Support for the show comes from Plod, the AI-powered note-taking device built for real-world conversations. Whether you're meeting in person or online, Plod can help you capture the conversations that matter, instead of interrupting the conversation to open an app or manually type notes. Plod is designed to be simple and ready when you need it. With just one tap, you can start capturing a conversation. No app to open, no complicated setup, and no need to stop what you're doing. For a limited time, listeners can get 22% off-plod with code
[email protected]/PropGMarkets. Spelled, PL-A-U-D.ai/PropGMarkets. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project, one app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at od.com/vox. That's od.o.com/vox. I'm Aina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. And this week's episode, I'm joined by Rose Byrne. We talk all about her love of mixology, doing a stoop sale in Brooklyn, and her dislike of marshmallows on sweet potatoes. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers! Welcome to Profty Markets, I'm Ed Elson, it is November 17th. Let's check in on yesterday's market vitals. The major indices slid as the Nvidia sell-off continued. The NASDAQ shed more than 2%, meanwhile Brent Crude declined, and finally the yield on 10-year treasuries slipped, but remained above 5.1%. Okay, what's happening? Jensen Huang may be out at Nvidia, but the campaign to bring him back is already underway. According to the Financial Times, Huang has discussed returning as Nvidia's CEO and allies are building a "war room" to lobby the board. An online petition calling for Huang's reinstatement has drawn nearly 180,000 signatures, including Elon Musk's. The FT later reported the board is not considering reinstatement Huang, though the board itself has not made a statement. When asked about whether he thought Huang should be reinstated, President Trump weighed in. He said, quote, "That certainly isn't a bad idea." But Treasury Secretary Scott Besant has taken a very different position. A day earlier, he called for, quote, "a dramatic shake-up in leadership and urged the board to look outside the company for its next CEO." Meanwhile, the scandal has revived a fight over export controls in Washington. On Monday, the Colmer's Department moved to block Chinese companies from remotely accessing US chips through data centers in Southeast Asia and Brazil, and Commerce Secretary Howard Lucknick is facing mounting scrutiny over his department's handling of suspected chips muggling to China. Nvidia's stock has fallen over 25% since the scandal broke. The company faces another major test later today when it reports third-quarter earnings. Its first results will happen under Interim CEO Collette Cress and its first earnings report since Huang's departure. So joining us to discuss all of this, we have a lot to get into. We have Deirdre Bosa, Founder and Host of Deirdre Bosa Live, and Rohan Goswami, Business Reporter at Semaphore. So thank you both for joining me. I think we should start with Jensen Huang's potential comeback. Supposedly, he is in talks. I don't know who he's talking about this with, but apparently this is something he'd like to do. I guess Rohan, I'll start with you. Do you think this is going to happen? Is he actually going to return? Absolutely not, and thanks as always for having me. We are in the thick of Silicon Valley in the world. So we have our Semaphore event. We have something like 400 AICOs, TXOs here, and this has of course been the topic to sure. We had Sam Altman yesterday talking about Jensen's return. And he offered a sort of very carefully nuanced Sam Altman-esque response, which is like, yeah, this guy's great, but didn't take a stance either way. One thing I can tell you based on my own reporting, when we reported that Collette Collette Cress was in the lead to become the CFO ad in video, we spoke of course with a number of people who are familiar with NVIDIA's boards thinking, and I think it's important to stress, this was not an easy decision for them to make. These are people who have known Jensen for three decades, some of whom have been with him since the beginning, and the point that was made to me time and time again, imagine how high the bar would have to be to get rid of Jensen. They're not going to undo that decision no matter what anyone says, because it's important to note he's acknowledged one affair that's been reporting to others. That is against his contract. That is just basic, good corporate government. So the idea that anyone could pressure this company into letting Jensen return is a non-starter from where I sit from the people that I talk to, who are close to this board. Okay, Deirdre Rohan says no shot he comes back. Do you agree? I am not as certain as Rohan is. First of all, Jensen Huang was not kicked out of his CO position by the board. He resigned, and some people around here believed that that maybe does open the way for him to come back. Now, absolutely, if Jensen Huang was found to have broken the law, to have somehow and around about way get Nvidia GPUs into China, that is an incredibly serious matter, and that is illegal. So in that scenario, I would also find it incredibly difficult that Jensen Huang could come back as CO. With the matter of