how dare you. - Right, TJ's point is that we might succeed in moving the overtoned window a little bit with the truth. And power will follow the overtoned window. - We need to take control of the institutions. - Right, no, I absolutely disagree. Let me give you the example of USAID. Here's a tactical approach that would have tremendous ramifications. If you simply pull the money away. So for example, if the United States government stops, stops providing student loans, right? Everyone says, oh God, a terrible sacrifice I have to make. I wouldn't be able to go to college. No, the price of university education would fall by one. - And that's the question of power, not truth. - I totally agree with you. - It's a tactical deployment of power that has a larger long term goal of giving us control of the institutions that convey the truth. - Agreed. - We can't just be in the East, or wrong on a street corner. - Today, power is more relevant than truth. - They're equally relevant. There's just the order of operations requires us to have the institutions not enough. - It's not an either way. I think you're saying that for PR reasons. You cannot go out and speak the truth when the institutions are controlled because you'll either be locked up or attacked or beaten. You need to control the institutions so that you can then present the truth.
Thus, a strategy right now would prioritize power over truth. I think it is not to say lie. I don't disagree with that. I don't say you have to control them. I think you just have to get a toe hold in them just like we did on X where you can begin to power. It's about the truth. Yes. You, you need access to these institutions. If your power is, you cannot change the world if you are powerless than I agree. And the funny thing is the left argued this the whole time, the late David Graber, the, the, he hated the name, but the anarchist anthropologist said the left has adopted the fascistic ethos. There is no truth, but power is just power. And they've been implementing that for decades and they've gained the foothold right now. And the right is going, if we just keep saying what's true, we'll win and I wonder why it is they're going to jail. But I'm not saying that. I'm not saying you'll speak the truth. I'm saying you must speak the truth. The larger problem is to be fair, we don't actually speak the truth. I have this litmus test that I use with, with some people that I know who are very intelligent, hardworking, right coded, honest family men made the sacrifices, et cetera. the types of people who you are glad are Americans. I don't know if we go to a local Mexican restaurant and I say 75% of the workforce here needs to be deported. They tell me to lower my shloy your voice. That's my litmus test. If regular Americans -- Why would they say that? They might spit in your food. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no It might spin in your face. This is the Overton window and the left has said that making comments like that for reason which are hard to articulate is outside the Overton window because -- Laureate yourself, why would you make the comment in the first place? Precisely because I recognize where the Overton window boundary is and I'm trying to re-normalize the truth. What does the comment mean? The comment suggests that there's something that it means to be an American in part because there's something that it means to not be an American. For example, if you take -- I want to know about the comment. I'm sorry I don't follow. 75% of the people need to be deported. They're illegal aliens. Is the question why do illegal aliens need to be deported? No, why would you think that 75% of a restaurant was illegal aliens? Because I was in a Mexican restaurant I'm observing people who can't speak English. I'm using common sense. If the suggestion is I should use my judgment, but they're not. If the point is that it was 55% or 81% or 12%, the point still stands. The objection from the litmus test from the weather vein is not that my percentage was wrong. The objection is my percentage was largely correct. But it can't be spoken. Because it's the truth and it's outside the Overton window. I would argue that's not even -- that maybe half the reason it can't be spoken. The other reason is that's ineffective as a tool for change. What I'm using it as is to gauge whether we're winning or not. And as long as a normal American thinks that you're saying something offensive, then you're losing. Well, there's a lot of other reasons because people use comments like that to convey something that isn't true. Like what? There are those who say that the crime rate is greater among immigrants. It's not true. That's what people say. Well, among illegal aliens, if you define the way you want, then that's true, but that's not true. I'll define it the way you want. Well, then define it as people who came to the country illegally. I don't want to get into that today. The 100% or I don't know. I'm writing down illegal immigrants' comments to drive a larger narrative. And that is what a lot of people react to. Look, I don't want to get caught in semantics with things that are half true. Absolutely not. Clearly, the reason that people cringe at this statement is because it is outside the Overton window. So if I had made a slightly different statement, like I'm saying, no, it's not always. What I'm saying is that sometimes people react to the things that people say in that category. Yes, but we've got to move past that if we wish to prevail. What I'm saying is if you make, again, this is just a litmus test statement. If you make the statement that 75% of illegal aliens, okay, now we're dealing with a class, a