Go back

Craiglist, Cyberstalking & Catfishing: The Story Of Michelle Hadley

43m 44s

Craiglist, Cyberstalking & Catfishing: The Story Of Michelle Hadley

A disturbing true crime case unfolds in Orange County, California, where Angela Marie Connell and Ian Diaz, a U.S. marshal, are falsely accused of harassment and stalking after a coordinated campaign orchestrated by Ian’s ex-girlfriend, Michelle Hadley. What begins as a seemingly malicious online harassment spree is revealed to be a carefully constructed scheme by Ian and Angela to falsely imprison Michelle, who was actually the victim of severe emotional and physical abuse. Michelle endured years of manipulation, physical threats, and psychological torment, including being falsely accused of crimes, falsely imprisoned for 88 days, and publicly vilified by the media. The justice system failed to uncover the truth, allowing Michelle to suffer immense emotional and financial harm, including PTSD, job loss, and a damaged reputation. Eventually, Angela is arrested and convicted on multiple charges for forging documents, false reporting, and kidnapping, while Ian is later convicted on federal charges for using government phones to commit crimes. Despite the legal outcomes, the case exposes deep flaws in how law enforcement and the justice system treat victims of domestic abuse, especially when powerful individuals are involved. Michelle, after enduring the ordeal, emerged as a powerful advocate for survivors, opening a retail store and supporting domestic violence shelters. The story serves as a stark reminder of the dangers of systemic bias, the need for accountability in law enforcement, and the strength of survivors who fight back. The case also highlights how deeply toxic manipulation and revenge can manifest in modern digital spaces, and how the justice system must prioritize truth and equity over convenience or power.

