The podcast analyzes *Clueless* through the lens of relationship science, drawing parallels to Jane Austen’s *Emma* to explore themes of attraction, matchmaking, and mate value. It highlights how characters like Cher attempt to reshape others—such as Ty—into idealized versions, echoing the Pigmalion effect, where people are molded to fit a preconceived image. Research shows that while initial judgments about desirability are fairly consistent, these agreements fade over time, with true attraction stemming from idiosyncratic, personal compatibility rather than shared traits or popularity. The film correctly illustrates reciprocity as a strong predictor of attraction, especially when a person is seen as uniquely appealing. However, it misrepresents relationships as driven by social hierarchy and desirability rankings, ignoring that compatibility and emotional connection dominate long-term attraction. The movie also contains outdated stereotypes, trivializes sexual norms, and underplays serious social issues, making it a flawed but insightful portrayal. Despite these shortcomings, key scientific concepts—like misattribution of arousal and the role of unique connections—remain effectively illustrated, making *Clueless* a useful, albeit imperfect, teaching tool for understanding romantic dynamics.
Welcome to Love Factually, the podcast that analyzes rom-coms and romantic films using
the science of close relationships.
We're your host Paul Eastwick and Eli Thinkal, Eli.
What are we talking about today?
Today we are talking about Clumus, Amy Heckerling's 1995 high school melodrama starring Alicia Silverstone
and featuring Paul Rudd in his film debut.
Some of the key themes we'll explore are whether similarity promotes attraction, how matchmaking
works, and whether we all agree on who's hot.
And fair warning, we'll be spoiling this movie today, so if you don't want to know whether
a near death experience can help you lose your virginity, go watch the movie and then
come back.
Okay, so Eli, kick it off by telling us who are the key characters and couples in this
movie.
The protagonist is Cher.
She is played by Alicia Silverstone.
She ends up with Josh, her erstwhile stepbrother, who is played by Paul Rudd.
And then Cher's friend, Dion, is dating a guy named Marie.
The actor is best known for playing Dr. Chris Turk on "Sherub."
Yep, that's how I know him.
And then Cher tries to set up her new friend Ty with a popular douche bag, but Ty ends
up with Travis Birkenstock, a lovable burnout.
A less fun aside, Ty is played by Brittany Murphy, Meshie, Reston Pies.
And then finally, the fourth significant couple is Mr. Hall and Ms. Geist.
They are socially hopeless middle-aged teachers for whom Cher successfully plays matchmaker,
where they note Mr. Hall is played by the impencipable guy from the princess brother.
So those are the chess pieces, Paul.
Are you ready to deliver a one-minute summary of how the plot moves those pieces across
the chessboard?
That is right.
Time me.
And I got a couple other guys that are going to make a brief appearance in the plot summary
here.
I'm excited to hear.
On your mark.
Get set.
Go.
All right.
So the three acts of this movie, more or less track, how Cher is relating to three different
men, first is Elton, and then Christian, and then finally Josh.
So to begin, Cher and her best friend, Dion, they do a little matchmaking between Mr.
Hall and Ms. Geist.
And then they adopt a new girl, Ty, into their click, and make her into an air quotes
popular girl.
Okay.
Cher does her best to set Ty up with Elton, but it turns out Elton has a thing for Cher and
is also a piece of shit.
So in part two, Cher works on attracting a new guy, Christian, and that seems to be going
well until it turns out that Christian isn't air quotes available.
That's okay.
He ends up being a good friend.
Okay.
Finally, third section, Ty becomes interested in Josh.
This confession sends Cher into a tale spin as she realizes she is in fact in love with
Josh.
Cher wins Josh over.
Feelings are confessed.
Ty ends up with a skater boy Travis.
Honestly, she should have been with all along.
And pretty much everything I've just said is also Indie Jane Austen novel Emma, from which
this movie is adapted.
Well, 59.26 seconds.
Well done.
Yes.
Okay.
So Eli, tell me about your relationship to this movie.
I don't know.
Like maybe this was huge for you in high school.
I don't know.
You know, I don't remember it from back then.
I mean, I've sort of always been aware of it, but I don't remember the first time I saw
it.
And I actually hadn't seen it many times before I watched it a couple times in advance
of this conversation.
You know, what the movie stood out to me for sort of an idiosyncratic reason, and in
particular, it had to do with this, you know, idea that Cher is trying to turn Ty basically
into Cher's own creation.
Cher has a vision for what Ty should be and then tries to make her that way.
And you may be familiar with George Bernard Shaw's Pig Malion over a century play at this
point.
But the plot there is, you know, a guy named a linguist named Henry Higgins decides it
would be fun to turn Eliza Doe Little, an impoverished and cockney speaking flower girl,
into a high-born lady.
So he's going to teach her for his own amusement, how to speak well and how to act well.
And he says to his mother, you have no idea how frightfully interesting it is to take
a human being and change her into a quite different human being.
Yes.
And the reason why this was so relevant for me is I was in that film.
Well, I was sorry, I wasn't in the film.
I was in the play.
You were in the middle.
I was in 1964 film.
So the play was from 1956, and sorry, the musical based on this was my very lady.
And I was in that.
And I was Colonel Pickering, the guy who places a bed.
No.
Yeah.
Places of Colonel Higgering.
Yeah.
Wow.
And so my view was like, no way.
You'll never succeed in passing her off as like a high-born, you know, basically princess.