set that by definition is here illegally because they are illegal. If you make the comment in public that 75% of illegal aliens need to be deported, then normal Americans will cringe because they don't like controversy. Just like they don't like cops arresting people, just like they don't like seeing violence or aliens being deported by ICE in courtrooms. They are afraid of the controversy. They don't like controversy. Most people are like that. I'm naturally the opposite. I'm very pugnacious. But the thing I say to them is, listen, the men who stormed off the land and craft at Omaha Beach understood what controversy was. This is not a sacrifice speaking the truth in public. That was a sacrifice. And if we are not willing to do that, I get it, but you just say that because you want to see where we're at, is that it? No, I also, I mean, look on this podcast right now on making the point that we have to confront the fact that, for example, if we want to, it's not just that, a weather van comment. In that particular example, I was using it as a weather van. I think you would agree with me if you made the comment in public, your normal American friends would probably cringe a little bit. You were saying you need to speak the truth. You need to try to advance the movements. That's why I was trying to speak. I'm not going to your local Mexican restaurant to pick, you know, I'm saying this. If you are sitting down with the government. That's not effective. If you are sitting down in a restaurant with the group of normies. And there's a bunch of Mexican workers and you say 75% of people here probably need to be deported. You will push them to the left. I don't think that's necessarily true. It is largely true. Probably really distasteful to go to a Mexican restaurant with your buddies. There's a few important things in psychology that people need to know. When you insult someone or deride someone, the average person associates that derision with you and not the target. And the problem is nothing about what I said there is an insult or a derogatory. Nothing about saying that those who are not Americans need to be deported. I said 75% of people here should be deported. You don't know whether they're American. No, stop. Stop with that. That's just not serious counter-argument. Whether it is. That's nitpicking the percentage. No, I am saying if you specifically and literally say to a group of normies 75% of people here probably deserve to be deported. Their immediate reaction is you don't even know if they're illegal or not. And when you're just saying they trained to say that by 30 or 40 or 50 years of indoctrination by left wing. My point is there are people in this country who speak Spanish and they're American. Yeah, fine. That's great. Of course. Yeah. They've been here for hundreds of years. There are people who are monolingal who've been here for hundreds of years. There are families. Well, first of all, now you're adding monolingal. You said they were speaking Spanish. That doesn't mean they only speak Spanish. Okay. Listen, do we wish to have a discussion about recreating the national ethos? If so, then we're not going to get into it. If your point is that there are people in the United States who speak Spanish who happen to be American citizens, then granted. I get that. And the point I made was that if you tell normies abruptly and without qualification, the guys speaking Spanish should be deported. Right. You push them to the left. And if you do the opposite of that, which is pretend that all of this is perfectly acceptable and normal, which has been the prevailing political wins for the last 50 years, then you lose your country. And that is not an answer either. Yeah. But being wrong doesn't solve the problem. Right. Nothing about what I said was wrong. The point is illegal aliens need to be deported. All the people in that, or large portion of the people in that workforce are illegal. By the way, this is nothing to do with whether these are good or bad people or Christians or non-Christians or right or wrong. It says simply to do with this. There's the same argument that I might make to say there are no, there are no commute. 100,000 strong communities of Americans in India is the same argument that we can make. I believe we need you are exemplifying whether right loses in the left wins right now. Really? The left understands. You think we're too strong in making our points go harrowly? I think that you functionally misunderstand the emotional reaction of human beings and the left plays into it. And the left understands. I agree with you that the left wing understands. That when you say, listen, I'm not trying to be harsh, but these people came here illegally. The left goes, these people think about their children and how they would suffer. And they go, you know what, it is better that these people are allowed to stay than what you said. Because you are not arguing to them the way the left is. Well, I'm not sure that I agree with you. I agree with you that I'm not arguing the way the left is not engaged in argumentation. The left is engaged in manipulation. Yeah, manipulation. And that's why they're winning. Yeah, that is right. You're right. An argument from justice will never defeat an argument from reason. And that's why they will always defeat this argument for reason. Correct. Because the argument you're making is that we should be blunt and say the truth to people when that's not how people. But the truth can also have a psychological component. Which is that if you understand that the barbarians are inside the gate and you wish to preserve Western civilization. And you wish to preserve the ideas that you take for