Go back

Coffee Meets Bagel co-founder on building the 'anti-Tinder' and turning down Mark Cuban

1h 9m 27s

Coffee Meets Bagel co-founder on building the 'anti-Tinder' and turning down Mark Cuban

Arum Khan co-founded Coffee Meets Bagel in 2012 with her sisters, inspired by the inefficiency and dejection of traditional dating apps—especially for women. The app’s core innovation lies in curating a single, intentional match per day, targeting users seeking serious relationships, not casual hookups. This focus on meaningful connections has helped it grow into a global platform with over 200 million matches and 10 million dates. A pivotal moment came in 2018 when unexpected employee resignations revealed a leadership flaw, prompting Arum to deeply reflect on her management style and prioritize employee trust and candid dialogue. She introduced "Five Discourses of a Team" to foster a culture of open feedback and accountability. The company has successfully filled a niche by serving Asian American singles, who value efficiency and long-term relationships, leading to strong growth in both the U.S. and Asia. In Asia, Coffee Meets Bagel has become a leader due to the region’s underdeveloped serious dating market and cultural alignment. The company continues to innovate, addressing issues like ghosting and unsafe behavior through education and smart product features. Arum also transitioned from a traditional, high-pressure leadership style to one grounded in empathy and self-awareness, which strengthened team well-being. Despite early struggles with scalability and burnout, the company achieved profitability by 2020, choosing sustainable growth over rapid expansion. Arum now emphasizes energy management, flexible work models, and team empowerment, ensuring long-term resilience. The journey reflects a broader lesson in entrepreneurship: success requires not just vision, but emotional intelligence, adaptability, and a commitment to both personal and professional well-being.

