Chris and Kyle – Biblical Archaeology Rising (Part 2)
from Biblical World
1h 32s
The history of biblical archaeology reveals a complex evolution shaped by competing scholarly approaches. Early thinkers like Melvin Grove and Friedrich Dalisch promoted the idea that Mesopotamian texts predate the Bible, while others like Albright initially embraced this view before shifting to use archaeology as a tool for historical investigation. George Ernest Wright helped define the field by linking archaeological findings to theological understanding, emphasizing that the physical remains of ancient Israel reflect the lived experience of its people. Over time, the field moved beyond simplistic claims of biblical accuracy, influenced by the rise of processual and post-processual archaeology, which stressed social complexity and context. Scholars like Bill Dever pushed for a separation between text and archaeology, leading to new questions about ancient Israelite society, yet both fields remained interconnected due to shared data and methods. Israeli archaeology, in particular, developed a regional, historically grounded approach that now incorporates broader anthropological insights. Despite debates over method and purpose, the core of biblical archaeology remains a dialogue between material evidence and textual tradition. Modern practice recognizes that archaeology doesn't provide definitive "proof" of biblical claims, but offers valuable context for interpretation. The field continues to evolve, driven by new discoveries, methodological advances, and a growing awareness that both texts and artifacts must be interpreted thoughtfully and critically. Ultimately, biblical archaeology is not about proving the Bible, but about understanding ancient cultures through a balanced, nuanced, and respectful engagement with both material and textual sources.
Welcome to Onscript's Biblical World, a podcast exploring the history, archaeology, geography,
and cultures of the Bible.
Visit us at onscript.study/biblicalworld.
Hey, everyone.
Welcome back to the Biblical World Podcast.
We have part two of our history of Biblical archaeology here.
Hope you enjoy it.
Thanks for listening.
Yeah, and really again, the approaches, or I should say, the divisions that start to show
are pretty clear.
I already mentioned some people wanted to basically use the archaeology to prove the Bible.
Melvin Grove Kyle was probably the most active American scholar that was most explicit about
that.
Then you have what we could call the kind of pan-Babylonianist scholars.
And these are scholars that we're looking at all the records coming out of Mesopotamia
and once Kineiformors was deciphered, they could read these and say, "Oh my goodness,
all this literature is exactly like the Biblical text, and it's a lot older.
Therefore, everything we know from the Bible is actually just a pale, late comparison to
that's basically just copying what was earlier Mesopotamian culture.
And the guy who really kind of kicked things off with this kind of framework, if you will,
is Friedrich Dalisch, who really pushed this agenda and created a bit of a rift.
And you had then scholars that either were very of the same accord and saying, "Yeah, everything
from Mesopotamia and/or even sometimes Egypt is earlier older, better than the Biblical
texts and forget all that Biblical stuff.
It's just late copies."
And then you have scholars that are trying to react to that, largely with other textual
sources, but sometimes the archaeology.
So that would be people like David Luckenbil, who was at the University of Chicago, was a
serialologist, and you have then any number of people within a spectrum under that.
So Albright himself, interestingly enough, didn't start as some raging Christian fundamentalist
to come out and prove the Biblical text.
He actually was a pan Babylonianist.
He was really influenced by this literature and said, "Well, it looks like it's older.
The Bible must have been later and all this."
But as higher text criticism was kind of evolving in Europe and reaches its culmination,
if you will, with Julius Velhausen's history of Israelite traditions or whatever the actual
name of the book is in the 1880s, this essentially serves as a bit of a shift for Albright because
there is, or he has questions about the text critical method that he's not happy with
how they're dealing with things and realizes that actually some of the pan Babylonian
claims have gone too far and aren't even supported by the data.
So he turns to archeology to say, "Well, can we address these questions of history in a
better way?
Can we use the archeology to articulate this?"
This ultimately leads him to be very positivist in the use of archeology for addressing issues
of historicity in the Biblical text.
Now, all along the while, you're discovering texts that Newsy, Ugarit, Mari, Boazkoi,
and then ultimately, later on, Amar, and so scholars from both sides of this argument
have all this fodder to try and fit biblical characters within the broader, near-eastern
context, kind of culturally speaking, historically speaking, and it doesn't really lead to any
solid conclusions one way or the other, which then fuels archeologists to come dig more
and to try and find more and to try and show that the archeology is, in particular, well,
I should say, is supportive of illustrating the biblical text and of illustrating the
culture and the reality of that time, then there are those that would go the step further
in saying and proving the accuracy of that text.
Yeah, I think what you're saying here is so important, especially for why this topic
is important, is because by means of analogy, we live in a political time, a very heated
political time here in the good U.S. of A, in which, in some sense, politics are always
heated, but it's easy to not really know what you're talking about or why you're fighting
and you're just sort of born into an environment and kind of come up with it and you're like,
well, I'm Democrat, or I'm Republican, I'm a Democrat, but then you talk to the people
that are older that fought and experienced things that made them a certain way, whether
that's listening to right-wing or left-wing talk radio, and then you look at those points
in time and what they're actually talking about and you're like, huh?
Actually, there has no relevance or very little relevance in terms of where politics
are at today.
It was just the steps by which we got to where we are now, and so, like, just as kind
of like a retrospective, if you look at where all bricked alt and all bright, and these
others were like, why would they fight like aharonian and Yadin are like, they're really
close.
You know, and it's just, I think that is exactly why it's helpful, and it can both show
you the similarities of where people were compared to who they are now, but also where
there really are, you know, supreme differences in method, you can really amplify them.
And this is exactly why it's so important to know kind of where you came from, so you
don't make, you know, you don't fight the battle that's unnecessary, and I think that's
a lesson not only for archeology, but for modern politics, because knowing what the basis
of this claim is and, you know, treating sports like politics and politics like sports
or even politics within the academy is never a good idea.
You need to really be educated with how these things have been fought, and so, again,
I think that that's what is such a powerful thing of seeing what the motivating factors
are, and how that shifting attention really, really changed things.
Yeah.
Exactly.
I think that's great.
Because again, you're just perfectly leading into the next thing I want to say.
It's like we've done this before or something.