granted because they're built into the fabric of our civilization. You can't even articulate what they are. They're everywhere. And Francis Fukuyama wrote a book about this. They're all women are simultaneously complaining about rape and also defending rape as being released for their argument doesn't apply. But to them it does not. That's correct. And that is applied to some people. And the majority of them are voting block. That's correct. But I'm not trying to appeal to the Democratic voting block. What I'm trying to appeal to is the normy American who's right-coded, who doesn't understand fully but intuitively grasps that the West is under great crisis. And is likely going to fail. And what that means is that their sons and daughters will not be raised in the community that they want. So, Francis. TJ, if I. What about. The future of the GOP. Well, I'm not. He's exactly as you're describing. That's what he talks about. That's what he does. It is what he talks about. And TJ, if I can just jump in. Sure. I think one of the problems, Tim is exactly right, is that people have an emotional reaction to when certain things are said. And I think you put your finger right on one. It is true that a whole lot of people in that room are probably there illegally. And our laws suggest that they need to go, right? Well, they don't suggest. Our laws dictate. They're explicit. Yeah. If you're here illegally, you should be deported. That's the law. And at least everyone at this table agrees with that. If I can speak on your behalf. I have probably the most right-wing opinion on immigration here. Yeah, that may be. I probably have problems. Here's the problem as I see it. You can flate being an American with not being an immigrant. No, I don't. You've done it three times at this table. No, you're just saying that. No, no, no, no. I heard you. And it was like all three times. No, no, no. Don't care. You're about to have an argument that all Americans were once immigrants. Look, the point that I'm making here is simply. I don't think that argument needs to be made. The point is. Well, that's what you're saying. Functionally. When you say conflate an illegal immigrant is not an American. Right? In illegal. Sure, not an American citizen. That's right. Not an American period.
I don't see the cultural difference. You don't see the cultural difference between the Somalian from Mogadishu, who comes to the United States, has never read the Declaration of Independence, doesn't know that it exists and does not care, it has no plan to assimilate and an American. You don't understand the difference between that? There's a huge difference between those two. There is a huge difference, and the problem is-- You were accusing me of finishing your sentence incorrectly. Now you're just making up. So what imagine I was gonna say? Okay, what is the point you're trying to make? Culturally, there's not a big difference between someone who is here legally and illegally. I disagree. Depends on-- Yeah, no, absolutely not. There's a huge variation on that. But there's a dramatic history. There's a huge variation among people who are here illegally. You talk about huge variation, people here or here-- Are they born here when they were very young or was an illegal person who came here when they were 30? No, no, no, no, no, no, hold on, hold on. Paper works-- Here is a tremendous cultural distinction between a person who says, let me file the paperwork, let me be of you and do your rules. And other people who are like, I'll give you an example. I was in an Uber in Tijuana. And the driver said, I put a ladder up to the wall. The coyotes, they built a ladder so I could climb over the wall. And then when the CBP came, I fell off the ladder and broke my leg. But I'm gonna get back in that country. I don't care how. And I said, that guy has a culture. His culture is take what you want, sacrifice the rest. The person who stands in line and says, I appreciate it. Thank you for everything. It's a tremendously different culture. And there's one-- I don't think you can back that up. I don't think that that is objectively true. But it's one for one. I will violate your laws. I will not violate your laws. These are two distinct moral worldviews. I think that if you and I were in Mexico-- and by the way, I totally agree. Again, if you're here illegally, you have to go. No one is arguing alternatively. If you and I were in Mexico, and raising a family, I raised a family, and you don't try to run that border. I don't think you're doing right by your family. That is an appeal that the left wing makes, which is we're all sympathetic to. I agree that these are fathers and mothers. What I'm saying is-- and some of them are good people. Many of them are good people. Maybe they're all fantastic people. Let's assume, Arguendo, that they're all fantastic people. The problem is that they are not Americans. And the body of ideas that exist-- But if they had the pay for worse, then it wouldn't be-- No, no, they would not. Hold on one second. Snowflake doesn't blame it. It's blame it. Hold on one second. Today, a larger percentage of the population in the United States is foreign-born than at any point in the last 150 years. That cannot be sustained, whether it is illegal or legal. The point is, there's a reason why we are the bastion of material prosperity. There's a set of ideas that most people could not even write down if you tried, that govern how we interact with one another and make us wealthy and fantastically successful at all the things we do, whether it's scientific discovery and cultural reasons to-- Cultural reasons, yes, this is our culture. I'm defining what our culture is. All