Transcription

8823 Words, 47341 Characters

English
okay i have my jersey joe's bringing the chairs for the tailgate oh but i still need to figure out how to get to the stadium well what is a ride gonna cost me that ride might be more expensive than my family's fifth inning hot dogs oh wait let me check lift too real quick before i book this lesson i thought i guess those savings can go towards buying everyone a soft pretzel today so when you need to get to stadium drive taking a few seconds to check lift when you book your next ride could save you money save the money check lift hey there's mario lopez from the all mario lopez daily podcast all right quick question you ever notice how some cars just steal the spotlight well that's the 2026 toyota rav4 it's got bold standout style intuitive tech inside and now hybrid power standard which means efficiency without the need to plug in so whether you care about looks smarts or just everyday practicality rav4 bring it on brings all of it you've been holding out for the right suv this is your sign check out the 2026 toyota rav4 at your local toyota dealer or visit toyota.com see packages and options at toyota.com for feature availability hi everyone i just wanted to let you all know that we have dropped several new merch items to our spring collection we have multiple new designs in t-shirts baby tees hats and totes and as a reminder 100 of the profit from any merch from any of the mile higher media shows goes directly to the higher hope foundation to support victims of violent crime as well as other like-minded non-profits we really appreciate your support why hello everyone and welcome back to another episode of true crime with kendall ray thank you so much for joining me today and if you're new to the show then welcome i'm so happy to have you here and make sure to click subscribe so you never miss an upload from me now guys today wow i have a case for you that is very different from what i normally cover in fact i don't know if i've covered one quite like this but as soon as i heard this story i knew i wanted to talk about it because i was just blown away i'm gonna be telling you guys a story of someone who was harassed and stalked and it is absolutely bizarre how this all played out and i was just floored to see the lengths someone would go to absolutely destroy the story of someone who was harassed and enjoy another person's life just for their own petty game and i think by the end of this you're going to be just as shocked as i was when i learned everything i did about this case now like i said this story is different from the cases that i normally cover it's pretty unique and so i'm going to be going about telling you in a completely different format than i normally do so it's going to feel like we're just kind of dropping right in and that's exactly how we're going to do it so let's begin in january of 2016 angela marie connell was in her early 30s and she was living in southern california when she met ian diaz who was a u.s marshal and the two of them connected over a dating app and really hit it off right away both of them had just gotten out of relationships and seemed to be looking for something more serious and so they quickly found that in each other and when i say their relationship moved fast i mean it moved fast because the two of them ended up getting married just a month after meeting and then angela moved into ian's condo in anaheim now ian had previously lived there with his ex-girlfriend michelle about six months earlier and they were currently in a legal dispute over ownership but that did not stop him and angela from laying down the groundwork to make this space their home and they needed their own space because turns out in may of 2016 angela announced that she was pregnant with twins and as you can imagine they were over the moon about this pregnancy but this exciting time didn't last very long at least they didn't get to enjoy it because it was overshadowed by an insane harassment campaign now when i tell you someone was harassing the two of them i bet you're already thinking it's got to be one of their exes and you would be right that same month that the two of them found out they were pregnant and began to get these very bizarre creepy emails addressed from his ex michelle he got one on may 22nd that said you told me i was your first love but you did not treat me like the precious perfect treasure that i am you have sinned against god and i want my power back because it belongs to us the daughters of god pretty weird right and then just a few days later angela starts getting terrifying messages as well and they were coming from different names but they sounded very similar and so they figured michelle had to be behind all of them like on may 26th for example angela received messages from someone under the name jason ray which so happened to be very close to the name of her ex-boyfriend jason rayburn but it definitely wasn't him and all of these messages they were getting were filled with these weird biblical threats for example there are legends that adam had a wife before eve who was named lilith but was not found in the bible you are not perfect but you are the eve to him michelle was the truth his lilith another said you have not heeded my warnings and will have to be hurt in order to see the truth about you and your ex-boyfriend jason rayburn but it definitely wasn't him and all of these messages him you need to watch your back do we have to hurt you to make you see this ian is a snake satan and is a sinner you are disposable and i hope to god on high you are put in your place i will prove to you the truth no matter the cost and obviously angela is bothered by these messages but she doesn't want to stoop to michelle's level so she responds and very simply says michelle hadley i want you to stop emailing me but spoiler alert she doesn't stop in fact the messages get a lot worse like on may 29th one email to angela said i hope you are scared of death tomorrow be prepared don't sleep be watchful of the daughters of god we will steal your child and we will watch as it dies you are a piece of shit and i hope to god you burn for what you have done to us now angela didn't have any children yet as i said earlier she was pregnant so it seemed like she was going to die and she was going to die and she was threatening her unborn twins which is just terrifying and she was just getting bombarded with these emails another one came in just a few days later and it said he is using you for everything don't you see this he is obsessed with me i am his treasure princess you are nothing watch your back tomorrow and then another said you might be beautiful you might be the one he married but you are still a sinner and must be punished i will make sure that you are not you are reminded of your place by force and then some of these emails even had just horrific disturbing images attached to them and i don't even want to go into detail about what they were but i'll just say they were very violent showing violence against women and children and of course when you're getting these messages paired with photos like that you're going to take this seriously and angela did she took these as a serious threat and ian took it seriously too so much so that on june 1st the two of them decided to go ahead and file a restraining order and due to his connections in law enforcement they took this seriously right away which i wish everyone would get that treatment but anyway one of his good friends and fellow marshals actually took it upon themselves to hand serve michelle the restraining order and when he did michelle acted like she didn't even know who angela was and said that i haven't been sending her any messages i have no idea what you're talking about but the police thought there was enough compelling evidence to say otherwise so the order was put in place and the judge ordered her to stop all contact with angela and ian but that