Go back

460: Cruise Ship Murder, Child Predator Sting & 3-Year-Old Says “Mama Cut Papa” To Babysitter

42m 58s

460: Cruise Ship Murder, Child Predator Sting & 3-Year-Old Says “Mama Cut Papa” To Babysitter

Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is scheduled for March 29, 2027, following an 11-to-1 jury verdict in her favor at the first trial, with prosecutors planning to reattempt the same first-degree murder charges despite a lack of formal confirmation. The case reflects ongoing tension over whether the prosecution will pursue lesser charges or maintain original accusations. Concurrently, a cruise ship homicide in Galveston involved Jason Watford, who allegedly strangled his wife during an argument on board, with a prior history of domestic violence and criminal convictions. In a separate sting operation, Preston Purdy was arrested in New York for planning to sexually assault and harm fictitious children, openly admitting to using assault tools and intending to have a child pregnant and groomed. A disturbing case in Orlando involves Eugenio Martinez, found dead in an apartment, with his girlfriend Isidra Hernandez arrested for allegedly hiding his body after an argument, while a three-year-old child reportedly made alarming statements about "mama cutting papa." The Michaela settles case saw Steven, the father of a victim of incest, re-arrested on a probation violation just days after release, raising serious questions about justice and sentencing adequacy. These cases collectively underscore how deeply entrenched child predator crimes are, with victims often receiving minimal consequences. The use of private sting operations to catch predators, while effective, raises ethical concerns about vigilantism and the potential for systemic failures in law enforcement. The narratives emphasize the trauma of children witnessing violence, the danger of under-punishment, and the need for stronger accountability in cases involving abuse and predation.