Transcription

11340 Words, 60620 Characters

English
The business was great. We're doubling every year and sort of like you're in like nothing is stopping us mode and I've made some series of in hindsight not so great decisions that my employees were not happy with and totally by surprise a lot of them decided to leave the company at the same time. Yeah and I've never had employee turnover until that point and so it was a real eye-opening moment for me and I really had to reflect okay what happened like what have I done? Welcome to Behind the Business a show about the people behind top consumer brands in emerging disruptors and how they push through to make the most about work and life each day. I'm Michelle Toe a journalist most recently with CNN. Today I'm here with Arum Khan, one of three Korean sisters who back in 2012 were fed up with how looking for love online often felt dejecting and demoralizing especially in their view for women their answer to create a new dating app called coffee meets bagel. Now from the start it build itself as a serious dating app boldly calling the platform the anti-tinder this meant that instead of giving users a C of endless swipes to go through it sent them just one curated match each day. The idea was hatched while Arum was studying at Harvard Business School and she later enlisted twin sister Dowoon and elder sister Sue to give up their high-paying jobs to come along for the ride. Together they've turned it into a household name coffee meets bagel is now one of the top dating apps globally it's set up over 200 million matches in more than 10 million dates around the world. The app is so prolific that a room is often invited to the weddings of users who matched on coffee meets bagel and at one point even officiated the wedding of a couple who met on the app. So I will tell you your app has helped several of my friends find their life partners and now get married. So on their behalf I will start off by thanking you. Yeah that's the best part about this job hearing these stories. Well it's actually really interesting because I learned recently that this is actually pretty much the norm for coffee meets bagel users. 91% of your users say they're looking for serious relationships is that right? That's absolutely right. So we're a dating app for singles who are ready for something serious and from the very beginning this is why we highly focused on curating limited number of matches so people don't have to waste so much time on others who are not looking for the same thing and people who are looking for you know long-term partners they do not want to waste time on people who don't have the same life goals as they do. So we are highly focused on helping those people. How have you managed though to curate this community right and keep it mostly to intentional daters and not just you know the people who are looking for hookups? You know we do that in sort of multiple fronts so number one we're very clear in our message about who this platform is intended for. It's funny because we also did a campaign while back that you know if you we ask users from the very beginning okay what is your intention of using coffee meets bagel and if your goal is finding a long-term partner we make that clear yes you are at the right place and if you're not if you're not ready for something serious we also welcome you but we all let them know hey maybe there are also better apps that you can use such as Tinder so we're very clear about okay who this app is for and the what the community is looking for so that is why we attract those people who are looking for something serious. And the second thing of course is we do a lot of things on the product side whether it's the algorithm or the features to also reinforce the intention of our users. So it's pretty unorthodox right because you're being very clear about you know hey like feel free to go someplace else but I imagine for you it's also about making sure you're giving them the best user experience so that everyone is aligned. Yeah yeah you have to be very clear about who you are going after you know and who you are serving yeah because we can't be servicing everyone you know every single's out there. Yes just to provide some context you were born and raised in South Korea before moving to Hawaii as a teenager along with your sisters but this was without your parents that must have been a really formative experience. Yeah I mean it was actually kind of crazy because now that I have my own children I'm kind of thinking like how do my parents like decide to actually do that because I don't think I could actually do that to my kids but it was it was somewhat of a crazy experience and I think couple things that I learned through that experience and of course number one like my sisters and I became super tight and so you know it was kind of almost like no brainer that we started working together and the second thing is like it almost forces you to grow up right and be independent and be responsible and I also knew you know we were high school students back then like what my parents had to go through to give us that opportunity it was my dad's dream to be able to study in the US and so knowing that you know a lot of people ask oh did you guys party every day like no adult supervision how did you guys do it but no we were very responsible and we wanted to make sure the sacrifice they made became worth worth the sacrifice yeah yeah how old were you exactly when you moved I was 13 and my older sister was 15 and in Hawaii actually when if your parents are divorced which my parents were actually you could get a driver's license at 15 not 16 and so as soon as my we got there my sister got her driver's license and she would like drive us to school and grocery shopping I mean she had a lot of responsibility yeah that's that's what we do for four years in Hawaii well you've been really open about the fact a room that your father made a lot of sacrifices to send you and your sisters to the US to which I can very much relate how did that shape your sense of drive did you from the start feel a sense of pressure to to impract yeah this is such an interesting question because I think it's like a double-edged sword right because in one sense you know what your parents had to go through to give you that opportunity so there is a tremendous sense of responsibility and pressure to be successful you know in a traditional sense and that's what I did you know you set goals and you strive and you get there and you build your resume etc. on the other hand I think over time what that does is after you get to certain level like I always had this fear of my biggest fear actually it was like being ordinary because my my father would always say hey you're gonna do extraordinary things and that actually landed on me as tremendous pressure so there's always like this fear of running behind your head okay I don't want to be the ordinary I don't want to be an ordinary person I need to do extraordinary things and so I think to a certain degree it helps you get to some level of success but after that I think it can actually work counter productively as well and so at some point as I gained experience it was also sort of a mind shift that I had to do hey actually this is not helping me like being so critical of myself and always driving and always driving and so that's one thing that I really had to learn like reprogram my myself and that took a lot of coaching and of course self-care and being more aware of how I'm thinking about myself yeah and how I approach things and how you approach things as a leader now yeah yeah yeah because the way you you know all these assumptions I think impacts also way you lead right because I grew up actually watching my dad and this is typically what you see on media right this charismatic and and he was my dad was a very tough leader who someone rules by fear and so I think that's kind of how I started my leadership journey and I I don't think that came naturally to me but I felt like okay that's what I had to do and so I think at the beginning of my career if you were to ask my employees like how I was as a leader I think a lot of people would have said hey she's a little bit scary yeah yeah yeah she's tough and I mean also the fact that like it doesn't help that in Silicon Valley that is sort of the norm of how you lead and I mean like interesting thing is when I first moved to the Valley of course I'm sort of seeking advice especially around fundraising and talking to VCs etc. And the first advice that I got, I still remember, was hey, you're too humble. Yeah, you need to be like less humble, you need to like brag more and like, you know, just exaggerate more, etc., etc., which I totally didn't feel myself during that, but I had to play that part. I felt like I had to play that part. And as I gained experience as a leader and did this sort of a lot of coaching, self-work, I realized, you know what, actually, that is not my style, it is not authentic to me. And I think when I finally became comfortable with sort of fully accepting my leadership style, sort of more softer style, being authentic, being vulnerable, being real and being truthful, that's I think when I started really shining as a leader. And I think that's also why if you look at sort of our glass door, any stats, or if you talked to any of my employees, like culture, and the kind of team that I've created, you know, that's one of the biggest assets that we have. Yeah. And when you say all you wanted to before was to be ordinary, because there was a lot of pressure to be extraordinary, was it because you felt like you were often, perhaps, a bit too harsh on yourself or that kind of thing? Were you very hard on yourself, you know, when you were at school or in the workplace? Oh, absolutely. Yeah, and I think a lot of, especially Asian Americans, maybe also children of immigrants can relate to that, my guess is, yeah, just kind of driving yourself always to do the next thing. And then you realize when you get to the next thing, it's like, oh, that's great for a second. And then it's anti-climactic and you're looking at the next thing and looking at the next thing, right? So it never ends. It never ends. And then at some point, you find yourself completely unhappy and forgetting that, like, the journey is really what counts, right? I think it took me a long time of being unhappy and somewhat desperate, actually, to actually be able to make that shift in perspective. Just to continue along the kind of timeline, at what point did you know that you wanted to become a founder? I think I knew that actually pretty early on. So I was one of those kids when you asked, like, what do you want to be when you grow up? I didn't know. I actually didn't know what I wanted to be. But I think there were always desires to do something independent, having autonomy, and creating something out of nothing. That's what my dad talked about a lot, you know, being entrepreneur. One of the greatest thing is that you get to create something, your legacy, out of nothing. And so I didn't know what I wanted to build or what kind of business I wanted to have, but I think I had an inkling that I wanted to be a founder from very early on. Maybe I couldn't articulate it. Yeah, and it was very natural for me to actually start it with my sisters because of how tight we have become. Still waiting in line? Again? That's time you will never get back. Save time and money with stamps.com. Over 4 million businesses have skipped the line with stamps.com. Join them to save up to 90% off carrier rates from your computer or phone right now. Print postage for certified mail, registered mail, and packages in seconds. Then schedule a pick-up right from your home or office. For a limited time, go to stamps.com and use code podcast for a free welcome gift. Taxes and fees apply. Meet TV is America's number one classic TV entertainment network, airing over 60 of the greatest TV series every week. Now, Meet TV presents The Golden Girls of Summer, showcasing the best of