I know.
Gosh.
What, you know, what I wanted to go next with this was this is exactly, you know, the big
beef that's going to develop between American archeologists and German tech scholars.
American archeologists are going to come with this background of, you know, out of a Protestant,
you know, traditional Protestant framework that the biblical text is accurate or has historically
accurate details.
And we can evaluate that via the archeology, whereas in Germany, with the rise of liberal
Protestantism and the attempt to kind of get behind the final text, if you will, looking
at the traditions that are there or the evolution of the text and how it got there.
So scholars like Albrecht Alt and Martin Note, they're not interested so much in the
final form of the text and then trying to illuminate that via the archeology, like an
Albrecht and his student, Giannis Wright, are they're looking at the traditions that
precede that final stage and trying to say, okay, what, how did we get to the final text
and then how do inscriptions, illustrations also illuminate these earlier stages?
Can the archeology shed light on these earlier stages?
And so it's a completely different framework, a different approach of how you're coming
to the same kind of question and the way you're using the resources that are available.
So you know, German biblical scholars will have this negative kind of perception or there's
a negative perception that they don't use the archeology.
Well, they do to a certain degree, but they're using in a different way than, say, American
scholars are using the archeology because of their, you know, take the step back, the
perceived preconceived notions that are underlying their approach and the kind of questions that
they're asking.
Yeah.
I mean, and just some examples of this, you know, that we can throw out are especially associated
with what you're saying earlier, is the historicity of the Hebrew Bible, putting together the
Hebrew Bible, document, or hypothesis in the next iteration, especially, you know, the
Deuteronomistic history.
And so, you know, this is exactly, you know, the area that I studied a bit of in my dissertation
and dealing with like the townlists, for instance, in Joshua, you know, for, for, you know,
Albrecht, Alt and others, they have to be, you know, dated to the time of Josiah because
this fits in with the wider perspective of when we can have writing and when such a time
period would fit.
And so, that's an exact example of ultimately what the aim of reading Joshua 15 is to know
what it's ancient setting was as opposed to how does it fit within the canonical text
of the book of Joshua.
And I mean, today, I think, and maybe even then, both are important, right?
Yeah.
And this is going to lead then to the next, an argumentative stage in biblical archeology,
if you will.
And this is the use of the biblical theological movement.
And the question within the church, then as we move into the, the early and ultimately
the mid-20th century is, what is the relevance of the Old Testament for the church?
You know, why not just do the New Testament?
You know, we can illuminate what it meant to these ancient cultures via all these inscriptions
that have been being discovered for the last 80 years and great, that's fantastic to
understand what it meant to maybe the original authors and shed light on that and articulate
maybe traditions that are underlying the text, but what does the church do with that?
And then you have archeologists coming.
coming in and saying, well, that's a good question.
What does the church do with the text
and what role does archeology have there?
All right, never necessarily delved too much into this topic.
He had his preconceived notions and kind of ran with him
and they evolved over time,
but he was always considered himself an orientalist
and always wanted to do more of the historical investigation
and evaluation, wasn't so much about proving the Bible for him.
But his student, George Ernest Wright,
came along and he was a theologian, then an archeologist.
And he was definitely more in tune with questions
facing the church, if you will.
And wanted to see in what ways can archeology bridge this gap?
Can it bridge the gap?
And here George Ernest Wright, more so even than all Wright,
is the one who really pushed the term biblical archeology
and set the agenda for what we think of
when we think of biblical archeology today,
of using archeology in the lands of the Bible
to illuminate the biblical text.
I mean, that could be one possible definition
of what biblical archeology does,
particularly at this time and period in history.
And Wright gave a clear definition of what he thought it was
back in the 1940s and then went out and tried to do that
through his excavations.
And for him, it was a very interesting connection
that, all right, if the Bible is this document
that is kind of inspired and gives us revelation of God,
then the Bible is something that unfolded
in a historical place.
And so if we investigate that place
or the remains of that place, it's going to shed light
on actually who God is or who the people chosen by God are.
And there's a direct link between the theology
that arises out of that, the physical kind of settings
that are left behind because of that theological experience
and the textual representation of that.
And so Wright tries to bridge archeology
and the biblical theological movement
to say, all right, we're articulating what people understood
back then.
We're also trying to show how it's meaningful
for the church in particular today.
One question for you or a task,
can you define Orientalist for our audience?
- Oh, yeah, so I would say that an Orientalist
is like a jack of all trades.
And if you look at Albright, if you read about his life,
there's a couple different biographies out there about him.
Here's a guy who could read every ancient language
in the Near East that you threw at him.
He'd pick it up, learn it.
He knew every modern language.
He knew something like 20 languages fluently.
Could speak them, read them, write them.
And he knew the archeology, he's, in fact,
the one who established the ceramic typology
that we have utilized for the last 100 years.
And we've always been refining,
but he's the one who really took the principles
that Petri and Bliss established at Tel Hesse
and connected that and made it really an articulated
evolutionary feature, if you will.
And so he's a guy that's got his fingers in everything.
And so that's how I would define an Orientalist
is someone who does the text, does the archeology,
is writing about historical geography as well
and can navigate all the other modern research languages as well.
- So thanks.
And I was just gonna just add two points to that.
One is both of us agree that even though
that's impossible to be Albright today,
it's a worthy pursuit.
And I think that not that he doesn't have his words,
but the pursuit of knowledge that's both broad
and deep is the way to borrow from the Mandalorian.
And the other point I wanted to make is just an observation
that both terms Oriental or Orientalist
and biblical archeology despite having the nuance
of perspective in Albright both have fallen in some sense.
The right starts the biblical archeologist, Albright.
I think we talked about this in class earlier this semester.
He writes the first article, which is what are Cherubim?
Which is a great first article and it's funny
because it's exactly the kind of thing that you would expect.
And he has a great response.
He points to the high room of Bob Biblos sarcophagus
and these different things and has the little baby fat,
fat baby angels from the Sistine Chapel.
So it's, but just just a point.
I mean, the school that Albright started,
which was called the American Schools of Oriental Research,
it's still sort of called that,
but it's now the Oriental is gone.