Transcription

8547 Words, 45606 Characters

English
If I'm being 100% honest, it feels like I handed my daughter to the devil. A new trial date set for Lindsay Clancy, March 29. That's if prosecutors decide to pursue a retrial. The FBI is now involved a possible homicide on board, and what witnesses say they saw on board that ship. A private child predator sting operation led to the arrest of a Colorado man accused of traveling to Saratoga County. Police say a three-year-old girl told her babysitter that her mama had cut her pop-up. Hey, true crime besties. Welcome back to an all-new episode of Serialistly. Hello, hello, hello, and welcome back to an all-new episode of Serialistly with me, your host, Annie Elise. Hope you are having a fantastic Thursday so far. A good week. All the amazing things, because you know what I'm going to say. I'm about to dump all over it, especially with all the cases we have to talk about today. There is so much happening right now. And I just got the notification, actually, that yesterday, Thomas Markle was charged with more child assault charges in the Philippines this time. So I think that's going to be one of those situations where it's like, lock him up and throw away the key. But, I mean, more to come on that. We're not talking about Thomas Markle today, but still wanted to just give you that little itsy-bitsy update. But a lot to talk about today. We have a couple case updates, some brand-new cases. I know a lot of you have also been DMing about the case. I know a lot of you have also been DMing about the cruise ship murder that happened in Galveston, Texas a couple weeks ago. We were waiting on some more documents to come in from that that we had requested. So have a lot of information regarding that to share with you. Some brand-new cases and, yeah, like I said, some updates. So I'm really excited because today we do have a special guest joining. I know you've heard from her, I think, once or twice on this podcast before. But it's my tortoise-lurving sister, Amy Collette. Hi. Hi. Welcome to the show. Thanks. Do you know why I said you're a tortoise-lurving? No. Your nails. Oh. She did what's called tiger's eye, I think they call it, or it's like marbling or something. Cat eye. Cat, that's it. That's what the kids are calling it. Yeah, but it's brown. I know. Celine convinced me. Okay. She said, you always stick to the same two colors. Let's go outside the box. And I felt like you'd be comfortable. I like it. And you have the brown heels. Even though you shaded me this week for my heels, that heel is not much higher. It's not higher. Okay. Fair. I did have quite a few people, though, in my Instagram who were responding to the story. They're like, that's not a heel. But they were also dying because I rarely hear a click clack coming around the office from your direction. So I was like, oh my gosh, she's dressed up. And I was awaiting for this outfit reveal. And it was the smallest heel known to man. The outfit was good. No, the outfit was great. I just was expecting, I guess, like a dressier outfit for the sound coming. And you know what? If you guys don't follow me on Instagram or Amy, you're missing out on things like that, behind the scenes content, because it was a hoot. I had a lot of laughter responses as well. Yeah. It reminds me of Luann in the iconic, where were they traveling in housewives? Where she's all, is that a buffalo coming down the stairs? I think they're in Morocco and then with Alex McCord. Alex flips the shawl and she's like, I'd like to speak with you. Oh, yeah. Not disrupting our henna. It's so good. I know. So I wasn't in a Maloof. I wasn't in a Maloof. I wasn't in a Maloof, but I was. I thought there was going to be a big reveal and it was a really small one. I know. Everybody was laughing at how you're like, did you get a nail stuck in your shoe? I don't know what. But that one is not much bigger. Fair. I feel like we need to measure them against each other. I know. Well, these were my Ibiza heels, like one outfit option. Because I'm like, I got to look kind of chic at the club, but also I'm dancing for hours. At the what? The clurb. The clurb. Thank you. Thank you. We only speak in clurbs on here. No, but I'm loving the nails. It's funny because I think that you and I have changed. I have gotten this exact. Same color now for literally three months because now I'm a creature of habit and I don't know what to do. I'm rubbing off on you. You are. But now I'm rubbing off on you. Look at that. Sister swap. I almost said on my thing yesterday or whatever day that was. Freaky Friday. Oh, wasn't that where they like switch spots? How much do people want to kill us right now? A lot. And we have the same Tumblr. Wake up. Do do do. Okay. People. I hate us. Let's get into it. Okay. So first. We're going to start with this Lindsay Clancy update because there was another hearing earlier this week. That's when we were supposed to learn. Okay. When's the retrial happening? What are the charges? What's going on? And sure enough, they're back in court on Monday. So this was where we were going to finally get that update, as I said, but there was quite a bit of arguing over when the second trial should happen. However, we finally have a date and I have to say it's sooner than I expected. So really quickly to recap. As you guys know, Lindsay's first trial ended in a mistrial after the jury couldn't reach a unanimous verdict. It was, however, definitely favoring Lindsay because 11 of the 12 jurors believed that she was not criminally responsible for the murder of her three children. However, there was one juror who disagreed. So she's now going through this whole process all over again. And I have to say, I'm kind of surprised at the charges that apparently are going to be revisited during this trial only because it was an 11 to 1 in her favor of not guilty by reason of insanity. So I had assumed, too, especially because during the jury instructions, the judge had said that manslaughter was on the table and that they could find her guilty of that, which is obviously far less than first degree. So my thought was, oh, OK, if they do retry her or when they retry her, if they don't reach a plea agreement, maybe it will be the lesser charge of manslaughter because they'll be more confident in a conviction with that. So are you surprised that they did schedule a retrial? Not entirely. I kind of thought in the beginning, like right off of the heels of the first trial, that they would come up with a plea deal. I thought there was going to be something happening. But then as more time went on and as they had the hearings, I was like, oh, no, they are going to plan to retry her. I think I don't know if it's fully out of ego necessarily that like the prosecutors want the win and they want the conviction. But I also think because like, hello, somebody does need to be held criminally responsible for the deaths of these three children. So I'm not surprised there. I am a bit surprised with the charges I'm hearing about. And at the time of this recording, it's not. It's not confirmed to my knowledge that those are the charges, but it appears that way based on what was said. So let me kind of tell you what happened. So during Monday's hearing, the prosecutors made it clear that they do intend to move forward with another jury trial, which is interesting, though, because as I just mentioned, they still haven't officially confirmed whether they're going to pursue the same first degree murder charges, which she was facing three different counts of first degree murder. However, Lindsay's attorney, Reddington, said that you can pretty much read between the lines on why they do want a jury trial. And you can tell what those charges are going to be based on that fact alone. If they were planning on reducing the charges, there would be an option of having a bench trial where the judge would just decide on the case rather than a jury. So again, reading between the lines, he believes that they are planning to go after the same charges again, but only time will tell. Now, honestly, most of this hearing was spent kind of going back and forth on when this retrial would actually happen because prosecutors wanted to push it out till May. Judge Sullivan, though, was pushing for a March date. He wanted the trial to happen in March so that they had plenty of time to finish it before his mandatory retirement. And despite prosecutors pushing back and arguing, scheduling conflicts, trials that are going all the way until the end of April or May and things like that, the judge basically said, nope, the date is going to be March 29th, 2027. And he told them, you know, you're just going to have to figure it out amongst yourselves. But that is when the trial is happening. So for now, Lindsay is due back in court on December 30th for another status hearing, February 18th for the pretrial conference. And unless something changes between now and then, her second trial is set to begin the end of March, which I don't know how long that jury selection process