the Golden Girls. Watch Dorothy, Blanche, Rose, and Sophia. Weeknights on Meet TV at 10 p.m. 9th Central. Log on to MeetTV.com now to find out where to watch Meet TV free over the air. And on cable, satellite, and select streaming services. MeetTV is memorable entertainment television. Yes. Well, I was going to ask you, actually. You later went on to Harvard Business School, so, by the way, far from ordinary things. So, I think check on that part, dad. But that's where I understand you got the idea to start coffee meets bagel. Tell us a bit more about that light bulb moment, because from what I understand, did you already have a partner, so it wasn't out of personal need? Yes. So, I was dating my current husband, and there were a couple of things that really drove us to founding of coffee meets bagel. So, like you mentioned, I was studying at Harvard Business School and took a class called "Competing Through Social Networks." And we looked at networks that foster existing relationships, as well as networks that foster new relationships. And as part of that ladder networks, we also looked at dating companies, and what I realized was, okay, first of all, the market is big and growing. The mobile was still growing, and so there was plenty of opportunity. And just globally, not even just in the US, especially internationally, the young population, the way that we are just becoming so busy every day, they really could leverage technology to meet new people. And on the personal side, even though I was already in a relationship, I saw my sisters, as well as plenty of my especially girlfriends, who are amazing in so many ways, having a really hard time finding and going on dates with the potential partners that they were happy with. And they were putting time and effort, right? They were dating apps, et cetera, because there were plenty of dating apps back then, too. And so, but it was really hard for them to actually decipher, okay, which of these people are actually worth spending time on, because they would get so many messages and so many interests, et cetera, right? So then the light bulb moment came when my older sister and I were in her apartment in New York. We were just, you know, talking about potential ideas, et cetera. And then we were looking at at the time, sort of curated e-commerce experience was really coming to light. And we thought, you know what, what if we take a similar approach and curate the immediate number of people, we started with one, at a regular time every day. And we picked noon because it's a sort of a break time, people have, you know, are taking lunch from work, et cetera. And so we decided, you know what, let's actually build an MVP. I don't know anything about like building a platform, but we can find somebody. And so we hired somebody, she designed something pretty rudimentary website and that was the beginning of Confirmance Bagel. Wow. And I understand that that first iteration, you were initially testing out with friends and family? Yeah. It was mostly friends. It was such, I just love this stage of building a company because it's all about just not worrying about anything else except building the right product. And so what we did was we recruited about 30 friends, single friends, and basically asked them, okay, like, we are going to have you use the product for a week and let us know what you think. And what we noticed, and at that time, we were making all the matches manually. I was doing the spreadsheet, Excel, thing, and every day at noon, I would just match and they would be connected via text message actually because we didn't, of course, have an app. And the feedback was overwhelmingly positive. The strong indicator to me at the time that, oh, wow, there's something here is vast majority of my friends were actually using it every day. Because having an app or any product and getting users to use it consistently is hard. So they're not going to do it unless they find it intriguing or it really serves their need, et cetera. And so I saw that they were actually using it every day. And then I called every one of them after that week a house experience and they loved it. And so that's when soon I decided, okay, there's something here, let's build it up. What were you basing it on at the time? It's so fascinating to hear that you were the one manually behind the fence playing the match. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because it was pre-algorithm, pre-everything, right? It was a website that you had people manually just put in their details and then you looked at it and said, look, here's what I think would work. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Honestly, at that time, because I only had 30 people, there wasn't really bases to go I, because I just have to match, but I mean, the good thing is because they're sort of among my friends and so's friends, you know, there are similarities, right, in the close network of people that we have. So I think they found it interesting enough, so we didn't need to have an advanced algorithm at that time. Right. It's not like you were like, this is going to be your future husband. Exactly. Exactly, exactly, yeah. Right. That's so interesting. So those who don't know what is behind the name, coffee means bagel. Because we're asking our data to come in every day at noon, we wanted to have the name represent something that they do on a regular basis every day, basically. And so we thought about, okay, coffee break, like people drink coffee almost every day. So coffee comes from that and then we were trying to find something complementary to coffee and of course like people think donut or whatever and then we chose bagel because it goes well with coffee as well as we started in New York City so it's kind of honor of the city itself. It sounds like it was firstly your idea and did you kind of have to convince Sue and Da Woon to you know because they were working jobs as well. Yeah you know it was a good timing for me because I had just graduated and basically I gave myself a year to you know find something product market fit and if I don't you know actually if nothing takes off after a year my plan was to get a job and then of course my older sister Sue and Da Woon they had their full-time jobs and so I spent most of the time you know during the day working on this thing and then Sue would actually help out after her day time job and so that sort of model when I think for about six months and when we started seeing the product really pick up and then we started getting actually inquiries from our users if we were raising money and that's when I think Da Woon she was actually at a private equity arm of JP Morgan in Hong Kong at the time decided you know what I'm gonna fly in and do this full-time yeah so the so the short answer to your question is they didn't need convincing. They convinced themselves to join this full-time. Oh that's so funny. Wow it's pretty remarkable though right to give up you know a stable income and to take that leap of faith. It isn't every day that you come across three sisters who started a tech startup together and have more importantly kept that partnership going for more than 10 years I know what has that been like you know working with family not always easy. I give a lot of credit to my dad about us quitting you know at least Sue and Da Woon quitting their job and joining because when me sort of floated that idea I think especially Asian American parents being a little bit more conservative he could have been like don't do that you know you're quitting a nice job but he wasn't like that at all he's I mean being an entrepreneur himself he basically told us go do it and whatever support you need to the extent I can I will help you guys so that really gave us the comfort and a confidence to dive in and then to go back to your original question it was not always easy especially at the beginning because you feel like you have to have control over everything and I of course we we all have different opinions so it was it was a lot of drama it was a lot of drama a lot of crying oh my god I still remember a lot of those conversations and at some point we said you know what we need help so we actually brought in um because Diamond to GSB one of the professors from GSB who specializes in family business so we had several sessions with her around just understanding each other I mean this was really the beginning of our sort of leadership work and so understanding each other what roles and responsibilities do we want to have and having that clear boundary of who is a decision maker within those roles and responsibilities and so it took a you know a lot of time and effort to be able to work as a family it is definitely possible yeah but you got to put in the effort because you get to know each other probably quite differently right it's obviously in a typical business meeting you may not show them if you've got tears coming on right like you might go outside whereas if you're with your sisters that you've known your whole lives you're kind of maybe feeling a bit more free to kind of say what you really think from almost the beginning when we started having employees even though it was a small team we started doing sort of anonymous feedback uh surveys and I remember one of the surveys uh response that I got in terms of like oh what can we do better et cetera it's like one employee said okay okay sisters please stop bickering because it makes me uncomfortable yeah so we definitely bickered yeah and that got better over time yeah that is funny and for those who don't know by the way GSB is uh Stanford's business school um so you brought in someone it sounds almost like they played the role of partly family therapists partly executive coach yeah yeah yeah yeah and I'm a big fan of working with professionals um coaches therapists et cetera to get help you really need all the support you can get as a founder yeah because just the roller coaster ride ever stops it's refreshing to hear that by the way because I think especially in you know our Asian community um people don't often speak about that yeah yeah yeah if they were going and getting help they might not want to be so open about it so you know thank you for sharing that you have become a mom during your tenure as CEO right speaking of family that can be a lot on one's plate how have you adapted to life as a working mother and has it shifted the way you lead in the workplace absolutely yeah absolutely you know I think before I became a mom of course I actually think I had bias against if I'm being really honest bias against working moms because the typical expectation in the valley tech companies is like you got to put everything in right you got to put the hours and you got to live in the you know live at work uh you got to hang out socialize like your life is work basically yeah and at the beginning just from the demographics of employees we had and myself that's what we did that's what we did that's what the culture was and when I became a mom I realized oh my god a lot of things that I was doing at the company such as like having late meetings and like having happy hours like every Friday whatever was not very probably convenient for uh at the time we only had working dads but working dads right and so when you are you become and you you are in that position that's when you start to understand okay what it takes and this is you know another topic this is why diversity is so important that work because you don't you just don't understand until you're in that position and when I became a mom it was really hard yeah it was really hard and that's when I became I think almost desperate for help because I really felt like okay I I can't do it all it's either my happiness or coffee means vehicle like I have to make a choice yeah and um I I started working with my first coach who actually introduced me to love kind um meta meditation at the time and and until then I was like what is meditation what is self-love I didn't know any of this uh but because I was so unhappy