It's the American Schools of Overseas Research,
still ASOR, and the biblical archeologist even before
the dawn of the 20th century changed its name
to Near Eastern Archaeology.
So just as kind of an observation of how even
what might be a different nuance within these two
different features, how names are reflective,
terms are reflective of the time.
And I would say one other thing.
I think, you know, and as we're going with Georgia,
it's right, but just to kind of like show my cards,
if you will, I think in some sense,
right is on the right track to some extent,
but in the sense that he wants to imbue
what he's doing with meaning.
And if you are a person of faith and an archeologist,
the question is, do you keep those in separate cupboards?
Are you dividing these up?
And I think at least to me,
the way that he suggests is a bit too narrow.
It's not that, you know, the particular archeology
that you do in the land of Israel,
or these different parts of what's called,
quote unquote, the book archeology,
is somehow more sacred than other types of archeology.
It's no, it's actually that all human culture
and material remains are of value.
And if you believe in a creator,
all culture has touchstones with who God is.
And, you know, to Baro Paul, you know,
you've been grasping until now on Mars Hill, he says,
but what you proclaim unknown, I proclaim to you known.
And so I think in that sense, everything is enchanted,
everything is meaningful.
When we deal with the archeology of the past
and archeologists are servants
and excavating that material and presenting it to people as well.
And so I just, I mean, I know we're going back and forth
between modern and now, modern and in these different periods.
But I think this is exactly why this article is important
is it's a reflection on a linear progression
that has these different divergences.
But it's also like, what have we gained and what have we lost
and what, how can we put it back together again in the present?
And so at least for me, thinking about right
and what you just described there, he's onto something,
but you can take it a different direction
and still have what I think is a very sophisticated approach
while also allowing for the divine spark,
the image of God in all cultures,
not just the ones that were in the land of Israel.
- Yeah, and I think broadening up,
I would agree with you.
I think we have very much the same kind of framework.
And this is one of the areas where Wright was really
criticized by theologians is that there is this specific idea
that because Israel had this experience
with Yahweh, with God, that was unique,
they somehow should have a unique fingerprint
in the archeological record because of this.
And when we find that material,
it's just objective data that we can use
to combat the subjectivity of biblical criticism,
which is all based on ideas and texts
that we don't have actual tangible evidence forwards,
layers within text that you're looking at language
to try and articulate.
And so in many regards, this is the shortcoming
of Wright's whole approach that ultimately,
I think he does start to realize
and steps back a little bit from,
particularly as he gets into his later years
and evolutions in world archeology are taking place
and he recognizes that, oh, there are other questions
or we have to actually look at this material we're finding.
And it doesn't just shout at us when we dig it out of the ground,
like, hey, look at me, here I am, this is what I mean.
I've never had a pot do that myself.
Not yet, who knows, maybe someday.
But you have to ask questions of that material
and depending on the types of questions you ask,
that's where you're gonna come up
with different answers.
So the material itself is still kind of this objective record
of the past, but you can ask different questions of it
that will give you potentially different informed
or less informed answers.
And so this is the challenge of looking at GE Wright
and his scholarship is how he shifts over time
and kind of comes to this realization
and pulls biblical archeology, which has become really romanticized
if we will in the public opinion through the work of Albright
and through Wright's early work.
As he steps back, it keeps going.
It keeps going in the public imagination
along those lines that the archeology can be used
to find all these things and it can be used in particular
for many Christians in the U.S. to prove the Bible
and all these things and that.
I think it's still with us today.
You talk to people out there like,
"Oh, what do you do?
Ibuquarianicologist."
You prove the Bible, or you find dinosaurs?
- No, I don't do either of those things.
Yeah, number one, the dinosaurs ate all the proof anyways.
- That's right.
- But it's a perspective, though,
that remains out there.
And it's understandable because of just the history
of the field and how it was,
it tapped into this desire of the people
to know what the biblical text are to,
have some knowledge of something.
And in that regard, right, really was onto it,
as you were saying, he's asking bigger questions
and trying to see the relevance that it's there.
How, where is the place for that today
and how do we do it differently
so that it is more balanced, perhaps,
in what we're trying to do
or the way that we're presenting it?
- Yeah, and that's where we're really getting at is,
I mean, you can become so nuanced
that you're not saying anything of meaning,
but I think that when we're talking about this,
you just feel when you talk about the history of archaeology
whiplashed because you see,
okay, clearly this is a bad idea and here's why.
And so we're gonna go the opposite direction.
And then in going the opposite direction
with this tug and pull tug of war game,
you end up with these vacuums of meaning,
these vacuums of, well, this is an area
that you've pulled it so far this way that, okay,
like, well, why are we doing this anyway?
I mean, is biblical archaeology not about the Bible at all,
is biblical archaeology since it can't prove
the Bible true, why are we doing it anyway?
What's the deal?
And then there's no theological aspect,
there's nothing meaningful.
And then not to mention, and this is something that I think
was a key factor and still a key factor today is,
if it's not about stuff that people care about
that are going to support archaeology
through universities or for public giving
or governmental funds, like how do you reach those people?
How do you get people invested?
And so this is why it's not only important to notice
why we do what we do, but to make biblical archaeology
understandable and understand that people understand
why it is that it's so important.
And so you can go down these paths of,
well, it gives you these tools, these weapons
that you can use against the liberal media
or the liberal European continental scholars.
And that you're absolutely right is still around with us today.
If you do an Amazon search for biblical archaeology,
the first 50 books you'll probably find
are apologetic books.
And I'm not gonna completely criticize them,
but that is not what archaeology is for.
I mean, archaeology is not a weapon to be wielded
by an apologist to slay the dragon of liberalism.
It's just not trying to do that.
It's not what it's been for now.
On the other hand, it also has this kind of like soft
apologetic because look, as I always tell students
when they ask me, the world of ancient Israel
as defined by archaeology matches very closely
with what we see in the biblical text.
And of course you have to talk about specifics of each one,
but it's not like the minimalists
who I know will get to eventually,
who simply say it's totally disconnected,
that you don't need to look at material culture.