is going to take because to find a non-biased. Yeah. And I mean, it was lengthy already the first time around and they had more jurors than they needed. But I think that how are you going to find someone who's unfamiliar with this case at that at this point, who's unbiased, who. I would imagine too, each side is probably going to be a bit more detailed on what type of, I don't know, requirements, but like criteria the jurors fit because they're going to really be now closely looking at, oh, it was an 11 to one. We really need to get the jury right. And I think that already is going to be more intentional. So then you layer in the fact that every single person in the world pretty much knows about this case. I just, that is not going to be an easy feat. Do you think that the charges, the new potential charges and the timing? Of the case, was it all influenced by, I felt like there was a lot of chatter during the trial about potentially someone else being held responsible and just a lot of different theories, which I feel like has quieted down quite a bit. So do you feel like that might have anything to do with it? I don't think that had anything to do with the retrial necessarily, but I wouldn't be surprised if the defense strategy changed up this time based on all of that, because you could already see towards the end of the last trial and then immediately after. That Reddington was aware of everything going on and so on social media, and he was saying little things. to elude and cast doubt and he even brought one of the tiktokers in who like bombed on the stand and didn't even get through uh what year but i i wouldn't be surprised if the defense strategy changed up a bit to create more doubt even though reddington himself has said multiple times patrick didn't do this patrick's a good husband he should be like free to live his life and move on and i don't think he actually believes that patrick did anything but obviously he's going to put forth the best defense for his client so we'll see um in another update i am very very excited to announce this update because we have news in the michaela settles case now we just talked about this case on monday this week we also talked about it a little bit last thursday but i did the deep dive for you on monday she is the 18 year old girl who moved to california to reconnect with her biological father the scumbag dirtbag piece of shit human being that he is you sexually assaulted her for over four hours she had to get carried into the er he pleaded guilty to incest but said that it was consensual and michaela ended up taking her own life also because he pled guilty to incest and furnishing alcohol to a minor all he received was one year in county jail and he only served six months and he was released last week which pissed me off that's why we talked about it last thursday and then i did the deep dive just a few days later and i did the deep dive just a few days later and i did the deep dive just a few days later and i did the deep dive just a few days later and i did the deep dive just a few days later and because now he has been re-arrested which makes me so beyond excited because even though it's not an arrest or a punishment that i think at all fits the severity of the crime it's at least something because just four days after his release steven was once again arrested and according to court records steven was arrested around 4 30 p.m on november 13th he was officially booked at 6 27 p.m and he was arrested on november 13th and he was officially booked at 6 27 p.m and he was arrested his bail was listed at zero dollars which means that he will stay in jail and he is not able to be bailed out now as of the time of this recording we don't know exactly what steven did to be arrested again however we do know that it was a probation violation however that could mean a number of things it could be that he didn't register in the amount of time that was required that he didn't check in with his probation officer he didn't provide an address which he was supposed to do within five days and i've heard that might be actually what it was i don't i haven't been able to confirm though what the violation itself was or if there were multiple perhaps but here's where things could get interesting and why i am very excited about this some reports say that when steven was originally sentenced the judge had ordered a zero tolerance piece of it when it came to his probation conditions now basically what that means is that his probation officer is required to report every single violation to the judge regardless of what it is so for steven we're talking about things like you know missing a scheduled check-in drinking alcohol which he's not allowed to do viewing content on his phone that he's no longer allowed to or failing to register or pay his restitution so rather than just getting a warning or a second chance or you know a light little you know slap on the wrist any single violation could result in steven having his probation revoked so he could be ordered to serve more time behind bars potentially up to the maximum sentence allowed for his original conviction which is the maximum sentence allowed for his original conviction which in this case was three years if you remember the prosecutors wanted the full three years which is so crazy to think it's only three years but because it was only the felony incest charge and the giving alcohol to a minor that's the maximum there he never was tried for assault because michaela was no longer there to testify but even though the prosecutors had asked for the maximum of three years the judge only gave him one which pissed everyone off and even the prosecutors were like no that's not like that's not what we want that's not at all what we want and so that's not at all what we think is fair now i do want to stress none of this is guaranteed we don't know the circumstances surrounding the latest arrest and there's a legal process that of course will need to play out before any of that could happen but i mean considering the fact that he only was out of jail for four days and then got arrested again not only is it a surprise but i believe it's like karma and divine intervention whatever you believe in and want to call it and even if he doesn't know like i know it's not enough it's not enough at all in comparison to the crime that he committed but at least it is something and at least his freedom is being taken away and i did see a comment on the deep dive that i thought was like so well put basically the reason the judge only sentenced him to one year even though the prosecution was pushing for three is because one of the conditions of that of getting the full maximum sentence has to be that the defendant consents to that and like agrees to doing the full sentence which i kind of went on a rant in my deep dive i'm like okay well tell me what fucking defendant is gonna make yeah even though you're only gonna give me one i think i do deserve the three like give me the full sentence like that will never happen but i thought that it was interesting because somebody actually commented and said something i'm paraphrasing here along the lines of like oh so michaela's consent didn't matter but steven's consent matters when it comes to his punishment and i thought that that was like just such a well like yeah exactly so i will definitely be keeping an eye on this one i will let you guys know what happens next this creep is on my radar and i'm gonna blast his face everywhere i possibly can because i think that he is disgusting and neat you know he needs to be off the streets he's a predator period well hopefully that weak ass sentence pissed a lot of people off to where they are keeping eyes on him so any small violation they're like ready to take him to task for it and then also what a moron if he didn't fill out his paperwork or whatever but good we love morons yeah we love morons yeah oh i know okay well this next one is the case that you brought up about the cruise ship that has been all over the news and it involves a woman who went on a caribbean cruise and just hours out of leaving texas she was found dead inside her cabin awful so on sunday november 8th 31 year old susan watford and her husband 48 year old jason watford boarded the msc seascape in galveston texas for a seven-day caribbean cruise but then that evening a housekeeper came by their cabin and when she got home she was like oh my god i'm gonna die i'm gonna die i'm gonna die i'm gonna die and she knocked on the door jason answered with what appeared to be blood on his hands and clothing and when the housekeeper looked inside the cabin she saw susan lying face down on the floor and she was completely motionless she immediately went to get help but sadly susan was already dead now as investigators started piecing together what happened they reviewed the surveillance footage from the ship and found out that susan and jason had gotten into an cruise ship the argument apparently continued after they left but at some point they separated and the