Go back

Cupcakes | CreepCast

1h 13s

Cupcakes | CreepCast

The podcast features a deep dive into the infamous My Little Pony fan fiction horror story "Cupcakes," originally posted on 4chan in 2011 and attributed to a young writer known as "Sergeant Sprinkles" (later linked to David Foster Wallace). The story follows a dark, graphic sequence in which Pinky Pie, a fictional character from the show, tortures Rainbow Dash using medical tools, dissection, electric shock, and psychological torment. Despite the extreme violence, the narrative is presented as a chilling and authentic example of child-authored internet horror, blending the show’s wholesome image with grotesque, detailed violence. The creators highlight how the story’s realism, layered horror, and dark satire—such as the use of adrenaline shots and torture techniques—exceed many traditional creepypastas in intensity and psychological impact. The podcast also explores the broader cultural phenomenon of internet fan fiction, where fandoms like My Little Pony become spaces for disturbing creative expression. Multiple alternate endings are discussed, including police intervention, a hospital reunion, or Rainbow Dash’s survival with trauma. Ultimately, the story is presented not just as a horror tale, but as a profound cultural artifact that reveals the potential for dark creativity in online communities, especially when influenced by young writers and internet culture. The hosts express both revulsion and fascination, acknowledging its disturbing power while recognizing its significance in the evolution of creepypasta.

