This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Sometimes we all need an extra helping hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is the AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you, and Claude isn't just for quick questions, handed a whole task like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a doc or deck right in front of you and Claude design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype your picturing. Attach your design system and it comes back in your own design language ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use like Gmail and Slack and whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model or strategising your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter for problems worth solving. Get started with Claude at Claude.ai/solve. That's Claude.ai/solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai/solve. Everyone's talking about AI, but to understand where it's going, you need to understand where it came from. What can the Luddites teachers about technology replacing human work? Can humanity learn from the nuclear age before creating something else it can't control? The future of AI didn't begin with chat GPT. It began centuries ago. This is the global backstory superintelligence. Five special episodes exploring the history behind the biggest story of our future. Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC podcast. This is the global news podcast from the BBC World Service. I'm Janet Joliel and at 15 hours GMT on Monday the 16th of November, these are our main stories. Moscow says Ukraine has launched what appears to be its biggest drone attack so far, including hitting a symbolically important bridge linking Crimea to Russia. After this month's heavy flooding in Gaza, Western countries called on Israel to stop blocking humanitarian aid before winter fully sets in. Days after Nvidia's chief executive, Jensen Huang, resigned over an affair with a suspected Chinese spy, reports say that he may be trying to make a comeback. -Also in this podcast? -To be or not to be. That is the question. Well, that is nobler in the mind to suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune. To be or not to be in Birmingham, the route over a decision to move the Shakespeare Institute out of its historic home in Stratford upon Avon. As targets go, the Kirchbridge is highly symbolic. It links Russia and the Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea and is the longest bridge in Europe. Crimea has been occupied by Russian forces since 2014. So the Kirchbridge has been repeatedly targeted by Ukraine. Its latest attack caused big tail backs. But the Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov played down the impact of the attack on the bridge. Russia was a massive drone attack. Our air defense systems are still continuing to operate very effectively. The assessment of the minor damage to the bridge is currently ongoing. Traffic on the bridge is continuing. Russia said Ukraine also fired more than 1,000 drones overnight. At the same time, there have been reports of further Russian strikes on cities in eastern Ukraine and blackouts were reported in the port of Odessa after power plants were hit. The correspondent in Keith, Sarah Reinsford, told me more about the attack on the bridge. The reports are coming from Russia and from the Russian-backed authorities in Crimea at this point. They have reported some damage to the Kirchbridge or the bridge that links the Crimea peninsula to the Russian mainland. Now, initially the report came from the local authorities that were talking about the tail back. The bridge apparently being closed. The Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov has said that the damage was minor. He said it was being evaluated and that the bridge was operational. The Ukrainian security services harassed them to comment on that. They haven't commented, but it certainly does come in the midst of what seems to have been a large-scale attack on Russia with multiple drones from here in Ukraine overnight. Russia is saying it's a record number of drones. Ukraine isn't confirming that. But as he said, certainly the Kremlin bridge has been targeted in the past. It seems from reports on the ground this time this could have been an interceptor drone that fell on the bridge rather than a direct hit. But it would have been a symbolic target if it were hit. And Sarah, you talked about these drones being fired from Ukraine on to Russia. What were the targets? And does the concern about restrictions on Starshield, a satellite communication system, do those concerns appear to have gone now that Ukraine is able to fire so many drones? Yeah, the restrictions on the styling Starshield system don't affect Ukraine's long-range strikes. Ukraine calls them long-range sanctions, but these are the long-range drone strikes reaching deep into Russia. Which it has been carrying out for several months now against particularly targets within the energy sector. So targeting oil refineries and production facilities inside Russia. Those strikes have continued and they haven't apparently been affected in any way by the restrictions. The restrictions affect Ukraine's ability to intercept Russian jet-powered drones coming in this direction and also it's kind of short-range strikes around the front line. So those restrictions still appear to be in place. Certainly, President