surveillance footage showed jason going into their cabin at around 7 46 p.m with susan following just about 25 minutes later and after that neither of them were seen entering or leaving the cabin until that housekeeper showed up and when fbi agents questioned jason he allegedly did admit that he had gotten so angry during their argument that he just snapped he told him investigators that he repeatedly struck susan before strangling her with his hands and arm for around four or five minutes and he only stopped because he was actually physically exhausted from strangling her and according to the affidavit after he stopped susan had been lying there motionless on the floor for about 10 minutes and that was when that housekeeper arrived to their cabin door and what makes all of this even more heartbreaking is that the couple's young daughter was reportedly inside of the cabin when all of this went down now thankfully she wasn't hurt but obviously i can't even imagine what she may have seen and we've been hearing about this a lot lately it's just these terrible violent crimes happening right with children present which is just unbelievable i think i saw too and i don't know if you saw this that after he left the cabin he was just like scrolling on his phone and just like casual and cool just like nothing happened like not disassociating but yeah like not a care in the world like not even why weren't you with your child why weren't you consoling like i i have so many questions it's wild now the ship ultimately then changed course and headed back to galveston shortly after midnight on monday november 9th and jason was taken into custody later that afternoon and he's now facing a federal murder charge and if convicted he could face up to life in prison and a 250 000 fine is it a federal murder charge do you know because it's on a maritime crime i believe so because it's on the water love that and he was in route to the caribbean which international waters but they were i don't it doesn't sound like they were too far out of a seven-day cruise but i think anything on the water is federal yeah i think so yeah good well now listen to this as more information's coming out we've actually learned that jason has a pretty extensive criminal history and it includes one attempted murder conviction in the past i know so back in 1996 he was convicted of attempted first degree murder in illinois along with aggravated battery involving a firearm and a gun and he was convicted of attempted first degree murder and drug-related offenses he received a 10-year prison sentence but we don't actually know who the victim was in that case and then in september 2024 jason was arrested for assaulting susan during an argument about money at their texas home so there was obviously a history there of some sort of domestic violence and according to court records susan had recorded audio of that confrontation and you could hear jason getting more and more aggressive while she repeatedly told him to back away from her she reportedly tried to get away from him and even tried to get away from him and even used a stun gun during that incident wow so obviously it sounds like it like escalated yeah and a history of just like him being dangerous and to have that like readily available like prepared to use it so sounds like there was maybe even previous incidents of that so jason ultimately pleaded guilty to misdemeanor assault in that case and was sentenced to 15 months of probation as well as community service now following that incident in 2024 susan and jason had separated but according to susan's adoptive mother dorothy mast susan eventually started to believe that he had changed dorothy recently spoke out and explained that susan had gone on this cruise to figure out whether their marriage could be repaired or if they needed to get a divorce which we've heard unfortunately oftentimes before and susan apparently did feel hopeful because jason had just finished all of his court-ordered anger management classes counseling and his community service but dorothy she still had serious concerns rightly so and she actually begged susan not to go she remembered telling her daughter i asked her not to go i asked her not to go but susan had told her i need to do it for me and that's really obviously what makes this all so heartbreaking is dorothy begging her daughter not to go on this cruise susan trying to decide whether her marriage was worth saving and to give it another chance and then just ultimately never ended up coming home i'd imagine too if she was at that crossroads of trying to figure out like okay this is the last moment let's see if we can reconnect let's see if things have changed i would think that she probably felt safe being on a cruise ship like surely he won't do anything around other people we are on like a populated vessel it's not behind closed doors at our house like i'm safe here we can try to enjoy ourselves have fun reconnect the child is there all of these things and it's like nothing would stop this guy because like clearly you're not going anywhere if on a ship the ship's on the water like kind of like anna kempter like you aren't you're where do you think you're gonna go to get away from this when it doesn't sound like it was premeditated so was this guy obviously has a serious anger problem and has had a history of it but can you imagine it's like you just wrapped up your anger management classes you're going you have this fresh start potentially to rekindle things with your ex-wife and then and again the fact of the matter that you have your child there right like nothing can stop you yeah it's it's wild disgusting well okay this next case i don't know if you've heard much about this one i've actually been talking to a couple people who have spoken with the members involved in the sting operation it's been all over my feed but i've been kind of like hesitant to go into it because even what i was just seeing through the headlines was so disturbing and disgusting and it happened in new york so we're going back to new york this week just like last week some of the details are actually so graphic and awful that i can't share them here i'm gonna still go through them and i'm gonna share them i'll give a trigger warning though for everybody listening what i am going to share is still more than enough to understand the case and i will try to you know work around the details to so you can be fully in the know but research independently with caution okay now thankfully as sting operations go none of the children actually existed that were plants for this it was all adults behind the screen however the man was caught and he was allegedly planning to do beyond disturbing things to these fictitious children that had been served up and offered up to him so the man is preston purdy and he had reportedly been communicating with a man named eric authors for about a month now eric has been conducting private predator stings for more than 20 years and in this case he was posing as a single mother who was offering her three children to men for sexual purposes the children were supposedly a three-year-old girl with autism an eight-year-old girl and an 11-year-old boy and preston who lived in colorado allegedly told eric that he was willing to fly all the way to new york to meet these kids and he fully did all of that he flew all the way to new york on november 9th then took an uber to a home in malta where he believed this mother and her son were in a relationship and he was willing to fly all the way to new york and her children were there waiting for him he also brought an obscene amount of sex toys i don't even like feel like you can say that like i don't even want to say that word like assault toys i guess you could say assault weapons zip ties all sorts of things with the intention of like inflicting horrific assault on these three children which again as a reminder these three children are fictitious okay but he thought they were real so when he got there he was confronted by eric and members of the group called new york state predator alert they live streamed the entire thing on facebook as well and during that confrontation preston made very sick foul dark sinister admissions he wasn't holding anything back he basically owned it from the very start saying what he fully intended to do at one point he was asked whether he would actually have followed through with sexually assaulting the kids if they had been real and if they were there and he said he could pretty much guarantee that at least some of what he had planned particularly involving the eight-year-old girl would have happened he also admitted to buying a camera specifically so that he could take pictures and record himself sexually assaulting the children and like i said brought all of the paraphernalia with him as well and while i'm not going to get into everything that he allegedly described openly wanting to do one of his alleged plans was to get the eight-year-old girl pregnant and he said he was going to have to go to the hospital