Transcription

9818 Words, 50879 Characters

English
Hi, I'm Karen Slaughter. If you love untangling mysteries and uncovering the truth behind what really happened, I think you'll love "The Good Daughter." Charlie, go! Sam! Now my best-selling novel is finally coming to life, and I got to write every episode. You should have died in them woods. Your father should have been a better shot. Starring Rose Byrne, Megan Fahey, and Brendan Gleeson. From page to screen, don't miss "The Good Daughter," now streaming only on Peacock. I'm here, Charlie, and I'm not going away. You know you don't have to wait to shop Black Friday at Lowe's, right? Save up to $150 now on select power tools, equipment, and accessories. Got gifts to get? We've got plenty under $50. Plus, "My Lowe's" rewards members get same-day delivery for free. Shop Black Friday deals before the rush at Lowe's. Valid through 11/18. $25 minimum and loyalty membership required. Order eligible items by 2:00 PM. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. Terms at Lowe's.com/shippingterms. Welcome back to Creepcast. Today, we are going to another original creepypasta. And yes, I do mean creepypasta. I was talking to Isaiah about this. And I was like, you know, we haven't read, like, a Jeff the Killer thing in a while. We've done, what, Laughing Jack, fucking Eyeless Jack, Mr. Widemouth, all this kind of stuff. But it's been a bit. We've had a lot of, like, great bangers lately. So I figured I was, I was asking him, I said, what is some good, original, fun creepypasta stuff that was definitely written by a young child? And he suggested cupcakes, which is apparently the beginning of, I guess, would you say this was written by a brony? It's a My Little Pony fanfic horror story. And we're going to be reading that today. I just want everyone to know that I joined the call. And I'm like, what were we doing today, Hunter? And he just doesn't say anything. Just DMs me something with My Little Pony in the title. And I was like, all right, well, I guess I've had a good run. It's we haven't. But YouTube was fun while it lasted, I guess. To be fair, to be fair, we have not ventured into brony territory yet. What is it oddball such as myself can Superman lean? My Little Pony friendship is magic. This is like a kind of a big moment, actually, where we were another another Internet sect comes together like an Internet fandom. If we finally get to go into new territory because we have I don't think we've done any any My Little Pony stuff, right? There hasn't even been a mention of My Little Pony on this channel until now. I don't think so. And we've gotten this far and you haven't made me do it. But here we are. Now is the day has happened. So to be fair, I did come in with a story called Rainbow Factory. That has some very, you know, absolutely cursed My Little Pony hard on it. But then Isaiah said, oh, hey, cupcakes is the like, I'm like, if we're going to do it, the classic. But you're saying that this is the O.G. My Little Pony. Oh, oh, gee. Yeah. Is there like this came out right around the time Jeff the killer did and stuff is there? Have you read this before? Is this just have you just heard of it? I've read it before because the thing back in the day I remember is I think you were right about a brony made it. But everyone would say, oh, this story is so scary. It's so creepy. You don't even have to know My Little Pony for it to be scary. And so I'm like, OK, I'll listen to it. And like me, who was afraid of laughing, Jack and Jeff, the killer and stuff did not find it scary. So I can only imagine what that means. So there's a couple of things here. I just want to I just want to point this out at the top. Right. So first off, it says this is. Random.com. We are looking at the the title here says Cupcakes Original. There's a not safe for work title at the top. But then the first couple sentences say this is the original version of the fanfic Cupcakes, the version posted on here and proliferating the Internet, i.e. the one that ends with the pinky pie about to stuff Rainbow Dash's corpse is actually the second version found here. So I guess that leads me. There's a link to that. Isaiah, do you do we want to go with the O.G. or do we want to have the one where they spoil the ending? Oh, this is the like short history of it also on the MLP pasta dot fandom dot com. I hate my life description says the Cupcakes fanfic is thought to have first appeared on four chance Image Board Co. sometime in January of 2011, though the date of the original post remains unknown. A canonical reference to Episode 12 in the fan fiction suggests that the earliest possible date was January 7th, 2011 on the Equestria Daily version. I hate myself. The authorship has been attributed to Sergeant Sprinkles. The earliest archived instance of My Little Pony fan fiction is Junior Speedsters Forever posted in January 24th, 2011. Okay, so that means I think that's what this saying is Cupcakes may not only be the original My Little Pony fan fiction, but the first My Little Pony fan fiction horror otherwise ever. I would suggest it's horror because there's no there has to be so much fan. I mean, I mean, could be. I don't know. Well, that's what's on Equestria Daily. Yes. Yes. On the on the website. It might be the first. Now, according to this, let me ask you this. Is there any realm of reality that this actually has some good spooky stuff? Is there any world where that happens? Other than like the fact I have to read it on this podcast? No, I don't think so. It's a little thing. I didn't think that we would go here, but I got to say I'm a little excited at least if I'm being honest. And that leads me to the next horrifying thing, which is be sure to check out this podcast on Spotify and Apple and Apple podcast, all the audio platforms and check us out there. Give us a nice rating. It really does help the show. And also, if you want extra episodes of this of this awesome show, feel free to sign up for our patron. We have, I think, how many three or four extra episodes now and a lot more coming. So if you want to support the show outside of just watching it here and you want extra content, feel free to go over there and check it out. Otherwise, Isaiah, are you ready to become a bro? For the next, I don't know, hour or so. Your silence is so loud. Thank you all for the support. You've shown the show and Brody is really cool. And all you know, it's, you know, so I don't know anything about my little putt. My sister was into it when she was a kid, but I never paid attention besides, you know, like throwing her toys across the room. So I know nothing of this. And I know. In fact, a lot of our Brony fans are going to come out of the woodwork. I, if you're a Brony, if you're a Brony stand up and be proud, be proud that you're, that you're a Brony. Cause I feel like right now it's a dying breed. I don't feel like that. That used to be like early internet cringe stuff is like, it's even before I would say even before furries, like you'd be like, oh, the Brony's and I feel like furries kind of took their place. I'm not sure if that's true or not, but it feels like there's not, I think, I think, or, well, they were kind of at the same time. Cause I remember hearing it. I'm hearing about both of them around the same era. I think it's just because didn't the show quit. I have no, I have no idea, but I don't, I don't think that I guess would that stop? I guess maybe that would stop. I hate that. I'm typing this in. I hate them. Well, yeah, it hasn't stopped completely. Just became more nice niche. So if the show's not running new fans, aren't coming into, if, if, if bread isn't being baked in the factory, no one's eating, you know, so what's the point? Pro the finale finale premiered October 12th 2019. I said he had a good run. Yes, nice run. Yeah, I mean what season How many see I hate season 46 MLP Friendship is magic have it had nine seasons not a bad run So this is this is fresh. So nine seasons. This was like Fresh off season one it it hooked People immediately. Okay. All right. Well shit you ready to get into this Yeah, as I'll ever be All right cupcakes and this is the original version as mentioned There's a second version that floats around a lot, but this is the OG from sergeant sprinkles. Yes The air was warm sun was shining and all of Ponyville was having oh my gosh And all of Ponyville was having a glorious day The town square was bustling and crowded busy Ponyville was having a glorious day I know I know this is just good. I know the whole thing is going to be like this. I just have to lock you to lock in It's going to be this optimistic