Go back

courtroom insider on lindsay clancy trial | sierra gillespie

50m 17s

courtroom insider on lindsay clancy trial | sierra gillespie

The Lindsay Clancy trial, which centered on the killing of her three young children in 2023, became a focal point for national discussion on postpartum psychosis. Prosecutors alleged premeditated murder, claiming Clancy planned the killings, while the defense argued she was not criminally responsible due to severe mental illness, including postpartum psychosis and bipolar disorder. Despite her admission of the acts, the jury deadlocked, resulting in a mistrial after 11 jurors voted for not criminally responsible and one held out. The trial revealed the complexity of diagnosing mental health conditions in real time, with evidence showing Clancy sought help through multiple doctors and medications, yet still experienced sudden psychotic episodes. The public reaction was deeply divided, with intense online debates and a surge in mental health advocacy, particularly through symbolic gestures like wearing pink. The case highlighted the invisibility of postpartum psychosis in public discourse, with many individuals unaware of its severity or prevalence. Sierra Gillespie, who reported from the courtroom, emphasized the emotional toll on both the family and the public, noting the trauma of hearing the 911 call and the stark contrast between Clancy’s outwardly normal life and her internal mental state. Ultimately, the case underscored the urgent need for greater education, early intervention, and societal understanding of postpartum mental health, showing how tragedy can catalyze meaningful change in awareness and support systems.