did not do much because on june 6th another email came in and it read you will pay for this i hope to god you are ready for the pain i will show you burn in the fiery pits of hell tonight as by god's law you will be hurt and then you guys the harassment evolved into something even more sick and twisted angela discovered that someone posing as her was responding to craigslist ads from men who were looking for women to fulfill rape fantasies with and whoever this person was even answered these ads by sending photos from angela's social media and gave personal details like her address the time that she was normally home a description of her dog and even when she could be found walking them and this is disturbing but they also said to not stop even if angela started screaming or resisted because it was all just part of the fantasy so on june 13th police responded to a call from ian saying that this random man responded to that craigslist ad and showed up at their condo but luckily they said they were able to get him to leave and at this point ian has had enough they are both so freaked out so disturbed and feel unsafe in their own homes so ian pleaded with officers to arrest michelle for this but they didn't take any action and then the following week the police were called again and this time it was because angela said that she was attacked by another random man she told them that she was in the garage of the building when out of nowhere she was jumped but luckily she was able to fight him off before he fled the scene and by the time officers got to her she had abrasions on her neck red marks on her chest a torn shirt and two black eyes so as you can imagine the police were able to get him to leave and at this point ian was now taking this way more seriously and that same night they confront michelle and serve her a search warrant for her devices. And not only that, they also arrest her for violating the restraining order. She spent the night in jail, so Angela and Ian were able to sleep a little better that night. But her parents ended up paying her bail the following day. And wouldn't you know it, no emails were sent the entire time she was in there, but they started up again an hour after she was released. Okay, I have my jersey, Joe's bringing the chairs for the tailgate. Oh, but I still need to figure out how to get to the stadium. But what is a ride going to cost me? That ride might be more expensive than my family's fifth-inning hot dogs. Oh, wait, let me check Lyft, too, real quick before I book. Less than I thought. I guess those savings can go towards buying everyone a soft pretzel today. So when you need to get to Stadium Drive, taking a few seconds to check Lyft when you book your next ride could save you money. Save the money. Check Lyft. You know what? You know that moment when everything lines up, when life gives you the green light and you just go. That's the 2026 Toyota Camry. No hesitation, no friction, just a car that's right there with you. Ready, responsive, in control the whole way through. Because when it's your moment, you shouldn't have to think twice. The 2026 Toyota Camry. Go like you mean it. Test drive at your local Toyota dealer or visit toyota.com today. Toyota. Let's go places. See packages and options at toyota.com for future availability. So then, about two weeks later, Angela says someone using her identity responded to another sexual assault fantasy ad on Craigslist. And two days after that, police were called again because more men were coming by the condo to act out this violence. And when they arrived, a 17-year-old boy was found hiding in the bushes, waiting for Angela to come out. And I'm a bit confused about this teenage boy that was in the bushes. I couldn't actually find any. I don't know if they were telling more details about what happened to him or if he was punished or if officers just let him go. I don't know. I can't imagine they did nothing about that. But either way, all of this was just too much at this point. The police knew they had to get even more serious. And, you know, last time they locked up Michelle, everything stopped, even though it was a short period of time. So it felt like the only way that this would end is if Michelle was locked up. So they charged her with everything they could get her on in order to. get her locked up. She was indicted on 10 felonies, including 6 counts of felony attempted forcible, 1 count of felony stalking with a restraining order, stalking, criminal threats, assault with the intent to commit a sexual offense during the commission of a first-degree burglary, and 1 misdemeanor count of violation of a protective order. And all of this carried the maximum sentence of life in prison. So they ended up putting her in the high-security jail section, and her bail was set at $1,000. $1,000,000, which is such a high and rare penalty seen with stalking. I mean, in some cases, police don't even take much action at all for stalking. And here, the Anaheim PD are going hard with it. And by this point, the story was so unbelievable that local and national media started reporting on it. And she even made it onto a local publication's annual list of Orange County's Scariest People of the Year. People saw Michelle as an unhinged. vindictive ex-girlfriend who was very jealous and just couldn't let Ian move on and be happy. And now she was facing a slew of consequences for what she had done. But you guys, what if I told you that Michelle was actually the real victim here? Yeah, yeah, that's right. And I'm sure you probably have a bunch of questions. And it's a real mindfuck, so let me tell you what was really happening. And first, I need to rewind. Let me rewind a bit here and tell you who Michelle Hadley actually is. So Michelle grew up in Ontario, California, with a younger sister and two loving parents. She described her younger self as a goody-two-shoes who was always focused on academics, which didn't really change much as she got older. And while she was in high school, she met and dated the man that would end up being her future husband. And the two of them got married in their early 20s while she was attending Dickinson University. But unfortunately, the two of them didn't work out. They ended up getting divorced after four years of marriage. And then shortly after that, she put herself back on the dating market. And that's when she met Ian Diaz. In August of 2013, they met for coffee on their first date. And by the second one, this weirdo was saying, I love you already. Which, of course, is a red flag to you and me. But at the time, Michelle wasn't freaked out by it. She would later say that she was raised on the happily ever after fantasy. So she just thought she connected quickly to her prince charming and that it was, you know, love at first sight. And then a few months later, they had a relationship. A real fairy tale moment when the two of them took a trip to New York. And while they were ice skating at Rockefeller Plaza, Ian got down on one knee and proposed. And of course, thinking she had met her prince charming finally, she said yes. And then after returning to California, the two of them started mapping out their future together. But it did not take long at all for his manipulative true colors to really start to show. And he became very abusive and controlling of her. First of all, he convinced her to quit her market. That she really liked, actually. And instead, take one at Disneyland for far less money. And you might be asking, why would he do that? What's the point of that? What's in it for him? Well, homeboy was a huge Disney adult and he had previously worked there himself. So he wanted to have access to all the employee perks. You know, get the Disney hookup, if you will. But most importantly, that way, he could also have his previous co-workers keep an eye on her. Now, during this time. Michelle was also pursuing an MBA at Chapman University. And he tried to convince her to let him sit in