Go back

Commanders come back to stun Giants, 24-21

42m 9s

Commanders come back to stun Giants, 24-21

The Washington Commanders defeated the New York Giants in a thrilling, high-stakes Thursday night game that delivered both excitement and drama. The victory was driven by a strong defensive effort from Washington, particularly from edge defender Cam Scadaboo, who made several impactful plays, including multiple aggressive blitzes and tackles. J.J. McCarthy showed significant improvement in the second half, demonstrating better rhythm, accuracy, and play design with several memorable throws, including a crucial touchdown completion. Despite strong defensive efforts by the Giants, key early setbacks—including a missed field goal and a fumble by Malik Neighbors—shifted momentum and ultimately cost them the win. The Giants' offense struggled with a lack of play-action and run-pass variety, relying heavily on a stagnant drop-back game, which limited their ability to create consistent pressure. Washington’s offense, while not dominant, showed flashes of potential, especially in the second half. The game was widely praised as a "perfect" matchup, blending high-energy action with unpredictable moments. Looking ahead, the future of the Commanders’ quarterback, Jaden Daniels, remains uncertain due to durability concerns, though his athleticism and ability to create plays in high-pressure situations suggest long-term potential. The Giants, despite their divisional leadership, are viewed as a plucky, underdog team with strong foundation and development, particularly in their coaching and young talent. Ultimately, the game underscored the unpredictability of football and the impact of key moments, while highlighting both the promise and challenges facing both franchises.