and cheery the whole time until we get our gruesome. Someone's getting murdered immediately I hope yeah, you know honestly and I need to get this. I need to get my biases out of the way first, right? Okay One of the things that annoys me so much about anyone who talks about MLP is that they replace any person pronoun with the word Pony it's like oh every pony or horse famous and stuff and here's the thing if it was just like people wholesomely enjoying the series They'd be fine. I wouldn't care but I know I've seen what the the miscreants of the fan base, which is a lot of them are capable of and it's just so tied to the image of it. I can't separate it in my mind. That's why I'm so violent if this was about what's a wholesome property from when we were kids. kids like Looney Tunes, no Looney Tunes is like. adults like that too you know what i mean if this was like something that was entirely safe i'd be fine but i'm just it's just in the back of my head the things i've seen sure on the internet that's why i'm very judgmental but i understand yes yeah yeah anyway busy ponies were making their busy way through the streets all the pony folks seem to see what i mean see what i mean all the pony folks seem to have somewhere to be all except rainbow dash her place was in the sky she freely tore through the air speeding one way and the damn she buzzed the treetops and raced the wind the pegasus swooped over a schoolyard much to the delight of the children climbing several hundred feet she dove going as fast as she could seconds before hitting the ground her wings flew open and she took off back into the clear blue rainbow dash felt alive all right so we got a pony that can fly yeah well pegasus it's a pegasus okay got it you i just made a winged horse yeah yeah right thank you then she remembered that she had somewhere to be she's supposed to meet with pinky pie in five minutes she'd gotten so caught up in her exercises that she nearly forgot also every sentence is the same the exact same structure just pointed that out pinky had asked dash to meet her at sugar cube corner at three she didn't say why i got a bomb you know you know it's also i'm gonna i'm gonna i'm gonna where this story's going where this story's going that's not far off like that this turned into a hostage saying you're like i'm gonna go and i'm gonna blow up pony bank you can't do it sugar blossom uh you know it's also crazy about this there was so i was at a wedding this last weekend and a guy came up to me and he was like he was one of the guys who was working the venue and he's like oh when to go and a huge fan of your stuff blah blah he's like i absolutely love creepcast and i just signed up for the patreon shout out that and i was like oh thanks man that means the world so that guy after after shaking my hand after touching me and making eye contact the next thing he will see is this i have to explain what this is to my dad now rainbow dash listen i got a bomb and a gun i'm playing i'm playing i'm robbing the bank on sugar cube corner you gotta be there at three of course it's gonna be innocent lives lost do the ponies have like like defense capabilities like do they have a police force oh i would you'd have to imagine like the horse is in my little pony you know well they probably have like wizards or something aren't they all magical and shit well i mean like there's a pegasus so i imagine they fly yeah here's a cop they have a cop does a cab apply to these oh absolutely a cab applies to everything sir law enforcement there's a wiki page for i forget how law enforcement characters who work or have worked in law enforcement includes all right i'm gonna i'm not gonna read all these names because people will be like you mispronounced it wrong you forgot about this one but there's multiple there's multiple phonies who have served in some kind of police come on man this is this is good this this is good law enforcement this is canon this is canon lore it's helping us build this universe for this spooky story what what what what what is the lore of this stuff i'm looking at the family hand boards the royal guard's job is to guard royal royalty and the capital city they have a capital city absolutely okay all right she didn't say why or what they'd be doing but dash knew that with pinky it could be anything she wasn't sure if she really wanted to go though she was so engaged with her stunts that she thought about blowing pinky off to continue flying but dash's conscience got the better of her she knew that it would hurt pinky's feelings after all she said it was going to be something special just for the two of them she considered it and thought why not what did she have to lose heck it might be more pranking pinky might have found a bunch more fun stuff to pull off on folks they had so much fun at the last time dash kicked it into overdrive mostly to make for lost time and sped to her appointment when she walked into the store she was immediately greeted with her host bouncing in excitement is that good little pony it is it is haunting come on well you know what how close that is how close how close that is to your gypsy rose impression the most knowledge i have of my little pony is the jenny nicholson video about it so i know that like i know that like the the actor the voice all the voice actors and actresses are like serious voice actors and actresses so i imagine pinky pie's voice doesn't sound you know i'm not gonna look so wait so are you saying should i should i make it more straight instead of being so bubbly um yeah i i realistically yes but for the sake of what we're doing today here let me literally try this as well just leave it you're here you're here i've been waiting all day that's probably about right yeah is rainbow dash a guy or a girl or is that um i want to say a girl hold on is rain but my search history right now sorry if i'm a little late pinky pie i was doing my afternoon exercises and lost track of time rainbow dash is a girl by the way pinky giggled and responded her tone gleefully reassuring that's okay you're here now what's a few more minutes i've been so excited thinking about all the fun stuff we're gonna do i haven't stopped bouncing since i woke up i mean i almost forgot to breathe since i've been so happy dash gave a slightly uncomfortable laugh she always appreciated pinky 's friendly outgoing way of life but her over abundant enthusiasm almost creeped her out dash was polite however if pinky had got this worked up then it must then it must good then it must good whatever it was so you're ready to get started rainbow dash i got everything already dash psyched yourself up you betcha pinky what do you got planned are you gonna prank somebody couple of i got a couple of good ones i've been thinking about or maybe you got some stunts you think i could i should try or maybe making cupcakes pinky happily announced oh yeah this is gonna get real good i know it's gonna we're getting ready to hey start a ladies and gentlemen start your engines dash was disappointed pinky you know i'm not good at baking remember the last time that's not a problem at all i only need your help making them i'll be doing most of the work dash thought for about it for a second and replied all right i guess that's okay what exactly do you need me to do that's the spirit here you go pinky handed dash a cupcake dash was puzzled i i thought i was helping you bake you will be i made this one just for you before you got here so this is like a like a taste testing or something sorta dash shrugged and popped the pastry in her mouth she chewed a bit and swallowed not bad okay now what now you take a nap fucking pinky just roofied rainbow dash jesus okay we're going to the clerk that's gotta be a brand new sentence no one's ever said that upon hearing that dash felt lightheaded her world spun and seconds later she dropped to the floor when dash regained consciousness she found herself in a dark room she tried to shake her head but found that a taut leather strap kept it firmly in place she struggled to move but the braces around her chest and limbs glued her to a rack formed from a series of sturdy planks which spread her legs wide apart dash's wings were the only part of her not tied down and they fluttered frantically while she struggled to escape as she rised pinky jumped into her line of sight hey you're awake now we can get started she was pushing a cart covered with a cloth hey pinky what's what's going on i i can't move well duh you're tied down that's why you can't move i didn't think you'd need to be told that but why what's happening i thought you said i thought you said i was going