on her classes. Or if she wouldn't do that, just stop going altogether. And this probably won't shock you. But as the absolutely controlling freak that Ian was, he also tried to control her appearance. And he always made her have acrylic nails on and dress sexier. He specifically wanted her to wear more crop tops. Oh, and he told her to get a belly button ring and even floated the idea of her. And let me be clear. There isn't anything wrong with these things if that's what you want for yourself. But these things just didn't align with who Michelle was or who she wanted to present herself as. But Michelle was serious about this relationship. And, you know, she saw these problems and wasn't thrilled about them. But also wanted to try and make things work. She really wanted her fairy tale ending. And so they took the next step and went ahead and moved in together. So then in June of 2020. In June of 2015, they purchased the condo that I mentioned earlier. And while Michelle had to be the one to pay the entire $14,000 down payment, both of their names, of course, were listed on the mortgage. But sadly, the toxicity in their marriage did not go away. In fact, it got worse. And after they moved in, Ian began physically and emotionally and sexually abusing Michelle. And Ian, dude, he is such a freak. I mean, I get people do things like this and it's their personal kink. And if it's consistent. If it's consensual, you know, do what you want. But this was not consensual at all. At one point, he started asking her to have sex with strangers while he watched. And when she refused because she wasn't interested in doing this at all, he did not respect her boundaries and he just kept pushing it. And after a while, she finally just caved. So Ian ends up finding some random guy off of Craigslist who is willing to do it, which is absolutely terrifying. But at this point, she still didn't want to. So she mentally prepared for it. And poor Michelle. This is heartbreaking. But she prepared for it by taking cold medicine and drinking a bunch of alcohol that night to sort of numb herself. And I hate to say this, but all of this actually did end up occurring. That stranger came over that night and Ian recorded it and watched from another room. And afterwards, Michelle was just horrified. She was understandably completely traumatized and felt violated. And that's when she started to react. She realized that what happened was sexual assault. And when she tried to talk to Ian's ugly ass about it, he would just brush it off, telling her that no one forced her and she should just get over it. But clearly, someone did force her. And that was her piece of shit, loser ass, monstrous fiance, Ian. Now, by this point in time, after all of this has happened, Michelle is really fearing for her life. So she starts trying to figure out a plan to leave. And as I've talked about before, this is always. One of the most terrifying times for survivors of domestic violence. And that was absolutely the case for Michelle, because he had multiple guns in the home. And one time she even tried to leave, but he pushed her down on the bed and physically restrained her. Then one day in August of 2015, she was able to escape when one of Ian's friends was at the condo. And she thought maybe he wouldn't do anything to her in front of that friend. So she took the risk and quietly packed up some belongings, slipped out and just drove away. And thankfully, she found safety. Living with her parents. But unfortunately, she couldn't be fully done with Ian because he still had contact with her and would sometimes harass her, of course. And other times he would even ask her to get back together with him. And one time he randomly texted her that he abruptly canceled her car insurance plan. So she needs to be careful on the roads. Now, Michelle took this as a threat, rightfully so. And she was worried that he was going to have one of his friends in law enforcement pull her over or something. And then she kept. seeing this same SUV without a license plate that was similar to Ian's car that was following her and she believed it was Ian following her, stalking her. And it got so bad that she even told campus security at Chapman what was going on and they barred Ian from entering the school. But Ian wasn't just harassing her and stalking her. He was also trying to ruin her reputation. He even told everyone he knew that he broke up with her because she cheated on him with multiple men that she met on Tinder, which could not be farther from the truth. And he was also telling people that he was trying to get her name off of the condo, but she was refusing to let it go when in reality, that wasn't the case at all. The truth was his sorry ass wouldn't move out and she obviously didn't want to live there with him. So because her name was on it, she still had to pay half of the mortgage, which was understandably really offensive. upsetting and frustrating. Okay, I have my jersey. Joe's bringing the chairs for the tailgate. What is a ride going to cost me? That ride might be more expensive than my family's fifth inning hot dogs. Oh, wait, let me check Lyft too real quick before I book. That's less than I thought. Save the money. Check Lyft. Go like you mean it. Toyota, let's go places. So in September of 2015, Michelle sent him an email saying, please explain to your real estate attorney that God's law is above all laws, including the law of man. Lilith, you may try to hide behind the law of man, but it is a weak shield that will bend and crack against the sword of God. And after hearing that, I'm sure you're thinking, what the hell? That sounds just like one of those emails that Michelle was writing earlier. Well, this time it actually was Michelle. And she would later say that this was very out of character for her and that she just wasn't thinking clearly because of all the trauma she had recently been through in her relationship with Ian, which is very understandable. But still, after Michelle sends this email, Ian is so bothered by it that he goes ahead and tries to file a restraining order against her, which ends up being denied. And by this point in time, it was obvious that they weren't going to be able to come to an agreement on their own regarding the condo. So they had to get the court involved. So in November of 2015, a judge decided that Ian had six months to either get a new mortgage on his own or sell the condo and just split the profits with Michelle, which did mean that she could potentially lose out on most of the money that she had put into the condo. But by this point, she just wanted to get the hell out of the condo. She wanted to get out of this situation and move on with her wife. And she thought that maybe he was moving on too, because after the agreement, she didn't hear from him at all. But unfortunately, Ian, of course, was not going away quietly. He had applied for multiple mortgages, and each one was denied. So as time went on, it seemed like he was going to just have to sell. But he really didn't want to, especially now that Angela was living there. Yeah, remember Angela from earlier, Ian's pregnant girlfriend? Well, this is the part of the story when the two of them devised a vicious plan. And they seemed to draw inspiration from that email that Michelle had sent him. Together, they created fake email addresses and then concocted these bizarre messages and sent themselves some of the most diabolical shit I have ever read or seen. And all of this just to set Michelle up to go to prison so that she couldn't fight anymore, and he could keep the fucking condo. Yeah, this is what it was all about. This property close to Disneyland. That is what he was willing to do all of this for. Mind you, they started sending these emails just after the six months was up. So in retrospect, it's pretty obvious what they were doing and why. So going back in time here, Michelle wasn't lying when she told that police officer who was getting her