bring her back to colorado until she gave birth and then groom the newborn which it is absolutely sick i don't even have words and there's one screenshot i saved that i may have to kind of paraphrase around but when talking about the 11 year old boy that he also wanted to inflict this horrific assault on he talked about how he wanted to disable the boy's genitals being that i'm trying to be careful being that rough with him which again research independently if you are more curious but hopefully this is oh you know a good enough indication of what this monster was up to so just be on sick i don't even have words mj jones who leads the new york state predator alert and helped eric with the sting said that preston was one of the most evil people that they had ever encountered and apparently when preston started demonstrating what he was allegedly planning to do to these children he said he was going to have to go to the hospital and he said he was going to mj a very seasoned person with sting operations like this and with child predators mj had to step out of the room multiple times because it was so disturbing and again this guy just having no shame laying all of his cards on the table and being like open with all of his disgusting sinister plans now while all of this was happening the saratoga county sheriff's office was contacted and deputies responded to the home around at 12 15 that afternoon so preston was ultimately arrested and charged with four counts in prison and sentenced to 12 15 that afternoon so preston went to jail and was charged with four counts in prison and sentenced to 12 15 that afternoon so preston went to jail and was charged with four counts in prison and sentenced to 12 15 that afternoon first degree attempted rape and first degree aggravated sexual assault and because this was a private sting rather than an official police operation there have been a lot of questions about whether preston's hour-long live streamed statements and pseudo interrogation will actually be used against him in court thankfully the da said that prosecutors believe the video will be admissible and he said that investigators continued gathering evidence beyond what people had already seen online so even if they can't use that video they have a treasure trove of other evidence they can use but it does raise the concern of when this i don't want to call it vigilante justice because that's not exactly what this is we also know that like chris hansen does stings even though he does have law enforcement involved with them we spoke with him when he was on the podcast about all of that but it makes you wonder at what point is it done not in a reckless way but like without the right officials in place to where you could potentially lose your life let a predator like this through a loophole and then they're back on the streets or they get a much less severe punishment and again that's not what these people did it's not like these sting operations that you may have seen on tiktok where people are like meeting up at the local in and out after they've catfished someone online this is more of like a legit agency that has been doing this and who's trained to do this but still you know that it caused some worry and some questions and luckily the da put all that dress saying well no no no don't worry we have plenty of evidence anyway so again thankfully no actual children were involved in this sting operation and hopefully that live stream can and will be used in court because this whole thing is just disgusting and so disturbing so did i miss was this guy on their radar already or they just set up a sting and this guy happened to be the sickest guy ever that comes through i believe he was the sickest guy ever who came through so it wasn't like this predator they're trying to catch i think it was one is similar to how other sting operations are where you kind of like are chatting with a bunch of people see who bites see how far they take it and then you execute the sting so i guess i've been even though i've been into true crime for quite some time and followed it like i think i've been a little naive to like how deep and disgusting this goes until obviously seeing a lot of the work you do and sometimes i can't wrap my head around how there are these people and how many of them are so as you were saying all of this and this sting operation and that this person that a mother was offering up her three children this must actually happen oh it happened enough that people have now had these fantasies because they can actually do them yeah and how is this and why and i just i can't it's a lot of it so much i know a lot of it is for money where it's happened i know we talked i think a few weeks ago there was that case that we partnered with crc on in the philippines where a mother also was selling her children basically and but it was real it wasn't a sting and so usually you'll see it more in impoverished countries and things like that where there is some sort of monetary gain or um influence involved however there also is this another sect who of parents and i say that term very loosely sperm donors birth you know pods i don't even want to call them parents but this whole other sect who participate in this for their own sexual gratification or for drug exchanges or for debts or whatever it may be and there was where was it was it victoria martin's in new mexico albuquerque i think it was and it was i i i'm sorry if i'm misremembering but i believe that it was victoria martin's in albuquerque and the mother had a fantasy of watching someone with her daughter and i believe she had fed her daughter methamphetamines as well and i don't remember all the details and i might be mixing up two cases but my point being that there are so many awful people out there not only willing participants and people who seek it out but people who offer up their own children for it well that's the problem i mean they're making it accessible in some way and thank god for these i mean organizations and law enforcement that are trying to stop it but and again maybe i'm just naive but are people getting sicker out there because there's more available or has this always existed and we just didn't know about it as much because i think a little bit of both i think it always has existed that perhaps it wasn't as widely known because we didn't have it accessible to us at our fingertips like we do now also think about it a lot of mainstream media will never cover something like this you'll never see it on abc7 you'll never see it on these so it's a lot of independent media or you know journalists or podcasts or youtube channels or whomever who's bringing a lot of attention to this so it seems like it's now heightened but i also think the world is getting sicker and we talked recently too i think um i don't remember if it was a deep dive episode or if it was headline highlights so i don't know if you were here for it but i had talked about how now they're in the seventh circuit there was a possession charge of c-sam material that was completely eliminated because the c-sam material was ai generated and they were like oh there's no real victim in here so by having that material with no punishment and the use of ai people are becoming desensitized to it so it's amplifying the urge to want to do it in real life and so i think it's just this mixture of so many different things to where the world is getting sicker but we also now are getting a peek behind the curtain because people are actually reporting on things and it's just very disheartening i think that's the best word to describe it absolutely it's it breaks my heart it's so sad that people like this exist it is it's hard to wrap your mind around it i know it truly is but i'm glad that this piece of shit is going to be locked up again research with caution if you are interested but um i actually so the person i had spoken with about this case as i mentioned she has been talking with a couple of people involved in the sting and she wanted to connect me with them so there is a possibility i might do a deep dive not only on this case but like on sting operations in general how they work maybe what the statistics are with predators out there so if that is something that you guys are interested in let me know in the comments or on the spotify q and a section i know some of the feedback i get sometimes is like pump the brakes there's only so much i can handle with the children cases which i totally understand and can relate to but this one would i think be more from like an educational perspective so what i was kind of thinking of when you said exactly that was they got a lot of knowledge from this guy i mean at least he was forthright in what he was saying and gave it to them it sounds like fully and so my question would be to his neighbors friends co-workers family like what were their red flags and what to look out for for someone who is that extreme living in your community yeah it's it's so scary it's like you really never know who your neighbors are and i've kind