Transcription

9058 Words, 48788 Characters

English
Hey, it's Avery. Welcome to Cheers. Just a quick content warning before we get into today's episode, we will be covering some very heavy material, including child loss, severe mental illness, suicide, and postpartum psychosis. So please tune in at your own discretion. Today we have host and legal reporter from the Lawn Crime Network, Sierra Gillespie. She covered the Lindsay Clancy trial from inside of the courtroom, which I think will give us all a completely different perspective from what we've seen on the news and social media. Just a quick background for anybody that's not familiar with the Lindsay Clancy case. The defendant is Lindsay Clancy, who's a 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse from Massachusetts. She was facing murder charges for killing her three young children, Korra Dawson, and Callen in January of 2023. Prosecutors say that she planned the killings and knew what she was doing. Her lawyers are arguing that she was not legally responsible because of her severe postpartum psychosis by polar disorder and medication side effects that broke her connection to reality. After days of deliberation, the judge ultimately declared a mistrial due to a deadlock jury. I actually became quite obsessed with this case before it ever became a big deal on social media when the trial started. I remember when the news broke of this happening in 2023 and being absolutely shocked that this mother who was a labor and delivery nurse did this and this happened to her and her family. It really rocked my world because postpartum psychosis is something that's very, very common, but people don't know a lot about it and people don't talk about it a lot. I obviously have had two children. I've been through postpartum twice. I feel like I really struggled with my mental health after my first baby. My second baby was kind of what felt like a redemption for me and made me realize that the first experience I had giving birth was not normal and I did experience postpartum depression. I was very fortunate that I did not experience dark thoughts and having symptoms of postpartum psychosis, but it is something that is happening to a lot of women in this world and unfortunately think that there is not enough education about it. I think people don't know enough about it and they confuse mental health disorders not being associated with postpartum psychosis, but in my opinion, this was a mom that loved her children dearly and she was very, very sick. She was crying for help to not only her friends and family, but also her physicians and watching this trial just broke my heart because she really wanted help more than anything. There are so many opinions out there, especially on social media and so many conspiracy theories, but I think being able to talk to Sierra who was physically in the courtroom, she was able to listen to everybody testify, she was able to listen to the prosecution, the defense, the judge and see the jury's reaction. That is something I'm very interested in and I hope can give a different perspective for everybody watching or listening and is interested in this case and also getting to know a little bit more about postpartum psychosis because I do think it's very important for us to educate ourselves for the future of women and mothers in this world, so more than anything, no matter what your opinion is about this case, I hope that this just brings more light to postpartum psychosis, what it is and how we can help people that are struggling after they have a baby. Hi, Sierra. Hi, how's it going? It's so good. Nice to meet you. Thank you so much for doing this long distance. Yeah, I wish it was in real life, like we were talking about before we were recording, next time I'll have to come in. It'll happen. I'm manifesting that for us, but your setup is so beautiful and you're my first ever long distance podcast interview, so thank you so much for doing this. I'm very grateful. Yeah, thank you for having me. I'm excited to come on. I talked a little bit about it in my intro before we started recording, but I've obsessed with this case since it happened. I remember when it was in the news because I was a pick you, Nick you nurse and so when I found out she was a labor and delivery nurse, it just really rocked my world and I knew about postpartum psychosis, but I felt like the world didn't know a lot about it. Yeah. And I feel like this has really opened up a huge conversation about that topic and I think it's scaring a lot of people, but it's also educating a lot of people for what to look for when they have kids and I think at the end of the day, you know, this was obviously such a horrible tragedy, but I think coming out of it is a lot more education and hopefully people understand the resources they can have if they're experiencing something like postpartum psychosis. Yeah, I totally agree. I mean, so many people had never even heard of postpartum psychosis at all. Women and men, by the way, people who could eventually have kids had never even heard about this. And so I think if there's one good thing that came out of this case, it's the awareness that people now know what it is. And to your point, realize that there are resources. If this happens to you, you're not alone because postpartum depression at the very least is relatively common. Yes, very common. And I experienced postpartum depression with my first baby, but I don't think I knew what I was going through until I was out of that phase. Yeah. And my second baby, I didn't experience that. And so when I was able to compare the two postpartum experiences, I was like, wow, I really, really, really struggled with my first baby. And I wish I would have been more educated on that to be able to help myself a little bit during that time. It's so hard because if it's your first baby, you think, oh, this is just how it is. I guess this is what happens postpartum. This is everyone says your hormones are off the charts. Okay, I guess I just feel like that's normal. But then when you had your second baby, you're like, wait, no, that wasn't right. That wasn't normal. I mean, it's normal to have, but there are resources that can help you combat those symptoms for those that aren't familiar with you and what you've been sharing about the case. Can you kind of explain who you are and what your involvement has been when it comes to the Clancy trial? Yeah. So my name's Sierra Gillespie. I'm a reporter for Lawn Crime. I have my own show. It's called Scandal where I talk about whatever the top trending true crime stories of the day, week year, whatever. And I also have been following this Lindsay Clancy case since it happened in January 2023 because I'm based in Boston and this happened in Duxbury, like an hour and a half south of me. So I've had a close eye on it really since the beginning. And when this went to trial, I was in the courtroom in the beginning. Things weren't as crazy. I mean, this still was like the details of the case are horrifying. And it's interesting, but it didn't take off until maybe week two or three that the entire world was talking about it and watching the live stream. I saw a woman in the grocery store like she had her cart with the trial up. And I was like, Oh, wow, okay, we've reached like Johnny Depp level here. So I went back for the last two weeks. So I've been in the courtroom probably about 15 days and sitting in the front row, really close to the jurors near Lindsay, near everyone. So I was kind of right in the mix of it and have been reporting on what I saw for those people that aren't aware of this trial. I gave a little bit of a background on it. What kind of shocked me was this obviously happened, you know, three years ago. And there wasn't much talk or chatter about it. And I think this case shows how powerful social media really is because since the trial has started and everyone starts clipping everything, it blew up into this massive thing again, like the Johnny Depp amber her case. It really has gone to that level. There's going to be I'm sure Netflix documentaries on it. Like I for sure see that happening in the future. But because we're all kind of watching through our screen and you were present in the courtroom, can you kind of describe that atmosphere? I think you can tell through the live stream that this was a circus, especially looking outside just the sheer amount of people at the very least when Kevin Rattington would walk outside. I would be the person who has the microphone right in front of his mouth walking with him as he went to his car. At times there were what felt like 50 people surrounding him. This was like the Beatles at Shay Stadium or something, just mobbing this defense attorney. I've never really seen anything like it before that I've been part of. And it's intense. I mean outside of the the courtroom. There are people who are literally screaming. Lindsay Clancy is a murderer. Other people are screaming for mental health awareness. So it's very divisive on the outside. And then when you go inside, it's a pretty big juxtaposition because obviously it's a lot more quiet people. I mean, things do get heated once in a while if you've been watching Kevin Rendington can get heated. Both sides really can, but it's a lot more quiet and yet intense. And I know this sounds silly, but you can feel it in the air, especially as we were going on with deliberations because it ended up being about seven days. The jury was deadlocked time and time again. And every time we the reporters went back into the courtroom, we're like, what's going to happen? You never know with this case. We literally never knew. And you could just feel