And so what was interesting to me is like, I thought, well, having we always known that
it was like a really bad idea to try to create people into some image just for our own entertainment.
And of course, that's what Cher tries to do.
That's what Emma tried to do in the original novel from Jane Austen.
And it seemed like a bad idea at the time.
And I have not seen anything that just waited me from that view.
So you're basically the Dion character.
You're basically sort of playing second in command to that's unbelievable.
Yeah.
I have never experienced the events of this film personally.
And this really wasn't in my personal canon until fairly recently.
But I guess, you know, this movie is spoofing a time that I remember very well.
And I think what's impressive about this movie is how much it, you know, it's satirical,
right?
But it's not mean.
And especially when you're satirizing, you know, the time that is currently happening,
I think that's hard to do all of those things in combination, right?
It's pretty affectionate toward its characters.
No, you're right.
And I really like that about it.
Yeah.
Yeah, she really does.
You know, it's interesting.
I think when when Jane Austen was writing Emma, of course, you know, 1815, over 200 years
ago.
Yeah, 200 years ago.
And again, this movie is a, you know, it's modern, but it is a pretty, you know, pretty
precise spiritual connection to the original.
But when, when Jane Austen was writing Emma, she wrote to a friend and said, I have a protagonist,
and I think I'm the only one who will like her.
And you do get that.
Right.
Yeah.
That's great.
Yeah.
That's exactly.
And that's kind of how this comes across.
Except I think, in the end, we all kind of love Sharon.
Okay.
In the end.
So I think this movie gets a lot of things right when it comes to the science of close relationships.
So it's also funny how what it gets right starts to blend into what it gets wrong too.
So let's start with mate value.
Yep.
So this, a lot of this movie is premised on the idea that there is a hierarchy of desirability.
Right.
A pecking order, if you will, especially in this high school context.
And some people are more desirable than others.
And share goes around, presuming that she can see matches often in the form of equivalent
desirability.
Yeah.
For sure.
That's what she's doing.
Yeah.
And part of the reason she takes on tie as a project is because she thinks this is a girl
I can make hotter and they have set her up with one of the very few acceptable boys at
this school.
Right.
She otherwise would be in danger of getting somebody who is beneath what she should actually
have.
Right.
So I am willing to at least at first put this into what the movie gets right category.
So Eli, you may have heard of something called the social relations model.
You heard of this.
I am a true admirer of Dave Kenny's brilliant work.
Okay.
Very good.
And a lot of these effect sizes, I've gotten help from Dave Kenny talking about these things.
So I swear to God, I'm not full of shit as I'm talking about these numbers.
Okay.
So what the social relations model does is it takes any judgment like I think this person
is hot and it divides it into three pieces.
The three pieces are how I see the world on the person making the hotness judgment.
Okay.
So maybe I think everybody's hot that's sometimes called the perceiver effect.
There's the target effect that is well, everybody agrees this person is hot.
Okay.
And then there's also a relationship effect.
Do I think you are especially hot above and beyond those first two components?
So this second one, the target effect.
This is the one that's really key to shares world view, right?
Because if that second component is really powerful, what it means is that people agree
about who's desirable and who's not right.
Like some people are tense and some people are threes.
And in the science, they call this mate value.
But the social relations model helpfully points out that, you know, hey, this is just one
of three components that explains why we think someone is hot and someone is not, right?
So it's unlikely that agreement is going to be perfect.
So is share right that mate value is a thing that we agree that some people are tense
and some people are threes.
Well, when people first meet, we can put some numbers on this.
So imagine Eli that you and I were at a high school and we had to make some call about
whether this new guy was hot.
Okay.
How, like, what percentage of the time do you think we would agree?
We're just rating hot or not?
New guy arrives.
What are the odds we agree?
So both on the same side of the coin flip.
Yeah.
Exactly.
I think you and I would agree about 75 to 80% of the time about whether somebody is or
is not heart-based.
on a first look. Right. I think that's close to what most people would predict. The actual answer
is lower. It's 63% of the time. Now that is greater than 50/50, right? I mean, it is meaningfully
larger than 50/50, although, yeah, we'd be disagreeing plenty of the time, too. Importantly,
the extent to which we agree that 63% is going to go down precipitously as people get to know
each other. So, after weeks pass, it's actually going to become like 58% agreement. And then if it's
people who've known each other for a long time, it's getting close to a 53%. Now, that is barely
better than 50/50. There's a coin flow. Yeah, exactly. So, I think this movie, you know,
it's working with the idea that there's made value at initial acquaintance. And that's part of how
Cher sees the world. And she's not wrong, at least when Ty has just arrived and people don't
know her yet. But I think where this issue is going to start to blend in to what the movie gets
wrong is that Cher's pretty overconfident that her perceptions are the correct ones. Oh, yeah.
You know, there's like no awareness of this idea that agreement about whether Ty is desirable
or that the popular guys are desirable is going to go down. It was time. So, one of the things I've
wondered, I'm familiar with the research you're talking about. And I've wondered, like, what's the
opposite prediction also plausible? So, as I understand the evidence, and again, this is evidence
from you and Lucy Hunt, I believe, it's that early on, we have some amount of agreement about who's
really appealing. But then as we get to know people better, there's less consensus about who's
appealing. But the other hypothesis have been plausible in advance that as we get to know better,
we discover who's actually appealing. Like, why do you think that isn't what happened?
It's totally fascinating. So, for a long time, people thought that was how it worked when it came
to like learning about somebody's personality traits. This work goes back several decades.