losing sleep becoming anxious etc I started diving into that I think that's when my whole sort of uh self-awareness journey started and of course that impacts your leadership style and your perspective in how you approach things yeah so just to be clear you're saying that when before you became a mother yourself you were maybe secretly you're just freely admitting perhaps a bit doubtful that working moms could give the same amount perhaps as someone than someone who didn't have kids yes yes but now that you are in that position yourself you see how much it takes to even be able to do both at all yeah and also just how much more efficient and effective I've personally became because you don't have all the time that you used to have before before kids and so you have to be really focused and great your you know great time management being productive I mean so many of our hours are wasted on on productive just busy work and so what is that thing that really matters to the company right and there's only a few things really that has enough leverage to make a big difference to the company and so uh learning what those are and also just giving people more flexibility um when people are happy with uh the way they can work that fit into their lifestyle I believe and I see it there is so much more productive um and so those differences yeah I've heard that by the way about efficiency it's like that saying if you want to get something done give it to a busy mom oh yeah because they totally they know what a juggle yeah um so would you say looking back now then a room that that assumption that you previously had you feel like it was incorrect I totally completely incorrect and I am a huge fan of hiring working uh working moms and also even just for not not even full-time jobs only right part-time flexible jobs I think there's so much talents out there that we can leverage this is not about okay let's do nice things this is about actually let's produce better results and we got so much talent among working not working but generally female sales, mom, pool that I think we can, the companies can totally take advantage of. Yeah, it'd be more flexible. Let's talk more about the takeoff phase of coffee meets bagel. Can you walk us through how you got the business off the ground? You mentioned that it started out with testing, with early users. You then had some folks who liked what you had done and reached out to you to see if you needed funding. How did it go from inception to development to then going really big with it? I think a lot of people, when they see companies, they think, "Oh, like it happened overnight, but that's not the full story. It happens over time." And so we weren't even thinking about fundraising until we started getting questions from our users like, "Hey, are you raising? I'm an angel investor, et cetera." And so that's when we thought, "Okay, this is a sign that perhaps maybe we should seek external funding to really build a team and grow this out." And so down and I made a trip at that time to San Francisco, we met a bunch of investors here and was lucky enough to rate seed round. And so we moved out to San Francisco and that was really the beginning of, I guess, building a proper company, yeah. Right. I am so curious about the fundraising game and your journey as a woman in tech. A fellow HBS alum who you might know is Tacha founder Vicky Ty. She's previously stated that even though I went to Harvard Business School, started off in finance, had multiple acquisition offers within the first month of launching, had a profitable business with brand awareness and a product and a CPG marketing background. I could not raise a dollar for the life of me. Now a room, you and your team have successfully raised over $20 million. So clearly this doesn't fully apply to you. But I wondered, could you relate to this at all, especially starting out? Yeah, yeah. And you know, what you have to realize is especially in the traditional venture capital funding, there's sort of the herd mentality that happens. So you know, at some point maybe the consumer sector is like everything that's where all the money is going and then the next year it's totally out of flavor. And so this is really not, first of all knowing just this may not be about your business and yourself. It's really about sort of macro trend also and whatever they're having to improve and go through the firms themselves. And then the other thing is, this is a highly competitive process, right? You know, they're getting pitched hundreds of companies all the time. They don't have the time really to properly like vet out, especially the early stage companies. And so what happens is a lot of VCs who are of course run by men. They tend to make unconsciously, I don't believe all these people are making consciously bios decisions but unconsciously, if you don't have a time to really get to know a business and look at all the, especially when there's not much data, right? And you have to be pretty quick at making those like few investments that you make in a year. Of course, you're going to have bios towards things that seem familiar to you, founders who sort of talk and think like you, so of course. So it's not, I don't blame them, it's more just a systematic thing that's happening. And this is why we need more representation in the investing side of more females. And so yeah, I can totally relate to that. And that's exactly how I felt too. And after my seed round, which actually was relatively quick, the fundraising was very difficult. And that's when I started really reaching out, okay, what kind of networks can I use? Female networks. I mean, I think it's getting better by the day, right? We have more females investing and more female focused also, investment philosophy, etc. And so really leveraging those has been helpful. In 2024, pitch book data shows that the share of venture funding by female founders actually had its lowest level in five years, which was already, as you just pointed to, widely known to long being issue. I mean, I've been covering this for so many years. I was going to ask what you think needs to be done to address this going forward. You've just kind of pointed to the need for more representation. Is there anything else that you think, short of getting more women in those chairs that would be helpful to founders and female founders? I really don't want to put this all on male investors because there are so many of them that are actually trying to make change too. But it also happens on our side too. I think for me, at least I can't speak for every other female, when I'm actually pitching to male, I have on my own bias about, okay, pitching to older male. And so I think unconsciously, I also put myself sort of in a weaker position. And so mentally, I have to really prepare myself, okay, like we are peer-to-peer. And the other thing that's really been game-changing sort of game-changer for me is, and this is why I think especially if you're minority pitching, I always advise this, is you got to, because it takes a longer time for us to actually get their attention and for them to get it, you got to build that relationship. And one really important lesson I learned is, you really don't want this to be a pitch. You really want this to be, hey, I'm building this thing, what do you think? Let's give me some advice, who should I talk to, et cetera, build that relationship. And over time, have them sort of feel vested and ask you, okay, like, hey, it looks like it's about time that you raise some more funding. I think that is such a much smoother way for minorities and especially females to raise. So you're like, give me one hour of your time and let me make a pitch. Shipping, building, admin, payroll, marketing, you're managing all the things. So why waste time sending important documents the old fashioned way? Mail and ship when you want, how you want, with stamps.com. Print postage on demand 24/7, and schedule pickups from your office or home. Save up to 90% with automated rate shopping. That's why over 1 million small businesses trust stamps.com. Go to stamps.com and use code podcast to try stamps.com risk-free for 60 days. A room you've also said that coffee meets bagel has been profitable since 2020 and highly profitable at that. We so often hear of tech firms that struggle to make money. What did it take to really get to this point? It's a strategic choice, I believe. And so for us, I had the advantage of, of course, being in a dating space, our business model is somewhat proven. We know people are willing to pay for if you look at the market. And so it was really a matter of when do we want to be profitable and how much? And it's a strategic choice because that potentially comes at the cost of growth, right? And I think back in early 2020s, when the economy was better, et cetera, it was all about okay, grow, grow, grow, grow, we don't care about margin. And then soon, in about 2020, when the economy started shifting, everybody sort of turned into like, that's the profit, profit, profit, forget the growth, you have to be sustainable. And so it's really a choice that you make as a founder, how you want to grow your company. I think a lot of us assume, especially in the tech world, like you got to grow and not think about profit from the beginning, but that's a choice you make. Yes, I remember in 2020, early days of COVID, there was an open letter that went viral. Do you know what I'm talking about? From Sequoia Capital, I was telling all their portfolio companies, forget what we said before, please make money because we're entering the winter for startups. And I cannot tell you, Michelle, being unprofitable versus profitable is an identity difference for your psyche and also just, you know, the things that you can do, the freedom it gives you. And so, again, it's a choice, having been there unprofitable and profitable, it is a much better place to be. What do you mean by that? Because before you're profitable, you're in a survival mode, right? Because there's always a time bomb ticking. And I cannot tell you how many times I felt like, oh my God, we're going to run out of money. And then, of course, like the, you know, you start thinking about all the worst case scenarios. And so to some extent, it could really push you, but in another way, it could make you make choices out of fear, which is not healthy, nor will you make the best choices. Whereas when you have this luxury of being profitable, there's nothing you have to do, right? Because you can, you don't need external help, source of funding. So completely changes, I think, your state of mind. And even for investors, right, I think they can, humans are so smart, they can smell it. in your desperate and unique way. something versus when you don't need it and you can always walk away, I think it's a night and day difference. Right. And when you say it was a choice to become profitable, are you referring to the fact that you were probably spending a lot to obviously chase growth at the time? And there was a point where you decided to turn on that. Yeah, yeah. And it came, you know, it was a difficult choice, right? Because, you know, whether it's marketing or workforce you have, like, we had to, I had to make conscious choice to reduce that. And we had to make some personal changes, cost reduction, layoffs. So it's not easy. It was not easy going from growth mode to profit mode. But I think it was, I just knew knowing the macro situation as well as how I wanted to lead the company in a more more sustainable way. I just knew that it was the right thing to do at the right time. What have been some of the lowest moments? There's so many peaks and valleys throughout a founder's journey, right? I imagine obviously like you just touched on, you know, the difficult decision to have to do cost reductions and restructuring have those been amongst some of the toughest decisions you've had to make. There's so many. There's so many. Oh my god, just yeah, layoffs are always the hardest. But my first actually sort of