the intensity in the air, the angst by the last day, the court officers who, by the way, were always so sweet, so nice. They were yelling at the spectators, get back it out of the way because people were rushing the courtroom, almost like this was entertainment and fun. And I think the hard part is that people forgot about these three children who were killed. That's really what this is all about. I mean, them and of course the mental health awareness here. But I think at times it became entertainment for people just watching it on their phones, but in real life, you can truly feel the intensity in the room. You know, with my past career, unfortunately, I did see a lot of death because I only worked with kids and I worked in a level in trauma. And so that was something that I saw so regularly. And almost became numb to it during that time in my life. But I sometimes forget that the majority of the world has not experienced such gruesome details or horrific events when it comes to children. And it really is such a horrible and shocking thing to listen to and witness and experience. And we'll kind of get into that and, you know, Lindsay being in the courtroom, having to hear all these things and see so many horrific things. But for, from a professional standpoint, can you break down the charges against Lindsay and the options that the jury has in front of them? Yeah. Okay. So she was charged with three counts of first degree murder. This is premeditated murder. The Commonwealth of Massachusetts says she was calculated. She planned it out. She wanted to kill these kids. She had no, I mean, she did have mental health issues. But in the moment she was of sound mind, you should convict her for this. And the defense said, yes, we admit that Lindsay Clancy did this. However, we say that she isn't criminally responsible because at the time of these deaths, she was going through postpartum psychosis. She basically snapped and had this moment where she wasn't of sound mind. So these two things put together, I think that's what confused a lot of people because they're all the conspiracy theories about Patrick actually doing it and question marks. But I can tell you from the plea, Lindsay Clancy admitted that she did do it. She just was saying, I'm not criminally responsible, which most people would know as not guilty by reason of insanity. That's usually what it is in other states, but in the Commonwealth, it's just not criminally responsible. So when the jurors go into the deliberation room, they have to figure it out for three different cases for Cora, Dawson, and Callan. She has the three charges. And there are five options for each of these charges. The first is first degree murder, but she would be guilty of it. The second would be second degree murder. If they can't decide on first, she doesn't meet all the qualifications. We could bump it down to murder too. If neither of those bump it down to manslaughter, then the fourth option would be not guilty. As in she didn't do this at all, it wasn't her. This one is just kind of on there as a formality. No one would really choose that one because she admitted she didn't. They would likely choose, if they were going to choose a not guilty, the fifth option, which would be not guilty by reason of insanity. And that's what we ended up seeing that 11 of the jurors thought that's what they wanted and there was one holdout that didn't. That was what really blew my mind. Was it was one single juror. And obviously that person is very set in stone on what I believe it's a male. It is a male, yes. And yeah, I was honestly quite shocked. I was honestly quite shocked when it was a mistrial. I remember getting that text from my trainer, my personal trainer. And I talk about this case all the time. And she texted me that morning and said it was a mistrial. And I was shocked. That actually you and I had set up a recording that day. Yes. We had to push it because deliberations went longer than I remember we booked it. And we're like, oh, it's like two weeks out will be fine. And then deliberations went for seven days. So no one expected that. But I think you're so right to have one person, one single holdout that was stopping Lindsey Clancy from receiving a not guilty by reason of insanity. That to me, wow, I was very shocked because the internet is divided on this case, whether they think that she is a cold blooded murderer or they think that this was a mental break and the system filter, whatever you believe, I mean, it's usually 50 50. And so to see just one holdout, that was it was shocking to me too. What's very interesting to me is I do feel that the people that and you can tell me what you've seen versus what I've seen because there's so many things on the internet about this case right now. But I feel like the people that are so set on charging her with murder either are very religious and maybe choosing not to educate themselves on postpartum psychosis, but also in their minds or maybe the way that they were raised, just look at a killing as a murder and only a murder because of of their beliefs. But then I've also seen the side of people just are not educated on what postpartum psychosis is or don't realize how severe it is to not be in your right mind during a manic episode like that. I would think that those people have never experienced anything like this because if they have, they would know what it's like to not be in your right mind. And I never have had postpartum psychosis. I've never had any sort of psychosis. But I do have multiple mental health diagnoses. And so bringing that to my reporting, I really wanted to share the facts. Obviously, this is what happened in court here is what came out about all of it. But I wanted to make clear that mental health is real. And I think what's interesting is that it's a bipartisan issue. Anyone can be affected by mental health. Anybody can have postpartum depression or psychosis as long as they've given birth. And so I think this could affect anyone no matter your political party. And that's where things kind of got wonky for me online because nobody's promoting children being murdered. Nobody's promoting the horrific truths of this case. But hoping to bring awareness to the mental health side of things. And I don't know. Things just, again, it's the internet. So take it with a grain of salt. But things really got off the rails in this one. Yeah. And, you know, in my previous profession, I unfortunately did take care of children that were affected by their moms having postpartum psychosis. And a lot of those kids did not make it. And so I have been educated on postpartum psychosis and the effects of it for a long time. But again, those are not public cases. Those are not cases that made the news. Those were just really horrific tragedies that happened, you know, near the hospital that I worked on. And so we got those patients just like, you know, when, when her kiddos that were brought to the hospital were brought to try to resuscitate. And unfortunately, they did not make it. But I think, again, it wasn't, those aren't public things that people see. So I think this is people's very first experience with postpartum psychosis. And seeing these, these children's lives be taken because of it. And I think that's just a huge shock value to people. Whereas, you know, some people have seen the effects of postpartum psychosis. I've seen like a lot of dads online share their wives that, you know, took their own life because of postpartum psychosis. And I just saw one the other day that I had reshared on my stories because it broke my heart. His daughter is 13 now. But it was a photo of his wife and newborn and his wife took her life during a state of postpartum psychosis. And he talked about, you know, how important it is to be educated on it because, you know, fortunately, his daughter is, is happy and healthy and has grown up. But he lost his wife and she lost her mom. Again, like these are not public cases. This is the first that people are really seeing it. And so I think for a lot of people, it's, they almost can't believe it. It almost doesn't seem real because it's so affordable. I've seen some people online who truly believe or it seems to in the comments that a mother could never kill their children, like does not actually have the capability of doing it. And I mean, the details of it are terrible. The, the facts that the jurors had to listen to that I had to report on that the world heard, they're really, they're hard. I mean, it's, it's a very, very, dark case, but the underlying thing for me is the postpartum depression, the postpartum psychosis. And that's really the crux of the defense's argument here. And I think it's great that we're talking about it more because I mean, you talked about all of those cases that none of us had ever heard of before. I mean, I'd heard of postpartum depression. I'd never heard of postpartum psychosis until this case back in 2023. And so just to bring the awareness to it, I feel like in my reporting, I mean, every day I do true crimes. So I talk about murder, I talk about really dark things. And it's great to bring awareness to people's families, members who, you know, they deserve to be remembered. And I take that very seriously. But in this case, because I have the connection of having mental health struggles with my own, that it just struck a different chord for me, I think. And I really wanted to handle it responsibly and respectfully because this is something we have to talk about. What really struck me was the fact that Lindsay knew she was not okay. And she advocated for herself. She was seeking treatment. She was going to those doctors appointments and a mental