to help you make cupcakes you are helping you see i ran out of my special ingredient i need you to get more special ingredient dash was now breathing heavily and starting to panic what special ingredient pinky giggled and responded you silly uh-oh i like how you're into this oh yeah dude well first off this is a hundred percent a fetish story just want to say that the binding and all that this is this is the binding and like her legs spread apart yeah I have a feeling that we're not out of the fetish forest yet. yet so i don't remember any of that from when i was like a kid and read this but when we started to read those last few lines i was like oh i see i see so i don't remember any but uh yeah clearly clearly that's what's happening on now a 12 year old me was not equipped to understand what i was 12 year old 12 years old like why do i like this so much no that's why is this so appealing no no no no no no don't don't you you can say a lot of things about me hunter but you let me have this you can say i killed my dog with chocolate you can say okay dash's eyes widen her face contorted in fear then she started to laugh it really got me there pinky pie i mean triggered me into thinking i'm gonna be made to a cupcake i gotta tell you that's the best best prank yet you win you're the best pinky giggled even more now ah thanks dash but i haven't done pranks today so i can't accept your praise dash we're struggling again come on this isn't funny then why are you laughing pinky grabbed the cloth and whipped it off the cart the top of the tray contained various sharp medical tools and knives carefully organized and ready oh my god there is a medicine bag and several other objects next to them dash was now in full panic she was starting to hyperventilate her mind was racing and she tried to reason with the pink pony you can't do this pinky i'm your friend i know you are and that's why i'm so happy i've got you here we get to share your last moments together just you and me she was skipping again but the other ponies will wonder where i am when the clouds pile up they'll come looking for me and then you'll get found out dash don't worry there are plenty of pegasus to take care of a few clouds and besides no pony will find out i mean how long do you think i've been doing this and with that the light suddenly came to life and showcased the rest of the room oh oh gosh oh no dash reeled in horror at the image presented to her the room was decorated with the typical but twisted pinky pie flavor colorful streamers of dried entrails danced around the ceiling brightly painted skulls of all sizes were stuck on the walls and organs done up in pastels filled with helium tied to the backs of chairs the tables and chairs were made of bones and flesh of past ponies dash cringed at the centerpiece on the table nearest to her the head of four foals their eyes closed like they were sleeping wearing party hats made from their own skin she recognized one of them as apple blooms classmates her eyes started back and forth and then gazed up at the patchwork banner hanging from the rafters made from several pony hides the words life is a party were scrawled in i legitimately thought that said life is a highway for a second like uh like pinky was a fan life truly is a highway love is a highway yeah during this like all the all the blood like it's funny how cartoonish it continues to be like she has organs blown up like balloons tied to chairs and then in the corner of the room just laughs like a road traveler i would legitimately say that if there was like a sansa lambs kind of scene of like you're a guy going into a basement like looking for somebody you know like those classic those classic scenes like the cops going down the stairs like they're all scared and shit yes yeah gun drawn like look around and then in the distance if you just heard my real heart i want to ride it all night long like a weird upbeat song like that would be that'd be a fuck juxtaposition like that'd be really sick where are you yeah it's just bodies everywhere come out screaming she's firing a couple shots that'd be pretty sick you know what fucking rascal flash is playing on the back of this right now Okay. That's canon. That's canon. Dash's attention was stolen by a party horn unfurling and tickling her nose. She saw a pinky pie standing in front of her. The party pony was wearing a dress quilted from cutie marks. On her back fluttered six pegasus wings, all different colors. As she skipped in excitement, her necklace of unicorn horns loudly clacked together. Okay, that's actually kind of metal. I just want to say right now, that's actually kind of sick. She has like a necklace made out of the horns. She has a necklace made out of horns, and then she has like a fucking cape or whatever that has six pegasus wings on it. And she's like skipping around like a fucking lunatic. She's like, heh, wee-hee, woo-hoo-hoo-hoo, woo-hoo-hoo-hoo. Like a fucking psychopath. I simultaneously hate and love how into this you are right now. I mean, it's got me. I mean, we're getting into it. I want to see what happens. Like it? I made it myself. Oh, God, Pinky! Please! I'm sorry if I did anything to you. I didn't mean it. Please, let me go. I promise I won't tell anypony. I won't tell anypony. That's good. Oh, Dash! You didn't do anything. It's just that your number came up, and, well, I don't make the rules. We can't turn back now. She's on a fucking bingo system. She's on a bingo system for killing ponies. I love it! A fair system. A lottery, perhaps. Yeah, exactly. One based on chance. Heads or tails. Heads or tails. I'm not one on that now. Every pony, you stand to lose every pony. Yeah. That works so good, dude. Now just imagine Anton, whatever, and it's like he has his face, like, superimposed on the horse's face, too. Don't put that quarter in your pocket. That's your lucky quarter. That's your lucky pony. That's your lucky horn. Uh, Rainbow Dash was tearing up. How could this be happening? Aw, don't be sad, Dash. Look, this'll cheer you up. I brought you a friend. Oh. Oh. Oh. Out of seemingly nowhere, Pinky displayed a blue and yellow painted skull. It was about pony size, but it had a very defining feature. Oh. A beak. Oh. Dash was freaking out. Is that. Is that. Hey, Dash! Let's hang together. These ponies are lame. Demos. Dweebs. Dweebs. Dweebs! I caught her right before she left town. Remember when I left the party for about 20 minutes? That wasn't enough time to play with her, of course. I had to wait till after the party to do that. But boy, am I glad I did. It was worth for the flavor alone. Griffins taste like two animals at once. It's. It's amazing. I know she didn't have a number like everyone else in Ponyville, but. When was I gonna get another chance to try a griffin? And. In hindsight, I probably should have asked where she came from so I didn't get more, but. I forget. I'll tell you what, though. She was quite the fighter. Lasted a long time. Which was fun for me. I got the chance to play with somebody other than a pony and try new things. It's too bad she had such a potty mouth. She said so much bad stuff. I had to take her tongue out. You know. Bad language makes for bad feelings, Dash. Dash didn't have anything. She didn't have anything to say. Just sobbed and writhed. Fuck! Well. Pinky said, putting down the skull. That's enough reminiscing. It's time to begin. She picked up a scalpel and walked over to Dash's right flank. Without any flair, she placed the blade an inch above her cutie mark and started a circular cut around it. Her lungs working overtime. Dash! Shouted in pain and tried desperately to pull away. But the braces held her still. Finishing the incision, Pinky grabbed the curved skinny knife from the tray. She worked it under the skin and sliced the hide away from the muscle. Dash ground her teeth as she tearfully watched as her flesh came off. Pinky then moved to the other side and completed the other flank. Once she was done, Pinky held up both cutie marks in front of her friend and started waving them like pom-poms. Dash just whimpered. Her thighs burned. My thighs! Placing the skin down, Pinky selected the large butcher knife and walked behind Rainbow Dash. Hope you don't mind. I think I'm gonna wing it now. Did you like that? Did you like that pun that Pinky made? I did. I did a nice hysterical evil laugh too. It probably got cut off, but it was. I sold it. Don't worry. It was sold. Also, I just want to say too, since we stopped, that I feel like that Griffin death to some people who know the show was probably quite devastating. It had to be. Oh, fuck! She grabbed the left one and