existential crisis, I think, come to my mind. And this was, this didn't have to do with layoffs that I had to make. It actually had to do with massive resignation that happened. That totally took me by surprise. So this was around like 2018, 19 and the business was great. We're doubling every year and sort of like you're in like nothing is stopping us mode. And we I've made some series of in hindsight, not so great decisions that my employees were not happy with and totally by surprise, a lot of them decided to leave the company at the same time. Yeah. I've never had employee turnover until that point. And so it was a real eye opening moment for me. And I really had to reflect, okay, what happened? Like what have I done? And I thought we had the best culture. I thought I knew the employees, et cetera. And so I spoke to pretty much everybody at the company like what happened, including people who were leaving. And what happened was because I sort of had this thing in my mind that I want to do this. I rushed into making that decision. And I thought I had the binds of my team. They didn't agree, but they sort of relatively went with it. And it turned out, you know, a particular thing that we were sort of betting on didn't result in what we were hoping for. And so they somewhat became demoralized and decided, okay, we're going to leave. So it was sort of series of things building up to that point. And that was when I really had to reflect, okay, like one of my cultural values was fear less candor. And like, did I actually foster the right environment for people to be candid? And so I worked with, again, leadership coaches, release, self-reflecting, et cetera. And that's when I actually brought this whole philosophy of what I absolutely, it's like, oh, it's become a Bible at our company called Five Dismonctions of a Team, which is all about basing your entire culture and trust. And so that comes to my mind as so much of a turning point for my leadership sort of style, as well as, I guess, a little point in our company history. It sounds like that was a wake-up call. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, it was a wake-up call. Do you mind my asking and feel free to share as much as you're comfortable with? But, you know, what really was the specific decision that led to that, do you think? And how many employees was it that ended up, you know, you ended up saying goodbye to you at that point? So it was actually, I don't even remember at this point what exact feature it was, but it was about this feature. And I wanted to launch that, like, in Q4, post-Christmas New Year is our biggest season for dating industry because this is when everybody's like, okay, New Year, New Me, I want to find a new relationship. And so I wanted to get this particular feature out and I thought it was like gonna be amazing, of course, rushed everybody into building this new thing. So people had to work overtime and, you know, basically do, you know, a lot of sort of bend over back to get this done. Yeah. Yeah. And it didn't do what you, I thought it was gonna do. It didn't take off the way that you explained. Yeah, exactly, exactly. So then you feel like maybe people were like, what was all that for? We, like, you know, busted our butts to make it happen. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And it was really hard because over like a month period, actually, I think about maybe 15% of our employees don't remember exactly how many people sort of trickled in over the course of like three to four weeks with resignation. Yeah. And did they say it was over that room specifically or was it, you know, maybe various things going on? I'm sure it was, you know, not just that, but maybe that was what sort of tipped people over. And when I had exit interviews, yeah, basically a lot of it was centered around, hey, you know, we didn't think this was the right thing to do. And we didn't have the really the right opportunity to talk about this. You just like kind of bulldoze over and made those decisions, etc. It's really refreshing to hear of, you know, a leader like you being so frank and honest about that. It sounds like you learned a lot from it. And you're taking steps to make sure that it wouldn't happen again. When you say that you've looked at your company culture now and kind of dug deeper, doesn't mean that you want to provide opportunities now for your staff to be able to raise their hand and say, Hey, look, I don't know if this is the right call here. Is that the kind of thing you mean? Yeah. Yeah. And the thing is, I think I didn't realize is when the leader is asking you, okay, like, what do you guys think about this? Just asking that isn't going to have your team give you honest and candid response. And I think my naive assumption was, well, I asked you that and nobody said anything. So therefore it's fine. And so what we, what we, how we train our managers is what we call mining for conflicts. And that is, we really, first of all, generally, I think people really have to trust each other. And that's a heart. That's the text time to be able to feel comfortable raising their, you know, candid opinion. But also the manager has to, so many times, I think we feel, like, we have to rush to a decision. But that actually ends up slowing things down, because not everybody's fully bought in. And I'm not saying everybody has to agree, but there has to be, I agree to disagreement. So, and that happens when people have ample time and space to be able to say all the things that they want to say. And after that concluding, okay, I heard you, we consider pros and cons, et cetera. And we're still going with this direction. But that, you need to take time for that to take place. Yeah. It sounds like that was actually a very valuable experience for you in the end. Oh, absolutely. Yeah, you've had a lot of clear takeaways that you can apply going forward. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm curious as well. You know, obviously, you play in a very competitive market, right? Online dating, there are apps out there. How does coffee meets bagel differentiate itself from other apps, like the Bumbles or the hinges of the world? Yeah. It is a very competitive world. And one of the things I tell my employees is, we have to know what our competitors are doing, but we don't obsess about our competitors. We obsess about our customers. And knowing who your customers are, your core audience, I think is the first step to be able to differentiate, because you cannot serve everyone out there. And the other thing that we found over time is that in particular in the U.S., we do very well among Asian Americans. And so, strategically, we decided, you know what, we're going to double down on servicing Asian American singles. And we want to be the best dating app out there for Asian Americans looking for serious relationships. So you talk to a lot of them, why are you using coffee meets bagel that we can double down on? And for particularly Asian Americans, I think this is somewhat in their culture. They value efficiency. There are certain things also, they value such as profession, education, basically similar values. And so it's funny, like one example of how we decided to service that customer-based better is like, when you look at our profile. Somebody described us, "Oh, a CNB profile looks more like a resume." And for some audience, that's a negative thing. Like I don't want to be on a dating app with a profile looking resume. For a lot of our core audience, for busy, and they want to get to the point and they know what they want, this is a huge plus. So we're sticking with that feature, for example. So you're making choices that are very unique to how to service your customers the best. One start that really stands out about coffee meets bagel is that it has seen this remarkable success within the Asian American community specifically. I believe this demographic makes up 40% of users for you in the US. Yeah. Why do you think that is? And how have you tried to continue to hone in on catering to this community while still making clear this is an app welcome for everybody? This is not even just for Asian Americans, but if we see this among Asian data in Asian Asia, because we're very growing fast over there too, I think culturally they really value serious relationship, like even at a pretty young age like college, for example. And so our value prop of focusing on serious relationship and also making what they're looking for, easy to filter, easy to see, et cetera, I think is primary reason why we've done so well with this audience, not just in the US, but in Asia too. Right. And that's happened fairly organically, it sounds like. And speaking of Asia, it's been a really bright spot for you as well. You've said that the region has emerged as the biggest source of growth for the company. To what do you attribute that and how are you investing to grow within Asia specifically now? Yeah. When you look at the region, it's interesting, the population is younger and online dating adoption is still significantly lower than the US. And so I think there's ample opportunity to growing. The market itself is just growing more. And the other thing is if you look at regionally who are the players, Tinder is still the biggest player in the market. And after that is Tantan, which is basically a local app that pretty much mimics Tinder. And so the most popular few apps tend to be very casual. So I believe there is a pent up demand for a product that really caters to serious relationship. And that's why Coffee Meets Bagel value proposition has really resonated so much in that region. And so probably four or five years ago also, we started organically seeing tremendous growth coming from that region. And we decided, OK, we're going to invest. And we have now our headquarters in Singapore. We have about over 30 employees. And our CMO is also based in Singapore. We have a general manager there. And we plan to really invest in the region to be the number more serious dating app. And what we realize is, OK, this momentum is very important. Another dating tip is, once the chat opens, how quickly you respond makes a huge difference in whether you're going to actually go on a date or not. So we've looked at chats that somebody actually responded within three hours of opening has a significantly better result than, let's say, chats where people didn't respond either parties for 24 hours. So we wanted to create some sort of momentum for people to have excuse to talk or exchange number, et cetera, which is why we have 7-day chat. What we learned in Asia is people need more time. They like to chat because in the US, it's like, OK, let's meet in person at this point. Like the sooner or the better, they have to talk more. And so then we introduced auto extensions. So as long as one person is talking, we're going to keep auto extending for another or three days. Yeah. Well, talk about the roadmap for coffee meets bagel going forward. In what direction do you really hope to grow in the next few years? I think you have a few goals that you're hoping to hit. Yeah. So our three-year goal is to become the number one dating app in A6, what we call A6, the six markets in Asia, as well as among Asian Americans in the US. And I think from product perspective, you know, there's still a lot of challenges that singles will be happy to tell you about dating and one of the big areas that we are thinking about is ghosting problem, yeah, ghosting problem and also safety. So our product team is working very hard at some really innovative and creative features to help that that we, you may sort of hear from us in a few months. So why waste time sending important documents the old fashioned way, mail and ship when you want how you want with stamps.com, print postage on demand 24/7 and schedule pickups from your office or home, save up to 90% with automated rate shopping. Go to stamps.com and use code podcast to try stamps.com risk free for 60 days. Can you say any more about the ghosting problem? Because