the things that you can't even articulate because you just live in it, like a-- And the mollies don't have this. They have something else. And the point is, they're not reconcilable, especially when this population-- I mean, the population is too low. You're saying the mollies don't have it because they don't have the paperwork or the-- No, let me give you an example. Let me explain it to you, OK? So what we found in Minnesota is that Somalis followed all the rules to extract public funds and mail it back to Somalia. That violates the spirit of our culture and laws. And we were shocked to find how could they be setting up fake daycares and fake hospice care, taking hundreds of millions of dollars and then putting in suitcases and flying to Somalia because they have a distinct culture. And what they said was, but I followed all the rules. We say, OK, this has to stop because you're stealing from us. They go, no, you told me if I filed these papers, I could do this. And we go, yeah, but it's supposed to be to help. That's not what it says. We filed the rules. See, those are two distinct cultures. Legal or illegal, the Somali community is doing this. I think it's high over there going out in Minnesota and they're doing it in Washington. And that perfectly clarified. Distinct immigrants, legal and illegal in various parts of the United States who do not share our culture and are damaging our country. Agreed, excellent clarification. Excellent clarification. We don't need to conflate this idea that American culture does not include a certain amount of immigration because 40 minutes ago-- You just said it just at a double negative. I don't think I've conflated anything. What I'm saying is that there's a body of ideas that define what it means to be American. And one of them goes-- And immigration. No, no, no, because in 1804, we needed a ton of immigrants and we needed people who would assimilate to what it meant to be an American. And largely the ocean served that for-- So we became less American 100 years ago? No, listen to me. Well, when you cross an ocean in 1804, you are indicating that you are a particular type of person, right? There's a rugged individualism. There's a willingness to follow certain types of rules as a willingness to provide for oneself. Probably you're escaping religious-- All of that would pertain to-- No. Someone would make it on the board. What does it mean to be an American in your-- OK, so that's what I feel like. We're kind of-- This veers into what does it mean to be an American? Is it an idea? Is it a creed? Is it an ethnicity? Is it something-- And who can be a part of it? Who can be an exclusionary to some? What I'm saying, let's set aside the theoretical argument of what it means to be an American to address the emergent reality, which is practically speaking, if 20% of your population is foreign-born, 30%, 40%, at some point, you no longer have a culture that's strong enough to assimilate anybody. The point that I'm making is-- and instead, they'll be swamped and you'll become a polyglot-balkanized community. Just like Yugoslavia, that's why you call it a Balkans, OK? So at what point do you cross that threshold and say, I don't know exactly what it means to be an American? I think I could put together a pretty good definition. But let's say I don't know exactly what it means-- The ship of these, whatever. OK, how much can you replace before it's not? Right, before it's not. You can add water to wine, and at some point, it's no longer wine. And what I'm saying now is, in 1850, this wasn't a problem, because the percentage of the population that was foreign-born was very low. And today, it's very high. And if we had an immigration pause for 75 years, then we can revisit the issue. This is nothing to do with it. That's nice and philosophical, but I feel like you're still feeling the question. That's very clear. OK, I mean, the easiest definition is that you accept the premise of the declaration of independence that we hold these truths all the time. So if a Somali dude comes over and accepts all the premises and the declaration of independence, poof, therefore-- But that's big in the question. You can't just poof do that, right? It's just like saying, I can't go to Somalia and poof understand-- Someone in Somali can study American cities. I know more than-- Hold on, hold on, hold on. No, I think-- It's actually-- You have to be here a certain number of years before you-- No, I'm trying to get to the bottom of it. What does that mean? I'm going to say this. There's a guy in Somalia who watches family guy every single day. He grew up watching Simpsons, married with children and family guy, and he dreams the one day coming to the United States. He works really hard. He saves up his money and he studies. He applies. It takes three years. But they finally say you're welcome to come. He speaks fluent English. He's read the Constitution front to back and knows more about it than everybody else in this country. And he knows all the presidents. That guy's American. That's American. Yeah, is that an American? Yeah, I agree with that. He shows up and says, I followed your rules. I followed your laws. I love you. I love everything you stand for. Let me join you. I also say that we can't have any immigration for 10, 20, 30 years. Oh, great. I would just say this. And I would say this. But do you agree that those two points can exist? Yes, I'm not. My point is, no. You give me. No. OK. We don't possibly justify a 30-year moratorium in immigration. What? Because you knew she played her for the agricultural companies? No, because much of our American culture is based on the idea that people had to struggle to get here. Immigration is fundamental to the American country. No, I totally disagree. Zero limits on how much immigration we should have. Yes. How much is it? I think you have to pace it according to how quickly we can. That's the point that I'm saying. No, it's not. You're saying that-- You have to pace it according to the percentage of the population that's foreign-born. It's too high. That's exactly the point that I'm making. You can not justify a 30-year moratorium. I can. On the foreign-born population being too high, why not? There's precedent. We've literally done this already. 