But what it turns out is that agreement stays pretty steady over time when it comes to somebody's,
you know, like, is this person extroverted or not? Right? So observers initially agree that somebody
is extroverted. And then as you get to know people, that same level of agreement is there.
It's far from perfect. But, you know, there's certainly agreement there. And the reason why,
according to Dave Kenny, the gospel known as Dave Kenny, initially people are kind of drawing
based on stereotypes, small snippet, you know, thin slices of information that have some
value to it. And also are misleading too. But again, if everybody's using the same wrong
information, they'll agree. Right. And then those stereotypes gradually get replaced with ground
truth. So that's why it doesn't really shift, right? But it's sort of, it's made up of, it has a
different composition, whether it's earlier or later, but consensus stays the same. And so the
argument that we've made is that when it comes to things like who's desirable and who's not,
ground truth over time, largely is illusory. Some people are desirable at first, but over time,
compatibility, that relationship component starts to matter a whole level.
I would love to keep chatting with you about this mainly because I find it to be such an
optimistic perspective. I love like one is like, well, I don't know, it's like tens. And if you're
with three, well, sucks to be you. And the others like, no, you're probably a 10 for somebody. That's
a very, very appealing possibility. Yeah. I have a couple things too. I'll toss one out here. So
one of the ideas in this movie is that reciprocity matters. That is, if we learn that somebody likes us,
that will increase the odds that we like them. And it's not clear to me whether that is,
you know, one of the core ideas in the movie or just one of the core ideas in shares own head.
But she keeps trying to set people up, including like Mr. Hall and Ms. Geist. And when she does it,
the primary strategy she uses is to say, well, I hear Ms. Geist likes you or actually, I think
I wrote this down. So they only hear the only one with any intelligence. Yeah, that's right. That's
right. Ms. Geist was right about you. And he's like, hmm, any intelligence. And he's like, well,
there's somebody with judgment. He does, in fact, develop the hots for her and vice versa,
develop the hots for Ms. Geist, thank goodness, not for sharing. And that they do end up together.
Now, I will say that share tries something similar with Elton and Ty, and that doesn't go well.
So it's not that thinking somebody is into you is sufficient to overcome the fact that one of
these people is a total douchebag. But it is, in fact, a strong predictor of whether we like
somebody. And in particular, learning that they uniquely like us, not learning like, well,
there's somebody who likes a lot of people, including you, that tends not to be very hot in
the research literature. Yeah. But we've seen, and certainly some of this research goes back
into the 70s, finding out that somebody has judgment and doesn't really dig everybody,
but there's something about you that is, in fact, very, very hot. That's right. And you know,
she says, you're the only one here with any intelligence. It really is making it that unique
component. I will say there are some other things that share does with respect to reciprocity
and her matchmaking that I think would not have gone as well. But that's the one that I think she
got right. The one where she says, you're the only one at this. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You are the one
that appeals to her. Yeah. There it is. Talk to me. Anything else that you saw on there that you
thought we should give credit to the movie for what the movie gets right about the science of
relationships? I think this is the movie sort of makes this point as an aside, but it'll end up
being important when we talk about similarity a little more is that the movie makes it clear that
even within this school, which is clearly extremely wealthy, there are still groups, right? These
groups of different kinds of kids who sort based on their interests, maybe a little bit based
on their personality and that this is the idea that similarity works through a process called
niche construction, right? So you have interests, you have values, you, you know, like being around
certain kinds of people and you will choose to be around those people. And then if you end up
dating people that you meet, it will often come from that same pool. Okay. So I just think that's
important context for thinking about, oh, why do romantic partners end up being similar to each
other? Oh, similarity must promote attraction. Just it's important to keep in mind that many times
that similarity is happening way upstream of when any particular romantic choices are happening.
Yeah. I mean, the major objection that Cher has to tie being attracted to Travis is that he's
like a burnout. He's not one of the popular kids. And therefore is not within the category of people
to be taken seriously as a potential partner. Right. Exactly. Exactly. Before we move on to some,
you know, misconceptions in the movie, I should give credit for one other thing that you referenced
earlier when you were first chatting about what we were talking about today, which is this idea
of misattribution of arousal. Oh, yeah. And Cher says, that's great. Right. Yeah. I mean, it's
perfect how it handles this. In fact, this is a clip that I think both of us show in our own
our own classes. Yeah. So the clip that the the part that you were talking about earlier is
Dion is learning how to drive. And her boyfriend is in the passenger seat and is trying to help her
learn how to drive. And things go very, very badly. And she inadvertently gets on the freeway.
And then there's a massive, massive 18 wheeler right behind them, like literally just a few feet
behind and blaring on the horn. And she is freaking out. And then eventually they find a safe spot.
After that, Dion's virginity went from technical to non-existent.
And it's a fun play on that idea that that, you know, these sorts of, I don't know, scary or near
death experiences can can increase attraction. And you know, this is a research literature that
goes back 50 years. The classic study was in British Columbia in the early 1970s where they
sort of an intriguing study. They studied men who were crossing either a really high, rickety, scary
bridge, or men that were crossing a very low stable bridge that was just a few feet above the water.
And the study had a woman, a female research assistant, ask him, like do a quick interview with
these men as they as they crossed over the bridge. And it included like, he, she asked the men to
tell a story. And then later the researchers coded for like sexual and romantic imagery in the story.