It's not true, even the most left-leaning scholars
who are active in the field acknowledge
that there is a historical background
to the material culture that you see in the text.
Yeah, this is something that right did a try to articulate.
I don't know if he probably could have done it better perhaps
or more vociferously, but he does all of me come to the place
where he says, you know, I, or the goal of biblical archaeology
is the search for truth, not proof.
And there's a big distinction there.
And because as more and more excavations were being done,
the realization that you had to ask the right questions also
meant that you could interpret the material differently.
And as you got more and more material,
it might change your reconstruction of a given site.
And so the things that you might be interested in,
the proofs, well, the Bible will have certain proof claims,
but how do you evaluate those archaeologically?
And right, I think ultimately realizes
that there are those biblical truth claims
that you just don't have archaeological proof for.
So we need to find archaeological truths
based on the material culture that we're getting out of the ground
to then try and paint the picture as best we can.
And there's a divide that's taking place.
So the kind of whole biblical archaeology paradigm
is based on this not only positivist assumption,
but the idea that the material culture is objective.
And the flip side to that is coming out of early Israeli,
but early British work in particular.
So Kathleen Kenyon comes on the scene of the 1930s at Samaria,
then we'll excavate Jericho in the 1950s
and drew some of the 1960s.
And she still views things kind of from a biblical lens,
but has a different take on it.
And it's far more interested in the historical type of questions
and reconstructs the evidence
that all right and right are excavating in a different way.
And says you can't be so definitive to say
that this destruction layer at, say, Talbate Mirasome
was destroyed by the Israelites.
Like it could have been destroyed by another group.
It could have been, it also depends on when you date
the actual arrival of the Israelites in Canaan.
It depends on when you date the Exodus.
And this is understood as kind of an attack on biblical archaeology
that this kind of very clear, forthright,
we find the material, it shows the Bible,
and we can tie it into these major events.
Really is a far more nuanced type of investigative process.
And Kenyon brings that out.
And it's not well received in many American circles
and it's, oh, we're under attack.
We've got to do even more here.
And yet, right starts to soften in the midst of this
and says, okay, let's take the best
and let's develop the field methodology
and let's think about asking the right kinds of question
of the data and see what we do with that.
And we have to keep in mind that also at this time,
you have the formation of the modern state of Israel
beginning in 1948.
So a year before you've got the discovery
of the dead sea scrolls, you've got, you know,
you had kind of Jewish scholars
that were doing archaeology from the early 20th century,
but now they are more legitimized.
If you will.
So the rise of Israeli kind of biblical archaeology
is taking place largely in the shadow
and very closely connected to American biblical archaeology,
but is distinct from a British excavation technology
or British excavation focus, shall we say.
And, you know, the kind of pickup
then of Israeli biblical archaeology,
even though it wasn't religious per se
in the same way that most kind of Protestant American
biblical archaeology was still was very closely connected
to the biblical text.
In fact, Shlomo Buenomovic and Zvi Letterman
who've written about kind of the Israeli perspective
and the evolution of Israeli archaeology
have said that basically it was a secular endeavor
yet existentially and emotionally tied to the Bible.
That's a quote, which I think is a fantastic quote there
that captures it and it was all kind of framed by one guy,
Miguel Yodin, who was essentially kind of the same kind
of cut as Albright, where you wouldn't necessarily call them
overtly religious.
I mean, Yodin even less so than Albright.
You wouldn't call them religious,
but they were very positive on the biblical text
and positive on how the archaeology could be used
to illustrate the biblical text.
- Yeah, I would just take a quick step back and say,
so what you're saying then is in some sense,
the historical, what we call classic archaeology,
not classical, but the pursuit from the 1870s,
up through the 1960s, even though there's a diversity
of voices there with George Ernest Wright
and Albright and Petri and so on.
Kenyan sits at a transitionary phase,
but she's still very much part of that classificatory.
They're trying to classify, they're trying to date,
that's the focal point.
But then as we move into those heyday,
those really important 19 years between 1940 and 1967,
that's between the War of Independence
and from Israel's perspective and the Six Day War,
there is a massive transition that happens
and you see the beginning of something
that is distinctive that still has an impact
until today with Israeli biblical archaeology.
But you know, when we talk about this though,
I don't wanna say on a hesitate,
but like if you look at like world archaeology
and of course we both taught this before
and one of the things that is sort of,
I don't wanna say praised or triumph is native archaeology.
That is, you know, it's good that different cultures
who are underrepresented or maybe they were impacted
by colonialism or whatever the case may be,
it's good that they own their heritage,
it's good that they buy into it
and that they participate in the archaeology.
And it's fascinating, you see, well, that's,
sort of what Israel's done since the beginning. And the question is today is that a positive or
negative or, you know, not, you know, on the spectrum of what's right or wrong. And it's just funny
kind of how the narrative shifts on that. Whereas, let's say we can talk about someplace as very
little excavation in Australia or something. And I don't know as much about that. But there it's
championed as, okay, they're turning colonialism on its head. Whereas here it's not quite up to
par in some certain circles. So I'm just making more of an observation of not only that we need to
compare, you know, different periods and different developments and be fair to those developments.
But we also need to see that in the case of Israel, they become a major center for archaeology.
It's not just that they're interested in it like you're saying, but almost all of the major
excavations that happen related to biblical archaeology from 1948 on happen by Israel and
many of them by Israeli archaeologists. Yeah, no, it's a great point. And I think it's an important
one to keep in mind because biblical archaeology, this American endeavor does have even though it
wasn't imperialist in the same sense that's, you know, early German and French and British exploration
was definitely kind of carries that cultural imperialism with it. And so when Israel becomes a state,
when you have the creation of the other kind of Arab states following World War One as well,
there is this attempt by every local group to kind of claim their spot and to claim their heritage.
And over time, you're going to see the kind of the rise of, yeah, what some scholars have called
native archaeology. And this creates a pressure on biblical archaeology, which is greatly exacerbated
in the 1960s when Bill Dever comes on the scene and says, why are we doing biblical archaeology?
Let's not be beholden to the text. Let's do syropalistinian archaeology, which is far more kind of
world archaeology base anthropologically informed. We're not, we don't care about text critical
issues or even the history of the text. We're asking archaeological and anthropological questions.