the other two affairs, yes, these are corporate governance issues, but Silicon Valley has collected a lot of influence and a lot of power over the last few years. And listen, if Sam Altman could come back within just a few days of being ousted, of CO, of OpenAI, it is plausible. Certainly, to people here, I'm not saying this is my opinion, but it is certainly plausible to people here in the tech community that Jensen Huang could come back that there is a path for him. And I think that's what you're seeing playing out, whether it's Elon Musk, whether it's other people in the tech community, saying Jensen is Nvidia, Nvidia is Jensen. You could also make the argument that him coming back is good for shareholders. You have a long way to go before that is actually a possibility, but I'm certainly not as sure as Rohan is that there is no way. I guess part of the question that hasn't been totally clear throughout this entire drama is, what does the board one actually think? And what are they actually, I mean, ousting him, I mean, they didn't really fire him, as you say, Deirdre, he resigned. So we don't really know how that interaction went down. But what is it, what is this all actually about? Because for my seat, I'm like, the big problem is that you seemed to be in a relationship with someone who was smuggling chips into China and therefore violating US export laws. That's a big deal. And maybe you were complicit in that because you had a relationship with this person. You seemed to know this person quite well. It doesn't look good. But then there's the other thing which is he had affairs with people. He had an affair with a subordinate, which a lot of people are saying, "Oh, that's terrible, you can't do that." I find it to be evidence that he might be kind of a more scummy guy than we had hoped. But to me, it's not grounds for firing. To me, I'm more focused on the first thing, but I guess we don't know. So, I mean, Rohan, just over to you, like, what does the board actually think at this point? And what are they not, if they go rid of him, what is it actually about? The comparison I've made before is that this is sort of the Al Capone situation. The federal government didn't get Al Capone for smuggling alcohol or for breaking any sort of law. They got him for tax evasion, right? This was a technical matter on which they nabbed him. And again, Deardre's absolutely right. Jensen did resign. I think the point there that's important, though, is that this was a board with Jensen that deliberated this for hours. And what my understanding is is that he was basically given an ultimatum. You can resign or we can fire you, but those are your two choices, which is usually how we see these things shaking out. What a board doesn't want to get rid of the CEO. I think you're also right to say that there is a lot of focus on the involvement of this alleged spy out of swung. I think where that misses the mark is twofold. One, anyone who follows China closely knows the word spy in this context is an expansive word. You can be an asset, you can be feeding information, you can just be incidentally or unwillingly or unwittingly helpful to the intelligence services without actually being a spy. It's a very, very nuanced subtle point. The Deardre knows, well, she's covered this space very well. And so I think that yes, it's a little misplaced to be super concerned about Alice Wong's involvement. What is more pressing and what is more concerning is what it's brought to light, which is not just Alice Wong specifically, but what did Nvidia know about its ships being used in China? And when did they know it? The third question to that is also what involvement or blessing do the U.S. government have with any of the Deardre you don't agree? No, I don't because it's one question to ask what Nvidia knew. It is another question to ask what Washington knew. Why wasn't Megat speed put on the entity?
Why wasn't it a blacklisted company? Absolutely. And that is a really important question. And I don't know that it's been proved that Alice Wong was a spy. I'm with Ed here, and that this is the question we need to be asking. And I think the other affairs, while not good and, you know, show something about Johnson Wong's character, are not as important as him breaking the law. And I think when you talk about Megaspin and you talk about, you know, this relationship that Nvidia has with Southeast Asian companies, and whether that ultimately fed chips into China, that is really important because it gets at the stakes here. There's somebody out there that are arguing that more expert controls, and remember, Johnson was the biggest advocate of them, that actually having those in place is going to be good for America. And I just wholeheartedly disagree with that argument. If Johnson is not in Washington arguing that we America should be competing on innovation versus restricting our technology overseas, that's going to lead in the long term to China building its own stack and exporting that to other countries, maybe not the United States, but to Africa, to Europe, to other companies that will build on models that, and chips that are capable, maybe not as capable as Nvidia, but maybe more efficient and easier to get. No, Dierdo, you've kind of hit the nail on the head with this issue, which