Transcription

8872 Words, 46273 Characters

English
Welcome to the Athletic Football Show, brought to you by the U.S. Bank Smartly Visa Signature Card. Thursday night football, Commanders, Giants, way more interesting on so many different levels than I think we probably thought it was going to be heading into the game. This is a 45-minute conversation that touched on the future of the Giants, the future of the Commanders, the stuff we saw tonight. So a lot to dig into. It became a pretty intriguing matchup and a pretty big win for the Washington Commanders. We did it all with me and Dave and Derek. Let's get to it right now. With about like four or so minutes left in that game, my thought was just, man, there's a lot to dig into, but a lot of good stuff from both teams. Like just some impressive, you know, coaching jobs, I think, on both sides of the ball. I thought J.J. McCarthy played really well, but a pretty normal game, all things considered. Like a back-to-back game. I thought it was going to be a pretty normal game. I thought it was going to be a back-and-forth game, a fun game. And then there are 10 things that happened in the final three minutes of that game that I just couldn't wrap my mind around. And so I think we have to start with some of those. Maybe the first one being Rasul Douglas decided to drop a pop fly on the second-to-last play of the game and then decided to follow it up. That's the Matthew Golden of defense. That's what we're calling it. That's what Rasul Douglas just did to put this thing away. Which like before he caught the second one, that's like a classic Rasul Douglas thing. And going back to his Philly days, I remember Philly fans being like, he just can't catch the football. Like he can be in position, he can do stuff. And so the fact that obviously, you know, he, I think fixed this a little bit when he was in Green Bay, but to have a moment where it's like, oh my God, old Rasul Douglas is back. And then he makes an insane catch on the second one, by the way, which like that made it more confusing. I was ready to shout out Darnell Mooney for playing great defense on that ball. And then they showed the replay and I was like, nah, not, not really. Like it just went through. Douglas's arms. It was too high. He made up for it. It was the ball was too high. It was like fielding a punt. It's already, there's already a reason he plays defense. There's another reason he doesn't return kicks. So that happened the giant specifically. I thought that they called a great game for most of the game. I thought that their pressure plan was excellent. I was ready to come on here and compliment the staff and JJ McCarthy and just the way that they handled this whole thing. The two kind of drive ending plays in their final two drives. I hate the third and three call to essentially run and give up run with McCarthy with less than two minutes left. Like I understand that you're trying to make sure that you're keeping the clock running there. Your offense has been pretty good all night. If you get a first down on that play, the game is over. And instead they give the ball back to Washington with plenty of time. They go down and score a touchdown and Derek, their pressure plan was excellent throughout this entire game. And then on the final drive, they decide their cover zero answer is it. We're just going to chuck it up twice. That's why I'm glad you talked about like before the final four minutes happened. We were going to talk about a completely different game because I'm with you. Like I thought the backs were protecting. Well, I thought their plan to keep like Washington's blitzes under bay and even some of like the camp Scadaboo toss into the boundary touchdown run. They're expecting inside blitz and Luvu does blitz and they just hit it on the boundary because there's nobody there. And so like they were doing such a good job with stuff. I thought JJ McCarthy like replaced the blitz pretty well for most of the night. And then like you said, on the last drive, it didn't even seem like he wanted to sit there and replace the blitz. And like, to be fair, Washington went like all out and they were bringing like seven and eight. And so there were free runners, but he wasn't even trying to find like where the space would be. He was just like, I'm going to chuck it up. And he did that like four times. And eventually it bit him. I understand there's 30 seconds left. You feel like it's a little bit harder to take an underneath completion, but you still have a couple of timeouts. I mean, there you can move it a little bit differently than they were trying to. It's not hard to take those completions given that they're they had the timeouts. Like it very much felt like the giants thought that they had to score a touchdown and they had to get these chunk plays. I was like, we can nickel and dime this if we want to. I mean, I'd prefer to play for the touchdown, but with a young quarterback and the situation at hand, like I wouldn't have blamed the giants for playing for overtime there, even if I'd prefer to go for the throat. And it didn't seem like they were interested in doing that. And then on the bring cover zero on that play. And I didn't like that either because the fun, the previous two short yardage, high leverage calls on those fourth and twos, they had a completely gloved up. And I just didn't think I thought Washington's calls on those fourth and twos that those are situations where Jane Daniels is legs have to come into play there. I just think those are the situations where you have to create some sort of conflict because they're passing game in general. I was looking at the numbers in the fourth quarter overall, and it's simply, this is skewed by the touchdown to digs. But, but for before that final drive, Jane Daniels was averaging like four and a half yards per attempt on shotgun throws in this game. Like they're pure drop back game. There just wasn't a lot happening. They were on under center or pistol plays in this game. And Jane Daniels was seven of seven for 99 yards. And then on from the gun, he finished 16 of 26 for one 50. And that includes the huge digs touchdown. And so them just lining up in the gun. And then on from the gun, he finished 16 of 26 for 150. And that just lined up in the gun. And that just going pure drop back on fourth and two, when you have a quarterback that theoretically should be able to really make it hard on defenses. I didn't like that at all. And then I feel like Durante Jones going with the cover zero in that situation kind of gives them a freak, like I get out of jail free card. He gives them an answer in that moment that they couldn't find on those previous fourth and shorts earlier in the half. I thought too, like, and if you think about it, like it makes sense. Like so many plays, I thought the giants defense made, they were like, what, five or six incompletions in the flat in this game from Washington where like their guys are just driving on the ball. One or two of them were dropped, but like guys are making plays, they're getting interceptions. Like I thought they did a really good job taking that away from Jaden Daniels. And then like you mentioned that it felt like the only time Washington had consistent offense was they came, I think it was right out of the half. Maybe they just came out on this drive where like everything was the pistol. They hit like the sale route to, uh, yeah, to send it like out of the backfield. And then later on they hit Antonio Williams for the touchdown. Like they were doing a really good job of forcing the run past conflict that they kind of told us they were going to do in August and really haven't actually done a lot of this season. That was the stretch of the game. Cause that was Washington's second drive was the sale to Senate. And before that was the giants touchdown drive where JJ hit Malachi fields on the corner route that like made me sit up in my seat. And there was