that is actually a very big one that I hear a lot of my single friends talk about. Yeah, yeah. I mean the ghosting problem, it's really funny because singles complain about ghosting problem, but they ghost all the time themselves. That's the thing. Because, you know, whatever, like you change your mind, et cetera and especially if men, when we sort of watch how they're using the app, because they don't hear back, they don't get liked back often enough, at least as often as woman, they tend to play this numbers game, right? They like everybody and then once they hear back, it's like, okay, let me now decide who I actually want to spend time talking about. So I think there's a variety of ways that we can solve this problem, whether it's upstream, you know, like, okay, we, I mean one brute way to do this, like we don't let you actually, you know, like as many people as you do, or how can we actually educate people? I mean, especially men, because they tend to be the one initially initiating conversation, make better conversation, because I mean, and education actually makes a huge difference. The number of one initial text that we see is hi. And when you say things like hi, first of all, a lot of people are just like, I'm not even going to respond at this point, like you are not putting any effort in, but also it just makes it hard to respond, right? Well, what's wrong with high, though, just like, what's wrong with high? I mean, what else do you expect from the least possible people out there, you know, sometimes high is okay, too, you know? Well, okay, so other person may not respond, or like likely we'll say hi back, and that it's like that silence again, so, I mean, there are very little things that we can teach educate singles, and that's the other thing that we believe at Kaupen-Witz-Bago, our job goes beyond introduction. Because in order for us to help people get into relationship, we must also educate our users healthy dating behaviors. So to that point, we've heard of some apps that try to integrate generative AI to help you craft a good opening line. Is that something that you guys are? I think AI has a huge place in terms of helping singles, not even just this specific problem, but of course, making better matches, et cetera, yeah, I think that's a very much of an opportunity area. Let's talk about outlook for a second. Dating apps have famously struggled on Wall Street in recent years. Having said that, would you ever consider taking Kaupen-Witz-Bago public, or have you felt pressure, too? You know, I've been very lucky with my investors in terms of not putting pressure in one way or the other, and the way I think about, but, you know, of course, I took external funding, so I think about how do I provide our investors with the gluity opportunities, and now I think nowadays there's other ways, whether it's secondary and other things to provide with the gluity that I don't particularly think going public is the only way. But I think about it more in terms of, in order for us to hate our goal, what is the resource we need, and does going public actually help us get there faster versus some other route? Yeah. Well, one potential exit that could have been really interesting was the time you appeared on Shark Tank. This was almost exactly 10 years ago, and at the time Mark Cuban famously asked you and your sisters if you would accept $30 million for your business, which in theory would have been the largest offer in Shark Tank history. Without even blinking a room, you straight up just said no. What made you so sure? Because we saw how much opportunity there is, and also what we can do to help singles. I mean, it was just so early in the company history to actually say, okay, we're done here. And so I just didn't even have to think at that point that we have so much work cut out for us. that we're not going to consider selling. - I totally hear your point, but I also see the flip side where one might point out, well, this was at a time where it was really early on. You guys were making, I believe, hundreds of thousands of dollars in revenue at that point compared to obviously tens of millions. So I guess looking back 10 years on, how do you reflect on that moment? - You know, it's interesting when I talk to first time, especially first time founders. I think they have this idea of, okay, there are like checklist of things you have to do. You go create something, you raise money, et cetera, et cetera. And often we think we have to do it all alone. I have to be the one to do it. But I've now seen different models, whether it's you partner with a strategic, you know, bigger company or you get an investor from Shark Tank, et cetera, that I do think, you know, at that point, my thought was, okay, if I sell the company, that's it. But it could've just as well been, oh, I have this great investor now on board. Well, I guess it would be the owner on board who can actually help us fly, right? So I think you don't have to think about your business growing in just one particular way. I think there are a lot of ways that you can in this help. I think it's a matter of like, do you want to retain control of your company or not? I am curious, did you ever run into Mark Cuban again or ever drop him a line to share how things were going? No, actually not. Maybe I should. Yeah. Just to also continue that zoom out for a second, you have been at this for a while, 13 years to be exact. How do you keep going on days when, you know, maybe it feels just a bit too much or it may not feel like that shiny new dream anymore? Yeah, I think this is a lot, a big thing for founders who's been at it for a long time. What it comes down to me is energy management. And this is a long journey, right? And you can't, it's not something like, okay, I'm gonna work really hard and like, overwork and take a vacation and then come back. It's just those, you'll burn out at that pace. It's really about knowing if, when I assess, you know, what activities bring me more energy versus draining energy? Where can I actually focus my time, right, on activities that really give me energy and therefore probably I'm better at? And delegating things that drains my energy and building a team around that and really working at a pace that works for you. So, you know, a couple of years ago, we actually implement, for example, implement a four day work week, flexible work environment. We have completely distributed workforce in the US and Canada and we have a hybrid model in Singapore. And I found that, honestly, if I hadn't made those arrangements, I think I would have completely burned out. Then I probably wouldn't have been able to continue, but I'm able to do that because I'm pacing myself. And ultimately, I think just knowing that this is a long-haul game and also knowing that this doesn't make you less productive, it actually gives you more power to go on and go through the low and tough moments and not break down, et cetera. And so it comes down to energy management for me. - That's a really great answer, I think. What are some of those specifics just to follow up on things that you do to keep your energy up maybe on a day-to-day basis and some of the things that you might hand off to preserve that? - Yeah, so I'm a product person. So what gives me energy is like jamming with my team on product features, et cetera. And so at our team right now, among my executive members, I don't have a chief product officer, that's basically me, because that's what gives me energy and I love and I'm good at it. But the example of something that drains me is, not that I'm not metrics oriented person I am, but having to deal with operational metrics and financials every day, that's just not my, something that gives me energy. So I have a really strategic and great CFO handling that. And I think auditing your calendar also on sort of, okay, when what activity actually did give me joy versus not, constantly just reassessing that? - What's the best use of your time? - Exactly, yeah. The other thing is, there are little things that I do that I think gives me burst of energy, which I think is really important. So for example, just getting up early when everybody's sleeping and doing a little journaling or having like a really refreshing hot cup of tea, things like that, sort of a ceremonial things that gives me joy. I think that, believe it or not, it's small thing, but it makes a big difference. - Definitely. I think the morning routine is something I never tire of hearing of, right? - Yeah. - Well, Arum, what is the end game for you here? We kind of touched on this briefly. You spoke about the secondary market. Does that mean that if we were to sit here again in five to 10 years, would you want to have been acquired by then, or what is the next step? - Yeah, again, I think those are all means to an end, which end being, for now, the three-year goal that we have. So I'm not attached to one particular path. In fact, I think that's kind of dangerous like being attached to one path. I think allowing yourself to go with the flow and letting the opportunity arise, I think that's really how I want to approach. So, for example, if there's a great strategic partner that we can partner with, who's gonna enable us to get to that goal earlier, of course, I will consider it. I don't have to be running this on my own, for example. I'm not married to that. - Well, this brings me to a segment. We are calling what it takes, where an audience member and fellow entrepreneur gets to ask for advice and hear more on what it takes to get where you are. Today, Sachin and e-commerce entrepreneur from London has another fundraising question that kind of ties into what we spoke about earlier. He asks, "What is it like raising funds from investors as an Asian, where there hurdles you had to overcome, and what was your early stage strategy?" - Yeah, I think we briefly touched on this. This is not even just about being Asian, but this is basically being minority, right? You could be woman, Asian, or old in Silicon Valley, being old is being a minority too. And so, early strategy, again, really knowing that you're gonna have to do more convincing, because your audience might not get you right away, or audiences bias towards people who may not talk and look like you, building that relationship. And so, just constantly keeping them in the loop, asking for advice, what do you think, et cetera, naturally gets them more vested in your business and you. And so, I think that really, I mean, that's really honestly how I raised seed round two, right, because they already knew the product and they were asking me, "Hey, do you guys need to raise money?" And so, the relationship building, I think, is what I would recommend, especially for minority founders. - Is there anything before you walk into that room, any rituals you'd like to do to kind of gear up for that mentally or anything like that? - You know what? I don't even want to actually walk into that room, per se anymore, because that already puts the dynamic, again, going back to who, you know, weaker or stronger position, going into, I found, personally, if I go into VC office and sort of whatever the room, even if you're not pitching or whatever, it kind of puts you in that weaker mentality again. And so, I would rather, I mean, at some point, you will have to do that, right? At some point, you're going to have to like, pitch to all the partners and stuff, but at the very beginning, in order for you to get there, make it a coffee shop, keep it very casual, right? And so, those dynamics actually make a big difference. - Yeah, so kind of, don't necessarily have to go to their turf so early on, especially if you feel like it puts you on uneven footing. - Yeah, exactly. - That's a good tip. All right, I'm going to do a quick rapid fire round with your room. Don't overthink it. Just say whatever comes down, ready? What is your favorite way to unwind after a long day? - Probably sauna. - Oh, yeah. - That's a good one. - Yeah. - True or false, does playing hard to get online actually work?