played with it for a second. Then stretching the wing out, she brought the blade down at the base. Instantly, Dash screamed and thrashed her appendage. The movement threw off Pinkie Pie's aim. She tried to hit the mark again, but missed wide and put a huge slice in Rainbow's back. Dash, you gotta stay still or I'm gonna keep missing! She took another whack and hit the target. She swung again and again, blood spraying into the air, but realized she wasn't getting anywhere. The blade just wasn't going through the bone. I guess I forgot to sharpen it. I'll try something else. She stated as she tossed the knife over her shoulder, the blade embedding itself in the table. The crying Rainbow Dash heard the sound of a metal box opening and closing. Got it! See that? Dash, why do they call it a hacksaw? It doesn't hack. Hacking is what I was doing with the knife. This is a saw. I don't get it. You know that line? I know we're reading it in My Little Pony fan fiction, right? But that line in itself is a funny, like a fun line for a torture to have in a movie. Like I could see, what's his name, Mr. Blonde from Reservoir Dogs saying that when he cuts off the guy's ear. Yeah. I don't get it. It's saws. It doesn't hack. You can see the obvious Tarantino influence on this story. I want to say this too. This is really, I mean, you know, it is what it is. This is far, far from the worst thing we've ever read. I just want to put that out. It is. It's true. I'm having way too much fun with this. It's far away. It's not, the worst crime a story can commit is being forgettable. Oh, I am. This is certainly not forgettable. No, God, no. Like now I'm imagining like as the Pinkie Pie is walking around, it's like, well, I don't know why I came in the night. She'd be dancing around to either life is a highway or it'd be what hurts the most is being so close and watching you walk away. The Rascal Flats kind of story. Of course. Pinkie placed the tool over the last attempt. It effortlessly. Helplessly sailed through the bone and skin. The painful feeling of the teeth biting into her made Dash want to vomit. She watched helplessly as her wing flew over her head and land with a fluff on the table. Pinkie moved the next and started sawing. Dash didn't struggle this time. She'd given up trying to fight, just cried. Then the sign abruptly paused. Pinkie was only halfway done. The wing hanging on only by a sliver. Hey, Dash. Think fast. Suddenly she yanked the wing. As hard as she touched the bone. God, what sadistic fucking 12-year-old is writing this? Hey, Dash. Hey, Dash. Like, rips out the fucking bone. You know, you know, I actually got to say that's kind of brutal. I know we're talking about like a horse swing. But imagining someone like ripping off a half-sawed through arm or something. It's not even just physical torture. It's fucking mental agony as well. Hey, Dash. Hey, Dash. And then just immediately ripping the thing out. I mean, my God. What kind of fucking. That's rough. What kind of like fat little boy or girl was sitting down writing this. And just like grinning ear to ear. What sadistic. What future serial killer was writing this? That's what I want to know. Captain Sprinkles. Yeah, Sergeant fucking Sprinkles. It's actually Captain Sparkles. The guy that made all the Minecraft. Songs back in the day. It's all connected. Yeah, as she's dancing, you can hear in the background. So, baby, tonight, the creeper's gonna steal. God. The bones snapped, but the skin held tight. The pull ripped a long strip of flesh down Dash's back to her rump. The unexpected trauma caused her body to seize. She felt the warm release between legs as her pelvis tensed up. Dash is loud. The loud, unending melody of pain filled the room. Unable to catch her breath, she blacked out. She awoke with a gasp. The stench of her urine filled her mucus-caked nostrils. Jesus fucking Christ, dude. it's such a good god like heavy description of a torture sequence get this child off immediately what happens when you torture someone for four hours search imagine the school counselor sitting down with their parents over this yeah dude that's i was that's so funny you bring that up i was thinking the exact same thing you know this little motherfucker went to school and printed this stuff off at the library and that that what in god's name is this this is i i hate to say this out loud this is actually better than just from how brutal the descriptions have been oh it's good yeah oh yeah she saw she saw a very pouty pinky pie removing the adrenaline needle from her chest what the adrenaline needle yeah so like rainbow dash is passed out because she's going to like a shock yeah so pinky pie is like uh-uh here's your epinephrine you you're coming back this motherfuckers saw Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction and decided to write a fucking My Little Pony Horror Story. Is that not what happened? It's becoming abundantly clear to me. Stomping her hooves, the frustrated Pinky lashed out. Didn't anybody teach you any manners? It's very rude to fall asleep when somebody invites you over to spend time with them. How would you like if I came over to your house and went to sleep? Oh, I'm sorry, Dash. You're boring. I think I'll take a nap. You think I always like doing this by myself? I told you how excited I got when I found you were next. I was excited to have a friend be here with me while I worked. But no! You've got to be inconsiderate! You know, I thought you were tough. I thought you could handle anything. I've had fowls stand up better than you. Do I have to baby you? Is that how you want me to remember you? As a baby? She stopped to catch her breath. Dash blinked and softly cried. Her back was on fire. Pinkie then popped something red into her mouth and began to chew. She noticed Dash was staring at her. What? Oh, this? Holding up another piece. Well, while you were asleep, I got a little impatient and helped myself sample. I got it from your lake. You're not bad. Want to try some? Without waiting for a response, she shoved the strip of meat into the revolted Rainbow Dash's mouth. She immediately spit it out. Pinkie picked it up. If you didn't want it, you could have said no! She then ate the discarded, snotty morsel. It's not like you haven't had it before. Swallowing, she turned her attention to the small can on the tray. She removed the lid, revealing that it was filled with burning coals. Sitting on top of the fire were several large nails. Dash began to, like, like super hot, like, like railroad nails. I'm trying to see if there, if she is legitimately going to, like, crucify this fucking horse right now. That's what I'm wondering. God Christ! She, like, starts nailing the fucking legs in there. Dash began. dash began to panic again pinky picked up the can and walked over to dash's left carefully picking up a nail and grabbing a hammer god she positioned the spike at the seat you might be right about the horse about the horse crucifixion she positioned the spike at the seam between her leg and her hoof no pinky no no no no the hammer came down and the nail punctured under her skin the white hot burning was too much dash pulled and thrashed at the brace her skin rubbed and tore pinky tried to line up another one but couldn't find her aim she let out a frustrated grunt when she pulled the hammer back to take a wild swing dash burst out crying pinky rolled her eyes putting the hammer back down she walked back in front of her friend she stared pensively at the broken pegasus gilda didn't even cry this much when she stuck that live paris sprite down her throat pinky thought for a minute about what to do next Dash's hind legs bringing the can with him. pinkie picked up the hammer again and she drove a searing piece of metal into the bottom of dash's hoof dash screamed again pinkie put one into the other next she located the small generator on the tray tying the copper wires to the nails she gave dash a wink and flipped the switch electricity rocketed through dash's body holy shit the blue pony reacted immediately body seized muscles her hips thrust skyward and her eyes rolled back she let out a deep throat shredding cry pinkie giggled and danced in place she turned up the juice dash convulsed uncontrollably her bladder emptied once more gosh just talk about like you what fucking i mean on herself i need to know what torture like what what they googled for the tour this is so specific even down to like nailing the fucking like nailing it into the bottom of the foot or whatever brutal but then even just like literal copper wiring and just like formed like this torture electric electricity device