And then she said something to the effect of, well, I don't have the results here, but here's
my phone number if you'd like to learn more about the study. And across all the various measures
they had, what they found is that men who had crossed the high rickety bridge were more sexual
in the content that they expressed to her. And then also more likely to call her, you know,
quote unquote, to hear about the study. And then you might think there's problems with that design.
Maybe it's like really bold, a sort of sexualized man or more likely to use the high bridges,
but at this point there's a lot of
you know, rigorously controlled laboratory experiments that show that when people are
physiologically aroused, that is their heart rate is up and so forth, and then they encounter
somebody who's a little bit attractive, they tend to think that person is more attractive than they
would otherwise because they're experiencing that physiological arousal. Yeah, that's right,
and but I think we want to be clear like you should not actually drive like anybody actually drives
in this movie with the exception of Paul Rodd. That's right. That's really that reasonable
man and the rest of them are chaos inducers. Yes, absolutely absolutely dangerous. All right,
talk to me about what this movie gets wrong. Mate preferences. Here I know that I'm speaking
your language. I don't know if you flagged this one as well, but there's that there's that scene where
tie and deon and share are in a restaurant and an attractive male waiter walks past
share that's out and says survey says and tie says doable, which I sort of remember from the 90s.
That was actually the way we talked about people, I think it's kind of weird. And then deon says
puny, I like him big and share says ew, I hate muscles. And so one of the things that's interesting
is these people certainly deon and share think they have real stable preferences that deon thinks
like I'm going to like the very specific things very specific. Yeah, it's very things like no,
I sort of like the skinnier guys. And it's an open question whether over time they will actually
end up more attracted to man who have those attributes versus not. That's right. I think when you
take single attributes like that in isolation, the extent to which you can expect their you know,
I think we're hearing their stated preferences in that moment. I believe them when they say like
that guy is doable or that guy is not doing that. So those are judgments that people can make,
but when it comes to the abstractions or the extrapolations to I don't like muscular guys or
I don't like puny guys, right? The odds that that stated preference is going to correlate with
somebody's revealed preference, what they would actually prefer across a whole cent of potential
men they might want to date. It will you know, it might be greater than zero, but it's going to be
really not much really small. This is something that the last 20 years of research has really
convinced me of that I did not know in advance. It's one of the things that I think is really
valuable about collecting evidence. I would have just had the assumption that look, you know,
people say they like muscular guys or they like skinny guys than they just do and that if you track
them over time that the people who like the muscular guys are going to be more attracted to the men
who are muscular than the women who say I don't like muscular guys, but those effects tend to be
absolutely tiny mainly because people are so vastly more complicated than any given attribute
in isolation. And so the ability to apply, you know, is this person muscular or not? I mean people
could do that in principle. That's just not how the attraction system works. You end up attracted
to the individual as a whole rather than to some collection of independent features. That's right.
That's right. For me, I think the thing that stands out the most, that the movie gets wrong,
and I think there's a case we made. The movie knows the movie knows what it's playing with here,
but this idea that the way to a stable relationship is through the process of becoming more desirable,
right? The idea of desirability as a project and you improve your standing in the mating market
and that is how you do better. So that is clearly the assumption that share and deon come to and
that, you know, tie goes along with, right? That idea, I think, it really rests on the
the main value consensus stuff. We talked about a few minutes ago that it initial acquaintance
people do agree, but what it misses is that that consensus declines over time. And it also misses
that the lion's share of the variance, the lion's share of what is important when it comes to
who you find desirable, what you find hot is idiosyncratic. It's in that relationship effect
component, right? There's far more disagreement because somebody just uniquely appeals to you
in a way that they wouldn't appeal to me or that they wouldn't appeal to somebody else.
And so when we think about mating as this competitive marketplace that actually forces
people to be operating in a set of mating dynamics, there's really good for some people and
not great for other people. But honestly, that's not the way it really works once people are out there
in the world and especially once they're interacting with each other with each other over time.
It's so fascinating, especially because of how not intuitive it is. So let's say there's
somebody out there listening who thinks, are you joking? Do you really think that if I could drop
20 pounds or if I were four inches taller or if I had a better car, whatever it is, that I wouldn't
be more appealing? It's not that you believe the very strongest version that those things don't
make a difference, right? Exactly. These things do make a difference. Basic like health and hygiene
sorts of stuff are always going to be a good idea. But the majority of why we find some people
appealing versus not has to do with the unique connections we have with other people. And sometimes
I'll just refer to that as compatibility, right? I mean, we understand that concept. We understand
the idea that like, you know, like that's my friend's girlfriend. And like, I think my friend's
awesome. And she seems all right, but I like, I wouldn't want a date. But that's not any kind of
judgment about core desirability or anything like that. And that is how it works most of the time.
So do I have it right that there's a little bit of a sequence thing here that sure, like people
who are like really fit looking and healthy looking more generally, they really do do better,
like by consensus, that is more people will be interested in them, rather than people who are
less fit and less healthy looking, let's say. But that's really something that fades,
that that preference for the person who's objectively fitter is more ephemeral. And really,
once you get to know people, sure, maybe it still matters a tiny bit after you've known people
six months, but very, very little, especially relative to the fact that's like, we laugh a lot
when we're together. That's right. Here's a great example that I'll describe concisely here,
but this is from a data set that tracks people's crushes over time. So you might be romantically
interested in several different people more or less over a period of several months. And what was
also a part of this data set were, you know, a coder's ratings of the attractiveness of the crushes
themselves, right? So if you're a participant in the study, Eli, those are ratings of the person
you might be interested in. And it turns out that after just a few weeks passing of you being,
you know, into some of these women, not so into others, that those coder ratings of the women's
attractiveness had nothing to do with how much you were into them. After just a few weeks,
the correlation was.03, right? So it doesn't take long once things start unfolding. Once you get
into the will, they won't they compose another attractiveness really stops mattering and it all
becomes those idiosyncratic judgments. That's fascinating. So it's like, okay, when you're swiping,
maybe these things matter on a first glance across a bar. Maybe these things matter. But like,
once you've been in a class together for, you know, six weeks, these things become almost irrelevant.