like a 10 minute stretch where I was just like, what the hell is going on? Which my overall thesis for this game, this was a perfect Thursday night. That's actually right. That's a hundred percent. Right. That's kind of what I meant about before the first four minutes. I was like, this was great. But then there was fodder at the end. Yeah. I also, I think that's part of it being perfect though. Like the fact that it had a stupid ending, you're just like, ah, this is, this is what it's supposed to be. But like, you know, I, I sat down, I sat down and then the giants missed the chip shot field goal at the beginning of the game. And I was like, this is going to suck. And like a half hour later, I was having the time of my life and JJ made some good plays, obviously made some dumb plays at the end of the game. Jaden picked it up at the end, sunny styles and Arvel Reese were all over the place. Like if you're tuning in to see the two young first round picks, you got everything you could possibly want. Sunny styles didn't just have the pressure on the pick, but he had a fantastic third down tackle at the end of the game too. And he was able to set up a fourth down incredible stuff. Like the young players were balling. The quarterbacks had some moments. We got some stupidity. We had some cool special teams plays the, the Luke McCaffrey, like lie down, you'd kick recovery. That was awesome. It was an awesome play. Like I just, and also I know that the giants are leading the division, but these teams are clearly more plucky than good. And so like, it was kind of, it was low stakes and we didn't like waste a fantastic game. On Thursday night, like this was just, it was chef's kiss. Perfect. And what you want from a Thursday night game. The only thing I agree with everything that you just said, the only thing that was missing, I needed that immaculate reception. Trayvon Burke's play in the first half to be complete. So bad. The one that ricocheted halfway across the field that they said was a catch and wasn't that. So the, the just mechanics of that play were incredible. The other best part of that play is that Al responded to it. Like it was the most hopeful. Oh, hum completion in the history of the NFL as the ball deflected halfway across the fields as he often does in those moments. I will say there are a lot of things about the college game that are different. I feel like those plays somehow get completed more in the college game, just like weird, bizarre. Like I've never seen that before type stuff. I want to start with the giants part of this because if Malik neighbors doesn't fumble that ball, there is a very good chance that the Giants will win. The Giants just kind of take control of this game in the second half, squeeze the life out of it and win. If not convincingly, then it like, as if they had control for the second half of that game. And I think part of that is I thought JJ McCarthy was legitimately really good in the second half of this game for huge swats of it. The first half reminded me a little bit of the Houston game. Dave talked about the corner out throw to Malachi fields. Like that's the type of throw where he's staring that thing down the whole time and he's the double move to Malik Neighbors. That's stuff that, again, similar to the Houston game where. He's making throws down the field, but there are throws that it's the first read within the play. The offense is being very well fed to him and he's just making a throw down the field, which is great, but it's not the most like advanced quarterback stuff. In the second half of this game, I thought the rhythm that he was playing with, whether it was there are two plays that really stick out. All of the underneath, I know where my outlet plays are, there's a lot of them are either you know where your answer is against the blitz or he's going one check down, one check down, just playing with like good rhythm in the second half. But the two plays that really stick out, the fake toss play action that they had coming all the way back on the cross or coming back to the left, he gets all the way back to his third option on that play in rhythm to hit that third in breaker for a chunk gain. And then obviously the touchdown to likely. I mean, he's staring down the barrel of the gun on that play and just rips that ball over the middle between two linebackers. And so there were multiple different plays in this game. I thought that just showed a little bit more nuance, a couple layers that he wasn't necessarily even asked to do or we didn't even see in the Houston game that are encouraging for him. And to me, Derek, it's again, just another example of the coaching staff for the Giants has just, I think, done a really good job on offense this year. And for 50. 56 minutes of this game. I think they did it again. They have. And like, I agree that this game was different than the Houston game for the most part, especially in the second half, because the Houston game, he makes five really impressive throws. It was a pretty low success rate game. Like he did not make like down to down consistent gains. This game, I felt differently about that. Like, obviously, you know, there's a little stop and start in the first half. But in the first half, they were doing a lot of like, we're going to dare you to either find the soft zones against our two high stuff. Or we're going to blitz and dare you to find, you know, the underneath option. And I thought for the most part, he like acquitted himself. And again, if they don't miss the field goal early and if we don't have the Malik neighbors fumble, like they put up more points than obviously they actually have at the end of the game. And it probably looks like a more impressive performance. And so I thought he, for the most part, played pretty well in this game. Obviously, whatever happens in whatever happens in the final two minutes is just like dumb young player stuff. And like, he should be better than that. And obviously, Washington, like way turned up the heat in those moments. But I don't think that that should. Wash away what happened for the first 57 minutes of this game. The other thing I want to say on the the likely throw, that's a crazy throw. What is Nick Cross doing on the blitz, though? I have no idea. Yeah, he's like, that was weird. He's like, he stops up as if he's afraid that JJ will run, which like, to be fair, JJ is a really good athlete. Like there was a play where he outrun Sonny Styles in this game. Like, obviously, he can do that. He used his legs multiple times. Well, in this game, he really did. The little tightrope scrambled on the left sideline was really impressive. It was a really nice play. And so I get why you might. Be scared of that. But I'm still like, I'd rather make him go make that play than just like not when you have a free run at the quarterback. Like, that's the point of calling a four week blitz like that is that you're going to get a free run. I found myself wondering if he was afraid of drawing a flag. But and like, I get that that's a possibility, but he's a safety like you're not. You don't weigh 300 pounds. Like, if you put all your weight into that hit, I don't think it's going to look as bad as it would if it were an edge rusher. And like, just go deck. Him, man. I understand that quarterbacks do get those sorts of calls, but you can't hesitate in a situation like that. They overload that side. And so obviously they're bringing one more than the Giants have to account for it based on the slide. But that's just another play where Scadaboo picks off. I think it was Sonny Stiles on that play and at least makes it one instead of two. And he was consistently how many like really nice like teach tape type reps of taking on the blitz. Did Cam Scadaboo have in this game? Four or five. Did he have different plays where he's just like stonewalling guys in the hole? And a lot of them are against Sonny Stiles, who like is a big guy who has