health facility and telling, you know, her husband and her parents and her friends, I'm not in my right state of mind. I'm not sleeping. I'm having dark thoughts. She really, she wanted to get help. And I think people are not taking that into consideration, that she did want to help herself in order to help her kids. It wasn't like she knew she was having these dark thoughts and chose to ignore them. She did try to advocate for herself. I think that's such an important part of the case is like you said, she has never denied her actions when it comes to killing her children. That was never a question and that's why, you know, with all these conspiracy theories, I don't even consider it because we know the facts. It's just the intent behind it that we should be focusing on. But since mental health was the central issue here, what's the core difference between the defense saying she lost touch with reality and then the prosecution claiming that she planned it out? This is huge and I think this is why the deliberations took so long because it's very complicated. Again, it's not a who done it. In some cases, as we've seen, we know who did it. We just need to and we, I mean, the jurors just need to decide what was her status, her mental health status at the time that she strangled each one of the kids. So individually for Korra Dawson, Callan, what was that? Now the prosecution says this was pre-meditated, they laid out multiple different reasons. But the big one that they said is that they alleged she sent Patrick out of the house. That she Apple maps how far her house was from CBS, then from the 3v restaurant. She kind of clocked how long is Patrick going to be out of the house? How can I get away with this? She sent him out specifically, this is their allegation, so that she could get away with it at this time and then kill herself, which she was unsuccessful with. That's what they say. However, the defense says if she wanted to actually kill her children, like first to remurder pre-meditation, why would she do it when Patrick's running to CBS three minutes down the road? The restaurant is one townover. A couple weeks before he was in New York for two days that she could have done it if it was pre-meditated. That's kind of one of their points. The other is that they alleged she was failed by the mental health system and this is something that you were just talking about. I mean, she went to, for instance, Dr. Jennifer Tufts, 14 different telehealth appointments she had with a specific doctor and that wasn't her only doctor. She had two or three multiple before she had any of her injuries. She had 13 different prescriptions that she was on and to be clear not all at once. This is over time she starts and stops them and whatever. She was in a hospital in Rhode Island. She was in McLean Hospital here in Massachusetts. She seems to me or the defense rather, let me say, that she was really, really trying her help. She was screaming and no one was listening. So they say Lindsey reported hearing voices one time when Patrick was out of the house that said, "You need to kill the kids. That's what you've got to do." And she says she listened. So I think that's really, that's what, to sum it up, that's what it was. And that's what the jurors were talking about in the deliberation room, whose side was more believable. And prosecutors pointed out what she did during that day before the killing. And that was taking a child to the doctor, playing in the snow, making lunch for the kids. So how did they use those routine actions to argue that she was in full control of her mental state? They talked about this all the time. I'm glad that you brought this up. Because in the morning, it was Kora's doctor's appointment. Lindsey was able to drive the car there. She knew how to get there. She was able to be alone with Kora. Everything was safe. The doctor reported everything was good to go. She talked a lot about how her words weren't slurring. Because I guess this is something if you're going through a mental health issue, or if you're having a medical episode, sometimes you don't make sense. Your words kind of slurred together. They talked about this at length. That Lindsey was understandable. She made sense. She was able to text back and forth a picture of Kora at the doctor. Dawson, it was the first day that he ever dressed himself. He was three at the time. And so Patrick sent that back. They communicated. They went outside and built a snowman. Patrick was downstairs. Everything seemed great. They also talked about how she Googled 3V this restaurant was able to read the menu. She talked to the person, the hostess, or whoever was taking orders at the restaurant. Everything seemed cool there. The person was like, yeah, I understood her. She ordered things off the menu. Everything made sense. So to the prosecution, they're saying, this was a normal day. She displayed nothing of a mental break at the time. All she displayed was premeditation in trying to get Patrick out of the house. So that was kind of their argument. And on the other hand, the defense showed that she checked into a hospital, saw multiple doctors, and tried to get help before this happened. So how did they frame her medical care? They basically said that she was failed by the medical system. And have whatever opinion you want on this, but they did lay out a long list of medications that she'd been on. I mean, the bag, when they held the bag up. And if you're familiar with mental health and SSRIs, these medications take weeks. It's to start working. And I've experienced that myself, you know, and you start an SSRI, and like one week goes by, two weeks goes by, and you're like, is this going to help me coming on and off these medications in such a short amount of time? Because again, like you said, no, she was not on all of them at once, but I think holding up that bag, if you are familiar with those types of medications, it was very impactful. And by the way, when the deliberations were going, the jury asked one question, and they asked to see that bag of the prescription pills and the knife that she used to slit her wrists and throat. But I thought that was stark, too, because clearly they're going, they're talking about her mental health status at the time. Those pills, I mean, the defense just kind of went at length talking about all of the treatment that she tried to seek and didn't necessarily help. They also talked about a bipolar two diagnosis that she shouldn't have been prescribed specific SSRIs that she was. And I think this is really what was tricky is that the commonwealth had two rebuttal witnesses that said Lindsay had a mental disease or defect at the time, meaning bipolar two. When she killed her kids, she was suffering from bipolar two. And that's one of the three prongs of criteria to be not held criminally responsible if you have a mental disease or defect. The three things are you got to have a mental disease or defect. You need to appreciate your actions and you need to be able to conform to the law. And so two of the witnesses for the prosecution to the three rebuttal were like, yeah, she did have a mental disease or defect. That was really stark to me that kind of seemed to help the defenses cause. And as a nurse, I've seen how fast and quickly a patient's condition can turn without warning and mentally seeing someone appears completely fine. You know, like I remember when the hostess was up on the stand and saying she called in the order. It was no problem at all. There was no sorry for words. She was talking like a regular person. Her husband walked in totally fine. And like I have seen that where people can appear completely normal. But inside, it's not. And I think everyone shows symptoms differently of what they're going through. And so I think having this black and white script of what needs to be shown or what symptoms need to be visible in order to diagnose someone with something like postpartum psychosis. But how did the defense explain that someone with postpartum psychosis can look totally fine one hour but then completely lose touch with reality the next? This is tricky to explain because what you just that I loved it, that it isn't black and white. It's kind of like a spectrum almost for lack of a better term of how people present. And one person who has bipolar to is different than another one or seen postpartum depression and psychosis. And I think they talked about that how it can display differently with different people. And they really tried to narrow in on this with their witnesses, their experts who were saying it can happen just like that. You can be good one seconds and the next you can be affected. And I think we see that in anybody who has mental health issues. I mean, like, if you look at Instagram, for example, everyone's posting photos where they look pretty. For the most part, you know, you want to post where you're having fun and you're on vacation. I do that. I post my best work. I'm not going to post photos where I'm, like, taking my anxiety medication in the morning or I'm crying on the floor. I don't really post those so people don't see that happening and yet it could still be happening. And so I think they did a good job of highlighting that maybe she was presenting at the time she called the hostess. The hostess was like, yeah, just seems like another mom calling up, great, have a good day, didn't know what was going on behind closed doors. And I think also, that's one of the reasons why everyone was so interested in this case. Because if you look at photos of this family, it's literally a white picket fence. They have this beautiful, nautical home on the way to the cape and Martha's