Zelensky has referred to them several times. He's urged the Americans to lift those restrictions and to allow Ukraine to defend itself fully. So that appears to still be the case. But yeah, those long-range attacks into Russia do appear to continue and appear to be hitting a number of targets there. Negotiations have restarted, but there's little sign of progress. Yeah, I think it's important to say that, of course, the missiles strikes the ballistic missile attacks and also the drone attacks from Russia into Ukraine have continued and have also escalated. Overnight, we had multiple air raids. There have been civilians killed in Zapadeja and in Nipro. In the east of this country, there has been an attack on an energy infrastructure in Odessa. There's widespread blackouts there and across the country. So the aerial war is escalating even as those negotiations have begun again. Sarah Rainesford in Kiev. The situation in Gaza where most of the population is displaced was already dire. Even before a heavy storm earlier this month caused flooding and a landslide in undating thousands of tents, much of the Palestinian territory remains in ruins after Israel's war with Hamas. But despite this, Israel is still blocking many aid deliveries to Gaza. Now in a joint statement, the UK, Australia, Canada and Italy have called in Israel to allow rapid and unimpeded humanitarian access. We've voiced a part of the statement released by those countries foreign ministers. 150,000 tents and other vital supplies are being held at the border and prevented from entering Gaza. This situation is entirely reversible and there is still time to act before the winter fully sets in. Our Middle East correspondent Yolène Nell told me more about this warning from Western countries. This is coming, of course, at a time when most people in the Gaza Strip are still living in temporary shelters, where there are these dire living conditions and it's extremely overcrowded. We've had warning after warning from UN officials, there was one last week about an acute rise in respiratory illnesses because of the situation in Gaza and just over a week ago there was that first really severe storm of the winter season that brought heavy flooding into Gaza. So the purpose of this statement coming right now is really to try to get Israel to act. What they want to see is all of the crossings for goods open so that winter supplies can be rushed into Gaza. And they want Israel also to ease some of the restrictions it imposes on what it calls dual use items. These are basically items that Israel's seas could have a military purpose as well as a civilian one and that applies to lots of humanitarian goods, things like tents and tarpaulins and ropes, solar panels, other things that parts for desalination plants. This is something that UN officials have frequently been complaining about. And this is just the latest call for Israel to allow in, more aid supplies into Gaza. Even the US-led board of peace, which really criticises the Israeli authorities, has said that more needs to be done to help the people of Gaza, what's the Israeli response been? You're right. So there was a statement from the European Union like this on Saturday and a week ago the board of peace put out a statement describing Israel's response to the situation as being insufficient. What we've had from Israel really, they have said that blame has to go to Hamas calling it responsible for the devastating situation in Gaza, the humanitarian crisis, because it carried out those deadly attacks on Israel more than three years ago. The Israeli body which controls the crossings into Gaza has been saying that it works with the board of peace and with the rest of the video.
the UN. It's been working with them on a winter plan and it's put out a statement saying that it's allowed in 90,000 new tents recently and more than 8,500 trucks loaded up with winter supplies. But there was an investigation by the Israeli newspaper Harretts last week that found that if you look at what Israel pledged as part of the ceasefire and the US-led peace plan just over a year ago, well it was saying that really since then only 18,000 trucks you know that were supposed to go in each month since March an average has gone in which is less than half of that. Yola Nell in Jerusalem. The Indonesian President Prabowo Sabiento has apologized to neighboring nations for the thick haze caused by massive forest fires in his country. He was speaking at the start of an ASEAN regional summit in the Philippines. The El Nino weather pattern this year has caused exceptionally hot and dry weather in Indonesia, making the fires worse than usual. Our Southeast Asia correspondent Jonathan Hed is at the summit in Manila. Earlier this year, President Prabowo suggested that countries criticizing the toxic haze caused by forest fires were insulting Indonesia. Now he appears to have had a change of heart, just as he's about to meet other Southeast Asian leaders in person at their annual summit in Manila. He said he apologized for the haze on behalf of his government and people, and that Indonesia had done its best to prevent and contain the fires. The El Nino phenomenon this year has made them much worse, as it has before in 2015 and in 1997. Previous Indonesian leaders have also apologized and promised to do more, but little has changed. Huge areas of once forested land have been cleared for palm oil plantations. Big