a lot of violence coming downhill. He exploded Tyrone Tracy in the first quarter. Yeah, exploded Tyrone Tracy, which like puts in context how impressive what Scadaboo was doing. Exactly like Tracy gets exploded like that. And so I really do think it was impressive. He like Scadaboo, obviously, just in his overall play style, has a physicality and willingness to just go and hit people. But it's like his technique is actually pretty impressive. Like he plays very square. He plays under himself. He knows when to like punch like it's actually it is pretty like teach tape stuff in that regard. Also, eyeing down the Skycam is all time Thursday night football stuff. That was so funny. It made me laugh out loud. I mean, this was the Cam Scadaboo show between the 20 commercials that we had over the course of this thing. Plus him eyeing down the Skycam. I mean, I've seen the State Farm one, obviously, a thousand times. What was like the online marketplace ad that he's doing now? That's what I had seen that one yet, where he's like slamming his head through every wall to buy whatever. Yeah, good for good. Yeah, he's a fourth round pick. Sign all the endorsement checks. They let will they will let you sign. Listen, when I was when Dak was doing the sleep number and like Oikos yogurt ads back in the day while he was making five hundred grand a year. I completely understand it. You got to get that money while you can. But it's funny that the majority of this broadcast, both during the game and during the commercial breaks, was heavily featuring Cam Scadaboo. And he scored twice. So good for him. Overall, I don't as I think about big picture takeaways for the Giants, I don't know if this is fair or unfair. It's just it's being reductionist. But I think I saw a lot of the same things from them tonight that I had seen for a good chunk of this season that made me think I really like the foundation of things that is being this being built here. I really like some of the building block things that are happening. I think that. Again, the offensive staff and just the staff in general continues to acquit itself. Well, the defense right now, I mean, they're so shorthanded up front, they are so shorthanded up front, and I think you just feel that. And so it's a team that's imperfect. You have a backup quarterback that's been there for six weeks that I think is playing about as well as you possibly could have hoped. Like, Dave, I don't think we've really talked about this thing. Derek and I have done it mostly on the hangover because just as like big picture conversation hang, they're very much a hangover team. So that makes sense. As you think. Think about just the New York Giants ten weeks into the NFL season based on preseason expectations and what they've been so far. What are your just impressions of where they are right now? I think the New York Giants are victims of their division, and it's not their fault, because if the Philadelphia Eagles or the Dallas Cowboys were running away with this division and the Giants were in second or third place, they would be the darlings of the NFL community and to some degree. Yeah, I think that's a good point, and I think that's a good point, and I think that's a good point, and I think that's a good point. Maybe they still are like they're an entertaining team, but the Giants, if they weren't leading the NFC East, would be a hipster's favorite team. Like, are you seeing what Arvel Reese is doing? JJ has got some nice throws every week. Yeah, they'd be the Dolphins. Yeah, they would be. They would be the Dolphins. They'd be a much more competent Dolphins. Yes, they're the Dolphins with a winning record instead of saying, I know they suck, but are you watching the games? Like, you don't have to look that hard to see what's good about the Giants. The problem is, they're leading the NFC East, and this, I mean, you have to frame this as a missed opportunity if you're talking about winning the NFC East. Like, you miss a chip shot field goal, you have some silly turnovers, the neighbor's fumble, like you mentioned, changes the complexion of this game. So, it's a missed opportunity to win the division, and I get you, you can't look that opportunity in the mouth. Like, it still matters, and John Harbaugh's obviously trying to set a culture for a team. That, you know, obviously the last decade's been a disaster. I didn't realize, I knew they hadn't, I knew they'd only been to the playoffs once since 2016. I didn't realize they hadn't won the division since 11. 15 years without winning a division. To some degree, that stuff does matter, and I'm not trying to say that it doesn't matter to win the division, right? But, if this was a plucky also ran in a tough division, we would be like, look at the Giants! This is such a cool team! And instead, they might win the NFC. And everybody's like, ah, these guys aren't very good. Like, they're just going to get murdered in the playoffs. Or even this game. That might be true, but even this game, if they're coming into this game, and they're 3-4-1, instead of having the record that they have. And they lose this game in this fashion, it's kind of like, ah, it's kind of frustrating, but there's a lot of stuff that we can build on here. But to your point, now it's like, oh man, now the division might be slipping away. Now they're letting the Cowboys back into this thing. They almost become a victim of their own sin. Success in that way, where it reframes even a performance like this. They are victims of playing in the most embarrassing division in the league. And I do think it is, by the way. The NFC South is. No, no, because the NFC South was supposed to be that way. That's true, that's true. The NFC East was supposed to have some juggernauts in it, and everybody's sorry instead. And that's not the Giants' fault. Yeah, the Eagles are banged up, obviously. The Dallas Cowboys have no excuse. I feel like with the NFC South, it's like if you put an eight-year-old behind the wheel of the car and they crash a car, it's like, well, you can't blame the eight-year-old. That's your fault. The NFC East, that's their fault. We can actually. There's some culpability happening with the state of the Dallas Cowboys right now. But I do. I'm so encouraged by everything that I've seen from the Giants for the most part. And yeah, I'm not trying to say JJ. Played like upper echelon quarterback tonight, but he had. I think I wrote down like five different throws where I was just like, all right, JJ. Good deal, man. And like for a fifth round pick, and you are. Like you. it's with everything that's happened. It's kind of easy to gloss over the fact that they lost their QB of choice in the first quarter of the second game. And so for JJ McCarthy to be playing well enough that this is an intriguing team. And I had fun watching this game and I've had fun watching quite a few of their games over the course of the year. It's an unmitigated success. And if they aren't good enough to hold onto the division, or if it doesn't matter, come playoff time. Like I don't really care about that. I'm, I'm encouraged by what I'm seeing. And my last note, I looked this up while you were talking six of JJ McCarthy's, sorry, of JJ McCarthy's six best games by EPA per drop back. Three of them have come in a giant's uniform. Yeah. I mean, that's not surprising. Cool. It's not surprising. That's cool. And it's, it's cool for JJ as bad as it got last year and all this shit that's been talked about him, including by us. I'm not absolving us of our role in. Talking about him. Uh, it's, it's cool to see him rebound like that. I'm, I'm, I'm excited to see where it goes from here. And I wonder where it goes from here. If he continues to play like this, it becomes an interesting off season conversation. I mean, it's Jackson dart from what we saw from Jackson dart as a rookie. And then what we saw in Jackson dart in week one, that is a step above the JJ McCarthy experience