And let's dissociate the two texts in the archaeology. Bye-bye. You guys are no longer friends.
And that coupled with the rise in local, you know, countries, nationalism as well is going to be
one of the big downfalls in the kind of biblical par- a biblical archaeology paradigm that
all bright and bright have been kind of fostering because in their mind, everything in the Near East
is connected to the Bible. You can be this orientalist and read all these different things. It
doesn't matter if you focus on the archaeology of of Syria or Mari, it's all connected in an
informative for filling out the picture of of the biblical text, which is ultimately the,
you know, the one text that holds, holds sway and has power over a living, you know, breathing
generation today. Yeah, and so this would be then finally the moment that biblical archaeology becomes
part of the processional movement towards a wider world of archaeology, which in some sense is
it's already lagging behind by that point. Yeah, so yeah, when in the 1960s, so we have the
development of what's called the new archaeology within world archaeology or processional archaeology,
where scholars have been growingly dissatisfied with the culture, historical approach of archaeology
that had been the norm for the last 120 years or so, where, you know, you can identify specific
cultures, everything happens kind of via diffusion and you're kind of creating this evolutionary framework
and articulating, you know, the specifics, you're figuring out when, how old something was and how it
relates to everything else. That's been the general approach. The new archaeology comes along and says,
let's ask different kinds of questions. Let's look at the process of how change actually happens.
And let's think about all the different types of systems, if you will, that are out there that are
interacting together to bring this change about. So if something happens in the political realm,
that actually is probably going to be connected to changes in the religious realm. It's going to be
changed, connected to changes in the economic realm. It's going to be connected to changes in
the social realm. And it's this interconnected network of components and you can investigate
each of these, ask different questions and then try to piece out and articulate these big narratives
of kind of generalized human social evolution and progression, if you will. And so when this
approach comes to biblical archaeology, which ironically it was introduced by George Ernest
Wright at his excavation in Shackham at the very end of it, it was then fully implemented by Bill
Dever when he started the first kind of big American excavation in the modern state of Israel
at Gezzar in the 1960s. It was a whole new framework for doing excavations. And so the kind of
culture history approach largely continued with Israelian excavations even into the 1980s,
the American excavations in the late 60s and 70s were starting to take this more comprehensive
approach and break the text from the archaeology and look at it more anthropologically.
Yeah, and I'm just going to make one quick comment and to say this is what we're seeing in terms of
the field pushing forward and what we're seeing in journals and journal names being changed, societies
being started or re-changed. But actually the funny thing is a lot of the, what counts in archaeology
is of course the primary publication, the final publication, those actually lag so that you end
up having kind of the traditional archaeology publication of place like Shackham and others
not come out so much later when we've already moved into kind of different phases of archaeological
interpretation. And so that's why it's not only important to kind of know where the field has
is going but like once you interact like if you're, if you're starting your dissertation and you
want to study a bit more, like you have to know that this was excavated this way. Like if you pick up
you know, Albright's volume on Bethel, you have to know why he's saying and you can't compare it
to apples to oranges to, you know, another excavation project that took place 70, 80 years ago.
So there's this, there's just, it's important to pay attention to not only
where the field is but also where our ultimate goal is is to publish this stuff and the stuff
that you held to at the time, the way you excavated at the time, the way you published it,
is going to be reflective of what you thought and how you would actually excavate as opposed to
when it actually comes out. So it's sort of like, you know, if there was a, you know, godfather
four that was made in the, you know, in the 1980s, I guess, and it comes out in 20, 2030, like,
oh, this is totally different movie. So I don't know if that's a good analogy or not, but I think it's
just kind of an observation to keep in the back of your mind. Yeah, no, it's a good one. And you know,
it is always fun. I like to read whenever I get a new excavation reporter like to read
the preface and all the things that are puts in there because a lot of times scholars will put in
and like, well, we excavated this back in the 1960s or the 1970s. Yeah, that was a long time ago,
but we're publishing it now. And there's various reasons for that, but it is an interesting insight
into the framework that they were using when they actually excavated the site versus how you try
to then publish it. And if you're framework when you're excavating was of a certain nature,
and you're trying to kind of publish it in a different nature, it isn't always easy to do.
And I've worked with old excavations from the 1950s and 60s and there's only limited things
you can ultimately do with the material that's there just because of that underlying framework
of what they were trying to accomplish, how they were excavating, the kind of records they were
keeping, you name it any other kind of variable as well. And it does kind of limit what we can
ultimately present today just because of the way it was excavated back then.
Yeah, and you know, another just side point to this that I think you bring out well in the
article is as we move into this next phase for Israeli archaeology, one of the things that actually
goes back really even to Robinson and others and something that I think has staying power
is the approach of both historical geography and a regional approach. So you point out
Yohananaharoni, his work at a rod at Bercheva at other sites in the Negev of seeing it regionally,
and this goes back to really that first dynamic we talked about of trying to figure out what these
places are, trying to see okay this site, this particular site through time, but also wider changes
to the region. I think one of the criticisms I know both of us have sometimes of our fellow
colleagues is it can be quite insular and looking at a particular site or a myopic look at a
particular site. And I think one of the values of that particular period in the 70s and into I
guess maybe the late 1670s is this kind of regional dynamic that look if you have that perspective,
it's going to allow you to be able to create something important that will be objectively
significant regardless of whatever phase of interpretation or approach you get at. Those are
the types of projects to me that continue to have staying power, which is why I think the discipline
of historical geography is kind of that foundational piece and you could go back to where podcasts were
we talked about that earlier, but it's those methods that incorporate that at the forefront and not
as a side piece.
that I think really have a staying power.
- Yeah, well, and it's interesting too,
because the Israeli approach of doing regional surveys
and of doing regional excavation projects like Ahoroni did
and following the war in 1967,
the surveys of the West Bank and the Golan,
and the Israelis are actually doing
new archeological archeology, if you will.
Like it's, that's the approach is there,
even though they didn't ever explicitly talk about it
or say that, you know, the Americans are much more explicit
and saying, oh, we're doing the new archeology.