companies say they no longer use fire to do this, but for many small holders, burning is the only affordable way to cultivate crops. The thick, peat underlying Indonesia's great forests has dried out over decades of this kind of development, and when it ignites, it can burn underground for months, emitting vast quantities of smoke and carbon dioxide. Critics point out that President Prabowo has actually slashed the budgets of government agencies charged with preventing the fires and promoted the expansion of cash crops in once forested areas. Jonathan Head in Manila, well after years in which extreme weather events have become increasingly common, this week another threat has been reported. The Arctic Polar Vortex, the ring of strong winds that normally keep extremely cold air trapped over the North Pole, is weakening unusually early this year, according to meteorologists. This means parts of the Northern Hemisphere could suffer colder winter than usual. Professor Liz Bentley is chair of the Royal Meteorological Society. She spoke to my colleague Nick Robinson about the polar vortex. It's a strong, westerly flow of air in the stratosphere, which is about 15 kilometers above our head, so way above even the atmosphere where our weather is. It flows westerly direction circular, it's vortex, but the key thing is it holds the cold air at the North Pole, so it keeps that air there, and it's only when it starts to disrupt, which it is doing at the moment, that we see that cold air penetrating down to lower latitudes. So that could mean could it appear at the cold weather, or is it by definition unpredictable? So it means it increases the likelihood of getting cold weather across North America, across Europe, into parts of Asia as well. The key is where that cold air is going to come, and that becomes the challenge, I think, when forecasting. What's interesting about this particular event, though, is it's quite remarkable, because it's the earliest that we have recorded this disruption in the polar vortex, so it's two and a half weeks earlier than over events that we've had recorded over the last 70 years also. And do we have theories about why that happened? Yeah, there's a lot of discussion at the moment in the science community, so you mentioned the El Niño, their warming phase in the eastern tropical Pacific, just off the coast of Peru. That's super strong at the moment, and that could be actually causing this disruption earlier than we would normally see, but the jury's out on that, there's a lot of discussion about what might be causing this polar vortex to disrupt this early in the season. And when you look ahead now, what weather patterns could it mean, I accept you're saying it's about probabilities rather than certainties, but what should we be looking for? Yeah, so as I mentioned, this system sits in the stratosphere, it now has to penetrate down through to solar levels, and that takes a couple of weeks, so it gives us an idea of what the weather might be like two or three weeks in advance, and usually it means we get high pressure forming, so it disrupts the jet stream, and it allows the high pressure systems to form, and it really depends where they sit, as to whether we're going to get cold, arctic blast of air, or whether it's just going to bring kind of dry, settled conditions, and that's probably the more concern to meteorologists at the moment is if we get this high pressure sitting over the UK, persistent high pressure for a few weeks, it'll mean no rainfall, which under the drought conditions that we still have across most of the UK is something we really don't want. Professor Liz Bentley. Still to come in this podcast? From a technological point of view, it's not difficult to create a weapon that can find human targets and track them and kill them. It's actually much easier than building a self-driving car. Can countries around the world stop the rise of lethal autonomous weapons or so-called killer robots? It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you, and Claude isn't just for quick questions, handed a whole task like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report, and it does the work, and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a dock or deck right in front of you, and Claude design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype your picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack, and whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at Claude.ai/solve. That's Claude.ai/solve, and check out ClaudePro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai/solve. This is the global news podcast. A decade after the momentous Brexit vote that led to Britain leaving the European Union, the British Prime Minister is expected to compare the Brexit agreement to the Emperor's new clothes. In a major speech Andy Burnham will argue that the UK has lost more than it's gained as a result of leaving the EU. This comes ahead of a summit in Brussels this week where he will sign agreements with the EU covering food exports and use mobility. The British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said his country's relationship with the EU needed to change. The status quo is not good enough. It hasn't delivered positive economic change for our country, which is what my constituents are many others voted for. It's delivered the opposite. It's delivered negative economic change. It's made our economy