vineyard. They're beautiful. The kids are so cute, they're well dressed, they're smart. She worked at Mass Gen Hospital. I mean, they look like they have it all. And Kevin Reddington pointed to this in the closing arguments. He had a picture of that. How do we go from this to this? The second, this being a photo of Lindsey in the hospital after she had jumped from a second story window. How does this happen? And so I think that they tried to show as best as they could that you can present one way and in reality, in your reality, be feeling a different way. Experts say postpartum psychosis affects roughly one to two out of every 1,000 babies, which I think seem small, but I don't think people realize that babies are born every second. So it's much more common than what we realize. And it acts like a sudden mental breakdown. So from a trial perspective, how was that explained to the jury? That's such an interesting question, because I learned those statistics, too, I researched them. I don't remember hearing them in the trial. And I wonder, too, if it was perhaps because of the defenses, like this isn't about anyone else. This is about how Lindsey was in the moment, and they wanted it to be so nuanced as to what she was like in that exact moment. So I don't think it was really talked about in the same way. However, I will note that bipolar disorder, if you have a diagnosis of that, you're more likely to suffer from postpartum depression or psychosis. This, I believe, was something that was addressed there. So they talked about she had this underlying diagnosis. Perhaps that's what exacerbated her symptoms that she had here. But to your point, I don't know that they really showed how prevalent this is in the world. Did they ever explain the difference between postpartum psychosis and postpartum depression? We definitely talked about that because they talked about the mania of it all, which is something that's different than postpartum depression, what you have. Generally, and I'm not a complete expert in this, but generally there isn't mania associated with postpartum depression, but with postpartum psychosis, there is or there could be. So they did distinguish the two because not that postpartum depression doesn't affect a lot of people or is easy by any means because it's not. They emphasize that postpartum psychosis is more encompassing, more kind of takes over and they really highlighted all of that. Did they ever bring in the fact that Lindsay was an RN and with her background, she should have recognized her own to climb more because I think that can be taken into perspective, but also I feel like she did ask for help so much and did realize that she wasn't doing well, but was that conversation, did that ever come up? They talked a lot about her history as a nurse, her nursing school when she met Patrick, the fact that she worked as a labor and delivery nurse and mass gen. And I think the defense used it to their advantage saying she is a medical professional. She's seen people who have experienced things like this. So that is why she went to the great lengths that she did. So they didn't say that she didn't do enough. They said, my God, look at the amount of times that she had telehealth appointments. She went from doctor to doctor to doctor. And I, again, I was just thinking about this in my own perspective. I feel like, just my personal opinion, she did go to doctors a lot because she started having these experiences, these symptoms in September, 2022. And then obviously the kids died in January of 2023. That's only a couple of months. She had all of those doctors appointments in that time, tried 13 different medications. It was a lot. And so I think the defense back to that pill bag, they were like, look at all of this. Her, her life as an L&D told her, raised the alarm for all of this and she tried her hardest. So I think they used it like that. What do you think is the reason why she chose not to take the stand? This is a lot of people ask me this question because we want to know, we want to hear from her perspective. And it's always up to the defendant if they want to take the stand or not. It's a discussion with their attorney. Some people think that the defense attorney can choose to put her on the stand. I always think of legally blonde when Brooke is like, if you put me on the stand, I'll lie. And I always am like, okay, first of all, great movie. But second of all, it's your choice if you want to go on the stand. So it was up to Lindsay in the very end. And I'm sure she and Kevin are writing to talk about it. But if I'm guessing what that conversation would be like, I think she already has all of the eyes of the world on her. She could definitely feel that, you know, like when you're somewhere and you can feel people watching you, I guarantee she could feel that because when everyone in the courtroom, all eyes were staring at her. She could definitely feel it. And I wonder if he thought you're just going to receive more criticism here. It's just going to make it worse. Number one, and number two, is she goes on the stand, whatever the questions are from the defense. That opens her up to cross-exam, which would be questions from the Commonwealth. And that to me, I don't want to testify at all. Cross-exam would be really hard, especially if we're talking about something so intense as killing your children. So I think it ultimately was the right decision, but that's likely some of the things they talked about. Yeah, I fully agree when it comes to the cross-examination because I can't even imagine the types of questions she would be asked. And you can physically see how affected she is by all of this, especially during the really intense portions of the trial, which I wanted to ask you about, being in the courtroom. What stood out to you about her reactions during some of these really painful testimonies? We saw a range of emotions in Lindsay, but all negative, let me say. Like, she was not happy during any of this. I saw her smile one singular time, and this was before the cameras were rolling. It was Kevin Reddington just kind of chatting with her. I think that they were joking or something. Kind of before anybody even came into the courtroom, except for me and my photographer. So that was one fleeting moment. The rest of the time, most of the time, she looked kind of in a trance. She would stare straight forward, almost like blurred eyes, just kind of zoning out, essentially. That was one of her kind of looks. Another one, she would follow along with what the witness was saying, you know, look at who's talking, whether it's the prosecutor asking questions, she would turn her head to the prosecutor, then back to the witness, so she was kind of following along sometimes. Other times, she would cry an open court. I think if anybody had watched the live stream, they've seen when she puts her head down on the desk, and she's crying audibly. One of the times most recently during deliberations, when we were kind of nearing the end, we could kind of tell, we could feel the vibes for lack of a better term, that we're going to reach probably a hung jury. It's going to be a mistrial. And she was wheeled out. So I had, usually in the live stream, you can see the left side of her face only, but I saw her front on. And she had mascara running down her face, like she had been crying in the back room. She at the moment was not crying, she looked fine, but she, you could tell that she had been crying. And that's something that Reddington said too. He talked about how he had mascara stands on his jacket, because she just would fall into him and just lose it. And so for the amount of times that we saw her reacting in court crying audibly, I think there was way more behind closed doors. You could not punish her more than she already is punishing herself. I can't even imagine what her daily thoughts are. And I'm sure for her, this is obviously a chapter that she wants to, it will never be closed for her. It's their children, but obviously, this has been a very intense situation when it comes to being essentially in a public courtroom for the world to see. And so knowing she was towards the end, and then it's a mistrial, I can't even imagine the weight, the weight of that. But I wanted to ask if you were in the courtroom during the 911 call. I was not in the courtroom for the 911 call, but I did interview my photographer who was in there for it. I can kind of recap for what he said. - Yes, please. - Because that one, I have heard from anybody who has actually heard the 911 call. My photographer who I'm very close with, Richie, I'll give him a shout out. Other reporters who were in there, jurors have now spoken out about it. Everybody that I've heard from says that their lives changed after hearing the 911 call, that they will never forget it, that it was guttural sounds from Patrick Clancy. I literally have chills. I didn't even hear it, by the way. And I have chills just talking about how they describe it. That the entire jury box, there was 18 people, so 12 jurors plus six alternates. Everyone was crying, every single person. Lindsay was losing it. The gallery people were tearing up. Reporters, my photographer, who's this like guy, I've never seen this man cry. And he said he was even tearing up, that this was, he described it as the sound of Patrick's heart breaking. His soul leaving his body is the quote from Richie. And I, I've thought about that so much because there's been so much flak around Patrick Clancy, the way that he-- he presented on the stand or his timeline doesn't add up or whatever it is on TikTok saying all these conspiracy theories and I really have to wonder if the world