But the Israelis are actually doing it,
they just never talk about it.
And so the perception of Israeli biblical archeology
is that this cultural historical approach
kind of through and through all the way
even into the 1980s, if not even today, in some regards.
But it's more nuanced than that.
And the things, the amount of data that the Israeli projects
are turning out in the '60s and '70s, even into the '80s,
is immense and is so essential for kind of moving
into the next realm of questions or the next phase
of biblical archeology that, you know,
the kind of American expeditions are working towards as well.
And ultimately, if we step back,
we have to see that a lot of this exploration
and a lot of the new questions that are going to arise
out of this, there is a certain dissatisfaction
with proceeding biblical archeology in the sense
that the claims that were kind of touted explicitly
or implicitly, that the archeology can support or shed light
on these major historical events recorded
in the biblical texts, the life and time of the patriarchs,
the Israelite kind of settlement in Canaan,
the establishment of the Israelite monarchy, right?
The archeological record hadn't up until that point,
really even up till today, hasn't provided a smoking gun
that says, boom, the Bible nailed it historically,
the archeology just supports and proves
that this representation is accurate.
And this, you know, is one of the reasons
that, you know, Dever, I think, starts to separate the two
and say, we're done with these types of questions
'cause we're not getting the resolved answers
that we were hoping we could get.
So let's ask better and different questions.
And then you have text critical scholars at the same time
that you see the seeds of biblical minimalism
actually coming out of this as well.
They're saying, well, there's no answers.
The archeology doesn't show anything,
but perhaps it's because it wasn't the way
that we've always understood it.
And we need to question it and think that maybe
all of this text is later or whatever else,
opinion comes out of it.
So there's always multiple movements coming
out of every change that we see along the way
in this field of, quote unquote, biblical archeology.
Yeah, and I would just add one other point about Israel
in terms of its archeological institutions.
I mean, it has an enormous,
already from these early days, antiquities authority
that excavates broadly.
So you have this massive amount of salvage material,
but it also has these research institutions
with fantastic professors that are trained
by second, third generations.
And even though the United States
and Europe are obviously much larger,
they don't have the quantity of research institutes.
So you end up, I felt, and I did my full disclosure
to my PhD in Israel, barilun,
I felt like there's so much competition
in those institutes because there's only
these few starting pitching jobs for these
that are only going to come up.
And you have to be publishing, you have to be working,
you have to be reading broadly.
And so in that sense, the culture of biblical archeology
or whatever different avenue that it went
with people like Finklstein and others,
it's built upon both a pursuit of knowledge,
but a heavy competition for grants for recognition,
for trying to do things to not necessarily impress academia,
but to live up to the standards.
And actually, I think that's a good thing.
I mean, to have this academic pressure
and to have this community of scholars
that are developing is quite unique,
certainly in biblical archeology.
Now that's not to say that there's not great scholars
throughout the world, of course there are,
but the concentration of the amount of research institutes
and the amount of amazing scholars
that don't get research jobs that end up
in a variety of positions is a really unique thing
for our field that I think is worth noting.
- Yeah, and I think kind of coupling on with that
as another important point is that, with the post-right
generation for Americans and the post-Yedin generation
for Israelis, in particular,
you have kind of the first real generation
of trained archeologists that are excavating in the field,
they're not biblical scholars,
they're not necessarily architects by day,
they're not theologians, but they're actually archeologists
who have been trained as archeologists by and large.
With the Americans, you still have a lot of them
coming from theological backgrounds
and/or they are also clergy of some sort,
but they're being trained as actual archeologists.
You have the creation of field schools
where yeah, let's teach people how to do
good archeological methodology
so that we're recording things well,
we're keeping track of everything
so that people can come back and reconstruct
what we've done, what we've destroyed
because once it's excavated, you can never have it back.
And this is a huge methodological development.
That's one component we haven't really addressed
throughout most of the talk so far,
it's just the advances in methodology
that are taking place along with all these other changes
that are taking place in what the field of biblical
archeology actually is.
And by the time we get to the new archeology
and the separation of text and archeology
with Diversiro-Palestinian archeology,
which is successful.
And by the '80s, largely a lot of people
are talking about seropalestinian archeology.
Biblical studies are doing their own thing,
they've moved on from historical critical questions
to narytological literary type of questions
and investigating the text in a different way,
not so much historical questions.
Archaeologists are bringing in more anthropology in some cases
and you could have had a complete dissociation of the two
yet that never actually happens.
There's, despite the call for a separation
and creation of biblical archeology
as this academic field that's anthropologically informed,
which is what Diver was calling for,
there's always this connection to the biblical text
because as people will realize 20 years later,
the biblical text is a historical document
that needs to be evaluated, needs to be addressed.
You can't just jettison it,
otherwise you can do anything you want with it.
And this is going to be Divers critique
of the so-called biblical minimalist,
is that they just do whatever they want with it.
They forget the archaeological material that's out there
or they misuse the archaeological material that's out there
so they can make up whatever claims
that they're saying about the composition of the text.
And that leads ultimately in the 1990s
and even the early 2000s to this vociferous debate
between biblical scholars and archaeologists
because the two fields had largely come apart.
Yet they were never fully separated
because both fields, fortunately,
started at adopting what we could call
social scientific methods of analysis.
And it looks a little bit different in textual studies
as it does in archaeology.
But in my opinion, I think this is kind of the saving grace
that never allowed for a full divorce between the two fields
and also may allow them to come back together
because in biblical archaeology,
you have adoption of anthropological,
or as you say, sociological models that are evolutionary
and the question becomes, well, when was Israel a state?
Was it a tribe? Was Saul a chiefed in?
Was David a, you know, these become the dominating questions
in looking at the archaeological record,
but you're always using the textual record as part of that
because that's the resource that you have available
whereas you have got text critical scholars
that are largely looking at it internally
from the textual element,
but they'll bring in some of the archaeological remains as well.
You know, one of the early and kind of most developed examples
I can think of is Norman Gottwald's "The Tribes of Yahweh"
from 1979.