Yeah. Yeah. Fascinating. What else you got here? Well, I mentioned earlier this idea of pigmalion,
the idea that, you know, we often try to sculpt people. I don't know if I would say we often,
certainly share is trying to sculpt people, Emma, from the initial book is trying to sculpt people.
Right. Sort of for their own entertainment value. But there is an alternative form of sculpting,
which, you know, my advisor, Carol Rusbalt, studied and I've studied myself, which is this
idea of the Michelangelo effect. Sure, sure. Tell us about that. And the major difference here is
both of these are situations in which I might contribute to somebody else's development over time,
to changing somebody else. The real difference here is am I changing them in accord with my own
vision that we can call the pigmalion effect or the share effect or am I changing them in a way
that's consistent with their vision? Right. That is the metaphor for the Michelangelo effect is,
as you well know at this point, is that all of us have the sort of unsculpted versions of ourselves,
that is like our actual self, but then, you know, metaphorically within us, we've got the ideal
version of ourselves. They hid in David inside us. And so the question is, are our relationship partners
changing us in ways that make them more like the person they want us to be or helping us in a way
that makes us more like the person we ourselves want to be? And the Michelangelo effect is generally
beneficial for relationship while being in contrast to the pigmalion. And you could argue that,
if Sharon knew about the Michelangelo phenomenon, she would have realized from the beginning of the
movie that Ty was, you know, trying to, you know, that her interests were more closely aligned with
Travis's, right? I mean, she was, you know, clearly interested in drugs from the beginning. Right?
And hanging out with that girl.
Yeah, right. I know. I love that God. I love that because what did she say? She knows she needed an herbal remedy. Yeah, right. A
herbal remedy. Exactly. Right. And so I think share again, I think that's a great, a great observation is she is much more in the
Pignalean. I'm going to make you what I think you need to be rather than the Michelangelo. Let me help you find, you know, your interests, your values, but
become who you want to be. Yeah. How about you? Anything else that the the movie is a misconception about how relationships work? I mean, one thing I think
is is interesting about this movie is how it takes those clicks from high school and layers it on top of what in Emma was social class. Right?
That's a great. Right. So Emma, these characters are operating within these different realms of social class and, you know, you don't want to date down in the market. Right? And so, you know, again, share in the movies, kind of
layering that on top. But I'm a big fan of this paper that came out a couple years ago that do do do if you watch Bridgerton and all of you, Bridgerton guy. I think I think I saw a little bit when my wife was
watching it, but I don't really know the characters. Okay. Okay. Well, I won't get into the characters,
but there's something called the season. Okay. So the season is when Queen Victoria hosts all these
balls and it's a chance for the, you know, children of aristocrats to meet each other, fall in love and
get married and it was a thing in real life and it worked for a long time. Until the 1860s, what happened
was that a Queen Victoria took a few years off of hosting the balls. And what happened was that
the aristocrats kids still wanted to get married and so then they went out and they met more
commoners and guess what? They married the commoners because they're meeting and they're discovering
compatibility and they're finding the idiosyncrasies and they marry the commoners and in a generation,
you have more distribution of wealth throughout Britain. How cool is that? Yeah, natural experiment
in the highest order. Exactly. Exactly. So, you know, the parallel works especially in the sense that
it highlights how unhelpful it is to think about some sort of true value hierarchy the way
there might be an animal. Yeah, social class is a thing and we use it to keep people separated
from each other, but the extent to which it's really related to attraction and relationships is
kind of suspect once people actually get to meet. You're right. One of the things that really worked
about Clueless is, you know, Amy Heckerling's insight that popularity at elite high schools
is kind of like, you know, being, you know, the social class circumstances in early 19th century
England. It does basically work. Yeah, totally. All right. So, I wonder if you have some things
you're wondering if we're okay with in this movie. Right. Yes, it is always interesting to revisit
these things. I had a couple of things that that's, I don't know, I don't want to say stuck in my
crawl, but raised questions for me to agree, you know, we sort of have to let some of the stuff go.
Like, we're going to watch 80s and 90s films. I mean, they all have stuff that that a lot of us
today would look back on and be like, I win some more than once. I win some more. Yeah, I mean,
and this one is not as bad as some, but, but let me, let me put a few things in that bucket. And
then I actually have a bigger bucket. So, so they're like, Oh, God, it's an 80s and 90s film bucket.
So it traffics in stereotypes about sexual orientation. Yeah. And, and has a lot of like
crafts language about it. And of course, the gay guy Christian is like super fashionable. And,
it trivializes unwanted sexual attention. So there's this party game they have literally called
suck and blow, but it's far less hot than that might make it seem. They take a playing card.
And they like sort of put it in there, but they put it next to their mouth. And then they can
suck on it and keep it there. And then they just turn to the person next to them. And then that
person sucks the fate, the card off their first person space. And they're extremely confusing.