is that this is actually a DC problem. And you have two very divided camps. You have Marco Rubio, who is a longtime China hog, one of the most aggressive people in the administration on China against Howard Ludnick, who does take a much more akin to the view that you're hearing from folks, Dierdo, a big tent approach to chip exports. And this has really driven the administration in a way that no other issue has, not immigration, not the elections. This has become the seminal issue. And I do think that that's what we're seeing play out in the reporting, and the leaks that are emerging, of course, Marco Rubio was the author of this alleged memo that the times reported on that really catalyzed this whole storyline, and I know a lot of folks in the valley have been very up in the arms about, up in arms about that, that it's the deep state. It's really not. It's actually politics as usual. It is two powerful political figures weaponizing or using different parts of their respective camps to get their agenda done. And Jensen Wong certainly seems to have been caught in the crosshairs of what is a DC turf fight. That the whole irony of this, guys, is that the position that the hawks in Washington are taking, is the Chinese position. China has been restricting the sale of NVIDIA chips inside of China so that they can build up demand for their own homegrown domestic chip companies like Huawei. So the irony in all of this is that you take Jensen Wong away, and it's actually good for China. Is your view then, Deirdre, that they would not smuggling these chips into China? I mean, it's hard to tell, and to your point, like, it's hard to tell what anyone's incentives actually are. Like even Trump, it's like, you know, he said that I don't know if she was a spy, but this is often his own intelligence agency is saying, no, no, we think that she's a spy. So we're getting mixed messages from everyone here. But what do you think was going on with China then if it's your view that actually they didn't want the chips to begin with? So I don't know if NVIDIA, if Jensen Wong was behind trying to get chips into China. What I do know is that it is not illegal for Chinese labs to rent GPUs outside of China. So again, the finger kind of goes back to Washington. They had all of these rules. They didn't enforce that. Jensen Wong, I should say though, he was following the letter of the law if he was not smuggling chips into China. If he was, you know, allowing them to be sold to Singaporean companies and maybe turning a blind eye if they were then putting them into China. But if he was getting chips into Singapore and then Chinese AI labs were renting them in Singapore, that is not against the law. So a lot of different things are being conflated here. And I think also because Jensen was this larger than life figure, gaining a lot of influence in Washington, adhering to the letter, but maybe not the spirit of the law, he made a lot of enemies. I totally agree with you there, Deirdre. There's one, there's two point I would make there. One my brilliant colleague Ashley Gold reported last night that commerce has actually changed that rule, so that now if you are an American supplier or an American cloud provider, you can no longer access these chips remotely. The other point I would make though, vis-a-vis the letter in the spirit of the law, that is also exactly right. We reported over the weekend, there are two figures that are not very well known, but are very important here. One is Jeff Kessler, he's at commerce and he sort of oversees all this. The other is Tim Teeter, who was really, if Jensen was the face of NVIDIA in DC, Tim Teeter was the muscle. He is their general counsel. And Teeter, on behalf of NVIDIA, violently fought back earlier this year against three rules that the Commerce Department wanted to impose on NVIDIA. One was that these advance ships would be destroyed at the end of their useful life. Two, was that you'd have some sort of geolocation or tracking functionality in there. And three, and this was most contentious for NVIDIA, was that their customers, these cloud providers, would have to certify who their end users were, similar to a bomb or a gun that's being exported from here. NVIDIA fought on all of those points, which to me, as we reported this out in the point that I've made, is you would not be opposed to those measures, unless ultimately on some level. You knew that your chips might be ending up in China or somewhere they weren't going to be. They weren't supposed to be. I hear what you're saying, however, it's really important to note that NVIDIA was allowed to sell previous generations, chips into China. NVIDIA was not selling, at least as far as we know, their most advanced, their latest generation chips. So, the whole idea of selling lesser generation, less capable chips, was to keep China on the American stack, which is an argument now that is more difficult to make because of Johnson's credibility and everything that we have found out. But I think it is still a very legitimate one. It is good for America if we can keep China on the American staff, but a less capable one. That is good for all of us, for American tech. It's not great for the Chinese. I mean, they're already closing the gap, but it's harder for them to do so if you're selling