So this adoption by both fields of social scientific approaches
really, I think, keeps them in conversation to a certain degree
and ultimately is going to create a bridge
that they can come back together.
- Yeah, and you know, just thinking about it,
couple observations, one is there's a sense in which
all of the different phases of archaeology live on, right?
You could point to particular elements in archaeology
of the region today and say, okay,
this excavation project is still holding fast
to this, you know, right approach or whatever one you would
and we won't list those, we won't go there.
We'll do that in class, but not here, not here.
And there's still that approach that's around.
And so, but I think what we're kind of looking at is in archaeology
for, you know, periodization of different periods,
it's hard to even nail down in the past,
but it's just as hard to do that kind of in the present.
But because we are closer to it,
there is this history that we can really point to.
The other point I wanted to make is like,
biblical archaeology is a term I'm very comfortable with.
It's a term because there's not a better one.
It's a term that encompasses, it's recognizable,
it needs explanation, but that's what we're doing anyway.
We're teachers and academics.
But if we were to try to make a. a comparison. I was just trying to think through this. If the archaeology, it's weird that
we call the archaeology of Spatini seriology because it's also Babylon. We call it that,
or Egyptology, which sort of encompasses other areas that are Egypt, but they're not
quite Egypt. Or if we call classical archaeology, the study of the Greco-Rum world, but I mean,
if they developed and they called classical archaeology Homeric archaeology, or if we
called, I wouldn't quite fit exactly, but you would get what we meant. Or if we called
Mesopotamian archaeology, or a seriology, we called it Gilgameshian archaeology, it would
make sense. I mean, imagine trying to divorce the book of the dead from Egyptian culture,
right? From Egyptian, like, it doesn't make any sense to do that. It's part of the fabric
of the world, and it's got stuff that you have to pay close attention to, to date it,
to understand it, you have to always be careful. And this is the last point I wanted to make.
You often hear that the Hebrew Bible or the New Testament is, some people will say on
the right that it should be treated just as other ancient inscriptions, and given the
same historical weight, I think, first of all, it's a misrepresentation of the Bible. It's
actually making the Bible less, because the Bible is much more important as a historical
and theological and source, but it's also filled with different, even if you don't
accept any critical approach. I mean, by the very fact that the names span from creation
to the exile and beyond, and that's not even taking into account, you know, different
layering of developments within the specific text, whether you're just looking at the book
of Psalms, which is, we don't know when these different Psalms are. So the closest thing
we have to what the Hebrew Bible is is Gilgamesh, and the Iliad Ne Odyssey, which are ancient,
but clearly have elements of those stories because they were relevant for so long that
grow, that expand, that retract, and yet still are part of the same thing. So that's
why as much as a critical scholar or historian wants to break it down and find the original
source behind it, I'm not saying that's a bad thing, we still have to recognize the
significance of it as, receive it as what it is for now, which means as a biblical archaeologist,
you have to be able to do both, and you have to be able to not just claim simplistically
that the Bible is a monolithic source just like the Meschistili, which by the way, has
its own nuance that you have to go into. So in any case, I just kind of a closing thought
on this bigger perspective. Well, and it gets to the point that people ultimately realized
and there was a call then as we move into the early 21st century to have the new biblical
archaeology that really reintegrates the texts and the archaeology together because of this
realization of the tradition that is there, but the applicability that is, or the impact
that is there as well. And it's a different, I should say, it's a different nature of
biblical archaeology, though, from right and all right. That is taking the best tenets
of the syropalestinian kind of model that Dever pushed for, which was based in anthropological
evaluation. And ultimately, which in world archaeology, you also have what's called post-processual
archaeology, which is going to be a change in how you understand the reality of the archaeological
record, and that things aren't just objective objects that tell you their meaning and shout
out to you when you find them. You actually have to interpret them, and you have to be
aware of the baggage that you come to those with to bring that interpretation. So I, if
I see a wall, I know what a wall is in my own experience. I'm bringing that to my understanding
of the ancient wall I'm looking at. Am I cognizant of that? And am I going to try to dissociate
that so I can try to interpret that wall as an ancient person might? And so post-processual
archaeology starts in the 1980s kind of influences. It really doesn't ultimately pick up in biblical
archaeology till the early 21st century, but it is part of this process of reintegrating
the text and the archaeology back together to see how we can make all the resources useful.
Because it's silly to basically throw away this great historic resource just because
either you don't want to ask certain questions of it or you think you can't ask certain
questions of it. There's still a whole lot you can do. You just got to be creative. You
got to think outside the box and you've got to allow the text to also kind of do what
it's supposed to do. And when we do that, right, this new biblical archaeological approach
is I think providing more fruitful investigations that are out there. And of course, you still
have people that have gone completely down the kind of secular, seropalestinian archaeological
avenue. And we'll want to call it that and we'll only not want to deal with the text at all.
And that's great. They're going to ask lots of questions. You've got biblical scholars that
don't deal with the archaeology at all. That's great. You can address literary questions or
narytological questions. But there's a huge room for bringing the two back together to see the
kinds of questions you can ask once you've looked at both corpora of data and brought them back
together in a more informed way. Yeah. And just more on the positive note, I would say
as we look at kind of across the field, if we look at the people who have influenced the field
the most, I think kind of the common denominator is they are fascinated by this material. Regardless
of how they approached it, right? And regardless of maybe what their motivations were, whether they
were deconstructionists or not, I think those who have impacted the field the most have not done
so out of like, you know, malevolent means or but like they've they've had that same experience
that you and I have had of, wow, this is ash from hazael, veronda mascus, and I'm smelling it
and touching it and they've experienced that like I'm touching the past in some way. And so what
I just like to think of that because in that sense, even if you have a diametrically opposed
view of an archaeologist in terms of method, you can often reach across the aisle and say, man,
this is just cool stuff that we get to do and experience and, you know, how we interpret it,
well, we can get to that down the line. But that's how actually a lot of times you can have more
and common with someone in your field with an archaeology who have very different views of
interpret interpretation versus someone who may be of the same political or religious background,
because this just have no idea of why this is so fun and why this so interesting and why this
sense of discovery is so new and relevant. And the best part about it is not, as Albright thought,
that when he was a teenager reading about all this great stuff, I'm like, oh, they better stop
because if I got a hurry and studying, get over there because it's all going to be discovered.