of made not like the joke in the past but the reference of like i don't know if i am just super type a but anytime i'm like on a road trip or i'm driving somewhere i'm looking around thinking how many of these houses i'm passing have someone locked up in the basement or the how many people here have ever committed murder that i'm walking around and like those are the kinds of like intrusive thoughts that i have but it's so true that you never know who your neighbor really is you can download all the apps there's a new one i just downloaded i was going to send it to actually called warden where it shows um it's kind of like a crime stop or crime what's that one called not crime stoppers the one where it like pops up everything on the map locally to you of what's happened it's similar to that but it's only for sexual assault and um people who are on the registry so it's like you can download all that and take all these precautions but what about the person who hasn't been convicted and who's gotten away with it or who is on the start of their predator journey and so yeah it's scary it's a scary thing to think about yeah all right well this next case brings us back to florida of course it does orlando specifically and it's extremely disturbing and heartbreaking especially when we start to get into some of these details so on monday november 9th around 9 20 in the morning two maintenance workers at an apartment complex noticed a large heavy trash bag that was sitting next to a dumpster and it was covered in flies and there appeared to be blood beneath it so they decided to call 9-1-1 and when officers arrived they opened the bag and inside they found a man's body he had several cuts to his neck and on the left side of his body and based on the state of decomposition investigators believed he had been dead for quite some time and as they searched the area around that dumpster investigators found several items that appeared to be connected to the death including bloody blankets towels a broken knife and a sandal but they also found a piece of mail that had an address on it and when they looked into it they realized that the address was for an apartment that was only 800 feet away from that dumpster so they got a search warrant and when they went inside that apartment they found blood on the walls the couch and on a set of couch cushions that had been removed they also found a driver's license that belonged to a 32 year old man who was in the apartment and they found blood on the walls the couch and on a set of couch cushions that belonged to a 32 year old man who was in the apartment and they found blood on the walls the couch cushions that belonged to a 32 year old man who was in the apartment and they found blood on the walls named eugenio martinez who they recognized as the man who they had just found near the dumpster as well as an ebt card belonging to a 36 year old woman named isidra hernandez who was later identified as eugenio's girlfriend and while investigators were still at the apartment a woman approached them and said that they had some information that might be helpful in figuring out what had happened to him and what she told the police was actually extremely alarming apparently her mom had been babysitting isidra's two young kids who were just one year old and one and three years old for the last several days and earlier that morning the three-year-old had suddenly started crying saying quote mama cut papa making slicing motions along her arms she was also talking about blood and about trash so i mean you can only imagine what she may have seen the babysitter also told investigators that the last time she had seen eugenio was two or three days earlier on saturday when he came to pick up the kids she described him as drunk and loud but didn't say really anything else about it but then when isidra came back to pick up the kids the following day the babysitter noticed that she had a bruise on her arm so between what that little girl had said to her about the cutting making the motions the blood the trash and everything else that the police had found inside the apartment investigators wanted to speak to isidra to find out exactly what happened to eugenio detectives brought her in for questioning and initially she claimed that eugenio had left their apartment on his own on saturday and she hadn't seen him since now of course investigators had already found quite a bit of evidence suggesting otherwise and when they confronted her about the blood and the fact that someone had clearly tried to clean up the apartment that's when the story completely started to change she eventually admitted that he had died during an argument between the two of them but she insisted that she had actually acted in self-defense and according to her he had a knife during their argument and allegedly began choking her she initially claimed that she'd swiped his hand away and then she said she had a knife in her hand and she had a knife in her hand and she had a knife and that's when she noticed a cut to his neck she said he then fell on the ground and she got scared and ran outside and when she eventually returned into the apartment that's when she noticed that he was dead but rather than calling 9-1-1 isidra called a friend who at that time warned her that if she called police she would probably get arrested and because she was afraid she decided to instead clean up the apartment herself and move eugenio's body and according to the affidavit she tied his body with an orange extension cord wrapped around his neck and tied his body with wrapped him in three black trash bags and a dark blue laundry bag then moved him over to that dumpster area where he was later found by those maintenance workers days later now after investigators pieced together what happened and heard this account from isidra she was arrested on wednesday november 11th and charged with second degree murder in eugenio's death and while isidra is claiming that she acted in self-defense we don't exactly know what did happen during that argument or how everything unfolded inside of that apartment But what does make this especially heartbreaking as we talked about that case earlier is that it's there's very big possibility that her two young children were inside the home when all this went down because based on what that three-year-old had said and reportedly made those motions it's possible that she may have witnessed what had happened so regardless of what happens outside of this investigation which we will continue to follow and update you with any details it's just sad to you know a mother is now facing a murder charge and those two young kids are without a dad i mean i would need to know more but if the three-year-old was already saying to the babysitter mom mama cut papa all of these things if it was how she had described it of where she hit his arm and that's when she noticed the cut on his neck i don't think a three-year-old would interpret that as mama was cutting papa and i'd like to know more about the wounds i think like and the cut like the cover-ups there it's not really feeling right and like this and you know not blaming of course any the victim in any way but just like the there was that comment that the neighbor noticed the last time he picked up the kids that he was drunk so just like during their altercation was there some sort of like under the influence there or what who knows what happened you know so we'll have to follow up yeah and if she had a bruise it's possible that he was going after her and she did something but like yeah and maybe it was self-defense i don't know but like the idea that the three-year-old recounts that yes with something that would normally not be hidden but like so quick and fleeting that you wouldn't necessarily think that i don't but then again talking about blood and trash so probably there for the cleanup which that and and i mean yeah that's what leads me to think it probably wasn't planned because obviously that part of it and then you're just leaving him right outside of your yeah like to be found which feels messy and not yeah unplanned yeah all right well thank you guys so much for tuning in to another episode with us this week let us know if you want the deep dive into any of these um or we you want the guest to come on and talk about the stings if you haven't listened to the deep dive already on the michaela settles case it's on this feed from monday there's also a deep dive on tuesday on my second true crime podcast feed 10 to life it's brand new and it's a deep dive into the case of ashley and murphy she was stabbed 11 times in broad daylight and the man tried to cover it up for him wow i know it is a wild wild case so both of those are available now for you to go binge otherwise i will be back with you on monday with an all-new case thank you guys so much for tuning in and until the next one be nice don't kill people just get a divorce stay away from kids don't want to cruise and stay away from kids if you're a freak yes okay bye Thanks for watching!