the restraining order that she didn't know who Angela was and that she never sent her any messages. But for some reason, the police didn't believe her to look further into it. Instead, they took Ian and Angela's word as gospel. But why? Hmm, maybe it had something to do with the fact that Ian was a U.S. marshal. I don't know. I'm not an expert, but it doesn't really make sense to me any other way. Now, during all of this, Michelle was still fighting for Ian to sell the condo. And since things weren't going their way yet, they had to take it further. So that's when the Craigslist ads were posted. But when police didn't arrest her for them, Angela faked that she was physically attacked by a man. She even tore her own damn shirt and gave herself the bruises and scratches to really sell it. Yet even after Michelle's first arrest, she was still going strong. In fact, she filed a breach of contract lawsuit on July 12th because Ian was still refusing to sell well after the six-month time limit. And Ian and Angela, being the absolute lunatics that they are, could not deal with that. So the next day, they called the police about the second sexual assault fantasy ad on Craigslist, which is what led to Michelle being arrested and facing the possibility of life in prison. Now, in retrospect, it does seem pretty damn obvious what was happening here, but police and detectives weren't looking past the bogus emails. And instead, Michelle was wrongfully imprisoned and treated like a complete menace to society. And luckily, her friends and family never believed that she would do something like this and right away, her parents, Michael and Suzanne, got to work trying to prove her innocence. And this must have been so difficult as parents, but they had to tell her that they couldn't afford to hire a good lawyer and pay her $1 million bond. So they left the choice up to her and she picked the lawyer. She decided that she would try to just tough it out in jail until the evidence showed the truth. But she had an extremely hard time in there. It was absolutely brutal. She was pretty meek and someone knew that she was in there for unhinged harassment, which made her an easy target for other inmates. Her cellmate even tried to help her by saying her walk was too weak and taught her how to, you know, toughen up a little bit. But that just didn't make her time any easier. But even though this had to be the worst time in her life and she really, really struggled in there, I mean, it was bad. She felt like all the other prisoners were just eating her alive. She did feel like it was worth it in the long run because her parents hired this amazing attorney named Michael Gusty. And he was incredibly passionate about helping them because he immediately knew that Michelle was innocent and later said this type of injustice is the reason to become a lawyer. But her parents didn't stop there. They went through all of the emails that were included in court documents. Michael would put each one through a software that would trace the IP address. And then Suzanne took those and cross-referenced them to Michelle's locations, which of course wouldn't match. And they were even able to find that some of those emails were sent while she was taking exams at Chapman. Where she definitely wouldn't be able to use the computer or phone. And while this was very significant information for her defense attorney, it wouldn't be enough to get her out right away. Because a judge wouldn't release her based off of something that her parents found, so they would have to hold on to it for a potential trial and hope that the charges would be dropped once investigators uncovered this themselves. And this is not totally shocking. Disappointing? Yes. Shocking? No. Her parents were much quicker at getting to the bottom of this whole thing than to detectives were, whose job it was to actually do that. But, you know, your own parents are going to go much harder in these circumstances, unfortunately. So in July, detectives obtained a search warrant for the IP address, but it was a slow process and the results didn't come until late September. And during all this time, Michelle is just suffering in jail and she shouldn't have ever been there a single day. But when the results finally came in, they showed that Angela used eight different emails with private networks and third-party networks. And she was able to get the results. And she was able to get the that were tied to the condo, to Angela's phone, and even to her dad's home in Arizona. But that wasn't the only bombshell that investigators got, because on September 30th, Ian came to speak with them to flip on Angela. Now, Ian vowed to Angela to be with her in sickness and health, but that doesn't apply in his case when police have figured out that the two of you have schemed to try to put someone in prison falsely for life. So anyway, he tells the police that there are two people in that he has decided to rat her out. The first was that he claimed that he became suspicious of her when he received an email from an account that he supposedly created. And the second was that she recently told him that she was, surprise, never actually pregnant. That's right. There were no babies, no twins. Didn't exist. And he told the police that he was a victim of her, that she had tricked him by using a fake sonogram that she just bought off Etsy. Now, obviously, Ian is a lying freak, so I have no idea if this is actually true, if it's true that she lied to him. I don't know. If he was in on that lie with her, if they came up with that together, or if he actually even saw a sonogram, I don't know. He probably just made it all up to heighten the drama of the fake harassment. And when I say made it up, I mean made up the fact that she lied to him and purchased the sonogram off of Etsy. I'm like starting to confuse myself. But you know what I mean? I don't know exactly how that shook out. And another thing I don't know, and I really wish I knew, is if his law enforcement buddies had tipped him off about the IP address before he started talking. And I say that because he was pretty protective of them. But more on that later. So, of course, after all of this was discovered, poor Michelle was released from prison on October 7th after spending 88 days in there, dude. But this ordeal was far from over. Even with all of this evidence pointing to her innocence, the charges were not dropped. But she was released on the condition of wearing an ankle monitor while the investigation continued. So she wasn't fully free from all of this and wouldn't be until January 2017 when Angela was finally charged. Now, at this point, Angela had moved in with her dad, a doctor in Arizona, probably because she didn't want to live with her accomplice husband anymore after he flipped on her. But still, she was arrested on January. On January 6th, eee, in Phoenix. Then she was extradited back to California where she faced the following felony charges. Two counts of kidnapping. Two counts of false imprisonment by menace, fraud, or deceit. Perjury. Two counts of forgery. Possession of a forged check over $950. Grand theft. One misdemeanor of false reporting a crime to a police agency. And 21 counts of falsely reporting a crime to a police officer. Now, those last few charges actually came from her trying to alter pay. Paychecks from her employer to add an additional $2,000. Just genius. And so with all of that, she was now facing up to 23 years in prison. Which is obviously far less than the life in prison that Michelle was facing for a crime that she didn't even commit. I mean, seriously, how does any of this make sense? I mean, Michelle was the victim here. And it was bad. She spent 88 days in prison for zero reason. And her reputation was ruined. And yet the justice system treated her worse than her unhinged. Tormentor. Hopefully that makes you just as mad as it made me when I first learned about this case. And just wait. Because Angela's