older chips. But the trouble is that he was selling via this Singaporean shell company in Megaspeed. He was selling the more advanced ones. But we don't know that for sure, although the actually dear to argue one point against that is that, yes, there is a popular sort of view from, I guess, for lack of a better word, not to ape back to our CNBC days, but the more dovish people who believe that, yes, that China should be building the American stack. The contrary is we've seen this story play out before in the late 80s, early 90s as American companies came into China, viewing it as this very fertile, untapped market and partnering with a lot of Chinese companies to get their businesses out there, to get their products out there. Ultimately, what many American companies have found to varying degrees is that in the end, it became sort of the harbinger of their own doom, whether it was allegations of industrial espionage or IP theft. This is a complicated story that we've seen and we've seen this argument before that working and going into China for American businesses will actually be good for American interests, but it hasn't always worked out that way. Sure. I guess you could point at electric vehicles in China was able to develop its industry, but I do think that in the case of chips, it's more dynamic, it's faster moving. I think it's more akin to the internet, and I lived in China for over five years, and I got to experience the great firewall, right? China basically just cut off American internet companies from operating there. What happened, they created demand for their own internet companies, which have now become some of the biggest in the world. So it's really that demand piece that I think is crucial here. Chinese companies and developers, they still want Nvidia chips, but by China banning them, they're creating this sort of demand for their homegrown chips, which over time is going to make them better because demand is the only thing right that they learn from, or the most effective way that they get better. We'll be right back, and be sure to tune in tomorrow November 18th at 10.30am for a live stream with Aswath Demoder and we'll be breaking down Nvidia's earnings that will only be available to ProfG+ subscribers, so if you want to go watch that, go to profgmedia.com/subscribe to sign up today. Build member means earning points on every housing payment no matter where you lift. Built points can be redeemed for flights, hotels, lift rides, Amazon.com purchases, future housing payments, and more. One unexpected benefit built gives every member access to is it's a genetic neighborhood concierge in the belt app. It doesn't just give you information about your home in neighborhood, you can ask it to pay your rent, make it in a reservation, book a fitness class, schedule a lift, and more. Here are the steps. First, download the built app. Second, link any credit or debit card to the app, so purchases at your local spots become even more rewarding. And third, ask the neighborhood concierge in the app pretty much anything. It'll tell you about exclusive member benefits at restaurants, fit the studios on your lift rides and more. And for the homeowners out there, built works for mortgages too. Download the built app and join the membership for where you live at joinbuilt.com/profg. That's j-o-i-n-b-i-l-t.com/profg, use our link so they know we sent you. Support for the show comes from SoFi. Here's the thing. Most traditional banks pay almost nothing in interest, so your money ends up just sitting there, twinling at sums, doing nothing. And if your money's doing nothing, it's not doing its job. You work hard for every dollar, so why not put those dollars to work for you? That's where SoFi comes in. This is the everything app for smarter money, with SoFi checking and savings. You can easily track your spending and save towards your goals while learning nine times the national average savings rate. You'll get paid up to two days early with direct deposit and you can access additional FUIC insurance up to $3 million on your phone.
deposits through a network of participating banks. You'll play no account or overdraft fees and you can also earn a cash bonus when you sign up with eligible direct deposit. You also can organize your savings and evolves for the goals that matter most. Small decisions like this can create big momentum over time. You can open your SoFi Checking and Savings account today. Head to SoFi.com/ProvGMac to get started. At SoFi.com/ProvGMac, SoFi Checking and Savings is offered through SoFiMac and a member FTIC. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One after accounting, another for inventory, another for sales and somehow none of them talk to each other. That's where auto comes in and all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs and best of all, no spreadsheets. Try for free today at odu.com/vox. That's oduo.com/vox. We're back with ProvG Markets. Let's move on to whether Nvidia can still be in video without Jensen Huang because that seems to be the question for shareholders at this point. You know, there is an argument that it's, you know, it's the board's fiduciary responsibility to protect shareholders, therefore to protect the stock price. That's their job. And if that's their job, then maybe there's a question of should they bring him back. Is it essential for Jensen Huang to be the CEO? Deirdre, what do you think of that question? Then I'll go to Rohan. I haven't had as many interactions with Colette Crass, the CFO, who's the interim CEO now. But I knew Jensen fairly well. And, you know, the thinking here, though, is that, and from people I've talked to, is that Colette Crass is very capable as an intern CEO. But who's going to be next? And I've heard the same names floated that you guys have, Ian Buck, who was sort of the creator of CUDA software, which became Nvidia's most most effective mode over the last few decades. Renee Haas from ARM could come in. But who's best equipped for this job? I mean, no question, absolutely no question. It's Jensen Huang. The question is, can you actually come back, which we've been debating? I'm not sure. So who is the next best person? As regards to earnings tonight and even sort of the trajectory of the company in the next one to two years, this roadmap has been laid out years in advance. So it is likely to continue to do very well in that sort of one to two year roadmap. Beyond that is a much bigger question, right? Because you need to stay at the frontier. That is something that Nvidia has done incredibly well, which led it to become the most valuable company in the world, is a new chip every single year. I don't know if the next CEO, whoever it is, can operate at that kind of level. And also, I should say, with the kind of level of paranoia that Jensen Huang had, when you have all of these competitors from Google, TPUs to Amazon, Trinion to even open AI's jalapeno in the early stages, who's going to be looking over their shoulders much as Jensen was to make sure Nvidia stays ahead. I do agree, mostly with with Deirdre that that Jensen is no doubt probably was probably the best guy to leave this thing on. On one point though, I'd say, you know, Collette is well known to the street. She's a steady pair of hands and Deirdre's absolutely right. This roadmap is sort of set in stone. But the real question is what what what happens over the course of the next few weeks, right, with earnings and what Collette is able to do to reassure customers, vendors, suppliers, I have to imagine she's going to be spending a lot of time on the road. And in many ways, she's, she's doomed to fail. If you go back to the financial crisis, there was a seminal earnings call similar to this one that Lehman Brothers put on to sort of a swage investors, calm the markets. And they put their CFO on a woman named Aaron Callan. And Aaron killed it. Aaron absolutely crushed it and did amazingly. And within I want to say two or three quarters, Lehman was bankrupt. That is obviously not going to happen here. But it is what happened when it is sort of when you're giving these jobs and you are not the guy, you are not the person, you are not the founder, you are not the visionary, you are almost set up to fail. And Deirdre is again right when she says that that Ian is in contention. The FT has reported that Renee Haas is also in contention. Renee, of course, has said, I'm not interested, but he would also say that even if he was interested, you know, what is clear is that whoever they pick, whether it's Tim Cook or Renee or Ian, we'll have to do two things, right? They have to solve the customer problem, right, which is make customers feel like they're still going to get their chips. And that to Deirdre's point, these chips are still going to be cutting edge. And two, they're going to have to solve the government problem, whether it's the Singaporean government or the Chinese government or the American government. They are one to have to be a person who can be like Jensen was this larger than life, statesman, who really did have this aura about him. Can I just say one more implication that I think is really important here that we haven't yet discussed on a week when Anthropic is going to go public. Jensen was building for this multi model world. He really believed that there should be many different labs, right? And that is really important for the balance of power in AI that you shouldn't just have to front to your labs. Anthropic and open AI, controlling everything. And he was as big an advocate for that as he was against export control. So that is something that I think the AI world is going to have to contend with in the weeks and months I had especially as Anthropic goes public and sort of consolidates that capital at a time when Jensen Wong is not there to argue for this open source world. That's something I'm going to talk about on DB life today as well. Anthropic's IPO also raises another interesting point about why Jensen was so singular. And Ed, here I will channel your friend Ed's a drone here, which is that they were the fact they were paying for everything. And it was financially untenable. There's been reporting some of which I can confirm from the times and the journal that that sort of exposed a deep conflict between Colette and and Jensen and Jensen's future son and law, Nico, about how much they were actually spending to finance startups, advanced companies like open AI or Anthropic. They were in many ways the center of this very tangled, very messy, very circular web, and without Jensen, why we're seeing the markets