15.4% of your population is what I just said. And it was a bad idea. I guess at 15.4% of your population. I disagree. Well, what could we definitely make in immigration moratorium a good idea? All the reasons we just-- We just preserved immemorial commemoration. He's in this of the country. So it's still all the foreign-born people. So that everybody in this country can learn how to speak-- You see Americanism is being distinct from immigration. What I'm saying is that-- That's a real important question. No, it wasn't a question at all. You just made a declaration. OK, so if you think that America does not-- there was an argument on Acts a few months ago. About whether-- this is a credal nation. And it's maybe it's an ethnic nation. It's obviously both. There's ethnic components to America. And there's ideal-- There are ethnic components to America. Do you don't think the 3 million people here in 1776 were of all polygOT ethnicities, or largely two ethnicities? I mean, I don't understand what the issue is. Like, I'm not saying that you have to be a particular ethnicity. Let's not do the left wing ad hominem attack. What I'm saying is-- Don't accuse me of it. Any political body has to have a shared political idea. It has to have some level of shared principles. It could be a religion. It's the argument for credal. OK, that's the argument for credal. And that is the argument that is largely destroyed by rampant illegal immigration and legal immigration when there's no-- You can't back that up. Oh, I absolutely can. I'm just-- I'm opening my eyes. I think actually that's the academic view. I mean, it's like-- If you have a heterogeneous society, you don't have an issue. What's the argument for there being an ethnic definition of America? I'm simply observing that Americans in history were largely of one ethnicity, then it expanded with the introduction of the Chinese, and then slightly more sex and Protestants? Well, and also Dutch, but then the slaves were added as citizens in 1865, and then Irish and Italians. But the point is, all of this happened gradually in a couple of years. Look, look, look, look. Let's make the argument in extremism.
>> There are brought 150 million Somalians who are Muslim or Islamic and believe in Sharia law. Do you think that the United States would exist the day after that? >> Of course not. >> So once you accept that premise, you've conceded the argument. The only question is what is the appropriate number and my contention is it's less than we have. >> That's what I was asking you. What is the appropriate number of immigrants before we say, okay, it's time to take a break. >> Well, I agree with you the implication, which is almost impossible to put a number on it. >> I want to, I want to, guys, we got to go to the concert portion of the show. It's 10 o'clock. >> That was me, the censor? >> I'm going to explain to you the ethnic component of nation. I mean, that's sincerely. We'll do it on the Uncensored portion of the show as we're going to it right now. I had a great conversation with a few guys about nation's ethnicity, laws, and how these things operate. So head over to rumble.com/timcastirl for the Uncensored portion. Sorry we didn't get to your super jets today, guys, but this is spicy and we're having a good time. You want to shout anything out before we go to the Uncensored show. >> Yeah, I wrote a book recently called American scapegoat in which we're talking about symbolic truths and real truths, and I encourage everyone to get it, it's coming out in two weeks. >> Right on. >> I appreciate that. >> I encourage folks to go to mictermont.com and learn about the campaign for earning the Vice-Presidential nomination of the Republican Party. >> Oh, yeah, we have goofy buttons, we have rectangular buttons. >> Who would you want as your president if you were the VP? Do you have a professor? >> Yes. >> The, the, the last Liberty-Minded party. >> Say a name. >> A lot. A lot of Yahoo, I'm a journalist, thanks for having me, guys, it was fun. >> I feel. >> I am. Fill the remains on twigs. You can check out my Patreon, let's patreon.com/fill the remains. This Sunday in Orlando, Florida, all the remains is playing Warped Tour. You can go down to Warped Tour dot com to get tickets. If you want to check out all the remains, music, it's Apple music, Amazon music, Pandora, YouTube, Spotify, and Deezer, don't forget the left lane is for crime, Carter. >> What's up, I'm Carter, follow me at Carter Banks everywhere at Carter Banks official or else, I'm really pumped to get on the censored show and watching you guys go back and forth and I've been like on different sides every 20 minutes, so we're going to get into it. Anyway, shout out to my mom, it's her birthday today, and yeah, it's a happy birthday. >> We'll see you all over at rumble.com/timcast. RL right now, it's going to get spicy, we'll see you there. [Music]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Dave Chappelle’s statement that he felt better after Charlie Kirk’s murder was not a joke but a serious and offensive claim that sparked widespread outrage.