It's extremely. Yeah. Yeah. It's the procedure is straightforward. Why they think it's fun
is confusing. Yeah. Right. Right. And then at one point, the douchebag who's into share, he, you
know, whoops, he like the card fell off his face. And he basically like gives her a big wet kiss.
And she's grossed out by it, but it's basically played for laughs. Yeah. Right. And more generally,
like serious social issues, they're largely absent from the film. Like they live in this sort of
phantasia, but, but then there's like even when things come up, like there's a debate in class where share
is trying to argue that the US should take in more people from Haiti due to the, you know, the
dire circumstances and poverty there. And she, you know, it's funny because she doesn't pronounce
Haitians correctly. They're aliens. And she gives. That was true. She actually didn't know how to
pronounce it. Oh, he's a silver stone. And they're like, keep it rolling. Keep it rolling. Not
know that that's funny. And then with the, you know, she, she gives some thing like, well,
America, we should have the resources to do this because like one time I held a dinner party and
people came over who didn't RSVP. And in a way, it's kind of a touching speech about like we,
we have the resources if we want it. But it's certainly like, you know, basically deals with,
with, you know, global oppression and, and, and grinding poverty as like a, as like a laugh line.
That's right. There are a lot of laugh lines in this movie that are, that are that kind of like
cringes like, eh, that haven't aged all that well. Let me, yeah, before it, before I turn it to you,
let me tell you what the big thing was for me because there's all that stuff that just feels like,
you know what, if we're going to watch 80s and 90s movies, we're just going to have to deal.
And I think everything I've talked about now fits into that. But this Fantasia thing,
this like not reality thing that felt so weird coming from 2024 was especially bizarre
with the mugging scene. So there's one point where share gets deserted by Elton in a, you know,
a bad part of town and she gets mugged at gunpoint. And she has no sort of concern about it. There's
no real sort of threat about it. She's really upset that he's going to make her get down on her
belly in the parking lot because she's wearing an alaya dress and he says, uh, what, uh, and it's,
it's just a big joke. But, but he literally has a gun pointed at her head and, you know, she's
making a fuss and being kind of whiny and he says, I will totally shoot you in the head. And it's
around that time that I think she's, maybe it's, she's on the phone with, with Josh and she says,
the evening turned into a royal mess sexually harassed, robbed and it's just a big joke.
I was curious what you thought about. We haven't really talked about Josh much. No. So at the end
of the movie, she ends up with a guy who is her step brother. They've not spent a lot of time
growing up together so they don't see each other as brother and sister. That is her step brother.
And, you know, which I think also tracks, you know, a lot of the Jane Stanere, like, you know,
these people, they are vaguely related to each other. Okay. So she ends up with her step brother.
Also, there's a considerable age difference, right? So he's in college and I think she turns
16 over the course of this movie. And so I was curious if, you know, how we feel about ending up
with a reasonably older step brother, how that struck you. Yeah. I mean, again, it's in this first
category of like, if you're going to watch 80s and 90s movies, you're going to see a lot of this.
I mean, I think you're led to believe that he's about 19 or 20 and she's about 16.
And clearly the movie makers don't think the age thing is a problem.
I think it's exacerbated a little bit because I think that Paul Rudd was 25 and Alicia Silverstone
was 17 and they do look different in age. That's the whole thing. Yeah, they really do. They
really do. That's a big difference. You know, I guess I think the, the, the, like being a step
sibling thing, it doesn't bother me. It's like a little weird that the movie doesn't actually
spend a lot of time commenting on it. It just, it just kind of moves on from that as well. Like,
I mean, it's not really played for laughs that hard. It's just, so just there. Yeah, exactly.
I think, I think in most circumstances, and to be clear, I think there's a lot about the
shared-josh relationship as it unfolds, especially in the last third of the movie, that's really
touching. I mean, they know each other really well. You can see her affection for him growing
over the course of the film. I think all of that's really nice. I think that the, the age difference
in real life would feel bigger than the way they interact on the screen. They really do interact
as equals, but I think the high school college relationship in real life would, would be a more
noticeable difference and would, would rightly be off-putting too many. All right, best relationship
quote. I have one I like quite a bit. Now, this is coming from Ty as she has been, you know, rejected
by Elton. Yeah, you're too good for him. If I'm too good for him, then how come I'm not with him?
And I just think that right there is the essence of the problem. Interesting.
You believe in the hierarchy of made value that you end up in this fundamental quandary, which is,
well, how can I feel better about what has just happened by saying like, oh, actually,
I deserve quotes.
quote unquote, it's like you end up tying yourself into knots as opposed to as opposed to
I'm not saying you got to be zen about it and just be like, well, I guess we're not compatible.
But instead thinking of yourself as not someone else's cup of tea, I'm not again, it's still
going to hurt. It's still going to feel like rejection. But it's less actually confusing. And I just
think Brittany Murphy just nails it there. She did. She did. She was crying and she did a beautiful
job. But you're right. There's something very, very different about saying to ourselves
looks like we weren't a good match versus looks like I'm not as appealing as I thought I was.
That's right. When every rejection is a referendum on your value, this thing sucks.
It's brutal. You don't, this is not, this is, this is one way to look at it.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. All right. What do you got? You know, one thing that I liked is the part
where Christian, the gay boy that that share really likes who turns out to be not interested
in her for reasons that we find out later. You like Billy Holiday? I love him.