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is set for March 29, 2027, after a contentious hearing over the date, with prosecutors pushing for a trial despite initially considering a plea deal.
  2. The retrial may involve the same first-degree murder charges, not a downgrade to manslaughter, as suggested by the defense’s strategy and the absence of a bench trial.
  3. A federal murder charge has been filed against Jason Watford, who allegedly strangled his wife Susan on a cruise ship in Galveston, with a history of domestic violence and prior criminal convictions.
  4. Preston Purdy, a man from Colorado, was arrested in a private sting operation for planning to sexually assault and harm fictitious children, including an 11-year-old boy and an 8-year-old girl, and admitted to having assault tools and intentions.
  5. A 32-year-old man, Eugenio Martinez, was found dead in an apartment complex in Orlando, with his girlfriend, Isidra Hernandez, arrested for second-degree murder after allegedly cleaning up the scene and hiding his body; a three-year-old child reportedly described seeing blood and "mama cut papa."
  6. The Michaela settles case saw Steven, the father of a 18-year-old victim, re-arrested on a probation violation just four days after being released from jail, raising concerns about the adequacy of his original one-year sentence.
  7. The case highlights systemic issues in how child predator crimes are prosecuted, with victims often receiving minimal punishment despite severe offenses.
  8. The use of sting operations and public livestreams to expose predators raises ethical questions about vigilante justice and the potential for underreporting or lack of accountability.