when you consider the totality of his career. And I would say even like on a very similar level, what do we, to what we've seen from JJ McCarthy over these last few games. But I don't think there's such a Delta between those two things that you can go into next season and just say Jackson dart should clearly be the starting quarterback for the giants. Like I think that there are competition is at least warranted. I hadn't thought that far ahead, but that is an interesting thought. Like what is Jackson dart done to just be like, he's the guy that's the one like, Oh, we traded up for him in the first round. Well, JJ McCarthy was traded up for in the first round too. Like, I don't know, like what's the difference at the end of the day? Cause they're both, I mean, if anything, JJ McCarthy was regarded as the better prospect by, uh, by like most people, like he obviously went higher in the draft. Yeah, exactly. And so I do think it's interesting, uh, for a lot of those reasons. And it's not like, you know, you bring in like a 30 year old who's playing at this level who has no runway to get better. Like JJ could get better. Assuming Joe Shane stays on as the giants GM, which like, I don't have a reason to think they would make a change after what we've seen so far this year. That is still like the, the people involved with drafting dart and getting dart. I mean, I know Dable is not there, but there's a lot of, uh, there's a lot of interest in capital invested in Jackson dart working out. So I, that's probably worth mentioning, but yeah, like I would at least let them compete. Why the hell not? And that's probably what it might be. It might be like a, usually when we have quarterback competitions and any given off season, they're the most depressing things in the world. I have, they're either fake. Right. Like the one that happened in Minnesota this year or whatever. Like, it's like, we've decided that we probably know who wants to win this thing. And we'll gesture at the idea of competition or they are just deeply depressing. I cannot tell you how many soul crushing quarterback competitions I have followed beat by beat from August 1st through the start of the regular season in my life, living where I live and following the team that I follow. This is actually a quarterback competition where you have two intriguing options where the answer that you get at the end of it won't make you want to go for a long walk in the woods. Like, and that just doesn't happen very often. I can't really remember the last time where it was like two, maybe legitimate, actual starting quarterbacks having like a competition like this, where one, like every now and then you get, you know, the 32 year old who is like, can be like, I don't know. It just doesn't really feel like you get two young potential starting quarterbacks like this. I also think too, there's a chance that like, if JJ plays well for the rest of the season, you just flip him for like a second round pick. And you've basically found like free money, like at this point, because maybe that's the answer to maybe that's what, I mean, maybe that's the better actual move is that you sell him at his highest point for a team that wants a dice roll, a quarterback, because that's actually the most valuable thing you now have having, having a backup that could be a starter obviously has some value. We're seeing the value of it right now, but maybe to actually, get the most you possibly can out of it. It's to convince another team that he's a worthwhile starting quarterback option. Cause somebody will need one. Minnesota might need one. It's just cruel. That's cruel. Sorry. Before we move on, let's take a quick break. All right. Let's talk about the team that won the game. And we haven't really had this sort of conversation about Washington at any point this year. It's been a weird season. Like when would we have had it? You know, they, they, they beat Seattle when their starting quarterback wasn't playing and Jane Daniels. Again, I think a lot of good things again from him tonight. I think that the offense overall, the dropback game, again, I said it earlier, I think left something to be desired, but I think some of the early down play action stuff, like I think David Blouse and doing some decent things without this team's best receiver, this team's best offensive lineman. It's not a very talented group. They came into this game 16th and passing DVO way. The commanders did like, that's not a bad, place to be considering Jaden Daniels has missed a couple of games and what they're working with on that side of the ball. I just don't really know what to make of this team. I re I re I really don't. Do you have any, like, as you, as you sit here right now, Derek, and you think about the 2026 commanders and just the long-term outlook for this group, this quarterback, everything, just how do you feel about them right now? I mean, I think it depends on which side of the ball, the defense. I don't feel very good about like, I think obviously it's like in terms of the talent. Yeah. They don't have very much talent, but like, it's an expensive defense. And I know that some of those guys are hurt, but it's an expense, like older defense. And I know Sonny styles is playing really well, but I think by having enough time in this system by now and being able to accumulate all the players you wanted, I think the defense should be some amount of better. I know it's a new system this year with Durante Jones, but like, I, at a certain point, the head coach who is a defensive guy deserves some amount of blame for the fact that they can't really get it together. Especially like in a game like this, where they're like, I don't know, I don't know. I don't know. I don't like this, where you're playing against the backup quarterback. The offense, I think is a little bit harder to untangle. I think in some moments I have actually been pretty impressed with what David Blau has done as a play caller, like coming out in the, in the second half of this game and just being like, everything is going to be out of dot formation. So we're going to be in pistol. We're going to be an under center and we're going to jump on them. And I think even the drive before that, where they're in the two minute, you know, going into the half, I thought they called a really good game or a really good drive there. And they were able to just kind of play calling has been solid to good. Given some of the constraints that they've had, just in terms of, it's not a very talented wide receiver core at the run game. Can't really do anything because they're not talented. Offensive line's not talented. Jaden Daniels, I think he's had a really weird season. Like his best moments still feel really good. Like the second half and fourth quarter he played against the Niners was really impressive. I think like the middle of this game, he was really impressive. Like, I don't think the first quarter was good. Fourth quarter was extremely up and down, but I thought the middle of it, he played really well, but he's been up and down for this team. I think they're just in a weird position. I think they're just in a weird They don't feel like a good team to me, but they don't, it doesn't quite feel like bottom out at least for the offense, I guess is the way that I would frame it. Jaden exists, Dave, in like this weird vortex right now where, because the other guys have come along and because not even, I mean, the guys in his draft class specifically, right. I've taken up so much oxygen over the last year. I mean, literally tonight, we're sitting here talking about another guy from his draft class more than him because it's new and novel and just, there's more to say about it seemingly in this moment than there is to say about Jaden Daniels. And because of that, because he exists in like this weird space where he was the talk of the town as a rookie, Washington just as a franchise has been in such a weird