And what I like about that is many of our listeners, of course, will be aware that Billy Holiday
is a woman. And this is how we end up feeling like similarity is such an important predictor
of our attraction. Yeah. There it is. Is that we're really interested in somebody. We just
tune ourselves to their frequency. And she's trying to do it. She's just being friendly and look,
it's easy to mock her like, oh, you know, what a fool. How clueless share is that, you know, she
says, I love him when talking about Billy Holiday, but all of us do this. We calibrate ourselves to
the person that we're talking to, especially if we like that person. And then we low and behold,
discover that we had a lot of stuff in common and stuff that we liked about each other.
And one thing that's kind of wild again, this is something that 15, 20 years ago, I wouldn't have
known. Actual similarity is a very small predictor of how much we were attracted to people.
That's a really big predictor of how attracted we are to people is I feel like we had a lot in
common. But of course, you know, share things that she has a lot in common with Christian because
they both love this male named Billy Holiday. So I have one more quote and it's kind of a long one,
but there's some, there are a number of things about it I deeply love. Okay, okay, three is kind
of a Baldwin. What would he want to tie? She could make him happy. Joshy is someone with
imagination. Someone to take care of him. Someone to laugh at his jokes. Okay, so you haven't made, Sunny. And suddenly,
oh my god. I love Josh. I am majorly totally but crazy and love with Josh.
But what I really love about that quote is at the end, the someone to take care of him,
someone to laugh at his jokes in case he ever makes any, right? Again, it's like the same like,
sort of needling affection that the whole movie has. Like she is the kind of making fun of him,
but what she sees as his faults, she also finds endearing at the same time. And there's also a certain
amount of like, you know, I want to care for him. And you know, to some extent, this is happening
in a gendered way, which makes me cringe a little bit. But the reality is that relationships both
sides often work well when people feel, you know, people want to be needed. And she is like all of a
sudden starting to have this realization. And that's the moment where it happens. And I just kind of
think that was a brilliant, you know, it's a funny speech, but it's also secretly a little brilliant.
Yeah, you know, it's interesting. She's an interesting character in this way. And you can understand
why Jane Austen felt about Emma the way she did that she sort of loves this kind of unlovable
character because, you know, Emma, of course, but also share by extension, narcissistic, conceited,
self-indulgent, but also big-hearted, like wanting to do good in the world. And you see right from
the very beginning of the movie that, that share is deeply devoted to her father and to care
exactly. And so that line, that quote that you just shared with us is interesting in the sense
that she seems to have like a category of people that she's going to take care of. And she just
inserted him into that category. That's a great point. Yeah, she made a shift and said, oh,
that category I have, that little category of people I really would do anything for is now bigger
by one. Yeah. Yep. That's great. Yeah. What do we wish we knew, you know, either about the science
or about what's going on behind the scenes of this movie that would, you know, help us to get
more insights here? You know, one thing that's been on my mind a lot over the last couple years,
especially as COVID hit, is like, what are the circumstances under which? An acute stressor
or a longer term stressor makes a relationship better versus worse. Like we have some general
sense in relationship science that stress is linked to negative relationship outcomes. Like we're
a little crankier with each other. Things are not great when we're stressed, but those facts aren't
as big as I would have anticipated them to be. And I haven't really been able to find much
evident that evidence that stress is linked to breakup exactly. And I think that the reason why,
and this is sort of analogous to the distinction between post-traumatic stress and post-traumatic growth,
right? Aren't there some circumstances under which going through something terrifying together,
something upsetting together can bring us closer together? I give this example of course because
Dionne and Murray's highway or highway terror brought them together. But the more general question of like,
when is it that going through something difficult together breaks us apart versus brings us together,
right? I feel like we don't know as much about that as I wish we did. I wanted to know more about,
you know, what is it that makes a good matchmaker? What makes a person a good matchmaker? There's
not much research on this. There is just a bring back Dave Canney one more time. He's got a study,
it's about 30 years old, where people try to judge unacquainted people how much they like each
other. And people have a lot of confidence that they're doing it pretty well. And they're trying
to use similarity to do it. But low and be all their judges or judgments are pretty much a chance,
right? So people aren't actually good at it, right? So if I'm watching two people and I'm like,
oh, they really dig each other, I'm basically flipping a coin in that as well. Your ability to judge
their unique interest in each other, right? So I think that's what he's able to do is how much
are you picking up on how much these two people uniquely like each other, right? Which is, I mean,
it's opposed to like, who's popular, right? I mean, you can see who's popular, right? But what
she's trying to do, she's trying to create matches, right? I mean, that's what she does with the
two teachers, right? It's like, oh, you too, I bet I can get you to be uniquely interested in
each other. And so, okay, people aren't great at doing it from initial acquaintance, but you know,
some people in their lives do bring people together and some people don't. And I just want to know more
about who are the people that are successful at doing that? You know, probably extroverts,
probably people with large social networks, but I actually don't know if we have a lot of good work
on that. I bet it's like invite people out in groups. That's, that's a, I bet you're right, that's
a ball. How good is this movie? Like, just as a movie, one to five stars, how do you feel about
this movie? I feel bad for saying it out loud. This is a two-star movie. Oh, no, I'm just saying,
you're not stating. I'm not into this movie. I know that it is well loved. My daughter is crazy
about it. Yeah, just didn't really do it for me. Oh, the hater. I give this four stars. I think
this is a very good movie. I think it's an excellent example of the genre. It is far from perfect.