weaker. It's made people poorer and we are about changing that because that is the fundamental and biggest issue that our country faces the cost of living crisis. I asked our political correspondent Rob Watson what he made of this shift. This is clearly a hugely important moment in British politics. I would argue the most important since the vote to leave because we had a series of Prime Ministers who essentially had a no murder about Brexit, but Andy Burnham is changing all that saying no we need to talk about it. It hasn't worked and essentially Jeanette he's making the case that really Brexit should be treated just like any other policy, right? That it's not something set in stone. There's nothing kind of holy about it even though there was a referendum and in his view as a policy it has failed and it needs re-examining. But that is a hugely important place to be in British politics. But he's reopening an acrimonious debate which went on for years before with critics saying that Britain will be a rule-taker not a rulemaker. Yes, I mean you've got sort of two kinds of criticism. I mean one is those who are still believers in Brexit and who want to protect their reputations make the argument that even if perhaps the voters haven't thought that Brexit is much of a success it could be made a success. and the others who worry about
opening up this debate, and not necessarily people who think Brexit is a good idea, but people who just are very worried about opening those, reopening those old divisions, and that is a concern within the governing Labour party. And could we see UK rejoining EU? After everything that's happened in these last days in that, you wouldn't rule anything out. I mean, what's really interesting is that the polls suggest that an absolute clear majority of the British people think that Brexit was a mistake that leaving has been bad for Britain they agree with the government. But when you go further into the polling and look at issues that might come up with rejoining that is, for example, back to freedom of movement, the UK having to pay membership fees, then it all becomes more complicated. But what's important here is that that, I mean, you might say, an extraordinary, almost weird silence about the biggest event since 1945, that silence is now over, and that is hugely significant. Rob Watson. Could Jensen Hoang be thinking about trying to make a comeback as chief executive of the multi-trillion dollar company in video? That's what the Financial Times newspaper is reporting, just days after the 63-year-old was forced to resign over affairs with a suspected Chinese spy and a subordinate. Elon Musk is said to be among those backing his return. This comes as an investigation is now underway into Jensen Hoang's conduct. For more on this, I speak to our business correspondent, Archenach Chukler. There is a lot of support being drawn up for Hoang. There are online petitions that are being signed, called Stand With Jensen, where people want, especially the employees and investors, want him to come back. Whether he's considering a comeback or not is yet to be verified, the BBC has not been able to independently verify that. But then there is definitely a lot of support. A lot of people in the tech industry want Jensen to come back to Nvidia because he's been the person driving force behind the global AI boom and he's the person who made Nvidia the company that it is today. Well, these reports that his allies are assembling a war room of Silicon Valley executives. Why would they be backing him when the investigation has barely started? Jensen Hoang really has been a person that many in the industry call the Godfather of AI. So he really draws a lot of respect in the tech world, even from his competing companies, CEOs and rivals. And there is a lot of support. Many of them are now saying that he was moved out of the company before any of the allegations have been established and that was wrong. And that he should be brought in while the investigation and independent investigation is ongoing. You know, he's also the face of the AI boom, also called the Central Bank of AI because he's been funding personally, also funding with equity investments into many small AI firms and investors feel a lot of it depend on Jensen Wang being in the tech industry right now. But this whole affair has cast a spotlight in the way he's run Nvidia and there's been a lot of criticism of the ways when it not least from the US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent who says he should be replaced by someone from outside the company. It definitely has. You know, the US government in fact now wants a probe into how Nvidia has been doing its business ties and US Treasury Secretary, in fact, publicly questioning if Nvidia actually knew that some of its advanced ships were being diverted to China. Now that raises a very big question mark that the US government is raising on the company. Again, we know how Nvidia was being run. It was run by the single leader. It had a flat management structure. The fact that they got a chairman after he left is very telling of how, you know, one person was kind of leading and these are a lot of things that the US government now wants to probe. Archana Shukla. Governments the meeting to discuss the future of so-called killer robots, artificial intelligence enabled weapon systems that can independently search for, identify, select and attack