spot over the last couple of years, he's been hurt. He's in this place and in this moment where I don't really know how to talk about him. And I don't really know how to think about him as like the centerpiece face of the franchise. For a team in transition right now, I think my instinct is based on who he is, what he's been, when he's been on the field is to say, we probably will be moving on from the coaching staff at the end of this year. If I had to be putting money on it right now, I think that's ultimately, I don't think it's unfair to say that's the most likely outcome. If they come in with a new staff next year, if they can put some more weapons around him, rather than signing Steph Diggs two weeks into free agency and that being their best option, this could still be a quarterback. We should be really excited about in the right situation with the right pieces. I guess I'm just a little bit less emphatic about that than I would expect to be at this point in his career. Is that unfair? I don't think it's unfair, but I'm probably a little more willing to say it with my chest is I think if you're like my big takeaway is watching this game. Cause I do think the commanders are in a weird place between their own injuries, having the quarterback and the injury to Jaden this year, just, it gives you existential dread where you're like, Oh my God, two years in a row. And you see that big brace on his elbow. Every time they cut to him and you're like, ah, please don't get killed. Jaden. You're so skinny. It sucks that that's part of it. It genuinely sucks that that's part of it. It's like the brace. Every time he takes off, I wince a little bit. Like I just wish that wasn't part of it, but if it wasn't in the back of your mind, I feel like you'd be deluding yourself. When they ran the speed option, I was like, do you want to do that? sure about that where he like cut it up between the tackle i was like man i don't know and maybe that's why my my complaining here about them not putting the like having a run past conflict on these fourth and twos maybe i'm the asshole maybe that's just not something they should be doing if that's how i'm gonna look at every one of those moments but i i agree like it's it it's there it's it hangs there in a way that maybe is unfair but it's also kind of hard to ignore it does hang there and and you you can't hand wave it away and so actually here's here's what I landed on it's not a one-to-one because I think I think CJ Stroud showed us more up to this point in his career and you weren't worried about durability but Jaden is starting to remind me a little bit about how I felt about CJ Stroud where last year where yeah it's a good comparison the the dialogue is just like I don't I don't know about this guy man like are they gonna pay CJ Stroud is CJ Stroud like the future of the franchise and I'm just like are we watching the same thing because I still see a lot of talent and a lot of promise and like Jaden Daniels when he's out there and and the durability is an issue but when he's out there the effortless athleticism that he brings to the position and the way that he can string plays out and put the defense in conflict and when he decides to move he is uncatchable and he by the way he's also incredibly accurate when he's dialed in and has a cannon I'm not going to compare him to the other guy that plays in the DMV area but it is a skill set like that just very very rare stuff and I look at like if I'm watching the commanders and remember it's not just that they signed Stefan Diggs in the summer and Antonio Williams and Traylon Burks are like guys that have to do meaningful stuff here they don't have a backfield and they lost Laramie Tunsell before the season started too so if this is what you're getting from Jaden Daniels with this assortment if I'm watching this play out I'm saying I don't know much but the next regime is going to build this thing around Jaden Daniels like we're going to try to give him two or three more years to really show us what he can do is not even the right way to frame it he's already shown us a lot like 2024 did happen and so I I don't know what the future holds and I think the commanders are weird because we assume the coaches are going to change but we don't know and like there there could be so much transition coming our way but whatever happens in 2027 I'm making Jaden Daniels the focal point of it for at least like the next two seasons like if we can play this thing out to the bitter end with Bryce Young we for damn sure can do it with Jaden Daniels. I want to be very clear I wouldn't suggest anything to the contrary like he I wouldn't even like it wouldn't even start to even become a kernel of a thought that he isn't the guy you want to build around to me it's just what is that what I'll take it a step further and say no he's he's damn he's damn good and can be damn good in a better environment and like I I feel convicted about that I like this Stroud comparison just in terms of like the space that he's currently existing in Derek I think that for me and even like the comparison of what they were as rookies being the like they came on the scene they were immediately these guys that were like holy shit I think even that part of it because that matters like that ability to show it early to that extent matters as we think about the long-term future of these guys I think that the tier like the the space they exist in the arc of it overall there aren't a lot of similarities there I think for me and this is just maybe my own mental block I understand what CJ Stroud is and I understand like what a ceiling for that sort of player looks like I don't have the same handle on what Jaden Daniels is and that might be a me issue but the path for like what he can become and what that looks like that plan you're saying of like we're gonna build this thing around Jaden Daniels and we're gonna make sure we're giving him every chance to succeed what that version of success looks like in the long term is harder for me to see because the way he succeeded as a rookie was a lot of stuff that is just hard to build the plane out of so a lot of scrambles there's a lot of late down conversions like I think for long-term success it would have to look a little different than it did then and I don't know exactly what that is and again that may be more of a me thing than a Jaden Daniels thing does that make sense it does I think it's a few things one like that was so central to the way that he won as a rookie in college and all that stuff but if he's gonna have the injury concerns like that's probably not gonna be as core of his game or it will get to the point where like he does get banged up and you have to worry about that I think the other thing that is different to me than Stroud at least in my personal opinion I know that like CJ Stroud there were these like low light moments where we were like oh my God this guy actually sucks but on a year-to-year basis I thought for the most part he continued to improve as a player and had like tangible things that I was like his pocket presence is better now oh it's year three and he's a better playmaker outside of the pocket than he used to be oh he's getting to play about Jaden Daniels and not that I don't think I don't think he's gotten worse I just think that he's not gotten better obviously the situation has not been conducive to that but I would argue in some ways neither was Houston and obviously CJ shot still found a way to do it I think the other thing obviously we're in a a position now where the NFL and the league is like mobility and scrambling is one of the most valuable things you can do at the end of the day the guys who are consistent top 10 NFL quarterbacks dominate from the pocket yeah and I just don't know if I've ever really seen that yes especially right now this year it's just been hammered home even more than in recent seasons like those guys that can just kill you