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Arum Khan co-founded Coffee Meets Bagel with her sisters after recognizing the frustration women faced in traditional dating apps.
  2. The app differentiates itself by curating one match per day, focusing exclusively on serious relationships to avoid wasting time on casual connections.
  3. A major early turning point was a sudden employee exodus in 2018, which forced Arum to reevaluate leadership, culture, and decision-making processes.
  4. The company strategically targets Asian American users, who make up 40% of its U.S. user base, due to cultural values like efficiency and long-term commitment.
  5. Coffee Meets Bagel has grown rapidly in Asia, where it now has a regional headquarters in Singapore and is becoming a leader in serious dating.
  6. The app addresses key issues like ghosting and unsafe interactions through product innovation and user education on healthy dating behaviors.
  7. Arum shifted from a tough, results-driven leadership style to a more authentic, empathetic one, which improved team morale and culture.
  8. After years of growth, the company prioritized profitability and sustainability over aggressive expansion, leading to better long-term stability and decision-making.

Summary:

Arum Khan co-founded Coffee Meets Bagel in 2012 with her sisters, inspired by the inefficiency and dejection of traditional dating apps—especially for women. The app’s core innovation lies in curating a single, intentional match per day, targeting users seeking serious relationships, not casual hookups. This focus on meaningful connections has helped it grow into a global platform with over 200 million matches and 10 million dates.