It's got the cringe moments that have an age well, but four stars I'm going overall. But the
real question, of course, is how many rustballs you give this movie? Now, the rustball is named after
Eli's advisor, the late great Carol Rustbold, who's a pioneer of close relationship research,
with five stars indicating near perfect depiction of the nature of close relationships. So,
here, I'll go first. I give this movie three rustballs. It got a lot of things right about attraction.
Got some things wrong about attraction too. Also, we don't really see anything in the way of
what an established relationship looks like, other than what you articulated earlier about her,
sort of, you know, bringing the people that Cher cares about into her circle. But really,
there's not much in here about ongoing relationships. And so, I've got a hard cap. I can't go higher
than three stars, given that it gets some things wrong, and given that it doesn't show us anything
really about ongoing relationships. I also gave it three rustballs. I think there's a lot of
insight here.
and it's a playful way to illustrate some of the ideas.
As I mentioned, that scene between Dion and Murray,
it's one that I show in class
'cause it's such a good illustration
of the, you know, misattribution of a rousal.
So I think there's a lot of stuff that it does well.
You and I do have some of the concerns
that we've voiced here.
So re-rust bolts for the win.
- All right.
Well, thank you everybody.
That's all we have for today.
This is the Love Factory podcast.
I'm Paul Eastwick and Eli, we will see you next time.
I look forward to it.
(upbeat music)
The Love Factory podcast is produced
and edited by Paul Eastwick and Eli Finkel,
featuring music from Andrew Fraker Insides.
(upbeat music)
[BLANK_AUDIO]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The movie *Clueless* draws on Jane Austen’s *Emma* to explore matchmaking, attraction, and mate value, highlighting how initial judgments about desirability are influenced by social perceptions.
The film portrays a hierarchy of desirability, with characters like Cher trying to elevate others—such as Ty—to fit a predefined ideal, reflecting the "Pigmalion effect" where people are reshaped to match a desired image.
Research shows that while people initially agree on who is attractive (around 63% agreement), this consensus declines over time, and individual, idiosyncratic connections (compatibility) become more influential than broad preferences.
Reciprocity—learning that someone likes you—strongly predicts attraction, especially when it's framed as a unique, personal connection ("you’re the only one with any intelligence"), not just general interest.
The film inaccurately assumes that improving desirability through appearance or social status leads to stable relationships, overlooking that attraction is largely driven by unique emotional and relational compatibility.
It satirizes social class and popularity, yet reduces complex social dynamics to stereotypes, including misrepresentations of sexuality and social issues.
The ending of Cher’s relationship with her stepbrother Josh reflects real-life concerns about age differences and familial boundaries, which are underexplored and potentially problematic in modern contexts.
Despite its flaws, the film effectively illustrates key relationship science concepts, such as misattribution of arousal and the role of shared values, making it a valuable educational tool despite its outdated and cringey elements.
Summary:
The podcast analyzes *Clueless* through the lens of relationship science, drawing parallels to Jane Austen’s *Emma* to explore themes of attraction, matchmaking, and mate value. It highlights how characters like Cher attempt to reshape others—such as Ty—into idealized versions, echoing the Pigmalion effect, where people are molded to fit a preconceived image. Research shows that while initial judgments about desirability are fairly consistent, these agreements fade over time, with true attraction stemming from idiosyncratic, personal compatibility rather than shared traits or popularity.
The film correctly illustrates reciprocity as a strong predictor of attraction, especially when a person is seen as uniquely appealing. However, it misrepresents relationships as driven by social hierarchy and desirability rankings, ignoring that compatibility and emotional connection dominate long-term attraction. The movie also contains outdated stereotypes, trivializes sexual norms, and underplays serious social issues, making it a flawed but insightful portrayal.
Despite these shortcomings, key scientific concepts—like misattribution of arousal and the role of unique connections—remain effectively illustrated, making *Clueless* a useful, albeit imperfect, teaching tool for understanding romantic dynamics.
FAQs
The main characters are Cher (played by Alicia Silverstone), her friend Dion, and her new friend Ty. Cher ends up with Josh, her stepbrother played by Paul Rudd. Dion dates a guy named Christian, and Ty ends up with Travis, a lovable burnout. Mr. Hall and Ms. Geist, two socially awkward teachers, also form a couple after Cher helps them connect.
The movie suggests a hierarchy of desirability based on popularity and social status, reflecting the idea that some people are seen as more attractive than others. However, research shows that initial agreement about desirability declines over time, and true attraction is more influenced by unique, personal connections than by broad social categories.
No, the film overemphasizes initial judgments of desirability and assumes that people will end up with others based on social status or popularity. In reality, attraction becomes more based on personal compatibility and unique connections as people get to know each other over time.
The Pigmalion effect refers to the idea that when someone is shaped or influenced by another person’s expectations, they may change to fit those expectations. In Clueless, Cher tries to mold Ty into a 'popular' girl, showing a classic example of this effect, which is often seen as harmful because it ignores individual authenticity.
The Michelangelo effect is when a partner helps you grow in ways that align with your own values and goals, rather than changing you into someone you’re told to be. Unlike the Pigmalion effect, which is about shaping someone to fit a mold, the Michelangelo effect supports personal development and is generally more beneficial for relationships.
The movie shows that when someone expresses interest in you, it increases your attraction to them. This is seen in characters like Mr. Hall and Ms. Geist, who develop feelings after getting positive feedback from Cher. Research supports that unique, individualized interest is more impactful than general approval.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.