heard that 911 call would they feel the same way because the descriptions I've gotten are that it was just heart breaking. I get asked all the time if what I saw in the pick you affects me or has scarred me and I always say it's the cries from the parents when they lose their child. That is that is something that you never forget. I don't know what it is about the whales of a father losing their child and I can distinctly think about who they were, what it sounded like, who their kids were like that is something that stays with you forever and so for that to be recorded with him discovering all three of his children I cannot even imagine the emotion of that and I can't imagine Lindsay having to sit there and core and listen to it. I mean just you describing that the whales of someone I truly have chills right now because that's the worst moment of their life and then for it to be recorded and out there for people to listen to I mean the judge did rule in favor of Patrick Clancy that this would not be published and I think that's probably a good thing because can you imagine he's on vacation just living his life just doom scrolling and all of a sudden it comes up on his tech talker Instagram I mean he already lives with this every single day all of the family members do by the way you know Lindsay's parents they're victims here too and so to have to hear that I think I'm glad I didn't hear it because it would be hard to go to sleep at night. Yeah and aside from him maybe having to listen to it again you know if he's scrolling I think it's what you said why should the worst moment of his entire life of her entire life of their whole family's entire life be released to the entire public who doesn't don't even know these people personally it's just tragic and I just I don't think it's necessary so I think it was a really good decision by the judge to not share that not in any murder case there is no winners obviously but in this case I feel like it's even worse it's because Lindsay if she was found not guilty by reason of insanity she wouldn't be free she'd be back to a hospital and institution so it's just there are so many victims in this case it's a true tragedy I'm just personally curious if you were there for when Lindsay was crying and the prosecution apparently said can you shut her up oh the shot her up thing I was not there for that one no they disputed that that they they wasn't them and but that was a huge drama that my photographer got called into the back courtroom where it was like give us your feed we need to enhance the audio whatever whatever I was not there for that but that was one of the times that she was crying yeah yeah defense was pissed as they should be if they heard something like that I mean which to the commonwealth's credit I've watched that video so many times because I've done like episodes about it and Jen sprig was like what like her face is like huh and so she's so confused about it she looked to me genuinely like what are they talking about so it was determined it wasn't them you said that outside the courtroom it's chaos I'm sure I've seen some of the clips of everyone like the attorneys leaving and they're just being swarmed do you think it's more in support of Lindsay for you know her mental health issues or do you think it's more people saying that she should be put away from murder I think that the people who accused her of murder are louder and I mean that literally they are screaming this one woman during one of my live shots I was I kept getting thrown off because she was screaming murder murder and I was like okay block her out block her out don't think about her and just work on my report so I think those people are literally louder like screaming but the other side I feel like there's more support for Lindsay pink kind of became her color there was that one day where they had all those people gathered wearing pink to support Lindsay and raise awareness for mental health issues and since that day that was I don't know three weeks ago every day after that I saw someone in the gallery a spectator just an everyday person not reporter wearing pink and they were always outside I would say there's definitely more people who were pro Lindsay who at least showed up than were anti Lindsay now that the judge has declared a mistrial because the jury couldn't reach a unanimous verdict what happens next for Lindsay and then will the prosecution choose to retry the case for now Lindsay goes back to the hospital that she's been at since I think was February of 2023 took spary hospital so she has her nurses there to help her she's been on one-on-one or one-to-one rather suicide watch since this happens three and a half years at this point which is a really long time by the way as a previous ice universe that is so long it's so long that is so long and isolating big yeah that's okay so she goes back to so she's back there and I thought that that was stark too because I've done stories where he did he for instance was on suicide watch when he first went into jail and then prison but it was like a three day period and it was kind of normal that usually happens that you have that for a little while and then whatever but three and a half years so long so anyway so she'll go back to the hospital that's where she is now and then as far as the DA there are a couple of different options that they could do they could do the exact same thing again charge her with three counts of first-degree murder say that we're going to trial judge Sullivan I was in the courtroom he's like let's put this on the books for the fall and I was like last I checked it September were in the false that means what October November so they could do it first degree in a matter of weeks I don't know that's a possibility another possibility is they could bump it down and charge her with second degree murder or manslaughter or something like that third option they could meet with Kevin Reddington possibly negotiate a plea deal so that we don't the taxpayers other jurors Lindsay the families nobody has to go through this all over again I don't know how likely that is and even less likely is option number four which would be that the Commonwealth says okay we tried it didn't work out we're not going to refile the charges Lindsay will not be charged and she can just live in the hospital I don't think that will happen though if we go back to trial a second time do you think this mistrial benefits either the defense or prosecution in any way by knowing where the jury pretty much stood I do I think it helps both sides honestly it's almost like a scrimmage you kind of know and it's a different jury obviously whoever that they would seat on this hypothetical jury Kevin Reddington was asked this on Friday we asked him you know what would you do differently and he said I wouldn't do anything differently I won so he says he's going to stick with the same thing for the prosecution I feel like they could switch up their playbook because in the end 11 people were essentially voting against they wanted a conviction of some sort and 11 out of the 12 jurors were voting that she's not guilty by reason of insanity so I think that kind of give them a leg up and I think they would probably change the way that they went about it because if you remember way back in opening statements they kind of changed their tune the start of opening statements they said we don't even really know if she tried to commit suicide he's hard to work that deep again I'm paraphrasing by the way but they said was it even a real suicide attempt she just didn't want to be a mom anymore and they asked so many of the experts how deep were the cuts you know she didn't even take enough prescription pills to overdose she went to died from that talking about her being a meticulous mom kind of like a helicopter mom when they interviewed her nanny saying oh weird that she wrote things really specific notes all of that switched to the end with closing arguments where they said she really actually was a good mom and she really did have mental health issues she tried to die by suicide but she was in the right mind at the time and so they kind of completely changed their tune at least I thought from the start to the finish and they had a very strong closing argument in my opinion they did a pretty good job with that so I wonder if this time they're going to go in knowing all the criticisms that the world over has and make sure to focus on the mental health in a different light than they did the first time around I agree and I think after seeing how big this has gone and everyone's outside opinions I think they kind of can go back to the drawing board and rebuild from the bottom up yeah totally but whenever that happens I'm flying there you're flying to LA and we'll do this all over again depending on what the results are yeah let's let's do it all over again I mean it'll be exhausting but I do like that people are talking about mental health and platforms like yours that you're bringing it up and bringing awareness to it I really like that so thank you for having me no thank you so much for coming on and same to you thank you for all of your knowledge and sharing what's going on inside the courtroom I'm very grateful and yeah at the end of the day all I want is to spread more awareness about what can happen after you have a baby because it's very hard so I hope the best for their entire family and I hope that they can have peace and yeah We'll see you hopefully sooner than later. - Yeah, sounds good. - It was so nice to meet you. Thank you again for coming on. I really appreciate it. - Yeah, thank you so much for having me. This was great. (upbeat music)