from the pocket are the guys and I think that that's a really good way of framing it and I think the idea of I think what year one to year two with Stroud was maybe a little bit less clear and like where the demonstrable steps were year two to year three I think you absolutely saw that stuff and I think because I understood what the arc was I understood the direction that it was heading in and where it could potentially go if things improved I think because Jaden's arc is just a little bit murkier what it's like you're moving through a storm and like what exists on the other side of the storm is just harder for me to picture than it would be for Stroud because I saw the path being mapped I think that that's a pretty good comparison like I think it's and again I don't even know if we're going to get a better answer by the end of this season and I don't know what it's going to look like next season because he might be on his third offensive coordinator that's my issue is and it's a valid point it's not as if Houston did a masterful job of putting CJ in a good situation but I just think Jaden's in a dog shit situation right now and you're not gonna it's not gonna be better it's not gonna be better and so you can call it blind faith if you want to but and and maybe that maybe that is the the case where I like the choice before you is do you buy in on the the talent that is oozing out of this guy and what you've seen or do you go fishing again hoping you're gonna find like a better set of skills than what is already on your team and by the way that doesn't seem realistic at all and to me I don't think this is like a is Jaden Daniels gonna be a quarterback you don't want to pay situation I think it's similar to Stroud where after his rookie year we were like he might be a top five quarterback sooner than later and that was obviously not the case and it you know CJ Stroud is maybe playing closer to that now but it was a little bit more of a windy road than we thought and I think with Jaden Daniels that's kind of the conversation now it's like I don't think he's bad I think he's an average to above average quarterback right now even in a poor situation and being young but does he have 25 right but it's a matter of like does he still do I still feel like he has that top six to seven to eight potential and I do think that I'm probably I think I was always a little bit more skeptical of that but I think that right now I'm in a little bit more of like he more realistically is like probably quarterback 11 and that's a perfectly good still a great you still pay that guy every time to be clear man quarterback 14 a you pay him yes and b he's 26 years old yes I think this is the and the even more important than whether or not you pay him Josh Harris or if Adam Peters makes the next coaching hire if there is another coaching hire I don't know like we're probably getting ahead of ourselves by even saying that given that they just won this game but if that is what happens that is the only thing I care about in the job interview is like what are we doing to maximize like figure out the defense I don't give a shit we'll we'll we'll make a good hire like I don't I don't care what's your plan for Jaden Daniels that's when you put the the playbook down on the desk in our four-hour meeting the whole freaking thing better be about number five that's that's that's where it begins and ends again I want to be very clear about this I think it is worth being a Jaden Daniels team at whatever price that's going to be a couple years from now like that's not again that's not even like a question to me it's worth being a Jaden Daniels team I guess I just wonder what that means that that's yeah I don't know that's the question I don't think I have an answer to the first one is not even a question I get right now what it means is having and I'm not talking about quarterbacking ability but what it means is like having one of the five or six most talented quarterbacks in the NFL on your team I would push back on that I think that's I think Derek and I think that that's Derek's in a similar spot where I think that there is like there is a unique combination of physical traits to the way that he plays I think that Purely, like, as a passer from the pocket and what the relative limitations of that might be, I think that, to me, puts – that's where, like, it depends on how we define talent. Like, physical ability and, like, it's – but, like, ceiling as a – I mean the whole thing. Ceiling as a passer, I think it's a little bit lower than a framing like that might make it out to be, and that's part of my, if not concern, then hesitation. The freakish mobility is a huge chunk of what I mean. I'm not trying to sell you on natural passing talent or, you know, mastery, but that athleticism and that mobility is enticing, and it makes you really difficult to deal with, at least, you know, for whatever his prime looks like, and I think that needs to be taken into account. And it is scary, like, to bring up the durability thing. Like, yeah. In order to maximize J. And Daniels, you have to put him at risk of getting hurt more so than some other quarterbacks, but that just is what it is to me. All right. This turned into a bigger picture conversation than I anticipated having, but we haven't had this conversation. Yeah. We just haven't really talked about him and them and just where they're at. Like, there just hasn't really been a good moment to do that, and I think this was a really good moment to do that. I had, like, a 2 out of 10 expectation of what Thursday night football was going to be going in, and I – like, everything. Beginning to end was like a 12 out of 10. I had a blast. All right. That's all we've got for today. The Week 10 preview is going to be available in your podcast feeds overnight. It'll be available on YouTube tomorrow at 12 p.m. Central. If you're watching this on YouTube, which it's the only place you can watch it right now, like, subscribe, do all of that great stuff. We would sincerely appreciate it. We will be back on Sunday night recapping all things Week 10. For now, that's all we got. Appreciate you guys listening. We'll talk to you very soon. We'll talk to you very soon.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The Washington Commanders delivered a dramatic, high-stakes victory over the Giants, fueled by strong defensive performances and a pivotal final drive that included multiple critical plays.
  2. J.J. McCarthy played notably well, especially in the second half, showing improved rhythm, accuracy, and play design, with several standout throws that highlighted his development as a quarterback.
  3. The Giants' defense, though undermanned and short-handed, made several impactful plays, including key interceptions and forcing Washington into turnovers, demonstrating defensive resilience despite injuries and limitations.
  4. Washington’s offensive strategy relied heavily on a pure drop-back game, lacking dynamic play-action and run-pass options, which limited their ability to create consistent pressure on the Giants’ defense.
  5. The game’s outcome was heavily influenced by missed opportunities—such as a missed field goal early and a fumble by Malik Neighbors—that shifted momentum and ultimately cost the Giants a division lead.
  6. Cam Scadaboo’s physicality and aggressive play, including multiple blitzes and strong tackles, were highlighted as a standout defensive performance, despite questions about coverage and decision-making in key moments.
  7. There is growing discussion about the future of Jaden Daniels in Washington, with some believing he has elite athleticism and promise, though concerns about durability and long-term development remain.
  8. The game exemplified a "perfect" Thursday night matchup—entertaining, unpredictable, and full of drama—despite the Giants’ position in a tough division, making it a compelling example of plucky, high-intensity football.