deranged behavior gets even deeper. That ride might be more expensive. Than my family's fifth inning hot dogs. Oh, wait. Let me check Lyft, too, real quick before I book. Less less than I thought. Save the money. Check Lyft. You know that moment when everything lines up? When life gives you the green light and you just go? No hesitation. No friction. Just a car that's right there with you. Go like you mean it. It was also uncovered that she had previously faked cervical cancer, lied about multiple pregnancies, forged doctor's notes, posed as an attorney, and made fake email accounts pretending to be two other ex-girlfriends of Ian's. And allegedly, in one of those cases, she had recently sent an email to a news publication under the name Lacey, claiming that Ian was having affairs with other women and that Angela was the true victim in all of this. One line read, Angela is a really pretty, nice girl, and has been a victim of not only Michelle, but her cheating hubby. Now, this reporter asked Lacey to verify her identity, but then Lacey refused and ghosted them. Interesting. So they passed the emails to Anaheim PD, who were able to verify that Lacey was a real person, but definitely didn't send those. And just when you thought that this woman couldn't get any more insufferable, she does. Listen to this. Investigators also found two documents on her computer that were titled, A Darkness Within, The Angela Diaz Story, and Daughters of God, The Angela Diaz Story. You guys, these were movie pitches about the case that she planned to send to who else? Lifetime. Yep. So it seems like after terrorizing and destroying Michelle, she was going to hustle for some money and fame. Now, I will say she did get that fame, but probably not in the way that she had hoped. Because on January 9th, the Orange County DA held a press conference and told the public about their findings. It's often said that true life is stranger than fiction. The facts of this case make that statement spot on. When a person who's committed a crime gets arrested and charged, that's a bad day. But when someone who's innocent gets arrested and charged with a crime, that's not just a bad day, it's a nightmare. This is a tale of a woman who faced such a nightmare. But with the help of her attorney and law enforcement who continued to seek the truth, she'll be able to be exonerated. I'm here to announce that this is the first time I've ever heard of a woman who has committed a crime. I'm here to announce the filing of a felony complaint against Angela Marie Diaz by the Orange County District Attorney's Office. The charges include numerous felony charges, including two counts of kidnapping, two counts of false imprisonment, perjury, two counts of forgery, two counts of possession of a forged instrument, grand theft, one misdemeanor count of filing a false report with an agency, and 21 misdemeanor counts of filing false police reports. As important as the filing of charges against Ms. Diaz is, the dismissal of the previous complaint and the exoneration of Michelle Suzanne Hadley is every bit as important. The complaint number, 16NF2004, previously charged Ms. Hadley with several felony counts that carried a maximum sentence of life in prison. This is a complex and detailed case, and I won't be able to share all of the details now. I wanted to make sure, however, that Ms. Hadley is cleared in every possible way, in the courtroom and in the court of public opinion. Now, if you haven't already picked up on this, I just wanted to point out that Angela and Ian met in January of 2016, and now we're in January of 2017, meaning all of this happened in just a year. The devil works hard, but Angela and Ian work harder. Am I right? And I'm sure you're getting a little bit annoyed here that Angela was outed. As a criminal, but Ian's reputation initially went unscathed. What is going on? Well, his identity wasn't revealed at the press conference. They just called him John Doe, and the situation was painted as if it were a toxic love triangle, with Angela being hateful towards her husband's ex, when in reality, they both wanted to take her down to get that condo. And of course, Michelle and her family, too, had issues with this because they knew that Ian was involved. I mean, he just had to be, but they felt like he was being protected, because he was a U.S. Marshal. And I'm sure there will be people who try to explain this some other way, but I don't think it makes sense any other way. He clearly used that to his advantage. And let's not forget that his friend literally served the search warrant and begged the police to arrest her. I just can't help but wonder how different all of this would have been if they were just regular civilians. But anyway, at least Michelle did have something worth celebrating, because later that day, she was fully exonerated on all charges. And I can't help but wonder how different all of this would have been I cannot imagine how good that must have felt. And while she was coming out of the courthouse, she spoke to the press, which was the first time Michelle was ever able to take back the narrative and, in her own words, share what really happened to her. I have a lot of friends and a lot of family who know me very well. And when they saw this in the media, they already knew I didn't do it. And they believed it even before the truth came out. So I think as far as my close circle, it's not going to be hard to rebuild my reputation. And I'm hoping that that kind of, it just grows from there. Now, Michelle could finally start to pick up the pieces and try to move on. But for Angela, the ramifications were just getting started. In October of 2017, she pled guilty and was sentenced to five years. And the judge said that he worked in the justice system for 30 years, but had never seen a case like this. Now, Michelle actually chose to not even read a victim impact statement at her sentencing because she felt like it was a sham, since Ian was the real mastermind behind all this. And wasn't getting punished at all. She actually didn't even go. And I'm glad she didn't, because apparently Angela didn't even show any sign of remorse or empathy while appearing in court. Her attorney stated that there were other suspects involved. And I think it's pretty obvious who she was talking about. She said that Angela was being singled out because she was an easier target for prosecutors. And in my opinion, she was. And yes, of course, she needs to be punished for what she did. I mean, her crimes were just unbelievable, ruthless, and evil. But the evidence against her, was pretty obvious. And had they done deeper investigating, they would have been able to find everything pointing to Ian as well. But it took them, sadly, badly years to do that. Now, before I continue, I do want to point out that I haven't really talked that much about Ian and who he was, and that's because there isn't that much information out there about the dude. Outside of what Michelle has said, I could really only pin down that he lived in California and started working for the Marshals around 2010, and that he was in his late 30s when all of this started. But honestly, I don't think we really need to know much more about him beyond the fact that he is a lying, heartless pig monster of a person who I am very happy to say did end up facing consequences for what he did. So a federal probe was actually first launched in 2017, and prosecutors didn't comment, of course, on why it took so many years to finally bring charges. But during the investigation, they were able to uncover that some of the emails were sent from a DOJ-issued IP address and his work phone, which he never gave anyone else the password to. So it was immediately obvious that this idiot actually used his government phones to do all of this. And he also originally told investigators that he never used Craigslist, but it was found that he communicated with people about the rape fantasy on there, and even