whatever just shock therapy i i don't know what happened to the guy that wrote this sergeant sprinkles or whatever but someone should check on him after about five minutes pinkie shut off the power the area smelled lightly of cooked flesh and burnt enamel but oh my what a deep she put dash upright again and tried to snap the delirious and drooling pony back to attention ash dash wake up rainbow dash managed to give her a modicum of weak acknowledgement pinkie reached into the medicine bag and pulled out a large syringe all right time for the last round dash looked at the needle and picky took that as a question as to what it was something to take the pain away she informed as she walked around to dash's ruined backside she stuck the needle into the lower part of her spine dash flinched coming to the front again she told her friend in a few minutes you won't be able to feel anything below your ribcage then you'll be able to stay awake to watch the harvest jesus christ my god dash started to cry again she trembled out yeah i want to go home yeah i can see you wanting to do it i want to do that sometimes i just want to give up and say i'm done with this mess and go to bed but you know what you get shrunk off your responsibilities gotta pull yourself up and meet the challenges head on that's really the way you're gonna get ahead in life dash cried minutes passed and the drug took effect dash was numb from her chest to her flanks aware of this binky approached with her scalpel with only a smiling glance to dash she made a long cut across her pelvis just above her crotch moving up her body she drew a similar incision under her ribs one final cut was made down her stomach connecting the first two looks like i got my eye on you rainbow dash draws a giant vivisection eye god it's like i got my eye on you i tell you what good good good actual quotes from a psychopath i just want to say that joke i know yeah legitimately this is good for a movie it reminds me of like you know that scene in uh the departed where uh jack nicholson shoots that girl and he's like she fell funny oh yeah yeah like that kind of that i hate to say this reminds me of a scored safety i mean we have two prolific directors while reading this and it came naturally mind you isaiah it came naturally all right looks like i got my eye on you with a moist gooey sound the new door flapped open the new door so so sick to refer to like someone's an open wound my god the side of her own organs and the lack of feeling caused dash's breathing to intensify pinky sliced open the abdominal sack and grabbed the large intestines separating it from the rest of the digestive tract and pulling them from the forming cavity pinky was getting jovial and started making jokes dash growing weaker from the new source of blood loss tried to shut out the comedy act pinky was laughing look at me i'm a rarity she said slinging the tube around her neck and spreading blood in all directions isn't my new scarf so pretty reaching back in she cut the smaller intestine off the bowels squeezing out the excess oh my god squeezing out the excess excrement pinky filed it through her teeth and dragged it back and forth tend to say you gotta floss every day dash god she's got blood in her teeth good my my god is it this has to be over this is this is just getting so vile my god raymond dash was barely aware of the fact that she was slinging the tube around her neck and putting it in the mouth of her mouth and then she slung the tube around her neck and then she slung the tube around her neck and then she slung the tube around her neck and then she slung the tube around her neck of what was going on anymore the shock was causing her to fade pinky got disappointed diving back into the gut she ramped up her routine don't go yet don't go yet dash she start that alone is freaky cutting someone open to being like don't go yeah like don't like hang around a little bit longer so creepy yeah she started pulling out the rest of the organs stopping at each one i know it could be a real pain achius but you know i'm just kidney with you you really got to learn to liver it up oh boy these jokes are getting bladder guess you got to develop a stomach for them i would if i would just i'd be screaming kill me kill me she placed the discarded body parts into a bucket keeping the last one for a bit longer bagpipes she said placing the tube in her mouth and the organ in her armpit a spurt of acid hit her tongue oh hey there's your cupcake rainbow dash the cupcake she ate earlier getting blown out of her dissected stomach it's like that thing i've talked about before where it's like kids don't understand how heavy it's awesome they're saying something into a story but it's an entire story about just the heaviness it's it's unbelievable how gripped i am and i hope to god that this child is locked up somewhere as a full-blown adult it's gonna be like the rob zombie remake of halloween where they're like i treated you good mikey and like michael myers is like this the kid who wrote this now is like a six foot seven super soldier that they're like keeping it in the same that's you your daily training yeah i just get thrown into a wall oh dash didn't hear her she had slipped from me and she was like oh my god i can't wait to see her she had slipped from consciousness minutes ago pinky not satisfied yet hit her with another adrenaline shot dash woke up for the last time her heart jumping her blood flowed out faster it wouldn't be long now pinky put dash down on her back and straddled her chest scalpel ready you know dash disappointed i thought she would have lasted longer i really wanted to spend more time with you before we got here but i guess it's my fault i should have taken it a little slower oh well it was really nice knowing you rainbow dash the blade sunk into the blue one's throat and worked its way up her chin coming back down it's circled around her neck the last thing dash felt was her skin being cut away from her skull the metal scraping her teeth then she was gone pinky pie stared into the mirror she did a really good job even keeping the eyelids she winked dash winked back pinky smiled oh she carved off her face and now she's wearing it yeah yeah i'm sorry was that not clearer yeah who am i what did i think happened but still she was sad that her friend was now gone it only lasted 50 minutes not nearly as long as she wanted she looked back the cadaver hanging there in the center of the room the last of its fluids draining into the pan yep no more Rainbow Dash. Then Pinkie cocked her head. She was starting to take notice of the fact that there really wasn't that much damage. In fact, she began to say, I think an idea exploded in her head. She was good at sewing and she had all the pieces. All she had to do was put her back together. Yeah, just get some stuffing and bingo. She'd have Rainbow Dash forever. In fact, that's what she'd do for all her friends when their numbers came up. She was so excited, she skipped over to the body with the Skinner to get started. Cupcakes can wait. Pinkie had a friend to make. Silver Spoon suddenly woke up. She was on her back. I assume this is another pony. She was on her back and couldn't move. She couldn't see. Where was she? Freaking out, she was just about to scream when the pony from the bakery appeared in front of her. Hi. where am i what's going on okay so since it says the frightened little foal i imagine this is a child so foals like a little horse right but i like that voice for like the little girl that's good oh well you see your number came up and i gotta make cupcakes wait well why are you what does that mean what are you talking about oh nothing i wouldn't worry if i was you it'll be over soon she approached the girl scalpel at the ready when a small voice called out for miss pinky what do you think you're doing she paused and turned to look at apple bloom the yellow baby pony walked up to her with an angry look on her face silver spoon started to feel relieved i can't believe you're doing this i thought you said this one's gonna be mine pinky apologized sorry about that guess i forgot here you go she handed the blade over apple bloom climbed on the table and stood over her prey silver spoon tried to struggle she stared in fear at apple bloom in her apron the pink apron with the shiny tiara on it silver spoon started to cry apple bloom grinned and opened her mouth hey silver spoon guess there's gonna be a blank flank what the fuck does that mean so i think so it flanks like the rear end of the horse like the back side so i imagine you know how like the my little pony things have the little they