freak out and sort of spasm in an unpredictable way is because no one can really figure out if whoever takes his job is still going to have not only the desire, but also the respect from investors to be able to write these massive, massive checks and keep the whole thing going. Well, reportedly, the interim CEO is expected to rein in this financing operation that Nvidia has been pursuing of AI customers, which I think has a lot of implications for all of the other AI companies down the chain, especially the Neo clouds, which have just gotten battered over the past several months. I mean, you know, I looked at the markets, the way the markets moved after this scandal broke and something that surprised me was that actually the stock market was fine, even though Nvidia was plummeting. Now, as we're getting into the second week of this scandal, it looks like maybe it's going to be a different story. The S&P has fallen more than 2% to begin the week. And so I think a lot of people are wondering, is this the beginning of a larger correction? Is this basically what it looks like when the AI bubble that everyone's been talking about finally pops? Deirdre, is this it? I'm so glad that you brought up the Neo clouds because this is what was rattling the markets just a few weeks ago. Remember, let me say what Neo clouds are, they are cloud providers that do not have hugely profitable businesses attached like Amazon or Google or Microsoft, right? They rely on funding and GPU allocation from Nvidia, from a CEO like Jensen Huang, who is able to see the bigger picture, able to see that it is important that we have these Neo clouds so that we can live in this multi-modular world, right? So that it's not just the hyperscalers in control of compute, which is the most important input in this AI revolution. So I think that markets, maybe they're starting to understand that, takes a little bit without the bank of Nvidia as Rohan called it, what happens to all of the companies, all the different industries that Jensen Huang was able to really pioneer and navigate and prop up through Nvidia's balance sheet. Ron, is this the end of your view? No, it's not the end. There's too much money at stake here for the government, any government to let that happen. And look, the problem with this reporting is that, look, I have the chance to see Mike and Trader at Cory Vidin or the other night. Last side, I should say, who was very happy and seems very bullish on the space generally. I would argue I would say that that what we're looking at is sort of a right sizing or a reckoning moment for this industry. There's somewhere in between Jensen's outsize bets on this industry and sort of the very risk off approach that some investors have taken. In other words, maybe this is a chance for this industry to grow up and impose very scary words like financial discipline and capex forecasts and actually, you know, caring about your investment grade rating. Maybe just maybe. Hey, I'm not saying it's over. I actually think that the Neil Clouds have done a pretty good job. I mean, if you look at the latest core weave and nebius quarters, they are getting more in prepayments. They have already been adjusting their businesses probably because of the volatility in bond markets over the last few months. So they're already on their way. Does this shake up the AI trade as a whole? Absolutely. But maybe we've gotten to a point where again, the Neil Clouds have become a little more financially disciplined. And we'll see some others sort of pick up some of the sock. And Vidin's earnings will come out tonight. Rohan, what are you going to be looking for? Something I can't really tell is if
If any of the numbers are even going to matter to anyone, I wonder if maybe it's just going to be about how great is the message from Colette Cress? And then also, does any of this matter? Is it basically just like, I mean, was he doing something illegal or not? Is 20% of the revenue really coming from China as Colbert research has suggested? I mean, I wonder if just there are bigger questions other than earnings. But what do you think? Well, to your point, credit to Culper for really being on the money, it seems like with a lot of their reporting months before any of this came out. It is, I've always believed that short sellers, Hindenburg being a great example are actually really important in an innovative industry because it's short set at the wheat from the shaft. You're right, the numbers actually don't matter at all. I would be in touch with the call. I am very curious about what Colette is going to say. I'm completely serious here because we can assume it's going to be a great print. We know that demand for their chips is insatiable, but it will be the call, Colette's demeanor, the way she, you know, reposts with analysts which she's very good at. And whether she can answer these questions, right, the dear to you and me have been talking about for the last 20, 30 minutes, where does the company go from here? She's very much a caretaker CEO, but it's not like there aren't really consequences of decisions she's going to have to make over the next two weeks, three weeks, four months, whatever how long it takes for this walktel to probe to wrap up? Her demeanor on the call and her ability to reinsure investors. Do