It ain't happening. It's one thing that we can definitely say Albright was wrong about
there will be new discoveries every year, some of which will change the game. You know,
I don't know if there's more Dead Sea Scrolls or something of that level to be discovered.
Maybe there is. I'm not going to say there's not. But I mean, we just found a new
Pharaoh of the Valley of the King. I mean, every year, there is new stuff that we get to
incorporate. And if I go back just personally to why I wanted to be a bit of archaeologist in the
first place, it was that. I mean, are we going to look at the same text and say, oh, no, it's
this theology or it's this. I'm not saying theology is not important in text study anymore, but
we get to find new stuff all the time that has the potential to change the way we read that text
regardless of that's the original one or not. And so again, if you've never done a dig,
this is your chance to sign up right before the summer.
I'm just going to echo that and then I'm all done. I'm tapped out here. But
yeah, I so much agree with what you're saying. There's, I think that's the big marker of the
most recent stage of biblical archaeology is the recognition that we need to interpret everything.
And this shouldn't be seen as something to shy away from or something that means we can never
get answers because there are all kinds of questions we can get pretty good clear answers to.
It just depends on the kind of question you're asking. But part of the joy, part of the fun is
not necessarily knowing, but having to go through that and being willing to look at the data
and interpret it and see, oh gosh, all right, let's go, let's dig a bit deeper and see what
else. Oh, what's going to come out next? Let's see what else comes along and being willing to,
to go along for the journey of understanding, of growing in our own kind of understanding what's
out there, of contributing to the understanding that is available as we find more and more
archaeological material, as we revise how we interpret that, as we revise how we read the biblical
text. And that, at least in my mind, shouldn't be daunting. It should be just part of the excitement.
So that's all I have to say that. That's great. Well, thanks for putting together this great article.
You'll have to let our audience know if and when.
And I'd say, if it were, will be when it's published
and where it's published and how they can access it.
Until then, Biblical World audience, keep on digging.
- You've been listening to Onscript's Biblical World podcast.
If you enjoy this show, please show your support
by giving us a rating on iTunes or wherever you listen.
You can support the show by visiting onscript.study/donate.
Until next time, keep digging.
[BLANK_AUDIO]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Early biblical archaeology was divided between those who used archaeology to prove the Bible and those who argued that Mesopotamian texts were older and more authentic, making the Bible a later copy.
Scholars like Albright initially embraced pan-Babylonianism but later shifted toward using archaeology to assess historical accuracy, recognizing limitations in earlier claims.
The work of George Ernest Wright defined biblical archaeology as a field bridging archaeology and theology, emphasizing the connection between historical settings and biblical narratives.
A major shift occurred in the 20th century with the rise of processual and post-processual archaeology, which emphasized complex social systems and challenged simplistic links between archaeology and biblical texts.
Despite calls for separation, archaeologists and textual scholars remain interconnected, using each other’s data to address questions about ancient Israelite history and culture.
Israeli archaeology developed a strong regional, historical approach that became influential, though it has evolved toward more nuanced, anthropological models.
The field has moved beyond claiming "proof" of biblical historicity, instead focusing on inquiry, interpretation, and the mutual value of both textual and material evidence.
A key lesson is that biblical archaeology must balance scientific rigor with theological relevance, avoiding ideological extremes while remaining open to new discoveries.
Summary:
The history of biblical archaeology reveals a complex evolution shaped by competing scholarly approaches. Early thinkers like Melvin Grove and Friedrich Dalisch promoted the idea that Mesopotamian texts predate the Bible, while others like Albright initially embraced this view before shifting to use archaeology as a tool for historical investigation. George Ernest Wright helped define the field by linking archaeological findings to theological understanding, emphasizing that the physical remains of ancient Israel reflect the lived experience of its people.
Over time, the field moved beyond simplistic claims of biblical accuracy, influenced by the rise of processual and post-processual archaeology, which stressed social complexity and context. Scholars like Bill Dever pushed for a separation between text and archaeology, leading to new questions about ancient Israelite society, yet both fields remained interconnected due to shared data and methods. Israeli archaeology, in particular, developed a regional, historically grounded approach that now incorporates broader anthropological insights.
Despite debates over method and purpose, the core of biblical archaeology remains a dialogue between material evidence and textual tradition. Modern practice recognizes that archaeology doesn't provide definitive "proof" of biblical claims, but offers valuable context for interpretation. The field continues to evolve, driven by new discoveries, methodological advances, and a growing awareness that both texts and artifacts must be interpreted thoughtfully and critically.
Ultimately, biblical archaeology is not about proving the Bible, but about understanding ancient cultures through a balanced, nuanced, and respectful engagement with both material and textual sources.
FAQs
Biblical archaeology is the study of the material remains of ancient Near Eastern cultures to understand the historical context of the Bible. It evolved from early positivist approaches, influenced by scholars like Albright and Wright, to more nuanced, interdisciplinary methods that integrate anthropology, historical geography, and text criticism.
American scholars often approached the Bible as historically accurate and used archaeology to support it, while German scholars focused on the evolution of biblical texts and viewed archaeology as a tool to understand textual development, not to prove the Bible's truth.
Wright defined and promoted biblical archaeology as a field that connects the physical remains of ancient Israel to the biblical text, aiming to show how historical context enriches theological understanding and makes the Bible more meaningful for modern believers.
Proving the Bible implies definitive validation of its historical claims, while seeking truth means using archaeology to understand the historical context of the text, recognizing that the Bible is a complex document that requires careful interpretation, not absolute proof.
Israeli archaeology became a major force after 1948, bringing large-scale excavations and a regional perspective that emphasized historical context. It influenced the field by introducing more nuanced interpretations and expanding the scope beyond biblical texts to broader Near Eastern cultures.
The New Archaeology introduced a systemic approach, focusing on how social, political, and economic changes drove historical development. This shifted biblical archaeology from simple 'proof' of biblical events to a more complex, interconnected understanding of ancient societies.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.