each have a shape on them or like a little bit of a shape on them like a symbol or something i think that means they're going to cut off the logo or whatever i'll tell you what because that's the end i guess and i want to say something one word isaiah cinema absolute cinema pure untapped cinema that uh little did i know that i needed to hear a child in great detail write a my little pony fan fiction that is just that is a hundred percent googled resources of torture and it was done so well yeah this is so far from one like a bad thing that we've read that this this even makes some of the longer serious stories we read it puts them to shame dare i say and to have a an evil twist where another pony is in on it as well cinema so i'm glad you enjoyed that it was admittedly more intense than i remember because in my head it was like oh it's like all the other you know kind of like you remember when we read the uh the simpsons one where it's like bark fell out of a plane and exploded or whatever i just kind of imagined it like all of those but this was far more intense and detailed than i remembered so it seems that the name of the sergeant sprinkles real name is drekker jones he originally posted it to 4chan uh cupcakes gained enough notoriety to guard her lengthy sub pages jones is stated in a journal entry on his deviant art profile that he never expected it to go any further than sharing it on 4chan he calls it the most infamous thing in the fandom and he's not sure what to think about its popularity let me look up the sergeant sprinkles his real name is actually david foster wallace and and this was his follow-up to infinite jest okay it looks like he's not in jail it looks like he's posting recently they have they have internet in his i don't know how deviant art works but they have internet and that is true it might be that yeah the funniest thing is when i type it in the first thing i see is a law firm called decker jones so it's funny if he is a paralegal now that is so sick drekker jones it'd be so funny if he's like defending people in court and that's like what he did for i don't want to have to i don't want to have to cut off your horn mr mr jones would you stop it i don't want to have to scalp the defendant sergeant sprinkles okay so yeah uh there's a bunch of different alternate endings different versions people have seen uh there was an animation i remember someone made an animation of this way back when because i saw i remember seeing clips from it when i was a kid the sheer thought that a child had the idea to not only once not only twice but three times use an adrenaline shot to wake their victim so they could feel an experience more of this torture is so haunting to think that a child knows that that i was like trying to think when i'm younger i don't think i really understood what adrenaline did so the idea that a child knew that it scares me even more there's so many layers to this that's just so so great and they wrote the sociopath in such a believable way really i mean i just have to tip i'm looking on i'm looking on the mlp fan art website and there's a bunch of unofficial alternate endings i don't even know if you've ever heard of it but i think it's a really good one and if you haven't you should definitely check it out because it's a really good one i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's a really good one and i think it's on to the fact that they're eating rainbow dash um when she is uh the whole story was a nightmare blah blah blah uh this one's great celestia's celestia's everfree forest run ranger hoof swat swat team storms the cellar prevents peaky pie from applying lethal damage to rainbow dash and takes her into custody another version the police show up and kill pinky pie i kind of love that too i love the my little pony swat team comes in and it's just like freeze that's such a fun idea also how do they not deliver the final blow like if it's like towards like that fucking pony's dead that pony is going to die yeah you would have been a nice ending too is that if uh rainbow dash did survive this whole ordeal rainbow dash is like blind missing a fucking leg and a wheelchair and a sane asylum and like it's she sees it's nubs whatever and so it's just like you made it out all right and we're so happy you survived and then rainbow dash is like you know what's the point some kind of existential thing if she's just like i'll never fly again right yeah i think i think that's i think it's good if it becomes like a war drama like a jacob's ladder kind of thing exactly it's all parallel for like like faith and belief and stuff like that and like all this other stuff yeah that'd be so sick then it hard cuts back to her dying on the table like it was all just like her trial of faith yeah it's like all that happened in like the last few seconds of her life that was her life flashing before her eyes it's sick well rainbow dash eventually loses her sanity and kills pinky pie in an alternate version of the story rainbow dash brings pinky pie to the hospital and they reconcile oh my god of course of course of course there's somebody who's like yeah but a happy ending would be kind of cool though yeah hey actually i totally i totally forgive you i totally forgive you for cutting off my wings and torturing me and shooting my fucking my cupcake out of my bladder or whatever and using it like a fucking like bon scott and acdc whatever uh i really appreciate that uh well that's your story for this week i honestly am thrilled this was a god what a this was a nice refresher man i really enjoyed this one i'm glad this meant so much it did it really did and i hope i hope we could get more of this kind of stuff in the future because this is what this is what we also need man this is this is what creepy pastas are this is creepy pasta i admittedly better than better than i remembered uh but still i can never forgive you for putting this out there there's going to be a thumbnail with my face on it and i'm going to put it on the that's related to my little pony forever you're going to be having sex with my little with my little pony that's what i'm going to do no no you bet i'm saying this right i have a reputation to keep in my community no i would never do that i would never do that uh yeah yes you know i would give you permission to do that in a heart i would never do it thank you so much to our audio listeners for listening over on spotify and apple podcasts and stuff and also a huge shout out to our patrons we appreciate you everyone we will see you in the next one stay creeped the one of me holding a being collared by an old man was bad enough do not put me in a compromising situation with the horse thank you the end bye I'm going to go ahead and do that. We'll see you next time. hi i'm karen slaughter if you love untangling mysteries and uncovering the truth behind what really happened i think you'll love the good daughter You should have died in them woods. From page to screen, Don't Miss the Good Daughter, now streaming only on Peacock. I'm here, Charlie, and I'm not going away.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The podcast explores the creepypasta fan fiction "Cupcakes," a horror story written by a young child and attributed to "Sergeant Sprinkles" (David Foster Wallace), which gained notoriety online.
  2. The story details a horrifying, graphic sequence in which Pinky Pie tortures Rainbow Dash using medical tools, electric shock, dissection, and psychological torment.
  3. Despite its extreme content, the story is presented as a chilling example of child-authored internet horror, with detailed and disturbing descriptions that evoke a sense of unease and psychological depth.
  4. The narrative blends My Little Pony lore with surreal, violent horror, creating a surreal and unsettling contrast between the show’s wholesome image and its dark, fan-created content.
  5. The creators highlight how the story’s authenticity and disturbing realism make it one of the most impactful and unforgettable creepypastas, surpassing many longer, more serious horror tales.
  6. The story’s origins trace back to 4chan in early 2011, and it has inspired numerous alternate endings, animations, and fan interpretations, including police intervention or a tragic, violent resolution.
  7. The podcast reflects on the cultural phenomenon of internet fandoms and how they can become breeding grounds for bizarre and disturbing content.
  8. The hosts express both horror and fascination at the story’s execution, noting its influence on internet horror culture and its potential as a powerful example of child-driven creativity gone dark.