you think Elon's earnings calls are closely watched? This is going to be a tick by tick like we've never seen. I would agree with Rohan, the numbers don't matter. They have been baked in when Jensen was CEO. I actually am so curious. I've kind of been obsessed with all the geopolitics of this because I think that's the bigger picture. I think those are the stakes as well as open source. So I'm really curious if she's going to say much because that was all Jensen and I have a hard time imagining Colette having the same eye on it. So very curious, if she gets asked by analysts, which I hope she is, how she thinks about it because we have no idea how anyone other than Jensen Wong thinks about these things. He is the frontman. Yeah. I mean, it seems as though the biggest questions surrounding the company right now are honestly the legal questions. And if you're sort of the analyst on the call trying to understand things, I wonder if you do have to sort of ask these legal questions, such as do we know if the chips that were being sold to mega speed were the advanced chips, and to what extent was management aware of that or not, if that is what happened. I mean, all of these very important legal questions that I assume they're going to have to ask, but I would expect that they're going to get zero answers on. They'll punch. They'll say that it's that they can't talk about it while the investigation is ongoing, which is why it's important to read between the lines. How much does Colette think about some of these broader issues beyond just the numbers of the quarter? You reported that there are multiple Justice Department probes that are touching in video right now. I mean, what are the biggest risks for an video? I mean, all of us own in video, if you own the S&P, you own in video. So this is in everyone's portfolios. It's anyone's guess as to whether the stock goes up or down tomorrow in your view as someone who covers this. What are the greatest risks to the company right now? It will be these export control and national security probes. So what we reported is that the antitrust division of the DOJ is specifically focused on Nvidia. They, of course, command huge pricing power. The president has joked before that he would have liked to have broken them up, but they're too important. That has obviously shifted over the last few weeks and months. The two other probes focused specifically on Alice Wong and on two companies, Megaspeed, one of which we've talked about. The other being Super Micro, which has a checkered history, actually was the subject of a short report and has been charged by the DOJ with violating export control laws. Those two probes in snare Nvidia because it's Nvidia's products that the DOJ is trying to figure out if these two companies shipped out. And of course, that will reel in the company. There is, of course, the possibility of secondary probes or secondary charges. It's important to note as we reported that Nvidia and Jensen right now do not face a criminal probe, right? They're not the subject of a criminal investigation. But of course, their products being used will then inevitably lead the question, the question that we've been trying to solve here. What did they know about it and when did they know about it if they did? Which will be the focus of the DOJ probes into their customers. Deirdre, all same question to you. And as we wrap up, I'm going to ask for a prediction, which is Will Jensen Wong be back. The calcium odds are on 9% right now for context, but let's start with largest risks and then I'll get your prediction. I'm not good at making predictions, which is why I don't invest in the stock market and to individual stocks, otherwise that maybe I'll be doing something else. I will say that there's a lot of support here in Silicon Valley and among the people in tech who have really been, there's such a huge group of people here who have been inspired by Jensen Wong and his story of the American Dream and founding Nvidia and Adenis on the back of a napkin. There's a lot of just sort of sadness and sort of sympathy for what him and his family are going through. Can he come back from this? I don't know because so much of it rests on the question, was, were laws broken? Did he do something illegal? I think it's very, very difficult to come back. But there is a very powerful contingent, including President himself who would like to see Jensen Wong remain CEO. Did you ask me at what are the risks of him coming back? Logist risks to the stock right now in your view. I mean, no Jensen Wong, right? This is a man who is just able to iterate, create a new chip every single year who believed in GPUs when the rest of the chip industry was all about CPUs. So that is the risk here and I guess the bigger risk not to be dramatic, but I do feel this to be the case is that we accelerate China's drive and ability to compete in the AI race because I mean, they're already cut off right from Nvidia chips. Maybe we're going to make it even harder. They already don't want them, but I think the real risk is that I'm trying to take advantage of this moment. No, I'm going to get a prediction from you. I got to get one. Is he back? No, 0%. You can't put this genie back in the bottle. You just can't. And I agree. It is a tragedy. And we have the