Summary:

The Washington Commanders defeated the New York Giants in a thrilling, high-stakes Thursday night game that delivered both excitement and drama. The victory was driven by a strong defensive effort from Washington, particularly from edge defender Cam Scadaboo, who made several impactful plays, including multiple aggressive blitzes and tackles. J.

McCarthy showed significant improvement in the second half, demonstrating better rhythm, accuracy, and play design with several memorable throws, including a crucial touchdown completion. Despite strong defensive efforts by the Giants, key early setbacks—including a missed field goal and a fumble by Malik Neighbors—shifted momentum and ultimately cost them the win. The Giants' offense struggled with a lack of play-action and run-pass variety, relying heavily on a stagnant drop-back game, which limited their ability to create consistent pressure.

Washington’s offense, while not dominant, showed flashes of potential, especially in the second half. The game was widely praised as a "perfect" matchup, blending high-energy action with unpredictable moments. Looking ahead, the future of the Commanders’ quarterback, Jaden Daniels, remains uncertain due to durability concerns, though his athleticism and ability to create plays in high-pressure situations suggest long-term potential.

The Giants, despite their divisional leadership, are viewed as a plucky, underdog team with strong foundation and development, particularly in their coaching and young talent. Ultimately, the game underscored the unpredictability of football and the impact of key moments, while highlighting both the promise and challenges facing both franchises.

FAQs

The Commanders won in a back-and-forth game with strong final drives, including a series of poor defensive calls and a last-minute decision to go for a field goal instead of a more conservative approach.

Rasul Douglas made an impressive catch on a pop fly, which was initially controversial due to the ball being too high, but his ability to recover and make the play earned praise from commentators.

The Giants' defense forced multiple turnovers, made several key interceptions, and successfully limited Washington's running game, especially in the second half.

J.J. McCarthy played well in the second half, showing improved rhythm, making several accurate throws, and executing plays with better decision-making, though his performance in the final minutes was inconsistent.

Washington relied heavily on pistol and drop-back formations, especially on fourth-down plays, which limited offensive variety and left the defense with a predictable game plan.

While Jaden Daniels has shown flashes of elite talent, particularly in mobility and scrambling, his durability and long-term development are uncertain, making his future role in the team a point of debate.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.