Summary:

Lindsay Clancy’s retrial is scheduled for March 29, 2027, following an 11-to-1 jury verdict in her favor at the first trial, with prosecutors planning to reattempt the same first-degree murder charges despite a lack of formal confirmation. The case reflects ongoing tension over whether the prosecution will pursue lesser charges or maintain original accusations. Concurrently, a cruise ship homicide in Galveston involved Jason Watford, who allegedly strangled his wife during an argument on board, with a prior history of domestic violence and criminal convictions.

In a separate sting operation, Preston Purdy was arrested in New York for planning to sexually assault and harm fictitious children, openly admitting to using assault tools and intending to have a child pregnant and groomed. " The Michaela settles case saw Steven, the father of a victim of incest, re-arrested on a probation violation just days after release, raising serious questions about justice and sentencing adequacy. These cases collectively underscore how deeply entrenched child predator crimes are, with victims often receiving minimal consequences.

The use of private sting operations to catch predators, while effective, raises ethical concerns about vigilantism and the potential for systemic failures in law enforcement. The narratives emphasize the trauma of children witnessing violence, the danger of under-punishment, and the need for stronger accountability in cases involving abuse and predation.

FAQs

Lindsay Clancy's retrial is scheduled for March 29, 2027.

The charges are not officially confirmed, but prosecutors appear to be pursuing the same first-degree murder charges, despite the previous 11-to-1 jury verdict in favor of not guilty by reason of insanity.

The prosecution is pushing for a retrial to hold someone criminally responsible for the deaths of the three children, and there’s no indication of a plea deal, suggesting a desire for a conviction.

The date was set by Judge Sullivan to ensure the trial concludes before his mandatory retirement, and prosecutors had to compromise on scheduling despite wanting to push it to May.

Steven, the biological father of Michaela, was re-arrested for a probation violation just four days after his release from jail, and he is now facing potential revocation of probation, which could result in additional prison time.

Susan Watford was found dead in her cabin on a cruise ship in Galveston, Texas. Jason Watford admitted to strangling her during an argument, and he is now facing a federal murder charge.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.