chance to Silicon Valley in the world where I am right now in Menlo with a chance to speak with Taiwan's deputy, I'm minister. And my colleague Ben Smith said, you know, what is sort of the mood about Jensen, the son of Taiwan? And she had one word. That. It is sad. This is a luminary. He's a brilliant founder. He's a brilliant businessman. And it's not uncommon for CEOs in this position to find themselves doing what he is accused and has admitted to doing. And it's a sad tale. Unfortunately, this board has made a decision. And it is not like open AI where it is a privately held company with a lot of control from a few key investors and tremendous key man risk where researchers and engineers had a job offers at Anthropic or Microsoft. Should they want to do that? These guys, their entire net worth is tied up in Nvidia. They just don't want the stock to go down any further. The idea that all of their engineering talent, tens of thousands of employees would jump ship to leave and lead to some sort of Altman-esque return, I just don't see it happening. So there's no way he comes back. What I do think will happen is that he and his very good friends who have stuck by him will raise and contribute $50 billion. He'll start an incredible new thing. And he is fundamentally a builder. And once he's had time to sort of lick his wounds and recover and hopefully tend to his family and whatever else he needs to do, I have no doubt he'll be back, but it won't be it in video. He'll be back. Deirdre Bosa is founder and host of Deirdre Bosa Live in Rohan, Giswami. His business reporter at Semaphore, Rohan Deirdre, thank you so much. Appreciate your time. Thanks, Ed. Thanks, Rohan. So did Jensen know or didn't he know? That is the question. Because if he did, well then he might actually go to prison, violating US export laws and offence punishable by up to 20 years. And I know no guilt has been proven in a court of law, but all I'm saying is if it is, well, those are the steaks. But if he didn't know, well then shareholders have a different problem. Because then they must ask the following question, which is how didn't he know? But telling me he struck up a relationship with a former TV reporter for Chinese state media, who mysteriously became the CEO of a Singaporean shell company, turned compute provider, and then showed up one day with billions of dollars to buy his chips for her offices, which turned out to be empty. And he never thought that there was a problem at any point in this process. If that is an ignorance, well then it would demonstrate what I think many would call unfathomably bad judgment. So no, in my view, he should not be CEO. On that note though, there is an interesting question. And that is, how could a man who has paid billions of dollars to make good decisions make so many bad decisions so many times? What happened in Jetson Huang's head that made him think, yeah, this is all fine? That is a genuine question. Well, the answer, I believe, lies in a 2011 study from the University of Michigan. It is known as the Icarus paradox. In this study, they looked at nearly 600 CEOs, along with their employees, and they measured how much pushback these executives received from their subordinates, and they found that the less pushback a CEO received, the higher they rated their own judgment, and more importantly, the less likely they were to change course when they made the wrong decision. Put another way they didn't just make mistakes, they doubled down on their mistakes. That was the price of excessive flattery, and it explains pretty much everything about the downfall of Jetson Huang. Remember, chances are. long had no board chair, no chief operating officer, no succession plan. Instead, he employed 60 direct reports in a culture that his own biographer described as having quote "little tolerance for disagreement." The entire company was built around him, or more specifically, around agreeing with him. These levels of obsequience might feel good, but they also screw with your head. They make you think that you're flawless, that you could never put a foot wrong, which of course increases the likelihood that you will. And I know that, because a Michigan study empirically proved it. As the name of the study implies, Jensen Huang flew too close to the sun. The parallels to the myth of Icarus are plain to see. The only difference, however, is who got burnt, because every S&P 500 holder owns Nvidia, which means we all hold Nvidia. So it's not just Jensen this time. It's the rest of us as well. Okay, that's it for today. This episode was produced by Claire Miller and Allison Weiss, and engineered by Benjamin Spencer. Our video editor is Brad Williams. Our research team is Dan Shalong, Kristen O'Donohue, and Mia Silverio, and our social producer is Judd McPherson. Thank you for listening to Profty Markets from Profty Media. If you liked what you heard, give us a follow. I'm Ed Allison. I will see you tomorrow. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project, one app for accounting another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow none of them talk to each other. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform, no messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Try for free today at odoo.com/box. That's odoo.com/box.