used two-step authentication with his phone number to approve an ad. And Ian, he thought he was real sly because he ended up getting a new phone number the next day, probably realizing what a massive mistake he just made. Now, as you probably guessed, shortly after the indictment, he was relieved of all duties as a criminal investigator in Los Angeles. But I do want to point out how crazy it is that he was even able to continue working as an investigator for years after a federal probe into him started. I mean, am I confused on something here? That seems really weird. Maybe they just don't care until you're found guilty, even if it takes years, which is really dangerous to society. But anyway, in the end, Ian was found guilty. After a week-long trial in March of 2023. Now, Michelle didn't even go. And I don't know if she would have if there were different circumstances. But the reason that she didn't go is because she actually gave birth to her first daughter on the day that he was convicted, which I think is really beautiful to symbolize the next chapter of her life starting in two different ways. But she did send a statement to the court and it read, this man did not just want the condo. He wanted to felony and sex offender registration on my record so I could never lead a normal life after he was done with me. Never work with kids again, which he knew I had done in the past and loved. He wanted to make my worst nightmare come true. Every unexpected knock or ring at the door caused me to break down in panic, my whole body shaking uncontrollably. He set me up for another decade of abuse. I have had to give up on some of my dreams for my life. Now his lawyer tried to argue for just five years in prison because she said his life has, quote, changed significantly for the better since the offense conduct took place over seven years ago. And guess what she meant by that? Ian now had a wife and a child. That's right. Somehow after all of this, he was able to find a woman who wanted to be with him and procreate with him. Now, I don't know if his wife knew everything that he had done or anything about him, but I just feel bad for that child and for her too. You know what I mean. But in the end, Ian was ultimately sentenced to 10 years in federal prison and three years of supervised release, so he will be in his 50s when he gets out around 2033, which I don't think is enough. And unfortunately, he will still be able to continue terrorizing women in his lifetime if he proceeds that way. And if you ask me, and I'm sure you guys are going to agree with me, I don't think he or Angela had tough enough consequences for what they did. What's crazy is Angela is now a free woman. I mean, she was released from prison just a few years ago, and I couldn't find any information about where she is now, but I really hope she learned her lesson because clearly she has a massive lying problem, even outside of this case. The shit that the two of them pulled has long-lasting repercussions, and it very much did for Michelle. Not only was she falsely imprisoned for quite a long time, but also the media portrayed her as this evil monster. Let's not forget that the county that she lived in, which is in the middle of the United States, was also in the middle of the United States. Put her on the list of the scariest people there. Oh, which, by the way, Angela made that list the following year, and other major news organizations were reporting on it before she was exonerated. So because of all of this, poor Michelle was diagnosed with PTSD, had to quit her job, had to drop out of her MBA program at Chapman, and she also says that she sometimes fears meeting new people. I can see why. And going to job interviews is difficult for her, just because they might find out that she's a bad person. She was in prison before she actually has a chance to explain it to them. So in late 2018, she ended up filing a federal civil lawsuit against Angela and the city of Anaheim and the police department, which was settled in 2021 for $1.8 million. And honestly, good for her, and in my opinion, that is not enough. The way that law enforcement treated her and then acted with this in-prison-first-and-question-later mentality is just disgusting and unacceptable. But I just want to say, if she ever sees this, that the way that you handled it is just so, so impressive. There aren't even words. You are seriously one of the strongest women I have ever seen. And she has gone on to do amazing things. She has used her story to help spread awareness about domestic violence and abuse. She says that she wants to be a beacon of hope for other survivors and remind them that they are not alone. And she put those words into action when she was able to open her own retail store and give money to a domestic violence shelter. And she has also used her voice to draw attention to glaring issues in the justice system. In 2020, she wrote an article for The Marshall Project, where she detailed the differences in treatment between her and the women of color that she was incarcerated with. Which is such a powerful way to use her voice, and I just have to say, she's really good at doing that. I just think the way that she was able to turn this horrible situation into something that helps others is truly amazing. And I mean, she was seriously just put through the ringer in ways that most of us can't even fathom. And she came out the other end seemingly tougher than she was before. Now, before I go, I want to leave you with some words from Michelle. In an interview, she said, I don't want people remembering me as the girl who suffered for this. I want to be remembered as the girl who fought back. And damn, that's exactly how I'm always going to remember Michelle. And I hope you do too. And that is going to be it for me today, guys. I am still on another episode for you next week. I don't know how many I'm going to end up being able to pre-record, but we'll see. So if there is no episode, then hang with me. If there is, then yay me or yay my team or whatever we do. But yeah, you can check in with me on social media if you want. I will have my Instagram on the screen if I'm even posting. I don't know. I'm probably in newborn bliss or newborn exhaustion, however you want to describe it. But that is it for me today, you guys. I will see you next time or whenever I see you. I don't know. This is getting confusing and weird. Thanks for tuning in. And that's it for me. I'll see you next time. Bye. Okay. I have my jersey. Well, what is a ride going to cost me? Save the money. Check Lyft. Hey, it's Mario Lopez from the All Mario Lopez Daily Podcast. All right. Quick question. You ever notice how some cars just steal the spotlight? Well, that's the 2026 Toyota RAV4. It's got bold standout style, intuitive tech inside, and now hybrid power standard, which means efficiency without the need to plug in. So whether you care about looks, smarts, or just everyday practicality, RAV4 brings all of it. If you've been holding out for the right SUV, this is your sign. Check out the 2026 Toyota RAV4 at your local Toyota dealer or visit toyota.com. See packages and options at toyota.com for feature availability.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Angela Marie Connell and Ian Diaz quickly fell in love, married, and moved into a condo in Anaheim, but their happiness was short-lived as they faced a violent harassment campaign targeting Angela.
  2. The harassment originated from Michelle Hadley, Ian’s ex-girlfriend, who sent bizarre, threatening emails and created fake online personas to stalk and terrorize Angela, including sending violent images and fabricating sexual assault fantasies.
  3. Michelle, in reality, was the victim of domestic abuse by Ian, who manipulated her, controlled her life, and used government resources to commit crimes, while Angela and Ian conspired to falsely imprison Michelle by staging fake threats and faking pregnancy and medical records.