Summary:

The podcast features a deep dive into the infamous My Little Pony fan fiction horror story "Cupcakes," originally posted on 4chan in 2011 and attributed to a young writer known as "Sergeant Sprinkles" (later linked to David Foster Wallace). The story follows a dark, graphic sequence in which Pinky Pie, a fictional character from the show, tortures Rainbow Dash using medical tools, dissection, electric shock, and psychological torment. Despite the extreme violence, the narrative is presented as a chilling and authentic example of child-authored internet horror, blending the show’s wholesome image with grotesque, detailed violence.

The creators highlight how the story’s realism, layered horror, and dark satire—such as the use of adrenaline shots and torture techniques—exceed many traditional creepypastas in intensity and psychological impact. The podcast also explores the broader cultural phenomenon of internet fan fiction, where fandoms like My Little Pony become spaces for disturbing creative expression. Multiple alternate endings are discussed, including police intervention, a hospital reunion, or Rainbow Dash’s survival with trauma.

Ultimately, the story is presented not just as a horror tale, but as a profound cultural artifact that reveals the potential for dark creativity in online communities, especially when influenced by young writers and internet culture. The hosts express both revulsion and fascination, acknowledging its disturbing power while recognizing its significance in the evolution of creepypasta.

FAQs

The Good Daughter is a mystery series based on a best-selling novel, starring Rose Byrne, Megan Fahey, and Brendan Gleeson. It is now streaming exclusively on Peacock.

The 'Cupcakes' creepypasta is a horror fan fiction written by a young child, attributed to a user named Sergeant Sprinkles (real name David Foster Wallace), and first posted on 4chan in January 2011.

Yes, the 'Cupcakes' story is widely regarded as the first horror fan fiction in the My Little Pony universe, and possibly the first horror story ever written by a child in an online fan community.

The story features graphic, detailed descriptions of torture, mutilation, and psychological horror, which are shocking and intense, highlighting the disturbing power of a child's imagination.

Yes, there are multiple versions and alternate endings, including one where Pinky is killed by law enforcement, another where Rainbow Dash survives and goes to a psychiatric hospital, and a happy ending where they reconcile.

Sergeant Sprinkles is the fictional author of the 'Cupcakes' story. His real name is David Foster Wallace, though this has been debated; some sources suggest it may be a mix-up with Drekker Jones, a paralegal known for internet content.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.