targets without direct human intervention or approval. At the gathering in Geneva, the International Committee of the Red Cross is calling for new international rules to govern the use of these weapons. Georgia Hines is a legal advisor with the ICRC. This is something we've been calling for since at least 2021 for new international law to set prohibitions on certain types of autonomous weapons and restrictions on others. We really need states this week to seize this opportunity to act is easier to act preventatively rather than to try to roll back practices or weapons once they've proliferated. Professor Stewart Russell is a world-renowned British computer scientist and pioneer in artificial intelligence. He made a film, nearly a decade ago, called slaughter-bots. It imagined a world in which tiny AI-powered drones could identify individuals and kill them without any human intervention. He gave us his assessment about the weapons that exist today. It's actually much easier than building a self-driving car, for example, which has to be literally millions of times more reliable than an autonomous weapon does. So yes, in Ukraine, there is a move towards full autonomy, so the pilots are basically switching toward autonomous mode a few miles from the enemy and then the weapons are finding particular targets and killing them. So yes, we are in this slaughter-bots era now. The issue there is what do people actually want to do? And if they want to terrorize, if they want to wipe out an ethnic group, then autonomous weapons are ideal because you can press a button, you can launch a million weapons and you can kill a million people with them. So it's kind of like having hydrogen bombs, except much, much cheaper, much easier to use. And you know, we don't sell hydrogen bombs in supermarkets for a good reason. It's not an ethical issue, right? It's just common sense, but we are going to be selling in the equivalent of supermarkets unless we have a binding treaty to prevent the manufacture of these weapons. Professor Stuart Russell, now when we think about British drama and the city of Birmingham, usually this comes to mind. That's the trailer from the hit period crime drama "Peaky Blinders". When we think of Birmingham, we don't usually think of this. Shakespeare is famous still illiquely in the play Hamlet. Millions of people visit Stratford or Naven where he was born to celebrate his life and work. He's also home to the Shakespeare Institute, a centre which is part of the University of Birmingham and dedicated to studying the Bard's works. Now in a decision that has outraged some academics, the Institute is being relocated to Birmingham. Professor Michael Dobson is the director of the Shakespeare Institute. I'm very unhappy about this and I'm rather skeptical about these announcements, saying that it's a great step forward for Shakespeare studies to take your Shakespeare department out of Shakespeare's hometown. It's as if the only university in the world that did Islamic studies and had a specialist unit in Mecca said it was going to show its commitment to the future of Islamic studies by taking it out of Mecca. Every other university in the country pretty much has very good Shakespeare experts. Birmingham, for 75 years, has been the only university in the world to be teaching Shakespeare and studying Shakespeare in Shakespeare's hometown. Stratford has been the place where people have come to dream of Shakespeare since the 18th century. It's the sort of focus for the world's love of Shakespeare now. Sooner or later anybody interested in Shakespeare comes to Stratford and that's been a huge advantage to the institute because prominent theatre makers, prominent scholars, they come through Stratford, they want to come to the institute and I don't think the institute will succeed in recruiting more students in Birmingham. In fact, I think it will lose. Students it has already. Imagine if you're a doctoral student, you've just moved your entire life to Stratford upon Averon to spend three years writing research thesis about things that are in our unique 60,000 volume specialist research library and you're suddenly told the institute is moving to rooms we haven't even seen in Birmingham and that the library will be vanishing into cardboard boxes. Professor Michael Dobson. And that's all from us for now. If you want to get in touch, you can email us at
[email protected]. This edition was mixed by Sydney Dundin, the producers were Aryan Cochie and Irokan, the editor is Karen Martin. I'm Jonathan Joliel, until next time, goodbye. Sometimes we all need an extra help in hand, especially with the tricky business problem you've been putting off. Lord is a AI for just that, it's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and
think with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hand it a whole task like turning a folder or scattered notes into a report, and it does the work and hands back something finish that you can open and edit. Claude can now drive the dock or deck right in front of you, and Claude design now lives right inside Claude. It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack, and whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model or strategising your next business move, Claude extend your thinking to tackle the problems at Meta. And check out ClaudePro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode, Claude.ai/solve. [BLANK_AUDIO]