Summary:

S. marshal, are falsely accused of harassment and stalking after a coordinated campaign orchestrated by Ian’s ex-girlfriend, Michelle Hadley. What begins as a seemingly malicious online harassment spree is revealed to be a carefully constructed scheme by Ian and Angela to falsely imprison Michelle, who was actually the victim of severe emotional and physical abuse.

Michelle endured years of manipulation, physical threats, and psychological torment, including being falsely accused of crimes, falsely imprisoned for 88 days, and publicly vilified by the media. The justice system failed to uncover the truth, allowing Michelle to suffer immense emotional and financial harm, including PTSD, job loss, and a damaged reputation. Eventually, Angela is arrested and convicted on multiple charges for forging documents, false reporting, and kidnapping, while Ian is later convicted on federal charges for using government phones to commit crimes.

Despite the legal outcomes, the case exposes deep flaws in how law enforcement and the justice system treat victims of domestic abuse, especially when powerful individuals are involved. Michelle, after enduring the ordeal, emerged as a powerful advocate for survivors, opening a retail store and supporting domestic violence shelters. The story serves as a stark reminder of the dangers of systemic bias, the need for accountability in law enforcement, and the strength of survivors who fight back.

The case also highlights how deeply toxic manipulation and revenge can manifest in modern digital spaces, and how the justice system must prioritize truth and equity over convenience or power.

FAQs

Checking Lyft in advance helps you compare prices and avoid overpaying, potentially saving money that can be used for other expenses like buying soft pretzels.

The 2026 Toyota RAV4 is known for its bold style, intuitive tech inside, and standard hybrid power, offering efficiency without needing to plug in.

The 2026 Toyota Camry is marketed as a car that offers no hesitation, no friction, and ready responsiveness, perfect for driving confidently in any situation.

Michelle Hadley was falsely accused and imprisoned for harassment and stalking after being set up by her ex-boyfriend Ian Diaz and his new partner, Angela, who fabricated emails and staged incidents to destroy her reputation.

She was wrongfully imprisoned because the police and investigators relied on fabricated emails and false allegations, while failing to investigate the true origin of the messages, which were created by Ian and Angela to frame her.

Angela pled guilty and was sentenced to five years in prison, and despite her crimes, she was released and faced no long-term restrictions, while the justice system failed to hold her accountable in a fair manner.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.