Chappelle’s comedy routine, which mocked Charlie Kirk’s death and referenced George Floyd, was seen as a deliberate insult and a violation of empathy and respect for victims.
The incident exposed deep cultural divisions, with many on the right seeing it as a dangerous display of "assassination culture" and a lack of moral boundaries.
Critics argue that Chappelle’s reaction reflects a broader "victim culture" where death and pain are used for political amusement, especially in the context of political figures.
The backlash included fans walking out, sponsors pulling support, and public criticism, signaling a shift in public tolerance for politically charged mockery.
The discussion highlights how free speech is protected from government censorship but does not shield individuals from social or economic consequences for offensive behavior.
A growing concern is that political extremism on both sides is eroding trust, with left-wing figures promoting violence as "justified" and right-wing figures being seen as unresponsive to real suffering.
The political climate shows increasing polarization, with public figures like Jennifer Welch facing backlash for laughing at a death, and a potential shift toward more intense cultural conflict.
Summary:
Dave Chappelle’s controversial remarks at a Madison Square Garden show, in which he claimed to feel better after Charlie Kirk’s murder and joked that George Floyd would be “laughing so hard he can’t breathe,” ignited a major backlash. Critics argue the statement was not a joke but a deeply offensive and inappropriate dismissal of a political assassination. The incident revealed a growing cultural rift, where both sides are seen as crossing moral boundaries: the left criticized Chappelle for mocking a death, while the right accused the left of glorifying violence and victimization.
Many fans walked out, and prominent figures like Jennifer Welch lost 26 sponsors after laughing at a tweet about re-excavating Kirk’s body. The conversation underscores a broader crisis in American politics—increasing polarization, the erosion of empathy, and the normalization of politically charged mockery. Critics warn that such behavior signals a dangerous shift toward "assassination culture," where political death is treated as entertainment.
The debate also highlights the limits of free speech, as private companies and public figures face real-world consequences for offensive content. Ultimately, the incident reflects a deepening political divide where trust is broken, and both sides are accused of hypocrisy, with the concern that societal norms are sliding into a state of escalating hostility and moral decay.
FAQs
No, it was not a joke. The statement that he felt better after Charlie Kirk was murdered was presented as a literal observation, not a humorous remark, and many viewers and critics saw it as inappropriate and offensive.
Dave Chappelle made a joke suggesting that George Floyd was laughing so hard he couldn't breathe, which sparked widespread outrage and accusations of disrespecting Floyd's death and family.
The joke was seen as deeply offensive because it mocked the murder of a political figure, implying that the killer's actions were acceptable or even celebrated, which many viewed as a violation of empathy and respect for victims of violence.
Yes, many fans reportedly walked out during the event, filming themselves leaving the venue, with some describing the atmosphere as hostile and angry over the politically charged content.
A joke is a lighthearted or humorous statement, while a diss is an intentional insult aimed at someone to ridicule them, often at the expense of their dignity or beliefs, which is considered more harmful in political discourse.
Jennifer Welch laughed at a tweet referencing the resurrection of Charlie Kirk, and as a result, 28 brands withdrew their sponsorships, showing the impact of mocking political violence on public trust and business relationships.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.