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Lindsay Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, faced murder charges for killing her three children, with prosecutors alleging premeditated intent and the defense arguing she suffered from severe postpartum psychosis.
  2. The trial ended in a mistrial due to a jury deadlock, with 11 jurors voting for "not criminally responsible" due to mental illness and one holdout opposing that verdict.
  3. The prosecution claimed Clancy planned the killings, citing actions like sending her husband out of the house, while the defense emphasized her active medical treatment, multiple doctor visits, and symptoms of psychosis.
  4. A key point of contention was whether Clancy was in full control of her mental state during the killings, with evidence including routine daily activities versus sudden psychotic episodes.
  5. Postpartum psychosis, though rare (1–2 in 1,000 births), is often misunderstood, and the case brought widespread public awareness about its severity and the medical system’s role in failing patients.
  6. Clancy’s medical history, including bipolar disorder and numerous medications, and her consistent efforts to seek help were central to the defense’s argument.
  7. The 911 call from Patrick Clancy, described as heart-wrenching and emotionally devastating, deeply affected the jury and observers, highlighting the trauma of parental loss.
  8. Public reaction was polarized, with strong mental health advocacy movements (like pink-themed support) emerging, indicating a shift in societal awareness beyond conspiracy theories and punitive judgment.

Summary:

The Lindsay Clancy trial, which centered on the killing of her three young children in 2023, became a focal point for national discussion on postpartum psychosis. Prosecutors alleged premeditated murder, claiming Clancy planned the killings, while the defense argued she was not criminally responsible due to severe mental illness, including postpartum psychosis and bipolar disorder. Despite her admission of the acts, the jury deadlocked, resulting in a mistrial after 11 jurors voted for not criminally responsible and one held out.