A pivotal moment came in 2018 when unexpected employee resignations revealed a leadership flaw, prompting Arum to deeply reflect on her management style and prioritize employee trust and candid dialogue. She introduced "Five Discourses of a Team" to foster a culture of open feedback and accountability. S.

and Asia. In Asia, Coffee Meets Bagel has become a leader due to the region’s underdeveloped serious dating market and cultural alignment. The company continues to innovate, addressing issues like ghosting and unsafe behavior through education and smart product features.

Arum also transitioned from a traditional, high-pressure leadership style to one grounded in empathy and self-awareness, which strengthened team well-being. Despite early struggles with scalability and burnout, the company achieved profitability by 2020, choosing sustainable growth over rapid expansion. Arum now emphasizes energy management, flexible work models, and team empowerment, ensuring long-term resilience.

The journey reflects a broader lesson in entrepreneurship: success requires not just vision, but emotional intelligence, adaptability, and a commitment to both personal and professional well-being.

FAQs

Coffee Meets Bagel focuses on serious relationships by offering only one curated match per day, unlike apps that rely on endless swipes. It targets users seeking long-term connections and emphasizes efficiency and alignment in goals, making it distinct from casual or hook-up focused platforms.

Asian American users value serious relationships and efficiency. The app’s clean, resume-like profile format and focus on meaningful matches resonate with cultural preferences for clear, goal-oriented dating, leading to strong adoption and trust within this community.

A significant employee turnover in 2018 revealed that her leadership style lacked candid feedback. She shifted to a culture of 'five dissonances'—emphasizing fearlessness in honest dialogue—and implemented training for managers to create safe spaces for open conflict and feedback.

The app began with a small team manually matching friends, who responded positively. This led to user feedback, early interest from investors, and a move to San Francisco. Strategic focus on serious dating, combined with strong product design and user experience, fueled growth and global expansion.

They struggled with balancing growth and profitability, making poor decisions like launching a feature without proper input, which led to employee dissatisfaction and mass resignations. This taught them the importance of listening to teams and prioritizing sustainable, employee-friendly practices.

The app educates users on healthy dating behaviors, such as using better opening messages, and introduces features like auto-chat extensions to encourage ongoing conversations. It also works to reduce ghosting by promoting mutual engagement and better communication habits.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.