The trial revealed the complexity of diagnosing mental health conditions in real time, with evidence showing Clancy sought help through multiple doctors and medications, yet still experienced sudden psychotic episodes. The public reaction was deeply divided, with intense online debates and a surge in mental health advocacy, particularly through symbolic gestures like wearing pink. The case highlighted the invisibility of postpartum psychosis in public discourse, with many individuals unaware of its severity or prevalence.

Sierra Gillespie, who reported from the courtroom, emphasized the emotional toll on both the family and the public, noting the trauma of hearing the 911 call and the stark contrast between Clancy’s outwardly normal life and her internal mental state. Ultimately, the case underscored the urgent need for greater education, early intervention, and societal understanding of postpartum mental health, showing how tragedy can catalyze meaningful change in awareness and support systems.

FAQs

Postpartum psychosis is a rare but serious mental health condition that involves sudden onset of symptoms like hallucinations, delusions, and disorganized thinking. It differs from postpartum depression, which involves sadness and anxiety but typically lacks mania or psychotic features. Postpartum psychosis can severely disrupt a mother's reality and is more dangerous in its symptoms.

The prosecution argued that Lindsay planned the killings and was of sound mind, citing actions like sending her partner out of the house to evade detection. The defense claimed she suffered from severe postpartum psychosis, where she lost touch with reality despite appearing normal during daily activities, and that she actively sought help before the incident.

After seven days of deliberation, the jury could not reach a unanimous decision. Eleven jurors voted for a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict, while one juror held out, leading to a mistrial. This outcome highlighted deep divisions in how mental health and criminal responsibility should be evaluated in such cases.

The trial gained massive global attention on social media, with intense online debates, conspiracy theories, and public outrage. The community reaction was deeply divided, with some demanding accountability and others advocating for mental health awareness, showing how social media can amplify both misinformation and awareness.

No, Lindsay chose not to take the stand. The defense cited concerns about the emotional toll of cross-examination and the potential for further public scrutiny, especially given the intense media attention and the trauma of the case.

The defense emphasized that Lindsay sought extensive medical care, including 13 doctor appointments and multiple medications, demonstrating her efforts to seek help. They argued that the medical system failed her, and that her symptoms were consistent with postpartum psychosis, not premeditated murder.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.